c561202310K
FALSE 2023 --12-31 167645373 1 0.01 167645373 1 0.01 0001770561 FY 167645373 1 1000000000 100000000 83-1780608 Yes No Yes Yes ☐ ☒ http://www.coronadocoal.com/20231231#LeaseLiabilityCurrent http://www.coronadocoal.com/20231231#LeaseLiabilityCurrent http://www.coronadocoal.com/20231231#LeaseLiabilityNonCurrent http://www.coronadocoal.com/20231231#LeaseLiabilityNonCurrent http://www.coronadocoal.com/20231231#LeaseLiabilityCurrent http://www.coronadocoal.com/20231231#LeaseLiabilityCurrent http://www.coronadocoal.com/20231231#LeaseLiabilityNonCurrent http://www.coronadocoal.com/20231231#LeaseLiabilityNonCurrent false false false false 0001770561 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 srt:MinimumMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 srt:MaximumMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 2021-12-31 0001770561 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:ConstructionInProgressMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoalLeasesContractLiabilityMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:LoganSegmentMember c561:MiningPermitsMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PreferredStockMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:StanwellReservedAreaDeferredConsiderationMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:BuchananSegmentMember c561:MiningPermitsMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:PlantMachineryMiningEquipmentAndTransportationVehiclesMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RetainedEarningsMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:LandMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:MiningPropertiesAndMineralRightsMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:StanwellBelowMarketCoalSupplyAgreementMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:StanwellReservedAreaDeferredConsiderationMember 2018-08-14 0001770561 us-gaap:MineDevelopmentMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CorporateNonSegmentMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AssetRetirementObligationCostsMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:BuildingAndBuildingImprovementsMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:BuchananMember 2016-03-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OfficeEquipmentMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AdditionalPaidInCapitalMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:NoncontrollingInterestMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:LoganSegmentMember c561:MiningPermitsMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:BuchananSegmentMember c561:MiningPermitsMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:LoganSegmentMember c561:MiningPermitsMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:BuchananSegmentMember c561:MiningPermitsMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoalRevenueMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoalRevenueMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoalRevenueFromRelatedPartiesMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoalRevenueFromRelatedPartiesMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 2020-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember 2018-10-23 0001770561 c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember 2016-06-30 0001770561 c561:NonMarketCoalSupplyAgreementMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:NonMarketCoalSupplyAgreementMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:NonMarketCoalSupplyAgreementMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember 2021-05-01 0001770561 us-gaap:WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:DefinedContributionPlan401KMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 srt:MaximumMember c561:DefinedContributionPlan401KMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 srt:MaximumMember c561:BuchananPlanMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 srt:MaximumMember c561:BuchananPlanMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:EquityIncentivePlan2018Member 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 2023-06-30 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2018-10-23 0001770561 2019-10-23 2019-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoalRevenueFromRelatedPartiesMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoalRevenueMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:MetallurgicalCoalMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:MetallurgicalCoalMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:ThermalCoalMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:ThermalCoalMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:TotalCoalRevenueMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:TotalCoalRevenueMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:MetallurgicalCoalMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:ThermalCoalMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:TotalCoalRevenueMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:MetallurgicalCoalMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:ThermalCoalMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:TotalCoalRevenueMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:MetallurgicalCoalMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:MetallurgicalCoalMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:ThermalCoalMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:ThermalCoalMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:TotalCoalRevenueMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:TotalCoalRevenueMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:MetallurgicalCoalMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:MetallurgicalCoalMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:ThermalCoalMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:ThermalCoalMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:TotalCoalRevenueMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:TotalCoalRevenueMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:MetallurgicalCoalMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:ThermalCoalMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:TotalCoalRevenueMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember 2020-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember c561:EquityIncentivePlan2018Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:AwardedIn2020Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:StandbyLettersOfCreditMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CorporateNonSegmentMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CorporateNonSegmentMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CorporateNonSegmentMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:AblFacilityMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccountsReceivableMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OtherAssetsMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccountsReceivableMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OtherAssetsMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:TradeAndRelatedPartyTradeReceivablesNetProvisionExpensesMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:OtherAssetsRelatedNetProvisionExpenseMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccountsReceivableMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OtherAssetsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:PlantMachineryMiningEquipmentAndTransportationVehiclesMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:MineDevelopmentMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:BuildingAndBuildingImprovementsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OfficeEquipmentMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:ConstructionInProgressMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:LandMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:MiningPropertiesAndMineralRightsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AssetRetirementObligationCostsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:LoganSegmentMember c561:MiningPermitsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:BuchananSegmentMember c561:MiningPermitsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:SeniorSecuredNotesMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:SeniorSecuredNotesMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:SeniorSecuredNotesMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:SeniorSecuredNotesMember 2021-05-12 0001770561 us-gaap:OtherNoncurrentLiabilitiesMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:AwardedIn2021Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CorporateNonSegmentMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OperatingSegmentsMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:StanwellBelowMarketCoalSupplyAgreementMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoalLeasesContractLiabilityMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:StanwellReservedAreaDeferredConsiderationMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember c561:CustomerBMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember c561:CustomerBMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember c561:CustomerBMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:NorthAmericaMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:NorthAmericaMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:NorthAmericaMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember country:AU 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember country:AU 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember country:AU 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:AsiaMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:AsiaMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:AsiaMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:EuropeMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:EuropeMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:EuropeMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:SouthAmericaMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:SouthAmericaMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember c561:BrokeredSalesMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember c561:BrokeredSalesMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember c561:BrokeredSalesMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:EmgGroupMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember 2023-05-01 0001770561 c561:FinanceleaseMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:FinanceleaseMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2020-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PreferredStockMember 2020-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PreferredStockMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PreferredStockMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AdditionalPaidInCapitalMember 2020-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember 2020-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RetainedEarningsMember 2020-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:NoncontrollingInterestMember 2020-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PreferredStockMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AdditionalPaidInCapitalMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RetainedEarningsMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:NoncontrollingInterestMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PreferredStockMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AdditionalPaidInCapitalMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RetainedEarningsMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:NoncontrollingInterestMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AdditionalPaidInCapitalMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RetainedEarningsMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:NoncontrollingInterestMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PreferredStockMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AdditionalPaidInCapitalMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RetainedEarningsMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:NoncontrollingInterestMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AdditionalPaidInCapitalMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RetainedEarningsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:NoncontrollingInterestMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:SalesRevenueNetMember c561:CustomerBalancesIndividuallyRepresented10OrMoreMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:AccountsReceivableMember c561:CustomerBalancesIndividuallyRepresented10OrMoreMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:SeriesAPreferredStockMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2022-02-24 2022-02-24 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2022-05-09 2022-05-09 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2022-08-08 2022-08-08 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2022-10-30 2022-10-30 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2022-02-24 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2022-05-09 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2022-08-08 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2022-10-30 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2022-02-24 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2022-05-09 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2022-08-08 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2022-10-30 0001770561 c561:TradeAndRelatedPartyTradeReceivablesNetProvisionExpensesMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:OtherAssetsRelatedNetProvisionExpenseMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:AblFacilityMember 2021-05-12 0001770561 c561:StampDutyOnCurraghAcquisitionMember 2022-09-20 0001770561 c561:AcquisitionRelatedAccrualsMember 2022-10-30 0001770561 c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:Grant2022Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:FairValueMeasurementsRecurringMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:AcquisitionRelatedAccrualsMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:GeographicConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember srt:ReportableGeographicalComponentsMember srt:SouthAmericaMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:BuchananAndLoganMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:GreenbrierSegmentMember c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:UnitedStatesSegmentMember c561:MonValleyAndRussellCountyMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:ForwardContractsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember c561:CoronadoGlobalResourcesIncMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:ForwardContractsMember 2022-12-12 0001770561 us-gaap:ForwardContractsMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:NonMarketCoalSupplyAgreementMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:AblFacilityMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RoyaltyAgreementsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:ProductMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:ProductMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2019-08-05 2019-08-05 0001770561 c561:EquityIncentivePlan2018Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 srt:MinimumMember c561:MachineryMiningEquipmentAndTransportationVehiclesMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 srt:MaximumMember c561:MachineryMiningEquipmentAndTransportationVehiclesMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OfficeEquipmentMember srt:MinimumMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OfficeEquipmentMember srt:MaximumMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:LandAndBuildingMember srt:MinimumMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:LandAndBuildingMember srt:MaximumMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:EmgGroupMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CorporateNonSegmentMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:FiveCustomersMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:FiveCustomersMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:SalesRevenueNetMember c561:FiveCustomersMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:SalesRevenueNetMember c561:FiveCustomersMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:AccountsReceivableMember c561:FourCustomersMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:FourCustomersMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:UnionizedEmployeesConcentrationRiskMember c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember c561:LaborMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:UsDollarCoalSalesInAustraliaMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:UsDollarCoalSalesInAustraliaMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2023-02-21 2023-02-21 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2023-08-07 2023-08-07 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2023-02-21 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2023-08-07 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2023-02-21 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember 2023-08-07 0001770561 c561:NewAblFacilityMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:NewAblFacilityMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:NewAblFacilityMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember 2022-05-01 0001770561 us-gaap:WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember srt:ScenarioForecastMember 2024-05-01 0001770561 us-gaap:WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 srt:MaximumMember c561:BuchananPlanMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:EquityIncentivePlan2018Member 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:VestingDate31032026Granted2023Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember c561:VestingDate31032026Granted2023Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:TotalShareholderReturnMember c561:RelativeTotalShareholderReturnMember c561:Grant2023Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:SafetyMember c561:RelativeTotalShareholderReturnMember c561:Grant2023Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:ScorecardAwardsMember c561:CashflowMember c561:Grant2023Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:TotalShareholderReturnMember c561:RelativeTotalShareholderReturnMember c561:AwardedIn20222021And2020Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:SafetyMember c561:RelativeTotalShareholderReturnMember c561:AwardedIn20222021And2020Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:ScorecardAwardsMember c561:TotalShareholderReturnMember c561:AwardedIn20222021And2020Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:ScorecardAwardsMember c561:CashflowMember c561:AwardedIn20222021And2020Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:Grant2023Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember 2020-01-01 2020-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:FairValueMeasurementsRecurringMember 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:MajorityShareholderMember c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember c561:MembershipInterestPurchaseAgreementMember c561:CdisMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:MajorityShareholderMember us-gaap:CommonStockMember c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember c561:MembershipInterestPurchaseAgreementMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:MajorityShareholderMember c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember c561:MembershipInterestPurchaseAgreementMember c561:SeriesAShareMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:FiveCustomersMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:SalesRevenueNetMember c561:FiveCustomersMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember c561:CustomerCMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember c561:CustomerCMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerMember c561:CustomerCMember 2021-01-01 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:ThreeCustomersMemberMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CustomerConcentrationRiskMember us-gaap:AccountsReceivableMember c561:ThreeCustomersMemberMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:UsDollarCoalSalesInAustraliaMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember c561:NewInvestorsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:CommonStockMember c561:CoronadoGroupLlcMember c561:NewInvestorsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:EquipmentEmbeddedWithinMiningServiceContractsMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:DebtInstrumentRedemptionPeriodTwoMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:DebtInstrumentRedemptionPeriodThreeMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:NewAblFacilityMember 2023-05-08 0001770561 us-gaap:LetterOfCreditMember c561:NewAblFacilityMember 2023-05-08 0001770561 us-gaap:RevolvingCreditFacilityMember c561:NewAblFacilityMember 2023-05-08 0001770561 srt:MaximumMember c561:NewAblFacilityMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 srt:MinimumMember c561:NewAblFacilityMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:NewAblFacilityMember 2023-08-03 0001770561 c561:XcoalEnergyAndResourcesMember 2021-01-01 2021-05-27 0001770561 c561:EmgGroupMember 2022-01-01 2022-12-31 0001770561 c561:EmgGroupMember 2021-05-12 0001770561 c561:EmgGroupMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:AblFacilityMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:CashCollateralMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:SuretyBondMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:OtherNoncurrentLiabilitiesMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:EquityIncentivePlan2018Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 srt:WeightedAverageMember c561:EquityIncentivePlan2018Member 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:VestingDate01012024Granted2023Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember c561:VestingDate01012024Granted2023Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:VestingDate01072024Granted2023Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember c561:VestingDate01072024Granted2023Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:VestingDate01012024Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember c561:VestingDate01012024Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:VestingDate01072024Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember c561:VestingDate01072024Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:VestingDate31032026Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember c561:VestingDate31032026Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:VestingDate31032025Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember c561:VestingDate31032025Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:PerformanceSharesMember c561:VestingDate31032024Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:RestrictedStockUnitsRSUMember c561:VestingDate31032024Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:FairValueInputsLevel2Member 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:BankGuaranteeFacilityMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:NewAblFacilityMember c561:BankGuaranteesCertainRailAndPortArrangementsMember 2023-01-01 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:CurraghHousingTransactionFirstMember 2023-05-08 2023-05-08 0001770561 c561:CurraghHousingTransactionSecondMember 2023-05-08 2023-05-08 0001770561 us-gaap:SubsequentEventMember c561:BiAnnualFullyFrankedFixedOrdinaryDividendMember 2024-02-19 0001770561 us-gaap:SubsequentEventMember c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember c561:BiAnnualFullyFrankedFixedOrdinaryDividendMember 2024-02-19 0001770561 us-gaap:SubsequentEventMember c561:ChessDepositaryInterestsMember c561:BiAnnualFullyFrankedFixedOrdinaryDividendMember 2024-03-12 2024-03-12 0001770561 us-gaap:AustralianTaxationOfficeMember c561:NonAustralianTaxConsolidatedGroupMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AustralianTaxationOfficeMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 us-gaap:AustralianTaxationOfficeMember c561:AustraliaSegmentMember 2021-12-31 0001770561 c561:CurrentAndNonCurrentLeaseLiabilitiesMember 2023-12-31 0001770561 c561:CurrentAndNonCurrentLeaseLiabilitiesMember 2022-12-31 iso4217:AUD iso4217:USD xbrli:pure xbrli:shares iso4217:USD xbrli:shares dummy:Item utr:segment iso4217:AUD xbrli:shares
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
___________________________________________________
FORM
10-K
___________________________________________________
(Mark One)
☒
 
ANNUAL REPORT
 
PURSUANT TO
 
SECTION 13 OR
 
15(d) OF THE
 
SECURITIES EXCHANGE
 
ACT
OF 1934
For the fiscal year ended
December 31, 2023
OR
☐
 
TRANSITION REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT
OF 1934
For the transition period from
 
to
 
Commission File Number:
000-56044
___________________________________________________
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
(Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)
___________________________________________________
Delaware
83-1780608
(State or other jurisdiction of
incorporation or organization)
(I.R.S. Employer
Identification No.)
Level 33, Central Plaza One
,
345 Queen Street
Brisbane, Queensland
,
Australia
,
4000
(Address of principal executive offices)
 
(Zip Code)
(
61
)
7
3031 7777
(Registrant’s telephone number, including area code)
___________________________________________________
Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act:
Title of each class
Trading Symbol(s)
Name of each exchange on which registered
None
None
None
Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(g) of the Act:
Title of each class
Name of each exchange on which registered
Common stock, par value $0.01 per share
None
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is a well-known seasoned issuer, as defined in Rule 405 of the Securities Act.
Yes
 
☒
 
No
 
☐
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is not required to file reports pursuant to Section
 
13 or Section 15(d) of the Act.
Yes
 
☐
 
No
 
☒
Indicate by
 
check mark
 
whether the
 
registrant (1) has
 
filed all
 
reports required
 
to be
 
filed by
 
Section 13 or
 
15(d) of the
 
Securities
Exchange Act of
 
1934 during the
 
preceding 12 months
 
(or for such
 
shorter period that
 
the registrant was
 
required to file
 
such reports),
and (2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90 days.
Yes
 
☒
 
No
 
☐
 
Indicate
 
by
 
check
 
mark
 
whether
 
the
 
registrant
 
has
 
submitted
 
electronically
 
every
 
Interactive
 
Data
 
File
 
required
 
to
 
be
 
submitted
pursuant to Rule 405
 
of Regulation S-T
 
(§232.405 of this
 
chapter) during the preceding
 
12 months (or
 
for such shorter
 
period that
the registrant was required to submit such files).
 
Yes
 
☒
 
No
 
☐
Indicate by
 
check
 
mark whether
 
the registrant
 
is a
 
large accelerated
 
filer,
 
an accelerated
 
filer,
 
a non-accelerated
 
filer,
 
a smaller
reporting
 
company,
 
or an
 
emerging growth
 
company.
 
See the
 
definitions
 
of
 
“large
 
accelerated filer,”
 
“accelerated filer,”
 
“smaller
reporting company,” and “emerging growth company” in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act.
 
Large accelerated filer
☒
Accelerated filer
☐
Non-accelerated filer
☐
Smaller reporting company
☐
Emerging growth company
 
☐
If an
 
emerging growth
 
company,
 
indicate by
 
check mark
 
if the
 
registrant has elected
 
not to
 
use the
 
extended transition period
 
for
complying
 
with
 
any
 
new
 
or
 
revised
 
financial
 
accounting
 
standards
 
provided
 
pursuant
 
to
 
Section 13(a) of
 
the
 
Exchange
 
Act.
 
 
☐
Indicate
 
by
 
check
 
mark
 
whether
 
the
 
registrant
 
has
 
filed
 
a
 
report
 
on
 
and
 
attestation
 
to
 
its
 
management’s
 
assessment
 
of
 
the
effectiveness of its
 
internal control over financial reporting
 
under Section 404(b) of
 
the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (15
 
U.S.C. 7262(b)) by
the registered public accounting firm that prepared or issued its audit report.
 
 
☒
If
 
securities are
 
registered pursuant
 
to Section
 
12(b) of
 
the
 
Act, indicate
 
by check
 
mark whether
 
the
 
financial statements
 
of
 
the
registrant included in the filing reflect the correction of an error to previously issued financial statements.
 
☐
Indicate by check mark whether any of those
 
error corrections are restatements that required
 
a recovery analysis of incentive-based
compensation received by any of
 
the registrant’s executive officers
 
during the relevant recovery period
 
pursuant to §240.10D-1(b).
☐
Indicate by check
 
mark whether the
 
registrant is a
 
shell company (as
 
defined in Rule
 
12b-2 of the Exchange
 
Act).
 
Yes
 
☐
 
No
☒
 
 
 
The registrant’s common stock is publicly traded on the Australian Securities Exchange in the form of CHESS Depositary Interests,
or CDIs, convertible
 
at the option
 
of the holders
 
into shares of
 
the registrant’s
 
common stock on
 
a 10-for-1 basis.
 
The aggregate
market value of the registrant’s common stock, par value $0.01
 
per share, in the form of CDIs, held by non-affiliates of the registrant
(without admitting that
 
any person whose shares
 
are not included
 
in such calculation
 
is an affiliate),
 
computed by reference
 
to the
price at which the
 
CDIs were last sold
 
on June 30,
 
2023, the last business
 
day of the
 
registrant’s most recently completed
 
second
fiscal quarter, as reported on the Australian Securities Exchange, was $
842,598,099
.
The total
 
number of
 
shares of
 
the registrant’s
 
common stock,
 
par value
 
$0.01 per
 
share, outstanding
 
on December
 
31, 2023,
 
including
shares of common stock underlying the issued and outstanding CDIs, was
167,645,373
.
DOCUMENTS INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE
Portions of
 
the registrant’s
 
proxy statement
 
to be
 
filed with
 
the Securities
 
and Exchange
 
Commission in
 
connection with
 
the registrants
2024 annual
 
meeting of
 
stockholders are
 
incorporated by
 
reference into
 
Part III
 
of this
 
Annual Report
 
on Form
 
10-K. Documents
incorporated by reference in this report are listed in the Exhibit Index of this Annual Report on Form
 
10-K.
c561202310Kp3i0 c561202310Kp3i1
Steel starts
here.
Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December
 
31, 2023.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
5
EXPLANATORY
 
NOTE
Unless
 
otherwise
 
noted,
 
references
 
in
 
this
 
Annual
 
Report
 
on
 
Form 10-K
 
to
 
“we,”
 
“us,”
 
“our,”
 
“Company,”
 
or
“Coronado” refer
 
to Coronado
 
Global Resources
 
Inc. and
 
its consolidated
 
subsidiaries and
 
associates, unless
the context indicates otherwise.
All production and sales volumes contained in this Annual Report on Form 10-K are expressed in metric tons, or
Mt,
 
millions
 
of
 
metric
 
tons,
 
or
 
MMt,
 
or
 
millions
 
of
 
metric
 
tons
 
per
 
annum,
 
or
 
MMtpa,
 
except
 
where
 
otherwise
stated. One Mt (1,000 kilograms)
 
is equal to 2,204.62 pounds and
 
is equivalent to 1.10231 short tons.
 
A net ton
is equivalent
 
to a
 
short ton,
 
or 2,000
 
pounds. In
 
addition, all
 
dollar amounts
 
contained herein
 
are expressed
 
in
United States
 
dollars, or
 
US$, except
 
where otherwise
 
stated. References
 
to “A$”
 
are references
 
to Australian
dollars, the
 
lawful currency
 
of the
 
Commonwealth of
 
Australia, or
 
the Commonwealth.
 
Some numerical
 
figures
included in this Annual Report on Form 10-K have been
 
subject to rounding adjustments. Accordingly, numerical
figures shown as totals in certain tables may not equal
 
the sum of the figures that precede them.
CAUTIONARY NOTICE REGARDING FORWARD
 
-LOOKING STATEMENTS
This Annual
 
Report on
 
Form 10-K
 
contains “forward-looking
 
statements” within
 
the meaning
 
of Section
 
27A of
the Securities Act
 
of 1933, as
 
amended, or the
 
Securities Act, and
 
Section 21E of
 
the Securities Exchange
 
Act
of
 
1934,
 
as
 
amended,
 
or
 
the
 
Exchange
 
Act,
 
concerning
 
our
 
business,
 
operations,
 
financial
 
performance
 
and
condition, the coal, steel and other industries, as well as our plans,
 
objectives and expectations for our business,
operations, financial performance and condition. Forward-looking statements may
 
be identified by words such
 
as
“may,”
 
“could,”
 
“believes,”
 
“estimates,”
 
“expects,”
 
“intends,”
 
“plans,”
 
“anticipate,”
 
“forecast,”
 
“outlook,”
 
“target,”
“likely,” “considers”
 
and other similar words.
Any
 
forward-looking
 
statements
 
involve
 
known
 
and
 
unknown
 
risks,
 
uncertainties,
 
assumptions
 
and
 
other
important factors that
 
could cause actual
 
results, performance,
 
events or outcomes
 
to differ
 
materially from
 
the
results,
 
performance,
 
events
 
or
 
outcomes
 
expressed
 
or
 
anticipated
 
in
 
these
 
statements,
 
many
 
of
 
which
 
are
beyond
 
our
 
control.
 
Such
 
forward-looking
 
statements
 
are
 
based
 
on
 
an
 
assessment
 
of
 
present
 
economic
 
and
operating
 
conditions
 
on
 
a
 
number
 
of
 
best
 
estimate
 
assumptions
 
regarding
 
future
 
events
 
and
 
actions.
 
These
factors are difficult to accurately predict and may be beyond our control. Factors that could affect our results, our
announced plans or an investment in our securities include,
 
but are not limited to:
•
 
the prices we receive for our coal;
•
 
uncertainty in global economic
 
conditions, including the
 
extent, duration and
 
impact of ongoing
 
civil
unrest and
 
wars, as
 
well as
 
risks related
 
to government
 
actions with
 
respect to
 
trade agreements,
treaties or policies;
•
 
a decrease in the availability or increase in costs of key supplies, capital equipment or commodities,
such as diesel fuel, steel, explosives and tires, as the result
 
of inflationary pressures or otherwise;
•
 
the extensive forms
 
of taxation that
 
our mining operations
 
are subject to,
 
and future tax
 
regulations
and developments.
 
For example,
 
the amendments
 
to the
 
coal royalty
 
regime implemented
 
in 2022
by the
 
Queensland
 
State Government
 
in Australia
 
introducing higher
 
tiers to
 
the coal
 
royalty rates
applicable to our Australian Operations;
•
 
concerns
 
about
 
the
 
environmental
 
impacts
 
of
 
coal
 
combustion
 
and
 
greenhouse
 
gas,
 
or
 
GHG
emissions, relating
 
to mining
 
activities,
 
including
 
possible
 
impacts on
 
global
 
climate issues,
 
which
could result in increased regulation of coal
 
combustion and requirements to reduce
 
GHG emissions
in many
 
jurisdictions,
 
including
 
federal and
 
state government
 
initiatives
 
to control
 
GHG
 
emissions
could increase costs associated
 
with coal production and consumption,
 
such as costs for
 
additional
controls
 
to
 
reduce
 
carbon
 
dioxide
 
emissions
 
or
 
costs
 
to
 
purchase
 
emissions
 
reduction
 
credits
 
to
comply
 
with
 
future
 
emissions
 
trading
 
programs,
 
which
 
could
 
significantly
 
impact
 
our
 
financial
condition
 
and
 
results
 
of
 
operations,
 
affect
 
demand for
 
our products
 
or our
 
securities
 
and
 
reduced
access to capital and insurance;
•
 
the impact of the SGI Transaction (as defined in Item 1.
 
“Business”), including the impact of the SGI
Transaction on change of control and related
 
provisions in material agreements;
•
 
severe financial hardship,
 
bankruptcy, temporary or permanent shut
 
downs or operational
 
challenges
of
 
one
 
or
 
more
 
of
 
our
 
major
 
customers,
 
including
 
customers
 
in
 
the
 
steel
 
industry,
 
key
suppliers/contractors,
 
which
 
among
 
other
 
adverse
 
effects,
 
could
 
lead
 
to
 
reduced
 
demand
 
for
 
our
coal,
 
increased
 
difficulty
 
collecting
 
receivables
 
and
 
customers
 
and/or
 
suppliers
 
asserting
 
force
majeure or other reasons for not performing their contractual
 
obligations to us;
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
6
•
 
our ability to generate sufficient cash to service
 
our indebtedness and other obligations;
•
 
our
 
indebtedness
 
and
 
ability
 
to
 
comply
 
with
 
the
 
covenants
 
and
 
other
 
undertakings
 
under
 
the
agreements governing such indebtedness;
•
 
our ability to
 
collect payments
 
from our customers
 
depending on
 
their creditworthiness,
 
contractual
performance or otherwise;
•
 
the demand for steel products, which impacts the demand for
 
our metallurgical, or Met, coals;
•
 
risks
 
inherent
 
to
 
mining
 
operations
 
could
 
impact
 
the
 
amount
 
of
 
coal
 
produced,
 
cause
 
delay
 
or
suspend coal deliveries, or increase the cost of operating
 
our business;
•
 
the loss of, or significant reduction in, purchases by our
 
largest customers;
•
 
risks
 
unique
 
to
 
international
 
mining
 
and
 
trading
 
operations,
 
including
 
tariffs
 
and
 
other
 
barriers
 
to
trade;
•
 
unfavorable economic and financial market conditions;
•
 
our ability to continue acquiring and developing coal reserves
 
that are economically recoverable;
•
 
uncertainties in estimating our economically recoverable
 
coal reserves;
•
 
transportation for our coal becoming unavailable or uneconomic
 
for our customers;
•
 
the risk that we may be required to pay for unused capacity pursuant to the terms of our take-or-pay
arrangements with rail and port operators;
•
 
our ability to retain key personnel and attract qualified
 
personnel;
•
 
any failure to maintain satisfactory labor relations;
•
 
our ability to obtain, renew or maintain permits and consents
 
necessary for our operations;
•
 
potential costs or
 
liability under applicable environmental
 
laws and regulations,
 
including with respect
to any exposure
 
to hazardous substances
 
caused by
 
our operations, as
 
well as
 
any environmental
contamination our properties may have or our operations
 
may cause;
•
 
extensive regulation of our mining operations and future
 
regulations and developments;
•
 
our ability to provide
 
appropriate financial assurances
 
for our obligations under
 
applicable laws and
regulations;
•
 
assumptions underlying our asset retirement obligations
 
for reclamation and mine closures;
•
 
any cyber-attacks or
 
other security breaches that
 
disrupt our operations
 
or result in
 
the dissemination
of proprietary or confidential information about us, our
 
customers or other third parties;
•
 
the risk that we may not
 
recover our investments in
 
our mining, exploration and other
 
assets, which
may require us to recognize impairment charges related
 
to those assets;
•
 
risks related to divestitures and acquisitions;
•
 
the risk that diversity in
 
interpretation and application of
 
accounting principles in the
 
mining industry
may impact our reported financial results; and
•
 
other risks and uncertainties described in Item 1A. “Risk
 
Factors.”
We
 
make
 
many
 
of
 
our
 
forward-looking
 
statements
 
based
 
on
 
our
 
operating
 
budgets
 
and
 
forecasts,
 
which
 
are
based upon
 
detailed assumptions.
 
While we
 
believe that
 
our assumptions
 
are reasonable,
 
we caution
 
that it
 
is
very difficult to
 
predict the impact
 
of known factors,
 
and it is
 
impossible for us
 
to anticipate all
 
factors that could
affect our actual results.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
7
See Item 1A. “Risk Factors” and
 
elsewhere in this Annual Report
 
on Form 10-K for a more
 
complete discussion
of the risks
 
and uncertainties
 
mentioned above
 
and for
 
discussion of other
 
risks and uncertainties
 
we face that
could
 
cause
 
actual
 
results
 
to
 
differ
 
materially
 
from
 
those
 
expressed
 
or
 
implied
 
by
 
these
 
forward-looking
statements.
 
All
 
forward-looking
 
statements
 
attributable
 
to
 
us
 
are
 
expressly
 
qualified
 
in
 
their
 
entirety
 
by
 
these
 
cautionary
statements, as well as others made in this Annual
 
Report on Form 10-K and hereafter in our other
 
filings with the
Securities
 
and
 
Exchange
 
Commission,
 
or
 
SEC,
 
and
 
public
 
communications.
 
You
 
should
 
evaluate
 
all
forward-looking statements made by us in the context
 
of these risks and uncertainties.
We caution you that the risks and uncertainties identified by us may not be all of the factors that are important to
you.
 
You
 
should
 
not
 
interpret
 
the
 
disclosure
 
of
 
any
 
risk
 
to
 
imply
 
that
 
the
 
risk
 
has
 
not
 
already
 
materialized.
Furthermore, the forward
 
-looking statements
 
included in this
 
Annual Report on
 
Form 10-K are
 
made only as
 
of
the date hereof.
 
We undertake no
 
obligation to publicly
 
update or revise
 
any forward-looking statement as
 
a result
of new information, future events, or otherwise, except
 
as required by applicable law.
Forward-looking and
 
other statements
 
in this
 
Annual Report
 
on Form
 
10-K regarding
 
our GHG
 
reduction plans
and
 
goals
 
are
 
not
 
an
 
indication
 
that
 
these
 
statements
 
are
 
necessarily
 
material
 
to
 
investors
 
or
 
required
 
to
 
be
disclosed in our filings with the SEC. In addition, historical, current and
 
forward-looking GHG-related statements
may be based on standards for measuring
 
progress that are still developing, internal controls and
 
processes that
continue to evolve and assumptions that are subject to
 
change in the future.
c561202310Kp8i1 c561202310Kp8i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
8
PART I
ITEM 1.
 
BUSINESS.
Overview
We are a leading producer, global marketer and exporter of high-quality Met coals, which
 
is an essential element
in
 
the
 
production
 
of
 
steel.
 
Our
 
coals,
 
transformed
 
in
 
the
 
steelmaking
 
process,
 
support
 
the
 
manufacture
 
of
everyday steel-based products, including steel required
 
in the manufacture of renewable energy infrastructure.
Our mining
 
operations and
 
development projects
 
are located
 
in Queensland
 
in Australia,
 
and in
 
Virginia, West
Virginia and
 
Pennsylvania in
 
the United
 
States. Coronado
 
is one
 
of the
 
largest Met
 
coal producers
 
globally by
export volume, serving customers on five continents.
Our operations in Australia, or our Australian
 
Operations, consist of the 100%-owned
 
Curragh producing mining
property located
 
in the
 
Bowen Basin
 
of Australia.
 
Our operations
 
in the
 
United States,
 
or our
 
U.S. Operations,
consist of
 
two producing
 
mining properties
 
(Buchanan and
 
Logan), one
 
idled mining
 
property (Greenbrier)
 
and
two
 
development
 
mining
 
properties
 
(Mon
 
Valley,
 
and
 
Russell
 
County),
 
primarily
 
located
 
in
 
the
 
Central
Appalachian
 
region
 
of
 
the
 
United
 
States,
 
or
 
CAPP,
 
all
 
of
 
which
 
are
 
100%-owned.
 
Our
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
and
Australian Operations are strategically located for access to transportation infrastructure. In addition to Met coal,
our
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
sell
 
thermal
 
coal
 
under
 
a
 
long-term
 
legacy
 
contract
 
assumed
 
in
 
the
 
acquisition
 
of
Curragh,
 
which
 
is
 
used
 
to
 
generate
 
electricity,
 
to
 
Stanwell
 
Corporation
 
Limited,
 
or
 
Stanwell,
 
a
 
Queensland
government-owned
 
entity
 
and
 
the
 
operator
 
of
 
the
 
Stanwell
 
Power
 
Station
 
located
 
near
 
Rockhampton,
Queensland,
 
and
 
some
 
thermal
 
coal
 
in
 
the
 
export
 
market.
 
Our
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
also
 
produce
 
and
 
sell
 
some
thermal coal that is extracted in the process of mining
 
Met coal.
Location of Australian Operations
 
Location of U.S. Operations
Our core business
 
strategy focuses
 
on the production
 
of Met coal
 
for the North
 
American and seaborne
 
export
markets. Met coal is a key ingredient
 
in the production of steel using blast
 
furnaces,
 
and approximately 0.78 ton
of Met coal is required to produce one ton of steel.
We
 
have
 
a
 
geographically
 
diverse
 
customer
 
base
 
across
 
a range
 
of
 
global
 
markets.
 
Major
 
consumers
 
of
 
our
seaborne Met coal in 2023 were located in high-growth Asian markets, Brazil
 
and Europe. These consumers are
all major
 
global steel or
 
Met coke producers.
 
We are well-positioned
 
in the
 
key high-growth Asian
 
markets (Japan,
South
 
Korea
 
and
 
India)
 
as
 
sales
 
to
 
direct
 
end
 
users
 
in
 
the
 
region
 
represented
 
64.1%
 
of
 
our
 
total
 
revenue,
including Tata
 
Steel Limited, or Tata
 
Steel, which accounted for 20.5% of total revenue,
 
in 2023.
The
 
charts
 
below
 
show
 
our
 
direct
 
sales
 
by
 
geographic
 
region
 
in
 
2023
 
and
 
our
 
sales
 
volume
 
by
 
export
 
and
domestic coal sales in 2021, 2022 and 2023.
c561202310Kp9i0 c561202310Kp9i1
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
c561202310Kp9i2
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
c561202310Kp9i3
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
c561202310Kp9i4
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
9
3%
26%
10%
25%
13%
10%
8%
5%
Customer -FY2023
 
direct sales by coal revenue
Other Asia countries
Japan
South Korea
India
North America
South America
Europe
Australia
75%
25%
FY2021
Export
Domestic
66%
34%
FY2022
Export
Domestic
72%
28%
FY2023
Export
Domestic
Sales volume by export and domestic coal sales
To
 
support our
 
operations, we
 
have proven
 
and probable
 
coal reserves
 
totaling
 
556
MMt as
 
of December
 
31,
2023, 223
MMt and 333
MMt of which are in Australia and the
 
United States, respectively.
 
For more information
regarding our coal reserves, see Item 2. “Properties.”
History and Australian Public Offering
We were founded in 2011
 
by our then Chief Executive Officer
 
and current Executive Chair,
 
Mr. Garold Spindler,
our then President and Chief Operating Officer, Mr. James Campbell and a private equity fund affiliated with The
Energy & Minerals
 
Group, or
 
EMG, with
 
the intention
 
of evaluating,
 
acquiring and
 
developing
 
Met coal
 
mining
properties.
 
Prior to our initial public
 
offering,
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.,
 
was a wholly-owned subsidiary
 
of Coronado
Group LLC.
On
 
October 23,
 
2018,
 
we
 
completed
 
an
 
initial
 
public
 
offering
 
on
 
the
 
Australian
 
Securities
 
Exchange,
 
or
 
ASX,
which we refer to as the Australian IPO.
Coronado Group LLC is currently owned by funds managed by EMG, which we refer to,
 
collectively, as the EMG
Group, and certain members of our management.
As of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
the
 
EMG Group
 
and
 
management
 
beneficially
 
owned
 
approximately
 
50.4%
 
of the
issued
 
and
 
outstanding
 
shares
 
of
 
our
 
common
 
stock
 
through
 
their
 
ownership
 
of
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC.
 
The
remaining 49.6% was owned by public investors in the form of
 
CDIs traded on the ASX.
 
c561202310Kp10i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
10
SGI Transaction
On September 25, 2023, EMG Group, the Company’s controlling stockholder through its ownership of Coronado
Group LLC,
 
including through
 
certain of
 
its affiliates
 
and managed
 
funds, which
 
we refer to,
 
collectively,
 
as the
Sellers, advised the Company that it had entered into a membership interest
 
purchase agreement, or MIPA, with
Sev.en Global Investments a.s., or SGI. A copy of the MIPA has not been made available to the Company or the
Special Committee referred to below as of the date of this Annual Report on Form 10-K. However, the Company
understands that, pursuant
 
to the terms of
 
the MIPA,
 
the Sellers agreed to
 
sell all of their
 
interests in Coronado
Group LLC to
 
a wholly-owned
 
subsidiary of
 
SGI. We
 
refer to the
 
proposed transaction
 
as the SGI
 
Transaction.
The
 
Company
 
also
 
understands
 
that,
 
under
 
the
 
MIPA,
 
the
 
SGI
 
Transaction
 
is
 
subject
 
to
 
customary
 
closing
conditions, including regulatory approvals in the U.S. and Australia.
 
The Board of
 
Directors has appointed
 
a special committee
 
of independent
 
directors, or the
 
Special Committee,
to, among other things, assess
 
the impact and consequences of the
 
SGI Transaction on the
 
Company and take
such actions as the Special Committee deems appropriate
 
in connection with the SGI Transaction.
 
EMG Group has
 
reported that following
 
the closing of
 
the SGI Transaction,
 
the timing of
 
which the Company
 
is
not aware, SGI will be the
 
direct or indirect owner of
 
Coronado Group LLC. As of
 
the date of this Annual Report
on Form 10-K, Coronado Group
 
LLC is the direct owner
 
of 845,061,399 CDIs (representing
 
a beneficial interest
in 84,506,140
 
shares of
 
common stock,
 
or 50.4%
 
of the
 
Company’s
 
outstanding
 
shares of
 
common
 
stock).
 
In
addition, Coronado
 
Group LLC, (subject
 
to the terms
 
of the Amended
 
and Restated
 
Certificate of Incorporation
dated
 
as
 
of
 
October
 
18,
 
2018
 
of
 
the
 
Company,
 
or
 
the
 
COI;
 
and
 
the
 
Stockholders
 
Agreement,
 
dated
 
as
 
of
September 23,
 
2018, between
 
the Company
 
and Coronado Group
 
LLC, or the
 
Stockholders Agreement)
 
holds
one share of preferred stock Series A, par value $0.01 per share, of
 
the Company,
 
or the Series A Share, which
is the
 
only share
 
of preferred
 
stock issued
 
and outstanding.
 
As holder
 
of the
 
Series A Share,
 
Coronado Group
LLC
 
is,
 
subject
 
to
 
the
 
COI
 
and
 
Stockholders
 
Agreement,
 
is
 
permitted
 
to
 
nominate
 
and
 
elect
 
members
 
of
 
our
Board
 
of
 
Directors
 
in
 
relation
 
to
 
the
 
amount
 
of
 
the
 
holder’s
 
aggregate
 
beneficial
 
ownership
 
of
 
shares
 
of
 
our
common stock.
Organizational Structure
The following chart shows our current organizational structure:
* Coronado Global Resources Inc. holds 100%
 
ownership interest in its subsidiaries, unless otherwise
 
stated.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
11
Overview of Operations
Met Coal
Met coal is primarily
 
used in the manufacture of
 
coke, which is used
 
in the steel-making process, as
 
well as direct
injection into a blast furnace as a replacement for coke.
Sales of Met coal represented 91.4%
 
of our total coal revenues for the
 
year ended December 31, 2023. Most
 
of
the Met
 
coal that
 
we produce
 
is sold,
 
directly or
 
indirectly,
 
to steel
 
producers. The
 
steel industry’s
 
demand for
Met
 
coal
 
is
 
affected
 
by
 
several
 
factors,
 
including
 
the
 
cyclical
 
nature
 
of
 
that
 
industry’s
 
business,
 
geopolitical
stability, general economic conditions affecting demand for
 
steel, tariffs on steel
 
and steel products,
 
technological
developments in the steelmaking process and
 
the availability and cost of
 
substitutes for steel, such as aluminum,
composites
 
and
 
plastics.
 
We
 
compete
 
based
 
on
 
coal
 
quality
 
and
 
characteristics,
 
price,
 
customer
 
service
 
and
support
 
and
 
reliability
 
of
 
supply.
 
Seaborne
 
Met
 
coal
 
import
 
demand,
 
which
 
is
 
most
 
of
 
our
 
business,
 
can
 
be
significantly impacted by the availability of indigenous coal production, particularly in the leading Met coal
 
import
countries of China
 
and India, among
 
others, and the
 
competitiveness of seaborne Met
 
coal supply, including from
the leading Met
 
coal exporting countries
 
of Australia,
 
the United
 
States, Russia,
 
Canada and Mongolia,
 
among
others.
 
In
 
2023,
 
the
 
seaborne
 
Met
 
coal
 
market
 
remained
 
volatile,
 
driven
 
by
 
supply
 
concerns
 
in
 
key
 
Met
 
coal
markets and trade flow disruptions due to ongoing civil unrests
 
and wars.
Thermal Coal
Sales of thermal
 
coal represented 8.6%
 
of our total
 
coal revenues
 
for the year
 
ended December
 
31, 2023. The
thermal coal we produce is predominantly
 
a byproduct of mining Met coal. The
 
thermal coal we produce is sold,
directly
 
or
 
indirectly,
 
to
 
power
 
stations,
 
predominantly
 
Stanwell,
 
as
 
an
 
energy
 
source
 
in
 
the
 
generation
 
of
electricity. Demand for our thermal coal is impacted by economic conditions, environmental regulations, demand
for
 
electricity,
 
including
 
the
 
impact
 
of
 
energy
 
efficient
 
products,
 
and
 
the
 
cost
 
of
 
electricity
 
generation
 
from
alternative
 
fuels.
 
Our
 
thermal
 
coal
 
primarily
 
competes
 
with
 
producers
 
of
 
other
 
forms
 
of
 
electric
 
generation,
including natural gas, oil, nuclear,
 
hydro, wind, solar and biomass, that provide an alternative to
 
coal use.
 
Segments
In accordance with
 
Accounting Standards Codification, or
 
ASC, Topic 280,
Segment Reporting
, we have
 
adopted
the following reporting segments:
•
 
Australia; and
•
 
United States.
In addition, “Other and Corporate” is not determined
 
to be a reporting segment but is disclosed
 
for the purposes
of reconciliation to our Consolidated Financial Statements.
These segments are grouped based on geography and reflect how we currently monitor
 
and report the results of
the business to
 
the Chief Executive
 
Officer who is
 
our chief operating
 
decision maker, or CODM.
 
Factors affecting
and
 
differentiating
 
the
 
financial
 
performance
 
of
 
each
 
of these
 
two
 
reportable
 
segments
 
generally
 
include
 
coal
quality,
 
geology,
 
coal
 
marketing
 
opportunities,
 
mining
 
and
 
transportation
 
methods
 
and
 
regulatory
 
issues.
 
We
believe
 
this
 
method
 
of
 
segment
 
reporting
 
reflects
 
the
 
way
 
our
 
business
 
segments
 
are
 
currently
 
managed,
resources are allocated and
 
the way the performance
 
of each segment is evaluated.
 
The two segments
 
consist
of similar operating activities as each segment produces similar
 
products.
Diversification
We benefit from a geographically
 
diverse asset base,
 
in Australia and the United States,
 
with access to multiple
transportation infrastructure options, including key rail and port infrastructure, providing access to both seaborne
export and domestic markets.
 
We have access to the
 
key major markets in both
 
the Atlantic and Pacific
 
basins,
and our wide footprint provides flexibility to respond quickly
 
to changes in global market demands.
We
 
have a
 
dedicated
 
global
 
marketing
 
team
 
that
 
generates
 
direct sales
 
for our
 
Met coal.
 
Our
 
customer
 
base
spans across a full
 
spectrum of key
 
global markets. We
 
sell directly to a
 
number of large,
 
high-quality and well-
known
 
companies
 
in
 
the
 
steel
 
industry
 
globally.
 
Many
 
of
 
our
 
core
 
customers
 
have
 
been
 
our
 
longstanding
customers for over 20 years,
 
and source our products as essential base load,
 
which translates into a long history
of
 
contract
 
renewal
 
for
 
such
 
customers.
 
We
 
are
 
a
 
key
 
supplier
 
to
 
tier
 
one
 
steel
 
mills
 
in
 
Japan,
 
South
 
Korea,
Taiwan,
 
India,
 
Europe,
 
Brazil,
 
North
 
America
 
and
 
China.
 
Given
 
the
 
quality
 
of
 
our
 
diverse
 
customer
 
base,
 
we
believe the
 
demand for
 
our products
 
is fundamentally
 
insulated across
 
all stages
 
of the
 
commodity cycle.
 
This
flexibility provides us the ability to take advantage of favorable
 
market pricing as and where it arises.
c561202310Kp12i0 c561202310Kp12i2 c561202310Kp12i3
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
c561202310Kp12i1 c561202310Kp12i4
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
12
55%
6%
39%
Australia
HCC
SCC
PCI
71%
29%
U.S.
Low Vol
High Vol
We have
 
100% ownership
 
over all
 
of our
 
operating mines,
 
allowing us
 
full control
 
over all
 
operating decisions.
This
 
control
 
is
 
critical
 
during
 
times
 
of
 
crisis
 
and
 
allows
 
us
 
to
 
react
 
swiftly
 
and
 
decisively
 
to
 
changes
 
in
 
global
market demands.
2023 Coronado’s key coal trade flows
Our Met
 
coal production is
 
diversified across high
 
quality products,
 
such as
 
hard coking coal,
 
or HCC,
 
semi coking
coals,
 
or
 
SCC,
 
and
 
pulverized
 
coal
 
injection,
 
or
 
PCI,
 
coal
 
from
 
our
 
Australian
 
Operations,
 
and
 
significant
production of HCC, comprising high volatile content,
 
or High-Vol,
 
(including sub-category A of High-Vol
 
,
 
or HVA,
and
 
sub-category
 
B
 
of
 
High-Vol,
 
or
 
HVB)
 
and
 
coal
 
with
 
low
 
volatile
 
content,
 
or
 
Low-Vol,
 
coals
 
from
 
our
 
U.S.
Operations. This
 
broad product
 
range supports
 
a wide
 
variety of
 
customer requirements
 
and various
 
blending
opportunities, being valued for its attractive coke-making characteristics.
The below charts
 
show Met
 
product ranges
 
for our Australian
 
Operations and
 
our U.S.
 
Operations for
 
the year
ended December 31, 2023.
Overview of Australian Operations—Curragh
Curragh is located in
 
Queensland’s Bowen Basin, one of the
 
world’s premier Met coal regions. Curragh
 
has been
operating since
 
1983, and
 
produces a
 
variety of
 
high-quality,
 
low-ash Met
 
coal products.
 
We believe
 
our HCC
product
 
is
 
recognized
 
by
 
steelmakers
 
for
 
its
 
low-ash
 
content,
 
consistency
 
of
 
quality
 
and
 
favorable
 
coking
attributes. We believe that
 
our SCC products are similarly
 
valued, in particular for their
 
low wall pressure, which
makes them suitable for stamp charging coke
 
ovens, and our PCI coal at Curragh
 
is recognized by steelmakers
for its low phosphorus and sulphur content. These Met
 
coal products are exported globally to a diverse customer
base located primarily in Asia.
 
Curragh also produces thermal
 
coal,
 
which is primarily sold domestically
 
under a
long-term contract with Stanwell, with a limited amount
 
of such thermal coal being exported.
 
 
c561202310Kp13i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
13
94.6%
5.4%
FY23 Coal revenue mix -Australian
Operations
Met
Thermal
Revenues from our Australian Operations represented
 
58.2% of our total revenue for the year ended December
31, 2023. See Item 2. “Properties” for more information regarding
 
Curragh.
 
For the year ended December 31, 2023, 68.7% of the total
 
volume of coal sold by our Australian Operations was
Met coal and 31.3% of the
 
total volume of coal sold
 
by our Australian Operations
 
was thermal coal, the majority
of which is sold to
 
Stanwell. For the year
 
ended December 31, 2023,
 
Curragh sold 6.7
MMt of Met coal
 
into the
seaborne coal
 
markets. The
 
majority
 
of customers
 
purchase
 
multiple grades
 
or products
 
and have
 
purchased
Curragh coal continuously through all stages of the coal/commodity
 
pricing cycle. Curragh’s Met coal is typically
sold
 
on
 
annual
 
contracts
 
negotiated
 
by
 
our
 
global
 
marketing
 
team,
 
with
 
pricing
 
agreed
 
to
 
bilaterally
 
or
 
with
reference
 
to
 
benchmark
 
indices
 
or
 
spot
 
indices.
 
Our
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
have
 
maintained
 
a
 
high
 
level
 
of
contract coverage against planned production. In 2023, substantially all of Curragh’s
 
Met coal export sales were
made under term contracts.
Overview of U.S. Operations—Buchanan and Logan
Our producing mining properties in the United States
 
are located in the CAPP region, specifically in
 
Virginia and
West
 
Virginia,
 
which
 
is
 
a
 
highly-developed
 
and
 
active
 
coal-producing
 
region.
 
Met
 
coal
 
produced
 
by
 
our
 
U.S.
Operations is consumed regionally by North American steel producers or
 
exported by seaborne transportation to
steel producers
 
(primarily in Asia,
 
Europe and South
 
America). The U.S.
 
Operations also
 
produce small quantities
of thermal coal
 
that is extracted
 
in the process
 
of mining Met
 
coal, which is
 
sold predominantly to
 
global export
markets, as well
 
as within North
 
America. We
 
believe that many
 
regard Met coal
 
from the CAPP
 
region (where
our
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
are
 
located)
 
to
 
be
 
of
 
the
 
highest
 
quality
 
in
 
the
 
world
 
owing
 
to
 
its
 
generally
 
low-ash
 
and
sulphur
 
content.
 
Our
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
offer
 
a
 
range
 
of
 
Met
 
coal
 
products,
 
with
 
significant
 
production
 
of
 
HCC,
comprising coal with High-Vol
 
(including HVA and
 
HVB) and coal with Low-Vol.
Sales from
 
our U.S.
 
Operations to
 
export markets
 
are typically
 
priced with
 
reference to
 
a benchmark
 
index. In
circumstances where we
 
sell our seaborne
 
coal through intermediaries
 
Free on Rail
 
(Incoterms 2010), or
 
FOR,
our realized price on FOR sales does not
 
include transportation to the seaborne port
 
or costs to transload into a
vessel. Consistent
 
with seaborne sales,
 
sales to North
 
American customers
 
are generally sold
 
on a FOR
 
basis
where the customer arranges for and incurs the cost of
 
transportation to their facility.
 
A portion of our sales is
 
sold to North American steel and coke producers on annual contracts at
 
fixed prices that
do
 
not
 
fluctuate
 
with
 
the
 
benchmark
 
index.
 
The
 
fixed-price
 
nature
 
of
 
these
 
annual
 
contracts
 
provides
 
us
 
with
visibility on our future revenues, as compared to spot sales or sales priced with reference to a benchmark index.
For
 
2024,
 
we
 
have
 
entered
 
into
 
annual
 
fixed
 
price
 
contracts
 
to
 
sell
 
approximately
 
2.5
 
MMt
 
Met
 
coal
 
to
 
North
American steel and coke producers. During
 
periods of stable and rising prices,
 
we strive to take advantage
 
of the
spot market. Spot export contracts are negotiated throughout
 
the year.
 
Revenues from our U.S.
 
Operations, in the aggregate, represented
 
41.8% of our total
 
revenue for the year
 
ended
December 31, 2023.
 
 
c561202310Kp14i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
14
87.0%
13.0%
FY23 Coal revenue mix -U.S.
Operations
Met
Thermal
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
Tata
Top 5
Top 10
Top
Customers
by coal revenues
FY 23
FY 22
For the year ended December 31, 2023,
 
87.7% of the total volume of
 
coal sold by our U.S. Operations
 
was Met
coal and 12.3%
 
was thermal coal.
 
We sold
 
74.3% of total
 
Met coal from
 
our U.S. Operations
 
into the seaborne
Met coal markets for the year ended December 31, 2023.
 
See Item 2.
 
“Properties” for
 
more information
 
regarding Buchanan
 
,
 
Logan and
 
the other
 
mining properties
 
that
compose our U.S. Operations.
Customers
We sell
 
most of our
 
coal to
 
steel producers,
 
either directly
 
or through
 
intermediaries, such
 
as brokers.
 
We also
sell
 
thermal
 
coal
 
to
 
electricity
 
generators
 
either
 
directly
 
or
 
through
 
intermediaries
 
such
 
as
 
brokers.
 
Major
consumers of our
 
seaborne Met
 
coal in 2023
 
were located
 
in India, China,
 
Japan, South
 
Korea, Taiwan,
 
Brazil
and Europe.
 
These consumers
 
are all
 
major global
 
steel or
 
Met coke
 
producers. The
 
majority of
 
our sales
 
are
made under contracts with terms of typically one year
 
or on a spot basis.
 
Tata
 
Steel
Our U.S. Operations
 
and Australian Operations
 
are parties to
 
Long Term
 
Coal Sale and
 
Purchase Agreements
with TS
 
Global Procurement
 
Company Pte
 
Ltd, or
 
Tata
 
Steel, with
 
terms ending
 
March 31,
 
2025. These
 
Long
Term Agreements provide for the sale of a minimum aggregate total of 2.25 MMt
 
of coal per contract year across
the Group, consisting of certain specific quantities of HCC, and pulverized
 
coal injection, or PCI, Coal.
 
The coal
is sold Free on
 
Board (Incoterms 2020), or FOB, priced with
 
reference to benchmark indices and the
 
agreements
contain industry
 
standard terms
 
and conditions
 
with respect
 
to delivery,
 
transportation, inspection,
 
assignment,
taxes and performance failure.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
15
Stanwell
We are
 
party to
 
contractual arrangements
 
with Stanwell,
 
including a
 
Coal Supply
 
Agreement, or
 
the CSA,
 
and
the Curragh Mine New Coal Supply Deed, dated August
 
14, 2018, or the Supply Deed.
Under the CSA, we deliver thermal coal from Curragh to Stanwell at an agreed price and quantity.
 
Stanwell may
vary the quantity of thermal coal purchased each year so the total quantity to be delivered to Stanwell each year
cannot
 
be
 
precisely
 
forecast.
 
The
 
coal
 
that
 
we
 
supply
 
to Stanwell
 
constitutes
 
the
 
majority
 
of the
 
thermal
 
coal
production from Curragh. Our cost of supplying coal to Stanwell has
 
been greater than the contracted price paid
by Stanwell during the year ended December 31, 2023
 
and for prior years.
 
Under the CSA, we also share part of the revenue earned from export coal sales (from particular Tenements
 
(as
defined below)) with Stanwell through
 
various rebates. The most material rebate is
 
the export price rebate, which
is linked to the realized export coal price for a defined
 
Met coal product, as follows:
•
 
For the
 
first 7.0 MMtpa
 
of export
 
coal sales: when
 
the 12-month trailing,
 
weighted-average realized export
coal price of Reference coal exceeds the Tier
 
1 Rebate Coal Floor Price, we pay a
 
rebate of 25% of the
difference between the realized export coal price and
 
the Tier 1 Rebate Coal Floor
 
Price.
•
 
For export
 
coal sales
 
above 7.0
 
MMtpa: when
 
the 12-month
 
trailing, weighted-average
 
realized export
coal price of Reference coal exceeds the Tier
 
2 Rebate Coal Floor Price, we pay a rebate
 
of 10% of the
difference between the realized export coal price and
 
the Tier 2 Rebate Coal Floor
 
Price.
In addition, the CSA also provides for:
•
 
a tonnage rebate to Stanwell per Mt on the first 7.0 MMtpa of export coal sales
 
and on export coal sales
above 7.0 MMtpa; and
•
 
a rebate on run-of-mine, or ROM, coal mined in the Curragh “Pit U
 
East Area.”
The total Stanwell
 
rebate for the
 
year ended
 
December 31,
 
2023, was $136.5
 
million and has
 
been included in
the
 
Consolidated
 
Statements
 
of
 
Operations
 
and
 
Comprehensive
 
Income
 
included
 
elsewhere
 
in
 
this
 
Annual
Report on Form 10-K.
The Supply
 
Deed grants
 
us the
 
right to
 
mine the
 
coal reserves
 
in the
 
Stanwell Reserved
 
Area, or
 
the SRA.
 
In
exchange, we agreed to certain amendments to the CSA and to
 
enter into a New Coal Supply Agreement, or the
NCSA, upon the expiration
 
of the CSA (which is
 
expected to occur in
 
2027).
 
On July 12, 2019,
 
we entered into
the NCSA with Stanwell. The key terms under the NCSA
 
are described below:
•
 
Coronado’s supply obligation under the NCSA
 
will commence on the earliest of:
-
 
The day after the final delivery date under the CSA;
-
 
the date of termination of the CSA, if it does so prior to
 
final delivery date; or
-
 
January 1, 2029.
 
•
 
The
 
term
 
of
 
the
 
NCSA
 
is
 
expected
 
to
 
be
 
10
 
years,
 
and
 
Coronado’s
 
thermal
 
coal
 
supply
 
obligation
 
to
Stanwell will reduce to
 
2 million ‘Tonnes Equivalent’ per annum (based on a
 
nominal gross calorific value
of
 
25.6GJ)
 
at
 
a
 
fixed
 
contract
 
price
 
that
 
varies
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
agreed
 
formulae,
 
inclusive
 
of
 
all
statutory charges and royalties
 
in respect of coal
 
sold and delivered under
 
the NCSA. The
 
supply term,
the contract
 
tonnage
 
and the
 
contract price
 
under the
 
NCSA are
 
subject to
 
adjustment in
 
accordance
with a financial model agreed between Stanwell and us.
•
 
The export rebates which were payable under the CSA are not
 
payable during the term of NCSA.
In summary, we have agreed that the total value of the discount
 
received by Stanwell on coal supplied to
 
it under
the
 
NCSA
 
should
 
(by
 
the
 
expiration
 
date
 
of
 
the
 
NCSA)
 
be
 
equal
 
to
 
the
 
net
 
present
 
value
 
of
 
$155.2
 
million
(A$210.0 million)
 
as at the date of the Supply Deed, using
 
a contractual pre-tax discount rate of 13% per annum.
 
The net present value of the deferred consideration was $277.4
 
million as of December 31, 2023.
 
On January 18, 2021, the Option Coal Supply Agreement,
 
or the OCSA, contemplated by clause 5 of the NCSA
was
 
entered
 
into,
 
in respect
 
of the
 
supply
 
of certain
 
additional
 
coal
 
to
 
Stanwell
 
during the
 
term
 
of the
 
NCSA.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
16
Thermal coal
 
supplied to
 
Stanwell under
 
the OCSA
 
will be
 
at the
 
higher of
 
cost or
 
market value
 
at the
 
time of
sale.
 
See Item 1A. “Risk
 
Factors—Risks related
 
to the Supply
 
Deed with
 
Stanwell may
 
adversely affect
 
our financial
condition and results of operations.”
Transportation
Coal produced
 
at
 
our mining
 
properties
 
is transported
 
to customers
 
by a
 
combination
 
of road,
 
rail,
 
barge
 
and
ship. See Item 2. “Properties”
 
for descriptions of the transportation infrastructure
 
available to each of our mining
properties. Rail
 
and port
 
services
 
are typically
 
contracted
 
on a
 
long-term,
 
take-or-pay basis
 
in Australia,
 
while
these contracts
 
are typically
 
negotiated on
 
a quarterly
 
basis in
 
the United
 
States.
 
See Item 7.
 
“Management’s
Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
 
—Liquidity and Capital Resources” for
additional information on our take-or-pay obligations.
Australian Operations
Our Australian
 
Operations
 
typically sell
 
export coal
 
FOB, with
 
the customer
 
paying for
 
transportation
 
from the
outbound shipping port.
 
The majority of
 
Curragh’s export
 
Met coal is railed
 
approximately 300 kilometers
 
to the
Port of
 
Gladstone for export
 
via two main
 
port terminals, RG
 
Tanna Coal Terminal,
 
or RGTCT, and Wiggins Island
Coal Export Terminal,
 
or WICET.
 
Curragh also has capacity available
 
to stockpile coal at the Port
 
of Gladstone.
For
 
sales
 
of
 
thermal
 
coal
 
to
 
Stanwell,
 
Stanwell
 
is
 
responsible
 
for
 
the
 
transport
 
of
 
coal
 
to
 
the
 
Stanwell
 
Power
Station.
 
Rail Services
Curragh is
 
linked to
 
the Blackwater
 
rail line
 
of the
 
Central Queensland
 
Coal Network,
 
or CQCN,
 
an integrated
coal
 
haulage
 
rail
 
system
 
owned
 
and
 
operated
 
by
 
Aurizon
 
Network
 
Pty Ltd,
 
or
 
Aurizon
 
Network.
 
Curragh
 
has
secured
 
annual
 
rail
 
haulage
 
capacity
 
of
 
up
 
to
 
11.5
 
MMtpa
 
(plus
 
surge
 
capacity)
 
under
 
long-term
 
rail
 
haulage
agreements with Aurizon
 
Operations Limited, or
 
Aurizon Operations, and
 
Pacific National Holdings
 
Pty Limited,
or Pacific National.
 
The RGTCT Coal
 
Transport Services
 
Agreement with Aurizon
 
Operations is for
 
8.5 MMtpa of
 
haulage capacity
to RGTCT. Curragh pays a minimum monthly charge (components of which are payable on a take-or-pay basis),
which is calculated with reference
 
to the below-rail access charges,
 
haulage/freight charges, a minimum
 
annual
tonnage
 
charge
 
and
 
other
 
charges.
 
The
 
RGTCT
 
Coal
 
Transport
 
Services
 
Agreement
 
terminates
 
on
 
June 30,
2030.
The Coal Transport
 
Services Agreement
 
with Pacific
 
National is
 
for 1.0
 
MMtpa of
 
haulage capacity
 
to RGTCT.
Curragh pays
 
a minimum
 
monthly charge
 
(components of
 
which are
 
payable on
 
a take-or-pay
 
basis), which
 
is
calculated with reference to the below-rail
 
access charges, haulage/freight charges, a
 
minimum annual tonnage
charge and other charges. The
 
Coal Transport Services
 
Agreement with Pacific National terminates
 
on July 31,
2029.
 
The
 
Wiggins
 
Island
 
Rail
 
Project,
 
or
 
WIRP,
 
Transport
 
Services
 
Agreement
 
with
 
Aurizon
 
Operations
 
is
 
for
 
2.0
MMtpa of capacity to
 
WICET.
 
This contract is effectively
 
100% take-or-pay (for a
 
portion of the rail haulage
 
and
all capacity access charges). This agreement expires on June
 
30, 2030.
Port Services
Curragh exports coal
 
through two terminals
 
at the Port
 
of Gladstone, RGTCT
 
and WICET.
 
At RGTCT,
 
Curragh
and
 
Gladstone
 
Port
 
Corporation
 
Limited,
 
or GPC,
 
are
 
parties
 
to
 
a
 
coal
 
handling
 
agreement
 
that
 
expires
 
on
June 30, 2030.
 
The agreement may
 
be renewed
 
at our
 
request and,
 
subject to certain
 
conditions, GPC is required
to agree
 
to the
 
extension
 
if there
 
is capacity
 
at RGTCT
 
to allow
 
the extension.
 
We currently
 
have the
 
right
 
to
export between 7.7 MMtpa and 8.7 MMtpa at our nomination
 
on a take-or-pay basis.
We have
 
a minority
 
interest
 
in WICET
 
Holdings
 
Pty Ltd, whose
 
wholly-owned
 
subsidiary,
 
Wiggins Island
 
Coal
Export Terminal
 
Pty Ltd, or WICET Pty Ltd, owns WICET.
 
Other coal producers who export coal through WICET
also hold
 
shares
 
in
 
WICET
 
Holdings
 
Pty Ltd.
 
In addition,
 
we and
 
the
 
other
 
coal
 
producers
 
(or
 
shippers)
 
have
take-or-pay agreements with WICET Pty
 
Ltd and pay a terminal handling charge
 
to export coal through WICET,
which is
 
calculated
 
by reference
 
to WICET’s
 
annual operating
 
costs, as
 
well as
 
finance
 
costs associated
 
with
WICET
 
Pty Ltd’s
 
external
 
debt
 
facilities.
 
Our
 
take-or-pay
 
agreement
 
with
 
WICET
 
Pty Ltd,
 
or
 
the
 
WICET
Take
 
-or-Pay
 
Agreement,
 
provides
 
Curragh
 
with
 
export
 
capacity
 
of
 
1.5
 
MMtpa.
 
The
 
WICET
 
Take
 
-or-Pay
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
17
Agreement is an “evergreen”
 
agreement, with rolling ten-year
 
terms. If we inform
 
WICET Pty Ltd that we
 
do not
wish to continue to roll the term
 
of the WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement, the term would
 
be set at nine years and
the terminal handling
 
charge payable
 
by us would
 
be increased so
 
that our
 
proportion of WICET
 
Pty Ltd’s debt
is amortized to nil by the end of that nine-year term.
Under
 
the
 
WICET
 
Take
 
-or-Pay
 
Agreement,
 
we
 
are
 
obligated
 
to
 
pay
 
for
 
that
 
capacity
 
via
 
terminal
 
handling
charges, whether utilized or not. The terminal handling charge payable by us can be adjusted by WICET
 
Pty Ltd
if
 
our
 
share
 
of
 
WICET
 
Pty Ltd’s
 
operational
 
and
 
finance
 
costs
 
increases,
 
including
 
because
 
of
 
increased
operational costs or because another shipper defaults
 
and has its capacity reduced to nil. The terminal handling
charge is subject
 
to a financing
 
cap set out
 
in the terminal
 
handling charge methodology
 
and has already
 
been
reached and
 
is in force.
 
If another shipper
 
defaults under
 
its take-or-pay
 
agreement, each
 
remaining shipper
 
is
effectively proportionately liable to pay that defaulting shipper’s share of WICET Pty Ltd’s costs going forward, in
the form of increased terminal handling charges.
If we default under the
 
WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement, we would
 
be obligated to pay a
 
termination payment to
WICET
 
Pty Ltd.
 
The
 
termination
 
payment
 
effectively
 
represents
 
our
 
proportion
 
of
 
WICET
 
Pty Ltd’s
 
total
 
debt
outstanding, based
 
on the
 
proportion of
 
our contracted
 
tonnage to
 
the total
 
contracted
 
tonnage of
 
shippers
 
at
WICET at
 
the time
 
the payment
 
is triggered.
 
Shippers can
 
also become
 
liable to
 
pay the
 
termination
 
payment
where there is a permanent cessation of operations at WICET.
 
Since WICET began shipping export tonnages in
April
 
2015,
 
five
 
WICET
 
Holdings
 
Pty Ltd
 
shareholders
 
have
 
entered
 
into
 
administration
 
and
 
Take
 
-or-Pay
Agreements subsequently terminated, resulting
 
in the aggregate
 
contracted tonnage of shippers
 
decreasing from
27 MMtpa to 13.9 MMtpa.
Under the WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement, we are required
 
to provide security (which is
 
provided in the form of
a bank guarantee). The amount of
 
the security must cover our estimated liabilities as
 
a shipper under the WICET
Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement for the following twelve-month period. If
 
we are in default under
 
the WICET Take-or-Pay
Agreement and
 
are subject
 
to a
 
termination payment,
 
WICET Pty Ltd
 
can draw
 
on the
 
security and
 
apply it
 
to
amounts
 
owing
 
by
 
us. See
 
Item 1A. “Risk
 
Factors—Risks
 
related to
 
our
 
investment
 
in
 
WICET
 
may adversely
affect our
 
financial condition
 
and results
 
of operations”
 
and Item 7.
 
“Management’s
 
Discussion and
 
Analysis of
Financial Condition
 
and Results
 
of Operations—Liquidity
 
and Capital
 
Resources”
 
for additional
 
information
 
on
our take-or-pay obligations.
U.S. Operations
Our
 
U.S.
 
Operations’
 
domestic
 
contracts
 
are
 
generally
 
priced
 
FOR
 
at
 
the
 
mine
 
with
 
customers
 
bearing
 
the
transportation costs from
 
the mine to the
 
applicable end user.
 
For direct sales to
 
export customers, we hold
 
the
transportation
 
contract
 
and
 
are
 
responsible
 
for
 
the
 
cost
 
to
 
the
 
export
 
facility,
 
and
 
the
 
export
 
customer
 
is
responsible
 
for
 
the
 
transportation/freight
 
cost
 
from
 
the
 
export
 
facility
 
to
 
the
 
destination.
 
A
 
portion
 
of
 
our
 
U.S.
export sales are
 
made through intermediaries.
 
For these sales,
 
the intermediary
 
typically take ownership
 
of the
coal as it is loaded into the railcar.
 
The intermediary is responsible for the rail transportation
 
and port costs.
Rail Services
Our U.S. Operations are served by Norfolk Southern and
 
CSX Transportation railroads.
 
Norfolk
 
Southern
 
railroad
 
serves
 
our
 
Buchanan
 
mining
 
property
 
and
 
transports
 
Buchanan’s
 
coal
 
to
 
Lamberts
Point Coal
 
Terminal
 
Pier 6
 
and to
 
CNX Marine
 
Terminal
 
for export
 
customers and
 
to our
 
domestic customers
either directly
 
or
 
indirectly
 
via inland
 
river
 
dock
 
facilities
 
where
 
the coal
 
is transloaded
 
on
 
to
 
barges
 
and
 
then
transported to the customer’s facilities.
CSX
 
Transportation
 
railroad
 
serves
 
our
 
Logan
 
and
 
Greenbrier
 
mining
 
properties.
 
CSX
 
transports
 
Logan
 
and
Greenbrier’s coal to Kinder
 
Morgan Pier IX Terminal
 
or CNX Marine Terminal
 
or Dominion Terminal
 
Associates
(DTA)
 
for
 
export
 
customers
 
and
 
either
 
directly
 
to
 
the
 
customers
 
or
 
to
 
inland
 
river
 
dock
 
facilities
 
for
 
domestic
customers.
 
Port Services
Norfolk
 
Southern’s
 
Lamberts
 
Point
 
Coal
 
Terminal
 
Pier
 
6
 
is
 
the
 
largest
 
coal
 
loading
 
facility
 
in
 
the
 
Northern
Hemisphere with 48 million tons
 
of annual export capacity
 
and is the main terminal
 
at Lamberts Point located
 
in
Norfolk, Virginia.
 
Kinder Morgan’s
 
Pier IX
 
is a
 
coal export
 
terminal with
 
an annual
 
export capacity
 
of 16
 
million
tons located in the Port of Hampton Roads in Newport
 
News, Virginia.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
18
Our U.S. Operations have dedicated inventory capacity
 
and a take-or-pay obligation to transload one million
 
net
tons per
 
year through
 
Kinder Morgan’s
 
Pier IX
 
Terminal
 
to the
 
end of
 
March 2024.
 
On November
 
1, 2022,
 
we
extended our
 
arrangement with
 
Kinder Morgan
 
from April
 
2024 to
 
March 2027,
 
with an
 
option to
 
extend for
 
an
additional
 
three
 
years,
 
for
 
a dedicated
 
inventory
 
capacity
 
and
 
take-or-pay
 
obligation
 
to
 
transload
 
650,000
 
net
tons per
 
year.
 
Our
 
U.S. Operations
 
also have
 
alternate port
 
access
 
through
 
CNX
 
Marine Terminal
 
which
 
is a
transshipping terminal at the Port of Baltimore owned
 
by CONSOL Energy.
Suppliers
The principal
 
goods we
 
purchase
 
in support
 
of our
 
mining activities
 
are mining
 
equipment, replacement
 
parts,
diesel fuel, natural gas, ammonium-nitrate
 
and emulsion-based explosives, off
 
-road tires, steel-related products
(including roof control materials),
 
lubricants and electricity.
 
As a general matter, we have many well-established,
strategic relationships
 
with our
 
key suppliers
 
of goods
 
and do not
 
believe that
 
we are
 
dependent on
 
any of
 
our
individual suppliers.
We also manage
 
and operate several
 
major pieces of
 
mining equipment and
 
facilities to produce
 
and transport
coal,
 
including,
 
but
 
not
 
limited to,
 
longwall
 
mining
 
systems,
 
continuous
 
miners,
 
draglines,
 
dozers,
 
excavators,
shovels,
 
haul
 
trucks,
 
conveyors,
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plants,
 
or
 
CPPs,
 
and
 
rail
 
loading
 
and
 
blending
 
facilities.
Obtaining and repairing these
 
major pieces of equipment
 
and facilities often involves
 
long lead times. We
 
strive
to extend the lives of existing equipment and facilities
 
through maintenance practices and equipment rebuilds to
defer the
 
requirement for
 
larger capital
 
purchases. We
 
use our
 
global leverage
 
with major
 
suppliers to
 
support
security of
 
supply to
 
meet the
 
requirements
 
of our
 
active mines.
 
See Item 2.
 
“Properties” for
 
more information
about operations at our mining properties.
We partner with contractors and other third parties for exploration, mining, and other services, generally, and the
success of these relationships
 
are important for our current
 
operations and the advancement of our development
projects.
 
See
 
Item
 
1A.
 
“Risk
 
Factors—Our
 
profitability
 
could
 
be
 
affected
 
adversely
 
by
 
the
 
failure
 
of
 
suppliers
and/or outside contractors to perform.”
Competition
We operate
 
in a competitive
 
environment. We
 
compete with domestic
 
and international coal
 
producers, traders
and brokers.
 
We compete on price, coal quality, transportation, optionality, reputation and reliability. Demand for
Met coal and the prices that we will be able to obtain
 
for our Met coal are highly competitive and
 
are determined
predominantly by
 
world markets,
 
which are
 
affected by
 
numerous factors
 
beyond our
 
control, including
 
but not
limited to:
 
•
 
general global, regional and local economic activity;
•
 
changes in demand for steel and energy;
•
 
industrial production levels;
•
 
short-term constraints, including weather incidents;
•
 
changes in the supply of seaborne coal;
•
 
technological changes;
•
 
changes in international freight or other transportation infrastructure
 
rates and costs;
•
 
the costs of other commodities and substitutes for coal
 
;
•
 
market changes in coal quality requirements;
•
 
government regulations which restrict, or increase the
 
cost of, using coal;
•
 
tariffs
 
imposed
 
by
 
countries,
 
including
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
and
 
Australia,
 
on
 
the
 
import
 
of
 
certain
 
steel
products and any retaliatory tariffs by other countries
 
;
 
and
•
 
tax impositions on the resources industry,
 
all of which are outside of our control;
In addition, coal prices are highly
 
dependent on the outlook for coal consumption in
 
large Asian economies, such
as China, Japan, South Korea and India,
 
as well as any changes in government
 
policy regarding coal or energy
in those countries.
 
In developing our
 
business plan and
 
operating budget, we
 
make certain assumptions
 
regarding future Met
 
coal
prices, coal demand and
 
coal supply. The prices we receive for
 
our Met coal depend on
 
numerous market factors
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
19
beyond our control. Accordingly,
 
some underlying coal price assumptions relied on by us may materially change
and
 
actual
 
coal
 
prices
 
and
 
demand
 
may
 
differ
 
materially
 
from
 
those
 
expected.
 
Our
 
business,
 
operating
 
and
financial
 
performance,
 
including
 
cash
 
flows
 
and
 
asset
 
values,
 
may
 
be
 
materially
 
and
 
adversely
 
affected
 
by
short- or long-term volatility in the prevailing prices of
 
our products.
Competition in
 
the coal
 
industry is based
 
on many
 
factors, including, among
 
others, world supply
 
price, production
capacity,
 
coal
 
quality
 
and
 
characteristics,
 
transportation
 
capability
 
and
 
costs,
 
blending
 
capability,
 
brand
 
name
and diversified operations. We are
 
subject to competition from
 
producers in Australia, the
 
United States, Canada,
Russia,
 
Mongolia
 
and
 
other
 
coal
 
producing
 
countries.
 
See
 
Item 1A.
 
“Risk
 
Factors—We
 
face
 
increasing
competition, which could adversely affect profitability.”
Environmental Sustainability
Met coal is an essential ingredient in the production of
 
steel, which is the most utilized metal in the world and
 
an
essential material underpinning social and economic growth. Steel’s strength and durability make it critical in the
construction of
 
major projects
 
(including renewable
 
energy infrastructure),
 
transportation
 
technology,
 
electrical
equipment, and everyday household goods.
We are focused
 
on extracting high
 
quality Met coal
 
with a commitment
 
to environment,
 
social and governance,
or ESG, practices. Coal mining is one of the most environmentally regulated industries in the world, and it is vital
that we consistently meet or exceed relevant regulatory
 
standards.
We are subject to various environmental laws, regulations and public policies in Australia
 
and the United States.
Managing
 
our
 
environment
 
and
 
climate
 
change
 
risks
 
is
 
a
 
key
 
component
 
of
 
our
 
corporate
 
strategy
 
and
 
it
 
is
integrated into all stages
 
and areas or our
 
daily operations. We
 
seek to minimize
 
our environmental impact and
ensure we meet or exceed our legislative and regulatory
 
environmental obligations.
 
Coronado’s environmental
 
sustainability initiatives
 
and strategy are
 
discussed further
 
in our 2022
 
Sustainability
Report released
 
on May
 
17, 2023, which
 
can be
 
found on
 
our website
 
at www.coronadoglobal.com/sustainability/.
Nothing
 
on
 
our
 
website,
 
including
 
our
 
2022
 
Sustainability
 
Report
 
or
 
sections
 
thereof,
 
shall
 
be
 
deemed
incorporated by reference
 
into this Annual
 
Report on Form
 
10-K. Our 2023
 
Sustainability Report
 
is expected to
be available in May 2024.
 
Climate change
 
We believe that
 
climate change is
 
a complex
 
challenge that requires
 
action at all
 
levels of
 
society. Climate change
can
 
heighten
 
existing
 
physical
 
and
 
non-physical
 
impacts
 
and
 
risks
 
and
 
introduce
 
new
 
ones
 
that
 
can
 
affect
business performance in the near and long-term.
 
While our operations
 
are recognized as
 
vital contributors to
 
the communities and
 
economies in which
 
we operate,
we acknowledge that our mining activities create greenhouse gas, or GHG, emissions. Climate change is one of
the
 
most
 
significant
 
issues
 
for
 
the
 
steel
 
industry
 
and
 
the
 
industry
 
has
 
made
 
significant
 
reductions
 
in
 
GHG
emissions
 
by
 
improving
 
energy
 
efficiency
 
and
 
using
 
new
 
technologies.
 
Where
 
possible,
 
we
 
are
 
continuing
 
to
identify and
 
implement GHG emissions
 
and energy
 
reduction opportunities across
 
our business,
 
whilst monitoring
climate related
 
risks
 
and the
 
sustainability
 
of our
 
operations.
 
We are
 
committed to
 
working with
 
other industry
partners to
 
support, develop
 
and introduce
 
new coal
 
production and
 
energy-generation technologies,
 
that help
reduce the environmental impact while continuing to meet
 
global energy and steel demands.
Our Australian
 
Operations
 
operate under
 
an Environmental
 
Management
 
System, or
 
EMS, which
 
provides for
environmental management activities
 
undertaken at the
 
mine to minimize environmental
 
harm and contains
 
set
plans
 
and
 
procedures
 
to
 
ensure
 
that
 
our
 
environmental
 
commitments
 
are
 
met.
 
The
 
EMS
 
is used
 
as
 
a
 
tool
 
to
uphold our Australian Operations’ Environmental Policy and integrate
 
environmental compliance into all facets of
the business. Our
 
Australian Operations
 
disclose GHG Scope
 
1 and 2
 
emissions annually
 
to the Clean
 
Energy
Regulator under the National Greenhouse and Energy
 
Reporting Scheme.
 
Our
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
undergo
 
detailed
 
internal
 
inspections
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
rigorous
 
evaluations
 
by
 
both
 
state
 
and
federal inspectors
 
on a
 
regular basis.
 
Our U.S.
 
Operations
 
disclose GHG
 
Scope 1
 
and 2
 
emissions, including
fugitive emissions
 
(methane),
 
for the
 
facilities
 
required
 
to report
 
their
 
emissions
 
annually
 
to the
 
United
 
States
Environmental Protection Agency.
 
Our
 
operations
 
are
 
currently
 
focused
 
on
 
implementing
 
reporting
 
improvements,
 
identifying
 
opportunities
 
for
reducing
 
emissions
 
on
 
a
 
per
 
ton
 
of
 
production
 
basis
 
and
 
benchmarking
 
ourselves
 
against
 
our
 
peer
 
group.
Coronado launched its first set of GHG targets
 
in our 2021 Sustainability Report and has
 
committed to targeting
reductions
 
in
 
its
 
Scope
 
1
 
and
 
2
 
emissions
 
by
 
30%
 
by
 
2030
 
from
 
its
 
2019
 
emissions
 
baseline.
 
In
 
our
 
2022
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
20
Sustainability Report,
 
we reported
 
that we
 
reduced such
 
emissions when
 
compared to
 
2021. Further
 
progress
updates will be included in our 2023 Sustainability Report
 
expected to be filed in May 2024.
 
Emissions
 
reduction
 
estimates
 
to 2030
 
have
 
been evaluated
 
based
 
on improvements
 
that
 
can reasonably
 
be
expected using
 
technologies
 
currently available.
 
Detailed
 
analysis to
 
determine
 
economic
 
viability of
 
available
technologies has not been considered.
The target reduction of 30% by 2030 is based on the current mine plans for Coronado's Curragh and U.S. mines
and
 
is
 
not
 
expected
 
to
 
be
 
a
 
linear
 
reduction.
 
As
 
we
 
address
 
our
 
material
 
areas
 
of
 
impact
 
including
 
emission
reductions and opportunities, the need for mitigation technologies
 
are likely to increase.
Our Central Emissions Group, or CEG, consists of senior leaders and subject matter experts from our Australian
and U.S. Operations who meet monthly to discuss and analyze how climate change might impact our strategies.
One of
 
the key
 
focus areas
 
of the
 
CEG is
 
to ensure
 
that we
 
are progressing
 
towards our
 
emissions reduction
targets.
 
This
 
is
 
achieved
 
through
 
reviewing
 
the
 
accuracy
 
of
 
the
 
emissions
 
forecast,
 
providing
 
updates
 
on
decarbonization
 
projects
 
and
 
discussing
 
idea
 
pipelines
 
in
 
relation
 
to
 
new
 
technologies.
 
Our
 
capital
 
allocation
framework integrates climate-related risks and opportunities
 
into its decision-making processes.
We are
 
also evaluating
 
a range
 
of potential
 
projects that
 
could have
 
a positive
 
impact on
 
our emissions
 
profile
including
 
options
 
for
 
energy
 
generation
 
from
 
solar,
 
wind
 
and
 
gas
 
along
 
with
 
on-grid
 
solutions.
 
In
 
2022,
 
we
commissioned the
 
Buchanan Ventilation
 
Air Methane,
 
or VAM,
 
abatement project
 
on vent
 
shaft 16
 
at our
 
U.S.
Operations. The
 
project utilizes the
 
latest technology
 
to convert
 
fugitive methane
 
gas emissions
 
to carbon
 
dioxide.
Since commencing, the VAM
 
project has destroyed 264,850 tCO2e with a 95% emission
 
destruction efficiency.
 
Given the proven success of the original VAM
 
unit, we have commenced the installation of a second unit at vent
shaft 18
 
at our
 
U.S. Operations
 
.
 
Construction
 
works are
 
underway and
 
are expected
 
to be
 
completed
 
in mid-
2024. While
 
Coronado is
 
also exploring
 
other projects
 
to reduce
 
its carbon
 
footprint, with
 
the establishment
 
of
the second VAM
 
unit we
 
expect to substantially
 
reduce our
 
emissions further,
 
as part
 
of our strategic
 
path to a
30% reduction target by 2030.
 
Similarly, our
 
project to understand and define gas
 
reservoirs at Curragh with gas
 
production drilling is targeting
the capture
 
and beneficial
 
use of
 
open-cut waste
 
mine coal
 
gas from
 
our operations,
 
with priority
 
downstream
use cases being for power generation and use as a diesel substitute
 
in our mining fleets.
 
Drilling works for the pilot
 
program completed in early July 2023
 
and subsequent surface and production facilities
have been procured and are in the final stages of installation.
 
During
 
2023,
 
at
 
our
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
we
 
completed
 
a
 
dual-fuel
 
mine
 
truck
 
12-week
 
trial
 
using
 
gas
transported
 
from
 
Brisbane
 
without
 
incident.
 
The
 
part
 
substitution
 
of
 
gas
 
for
 
diesel
 
showed
 
no
 
discernible
difference
 
to
 
a
 
full
 
diesel-run
 
truck
 
and
 
performed
 
safely.
 
Coronado
 
has
 
commenced
 
the
 
development
 
of
 
a
roadmap to
 
potentially
 
roll-out the
 
conversion
 
of a
 
broader truck
 
fleet
 
pilot. This
 
project is
 
expected
 
to reduce
emissions at Curragh and also realize a reduction in cost given the substitution of diesel for incidental coal seam
gas to power our fleets.
Increased public concern may result in
 
additional regulatory risks as new laws and
 
regulations aimed at reducing
GHG emissions come into effect in the jurisdictions in which we operate. Any legislation that limits or taxes GHG
emissions could adversely impact our growth, increase
 
our operating costs, or reduce demand for our coal.
 
With
 
respect
 
to
 
physical
 
climate
 
risks,
 
our
 
operations
 
may
 
be
 
impacted
 
by
 
weather-related
 
events
 
potentially
resulting in lost production, supply chain disruptions and increased
 
operating costs, which could have a material
adverse impact on our financial results of operations.
 
Increasingly, both foreign and domestic banks, insurance companies and large investors are curtailing or ending
their financial relationships with fossil
 
fuel-related companies. This
 
has and is likely to continue
 
to have adverse
impacts on the liquidity and operations of coal producers.
Additionally, federal,
 
state and international GHG and climate
 
change initiatives, associated regulations or
 
other
voluntary
 
commitments
 
to
 
reduce
 
GHG
 
emissions,
 
including
 
recent
 
reform
 
to
 
the
 
Safeguard
 
Mechanism
 
in
Australia, could significantly increase
 
the cost of coal production
 
and consumption, increase costs
 
as a result of
regulations requiring
 
the installation
 
of emissions
 
control technologies,
 
increase expenses
 
associated with
 
the
purchase of emissions reduction credits
 
to comply with future emissions
 
trading programs, or significantly reduce
coal
 
consumption
 
through
 
implementation
 
of
 
a
 
future
 
clean
 
energy
 
standard.
 
Such
 
initiatives
 
and
 
regulations
could further reduce
 
demand or prices
 
for our coal
 
in both domestic
 
and international
 
markets, could adversely
affect
 
our
 
ability
 
to
 
produce
 
coal
 
and
 
to
 
develop
 
our
 
reserves,
 
could
 
reduce
 
the
 
value
 
of
 
our
 
coal
 
and
 
coal
reserves, and may have a material adverse effect
 
on our business, financial condition and results of operations
 
.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
21
Human Capital Disclosures
People
Our ability to
 
attract and
 
retain skilled,
 
motivated and
 
engaged employees
 
is an
 
essential part
 
of our
 
business.
Investing in the skill and capabilities of our people will underwrite
 
our long-term growth and sustainability. In both
Australia and the
 
United States, we
 
operate in regional
 
locations with highly
 
competitive labor markets.
 
In each
location,
 
we
 
are
 
creating
 
a
 
high-performing
 
workforce
 
with
 
a
 
talent
 
pipeline
 
for
 
future
 
leaders,
 
including
succession planning for critical roles. To
 
achieve this, we continue to create a
 
culture that welcomes and values
all people and
 
where our core
 
values of collaboration,
 
accountability,
 
respect and excellence
 
are demonstrated
in everything that we do.
Worldwide we had 1,878 employees as of
 
December 31, 2023. In addition, as of
 
December 31, 2023, there were
2,335 contractors supplementing the permanent workforce, primarily
 
at Curragh. Since we operate in areas with
highly competitive labor markets, it is essential that
 
we have a continued focus on attracting
 
the best people, and
ensuring we have programs in place to engage, develop
 
and retain them within our business.
We continue to support
 
initiatives to enhance our
 
culture, increase our
 
ability to attract and
 
retain the workforce
we need, and
 
to drive our
 
desire to build
 
safe, high-performing
 
teams. This
 
includes extensive
 
efforts to
 
gather
feedback from our
 
employees and contracting
 
partners through surveys,
 
focus groups and
 
team empowerment
sessions. Following
 
analysis of the
 
feedback, priorities
 
are identified,
 
and cultural
 
programs designed
 
to bridge
gaps between current and desired cultural states are developed
 
and implemented.
As of
 
December 31,
 
2023, approximately
 
10.8% of
 
our total
 
employees, all
 
at our
 
Australian Operations,
 
were
covered by a single, federally-certified collective Enterprise Agreement, or the EA, for specified groups
 
of mining
and maintenance employees. In
 
July 2023, the
 
Australian Fair Work Commission
 
approved the four
 
year Curragh
Mine Enterprise Agreement 2023. Our U.S. Operations
 
employ a 100% non-union labor force.
Safety
Our
 
employees
 
and
 
contractors
 
are
 
our
 
most
 
valuable
 
assets,
 
and
 
we
 
consider
 
their
 
safety
 
our
 
number
 
one
priority.
 
Safety is
 
essential to
 
all business
 
functions and
 
is never
 
to be
 
compromised, under
 
any circumstance.
The
 
health
 
and
 
safety
 
of
 
our
 
people
 
is
 
reinforced
 
every
 
day
 
through
 
our
 
culture,
 
behaviors,
 
training,
communication and procedures.
 
We manage safety and health
 
through continuous improvement efforts
 
and the implementation of practices
 
and
procedures that address safety risks first and in full compliance with the legal and
 
regulatory frameworks of both
the United States and Australia. We empower our people to consistently strive to have a safety mindset, and act
by
 
applying,
 
managing
 
and
 
monitoring
 
effective
 
controls
 
to
 
prevent
 
adverse
 
outcomes
 
with
 
all
 
activities
 
and
operations. Our programs are intended
 
to reinforce our position that safety
 
and health should always be
 
front of
mind for all employees and contractors.
 
Safety
 
performance
 
is
 
monitored
 
through
 
physical
 
observations
 
from
 
both
 
internal
 
and
 
external
 
parties
 
and
through the
 
reporting of
 
key metrics.
 
Safety performance
 
is assessed
 
monthly against
 
internal goals
 
and on
 
a
quarterly basis is benchmarked against our peers within
 
the mining industry.
 
We set targets
 
for safety interactions
 
which is a process
 
where employees observe
 
a risk behavior and
 
provide
immediate feedback
 
if it
 
is deemed,
 
or has the
 
potential to
 
be, unsafe.
 
This is
 
monitored by
 
management daily
through safety meetings,
 
site visits, employee
 
discussions, and management
 
observations. The process
 
allows
for greater empowerment, innovation and employee input
 
into the mining process.
 
The 12-month rolling average Total
 
Reportable Injury Frequency Rate, or “TRIFR”,
 
as of December 31, 2023 for
our
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
was
 
1.83
 
and
 
the
 
Total
 
Reportable
 
Incident
 
Rate,
 
or
 
“TRIR”,
 
for
 
12-month
 
rolling
average
 
as
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023
 
for
 
our
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
was
 
1.44.
 
As
 
indicated
 
in
 
the
 
graphs
 
below,
 
our
Australian Operations outperformed the
 
Queensland industry average in
 
2022 and 2023
 
and our U.S.
 
Operations
outperformed the U.S. national average in
 
2022 and 2023. We strive to
 
ensure that we continue to
 
provide a safe
operating environment for all employees and contractors.
c561202310Kp22i1 c561202310Kp22i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
22
Workforce composition and diversity
Our
 
values
 
(CARE
 
–
 
Collaboration,
 
Accountability,
 
Respect,
 
Excellence)
 
guide
 
our
 
policies,
 
processes
 
and
actions as they
 
relate to
 
all workforce
 
interactions and
 
people related
 
initiatives. As
 
part of these
 
values and
 
to
enable our people to excel within the workplace we are building a diverse and inclusive workforce, where unique
viewpoints are
 
heard, valued and
 
respected. We understand
 
the value
 
diversity brings and
 
recognize that
 
creating
a culture
 
which welcomes
 
and values
 
all individuals
 
is paramount
 
to our
 
ability to
 
attract, retain,
 
motivate and
develop the best talent. We believe
 
this directly impacts the safety
 
and productivity of our people.
 
Our employees
are trained to recognize and mitigate potential biases towards
 
others.
 
We
 
invest
 
in
 
training
 
and
 
development
 
programs
 
for
 
both
 
our
 
new
 
and
 
long-serving
 
employees.
 
Investing
 
in
graduate
 
recruitment,
 
traineeships
 
and
 
internship
 
programs
 
through
 
partnerships
 
with
 
leading
 
education
institutions
 
has
 
been
 
central
 
to
 
accessing
 
talent
 
and
 
building
 
our
 
brand.
 
Further,
 
our
 
internal
 
leadership
development enhances succession planning and the transfer
 
of skills and knowledge across our business.
As of December 31, 2023:
•
 
in the
 
United States,
 
approximately 6.8%
 
of Senior
 
Managers were
 
female,
 
increased from
 
6.1% as
 
of
December 31, 2022.
•
 
in Australia,
 
over
 
28% of
 
employees
 
at a
 
General
 
Manager,
 
Senior Manager
 
and Senior
 
Professional
level were female.
•
 
6.8% of our global workforce was female.
•
 
57% of
 
all employees
 
were
 
between the
 
ages
 
of 30
 
and 50
 
years
 
old, and
 
the
 
number
 
of employees
under 30 increased from 11.5%
 
as of December 31, 2022 to 13.7% as of December
 
31, 2023.
Attracting and retaining the right people
We continued
 
to focus our
 
efforts on
 
recruiting trainees
 
and other entry
 
level roles. We
 
have also implemented
the following initiatives:
 
•
 
Comprehensive training, performance and leadership development
 
programs.
•
 
Competitive and flexible remuneration structure.
In
 
2023,
 
our
 
total
 
rolling
 
turnover
 
rate
 
was
 
18.1%
 
and
 
13.4%
 
in
 
Australia
 
and
 
the
 
U.S.,
 
respectively,
 
and
 
our
voluntary departure
 
rolling turnover rate
 
was 15.5%
 
in Australia
 
and 10.9% in
 
the U.S. In
 
2022, our total
 
rolling
turnover rate
 
was 16.0%
 
and 16.7%
 
in Australia
 
and the
 
U.S., respectively,
 
and our
 
voluntary departure
 
rolling
turnover rate was 14.5% in both Australia and the U.S.
 
Regulatory Matters—Australia
Our Australian Operations
 
are regulated by the
 
laws and regulations
 
of the Commonwealth
 
of Australia, or
 
Cth,
the State
 
of Queensland,
 
or Qld,
 
and local
 
jurisdictions. Most
 
environmental laws
 
are promulgated
 
at the
 
state
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
23
level, but the Australian federal government has a role
 
in approval of actions which have national environmental
significance.
 
In
 
Queensland,
 
the
 
environmental
 
laws
 
relevant
 
to
 
coal
 
mining
 
include
 
development
 
legislation,
pollution,
 
waste,
 
ecosystem
 
protection,
 
cultural
 
heritage
 
and
 
native
 
title
 
land
 
contamination
 
and
 
rehabilitation
legislation. In addition, the Australian federal government regulates
 
foreign investment and export approvals.
Tenements
We control the
 
coal mining
 
rights at Curragh
 
under 14 coal
 
and infrastructure
 
mining leases, or
 
MLs, and three
mineral development licenses, or MDLs, granted pursuant to the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (Qld).
 
See Item 2.
“Properties” for more information regarding the Tenements.
Mineral Resources Act 1989 (Qld)
The Mineral Resources
 
Act 1989 (Qld)
 
and the Mineral
 
and Energy Resources
 
(Common Provisions)
 
Act 2014
(Qld), together,
 
provide for the
 
assessment, development
 
and utilization of
 
mineral resources in
 
Queensland to
the
 
maximum
 
extent
 
practicable,
 
consistent
 
with
 
sound
 
economic
 
and
 
land
 
use
 
management.
 
The
 
Mineral
Resources
 
Act
 
1989
 
(Qld)
 
vests
 
ownership
 
of
 
minerals,
 
with
 
limited
 
exceptions,
 
in
 
the
 
Crown
 
(i.e., the
 
state
government). A royalty is payable to the Crown for
 
the right to extract minerals. The Mineral Resources Act 1989
(Qld) creates different tenures
 
for different mining activities,
 
such as prospecting, exploring
 
and mining. A ML is
the most important
 
tenure, as it permits
 
the extraction of
 
minerals in conjunction
 
with other required
 
authorities.
The Mineral Resources Act 1989 (Qld) imposes general conditions
 
on a ML.
A person who is the holder
 
of a ML must keep
 
the records necessary to enable the royalty payable
 
by the person
to
 
be
 
ascertained.
 
In
 
2022,
 
the
 
Queensland
 
State
 
Government
 
in
 
Australia
 
amended
 
the
 
Mineral
 
Resources
Regulation
 
2013
 
(Qld)
 
introducing
 
additional
 
higher
 
tiers
 
to
 
the
 
coal
 
royalty
 
rates
 
effective
 
from
 
July
 
1,
 
2022,
increasing the royalty payable by our Australian Operations.
The new tiers applicable in calculating the royalty payable for our Australian Operations from July 1, 2022 are as
set out below:
•
 
7% for average coal price per Mt sold up to and including
 
A$100 per Mt;
•
 
12.5% for average coal price per Mt sold from A$100 to
 
A$150 per Mt;
•
 
15% for average coal price per Mt sold from A$150 to
 
A$175 per Mt;
•
 
20% for average coal price per Mt sold from A$175 to
 
A$225 per Mt;
•
 
30% for average coal price per Mt sold from A$225 to
 
A$300 per Mt; and
•
40% for average coal price per Mt sold above A$300 per
 
Mt.
The royalty
 
payable
 
for
 
coal sold,
 
disposed
 
of or
 
used
 
in
 
a return
 
period
 
is then
 
calculated
 
by multiplying
 
the
royalty rate by the
 
value of the coal.
 
Queensland Revenue
 
Office Royalty
 
Ruling MRA001.1 contains
 
details on
the
 
costs
 
that
 
can
 
(and
 
cannot)
 
be
 
deducted
 
when
 
calculating
 
the
 
applicable
 
royalty
 
and
 
the
 
method
 
for
determining the value of the coal. Where there is a change in legislation
 
or case law that affects the content of a
royalty ruling, the change
 
in the law
 
overrides the royalty ruling—i.e., the
 
Commissioner will determine the royalty
liability in
 
accordance with
 
the changed
 
law.
 
See Item 2.
 
“Properties” for
 
a discussion
 
of the
 
royalties currently
applicable to Curragh.
Mining Rehabilitation (Reclamation)
Mine closure and rehabilitation risks and costs are regulated
 
by Queensland state legislation.
Amongst
 
other
 
things,
 
an
 
Environmental
 
Authority
 
Holder,
 
or
 
EA
 
Holder,
 
must
 
provide
 
the
 
Queensland
 
State
Government with financial assurance for the purpose of drawing upon in the event that an EA Holder defaults on
its obligations to rehabilitate the mine site.
The Mineral
 
and
 
Energy
 
Resources
 
(Financial
 
Provisioning)
 
Act
 
2018 (Qld),
 
or the
 
Financial
 
Provisioning
 
Act
establishes
 
a
 
financial
 
provisioning
 
scheme,
 
or
 
the
 
Scheme,
 
from
 
which
 
the
 
Department
 
of
 
Environment
 
and
Science, or the DES, sources funds to rehabilitate and
 
remediate land subject to mining.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
24
Under the Financial Provisioning Act,
 
all mine operators are required
 
to make a submission
 
to the DES in
 
respect
of an Estimated Rehabilitation Cost, or ERC,
 
for the mine site. The ERC is determined
 
using the DES-approved
ERC calculator.
 
Using this
 
information, the
 
DES sets
 
the ERC
 
for the
 
mine. The
 
DES provides
 
the ERC
 
to the
manager of the
 
Scheme, or
 
the Scheme Manager.
 
The Scheme
 
Manager undertakes
 
a risk assessment
 
of the
mine,
 
which
 
is
 
based
 
upon
 
independent
 
advice
 
from
 
a
 
Scheme
 
risk
 
advisor.
 
EAs
 
with
 
at
 
least
 
$100,000
 
in
estimated
 
rehabilitation
 
costs
 
will
 
undergo
 
an
 
annual
 
risk
 
category
 
allocation
 
assessment
 
process.
 
The
assessment process will determine whether the holder will be required to provide a contribution to the Scheme’s
Financial Provisioning Fund and/or to provide surety to
 
the Scheme Manager for that EA.
 
It includes detail on the
mine operator’s financial
 
soundness and
 
credit rating,
 
characteristics of
 
the mining operation
 
(e.g., life of
 
mine,
or LOM,
 
and off-take
 
agreements), rehabilitation
 
history,
 
environmental compliance
 
history and the
 
submission
made by the Company. Risk categories include high, moderate, low and very low. If the ERC and risk categories
are set
 
at moderate,
 
low or
 
very low
 
for a mine,
 
then there
 
is a need
 
to pay
 
an annual
 
contribution based
 
on a
small percentage
 
of the
 
ERC to
 
the Scheme.
 
The prescribed
 
percentages for
 
each category
 
are: (1)
 
Very
 
low:
0.5%; (2) Low:
 
1.0%; and (3)
 
Moderate: 2.75%. If
 
the category is
 
high, then the
 
operation provides
 
a surety for
the whole ERC and
 
possibly a contribution
 
to the Scheme. The
 
risk assessment of
 
the mine and, therefore,
 
the
amount of the contribution to the fund is assessed and paid annually in perpetuity,
 
or until a clearance certificate
is obtained.
 
Each year, the Scheme Manager
 
is required to
 
make an Annual
 
Review Allocation to determine
 
whether the mine
will provide surety or pay a contribution to the Scheme
 
depending on the value of the ERC relating to applicable
environmental authorities, as follows:
1)
 
ERC < A$100,000 - cash surety or bank guarantees
2)
 
ERC = A$100,000 – A$450 million - pay a cash contribution
 
into the Scheme
3)
 
ERC > A$450 million - pay a cash contribution into the
 
Scheme and provide bank guarantees.
There
 
can
 
be
 
no
 
assurance
 
that
 
our
 
risk
 
category
 
allocation
 
will
 
not
 
change
 
in
 
future
 
years.
 
Our
 
financial
obligations may increase due to a number of factors, including
 
but not limited to:
•
 
any changes that increases ERC or are of disturbances;
•
 
any major Environmental Authority,
 
or EA, amendment;
•
 
compliance with existing EA obligations; and
 
•
 
major changes to financial soundness of the EA holder.
 
Curragh has
 
2
 
EAs, which
 
are covered
 
by the
 
Scheme,
 
namely
 
EA number
 
EPML00643713
 
and
 
EA number
EPVX00635313.
 
In
 
October
 
2023,
 
the
 
Scheme
 
Manager
 
completed
 
the
 
assessment
 
of
 
the
 
Annual
 
Review
Allocation
 
for
 
environmental
 
authority
 
number
 
EPML00643713
 
and
 
issued
 
an
 
Annual
 
Review
 
Allocation
 
of
“Moderate”.
 
The
 
moderate
 
rating
 
resulted
 
in
 
Curragh
 
being
 
obliged
 
to
 
make
 
a
 
financial
 
contribution
 
to
 
the
Scheme of 2.75% of the ERC.
 
In January 2024, the Scheme Manager completed
 
an assessment of the Annual
Review Allocation for
 
EA Number EPVX00635313
 
and issued an Annual
 
Review Allocation of
 
“High” in respect
of MDL162 requiring Curragh to maintain its historical financial assurance in respect of 100% of the ERC for that
EA.
The Financial Provisioning Act also requires
 
for a Progressive Rehabilitation and
 
Closure Plan, or a PRCP,
 
with
respect to mined
 
land. This requirement
 
is integrated into
 
the existing EA
 
processes for
 
new mines, minimizing
the
 
regulatory
 
burden
 
on
 
government
 
and
 
industry.
 
All
 
mining
 
projects
 
carried
 
out
 
under
 
a
 
ML
 
that
 
make
 
a
site-specific
 
EA
 
application
 
will
 
be
 
required
 
to
 
provide
 
a
 
PRCP.
 
If
 
approved
 
by
 
the
 
administering
 
authority,
 
a
stand-alone PRCP schedule will be given to the applicant together with the EA. The PRCP schedule will
 
contain
milestones
 
with
 
completion
 
dates
 
for
 
achieving
 
progressive
 
rehabilitation
 
of
 
the
 
mine
 
site.
 
The
 
Financial
Provisioning Act provided
 
transitional arrangements for three
 
years for the application of
 
the PRCP requirement
to
 
existing
 
mines.
 
The
 
requirement
 
for
 
a
 
PRCP
 
commenced
 
on
 
November
 
1,
 
2019,
 
or
 
the
 
PRCP
 
start
 
date,
however all existing mining operations only transition into the PRCP framework once a transition notice is
 
issued
by DES, the relevant
 
government department.
 
Curragh’s PRCP was
 
submitted to DES
 
on October 20,
 
2022, in
accordance
 
with
 
the
 
transition
 
notice
 
it
 
received;
 
and
 
Curragh
 
has
 
complied
 
with
 
all
 
further
 
requests
 
for
information made by
 
DES. DES recently
 
advised Curragh that
 
the end date
 
of the decision
 
period in relation
 
to
the PRCP has been extended to June 10, 2024.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
25
Environmental Protection Act 1994 (Qld)
The
 
primary
 
legislation
 
regulating
 
environmental
 
management
 
of
 
mining
 
activities
 
in
 
Queensland
 
is
 
the
Environmental
 
Protection
 
Act 1994
 
(Qld),
 
or
 
the
 
EP
 
Act. Its
 
objective
 
is to
 
protect
 
Queensland’s
 
environment
while allowing
 
for development
 
that improves
 
the total
 
quality of
 
life, both
 
now and
 
in the
 
future, in
 
a way
 
that
maintains ecologically sustainable
 
development. Under the EP
 
Act, it is an offense
 
to carry out a
 
mining activity
unless the person holds or is acting under an EA for the activity. The EA imposes conditions on a project. It is an
offense to contravene a condition of an
 
EA. In addition to the requirements found
 
in the conditions of an EA, the
holder must
 
also meet
 
its general
 
environmental
 
duty and
 
duty to
 
notify of
 
environmental
 
harm and
 
otherwise
comply with the provisions of the EP
 
Act and the regulations promulgated thereunder. For example, the following
are offenses under the EP Act:
•
 
causing serious or material environmental harm;
•
 
causing environmental nuisance;
•
 
depositing proscribed water contaminants in waters and related
 
matters; and
•
 
placing contaminants where environmental harm or nuisance
 
may be caused.
The
 
EA
 
holder
 
must
 
also
 
be
 
a
 
registered
 
suitable
 
operator
 
under
 
the
 
EP
 
Act.
 
We
 
are
 
a
 
registered
 
suitable
operator.
We hold
 
EA EPML00643713, which
 
authorizes the
 
mining of black
 
coal, mineral
 
processing, chemical storage,
waste disposal and
 
sewage treatment over
 
the 14 MLs
 
at Curragh on
 
certain conditions. Those
 
conditions include
requirements
 
in relation
 
to
 
air and
 
water quality,
 
regulated structures
 
(e.g., dams),
 
noise and
 
vibration, waste,
land use, rehabilitation and watercourse diversion.
We
 
also
 
hold
 
a
 
range
 
of
 
subsidiary
 
EAs
 
for
 
our
 
Australian
 
Operations.
 
See
 
“—Mining
 
Rehabilitation
(Reclamation)
”
above
for more information regarding the Financial Provisioning
 
Act.
 
Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 (Qld)
The Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 (Qld) imposes a duty of care on all persons to take all reasonable and
practicable measures to ensure that any activity conducted does not harm
 
Aboriginal cultural heritage. Its object
is to provide effective recognition, protection and conservation
 
of Aboriginal cultural heritage.
We have obligations
 
relating to Aboriginal cultural
 
heritage with respect
 
to a number of
 
cultural heritage objects
and areas located within
 
the area of the
 
Tenements.
 
We work closely
 
with the Aboriginal people
 
to manage the
cultural heritage objects, areas or
 
evidence of archaeological significance, within
 
our mining operations. We
 
are
party to a Cultural Heritage Management Plan (and associated Cultural
 
Services Agreement) with the Gaangalu
Nation People that applies
 
to all of the Tenements.
 
The plan establishes a
 
coordinating committee and sets
 
out
the steps to be followed to manage activities that may impact
 
Aboriginal cultural heritage.
Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)
The Native Title Act
 
1993 (Cth), or NTA,
 
sets out procedures under which
 
native title claims may be lodged
 
and
determined and compensation claimed for
 
the extinguishment or impairment of
 
the native title rights or interests
of Aboriginal peoples. Its object is to provide for the recognition and protection of native title, to establish ways in
which future
 
dealings affecting
 
native title
 
may proceed
 
and to
 
set standards
 
for those
 
dealings, to
 
establish a
mechanism
 
for determining
 
claims to
 
native
 
title
 
and to
 
provide for,
 
or permit,
 
the
 
validation of
 
past
 
acts,
 
and
intermediate period acts, invalidated because of the existence
 
of native title.
With respect to MLs and MDLs
 
granted under the Mineral Resources
 
Act 1989 (Qld) on state land
 
where native
title has not
 
been extinguished,
 
a principle
 
known as
 
the non-extinguishment
 
principle governs.
 
Broadly,
 
under
this principle, native title rights are suspended while the mining tenure,
 
as renewed from time to time, is in force.
The grant
 
(or renewal)
 
of a
 
mining tenure
 
in respect
 
of land
 
where native
 
title may
 
exist must
 
comply with
 
the
NTA
 
to ensure
 
the validity
 
of the tenure.
 
Registered native
 
title claimants
 
have certain
 
notification, consultation
and negotiation rights relating
 
to mining tenures. Where
 
native title is extinguished
 
(i.e., freehold land), the NTA
does not apply.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
26
Regional Planning Interests
The Regional
 
Planning Interests
 
Act 2014
 
(Qld), or
 
the RPI
 
Act manages
 
the impact
 
of resource
 
activities and
other
 
regulated
 
activities
 
in
 
areas
 
of
 
the
 
state
 
that
 
contribute,
 
or
 
are
 
likely
 
to
 
contribute,
 
to
 
Queensland’s
economic, social
 
and environmental
 
prosperity (e.g., competing
 
land use
 
activities on
 
prime farming
 
land). The
RPI
 
Act
 
identifies
 
areas
 
of
 
Queensland
 
that
 
are
 
of
 
regional
 
interest,
 
including
 
strategic
 
cropping
 
areas
 
and
strategic environmental
 
areas. Under
 
the RPI Act,
 
conducting a
 
resource activity
 
in an area
 
of regional
 
interest
requires
 
a
 
regional
 
interest
 
development
 
approval,
 
unless
 
operating
 
under
 
an
 
exemption.
 
Importantly,
pre-existing mining activities being undertaken at the date of
 
the introduction of the legislation are exempt.
We
 
have
 
been
 
granted
 
a
 
regional
 
interest
 
development
 
approval
 
for
 
the
 
“Curragh
 
Expansion
 
Project”
 
(for
ML700006,
 
ML
 
700007
 
and
 
ML
 
700008),
 
which
 
is subject
 
to regional
 
interest
 
conditions,
 
such
 
as mitigation.
Certain protection conditions
 
are also imposed
 
on us with respect
 
to ML 80171,
 
which includes an
 
obligation to
provide mitigation in the event that strategic cropping land
 
is impacted by future operations.
Environmental Protection and Biodiversity Conservation
 
Act 1999 (Cth)
The Environment Protection
 
and Biodiversity Conservation
 
Act 1999 (Cth),
 
or the EPBC Act,
 
provides a federal
framework
 
to
 
protect
 
and
 
manage
 
matters
 
of
 
national
 
environmental
 
significance,
 
such
 
as
 
listed
 
threatened
species
 
and
 
ecological
 
communities
 
and
 
water
 
resources.
 
In
 
addition,
 
the
 
EPBC
 
Act
 
confers
 
jurisdiction
 
over
actions
 
that
 
have
 
a
 
significant
 
impact
 
on
 
the
 
environment
 
where
 
the
 
actions
 
affect,
 
or
 
are
 
taken
 
on,
Commonwealth land, or are carried out by a Commonwealth agency.
Under the
 
EPBC Act, “controlled
 
actions” that have
 
or are likely
 
to have a
 
significant impact on
 
a matter
 
of national
environmental significance are subject
 
to a rigorous assessment
 
and approval process. A
 
person must not take
a “controlled
 
action” unless approval
 
is granted
 
under the
 
EPBC Act.
 
Any person
 
proposing to
 
carry out
 
an “action”
that may be
 
a “controlled action”
 
must refer the
 
matter to the
 
Commonwealth Minister
 
for a determination
 
as to
whether the proposed action is a controlled action.
On
 
November 2,
 
2016,
 
the
 
Commonwealth
 
Minister
 
for
 
the
 
Department
 
of
 
the
 
Environment
 
and
 
Energy
administering the
 
EPBC Act
 
approved the
 
extension of
 
the existing Curragh
 
mining area to
 
include mining
 
four
additional Tenements
 
—ML 700006,
 
ML 700007,
 
ML 700008
 
and ML 700009
 
(EPBC Act
 
referral 2015/7508)—
as
 
a
 
“controlled
 
action,”
 
on
 
certain
 
conditions.
 
The
 
conditions
 
include
 
requirements
 
in
 
relation
 
to
 
offsets
 
and
groundwater.
Mine Health and Safety
The primary health and safety legislation that applies
 
to Curragh are the Coal Mining Safety and
 
Health Act 1999
(Qld)
 
and
 
the
 
Coal
 
Mining
 
Safety
 
and
 
Health
 
Regulation 2001
 
(Qld),
 
which
 
we
 
refer
 
to,
 
together,
 
as the
 
Coal
Mining Safety Legislation.
Additional
 
legislative
 
requirements
 
apply
 
to
 
operations
 
that
 
are
 
carried
 
on
 
off-site
 
or
 
which
 
are
 
not
 
principally
related to
 
coal mining
 
(e.g., transport, rail
 
operations, etc.).
 
The Coal
 
Mining Safety
 
Legislation imposes
 
safety
and health
 
obligations on
 
persons who
 
operate coal
 
mines or
 
who may
 
affect
 
the safety
 
or health
 
of others
 
at
coal mines. Under the Coal Mining Safety Legislation, the operator
 
of a coal mine must, among other things:
•
 
ensure that the risk to coal mine workers while at the
 
operator’s mine is at an acceptable level;
•
 
audit and review the
 
effectiveness and
 
implementation of the
 
safety and health
 
management system to
ensure the risk to persons is at an acceptable level;
•
 
provide
 
adequate
 
resources
 
to
 
ensure
 
the
 
effectiveness
 
and
 
implementation
 
of
 
the
 
safety
 
and
 
health
management system;
•
 
ensure the
 
operator’s own
 
safety and
 
health and
 
the safety
 
and health
 
of others
 
is not
 
affected by
 
the
way the operator conducts coal mining operations;
•
 
not carry
 
out an
 
activity at
 
the coal
 
mine that
 
creates a
 
risk to
 
a person
 
on an
 
adjacent or
 
overlapping
petroleum authority if the risk is higher than an acceptable
 
level of risk;
•
 
appoint a site senior executive for the mine;
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
27
•
 
ensure the site senior
 
executive develops and
 
implements a safety
 
and health management
 
system for
all people at the mine;
•
 
ensure the
 
site senior
 
executive develops,
 
implements
 
and maintains
 
a management
 
structure for
 
the
mine that helps ensure the safety and health of persons
 
at the mine; and
•
 
not operate the coal mine without a safety and health
 
management system for the mine.
We recognize that health and
 
safety are imperative to the ongoing
 
success of our Australian Operations.
 
As the
operator at Curragh, we have
 
in place a comprehensive safety
 
and health management system,
 
which includes
an emergency
 
response
 
team,
 
to address
 
these legislative
 
requirements.
 
In accordance
 
with the
 
Coal Mining
Safety Legislation we have also established an occupational
 
hygiene baseline for dust exposure at Curragh.
Water Act 2000 (Qld)
 
In Queensland, all entitlements to the use, control and
 
flow of water are vested in the state and regulated by
 
the
Water Act
 
2000 (Qld).
 
Allocations under
 
the Water
 
Act 2000 (Qld)
 
can be managed
 
by a water
 
supply scheme
operator,
 
such
 
as
 
SunWater Ltd,
 
which
 
is
 
a
 
Government-owned
 
corporation
 
regulated
 
by
 
the
 
Queensland
Competition Authority. We
 
have purchased the required water allocations for Curragh and entered into a suite of
related
 
channel
 
and
 
pipeline
 
infrastructure
 
agreements
 
and
 
river
 
supply
 
agreements
 
with
 
SunWater Ltd
 
to
regulate the
 
supply of water
 
pursuant to these
 
allocations. See Item 1A.
 
“Risk Factors—In times
 
of drought and/or
shortage of available water, our operations and production, particularly at Curragh, could be negatively impacted
if the regulators impose restrictions on our water offtake
 
licenses that are required for water used in the CPPs.”
National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting Act 2007
 
(Cth)
The National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting Act 2007 (Cth) imposes requirements for both foreign and local
corporations
 
whose
 
carbon
 
dioxide
 
production
 
GHG
 
and/or
 
energy
 
consumption
 
meets
 
a
 
certain
 
threshold
 
to
register and
 
report GHG
 
emissions and
 
abatement actions,
 
as well
 
as energy
 
production and
 
consumption
 
as
part of
 
a single,
 
national reporting
 
system. The
 
Clean Energy
 
Regulator administers
 
the National
 
Greenhouse
and
 
Energy Reporting
 
Act
 
2007 (Cth),
 
and
 
the
 
Department
 
of Climate
 
Change,
 
Energy,
 
the
 
Environment
 
and
Water is responsible for related policy
 
developments and review.
The
 
Australian
 
Government
 
recently
 
reformed
 
the
 
Safeguard
 
Mechanism
 
to
 
incentivize
 
emissions
 
reductions,
through
 
declining
 
emissions
 
limits,
 
called
 
baselines,
 
predictably
 
and
 
gradually
 
on
 
a
 
trajectory
 
consistent
 
with
achieving the Government’s emissions reduction target of 43% below 2005
 
levels by 2030 and net zero by
 
2050.
On March
 
31, 2023, the
 
Australian Federal Parliament
 
passed the Safeguard
 
Mechanism (Crediting) Amendment
Bill 2023 amending the
 
National Greenhouse and
 
Energy Reporting Act 2007
 
and other legislation,
 
to establish
the framework to give effect to key elements of the reforms, such as introducing credits to
 
the scheme to provide
an incentive to companies to go below their baselines.
The
 
Safeguard
 
Mechanism
 
applies
 
to
 
industrial
 
facilities
 
emitting
 
more
 
than
 
100,000
 
tons
 
of
 
carbon
 
dioxide
equivalent per
 
year,
 
including in
 
electricity,
 
mining, oil
 
and gas
 
production, manufacturing,
 
transport and
 
waste
facilities.
In accordance
 
with the
 
Safeguard Mechanism, and
 
following the
 
Federal Government’s finalization
 
of the
 
National
Greenhouse and Energy Reporting (Safeguard Mechanism) Amendment
 
(Reforms) Rule 2023, Curragh intends
to
 
establish
 
a
 
new
 
production-adjusted
 
(intensity)
 
baseline
 
for
 
covered
 
emissions
 
(Scope
 
1).
 
Curragh
 
will
 
be
required to take action to keep its’
 
net Scope 1 emissions at or below
 
the baseline through emissions reduction,
by
 
for
 
example,
 
purchasing
 
Safeguard
 
Mechanism
 
Credits,
 
or
 
SMCs,
 
from
 
another
 
facility
 
captured
 
by
 
the
Safeguard
 
Mechanism,
 
purchasing
 
and
 
surrendering
 
Australian
 
Carbon
 
Credit
 
Units,
 
or
 
ACCUs,
 
or
 
face
enforcement measures.
Labor Relations
Minimum employment entitlements, embodied in the National Employment Standards, apply to all private-sector
employees
 
and
 
employers
 
in Australia
 
under
 
the federal
 
Fair Work
 
Act 2009
 
(Cth).
 
These standards
 
regulate
employment conditions and paid leave. Employees who are associated with
 
the day-to-day operations of a local
mine or mines and who are not located in head office or corporate administration offices are also covered by the
Black Coal Mining Industry Award 2010 which regulates conditions including termination arrangements,
 
pay and
hours of work.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
28
Unfair dismissal,
 
enterprise bargaining,
 
bullying claims,
 
industrial actions
 
and resolution
 
of workplace
 
disputes
are also regulated
 
under state
 
and federal
 
legislation. Some
 
of the workers
 
at Curragh
 
are covered
 
by the
 
EA,
which
 
was
 
approved
 
by
 
the
 
Fair
 
Work
 
Commission,
 
Australia’s
 
national
 
workplace
 
relations
 
tribunal.
 
See
 
“—
Human Capital Disclosures” above.
Regulatory Matters—United States
Federal,
 
state
 
and
 
local
 
authorities
 
regulate
 
the
 
U.S.
 
coal
 
mining
 
industry
 
with
 
respect
 
to
 
matters
 
such
 
as
employee
 
health
 
and
 
safety,
 
protection
 
of
 
the
 
environment,
 
permitting
 
and
 
licensing
 
requirements,
 
air
 
quality
standards, water pollution, plant and wildlife protection, the
 
reclamation and restoration of mining properties after
mining
 
has
 
been
 
completed,
 
the
 
discharge
 
of
 
materials
 
into
 
the
 
environment,
 
surface
 
subsidence
 
from
underground mining and the effects
 
of mining on groundwater quality
 
and availability.
 
In addition, the industry is
affected
 
by significant
 
requirements
 
mandating
 
certain
 
benefits for
 
current
 
and
 
retired
 
coal miners.
 
Numerous
federal,
 
state
 
and
 
local
 
governmental
 
permits
 
and
 
approvals
 
are
 
required
 
for
 
mining
 
operations.
 
Because
 
of
extensive and
 
comprehensive
 
regulatory
 
requirements,
 
violations during
 
mining
 
operations
 
occur from
 
time
 
to
time in
 
the industry.
 
In addition
 
to the
 
non-exhaustive summary
 
of material
 
federal legislation
 
described below,
our operations are
 
subject to a
 
wide array of
 
federal, state and
 
local environmental
 
law, including,
 
for example,
the Safe Drinking Water Act, the Toxic
 
Substances Control Act, the Emergency Planning and Community Right-
to-Know Act, the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 and the Migratory Bird Treaty Act of 1918, as well as
state regulatory schemes that either mirror federal law or
 
create additional layers of regulation.
Clean Air Act of 1970
The U.S.
 
Clean Air
 
Act of
 
1970, or
 
the CAA,
 
regulates airborne
 
pollution that
 
may be
 
potentially detrimental
 
to
human
 
health,
 
the
 
environment
 
or
 
natural
 
resources.
 
The
 
CAA
 
and
 
comparable
 
state
 
laws
 
that
 
govern
 
air
emissions affect U.S. coal mining operations both
 
directly and indirectly.
Direct impacts
 
on coal
 
mining and
 
processing operations
 
may occur
 
through the
 
CAA permitting
 
requirements
and/or
 
emission
 
control
 
requirements
 
relating
 
to
 
particulate
 
matter,
 
or
 
PM,
 
nitrogen
 
dioxide,
 
ozone
 
and
 
sulfur
dioxide,
 
or
 
SO
2
.
 
For
 
example,
 
the
 
U.S.
 
Environmental
 
Protection
 
Agency,
 
or
 
the
 
EPA,
 
pursuant
 
to
 
the
 
CAA,
administers rules
 
that apply
 
PM limits to
 
emissions from
 
coal preparation
 
and processing
 
plants constructed
 
or
modified after April 28, 2008.
 
In addition, in recent years,
 
the EPA
 
has adopted
 
more stringent national ambient
air quality standards, or NAAQS for PM, nitrogen oxide, ozone
 
and SO
2
. It is possible that these modifications as
well as future modifications
 
to NAAQS could directly
 
or indirectly impact our
 
mining operations in a
 
manner that
includes,
 
but
 
is
 
not
 
limited
 
to,
 
the
 
EPA
 
designating
 
new
 
areas
 
of
 
the
 
country
 
as
 
being
 
in
 
nonattainment
 
of
applicable NAAQS or expanding existing
 
nonattainment areas, and prompting
 
additional local control measures
pursuant to state
 
implementation plans, or
 
SIPs, required to
 
address such revised
 
NAAQS. SIPs may
 
be state-
specific or regional in scope.
 
Under the CAA, individual
 
states have up to
 
12 years from the
 
date of designation
of attainment/nonattainment areas to secure reductions
 
from emission sources.
 
The CAA
 
also indirectly, but significantly, affects the
 
U.S. coal
 
industry by
 
extensively regulating the
 
SO2, nitrogen
oxides, mercury,
 
PM, greenhouse gases,
 
and other substances
 
emitted by coal-burning
 
facilities, such as
 
steel
manufacturers,
 
coke
 
ovens
 
and
 
coal
 
fired
 
electric
 
power
 
generating
 
facilities.
 
Over
 
time,
 
the
 
EPA
 
has
promulgated or proposed CAA
 
regulations to impose more
 
stringent air emission standards
 
for a number
 
of these
coal-burning
 
industries,
 
especially
 
the
 
power
 
generation
 
sector.
 
Collectively,
 
CAA
 
regulations
 
and
 
uncertainty
around
 
future
 
CAA
 
requirements
 
could
 
reduce
 
the
 
demand
 
for
 
coal
 
and,
 
depending
 
on
 
the
 
extent
 
of
 
such
reduction, could have a material adverse effect
 
on our business, financial condition and operations.
NAAQS Revisions
.
 
The CAA
 
requires the
 
EPA
 
to periodically
 
review and,
 
if appropriate,
 
revise the
 
NAAQS to
ensure protection of
 
public health.
 
In recent years,
 
the EPA
 
has reviewed the
 
NAAQS for PM,
 
ozone and SO
2
.
 
The PM NAAQS
 
was last revised
 
and made more
 
stringent in 2012.
 
Individual states have developed
 
SIPs, which
detail the PM emission reductions their sources must meet in order
 
for the state to maintain or achieve the 2012
PM NAAQS. On
 
April 14,
 
2020, the EPA announced
 
its intention
 
to retain, without
 
changes, the 2012
 
PM NAAQS.
 
This action was finalized by EPA on December 18, 2020.
 
On January 6, 2023, EPA proposed lowering the level
of the
 
annual 24-hour
 
PM2.5 standards
 
for fine
 
PM NAAQS
 
from 12.0
 
ug/m3 to
 
within the
 
range of
 
9.0 to 10.0
ug/m3. More stringent
 
NAAQS, if promulgated,
 
would require new
 
SIPs to be developed
 
and filed with the
 
EPA
and may trigger
 
additional control technology for
 
mining equipment or
 
coal-burning facilities, or result
 
in additional
challenges to permitting and expansion efforts
Cross State Air Pollution Rule, or CSAPR.
 
The CAA includes a so-called Good Neighbor
 
Provision that requires
upwind states to
 
eliminate their
 
significant contributions
 
to downwind states’
 
nonattainment of the
 
NAAQS. On
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
29
July 6, 2011,
 
the EPA
 
finalized the CSAPR,
 
which was
 
meant to satisfy
 
this Good Neighbor
 
Provision. CSAPR
requires the
 
District of
 
Columbia and
 
27 states
 
from Texas
 
eastward (not
 
including the
 
New England
 
states or
Delaware) to reduce power plant emissions that
 
cross state lines and significantly contribute to ozone
 
and/or fine
particle
 
pollution
 
in
 
downwind
 
states.
 
Following
 
litigation
 
in the
 
D.C. Circuit
 
and
 
U.S. Supreme
 
Court,
 
the first
phase of
 
the nitrogen
 
oxide and
 
SO2 emissions
 
reductions required
 
by CSAPR
 
commenced in
 
January 2015;
further reductions of both pollutants in the second phase
 
of CSAPR became effective in January 2017.
 
On March 15,
 
2021, EPA
 
finalized a rule
 
update that requires
 
additional emissions
 
reduction of nitrogen
 
oxides
from power plants in
 
twelve states.
 
Additional emission reduction
 
requirements in these
 
states could adversely
affect the demand for coal.
 
On April
 
30,
 
2021,
 
EPA
 
finalized
 
the
 
Revised
 
CSAPR
 
Update Rule,
 
which
 
fully
 
addressed
 
twenty-one
 
states’
outstanding interstate pollution transport obligations for the 2008 NAAQS for ozone.
 
For nine states, EPA found
that
 
their
 
projected
 
2021
 
emissions
 
do
 
not
 
significantly
 
contribute
 
to
 
non-attainment
 
and/or
 
maintenance
problems in downwind states.
 
The remaining twelve states
 
were found to
 
contribute to the non-attainment and/or
maintenance
 
problems
 
in
 
downwind
 
states.
 
EPA
 
indicated
 
that
 
it
 
would
 
issue
 
new
 
or
 
amended
 
Federal
Implementation Plans
 
requiring additional
 
emissions reductions
 
from electricity
 
generating units
 
in those states
beginning in the 2021 ozone season.
Mercury and Air
 
Toxic
 
Standards, or MATS.
 
The EPA
 
published the final
 
MATS
 
rule in the
 
Federal Register
 
on
February 16,
 
2012.
 
The
 
MATS
 
rule
 
revised
 
the
 
New
 
Source
 
Performance
 
Standards,
 
or
 
NSPS,
 
for
 
nitrogen
oxides,
 
SO2
 
and
 
PM
 
for
 
new
 
and
 
modified
 
coal-fueled
 
electricity
 
generating
 
plants,
 
and
 
imposed
 
Maximum
Achievable Control
 
Technology,
 
or MACT,
 
emission limits
 
on hazardous
 
air pollutants,
 
or HAPs,
 
from new
 
and
existing coal-fueled and oil-fueled electricity generating plants. MACT standards limit emissions of mercury,
 
acid
gas HAPs, non-mercury HAP
 
metals and organic
 
HAPs. The rule
 
provided three years
 
for compliance with
 
MACT
standards and
 
a possible
 
fourth year
 
if a
 
state permitting
 
agency determined
 
that such
 
was necessary
 
for the
installation of controls. Though the
 
MATS rule
 
has been the subject of various
 
legal challenges, EPA
 
reaffirmed
the scientific, economic, and legal underpinnings of
 
the MATS rule in February 2023 and, in
 
April, proposed even
more stringent
 
non-mercury
 
metal surrogate
 
filterable
 
particulate matter
 
emission
 
standards
 
for all
 
coal-fueled
electricity generating plants
 
and new mercury
 
emission standards for
 
lignite-powered units. This
 
could increase
the cost of coal-fired electric power generation and
 
negatively impact the demand for coal.
Greenhouse Gas Emissions Standards
 
and Guidelines
.
 
In 2014, the EPA
 
proposed a sweeping rule, known
 
as
the “Clean
 
Power
 
Plan,” to
 
cut carbon
 
emissions
 
from existing
 
electricity
 
generating
 
units,
 
including coal-fired
power plants. Following
 
a series of legal
 
challenges, EPA
 
commenced new rulemaking
 
proceedings in October
2017, ultimately rescinding the Clean Power Plan and finalizing its replacement, the Affordable Clean Energy, or
ACE plan,
 
in June
 
2019. The
 
ACE rule
 
establishes emission
 
guidelines for
 
states to
 
develop plans
 
to address
greenhouse gas emissions from existing coal-fired power
 
plants. Like its predecessor,
 
the ACE rule was subject
to significant litigation and was remanded to EPA
 
for further action.
 
On
 
May 23,
 
2023,
 
EPA
 
issued
 
a proposed
 
rule
 
to repeal
 
ACE and
 
implement
 
sweeping
 
new
 
NSPS
 
for GHG
emissions from new, modified, and reconstructed power plants under the CAA as well as emission guidelines for
existing
 
power
 
plants.
 
The
 
proposed
 
rule
 
would
 
require
 
widespread
 
implementation
 
of
 
carbon
 
capture
 
and
sequestration, or CCS, and
 
use of green hydrogen.
 
On November 15, 2023,
 
EPA issued
 
a supplemental notice
of
 
proposed
 
rulemaking
 
to
 
request
 
additional
 
comment
 
on
 
the
 
proposal
 
following
 
publication
 
of
 
the
 
Initial
Regulatory Flexibility Analysis and completion of a Small Business Advocacy Review Panel. If implemented, the
new rules
 
would require
 
significant capital
 
expenditure
 
to develop
 
the infrastructure
 
necessary
 
for compliance
and could impact our customers and future demand for
 
coal.
On June
 
19, 2019,
 
the EPA
 
finalized the
 
ACE rule
 
as a
 
replacement for
 
the Clean
 
Power Plan.
 
The ACE
 
rule
establishes emission guidelines
 
for states to develop
 
plans to address greenhouse
 
gas emissions from existing
coal-fired power plants.
 
The ACE rule
 
has several components:
 
a determination of
 
the best system
 
of emission
reduction for
 
greenhouse
 
gas
 
emissions from
 
coal-fired
 
power plants,
 
a list
 
of “candidate
 
technologies”
 
states
can use when
 
developing their
 
plans, and new
 
implementing regulations
 
for emission guidelines
 
under Section
111(d)
 
of the CAA.
 
Unlike the
 
Clean Power
 
Plan, the
 
ACE rule
 
only includes
 
as candidate
 
technologies those
that increase the efficiency of individual emission units, also referred to as heat rate improvement measures; the
ACE
 
rule
 
does
 
not
 
include
 
other
 
methods
 
such
 
as
 
co-firing
 
with
 
natural
 
gas
 
or
 
adding
 
renewable
 
generation
facilities.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
30
There have
 
also been
 
numerous challenges
 
to the
 
permitting of
 
new coal-fired
 
power plants
 
by environmental
organizations and state
 
regulators for concerns related
 
to greenhouse gas
 
emissions.
 
For instance, various state
regulatory authorities
 
have rejected
 
the construction
 
of new
 
coal-fueled power
 
plants based
 
on the
 
uncertainty
surrounding the potential
 
costs associated with
 
greenhouse gas emissions under
 
future laws.
 
In addition, several
permits issued to
 
new coal-fueled power
 
plants without greenhouse
 
gas emission limits
 
have been appealed
 
to
the EPA's
 
Environmental
 
Appeals Board.
 
A federal
 
appeals court
 
allowed a
 
lawsuit pursuing
 
federal common
law claims to proceed
 
against certain utilities
 
on the basis
 
that they may
 
have created a
 
public nuisance due
 
to
their emissions of
 
carbon dioxide, while
 
a second federal
 
appeals court dismissed
 
a similar case
 
on procedural
grounds.
 
The United States Supreme Court overturned that decision in June 2011, holding that federal common
law
 
provides
 
no
 
basis
 
for
 
public
 
nuisance
 
claims
 
against
 
utilities
 
due
 
to
 
their
 
carbon
 
dioxide
 
emissions.
 
The
United
 
States
 
Supreme
 
Court
 
did
 
not,
 
however,
 
decide
 
whether
 
similar
 
claims
 
can
 
be
 
brought
 
under
 
state
common law.
 
As a result, tort-type
 
liabilities remain a concern.
 
To
the extent that these
 
risks affect our
 
current
and prospective customers,
 
they may reduce the demand
 
for coal-fired power, and may affect long-term demand
for coal.
Regional Haze.
 
The EPA
 
promulgated a regional
 
haze program designed
 
to protect and
 
to improve visibility
 
at
and around Class I Areas, which are generally national parks, national wilderness areas and international parks.
This program
 
may restrict
 
the construction
 
of
 
new
 
coal-fired
 
power
 
plants,
 
the
 
operation
 
of
 
which
 
may
 
impair
visibility
 
at
 
and
 
around
 
the
 
Class
 
I
 
Areas.
 
Additionally,
 
the
 
program
 
requires
 
certain
 
existing
 
coal-fired
 
power
plants
 
to install
 
additional
 
control measures
 
designed
 
to limit
 
haze-causing
 
emissions,
 
such
 
as SO2,
 
nitrogen
oxide and PM. On August
 
30, 2022 EPA
 
issued a final action finding that
 
15 states had failed to
 
submit SIPs by
the
 
July
 
31,
 
2021
 
deadline.
 
Such
 
failure
 
triggers
 
a
 
two
 
year
 
deadline
 
for
 
EPA
 
to
 
promulgate
 
a
 
Federal
Implementation Plan unless the states submit
 
and EPA approves
 
a SIP that meets the applicable requirements.
 
If states adopt SIPs with more stringent requirements,
 
demand for coal could be affected.
New Source
 
Review,
 
or NSR
. Pursuant
 
to NSR
 
regulations,
 
stationary sources
 
of air
 
pollution must
 
obtain an
NSR permit prior to beginning
 
construction of a new
 
“major” source of emissions
 
or a “major” modification
 
of an
existing major source.
 
If a project
 
is determined to
 
trigger NSR, Prevention
 
of Significant Deterioration
 
regulations
require the project to implement Best
 
Available Control Technology
 
and/or Non-Attainment New Source Review
Lowest Achievable Emission Rate control technology.
Beginning in the late 1990s, the EPA filed lawsuits against owners of many
 
coal-fired power plants in the eastern
U.S. alleging that
 
the owners performed non-routine
 
maintenance, causing increased emissions
 
that should have
triggered
 
the
 
application
 
of
 
these NSR
 
standards.
 
Some of
 
these
 
lawsuits
 
have
 
been settled
 
with
 
the
 
owners
agreeing
 
to
 
install
 
additional
 
emission
 
control
 
devices
 
in
 
their
 
coal-fired
 
power
 
plants.
 
In
 
recent
 
years,
 
EPA
proposed and promulgated several revisions to its
 
NSR regulations and policies concerning NSR permitting.
 
For
example, in
 
2022, EPA
 
proposed to
 
reconsider its
 
fugitive emissions
 
rule. Remaining
 
litigation and
 
uncertainty
around the NSR program rules could impact demand
 
for coal.
Coke Ovens.
 
Coke Oven
 
Batteries and
 
Coke Ovens:
 
Pushing, Quenching,
 
and Battery
 
Stacks are
 
two source
categories regulated by the
 
CAA. On August 16,
 
2023, EPA
 
proposed amendments to the
 
emissions standards
for Coke Ovens which would
 
lower the limits for leaks
 
from doors, lids, and offtakes, require
 
fence line monitoring
for benzene and impose new emissions standards for previously unregulated hazardous air pollutants within
 
the
category
 
such
 
as
 
hydrogen
 
chloride,
 
hydrogen
 
fluoride,
 
and
 
mercury.
 
If
 
implemented,
 
these
 
standards
 
may
impact our current and prospective customers and reduce long-term
 
demand for coal.
Clean Water Act of 1972
The U.S. Clean Water Act of 1972, or the CWA,
 
and corresponding state law governs the discharge of toxic and
non-toxic pollutants into the waters of the United States. CWA requirements
 
may directly or indirectly affect U.S.
coal mining operations.
Water Discharge.
 
The CWA and corresponding state laws affect coal mining operations by imposing restrictions
on discharges
 
of wastewater into
 
waters of
 
the United
 
States through the
 
National Pollutant Discharge
 
Elimination
System,
 
or
 
NPDES,
 
or
 
an
 
equally
 
stringent
 
program
 
delegated
 
to
 
a
 
state
 
agency.
 
The
 
EPA
 
and
 
states
 
may
develop
 
standards
 
and
 
limitations
 
for
 
certain
 
pollutants,
 
including
 
through
 
the
 
technology-based
 
standard
program and water quality
 
standard program. These restrictions often
 
require us to pre-treat
 
the wastewater prior
to discharging
 
it. NPDES
 
permits require
 
regular monitoring,
 
reporting and
 
compliance with
 
effluent limitations.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
31
New requirements
 
under
 
the
 
CWA
 
and
 
corresponding
 
state
 
laws
 
may
 
cause
 
us
 
to
 
incur
 
significant
 
additional
costs that could adversely affect our operating results.
Dredge and Fill Permits.
 
Many mining activities, such as the development
 
of refuse impoundments, fresh water
impoundments,
 
refuse fills,
 
and other
 
similar structures,
 
may result
 
in
 
impacts
 
to
 
waters
 
of the
 
United
 
States,
including wetlands, streams
 
and, in certain
 
instances, man-made conveyances that
 
have a hydrologic
 
connection
to such streams
 
or wetlands. Under
 
the CWA,
 
coal companies are
 
also required to
 
obtain a Section 404
 
permit
from
 
the
 
USACE
 
prior
 
to
 
conducting
 
certain
 
mining
 
activities,
 
such
 
as
 
the
 
development
 
of
 
refuse
 
and
 
slurry
impoundments, fresh water impoundments,
 
refuse fills and other similar
 
structures that may affect
 
waters of the
United
 
States,
 
including
 
wetlands,
 
streams
 
and,
 
in
 
certain
 
instances,
 
man-made
 
conveyances
 
that
 
have
 
a
hydrologic connection
 
to streams
 
or wetlands.
 
The USACE
 
is authorized
 
to issue
 
general “nationwide”
 
permits
for specific
 
categories of
 
activities
 
that are
 
similar in
 
nature and
 
that are
 
determined
 
to have
 
minimal adverse
effects on
 
the environment.
 
Permits issued
 
pursuant to
 
Nationwide Permit
 
21, or
 
NWP 21,
 
generally authorize
the
 
disposal
 
of
 
dredged
 
and
 
fill
 
material
 
from
 
surface
 
coal
 
mining
 
activities
 
into
 
waters
 
of
 
the
 
United
 
States,
subject to certain restrictions. Since
 
March 2007, permits under
 
NWP 21 were reissued
 
for a five-year period
 
with
new
 
provisions
 
intended
 
to
 
strengthen
 
environmental
 
protections.
 
There
 
must
 
be
 
appropriate
 
mitigation
 
in
accordance
 
with
 
nationwide
 
general
 
permit
 
conditions
 
rather
 
than
 
less
 
restricted
 
state-required
 
mitigation
requirements,
 
and
 
permit
 
holders
 
must
 
receive
 
explicit
 
authorization
 
from
 
the
 
USACE
 
before
 
proceeding
 
with
proposed mining activities. The USACE may also issue individual
 
permits for mining activities that do not qualify
for Nationwide Permit 21.
For many years, there has been uncertainty surrounding the definition of “waters of the United States” the scope
of CWA
 
jurisdiction. On
 
August 29,
 
2023, EPA
 
and the
 
Department of
 
the Army
 
issued a
 
final rule
 
revising the
definition of “waters of the United States ” under
 
the CWA. This rule conforms with the Supreme Court’s decision
in Sackett
v.
Environmental
 
Protection,
 
598
 
U.S.
 
651
 
(2023). The
 
revised
 
definition
 
and
 
the
 
Supreme
 
Court’s
decision in
 
Sackett narrow
 
agency jurisdiction under
 
the CWA. However, due
 
to ongoing
 
litigation, implementation
of the
 
revised definition
 
has been
 
delayed in
 
several states
 
and territories.
 
It is
 
uncertain what
 
impact this
 
may
have on our operations.
Effluent Limitations
 
Guidelines for
 
the Steam
 
Electric Power
 
Generating Industry.
 
On September
 
30, 2015,
 
the
EPA published a
 
final rule setting new or additional requirements for
 
various wastewater discharges from steam
electric power plants.
 
The rule set
 
zero discharge
 
requirements for
 
some waste streams,
 
as well as
 
new, more
stringent limits for arsenic, mercury,
 
selenium and nitrogen applicable to certain other waste streams.
 
On August 31, 2020, the EPA finalized a rule to revise the guidelines and standards for the steam electric power
generating point source category applicable to two categories of wastewater streams regulated by
 
the 2015 rule:
flue
 
gas
 
desulfurization
 
wastewater,
 
or
 
FGD,
 
and
 
bottom
 
ash
 
transport
 
water,
 
or
 
BA.
 
With
 
respect
 
to
 
FGD,
selenium standards are
 
less stringent than
 
under the 2015
 
rule, and certain
 
types of facilities,
 
such as facilities
with
 
high
 
FGD
 
flow,
 
low
 
utilization
 
boilers
 
and
 
those
 
set
 
to
 
retire
 
coal
 
combustion
 
units,
 
are
 
subject
 
to
 
less
stringent
 
effluent
 
limits.
 
The
 
compliance
 
deadline
 
for
 
FGD
 
technology-based
 
wastewater
 
limits
 
was
 
extended
from December
 
31,
 
2023 to
 
December
 
31,
 
2025.
 
On
 
March
 
29,
 
2023, EPA
 
proposed
 
new
 
rules to
 
revise
 
the
technology-based
 
effluent
 
limitations
 
guidelines
 
and
 
standards
 
for
 
the
 
steam
 
electric
 
power
 
generating
 
point
source category
 
applicable to
 
FGD wastewater,
 
bottom ash
 
transport water,
 
and combustion
 
residual leachate
at existing
 
sources. If
 
finalized, these
 
rules could
 
significantly increase
 
costs for
 
many coal-fired
 
steam electric
power plants.
Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977
The
 
Surface
 
Mining
 
Control
 
and
 
Reclamation
 
Act of
 
1977,
 
or the
 
SMCRA,
 
which
 
is administered
 
by the
 
U.S.
Office
 
of
 
Surface
 
Mining
 
Reclamation
 
and
 
Enforcement,
 
or
 
OSM,
 
establishes
 
operational,
 
reclamation
 
and
closure standards for
 
all aspects of
 
surface mining and
 
many aspects of
 
underground mining in
 
the United States.
 
Under the SMCRA, a
 
state may submit a
 
qualifying surface mining
 
regulatory scheme to the
 
OSM, and request
to exert
 
exclusive jurisdiction over
 
surface mining activities
 
within its territory. If
 
OSM finds that
 
the state’s scheme
meets
 
SMCRA’s
 
requirements
 
and
 
gives
 
approval,
 
the
 
state
 
becomes
 
the
 
primary
 
regulatory
 
authority
 
with
oversight from OSM. Each of Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, where our Buchanan, Logan, Greenbrier
and
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
operations
 
are
 
based,
 
has
 
adopted
 
qualifying
 
surface
 
mining
 
regulatory
 
schemes
 
and
 
has
primary jurisdiction over surface mining activities within their
 
respective territories. However, even if a state gains
approval for
 
its surface
 
mining regulatory
 
program, the
 
OSM retains
 
significant federal
 
oversight, including
 
the
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
32
ability to perform
 
inspections of
 
all surface mining
 
sites to ensure
 
state program and
 
mine operator compliance
with federal minimum standards. The OSM and its state counterparts
 
also oversee and evaluate standards of:
•
 
performance (both during operations and during reclamation);
•
 
permitting
 
(applications
 
must
 
describe
 
the
 
pre-mining
 
environmental
 
conditions
 
and
 
land
 
use,
 
the
intended mining and reclamation standards, and the post-mining
 
use);
•
 
financial assurance (SMCRA
 
requires that mining companies
 
post a bond sufficient
 
to cover the cost
 
of
reclaiming the site,
 
and the
 
bond is not
 
released until
 
mining is
 
complete, the
 
land has
 
been reclaimed
and the OSM has approved the release);
•
 
inspection and enforcement (including the issuance of notices of violation and the placement of a
 
mining
operation,
 
its
 
owners
 
and
 
controllers
 
on
 
a
 
federal
 
database
 
known
 
as
 
the
 
Applicant
 
Violator
 
System,
meaning that such person or entity is blocked from obtaining
 
future mining permits); and
•
 
land restrictions (SMCRA prohibits surface mining on certain lands and also allows
 
citizens to challenge
surface mining operations on the grounds that they will cause
 
a negative environmental impact).
Under the SMCRA
 
and its state
 
law counterparts, all
 
coal mining applications must
 
include mandatory “ownership
and control” information,
 
which generally includes
 
listing the names of
 
the operator’s officers
 
and directors, and
its principal stockholders owning 10% or
 
more of its voting shares,
 
among others. Regulations under the SMCRA
and its
 
state analogues provide
 
that a
 
mining permit or
 
modification can,
 
under certain
 
circumstances, be delayed,
refused or revoked if we
 
or any entity that owns
 
or controls us or is
 
under common ownership or
 
control with us
have unabated permit
 
violations or
 
have been
 
the subject of
 
permit or
 
reclamation bond revocation
 
or suspension.
In recent years, the
 
permitting required for
 
coal mining has been
 
the subject of increasingly
 
stringent regulatory
and administrative
 
requirements
 
and extensive
 
activism and
 
litigation by
 
environmental
 
groups.
 
After a
 
permit
application is
 
prepared and
 
submitted to
 
the regulatory
 
agency,
 
it goes
 
through a
 
completeness and
 
technical
review.
 
Regulatory authorities
 
have considerable
 
discretion in
 
the timing
 
of the
 
permit issuance
 
and the
 
public
has
 
the
 
right
 
to
 
comment
 
on
 
and
 
otherwise
 
engage
 
in
 
the
 
permitting
 
process,
 
including
 
public
 
hearings
 
and
through
 
intervention
 
in the
 
courts. Before
 
a SMCRA
 
permit
 
is issued,
 
a mine
 
operator
 
must submit
 
a bond
 
or
other form of financial security to guarantee the performance
 
of reclamation bonding requirements.
SMCRA
 
provides
 
for
 
three
 
categories
 
of
 
bonds:
 
surety
 
bonds,
 
collateral
 
bonds
 
and
 
self-bonds.
 
For
 
our
 
U.S.
Operations,
 
we
 
meet
 
our
 
reclamation
 
bonding
 
requirements
 
by
 
posting
 
surety
 
bonds
 
and
 
participation
 
in
 
the
Commonwealth
 
of
 
Virginia
 
bond
 
pool.
 
Our
 
total
 
amount
 
of
 
reclamation
 
surety
 
bonds
 
outstanding
 
was
approximately $28.5
million as
 
of December
 
31, 2023.
 
The surety
 
bond requirements
 
for a
 
mine represent
 
the
calculated cost to reclaim the current operations if it ceased to operate in
 
the current period. The cost calculation
for each surety bond must be completed according to
 
the regulatory authority of each state.
The SMCRA Abandoned Mine Land Fund requires
 
a fee on all coal
 
produced in the United States. The proceeds
are used to rehabilitate
 
lands mined and left
 
unreclaimed prior to August
 
3, 1977 and to pay
 
health care benefit
costs of
 
orphan beneficiaries
 
of the Combined
 
Fund created
 
by the
 
Coal Industry
 
Retiree Health
 
Benefit Act
 
of
1992. The fee amount can change periodically
 
based on changes in federal legislation.
 
See Item 2. “Properties”
for information regarding reclamation and other taxes applicable
 
to our U.S. mining properties.
National Environmental Policy Act of 1969
The National Environmental Policy
 
Act of 1969,
 
or NEPA, applies to mining
 
operations or permitting requirements
that
 
require
 
federal
 
approvals
.
 
NEPA
 
defines
 
the
 
processes
 
for
 
evaluating
 
and
 
communicating
 
environmental
impact
 
of
 
“major
 
federal
 
actions”
 
significantly
 
affecting
 
the
 
quality
 
of
 
the
 
human
 
environment,
 
such
 
as
 
the
permitting of new mine
 
development on federal
 
lands. NEPA
 
requires federal agencies, such
 
as the EPA
 
or the
OSM,
 
to
 
incorporate
 
environmental
 
considerations
 
in
 
their
 
planning
 
and
 
decision-making.
 
The
 
federal
 
agency
carrying out
 
the requirements
 
of NEPA
 
must prepare
 
a detailed statement
 
assessing the
 
environmental impact
of
 
and
 
alternatives
 
to
 
the
 
particular
 
action
 
requiring
 
agency
 
approval.
 
These
 
statements
 
are
 
referred
 
to
 
as
Environmental Impact Statements or Environmental Assessments. As codified in the Fiscal Respons
 
ibility Act of
2023, environmental impact statements must include any reasonably foreseeable climate change-related effects
of
 
a
 
proposed
 
action,
 
reasonably
 
foreseeable
 
effects
 
that
 
cannot
 
be
 
avoided,
 
and
 
a
 
reasonable
 
range
 
of
alternatives. Interim guidance issued
 
in January 2023 by the
 
White House Council on Environmental
 
Quality,
 
or
the
 
CEQ,
 
instructs
 
federal
 
agencies
 
to
 
consider
 
climate
 
change
 
impacts
 
of
 
a
 
proposed
 
action,
 
including
 
both
GHG emissions and
 
reductions, and recommends
 
consideration of additional
 
context for GHG
 
emissions, such
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
33
as social cost of
 
GHG estimates.
 
It is possible that
 
future mining permitting decisions will
 
require more significant
analysis of potential climate change impacts.
Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976
The
 
Resource
 
Conservation
 
and
 
Recovery
 
Act
 
of
 
1976,
 
or
 
RCRA,
 
affects
 
U.S.
 
coal
 
mining
 
operations
 
by
establishing “cradle to grave” requirements for the generation, transportation, treatment, storage
 
and disposal of
solid and
 
hazardous wastes.
 
RCRA also
 
addresses the
 
environmental effects
 
of certain
 
past hazardous
 
waste
treatment, storage
 
and disposal
 
practices, and
 
may require
 
a current
 
or past
 
site owner
 
or operator
 
to remove
improperly disposed hazardous wastes. RCRA
 
also sets forth a framework for managing certain
 
non-hazardous
solid wastes.
 
Although coal combustion residuals,
 
or CCR, are exempted
 
from regulation as a
 
hazardous waste, CCR disposal
is
 
regulated
 
under
 
RCRA.
 
On
 
December
 
19,
 
2014,
 
the
 
EPA
 
finalized
 
a
 
CCR
 
rule
 
setting
 
nationwide
 
waste
standards for CCR disposal On
 
August 24, 2018, the U.S. Court of Appeals
 
for the D.C. Circuit held that certain
provisions of the EPA’s
 
CCR rule were not sufficiently protective, and it invalidated those provisions. Since then,
the
 
EPA
 
has
 
finalized
 
changes
 
to
 
its
 
CCR
 
regulations,
 
which
 
include,
 
in
 
part,
 
regulating
 
unlined
 
ponds
 
but
extending
 
certain
 
compliance
 
deadlines
 
related
 
to
 
their
 
closure,
 
allowing
 
site-specific
 
alternate
 
liner
determinations. , and modifying
 
standards regarding beneficial use
 
and assessment of environmental
 
harm. On
May 18, 2023,
 
EPA
 
proposed new
 
regulatory requirements
 
for inactive
 
CCR surface
 
impoundments at
 
inactive
utilities that would require closure of such so-called “legacy”
 
CCR surface impoundments.
The EPA
 
regulations on CCR
 
management and disposal
 
exempt coal ash
 
that is disposed
 
of at mine
 
sites and
reserve any regulation thereof to the Office
 
of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement
 
or "OSMRE." After
proposing CCR regulations in 2007,
 
the OSMRE suspended all rulemaking
 
actions on CCRs, but
 
could re-initiate
them in the future.
 
Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation,
 
and Liability Act of 1980
The Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation
 
and Liability Act of 1980, or CERCLA, authorizes
the federal
 
government and private
 
parties to
 
recover costs to
 
address threatened
 
or actual
 
releases of
 
hazardous
substances (broadly defined) that may
 
endanger public health or the
 
environment. Current owners and operators
of contaminated sites, past owners and operators
 
of contaminated sites at the time hazardous
 
substances were
disposed,
 
parties that
 
arranged
 
for the
 
disposal
 
or transport
 
of the
 
hazardous
 
substances
 
and transporters
 
of
hazardous substances
 
could be
 
potentially responsible
 
parties, or
 
PRPs, under
 
CERCLA. PRPs
 
may be
 
liable
for costs related to contaminated sites, including, but not limited to, site investigation and cleanup costs incurred
by the
 
government or
 
other parties,
 
damages to
 
natural resources
 
and costs
 
of certain
 
health assessments
 
or
studies.
 
We
 
could
 
face
 
liability
 
under
 
CERCLA
 
and
 
similar
 
state
 
laws
 
for
 
contamination
 
discovered
 
at
 
properties
 
that
(1) we currently own, lease or operate, (2) we, our
 
predecessors, or former subsidiaries have previously
 
owned,
leased or
 
operated, (3)
 
sites
 
to which
 
we, our
 
predecessors
 
or former
 
subsidiaries,
 
sent waste
 
materials, and
(4) sites at which hazardous substances from our facilities’
 
operations have otherwise come to be located.
Federal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1977
The Mine Act, which was
 
amended by the Mine Improvement and
 
New Emergency Response Act of 2006,
 
or the
MINER Act, governs federal oversight of mine safety and
 
authorizes the U.S. Department of Labor’s Mine Safety
and Health
 
Administration,
 
or MSHA,
 
to regulate
 
safety
 
and health
 
conditions for
 
employees working
 
in mines
within
 
the
 
United
 
States,
 
and
 
to
 
enforce
 
various
 
mandatory
 
health
 
and
 
safety
 
requirements.
 
The
 
Mine
 
Act
mandates four annual inspections
 
of underground coal
 
mines, two annual inspections
 
of all surface coal
 
mines,
and permits
 
inspections in
 
response to
 
employee complaints
 
of unsafe
 
working conditions.
 
The statute
 
and its
regulations also
 
mandate miner
 
training, mine
 
rescue teams
 
for all
 
underground mines, and
 
involvement of
 
miners
and their
 
representatives
 
in
 
health and
 
safety
 
activities.
 
MSHA has
 
also
 
promulgated
 
regulations
 
governing
 
a
wide
 
range
 
of
 
activities,
 
including
 
roof
 
support,
 
ventilation,
 
combustible
 
materials,
 
electrical
 
equipment,
 
fire
protection,
 
explosives
 
and
 
blasting,
 
and
 
mine
 
emergencies.
 
MSHA
 
has
 
the
 
statutory
 
authority
 
to
 
issue
 
civil
penalties for non-compliance, to set the period for abatement
 
of violations, and to seek injunctive relief requiring
a
 
company
 
to
 
cease
 
operations
 
until
 
certain
 
conditions
 
are
 
corrected.
 
The
 
MINER
 
Act
 
requires
 
mine
 
specific
emergency
 
response
 
plans
 
in
 
underground
 
coal
 
mines,
 
implemented
 
new
 
regulations
 
regarding
 
mine
 
rescue
teams and sealing
 
of abandoned areas,
 
requires prompt
 
notification of mine
 
accidents, and
 
imposes enhanced
civil and
 
criminal penalties
 
for violations.
 
MSHA continues
 
to interpret
 
and implement
 
various provisions
 
of the
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
34
MINER Act, along with introducing
 
new proposed regulations and standards.
 
For example, the second phase
 
of
MSHA’s
 
respirable
 
coal
 
mine
 
dust
 
rule
 
went
 
into
 
effect
 
in
 
February
 
2016
 
and
 
requires
 
increased
 
sampling
frequency and the use of continuous personal dust monitors.
 
In August 2016, the third and final phase of
 
the rule
became effective, reducing the overall respirable dust standard in
 
coal mines from 2.0 to 1.5
 
milligrams per cubic
meter of air.
 
In July 2023, MSHA
 
proposed regulations governing
 
respirable crystalline silica
 
which would lower
the
 
permissible
 
exposure
 
limit
 
and
 
require
 
other
 
safety
 
measures
 
such
 
as
 
exposure
 
sampling
 
and
 
medical
surveillance.
Black Lung (Coal Worker’s Pneumoconiosis)
The
 
Mine
 
Act
 
amended
 
the
 
Federal
 
Coal
 
Mine
 
Health
 
and
 
Safety
 
Act
 
of
 
1969,
 
which
 
is
 
the
 
legislation
 
that
mandates compensation
 
for miners
 
who were
 
totally and
 
permanently
 
disabled
 
by the
 
progressive
 
respiratory
disease caused
 
by coal
 
workers’
 
pneumoconiosis,
 
or
 
black lung.
 
Under
 
current
 
federal law,
 
a U.S.
 
coal
 
mine
operator must
 
pay federal
 
black lung
 
benefits and
 
medical expenses
 
to claimants
 
who are
 
current employees,
and
 
to
 
claimants
 
who
 
are
 
former
 
employees
 
who
 
last
 
worked
 
for
 
the
 
operator
 
after
 
July 1,
 
1973,
 
and
 
whose
claims for benefits are allowed. Coal mine operators must also make payments to a trust fund for
 
the payment of
benefits and medical expenses
 
to claimants who last
 
worked in the coal
 
industry prior to July 1,
 
1973. The trust
fund is funded by
 
an excise tax on sales
 
of U.S. production, excluding export
 
sales excluding export sales. Under
the Inflation Reduction
 
Act of 2022,
 
the excise tax
 
rates are 4.4%
 
of gross sales
 
price, not to
 
exceed $1.10 per
ton of underground coal and $0.55 per ton of surface coal.
In recent months,
 
the Office
 
of Workers’
 
Compensation Programs
 
has taken steps
 
to reform the
 
self-insurance
process for coal mine operators. On November 21, 2023, the Black Lung Benefits Improvement Act of 2023 was
introduced into
 
the U.S.
 
House of
 
Representatives. If
 
enacted, this
 
legislation would
 
establish stringent
 
criteria
for mine operators that seek to self-insure. Additionally, it would increase civil penalties and expand the scope of
potentially liable parties in instances where an operator
 
fails to secure benefits.
Historically, very few of
 
the miners who
 
sought federal black
 
lung benefits were
 
awarded these benefits;
 
however,
the
 
approval
 
rate
 
has
 
increased
 
following
 
implementation
 
of
 
black
 
lung
 
provisions
 
contained
 
in
 
the
 
Patient
Protection
 
and
 
Affordable
 
Care
 
Act
 
of
 
2010,
 
or
 
the
 
Affordable
 
Care
 
Act.
 
The
 
Affordable
 
Care
 
Act
 
introduced
significant changes to
 
the federal black
 
lung program, including
 
an automatic survivor benefit
 
paid upon the
 
death
of
 
a
 
miner
 
with
 
an
 
awarded
 
black
 
lung
 
claim,
 
and
 
established
 
a
 
rebuttable
 
presumption
 
with
 
regard
 
to
pneumoconiosis
 
among miners
 
with 15
 
or more
 
years of
 
coal
 
mine employment
 
that are
 
totally disabled
 
by a
respiratory condition. These changes could have
 
a material impact on
 
our costs expended in association
 
with the
federal black lung program. In addition to possibly incurring liability under federal statutes, we may also be liable
under
 
state
 
laws
 
for
 
black
 
lung
 
claims.
 
See
 
Note
 
20
to
 
the
 
accompanying
 
audited
 
Consolidated
 
Financial
Statements for further information of applicable insurance coverage.
Endangered Species Act of 1973
The Endangered
 
Species Act
 
of 1973
 
governs the
 
protection
 
of endangered
 
species in
 
the United
 
States and
requires the
 
U.S. Department
 
of the
 
Interior’s Fish
 
and Wildlife
 
Service and
 
the National
 
Oceanic and
 
Atmospheric
Administration’s
 
National
 
Marine
 
Fisheries
 
Service
 
to
 
formally
 
review
 
any
 
federally
 
authorized,
 
funded
 
or
administered
 
action
 
that
 
could
 
negatively
 
affect
 
endangered
 
or
 
threatened
 
species.
 
Changes
 
in
 
listings
 
of
endangered species
 
or requirements
 
under these
 
regulations may impact
 
costs and our
 
ability to
 
mine at
 
locations
where endangered species are observed or may be affecte
 
d
 
by mining operations.
National Labor Relations Act of 1935
The National
 
Labor Relations
 
Act of
 
1935
, or
 
the NLRA,
 
governs collective
 
bargaining and
 
private sector
 
labor
and management relations.
 
While we do not
 
have a unionized workforce
 
in the United States,
 
to the extent that
non-supervisory employees decide
 
to seek representation
 
or engage in
 
other protected concerted
 
labor activities,
the NLRA
 
and the
 
rules promulgated
 
by the
 
National
 
Labor Relations
 
Board, or
 
NLRB, set
 
the parameters
 
for
employees’ and union activity and our
 
response. The NLRA applies to both
 
unionized and non-union workforces.
Any employee
 
complaints related
 
to the
 
pandemic and
 
any related
 
labor actions,
 
if they
 
are tied
 
to terms
 
and
conditions of employment
 
that affect the
 
workforce generally,
 
will be governed
 
by the NLRA.
 
In addition, recent
NLRB-
 
promulgated
 
rules
 
regarding
 
joint
 
employer
 
status
 
under
 
the
 
NLRA
 
clarified
 
the
 
basis
 
upon
 
which
contractors and
 
vendors, as
 
well as
 
their employees
 
(and the
 
unions representing
 
them), could
 
allege that
 
we
are jointly and severally liable for any unfair labor practices or bargaining
 
obligations of the third-party employer.
While the rules
 
made the joint
 
employer test generally
 
more employer-friendly,
 
there is always
 
the possibility of
claims that we are a joint employer with a contractor or
 
vendor.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
35
Regulation of explosives
Our surface
 
mining operations
 
are subject
 
to numerous
 
regulations relating
 
to blasting
 
activities,
 
including the
Federal Safe Explosives
 
Act, or SEA. SEA
 
applies to all
 
users of explosives.
 
Knowing or willful violations
 
of the
SEA may
 
result in
 
fines, imprisonment,
 
or both.
 
In addition,
 
violations of
 
SEA may
 
result in
 
revocation of
 
user
permits and seizure or forfeiture of explosive materials. Pursuant to federal regulations, we incur costs
 
to design
and implement blast schedules and to conduct pre-blast surveys and blast monitoring. In addition, the storage of
explosives is
 
subject to
 
strict regulatory
 
requirements established
 
by four
 
different federal
 
regulatory agencies.
For example, pursuant to a rule issued by the Department of Homeland Security in 2007, facilities
 
in possession
of chemicals
 
of interest,
 
including ammonium nitrate
 
at certain
 
threshold levels, must
 
complete a
 
screening review
in
 
order
 
to
 
help
 
determine
 
whether
 
there
 
is
 
a
 
high
 
level
 
of
 
security
 
risk
 
such
 
that
 
a
 
security
 
vulnerability
assessment and site
 
security plan
 
will be
 
required. The Bureau
 
of Alcohol,
 
Tobacco and Firearms and Explosives,
or
 
ATF,
 
regulates
 
the
 
sale,
 
possession,
 
storage
 
and
 
transportation
 
of
 
explosives
 
in
 
interstate
 
commerce.
 
In
August 2023, ATF
 
proposed an amendment
 
to its regulations
 
to require annual
 
reporting of explosive
 
materials
storage
 
to
 
local
 
fire
 
authorities.
 
In
 
addition
 
to
 
ATF
 
regulation,
 
the
 
U.S.
 
Department
 
of
 
Homeland
 
Security
continues to evaluate a proposed ammonium nitrate security
 
program rule.
 
Available Information
We file
 
annual, quarterly
 
and current
 
reports and
 
other documents
 
with the
 
SEC under
 
the Exchange
 
Act. The
public
 
can
 
obtain
 
any
 
documents
 
that
 
we
 
file
 
with
 
the
 
SEC
 
at
 
www.sec.gov.
 
We
 
also
 
make
 
available
 
free
 
of
charge our
 
Annual Report
 
on Form
 
10-K, Quarterly
 
Reports on
 
Form 10-Q,
 
Current Reports
 
on Form
 
8-K and
any amendments
 
to those
 
reports filed
 
or furnished
 
pursuant to
 
Section 13(a)
 
or 15(d)
 
of the
 
Exchange Act
 
as
soon as
 
reasonably practicable
 
after filing
 
such materials
 
with, or
 
furnishing such
 
materials to,
 
the SEC,
 
on or
through our internet website, https://coronadoglobal.com.au/. We are not including the information contained on,
or accessible through, any website as a part of, or incorporating it by reference into, this Annual Report
 
on Form
10-K, unless expressly noted.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
36
ITEM 1A.
 
RISK FACTORS.
An investment
 
in our
 
securities
 
is speculative
 
and involves
 
a number
 
of risks.
 
We
 
believe
 
the risks
 
described
below are the
 
material risks most
 
likely to affect
 
the Company.
 
However,
 
the risks described
 
below may not
 
be
the only
 
risks
 
that
 
we
 
face.
 
Additional
 
unknown
 
risks
 
or risks
 
that we
 
currently
 
consider
 
immaterial,
 
may also
impair our business operations. You should not interpret the
 
disclosure of any risk factor
 
to imply that the risk
 
has
not already
 
materialized. You
 
should carefully
 
consider the
 
specific risk
 
factors discussed
 
below,
 
together with
the information contained in this Annual Report
 
on Form 10-K, including Item 7. “Management’s
 
Discussion and
Analysis of Financial
 
Condition and
 
Results of Operations”
 
and our Consolidated
 
Financial Statements
 
and the
related notes to
 
those statements
included elsewhere
 
in this Annual
 
Report on
 
Form 10-K.
 
If any of
 
the events
or circumstances described below actually occurs,
 
our business, financial condition or
 
results of operations could
suffer, and the trading price
 
of our securities could decline significantly in future periods.
Some of these principal risk factors include:
•
Consummation
 
of
 
the
 
proposed
 
SGI
 
Transaction
 
may
 
constitute
 
a
 
change
 
of
 
control
 
under
 
our
 
Senior
Secured
 
Notes
 
Indenture
 
and
 
our
 
New
 
ABL
 
Facility,
 
which
 
could
 
materially
 
and
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our
business, financial condition and results of operations;
•
Uncertainty
 
about
 
the
 
effects
 
of
 
the
 
SGI
 
Transaction
 
may
 
affect
 
our
 
potential
 
and
 
existing
 
financial
arrangements and customer relationships, including contractual rights triggered upon a change of
 
control in
connection
 
with
 
the
 
SGI
 
Transaction,
 
and
 
may
 
materially
 
and
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our
 
business,
 
results
 
of
operations and financial condition;
•
Following
 
the
 
consummation
 
of
 
the
 
SGI
 
Transaction,
 
we
 
expect
 
that
 
Coronado
 
Group
 
LLC
 
and
 
SGI
 
will
have significant
 
influence over
 
corporate matters,
 
including control
 
over certain
 
decisions that
 
require the
approval of stockholders;
•
Concerns
 
about
 
the
 
environmental
 
impacts
 
of
 
coal
 
combustion,
 
including
 
possible
 
impacts
 
on
 
global
climate
 
issues,
 
are
 
resulting
 
in
 
increased
 
regulation
 
of
 
coal
 
combustion
 
and
 
coal
 
mining
 
in
 
many
jurisdictions, which
 
could significantly
 
affect demand
 
for our
 
products or
 
our securities
 
and reduce
 
access
to capital and insurance;
•
We
 
are
 
subject
 
to
 
extensive
 
health
 
and
 
safety
 
laws
 
and
 
regulations
 
that
 
could
 
have
 
a
 
material
 
adverse
effect on our reputation and financial condition and results
 
of operations;
•
Our business may be adversely affected by the impact on the global economy due to, among other
 
events,
ongoing civil unrest, wars or other significant geopolitical tensions
;
•
Our profitability
 
depends upon the
 
prices we
 
receive for
 
our coal.
 
Prices for
 
coal are
 
volatile and
 
can fluctuate
widely based upon a number of factors beyond our control
;
•
 
Demand for our Met coal is significantly dependent on the steel
 
industry;
•
We face increasing competition, which could adversely
 
affect profitability;
•
We may face restricted access to international
 
markets in the future
;
•
If transportation for our
 
coal becomes unavailable
 
or uneconomic for
 
our customers, our
 
ability to sell coal
could suffer;
•
Take-or-pay
 
arrangements within the coal industry could unfavorably
 
affect our profitability
;
•
A
 
decrease
 
in
 
the
 
availability
 
or
 
increase
 
in
 
costs
 
of
 
key
 
supplies,
 
capital
 
equipment,
 
commodities
 
and
purchased components, such as diesel
 
fuel, steel, explosives and
 
tires could materially and
 
adversely affect
our financial condition and results of operations
;
•
Our
 
business,
 
financial
 
condition
 
and
 
results
 
of
 
operations
 
may
 
be
 
adversely
 
impacted
 
by
 
global
pandemics or other widespread public health concerns;
•
Defects
 
in
 
title
 
or
 
loss
 
of
 
any
 
leasehold
 
interests
 
in
 
our
 
properties
 
could
 
limit
 
our
 
ability
 
to
 
mine
 
these
properties or result in significant unanticipated costs;
•
A shortage of skilled labor in the mining industry could pose a risk to achieving improved labor productivity
;
•
Risks
 
inherent
 
to
 
mining
 
operations
 
could
 
impact
 
the
 
amount
 
of coal
 
produced,
 
cause
 
delay
 
or suspend
coal deliveries, or increase the cost of operating our business;
•
Our
 
long-term
 
success
 
depends
 
upon
 
our
 
ability
 
to
 
continue
 
discovering,
 
or
 
acquiring
 
and
 
developing
assets containing, coal reserves that are economically
 
recoverable
;
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
37
•
We
 
rely
 
on
 
estimates
 
of
 
our
 
recoverable
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves,
 
which
 
are
 
complex
 
due
 
to
 
geological
characteristics of the properties and the number of
 
assumptions made
;
•
Our profitability could be affected adversely
 
by the failure of
 
suppliers and/or outside contractors to perform;
•
Our
 
inability
 
to
 
replace
 
or
 
repair
 
damaged
 
or
 
destroyed
 
equipment
 
or
 
facilities
 
in
 
a
 
timely
 
manner
 
could
materially and adversely affect our financial condition and results
 
of operations;
•
 
Our
 
ability
 
to
 
operate
 
effectively
 
could
 
be
 
impaired
 
if
 
we
 
lose
 
key
 
personnel
 
or
 
fail
 
to
 
attract
 
qualified
personnel;
•
We may not have adequate insurance coverage
 
for some business risks
;
•
Cybersecurity attacks
 
and other
 
similar crises
 
or disruptions
 
may negatively
 
affect our
 
business, financial
condition and results of operations;
•
The
 
loss
 
of,
 
or
 
significant
 
reduction
 
in,
 
purchases
 
by
 
our
 
largest
 
customers
 
could
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our
revenues;
•
Our existing
 
and future
 
indebtedness
 
may limit
 
cash
 
flow available
 
to invest
 
in the
 
ongoing
 
needs of
 
our
businesses,
 
which could
 
prevent
 
us from
 
fulfilling
 
our
 
obligations under
 
our senior
 
secured
 
notes, senior
secured asset-based
 
revolving credit agreement
 
in an initial
 
aggregate principal
 
amount of $150.0
 
million,
or the New ABL Facility (more fully discussed
 
in the Management Discussion & Analysis Section
 
at Item 7.
“Liquidity and Capital Resources), and other debt, and we may be forced to take other actions to
 
satisfy our
obligations under our debt, which may not be successful
 
;
•
We
 
adjust
 
our
 
capital
 
structure
 
from
 
time
 
to
 
time
 
and
 
may
 
need
 
to
 
increase
 
our
 
debt
 
leverage,
 
which
would make us more sensitive to the effects of economic
 
downturns;
•
Our business
 
may require
 
substantial ongoing
 
capital
 
expenditures,
 
and
 
we may
 
not have
 
access
 
to the
capital required to reach full productive capacity at our mines;
•
Risks
 
related
 
to
 
our
 
investment
 
in
 
WICET
 
may
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our
 
financial
 
condition
 
and
 
results
 
of
operations;
•
Risks related to
 
the Supply
 
Deed with Stanwell
 
may adversely
 
affect our financial
 
condition and results
 
of
operations;
•
We could be adversely affected if we fail to appropriately
 
provide financial assurances for our obligations;
•
Mine closures
 
entail substantial
 
costs. If
 
we prematurely
 
close one
 
or more
 
of our
 
mines, our
 
operations
and financial performance would likely be affected adversely
 
;
•
If
 
the
 
assumptions
 
underlying
 
our
 
provision
 
for
 
reclamation
 
and
 
mine
 
closure
 
obligations
 
prove
 
to
 
be
inaccurate, we could be required to expend greater amounts
 
than anticipated;
•
We could be negatively affected if we fail to maintain
 
satisfactory labor relations;
•
Our
 
operations
 
may
 
impact
 
the
 
environment
 
or
 
cause
 
exposure
 
to
 
hazardous
 
substances,
 
which
 
could
result in material liabilities to us; and
•
We are subject to extensive
 
forms of taxation, which impose
 
significant costs on us,
 
and future regulations
and developments could increase those costs or limit
 
our ability to produce coal competitively;
Sev.en Global Investment
 
Transaction Risks
Consummation
 
of the
 
proposed SGI
 
Transaction
 
may constitute
 
a change
 
of control
 
under our
 
Senior
Secured
 
Notes
 
Indenture
 
and
 
our
 
New
 
ABL
 
Facility,
 
which
 
could
 
materially
 
and
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our
business, financial condition and results of operations.
On September
 
25, 2023,
 
the Sellers
 
advised the
 
Company that
 
the Sellers
 
had entered
 
into a
 
MIPA
 
with SGI.
The Company understands that, pursuant to the terms of
 
the MIPA, the Sellers agreed to sell all of their interests
in Coronado
 
Group LLC
 
to a
 
wholly-owned subsidiary
 
of SGI
 
in the
 
SGI Transaction.
 
For further
 
description of
the
 
SGI
 
Transaction
 
refer
 
to
 
Note
 
27.
 
“Related
 
Party
 
Transactions”
 
to
 
the
 
consolidated
 
financial
 
statements
included in Part II, Item 8. “Financial
 
Statements and Supplementary Data” of this
 
Annual Report on Form 10-K,
which information is incorporated by reference herein.
 
Energy & Minerals Group has reported that following the closing of the SGI Transaction, SGI will be the direct or
indirect owner of Coronado
 
Group LLC. As of
 
the date of this
 
Annual Report on Form
 
10-K, Coronado Group LLC
is
 
the
 
direct
 
owner
 
of
 
845,061,399
 
CDIs
 
(representing
 
a
 
beneficial
 
interest
 
in
 
84,506,140
 
shares
 
of
 
common
stock, or 50.4% of the Company’s outstanding total
 
common stock) and the one Series A Share.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
38
The consummation
 
of the
 
proposed SGI
 
Transaction
 
may constitute
 
a change
 
of control
 
under the
 
Company’s
Senior Secured
 
Notes
 
Indenture,
 
dated as
 
of May
 
12,
 
2021, pursuant
 
to which
 
the Company
 
has issued
 
and
outstanding approximately $242.3
 
million aggregate principal amount
 
of its 10.750% Senior Secured
 
Notes due
2026, or the Notes, as of
 
December 31, 2023. Upon
 
a change of control, Coronado
 
Finance Pty Ltd., the issuer
of the
 
Notes, is
 
required to
 
offer
 
to repurchase
 
all or
 
any part
 
of a
 
holder’s Notes
 
at a
 
purchase price
 
in cash
equal to
 
101% of
 
the principal
 
amount thereof,
 
plus accrued
 
and unpaid
 
interest, if
 
any,
 
to, but
 
excluding, the
date of repurchase, subject to the terms and
 
conditions of the indenture. Failure to
 
consummate the repurchase
offer, whether
 
as a result of lack of sufficient
 
funds or otherwise is an event
 
of default under the Senior Secured
Notes Indenture that would accelerate
 
the maturity of the
 
Notes and permit holders
 
to pursue available remedies.
 
The
 
consummation
 
of
 
the
 
proposed
 
SGI
 
Transaction
 
may
 
also
 
constitute
 
a
 
change
 
of
 
control
 
under
 
our
Syndicated Facility
 
Agreement,
 
dated as
 
of May
 
8, 2023,
 
or the
 
New ABL
 
Facility.
 
The New
 
ABL Facility
 
is a
source of liquidity to us. Upon a change of control, the lenders under the New ABL Facility may,
 
pursuant to and
following the terms and
 
review procedures of the
 
New ABL Facility, cancel existing commitments and require any
unpaid amounts under the New
 
ABL Facility to be
 
due and payable. As of
 
December 31, 2023, the Company had
$128.1 million of available borrowings
 
under our New ABL Facility.
 
If the lenders under the
 
New ABL Facility do
not
 
consent
 
to
 
the
 
change
 
of
 
control
 
and
 
we
 
are
 
unable
 
to
 
repay
 
the
 
borrowings,
 
the
 
lenders
 
could
 
pursue
available remedies.
 
Upon consummation of the
 
SGI Transaction, we may not
 
have sufficient assets or liquidity
 
to satisfy all
 
applicable
change
 
of control
 
obligations
 
under the
 
Senior
 
Secured
 
Notes
 
Indenture,
 
the
 
New
 
ABL Facility
 
and
 
our other
indebtedness (which we
 
refer to herein
 
as the Debt
 
Repayment Obligations), and we
 
may not be
 
able to refinance
the Notes,
 
the New
 
ABL Facility
 
or such
 
other indebtedness
 
on commercially
 
reasonable terms
 
or at all,
 
which
would materially and adversely affect our business,
 
financial condition
 
and results of operations.
 
Further, any use by the Company or its subsidiaries of cash on hand or
 
any divestiture of assets of the Company
or its
 
subsidiaries to
 
satisfy the
 
Debt Repayment
 
Obligations could
 
have a
 
negative effect
 
on our
 
liquidity,
 
and
any new equity issuance
 
by the Company
 
to raise liquidity
 
to satisfy the
 
Debt Repayment Obligations
 
would be
dilutive to the Company’s existing stockholders.
 
Uncertainty
 
about
 
the
 
effects
 
of
 
the
 
SGI
 
Transaction
 
may
 
affect
 
our
 
potential
 
and
 
existing
 
financial
arrangements
 
and
 
customer
 
relationships,
 
including
 
contractual
 
rights
 
triggered
 
upon
 
a
 
change
 
of
control in
 
connection with
 
the SGI
 
Transaction,
 
and may
 
materially and
 
adversely affect
 
our business,
results of operations and financial condition.
Certain contract
 
counterparties, including
 
Stanwell, customers,
 
suppliers, third-party
 
providers and
 
employees,
may assert contractual consent
 
rights or termination rights
 
that may be
 
triggered by the consummation of
 
the SGI
Transaction. In relation
 
to the arrangements with
 
Stanwell, we are required
 
to request Stanwell’s
 
consent to the
change of control that,
 
based on information currently
 
available to us, is expected
 
to occur on consummation
 
of
the SGI
 
Transaction. Stanwell must either
 
give or refuse
 
to give consent
 
within a specified
 
period following receipt
of the request, and
 
may only refuse
 
to consent if
 
it determines, acting
 
reasonably,
 
that the SGI
 
Transaction
 
will
have
 
a
 
material
 
adverse
 
effect
 
on
 
the
 
financial
 
ability
 
of
 
us
 
to
 
perform
 
our
 
obligations
 
under
 
the
 
Stanwell
agreements.
 
In
 
circumstances
 
where
 
consent
 
is
 
not
 
obtained,
 
the
 
Company
 
would
 
seek
 
to
 
find
 
mutually
agreeable alternative terms on which Stanwell would consent
 
to the change in control.
The Company is also required to request Aurizon Network’s
 
consent to the change of control that is expected
 
to
occur on consummation
 
of the SGI
 
Transaction under the Aurizon Network
 
UT5 Rail Access
 
Agreement. A failure
to obtain
 
Aurizon Network’s
 
consent to
 
the consummation
 
of the
 
SGI Transaction
 
,
 
if required,
 
will constitute
 
a
breach of the agreement, entitling Aurizon Network to legal or equitable remedies which may include termination
of the agreement.
For a number of
 
customers and supplier agreements, including
 
contractor agreements, the completion of
 
the SGI
Transaction
 
may
 
trigger
 
a
 
financial
 
or
 
suitability
 
assessment
 
by
 
the
 
counterparty,
 
which
 
may
 
entitle
 
the
counterparty
 
to
 
terminate
 
the
 
agreement,
 
request
 
further
 
security
 
or
 
seek
 
amendments
 
to
 
the
 
terms
 
of
 
the
agreement. The
 
termination
 
of these
 
arrangements, or
 
the requirement
 
to provide
 
further security,
 
could harm
our
 
relationships
 
with
 
such
 
third
 
parties
 
and
 
could
 
have
 
a
 
material
 
adverse
 
effect
 
on
 
our
 
business,
 
financial
condition, and results of operations.
 
Consummation of the SGI
 
Transaction is
 
expected to also constitute
 
a “changed holder event”
 
for the purposes
of
 
Queensland
 
financial
 
provisioning
 
legislation
 
relating
 
to
 
rehabilitation
 
obligations
 
for
 
the
 
Curragh
 
mining
tenements, which
 
may result
 
in the
 
Queensland government
 
reviewing the
 
“risk category”
 
to which
 
the mining
tenements are allocated
 
(i.e., very low,
 
low, moderate
 
or high), which may
 
require us to
 
provide further security
to the Queensland government.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
39
Following the
 
consummation of
 
the SGI
 
Transaction, we
 
expect that
 
Coronado Group
 
LLC and
 
SGI will
have significant
 
influence over
 
corporate matters,
 
including control
 
over certain
 
decisions that
 
require
the approval of stockholders.
The Special Committee is reviewing
 
the terms of the Certificate
 
of Incorporation regarding the Series A
 
Preferred
Stock and the terms of the Stockholders Agreement dated
 
as of September 24, 2018 between the Company and
Coronado Group
 
to evaluate
 
whether the
 
rights ascribed
 
collectively to
 
the EMG
 
group thereunder
 
will inure
 
to
SGI as the new owner of the Coronado Group LLC.
 
Even apart from those rights, SGI as the indirect owner
 
of a
majority of the Company’s common stock will
 
have significant influence over corporate matters.
Further, uncertainty about the effects of
 
the SGI Transaction on counterparties
 
to contracts, employees and
 
other
parties may
 
have an
 
adverse effect
 
on us.
 
These uncertainties
 
could cause
 
contract counterparties
 
and others
who deal with us to seek to terminate or amend their existing business relationships with us, and may impair our
ability to attract, retain
 
and motivate key
 
personnel for a period
 
of time prior to
 
and following the
 
consummation
of the SGI
 
Transaction.
 
As a
 
result, uncertainties
 
regarding the
 
impact of
 
the SGI
 
Transaction
 
on our
 
business
strategy may have a material and adverse effect on
 
our business, financial condition and results of operations.
Environmental and Sustainability Risks
Concerns
 
about
 
the
 
environmental
 
impacts
 
of
 
coal
 
combustion,
 
including
 
possible
 
impacts
 
on
 
global
climate
 
issues,
 
are
 
resulting
 
in
 
increased
 
regulation
 
of
 
coal
 
combustion
 
and
 
coal
 
mining
 
in
 
many
jurisdictions,
 
which
 
could
 
significantly
 
affect
 
demand
 
for
 
our
 
products
 
or
 
our
 
securities
 
and
 
reduce
access to capital and insurance.
Global concerns
 
about climate
 
change continues
 
to attract
 
considerable attention,
 
particularly in
 
relation to
 
the
coal industry. Emissions from coal
 
consumption, both directly and
 
indirectly, and emissions from coal
 
mining itself
are subject to pending and proposed regulation as part of initiatives to address global climate change. A number
of
 
countries,
 
including
 
Australia
 
and
 
the
 
United
 
States,
 
have
 
already
 
introduced,
 
or
 
are
 
contemplating
 
the
introduction of, regulatory responses to GHGs, including the
 
extraction and combustion of fossil fuels, to
 
address
the impacts of climate change.
There are three primary sources of GHGs associated with the coal industry.
 
First, the end use of our coal by our
customers
 
in
 
coal-fired
 
electricity
 
generation,
 
coke
 
plants,
 
and
 
steelmaking.
 
Second,
 
combustion
 
of
 
fuel
 
by
equipment used in
 
coal production and
 
to transport our
 
coal to
 
our customers. Third,
 
coal mining itself
 
can release
methane, which is considered to
 
be a more potent
 
GHG than carbon dioxide, directly into
 
the atmosphere. These
emissions from coal consumption, transportation
 
and production are subject to
 
pending and proposed regulation,
in the jurisdictions in which we operate as part of initiatives
 
to address global climate change.
As
 
a
 
result,
 
numerous
 
proposals
 
have
 
been
 
made
 
and
 
are
 
likely
 
to
 
continue
 
to
 
be
 
made
 
at
 
the
 
international,
national, regional and state levels of government to monitor
 
and limit emissions of GHGs.
 
For example,
 
the Australian
 
Government recently
 
reformed the
 
Safeguard Mechanism
 
to incentivize
 
emissions
reductions,
 
through
 
declining
 
emissions
 
limits,
 
called
 
baselines,
 
predictably
 
and
 
gradually
 
on
 
a
 
trajectory
consistent with
 
achieving the
 
Government’s emissions
 
reduction target
 
of 43%
 
below 2005
 
levels by
 
2030 and
net
 
zero
 
by
 
2050.
 
On
 
March
 
31,
 
2023,
 
the
 
Australian
 
Federal
 
Parliament
 
passed
 
the
 
Safeguard
 
Mechanism
(Crediting) Amendment Bill 2023 amending the
 
National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting
 
Act 2007 and other
legislation, to establish
 
the framework
 
to give effect
 
to key
 
elements of the
 
reforms, such
 
as introducing credits
to the scheme to provide an incentive to companies to
 
go below their baselines.
The
 
Safeguard
 
Mechanism
 
applies
 
to
 
industrial
 
facilities
 
emitting
 
more
 
than
 
100,000
 
tons
 
of
 
carbon
 
dioxide
equivalent per
 
year,
 
including in
 
electricity,
 
mining, oil
 
and gas
 
production, manufacturing,
 
transport and
 
waste
facilities.
In accordance with
 
the Safeguard Mechanism and
 
following the Federal Government’s finalization
 
of the National
Greenhouse and Energy Reporting (Safeguard Mechanism) Amendment
 
(Reforms) Rule 2023, Curragh intends
to
 
establish
 
a
 
new
 
production-adjusted
 
(intensity)
 
baseline
 
for
 
covered
 
emissions
 
(Scope
 
1).
 
Curragh
 
will
 
be
required to take action
 
to keep its net
 
Scope 1 emissions at
 
or below the baseline
 
through emissions reduction,
by
 
for
 
example,
 
purchasing
 
Safeguard
 
Mechanism
 
Credits
 
(SMCs)
 
from
 
another
 
facility,
 
captured
 
by
 
the
Safeguard
 
Mechanism,
 
purchasing
 
and
 
surrendering
 
Australian
 
Carbon
 
Credit
 
Units
 
(ACCUs),
 
or
 
face
enforcement measures.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
40
Additionally,
 
in
 
November
 
2014,
 
an
 
agreement
 
was
 
announced
 
between
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
and
 
China
 
to
 
cut
GHGs by more than 25% below 2005
 
levels by 2025. This agreement was followed by
 
the UNFCCC, conference
in Paris, France, in which an agreement was adopted calling for voluntary emissions reductions contributions, or
the Paris
 
Agreement. The
 
Paris Agreement
 
was entered
 
into force
 
on November
 
4, 2016
 
after ratification
 
and
execution
 
by
 
more
 
than
 
55
 
countries,
 
which
 
account
 
for
 
at
 
least
 
55%
 
of
 
global
 
GHG
 
emissions.
 
The
 
Paris
Agreement
 
was
 
signed
 
by
 
representatives
 
from
 
195
 
countries
 
and
 
aims
 
to
 
hold
 
back
 
the
 
increase
 
in
 
global
temperatures,
 
increase the
 
ability of
 
countries
 
to adapt
 
to the
 
adverse impacts
 
of climate
 
change
 
and provide
channels to finance projects that lead to GHG reductions.
 
The
 
growth
 
of
 
alternative
 
energy
 
options,
 
such
 
as
 
renewables
 
and
 
disruptive
 
power
 
generation
 
technologies,
changes in community or
 
government attitudes to climate change,
 
government measures to subsidize renewable
energy production while reducing subsidies for the fossil fuel industry, efforts to promote divestment of fossil fuel
equities and pressure from lenders to limit funding to fossil fuel companies could result in further development of
alternative energy industries
 
and broader
 
mainstream acceptance of
 
alternative energy options
 
which could result
in a
 
material reduction in
 
the demand for
 
coal. It
 
could also result
 
in reduced access
 
to capital to
 
fund our activities
as lenders and investors divert capital to low emission sectors
 
of the economy.
 
The absence of regulatory certainty,
 
global policy inconsistencies and direct regulatory impacts
 
(such as carbon
taxes or
 
other charges)
 
each have
 
the potential
 
to adversely
 
affect our
 
operations—either directly
 
or indirectly,
through suppliers and
 
customers. Collectively, these initiatives and developments could
 
result in higher
 
electricity
costs
 
to
 
us
 
or
 
our
 
customers
 
or
 
lower
 
the
 
demand
 
for
 
coal
 
used
 
in
 
electricity
 
generation,
 
which
 
could
 
in
 
turn
adversely impact our business.
At present, we
 
are principally focused on
 
Met coal production,
 
which is not
 
used in connection with
 
the production
of
 
coal-fired
 
electricity
 
generation.
 
The
 
market
 
for
 
our
 
coal
 
may
 
be
 
adversely
 
impacted
 
if
 
comprehensive
legislation
 
or
 
regulations
 
focusing
 
on
 
GHG
 
emission
 
reductions
 
are
 
adopted,
 
particularly
 
if
 
they
 
directly
 
or
indirectly impact the Met coal industry,
 
or if our ability to obtain capital for operations is materially reduced.
We and
 
our customers
 
may also
 
have to
 
invest in
 
carbon-capture, usage
 
and storage
 
technologies in
 
order to
burn thermal
 
coal
 
and
 
comply
 
with
 
future
 
GHG
 
emission
 
standards.
 
The
 
potential
 
direct
 
and
 
indirect
 
financial
impact on us from future laws, regulations, policies and
 
technology developments may depend upon the degree
to which
 
any such
 
laws, regulations
 
and developments
 
force reduced
 
reliance on
 
coal as
 
a fuel
 
source. Such
developments
 
could
 
result
 
in
 
adverse
 
impacts
 
on
 
our
 
financial
 
condition
 
or
 
results
 
of
 
operations.
 
See
 
Item 1.
“Business—Regulatory Matters—Australia” and “Business—Regulatory
 
Matters—United States.”
We are
 
subject to
 
extensive health
 
and safety
 
laws and
 
regulations that
 
could have
 
a material
 
adverse
effect on our reputation and financial condition
 
and results of operations.
We are subject to extensive laws and regulations governing health and safety at coal
 
mines in the United States
and Australia. As a
 
result of increased stakeholder focus on
 
health and safety issues (such
 
as black lung disease
or
 
coal
 
workers’
 
pneumoconiosis),
 
there
 
is
 
a
 
risk
 
of
 
legislation
 
and
 
regulatory
 
change
 
that
 
may
 
increase
 
our
exposure to claims arising
 
out of current or
 
former activities or result in
 
increased compliance costs (e.g., through
requiring improved
 
monitoring standards
 
or contribution
 
to an
 
industry-pooled fund).
 
Regulatory agencies
 
also
have the authority, following
 
significant health and safety incidents, such as fatalities, to order mining operations
to be temporarily suspended or
 
the facility be permanently closed.
 
For example, on January 12, 2020,
 
operations
at our
 
Curragh mine were
 
temporarily suspended after
 
a contractor was
 
fatally injured during
 
a tire
 
change activity
in
 
the
 
main
 
workshop
 
on
 
site
 
and
 
on
 
November
 
21,
 
2021,
 
operations
 
at
 
our
 
Curragh
 
mine
 
were
 
temporarily
suspended after an employee
 
was fatally injured while working
 
in the dragline operations.
 
If further serious safety
incidents were to
 
occur at any
 
of our mining
 
facilities in the
 
future, it is
 
possible that a
 
regulator might impose
 
a
range
 
of
 
conditions
 
on
 
re-opening
 
of
 
a
 
facility,
 
including
 
requiring
 
capital
 
expenditures,
 
which
 
could
 
have
 
a
material adverse effect on our reputation, financial
 
condition and results of operations.
For
 
additional
 
information
 
about
 
the
 
various
 
regulations
 
affecting
 
us,
 
see
 
Item 1.
 
“Business—Regulatory
Matters—Australia” and “Business—Regulatory Matters
 
—United States.”
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
41
In
 
times
 
of
 
drought
 
and/or
 
shortage
 
of
 
available
 
water,
 
our
 
operations
 
and
 
production,
 
particularly
 
at
Curragh, could be negatively impacted if
 
the regulators impose restrictions on our
 
water offtake licenses
that are required for water used in the CPPs.
In Queensland, all entitlements to the use, control and
 
flow of water are vested in the state and regulated by
 
the
Water Act
 
2000 (Qld).
 
Allocations under
 
the Water
 
Act 2000 (Qld)
 
can be managed
 
by a water
 
supply scheme
operator, such as SunWater Ltd. We have purchased the required water allocations for Curragh and
 
entered into
a suite of
 
related channel and pipeline
 
infrastructure agreements and river supply
 
agreements with SunWater Ltd
to regulate the supply of water pursuant to these allocations.
The amount
 
of water
 
that is
 
available to
 
be taken
 
under a
 
water entitlement
 
will vary
 
from year
 
to year
 
and is
determined by
 
water sharing rules
 
of the
 
relevant catchment area.
 
These rules
 
will, for
 
example, state
 
a procedure
for water supply scheme holders to calculate
 
the water available to an allocation holder,
 
based on available and
predicted supply.
 
In situations
 
of severely
 
constrained supply
 
(such as during
 
a drought),
 
supply contracts
 
with
the scheme operator generally provide for a
 
reduced apportionment, with certain uses (e.g., domestic use) being
given higher
 
priority.
 
It is
 
possible that
 
during times
 
of drought
 
our water
 
offtake entitlements
 
in Australia
 
could
be reduced. If our water
 
offtake entitlement was reduced, the operations would have to recycle
 
more of the water
collected in
 
on-site dams
 
and former
 
mining pits,
 
from rainfall
 
and dewatering
 
activities, for
 
use in
 
the Curragh
CPP.
 
This may
 
impact our
 
ability to
 
maintain current
 
production levels
 
without incurring
 
additional costs,
 
which
could adversely impact our operations and production.
Economic, Competitive and Industry Risks
Our
 
business
 
may
 
be
 
adversely
 
affected
 
by
 
the
 
impact
 
on
 
the
 
global
 
economy
 
due
 
to,
 
among
 
other
events, ongoing civil unrest, wars or other significant
 
geopolitical tensions.
Geopolitical tensions, ongoing civil unrest and wars can have
 
a significant impact on global markets, influencing
both the
 
supply
 
and
 
demand
 
of coal
 
we sell
 
into the
 
export market
 
and the
 
cost
 
or availability
 
of supplies
 
we
consume in producing our coal.
 
For example, global markets
 
are experiencing volatility
 
and disruption with current
 
geopolitical tensions and the
military invasion of
 
Ukraine by Russia.
 
This military conflict
 
led to sanctions
 
and other penalties
 
being levied by
the United States, the European Union and other countries against Russia, including expansive bans on imports
and exports of products to and from Russia.
 
The
 
extent
 
and
 
duration
 
of
 
such
 
conflicts
 
could
 
lead
 
to
 
market
 
disruptions,
 
including
 
significant
 
volatility
 
in
commodity prices, such as
 
the coal we
 
sell and diesel fuel
 
we purchase, instability in
 
the financial markets, higher
inflation,
 
supply
 
chain
 
interruptions,
 
political
 
and
 
social
 
instability
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
an
 
increase
 
in
 
cyberattacks
 
and
espionage.
Our
 
profitability
 
depends
 
upon
 
the
 
prices we
 
receive
 
for our
 
coal.
 
Prices
 
for
 
coal are
 
volatile
 
and
 
can
fluctuate widely based upon a number of factors beyond
 
our control.
We generate
 
revenue from
 
the sale
 
of coal
 
and our
 
financial
 
results
 
are materially
 
impacted by
 
the prices
 
we
receive.
 
Prices
 
and
 
quantities
 
under
 
Met
 
coal
 
sales
 
contracts
 
in
 
North
 
America
 
are
 
generally
 
based
 
on
expectations
 
of
 
the
 
next
 
year’s
 
coal
 
prices
 
at
 
the
 
time
 
the
 
contract
 
is
 
entered
 
into,
 
renewed,
 
extended
 
or
re-opened. Pricing in the global seaborne market is typically
 
set on a rolling quarterly average benchmark price.
 
Sales by our
 
U.S. Operations to the
 
export market are
 
typically priced with reference
 
to a benchmark
 
index. Sales
by our Australian Operations have typically been contracted on an annual basis and are priced with reference
 
to
benchmark indices or bilaterally
 
negotiated term prices
 
and spot indices. As
 
a result, a significant
 
portion of our
revenue is
 
exposed to
 
movements in
 
coal prices
 
and any
 
weakening in
 
Met or
 
thermal coal
 
prices would
 
have
an adverse impact on our financial condition and results
 
of operations.
The expectation of future prices for coal depends upon many factors beyond our
 
control, including the following:
•
 
the current market price of coal;
•
 
overall domestic and global economic conditions,
 
including inflationary conditions and the supply
 
of and
demand for domestic and foreign coal, coke and steel;
•
 
the consumption pattern of industrial consumers, electricity generators
 
and residential users;
•
 
weather
 
conditions
 
in
 
our
 
markets
 
that
 
affect
 
the
 
ability
 
to
 
produce
 
Met
 
coal
 
or
 
affect
 
the
 
demand
 
for
thermal coal;
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
42
•
 
competition from other coal suppliers;
•
 
technological advances affecting the steel production
 
process and/or energy consumption;
•
 
the costs, availability and capacity of transportation infrastructure;
 
and
•
 
the impact
 
of domestic
 
and foreign
 
governmental policy,
 
laws and
 
regulations, including
 
the imposition
of tariffs, environmental
 
and climate change
 
regulations and
 
other regulations
 
affecting the
 
coal mining
industry,
 
including regulations and measures introduced in response
 
to global pandemics.
Met coal has
 
been a volatile
 
commodity over the
 
past ten years.
 
Although coking coal
 
index prices improved
 
in
the second
 
half of
 
2023 due
 
to tight
 
supply,
 
on average
 
coking coal
 
prices were
 
significantly lower
 
than 2022
when
 
supply
 
in
 
global
 
met
 
coal
 
market
 
was
 
readjusting
 
from
 
the
 
impact
 
of
 
the
 
Russia
 
and
 
Ukraine
 
war.
 
The
demand and supply in the Met
 
coal industry changes from time to time.
 
There are no assurances that oversupply
will not
 
occur,
 
that demand
 
will not
 
decrease or
 
that overcapacity
 
will not
 
occur,
 
which could
 
cause declines
 
in
the prices of coal,
 
which could have a material adverse
 
effect on our financial condition and
 
results of operations.
In addition, coal prices are highly
 
dependent on the outlook for coal consumption in
 
large Asian economies, such
as China, India, South Korea and Japan,
 
as well as any changes in government
 
policy regarding coal or energy
in those
 
countries.
 
Seaborne
 
Met coal
 
import
 
demand
 
can also
 
be significantly
 
impacted by
 
the
 
availability
 
of
local coal production, particularly in the leading Met coal import countries of China and India, among others, and
the
 
competitiveness
 
of
 
seaborne
 
Met
 
coal
 
supply,
 
including
 
from
 
the
 
leading
 
Met
 
coal
 
exporting
 
countries
 
of
Australia, the United States, Russia, Canada and Mongolia,
 
among others.
 
Demand for our Met coal is significantly dependent on
 
the steel industry.
The majority of
 
the coal that
 
we produce
 
is Met coal
 
that is
 
sold, directly
 
or indirectly,
 
to steel
 
producers and
 
is
used in blast furnaces for steel production. Met coal,
 
specifically high-quality HCC and low-volatile PCI,
 
which is
produced at most of our
 
assets, has specific physical
 
and chemical properties, which are
 
necessary for efficient
blast furnace operation.
 
Therefore, demand for
 
our Met coal is
 
correlated to demands
 
of the steel industry.
 
The
steel industry’s
 
demand for
 
Met coal
 
is influenced
 
by a
 
number of
 
factors, including:
 
the cyclical
 
nature of
 
that
industry’s business; general economic
 
and regulatory conditions and demand
 
for steel; and the availability,
 
cost
and preference for substitutes for steel, such as aluminum, composites and plastics,
 
all of which may impact the
demand
 
for steel
 
products.
 
Similarly,
 
if
 
new
 
steelmaking
 
technologies
 
or practices
 
are developed
 
that
 
can
 
be
substituted
 
for
 
Met
 
coal
 
in
 
the
 
integrated
 
steel
 
mill
 
process,
 
then
 
demand
 
for
 
Met
 
coal
 
would
 
be
 
expected
 
to
decrease.
Although
 
conventional
 
blast
 
furnace
 
technology
 
has
 
been
 
the
 
most
 
economic
 
large-scale
 
steel
 
production
technology for a number of years, there can
 
be no assurance that over the longer term,
 
competitive technologies
not reliant on
 
Met coal would
 
not emerge,
 
which could reduce
 
the demand
 
and price
 
premiums for
 
Met coal.
 
A
significant reduction in
 
the demand for
 
steel products would
 
reduce the demand
 
for Met coal, which
 
could have
a material adverse effect on our financial condition
 
and results of operations.
Additionally, tariffs imposed by the United States on the import of certain steel products may impact foreign steel
producers
 
to
 
the
 
extent
 
their
 
production
 
is
 
imported
 
into the
 
United
 
States.
 
Future
 
tariffs
 
could
 
further
 
reduce
imports
 
of
 
steel
 
and
 
increase
 
U.S.
 
Met
 
coal
 
demand.
 
This
 
additional
 
U.S.
 
Met
 
coal
 
demand
 
could
 
be
 
met
 
by
reducing exports of Met coal and redirecting that volume
 
to domestic consumption.
The tariffs
 
established by
 
the United
 
States have
 
prompted retaliatory
 
tariffs from
 
key trading
 
partners, notably
Europe and China. Any further retaliatory tariffs by these or other countries to these tariffs may limit international
trade and adversely impact
 
global economic conditions. We cannot ascertain
 
the impact, if any, that similar tariffs
may have
 
on demand
 
for our
 
Met coal.
 
See “—We
 
may face
 
restricted
 
access
 
to international
 
markets in
 
the
future.”
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
43
We face increasing competition, which could adversely
 
affect profitability.
Competition
 
in
 
the
 
coal
 
industry
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
many
 
factors,
 
including,
 
among
 
others,
 
world
 
supply,
 
price,
production
 
capacity,
 
coal
 
quality
 
and
 
characteristics,
 
transportation
 
capability
 
and
 
costs,
 
blending
 
capability,
brand name
 
and diversified
 
operations. We
 
are subject
 
to competition
 
from Met
 
coal producers
 
from Australia,
the United States, Russia, Canada, Mongolia and other Met coal producing countries.
 
Should those competitors
obtain a
 
competitive advantage in comparison
 
to us (whether
 
by way of
 
an increase in
 
production capacity, higher
realized
 
prices,
 
lower
 
operating
 
costs,
 
export/import
 
tariffs,
 
being
 
comparatively
 
less
 
impacted
 
as
 
a
 
result
 
of
global pandemics or otherwise),
 
such competitive advantage
 
may have an adverse
 
impact on our ability
 
to sell,
or the
 
prices at
 
which we
 
are able
 
to sell
 
coal
 
products.
 
In addition,
 
some of
 
our competitors
 
may have
 
more
production capacity as well as greater financial, marketing, distribution and other resources than we do and may
be subject to less stringent environmental and other regulations
 
than we are.
The consolidation
 
of the global
 
Met coal industry
 
in recent years
 
has contributed
 
to increased competition,
 
and
our competitive
 
position may
 
be adversely
 
impacted by
 
further consolidation
 
among
 
market participants
 
or by
further
 
competitors
 
entering
 
into
 
and
 
exiting
 
bankruptcy
 
proceedings
 
under
 
a
 
lower
 
cost
 
structure.
 
Similarly,
potential
 
changes
 
to
 
international
 
trade
 
agreements,
 
trade
 
concessions
 
or
 
other
 
political
 
and
 
economic
arrangements may benefit
 
coal producers operating
 
in countries
 
other than the
 
United States and
 
Australia. Other
coal producers may also develop or acquire new projects to increase their coal production, which may adversely
impact our competitiveness. Some
 
of our global competitors
 
have significantly greater financial
 
resources, such
that increases in their coal production may affect domestic and foreign Met coal supply into the seaborne market
and associated prices and impact our ability to retain or
 
attract Met coal customers. In addition, our ability to ship
our Met coal to non-U.S.
 
and non-Australian customers
 
depends on port and transportation
 
capacity.
 
Increased
competition
 
within
 
the
 
Met
 
coal
 
industry
 
for
 
international
 
sales
 
could
 
result
 
in
 
us
 
not
 
being
 
able
 
to
 
obtain
throughput capacity at port facilities, as well as transport capacity, and could cause the rates for such services to
increase to a point where it is not economically feasible to export
 
our Met coal.
Increased competition, or a
 
failure to compete effectively,
 
in the markets in
 
which we participate
 
may result in a
loss of market share and could adversely affect our financial
 
condition and results of operations.
We may face restricted access to international markets
 
in the future.
Access to
 
international markets
 
may be
 
subject to
 
ongoing interruptions
 
and trade
 
barriers due
 
to policies
 
and
tariffs of
 
individual countries,
 
and the actions
 
of certain interest
 
groups to restrict
 
the import or
 
export of certain
commodities. There
 
can be
 
no guarantee
 
that tariffs,
 
import quota
 
restrictions, bans
 
or other
 
trade barriers
 
will
not be
 
imposed (whether
 
as a
 
result of
 
geopolitical tensions
 
or for
 
other reasons)
 
for our
 
products. We
 
may or
may
 
not
 
be
 
able
 
to
 
access
 
alternate
 
markets
 
for
 
our
 
coal should
 
interruptions
 
and
 
trade
 
barriers
 
occur
 
in
 
the
future. An inability
 
for Met
 
coal suppliers
 
to access
 
international markets
 
would likely
 
result in
 
an oversupply
 
of
Met coal
 
and may
 
result in
 
a decrease
 
in prices
 
or the
 
curtailment of
 
production, which
 
could
 
have a
 
material
adverse effect on our financial condition and results
 
of operations.
If transportation
 
for our
 
coal becomes
 
unavailable or
 
uneconomic for
 
our customers,
 
our ability
 
to sell
coal could suffer.
Our mining operations produce coal, which is transported to customers by a combination of road, rail, barge and
ship. The
 
delivery of
 
coal produced
 
by our
 
mining operations
 
is subject
 
to potential
 
disruption and
 
competition
from other network users,
 
which may affect
 
our ability to deliver
 
coal to our customers
 
and may have an impact
on productivity and profitability.
 
Such disruptions to transportation services may include,
 
among others:
•
 
disruptions due to weather-related problems;
•
 
key equipment or infrastructure failures;
•
 
industrial action;
•
 
rail or port capacity congestion or constraints;
•
 
commercial disputes;
•
 
failure to
 
obtain consents
 
from third
 
parties for
 
access to
 
rail or
 
land, or
 
access being
 
removed
 
or not
granted by regulatory authorities;
•
 
changes in applicable regulations;
•
 
failure or delay in the construction of new rail or port capacity;
 
and
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
44
•
 
terrorist attacks, natural disasters, the impact from global pandemics
 
or other events.
Any
 
such
 
disruptions,
 
or
 
any
 
deterioration
 
in
 
the
 
reliability
 
of
 
services
 
provided
 
by
 
our
 
transportation
 
service
providers, could
 
impair our
 
ability to
 
supply coal
 
to our
 
customers, result
 
in decreased
 
shipments and
 
revenue
and adversely affect our results of operations.
Typically,
 
we sell coal at the mine
 
gate and/or loaded into vessels at
 
the port. While ordinarily our coal
 
customers
arrange
 
and
 
pay
 
for
 
transportation
 
of
 
coal
 
from
 
the
 
mine
 
or
 
port
 
to
 
the
 
point
 
of
 
use,
 
we
 
have
 
entered
 
into
arrangements
 
with
 
third
 
parties
 
to
 
gain
 
access
 
to
 
transportation
 
infrastructure
 
and
 
services
 
where
 
required,
including road transport organizations, rail carriers and port owners. Where coal is exported or sold other than at
the mine gate, the costs associated with these arrangements represent a significant portion of both the total cost
of supplying
 
coal to
 
customers and
 
of our
 
production costs.
 
As a
 
result, the
 
cost of
 
transportation is
 
not only
 
a
key factor in our cost base, but also in the purchasing decision of customers. Transportation
 
costs may increase
and
 
we
 
may
 
not
 
be
 
able
 
to
 
pass
 
on
 
the
 
full
 
extent
 
of
 
cost
 
increases
 
to
 
our
 
customers.
 
For
 
example,
 
where
transportation
 
costs
 
are
 
connected
 
to
 
market
 
demand,
 
costs
 
may
 
increase
 
if
 
usage
 
by
 
us
 
and
 
other
 
market
participants increases. Significant
 
increases in transport
 
costs due to factors
 
such as fluctuations in
 
the price of
diesel fuel, electricity and demurrage or environmental requirements could make our coal less competitive when
compared to coal produced from other regions and countries. As the transportation capacity secured
 
by our port
and rail agreements is based
 
on assumed production volumes, we may
 
also have excess transportation capacity
(which, in the
 
case of take-or-pay
 
agreements, we may
 
have to pay
 
for even if
 
unused) if our
 
actual production
volumes are lower
 
than our estimated production
 
volumes. Conversely, we may not have
 
sufficient transportation
capacity if our actual production volumes
 
exceed our estimated production volumes, if
 
we are unable to transport
the
 
full
 
capacity
 
due
 
to
 
contractual
 
limitations
 
or
 
if
 
any
 
deterioration
 
in
 
our
 
relationship
 
with
 
brokers
 
and
intermediaries results
 
in a
 
reduction in
 
the proportion
 
of coal
 
purchased FOR
 
from our
 
U.S. Operations
 
(and a
corresponding increase in the proportion of coal purchased
 
FOB).
Take-or-pay arrangements within the
 
coal industry could unfavorably affect our profitability.
Our
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
generally
 
contract
 
port
 
and
 
rail
 
capacity
 
via
 
long-term
 
take-or-pay
 
contracts
 
for
transport, currently with
 
Aurizon Operations
 
Limited and Pacific
 
National Pty Ltd,
 
to and export
 
from the Port
 
of
Gladstone via two main port terminals, RGTCT and WICET.
 
At our U.S. Operations, we also have a take-or-pay
agreement in
 
connection
 
with the
 
Kinder Morgan
 
Pier IX
 
Terminal
 
in Hampton
 
Roads, Virginia.
 
We may
 
enter
into other take-or-pay arrangements in the future.
Where we have entered into take-or-pay contracts, we will generally be required to pay for our
 
contracted port or
rail capacity, even
 
if it
 
is not
 
utilized by
 
us or
 
other shippers. Although
 
the majority
 
of our
 
take-or-pay arrangements
provide security over minimum port and
 
rail infrastructure availability,
 
unused port or rail capacity can
 
arise as a
result
 
of
 
varying
 
unforeseen
 
circumstances,
 
including
 
insufficient
 
production
 
from
 
a
 
given
 
mine,
 
a
 
mismatch
between the timing of
 
required port and rail
 
capacity for a
 
mine, or an inability
 
to transfer the used
 
capacity due
to contractual limitations, such as
 
required consent of the provider of
 
the port or rail services,
 
or because the coal
must emanate from specified
 
source mines or
 
be loaded onto trains
 
at specified load
 
points. Paying for
 
unused
transport
 
capacity
 
could
 
materially
 
and
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our
 
cost
 
structures
 
and
 
financial
 
performance.
 
See
Item 7. “Management’s Discussion and
 
Analysis of Financial
 
Condition and Results of
 
Operations” for a
 
summary
of our expected future obligations under take-or-pay arrangements
 
as of December 31, 2023.
A decrease in
 
the availability
 
or increase
 
in costs of
 
key supplies, capital
 
equipment, commodities
 
and
purchased components,
 
such as
 
diesel fuel,
 
steel, explosives
 
and tires
 
could materially
 
and adversely
affect our financial condition and results of operations.
Our mining operations require a reliable
 
supply of large quantities of fuel,
 
explosives, tires, steel-related products
(including
 
roof
 
control
 
materials),
 
lubricants
 
and
 
electricity.
 
The
 
prices
 
we
 
pay
 
for
 
commodities
 
are
 
strongly
impacted by the global
 
market. In situations where
 
we have chosen to
 
concentrate a large portion
 
of purchases
with one supplier, it has been to take
 
advantage of cost savings from larger volumes of
 
purchases and to support
security of supply.
 
If the cost
 
of any of
 
these key supplies
 
or commodities increased
 
significantly,
 
or if a
 
source
for these supplies or mining equipment was unavailable to meet our replacement demands our profitability could
be reduced or we could experience a delay or halt in
 
our production.
Prices
 
for equipment,
 
materials,
 
supplies
 
and employee
 
labor
 
contractor
 
services
 
increased during
 
2023,
 
and
could
 
continue
 
to
 
increase
 
in
 
2024
 
and
 
beyond.
 
Long-term
 
inflationary
 
pressures
 
may
 
result
 
in
 
such
 
prices
continuing to
 
increase
 
more quickly
 
than expected.
 
Inflation increases
 
costs for
 
materials, labor
 
and services,
and we
 
may be
 
unable to
 
secure these
 
resources on
 
economically acceptable
 
terms or
 
offset such
 
costs with
increased revenues, operating efficiencies,
 
or cost savings, which may adversely
 
impact our financial condition,
results of operations, liquidity,
 
and cash flows.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
45
Our coal production and production costs can be materially and adversely impacted by unexpected shortages or
increases in the costs of consumables, spare parts,
 
plant and equipment. For example, operation
 
of the thermal
dryer located at
 
the CPP at
 
Buchanan is dependent
 
upon the delivery
 
of natural gas
 
and there is
 
currently only
one
 
natural
 
gas
 
supplier
 
in
 
the
 
area,
 
an
 
affiliate
 
of
 
CONSOL
 
Energy.
 
Although
 
we
 
have
 
entered
 
into
 
a
 
gas
purchase agreement with CONSOL Energy,
 
this agreement can be terminated by CONSOL
 
Energy on 30 days’
notice and any delay
 
or inability to negotiate
 
a replacement agreement
 
would impact our costs
 
of production as
we would need to change our processing method at Buchanan.
Our
 
business,
 
financial
 
condition
 
and
 
results
 
of
 
operations
 
may
 
be
 
adversely
 
impacted
 
by
 
global
pandemics or other widespread public health concerns.
Global pandemics
 
or other
 
widespread
 
public health
 
concerns could
 
have an
 
adverse
 
effect
 
on our
 
business,
financial condition and results of operations.
 
International, federal, state and local public health and governmental authorities’ mandates in response to global
pandemics could require forced
 
shutdowns of our mines
 
and other facilities
 
in Australia and the
 
U.S. for extended
periods, restrict movement and the implementation of social distancing
 
protocols and restrict travelling overseas
or
 
across
 
borders
 
(including
 
interstate),
 
affecting
 
a
 
number
 
of
 
our
 
normal
 
business
 
practices
 
and
 
operations.
These
 
restrictions
 
could
 
cause
 
disruptions
 
to
 
mining
 
operations,
 
manufacturing
 
operations
 
and
 
supply
 
chains
around the world.
 
The extent and duration of the impact
 
that global pandemics and other public
 
health concerns could have in our
business and results of operations will depend on numerous factors out of our control that we may not
 
be able to
accurately predict
 
and could
 
also heighten
 
other risks
 
described in
 
this “Item
 
1A. Risk
 
Factors” section,
 
which
could have a material adverse impact in our business and results
 
of operations.
Defects in
 
title or
 
loss of
 
any leasehold
 
interests in
 
our properties
 
could limit
 
our ability
 
to mine
 
these
properties or result in significant unanticipated costs.
In Queensland,
 
where all
 
of our
 
Australian Operations
 
are carried
 
out, exploring
 
or mining
 
for coal
 
is unlawful
without a tenement granted by the Queensland
 
government. The grant and renewal of tenements
 
are subject to
a regulatory regime and each
 
tenement is subject to certain
 
conditions. There is no certainty
 
that an application
for the grant of a
 
new tenement or renewal
 
of one of the
 
existing Tenements
 
at Curragh will be
 
granted at all or
on
 
satisfactory
 
terms
 
or
 
within
 
expected
 
timeframes.
 
Further,
 
the
 
conditions
 
attached
 
to
 
the
 
Tenements
 
may
change at the time they are renewed. There is
 
a risk that we may lose title to
 
any of our granted Tenements if we
fail to comply with
 
the Tenement
 
conditions and other
 
applicable legislative requirements
 
(including payment of
State
 
royalties)
 
or
 
if
 
the
 
land
 
that
 
is
 
subject
 
to
 
the
 
title
 
is
 
required
 
for
 
public
 
purposes.
 
The
 
Tenements
 
have
expiration dates ranging from
 
May 31, 2024 to July
 
31, 2044 and, where renewal
 
is required, there is a
 
risk that
the Queensland government may change the terms and conditions
 
of such Tenement
 
upon renewal.
In
 
the
 
United
 
States,
 
title
 
to
 
a
 
leased
 
property
 
and
 
mineral
 
rights
 
is
 
generally
 
secured
 
prior
 
to
 
permitting
 
and
developing a property. In some cases,
 
we rely on title information or representations and warranties provided by
our lessors, grantors
 
or other third
 
parties. Our right
 
to mine some
 
of our reserves
 
may be adversely
 
affected if
defects in
 
title or
 
boundaries
 
exist or
 
if a
 
lease expires.
 
Any challenge
 
to our
 
title or
 
leasehold interests
 
could
delay the exploration and development of the property and could ultimately result in the loss of some
 
or all of our
interest in the property and, accordingly, require us to reduce our estimated coal
 
reserves. In addition, if we mine
on property that we do not
 
own or lease, we could incur
 
civil damages or liability for
 
such mining and be subject
to conversion, negligence,
 
trespass, regulatory sanction
 
and penalties. Some
 
leases have minimum
 
production
requirements or require us
 
to commence mining operations in
 
a specified term to
 
retain the lease. Failure
 
to meet
those requirements
 
could result
 
in losses of
 
prepaid royalties
 
and, in some
 
rare cases,
 
could result
 
in a loss
 
of
the lease itself.
In
 
the
 
United
 
States,
 
we
 
predominantly
 
access
 
our
 
mining
 
properties
 
through
 
leases
 
with
 
a
 
range
 
of
 
private
landholders.
 
If
 
a
 
default
 
under
 
a
 
lease
 
for
 
properties
 
on
 
which
 
we
 
have
 
mining
 
operations
 
resulted
 
in
 
the
termination of the
 
applicable lease,
 
we may
 
have to suspend
 
mining or significantly
 
alter the sequence
 
of such
mining operations, which may adversely affect our
 
future coal production and future revenues.
To
 
obtain
 
leases
 
or
 
mining
 
contracts
 
to
 
conduct
 
our
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
on
 
properties
 
where
 
defects
 
exist
 
or
 
to
negotiate extensions or amendments
 
to existing leases, we
 
may in the future have
 
to incur unanticipated costs.
In addition, we may
 
not be able
 
to successfully negotiate new leases
 
or mining contracts for
 
properties containing
additional
 
reserves
 
or
 
maintain
 
our
 
leasehold
 
interests
 
in
 
properties
 
where
 
we
 
have
 
not
 
commenced
 
mining
operations during the term of the lease.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
46
A defect in our title or the loss of any lease or Tenement
 
upon expiration of its term, upon a default or otherwise,
could adversely affect our ability to mine the associated
 
reserves or process the coal we mine.
We may
 
be unable
 
to obtain,
 
renew or
 
maintain permits necessary
 
for our
 
operations, which
 
would reduce
coal production, cash flows and profitability.
Our performance
 
and
 
operations
 
depend
 
on, among
 
other things,
 
being able
 
to
 
obtain on
 
a timely
 
basis,
 
and
maintain,
 
all
 
necessary
 
regulatory
 
approvals,
 
including
 
any
 
approvals
 
arising
 
under
 
applicable
 
mining
 
laws,
environmental regulations and
 
other laws, for our
 
current operations, expansion
 
and growth projects. Examples
of regulatory
 
approvals that
 
we must
 
obtain and
 
maintain include
 
mine development
 
approvals, environmental
permits and, in
 
Australia, tenure and approvals
 
relating to native
 
title and indigenous cultural
 
heritage. In addition,
our operations depend
 
on our ability
 
to obtain and
 
maintain consents from private
 
land owners and
 
good relations
with local communities.
The requirement
 
to obtain
 
and maintain
 
approvals and
 
address potential
 
and actual
 
issues for
 
former,
 
existing
and future
 
mining
 
projects
 
is common
 
to all
 
companies
 
in the
 
coal sector.
 
However,
 
there is
 
no assurance
 
or
guarantee that we
 
will obtain,
 
secure, or be
 
able to maintain
 
any or all
 
of the required
 
consents, approvals
 
and
rights necessary to maintain our current
 
production profile from our existing
 
operations or to develop our
 
growth
projects
 
in a
 
manner
 
which
 
will result
 
in
 
profitable
 
mining
 
operations
 
and/or
 
achieve
 
our long-term
 
production
targets. The permitting rules, and
 
the interpretations of these rules,
 
are complex, change frequently and
 
are often
subject to the interpretation of the regulators that
 
enforce them, all of which may make compliance more
 
difficult
or impractical,
 
and may
 
possibly preclude
 
the continuance
 
of ongoing
 
operations or
 
the development
 
of future
mining operations. Certain
 
laws, such as
 
the SMCRA, require
 
that certain environmental
 
standards be met
 
before
a
 
permit
 
is
 
issued.
 
The
 
public,
 
including
 
non-governmental
 
organizations,
 
anti-mining
 
groups
 
and
 
individuals,
have certain
 
statutory
 
rights
 
to comment
 
upon and
 
submit
 
objections to
 
requested
 
permits and
 
environmental
impact statements.
 
These comments
 
are prepared
 
in connection
 
with applicable
 
regulatory processes,
 
and the
public may otherwise engage
 
in the permitting
 
process, including bringing
 
lawsuits to challenge the
 
issuance of
permits, the
 
validity or
 
adequacy of environmental
 
impact statements or
 
performance of mining
 
activities. In
 
states
where we operate, applicable
 
laws and regulations
 
also provide that
 
a mining permit
 
or modification can,
 
under
certain
 
circumstances,
 
be
 
delayed,
 
refused
 
or
 
revoked
 
if
 
we
 
or
 
any
 
entity
 
that
 
owns
 
or
 
controls
 
or
 
is
 
under
common
 
ownership
 
or
 
control
 
with
 
us
 
have
 
unabated
 
permit
 
violations
 
or
 
have
 
been
 
the
 
subject
 
of
 
permit
 
or
reclamation bond revocation or suspension. Thus, past or ongoing violations of federal and state mining laws
 
by
us or such entity could provide a basis
 
to revoke existing permits and to
 
deny the issuance of additional permits
or modification
 
or amendment
 
of existing
 
permits. In
 
recent years,
 
the
 
permitting
 
required for
 
coal mining
 
has
been the subject of increasingly stringent regulatory and
 
administrative requirements and extensive activism and
litigation
 
by
 
environmental
 
groups.
 
If
 
this
 
trend
 
continues,
 
it
 
could
 
materially
 
and
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our
 
mining
operations, development
 
and expansion
 
and cost
 
structures, the
 
transport of
 
coal and
 
our customers’
 
ability to
use coal produced
 
by our mines,
 
which, in turn,
 
could have
 
a material
 
adverse effect
 
on our financial
 
condition
and results of operation.
In particular,
 
certain of
 
our activities
 
require a
 
dredge and
 
fill permit
 
from the
 
USACE under
 
Section 404 of
 
the
CWA. In
 
recent years, the
 
Section 404 permitting
 
process has
 
been subject to
 
increasingly stringent
 
regulatory
and administrative
 
requirements
 
and a
 
series of
 
court challenges,
 
which have
 
resulted in
 
increased costs
 
and
delays in the permitting process. In addition, in 2015, the EPA and the USACE issued the CWR, under the CWA
that would
 
further expand
 
the circumstances
 
when a
 
Section 404 permit
 
is needed.
 
The CWR
 
is the
 
subject of
extensive ongoing litigation and
 
administrative proceedings, as
 
a result of which the
 
CWR has been enjoined
 
in
certain
 
states
 
(including
 
West
 
Virginia)
 
and
 
reinstated
 
in
 
others
 
(including
 
Virginia
 
and
 
Pennsylvania),
 
and
 
its
current and future impact on our operations are the subject of significant uncertainty. On April 21, 2020, the EPA
and the
 
USACE
 
published
 
the NWPR,
 
replacing
 
the
 
CWR. The
 
NWPR
 
revises
 
the definition
 
of
 
waters
 
of
 
the
United States
 
and replaces
 
the CWR.
 
The NWPR
 
shrinks the
 
agencies’ jurisdiction,
 
particularly as
 
it relates
 
to
tributaries and adjacent waters, such
 
as wetlands, that were previously
 
covered by the definition under
 
the CWR.
The NWPR
 
went into
 
effect
 
on June
 
22, 2020.
 
States and
 
environmental
 
groups have
 
filed challenges
 
to the
NWPR in various federal
 
district courts.
 
We cannot at this time
 
predict how this rule
 
will be enforced in
 
the future.
Additionally, we may rely on nationwide permits under
 
the CWA Section 404 program for some
 
of our operations.
These nationwide permits are issued every
 
five years, and the 2017 nationwide permit
 
program was reissued in
January 2017. If
 
we are unable
 
to use the
 
nationwide permits
 
and require an
 
individual permit
 
for certain work,
that could delay operations.
If we
 
are unable
 
to obtain
 
and maintain
 
the approvals,
 
consents and
 
rights required
 
for our
 
current and
 
future
operations,
 
or if
 
we obtain
 
approvals subject
 
to conditions
 
or limitations,
 
the
 
economic
 
viability of
 
the relevant
projects may be
 
adversely affected,
 
which may in
 
turn result in
 
the value of
 
the relevant assets
 
being impaired,
which could have a material adverse effect
 
on our financial condition and results of operations.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
47
A
 
shortage
 
of
 
skilled
 
labor
 
in
 
the
 
mining
 
industry
 
could
 
pose
 
a
 
risk
 
to
 
achieving
 
improved
 
labor
productivity.
Efficient coal mining using modern techniques and equipment requires
 
skilled workers, preferably with at least a
year of experience and proficiency in multiple
 
mining tasks. Any reduced availability or future
 
shortage of skilled
labor in the
 
Australian and U.S.
 
mining industries could
 
result in us
 
having insufficient
 
personnel to operate
 
our
business, or expand
 
production, particularly
 
in the event
 
there is an
 
increase in the
 
demand for our
 
coal, which
could adversely affect our financial condition and results
 
of operations.
Operational and Technology
 
Risks
Risks inherent to mining operations could impact the amount of coal produced,
 
cause delay or suspend
coal deliveries, or increase the cost of operating our
 
business.
Our
 
mining
 
operations,
 
including
 
exploration,
 
development,
 
preparation,
 
product
 
handling
 
and
 
accessing
transport infrastructure,
 
may be affected
 
by various operational
 
difficulties that
 
could impact the
 
amount of coal
produced at our coal mines, cause
 
delay or suspend coal deliveries, or increase
 
the cost of mining for a varying
length of time.
 
Our financial performance
 
is dependent
 
on our ability
 
to sustain or
 
increase coal production
 
and
maintain or increase operating margins. Our coal production and production costs are, in
 
many respects, subject
to conditions and events beyond our control, which could disrupt our operations
 
and have a significant impact on
our financial results. Adverse operating conditions and
 
events that we may have experienced in the past
 
or may
experience in the future include:
•
 
a failure to achieve the Met coal qualities or quantities
 
anticipated from exploration activities;
•
 
variations in
 
mining and
 
geological
 
conditions from
 
those anticipated,
 
such as
 
variations in
 
coal seam
thickness and quality,
 
and geotechnical conclusions;
•
 
operational and technical
 
difficulties encountered in mining,
 
including equipment failure,
 
delays in moving
longwall equipment, drag-lines and other equipment and maintenance
 
or technical issues;
•
 
adverse weather conditions
 
or natural or
 
man-made disasters, including
 
hurricanes, cyclones, tornadoes,
floods, droughts, bush
 
fires, seismic activities,
 
ground failures, rock
 
bursts, structural cave-ins
 
or slides
and other catastrophic events (such as global pandemics);
•
 
insufficient or unreliable infrastructure, such as power,
 
water and transport;
•
 
industrial and
 
environmental accidents,
 
such as
 
releases of
 
mine-affected water
 
and diesel
 
spills (both
of which have affected our Australian Operations
 
in the past);
•
 
industrial disputes and labor shortages;
•
 
mine safety accidents, including fatalities, fires and explosions
 
from methane and other sources;
•
 
competition
 
and
 
conflicts
 
with
 
other
 
natural
 
resource
 
extraction
 
and
 
production
 
activities
 
within
overlapping operating areas, such as natural gas extraction
 
or oil and gas development;
•
 
unexpected shortages, or increases in the costs, of consumables,
 
spare parts, plant and equipment;
•
 
cyber-attacks that could disrupt systems we rely on for
 
our operations; and
•
 
security breaches or terrorist acts.
If any
 
of the
 
foregoing conditions
 
or events
 
occurs and
 
is not
 
mitigated or
 
excusable as
 
a force
 
majeure event
under
 
our
 
coal
 
sales
 
contracts,
 
any
 
resulting
 
failure
 
on
 
our
 
part
 
to
 
deliver
 
coal
 
to
 
the
 
purchaser
 
under
 
such
contracts
 
could
 
result
 
in
 
economic
 
penalties,
 
demurrage
 
costs,
 
suspension
 
or
 
cancellation
 
of
 
shipments
 
or
ultimately termination
 
of such
 
contracts, which
 
could
 
have a
 
material adverse
 
effect
 
on our
 
financial condition
and results of operations.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
48
Our U.S.
 
Operations are
 
concentrated in
 
a small
 
number of
 
mines in
 
the CAPP
 
and our
 
Australian Operations
include one
 
mine in
 
the Bowen
 
Basin of
 
Australia. As
 
a result,
 
the effects
 
of any
 
of these
 
conditions or
 
events
may be exacerbated and may have a disproportionate
 
impact on our results of operations and assets. Any such
operational
 
conditions
 
or
 
events
 
could
 
also
 
result
 
in
 
disruption
 
to
 
key
 
infrastructure
 
(including
 
infrastructure
located at or serving our mining activities, as well as the infrastructure that
 
supports freight and logistics). These
conditions and events could
 
also result in the
 
partial or complete closure
 
of particular railways, ports or
 
significant
inland waterways
 
or sea
 
passages, potentially
 
resulting in
 
higher costs,
 
congestion, delays
 
or cancellations
 
on
some
 
transport
 
routes.
 
Any
 
of
 
these
 
conditions
 
or
 
events
 
could
 
adversely
 
impact
 
our
 
business
 
and
 
results
 
of
operations.
Our long-term
 
success depends
 
upon our
 
ability to
 
continue discovering,
 
or acquiring
 
and developing
assets containing, coal reserves that are economically
 
recoverable.
Our recoverable reserves decline
 
as we produce coal.
 
Our long-term outlook depends
 
on our ability to maintain
a commercially viable portfolio of coal reserves that are economically recoverable. Failure to acquire or discover
new coal reserves or
 
develop new assets could negatively
 
affect our financial condition and
 
results of operations.
Exploration activity may occur adjacent to established
 
assets and in new regions. These activities
 
may increase
land tenure,
 
infrastructure
 
and related
 
political risks.
 
Failure to
 
discover or
 
acquire new
 
coal reserves,
 
replace
coal reserves or develop new assets or operations in sufficient quantities to maintain or grow the
 
current level of
reserves could negatively affect our financial condition
 
and results of operations.
Potential changes to our portfolio of assets through acquisitions and divestments may have an adverse effect on
future results
 
of operations
 
and financial
 
condition. From
 
time to
 
time, we
 
may add
 
assets to,
 
or divest
 
assets
from, our portfolio. There are a number of risks associated with historical
 
and future acquisitions or divestments,
including, among others:
•
 
adverse market
 
reaction to
 
such acquisitions
 
and divestments
 
or the
 
timing or
 
terms on
 
which acquisitions
and divestments are made;
•
 
imposition of adverse regulatory conditions and obligations;
•
 
geopolitical risks;
•
 
commercial objectives not being achieved as expected;
•
 
unforeseen liabilities arising from changes to the portfolio;
•
 
sales revenues and operational performance not meeting
 
expectations;
•
 
anticipated synergies or cost savings being delayed or not
 
being achieved; and
•
 
inability to retain key staff and transaction-related costs
 
being more than anticipated.
These factors could materially and adversely affect
 
our financial condition and results of operations.
We rely
 
on estimates
 
of our
 
recoverable resources
 
and reserves,
 
which are
 
complex due
 
to geological
characteristics of the properties and the number of
 
assumptions made.
We rely on estimates of our recoverable resources and reserves.
 
In this Annual Report on Form 10-K, we report
our estimated resources
 
and reserves in
 
accordance with
 
subpart 1300
 
of Regulation S-K
 
under the Exchange
Act. See Item
 
2. “Properties.”
 
Subpart 1300 of
 
Regulation S-K requires
 
us to disclose
 
our mineral resources,
 
in
addition to
 
our mineral reserves.
 
In addition,
 
as an
 
ASX-listed company, our ASX disclosures
 
follow the Australian
Code
 
for
 
Reporting
 
of
 
Exploration
 
Results,
 
Mineral
 
Resources
 
and
 
Ore
 
Reserves
 
2012,
 
or
 
the
 
JORC
 
Code.
Accordingly,
 
our estimates
 
of resources
 
and reserves
 
in this
 
Annual Report
 
on Form
 
10-K and
 
in other
 
reports
that
 
we
 
are
 
required
 
to
 
file
 
with
 
the
 
SEC
 
may
 
be
 
different
 
than
 
our
 
estimates
 
of
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
as
reported in our ASX disclosures.
Coal
 
is
 
economically
 
recoverable
 
when
 
the
 
price
 
at
 
which
 
it
 
can
 
be
 
sold
 
exceeds
 
the
 
costs
 
and
 
expenses
 
of
mining
 
and
 
selling
 
the
 
coal.
 
The
 
costs
 
and
 
expenses
 
of
 
mining
 
and
 
selling
 
the
 
coal
 
are
 
determined
 
on
 
a
mine-by-mine basis, and as a result, the price at which our coal is economically recoverable varies based on the
mine. We
 
base our resource
 
and reserve
 
information on geologic
 
data, coal ownership
 
information and current
and
 
proposed
 
mine
 
plans,
 
and
 
mining
 
cost
 
assumptions
 
may
 
be
 
affected
 
by
 
changes
 
in
 
mine
 
planning
 
or
scheduling over
 
time. There
 
are numerous
 
uncertainties
 
inherent in
 
estimating
 
quantities
 
and qualities
 
of coal
and
 
costs
 
to
 
mine
 
recoverable
 
reserves,
 
including
 
many
 
factors
 
beyond
 
our
 
control.
 
There
 
are
 
inherent
uncertainties and risks associated with such estimates, includi
 
ng:
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
49
•
 
geologic and mining conditions,
 
which may not be
 
fully identified by available
 
exploration data and may
differ from our experience and assumptions in areas
 
we currently mine;
•
 
current
 
and
 
future
 
market
 
prices
 
for
 
coal,
 
contractual
 
arrangements,
 
operating
 
costs
 
and
 
capital
expenditures;
•
 
severance and
 
excise
 
taxes,
 
unexpected
 
governmental
 
taxes, royalties
 
,
 
stamp
 
duty and
 
development
and reclamation costs;
•
 
future mining technology improvements;
•
 
the effects of regulation by governmental agencies;
•
 
the ability to obtain, maintain and renew all required permits;
•
 
employee health and safety; and
•
 
historical production from the area compared with production from
 
other producing areas.
Except
 
for
 
that
 
portion
 
of
 
mineral
 
resources
 
classified
 
as
 
mineral
 
reserves,
 
mineral
 
resources
 
do
 
not
 
have
demonstrated economic value. Even
 
if a mineral
 
resource exists, there can
 
be no assurance that
 
any part of
 
such
mineral resource will ever be converted to mineral reserves.
In addition, estimates of coal resources and reserves are revised based on actual production experience, and/or
new exploration
 
information and therefore
 
the estimates
 
of coal resources
 
and reserves
 
are subject to
 
change.
Should we
 
encounter geological
 
conditions or
 
qualities different
 
from those
 
predicted by
 
past drilling,
 
sampling
and similar examinations, estimates
 
of coal resources and reserves
 
may have to be adjusted
 
and mining plans,
coal processing and infrastructure may have to be
 
altered in a way that might adversely affect our operations. As
a result, our estimates may not accurately reflect our actual future coal
 
resources and reserves.
As
 
a
 
result,
 
the
 
quantity
 
and
 
quality
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
that
 
we
 
recover
 
may
 
be
 
less
 
than
 
the
 
resource
 
and
 
reserve
estimates included in
 
this Annual Report
 
on Form 10-K.
 
If our actual coal
 
resources and reserves
 
are less than
current estimates,
 
or the
 
rate at
 
which they
 
are recovered
 
is less
 
than estimated
 
or results
 
in higher
 
than estimated
cost, our financial condition and results of operations may
 
be materially adversely affected.
Our
 
profitability
 
could
 
be
 
affected
 
adversely
 
by
 
the
 
failure
 
of
 
suppliers
 
and/or
 
outside
 
contractors
 
to
perform.
We use
 
contractors and
 
other third
 
parties for
 
exploration, mining
 
and other
 
services generally,
 
and are
 
reliant
on several
 
third parties
 
for the
 
success of
 
our current
 
operations and
 
the development
 
of our
 
growth projects.
While
 
this
 
is normal
 
for
 
the
 
mining
 
industry,
 
problems
 
caused
 
by third
 
parties
 
may arise,
 
which
 
may
 
have
 
an
impact on our performance and operations. In particular, the majority of workers at our
 
Australian Operations are
employed by contractors, including Thiess Pty Ltd and
 
Golding Contractors Pty Ltd.
Operations
 
at
 
our
 
mines
 
may
 
be
 
interrupted
 
for
 
an
 
extended
 
period
 
in
 
the
 
event
 
that
 
we
 
lose
 
any
 
of
 
our
 
key
contractors (because their
 
contract is terminated or
 
expires) and are required
 
to replace them. There
 
can be no
assurance that skilled third parties
 
or contractors will continue
 
to be available at reasonable
 
rates. As we do not
have the
 
same control
 
over contractors
 
as we
 
do over
 
employees, we
 
are also
 
exposed to
 
risks related
 
to the
quality or
 
continuation of
 
the services
 
of, and
 
the equipment
 
and supplies
 
used by,
 
our contractors,
 
as well
 
as
risks related
 
to the
 
compliance of our
 
contractors with environmental
 
and health and
 
safety legislation and
 
internal
policies, standards and
 
processes. Any failure
 
by our key
 
contractors to comply
 
with their obligations
 
under our
operating agreements with
 
them (whether as a
 
result of financial, safety
 
or operational difficulties
 
or otherwise),
any
 
termination
 
or
 
breach
 
of
 
our
 
operating
 
agreements
 
by
 
our
 
contractors,
 
any
 
protracted
 
dispute
 
with
 
a
contractor, any inability to perform due to global pandemics or other health concerns,
 
any material labor dispute
between
 
our
 
contractors
 
and
 
their
 
employees
 
or
 
any
 
major
 
labor
 
action
 
by
 
those
 
employees
 
against
 
our
contractors, could have a material adverse effect
 
on our financial condition and results of operations.
Further, in
 
periods of high
 
commodity prices, demand
 
for contractors may
 
exceed supply resulting
 
in increased
costs or lack
 
of availability
 
of key contractors.
 
Disruptions of
 
operations or
 
increased costs also
 
can occur as
 
a
result of disputes with contractors or a shortage
 
of contractors with particular capabilities. To
 
the extent that any
of the foregoing risks were to materialize, our operating
 
results and cash flows could be adversely affected.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
50
Our inability to replace or
 
repair damaged or destroyed
 
equipment or facilities in
 
a timely manner could
materially and adversely affect our financial condition
 
and results of operations.
We depend on several
 
major pieces of mining
 
equipment and facilities to
 
produce and transport coal,
 
including,
but
 
not
 
limited
 
to,
 
longwall
 
mining
 
systems,
 
continuous
 
miners,
 
draglines,
 
dozers,
 
excavators,
 
shovels,
 
haul
trucks, conveyors,
 
CPPs and
 
rail loading
 
and blending
 
facilities. Obtaining
 
and repairing
 
these major
 
pieces of
equipment often involves long lead
 
times. If any of these
 
pieces of equipment and facilities suffers major
 
damage
or is destroyed by fire,
 
abnormal wear and tear,
 
flooding, incorrect operation or
 
otherwise, we may be unable
 
to
replace or repair them in a timely manner or at a reasonable cost, which would impact our ability
 
to produce and
transport
 
coal
 
and
 
could
 
materially
 
and
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our financial
 
condition
 
and
 
results
 
of
 
operations.
 
Our
ability to replace or
 
repair damaged or destroyed
 
equipment or facilities
 
may also be dependent
 
on suppliers or
manufacturers remaining operational and having the relevant equipment, work force or services available for us.
Suppliers
 
and
 
manufacturers
 
may be
 
unable
 
to
 
provide
 
such
 
equipment,
 
work
 
force
 
or service
 
for
 
a
 
range
 
of
reasons, including but not limited to their business suffering
 
adverse effects as a result of global pandemics.
 
Additionally, regulatory agencies sometimes make changes with regard to requirements for pieces of
 
equipment.
Such changes can impose costs on us and can cause delays if manufacturers and suppliers are unable to make
the required changes in compliance with mandated deadlines.
Our
 
ability to
 
operate effectively
 
could
 
be impaired
 
if we
 
lose key
 
personnel
 
or fail
 
to
 
attract qualified
personnel.
The loss of key personnel and the failure to recruit sufficiently qualified staff
 
could affect our future performance.
We have entered into employment
 
contracts with a number of
 
key personnel in Australia
 
and the United States,
including our
 
Managing
 
Director
 
and
 
Chief
 
Executive
 
Officer,
 
Douglas
 
Thompson,
 
our Group
 
Chief
 
Operating
Officer, Jeffrey Bitzer and our Group
 
Chief Financial Officer and Head
 
of Marketing and Strategy, Gerhard Ziems.
 
Mr. Thompson’s,
 
Mr. Bitzer’s and Mr. Ziems’ expertise and experience in the mining industry are important to
 
the
continued
 
development
 
and
 
operation
 
of
 
our
 
mining
 
interests.
 
However,
 
there
 
is
 
no
 
assurance
 
that
 
such
personnel will
 
remain with
 
us for
 
the term
 
of their
 
employment contracts
 
or beyond.
 
Although all
 
our Australian
based employees
 
have contracts
 
of employment,
 
in the
 
United States,
 
we have
 
not entered
 
into employment
contracts
 
with
 
any
 
of
 
our key
 
personnel
 
(other
 
than
 
Mr. Bitzer,
 
Mr.
 
Christopher
 
Meyering,
 
our
 
Vice
 
President,
Chief Legal
 
Officer and
 
Mr.
 
Brett Holbrook,
 
our Vice
 
President Operations
 
U.S.), meaning
 
that we
 
do not
 
have
the benefit of notice provisions or non-compete restraints with these employees. There may be a limited number
of persons with the requisite experience and
 
skills to serve in our senior management
 
positions. We may not be
able to
 
locate
 
or employ
 
qualified executives
 
on acceptable
 
terms.
 
In
 
addition,
 
as
 
our business
 
develops
 
and
expands,
 
we
 
believe
 
that
 
our
 
future
 
success
 
will
 
depend
 
greatly
 
on
 
our
 
continued
 
ability
 
to
 
attract
 
and
 
retain
highly skilled personnel with coal
 
industry experience in Australia and
 
the United States. We may
 
not be able to
continue to
 
employ
 
key personnel
 
or attract
 
and retain
 
qualified
 
personnel
 
in the
 
future. The
 
loss of
 
such
 
key
personnel
 
or the
 
failure to
 
recruit sufficiently qualified
 
employees may affect
 
our business and
 
future performance.
We may not have adequate insurance coverage
 
for some business risks.
We have insurance coverage for certain
 
operating risks that provide limited coverage
 
for some potential liabilities
associated with our
 
business. As
 
a result of
 
market conditions, premiums
 
and deductibles for
 
certain insurance
policies
 
can
 
increase
 
substantially,
 
and
 
in
 
some
 
instances,
 
certain
 
insurance
 
may
 
become
 
unavailable
 
or
available only for reduced amounts of coverage. As a result, we may not be able
 
to renew our existing insurance
policies or
 
procure
 
other
 
desirable
 
insurance
 
on commercially
 
reasonable
 
terms,
 
if at
 
all. In
 
addition,
 
we
 
may
become subject
 
to liability
 
(including in
 
relation to
 
pollution, occupational
 
illnesses
 
or other
 
hazards),
 
or suffer
loss resulting from
 
business interruption, for
 
which we are
 
not insured (or
 
are not sufficiently
 
insured) or cannot
insure, including liabilities in respect of past activities.
Should we suffer a major
 
uninsured loss, future financial
 
performance could be materially
 
adversely affected. In
addition, insurance may not
 
continue to be available
 
at economically acceptable
 
premiums or coverage may
 
be
reduced. As
 
a result,
 
the insurance
 
coverage
 
may not
 
cover the
 
full scope
 
and extent
 
of claims
 
against us
 
or
losses we
 
may incur.
 
The occurrence
 
of a
 
significant
 
adverse event
 
not fully
 
or partially
 
covered by
 
insurance
could have a material adverse effect on our financial
 
condition and results of operations.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
51
Cybersecurity
 
attacks
 
and
 
other
 
similar
 
crises
 
or
 
disruptions
 
may
 
negatively
 
affect
 
our
 
business,
financial condition and results of operations.
Our
 
business
 
may be
 
impacted
 
by cybersecurity
 
attacks
 
or failures.
 
Strategic
 
targets,
 
such
 
as
 
energy-related
assets, may
 
be at greater
 
risk of
 
cybersecurity attacks
 
than other targets
 
in the United
 
States or
 
Australia. Our
insurance may
 
not protect
 
us against
 
such occurrences.
 
It is
 
possible that
 
any such
 
occurrences could
 
have a
material adverse effect on our business, financial
 
condition and results of operations.
In addition, a disruption in,
 
or failure of, our information
 
technology systems could adversely affect
 
our business
operations
 
and
 
financial
 
performance.
 
We
 
rely
 
on
 
the
 
accuracy,
 
capacity
 
and
 
security
 
of
 
our
 
information
technology,
 
or IT,
 
systems for the operations
 
of many of our
 
business processes and to
 
comply with regulatory,
legal and tax
 
requirements. While
 
we maintain
 
some of
 
our critical IT
 
systems, we
 
are also dependent
 
on third
parties
 
to
 
provide
 
important
 
IT
 
services
 
relating
 
to,
 
among
 
other
 
things,
 
human
 
resources,
 
electronic
communications
 
and
 
certain
 
finance
 
functions.
 
Despite
 
the
 
security
 
measures
 
that
 
we
 
have
 
implemented,
including those
 
related to cybersecurity, our systems
 
could be breached
 
or damaged by
 
computer viruses, natural
or man-made
 
incidents or
 
disasters or
 
unauthorized physical
 
or electronic
 
access. Though
 
we have
 
controls in
place, we cannot provide assurance that a cyber-attack
 
will not occur.
 
Furthermore, we may
 
have little or
 
no oversight with
 
respect to security
 
measures employed by
 
third-party service
providers, which may ultimately prove to be ineffective at countering threats. Failures of our IT systems, whether
caused
 
maliciously
 
or inadvertently,
 
may
 
result
 
in
 
the
 
disruption
 
of
 
our
 
business
 
processes,
 
the
 
unauthorized
release
 
of
 
sensitive,
 
confidential
 
or
 
otherwise
 
protected
 
information
 
or
 
the
 
corruption
 
of
 
data,
 
which
 
could
adversely affect our
 
business operations and
 
financial performance. We may
 
be required to
 
incur significant costs
to protect against and remediate the damage caused by
 
such disruptions or system failures in the future.
Financial and Strategic Risks
The loss
 
of, or
 
significant reduction
 
in, purchases
 
by our
 
largest customers
 
could adversely
 
affect our
revenues.
A significant portion of the sales of our Met coal is to
 
customers with whom we have had long-term relationships.
The success of our business depends on our
 
ability to retain our current customers, renew our existing customer
contracts
 
and
 
solicit
 
new
 
customers.
 
Our
 
ability
 
to
 
do
 
so
 
generally
 
depends
 
on
 
a
 
variety
 
of
 
factors,
 
including
having our mines
 
operational, having the type
 
and quantity of
 
coal available, the quality
 
and price of
 
our products,
our ability to market these products effectively, our ability to deliver on a timely basis and the level of competition
that we face.
In addition, our
 
sales contracts
 
generally contain
 
provisions that
 
allow customers
 
to suspend or
 
terminate if
 
we
commit a material breach of the terms of the contract, a change in law
 
restricts or prohibits a party from carrying
out its
 
material obligations
 
under the
 
contract or
 
a material
 
adverse change
 
occurs in
 
our financial
 
standing or
creditworthiness. If customers suspend
 
or terminate existing contracts,
 
or otherwise refuse to accept
 
shipments
of our Met
 
coal for which
 
they have an
 
existing contractual
 
obligation, our revenues
 
will decrease, and
 
we may
have to reduce production at our mines until our customers’
 
contractual obligations are honored.
For the
 
year ended
 
December 31,
 
2023, our
 
top ten
 
customers comprised
 
74.2% of
 
our total
 
revenue and
 
our
top five customers comprised
 
53.3% of our total revenue. For the year ended December
 
31, 2023, sales to Tata
Steel and AcelorMittal represented
 
20.5% and 10.0%,
 
respectively, of our total revenue. The
 
majority of our
 
sales
are made
 
on
 
a spot
 
basis
 
or under
 
contracts
 
with
 
terms
 
of typically
 
one
 
year.
 
The
 
failure
 
to
 
obtain
 
additional
customers or the
 
loss of all
 
or a portion
 
of the revenues
 
attributable to any
 
customer as a
 
result of competition,
creditworthiness,
 
inability
 
to
 
negotiate
 
extensions,
 
replacement
 
of
 
contracts
 
or
 
the
 
impact
 
of
 
the
 
global
pandemics, or otherwise, may adversely affect our
 
business, financial condition and results of operations.
If our ability
 
to collect
 
payments from
 
customers is
 
impaired, our
 
revenues and
 
operating profits
 
could
suffer.
Our
 
ability
 
to
 
receive
 
payment
 
for
 
coal
 
sold
 
and
 
delivered
 
will
 
depend
 
on
 
the
 
continued
 
creditworthiness
 
and
contractual performance of our customers and counterparties. For certain customers, we require the provision of
a letter of credit as
 
security for payment. The inability of key customers
 
to procure letters of credit (due
 
to general
economic conditions or the
 
specific circumstances of the
 
customer) may restrict our
 
ability to contract with such
customers or result in fewer sales contracts being executed, which could materially adversely affect our financial
condition and results of operations. For certain of our large customers
 
in Australia who have not provided letters
of
 
credit
 
or
 
other
 
form
 
of
 
security,
 
we
 
maintain
 
an
 
insurance
 
policy
 
to
 
cover
 
for
 
any
 
failure
 
in
 
payment.
 
This
insurance coverage, however,
 
may not cover the full scope
 
and extent of losses we
 
may incur as the result
 
of a
payment default or otherwise.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
52
If a customer
 
does not
 
pay amounts
 
due in
 
a timely
 
manner,
 
we may
 
decide to sell
 
the customer’s coal
 
on the
spot market, which may be
 
at prices lower than the contracted
 
price, or we may be unable
 
to sell the coal at all.
If our customers’ or counterparties’ creditworthiness deteriorates,
 
our business could be adversely affected.
 
Changes in credit
 
ratings issued by
 
nationally recognized statistical
 
rating organizations could
 
adversely
affect our cost of financing and the market price
 
of our securities.
 
Credit rating agencies
 
could downgrade our ratings
 
due to factors specific
 
to our business,
 
a prolonged cyclical
downturn in the
 
mining industry or
 
macroeconomic trends
 
(such as global
 
or regional recessions)
 
and trends in
credit and
 
capital markets
 
more generally.
 
Any decline
 
in our credit
 
ratings would
 
likely result
 
in an
 
increase to
our cost of financing, limit our access to the capital markets, significantly harm our financial condition and results
of operations,
 
hinder
 
our ability
 
to refinance
 
existing
 
indebtedness
 
on
 
acceptable
 
terms
 
and
 
have an
 
adverse
effect on the market price of our securities.
Our existing and future indebtedness may limit cash flow available to invest in the ongoing needs of our
businesses, which could
 
prevent us
 
from fulfilling our
 
obligations under our
 
senior secured notes,
 
senior
secured asset-based revolving
 
credit agreement in
 
an initial
 
aggregate principal amount
 
of $150.0
 
million,
or
 
the
 
New
 
ABL
 
Facility,
 
and
 
other
 
debt,
 
and
 
we
 
may
 
be
 
forced
 
to
 
take
 
other
 
actions
 
to
 
satisfy
 
our
obligations under our debt, which may not be successful.
As
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
we
 
had
 
$242.3
 
million
 
aggregate
 
principal
 
amount
 
of
 
our
 
senior
 
secured
 
notes
outstanding. As of December 31, 2023, the
 
letter of credit sublimit had been partially used
 
to issue $21.9 million
of bank guarantees on behalf of the Company and no amounts were drawn under the revolving credit sublimit of
the New ABL Facility.
 
As of December 31, 2023,
 
the available borrowing
 
capacity under this facility
 
was $128.1
million.
 
We dedicate a
 
portion of our
 
cash flow from
 
operations to the
 
payment of debt
 
service, reducing the
 
availability
of our cash flow
 
to fund capital expenditures,
 
acquisitions or strategic
 
development initiatives and
 
other general
corporate purposes. Our ability to make scheduled payments on or to refinance our debt obligations depends on
our ability to
 
generate cash in
 
the future and our
 
financial condition and operating
 
performance, which are subject
to prevailing economic and competitive
 
conditions and to certain
 
financial, business and other factors
 
beyond our
control. There can be no assurance that we
 
will maintain a level of cash flows from
 
operating activities sufficient
to permit us to pay the principal, premium, if any,
 
and interest on our debt. In addition, any failure to comply
 
with
covenants in the
 
instruments governing
 
our debt could
 
result in an
 
event of default
 
that, if not
 
cured or
 
waived,
would have a material adverse effect on us.
Our
 
level
 
of
 
indebtedness
 
could
 
have
 
further
 
consequences,
 
including,
 
but
 
not
 
limited
 
to,
 
increasing
 
our
vulnerability to adverse
 
economic or industry
 
conditions, placing us
 
at a competitive
 
disadvantage compared
 
to
other businesses in
 
the industries in
 
which we operate
 
that are
 
not as leveraged
 
and that may
 
be better positioned
to withstand
 
economic downturns,
 
limiting our
 
flexibility to
 
plan for,
 
or react
 
to, changes
 
in our
 
businesses and
the industries in which we operate, and requiring us to refinance all or a portion of our existing debt. We may not
be
 
able
 
to
 
refinance
 
on
 
commercially
 
reasonable
 
terms
 
or
 
at
 
all,
 
and
 
any
 
refinancing
 
of
 
our
 
debt
 
could
 
be
 
at
higher interest rates
 
and may require
 
us to comply
 
with more onerous
 
covenants, making it more
 
difficult to obtain
surety bonds, letters of credit or
 
other financial assurances that may be
 
demanded by our vendors or regulatory
agencies, particularly during periods in which credit markets
 
are weak.
If
 
we
 
are
 
unable
 
to
 
service
 
our
 
debt
 
obligations,
 
we
 
could
 
face
 
substantial
 
liquidity
 
problems
 
and
 
we
 
may
 
be
forced to
 
reduce or delay
 
investments and capital
 
expenditures, or to
 
sell assets, seek
 
additional capital, including
additional secured or unsecured debt, or restructure or refinance our debt, and we may be unable to continue as
a going concern.
 
We may be
 
unable to consummate
 
any proposed asset
 
sales or recover
 
the carrying value
 
of
these assets,
 
and
 
any proceeds
 
may
 
not
 
be adequate
 
to
 
meet
 
any
 
debt
 
service
 
obligations
 
then
 
due.
 
Any
 
of
these
 
examples
 
potentially
 
could
 
have
 
a
 
material
 
adverse
 
impact
 
on
 
our
 
results
 
of
 
operations,
 
profitability,
stockholders’ equity and capital structure.
Our ability to service
 
our debt obligations
 
could be impacted
 
by the consummation
 
of the SGI Transaction.
 
See
“—Consummation of the
 
proposed SGI Transaction may constitute
 
a change of
 
control under our
 
Senior Secured
Notes Indenture
 
and our
 
New ABL
 
Facility,
 
which could
 
materially and
 
adversely affect
 
our business,
 
financial
condition and results of operations.”
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
53
We
 
adjust
 
our
 
capital
 
structure
 
from
 
time
 
to
 
time
 
and
 
may
 
need
 
to
 
increase
 
our
 
debt
 
leverage,
 
which
would make us more sensitive to the effects of
 
economic downturns.
It is possible
 
that we
 
may need
 
to raise
 
additional debt
 
or equity funds
 
in the future.
 
Our New
 
ABL Facility
 
and
operating cash flows
 
may not be adequate
 
to fund our ongoing
 
capital requirements,
 
for any future acquisitions
or projects or to
 
refinance our debt. There
 
is no guarantee that
 
we will be able to
 
refinance our existing
 
debt, or
if we do, there is no guarantee that such new funding will be
 
on terms acceptable to us.
Global credit markets have been severely constrained in the
 
past, such as during a global financial crisis and the
European sovereign
 
debt crisis,
 
and during
 
the
 
COVID-19
 
pandemic,
 
and
 
the ability
 
to obtain
 
new funding
 
or
refinance in
 
the future
 
may be
 
significantly reduced.
 
If we
 
are unable
 
to obtain
 
sufficient funding,
 
either due
 
to
banking and
 
capital market
 
conditions, generally,
 
or due
 
to factors
 
specific to
 
our
 
business, we
 
may not
 
have
sufficient cash to meet our
 
ongoing capital requirements, which
 
in turn could materially and
 
adversely affect our
financial
 
condition.
 
Failure
 
to
 
obtain
 
sufficient
 
financing
 
could
 
cause
 
delays
 
or
 
abandonment
 
of
 
business
development plans and have a material adverse effect
 
on our business, operations and financial condition.
In
 
recent
 
years,
 
certain
 
financial
 
institutions,
 
investment
 
managers
 
and
 
insurance
 
companies
 
globally
 
have
responded to pressure
 
to take actions
 
to limit or
 
divest investments in,
 
financing made available
 
to, and insurance
coverage
 
provided
 
for,
 
the
 
development
 
of
 
new
 
coal-fired
 
power
 
plants
 
and
 
coal
 
miners
 
that
 
derive
 
revenues
from thermal
 
coal sales.
 
For example,
 
recently,
 
some financial
 
institutions publicly
 
announced that
 
they would
stop funding new thermal coal projects or would
 
otherwise reduce their overall lending
 
to coal producers. These
or similar
 
policies
 
may adversely
 
impact
 
the coal
 
industry
 
generally,
 
our ability
 
to
 
access
 
capital and
 
financial
markets in the future, our costs of capital and the future
 
global demand for coal.
Our business may require substantial ongoing capital
 
expenditures, and we may not have access to
 
the
capital required to reach full productive capacity at our
 
mines.
Maintaining
 
and
 
expanding
 
mines
 
and
 
related
 
infrastructure
 
is
 
capital
 
intensive.
 
Specifically,
 
the
 
exploration,
permitting
 
and
 
development
 
of
 
Met
 
coal
 
reserves,
 
mining
 
costs,
 
the
 
maintenance
 
of
 
machinery,
 
facilities
 
and
equipment
 
and
 
compliance
 
with
 
applicable
 
laws
 
and
 
regulations
 
require
 
ongoing
 
capital
 
expenditures.
 
Any
decision to increase
 
production at our existing
 
mines or to
 
develop the high-quality Met
 
coal recoverable reserves
at our
 
development properties in
 
the future
 
could also affect
 
our capital
 
needs or
 
cause future
 
capital expenditures
to be higher than in the past and/or higher than our estimates. We cannot assure that we will be able to maintain
our production
 
levels or
 
generate sufficient cash
 
flow, or that
 
we will
 
have access
 
to sufficient financing
 
to continue
our
 
production,
 
exploration,
 
permitting
 
and
 
development
 
activities
 
at
 
or
 
above
 
our
 
present
 
levels
 
and
 
on
 
our
current or projected
 
timelines, and we
 
may be required
 
to defer all
 
or a portion
 
of our capital
 
expenditures. Our
results of
 
operations, business
 
and financial
 
condition may
 
be materially
 
adversely affected
 
if we
 
cannot make
such capital expenditures.
To
 
fund our
 
capital expenditures,
 
we will
 
be required
 
to use
 
cash from
 
our operations,
 
incur debt
 
or raise
 
new
equity.
 
Our ability
 
to obtain
 
bank financing
 
or our
 
ability to
 
access the
 
capital markets
 
for future
 
equity or
 
debt
offerings, on the other hand, may
 
be limited by our financial
 
condition at the time of any
 
such financing or offering
and the
 
covenants in
 
our existing
 
debt agreements,
 
as well
 
as by
 
general economic
 
conditions, contingencies
and uncertainties that
 
are beyond
 
our control. If
 
cash flow generated
 
by our operations
 
or available borrowings
under our
 
bank financing
 
arrangements are
 
insufficient to
 
meet our
 
capital requirements
 
and we
 
are unable
 
to
access
 
the
 
capital
 
markets
 
on
 
acceptable
 
terms
 
or
 
at
 
all,
 
we
 
could
 
be
 
forced
 
to
 
curtail
 
the
 
expansion
 
of
 
our
existing mines and the development of
 
our properties which, in turn, could
 
lead to a decline in
 
our production and
could materially and adversely affect our business,
 
financial condition and results of operations.
Risks
 
related
 
to
 
our
 
investment
 
in
 
WICET
 
may
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our
 
financial
 
condition
 
and
 
results
 
of
operations.
We have
 
a minority
 
interest in
 
WICET Holdings
 
Pty Ltd,
 
whose wholly
 
owned subsidiary,
 
Wiggins Island
 
Coal
Export Terminal
 
Pty Ltd, or WICET Pty Ltd, owns WICET. Other coal producers who export coal through WICET
also hold
 
shares
 
in
 
WICET
 
Holdings
 
Pty Ltd.
 
In addition,
 
we
 
and the
 
other coal
 
producers (or
 
shippers)
 
have
evergreen, ten
 
year take-or-pay
 
agreements with
 
WICET Pty
 
Ltd and
 
pay a
 
terminal handling
 
charge to
 
export
coal through
 
WICET,
 
which
 
is calculated
 
by reference
 
to WICET’s
 
annual
 
operating
 
costs,
 
as well
 
as finance
costs associated with WICET Pty Ltd’s external
 
debt facilities.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
54
Under our take-or-pay agreement with WICET
 
Pty Ltd, or the WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement, Curragh’s export
capacity is 1.5 MMtpa and we
 
are obligated to pay the
 
terminal handling charge for this capacity, whether utilized
or not. The terminal handling
 
charge calculation is based on
 
total operating and finance costs
 
of WICET Pty Ltd
being charged to contracted shippers in proportion to each shipper’s contracted capacity. Under the terms of the
WICET
 
Take
 
-or-Pay
 
Agreement
 
the
 
terminal
 
handling
 
charge
 
payable
 
by
 
us
 
can
 
be
 
adjusted
 
(increased
 
or
decreased) by WICET Pty Ltd if WICET Pty
 
Ltd’s operating and finance costs change,
 
or if a contracted shipper
defaults on its take-or-pay agreement obligations and has its contracted capacity reduced to
 
nil. Under the terms
of the WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement there is a limit of how much WICET Pty Ltd can charge us for recovery of
its finance costs, referred to as a finance cap. Since WICET began operating in April 2015, five WICET Holdings
Pty Ltd shipper-shareholders
 
have defaulted on their
 
obligations under their respective
 
take-or-pay agreements
and
 
subsequently
 
had
 
those
 
agreements
 
terminated.
 
The
 
result
 
of
 
these
 
terminations
 
is
 
a
 
decrease
 
in
 
the
aggregate contracted tonnage at WICET from 27 MMtpa to
 
13.9 MMtpa.
Given the
 
operation
 
of the
 
finance cap
 
(which
 
has been
 
reached,
 
subject
 
to further
 
adjustment
 
for Consumer
Price Index,
 
or CPI) there
 
is a
 
limit to the
 
recovery by
 
WICET of its
 
financing costs
 
from shippers. Accordingly,
prior defaults referred
 
to above have
 
resulted in only
 
minor increases to
 
the terminal handling
 
charges payable
by the remaining
 
shipper shareholders (including us).
 
These increases have related
 
to higher A$/ton (or
 
US$/ton)
charge for
 
operating
 
costs
 
resulting
 
from
 
a
 
lower
 
contract
 
base.
 
If
 
any of
 
the
 
remaining
 
shipper
 
shareholders
becomes
 
insolvent
 
and/or
 
defaults
 
under
 
its
 
take-or-pay
 
agreement,
 
the
 
terminal
 
handling
 
charges
 
for
 
the
remaining shipper shareholders, including us, may increase proportionately to pay the defaulting shipper’s share
of WICET’s
 
operating
 
and
 
financing costs
 
going forward
 
(noting that
 
the
 
finance cap
 
applies
 
in respect
 
of the
financing costs component of the terminal handling charges).
In addition, if we default under the WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement and that default is not remedied, then we will
be obligated
 
to pay
 
a termination
 
payment. The
 
termination payment
 
is equal
 
to the
 
lesser of
 
our proportion
 
of
WICET Pty Ltd’s
 
total external
 
debt (which
 
is based on
 
the proportion
 
that our contracted
 
tonnage bears to
 
the
total contracted tonnage
 
at WICET when
 
the payment obligation
 
is triggered) and
 
ten years equivalent
 
terminal
handling
 
charges
 
at
 
the
 
prevailing
 
rate
 
at
 
the
 
time
 
that
 
the
 
termination
 
payment
 
falls
 
due.
 
We
 
have
 
provided
security to WICET
 
Pty Ltd in
 
the form of
 
a bank guarantee, the
 
amount of which
 
is required to
 
cover our estimated
liabilities as a shipper under the WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement for the following twelve-month period.
 
In the event of WICET Pty Ltd defaulting on its external debt obligations, external lenders to WICET Pty Ltd may
enforce
 
their
 
rights
 
to
 
the
 
security
 
over
 
the
 
assets
 
of
 
WICET
 
and
 
appoint
 
a
 
receiver
 
to
 
take
 
steps
 
to
 
recover
outstanding debt. The
 
external lenders
 
do not have
 
direct recourse to
 
the shippers
 
to recover outstanding
 
debt
and shipper take-or-pay agreements would remain on foot and access to the port would continue to be available
to us.
 
In the
 
event of
 
a permanent
 
cessation of
 
operations
 
at WICET,
 
we may
 
be required
 
to procure
 
additional
 
port
capacity elsewhere, as well as be liable for a termination payment
 
under the WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement.
Risks related to
 
the Supply Deed
 
with Stanwell may
 
adversely affect
 
our financial condition
 
and results
of operations.
Curragh has a CSA,
 
as amended from
 
time to time,
 
with Stanwell to
 
supply thermal coal
 
to the Stanwell
 
Power
Station. The
 
CSA restricted
 
Curragh from
 
mining the
 
SRA which
 
was reserved
 
for the
 
benefit of
 
Stanwell and
could not be
 
mined without
 
Stanwell’s consent.
 
Under the
 
CSA, in addition
 
to supplying thermal
 
coal at
 
a price
below the cost
 
to Curragh
 
of mining and
 
processing the
 
coal, Curragh
 
pays certain
 
rebates to
 
Stanwell on
 
Met
coal exported
 
from certain
 
parts of
 
Curragh, which
 
represents
 
the deferred
 
purchase
 
cost of
 
the right
 
to mine
some areas at Curragh. Our cost of
 
supplying coal to Stanwell has been
 
and may continue to be greater than
 
the
price paid by Stanwell.
 
On August 14, 2018, Curragh entered into the Supply
 
Deed with Stanwell. The Supply Deed grants Curragh
 
the
right
 
to
 
mine
 
the
 
coal
 
reserves
 
in
 
the
 
SRA.
 
In
 
exchange
 
for
 
these
 
rights,
 
Curragh
 
has
 
agreed
 
to
 
certain
amendments to
 
the CSA
 
and to
 
enter into
 
the NCSA,
 
which will
 
commence on
 
or around
 
the expiration
 
of the
CSA (currently
 
expected to
 
expire in
 
2027).
 
On July
 
12, 2019,
 
Curragh entered
 
into the
 
NCSA with
 
Stanwell.
 
Curragh agreed that
 
the total value
 
of the discount
 
received by Stanwell
 
on coal supplied
 
to it under
 
the NCSA
should (by the expiration
 
date of the NCSA)
 
be equal to the net
 
present value of A$210
 
million as at the date
 
of
the Supply Deed.
 
No export rebates
 
are payable during
 
the term
 
of the NCSA.
 
The amortized cost
 
of the deferred
consideration was $277.4 million (A$405.6 million) as of December
 
31, 2023.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
55
Stanwell may assert contractual consent rights
 
or termination rights that may be triggered
 
by the consummation
of the Stanwell Transaction. See “—Uncertainty about the effects of the SGI Transaction may affect our potential
and
 
existing
 
financial
 
arrangements
 
and
 
customer
 
relationships,
 
including
 
contractual
 
rights
 
triggered
 
upon
 
a
change of control in connection with the SGI Transaction, and may materially and adversely affect our business,
results of operations and financial condition”.
We could
 
be adversely
 
affected if we
 
fail to
 
appropriately provide financial
 
assurances for
 
our obligations.
Australian laws and
 
U.S. federal and
 
state laws require
 
us to provide
 
financial assurances related
 
to requirements
to reclaim lands used
 
for mining, to pay
 
federal and state workers’
 
compensation, to provide financial assurances
for coal
 
lease obligations
 
and to
 
satisfy other
 
miscellaneous obligations.
 
The primary
 
methods we
 
use to
 
meet
those obligations in
 
the United States
 
are to provide
 
a third-party surety
 
bond or provide
 
a letter of credit.
 
As of
December 31, 2023,
 
we provided $44.0
 
million of third-party
 
surety bonds in
 
connection with our
 
U.S. Operations.
There are no cash collateral requirements to support any
 
of the outstanding bonds.
Our financial
 
assurance obligations
 
may increase
 
due to
 
a number
 
of factors,
 
including the
 
size of
 
our mining
footprint and
 
new government
 
regulations,
 
and
 
we may
 
experience
 
difficulty
 
procuring
 
or renewing
 
our surety
bonds. In addition, our bond issuers may demand higher fees or additional collateral, including letters of
 
credit or
other terms less favorable to us upon those renewals. Because we are required by federal and state law to have
these
 
bonds
 
or
 
other
 
acceptable
 
security
 
in
 
place
 
before
 
mining
 
can
 
commence
 
or
 
continue,
 
any
 
failure
 
to
maintain surety bonds, letters
 
of credit or other guarantees or
 
security arrangements would adversely
 
affect our
ability to mine coal. That failure
 
could result from a variety
 
of factors, including lack of
 
availability of surety bond
or letters of credit,
 
higher expense or
 
unfavorable market terms,
 
the exercise by
 
third-party surety bond
 
issuers
of their right
 
to refuse
 
to renew
 
the surety
 
and the
 
requirement to
 
provide collateral
 
for future
 
third-party surety
bond
 
issuers
 
under
 
the
 
terms
 
of
 
financing
 
arrangements.
 
If
 
we
 
fail
 
to
 
maintain
 
adequate
 
bonding,
 
our
 
mining
permits could be
 
invalidated, which would
 
prevent mining operations from
 
continuing, and future
 
operating results
could be materially adversely affected.
In
 
Australia,
 
the
 
Financial
 
Provisioning
 
Act
 
amended
 
the
 
financial
 
assurance
 
provisions
 
of
 
the
 
EP
 
Act,
 
and
impacted the way that our Australian Operations
 
provide for and manage associated costs
 
of providing financial
assurances related to mine rehabilitation
 
obligations. There can be no
 
assurance that our risk category
 
allocation
will not change in future years.
 
For more information on the Financial Provisioning Act, see Item 1.
 
“Business—Regulatory Matters—Australia—
Environmental Protection Act 1994 (Qld).”
Mine closures entail substantial costs. If we prematurely close one or more of our mines, our operations
and financial performance would likely be affected
 
adversely.
Federal and state
 
regulatory agencies
 
have the
 
authority following
 
significant health
 
and safety
 
incidents, such
as
 
fatalities,
 
to
 
order
 
mining
 
operations
 
to
 
be
 
temporarily
 
suspended
 
or
 
a
 
facility
 
be
 
permanently
 
closed.
 
For
example, on
 
January 12,
 
2020, operations
 
at our
 
Curragh mine
 
were temporarily
 
suspended after
 
a contractor
was
 
fatally
 
injured
 
during
 
a
 
tire
 
change
 
activity
 
in
 
the
 
main
 
workshop
 
on
 
site
 
and
 
on
 
November
 
21,
 
2021,
operations at our Curragh mine were temporarily suspended after an employee was fatally injured while working
in the dragline
 
operations. We could also
 
be required to
 
close or discontinue
 
operations at particular
 
mines before
the end
 
of their
 
mine life
 
due to
 
environmental,
 
geological,
 
geotechnical,
 
commercial,
 
leasing or
 
other issues.
Such
 
closure
 
or
 
discontinuance
 
of
 
operations
 
could
 
result
 
in
 
significant
 
closure
 
and
 
rehabilitation
 
expenses,
employee redundancy
 
costs, contractor
 
demobilization costs
 
and other
 
costs or
 
loss of
 
revenues. If
 
and when
incurred, these closure and
 
rehabilitation costs could
 
exceed our current estimates.
 
If one or more
 
of our mines
is closed earlier
 
than anticipated, we
 
would be required
 
to fund the
 
reclamation and closure costs
 
on an
 
expedited
basis and potentially
 
lose revenues and,
 
for some
 
of our operations,
 
pay for take-or-pay
 
arrangements that
 
we
no longer use, which would
 
have an adverse impact on
 
our operating and financial performance.
 
Many of these
costs could also
 
be incurred
 
if a mine
 
was unexpectedly
 
placed on care
 
and maintenance
 
before the end
 
of its
planned mine life
 
such as our
 
mines in the
 
U.S. Operations, which
 
were temporarily idled
 
in 2020 as a
 
result of
the COVID-19 pandemic.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
56
If the
 
assumptions underlying
 
our provision
 
for reclamation
 
and mine
 
closure obligations
 
prove to
 
be
inaccurate, we could be required to expend greater
 
amounts than anticipated.
The
 
Environmental
 
Protection
 
Act 1994
 
(Qld)
 
and
 
the
 
SMCRA
 
establish
 
operational,
 
reclamation
 
and
 
closure
standards
 
for
 
all
 
aspects
 
of
 
surface
 
mining
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
deep
 
mining.
 
We
 
accrue
 
for
 
the
 
costs
 
of
 
current
 
mine
disturbance
 
and
 
final
 
mine
 
closure,
 
including
 
the
 
cost
 
of
 
treating
 
mine
 
water
 
discharge
 
where
 
necessary.
Estimates of
 
our total
 
reclamation and
 
mine-closing
 
liabilities totaled
 
$163.9 million
 
as of
 
December 31,
 
2023,
based upon
 
permit requirements
 
and the
 
historical
 
experience at
 
our operations,
 
and depend
 
on a
 
number
 
of
variables involving assumptions and estimation and therefore may be subject to change, including the estimated
future
 
asset
 
retirement
 
costs
 
and the
 
timing
 
of
 
such
 
costs,
 
estimated
 
proven
 
reserves,
 
assumptions
 
involving
third-party contractors, inflation rates
 
and discount rates.
 
If these accruals
 
are insufficient or our
 
liability in a
 
future
year is
 
greater than
 
currently anticipated,
 
our future
 
operating results
 
and financial
 
position could
 
be adversely
affected. See
 
Item 7. “Management’s Discussion
 
and Analysis
 
of Financial
 
Condition and
 
Results of
 
Operations—
Critical Accounting Policies and Estimates.”
We are subject to foreign exchange risks involving
 
certain operations in multiple countries.
Loss sustained from adverse movements
 
in currency exchange rates
 
can impact our financial performance
 
and
financial position and the level of additional funding required to support
 
our businesses. Our financial results are
reported
 
in
 
US$
 
and
 
certain
 
parts
 
of
 
our
 
liabilities,
 
earnings
 
and
 
cash
 
flows
 
are
 
influenced
 
by
 
movements
 
in
exchange rates, especially movements in A$
 
to US$ exchange rate. For
 
example, costs relating to our
 
Australian
Operations
 
are
 
generally
 
denominated
 
in
 
A$.
 
In
 
addition,
 
foreign
 
currency
 
exposures
 
arise
 
in
 
relation
 
to
 
coal
supply
 
contracts,
 
procurement
 
of
 
plant
 
and
 
equipment
 
and
 
debt,
 
which
 
may
 
be
 
priced
 
in
 
A$
 
or
 
other
 
foreign
currencies other than US$.
The impact of currency exchange rate movements will vary depending on factors such as the nature, magnitude
and duration
 
of the movements,
 
the extent
 
to which
 
currency risk
 
is hedged under
 
forward exchange
 
contracts
or other hedging instruments and the terms of these contracts. We may enter into forward exchange
 
contracts to
hedge a portion of our
 
foreign currency exposure of
 
our Australian Operations from
 
time to time. The unhedged
portion of our non-US$
 
exposures against exchange rate fluctuations will
 
be at the risk
 
of any adverse movement
in exchange rates, which may affect our operating results,
 
cash flows and financial condition.
Interest rates could change substantially and have an adverse
 
effect on our profitability.
We are exposed to interest rate risk
 
in relation to variable-rate bank balances
 
and variable-rate borrowings. Our
interest
 
rate
 
risk
 
primarily
 
arises
 
from
 
fluctuations
 
in
 
Secured
 
Overnight
 
Financing
 
Rate,
 
or
 
SOFR,
 
and
 
the
Australian Bank Bill Swap Yield, or BBSY, in relation to US$- and A$-denominated borrowings, respectively.
 
Our
lending rates
 
may increase
 
in the future
 
as a result
 
of factors
 
beyond our
 
control and may
 
result in an
 
adverse
effect on our financial condition and results
 
of operations.
In addition,
 
national and
 
international regulators
 
and law
 
enforcement agencies
 
have conducted
 
investigations
into a number of rates or indices, which
 
are deemed to be “reference rates.”
 
Actions by such regulators and law
enforcement agencies may result
 
in changes to the
 
manner in which certain
 
reference rates are determined,
 
their
discontinuance,
 
or
 
the
 
establishment
 
of
 
alternative
 
reference
 
rates.
 
For
 
example,
 
after
 
2021,
 
the
 
United
Kingdom’s Financial
 
Conduct Authority,
 
which regulates
 
LIBOR, no
 
longer compelled
 
banks to submit
 
rates for
the calculation of non-U.S.-dollar LIBOR. The U.S-dollar
 
LIBOR was discontinued in June 2023. The Alternative
Reference Rates Committee has proposed SOFR as its
 
recommended alternative to LIBOR.
 
We may
 
be unsuccessful
 
in integrating
 
the operations
 
of acquisitions
 
with our
 
existing operations
 
and
in realizing all or any part of the anticipated benefits of
 
any such acquisitions.
From time to time, we
 
may evaluate and acquire assets and businesses that
 
we believe complement our existing
assets and business. Acquisitions may
 
require substantial capital or the
 
incurrence of substantial indebtedness.
Our capitalization
 
and results
 
of operations
 
may change
 
significantly as
 
a result
 
of future
 
acquisitions. Acquisitions
and business expansions involve numerous risks, including the
 
following:
•
 
difficulties in the integration of the assets and operations
 
of the acquired businesses;
•
 
inefficiencies
 
and
 
difficulties
 
that
 
arise
 
because
 
of
 
unfamiliarity
 
with
 
new
 
assets
 
and
 
the
 
businesses
associated with them and new geographic areas;
•
 
the diversion of management’s attention from other
 
operations; and
•
 
timing, and whether the acquisition
 
or business expansion is occurring
 
during adverse economic, social
and regulatory periods.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
57
Further,
 
unexpected
 
costs
 
and
 
challenges
 
may
 
arise
 
whenever
 
businesses
 
with
 
different
 
operations
 
or
management
 
are
 
combined,
 
and
 
we
 
may
 
experience
 
unanticipated
 
delays
 
in
 
realizing
 
the
 
benefits
 
of
 
an
acquisition. Entry into certain lines of
 
business may subject us to new
 
laws and regulations with which we
 
are not
familiar and may lead
 
to increased litigation and
 
regulatory risk. Also, following
 
an acquisition, we may
 
discover
previously unknown
 
liabilities associated
 
with the
 
acquired business
 
or assets
 
for which
 
we have
 
no recourse
under applicable indemnification provisions. If a new business generates insufficient revenue or if we are unable
to efficiently manage our expanded operations, our results
 
of operations may be adversely affected.
Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources Inc.
 
is
 
a
 
holding
 
company
 
with
 
no
 
operations
 
of
 
its
 
own
 
and,
 
as
 
such,
 
it
depends
 
on
 
its
 
subsidiaries
 
for
 
cash
 
to
 
fund
 
its
 
operations
 
and
 
expenses,
 
including
 
future
 
dividend
payments, if any.
As a
 
holding company,
 
our
 
principal
 
source
 
of cash
 
flow
 
is
 
distributions
 
from
 
our
 
subsidiaries.
 
Therefore,
 
our
ability to fund and conduct our business, service our debt,
 
and pay dividends, if any,
 
in the future will depend on
the
 
ability
 
of
 
our
 
subsidiaries
 
to
 
generate
 
sufficient
 
cash
 
flow
 
to
 
make
 
upstream
 
cash
 
distributions
 
to
 
us.
 
Our
subsidiaries are separate legal
 
entities, and although they
 
are wholly-owned and controlled
 
by us, they have
 
no
obligation to make any funds available to us, whether
 
in the form of loans, dividends, or otherwise. The
 
ability of
our
 
subsidiaries
 
to
 
distribute
 
cash
 
to
 
us
 
will
 
also
 
be
 
subject
 
to,
 
among
 
other
 
things,
 
restrictions
 
that
 
may
 
be
contained in our subsidiary agreements (as entered into from time to time), availability
 
of sufficient funds in such
subsidiaries and applicable laws and regulatory restrictions. Claims of any creditors of our subsidiaries generally
will have
 
priority as
 
to the
 
assets of
 
such subsidiaries
 
over our
 
claims and
 
claims of
 
our creditors
 
and stockholders.
To
 
the extent the ability
 
of our subsidiaries
 
to distribute dividends or
 
other payments to us
 
is limited in any
 
way,
our ability to fund and conduct our business, service our
 
debt, and pay dividends, if any,
 
could be harmed.
Legal, Compliance and Sustainability Risks
We could be negatively affected if
 
we fail to maintain satisfactory labor relations.
Relations with
 
our employees
 
and, where
 
applicable, organized
 
labor are
 
important to
 
our success.
 
Enterprise
bargaining and other disputes between us and our employees or disputes affecting our contractors may result in
strikes or uncompetitive work practices.
As of
 
December 31,
 
2023, we
 
had 1,878
 
employees.
 
In addition,
 
as of
 
December 31,
 
2023, there
 
were 2,335
contractors
 
supplementing
 
the
 
permanent
 
workforce,
 
primarily
 
at
 
Curragh.
 
As
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
approximately
 
10.8%
 
of our
 
total employees,
 
all at
 
our
 
Australian Operations,
 
were represented
 
by organized
labor unions and covered by the
 
EA. In July 2023, the Australian Fair
 
Work Commission approved the
 
four year
Curragh Mine
 
Enterprise Agreement
 
2023. This
 
EA has
 
a four-year
 
expiration date
 
and will
 
remain in
 
place by
operation of
 
the Fair
 
Work Act
 
2009 (Cth)
 
until replaced
 
or terminated
 
by the Fair
 
Work Commission.
 
Our U.S.
Operations employ a 100% non-union labor force.
Future industrial
 
action by
 
our employees
 
or mining
 
contractors’ employees or
 
involving trade unions
 
could disrupt
operations and negatively impact mine productivity,
 
production and profitability.
Our operations
 
may impact
 
the environment
 
or cause
 
exposure to
 
hazardous substances,
 
which could
result in material liabilities to us.
We are
 
subject to
 
extensive environmental
 
laws and
 
regulations,
 
and our
 
operations may
 
substantially
 
impact
the
 
environment
 
or
 
cause
 
exposure
 
to
 
hazardous
 
materials
 
to
 
our
 
contractors,
 
our
 
employees
 
or
 
local
communities. We use hazardous materials
 
and generate hazardous or other regulated
 
waste, which we store in
our storage or disposal
 
facilities. We may become subject to
 
statutory or common law claims
 
(including damages
claims) as
 
a result
 
of
 
our
 
use of
 
hazardous
 
materials
 
and generation
 
of hazardous
 
waste.
 
A number
 
of laws,
including, in
 
the United
 
States, the
 
CERCLA or
 
Superfund, and
 
the RCRA,
 
and in
 
Australia, the
 
Environmental
Protection Act 1994 (Qld),
 
impose liability relating to
 
contamination by hazardous
 
substances. Furthermore, the
use of
 
hazardous materials
 
and generation
 
of hazardous
 
and other
 
waste may
 
subject us
 
to investigation
 
and
require the clean-up of soil, surface water,
 
groundwater and other media.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
58
Mining
 
operation
 
process,
 
including
 
blasting
 
and
 
processing
 
ore
 
bodies,
 
can
 
also
 
generate
 
environmental
impacts. These
 
impacts include,
 
but are
 
not limited
 
to, leakages
 
of polluting
 
substances,
 
explosions,
 
flooding,
fires, accidental mine water discharges,
 
and excessive dust and noise. Such
 
risks could result in damage to
 
the
applicable mine site, personal
 
injury to our employees
 
and contractors, environmental
 
damage, decreased coal
production and
 
possible legal
 
liability under
 
environmental regulations.
 
Employee or
 
strict liability
 
claims under
common law
 
or environmental
 
regulations in
 
relation to
 
these matters
 
may arise,
 
for example, out
 
of current
 
or
former activities
 
at sites
 
that we
 
own, lease
 
or operate
 
and at
 
properties to
 
which hazardous
 
substances have
been sent for treatment,
 
storage, disposal or other
 
handling. Our liability
 
for such claims may
 
be strict, joint and
several with other miners or parties or with our
 
contractors, such that we may be held
 
responsible for more than
our
 
share
 
of
 
the
 
contamination
 
or
 
other
 
damages,
 
or
 
even
 
for
 
the
 
entire
 
amount
 
of
 
damages
 
assessed.
Additionally,
 
any violations of
 
environmental laws by
 
us could lead
 
to, among other
 
things, the imposition
 
on us
of substantial fines,
 
penalties, other civil and
 
criminal sanctions, the curtailment
 
or cessation of
 
operations, orders
to
 
pay
 
compensation,
 
orders
 
to
 
remedy
 
the
 
effects
 
of
 
violations
 
and
 
take
 
preventative
 
steps
 
against
 
possible
future violations,
 
increased compliance costs,
 
or costs
 
for environmental remediation,
 
rehabilitation or rectification
works.
We maintain extensive Met
 
coal refuse areas
 
and slurry impoundments at
 
our mining properties. At
 
Curragh, coal
slurry
 
is
 
disposed
 
of
 
by
 
pumping
 
into
 
an
 
impoundment
 
area
 
where
 
particles
 
are
 
allowed
 
to
 
settle.
 
We
 
have
procedures
 
in
 
place
 
that
 
the
 
Curragh
 
slurry
 
impoundments
 
remain
 
below
 
the
 
surrounding
 
topography
 
so
 
that
there is
 
minimal likelihood
 
of failure
 
and/or spills.
 
At our
 
U.S. Operations,
 
refuse areas
 
and impoundments
 
are
frequently inspected and subject
 
to extensive governmental regulation.
 
Slurry impoundments have
 
been known
to
 
fail,
 
releasing
 
large
 
volumes
 
of
 
coal
 
slurry
 
into
 
the
 
surrounding
 
environment.
 
Structural
 
failure
 
of
 
an
impoundment can result in extensive damage to the environment
 
and natural resources, such as bodies of water
that the coal slurry reaches, as well as create liability for
 
related personal injuries, property damages and injuries
to natural resources
 
and plant and
 
wildlife. Of the
 
five refuse areas
 
among our U.S.
 
mining properties, only
 
two
impound slurry; the other facilities are combined refuse
 
and do not impound slurry.
 
Two of our impoundments
 
in
the U.S. overlie
 
mined out
 
areas, which
 
can pose
 
a heightened
 
risk of
 
failure and
 
the assessment
 
of damages
arising out of such failure.
 
If one of our impoundments
 
were to fail, we could
 
be subject to substantial
 
claims for
the resulting environmental contamination and associated
 
liability, as well as
 
for related fines and penalties.
Changes in
 
and compliance
 
with government
 
policy, regulation
 
or legislation
 
may adversely
 
affect our
financial condition and results of operations.
The coal mining industry
 
is subject to regulation
 
by federal, state and
 
local authorities in each
 
relevant jurisdiction
with respect
 
to
 
a range
 
of industry
 
specific and
 
general
 
matters.
 
Any future
 
legislation
 
and
 
regulatory
 
change
imposing more constraints or
 
more stringent requirements may
 
affect the coal mining
 
industry and may adversely
affect our financial condition and results of operations. Examples of such changes are, future laws or regulations
that may limit
 
the emission
 
of GHGs, attach
 
a cost to
 
GHG emissions,
 
or limit the
 
use of thermal
 
coal in power
generation, more stringent workplace health and safety laws, more rigorous environmental laws, and changes to
existing taxation and royalty legislation.
Compliance
 
with
 
applicable
 
federal,
 
state
 
and
 
local
 
laws
 
and
 
regulations
 
may
 
become
 
more
 
costly
 
and
time-consuming
 
and
 
may
 
delay
 
commencement
 
or
 
interrupt
 
continuation
 
of
 
exploration
 
or
 
production
 
at
 
our
operations. We have
 
incurred, and may
 
in the future
 
incur, significant expenditures to comply
 
with such regulation
and legislation. These laws are constantly evolving and may become increasingly
 
stringent. The ultimate impact
of complying with existing laws
 
and regulations is not always
 
clearly known or determinable due
 
in part to the
 
fact
that
 
certain
 
implementation
 
of
 
the
 
regulations
 
for
 
these
 
laws
 
have
 
not
 
yet
 
been
 
promulgated
 
and
 
in
 
certain
instances
 
are
 
undergoing
 
revision.
 
These
 
laws
 
and
 
regulations,
 
particularly
 
new
 
legislative
 
or
 
administrative
proposals
 
(or
 
judicial
 
interpretations
 
of
 
existing
 
laws
 
and
 
regulations),
 
could
 
result
 
in
 
substantially
 
increased
capital,
 
operating
 
and
 
compliance
 
costs
 
and
 
could
 
have
 
a
 
material
 
adverse
 
effect
 
on
 
our
 
operations
 
and
 
our
customers’ ability to use our products. Due in part to the extensive and comprehensive
 
regulatory requirements,
along with
 
changing interpretations
 
of these
 
requirements, violations
 
of applicable
 
federal, state
 
and local
 
laws
and regulations occur from time to time in the
 
coal industry and minor violations have
 
occurred at our Australian
Operations and our U.S. Operations in the past.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
59
Moreover, changes in the law
 
may impose additional standards and a heightened degree
 
of responsibility for us
and our stockholders, directors and employees; may
 
require unprecedented compliance efforts; could
 
divert our
management’s
 
attention;
 
and
 
may
 
require
 
significant
 
expenditures.
 
For
 
example,
 
we
 
may
 
also
 
be
 
subject
 
to
unforeseen
 
environmental
 
liabilities
 
resulting
 
from
 
coal-related
 
activities,
 
which
 
may
 
be
 
costly
 
to
 
remedy
 
or
adversely impact
 
our operations.
 
In particular,
 
the acceptable
 
level of
 
pollution and
 
the potential
 
abandonment
costs and obligations for which we
 
may become liable as a result
 
of our activities may be
 
difficult to assess under
the current legal
 
framework. To the extent that
 
required expenditures, as
 
with all
 
costs, are not
 
ultimately reflected
in the
 
prices of
 
coal, our
 
operating results
 
will be
 
detrimentally
 
impacted. The
 
costs
 
and operating
 
restrictions
necessary for compliance
 
with safety
 
and environmental laws
 
and regulations,
 
which is a
 
major cost
 
consideration
for
 
our
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
and
 
U.S.
 
Operations,
 
may
 
have
 
an
 
adverse
 
effect
 
on
 
our
 
competitive
 
position
relative to foreign producers and operators in
 
other countries which may not be
 
required to incur equivalent costs
in their operations.
We are
 
also affected
 
by various
 
other international,
 
federal, state,
 
local and
 
tribal or
 
indigenous environmental
laws
 
and
 
regulations
 
that
 
impact
 
our
 
customers.
 
To
 
the
 
extent
 
that
 
such
 
environmental
 
laws
 
and
 
regulations
reduce
 
customer
 
demand
 
for
 
or
 
increase
 
the
 
price
 
of
 
coal,
 
we
 
will
 
be
 
detrimentally
 
impacted.
 
For
 
additional
information
 
about
 
the
 
various
 
regulations
 
affecting
 
us,
 
see
 
Item 1.
 
“Business—Regulatory
 
Matters—Australia”
and “Business—Regulatory Matters—United States.”
We
 
are
 
subject
 
to
 
extensive
 
forms
 
of
 
taxation,
 
which
 
imposes
 
significant
 
costs
 
on
 
us,
 
and
 
future
regulations
 
and
 
developments
 
could
 
increase
 
those
 
costs
 
or
 
limit
 
our
 
ability
 
to
 
produce
 
coal
competitively.
Federal,
 
state
 
or
 
local
 
governmental
 
authorities
 
in
 
nearly
 
all
 
countries
 
across
 
the
 
global
 
coal
 
mining
 
industry
impose various
 
forms of
 
taxation
 
on coal
 
producers,
 
including production
 
taxes,
 
sales-related
 
taxes,
 
royalties,
stamp duty, environmental
 
taxes and income taxes.
 
For example, on September 27, 2022, the Company received from the Queensland Revenue Office, or QRO, an
assessment of the stamp duty payable
 
on its acquisition of the Curragh mine
 
in March 2018. The QRO assessed
the stamp
 
duty on
 
this
 
acquisition
 
at
 
an
 
amount
 
of $56.2
 
million
 
(A$82.2
 
million)
 
plus
 
unpaid
 
tax
 
interest.
 
On
November 23, 2022, the Company filed an objection to the assessment.
 
On January 9, 2024, the Company’s objection
 
to the assessed stamp duty was disallowed by the
 
QRO.
The Company, based on legal
 
and valuation advice
 
obtained, continues to
 
maintain its position
 
and the estimated
stamp duty payable of $29.4 million (A$43.0 million) on
 
the Curragh acquisition.
 
As per the Taxation
 
Administration Act (Queensland)
 
2001, the Company
 
can only appeal
 
or apply for a
 
review
of QRO’s
 
decision if
 
it has
 
paid the
 
total assessed
 
stamp duty
 
of $56.2
 
million (A$82.2
 
million) plus
 
unpaid tax
interest of $14.5 million (A$21.2 million). Such appeal
 
must be lodged by March 11,
 
2024.
 
The Company
 
disputes the
 
additional amount
 
assessed of
 
stamp duty
 
and unpaid
 
tax interest
 
and is
 
currently
considering its options to either appeal the decision to the Supreme Court of
 
Queensland or apply for a review of
QRO’s decision by the Queensland Civil and
 
Administrative Tribunal.
 
Given that
 
the Company
 
is unable
 
to avoid
 
the payment,
 
and the
 
recovery of
 
such amount
 
through litigation
 
is
uncertain,
 
the
 
additional
 
accrual
 
of
 
$41.3
 
million
 
has
 
been
 
recognized
 
within
 
“Accrued
 
Expenses
 
and
 
Other
Current Liabilities”
 
in the
 
Consolidated Balance
 
Sheet as
 
at December
 
31, 2023,
 
and a
 
corresponding amount
recognized
 
under
 
“Selling,
 
general
 
and
 
administrative”
 
expense
 
in
 
the
 
Company’s
 
Consolidated
 
Statement
 
of
Operations and
 
Comprehensive Income.
 
The total
 
accrual of
 
$53.7 million
 
(A$79.0 million)
 
as at
 
31 December
2023
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
Company’s
 
estimate
 
of
 
the
 
outstanding
 
stamp
 
duty
 
payable,
 
the
 
additional
 
accrual
recognized, less partial payments to date of $17.6 million
 
(A$25.7 million).
 
We cannot guarantee that the steps we take to
 
defend our position on this matter will be successful.
In 2022, the Queensland State Government in Australia amended the
 
Mineral Resources Regulation 2013 (Qld)
introducing
 
additional
 
higher
 
tiers
 
to
 
the
 
coal
 
royalty
 
rates
 
effective
 
from
 
July
 
1,
 
2022,
 
increasing
 
the
 
royalty
payable by our Australian Operations.
 
The tiers currently applicable are as set out below:
•
 
7% for average coal price per Mt sold up to and including
 
A$ 100 per Mt;
•
 
12.5% for average coal price per Mt sold from A$100 to
 
A$150 per Mt;
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
60
•
 
15% for average coal price per Mt sold from A$150 to
 
A$175 per Mt;
•
 
20% for average coal price per Mt sold from A$175 to
 
A$225 per Mt;
•
 
30% for average coal price per Mt sold from A$225 to
 
A$300 per Mt; and
•
 
40% for average coal price per Mt sold above A$300 per
 
Mt.
If new legislation or
 
regulations related to various forms
 
of coal taxation or
 
income or other taxes
 
generally, which
increase our costs or limit our ability to compete
 
in the areas in which we sell coal, or which
 
adversely affect our
key customers, are adopted, or if
 
the basis upon which such
 
duties or taxes are assessed
 
or levied, changes or
is different from that provided by us, our business, financial condition or results of
 
operations could be adversely
affected.
We may be subject
 
to litigation, the disposition
 
of which could negatively
 
affect our profitability and cash
flow
 
in
 
a
 
particular
 
period,
 
or
 
have
 
a
 
material
 
adverse
 
effect
 
on
 
our
 
business,
 
financial
 
condition
 
and
results of operations.
Our profitability or cash flow in
 
a particular period could be affected by
 
an adverse ruling in any litigation that
 
may
be filed against us in the future. In addition, such litigation could have
 
a material adverse effect on our business,
financial condition and results of operations. See Item
 
3. “Legal Proceedings.”
We have no
 
registered trademarks for
 
our Company
 
name used by
 
us in the
 
United States or
 
any other
countries, and failure to obtain those registrations
 
could adversely affect our business.
Although
 
we
 
have
 
filed
 
a
 
trademark
 
application
 
for
 
use
 
of
 
the
 
stylized
 
mark
 
“CORONADO
 
STEEL
 
STARTS
HERE” in the United States and Australia, our applications are still pending
 
and the corresponding mark has not
been registered
 
in
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
or
 
Australia.
 
We
 
have
 
not
 
filed
 
for
 
this
 
or
 
other
 
trademarks
 
in
 
any
 
other
country. During trademark registration proceedings, we may receive rejections. If so, we will have an opportunity
to respond,
 
but we
 
may be
 
unable to
 
overcome such
 
rejections. In
 
addition, Intellectual
 
Property Australia
 
and
the United
 
States Patent
 
and Trademark Office
 
and comparable agencies
 
in many
 
foreign jurisdictions
 
may permit
third parties to oppose pending trademark
 
applications and to seek to
 
cancel registered trademarks. If opposition
or
 
cancellation
 
proceedings
 
are
 
filed
 
against
 
our
 
trademark
 
application,
 
our
 
trademark
 
may
 
not
 
survive
 
such
proceedings,
 
and/or
 
we
 
may
 
be
 
required
 
to
 
expend
 
significant
 
additional
 
resources
 
in
 
an
 
effort
 
to
 
defend
ourselves in the proceedings or identify a suitable substitute
 
mark for future use.
Failure to comply with applicable anti-corruption and trade laws, regulations and policies could result in
fines and criminal
 
penalties, causing
 
a material adverse
 
effect on our
 
business, operating and
 
financial
prospects or performance.
Any
 
fraud,
 
bribery,
 
misrepresentation,
 
money
 
laundering,
 
violations
 
of
 
applicable
 
trade
 
sanctions,
anti-competitive
 
behavior
 
or
 
other
 
misconduct
 
by
 
our
 
employees,
 
contractors,
 
customers,
 
service
 
providers,
business
 
partners
 
and
 
other
 
third parties
 
could
 
result
 
in violations
 
of relevant
 
laws
 
and regulations
 
by us
 
and
subject us or relevant
 
individuals to corresponding regulatory
 
sanctions or other claims,
 
and could also result
 
in
an event of default under our financing arrangements. These unlawful activities
 
and other misconduct may have
occurred in
 
the past
 
and may
 
occur in
 
the future
 
and may
 
result in
 
civil and
 
criminal liability
 
under increasingly
stringent laws relating
 
to fraud, bribery,
 
sanctions, competition and
 
misconduct or cause
 
serious reputational
 
or
financial
 
harm
 
to
 
us.
 
In
 
addition,
 
failure
 
to
 
comply
 
with
 
environmental,
 
health
 
or
 
safety
 
laws
 
and
 
regulations,
privacy laws and regulations,
 
U.S. trade sanctions,
 
the U.S. Foreign Corrupt
 
Practices Act and other
 
applicable
laws or regulations could result in litigation, the assessment of damages, the imposition of penalties, suspension
of production
 
or distribution,
 
costly changes
 
to equipment
 
or processes
 
due to
 
required corrective
 
action, or
 
a
cessation or interruption of operations.
We
 
have
 
policies
 
and
 
procedures
 
to
 
identify,
 
manage
 
and
 
mitigate
 
legal
 
risks
 
and
 
address
 
regulatory
requirements
 
and
 
other
 
compliance
 
obligations.
 
However,
 
there
 
can
 
be
 
no
 
assurance
 
that
 
such
 
policies,
procedures and established internal controls
 
will adequately protect us against
 
fraudulent or corrupt activity and
such activity could have an adverse effect on our reputation,
 
financial condition and results of operations.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
61
Risks Specific to Our Common Stock
Our certificate of incorporation and bylaws include
 
provisions that may discourage a change in control.
Provisions contained in our amended and restated certificate of incorporation, or certificate of incorporation, and
amended and
 
restated bylaws, or
 
bylaws, and
 
Delaware law
 
could make
 
it more
 
difficult for a
 
third-party to acquire
us,
 
even
 
if
 
doing
 
so
 
might
 
be
 
beneficial
 
to
 
our
 
stockholders.
 
Provisions
 
of
 
our
 
bylaws
 
and
 
certificate
 
of
incorporation impose various procedural and other
 
requirements that could make it
 
more difficult for stockholders
to effect certain corporate actions.
 
We have elected not to be governed by Section 203 of the General Corporation Law of
 
the State of Delaware,
 
or
the DGCL (or any successor provision thereto),
 
until immediately following the time at
 
which the EMG Group no
longer beneficially
 
owns in
 
the aggregate
 
shares of
 
our common
 
stock representing
 
at least
 
10% of
 
our voting
stock, in which case we
 
shall thereafter be governed by Section
 
203 if and for
 
so long as Section 203
 
by its terms
would apply to
 
us. Upon the
 
closing of the
 
SGI Transaction,
 
EMG Group will
 
no longer own
 
at least 10%
 
of our
voting stock and we will be
 
governed by Section 203 at that
 
time. See “—Following the consummation of the SGI
Transaction, we expect that Coronado Group LLC and SGI
 
will have significant influence over corporate matters,
including control over
 
certain decisions that
 
require the approval
 
of stockholders”.
 
Section 203 provides
 
that an
interested stockholder, along with its affiliates and
 
associates (i.e., a stockholder
 
that has purchased greater
 
than
15%, but less than 85%, of
 
a company’s outstanding voting
 
stock (with some exclusions)), may
 
not engage in a
business combination transaction with
 
the company for a period
 
of three years after buying
 
more than 15% of a
company’s outstanding
 
voting stock
 
unless certain
 
criteria are
 
met or
 
certain other
 
corporate actions
 
are taken
by the company.
These provisions could limit the price
 
that certain investors might be willing
 
to pay in the future for
 
shares of our
common stock and may have the effect of delaying
 
or preventing a change in control.
Our
 
certificate
 
of
 
incorporation
 
limits
 
the
 
personal
 
liability
 
of
 
our
 
directors
 
for
 
certain
 
breaches
 
of
fiduciary duty.
Our
 
certificate
 
of
 
incorporation
 
and
 
bylaws
 
include
 
provisions
 
limiting
 
the
 
personal
 
liability
 
of
 
our
 
directors
 
for
breaches
 
of
 
fiduciary
 
duty
 
under
 
the
 
DGCL.
 
Specifically,
 
our
 
certificate
 
of
 
incorporation
 
contains
 
provisions
limiting
 
a
 
director’s
 
personal
 
liability
 
to
 
us
 
and
 
our
 
stockholders
 
to
 
the
 
fullest
 
extent
 
permitted
 
by
 
the
 
DGCL.
Furthermore, our
 
certificate of
 
incorporation provides
 
that no director
 
shall be
 
liable to
 
us and
 
our stockholders
for
 
monetary
 
damages
 
resulting
 
from
 
a
 
breach
 
of
 
fiduciary
 
duty
 
as
 
a
 
director,
 
except
 
to
 
the
 
extent
 
that
 
such
exemption from liability or limitation thereof is
 
not permitted under the DGCL. The principal
 
effect of this limitation
on liability
 
is that
 
a stockholder
 
will be
 
unable to
 
prosecute an
 
action for
 
monetary damages
 
against a
 
director
unless the
 
stockholder can
 
demonstrate a
 
basis for
 
liability that
 
cannot be
 
eliminated under
 
the DGCL.
 
These
provisions, however, should not limit or eliminate our right or any stockholder’s right to seek non-monetary relief,
such as an injunction or rescission,
 
in the event of a
 
breach of a director’s fiduciary duty. These provisions do not
alter a director’s liability under
 
U.S. federal securities laws.
 
The inclusion of these
 
provisions in our certificate
 
of
incorporation may discourage or deter stockholders or management from bringing
 
a lawsuit against directors for
a breach of
 
their fiduciary
 
duties, even
 
though such an
 
action, if successful,
 
might otherwise have
 
benefited us
and our stockholders.
Coronado
 
Group
 
LLC
 
and
 
the
 
EMG
 
Group
 
have
 
substantial
 
control
 
over
 
us
 
and
 
are
 
able
 
to
 
influence
corporate matters.
Coronado Group
 
LLC and
 
the EMG
 
Group have
 
significant
 
influence over
 
us, including
 
control over
 
decisions
that
 
require
 
the
 
approval
 
of
 
stockholders,
 
which
 
could
 
limit
 
the
 
ability
 
of
 
other
 
stockholders
 
to
 
influence
 
the
outcome of stockholders votes.
As of
 
December 31,
 
2023, the
 
EMG Group
 
indirectly held
 
50.4% of
 
our outstanding
 
shares of
 
common stock.
Therefore, the EMG
 
Group has
 
effective control
 
over the outcome
 
of votes on
 
all matters requiring
 
approval by
stockholders. There is a risk that the interests of the EMG Group could conflict with or differ from our interests or
the interests of
 
other stockholders.
 
In addition, pursuant
 
to the terms
 
of the Stockholder’s
 
Agreement, dated
 
as
of September
 
24, 2018,
 
between us
 
and Coronado
 
Group LLC,
 
or the
 
Stockholder’s Agreement,
 
so long
 
as it
beneficially owns in the aggregate at least 25% of the outstanding shares of our common stock, the EMG Group
will have
 
the ability
 
to exercise
 
substantial control
 
over certain
 
of our
 
transactions,
 
including change
 
of control
transactions,
 
such
 
as
 
mergers
 
and
 
capital
 
and
 
debt
 
raising
 
transactions.
 
See Item
 
5.
 
“Market
 
for
 
Registrant’s
Common Equity, Related Stockholder Matters and Issuer Purchases of Equity Securities” for a description of the
Stockholder’s Agreement.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
62
Further, pursuant to
 
the terms of the Series A
 
Share, Coronado Group and the
 
EMG Group or its successors
 
or
permitted
 
assigns,
 
as
 
the
 
beneficial
 
owner
 
of
 
the
 
Series A
 
Share,
 
at
 
its
 
option,
 
will
 
have
 
the
 
ability
 
to
 
elect
 
a
specified number of directors, or the Series A Directors, based on
 
the EMG Group’s aggregate level of beneficial
ownership of shares
 
of our common
 
stock. For more
 
details on the
 
ability of Coronado
 
Group and the
 
EMG Group
to elect Series A Directors, as
 
well as the rights of
 
stockholders to participate in the removal of
 
any such Series
A
Directors,
 
see
 
Item 5.
 
“Market
 
for
 
Registrant’s
 
Common
 
Equity,
 
Related
 
Stockholder
 
Matters
 
and
 
Issuer
Purchases of Equity Securities.”
Moreover, the
 
EMG Group’s beneficial
 
ownership of shares of
 
our common stock may
 
also adversely affect
 
the
price of our
 
common stock
 
to the extent
 
equity investors
 
perceive disadvantages
 
in owning common
 
stock of a
company with a controlling stockholder.
 
In addition, the EMG Group
 
is in the business of making
 
investments in
companies and may, from time to time, acquire interests in businesses that
 
directly or indirectly compete with us,
as well as businesses of our existing or potential significant
 
customers. The EMG Group may acquire or seek
 
to
acquire assets that
 
we seek to
 
acquire and, as
 
a result, those
 
acquisition opportunities
 
may not be
 
available to
us or
 
may be
 
more expensive
 
for us
 
to pursue,
 
and as
 
a result,
 
the interests
 
of the
 
EMG Group
 
may not
 
align
with the interests of our other stockholders.
The EMG Group has the
 
right, subject to certain conditions, to
 
require us to cooperate in
 
a sale of shares
of our common stock held by it (including in the form
 
of CDIs) under the Securities Act.
Pursuant to the Registration
 
Rights and Sell-Down Agreement,
 
dated as of September 24,
 
2018, between us and
Coronado
 
Group LLC,
 
or
 
the
 
Registration
 
Rights
 
and
 
Sell-Down
 
Agreement,
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC
 
(or
 
its
successors
 
or
 
permitted
 
assigns
 
or
 
transferees)
 
has
 
the
 
right,
 
subject
 
to
 
certain
 
conditions,
 
to
 
require
 
us
 
to
cooperate in a
 
sell-down of
 
shares of
 
our common
 
stock or
 
CDIs held by
 
it. By virtue
 
of its majority
 
ownership,
exercising its registration rights and selling a large number of shares or CDIs, Coronado Group LLC could cause
undue volatility in the
 
prevailing market price of
 
our common stock. See
 
Item 5. “Market for Registrant’s Common
Equity, Related Stockholder
 
Matters and Issuer Purchases of Equity Securities.”
Our non-employee directors and their respective
 
affiliates, including the EMG Group, may
 
be able to take
advantage of a corporate opportunity that would otherwise
 
be available to us.
The corporate opportunity
 
and related
 
party transactions provisions
 
in our
 
certificate of incorporation
 
could enable
any
 
of
 
our
 
non-employee
 
directors
 
or
 
their
 
respective
 
affiliates,
 
including
 
the
 
EMG
 
Group,
 
to
 
benefit
 
from
corporate opportunities
 
that might
 
otherwise be
 
available to
 
us. Subject
 
to the
 
limitations of
 
applicable law,
 
our
certificate of incorporation, among other things, will:
•
 
permit
 
us
 
to
 
enter
 
into
 
transactions
 
with
 
entities
 
in
 
which
 
one
 
or
 
more
 
non-employee
 
directors
 
are
financially or otherwise interested;
•
 
permit any non-employee director or
 
his or her affiliates to
 
conduct a business that competes
 
with us and
to make investments in any kind of property in which we
 
may make investments; and
•
 
provide that if
 
any non-employee director
 
becomes aware of
 
a potential business
 
opportunity, transaction
or
 
other
 
matter
 
(other
 
than
 
one
 
expressly
 
offered
 
to
 
that
 
non-employee
 
director
 
solely
 
in
 
his
 
or
 
her
capacity
 
as
 
our
 
director),
 
that
 
non-employee
 
director
 
will
 
have
 
no
 
duty
 
to
 
communicate
 
or
 
offer
 
that
opportunity to
 
us, and
 
will be
 
permitted to
 
communicate
 
or offer
 
that opportunity
 
to his
 
or her
 
affiliates
and pursue or acquire such opportunity for himself
 
or herself, and that non-executive director
 
will not be
deemed
 
to
 
have
 
acted
 
in
 
a
 
manner
 
inconsistent
 
with
 
his
 
or
 
her
 
fiduciary
 
or
 
other
 
duties
 
to
 
us
 
or
 
our
stockholders regarding the opportunity or acted in bad faith or in a manner inconsistent with
 
our and our
stockholders’ best interests.
These provisions enable a
 
corporate opportunity that would
 
otherwise be available to
 
us to be taken by
 
or used
for the
 
benefit of
 
the
 
non-employee
 
directors
 
or their
 
respective
 
affiliates,
 
which
 
include the
 
EMG Group
 
as a
result of the rights granted to it under the Stockholder’s Agreement.
General Risk Factors
Any
 
failure
 
to
 
maintain
 
effective
 
internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
 
reporting
 
may
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our
financial condition and results of operations.
Our
 
management
 
is
 
responsible
 
for
 
establishing
 
and
 
maintaining
 
adequate
 
internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
reporting.
 
Internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
 
reporting
 
is
 
a
 
process
 
designed
 
to
 
provide
 
reasonable
 
assurance
regarding
 
the
 
reliability
 
of
 
financial
 
reporting
 
and
 
the
 
preparation
 
of
 
financial
 
statements
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
generally accepted accounting principles in the United
 
States, or U.S. GAAP.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
63
During the course of the preparation of our financial statements,
 
we evaluate and correct any deficiencies in
 
our
internal controls over
 
financial reporting. If
 
we fail to
 
maintain an effective system
 
of disclosure or
 
internal controls
over financial
 
reporting, including
 
satisfaction of
 
the requirements
 
of Section
 
404 of
 
the Sarbanes-Oxley
 
Act of
2002, we may not be able to report
 
accurately or timely on our financial results or adequately identify and reduce
fraud. Therefore, the financial condition of our business could be adversely
 
affected, current and potential future
stockholders could lose confidence in us and/or
 
our reported financial results, which may cause
 
a negative effect
on the trading price of our
 
CDIs, and we could be exposed
 
to litigation or regulatory
 
proceedings, which may be
costly or divert management attention.
 
The requirements of
 
being a public company
 
in the United
 
States and Australia may
 
strain our resources,
divert
 
management’s
 
attention,
 
and
 
affect
 
our
 
ability
 
to
 
attract
 
and
 
retain
 
executive
 
management
 
and
qualified board members.
Our CDIs are
 
currently listed on
 
the ASX and
 
we are registered
 
as a foreign
 
company in
 
Australia. As such
 
we
need to ensure continuous compliance with relevant Australian laws
 
and regulations, including the listing rules of
the ASX, as amended from time to time, or the ASX Listing
 
Rules,
 
and certain provisions of the Corporations Act
2001 (Cth), or the Corporations Act.
 
As a U.S.
 
public company, we are subject
 
to the reporting
 
requirements of the
 
Exchange Act, the
 
Sarbanes-Oxley
Act
 
of
 
2002,
 
the
 
Dodd-Frank
 
Wall
 
Street
 
Reform
 
and
 
Consumer
 
Protection
 
Act
 
of
 
2010
 
and
 
other
 
applicable
securities laws, rules and regulations. Compliance with these
 
laws, rules, and regulations may increase our legal
and
 
financial
 
compliance
 
costs,
 
make
 
some
 
activities
 
more
 
difficult,
 
time-consuming,
 
or
 
costly,
 
and
 
increase
demand on
 
our systems
 
and resources.
 
The Exchange
 
Act requires,
 
among other
 
things,
 
that
 
we file
 
annual,
quarterly, and
 
current reports with respect
 
to our business and
 
results of operations. In
 
the absence of a waiver
from the ASX
 
Listing Rules, these
 
SEC periodic reports
 
will be in addition
 
to our periodic
 
filings required by
 
the
ASX Listing
 
Rules.
 
The
 
Sarbanes-Oxley
 
Act of
 
2002 requires,
 
among
 
other things,
 
that we
 
maintain
 
effective
disclosure
 
controls
 
and
 
procedures
 
and
 
internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
 
reporting.
 
In
 
order
 
to
 
maintain
 
and,
 
if
required, improve our disclosure
 
controls and procedures and
 
internal control over financial
 
reporting to meet this
standard, significant resources and management oversight will be required. As a result, management’s attention
may be diverted from other
 
business concerns and our
 
costs and expenses will
 
increase, which could harm our
business
 
and
 
results
 
of
 
operations.
 
We
 
may
 
need
 
to
 
hire
 
more
 
employees
 
in
 
the
 
future
 
or
 
engage
 
outside
consultants, which will increase our costs and expenses.
In addition, changing laws,
 
regulations, and standards relating to
 
corporate governance and public disclosure
 
are
creating
 
uncertainty
 
for
 
public
 
companies,
 
increasing
 
legal
 
and
 
financial
 
compliance
 
costs
 
and
 
making
 
some
activities more time consuming.
 
These laws, regulations
 
and standards are subject
 
to varying interpretations, in
many cases due to their
 
lack of specificity and,
 
as a result, their
 
application in practice may
 
evolve over time as
new
 
guidance
 
is
 
provided
 
by
 
regulatory
 
and
 
governing
 
bodies.
 
This
 
could
 
result
 
in
 
continuing
 
uncertainty
regarding compliance matters and higher costs necessitated by ongoing revisions to disclosure and governance
practices.
 
We
 
intend
 
to
 
invest
 
resources
 
to
 
comply
 
with
 
evolving
 
laws,
 
regulations
 
and
 
standards,
 
and
 
this
investment may result in increased
 
general and administrative expenses
 
and a diversion of management’s
 
time
and
 
attention
 
from
 
sales-generating
 
activities
 
to
 
compliance
 
activities.
 
If
 
our
 
efforts
 
to
 
comply
 
with
 
new
 
laws,
regulations and standards differ from the activities intended by
 
regulatory or governing bodies due to ambiguities
related
 
to
 
their
 
application
 
and
 
practice,
 
regulatory
 
authorities
 
may
 
initiate
 
legal,
 
administrative
 
or
 
other
proceedings against us and our business may be harmed.
A state
 
court located within
 
the State
 
of Delaware (or, if
 
no state court
 
located within the
 
State of
 
Delaware
has jurisdiction, the
 
federal district court
 
for the District
 
of Delaware) will
 
be, to the
 
extent permitted by
law,
 
the
 
sole
 
and
 
exclusive
 
forum
 
for
 
substantially
 
all
 
state
 
law
 
based
 
disputes
 
between
 
us
 
and
stockholders.
Our bylaws provide
 
that, unless we
 
consent in writing
 
to the selection
 
of an alternative
 
forum, a state
 
or federal
court within the State of Delaware will be the sole and
 
exclusive forum for:
•
 
any derivative action or proceeding brought on our behalf;
•
 
any action or proceeding asserting a claim of breach of
 
a fiduciary duty owed by any director or
 
officer or
other employee or
 
agent of the
 
Company to the
 
Company or the
 
Company’s stockholders or debtholders;
•
 
any
 
action
 
or
 
proceeding
 
asserting
 
a
 
claim
 
against
 
the
 
Company
 
or
 
any
 
director
 
or
 
officer
 
or
 
other
employee or
 
agent of
 
the Company
 
arising pursuant
 
to any
 
provision of
 
the DGCL
 
or our
 
certificate of
incorporation or bylaws; or
•
 
any action
 
asserting
 
a claim
 
against
 
the
 
Company
 
or
 
any
 
director
 
or
 
officer
 
or
 
other
 
employee
 
of
 
the
Company
 
governed
 
by
 
the
 
internal
 
affairs
 
doctrine
 
or
 
other
 
“internal
 
corporate
 
claims”
 
as
 
defined
 
in
Section 115 of the DGCL.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
64
The choice of
 
forum provision may limit
 
a stockholder’s ability
 
to bring a claim
 
against us or our
 
directors, officers,
employees or
 
agents in
 
a forum
 
that it
 
finds favorable,
 
which may
 
discourage stockholders
 
from bringing
 
such
claims
 
at
 
all.
 
Alternatively,
 
if a
 
court
 
were
 
to
 
find
 
the
 
choice
 
of forum
 
provision
 
contained
 
in
 
our
 
bylaws
 
to
 
be
inapplicable or unenforceable
 
in an action,
 
we may incur
 
additional costs associated
 
with resolving such
 
action
in
 
another
 
forum,
 
which
 
could
 
materially
 
adversely
 
affect
 
our
 
business,
 
financial
 
condition
 
and
 
results
 
of
operations. However, the choice of forum provision does
 
not apply to any actions
 
arising under the Securities Act
or the Exchange Act.
The issuance of additional
 
common stock or securities
 
convertible into our
 
common stock could
 
result
in dilution of the ownership interest in us held by existing
 
stockholders.
We may
 
issue more
 
CDIs in
 
the future
 
in order
 
to fund
 
future investments, acquisitions,
 
capital raising
 
transactions
or
 
to
 
reduce
 
our
 
debt.
 
While
 
we
 
will
 
be
 
subject
 
to
 
the
 
constraints
 
of
 
the
 
ASX
 
Listing
 
Rules
 
regarding
 
the
percentage of our
 
capital that we
 
are able to
 
issue within a
 
12-month period
 
(subject to applicable
 
exceptions),
any such equity raisings may dilute the ownership of existing
 
common stockholders.
 
We are subject to general
 
market risks that are
 
inherent to companies with publicly-traded securities
 
and
the price of our securities may be volatile.
We are subject to
 
the general market risks that
 
are inherent in all
 
securities traded on a
 
securities exchange. This
may result
 
in fluctuations
 
in the
 
trading price
 
of our
 
securities that are
 
not explained
 
by our
 
fundamental operations
and activities. There is
 
no guarantee that the
 
price of our securities
 
will increase in the
 
future, even if our
 
earnings
increase.
Our securities may trade at, above or below the price paid by an investor for those securities due to a number of
factors, including, among others:
•
 
general market conditions, including investor sentiment;
•
 
movements in interest and exchange rates;
•
 
fluctuations in the local and global market for listed stocks;
•
 
actual or anticipated
 
fluctuations in
 
our interim and
 
annual results and
 
those of other
 
public companies
in our industry;
•
 
industry cycles and trends;
•
 
mergers and strategic alliances in the coal industry;
•
 
changes in government regulation;
•
 
potential or actual military conflicts or acts of terrorism;
•
 
changes in accounting principles;
•
 
announcements concerning us or our competitors;
•
 
changes in government policy,
 
legislation or regulation;
•
 
inclusion of our securities in or removal from particular market
 
indices (including S&P/ASX indices); and
•
 
the nature of the markets in which we operate.
Other factors
 
that may
 
negatively affect
 
investor sentiment
 
and influence
 
us, specifically,
 
or the
 
stock market,
more generally, include acts
 
of terrorism, an outbreak of international hostilities, fires, floods, earthquakes,
 
labor
strikes, civil
 
wars, natural
 
disasters, outbreaks
 
of disease,
 
including a
 
global pandemic,
 
or other
 
man-made
 
or
natural events.
Stock markets have
 
experienced extreme price
 
and volume fluctuations
 
in the past
 
that are
 
often disproportionate
or
 
unrelated
 
to
 
the
 
operating
 
performance
 
of
 
companies.
 
There
 
can
 
be
 
no
 
guarantee
 
that
 
trading
 
prices
 
and
volumes of any securities
 
will be sustained. These
 
factors may materially affect the
 
market price of our
 
securities,
regardless of our
 
operational performance. This
 
may then significantly
 
impact our ability
 
to raise new
 
equity which
may be required to fund our operations if our financial
 
performance deteriorates due to other factors.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
65
The payment of
 
dividends and repurchases
 
of our stock
 
are dependent on
 
a number
 
of factors, and
 
future
payments and repurchases cannot be assured.
The
 
payment
 
of
 
dividends
 
in
 
respect
 
of
 
our
 
common
 
stock
 
is
 
impacted
 
by
 
several
 
factors,
 
including
 
our
profitability,
 
retained earnings,
 
capital requirements
 
and free
 
cash flow,
 
as well
 
as applicable
 
covenants under
the Senior Secured Notes Indenture governing our Notes and covenants under the New ABL Facility.
 
Any future
dividends will be determined by our Board of Directors having
 
regard to these factors, among others. There is no
guarantee that any
 
dividend will be
 
paid, or repurchases
 
will be made,
 
by us, or
 
if paid, paid
 
at previous levels.
From time to time, our Board of Directors may also cancel
 
previously announced dividends.
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
66
ITEM 1B. UNRESOLVED
 
STAFF COMMENTS
None.
 
ITEM 1C. CYBERSECURITY
Risk Management and Strategy:
Coronado
 
has
 
implemented
 
software
 
governance
 
tools
 
to
 
assess,
 
identify,
 
and
 
manage
 
material
 
risks
 
from
cybersecurity threats. Coronado heavily relies on information technology systems throughout its operations, and
acknowledges
 
the
 
critical
 
importance
 
of
 
safeguarding
 
its
 
digital
 
assets
 
and
 
protecting
 
sensitive
 
information.
Regular security assessments are conducted
 
to monitor technological implementations against
 
global standards.
Coronado
 
also
 
maintains
 
a
 
suite
 
of
 
security
 
measures
 
to
 
help
 
defend
 
against
 
unauthorized
 
access
 
and
misappropriation
 
of
 
technology.
 
Additionally,
 
the
 
Coronado
 
IT
 
department
 
distributes
 
training
 
and
 
awareness
information covering email security,
 
password security,
 
data handling security,
 
and cloud security.
Coronado’s cybersecurity
 
risk management
 
is integrated
 
into its Group
 
risk management
 
processes, which
 
are
governed
 
by
 
the
 
Group
 
Risk
 
Management
 
Framework
 
and
 
Risk
 
Management
 
Policy.
 
The
 
Risk
 
Management
Framework and Risk Management Policy outline:
●
 
Risk management responsibilities;
●
 
Risk assessment frequency;
●
 
Risk assessment criteria (likelihood and consequence);
●
 
The requirement to implement internal controls; and
●
 
The level within the organization risk assessments are
 
to be performed.
Certain key controls considered through Coronado’s
 
internal control processes are linked to cybersecurity
 
risks,
these include controls over access and change management for key financial
 
systems. Where the management
of
 
these
 
key
 
financial
 
systems
 
is
 
outsourced
 
to
 
third
 
parties,
 
Coronado
 
receives
 
assurance
 
reports
 
on
 
the
effectiveness
 
of
 
key
 
vendor
 
controls.
 
Additionally,
 
Coronado
 
uses
 
third
 
parties
 
to
 
conduct
 
cybersecurity
penetration testing at Coronado's US and Australian
 
operations. In 2023, Coronado created the
 
Digital Advisory
Committee (Committee), which is
 
chaired by the
 
Vice President of
 
Information Technology.
 
As part of
 
Coronado’s
processes to
 
oversee and
 
identify cybersecurity
 
threats associated
 
with its
 
use of
 
third-party service
 
providers,
the Committee
 
is tasked
 
with reviewing
 
new software
 
requests from
 
Coronado’s various divisions.
 
The Committee
is comprised
 
of
 
business
 
systems,
 
plant,
 
and
 
operational
 
personnel
 
from
 
both
 
Coronado’s
 
US
 
and
 
Australian
operations.
As of
 
the filing
 
of this
 
Annual Report
 
on Form
 
10-K, Coronado
 
is not
 
aware of
 
any cybersecurity
 
incidents that
have occurred
 
since the
 
beginning of
 
2023 that
 
have materially
 
affected,
 
or are
 
reasonably likely
 
to materially
affect, Coronado, including Coronado’s
 
business strategy,
 
results of operations or financial condition.
 
Coronado
could be subject to cybersecurity incidents in
 
the future which may have a material
 
adverse effect on Coronado’s
business strategy, results of operations or financial
 
condition. For further information on
 
Coronado’s risks relating
to cybersecurity threats, see “Operation and Technology
 
Risks” in “Risk Factors” on page 51
of this Form 10-K.
 
Governance:
The
 
Board
 
of
 
Directors
 
(Board)
 
is
 
responsible
 
for
 
reviewing,
 
ratifying,
 
and
 
monitoring
 
systems
 
of
 
risk
management,
 
internal
 
control,
 
and
 
legal
 
compliance.
 
This
 
includes
 
identifying
 
the
 
main
 
risks
 
associated
 
with
Coronado's
 
businesses,
 
including
 
cybersecurity
 
risk,
 
and
 
implementing
 
appropriate
 
systems
 
to
 
manage
 
such
risks. As outlined in the Audit Governance and Risk
 
Committee (AGRC) charter, the
 
Board has delegated to the
AGRC responsibility for
 
overseeing corporate and governance
 
risk management, financial risk
 
management, and
compliance with applicable laws,
 
regulations, standards, and best
 
practice guidelines. In 2024,
 
the AGRC charter
was amended
 
to confirm
 
that this
 
responsibility includes the
 
oversight of
 
cybersecurity risk. The
 
AGRC is
 
informed
of cybersecurity risks by management, which includes an annual cybersecurity
 
risk presentation. As part of their
review of reports
 
from management,
 
the AGRC reports
 
cybersecurity risk
 
updates to the
 
Board, which enables
the Board to incorporate the insights of such reports into its
 
overall risk oversight analysis.
Supporting
 
this
 
governance
 
framework,
 
the
 
Executive
 
Leadership
 
Team
 
(ELT)
 
is
 
responsible
 
for
 
maintaining
effective systems of risk management and internal control, as well as responding to cybersecurity incidents. The
Vice
 
President
 
of
 
Information
 
Technology
 
is
 
responsible
 
for
 
the
 
cybersecurity
 
function.
 
The
 
Vice
 
President
 
of
Information
 
Technology
 
has
 
experience
 
in
 
various
 
roles
 
involving
 
managing
 
information
 
systems
 
and
cybersecurity functions
 
and developing
 
cybersecurity strategies.
 
The Vice
 
President of
 
Information Technology
reports to the Group Chief Financial Officer (Group
 
CFO), who is a member of the ELT.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
67
In order to prevent, detect, mitigate and
 
remediate cybersecurity incidents, Coronado maintains a Cyber Incident
Response
 
Plan
 
(Plan).
 
The
 
Plan
 
outlines
 
Coronado's
 
approach
 
to
 
identifying
 
and
 
containing
 
cybersecurity
incidents, along with recovery
 
and improvement processes.
 
The Plan includes incident
 
assessment criteria that
allow for
 
escalation of
 
potentially material
 
cybersecurity
 
incidents. The
 
Group CFO
 
reports to
 
the AGRC
 
in the
event
 
of
 
a
 
potentially
 
material
 
cybersecurity
 
incident.
 
Additionally,
 
annual
 
reviews
 
of
 
Coronado’s
 
current
cybersecurity status are presented to the Board and the AGRC
 
by management.
c561202310Kp68i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
68
ITEM 2.
 
PROPERTIES
 
Summary Overview of Mining Operations
Coronado owns and controls
 
a portfolio of operating
 
mines and development projects
 
in Queensland, Australia,
and
 
Virginia,
 
West
 
Virginia
 
and
 
Pennsylvania
 
in
 
the
 
United
 
States.
 
Our
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
consist
 
of
 
the
100%-owned Curragh
 
producing mine
 
complex. With
 
respect to
 
our U.S.
 
Operations, Coronado
 
owns a
 
100%
interest in two producing
 
mine complexes (Buchanan
 
and Logan) and
 
a 100% interest
 
in one idled, production-
stage
 
mine
 
complex
 
(Greenbrier)
 
and
 
two
 
development
 
properties
 
(Mon
 
Valley
 
Minerals
 
(formerly
 
called
Pangburn-Shaner-Fallowfield)
 
and
 
Russell
 
County).
 
Figures
 
1
 
and
 
2
 
below
 
show
 
the
 
locations
 
of
 
our
 
mining
properties in Australia and the United States, respectively
 
.
 
Figure 1: Australian Operations:
c561202310Kp69i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
69
13.6
12.8
26.4
12.4
13
25.3
12.8
12.6
25.4
Australia
United States
Group
ROM production (Mt)
FY21
FY22
FY23
11.1
6.3
17.4
9.8
6.2
16.0
10.0
5.8
15.8
Australia
United States
Group
Saleable production (Mt)
FY21
FY22
FY23
Figure 2: U.S. Operations:
The below charts
 
show run-of-mine, or
 
ROM, production
 
and saleable production
 
for our Australian
 
Operations
and our U.S. Operations for the years ended December
 
31, 2023, 2022 and 2021.
See the descriptions of our material mining properties
 
under “—Curragh,” “—Buchanan,” “—Logan” and “—Mon
Valley”
 
below
 
for
 
more
 
information.
 
Table
 
1
 
below
 
contains
 
a
 
summary
 
of
 
the
 
key
 
information
 
relative
 
to
 
the
various
 
Coronado
 
properties.
 
Tables
 
2
 
and
 
3
 
provide
 
a
 
summary
 
of
 
our
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves,
respectively, as of December
 
31, 2023.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
70
Table 1.
 
Summary of Coronado Properties
Property
(Property
Stage)
Mineral Rights
(1)
Permit
Status
(2)
Mine Type(s)
Coal Type
Coal Seams of
Economic
Interest
(Formation)
Processing
Plants/
Facilities
Curragh
(Production)
25,586 hectares
leased; 6,381
hectares owned
Permitted
Surface &
Underground
(4)
HCC, SCC,
PCI, Thermal
Various (Rangal
Coal Measures)
CPP1 - 1,100 raw
Mt per hour;
CPP2 - 1,200 raw
Mt per hour; Rail
Loadout
Buchanan
(Production)
25,853 hectares
leased
(3)
; 7,725
hectares owned
1 Permit
Underground
Low-Vol
Pocahontas #3
(Pocahontas
Formation)
CPP - 1,270 raw
Mt per hour; Rail
Loadout
Logan
(Production)
13,114 hectares
leased
(3)
; 69
hectares owned
27 Permits
Surface &
Underground
HVA, HVB,
Thermal
Various
(Kanawha
Formation)
CPP - 1,088 raw
Mt per hour; Rail
Loadout
Mon Valley
(Development)
1,339 hectares
leased
(3)
; 40,276
hectares owned
Not
Permitted
Underground
(4)
High-Vol
Upper Freeport
(Freeport
Formation)
Future
Greenbrier
(Production -
Idled)
18,907 hectares
leased
(3)
22 Permits
Surface &
Underground
Mid-Vol, PCI,
Thermal
Pocahontas #6,
#7, #8
(Pocahontas
Formation);
Various (New
River Formation)
CPP - 544 raw Mt
per hour; Rail
Loadout
Russell County
(Development)
7,111
 
hectares
leased
(3)
; 378
hectares owned
Not
Permitted
Underground
(4)
High-Vol
Lower Castle
(Norton
Formation);
Upper Horsepen
(Middle Lee
Formation)
Future
(1)
 
We are
 
not aware of
 
any significant encumbrances or
 
defects in title
 
with respect to
 
any of our
 
mining properties.
 
Certain credit
facilities of the Company are secured by a lien on
 
substantially all of the Company’s assets, including
 
mining properties.
(2)
 
We believe we
 
have secured
 
all applicable
 
environmental licenses
 
and permits
 
under applicable
 
law and
 
have all
 
necessary permits
and licenses regarding cultural heritage, native
 
title and various other social issues to support
 
current mining operations.
(3)
 
Subject to the exercise of our renewal rights thereunder, most of the leases at our U.S. mining properties expire upon exhaustion
of the relevant reserves.
(4)
 
Proposed mine type.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
71
Table 2.
 
Summary Coal Resources Exclusive of Reserves at End
 
of the Fiscal Year Ended December 31,
2023.
(1)
Coal Resources (In Situ, MMt)
(2)
Quality (Air-Dried Basis)
Measured
Indicated
Measured
+
Indicated
Inferred
Ash
Sulfur
Volatile
Matter
Australia
Curragh Open Cut
167
81
247
54
22.9%
0.6%
19.1%
Curragh Underground
41
62
103
106
18.6%
0.4%
18.1%
Total
 
Australia
208
143
350
160
United States
Buchanan
31
4
35
—
16.0%
0.8%
18.0%
Logan
39
36
75
3
17.0%
1.0%
31.0%
Mon Valley
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Greenbrier
19
14
33
—
31.0%
1.1%
20.0%
Russell County
40
4
44
—
29.0%
0.7%
23.0%
Total
 
United States
129
58
187
3
Total
337
201
537
163
(1)
 
For more
 
information regarding price
 
assumptions used
 
in the
 
calculation of
 
coal resources
 
as of
 
December 31,
 
2023, see
 
the
individual property disclosures below.
(2)
 
Australian resources are estimated inclusive of 5.3%
 
in-situ moisture.
 
United States resources are estimated on a
 
dry basis.
(3)
 
Some numerical figures in the
 
above table have been subject
 
to rounding adjustments. Accordingly,
 
numerical figures shown as
totals may not equal the sum of the figures that
 
precede them.
 
Table 3.
 
Summary Coal Reserves (Marketable Sales Basis) at End of the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2023.
(1)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet
Tons,
Washed or Direct Shipped, MMt)
(2)
Quality (Air-Dried Basis)
Proven
Probable
Total
Ash
Sulfur
Volatile
Matter
Australia
Curragh Open Cut
173
16
189
12.2%
0.5%
19.5%
Curragh Underground
25
9
34
10.0%
0.3%
16.9%
Total
 
Australia
198
25
223
United States
Buchanan
87
5
92
6.0%
0.7%
20.0%
Logan
55
16
71
8.0%
0.9%
35.0%
Mon Valley
78
57
134
8.0%
1.2%
(3)
35.0%
Greenbrier
4
2
7
8.0%
1.0%
26.0%
Russell County
24
5
29
8.0%
0.9%
31.0%
Total
 
United States
248
85
333
Total
446
110
556
(1)
 
For more
 
information regarding
 
price assumptions
 
used in
 
the calculation
 
of coal
 
reserves as
 
of December
 
31, 2023,
 
see the
individual property disclosures below.
(2)
 
For more information regarding moisture assumptions used in the calculation of coal
 
reserves as of December 31, 2023, see the
individual property disclosures below.
(3)
 
Life-of-mine,
 
or
 
LOM,
 
sulfur
 
for
 
Pangburn
 
is
 
an
 
estimated
 
1.2%;
 
however,
 
overall
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
complex
 
reserve
 
average
 
is
1.4%sulfur.
(4)
 
Some numerical figures in the
 
above table have been subject
 
to rounding adjustments. Accordingly,
 
numerical figures shown as
totals may not equal the sum of the figures that
 
precede them.
 
 
c561202310Kp72i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
72
Curragh
Curragh is a
 
production-stage mining property that
 
consists of two
 
active, open cut,
 
surface mines (Curragh
 
North
and Curragh Main) and one proposed
 
underground mine (east of the Curragh
 
North open cut mine).
 
Coal mine
development at
 
the Curragh
 
property has
 
been historically
 
accomplished by
 
surface mining
 
methods since
 
the
mine’s inception in 1983.
 
Presently, coal mine development at the Curragh property
 
is accomplished by surface
mining
 
methods
 
and
 
by
 
an
 
underground
 
development
 
project,
 
which
 
is
 
undergoing
 
operational
 
readiness
 
in
preparation for
 
execution and
 
commencement of
 
underground coal
 
production in
 
late 2024.
 
Curragh coals
 
are
widely known for their low
 
ash, low to mid volatile
 
matter, low sulfur
 
and low phosphorous content.
 
Curragh Met
coal products are also known
 
for their consistent delivered
 
quality, which
 
supports a consistent offtake
 
across a
diversified market base.
 
A map of the Curragh tenements is shown in Figure 3.
Figure 3.
 
Coronado Curragh Mine Complex Property Location
 
Map.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
73
The Curragh mine
 
complex is
 
located within the
 
Bowen Basin coalfields,
 
approximately 200
 
kilometers by road
west of Rockhampton, Queensland, Australia,
 
and approximately 14 kilometers north of
 
the town of Blackwater,
Queensland, Australia. The
 
coordinates of CPP1,
 
which is located
 
within Curragh Main,
 
are 688,561 meters
 
East,
7,400,933 meters North
 
in the AMG66 grid
 
system. Curragh owns
 
and operates the
 
necessary CPPs and
 
load-
out system
 
for dispatches
 
via Blackwater
 
rail line
 
to the
 
Port of
 
Gladstone or
 
the Stanwell
 
Power Station.
 
See
Item 1. “Business—Transportation
 
—Australian Operations” for
 
additional information regarding
 
the rail and port
services available to Curragh.
 
Curragh also has maintenance
 
facilities for the fleet
 
of mining equipment, as
 
well
as office
 
buildings for
 
the mine
 
staff and
 
personnel.
 
Established sealed
 
roads connect
 
the mine
 
to the
 
town of
Emerald, Queensland,
 
Australia,
 
to the
 
west and
 
the
 
Port of
 
Gladstone
 
to the
 
east.
 
Third-party
 
rail providers
operate the Blackwater rail line and transport Curragh
 
export coal, for sale to international customers, to
 
the RG
Tanna Coal Terminal
 
or Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal at the Port of Gladstone.
 
Curragh domestic coal is
loaded onto train wagons for transportation to the Stanwell
 
Power Station for power generation.
 
Curragh has ready access
 
to water,
 
electricity and personnel
 
to support its operations.
 
SunWater Ltd.
 
supplies
water to the mine complex from the Fairbairn Dam via the Bedford Weir.
 
The mine complex also recycles water
from on-site dams—i.e., old open-cut pits that capture rainfall and water from dewatering activities.
 
Curragh has
a
 
dedicated
 
66-kilovolt,
 
or
 
kV,
 
power
 
supply
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
mining
 
operations
 
with
 
a
 
capacity
 
of
 
up
 
to
 
57-
megawatt,
 
or
 
MW,
 
sourced
 
from
 
the
 
main
 
grid
 
power.
 
The
 
substation
 
is
 
located
 
on
 
the
 
southwest
 
corner
 
of
ML1878
 
with
 
both
 
66kv
 
and
 
22kv
 
distribution
 
networks
 
to
 
supply
 
the
 
draglines,
 
shovel
 
and
 
CPPs.
 
There
 
is
adequate power
 
on site
 
for establishing
 
the underground
 
mine and
 
commencing the
 
first two
 
continuous miner
units;
 
however,
 
upgrades
 
to
 
the
 
site
 
infrastructure
 
are
 
required
 
for
 
full
 
underground
 
production
 
with
 
four
continuous miner units.
 
The Mineral Resources
 
Act 1989 (Qld),
 
or MRA, and
 
the Mineral and
 
Energy Resources (Common
 
Provisions)
Act
 
2014
 
(Qld),
 
or
 
MERCPA,
 
together,
 
provide
 
for
 
the
 
assessment,
 
development
 
and
 
utilization
 
of
 
mineral
resources
 
in
 
Queensland
 
to
 
the
 
maximum
 
extent
 
practicable,
 
consistent
 
with
 
sound
 
economic
 
and
 
land
 
use
management. The MRA vests ownership of minerals, with limited exceptions, in the “Crown,” which in relation to
Curragh,
 
is
 
the
 
Queensland
 
government.
 
A
 
royalty
 
is
 
payable
 
to
 
the
 
Queensland
 
government
 
for
 
the
 
right
 
to
extract
 
minerals.
 
The
 
MRA
 
also
 
creates
 
different
 
tenures
 
for
 
different
 
mining
 
activities,
 
such
 
as
 
prospecting,
exploring and
 
mining. A ML
 
is the
 
most important tenure,
 
as it permits
 
the extraction
 
of minerals
 
in conjunction
with other required authorities. The MRA imposes general conditions
 
on a ML.
We
 
control
 
the
 
coal
 
mining
 
rights
 
at
 
Curragh
 
under
 
14
 
coal
 
and
 
infrastructure
 
MLs
 
and
 
three
 
MDLs
 
granted
pursuant to
 
the MRA.
 
We
 
refer to
 
the MLs
 
and MDLs
 
at Curragh,
 
collectively,
 
as the
 
Tenements.
 
Renewal
 
of
certain Tenements
 
will be required during the mine life of Curragh and the Queensland government can vary the
terms and
 
conditions on
 
renewal. There
 
are a
 
number of
 
existing petroleum
 
tenements which
 
overlap with
 
the
Tenements.
 
The priority,
 
consent and
 
coordination requirements
 
under the
 
MRA, MERCPA
 
and the
 
Petroleum
and Gas
 
(Production and Safety)
 
Act 2004
 
(Qld) (as relevant)
 
may apply
 
with respect to
 
those overlaps. Extensive
statutory
 
protocols
 
govern
 
the
 
relationships
 
between
 
co-existing
 
mining
 
and
 
exploration
 
rights
 
and
 
these
protocols
 
are
 
largely
 
focused
 
on
 
encouraging
 
the
 
overlapping
 
tenement
 
holders
 
to
 
negotiate
 
and
 
formulate
arrangements
 
that
 
enable
 
the
 
co-existence
 
of
 
their
 
respective
 
interests.
 
To
 
date,
 
we
 
have
 
negotiated
arrangements in place with all of our overlapping
 
tenement holders and full access
 
to all of our Tenements.
 
See
Item 1. “Business—Regulatory Matters—Australia” for additional
 
information regarding Curragh’s Tenements.
 
Property control and mining rights at Curragh are entirely expressed in the MLs and MDLs mentioned above. An
overlapping petroleum tenure exists over the
 
southern and eastern extents of
 
the Tenements.
 
Under the Mineral
and
 
Energy
 
Resources
 
(Common
 
Provisions)
 
Act
 
2014
 
(Qld),
 
this
 
requires
 
annual
 
information
 
exchanges,
including the
 
provision and
 
maintenance of
 
joint information
 
management plans
 
with the
 
overlapping tenement
holder.
 
Curragh is compliant with the legislation and there are
 
no current restrictions to coal mining.
As conditions to certain
 
of the Tenements, Curragh is subject to royalties payable
 
to the Queensland government
on a regulated tiered
 
structure introduced July
 
1, 2022. This tiered
 
royalty payment regime
 
is dependent on the
received AUD/t
 
revenue received
 
from the
 
coal sales,
 
and varies
 
from 7%
 
for up
 
to A$100/t
 
sales, up
 
to 40%
payable for
 
sales over
 
A$300/t. These
 
royalties are
 
in addition
 
to the
 
Stanwell rebate,
 
as described
 
in Item
 
1.
“Business—Customers—Stanwell.” Additionally, if MDL 162
 
advances from development
 
to production,
 
we would
be required to
 
pay under a
 
private royalty deed
 
a base royalty
 
of A$0.50 per
 
Mt of coal and
 
a royalty of
 
A$0.70
for every Mt of SCC produced above 2.5 MMt per year.
A joint venture between
 
Arco Australia Ltd., Australian Consolidated Industries
 
Ltd., R.W. Miller & Co.
 
and Mitsui
& Co. (Australia) first began development on certain
 
of the Tenements in 1983.
 
Later, Arco Australia Ltd. bought
out the
 
other joint
 
venturers
 
and, in
 
2000, sold
 
the Curragh
 
property to
 
Wesfarmers
 
Ltd. In
 
2014, Wesfarmers
acquired MDL 162 from Peabody Budjero Pty
 
Ltd.
 
Coronado acquired all the Tenements
 
from Wesfarmers Ltd.
in March 2018.
 
Production history has been approximately
 
11.1 MMt in
 
2021, 9.8 MMt in 2022 and 10.0 MMt
 
in
2023.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
74
Beginning
 
in the
 
1960’s,
 
various
 
tenement
 
holders
 
began prospecting
 
and exploratory
 
drilling
 
at Curragh.
 
We
currently
 
have
 
an
 
active,
 
ongoing
 
exploration
 
program
 
at
 
Curragh
 
that
 
allows
 
us
 
to
 
update
 
and
 
refine
 
the
geological
 
model
 
ahead
 
of
 
pit
 
development.
 
Recently,
 
we
 
have
 
increasingly
 
focused
 
on
 
an
 
underground
exploration program,
 
which has
 
included seismic
 
2-D
 
and 3-D
 
surveys and
 
core drilling
 
for gas,
 
geotech, coal
quality
 
and
 
spontaneous
 
combustion
 
evaluation.
 
Additional
 
exploration
 
has
 
included
 
permeability
 
and
hydrological assessments.
Open cut coal mine development
 
at the Curragh property is presently
 
accomplished by surface mining methods
and has been so historically
 
since the mine’s inception.
 
The mine characteristics and output
 
levels allow it to be
ranked as
 
a large
 
coal operation
 
when compared
 
to domestic
 
producers in
 
Australia and
 
worldwide.
 
Curragh
operates four large electric draglines, one large electric
 
shovel and additional fleets of hydraulic excavators.
 
Curragh has two coal preparation
 
plants, CPP1 and CPP2. CPP1
 
is the oldest of the two processing
 
plants and
has a documented
 
nameplate capacity of
 
1,100 raw tons
 
per hour, or tph
 
(as received).
 
CPP2 has a
 
documented
nameplate capacity of 1,200 tph (as received) with a capability of up to
 
1350 tph when processing selected feed
types.
 
Curragh has
 
a loadout
 
facility for
 
loading coal
 
onto railcars,
 
which is
 
connected to
 
the main
 
Blackwater
rail link.
 
Generally, the mining equipment and facilities at Curragh are in good operating condition.
 
We focus on the long-
term
 
potential
 
of
 
the
 
mine
 
complex
 
and
 
regularly
 
monitor
 
developments
 
in
 
the
 
mining
 
industry
 
for
 
technology
improvements and
 
new equipment
 
that could
 
help us
 
increase efficiency
 
and lower our
 
costs. Curragh’s
 
oldest
mining
 
equipment,
 
including
 
two
 
draglines,
 
began
 
operations
 
in
 
1983.
 
Prior
 
to
 
Coronado
 
taking
 
over
 
mining
operations,
 
Wesfarmers
 
Ltd.
 
made
 
improvements
 
to
 
the
 
processing
 
facilities
 
at
 
Curragh,
 
including
 
the
commissioning of the second CPP
 
in 2012 and replacing the raw
 
coal crushing system at Curragh
 
Main with an
updated circuit
 
in 2016.
 
Wesfarmers Ltd.
 
also started
 
a corrosion
 
and structural
 
repair program
 
over ten
 
years
ago that
 
has continued
 
since acquisition.
 
This program
 
helps ensure
 
that the
 
assets are
 
available well
 
into the
future. From time to time, we also
 
update and improve other equipment and facilities to maintain their usefulness
and optimize our competitiveness. As of December 31, 2023, the book value of Curragh and its associated plant
and equipment was $767.8 million.
Studies
 
for
 
determining
 
the
 
feasibility
 
of
 
underground
 
mining
 
of
 
the
 
Curragh
 
North
 
mine
 
east
 
of
 
the
 
existing
Curragh
 
North
 
open
 
cut
 
mine
 
has
 
been
 
undertaken
 
between
 
2020 to
 
2023, comprising
 
a
 
pre-feasibility
 
study
completed
 
in
 
the
 
first quarter
 
of 2023
 
and
 
a subsequent
 
more
 
detailed
 
feasibility
 
study
 
on the
 
South
 
planned
operations
 
area in
 
the Mammoth
 
Seam. The
 
selected
 
mining
 
method for
 
the underground
 
project is
 
bord and
pillar mining using
 
primary extraction
 
of panels
 
with roadway
 
widths of
 
6.5 meters,
 
reducing to
 
6 meters
 
where
the overburden thickness or
 
mining conditions require. The
 
project is currently in
 
the operational readiness phase
and preparation is currently underway
 
for execution and commencement
 
of underground coal production
 
in late
2024. The ROM
 
coal is planned
 
to be transported
 
on the existing
 
installed overland conveyor south
 
to the existing
CPPs for
 
processing. The
 
product coal
 
will be
 
handled through
 
the existing
 
product coal
 
stockpile system
 
and
train load out facility at Curragh.
 
Underground mine access is planned
 
via four portal entries from the
 
southern end of the final highwall
 
of one of
the open
 
cut pits
 
in Curragh,
 
called S-Pit.
 
Surface infrastructure
 
planned for
 
the underground
 
mine includes
 
a
ROM stockpile
 
pad, conveyor
 
and radial
 
stacker, Mine Industrial
 
Area and
 
workshop. This
 
is planned
 
to be
 
located
adjacent to the S-Pit
 
portal entries from the
 
open cut, with access
 
to the underground mine
 
via mobile vehicles.
The mine access methodology and
 
surface infrastructure arrangement is consistent with other
 
underground bord
and pillar mines operating from existing open cut mines
 
in Queensland.
The underground mine has been
 
planned with three mining areas: South, Central and
 
North. Planned production
transitions
 
from
 
South
 
to
 
Central
 
and
 
then
 
North
 
areas
 
as
 
reserves
 
deplete
 
and
 
geographical
 
expansion
 
is
required to maintain
 
the required LOM
 
production. The mine
 
is expected to
 
commence in the
 
South area in
 
the
Mammoth Seam in late 2024 with two continuous miner
 
units, then later introducing additional continuous miner
units, with full production
 
using four units by
 
2026. Production is planned
 
to commence in the
 
Mackenzie Seam
in 2034 and continue throughout the expected LOM of approximately
 
20 years for the underground mine.
 
We are
 
not aware of
 
any significant
 
encumbrances or
 
defects in title
 
with respect
 
to the Curragh
 
property.
 
We
believe
 
we
 
have
 
secured
 
all
 
applicable
 
environmental
 
licenses
 
and
 
permits
 
under
 
both
 
Queensland
 
and
Australian Commonwealth
 
legislation and
 
have all
 
permits and
 
licenses regarding
 
cultural heritage,
 
native title
and various
 
other social
 
issues. See
 
Item 1. “Business
 
—Regulatory Matters—Australia”
 
for a discussion
 
of the
permitting conditions applicable to Curragh.
Summaries of Curragh’s
 
coal resources
 
and reserves estimates as
 
of December 31, 2023
 
and 2022 are shown
in Tables
 
4 and 5, respectively.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
75
Table
 
4.
 
Curragh
 
–
 
Summary
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
Exclusive
 
of
 
Reserves
 
at
 
the
 
End
 
of
 
the
 
Fiscal
 
Year
Ended December 31, 2023 and 2022.
(1)
Coal Resources
(Wet Tons, In Situ, MMt)
(2)(3)
Quality (Air-Dried Basis)
Measured
Indicated
Measured
+
Indicated
Inferred
Ash
Sulfur
Volatile
Matter
December 31, 2023
Open Cut
167
81
247
54
22.9%
0.60%
19.1%
Underground
41
62
103
106
18.6%
0.40%
18.1%
Total
208
143
350
160
December 31, 2022
Open Cut
328
184
512
142
19.5%
0.50%
18.4%
Total
328
184
512
142
(1)
 
Curragh determines the resources exclusive of reserves below a 15:1
 
in-situ strip ratio as being suitable for
 
open pit mining, and
above 15:1 in-situ strip ratio being suitable for underground
 
mining with a minimum seam thickness of 1.8
 
meters.
(2)
 
There are resources suitable for open
 
cut mining outside of the declared
 
reserves.
 
The initial economic assessment
 
for resources
exclusive of
 
reserves as
 
of December
 
31, 2022,
 
and 2023
 
assumed revenue
 
pricing based
 
on an
 
assumed long-term
 
average
realized sales prices
 
of $143 per
 
Mt (FOB) and
 
$133 per Mt (FOB),
 
respectively, for the open cut
 
resources and $147
 
per Mt (FOB)
and $140 per Mt (FOB), respectively, for the underground
 
resources. This is explained further in
 
Section 11.5 of the Curragh TRS.
(3)
 
Table 1-1 of the Curragh TRS provides a summary of Curragh resource tons inclusive
 
of reserve tons as of December 31, 2023.
(4)
 
Reported on a 5.3% in-situ moisture basis.
 
(5)
 
Some numerical figures in the
 
above table have been subject
 
to rounding adjustments. Accordingly,
 
numerical figures shown as
totals may not equal the sum of the figures that
 
precede them.
Table
 
5.
 
Curragh –
 
Summary of
 
Coal Reserves
 
(Marketable
 
Sales Basis)
 
at the
 
End of
 
the Fiscal
 
Year
Ended December 31, 2023 and 2022.
(1)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet
Tons, Washed
or Direct Shipped, MMt)
(2)
Quality (Air-Dried Basis)
Proven
Probable
Total
Ash
Sulfur
Volatile
Matter
December 31, 2023
Open Cut
173
16
189
12.2%
0.5%
19.5%
Underground
25
9
34
10.0%
0.3%
16.9%
Total
198
25
223
December 31, 2022
Open Cut
188
18
205
10.7%
0.4%
19.0%
Total
188
18
205
(1)
 
Based on
 
long-term revenue
 
pricing assumption
 
data outlined
 
by Coronado
 
described in
 
Section 16
 
of the
 
Curragh TRS.
 
The
pricing data assumes an average
 
realized price of $141 per
 
Mt produced over the LOM
 
as of December 31, 2022
 
and $131 per Mt
sold over the LOM as of December 31, 2023.
(2)
 
The December 31,
 
2022 marketable reserves
 
are reported on
 
an 11.0%
 
moisture basis. For
 
the December 31,
 
2023 marketing
reserves, the
 
open cut
 
marketable reserves
 
are
 
reported on
 
a
 
9.5% product
 
moisture
 
basis and
 
the underground
 
marketable
reserves are reported on a 10% product moisture
 
basis.
(3)
 
Some numerical figures in the
 
above table have been subject
 
to rounding adjustments. Accordingly,
 
numerical figures shown as
totals may not equal the sum of the figures that
 
precede them.
From
 
December
 
31,
 
2022,
 
to
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
measured
 
and
 
indicated
 
resources
 
decreased
 
by
approximately 32%, from
 
512 MMt
 
to 350 MMt.
 
This decrease in
 
measured and indicated
 
resources is attributable
to the conversion of resources
 
to reserves being declared in
 
2023 for the underground project.
 
From December
31, 2022, to December 31,
 
2023, total marketable coal
 
reserves increased by approximately 9%,
 
from 205 MMt
to approximately 223 MMt. This increase
 
in marketable coal reserves is attributable
 
mainly to the addition of the
Curragh North
 
underground project
 
reserves estimate.
 
A TRS
 
with respect
 
to Curragh,
 
updating the
 
TRS with
respect to Curragh
 
incorporated by reference
 
into Coronado’s
 
Annual Report on
 
Form 10-K for
 
the year ended
December 31,
 
2022, was
 
prepared in
 
February
 
2024 due
 
to material
 
differences
 
in the
 
key modifying
 
factors,
including the addition of
 
an underground LOM plan
 
and changes to coal
 
sales price assumptions, operating
 
costs
and capital costs, from December 31, 2022 to December
 
31, 2023.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
76
Barry Lay,
 
BSc Geology (Hons);
 
MAusIMM of Resology
 
Pty Ltd, Daniel
 
Millers, B. Eng.;
 
MAusIMM(CP), who
 
is
employed full-time as the Superintendent Long Term
 
Planning of our subsidiary, Coronado Curragh Pty Ltd, and
Chris Wilkinson, BSc
 
(Mining); MAusIMM(CP);
 
Director Mining
 
Consultancy Services
 
(Australia) Pty Ltd,
 
whom
we
 
refer
 
to,
 
collectively,
 
as
 
the
 
Australian
 
QPs,
 
prepared
 
the
 
estimates
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
summarized in Tables
 
4 and 5.
 
A copy of the Australian QPs’ technical report summary,
 
or TRS, with respect to
Curragh, dated February
 
16, 2024,
 
or the Curragh
 
TRS, is filed
 
as Exhibit 96.1
 
hereto. None of
 
Mr. Barry
 
Lay,
Resology
 
Pty
 
Ltd,
 
Mr.
 
Chris
 
Wilkinson
 
or
 
Mining
 
Consultancy
 
Services
 
(Australia)
 
Pty
 
Ltd
 
are
 
affiliated
 
with
Coronado.
 
The Australian QPs prepared the estimates of Curragh
 
coal resources and reserves using drilling data available
from exploration
 
activities at
 
Curragh conducted
 
by numerous
 
entities over
 
time.
 
Most of
 
this information
 
was
obtained prior to our
 
acquisition of Curragh,
 
using varying drilling and
 
core-logging techniques, survey
 
methods
and testing procedures.
 
As a
 
result, in verifying
 
the data,
 
the Australian
 
QPs made
 
certain assumptions
 
about
the adequacy of the
 
processes performed and
 
comparability of the data
 
based on their professional
 
experience
and familiarity with Curragh.
Per
 
Section
 
12.1
 
of
 
the
 
Curragh
 
TRS,
 
coal
 
reserve
 
estimates
 
were
 
classified
 
as
 
proven
 
or
 
probable,
 
with
consideration given to
 
“modifying factors,”
 
including mining, processing,
 
metallurgical, infrastructure,
 
economic,
marketing, legal,
 
environmental, social
 
and governmental
 
factors. Section
 
22.2 of
 
the Curragh
 
TRS includes
 
a
risk
 
assessment
 
of
 
the
 
key
 
modifying
 
factors
 
that
 
could
 
potentially
 
impact
 
the
 
operations
 
and
 
therefore
 
the
estimate of coal reserves and resources.
 
As
 
summarized
 
in
 
Section
 
7.1
 
of
 
the
 
Curragh
 
TRS,
 
the
 
concentration
 
of
 
exploration
 
drill
 
holes
 
varies
 
slightly
across the Curragh
 
property.
 
The location of
 
the drilling
 
is shown on
 
the maps
 
included in Section
 
7.
 
Points of
observation include
 
exploration drill
 
holes, degas
 
holes and
 
mine measurements,
 
which have
 
been fully
 
vetted
and
 
processed
 
into
 
a
 
geological
 
model.
 
The
 
geological
 
model
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
seam
 
depositional
 
modelling,
 
the
interrelationship
 
of
 
overlying
 
and
 
underlying
 
strata
 
on
 
seam
 
mineability,
 
seam
 
thickness
 
trends, the
 
impact
 
of
seam structure (i.e., faulting), intra-seam
 
characteristics, etc.
 
Section 11.6
 
of the Curragh TRS summarizes
 
the
drill hole spacings and accuracy associated with each
 
resource category.
Coal quality is instrumental
 
in determining whether there
 
are reasonable prospects
 
for economic extraction of
 
a
coal resource
 
and
 
the economic
 
viability
 
of a
 
coal
 
reserve.
 
These quality
 
attributes
 
aided
 
in converting
 
in-situ
resource tons to
 
demonstrated coal
 
reserves (recoverable washed
 
tons). The reserve
 
and resource criteria
 
are
presented in
 
Sections 12.1
 
and 11.3,
 
respectively,
 
of the Curragh
 
TRS, including
 
assumptions related
 
to seam
density, minimum
 
cut-off thickness, and recoveries.
 
Pricing data as provided
 
by Coronado is described in
 
Table
16.2 of the Curragh TRS.
 
These are weighted-average realized values across
 
the LOM schedule.
Regarding
 
production
 
rates
 
as
 
described
 
in
 
Section
 
13
 
of
 
the
 
Curragh
 
TRS,
 
the
 
mine
 
plan
 
and
 
productivity
expectations
 
consider
 
historical
 
performance
 
and
 
efforts
 
have
 
been made
 
to
 
adjust
 
the plan
 
to
 
reflect
 
current
technology and future
 
conditions. Additional mine-specific factors
 
can be found
 
in Section 13
 
of the Curragh
 
TRS.
 
Buchanan
Buchanan
 
is
 
a
 
production-stage
 
mining
 
property,
 
consisting
 
of
 
one
 
active
 
underground
 
mine
 
and
 
supporting
infrastructure that
 
produces Low-Vol
 
Met coal using
 
the longwall
 
mining method.
 
The mine complex
 
is located
in Buchanan County in southwest Virginia.
 
A map of Buchanan is shown in Figure 4.
c561202310Kp77i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
77
Figure 4.
 
Coronado Buchanan Mine Complex Property Location
 
Map.
The Buchanan
 
mine complex
 
is located
 
approximately
 
6.4 kilometers
 
southeast of
 
Oakwood, Virginia,
 
and 16
kilometers
 
southeast
 
of
 
Grundy,
 
Virginia.
 
The
 
coordinates
 
of
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
CPP
 
are
 
latitude
 
37°
 
09'
 
40"
 
and
longitude 81° 59' 13"
 
(Easting 984,100’, Northing 320,100’
 
– in the VA
 
State Plane South NAD
 
27 grid system).
The
 
nearest
 
major
 
population
 
centers
 
are
 
Roanoke,
 
Virginia,
 
and
 
Lexington,
 
Kentucky,
 
which
 
are
 
about
 
153
kilometers northeast
 
and 290
 
kilometers northwest
 
of the
 
property,
 
respectively.
 
From U.S.
 
Route 460,
 
which
runs
 
through
 
Oakwood,
 
a
 
well-developed
 
network
 
of
 
improved
 
and
 
unimproved
 
roads provides
 
access
 
to
 
the
property.
 
The surface facilities
 
at Buchanan are
 
located along a
 
Norfolk Southern rail
 
line, which serves
 
as the
primary means
 
of transport for
 
produced coal.
 
Norfolk Southern transports
 
coal from
 
the Buchanan mine
 
complex
either
 
to
 
domestic
 
customers
 
or
 
to
 
Lamberts
 
Point
 
Coal
 
Terminal
 
Pier
 
6
 
in
 
Norfolk,
 
Virginia,
 
for
 
overseas
shipment.
Buchanan
 
has
 
ready
 
access
 
to water,
 
electricity
 
and
 
personnel
 
to
 
support
 
its operations.
 
The
 
mine
 
complex
sources water from streams that
 
flow over Company-owned property.
 
The mine also utilizes ground
 
water from
an old, abandoned mine.
 
Electricity is sourced from American Electric Power.
 
Personnel have historically been
sourced
 
from
 
the
 
surrounding
 
communities
 
in
 
Buchanan,
 
Tazewell,
 
McDowell
 
and
 
Pike
 
Counties
 
and
 
have
proven to be adequate in numbers
 
to operate the mine complex.
 
As mining is common in the surrounding
 
areas,
the workforce is generally familiar with mining practices,
 
and many are experienced miners.
 
The property mineral rights are composed of approximately 33,578 total hectares, of which 25,853 are leased or
subleased from private landholders under approximately 150 individual coal lease tracts, and
 
7,725 hectares are
owned by Coronado.
 
Subject to Coronado’s exercising
 
its renewal rights thereunder,
 
all the leases expire upon
exhaustion of the relevant coal reserves, which is expected
 
to occur in 2042.
 
Under the
 
terms of
 
the relevant
 
leases, we
 
are required
 
to pay
 
royalties ranging
 
from 4%
 
to 6%
 
of the
 
selling
price
 
of
 
coal
 
mined
 
from
 
the
 
corresponding
 
leasehold
 
and,
 
for
 
the
 
majority,
 
an
 
annual
 
minimum
 
royalty,
irrespective of
 
production.
 
Coal produced
 
at Buchanan,
 
however,
 
is not
 
subject
 
to “wheelage
 
fees”
 
(i.e., fees
payable on coal
 
mined and
 
removed from properties
 
other than
 
the particular
 
leasehold and hauled
 
across the
leasehold premises).
The
 
property
 
was
 
formerly
 
controlled
 
by
 
Consolidation
 
Coal
 
Company,
 
or
 
CONSOL.
 
Mine
 
development
 
was
started by
 
CONSOL
 
in 1983
 
and longwall
 
production
 
began in
 
1987.
 
Coronado
 
acquired the
 
Buchanan Mine
from CONSOL in March 2016.
 
Production history has been approximately 4.4
 
MMt in 2021, 3.9 MMt
 
in 2022 and
3.6 MMt in 2023.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
78
Our right
 
to commercially
 
mine and
 
recover coal
 
reserves at
 
Buchanan overlaps
 
with the
 
right of
 
an affiliate
 
of
CNX Resources Corporation, which we refer to as the Gas Party,
 
to commercially recover and develop coal gas
interests
 
from
 
the
 
mine
 
area.
 
The
 
Gas
 
Party
 
and
 
we
 
have
 
entered
 
into
 
certain
 
agreements
 
to
 
regulate
 
the
interaction between, and coordinate, our
 
respective operations.
 
In general, the combination of
 
these overlapping
interests allows
 
for mutual
 
benefits to
 
the parties,
 
namely,
 
the degassing
 
of our
 
coal mining
 
operations
 
in
 
the
mine, which helps assure the safety of mine
 
personnel, and the Gas Party’s
 
commercial capture and sale of the
coal gas.
 
In addition, the Gas Party’s drilling activities have contributed to exploration efforts with respect to coal
deposits at Buchanan.
 
As the only natural gas supplier in
 
the area, we purchase our requirements of
 
natural gas
for the operation of our thermal dryer at Buchanan from
 
the Gas Party.
 
Before
 
Coronado
 
took
 
over
 
mining
 
operations
 
at
 
Buchanan,
 
CONSOL
 
Energy
 
had
 
conducted
 
extensive
exploration of the property.
 
We have continued
 
exploration at the property
 
through a program of
 
core drilling to
confirm reserves, establish additional resources
 
and assess the geotechnical viability of mining.
 
Buchanan
 
produces
 
primarily
 
a
 
Low-Vol
 
HCC,
 
but
 
it
 
also
 
produces
 
a
 
premium
 
Low-Vol
 
PCI
 
product.
 
The
Buchanan mine
 
extracts coal
 
from the
 
Pocahontas #3
 
seam of
 
the Pennsylvanian-age
 
Pocahontas Formation,
which is the principal minable coal seam
 
of that formation.
 
The seam is situated below drainage
 
throughout the
Property and is accessed by vertical shafts.
 
The seam thickness averages 1.57 meters within the mining
 
area.
 
The Buchanan
 
mine currently
 
extracts
 
coal using
 
a single
 
longwall system
 
supported by
 
six continuous
 
miner
sections,
 
which
 
develop
 
main
 
entries
 
and
 
gate
 
roads
 
in
 
preparation
 
for
 
the
 
longwall.
 
Each
 
continuous
 
miner
section is equipped with
 
one or two
 
continuous miners, two roof
 
bolters and two or
 
three coal haulage units.
 
After
extraction, a series
 
of conveyor
 
belts deliver raw
 
coal to an
 
underground storage
 
bunker.
 
The Buchanan
 
mine
complex uses a skip
 
hoist system to
 
lift raw coal to
 
the surface.
 
Buchanan has a
 
CPP that processes
 
raw coal
at a rate of approximately 1,270 raw tph, as well as the other necessary support infrastructure, including loadout
and portal facilities.
Generally,
 
the mining
 
equipment
 
and facilities
 
at Buchanan
 
are in
 
good operating
 
condition.
 
We focus
 
on the
long-term potential of
 
the mine complex and
 
regularly monitor developments in
 
the mining industry for
 
technology
improvements and
 
new equipment
 
that could
 
help us
 
increase efficiency
 
and lower
 
our costs.
 
Since acquiring
the Buchanan
 
operations,
 
we have
 
implemented
 
improvements
 
at the
 
CPP,
 
which
 
have resulted
 
in increased
capacity.
 
From
 
time
 
to
 
time,
 
we
 
also
 
update
 
and
 
improve
 
other
 
equipment
 
and
 
facilities
 
to
 
maintain
 
their
usefulness
 
and
 
optimize
 
our
 
competitiveness.
 
For
 
example, we
 
rebuild
 
our longwall
 
shear,
 
drives
 
and cycling
shields after every panel. We
 
have also entered into life
 
cycle management agreements for our
 
continuous miner
equipment, installed programmable logic controller,
 
or PLC, controls on the skip hoist system, upgraded our belt
drives for increased horsepower, deployed state-of-the-art Fletcher roof
 
bolters on our continuous miner
 
sections
and switched
 
to
 
PLC
 
control
 
systems
 
and variable
 
frequency
 
drive,
 
or VFD,
 
starters
 
on our
 
belt
 
drives.
 
As
 
of
December 31, 2023, the book value of Buchanan and its
 
associated plant and equipment was $464.7 million.
We are not
 
aware of any
 
significant encumbrances
 
or defects in
 
title with respect
 
to the Property.
 
Additionally,
we believe we have
 
obtained all requisite
 
mining and discharge
 
permits to conduct
 
our operations at Buchanan
and expect to
 
be able to
 
obtain all required
 
permits in the
 
future. The
 
Buchanan mine complex
 
holds one state
permit, with the associated NPDES permit.
 
Buchanan is
 
subject to
 
a federal
 
black lung
 
excise tax
 
of $1.21
 
per ton
 
for underground
 
mining and
 
a federal
reclamation tax of $0.13 per ton
 
for underground mining.
 
However, the federal black lung excise tax applies only
with respect
 
to coal
 
sold domestically.
 
Additionally,
 
Buchanan is
 
subject to
 
a Virginia
 
reclamation tax
 
of $0.05
per ton (which amount is contributed to a state-funded bond pool) and a Virginia severance tax of 2% for all coal
sold. See
 
Item 1.
 
“Business—Regulatory
 
Matters—United States”
 
for a
 
discussion of
 
the permitting
 
conditions
applicable to Buchanan.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
79
Summaries of Buchanan’s coal resources and reserves as of December 31,
 
2023 and 2022 are shown in Tables
6 and 7, respectively.
Table
 
6.
 
Buchanan –
 
Summary of
 
Coal Resources
 
Exclusive of
 
Reserves at
 
the End
 
of the
 
Fiscal Year
Ended December 31, 2023 and 2022.
(1)
 
Coal Resources (Dry Tons, In Situ, MMt)
(2)(3)
Quality (Air-Dried Basis)
Measured
Indicated
Measured
+
Indicated
Inferred
Ash
Sulfur
Volatile
Matter
December 31, 2023
31
4
35
—
16.0%
0.8%
18.0%
December 31, 2022
34
6
40
—
25.0%
0.7%
16.0%
(1)
 
Pricing for
 
resources is
 
described in
 
Section 11.3.1
 
of the
 
Buchanan TRS
 
(as defined
 
below).
 
Based on
 
assumed long-term
average price of $110 per Mt (FOB loadout) for Buchanan
 
resources as of December 31,
 
2022 and $143 per Mt (FOB
 
loadout) for
resources at
 
December 31,
 
2023, representing the
 
long-term average price
 
forecast for
 
Buchanan based on
 
independent price
forecasts.
(2)
 
Exclusive of reserve
 
tons. Table
 
1-1 of the
 
Buchanan TRS provides
 
a summary of
 
Buchanan resource tons
 
inclusive of reserve
tons as of December 31, 2023.
(3)
 
Reported on a dry basis.
 
Surface moisture and inherent moisture are excluded.
(4)
 
Some numerical figures in the
 
above table have been subject
 
to rounding adjustments. Accordingly,
 
numerical figures shown as
totals may not equal the sum of the figures that
 
precede them.
Table
 
7.
 
Buchanan – Summary
 
of Coal Reserves
 
(Marketable Sales Basis)
 
at the End of
 
the Fiscal Year
Ended December 31, 2023 and 2022.
(1)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet
Tons, Washed
or Direct Shipped, MMt)
(2)
Quality (Air-Dried Basis)
Proven
Probable
Total
Ash
Sulfur
Volatile
Matter
December 31, 2023
87
5
92
6.0%
0.7%
20.0%
December 31, 2022
88
5
93
6.0%
0.7%
19.0%
(1)
 
Pricing data as provided
 
by Coronado is described
 
in Section 16.2 of
 
the Buchanan TRS.
 
For Buchanan reserves as
 
of December
31, 2022, the pricing data assumes a weighted average domestic and
 
international FOB-mine price of approximately $179 per Mt
for calendar
 
year 2023;
 
the weighted
 
average price
 
decreases to
 
approximately $132
 
to
 
$143
 
per Mt
 
through year
 
2027 and
averages approximately $153 per Mt over the LOM.
 
For Buchanan reserves as of December 31, 2023, the pricing data assumes
a weighted average domestic
 
and international FOB-mine
 
price of approximately
 
$172 per Mt for
 
calendar year 2024;
 
the weighted
average price decreases to approximately $138 to $145 per Mt through year 2028 and averages approximately $173 per Mt over
the LOM.
(2)
 
Reported on a 6.0% moisture basis.
(3)
 
Some numerical figures in the
 
above table have been subject
 
to rounding adjustments. Accordingly,
 
numerical figures shown as
totals may not equal the sum of the figures that
 
precede them.
From
 
December
 
31,
 
2022
 
to
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
total
 
reserves
 
decreased
 
approximately
 
1%,
 
from
approximately
 
93.0
 
MMt
 
to
 
approximately
 
92.0
 
MMt.
 
This
 
net
 
reduction
 
of
 
1.0
 
MMt
 
of
 
total
 
reserves
 
was
attributable to
 
a combination
 
of updates
 
to the
 
mine plan
 
along with
 
one year
 
of mining
 
depletion. A
 
TRS with
respect to Buchanan, updating the TRS with respect
 
to Buchanan filed with Coronado’s Annual
 
Report on Form
10-K for the
 
year ended December
 
31, 2022, was
 
prepared in February
 
2024 due to
 
material differences
 
in the
key financial modifying factors, including mining plans, coal sales price assumptions, operating costs and capital
costs from December 31,
 
2022 to December 31,
 
2023. Mining plans
 
are discussed in Section
 
13 of the Buchanan
TRS. Coal sales price assumptions underlying the reserve estimates are discussed in Sections
 
12 and 16 of the
Buchanan
 
TRS,
 
while
 
operating
 
costs
 
and
 
capital
 
costs
 
assumptions
 
underlying
 
the
 
reserve
 
estimates
 
are
discussed in Sections 18 and 19
 
of the Buchanan TRS.
 
The differences in the key financial modifying factors
 
did
not have
 
a material
 
impact
 
on the
 
reserve
 
estimates
 
from
 
December
 
31,
 
2022 to
 
December
 
31,
 
2023.
 
From
December 31,
 
2022 to
 
December 31, 2023,
 
measured and
 
indicated resources decreased
 
by approximately 13%,
due to conversion of a
 
portion of the resources
 
to reserves.
 
Updated financial inputs, including
 
coal sales price
assumptions and
 
operating and
 
capital costs
 
used in
 
estimating the
 
resources exclusive of
 
reserves, as
 
discussed
in Section
 
11.3
 
of the Buchanan
 
TRS, did
 
not have
 
a material
 
impact on the
 
measured and
 
indicated resource
estimates
 
as
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
as
 
compared
 
to
 
the
 
measured
 
and
 
indicated
 
resource
 
estimates
 
as
 
of
December 31, 2022.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
80
Marshall Miller
 
& Associates,
 
Inc., a
 
third-party
 
firm comprising
 
mining
 
experts, whom
 
we refer
 
to as
 
the U.S.
QPs, prepared the estimates
 
of coal resources and reserves
 
as of December 31, 2023
 
summarized in Tables
 
6
and 7.
 
A copy of the U.S. QPs’ TRS with respect to Buchanan, dated as of February 16, 2024, or the Buchanan
TRS, is filed as Exhibit 96.2 hereto. The U.S. QPs are
 
not affiliated with Coronado.
The
 
U.S.
 
QPs
 
prepared
 
the
 
estimates
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
using
 
core
 
drilling
 
data
 
available
 
from
exploration
 
activities
 
at
 
Buchanan
 
conducted
 
by
 
numerous
 
entities
 
over
 
time.
 
Most
 
of
 
this
 
information
 
was
obtained
 
prior
 
to
 
our
 
acquisition
 
of
 
the
 
property,
 
using
 
varying
 
drilling
 
and
 
core-logging
 
techniques,
 
survey
methods and testing
 
procedures.
 
As a result,
 
in verifying the
 
data, the U.S.
 
QPs made certain
 
assumptions about
the adequacy of the
 
processes performed and
 
comparability of the data
 
based on their professional
 
experience
and familiarity with Buchanan.
 
Per
 
Section
 
12.1
 
of
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
TRS,
 
coal
 
reserves
 
were
 
classified
 
as
 
proven
 
or
 
probable
 
considering
“modifying
 
factors,”
 
including
 
mining,
 
metallurgical,
 
economic,
 
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
 
social
 
and
governmental factors.
 
Section 22.2
 
of the
 
Buchanan TRS includes
 
a risk
 
assessment of the
 
key modifying factors
that could potentially impact the operations and therefore the
 
estimate of coal reserves and resources.
 
As summarized in Section 7.1 in
 
the Buchanan TRS, the U.S. QPs utilized 15,725
 
available core, rotary, channel
samples,
 
mine
 
measurements
 
and
 
coalbed
 
methane
 
wells
 
on
 
and
 
around
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
property.
 
Points
 
of
observation include exploration
 
drill holes, degas
 
holes, and mine
 
measurements, which have
 
been fully vetted
and
 
processed
 
into
 
a
 
geologic
 
model.
 
The
 
geologic
 
model
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
seam
 
depositional
 
modeling,
 
the
interrelationship
 
of
 
overlying
 
and
 
underlying
 
strata
 
on
 
seam
 
mineability,
 
seam
 
thickness
 
trends, the
 
impact
 
of
seam structure (i.e., faulting), intra-seam
 
characteristics, etc.
 
The U.S. QPs completed a geostatistical
 
analysis
on
 
drill
 
holes
 
within
 
the
 
reserve
 
boundaries
 
to
 
determine
 
the
 
applicability
 
of
 
the
 
common
 
United
 
States
classification system
 
for measured
 
and indicated
 
coal resources.
 
Historically,
 
the United
 
States has
 
assumed
that coal within 0.4 kilometers of a point of observation
 
represents a measured resource, whereas coal
 
between
0.4 kilometers
 
and 1.2
 
kilometers from
 
a point
 
of observation
 
is classified
 
as indicated.
 
Inferred resources
 
are
commonly assumed
 
to be
 
located between
 
1.2 kilometers
 
and 4.8
 
kilometers from
 
a point
 
of observation.
 
The
U.S. QPs performed a geostatistical
 
analysis of the Buchanan data set
 
using the Drill Hole Spacing Analysis,
 
or
DHSA, method. DHSA prescribes that measured, indicated and inferred drill hole spacings be determined at the
10%, 20%,
 
and 50%
 
levels of
 
relative
 
error,
 
respectively.
 
Comparing
 
the results
 
of the
 
DHSA to
 
the historical
standards, it
 
is evident
 
that the
 
historical standards are
 
more conservative
 
than even the
 
most conservative DHSA
model
 
with
 
regards
 
to
 
determining
 
measured
 
resources.
 
The
 
Exponential
 
model
 
included
 
in
 
the
 
DHSA
recommends using
 
a radius
 
of 0.67
 
kilometers for
 
measured resources
 
compared to
 
the historical
 
value of
 
0.4
kilometers. With
 
respect to
 
indicated resources
 
the DHSA falls
 
in line closely
 
with the historical
 
standards. The
Exponential and
 
Spherical
 
models of
 
the DHSA
 
recommend
 
using a
 
radius
 
of 1.08
 
kilometers
 
from
 
a point
 
of
observation for
 
indicated resources,
 
while the
 
Gaussian model
 
included in
 
the DHSA
 
recommends a
 
radius of
1.10 kilometers from
 
a point of
 
observation for indicated
 
resources. These values
 
line up
 
closely with
 
the historical
radius
 
of
 
1.2
 
kilometers.
 
These
 
results
 
have
 
led
 
the
 
U.S.
 
QPs
 
to
 
report
 
the
 
data
 
following
 
the
 
historical
classification standards, rather than use the results of the DHSA.
Coal quality is
 
instrumental in determining
 
the viability of
 
a coal deposit.
 
Per Section 8.2
 
of the Buchanan
 
TRS,
coal
 
quality
 
conforms
 
to
 
the
 
American
 
Society
 
for
 
Testing
 
and
 
Materials,
 
or
 
ASTM,
 
standards.
 
These
 
quality
attributes aided
 
in converting
 
dry,
 
in-place tons
 
to demonstrated
 
coal reserves
 
(recoverable washed
 
tons). The
reserve and resource
 
criteria are presented
 
in Table
 
11-1
 
of the Buchanan
 
TRS, including assumptions
 
related
to seam density, minimum
 
cut-off thickness, and recoveries.
 
Regarding production
 
rates as
 
described in
 
Section 13.2
 
of the Buchanan
 
TRS, the
 
mine plan
 
and productivity
expectations
 
reflect
 
historical
 
performance
 
and
 
efforts
 
have
 
been
 
made
 
to
 
adjust
 
the
 
plan
 
to
 
reflect
 
future
conditions.
 
Mine development and operation have not been
 
optimized within the Buchanan TRS.
 
Logan
Coronado’s Logan property is
 
currently in the
 
production stage.
 
Logan consists of four
 
active underground mines
and supporting
 
infrastructure that
 
produce High-Volatile
 
Met coal
 
using the
 
room and
 
pillar mining
 
method and
two
 
active
 
surface
 
mines
 
(Toney
 
Fork
 
and
 
Elklick)
 
and
 
supporting
 
infrastructure
 
that
 
produce
 
both
 
Met
 
and
thermal coal using
 
the contour
 
and highwall
 
mining methods.
 
Underground mine
 
operations were
 
active during
2023 at
 
the
 
Lower
 
War
 
Eagle,
 
Eagle
 
No.
 
1
 
and
 
Muddy
 
Bridge
 
Mines
 
with
 
three,
 
three
 
and
 
two
 
active
 
mining
sections, respectively.
 
The North Fork Winifrede Mine was active but was fully depleted in 2023.
 
The Powellton
No. 1
 
Mine
 
was
 
in
 
the
 
process
 
of being
 
rehabilitated
 
and had
 
minimal
 
production
 
during the
 
fourth
 
quarter
 
of
2023, with plans to initiate
 
full production with one mining
 
section in the first quarter
 
of 2024.
 
The Logan complex
life plan includes
 
13 proposed mines,
 
consisting of ten
 
underground mines and
 
three surface mines.
 
The property
is located in Boone,
 
Logan and Wyoming
 
Counties in southern
 
West Virginia.
 
The surface facilities
 
are located
in Logan County,
 
West Virginia.
 
A map of Logan is shown in Figure 5.
c561202310Kp81i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
81
Figure 5.
 
Coronado Logan Mine Complex Property Location Map.
The Logan
 
mine complex
 
encompasses the
 
towns of
 
Lorado and
 
Pardee in
 
Logan County,
 
West Virginia,
 
and
Cyclone and Lacoma in Wyoming County,
 
West Virginia. The coordinates
 
of the Saunders CPP are latitude
 
37°
47' 58" and longitude 81° 40' 01" (Easting 1,806,880’, Northing
 
291,517’ – in the WV State Plane South NAD 27
grid system). The nearest
 
major population centers are
 
Huntington, West Virginia, and Charleston,
 
West Virginia,
which are about 145 kilometers northwest and 129 kilometers northeast of the property, respectively.
 
From U.S.
Route
 
119,
 
which
 
runs
 
through
 
Mingo,
 
Logan
 
and
 
Boone
 
Counties
 
to
 
the
 
north,
 
a
 
well-developed
 
network
 
of
improved and
 
unimproved roads
 
provides access
 
to the
 
property,
 
including Route
 
16 and
 
Route 10,
 
which run
east-west across the property in Logan County and Wyoming
 
County, respectively.
 
The Logan surface facilities
are located approximately 21 kilometers northeast
 
of Man, West Virginia, along
 
a CSX Corporation, or CSX, rail
line, which serves as
 
the primary means of
 
transport for produced
 
coal.
 
CSX transports coal from
 
Logan either
to domestic customers or to the Kinder Morgan Pier IX and
 
Dominion Terminals
 
in Norfolk, Virginia, for overseas
shipment.
Logan has
 
ready access
 
to water, electricity
 
and personnel
 
to support
 
its operations.
 
Buffalo Creek Public
 
Service
District supplies
 
water and
 
American Electric
 
Power supplies
 
electricity
 
to the
 
mine complex.
 
Mine personnel
generally live in the surrounding communities of Logan,
 
Boone, Wyoming and Mingo Counties in West
 
Virginia.
 
The
 
property
 
mineral
 
rights
 
are
 
composed
 
of
 
13,183
 
total
 
hectares,
 
13,114
 
of
 
which
 
are
 
leased
 
from
 
private
landholders
 
under
 
approximately
 
15
 
individual
 
leases,
 
and
 
69
 
hectares
 
are
 
owned
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
Subject
 
to
Coronado
 
exercising
 
its renewal
 
rights
 
thereunder,
 
a
 
majority
 
of
 
the
 
leases,
 
covering
 
a
 
majority
 
of
 
the
 
Logan
reserves, expire upon
 
exhaustion of the
 
relevant coal reserves,
 
which is expected
 
to occur in
 
2057.
 
One lease
expires in 2032; however,
 
Coronado is projected to have previously exhausted th
 
e
 
reserves covered thereby.
Under the terms of the leases, we are required to pay royalties ranging from 3.0% to 9.0%
 
of revenue from sales
of coal
 
produced depending
 
on mining
 
method. Certain
 
of the
 
leases also
 
provide for
 
“wheelage fees”
 
ranging
from 0.25% to 1.0%
 
of revenue from
 
sales of coal
 
mined and removed
 
from properties other
 
than the particular
leasehold and hauled across the leasehold premises.
The mining of
 
Logan was commenced in
 
1945 by Lorado
 
Mining Company, or Lorado. Lorado was
 
sold to Buffalo
Mining Company
 
in 1964
 
and then
 
to Pittston
 
Coal Company
 
in 1971.
 
Pittston operated
 
the property
 
until the
early 1990’s.
 
After being idle for
 
a period, the property
 
was then sold to
 
Addington Resources in
 
2004.
 
Imagin
Natural
 
Resources
 
acquired
 
the
 
property
 
in
 
2007
 
and
 
sold
 
it
 
to
 
Cliffs
 
Natural
 
Resources Inc.
 
(now
 
known
 
as
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.) in 2011,
 
which in turn sold
 
the property to Coronado
 
in 2014. Production history
 
has been
approximately 1.9 MMt in 2021, 2.1 MMt in 2022 and 2.5 MMt
 
in 2023.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
82
Before
 
Coronado
 
acquired
 
Logan,
 
previous
 
owners
 
had
 
conducted
 
extensive
 
exploration
 
on
 
the
 
property.
Coronado
 
has
 
continued
 
exploration
 
at
 
the
 
property
 
through
 
a
 
program
 
of
 
core
 
drilling
 
to
 
confirm
 
reserves,
establish additional resources and assess the geotechnical
 
viability of mining.
 
Logan
 
produces
 
primarily
 
High-Vol
 
Met
 
coal
 
(HVA
 
HCC
 
and
 
HVB
 
HCC),
 
mined
 
from
 
various
 
seams
 
of
 
the
Kanawha Formation. A few of the seams lie below drainage;
 
however, a substantial number of metallurgical coal
seams
 
are
 
situated
 
above
 
drainage.
 
Logan
 
also
 
produces
 
thermal
 
coal
 
from
 
upper
 
portions
 
of
 
the
 
Kanawha
Formation.
As of December
 
31, 2023, underground
 
mine operations
 
were active at
 
the Lower
 
War Eagle,
 
Eagle No. 1
 
and
Muddy
 
Bridge
 
Mines
 
with
 
three,
 
three
 
and
 
two
 
active
 
mining
 
sections,
 
respectively,
 
using
 
the
 
room-and-pillar
method.
 
The North Fork
 
Winifrede Mine was
 
fully depleted in
 
2023.
 
The Powellton No.
 
1 Mine was in
 
process
of
 
being
 
rehabilitated
 
and
 
had
 
minimal
 
production
 
during
 
the
 
fourth
 
quarter
 
of
 
2023,
 
with
 
plans
 
to
 
initiate
 
full
production with one mining section in the first quarter of
 
2024.
All sections of the active underground mines at Logan are configured as
 
full super sections, with two continuous
miners per
 
section.
 
Each section
 
also has
 
two roof
 
bolters, four
 
shuttle cars
 
and two
 
scoops.
 
From the
 
continuous
miner at the production face, the shuttle cars haul extracted coal to a feeder breaker, which transfers raw coal to
a conveyor
 
belt for
 
transport
 
to a
 
surface stockpile
 
holding area.
 
A shared
 
overland conveyor
 
carries raw
 
coal
from the Lower War
 
Eagle mine to a CPP.
 
Trucks haul raw
 
coal from the Eagle
 
No. 1 and North Fork
 
Winifrede
mines to the
 
CPP and
 
from the
 
Muddy Bridge
 
mine to
 
the Logan
 
overland conveyor.
 
The CPP has
 
a feed rate
capacity of 1,088 raw tph.
 
The CPP site includes raw coal storage, clean coal storage, a loadout connected to a
CSX rail line and refuse disposal area.
 
The
 
Toney
 
Fork
 
and
 
Elklick
 
surface
 
mines
 
extract
 
Met
 
and
 
thermal
 
coal
 
using
 
the
 
contour
 
and
 
area
 
mining
methods.
 
The
 
mines
 
use
 
spreads
 
of
 
front-end
 
loaders,
 
large
 
tractors/dozers
 
and
 
rock
 
trucks
 
to
 
remove
overburden and expose the coal. We
 
will deploy highwall mining when
 
overburden volumes exceed economical
stripping ratios associated with area and
 
contour mining. Trucks haul raw coal from Toney Fork and Elklick to the
CPP site for cleaning or to the loading site to be shipped
 
directly to customers.
Our
 
current
 
plans
 
at
 
Logan
 
contemplate
 
13
 
proposed
 
mines,
 
consisting
 
of
 
ten
 
underground
 
mines
 
and
 
three
surface mines,
 
including the
 
six mines
 
currently in
 
operation.
 
The proposed
 
underground mines
 
would extract
coal using
 
the room
 
and pillar
 
mining method,
 
and the
 
proposed surface
 
mines would
 
extract coal
 
using area,
contour or highwall mining methods, or some combination thereof.
 
Generally,
 
the mining equipment
 
and facilities at Logan
 
are in good operating
 
condition.
 
We focus on the
 
long-
term
 
potential
 
of
 
the
 
mine
 
complex
 
and
 
regularly
 
monitor
 
developments
 
in
 
the
 
mining
 
industry
 
for
 
technology
improvements
 
and
 
new
 
equipment
 
that
 
could
 
help
 
us increase
 
efficiency
 
and
 
lower
 
our costs.
 
Logan’s
 
oldest
mining
 
equipment
 
and
 
facilities,
 
including
 
the
 
CPP
 
and
 
loadout
 
facility,
 
began
 
operations
 
in
 
2008,
 
when
 
the
Powellton
 
No.
 
1
 
mine
 
started
 
production.
 
Since
 
acquiring
 
the
 
Logan
 
operations,
 
we
 
have
 
implemented
improvements
 
at the
 
CPP,
 
which have
 
resulted in
 
increased capacity.
 
From time
 
to time,
 
we also
 
update and
improve
 
other
 
equipment
 
and
 
facilities
 
to
 
maintain
 
their
 
usefulness
 
and
 
optimize
 
our
 
competitiveness.
 
As
 
of
December 31, 2023, the book value of Logan and its associated
 
plant and equipment was $244.1 million.
 
We are
 
not aware
 
of any significant
 
encumbrances or
 
defects in title
 
with respect
 
to the property.
 
Additionally,
we believe we have obtained all requisite
 
mining and discharge permits to conduct
 
our operations at Logan and
expect to be
 
able to obtain
 
or renew all
 
required permits
 
in the future.
 
The Logan
 
mine complex holds
 
27 state
permits with associated NPDES permits.
 
Logan is subject to a federal black lung excise tax of $1.21 per ton for underground mining and $0.61 per ton for
surface and highwall mining; however, this
 
tax applies only with respect to coal sold domestically.
 
Logan is also
subject to a
 
federal reclamation
 
fee of $0.13
 
per ton
 
for underground
 
mining and
 
$0.31 per ton
 
for surface
 
and
highwall mining.
 
Additionally,
 
Logan is subject to
 
a West Virginia
 
reclamation tax of
 
$0.308 per ton and
 
a West
Virginia severance
 
tax of
 
1.0% to
 
5.0% of
 
revenues for
 
all coal
 
produced. See
 
Item 1.
 
“Business—Regulatory
Matters—United States” for a discussion of the permitting
 
conditions applicable to Logan.
 
Summaries of Logan’s
 
coal resources and
 
reserves as of
 
December 31, 2023
 
and 2022 are
 
shown in Tables
 
8
and 9, respectively.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
83
Table 8.
 
Logan – Summary of Coal Resources Exclusive
 
of Reserves at the End of the
 
Fiscal Year Ended
December 31, 2023 and 2022.
(1)
Coal Resources (Dry Tons, In Situ, MMt)
(2)(3)
Quality (Air-Dried Basis)
Measured
Indicated
Measured
+
Indicated
Inferred
Ash
Sulfur
Volatile
Matter
December 31, 2023
39
36
75
3
17.0%
1.0%
31.0%
December 31, 2022
45
37
82
3
24.0%
1.0%
28.0%
(1)
 
Pricing for resources is described in Section
 
11.3.1 of the
 
Logan TRS (as defined below).
 
For Logan resources as of December
31,
 
2022,
 
based
 
on
 
assumed
 
long-term
 
average
 
price
 
of
 
$154
 
per
 
Mt
 
(FOB
 
loadout)
 
for
 
underground-mineable
 
resources,
representing the
 
long-term average price
 
forecast for
 
HVB provided by
 
Coronado; surface resources
 
were assessed
 
at a
 
sales
price of $83 per Mt (FOB loadout) based on estimated historical pricing for Coronado’s surface operations.
 
For Logan resources
as of December
 
31, 2023, based on
 
assumed long-term average price
 
of $154 per
 
Mt (FOB loadout)
 
for underground-mineable
resources, representing the long-term average
 
price forecast for HVB provided by
 
Coronado; surface resources were assessed
 
at
a sales price of $83 per Mt (FOB loadout)
 
based on estimated historical pricing for Coronado’s surface
 
operations.
(2)
 
Exclusive of reserve tons. Table 1-1 of the Logan TRS provides
 
a summary of Logan resource tons
 
inclusive of reserve tons as of
December 31, 2023.
(3)
 
Reported on a dry basis.
 
Surface moisture and inherent moisture are excluded.
(4)
 
Some numerical figures in the
 
above table have been subject
 
to rounding adjustments. Accordingly,
 
numerical figures shown as
totals may not equal the sum of the figures that
 
precede them.
Table 9.
 
Logan – Summary
 
of Coal Reserves
 
(Marketable Sales Basis)
 
at the End
 
of the
 
Fiscal Year Ended
December 31, 2023 and 2022.
(1)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet
Tons,
Washed or Direct Shipped, MMt)
(2)
Quality (Air-Dried Basis)
Proven
Probable
Total
Ash
Sulfur
Volatile
Matter
December 31, 2023
55
16
71
8.0%
0.9%
35.0%
December 31, 2022
53
17
71
8.0%
0.9%
36.0%
(1)
 
Pricing data as
 
provided by Coronado is
 
described in Section
 
16.2 of the
 
Logan TRS.
 
For Logan reserves
 
as of December
 
31,
2022, the pricing data
 
assumes respective HVA,
 
HVB and thermal FOB-mine prices
 
of approximately $192, $170, and
 
$227 per
Mt for calendar
 
year 2023. HVA,
 
HVB, and thermal
 
prices decrease to approximately
 
$151, $132, and $83
 
per Mt, respectively,
through year 2027, and then increase to $271, $237, and $150
 
per Mt, respectively, through year 2056. For Logan reserves as of
December 31, 2023, the pricing data assumes respective HVA,
 
HVB and thermal FOB-mine prices of approximately $162, $144,
and $120 per Mt for calendar year 2024.
 
HVA, HVB, and thermal prices respectively decrease to approximately $161, $143, and
$114 per Mt through year 2026, and then increase to $308, $273, and
 
$212 per Mt through year 2057.
(2)
 
Reported on a 4.5% - 6.0% moisture basis.
(3)
 
Some numerical figures in the
 
above table have been subject
 
to rounding adjustments. Accordingly,
 
numerical figures shown as
totals may not equal the sum of the figures that
 
precede them.
From December
 
31, 2022
 
to December
 
31, 2023,
 
total reserves
 
remain unchanged.
 
This consistent
 
number of
total
 
reserves
 
was
 
attributable
 
to
 
a
 
combination
 
of
 
updates
 
to
 
the
 
mine
 
plans,
 
including
 
conversion
 
of
 
select
resources to reserves, along with
 
one year of mining depletion.
 
A TRS with respect to Logan,
 
updating the TRS
with respect to Logan filed
 
with Coronado’s Annual Report on Form
 
10-K for the year ended
 
December 31, 2022,
was prepared
 
in February
 
2024 due to
 
material differences
 
in the key
 
financial modifying
 
factors including
 
coal
sales price
 
assumptions,
 
operating
 
costs
 
and
 
capital
 
costs
 
from
 
December
 
31,
 
2022, to
 
December
 
31,
 
2023.
Coal sales price assumptions underlying
 
the reserve estimates are discussed in
 
Sections 12 and 16
 
of the Logan
TRS,
 
while
 
operating
 
costs
 
and
 
capital
 
costs
 
assumptions
 
underlying
 
the
 
reserve
 
estimates
 
are
 
discussed
 
in
Sections
 
18
 
and
 
19
 
of the
 
Logan TRS.
 
The
 
differences
 
in
 
the
 
key
 
financial
 
modifying
 
factors
 
did
 
not
 
have
 
a
material impact on the reserve estimates
 
as of December 31, 2023, as compared
 
to the reserve estimates as of
December
 
31,
 
2022.
 
From
 
December
 
31,
 
2022,
 
to
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
measured
 
and
 
indicated
 
resources
decreased
 
by
 
approximately
 
8.5%,
 
from
 
approximately
 
82
 
MMt
 
to
 
75
 
MMt.
 
This
 
net
 
reduction
 
of
 
7
 
MMt
 
of
measured and indicated
 
mineral resources was
 
attributable to one
 
year of mining
 
depletion along with changes
to the mine
 
plan. Updated financial inputs,
 
including coal sales price
 
assumptions and operating and
 
capital costs
used
 
in
 
estimating
 
the
 
resources
 
exclusive
 
of
 
reserves,
 
including
 
conversion
 
of
 
resources
 
to
 
reserves,
 
as
discussed
 
in
 
Section
 
11.3
 
of
 
the
 
Logan
 
TRS,
 
did
 
not
 
have
 
a
 
material
 
impact
 
on
 
the
 
measured
 
and
 
indicated
resource estimates
 
as of December
 
31, 2023, as
 
compared to the
 
measured and
 
indicated resource
 
estimates
as of December 31, 2022.
Marshall Miller
 
& Associates,
 
Inc., a
 
third-party
 
firm comprising
 
mining
 
experts, whom
 
we refer
 
to as
 
the U.S.
QPs, prepared the estimates
 
of coal resources and reserves
 
as of December 31, 2023
 
summarized in Tables
 
8
and 9.
 
A copy of the U.S. QPs’ TRS with respect to Logan, dated as of February 16, 2024, or the Logan TRS, is
filed as Exhibit 96.3 hereto. The U.S. QPs are not affiliated
 
with Coronado.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
84
The
 
U.S.
 
QPs
 
prepared
 
the
 
estimates
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
using
 
core
 
drilling
 
data
 
available
 
from
exploration activities at Logan conducted by numerous
 
entities over time.
 
Most of this information was obtained
prior to
 
our acquisition
 
of the prop
 
erty,
 
using varying
 
drilling and
 
core-logging techniques,
 
survey methods
 
and
testing procedures.
 
As a
 
result, in
 
verifying the data,
 
the U.S.
 
QPs made
 
certain assumptions about
 
the adequacy
of the processes performed and comparability
 
of the data based on their
 
professional experience and familiarity
with Logan. Per Section 12.1 of the Logan TRS, coal reserves were
 
classified as proven or probable considering
“modifying
 
factors,”
 
including
 
mining,
 
metallurgical,
 
economic,
 
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
 
social
 
and
governmental factors.
 
Section 22.2
 
of the Logan
 
TRS includes
 
a risk
 
assessment of
 
the key
 
modifying factors
that could potentially impact the operations and therefore the
 
estimate of coal reserves and resources.
 
As summarized in Section 7.1 in the Logan TRS, the U.S. QPs utilized 1,133 available core, rotary, and gas well
drilling on and around
 
the Logan property. Mine data from active
 
underground mines was supplied to
 
supplement
the exploration
 
drillhole records,
 
by seam.
 
Points of
 
observation
 
include exploration
 
drill holes,
 
gas wells,
 
and
mine measurements, which have been fully vetted
 
and processed into a geologic model.
 
The geologic model is
based
 
on
 
seam
 
depositional
 
modeling,
 
the
 
interrelationship
 
of
 
overlying
 
and
 
underlying
 
strata
 
on
 
seam
mineability,
 
seam thickness
 
trends, the
 
impact of
 
seam structure
 
(i.e., faulting),
 
intra-seam characteristics,
 
etc.
 
The U.S.
 
QPs completed
 
a geostatistical
 
analysis on
 
drill holes
 
within the
 
reserve boundaries
 
to determine
 
the
applicability
 
of
 
the
 
common
 
United
 
States
 
classification
 
system
 
for
 
measured
 
and
 
indicated
 
coal
 
resources.
 
Historically, the United States has assumed that coal
 
within 0.4 kilometers of a point of observation represents a
measured
 
resource
 
whereas
 
coal
 
between
 
0.4
 
kilometers
 
and
 
1.2
 
kilometers
 
from
 
a
 
point
 
of
 
observation
 
is
classified as indicated.
 
Inferred resources are commonly assumed to be located
 
between 1.2 kilometers and 4.8
kilometers from a
 
point of observation.
 
The U.S. QPs
 
performed a geostatistical
 
analysis of the
 
Logan data
 
set
using the DHSA method.
 
DHSA prescribes measured,
 
indicated, and inferred drill
 
hole spacings be determined
at
 
the
 
10%,
 
20%,
 
and
 
50%
 
levels
 
of
 
relative
 
error,
 
respectively.
 
Comparing
 
the
 
results
 
of
 
the
 
DHSA
 
to
 
the
historical
 
standards,
 
it
 
is
 
evident
 
that
 
the
 
historical
 
standards
 
are
 
more
 
conservative
 
than
 
even
 
the
 
most
conservative
 
DHSA
 
model
 
with
 
regards
 
to
 
determining
 
measured
 
resources.
 
The
 
Exponential
 
and
 
Spherical
models recommend
 
using a radius
 
of 0.87 kilometers
 
for measured resources
 
compared to
 
the historical
 
value
of 0.4 kilometers.
 
With respect to indicated resources
 
the Spherical and Exponential
 
models recommend using
a radius of 1.53
 
kilometers.
 
The historical radius
 
of 1.2 kilometers
 
is therefore also
 
more conservative than
 
the
DHSA
 
results
 
for
 
indicated
 
resources.
 
These
 
results
 
have
 
led
 
the
 
U.S.
 
QPs
 
to
 
report
 
the
 
data
 
following
 
the
historical classification standards, rather than use the results
 
of the DHSA.
Coal quality is instrumental in determining
 
the viability of a coal deposit. Per
 
Section 8.2 of the Logan TRS, coal
quality
 
conforms
 
to
 
the
 
ASTM
 
standards.
 
These
 
quality
 
attributes
 
aided
 
in
 
converting
 
dry,
 
in-place
 
tons
 
to
demonstrated coal reserves (recoverable
 
washed tons). The
 
reserve and resource
 
criteria are presented in
 
Table
11-1
 
of
 
the
 
Logan
 
TRS,
 
including
 
assumptions
 
related
 
to
 
seam
 
density,
 
minimum
 
cut-off
 
thickness,
 
and
recoveries.
 
Pricing data as provided by Coronado is described
 
in Section 16.2 of the Logan TRS.
 
Regarding production
 
rates as
 
described in
 
Section 13.2
 
of the
 
Logan TRS,
 
the projected
 
underground mines
are set up similarly to the
 
four active underground operations as of December 31,
 
2023.
 
Each mine is scheduled
to operate one
 
to three production
 
sections.
 
All sections are
 
configured as full
 
super sections with
 
two continuous
miners per section.
 
Three surface resource areas
 
were modeled.
 
Mining operations are projected
 
to utilize area,
as well as contour,
 
mining methods.
 
The three areas
 
planned for highwall
 
mining are assumed
 
to be mined
 
by
a
 
contractor;
 
therefore,
 
the
 
contractor
 
costs
 
included
 
in
 
the
 
financial
 
model
 
assume
 
that
 
the
 
contractor
 
is
responsible for staffing
 
those operations along
 
with providing necessary equipment
 
capital. Spoil for
 
final highwall
reclamation is expected
 
to come from
 
strategic placement
 
of spoil on
 
pre-existing benches
 
by haul trucks
 
such
that they
 
are within
 
the push
 
distance of
 
the reclamation
 
dozer.
 
Additional information
 
regarding mine-specific
production factors can be found in Section 13.4 of the
 
Logan TRS.
 
Mon Valley
The Mon Valley mine
 
complex comprises three
 
development-stage mining properties, namely, Pangburn, Shaner
and Fallowfield,
 
each consisting
 
of a
 
proposed underground
 
mine that
 
would produce
 
High-Vol
 
Met coal
 
using
the room
 
and
 
pillar
 
mining
 
method.
 
The
 
preliminary
 
design
 
for
 
the
 
properties
 
also
 
includes
 
plans
 
for
 
surface
facilities
 
and
 
a
 
preparation
 
plant
 
for
 
each
 
mine.
 
The
 
properties
 
reside
 
in
 
Allegheny,
 
Washington
 
and
Westmoreland Counties in southwestern Pennsylvania.
 
The proposed facilities include
 
a barge loading
 
dock and
CSX rail loadout
 
on the Monongahela
 
River in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, which
 
would ship clean
 
coal from
all three mines to end customers.
 
A map of Mon Valley
 
is shown in Figure 6.
c561202310Kp85i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
85
Figure 6.
 
Coronado Mon Valley
 
Mine Complex Property Location Map.
Mon Valley is located
 
approximately 22.5 kilometers
 
southeast of
 
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, near
 
the communities
of Bentleyville,
 
Lockview,
 
Monongahela, Elizabeth,
 
Sutersville and
 
Irwin, Pennsylvania.
 
The coordinates
 
of the
proposed infrastructure are latitude 40° 15' 24" and longitude 79° 53' 50" (Easting
 
1,398,821’, Northing 343,480’
– in the PA State
 
Plane South NAD 27 grid system). From U.S. Interstate 70
 
and Pennsylvania Route 51, which
traverse
 
the
 
Fallowfield
 
and
 
Pangburn
 
areas,
 
respectively,
 
a
 
well-developed
 
network
 
of
 
improved
 
and
unimproved roads allows general access to the
 
property.
 
The Monongahela and Youghiogheny
 
Rivers also run
through the property.
 
The primary means of transport for produced coal would be by barge
 
on the Monongahela
River/Ohio River system.
 
Additionally,
 
a CSX rail line located
 
along the banks of the
 
Monongahela River would
provide another option for the shipment of coal.
Mon
 
Valley
 
has
 
sources
 
of
 
water,
 
power,
 
and
 
supplies
 
readily
 
available
 
for
 
use.
 
Personnel
 
in
 
the
 
area
 
have
historically
 
been
 
sourced
 
from
 
the
 
surrounding
 
communities
 
in
 
Allegheny,
 
Washington,
 
and
 
Westmoreland
Counties,
 
and
 
have
 
proven
 
to
 
be
 
adequate
 
in
 
numbers
 
to
 
operate
 
the
 
mines.
 
As
 
mining
 
is
 
common
 
in
 
the
surrounding areas, the
 
workforce is generally
 
familiar with mining
 
practices, and many are
 
experienced miners.
 
Water is expected to be sourced locally from a nearby public water sources or rivers.
 
Electricity is anticipated to
be
 
sourced
 
from
 
West
 
Penn
 
Power
 
or
 
Duquesne
 
Light.
 
The
 
service
 
industry
 
in
 
the
 
areas
 
surrounding
 
the
proposed mine complex has historically provided supplies,
 
equipment repairs and fabrication, etc.
 
The
 
property
 
mineral
 
rights
 
are
 
composed
 
of
 
41,615
 
total
 
hectares,
 
of
 
which
 
1,339
 
are
 
leased
 
from
 
private
landholders under two leases,
 
and 40,276 hectares are
 
owned by Coronado.
 
Subject to Coronado’s exercising
its renewal rights
 
thereunder,
 
both of the
 
leases expire
 
upon exhaustion
 
of the relevant
 
coal reserves,
 
which is
expected to occur in 2101.
 
A
 
predecessor
 
of
 
CONSOL
 
Energy
 
previously
 
controlled
 
the
 
properties.
 
We
 
acquired
 
the
 
properties
 
from
CONSOL Energy in March 2016 in connection with the
 
acquisition of the Buchanan property.
Before we acquired Mon Valley, CONSOL Energy had conducted extensive exploration of Mon Valley.
 
We have
continued
 
an
 
exploration
 
program
 
focused
 
on
 
defining
 
reserves
 
and
 
assessing
 
the
 
geotechnical
 
viability
 
of
mining.
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
is
 
capable
 
of
 
producing
 
primarily
 
a
 
High-Vol
 
Met
 
coal
 
from
 
the
 
Upper
 
Freeport
 
seam
 
of
 
the
Pennsylvania-age
 
Allegheny
 
Formation.
 
The
 
seam
 
is
 
situated
 
below
 
drainage
 
throughout
 
the
 
properties
 
and
would be
 
accessed with
 
slopes and
 
shafts.
 
The seam
 
thickness in
 
the projected
 
mining areas
 
averages 1.95
meters.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
86
Under our current
 
mine development
 
plans, production
 
would begin at
 
the Pangburn
 
mine in 2033,
 
followed by
the Shaner mine in
 
2039 and, finally, the Fallowfield mine in
 
2058.
 
The proposed Mon Valley underground mines
would use the room and pillar
 
mining method with limited pillaring
 
as to cause no subsidence.
 
Each mine would
have three
 
continuous
 
miner
 
sections,
 
with two
 
continuous
 
miners, two
 
roof bolters,
 
four shuttle
 
cars and
 
two
scoops per
 
section.
 
The shuttle
 
cars would
 
haul extracted
 
coal from
 
the production
 
face to
 
a feeder
 
breaker-
conveyor system, which
 
would carry raw
 
coal to a
 
surface stockpile
 
and CPP.
 
The CPPs and
 
surface facilities
would have large
 
raw and clean
 
coal storage areas
 
to facilitate efficient
 
loading of clean
 
coal into barges
 
or rail
cars for transport.
 
We have
 
not yet completed
 
detailed designs
 
of the infrastructure
 
or surface
 
facilities for
 
the
proposed Shaner and Fallowfield mines.
As of December 31, 2023, the book value of Mon
 
Valley was $17.5 million.
We are not aware of any significant encumbrances or defects in title with respect to the properties. However,
 
we
will be required to obtain alternate
 
zoning approval from the local township. Further, we will be required
 
to submit
formal permit
 
applications
 
to state
 
or federal
 
regulatory
 
agencies.
 
Although we
 
have commenced
 
the work
 
to
obtain the
 
necessary
 
permits and
 
zoning variances,
 
we are
 
aware that
 
the period
 
of time
 
necessary
 
to obtain
final authorizations,
 
for purposes
 
of commencing
 
the development,
 
construction and
 
ultimate production
 
at the
proposed mine site, may be significant, and there can be no assurance that we can obtain the necessary zoning
and
 
permits.
 
See
 
Item
 
1.
 
“Business—Regulatory
 
Matters—United
 
States”
 
for
 
a
 
discussion
 
of
 
the
 
permitting
conditions applicable to Mon Valley.
 
Coal mined from the
 
Mon Valley
 
mine complex would
 
be subject to a
 
federal black lung
 
excise tax of
 
$1.21 per
ton for underground mining and a
 
federal reclamation tax of $0.13 per ton
 
for underground mining.
 
However, the
federal black lung excise tax will only apply with respect
 
to coal sold domestically.
Mon Valley contains no resources exclusive of reserve tons as of
 
December 31, 2023 and 2022. Table 1-1 of the
Mon Valley
 
TRS (as
 
defined below)
 
provides a summary
 
of Mon Valley
 
resource tons
 
inclusive of
 
reserve tons
as of December 31, 2023.
A summary of Mon Valley’s
 
coal reserves as of December 31, 2023 and 2022 is shown
 
in Table
 
10.
Table 10.
 
Mon Valley – Summary of Coal Reserves (Marketable Sales Basis) at the
 
End of the Fiscal Year
Ended December 31, 2023 and 2022.
(1)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet
Tons, Washed
or Direct Shipped, MMt)
(2)
Quality (Air-Dried Basis)
Proven
Probable
Total
Ash
Sulfur
Volatile
Matter
December 31, 2023
78
57
134
8.0%
1.2%
(3)
35.0%
December 31, 2022
78
57
134
8.0%
1.2%
35.0%
 
(1)
 
Pricing data as
 
provided by
 
Coronado is described
 
in Section 16.2
 
of the
 
Mon Valley TRS. For
 
Mon Valley reserves as
 
of December
31,
 
2022,
 
the
 
pricing
 
data
 
assumes
 
HVB
 
domestic
 
and
 
export
 
FOB-mine
 
prices
 
of
 
approximately
 
$130
 
and
 
$114
 
per
 
Mt,
respectively,
 
for
 
calendar
 
year
 
2028;
 
HVB
 
domestic
 
and
 
export
 
prices
 
increase
 
to
 
approximately
 
$208
 
and
 
$178
 
per
 
Mt,
respectively, through year 2050, and
 
then increased by 2% annual inflation thereafter.
 
For Mon Valley reserves as
 
of December
31, 2023, the pricing data assumes
 
a blended HVB domestic and
 
export FOB-mine nominal price
 
of $164 per Mt for calendar
 
year
2029; HVB domestic and export prices respectively
 
are increased by 2% annual inflation thereafter.
(2)
 
Reported on a 6.0% moisture basis.
(3)
 
LOM sulfur for Pangburn is an estimated 1.2%; however, overall Mon
 
Valley Complex reserve average is 1.4% sulfur.
(4)
 
Some numerical figures in the
 
above table have been subject
 
to rounding adjustments. Accordingly,
 
numerical figures shown as
totals may not equal the sum of the figures that
 
precede them.
Total
 
reserves
 
did
 
not
 
change
 
from
 
December
 
31,
 
2022,
 
to
 
December
 
31,
 
2023.
 
A
 
TRS
 
with
 
respect
 
to
 
Mon
Valley,
 
updating the TRS
 
with respect to
 
Mon Valley
 
filed with Coronado’s
 
Annual Report on
 
Form 10-K
 
for the
year ended December 31, 2022,
 
was prepared in February
 
2024 due to material differences
 
in the key financial
modifying factors
 
including coal sales
 
price assumptions,
 
operating costs
 
and capital
 
costs from
 
December 31,
2022, to
 
December
 
31,
 
2023.
 
Coal
 
sales
 
price
 
assumptions
 
are
 
discussed
 
in
 
Sections
 
12
 
and
 
16
 
of
 
the
 
Mon
Valley TRS, while operating costs and capital costs are discussed in Sections 18 and 19 of the Mon Valley
 
TRS.
Marshall
 
Miller
 
&
 
Associates,
 
Inc.,
 
a
 
third-party
 
firm
 
comprising
 
mining,
 
whom
 
we
 
refer
 
to
 
as
 
the
 
U.S.
 
QPs,
prepared the estimates of coal reserves summarized in Tables
 
10.
 
A copy of the U.S. QPs’ TRS with respect to
Mon Valley
 
(Pennsylvania Upper Freeport
 
Holdings), dated as
 
of February 16,
 
2024, or the Mon
 
Valley
 
TRS, is
filed as Exhibit 96.4 hereto. The U.S. QPs are not affiliated
 
with Coronado.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
87
The
 
U.S.
 
QPs
 
prepared
 
the
 
estimates
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
using
 
core
 
drilling
 
data
 
available
 
from
exploration
 
activities
 
at
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
conducted
 
by
 
numerous
 
entities
 
over
 
time.
 
Most
 
of
 
this
 
information
 
was
obtained
 
prior
 
to
 
our
 
acquisition
 
of
 
the
 
Property,
 
using
 
varying
 
drilling
 
and
 
core-logging
 
techniques,
 
survey
methods and testing
 
procedures.
 
As a result,
 
in verifying the
 
data, the U.S.
 
QPs made certain
 
assumptions about
the adequacy of the
 
processes performed and
 
comparability of the data
 
based on their professional
 
experience
and familiarity with Mon Valley.
 
Per
 
Section
 
12.1
 
of
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
TRS,
 
coal
 
reserves
 
were
 
classified
 
as
 
proven
 
or
 
probable
 
considering
“modifying
 
factors,”
 
including
 
mining,
 
metallurgical,
 
economic,
 
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
 
social
 
and
governmental
 
factors.
 
Section
 
22.2
 
of
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
TRS
 
includes
 
a
 
risk
 
assessment
 
of
 
the
 
key
 
modifying
factors that could potentially impact the operations and therefore the
 
estimate of coal reserves and resources.
 
As summarized
 
in Section
 
7.1 in
 
the Mon
 
Valley
 
TRS, the
 
U.S. QPs
 
utilized approximately
 
750 available
 
core
and rotary holes
 
on and around
 
the Mon Valley
 
properties. Points of
 
observation include exploration
 
drill holes,
degas holes, and mine measurements,
 
which have been fully vetted and processed
 
into a geologic model.
 
The
geologic model is based
 
on seam depositional
 
modeling, the interrelationship
 
of overlying and underlying
 
strata
on
 
seam
 
mineability,
 
seam
 
thickness
 
trends,
 
the
 
impact
 
of
 
seam
 
structure
 
(i.e.
 
faulting),
 
intra-seam
characteristics, etc.
 
The U.S. QPs
 
completed a geostatistical
 
analysis on drill
 
holes within the
 
reserve boundaries
to determine the applicability of the
 
common United States classification system for measured and
 
indicated coal
resources.
 
Historically,
 
the United States
 
has assumed that
 
coal within 0.4
 
kilometers of a
 
point of observation
represents
 
a
 
measured
 
resource
 
whereas
 
coal
 
between
 
0.4
 
kilometer
 
and
 
1.2
 
kilometers
 
from
 
a
 
point
 
of
observation
 
is
 
classified
 
as
 
indicated.
 
Inferred
 
resources
 
are
 
commonly
 
assumed
 
to
 
be
 
located
 
between
 
1.2
kilometers and
 
4.8 kilometers
 
from a point
 
of observation.
 
The U.S.
 
QPs performed
 
a geostatistical
 
analysis of
the Pennsylvania data set
 
using the DHSA method.
 
DHSA prescribes measured, indicated, and inferred
 
drill hole
spacings
 
be
 
determined
 
at
 
the
 
10-percent,
 
20-percent,
 
and
 
50-percent
 
levels
 
of
 
relative
 
error,
 
respectively.
Comparing the results of the DHSA to the historical standards, it is evident that
 
the historical standards are more
conservative than
 
even the
 
most conservative
 
DHSA model
 
with regards
 
to determining
 
measured resources.
 
The
 
Gaussian
 
and
 
Spherical
 
models
 
recommend
 
using
 
a
 
radius
 
of
 
0.72
 
kilometers
 
for
 
measured
 
resources
compared to
 
the historical
 
value of
 
0.4 kilometers.
 
With respect
 
to indicated
 
resources
 
the DHSA
 
falls in
 
line
closely with the historical standards.
 
The Exponential model recommends using
 
a radius 1.43 kilometers, while
the Spherical and Gaussian models
 
recommend a radius of 1.42 kilometers,
 
respectively.
 
These values line up
closely with
 
the historical
 
radius of
 
1.2 kilometers.
 
These results have
 
led the
 
U.S. QPs
 
to report
 
the data
 
following
the historical classification standards, rather than use the
 
results of the DHSA.
Coal quality is instrumental in determining the
 
viability of a coal deposit. Per Section
 
8.2 of the Mon Valley
 
TRS,
coal quality
 
conforms to
 
the ASTM
 
standards. These
 
quality attributes
 
aided in
 
converting dry,
 
in-place tons
 
to
demonstrated coal reserves (recoverable
 
washed tons). The
 
reserve and resource
 
criteria are presented in
 
Table
11-1
 
of
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
TRS,
 
including
 
assumptions
 
related
 
to
 
seam
 
density,
 
minimum
 
cut-off
 
thickness,
 
and
recoveries. Pricing data as provided by Coronado is described
 
in Section 16.2 of the Mon Valley
 
TRS.
 
Regarding production rates
 
as described in
 
Section 13.2 of
 
the Mon Valley
 
TRS, the Mon
 
Valley
 
mine complex
is not yet
 
active, with three distinct
 
mines and CPPs planned.
 
The mine plan and
 
productivity expectations reflect
historical performance from other similar mines
 
with similar conditions and efforts
 
have been made to adjust the
plan to reflect future conditions. Mine development and operation have not been
 
optimized within the Mon Valley
TRS.
 
Additional mine-specific factors can be found in Section 13.4
 
of the Mon Valley TRS.
Greenbrier (Non-Material Property)
The
 
Greenbrier
 
property
 
has
 
been idled
 
since
 
April
 
1,
 
2020. During
 
the
 
fourth
 
quarter
 
of
 
2020,
 
the
 
Company
committed to
 
a plan
 
to sell
 
Greenbrier on
 
the basis
 
that it
 
does not
 
form part
 
of the
 
Company’s
 
core business
strategy. The Greenbrier
 
property is not considered material to Coronado’s business
 
or financial conditions, and
thus no update was
 
completed for Greenbrier in
 
2024. Resources exclusive
 
of reserves are based
 
on assumed
(December 31, 2022)
 
long-term average
 
price of $154
 
per Mt (FOB
 
loadout) for
 
all resources,
 
representing the
Company’s
 
long-term
 
average
 
price
 
forecast
 
for
 
Greenbrier.
 
The
 
December
 
31,
 
2022,
 
reserve
 
pricing
 
data
assumes respective
 
Mid-Vol/Low-Vol
 
and thermal/PCI
 
FOB-mine prices
 
of approximately
 
$152 and
 
$80 per
 
Mt
for calendar year
 
2028.
 
Mid-Vol/Low-Vol
 
and thermal/PCI prices
 
increase to approximately
 
$206 and $109
 
per
Mt,
 
respectively,
 
through
 
year
 
2043.
 
The
 
Greenbrier
 
operations
 
are
 
projected
 
to
 
be
 
fully
 
depleted
 
in
 
2043.
Marketable reserve tons are reported
 
on a moist basis,
 
including a combination of surface
 
and inherent moisture.
 
The combination of surface and inherent moisture is modeled
 
at 6.0%.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
88
Russell County (Non-Material Property)
The
 
Russell
 
County
 
property
 
is
 
not
 
considered
 
material
 
to
 
Coronado’s
 
business
 
or
 
financial
 
conditions.
 
In
addition, pursuant to the current mine plan, the
 
property will only start generating cash flows when it commences
production in 2040. Resources exclusive of
 
reserves are based on assumed long-term average
 
price of $143 per
Mt (FOB loadout), representing the Company’s long-term
 
average price forecast for Russell County.
 
The pricing
data assumes
 
HVA
 
FOB-mine prices
 
with a
 
weighted LOM
 
average of
 
approximately $263
 
per Mt.
 
Marketable
reserve
 
tons
 
are
 
reported
 
on
 
a
 
moist
 
basis,
 
including
 
a
 
combination
 
of
 
surface
 
and
 
inherent
 
moisture.
 
The
combination of surface and inherent moisture is modeled
 
at 6.0%.
Internal Controls
Our
 
staff
 
of
 
geologists
 
and
 
engineers
 
worked
 
with
 
the
 
qualified
 
persons
 
throughout
 
the
 
mineral
 
resource
 
and
reserve estimation process and provided data
 
from our own exploration and
 
operating activities at the properties.
We
 
have
 
internal
 
control
 
procedures,
 
including
 
quality
 
assurance/quality
 
control
 
procedures
 
and
 
internal
verification of input data and geological modelling, subject
 
to multi-level review, to
 
help ensure the validity of the
data. These procedures include, but are not limited to:
•
 
Oversight and approval of each annual statement by responsible
 
senior officers;
•
 
Independent, external review of new and materially changed
 
estimates at regular intervals;
•
 
Annual
 
reconciliation
 
with
 
internal
 
planning
 
by
 
our
 
staff
 
of
 
geologists
 
and
 
engineers
 
to
 
validate
 
coal
reserve and coal resource estimates for operating mines,
 
including the following procedures:
•
 
Assessments
 
of
 
drilling,
 
sampling
 
and
 
quality
 
assurance/quality
 
control
 
data,
 
resource
modelling, resource estimation, classification, and reporting;
•
 
Assessment
 
and
 
benchmarking
 
of
 
production
 
assumptions,
 
mining
 
rate
 
and
 
production
schedules against historical production data;
•
 
Assessments
 
of
 
capital
 
and
 
operating
 
costs
 
against
 
other
 
comparable
 
projects
 
for
reasonableness;
•
 
Continual identification
 
and
 
evaluation
 
of material
 
technical
 
issues
 
likely to
 
impact
 
the five-
year plan and the future performance of producing properties;
•
 
An examination of historical
 
information and results in
 
respect of the technical
 
aspects of the properties
by our staff of geologists and engineers, including
 
a review of the following key elements:
 
•
 
Geology mapping, reports and models, including geotechnical and
 
hydrology aspects;
•
 
Coal resource and coal reserve estimates;
•
 
Mining operations and proposed growth options;
•
 
Coal preparation facilities;
•
 
Coal handling and transport;
•
 
Environmental matters and approvals;
•
 
Land management, including leases and other pertinent
 
agreements;
•
 
Veracity of existing information
 
supporting five-year plans and business plans;
•
 
Identification of key project drivers; and
•
 
Risks and opportunities.
The pricing
 
information
 
used for
 
preliminary
 
resource
 
valuation and
 
to estimate
 
our proven
 
and probable
 
coal
reserves was based on prices under our existing contracts and price forecasts. Below
 
is a description of some of
the factors
 
that could
 
affect price
 
forecasts for
 
Met and
 
thermal coal
 
products on
 
a mine-by-mine
 
and product-
by-product basis. Differences between
 
the assumptions and analyses
 
included in the
 
price forecasts and realized
factors could cause actual pricing to differ from
 
the forecasts.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
89
Metallurgical.
 
Several factors
 
can influence
 
Met coal
 
supply and
 
demand and
 
pricing. Demand
 
is impacted
 
by
economic conditions and demand for
 
steel and is also impacted by competing
 
technologies used to make steel,
some of which do not use coal as a manufacturing input. Competition from other types of coal is also a key price
consideration
 
and
 
can
 
be
 
impacted
 
by
 
coal
 
quality
 
and
 
characteristics,
 
delivered
 
energy
 
cost
 
(including
transportation costs), customer service and support and
 
reliability of supply.
Seaborne
 
Met
 
coal
 
import
 
demand
 
can
 
be
 
significantly
 
impacted
 
by
 
the
 
availability
 
of
 
local
 
coal
 
production,
particularly
 
in
 
leading
 
Met
 
coal
 
import
 
countries
 
such
 
as
 
China
 
and
 
India,
 
among
 
others,
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
country-
specific policies restricting or promoting domestic supply. The competitiveness of seaborne Met coal supply from
leading Met coal
 
exporting countries, such as
 
Australia, the United
 
States, Russia, Canada and
 
Mongolia, among
others, is also an important price consideration.
In addition to
 
the factors noted
 
above, the prices
 
which may be
 
obtained at each
 
individual mine or
 
future mine
can be impacted
 
by factors such
 
as (i) the
 
mine’s location,
 
which impacts the
 
total delivered energy
 
costs to its
customers, (ii)
 
quality characteristics,
 
particularly
 
if they
 
are unique
 
relative
 
to competing
 
mines, (iii)
 
assumed
transportation costs and
 
(iv) other mine
 
costs that are
 
contractually passed on to
 
customers in certain
 
commercial
relationships.
Thermal.
 
Several factors can influence thermal coal supply
 
and demand and pricing. Demand is sensitive
 
to total
electric power generation volumes, which are
 
determined in part by the
 
impact of weather on heating
 
and cooling
demand,
 
inter-fuel
 
competition
 
in
 
the
 
electric
 
power
 
generation
 
mix,
 
changes
 
in
 
capacity
 
(additions
 
and
retirements),
 
inter-basin
 
or
 
inter-country
 
coal
 
competition,
 
coal
 
stockpiles
 
and
 
policy
 
and
 
regulations.
 
Supply
considerations
 
impacting
 
pricing
 
include
 
reserve
 
positions,
 
mining
 
methods,
 
strip
 
ratios,
 
production
 
costs
 
and
capacity and the cost of new supply (new mine developments
 
or extensions at existing mines).
The
 
cost
 
information
 
that
 
the
 
QPs
 
used
 
for
 
preliminary
 
resource
 
valuation
 
and
 
to
 
estimate
 
our
 
proven
 
and
probable reserves
 
were generally
 
internal projected
 
future costs
 
based on
 
historical costs
 
and expected
 
future
trends. The
 
estimated costs
 
normally include
 
mining, processing,
 
transportation, royalty,
 
tax and
 
other mining-
related
 
costs.
 
Our
 
estimated
 
mining
 
and
 
processing
 
costs
 
reflect
 
projected
 
changes
 
in
 
prices
 
of
 
consumable
commodities (mainly diesel fuel,
 
natural gas, explosives and
 
steel), labor costs,
 
geological and mining
 
conditions,
targeted
 
product
 
qualities
 
and
 
other
 
mining-related
 
costs.
 
Estimates
 
for
 
other
 
sales-related
 
costs
 
(mainly
transportation, royalty
 
and tax)
 
are based
 
on contractual
 
prices or
 
fixed rates.
 
Specific factors
 
that may
 
impact
the cost at our various operations include:
•
Geological settings.
 
The geological
 
characteristics of
 
each mine
 
are among
 
the most
 
important factors
that determine the mining cost. Our geology department conducts the exploration program and provides
geological models for the LOM process. Coal seam depth, thickness, dipping angle, partings and quality
constrain the available mining methods
 
and size of operations. Shallow
 
coal is typically mined by
 
surface
mining
 
methods
 
by
 
which
 
the
 
primary
 
cost
 
is
 
overburden
 
removal.
 
Deep
 
coal
 
is
 
typically
 
mined
 
by
underground
 
mining
 
methods
 
where
 
the
 
primary
 
costs
 
include
 
coal
 
extraction,
 
conveyance
 
and
 
roof
control.
•
Scale of operations and the equipment
 
sizes.
 
For surface mines, our dragline systems
 
generally have a
lower unit cost
 
than truck-and-shovel systems for
 
overburden removal. The longwall
 
operations generally
are more cost effective than bord-and-pillar operations
 
for underground mines.
•
Commodity prices.
 
For surface mines,
 
the costs of
 
diesel fuel and
 
explosives are
 
major components of
the total mining cost.
 
For underground mines, the
 
steel used for roof
 
bolts represents a significant
 
cost.
Commodity price
 
forecasts are
 
used to
 
project those
 
costs in
 
the financial
 
models we
 
use to
 
establish
our reserves.
•
Target
 
product quality.
 
By targeting
 
a premium
 
quality,
 
product, our
 
mining and
 
processing
 
processes
may experience
 
more coal
 
losses. By
 
lowering product
 
quality,
 
the coal
 
losses can
 
be minimized
 
and
therefore a lower cost per
 
Mt can be achieved. In
 
our mine plans, the product
 
qualities are estimated to
correspond to existing contracts and forecasted market
 
demands.
•
Transportation
 
costs.
 
We
 
have
 
entered
 
into
 
arrangements
 
with
 
third
 
parties
 
to
 
gain
 
access
 
to
transportation infrastructure and services where required, including
 
rail carriers and port owners. Where
coal
 
is
 
exported
 
or
 
sold
 
other
 
than
 
at
 
the
 
mine
 
gate,
 
the
 
costs
 
associated
 
with
 
these
 
arrangements
represent a significant portion of both the total cost of supplying coal to customers and of our production
costs.
 
As
 
a
 
result,
 
the
 
cost
 
of
 
transportation
 
is
 
not
 
only
 
a
 
key
 
factor
 
in
 
our
 
cost
 
base
 
but
 
also
 
in
 
the
purchasing
 
decision
 
of
 
customers.
 
Our
 
transportation
 
costs
 
vary
 
by
 
region.
 
See
 
Item
 
1.
 
“Business—
Transportation” for more information regarding
 
transportation arrangements for our operations.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
90
•
Royalty costs.
 
As conditions to
 
certain of the
 
Tenements,
 
Curragh is subject
 
to royalties payable
 
to the
Queensland
 
government
 
as
 
described
 
in
 
Item
 
1.
 
“Business—Regulatory
 
Matters—Australia—Mineral
Resources Act 1989
 
(Qld)”. These royalties
 
are in addition
 
to the Stanwell
 
rebate, as described
 
in Item
1. “Business—Customers—Stanwell.” Royalty
 
costs at our U.S. Operations
 
are based upon contractual
agreements for the coal
 
leased from private owners
 
and vary from
 
property to property
 
and by the type
of
 
mine
 
(i.e.,
 
surface
 
or
 
underground).
 
The
 
royalty
 
rates
 
under
 
leases
 
at
 
our
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
range
between
 
3%
 
-
 
9%
 
of
 
revenues
 
from
 
coal
 
sales.
 
Under
 
some
 
of
 
the
 
leases,
 
we
 
are
 
required
 
to
 
pay
minimum royalties,
 
regardless
 
of production,
 
and/or “wheelage
 
fees” (i.e.,
 
fees payable
 
on coal
 
mined
and
 
removed
 
from
 
properties
 
other
 
than
 
the
 
particular
 
leasehold
 
and
 
hauled
 
across
 
the
 
leasehold
premises).
•
Black lung,
 
severance and
 
reclamation taxes.
 
Our U.S.
 
Operations are
 
subject to
 
a federal
 
black lung
excise tax on coal sold domestically.
•
Exchange rates.
 
Costs related to our Australian Operations are predominantly denominated in A$, while
the coal that our Australian Operations
 
export is sold in US$. As
 
a result, A$-US$ exchange rates impact
the U.S. dollar cost of our Australian Operations’ production
 
.
For further discussion of comprehensive risk inherent in the estimation, see Item 1A.
 
“Risk Factors—Operational
and Technology
 
Risks—We
 
rely on
 
estimates
 
of our
 
recoverable resources
 
and
 
reserves,
 
which
 
are complex
due to geological characteristics of the properties and the
 
number of assumptions made.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
91
ITEM 3.
 
LEGAL PROCEEDINGS.
We are
 
involved in
 
various
 
legal proceedings
 
occurring
 
in the
 
ordinary course
 
of business.
 
It is
 
the opinion
 
of
management, after consultation
 
with legal counsel,
 
that these matters
 
will not materially
 
affect our consolidated
financial position, results of operations or cash flows.
The Company is subject to a wide
 
variety of laws and regulations within the legal jurisdiction in
 
which it operates.
See “Part I, Item 1. Business—Regulatory Matters”
 
for additional information. The Company believes that
 
it is in
substantial compliance with federal, state and local laws
 
and regulations.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
92
ITEM 4. MINE SAFETY DISCLOSURES
Safety is the cornerstone of the Company’s values and is the number one priority
 
for all employees at Coronado
Global Resources.
 
Our U.S. Operations
 
include multiple mining
 
complexes across
 
three states and
 
are regulated by
 
both the U.S.
Mine Safety
 
and Health
 
Administration, or
 
MSHA, and
 
state regulatory
 
agencies. Under
 
regulations mandated
by the Federal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1977, or the Mine Act, MSHA inspects our U.S. mines on a regular
basis and issues various citations and orders when it believes
 
a violation has occurred under the Mine Act.
In accordance
 
with
 
Section
 
1503(a) of
 
the Dodd-Frank
 
Wall
 
Street Reform
 
and
 
Consumer
 
Protection
 
Act and
Item 104 of Regulation S-K (17 CFR 229.104), each operator of a coal or other mine is required to report certain
mine safety results in its periodic reports filed with the SEC
 
under the Exchange Act.
Information pertaining to mine safety
 
matters is included in Exhibit
 
95.1 attached to this Annual
 
Report on Form
10-K. The disclosures reflect the
 
United States mining operations only, as these requirements do
 
not apply to our
mines operated outside the United States.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
93
ITEM
 
5.
 
MARKET
 
FOR
 
REGISTRANT’S
 
COMMON
 
EQUITY,
 
RELATED
 
STOCKHOLDER
 
MATTERS
 
AND
ISSUER PURCHASES OF EQUITY SECURITIES.
Market Information
Our CDIs, each
 
representing one-tenth
 
of one share
 
of our common
 
stock, have
 
been listed on
 
the ASX under
the
 
trading
 
symbol
 
“CRN”
 
since
 
October 23,
 
2018.
 
Prior
 
to
 
such
 
time,
 
there
 
was
 
no
 
public
 
market
 
for
 
our
securities. There is no principal market in the United States
 
for our CDIs or shares of our common stock.
Holders
As of December 31, 2023, we had 167,645,373
 
shares of our common stock issued
 
and outstanding with 7,735
holders of record.
 
The holders included CHESS
 
Depositary Nominees Pty Limited,
 
which held 90,337,270 shares
of our common stock in the form of
 
CDIs on behalf of the CDI holders; there were 7,734 registered owners
 
of our
CDIs on December 31, 2023.
Series A Preferred Share
On September
 
20, 2018,
 
we issued
 
the Series
 
A Preferred
 
Share to
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC,
 
at par
 
value.
 
The
offer, sale, and issuance of the Series A Share were deemed to be exempt from registration under
 
the Securities
Act in reliance on Section
 
4(a)(2) of the Securities Act as
 
transactions by an issuer not involving
 
a public offering.
The recipient of the Series A Share acquired the Series A Share for investment only and not with a view to or for
sale in connection with any distribution thereof and appropriate
 
legends were affixed to the Series A Share.
Dividends
The
 
payment
 
of
 
dividends
 
is
 
at
 
the
 
discretion
 
of
 
the
 
Board
 
of
 
Directors.
 
The
 
decision
 
as
 
to
 
whether
 
or
 
not
 
a
dividend will be
 
paid will
 
be subject to
 
a number of
 
considerations including
 
the general
 
business environment,
operating
 
results,
 
cash
 
flows,
 
future
 
capital
 
requirements,
 
regulatory
 
and
 
contractual
 
restrictions,
 
as
 
well
 
as
applicable covenants under
 
the Senior Secured
 
Notes Indenture governing
 
our Notes and
 
covenants under the
ABL Facility and any other factors the Board of Directors
 
may consider relevant.
 
Our objective in setting our dividend policy is to deliver
 
stockholder returns while maintaining flexibility to pursue
our strategic
 
initiatives within
 
a prudent
 
capital structure.
 
Our dividend
 
policy is
 
to distribute
 
between 60%
 
and
100%
 
of
 
available
 
free
 
cash.
 
Available
 
free
 
cash
 
is
 
defined
 
as
 
net
 
cash
 
from
 
operating
 
activities
 
less
 
capital
expenditure, acquisition expenditure,
 
amounts reserved for
 
capital expenditure and
 
acquisition expenditure and
amounts required for
 
debt servicing. In
 
circumstances where there is
 
surplus available free
 
cash, at the
 
discretion
of
 
our
 
Board
 
of
 
Directors
 
and
 
in
 
light
 
of
 
business
 
and
 
market
 
conditions,
 
we
 
may
 
consider
 
the
 
potential
 
for
additional
 
stockholder
 
returns
 
through
 
special
 
dividends
 
and
 
share
 
buy-backs
 
as
 
part
 
of
 
its
 
broader
 
capital
management strategy.
Summary Description of the Company’s
 
Non-Stockholder Approved Equity Compensation
 
Plans
The Company does not have any non-stockholder approved
 
equity compensation plans.
Recent Sales of Unregistered Securities
Other than as previously
 
disclosed in a Quarterly
 
Report on Form 10-Q
 
or in a Current
 
Report on Form 8-K,
 
we
did not issue
 
any shares of
 
our common stock
 
in a transaction
 
that was not
 
registered under
 
the Securities Act
during the year ended December 31, 2023.
Purchases of Equity Securities by the Issuer and
 
Affiliated Purchases
We had no repurchases of equity securities for the
 
three months ended December 31, 2023.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
94
ITEM 6.
 
[Reserved]
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
95
ITEM 7.
 
MANAGEMENT’S DISCUSSION
 
AND ANALYSIS
 
OF FINANCIAL
 
CONDITION AND
 
RESULTS
 
OF
OPERATIONS
The following
 
Management’s Discussion
 
and Analysis
 
of our Financial
 
Condition and
 
Results of
 
Operations, or
MD&A, should be read in conjunction with the Consolidated Financial Statements and the related notes to those
statements included elsewhere in this Annual Report on Form
 
10-K.
 
Overview
For the year
 
ended December 31, 2023,
 
we produced and sold
 
15.8 MMt of coal.
 
Met coal and
 
thermal coal sales
represented 75.8% and 24.2%, respectively,
 
of our total volume of coal
 
sold and 91.4% and 8.6%,
 
respectively,
of total coal revenues.
During the year ended December 31, 2023, Coronado navigated through some operational headwinds that were
out of our control.
Our
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
suffered
 
production
 
downtime
 
as
 
a
 
result
 
of
 
severe
 
weather
 
events,
 
including
significant
 
rainfall
 
in
 
the
 
March
 
and
 
December
 
quarters,
 
and
 
unscheduled
 
downtime
 
of
 
a
 
dragline
 
due
 
to
mechanical failure. Despite these adverse
 
events, our Australian Operations completed
 
planned maintenance on
its
 
two
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plants
 
and
 
invested
 
in
 
additional
 
fleets
 
to
 
advance
 
pre-strip
 
waste
 
movement,
 
to
decongest the
 
operating pits,
 
and to
 
improve the
 
mine’s strike
 
-length and
 
future coal
 
availability.
 
In addition
 
to
lost production from
 
the unforeseen events,
 
our Australian Operation
 
also experienced significant
 
shipping delays
in the December quarter
 
due to labor
 
issues faced at the
 
RG Tanna
 
Coal Terminal
 
resulting in deferral
 
of sales
volumes to 2024.
Our U.S. Operations
 
were impacted
 
by geotechnical
 
issues at the
 
Buchanan mine, specifically
 
a roof fall
 
in the
December
 
quarter,
 
resulting
 
in
 
10
 
days
 
outage
 
to
 
production
 
to
 
repair
 
equipment
 
and
 
secure
 
additional
 
roof
support, and the
 
impact of
 
a rock intrusion
 
in the September
 
quarter resulting
 
in a 14-day
 
outage to production
as
 
we
 
mined
 
through
 
the
 
intrusion.
 
Both
 
events
 
have
 
been
 
successfully
 
addressed,
 
with
 
normal
 
longwall
operating conditions restored at the mine.
Overall, for
 
the year
 
ended December
 
31, 2023,
 
saleable production
 
was 0.2MMt
 
lower and sales
 
volume was
0.6MMt compared to the year ended December 31, 2022.
The
 
benchmark
 
PLV
 
HCC
 
FOB
 
AUS average
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
of
 
$296.3
 
per
 
Mt
 
was
18.5% lower compared to
 
$363.7 per Mt for
 
the year ended December 31,
 
2022, when we saw
 
record high prices
as global Met coal supply readjusted from the impact
 
of the Russia and Ukraine war.
 
Met coal
 
market remains
 
buoyant as
 
demand
 
in emerging
 
and developing
 
economies,
 
such as
 
India, a
 
major
export destination, continues
 
to be strong. The
 
PLV HCC
 
FOB AUS index price
 
trended upwards in
 
the second
half of 2023 increasing 39% to $323.8 per Mt at the end of December 31, 2023. This increase
 
is primarily due to
a combination of tight supply
 
from Australia, caused by
 
adverse weather events and
 
reduced port throughput in
Queensland,
 
and
 
heightened
 
demand
 
from
 
Indian
 
and
 
Asian
 
steel
 
makers
 
who
 
were
 
restocking
 
from
 
lower
inventory levels.
 
Coal revenues of $2,830.7
 
million for the year ended
 
December 31, 2023, 19.8%
 
lower compared to 2022,
 
was
largely driven by lower sales
 
volumes, 0.6MMt lower compared to
 
2022 and lower average realized Met
 
price per
Mt sold,
 
which was
 
$50.2 per
 
Mt lower
 
than the
 
average realized
 
Met price
 
of $265.8
 
per Mt
 
sold for
 
the year
ended December 31, 2022.
 
Mining costs for the
 
year ended December 31, 2023, were
 
$273.1 million and $19.2 per
 
Mt sold higher compared
to the
 
corresponding period in
 
2022, largely
 
driven by
 
the impacts of
 
lower production
 
following significant weather
events
 
and
 
equipment
 
breakdown
 
at
 
our
 
Australian
 
Operations,
 
adverse
 
geological
 
conditions
 
at
 
our
 
U.S.
Operations,
 
combined
 
with
 
elevated
 
inflation
 
levels
 
mobilization
 
of
 
additional
 
fleets,
 
and
 
port
 
constraints
impacting sales volumes at our Australian Operations.
 
Dividends
During the year
 
ended December
 
31, 2023, Coronado
 
paid total dividends
 
of $16.7 million
 
to stockholders
 
and
CDI holders on the ASX.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
96
Liquidity
As of December
 
31, 2023,
 
our net cash
 
position was
 
$96.7 million,
 
comprised of
 
$339.0 million
 
cash and cash
equivalents
 
(excluding
 
restricted
 
cash)
 
less
 
$242.3
 
million
 
aggregate
 
principal
 
amount
 
of
 
Notes
 
outstanding.
Coronado
 
had
 
available
 
liquidity
 
of
 
$489.0
 
million
 
as
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
consisting
 
of
 
cash
 
and
 
cash
equivalents
 
(excluding
 
restricted
 
cash),
 
unrestricted
 
short-term
 
deposits
 
of
 
$21.9
 
million
 
and
 
$128.1
 
million
availability under our New ABL facility.
Safety
For
 
our
 
Australian
 
Operations,
 
the
 
twelve-month
 
rolling
 
average
 
Total
 
Reportable
 
Injury
 
Frequency
 
Rate
 
at
December 31, 2023
 
was 1.83 compared
 
to 3.92 at
 
the end of
 
December 31,
 
2022. At our
 
U.S. Operations,
 
the
twelve-month rolling average Total
 
Reportable Incident Rate, at December 31, 2023 was 1.44 compared to 2.42
at the end of December 31, 2022.
 
These strong results reflect a record
 
safety rate at our U.S. Operations
 
under
Coronado’s ownership, and the best safety
 
rate since May 2018 for our Australian
 
Operations. Reportable rates
for our Australian and U.S. Operations are below the relevant
 
industry benchmarks.
Our Lower
 
War Eagle
 
mine, part
 
of our
 
Logan mining
 
complex at
 
our U.S.
 
Operations, which
 
includes multiple
underground and surface mines, achieved 4 years of being Lost
 
Time Injury,
 
or LTI, free
 
in 2023.
The safety of our workforce is our number one priority,
 
and we remain focused on the safety and wellbeing of all
employees and
 
contracting parties. Coronado
 
continues to implement
 
safety initiatives to
 
improve our
 
safety rates
every quarter.
Segment Reporting
In accordance with
 
Accounting Standards Codification,
 
or ASC, 280,
 
Segment Reporting, we
 
have adopted the
following reporting
 
segments: Australia and
 
the United
 
States. In
 
addition, “Other and
 
Corporate” is
 
not a
 
reporting
segment but is disclosed for the purposes of reconciliation
 
to our Consolidated Financial Statements.
Results of Operations
How We Evaluate Our Operations
We
 
evaluate
 
our
 
operations
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
volume
 
of
 
coal
 
we
 
can
 
safely
 
produce
 
and
 
sell
 
in
 
compliance
 
with
regulatory
 
standards,
 
and
 
the
 
prices
 
we
 
receive
 
for
 
our
 
coal.
 
Our
 
sales
 
volume
 
and
 
sales
 
prices
 
are
 
largely
dependent upon
 
the terms
 
of our
 
coal sales
 
contracts, for
 
which prices
 
generally are
 
set based
 
on daily
 
index
averages, on a quarterly basis or on annual fixed price
 
contracts.
Our management
 
uses a
 
variety of
 
financial and
 
operating metrics
 
to analyze
 
our performance.
 
These metrics
are significant factors
 
in assessing
 
our operating results
 
and profitability.
 
These financial
 
and operating metrics
include: (i) safety and environmental metrics; (ii) Adjusted EBITDA; (iii) total sales volumes and average realized
price
 
per
 
Mt
 
sold,
 
which
 
we
 
define
 
as
 
total
 
coal
 
revenues
 
divided
 
by
 
total
 
sales
 
volume;
 
(iv)
 
Met
 
coal
 
sales
volumes and average realized Met price per
 
Mt sold, which we define as Met coal
 
revenues divided by Met coal
sales volume; (v)
 
average segment mining
 
costs per Mt sold,
 
which we define
 
as mining costs
 
divided by sales
volumes (excluding non-produced coal) for the respective segment; (vi) average segment operating costs per
 
Mt
sold, which we define as segment operating costs
 
divided by sales volumes for the respective segment
 
and (vii)
net cash, which we define
 
as cash and cash equivalents
 
(excluding restricted cash)
 
less outstanding aggregate
principal amount of the Notes.
Coal revenues are shown on our Consolidated Statements of Operations
 
and Comprehensive Income exclusive
of other
 
revenues. Generally,
 
export sale
 
contracts for
 
our Australian
 
Operations require
 
us to
 
bear the
 
cost of
freight
 
from
 
our
 
mines
 
to
 
the
 
applicable
 
outbound
 
shipping
 
port,
 
while
 
freight
 
costs
 
from
 
the
 
port
 
to
 
the
 
end
destination
 
are typically
 
borne
 
by the
 
customer.
 
In circumstances
 
where
 
we sell
 
through
 
intermediaries
 
to the
export market from our
 
U.S. Operations, sales
 
are recognized when
 
the title to the
 
coal passes to the
 
customer
at the
 
mine
 
load out
 
similar
 
to a
 
domestic
 
sale.
 
For
 
our domestic
 
sales,
 
customers
 
typically
 
bear
 
the
 
cost
 
of
freight.
 
As
 
such,
 
freight
 
expenses
 
are
 
excluded
 
from
 
the
 
cost
 
of
 
coal
 
revenues
 
to
 
allow
 
for
 
consistency
 
and
comparability in evaluating our operating performance.
Non-GAAP Financial Measures; Other Measures
The
 
following
 
discussion
 
of
 
our
 
results
 
includes
 
references
 
to
 
and
 
analysis
 
of
 
Adjusted
 
EBITDA,
 
Segment
Adjusted EBITDA and mining
 
costs, which are financial
 
measures not recognized in
 
accordance with U.S. GAAP.
Non-GAAP financial
 
measures, including
 
Adjusted EBITDA,
 
Segment Adjusted
 
EBITDA and
 
mining costs,
 
are
useful to our investors to measure our operating performance.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
97
Non-GAAP financial measures are intended to provide additional information only and do not have any standard
meaning prescribed
 
by U.S.
 
GAAP.
 
These measures
 
should not
 
be considered
 
in isolation
 
or as
 
substitute for
measures of performance prepared in accordance with
 
U.S. GAAP.
Adjusted EBITDA, a non-GAAP measure, is defined as earnings before interest, tax, depreciation, depletion and
amortization
 
and
 
other
 
foreign
 
exchange
 
losses.
 
Adjusted
 
EBITDA
 
is
 
also
 
adjusted
 
for
 
certain
 
discrete
 
non-
recurring items that we exclude in
 
analyzing each of our segments’
 
operating performance. Adjusted EBITDA
 
is
not intended to
 
serve as an
 
alternative to U.S. GAAP
 
measures of performance
 
and may not
 
be comparable to
similarly titled measures presented
 
by other companies. A reconciliation
 
of Adjusted EBITDA to its most
 
directly
comparable measure under U.S. GAAP is included below.
 
Segment
 
Adjusted
 
EBITDA
 
is
 
defined
 
as
 
Adjusted
 
EBITDA
 
by
 
operating
 
and
 
reporting
 
segment,
 
adjusted
 
for
certain
 
transactions,
 
eliminations
 
or
 
adjustments
 
that
 
our
 
CODM
 
does
 
not
 
consider
 
for
 
making
 
decisions
 
to
allocate resources among segments or assessing segment performance.
 
Segment Adjusted EBITDA is used as
a
 
supplemental
 
financial
 
measure
 
by
 
management
 
and
 
by
 
external
 
users
 
of
 
our
 
Consolidated
 
Financial
Statements such
 
as investors,
 
industry analysts
 
and lenders
 
to assess
 
the operating
 
performance of
 
the business.
Mining costs,
 
a non-GAAP
 
measure, are
 
based on
 
the reported
 
cost of
 
coal revenues,
 
which is
 
shown on
 
our
statement of
 
operations and comprehensive
 
income exclusive of
 
freight expense, Stanwell
 
rebate, other royalties,
depreciation,
 
depletion
 
and
 
amortization
 
and
 
selling,
 
general
 
and
 
administrative
 
expenses,
 
adjusted
 
for
 
other
items that do not relate
 
directly to the costs incurred to
 
produce coal at the mine.
 
Mining costs exclude these cost
components as
 
our CODM
 
does not
 
view these
 
costs as
 
directly attributable
 
to the
 
production of
 
coal. Mining
costs
 
is
 
used
 
as
 
a
 
supplemental
 
financial
 
measure
 
by
 
management,
 
providing
 
an
 
accurate
 
view
 
of
 
the
 
costs
directly attributable to the production
 
of coal at our mining
 
segments, and by external
 
users of our Consolidated
Financial Statements,
 
such as
 
investors, industry
 
analysts and
 
ratings agencies,
 
to assess
 
our mine
 
operating
performance in comparison to the mine operating performance
 
of other companies in the coal industry.
Year Ended December 31,
 
2023 Compared to Year
 
Ended December 31, 2022
Summary
The financial and operational highlights for the year ended December
 
31, 2023 include:
•
 
Net income of $156.1 million for the
 
year ended December 31, 2023, decreased
 
by $615.6 million, from
$771.7 million for the year
 
ended December 31, 2022. The
 
decrease was primarily driven
 
by lower coal
revenues
 
and
 
higher
 
mining
 
and
 
operating
 
costs,
 
partially
 
offset
 
by
 
an
 
income
 
tax
 
benefit
 
in
 
2023
compared to an income tax expense in 2022.
 
•
 
Average realized Met price per
 
Mt sold of $215.7 for the year
 
ended December 31, 2023 was
 
$50.2 per
Mt sold lower compared to $265.8 per Mt sold for the year ended December 31, 2022, largely a result of
lower Met coal index price in 2023 compared to the record
 
highs in 2022 from the impacts of the Russia
and Ukraine war.
 
The first half
 
of 2023 saw
 
Met coal index
 
prices decline significantly
 
as steel demand
weakened, however,
 
Met coal prices trended upwards in the second half of 2023 due to tight supply and
port constraints in Australia.
•
 
Total sales volume was 15.8 MMt for the
 
year ended December 31, 2023,
 
or 0.6 MMt lower
 
than the year
ended December 31, 2022. The lower sales volumes were primarily driven by port constraints impacting
shipments from RG Tanna
 
Terminal
 
in Queensland, Australia
 
and production downtime
 
from significant
wet weather events
 
and equipment breakdowns
 
at our Australian
 
Operations combined
 
with geological
issues at our U.S. Operations.
 
•
 
Adjusted EBITDA for
 
the year ended
 
December 31, 2023,
 
totaled $381.7 million,
 
a decrease of
 
$833.9
million, from Adjusted EBITDA of $1,215.6 million
 
for the year ended December 31, 2022.
 
This decrease
was a result of lower coal revenues and higher operating
 
costs.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
98
For Year Ended December 31,
 
(US$ in thousands)
2023
2022
Change
%
Revenues:
Coal revenues
2,830,689
3,527,626
(696,937)
(19.8%)
Other revenues
59,914
43,916
15,998
36.4%
Total
 
revenues
2,890,603
3,571,542
(680,939)
(19.1%)
Costs and expenses:
Cost of coal revenues (exclusive of items shown
separately below)
1,731,630
1,515,585
216,045
14.3%
Depreciation, depletion and amortization
160,711
167,046
(6,335)
(3.8%)
Freight expenses
259,710
249,081
10,629
4.3%
Stanwell rebate
136,523
165,995
(29,472)
(17.8%)
Other royalties
345,882
385,065
(39,183)
(10.2%)
Selling, general, and administrative expenses
84,177
42,499
41,678
98.1%
Total
 
costs and expenses
2,718,633
2,525,271
193,362
7.7%
Other income (expenses):
Interest expense, net
(56,751)
(67,632)
10,881
(16.1%)
Loss on debt extinguishment
(1,385)
(5,336)
3,951
(74.0%)
Decrease (increase) in provision for discounting and
credit losses
4,216
(3,821)
8,037
(210.3%)
Other, net
5,764
33,795
(28,031)
(82.9%)
Total
 
other expense, net
(48,156)
(42,994)
(5,162)
12.0%
Income before tax
123,814
1,003,277
(879,463)
(87.7%)
Income tax benefit (expense)
32,251
(231,574)
263,825
(113.9%)
Net income
156,065
771,703
(615,638)
(79.8%)
Net income attributable to Coronado Global
Resources Inc.
156,065
771,703
(615,638)
(79.8%)
Coal revenues
Coal
 
revenues
 
were
 
$2,830.7 million
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
a
 
decrease
 
of
 
$696.9
 
million,
compared to $3,527.6 million for
 
the year ended
 
December 31, 2022.
 
This decrease was driven
 
by 0.6 MMt
 
lower
sales volumes in 2023 and lower average realized Met price per Mt sold of $215.7 for the year ended December
31, 2023, compared to $265.8 per Mt sold in 2022.
 
Other revenues
Other revenues
 
were $59.9 million
 
for the
 
year ended
 
December 31, 2023,
 
an increase of
 
$16.0 million,
 
compared
to $43.9 million for the same
 
period in 2022. This increase was
 
primarily driven by termination fee revenue
 
from
a coal sales contract cancelled at our U.S. Operations.
Cost of coal revenues (exclusive of Items shown
 
separately below)
Cost of coal revenues comprised of costs related to produced tons sold, along with changes in both the volumes
and carrying values of coal inventory.
 
Cost of coal revenues include items
 
such as direct operating costs, which
include employee-related costs, materials and supplies, contractor services, coal handling and preparation costs
and production taxes.
 
Total
 
cost of coal revenues
 
was $1,731.6 million for
 
the year ended
 
December 31, 2023,
 
an increase of $216.0
million, compared to $1,515.6 million for the same period
 
in 2022.
 
Cost of coal revenues for our Australian Operations for the year ended
 
December 31, 2023, were $155.8 million
higher compared to
 
the same period
 
in 2022, primarily
 
driven by additional
 
fleets mobilized in
 
2023 to advance
pre-strip
 
overburden
 
removal,
 
the
 
inflationary
 
impact
 
on
 
labor,
 
contractor
 
and
 
other
 
supply
 
costs,
 
higher
maintenance
 
expenses
 
from
 
unexpected
 
equipment
 
failures,
 
partially
 
offset
 
by
 
lower
 
purchased
 
coal
 
and
favorable foreign
 
exchange
 
rate on
 
translation
 
of our
 
Australian Operations
 
for the
 
year
 
ended December
 
31,
2023,
 
of
 
A$/US$:
 
0.66
 
compared
 
to
 
0.70
 
for
 
the
 
same
 
period
 
in
 
2022.
 
Cost
 
of
 
coal
 
revenues
 
for
 
our
 
U.S.
Operations were
 
$60.3 million
 
higher for
 
the year
 
ended December
 
31, 2023,
 
compared to
 
the same
 
period in
2022,
 
also
 
impacted
 
by
 
an
 
elevated
 
inflationary
 
environment
 
and
 
higher
 
consumables
 
and
 
unplanned
maintenance costs following a rock intrusion and a roof
 
collapse in 2023.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
99
Depreciation, depletion and amortization
Depreciation, depletion and amortization were $160.7 million for the
 
year ended December 31, 2023, a
 
decrease
of $6.3 million, compared to
 
$167.0 million for the
 
year ended December 31,
 
2022. The decrease was
 
associated
with assets fully depreciated, lower depreciation
 
rates following annual useful life review at
 
the beginning of 2023
and
 
favorable
 
average
 
foreign
 
exchange
 
rate
 
on
 
translation
 
of
 
the
 
Australian
 
Operations,
 
partially
 
offset
 
by
depreciation on equipment brought into service during the year
 
ended December 31, 2023.
Freight expenses
Freight expenses
 
totaled
 
$259.7
 
million for
 
the year
 
ended December
 
31, 2023,
 
an increase
 
of $10.6
 
million,
compared to $249.1 million
 
for the same
 
period in 2022. Rail
 
costs at our Australian
 
Operations contributed $13.2
million to the
 
increase, mainly
 
due to higher
 
regulated costs
 
associated with access
 
to the Central
 
Queensland
Coal Network, partially offset by lower freight costs
 
at our U.S. Operations due to lower sales volumes.
 
Stanwell rebate
The Stanwell rebate was
 
$136.5 million for the
 
year ended December
 
31, 2023, a decrease
 
of $29.5 million, as
compared
 
to
 
$166.0
 
million
 
for the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2022.
 
The
 
decrease
 
was
 
due
 
to
 
lower
 
realized
reference coal pricing
 
for the prior
 
twelve-month period used to
 
calculate the rebate compared
 
to the same
 
period
in 2022 and favorable average foreign exchange rate
 
on translation of the Australian Operations.
Other royalties
Other
 
royalties
 
were
 
$345.9 million
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
a
 
decrease
 
of
 
$39.2 million,
 
as
compared
 
to $385.1
 
million
 
for the
 
year
 
ended December
 
31,
 
2022. Our
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
contributed
 
to
$36.0
 
million
 
of
 
the
 
decrease
 
due
 
to
 
lower
 
coal
 
revenues
 
and
 
favorable
 
exchange
 
rate
 
on
 
translation
 
of
 
the
Australian Operations, partially
 
offset by
 
the adverse impact
 
of the new
 
QLD royalty regime,
 
effective from
 
July
1, 2022, which resulted in $59 million additional royalty
 
cost in 2023.
Selling, general, and administrative expenses
 
Selling,
 
general,
 
and
 
administrative
 
expenses
 
increased
 
by
 
$41.7
 
million
 
to
 
$84.2
 
million
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
December 31, 2023, compared
 
to $42.5 million for
 
the year ended December
 
31, 2022. The increase
 
relates to
the additional accrual of $41.3 million relating to the stamp
 
duty on Curragh’s acquisition assessed by the
 
QRO.
The Company
 
disputes
 
the
 
amount
 
assessed by
 
the
 
QRO. Refer
 
to Part
 
II, Item
 
8. Financial
 
Statements and
Supplementary Data, Note 26 “Contingencies” for further
 
information.
Interest Expense, net
Interest
 
expense,
 
net
 
was
 
$56.8
 
million
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
a
 
decrease
 
of
 
$10.9
 
million
compared
 
to
 
$67.6
 
million
 
for
 
the
 
same
 
period
 
in
 
2022.
 
The
 
decrease
 
was
 
due
 
to
 
lower
 
aggregate
 
principal
amount of the Notes outstanding following redemptions
 
of $72.7 million in the fourth quarter of 2022.
Decrease (increase) in Provision for Discounting and
 
Credit Losses
Decrease in provision for discounting
 
and credit losses of $4.2 million for
 
the year ended December 31, 2023,
 
a
favorable movement
 
of $8.0 million
 
compared to
 
increase in
 
provision for
 
discounting and
 
credit losses
 
of $3.8
million for the
 
year ended December
 
31, 2022. The
 
lower provision was
 
primarily driven by
 
collection of certain
overdue trade receivables at December 31, 2022 during
 
the year ended December 31, 2023.
Other, net
Other,
 
net was
 
$5.8 million
 
in the
 
year ended
 
December 31,
 
2023, a
 
decrease of
 
$28.0 million
 
compared to
 
of
$33.8 million
 
for the
 
year ended
 
December
 
31, 2022.
 
The decrease
 
largely
 
relates
 
to lower
 
foreign
 
exchange
gains recognized
 
in the translation
 
of short-term
 
inter-entity balances
 
between certain
 
entities within
 
the Group
that are denominated in currencies other than their
 
respective functional currencies.
Income tax benefit (expense)
Income tax benefit
 
of $32.2 million
 
for the year
 
ended December
 
31, 2023, compared
 
to $231.6 million
 
income
tax
 
expense
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2022,
 
primarily
 
driven
 
by
 
loss
 
before
 
tax
 
from
 
our
 
Australian
operations and the benefit of prior year tax return adjustments
 
and amendments.
The income tax benefit for
 
the year ended December 31,
 
2023 resulted in an annual effective
 
tax rate of (26.0%).
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
100
Year Ended December 31,
 
2022 Compared to Year
 
Ended December 31, 2021
The Company’s comparison of 2022 results to
 
2021 results is included in the
 
Company’s
 
under Part II Item 7,
 
“Management’s Discussion and Analysis
of Financial Condition and Results of Operations”.
 
Supplemental Segment Financial Data
Year Ended December 31,
 
2023 Compared to Year
 
Ended December 31, 2022
Australian Operations
For Year Ended December 31,
(US$ in thousands)
2023
2022
Change
%
Sales Volume (MMt)
9.9
10.0
(0.1)
(1.0)%
Total
 
revenues ($)
1,681,522
2,116,555
(435,033)
(20.6)%
Coal revenues ($)
1,645,752
2,078,518
(432,766)
(20.8)%
Average realized price per Mt sold ($/Mt)
167.0
208.9
(41.9)
(20.0)%
Met sales volume (MMt)
6.8
6.5
0.3
4.2%
Met coal revenues ($)
1,557,471
1,968,173
(410,702)
(20.9)%
Average realized Met price per Mt sold ($/Mt)
230.2
303.1
(72.9)
(24.1)%
Mining costs ($)
1,058,598
864,616
193,982
22.4%
Mining costs per Mt sold ($/Mt)
108.5
89.5
19.0
21.2%
Operating costs ($)
1,679,954
1,575,786
104,168
6.6%
Operating costs per Mt sold ($/Mt)
170.5
158.3
12.2
7.7%
Segment Adjusted EBITDA ($)
2,249
541,208
(538,959)
(99.6)%
Coal revenues
 
for our
 
Australian Operations
 
for the
 
year ended
 
December
 
31, 2023,
 
were $1,645.8
 
million,
 
a
decrease of $432.8 million, or 20.6%, compared to $2,078.5 million for the year ended December 31, 2022. This
decrease was primarily driven by lower average realized Met price of $230.2 per Mt, a decrease of
 
$72.9 per Mt,
compared to $303.1 per Mt sold during the
 
same period in 2022. The higher realized price during the
 
year ended
December
 
31,
 
2022,
 
was
 
a
 
result
 
of
 
higher
 
Met
 
coal
 
index
 
prices
 
from
 
disruptions
 
in
 
trade
 
flows
 
and
 
supply
dynamics caused by
 
the war between
 
Russia and Ukraine.
 
Significant wet weather
 
events and port
 
constraints
during
 
2023
 
impacted
 
the
 
recovery
 
from
 
low
 
sales
 
volumes
 
in
 
2022
 
and
 
overall
 
sales
 
volumes
 
remained
consistent year on year.
 
Operating costs increased
 
by $104.2 million, or
 
6.6%, for the year
 
ended December 31,
 
2023, compared to the
year ended
 
December 31,
 
2022. The
 
increase was
 
driven by
 
higher mining
 
costs and
 
freight expense.
 
Mining
costs were $194.0
 
million, or 22.4%,
 
higher for the
 
year ended December 31,
 
2023, compared to the
 
same period
in
 
2022,
 
due
 
to
 
additional
 
fleets
 
mobilized
 
in
 
2023,
 
inflationary
 
impact
 
on
 
costs
 
and
 
additional
 
repairs
 
and
maintenance
 
costs
 
associated
 
with
 
equipment
 
failures.
 
Higher
 
mining
 
costs
 
were
 
partially
 
offset
 
by
 
favorable
average foreign exchange on translation of our Australian Operations, lower Stanwell rebate and other royalties’
expense as a result
 
of lower sales volume
 
and lower price
 
realizations. Mining and
 
Operating costs per
 
Mt sold
increased by
 
$19.0 and $12.2,
 
respectively,
 
compared to
 
the same
 
period in 2022,
 
due to increased
 
costs and
lower sales volume.
For
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
Segment
 
Adjusted
 
EBITDA
 
was
 
$2.2
 
million,
 
a
 
decrease
 
of
 
$539.0
million compared
 
to Segment
 
Adjusted EBITDA
 
of $541.2
 
million for
 
the year
 
ended December
 
31, 2022.
 
This
decrease was a result of lower coal revenues and higher
 
mining and operating costs.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
101
United States
For Year Ended December 31,
(US$ in thousands)
2023
2022
Change
%
Sales Volume (MMt)
6.0
6.4
(0.4)
(7.2)%
Total
 
revenues ($)
1,209,081
1,454,987
(245,906)
(16.9)%
Coal revenues ($)
1,184,937
1,449,108
(264,171)
(18.2)%
Average realized price per Mt sold ($/Mt)
198.4
225.2
(26.8)
(11.9)%
Met sales volume (MMt)
5.2
6.2
(1.0)
(14.9)%
Met coal revenues ($)
1,031,012
1,394,880
(363,868)
(26.1)%
Average realized Met price per Mt sold ($/Mt)
196.9
226.5
(29.6)
(13.1)%
Mining costs ($)
610,925
531,812
79,113
14.9%
Mining costs per Mt sold ($/Mt)
106.0
86.5
19.5
22.5%
Operating costs ($)
793,791
739,940
53,851
7.3%
Operating costs per Mt sold ($/Mt)
132.9
115.0
17.9
15.6%
Segment Adjusted EBITDA ($)
421,093
716,661
(295,568)
(41.2)%
Coal revenues
 
for our
 
U.S. Operations
 
decreased by
 
$264.2 million,
 
or 18.2%,
 
to $1,184.9
 
million for
 
the year
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
as
 
compared
 
to
 
$1,449.1
 
million
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2022.
 
This
decrease was driven
 
by a lower
 
average realized Met
 
price per Mt
 
sold for the
 
year ended December
 
31, 2023
of $196.9
 
compared to
 
$226.5 per
 
Mt sold
 
for the
 
same period
 
in 2022,
 
a result
 
of lower
 
Met coal
 
price index,
product mix skewed towards lower quality Met
 
coal and lower sales volumes driven primarily
 
by lower production
as a result of adverse geological conditions experienced
 
at the Buchanan mine.
Operating costs
 
increased by
 
$53.9 million,
 
or 7.3%,
 
to $793.8
 
million for
 
the year
 
ended December
 
31, 2023,
compared to
 
operating costs
 
of $739.9
 
million for
 
the year
 
ended December
 
31, 2022,
 
driven by
 
higher mining
costs, partially offset
 
by lower royalties
 
and freight expenses
 
from lower sales volume.
 
Mining costs contributed
$79.1 million
 
of the
 
increase driven
 
by continued
 
inflationary
 
impact on
 
labor and
 
supply costs
 
and unplanned
maintenance costs. Mining
 
and Operating costs
 
per Mt sold
 
increased by $19.5
 
and $17.9, respectively,
 
due to
lower sales volume and higher costs for the year ended December
 
31, 2023.
 
Segment Adjusted EBITDA
 
of $421.1
 
million for
 
the year ended
 
December 31,
 
2023, decreased by
 
$295.6 million,
or 41.2%, compared to
 
$716.7 million for the
 
year ended December 31, 2022.
 
This decrease was primarily
 
driven
by lower coal revenues and higher mining and other
 
operating costs.
Corporate and Other Adjusted EBITDA
The following table presents a summary of the components
 
of Corporate and Other Adjusted EBITDA:
For Year Ended December 31,
(US$ in thousands)
2023
2022
Change
%
Corporate and other expenses
42,856
42,499
357
0.8%
Other, net
(1,227)
(254)
(973)
383.1%
Total
 
Corporate and Other Adjusted EBITDA
41,629
42,245
(616)
(1.5)%
Corporate
 
and
 
other
 
costs
 
decreased
 
$0.6
 
million
 
to
 
$41.6
 
million
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
compared to $42.2 million for the year ended December
 
31, 2022, due to the timing of certain corporate costs
 
.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
102
Mining and operating costs for the Year Ended December 31, 2023 compared to Year
 
December 31, 2022
A reconciliation of
 
segment costs and
 
expenses, segment operating
 
costs, and segment
 
mining costs is
 
shown
below:
For Year Ended December 31, 2023
(US$ in thousands)
Australia
United States
Other /
Corporate
Total
Consolidated
Total costs and
 
expenses
1,756,635
876,753
85,245
2,718,633
Less: Selling, general and administrative expense
(30)
—
(84,147)
(84,177)
Less: Depreciation, depletion and amortization
(76,651)
(82,962)
(1,098)
(160,711)
Total operating costs
1,679,954
793,791
—
2,473,745
Less: Other royalties
(294,467)
(51,415)
—
(345,882)
Less: Stanwell rebate
(136,523)
—
—
(136,523)
Less: Freight expenses
(166,980)
(92,730)
—
(259,710)
Less: Other non-mining costs
(23,386)
(38,721)
—
(62,107)
Total mining costs
1,058,598
610,925
—
1,669,523
Sales Volume excluding non-produced
 
coal (MMt)
9.8
5.8
—
15.5
Mining cost per Mt sold ($/Mt)
108.5
106.0
—
107.6
For Year Ended December 31, 2022
(US$ in thousands)
Australia
United States
Other /
Corporate
Total
Consolidated
Total costs and
 
expenses
1,658,105
823,529
43,637
2,525,271
Less: Selling, general and administrative expense
(24)
—
(42,475)
(42,499)
Less: Depreciation, depletion and amortization
(82,295)
(83,589)
(1,162)
(167,046)
Total operating costs
1,575,786
739,940
—
2,315,726
Less: Other royalties
(330,503)
(54,562)
—
(385,065)
Less: Stanwell rebate
(165,995)
—
—
(165,995)
Less: Freight expenses
(153,068)
(96,013)
—
(249,081)
Less: Other non-mining costs
(61,604)
(57,553)
—
(119,157)
Total mining costs
864,616
531,812
—
1,396,428
Sales Volume excluding non-produced
 
coal (MMt)
9.7
6.1
—
15.8
Mining cost per Mt sold ($/Mt)
89.5
86.5
—
88.4
Average realized Met price for the Year
 
Ended December 31, 2023 compared to Year
 
December 31, 2022
A reconciliation of the Company’s average realized
 
Met coal revenue is shown below:
For Year Ended December 31,
(US$ in thousands)
2023
2022
Change
%
Met sales volume (MMt)
12.0
12.7
(0.7)
(5.5)%
Met coal revenues ($)
2,588,483
3,363,053
(774,570)
(23.0)%
Average realized met price per Mt sold ($/Mt)
215.7
265.8
(50.2)
(19.0)%
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
103
Reconciliation of Non-GAAP Financial Measures
Adjusted EBITDA
For year ended December 31,
(US$ in thousands)
2023
2022
2021
Reconciliation to Adjusted EBITDA:
Net income
156,065
771,703
189,423
Add: Depreciation, depletion and amortization
160,711
167,046
177,875
Add: Interest expense, net
56,751
67,632
68,062
Add: Other foreign exchange (gains) losses
(2,899)
(32,259)
7,049
Add: Loss on debt extinguishment
1,385
5,336
8,477
Add: Income tax (benefit) expense
(32,251)
231,574
53,102
Add: Uncertain stamp duty position
41,321
—
—
Add: Restructuring costs
—
—
2,300
Add: Losses on idled assets held for sale
4,846
771
2,732
Add: Gain on disposal of asset held for sale
—
—
(14,845)
Add: (Decrease) increase in provision for discounting
and credit losses
(4,216)
3,821
(8,042)
Adjusted EBITDA
381,713
1,215,624
486,133
Liquidity and Capital Resources
Overview
Our objective is to maintain a prudent capital structure and to ensure that sufficient liquid assets and funding are
available to meet both anticipated and
 
unanticipated financial obligations, including unforeseen events that could
have an
 
adverse impact
 
on revenues
 
or costs.
 
Our principal
 
sources of
 
funds are
 
cash and
 
cash equivalents,
cash flow from operations and availability under our debt
 
facilities.
 
Our main uses of cash have historically been, and are expected to continue to be, the funding of our
 
operations,
working capital,
 
capital
 
expenditure,
 
debt
 
service
 
obligations,
 
business
 
or assets
 
acquisitions
 
and
 
payment
 
of
dividends. Based
 
on our
 
outlook for
 
the next
 
twelve months,
 
which is
 
subject to
 
completion of
 
the SGI
 
Transaction,
continued changing demand from our customers, volatility in coal prices, ongoing interruptions and uncertainties
surrounding China’s import restrictions, such as trade barriers imposed by China on Australian sourced coal and
the
 
uncertainty
 
of
 
impacts
 
from
 
ongoing
 
civil
 
unrest
 
and
 
wars,
 
we
 
believe
 
expected
 
cash
 
generated
 
from
operations together with available borrowing facilities
 
and other strategic and financial
 
initiatives, will be sufficient
to meet
 
the needs
 
of our
 
existing operations,
 
capital expenditure,
 
service our
 
debt obligations
 
and, if
 
declared,
payment of dividends.
 
Under
 
the
 
Senior
 
Secured
 
Notes
 
Indenture,
 
upon
 
a
 
change
 
of
 
control,
 
we
 
are
 
required
 
to
 
make
 
an
 
offer
 
to
purchase the Notes from the holders at a
 
price of 101% of the principal amount thereof,
 
plus accrued and unpaid
interest.
 
Under the New ABL Facility,
 
a change of control constitutes a Review Event pursuant to which the Lenders may
request to meet
 
and consult with
 
us to agree
 
a strategy to
 
address the relevant
 
Review Event including
 
but not
limited to a restructure of the terms of the New ABL Facility
 
to the satisfaction of the Lenders.
 
Refer to Part II, Item 8. Financial Statements and Supplementary Data - Note 16. “Interest Bearing Liabilities” for
further information.
Our ability to generate
 
sufficient cash depends
 
on our future performance
 
which may be subject
 
to a number of
factors
 
beyond
 
our
 
control,
 
including
 
general
 
economic,
 
financial
 
and
 
competitive
 
conditions
 
and
 
other
 
risks
described in Part I, Item 1A. “Risk Factors” of this Annual
 
Report on Form 10-K.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
104
Liquidity as of December 31, 2023 and December 31,
 
2022 was as follows:
December 31,
(US$ in thousands)
2023
2022
Cash and cash equivalents, excluding restricted cash
339,043
334,378
Short-term deposits
21,906
—
Availability under the Predecessor ABL Facility
—
100,000
Availability under the New ABL Facility
(1)
128,094
—
Total
489,043
434,378
(1)
 
The New ABL Facility
 
provides for up
 
to $150.0 million
 
in borrowings, including
 
a $100.0 million
 
sublimit for the issuance
 
of letters of
 
credit,
of which $21.9 million has been issued, and $70.0 million sublimit as a revolving credit facility. The letter of credit sublimit contributes to our
liquidity as the Company can replace cash collateral, provided in the form of restricted deposits, with letters of credit allowing the release of
such restricted deposits to cash and cash equivalents.
Our total indebtedness as of December 31, 2023 and
 
December 31, 2022 consisted of the following:
(US$ in thousands)
2023
2022
Interest bearing liabilities, excluding current installments
242,326
242,326
Current installments of other financial liabilities and finance
 
lease obligations
2,893
4,585
Other financial liabilities and finance lease obligations, excluding current
installments
5,307
8,336
Total
250,526
255,247
Liquidity
As
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
available
 
liquidity
 
was
 
$489.0
 
million,
 
comprising
 
of
 
cash
 
and
 
cash
 
equivalents
(excluding restricted cash)
 
of $339.0 million,
 
short-term deposits of $21.9
 
million and $128.1 million
 
of available
borrowings under our New ABL Facility.
Coronado continues to actively
 
review plans for reducing
 
operating, corporate and capital expenditures
 
to ensure
sufficient available liquidity during periods of uncertainty
 
and volatility.
Cash and cash equivalents
Cash
 
and
 
cash
 
equivalents
 
are
 
held
 
in
 
multicurrency
 
interest
 
bearing
 
bank
 
accounts
 
available
 
to
 
be
 
used
 
to
service
 
the
 
working
 
capital
 
needs
 
of
 
the
 
Company.
 
Cash
 
balances
 
surplus
 
to
 
immediate
 
working
 
capital
requirements
 
are
 
invested
 
in
 
short-term
 
interest-bearing
 
deposit
 
accounts
 
or
 
used
 
to
 
repay
 
interest
 
bearing
liabilities.
Senior Secured Notes
As
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
the
 
outstanding
 
principal
 
amount
 
of
 
our
 
Notes
 
was
 
$242.3
 
million.
 
Interest
 
on
 
the
Notes is payable semi-annually in arrears on May 15 and November 15 of each year.
 
The Notes mature on May
15, 2026 and are senior secured obligations of the Company.
The Notes are guaranteed
 
on a senior secured
 
basis by the Company
 
and its wholly-owned
 
subsidiaries (other
than
 
the
 
Issuer)
 
(subject
 
to
 
certain
 
exceptions
 
and
 
permitted
 
liens)
 
and
 
secured
 
by
 
(i)
 
a
 
first-priority
 
lien
 
on
substantially all of the Company’s assets and the assets of the other guarantors (other than
 
accounts receivable
and other rights to payment,
 
inventory,
 
intercompany indebtedness, certain
 
general intangibles and commercial
tort claims, commodities accounts, deposit accounts, securities accounts and other related assets and proceeds
and
 
products
 
of
 
each
 
of
 
the
 
foregoing,
 
or,
 
collectively,
 
the
 
ABL
 
Collateral),
 
or
 
the
 
Notes
 
Collateral,
 
and
 
(ii)
 
a
second-priority lien on the ABL Collateral, which is
 
junior to a first-priority lien, for the
 
benefit of the lenders under
the ABL Facility.
The
 
terms
 
of
 
the
 
Notes
 
are
 
governed
 
by
 
the
 
Senior
 
Secured
 
Notes
 
Indenture,
 
which
 
contains
 
customary
covenants for high
 
yield bonds, including, but
 
not limited to,
 
limitations on investments, liens,
 
indebtedness, asset
sales, transactions with affiliates and restricted
 
payments, including payment of dividends on capital stock.
The Company may
 
redeem some or
 
all of the
 
Notes at the
 
redemption prices and
 
on the terms
 
specified in the
Senior Secured
 
Notes Indenture.
 
In addition,
 
the Company
 
may,
 
from time
 
to time,
 
seek to
 
retire or
 
purchase
outstanding
 
debt
 
through
 
open-market
 
purchases,
 
privately
 
negotiated
 
transactions
 
or
 
otherwise.
 
Such
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
105
repurchases, if any, will be upon such terms and at such
 
prices as the Company may determine, and will
 
depend
on prevailing market conditions, liquidity requirements, contractual
 
restrictions and other factors.
Based on information that
 
we are currently aware
 
of, on completion of
 
the SGI Transaction, a “Change
 
of Control”
as defined under the Senior
 
Secured Notes Indenture may occur.
 
Refer to Part II, Item 8.
 
Financial Statements,
Note 16. “Interest Bearing Liabilities” for further information.
 
As of December 31, 2023, we were in compliance with all applicable covenants under the Senior Secured Notes
Indenture.
New ABL Facility
On May 8, 2023, we entered into
 
a senior secured asset-based revolving credit agreement in an
 
initial aggregate
amount of $150.0 million, or the New ABL Facility.
On August 3, 2023, the
 
Company satisfied all conditions
 
precedent under the New ABL
 
Facility,
 
at which time it
became effective and replaced the predecessor
 
ABL Facility.
 
The New
 
ABL Facility
 
matures in
 
August 2026
 
and provides
 
for up
 
to $150.0
 
million in
 
borrowings, including
 
a
$100.0 million sublimit for the issuance
 
of letters of credit and $70.0
 
million sublimit as a revolving
 
credit facility.
Availability under the New
 
ABL Facility is
 
limited to an
 
eligible borrowing base, determined
 
by applying customary
advance rates to eligible accounts receivable and inventory.
Borrowings under the New
 
ABL Facility bear interest
 
at a rate per
 
annum equal to applicable
 
rate of 2.80% and
BBSY,
 
for loans denominated in A$, or SOFR, for loans
 
denominated in US$, at the Borrower’s election.
 
Subject
 
to
 
customary
 
grace
 
periods
 
and
 
notice
 
requirements,
 
the
 
New
 
ABL
 
Facility
 
also
 
contains
 
customary
events of default.
Based on information that
 
we are currently aware
 
of, on completion of
 
the SGI Transaction, a “Change
 
of Control”
as defined
 
under the
 
terms of
 
the New
 
ABL Facility
 
may occur.
 
Refer to
 
Part II,
 
Item 8.
 
Financial Statements,
Note 16. “Interest Bearing Liabilities” for further information.
 
As at
 
December 31 2023,
 
letter of
 
credit sublimit had
 
been partially used
 
to issue $21.9
 
million of bank
 
guarantees
on behalf
 
of the
 
Company and no
 
amounts were drawn
 
under the
 
revolving credit sublimit
 
of the
 
New ABL Facility.
As at
 
December 31,
 
2023, the
 
Company was
 
in compliance
 
with all
 
applicable covenants
 
under the
 
New ABL
Facility.
Predecessor ABL Facility
On August 3, 2023, we satisfied all conditions precedent under the New ABL Facility at which time the New ABL
Facility replaced
 
the predecessor ABL
 
Facility. As a result
 
of the
 
early termination of
 
the predecessor ABL
 
Facility,
we
 
recorded
 
a
 
loss
 
on
 
debt
 
extinguishment
 
of
 
$1.4
 
million
 
in
 
our
 
Consolidated
 
Statement
 
of
 
Operations
 
and
Comprehensive Income for the year ended December
 
31, 2023.
Surety Bonds, Letters of Credit and Bank Guarantees
We
 
are
 
required
 
to
 
provide
 
financial
 
assurances
 
and
 
securities
 
to
 
satisfy
 
contractual
 
and
 
other
 
requirements
generated in the
 
normal course of
 
business. Some of
 
these assurances are provided
 
to comply with
 
state or other
government agencies’ statutes and regulations.
 
For
 
the
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
in
 
order
 
to
 
provide
 
the
 
required
 
financial
 
assurance
 
for
 
post
 
mining
 
reclamation,
 
we
generally
 
use
 
surety
 
bonds.
 
We
 
use
 
surety
 
bonds
 
and
 
bank
 
letters
 
of
 
credit
 
to
 
collateralize
 
certain
 
other
obligations including contractual obligations under
 
workers’ compensation insurances. As of
 
December 31, 2023,
we had outstanding surety bonds of $44.0 million and letters of credit of $16.8 million issued from available bank
guarantees under the New ABL Facility.
 
For the Australian
 
Operations as
 
at December 31,
 
2023, we had
 
bank guarantees
 
outstanding of $24.4
 
million,
including $5.1 million issued from the New ABL Facility, primarily in respect of certain rail and port arrangements
of the Company.
 
As at December 31, 2023,
 
we, in aggregate, had total
 
outstanding bank guarantees provided
 
of $41.2 million to
secure obligations and commitments, including $21.9
 
million issued from the New ABL Facility.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
106
Future regulatory changes relating to the above obligations could result in
 
increased obligations, additional costs
or additional collateral requirements.
Restricted deposits – cash collateral
As required by certain agreements,
 
we had cash collateral in the form
 
of deposits in the amount of $68.7
 
million
and $89.1
 
million
 
as of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023
 
and
 
2022, respectively,
 
to
 
provide
 
back-to-back
 
support for
 
bank
guarantees,
 
financial
 
payments,
 
other
 
performance
 
obligations,
 
various
 
other
 
operating
 
agreements
 
and
contractual obligations
 
under workers
 
compensation insurance.
 
These deposits
 
are restricted
 
and classified
 
as
long-term assets in the Consolidated Balance Sheets.
In accordance
 
with the
 
terms of
 
the New
 
ABL Facility,
 
we may
 
be required
 
to cash
 
collateralize the
 
New ABL
Facility to the extent of outstanding letters of credit after the expiration or termination date of such letter of credit.
As of December 31, 2023, no such letter
 
of credit was outstanding after the expiration or termination date
 
and no
cash collateral was required.
Dividend
During the year ended December 31, 2023, we paid $16.7 million in dividends to stockholders or CDI holders on
the ASX,
 
net of $0.1
 
million foreign exchange
 
gain on payment
 
of dividends to
 
certain CDI holders
 
that elected
to be paid in Australian dollars.
On
 
February
 
19,
 
2024,
 
the
 
Company’s
 
Board
 
of
 
Directors
 
declared
 
a
 
bi-annual
 
fully
 
franked
 
fixed
 
ordinary
dividend of $8.4 million, or
 
0.5 cents per CDI. The
 
dividend will have a
 
record date of March
 
12, 2024, Australia
time, and
 
be payable
 
on April
 
4, 2024,
 
Australia time.
 
The total
 
ordinary dividend
 
will be
 
funded from
 
available
cash.
Capital Requirements
Our main uses of cash have historically been the funding
 
of our operations, working capital, capital expenditure,
the payment of
 
interest and dividends.
 
We intend
 
to use cash
 
to fund debt
 
service payments
 
on our Notes,
 
the
New ABL Facility and our
 
other indebtedness, to fund
 
operating activities, working capital,
 
capital expenditures,
partial redemption of the Notes, business or assets acquisitions
 
and, if declared, payment of dividends.
Historical Cash Flows
 
The
 
following
 
table
 
summarizes
 
our
 
cash
 
flows
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
2022
 
and
 
2021
 
as
reported in the accompanying Consolidated Financial Statements:
Cash Flow
For Year Ended December 31,
 
(US$ in thousands)
2023
2022
2021
Net cash provided by operating activities
268,282
926,643
442,014
Net cash used in investing activities
(238,168)
(208,343)
(134,332)
Net cash (used in) provided by financing activities
(24,679)
(784,251)
80,836
Net change in cash and cash equivalents
5,435
(65,951)
388,518
Effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash
 
equivalents
(769)
(37,351)
3,677
Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of period
334,629
437,931
45,736
Cash and cash equivalents at end of period
339,295
334,629
437,931
Operating activities
Net cash provided
 
by operating activities
 
was $268.3 million
 
for the year ended
 
December 31, 2023,
 
compared
to $926.6
 
million
 
for the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2022.
 
The
 
decrease
 
in
 
cash
 
from
 
operating
 
activities
 
was
primarily driven by lower coal revenues,
 
higher operating costs and income tax
 
paid of $147.1 million during the
year.
 
Net cash provided
 
by operating activities
 
was $926.6 million
 
for the year ended
 
December 31, 2022,
 
compared
to a
 
cash provided
 
by in
 
operating activities of
 
$442.0 million for the
 
year ended
 
December 31, 2021.
 
The increase
was primarily driven by higher coal revenues due to an increase in the average
 
realized Met coal pricing partially
offset by higher operating
 
costs and unfavorable working capital
 
movement due to higher trade
 
receivables and
inventories at December 31, 2022.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
107
Investing activities
Net cash
 
used in
 
investing
 
activities was
 
$238.2 million
 
for the
 
year
 
ended December
 
31, 2023,
 
compared
 
to
$208.3 million
 
for the
 
year ended
 
December 31,
 
2022. Cash
 
spent on
 
capital expenditures
 
for the
 
year ended
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
was
 
$237.2
 
million,
 
of
 
which
 
$65.4
 
million
 
was
 
related
 
to
 
the
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
and
$171.2
 
million was related to the U.S. Operations.
Net cash
 
used in
 
investing
 
activities was
 
$208.3 million
 
for the
 
year
 
ended December
 
31, 2022,
 
compared
 
to
$134.3 million
 
for the
 
year ended
 
December 31,
 
2021. Cash
 
spent on
 
capital expenditures
 
for the
 
year ended
December 31,
 
2022, was
 
$199.7 million,
 
of which
 
$79.4
 
million is
 
related to
 
the Australian
 
Operations, $119.7
million is related
 
to the U.S.
 
Operations and the
 
remaining $0.6 million
 
for other and corporate.
 
During the year
ended December
 
31, 2022,
 
a net
 
of $6.5
 
million of
 
additional deposits
 
were provided
 
as collateral
 
for our
 
U.S.
workers
 
compensation
 
obligations
 
and
 
$2.4
 
million
 
of
 
the
 
additional
 
security
 
deposits
 
were
 
provided
 
by
 
our
Australian Operations to satisfy contractual requirements
 
in the normal course of business.
Financing activities
Net cash used in financing activities was $24.7
 
million for the year ended December 31, 2023,
 
compared to cash
used
 
in
 
financing
 
activities
 
of
 
$784.3
 
million
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2022.
 
The
 
net
 
cash
 
used
 
in
financing activities for the year ended December 31, 2023, largely related to dividend payments of $16.8 million,
payment of debt issuance costs in connection with the establishment
 
of the New ABL Facility of $3.4 million and
the remainder related to repayment of other financial liabilities.
Net cash
 
used in
 
financing
 
activities was
 
$784.3 million
 
for the
 
year ended
 
December
 
31, 2022,
 
compared
 
to
cash provided by financing activities of
 
$80.8 million for the year ended
 
December 31, 2021. The net cash
 
used
in financing activities for
 
the year ended December
 
31, 2022, included dividend
 
payments of $700.2
million,
 
net
of a
 
$1.4 million
 
foreign exchange
 
gain on
 
settlement
 
of dividends
 
for shareholders
 
who elected
 
to be
 
paid
 
in
Australian dollars
 
,
 
$72.7 million
 
of Notes
 
redeemed
 
and
 
$2.6 million
 
of premium
 
paid on
 
redemption,
 
and the
remainder related to repayment of other financial liabilities.
Contractual Obligations
The following is a summary of our contractual obligations
 
at December 31, 2023:
Payments Due By Year
Less than
1
‑
 
3
3
‑
 
5
More than
(US$ in thousands)
Total
1 Year
Years
Years
5 Years
Long
‑
term debt obligations
(1)
9,172
3,466
5,706
—
—
Senior secured notes
(2)
242,326
—
242,326
—
—
Mineral lease commitments
(3)
53,075
5,795
10,703
10,415
26,162
Lease commitments
99,229
29,218
48,989
21,022
—
Unconditional purchase obligations
(4)
20,872
20,872
—
—
—
Take
‑
or
‑
pay contracts
(5)
788,431
94,688
187,326
189,295
317,122
Total
 
contractual cash obligations
1,213,105
154,039
495,050
220,732
343,284
(1)
 
Represents
 
financial
 
obligation
 
relating
 
to
 
amounts
 
outstanding
 
from
 
financing
 
equipment
 
purchases,
insurance premiums and financial liabilities for a sale and lease
 
back type arrangement.
(2)
 
Represents financial obligation
 
outstanding under the
 
Senior Secured Notes. Refer
 
to Note 16 “Interest
Bearing
 
Liabilities”
 
in
 
the
 
accompanying
 
audited
 
Consolidated
 
Financial
 
Statements
 
for
 
additional
discussion.
(3)
 
Represents
 
future
 
minimum
 
royalties
 
and
 
payments
 
under
 
mineral
 
leases.
 
Refer
 
to
 
Note
 
25
“Commitments”
in
 
the
 
accompanying
 
audited
 
Consolidated
 
Financial
 
Statements
 
for
 
additional
discussion.
(4)
 
Represents firm purchase commitments for
 
capital expenditures (based on order to
 
suppliers for capital
purchases) for 2024.
(5)
 
Represents various short- and long-term
 
take-or-pay arrangements in
 
Australia associated with rail and
port commitments for the delivery of coal.
This
 
table
 
does
 
not
 
include
 
our
 
estimated
 
Asset
 
Retirement
 
Obligations,
 
or
 
ARO.
 
As
 
discussed
 
in
 
“—Critical
Accounting
 
Policies
 
and
 
Estimates—Carrying
 
Value
 
of
 
Asset
 
Retirement
 
Obligations”
 
below,
 
the
 
current
 
and
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
108
non-current
 
carrying
 
amount
 
of
 
our
 
ARO
 
involves
 
several
 
estimates,
 
including
 
the
 
amount
 
and
 
timing
 
of
 
the
payments required to satisfy
 
these obligations. The timing
 
of payments is based on numerous
 
factors, including
projected
 
mine
 
closure
 
dates.
 
Based
 
on
 
our
 
assumptions,
 
the
 
carrying
 
amount
 
of
 
our
 
ARO
 
as
 
determined
 
in
accordance with U.S. GAAP was $163.9 million as of
 
December 31, 2023.
Critical Accounting Policies and Estimates
The preparation
 
of
 
our Consolidated
 
Financial
 
Statements
 
in conformity
 
with
 
U.S. GAAP
 
requires
 
us
 
to
 
make
estimates
 
and
 
assumptions
 
that
 
affect
 
the
 
reported
 
amounts
 
of
 
assets
 
and
 
liabilities
 
at
 
the
 
date
 
of
 
the
Consolidated
 
Financial
 
Statements
 
and
 
the
 
reported
 
amounts
 
of
 
revenue
 
and
 
expenses
 
during
 
the
 
reporting
period.
 
Listed
 
below
 
are
 
the
 
accounting
 
estimates
 
that
 
we
 
believe
 
are
 
critical
 
to
 
our
 
Consolidated
 
Financial
Statements due to the degree of
 
uncertainty regarding the estimates or assumptions involved and
 
the magnitude
of the asset, liability, revenue or expense being reported. All of these accounting
 
estimates and assumptions, as
well
 
as
 
the
 
resulting
 
impact
 
to
 
our
 
Consolidated
 
Financial
 
Statements,
 
have
 
been
 
discussed
 
with
 
the
 
Audit,
Governance and Risk Committee, or Audit Committee,
 
of our Board of Directors.
See Note 2.
 
“Summary of Significant
 
Accounting Policies”
 
to the accompanying
 
audited Consolidated Financial
Statements for a summary of our significant accounting policies.
 
Fair Value of Non-Financial Assets
Long-Lived Assets
We
 
review
 
the
 
carrying
 
value
 
of
 
long-lived
 
assets
 
to
 
be
 
used
 
in
 
operations
 
annually
 
or
 
whenever
 
events
 
or
changes
 
in
 
circumstances
 
indicate
 
that
 
the
 
carrying
 
amount
 
of
 
the
 
assets
 
or
 
asset
 
groups
 
might
 
not
 
be
recoverable.
 
Factors that would necessitate
 
an impairment assessment
 
include a significant adverse
 
change in the extent
 
or
manner in which an asset is
 
used, a significant adverse change in
 
legal factors or the business climate
 
that could
affect
 
the
 
value
 
of
 
the
 
asset
 
group
 
or
 
a significant
 
decline
 
in
 
the
 
observable
 
market
 
value
 
of
 
an
 
asset
 
group,
among others. If such facts
 
indicate a potential impairment,
 
the recoverability of the asset
 
group is assessed by
determining whether the carrying value
 
of the asset group exceeds
 
the sum of the projected
 
undiscounted cash
flows expected to
 
result from
 
the use and
 
eventual disposition
 
of the asset
 
group over the
 
remaining economic
life of the asset
 
group. If the projected undiscounted cash
 
flows are less than
 
the carrying amount, an impairment
is recorded
 
for the
 
excess of
 
the carrying
 
amount over
 
the estimated
 
fair value,
 
which is
 
generally determined
using discounted future cash
 
flows. Any such write
 
down is included in
 
impairment expense in our
 
consolidated
statement of operations.
A high degree of
 
judgment is required
 
to estimate the
 
fair value of
 
our intangible and
 
long-lived assets, and
 
the
conclusions that
 
we reach
 
could vary
 
significantly based
 
on these
 
judgments.
 
We make
 
various
 
assumptions,
including assumptions regarding
 
future cash flows
 
in our
 
assessments of
 
fair value. The
 
assumptions about future
cash
 
flows
 
and
 
growth
 
rates
 
are
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
current
 
and
 
long-term
 
business
 
plans
 
related
 
to
 
the
 
long-lived
assets. Discount
 
rate assumptions
 
are based
 
on an
 
assessment of
 
the risk
 
inherent in
 
the future
 
cash flows
 
of
the long-lived assets.
At
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
we
 
determined,
 
based
 
on
 
our
 
qualitative
 
assessment,
 
that
 
no
 
impairment
 
indicators
existed.
 
Goodwill Impairment
We had
 
a balance
 
of goodwill
 
of $28.0 million
 
recorded at
 
December 31,
 
2023, which
 
was generated
 
upon the
acquisition of Buchanan
 
in 2016. We
 
perform our annual assessment
 
of the recoverability of
 
our goodwill in
 
the
fourth quarter of each year. We utilize a qualitative assessment for determining whether the quantitative goodwill
impairment analysis is
 
necessary.
 
The accounting guidance
 
permits entities to
 
first assess qualitative
 
factors to
determine whether it is more
 
likely than not that the
 
fair value of a reporting
 
unit is less than its carrying
 
amount
as
 
a
 
basis
 
for
 
determining
 
whether
 
it
 
is
 
necessary
 
to
 
perform
 
the
 
quantitative
 
goodwill
 
impairment
 
test.
 
In
evaluating goodwill on
 
a qualitative basis,
 
we review the
 
business performance
 
of the Buchanan
 
mine complex
(the only reporting
 
unit with
 
a goodwill balance)
 
and evaluate
 
other relevant
 
factors as
 
identified in the
 
relevant
accounting
 
guidance
 
to
 
determine
 
whether
 
it
 
is
 
more
 
likely
 
than
 
not
 
that
 
an
 
indicator
 
of
 
impairment
 
exists
 
at
Buchanan. We consider whether there are any negative macroeconomic conditions, industry specific conditions,
market
 
changes,
 
increased
 
competition,
 
increased
 
costs
 
in
 
doing
 
business,
 
management
 
challenges,
 
legal
environments and how these factors might
 
impact company specific performance in future periods.
 
As part of the
analysis, we
 
also consider
 
fair value
 
determinations for
 
certain reporting
 
units that
 
have been
 
made at
 
various
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
109
points throughout
 
the current
 
and prior
 
year for
 
other purposes
 
to ensure
 
there is
 
no contrary
 
evidence to
 
our
analysis. At
 
December 31,
 
2023, we
 
did not
 
perform a
 
quantitative impairment
 
assessment as
 
we determined,
based on our qualitative assessment, that no impairment
 
indicators existed.
Carrying Value of Asset Retirement Obligations
The Company is required to maintain a liability
 
(and associated asset) for the expected value of future
 
retirement
obligations on their mines, in line with ASC 410, Asset
 
Retirement and Environmental Obligations.
Reclamation
 
of
 
areas
 
disturbed
 
by
 
mining
 
operations
 
must
 
be
 
performed
 
by
 
us
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
approved
reclamation plans and in compliance with state and federal laws in the states of West Virginia and Virginia
 
in the
U.S., and Queensland in Australia. For areas disturbed, a significant amount of the reclamation will take place in
the future, when
 
operations cease. There
 
were no assets
 
that were
 
legally restricted for
 
purposes of settling
 
asset
retirement obligations
 
as of
 
December 31,
 
2023. In
 
addition, state
 
agencies monitor
 
compliance with
 
the mine
plans, including reclamation.
We
 
record
 
the
 
fair
 
value
 
of
 
additions
 
to
 
our
 
asset
 
retirement
 
obligations
 
using
 
the
 
present
 
value
 
of
 
projected
future
 
cash
 
flows
 
discounted
 
using
 
a
 
credit-adjusted
 
risk-free
 
rate,
 
with
 
an
 
equivalent
 
amount
 
recorded
 
as
 
a
long-lived asset. An accretion
 
cost is recorded each
 
period and the capitalized cost
 
is depreciated over the
 
useful
life of the
 
related asset. As reclamation
 
work is performed or
 
liabilities are otherwise settled, the
 
recorded amount
of the liability is reduced.
A review
 
of restoration
 
and
 
decommissioning
 
provisions
 
is carried
 
out annually
 
on a
 
mine-by-mine
 
basis,
 
and
adjustments are made to reflect any changes in estimates, if necessary. On an interim basis, we may update the
liability based on significant changes to the life of mine or significant increases in disturbances during the period.
Expected Credit Losses
For trade and related party
 
receivables carried at amortized
 
cost, we determine expected
 
credit losses, or ECL,
on a forward-looking basis. The amount of ECL is updated at each reporting date to reflect changes in credit risk
since the
 
initial recognition of
 
the respective
 
financial instrument. We
 
recognize the lifetime
 
ECL. ECL
 
is estimated
based on our
 
historic credit loss
 
experience, adjusted for
 
factors that are
 
specific to the
 
financial asset, general
economic
 
conditions,
 
financial
 
asset
 
type,
 
term
 
and
 
an
 
assessment
 
of
 
both
 
the
 
current
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
forecast
conditions, including
 
the expected
 
timing of
 
collection, at
 
the reporting
 
date, modified
 
for credit
 
enhancements
such
 
as
 
letters
 
of
 
credit
 
obtained.
To
measure
 
ECL,
 
trade
 
and
 
related
 
party
 
receivables
 
have
 
been
 
grouped
based on shared credit risk characteristics and the days
 
past due.
We consider
 
an event
 
of default
 
has occurred
 
when
 
a financial
 
asset is
 
significantly
 
past due
 
or other
 
factors
indicate that the debtor
 
is unlikely to pay
 
amounts owed to us.
 
A financial asset is
 
credit impaired when there
 
is
evidence that the counterparty
 
is in significant financial
 
difficulty or a
 
breach of contract, such
 
as default or past
due event
 
has occurred.
 
We write
 
off a
 
financial asset
 
when there
 
is information
 
indicating there
 
is no
 
realistic
prospect of recovery of the
 
asset from the counterparty.
 
The amount of the impairment
 
loss is recognized in the
consolidated statement of operations
 
and other comprehensive income
 
within “Decrease (increase) in
 
provision
for discounting
 
and
 
credit
 
losses”.
 
Subsequent
 
recoveries
 
of
 
amounts
 
previously
 
written
 
off
 
are credit
 
against
“Decrease (increase) provision for discounting and
 
credit losses” in the
 
consolidated statement of operations and
other comprehensive income.
Recoverable Coal Reserves
There are numerous uncertainties inherent
 
in estimating quantities and values of economically
 
recoverable coal
reserves,
 
including
 
many
 
factors
 
beyond
 
our
 
control.
 
As
 
a
 
result,
 
estimates
 
of
 
economically
 
recoverable
 
coal
reserves
 
are
 
by
 
their
 
nature
 
uncertain.
 
Information
 
about
 
our
 
reserves
 
consists
 
of
 
estimates
 
based
 
on
engineering,
 
economic
 
and
 
geological
 
data
 
assembled
 
and
 
analyzed
 
by
 
our
 
staff
 
and
 
third-party
 
qualified
persons. Our
 
reserves are
 
periodically reviewed
 
by an
 
independent third
 
party consultant.
 
Some of
 
the factors
and assumptions which impact economically recoverable reserve
 
estimates include:
•
 
geological settings;
•
 
historical production from the area compared with production from
 
other producing areas;
•
 
the assumed effects of regulations and taxes by governmental
 
agencies
;
•
 
assumptions governing future prices; and
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
110
•
 
future operating costs.
Each of these factors may in fact vary considerably from the
 
assumptions used in estimating reserves. For these
reasons,
 
estimates
 
of
 
the
 
economically
 
recoverable
 
quantities
 
of
 
coal
 
attributable
 
to
 
a
 
particular
 
group
 
of
properties, and classifications
 
of these reserves
 
based on the
 
risk of recovery
 
and estimates of
 
future net cash
flows,
 
may
 
vary
 
substantially.
 
Actual
 
production,
 
revenues
 
and
 
expenditures
 
with
 
respect
 
to
 
our
 
reserves
 
will
likely
 
vary
 
from
 
estimates,
 
and
 
these
 
variances
 
may
 
be
 
material.
 
See
 
Item 1A.
 
“Risk
 
Factors—We
 
rely
 
on
estimates of our
 
recoverable reserves,
 
which is complex
 
due to geological
 
characteristics of the
 
properties and
the number of assumptions made”
 
and Item 2. “Properties” for discussions
 
of the uncertainties in estimating
 
our
proven and probable coal reserves.
Taxes
We are required to
 
estimate the amount of
 
tax payable or
 
refundable for the
 
current year and the
 
deferred income
tax liabilities and assets
 
for the future tax consequences
 
of events that have
 
been reflected in our
 
Consolidated
Financial Statements
 
or tax
 
returns for
 
each taxing
 
jurisdiction in
 
which we
 
operate. This
 
process requires
 
our
management to
 
make judgments
 
regarding the
 
timing and
 
probability of
 
the ultimate
 
tax impact
 
of the
 
various
agreements
 
and
 
transactions
 
that
 
we
 
enter
 
into.
 
Based
 
on
 
these
 
judgments
 
we
 
may
 
record
 
tax
 
reserves
 
or
adjustments
 
to
 
valuation
 
allowances
 
on
 
deferred
 
tax
 
assets
 
to
 
reflect
 
the
 
expected
 
realizability
 
of
 
future
 
tax
benefits. Actual income
 
taxes could vary
 
from these estimates
 
due to
 
future changes in
 
income tax
 
law, significant
changes
 
in
 
the
 
jurisdictions
 
in
 
which
 
we
 
operate,
 
our
 
inability
 
to
 
generate
 
sufficient
 
future
 
taxable
 
income
 
or
unpredicted results from the final
 
determination of each year’s
 
liability by taxing authorities. These
 
changes could
have a significant impact on our financial position.
Newly Adopted Accounting Standards and Accounting
 
Standards Not Yet Implemented
See Note 2. “Summary
 
of Significant Accounting
 
Policies” to the
 
accompanying audited
 
Consolidated Financial
Statements
 
for
 
a
 
discussion
 
of
 
newly
 
adopted
 
accounting
 
standards
 
and
 
accounting
 
standards
 
not
 
yet
implemented.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
111
ITEM 7A.
 
QUANTITATIVE
 
AND QUALITATIVE
 
DISCLOSURES ABOUT MARKET RISK
Our activities
 
expose us
 
to
 
a variety
 
of financial
 
risks, such
 
as commodity
 
price risk,
 
interest rate
 
risk, foreign
currency risk, liquidity risk and credit
 
risk. The overall risk management objective is
 
to minimize potential adverse
effects on our financial performance from those
 
risks which are not coal price related.
We manage
 
financial risk
 
through policies
 
and procedures
 
approved by
 
our Board
 
of Directors.
 
These specify
the responsibility
 
of the
 
Board
 
of Directors
 
and
 
management
 
with regard
 
to the
 
management
 
of financial
 
risk.
Financial risks are
 
managed centrally by
 
our finance
 
team under the
 
direction of the
 
Group Chief
 
Financial Officer.
The finance team manages risk exposures primarily through delegated authority limits approved by the Board of
Directors. The finance team regularly monitors our exposure
 
to these financial risks and reports to management
and
 
the
 
Board
 
of
 
Directors
 
on
 
a
 
regular
 
basis.
 
Policies
 
are
 
reviewed
 
at
 
least
 
annually
 
and
 
amended
 
where
appropriate.
We may use
 
derivative financial instruments such
 
as forward fixed
 
price commodity contracts, interest
 
rate swaps
and
 
foreign
 
exchange
 
rate
 
contracts
 
to
 
hedge
 
certain
 
risk
 
exposures.
 
Derivatives
 
for
 
speculative
 
purposes
 
is
strictly prohibited by the Treasury Risk Management Policy approved by our Board of
 
Directors. We use different
methods
 
to
 
measure
 
the
 
extent
 
to
 
which
 
we
 
are
 
exposed
 
to
 
various
 
financial
 
risks.
 
These
 
methods
 
include
sensitivity analysis in
 
the case of
 
interest rate, foreign
 
exchange and other
 
price risks and
 
aging analysis for
 
credit
risk.
Commodity Price Risk
Coal Price Risk
We
 
are
 
exposed
 
to
 
domestic
 
and
 
global
 
coal
 
prices.
 
Our
 
principal
 
philosophy
 
is
 
that
 
our
 
investors
 
would
 
not
consider
 
hedging
 
of
 
coal
 
prices
 
to
 
be
 
in
 
the
 
long-term
 
interest
 
of
 
our
 
stockholders.
 
Therefore,
 
any
 
potential
hedging of coal prices through long-term fixed price contracts is subject to the approval of our Board of Directors
and would only be adopted in exceptional circumstances.
The
 
expectation
 
of
 
future
 
prices
 
for
 
coal
 
depends
 
upon
 
many
 
factors
 
beyond
 
our
 
control.
 
Met
 
coal
 
has
 
been
volatile commodity
 
over the
 
past ten
 
years. Met
 
coal prices
 
were lower
 
in 2023
 
compared to
 
record highs
 
achieved
in 2022 from the impacts of the Russia and Ukraine war. The first half of 2023 saw Met coal index prices
 
decline
significantly as steel
 
demand weakened,
 
however,
 
Met coal prices
 
trended upwards
 
in the second
 
half of 2023
due to
 
tight supply
 
and port
 
constraints in
 
Australia. The
 
demand and
 
supply in
 
the Met
 
coal industry
 
changes
from time to time. There are no
 
assurances that oversupply will not occur,
 
that demand will not decrease or
 
that
overcapacity will not occur, which could cause
 
declines in the prices of
 
coal, which could have a
 
material adverse
effect on our financial condition and results
 
of operations
Access to
 
international markets
 
may be
 
subject to
 
ongoing interruptions
 
and trade
 
barriers due
 
to policies
 
and
tariffs
 
of
 
individual
 
countries.
 
We
 
may
 
or
 
may
 
not
 
be
 
able
 
to
 
access
 
alternate
 
markets
 
of
 
our
 
coal
 
should
interruptions
 
or
 
trade
 
barriers
 
occur
 
in
 
the
 
future.
 
An
 
inability
 
for
 
metallurgical
 
coal
 
suppliers
 
to
 
access
international markets would likely result
 
in an oversupply of Met coal and
 
may result in a decrease in prices
 
and
or the curtailment of production.
We manage
 
our commodity
 
price risk
 
for our non-trading,
 
thermal coal
 
sales through
 
the use
 
of long-term
 
coal
supply agreements in our
 
U.S. Operations. In Australia, thermal
 
coal is sold
 
to Stanwell on a
 
supply contract. See
Part I, Item 1A. “Risk Factors—Risks related to the Supply Deed with Stanwell may
 
adversely affect our financial
condition and results of operations.”
Sales commitments in the
 
Met coal market are typically
 
not long-term in nature, and
 
we are therefore subject
 
to
fluctuations in
 
market pricing.
 
Certain coal
 
sales are
 
provisionally priced
 
initially.
 
Provisionally priced
 
sales are
those for which price finalization,
 
referenced to the relevant index,
 
is outstanding at the reporting
 
date. The final
sales price
 
is determined
 
within 7
 
to 90
 
days after
 
delivery to
 
the customer.
 
As of
 
December 31,
 
2023, we had
$11.9
 
million
 
of
 
outstanding
 
provisionally
 
priced
 
receivables
 
subject
 
to
 
changes
 
in
 
the
 
relevant
 
price
 
index.
 
If
prices decreased 10%,
 
these provisionally priced
 
receivables would decrease
 
by $1.2 million.
 
See Part
 
I, Item
 
1A.
“Risk Factors—Our profitability depends
 
upon the prices we receive for
 
our coal. Prices for coal
 
are volatile and
can fluctuate widely based upon a number of factors
 
beyond our control.”
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
112
Diesel Fuel
We may
 
be exposed
 
to price
 
risk in
 
relation to
 
other commodities
 
from time
 
to time
 
arising from
 
raw materials
used in
 
our operations
 
(such as
 
gas or
 
diesel). The
 
expectation of
 
future prices
 
for diesel
 
depends upon
 
many
factors
 
beyond
 
our
 
control.
 
The
 
current
 
Israel-Palestine
 
conflict
 
could
 
create
 
significant
 
uncertainty
 
regarding
interruptions to global oil supply causing significant
 
volatility in prices of related commodities,
 
including the price
of diesel fuel we
 
purchase. These commodities
 
may be hedged
 
through financial instruments
 
if the exposure
 
is
considered material and where the exposure cannot be
 
mitigated through fixed price supply agreements.
The fuel required for our operations in 2024 will be purchased
 
under fixed-price contracts or on a spot basis.
 
Interest Rate Risk
Interest rate risk is the risk that a change in interest rates
 
on our borrowing facilities will have an adverse impact
on
 
our
 
financial
 
performance,
 
investment
 
decisions
 
and
 
stockholder
 
return.
 
Our
 
objectives
 
in
 
managing
 
our
exposure
 
to
 
interest
 
rates
 
include
 
minimizing
 
interest
 
costs
 
in
 
the
 
long
 
term,
 
providing
 
a
 
reliable
 
estimate
 
of
interest costs for the
 
annual work program
 
and budget and ensuring
 
that changes in interest
 
rates will not have
a material impact on our financial performance.
As
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
we
 
had
 
$250.5
 
million
 
of
 
fixed-rate
 
borrowings
 
and
 
no variable-rate
 
borrowings
outstanding.
 
We currently do not hedge against interest rate
 
fluctuations.
 
Foreign Exchange Risk
A significant portion of our
 
sales are denominated in US$.
 
Foreign exchange risk is
 
the risk that our earnings
 
or
cash flows are adversely impacted by movements in
 
exchange rates of currencies that are not in US$.
Our main exposure
 
is to the
 
A$-US$ exchange rate
 
through our Australian
 
Operations, which have
 
predominantly
A$
 
denominated
 
costs.
 
In
 
2023,
 
greater
 
than
 
70%
 
of
 
expenses
 
incurred
 
at
 
our
 
Australian
 
Operations
 
were
denominated in
 
A$. Approximately
 
30% of
 
our Australian
 
Operations’
 
purchases were
 
made with
 
reference
 
to
US$, which provides
 
a natural hedge
 
against foreign exchange
 
movements on these
 
purchases (including fuel,
several port handling charges,
 
demurrage, purchased coal
 
and some insurance
 
premiums). Appreciation of
 
the
A$ against
 
US$ will
 
increase our
 
Australian Operations’
 
US$ reported
 
cost base
 
and reduce
 
US$ reported
 
net
income. For
 
the portion
 
of US$
 
required to
 
purchase A$
 
to settle
 
our Australian
 
Operations’ operating
 
costs, a
10%
 
increase
 
in
 
the
 
A$
 
to
 
US$
 
exchange
 
rate
 
would
 
have
 
increased
 
reported
 
total
 
costs
 
and
 
expenses
 
by
approximately $122.8 million for the year ended December
 
31, 2023.
 
Under normal market conditions, we generally do not consider it necessary to hedge our
 
exposure to this foreign
exchange risk.
 
However,
 
there
 
may be
 
specific commercial
 
circumstances,
 
such
 
as the
 
hedging
 
of significant
capital
 
expenditure,
 
acquisitions,
 
disposals
 
and
 
other
 
financial
 
transactions,
 
where
 
we
 
may
 
deem
 
foreign
exchange hedging
 
as appropriate
 
and
 
where a
 
US$ contract
 
cannot
 
be negotiated
 
directly with
 
suppliers
 
and
other third parties.
 
For our Australian
 
Operations, we
 
translate all
 
monetary assets
 
and liabilities
 
at the period-end
 
exchange rate,
all non-monetary
 
assets and
 
liabilities
 
at historical
 
rates
 
and revenue
 
and expenses
 
at the
 
average exchange
rates in effect
 
during the periods. The
 
net effect of
 
these translation adjustments
 
is shown in the
 
accompanying
Consolidated Financial Statements within components
 
of net income.
We currently do not hedge our non-US$ exposures
 
against exchange rate fluctuations.
Credit Risk
Credit risk is the risk of
 
sustaining a financial loss
 
as a result of a counterparty
 
not meeting its obligations
 
under
a financial instrument or customer contract.
We are exposed
 
to credit risk
 
when we have financial
 
derivatives, cash deposits,
 
lines of credit, letters
 
of credit
or bank guarantees
 
in place with
 
financial institutions.
To
mitigate against credit risk
 
from financial counterparties,
we have minimum credit rating requirements with financial
 
institutions where we transact.
We
 
are
 
also
 
exposed
 
to
 
counterparty
 
credit
 
risk
 
arising
 
from
 
our
 
operating
 
activities,
 
primarily
 
from
 
trade
receivables. Customers who wish to trade
 
on credit terms are subject to credit
 
verification procedures, including
an assessment of their independent credit rating, financial position, past experience and industry reputation.
 
We
monitor the financial performance
 
of counterparties on a routine
 
basis to ensure credit
 
thresholds are achieved.
Where required, we will request additional credit
 
support, such as letters of credit,
 
to mitigate against credit risk.
Credit
 
risk
 
is
 
monitored
 
regularly,
 
and
 
performance
 
reports
 
are
 
provided
 
to
 
our
 
management
 
and
 
Board
 
of
Directors.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
113
As of December
 
31, 2023,
 
we had financial
 
assets of
 
$694.7 million, comprising
 
of cash and
 
cash equivalents,
trade
 
receivables,
 
short
 
term
 
deposits
 
and
 
restricted
 
deposits,
 
which
 
are
 
exposed
 
to
 
counterparty
 
credit
 
risk.
These
 
financial
 
assets
 
have
 
been
 
assessed
 
under
 
ASC
 
326,
 
Financial
 
Instruments
 
–
 
Credit
 
Losses,
 
and
 
a
provision for
 
discounting and
 
credit losses
 
of $0.9 million
 
was recorded
 
as of
 
December 31,
 
2023. See
 
Item 8.
Financial Statements and Supplementary Data—Note
 
8. Provision for Discounting and Credit Losses.
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
114
ITEM 8. FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
AND SUPPLEMENTARY
 
DATA
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Number
115
116
117
118
119
 
(PCAOB
 
ID:
0
1435
)
153
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
115
Consolidated Balance Sheets
(In US$ thousands, except share data)
Assets
Note
December 31,
2023
December 31,
2022
Current assets:
Cash and cash equivalents
 
$
339,295
$
334,629
Trade receivables, net
7
 
263,951
409,979
Income tax receivable
22
 
44,906
—
Inventories
9
 
192,279
158,018
Other current assets
10
 
103,609
60,188
Assets held for sale
4
 
—
26,214
Total
 
current assets
 
944,040
989,028
Non-current assets:
Property, plant and
 
equipment, net
11
 
1,506,437
1,389,548
Right of use asset – operating leases, net
14
 
80,899
17,385
Goodwill
12
 
28,008
28,008
Intangible assets, net
12
 
3,108
3,311
Restricted deposits
26
 
68,660
89,062
Deferred income tax assets
22
 
27,230
—
Other non-current assets
10
 
19,656
33,585
Total
 
assets
 
$
2,678,038
$
2,549,927
Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity
Current liabilities:
 
Accounts payable
 
$
113,273
$
61,780
Accrued expenses and other current liabilities
13
 
312,705
343,691
Income tax payable
22
 
—
119,981
Asset retirement obligations
15
 
15,321
10,646
Contract obligations
17
 
40,722
40,343
Lease liabilities
14
 
22,879
7,720
Other current financial liabilities
 
2,825
4,458
Liabilities held for sale
4
 
—
12,241
Total
 
current liabilities
 
507,725
600,860
Non-current liabilities:
Asset retirement obligations
15
 
148,608
127,844
Contract obligations
17
 
61,192
94,525
Deferred consideration liability
18
 
277,442
243,191
Interest bearing liabilities
16
 
235,343
232,953
Other financial liabilities
 
5,307
8,268
Lease liabilities
14
 
61,692
15,573
Deferred income tax liabilities
22
 
100,145
95,671
Other non-current liabilities
 
34,549
27,952
Total
 
liabilities
 
$
1,432,003
$
1,446,837
Common stock $
0.01
 
par value;
1,000,000,000
 
shares authorized,
167,645,373
 
shares issued and outstanding as of December 31, 2023 and
December 31, 2022
 
1,677
1,677
Series A Preferred stock $
0.01
 
par value;
100,000,000
 
shares authorized,
1
Share issued and outstanding as of December 31, 2023 and
 
December 31,
2022
—
—
Additional paid-in capital
 
1,094,431
1,092,282
Accumulated other comprehensive losses
24
 
(89,927)
(91,423)
Retained earnings
 
239,854
100,554
Total
 
stockholders’ equity
 
1,246,035
1,103,090
Total
 
liabilities and stockholders’ equity
 
$
2,678,038
$
2,549,927
See accompanying notes to consolidated financial
 
statements.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
116
Consolidated Statements of Operations and Comprehensive
 
Income
(In US$ thousands, except share data)
 
Year ended December 31,
Note
2023
2022
2021
Revenues:
Coal revenues
$
2,830,689
$
3,527,626
$
2,010,996
Coal revenues from related parties
27
—
—
97,335
Other revenues
59,914
43,916
40,140
Total
 
revenues
3
2,890,603
3,571,542
2,148,471
Costs and expenses:
Cost of coal revenues (exclusive of items shown
separately below)
1,731,630
1,515,585
1,195,250
Depreciation, depletion and amortization
160,711
167,046
177,875
Freight expenses
259,710
249,081
241,862
Stanwell rebate
136,523
165,995
55,403
Other royalties
345,882
385,065
142,751
Selling, general, and administrative expenses
 
84,177
42,499
30,666
Restructuring costs
—
—
2,300
Total
 
costs and expenses
2,718,633
2,525,271
1,846,107
Other income (expenses):
Interest expense, net
(56,751)
(67,632)
(68,062)
Loss on debt extinguishment
(1,385)
(5,336)
(8,477)
Decrease (increase) in provision for discounting and
credit losses
 
4,216
(3,821)
8,042
Gain on disposal of asset held for sale
—
—
14,845
Other, net
5
5,764
33,795
(6,187)
Total
 
other expense, net
(48,156)
(42,994)
(59,839)
Income before tax
123,814
1,003,277
242,525
Income tax benefit (expense)
22
32,251
(231,574)
(53,102)
Net income
156,065
771,703
189,423
Less: Net loss attributable to noncontrolling
interest
—
—
(2)
Net income attributable to Coronado Global
Resources Inc.
$
156,065
$
771,703
$
189,425
Other comprehensive loss, net of income taxes:
Foreign currency translation adjustment
1,496
(47,195)
(17,451)
Net gain on cash flow hedges, net of tax
—
—
2,029
Total
 
other comprehensive gain (loss)
1,496
(47,195)
(15,422)
Total
 
comprehensive income
157,561
724,508
174,001
Less: Net loss attributable to noncontrolling
interest
—
—
(2)
Total
 
comprehensive income attributable to
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
$
157,561
$
724,508
$
174,003
Earnings per share of common stock
Basic
6 (c)
 
0.93
4.60
1.21
Diluted
6 (c)
 
0.93
4.60
1.21
See accompanying notes to consolidated financial
 
statements.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
117
Consolidated Statements of Stockholders’ Equity
(In US$ thousands, except share data)
Common stock
Preferred stock
Additional
paid in
capital
Accumulated
other
comprehensive
losses
(Accumulated
losses)
Retained
earnings
Noncontrolling
interest
Total
stockholders'
equity
Shares
Amount
Series A
Amount
Balance December 31, 2020
138,387,890
$
1,384
1
$
—
$
993,052
$
(28,806)
$
(158,919)
$
152
$
806,863
Net income (loss)
—
—
—
—
—
—
189,425
(2)
189,423
Other comprehensive loss (net of $
870
deferred income tax)
—
—
—
—
—
(15,422)
—
—
(15,422)
Total comprehensive (loss) income
—
—
—
—
—
(15,422)
189,425
(2)
174,001
Issuance of common stock, net
29,257,483
293
—
—
97,448
—
—
—
97,741
Stock-based compensation for equity
classified awards
—
—
—
—
(250)
—
—
—
(250)
Acquisition of non-controlling interest
—
—
—
—
(703)
—
—
(150)
(853)
Balance December 31, 2021
167,645,373
$
1,677
1
$
—
$
1,089,547
$
(44,228)
$
30,506
$
—
$
1,077,502
Net income
—
—
—
—
—
—
771,703
—
771,703
Other comprehensive loss
—
—
—
—
—
(47,195)
—
—
(47,195)
Total comprehensive (loss) income
—
—
—
—
—
(47,195)
771,703
—
724,508
Stock-based compensation for equity
classified awards
—
—
—
—
2,735
—
—
—
2,735
Dividends
—
—
—
—
—
—
(701,655)
—
(701,655)
Balance December 31, 2022
167,645,373
$
1,677
1
$
—
$
1,092,282
$
(91,423)
$
100,554
$
—
$
1,103,090
Net income
—
—
—
—
—
—
156,065
—
156,065
Other comprehensive income
—
—
—
—
—
1,496
—
—
1,496
Total comprehensive income
—
—
—
—
—
1,496
156,065
—
157,561
Stock-based compensation for equity
classified awards
—
—
—
—
2,149
—
—
—
2,149
Dividends
—
—
—
—
—
—
(16,765)
—
(16,765)
Balance December 31, 2023
167,645,373
$
1,677
1
$
—
$
1,094,431
$
(89,927)
$
239,854
$
—
$
1,246,035
See accompanying notes to consolidated financial
 
statements
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
118
Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows
(In US$ thousands)
Year Ended December 31,
2023
2022
2021
Cash flows from operating activities:
Net income
$
156,065
$
771,703
$
189,423
Adjustments to reconcile net income to cash and
 
cash equivalents provided
by operating activities:
Depreciation, depletion and amortization
163,862
165,503
175,814
Amortization of right of use asset - operating leases
12,415
6,704
8,899
Amortization of deferred financing costs
4,300
1,933
3,133
Non-cash interest expense
30,997
31,362
29,120
Amortization of contract obligations
(33,026)
(36,519)
(33,967)
Loss on disposal of property, plant and equipment
516
855
415
Equity-based compensation expense (gain)
2,149
2,735
(250)
Loss on debt extinguishment
1,385
5,336
8,477
Deferred income taxes
(21,338)
40,423
24,417
Reclamation of asset retirement obligations
(5,334)
(4,543)
(4,273)
Change in estimate of asset retirement obligation
(3,151)
1,543
2,061
Gain on disposal of asset held for sale
—
—
(14,845)
(Decrease) increase in provision for discounting and
 
credit losses
(4,216)
3,821
(8,042)
Changes in operating assets and liabilities:
Accounts receivable - including related party receivables,
 
net
155,056
(156,818)
(33,545)
Inventories
(32,774)
(41,243)
(9,637)
Other current assets
(477)
(12,365)
24,573
Accounts payable
40,159
(27,664)
24,166
Accrued expenses and other current liabilities
(25,435)
84,041
64,285
Operating lease liabilities
(14,597)
(8,244)
(10,986)
Income tax payable
(164,834)
96,326
—
Change in other liabilities
6,560
1,754
2,776
Net cash provided by operating activities
268,282
926,643
442,014
Cash flows from investing activities:
Capital expenditures
(237,205)
(199,716)
(89,661)
Proceeds from the disposal of property, plant, and equipment
—
318
1,594
Proceeds from disposal of assets held for sale
—
—
27,451
Purchase of restricted and other deposits
(27,213)
(9,761)
(103,997)
Redemption of restricted and other deposits
26,250
816
30,281
Net cash used in investing activities
(238,168)
(208,343)
(134,332)
Cash flows from financing activities:
Proceeds from interest bearing liabilities and other
 
financial liabilities
—
—
411,524
Debt issuance costs and other financing costs
(3,436)
—
(15,263)
Principal payments on interest bearing liabilities
 
and other financial liabilities
(4,361)
(81,310)
(412,046)
Call premiums paid on early redemption of debt
—
(2,557)
(1,050)
Principal payments on finance lease obligations
(127)
(140)
(70)
Dividends paid
(16,755)
(700,244)
—
Proceeds from stock issuance, net
—
—
97,741
Net cash (used in) provided by financing activities
(24,679)
(784,251)
80,836
Net increase (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents
5,435
(65,951)
388,518
Effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents
(769)
(37,351)
3,677
Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of period
334,629
437,931
45,736
Cash and cash equivalents at end of period
$
339,295
$
334,629
$
437,931
Supplemental disclosure of cash flow information:
Cash payments for interest
$
28,632
$
36,728
$
33,462
Cash paid (refund) for taxes
$
147,106
$
90,888
$
(16,582)
Restricted cash
$
251
$
251
$
251
See accompanying notes to consolidated financial
 
statements
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
119
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
1.
 
Description of Business, Basis of Presentation
(a)
Nature of operations
Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources Inc.
 
(together
 
with
 
its
 
subsidiaries,
 
the
 
“Company”
 
or
 
“Coronado”)
 
is
 
a
 
global
producer, marketer,
 
and exporter of a full range
 
of metallurgical coals, an
 
essential element in the production
 
of
steel. The Company
 
has a portfolio
 
of operating mines
 
and development projects
 
in Queensland, Australia
 
and
in the
 
states of Pennsylvania,
 
Virginia and West
 
Virginia in the
 
United States, or
 
U.S. For details
 
of the
 
Company’s
capital structure, refer to Note 6 “Capital Structure” for
 
further information.
(b)
Basis of Presentation
The
 
Consolidated
 
Financial
 
Statements
 
have
 
been
 
prepared
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
requirements
 
of
 
the
 
U.S.
Generally Accepted
 
Accounting
 
Principles,
 
or U.S.
 
GAAP and
 
are presented
 
in U.S.
 
dollars,
 
unless otherwise
stated.
The Consolidated Financial Statements include the accounts of the Company and its
 
affiliates. The Company, or
Coronado, are used interchangeably to refer to Coronado Global Resources Inc. or Coronado Global Resources
Inc. and
 
its subsidiaries,
 
as appropriate
 
to the
 
context. Interests
 
in subsidiaries
 
controlled by
 
the Company
 
are
consolidated
 
with
 
any
 
outside
 
stockholder
 
interests
 
reflected
 
as
 
noncontrolling
 
interests.
 
All
 
intercompany
balances and transactions have been eliminated on consolidation.
(c)
Certain Significant Risks and Uncertainties
External
 
factors,
 
including
 
general
 
economic
 
conditions,
 
international
 
events
 
and
 
circumstances,
 
competitor
actions, governmental actions
 
and regulations are beyond
 
the Company’s control
 
and can cause fluctuations
 
in
demand
 
for
 
coal
 
and
 
volatility
 
in
 
the
 
price
 
of
 
commodities.
 
This
 
in
 
turn
 
may
 
adversely
 
impact
 
the
 
Company’s
future operating results, purchase or investment opportunities
 
in the coal mining industry.
Concentration of customers
The Company has a credit
 
policy that establishes procedures
 
to determine creditworthiness
 
and credit limits for
trade customers and counterparties
 
in the over-the-counter coal
 
market. Generally,
 
credit is extended based on
an evaluation
 
of the customer’s
 
financial condition.
 
Collateral is
 
not generally
 
required, unless
 
credit cannot
 
be
established.
 
Payments from customers are generally due between
 
30 to 60 days after
 
invoicing. Invoicing usually occurs after
shipment
 
or
 
delivery
 
of
 
goods.
 
The
 
timing
 
between
 
the
 
recognition
 
of
 
revenue
 
and
 
receipt
 
of
 
payment
 
is
 
not
significant.
The Company had certain customers
 
whose accounts receivable balances individually represented
10
% or more
of
 
the
 
Company’s
 
total
 
accounts
 
receivable,
 
or
 
whose
 
revenue
 
individually
 
represented
10
%
 
or
 
more
 
of
 
the
Company’s total revenue.
The
 
following
 
table
 
summarizes
 
any
 
customer
 
whose
 
revenue
 
individually
 
represented
10
%
 
or
 
more
 
of
 
the
Company’s total coal revenues in the year ended
 
December 31, 2023.
 
 
 
 
Year Ended December 31,
2023
2022
2021
Tata
 
Steel
21%
19%
17%
ArcelorMittal
10%
8%
7%
For the
 
year ended
 
December 31,
 
2023, $
1,509.1
 
million, or
53.3
% of
 
total coal
 
revenues, were
 
attributable to
five
 
customers. In
 
comparison, for
 
the year
 
ended December
 
31, 2022,
 
$
1,848.8
 
million, or
52.6
% of
 
total coal
revenues were
 
attributable to
five
 
customers and for
 
the year ended
 
December 31, 2021,
 
$
971.6
 
million, or
46.3
%
of
 
total
 
revenues
 
were
 
attributable
 
to
five
 
customers.
 
As
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
the
 
Company
 
had
three
customers that
 
accounted for
 
$
152.9
 
million, or
57.9
%, of
 
accounts receivable.
 
As of
 
December 31,
 
2022, the
Company had
four
 
customers that accounted for $
212.5
 
million, or
51.6
%, of accounts receivable.
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
120
The
 
following
 
table
 
presents
 
revenues
 
as
 
a
 
percent
 
of
 
total
 
revenue
 
from
 
external
 
customers
 
by
 
geographic
region:
 
 
 
 
Year Ended December 31,
2023
2022
2021
Asia
50%
46%
48%
North America
11%
12%
7%
South America
8%
8%
6%
Europe
6%
11%
12%
Australia
4%
4%
6%
Brokered sales
21%
19%
21%
Total
100%
100%
100%
The Company uses shipping destination as the
 
basis for attributing revenue to individual
 
countries. The transfer
of title on
 
brokered transactions
 
may occur at
 
a point that
 
does not reflect
 
the end usage
 
point, therefore
 
these
sales are reflected as exports and classified as brokerage sales.
Concentration of labor
Out
 
of
 
the
 
Company’s
 
total
 
employees,
10.8
%
 
as
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
are
 
subject
 
to
 
the
 
Curragh
 
Mine
Enterprise
 
Agreement
 
2023.
 
This
 
agreement
 
covers
 
work
 
carried out
 
by permanent,
 
full-time,
 
temporary,
 
and
casual coal
 
mining employees
 
engaged by
 
Curragh to
 
fulfil production,
 
maintenance and
 
processing activities.
Other than
 
the Curragh
 
Mine Enterprise
 
Agreement 2023,
 
there are
 
no other
 
collective bargaining
 
agreements
or union contracts covering employees of the Company
 
.
Transportation
The Company depends
 
upon port and
 
rail transportation
 
systems to deliver
 
coal to
 
its customers.
 
Disruption of
these
 
transportation
 
services
 
due
 
to
 
weather-related
 
problems,
 
mechanical
 
difficulties,
 
strikes,
 
lockouts,
bottlenecks, and other
 
events could temporarily
 
impair the Company’s
 
ability to supply
 
coal to its
 
customers. In
the past, disruptions in these services have resulted in
 
delayed shipments and production interruptions.
2.
 
Summary of Significant Accounting Policies
(a)
 
Newly Adopted Accounting Standards
During the period,
 
there have
 
been no new
 
Accounting Standards
 
Updates issued
 
by the Financial
 
Accounting
Standards Board, or FASB,
 
that had a material impact on the Company’s Consolidated
 
Financial Statements.
 
(b)
 
Accounting Standards Not Yet
 
Implemented
Accounting Standards
 
Update, or
 
ASU, No. 2023-07
 
“Segment Reporting”
 
(Topic
 
280)
: In November
 
2023, the
FASB
 
issued
 
ASU
 
2023-07,
 
which
 
intended
 
to
 
improve
 
reportable
 
segment
 
disclosure
 
requirements
 
through
enhanced disclosures of significant segment expenses. The guidance is effective for fiscal years
 
beginning after
December 15, 2023,
 
and interim periods
 
within fiscal years
 
beginning after December
 
31, 2024. Early
 
adoption
is permitted. The
 
updated standard is
 
to be applied
 
retrospectively to all
 
prior periods presented
 
in the financial
statements. The
 
Company is
 
currently evaluating
 
the impact
 
that the updated
 
standard will
 
have in its
 
financial
statement disclosures.
 
ASU 2023-09
 
“Income Taxes”
 
(Topic
 
740):
 
In December
 
2023, the
 
FASB
 
issued 2023-09,
 
which modifies
 
the
rules on
 
income tax
 
disclosures to
 
require companies
 
to disclose:
 
specific categories
 
in the
 
rate reconciliation,
the income
 
or loss
 
from continuing
 
operations before income
 
tax expense
 
or benefit
 
(separated between
 
domestic
and
 
foreign)
 
and
 
income
 
tax
 
expense
 
or
 
benefit
 
from
 
continuing
 
operations
 
(separated
 
by
 
federal,
 
state,
 
and
foreign). The updated standard is
 
effective for annual periods beginning after December
 
15, 2024. The Company
is currently evaluating the impact that the updated standard
 
will have in its financial statement disclosures.
 
There have been
 
no other recent
 
accounting pronouncements not yet
 
effective that have significance,
 
or potential
significance, to the Company’s Consolidated Financial
 
Statements.
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
121
(c) Use of Estimates
The preparation
 
of Consolidated
 
Financial
 
Statements
 
in conformity
 
with U.S. GAAP
 
requires
 
management
 
to
make certain
 
judgements, estimates
 
and assumptions
 
that affect
 
the reported
 
amounts of
 
assets and
 
liabilities
and disclosure of
 
contingent assets and contingent
 
liabilities at the
 
date of the
 
Consolidated Financial Statements
and
 
the
 
reported
 
amounts
 
of
 
revenues
 
and
 
expenses
 
during
 
the
 
reporting
 
periods.
 
Actual
 
results
 
could
 
differ
materially
 
from
 
those
 
estimates.
 
Significant
 
items
 
subject
 
to
 
such
 
estimates
 
and
 
assumptions
 
include
 
asset
retirement obligations; useful lives for depreciation,
 
depletion and amortization; expected credit
 
losses; deferred
income tax
 
assets and
 
liabilities; values
 
of coal
 
properties;
 
goodwill; workers’
 
compensation
 
liability and
 
other
contingencies.
(d)
 
Foreign Currency
Financial Statements of foreign operations
The reporting currency of the Company is the U.S. Dollar,
 
or US$.
Functional
 
currency
 
is
 
determined
 
by
 
the
 
primary
 
economic
 
environment
 
in
 
which
 
an
 
entity
 
operates.
 
The
functional currency of
 
the Company
 
and its subsidiaries
 
is the US$,
 
with the exception
 
of two foreign
 
operating
subsidiaries, Curragh
 
and its
 
immediate parent
 
CAH, whose
 
functional currency
 
is the
 
Australian dollar,
 
or A$,
since Curragh’s predominant sources of operating
 
expenses are denominated in that currency.
Assets and liabilities
 
are translated at
 
the year-end exchange
 
rate and items
 
in the statement
 
of operations are
translated at average rates with gains and losses from
 
translation recorded in other comprehensive losses.
Foreign Currency Transactions
Monetary
 
assets
 
and
 
liabilities
 
are
 
remeasured
 
at
 
year-end
 
exchange
 
rates
 
while
 
non-monetary
 
items
 
are
remeasured at historical rates.
 
Gains and losses from foreign
 
currency remeasurement related to Curragh’s U.S. dollar receivables are
 
included
in coal revenues. All other gains and losses
 
from foreign currency remeasurement
 
and foreign currency forward
contracts
 
are
 
included
 
in
 
“Other,
 
net”,
 
with
 
exception
 
of
 
foreign
 
currency
 
gains
 
or
 
losses
 
on
 
long-term
intercompany
 
loan
 
balances
 
which
 
are classified
 
within
 
“Accumulated
 
other
 
comprehensive
 
losses”.
 
The
 
total
aggregate impact of foreign currency
 
transaction gains or losses on the
 
Consolidated Statements of Operations
and Comprehensive
 
Income was
 
a net
 
gain of
 
$
2.5
 
million, $
47.6
 
million and
 
$
1.7
 
million for
 
the years
 
ended
December 31,
 
2023,
 
2022 and
 
2021, respectively.
 
The total
 
impact of
 
foreign currency
 
transactions related
 
to
U.S. dollar
 
coal sales
 
in Australia
 
(included in
 
the total
 
above) was
 
a net
 
loss of
 
$
1.0
 
million, net
 
gain of
 
$
15.0
million and $
8.7
 
million for the years ended December 31, 2023, 2022
 
and 2021, respectively.
(e)
 
Cash and Cash Equivalents
Cash and cash
 
equivalents include cash
 
at bank and
 
short-term highly liquid investments
 
with an original
 
maturity
date of three months or less. At December 31, 2023,
 
the Company had $
130.0
 
million of short-term highly liquid
investments classified as cash equivalents. At December
 
31, 2022, the Company had
no
 
cash equivalents.
 
“Cash
 
and
 
cash
 
equivalents”,
 
as disclosed
 
in
 
the
 
accompanying
 
Consolidated
 
Balance
 
Sheets,
 
includes
 
$
0.3
million of restricted cash at December 31, 2023 and
 
2022.
(f)
 
Trade Accounts Receivables
The Company
 
extends trade
 
credit to
 
its customers
 
in the
 
ordinary course
 
of business.
 
Trade
 
receivables are
recorded initially at fair value and subsequently at amortized
 
cost, less any Expected Credit Losses, or ECL.
 
For trade receivables
 
carried at amortized
 
cost, the Company
 
determines ECL on
 
a forward-looking
 
basis. The
amount of
 
ECL is
 
updated at
 
each reporting
 
date to reflect
 
changes in
 
credit risk
 
since initial recognition
 
of the
respective financial instrument.
 
The Company recognizes
 
the lifetime ECL. The
 
ECL is estimated
 
based on the
Company’s
 
historic credit
 
loss
 
experience,
 
adjusted for
 
factors that
 
are specific
 
to the
 
financial
 
asset, general
economic
 
conditions,
 
financial
 
asset
 
type,
 
term
 
and
 
an
 
assessment
 
of
 
both
 
the
 
current
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
forecast
conditions, including expected timing
 
of collection, at the
 
reporting date, modified for
 
credit enhancements such
as letters of credit obtained.
To
measure ECL, trade receivables have been grouped based on shared credit risk
characteristics and the days past due.
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
122
The amount of credit
 
loss is recognized in
 
the Consolidated Statements
 
of Operations and Other Comprehensive
Income within “Provision for discounting and credit losses”. The Company writes off a financial asset when there
is information indicating there is no realistic prospect of recovery of the asset from the counterparty. Subsequent
recoveries of amounts
 
previously written off
 
are credited against “Provision
 
for discounting and
 
credit losses” in
the Consolidated Statements of Operations and Other
 
Comprehensive Income.
(g)
 
Inventories
Coal is recorded
 
as inventory at the
 
point in time
 
the coal is
 
extracted from the
 
mine. Raw coal
 
represents coal
stockpiles that
 
may be
 
sold in
 
current condition
 
or may
 
be further
 
processed
 
prior to
 
shipment to
 
a customer.
Saleable coal represents coal stockpiles which require no further
 
processing prior to shipment to a customer.
Coal inventories are stated
 
at the lower of average
 
cost and net realizable
 
value. The cost of coal
 
inventories is
determined based
 
on an
 
average cost
 
of production,
 
which includes
 
all costs
 
incurred to
 
extract, transport
 
and
process
 
the coal.
 
Net
 
realizable
 
value
 
considers
 
the
 
estimated
 
sales
 
price
 
of
 
the
 
particular
 
coal
 
product,
 
less
applicable selling costs, and, in the case of raw coal, estimated
 
remaining processing costs.
Supplies
 
inventory
 
is
 
comprised
 
of
 
replacement
 
parts
 
for
 
operational
 
equipment
 
and
 
other
 
miscellaneous
materials and supplies
 
required for mining
 
which are stated
 
at cost on the
 
date of purchase.
 
Supplies inventory
is valued at
 
the lower of
 
average cost or
 
net realizable
 
value, less a
 
reserve for obsolete
 
or surplus items.
 
This
reserve incorporates several factors, such as anticipated usage, inventory turnover and inventory levels. It is not
customary to sell these inventories; the Company plans
 
to use them in mining operations as needed.
(h)
 
Assets held for sale
Assets
 
held
 
for
 
sale
 
are
 
measured
 
at
 
the
 
lower
 
of
 
their
 
carrying
 
amount
 
or
 
fair
 
value
 
less
 
costs
 
to
 
sell.
 
The
Company classifies
 
assets and
 
liabilities as
 
held for
 
sale (disposal
 
group) when
 
management, having
 
the authority
to approve the action,
 
commits to a plan
 
to sell the disposal
 
group, the sale is
 
probable within one year
 
and the
disposal
 
group
 
is
 
available
 
for
 
sale
 
in
 
its
 
present
 
condition.
 
The
 
Company
 
also
 
considers
 
whether
 
an
 
active
program to locate a buyer
 
has been initiated, whether the
 
disposal group is marketed
 
actively for sale at a
 
price
that is reasonable in relation
 
to its current fair value,
 
and whether actions required
 
to complete the plan indicate
that it
 
is unlikely
 
that significant
 
changes to
 
the plan
 
will be
 
made or
 
that the
 
plan will
 
be withdrawn.
 
All criteria
must be met at or prior to balance sheet date for a long-lived asset to qualify as held for
 
sale. An impairment test
is performed when a disposal group is classified
 
as held for sale and an impairment charge is
 
recorded when the
carrying
 
amount
 
of
 
the
 
disposal
 
group
 
exceeds
 
its
 
estimated
 
fair
 
value,
 
less
 
cost
 
to
 
sell.
 
Depreciation
 
and
amortization for
 
assets classified
 
as held
 
for sale
 
are ceased.
 
When any
 
of the
 
criteria are
 
not met
 
after initial
classification, the Company ceases to classify the asset as held for sale and reclassify the asset as held for use.
On reclassification, the asset is measured
 
at the lower of its (a) carrying
 
amount before it was classified
 
as held
for sale, adjusted
 
for any depreciation
 
expense or impairment
 
losses that would
 
have been recognized
 
had the
asset been continuously classified as held and used or
 
(b) fair value at the date of reclassification.
(i)
 
Property, Plant and
 
Equipment, Impairment of Long-Lived Assets and Goodwill
Property, Plant, and
 
Equipment
Costs for mine development incurred to
 
expand capacity of operating mines or to
 
develop new mines and certain
mining equipment are capitalized and charged to operations on the
 
hours of usage or units of production method
over
 
the
 
estimated
 
proven
 
and
 
probable
 
reserve
 
tons
 
directly
 
benefiting
 
from
 
the
 
capital
 
expenditures.
 
Mine
development
 
costs
 
include
 
costs
 
incurred
 
for
 
site
 
preparation
 
and
 
development
 
of
 
the
 
mines
 
during
 
the
development stage.
 
Mineral rights
 
and reserves
 
acquired are
 
measured at
 
cost and
 
are depleted
 
on a
 
units of
production
 
method
 
over
 
the
 
estimated
 
proven
 
and
 
probable
 
reserve
 
tons
 
of
 
the
 
relevant
 
mineral
 
property.
Capitalized costs related to internal-use software are amortized on
 
a straight-line basis over the estimated useful
lives of the assets.
Property,
 
plant,
 
and
 
equipment
 
are
 
recorded
 
at
 
cost
 
and
 
include
 
expenditures
 
for
 
improvements
 
when
 
they
substantially
 
increase
 
the
 
productive
 
lives
 
of existing
 
assets.
 
Depreciation
 
is calculated
 
using
 
the
 
straight-line
method over
 
the estimated
 
useful lives
 
of the
 
depreciable assets of
3
 
to
10
 
years for machinery, mining
 
equipment
and
 
transportation
 
vehicles,
5
 
to
10
 
years
 
for
 
office
 
equipment,
 
and
10
 
to
20
 
years
 
for
 
plant,
 
buildings
 
and
improvements.
Maintenance and
 
repair costs
 
are expensed to
 
operations as
 
incurred. When
 
equipment is
 
retired or
 
disposed,
the related cost
 
and accumulated
 
depreciation are
 
removed from
 
the respective
 
accounts and any
 
gain or loss
on disposal is recognized in operations.
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
123
Impairment of long-lived assets
Long-lived
 
assets,
 
such
 
as
 
property,
 
plant,
 
and
 
equipment,
 
and
 
purchased
 
intangible
 
assets
 
subject
 
to
amortization,
 
are
 
reviewed
 
for
 
impairment
 
whenever
 
events
 
or
 
changes
 
in
 
circumstances
 
indicate
 
that
 
the
carrying amount of an
 
asset may not be
 
recoverable.
 
If circumstances require
 
a long-lived asset or
 
asset group
be
 
tested
 
for
 
possible
 
impairment,
 
the
 
Company
 
first
 
compares
 
undiscounted
 
cash
 
flows
 
expected
 
to
 
be
generated by
 
that asset
 
or asset
 
group to
 
its carrying
 
amount. If
 
the carrying
 
amount of
 
the long-lived
 
asset or
asset group
 
is not
 
recoverable on
 
an undiscounted
 
cash flow
 
basis, an
 
impairment is
 
recognized to
 
the extent
that the
 
carrying amount
 
exceeds its
 
fair value.
 
Fair value
 
is determined
 
through
 
various valuation
 
techniques
including
 
discounted
 
cash
 
flow
 
models,
 
quoted
 
market
 
values
 
and
 
third-party
 
independent
 
appraisals,
 
as
considered
 
necessary.
 
The
 
Company
 
concluded
 
that
no
 
impairment
 
charges
 
were
 
required
 
at
 
any
 
of
 
the
Company’s mining assets for the years ended December
 
31, 2023, 2022 and 2021.
Goodwill
Goodwill is an asset
 
representing the future economic
 
benefits arising from other
 
assets acquired in a
 
business
combination
 
that
 
are
 
not
 
individually
 
identified
 
and
 
separately
 
recognized.
 
In
 
connection
 
with
 
the
 
Buchanan
acquisition on
 
March 31, 2016,
 
the Company
 
recorded goodwill
 
in the
 
amount of
 
$
28.0
 
million. Goodwill
 
is not
amortized but
 
is reviewed
 
for impairment
 
annually or
 
when circumstances or
 
other events
 
indicate that
 
impairment
may have occurred. The Company follows the guidance in Accounting Standards Update 2017-04 “
Intangibles –
Goodwill
 
and
 
Other:
 
Simplifying
 
the
 
Test
 
for
 
Goodwill
 
Impairment
”
 
(ASU 2017-04).
 
The
 
Company
 
makes
 
a
qualitative assessment of whether it
 
is more likely than
 
not that a
 
reporting unit’s fair value is
 
less than its carrying
amount. Circumstances that are considered as
 
part of the qualitative
 
assessment and could trigger a
 
quantitative
impairment test include but are
 
not limited to: a significant
 
adverse change in the business
 
climate; a significant
adverse legal judgment;
 
adverse cash flow
 
trends; an
 
adverse action
 
or assessment
 
by a government
 
agency;
unanticipated
 
competition;
 
and
 
a
 
significant
 
restructuring
 
charge
 
within
 
a
 
reporting
 
unit.
 
If
 
a
 
quantitative
assessment
 
is
 
determined
 
to
 
be
 
necessary,
 
the
 
Company
 
compares
 
the
 
fair
 
value
 
of
 
a
 
reporting
 
unit
 
with
 
its
carrying amount, including goodwill.
 
If the carrying amount
 
of a reporting unit
 
exceeds its fair value,
 
the Company
recognizes an impairment
 
charge for the
 
amount by which
 
the carrying amount
 
exceeds its fair
 
value to the
 
extent
of the amount of goodwill allocated to that reporting unit.
The Company defines reporting
 
units at the mining
 
asset level. For purposes
 
of testing goodwill for
 
impairment,
goodwill has been allocated to the reporting units to the
 
extent it relates to each reporting unit.
(j)
 
Asset Retirement Obligations
The
 
Company’s
 
asset
 
retirement
 
obligation,
 
or
 
ARO,
 
liabilities
 
primarily
 
consist
 
of
 
estimates
 
of
 
surface
 
land
reclamation
 
and
 
support
 
facilities
 
at
 
both
 
surface
 
and
 
underground
 
mines
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
applicable
reclamation laws and regulations in the U.S. and Australia
 
as defined by each mining permit.
The Company
 
estimates its ARO
 
liabilities for
 
final reclamation
 
and mine
 
closure based upon
 
detailed engineering
calculations of the amount
 
and timing of the future
 
cash spending for a
 
third party to perform
 
the required work.
Spending
 
estimates
 
are
 
escalated
 
for
 
inflation
 
and
 
then
 
discounted
 
at
 
the
 
credit-adjusted,
 
risk-free
 
rate.
 
The
Company records
 
an ARO asset
 
associated with
 
the discounted
 
liability for final
 
reclamation and
 
mine closure.
The obligation
 
and corresponding
 
asset are recognized
 
in the period
 
in which the
 
liability is incurred.
 
The ARO
asset
 
is
 
amortized
 
on
 
the
 
units-of-production
 
method
 
over
 
its
 
expected
 
life
 
of
 
the
 
related
 
asset
 
and
 
the
 
ARO
liability is accreted to the projected
 
spending date. As changes
 
in estimates occur (such as
 
mine plan revisions,
changes in
 
estimated costs
 
or changes
 
in timing
 
of the
 
performance of
 
reclamation activities),
 
the revisions
 
to
the
 
obligation
 
and
 
asset
 
are
 
recognized
 
at
 
the
 
appropriate
 
credit-adjusted,
 
risk-free
 
rate.
 
The
 
Company
 
also
recognizes
 
an
 
obligation
 
for
 
contemporaneous
 
reclamation
 
liabilities
 
incurred
 
as
 
a
 
result
 
of
 
surface
 
mining.
Contemporaneous reclamation consists primarily
 
of grading, topsoil replacement
 
and re-vegetation of backfilled
pit areas. To
 
settle the liability,
 
the obligation is paid,
 
and to the extent
 
there is a difference
 
between the liability
and
 
the
 
amount
 
of cash
 
paid,
 
a
 
gain
 
or
 
loss
 
upon
 
settlement
 
is
 
recorded.
 
The
 
Company
 
annually
 
reviews
 
its
estimated future cash flows for its asset retirement obligations.
(k)
 
Borrowing costs
Borrowing costs are
 
recognized as an
 
expense when they
 
are incurred, except
 
for interest charges
 
attributable
to major projects with substantial development and construction phases which are capitalized
 
as part of the cost
of the asset. There was
no
 
interest capitalized during the years ended December
 
31, 2023 and 2022.
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
124
(l)
 
Leases
From time to
 
time, the Company
 
enters into contractual
 
agreements to
 
lease property,
 
plant and equipment.
 
In
addition, the Company also enters into mining services contracts which may include embedded leases of mining
equipment. Based
 
upon the
 
Company’s assessment
 
of the
 
terms of
 
a specific
 
lease agreement,
 
the Company
classifies a lease as either finance or operating.
Finance leases
Right of Use,
 
or ROU,
 
assets related
 
to finance
 
leases are
 
presented in
 
Property,
 
plant and
 
equipment, net
 
on
the Consolidated
 
Balance Sheet.
 
Lease liabilities
 
related to
 
finance leases
 
are presented
 
in “Lease
 
Liabilities”
(current) and “Lease Liabilities” (non-current) on the Consolidated
 
Balance Sheets.
Finance lease ROU assets and lease liabilities are recognized at the commencement date based on the present
value of the
 
future lease payments
 
over the lease
 
term. The
 
discount rate used
 
to determine
 
the present
 
value
of the
 
lease
 
payments
 
is the
 
rate
 
implicit in
 
the
 
lease unless
 
that
 
rate cannot
 
be readily
 
determined,
 
in which
case, the
 
Company utilizes
 
its incremental
 
borrowing
 
rate in
 
determining the
 
present value
 
of the
 
future lease
payments. The incremental borrowing
 
rate is the rate
 
of interest that the
 
Company would have to
 
pay to borrow
on
 
a
 
collateralized
 
basis
 
over
 
a
 
similar
 
term
 
an
 
amount
 
equal
 
to
 
the
 
lease
 
payments
 
in
 
a
 
similar
 
economic
environment.
Operating leases
ROU
 
assets
 
related to
 
operating
 
leases
 
are presented
 
as
 
Right of
 
Use
 
assets
 
– operating
 
leases,
 
net
 
on the
Consolidated
 
Balance
 
Sheet.
 
Lease
 
liabilities
 
related
 
to
 
operating
 
leases
 
that
 
are
 
subject
 
to
 
the
 
ASC
 
842
measurement requirements such as operating
 
leases with lease terms
 
greater than twelve months are
 
presented
in “Lease Liabilities” (current) and “Lease Liabilities” (non-current)
 
on Consolidated Balance Sheets.
 
Operating lease
 
ROU assets and
 
lease liabilities
 
are recognized at
 
the commencement date
 
based on
 
the present
value of the
 
future lease payments
 
over the lease
 
term. The
 
discount rate used
 
to determine
 
the present
 
value
of the
 
lease
 
payments
 
is the
 
rate
 
implicit in
 
the
 
lease unless
 
that
 
rate cannot
 
be readily
 
determined,
 
in which
case, the
 
Company utilizes
 
its incremental
 
borrowing
 
rate in
 
determining the
 
present value
 
of the
 
future lease
payments. The incremental borrowing
 
rate is the rate
 
of interest that the
 
Company would have to
 
pay to borrow
on
 
a
 
collateralized
 
basis
 
over
 
a
 
similar
 
term
 
an
 
amount
 
equal
 
to
 
the
 
lease
 
payments
 
in
 
a
 
similar
 
economic
environment. Operating
 
lease ROU
 
assets may
 
also include
 
any cumulative
 
prepaid or
 
accrued rent
 
when the
lease payments
 
are uneven
 
throughout the
 
lease term.
 
The ROU
 
assets and
 
lease liabilities
 
may also
 
include
options to extend or terminate the lease when it is reasonably certain that the Company will exercise that option.
The ROU
 
asset includes
 
any lease
 
payments made
 
and lease
 
incentives received
 
prior to
 
the commencement
date.
 
The
 
Company
 
has
 
lease
 
arrangements
 
with
 
lease
 
and
 
non-lease
 
components
 
which
 
are
 
accounted
 
for
separately.
 
Non-lease
 
components
 
of
 
the
 
lease
 
payments
 
are
 
expensed
 
as
 
incurred
 
and
 
are
 
not
 
included
 
in
determining the present value.
(m) Royalties
Lease rights
 
to coal
 
lands are
 
often acquired
 
in exchange
 
for royalty
 
payments. Royalties
 
are payable
 
monthly
as a percentage of the gross
 
realization from the sale of the coal
 
mined using surface mining methods
 
and as a
percentage
 
of
 
the
 
gross
 
realization
 
for
 
coal
 
produced
 
using
 
underground
 
mining
 
methods.
 
Advance
 
mining
royalties are advance
 
payments made to
 
lessors under terms
 
of mineral lease
 
agreements that are
 
recoupable
against
 
future
 
production.
 
The
 
Company
 
had
 
advance
 
mining
 
royalties
 
of
 
$
8.9
 
million
 
and
 
$
6.8
 
million
respectively, included
 
in “Other current assets” as of December 31, 2023
 
and 2022.
(n)
 
Stanwell Rebate
The
 
Stanwell
 
rebate
 
relates
 
to
 
a
 
contractual
 
arrangement
 
entered
 
into
 
by
 
Curragh
 
with
 
Stanwell
 
Corporation
Limited, a State
 
of Queensland
 
owned electricity
 
generator, which
 
requires payment
 
of a rebate
 
for export coal
sold from some of Curragh’s
 
mining tenements. The rebate obligation is
 
accounted for as an executory
 
contract
and the expense is recognized as incurred.
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
125
(o)
 
Revenue Recognition
The Company accounts for
 
a contract when it
 
has approval and commitment
 
from both parties, the
 
rights of the
parties are identified,
 
payment terms
 
are identified,
 
the contract has
 
commercial substance
 
and collectability
 
of
consideration is probable. Once a contract
 
is identified, the Company evaluates
 
whether the combined or single
contract should be accounted for as more than one performance
 
obligation.
The Company recognizes revenue when
 
control is transferred to the customer.
 
For the Company’s contracts,
 
in
order to determine
 
the point
 
in time when
 
control transfers
 
to customers, the
 
Company uses
 
standard shipping
terms to
 
determine
 
the timing
 
of transfer
 
of
 
legal title
 
and the
 
significant
 
risks
 
and rewards
 
of ownership.
 
The
Company also considers other
 
indicators including timing
 
of when the Company
 
has a present right
 
to payment
and
 
when
 
physical
 
possession
 
of
 
products
 
is
 
transferred
 
to
 
customers.
 
The
 
amount
 
of
 
revenue
 
recognized
includes any
 
adjustments for
 
variable consideration,
 
which is
 
included in
 
the transaction
 
price and
 
allocated to
each
 
performance
 
obligation
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
relative
 
standalone
 
selling
 
price.
 
The
 
variable
 
consideration
 
is
estimated through the course of the contract using management’s
 
best estimates.
The majority of
 
the Company’s revenue is derived
 
from short term
 
contracts where the
 
time between confirmation
of sales orders and collection of cash is not more than
 
a few months.
Taxes
 
assessed
 
by
 
a
 
governmental
 
authority
 
that
 
are
 
both
 
imposed
 
on
 
and
 
concurrent
 
with
 
a
 
specific
revenue-producing transaction that are collected by the
 
Company from a customer are excluded from revenue.
Performance obligations
A
 
performance
 
obligation
 
is
 
a
 
promise
 
in
 
a
 
contract
 
to
 
transfer
 
a
 
distinct
 
good
 
or
 
service
 
to
 
the
 
customer.
 
A
contract’s transaction price is allocated
 
to each distinct performance obligation
 
and recognized as revenue
 
when,
or as, the performance obligation
 
is satisfied.
The Company’s contracts have
 
multiple performance obligations as the
 
promise to transfer the individual
 
unit of
coal
 
is
 
separately
 
identifiable
 
from
 
other
 
units
 
of
 
coal
 
promised
 
in
 
the
 
contracts
 
and,
 
therefore,
 
distinct.
Performance obligations, as described above, primarily relate to the Company’s
 
promise to deliver a designated
quantity and type of coal within the quality specifications
 
stated in the contract.
For
 
contracts
 
with
 
multiple
 
performance
 
obligations,
 
we
 
allocate
 
the
 
contract’s
 
transaction
 
price
 
to
 
each
performance obligation on a relative standalone selling price basis. The
 
standalone selling price is determined at
each contract inception using
 
an adjusted market assessment
 
approach. This approach focuses
 
on the amount
that the Company believes the market is willing to pay
 
for a good or service, considering market conditions, such
as benchmark pricing, competitor pricing, market awareness of the product and current market trends that affect
the pricing.
Warranties provided to customers are
 
assurance-type of warranties on
 
the fitness of
 
purpose and merchantability
of the Company’s goods. The Company does not
 
provide service-type of warranties to customers.
Revenue
 
is
 
recognized
 
at
 
a
 
point
 
in
 
time
 
and
 
therefore
 
there
 
are
no
 
unsatisfied
 
and/or
 
partially
 
satisfied
performance obligations at December 31, 2023 and 2022.
Shipping and Handling
The Company
 
accounts
 
for
 
shipping
 
and
 
handling
 
activities
 
on
 
Free
 
on
 
Rail
 
sales
 
after
 
the
 
customer
 
obtains
control of the good. In this instance,
 
shipping and handling costs
 
paid to third party carriers and
 
invoiced to coal
customers are recorded as freight expense and other revenues, respectively.
(p)
 
Commodity Price Risk
The Company has commodity price risk arising from fluctuations
 
in domestic and global coal prices.
 
The
 
Company’s
 
principal
 
philosophy
 
is
 
not
 
to
 
hedge
 
against
 
movements
 
in
 
coal
 
prices
 
unless
 
there
 
are
exceptional circumstances.
 
Any potential hedging of coal prices would be through fixed
 
price contracts.
 
The
 
Company
 
is
 
also
 
exposed
 
to
 
commodity
 
price
 
risk
 
related
 
to
 
diesel
 
fuel
 
purchases.
 
The
 
Company
 
may
periodically enter into arrangements that protect against
 
the volatility in fuel prices as follows:
•
 
enter into fixed price contracts to purchase fuel for the U.S. Operations
 
.
•
 
enter into derivative financial instruments to hedge exposures to fuel
 
price fluctuations.
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
126
There are
no
 
derivative contracts outstanding December 31, 2023 and
 
2022.
(q)
 
Income Taxes
The Company uses the asset
 
and liability approach to account
 
for income taxes as required by
 
ASC 740, Income
Taxes,
 
which requires
 
the
 
recognition
 
of deferred
 
income
 
tax assets
 
and
 
liabilities
 
for the
 
expected
 
future
 
tax
consequences
 
attributable
 
to differences
 
between
 
the
 
financial
 
statement
 
carrying
 
amounts
 
of
 
existing
 
assets
and liabilities and their respective tax bases.
Valuation allowances are provided
 
when necessary to
 
reduce deferred income
 
tax assets to
 
the amount expected
to be realized, on a more likely than not basis.
The Company recognizes the
 
benefit of an uncertain
 
tax position that it has
 
taken or expects
 
to take on income
tax
 
returns
 
it
 
files
 
if
 
such
 
tax
 
position
 
is
 
more
 
likely
 
than
 
not
 
to
 
be
 
sustained
 
on
 
examination
 
by
 
the
 
taxing
authorities, based on the technical
 
merits of the position. These tax
 
benefits are measured based on the
 
largest
benefit that has a greater than 50% likelihood of being realized
 
upon ultimate resolution.
The Company’s foreign
 
structure consists of
 
Australian entities which
 
are treated as
 
corporations subject to
 
tax
under Australian
 
taxing authorities.
 
The Curragh
 
entities are
 
treated as
 
a branch
 
for U.S.
 
tax purposes
 
and all
income flows through the ultimate parent (the Company).
(r)
 
Fair Value Measurements
The Company utilizes valuation
 
techniques that maximize
 
the use of observable inputs
 
and minimize the use
 
of
unobservable
 
inputs
 
to
 
the
 
extent
 
possible.
 
The
 
Company
 
determines
 
fair
 
value
 
based
 
on
 
assumptions
 
that
market
 
participants
 
would
 
use
 
in
 
pricing
 
an
 
asset
 
or
 
liability
 
in
 
the
 
principal
 
or
 
most
 
relevant
 
market.
 
When
considering
 
market
 
participant
 
assumptions
 
in
 
fair
 
value
 
measurements,
 
the
 
Company
 
distinguishes
 
between
observable and unobservable inputs, which are categorized
 
in one of 3 levels of inputs.
Refer to Note 23 “Fair
 
Value
 
Measurement” for detailed
 
information related to the
 
Company’s fair value
 
policies
and disclosures.
(s)
 
Derivative accounting
The Company recognizes at fair value all contracts meeting the definition of a derivative as assets or liabilities in
the Consolidated Balance Sheet.
With
 
respect
 
to
 
derivatives
 
used
 
in
 
hedging
 
activities,
 
the
 
Company
 
assesses,
 
both
 
at
 
inception
 
and
 
at
 
least
quarterly
 
thereafter,
 
whether
 
such
 
derivatives
 
are
 
highly
 
effective
 
at
 
offsetting
 
the
 
changes
 
in
 
the
 
anticipated
exposure of the
 
hedged item.
 
The change
 
in the fair
 
value of derivatives
 
designated as a
 
cash flow
 
hedge and
deemed highly effective
 
is recorded
 
in “Accumulated
 
other comprehensive
 
losses” until
 
the hedged
 
transaction
impacts reported earnings,
 
at which
 
time any gain
 
or loss is
 
reclassified to earnings.
 
If the
 
hedge ceases to
 
qualify
for
 
hedge
 
accounting,
 
the
 
Company
 
prospectively
 
recognizes
 
changes
 
in
 
the
 
fair
 
value
 
of
 
the
 
instrument
 
in
earnings in the
 
period of the
 
change. The
 
potential for hedge
 
ineffectiveness is
 
present in the
 
design of certain
of the Company’s cash flow hedge relationships.
The Company’s
 
asset and
 
liability derivative
 
positions are
 
offset on
 
a counterparty-by-counterparty
 
basis if
 
the
contractual agreement provides for the net settlement of contracts with the
 
counterparty in the event of default or
termination of any one contract.
There are
no
 
derivative contracts outstanding at December 31, 2023
 
and 2022.
(t)
 
Stock-based Compensation
The Company has
 
a stock-based compensation plan
 
which allows for
 
the grant of
 
certain equity-based incentives
including stock options,
 
performance stock units,
 
or PSU, and
 
restricted stock units,
 
or RSU, to
 
employees and
executive
 
directors,
 
valued
 
in
 
whole
 
or
 
in
 
part
 
with
 
reference
 
to
 
the
 
Company’s
 
CDIs
 
or
 
equivalent
 
common
shares (on a
10
:1 CDI to common share ratio).
The grant-date
 
fair value
 
of stock
 
option
 
award is
 
estimated on
 
the
 
date
 
of grant
 
using
 
Black-Scholes-Merton
option-pricing model. For
 
certain options and
 
PSUs, the Company includes
 
a relative Total
 
Stockholder Return,
or TSR, modifier to determine the number of shares
 
earned at the end of the performance period. The
 
fair value
of awards that include the TSR modifier is determined
 
using a Monte Carlo valuation model.
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
127
The expense for these equity-based incentives is based on their fair value at date of grant and is amortized over
the required service
 
period, generally the vesting
 
period. The Company accounts
 
for forfeitures as
 
and when they
occur.
Refer to
 
Note
 
21 “Stock-Based
 
Compensation”
for detailed
 
information
 
related
 
to the
 
Company’s
 
stock-based
compensation plans.
(
u)
 
Earnings per Share
Basic earnings per share is computed by dividing net income attributable to stockholders of the Company by the
weighted-average number of shares of common stock
 
outstanding during the reporting period.
Diluted net income
 
per share is computed
 
using the weighted-average
 
number of shares
 
of common stock
 
and
dilutive
 
potential
 
shares
 
of
 
common
 
stock
 
outstanding
 
during
 
the
 
period.
 
Dilutive
 
potential
 
shares
 
of
 
common
stock primarily consist of employee stock options and
 
restricted stock.
(v)
 
Deferred Financing Costs
The Company capitalizes costs
 
incurred in connection with new
 
borrowings, the establishment
 
or enhancement
of credit
 
facilities
 
and the
 
issuance
 
of debt
 
securities.
 
These costs
 
are amortized
 
as an
 
adjustment to
 
interest
expense
 
over
 
the
 
life
 
of
 
the
 
borrowing
 
or
 
term
 
of
 
the
 
credit
 
facility
 
using
 
the
 
effective
 
interest
 
method.
 
Debt
issuance costs related to a recognized
 
liability are presented in the balance
 
sheet as a direct reduction from
 
the
carrying amount of that liability whereas debt issuance costs
 
related to a credit facility are shown as an asset.
 
For information on the
 
unamortized balance of
 
deferred financing fees
 
related to outstanding
 
debt, see Note
 
16
“Interest Bearing Liabilities”.
3.
 
Segment Information
The Company has
 
a portfolio of operating
 
mines and development
 
projects in Queensland,
 
Australia and in the
states of
 
Pennsylvania,
 
Virginia
 
and West
 
Virginia
 
in the
 
U.S. The
 
Australian Operations
 
comprise the
 
100%-
owned
 
Curragh
 
producing
 
mine
 
complex.
 
The
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
comprise
two
 
100%-owned
 
producing
 
mine
complexes
 
(Buchanan
 
and
 
Logan),
one
 
100%-owned
 
idled
 
mine
 
complex
 
(Greenbrier)
 
and
two
 
development
properties (Mon Valley
 
and Russell County).
 
The
 
Company
 
operates
 
its
 
business
 
along
two
 
reportable
 
segments:
 
Australia
 
and
 
United
 
States.
 
The
organization of the
two
 
reportable segments reflects how Coronado’s chief
 
operating decision maker, or
 
CODM,
manages and allocates resources to the various components
 
of the Company’s business.
 
The CODM
 
uses Adjusted
 
EBITDA as
 
the primary
 
metric to
 
measure each
 
segment’s
 
operating performance.
Adjusted EBITDA is not a measure of financial performance in accordance with U.S. GAAP.
 
Investors should be
aware that
 
the Company’s
 
presentation of
 
Adjusted EBITDA
 
may not
 
be comparable
 
to similarly
 
titled financial
measures used by other companies.
 
Adjusted EBITDA is
 
defined as earnings
 
before interest, taxes,
 
depreciation, depletion and
 
amortization and other
foreign exchange losses. Adjusted EBITDA is
 
also adjusted for certain discrete items that
 
management exclude
in analyzing each
 
of the
 
Company’s segments’ operating performance.
 
“Other and corporate”
 
relates to additional
financial information for the
 
corporate function such as financial reporting and accounting,
 
treasury, legal, human
resources, compliance,
 
and tax.
 
As such, the
 
corporate function
 
is not determined
 
to be
 
a reportable segment
but is discretely disclosed for purposes of reconciliation to the
 
Company’s Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
128
Reportable segment results for the years ended December 31,
 
2023, 2022 and 2021 are presented below:
 
 
 
 
 
(US$ thousands)
Australia
United
States
Other and
Corporate
Total
Year ended December 31,
 
2023
Total
 
revenues
$
1,681,522
$
1,209,081
$
—
$
2,890,603
Adjusted EBITDA
2,249
421,093
(41,629)
381,713
Total
 
assets
1,322,610
1,010,199
345,229
2,678,038
Capital expenditures
55,412
171,686
660
227,758
Year ended December 31,
 
2022
Total
 
revenues
$
2,116,555
$
1,454,987
$
—
$
3,571,542
Adjusted EBITDA
541,208
716,661
(42,245)
1,215,624
Total
 
assets
1,353,424
1,013,359
183,144
2,549,927
Capital expenditures
89,001
95,769
587
185,357
Year ended December 31,
 
2021
Total
 
revenues
$
1,315,851
$
832,620
$
—
$
2,148,471
Adjusted EBITDA
204,992
312,048
(30,907)
486,133
Total
 
assets
1,357,132
822,222
282,058
2,461,412
Capital expenditures
38,733
50,787
1,616
91,136
The reconciliation of Adjusted EBITDA to net income attributable to the Company for
 
the years ended December
31, 2023, 2022 and 2021 are as follows:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Year Ended December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
2021
Net income
$
156,065
$
771,703
$
189,423
Depreciation, depletion and amortization
160,711
167,046
177,875
Interest expense, net
(1)
56,751
67,632
68,062
Income tax (benefit) expense
(32,251)
231,574
53,102
Other foreign exchange (gains) losses
(2)
(2,899)
(32,259)
7,049
Loss on debt extinguishment
1,385
5,336
8,477
Uncertain stamp duty position
(3)
41,321
—
—
Restructuring costs
—
—
2,300
Losses on idled assets
(4)
4,846
771
2,732
Gain on disposal of assets held for sale
—
—
(14,845)
(Decrease) increase in provision for discounting
 
and credit losses
(4,216)
3,821
(8,042)
Consolidated adjusted EBITDA
$
381,713
$
1,215,624
$
486,133
(1)
Includes interest income of $
7.6
 
million, $
1.5
 
million, and $
0.1
 
million for the years ended December 31, 2023,
2022, 2021, respectively.
(2)
Refer to Note 5 “Other, net”
 
for further discussion.
(3)
 
Relates to stamp duty on Curragh’s acquisition.
 
Refer to Note 26 “Contingencies” for further discussion.
 
(4)
These losses
 
relate to idled
 
non-core assets
 
that the Company
 
has an
 
active plan
 
to sell. Prior
 
to March
 
31,
2023, the Company had idled assets that were classified as
 
held for sale.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
129
The
 
reconciliations
 
of
 
capital
 
expenditures
 
per
 
the
 
Company’s
 
segment
 
information
 
to
 
capital
 
expenditures
disclosed on
 
the Consolidated
 
Statements of
 
Cash Flows
 
for the
 
years ended
 
December
 
31, 2023,
 
2022 and
2021 are as follows:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Year Ended December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
2021
Capital expenditures per Consolidated Statement of Cash
flows
$
237,205
$
199,716
$
89,661
Payment for capital acquired in prior period
(11,243)
(7,475)
(6,000)
Accruals for capital expenditures
10,790
11,243
7,475
Advance payment to acquire long lead capital items
(8,994)
(18,127)
—
Capital expenditures per segment detail
$
227,758
$
185,357
$
91,136
Disaggregation of Revenue
The Company disaggregates the revenue
 
from contracts with customers by
 
major product group for each of
 
the
Company’s
 
segments,
 
as the
 
Company
 
believes
 
it best
 
depicts the
 
nature,
 
amount,
 
timing
 
and
 
uncertainty
 
of
revenues and cash flows. All revenue is recognized at a point
 
in time.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Year ended December 31, 2023
(US$ thousands)
Australia
United States
Total
Product Groups:
Metallurgical coal
$
1,557,471
$
1,031,012
$
2,588,483
Thermal coal
88,281
153,925
242,206
Total
 
coal revenue
1,645,752
1,184,937
2,830,689
Other
(1)
35,770
24,144
59,914
Total
$
1,681,522
$
1,209,081
$
2,890,603
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Year ended December 31, 2022
(US$ thousands)
Australia
United States
Total
Product Groups:
Metallurgical coal
$
1,968,173
$
1,394,880
$
3,363,053
Thermal coal
110,345
54,228
164,573
Total
 
coal revenue
2,078,518
1,449,108
3,527,626
Other
(1)
38,037
5,879
43,916
Total
$
2,116,555
$
1,454,987
$
3,571,542
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Year ended December 31, 2021
(US$ thousands)
Australia
United States
Total
Product Groups:
Metallurgical coal
$
1,171,869
$
822,000
$
1,993,869
Thermal coal
107,867
6,595
114,462
Total
 
coal revenue
1,279,736
828,595
2,108,331
Other
(1)
36,115
4,025
40,140
Total
$
1,315,851
$
832,620
$
2,148,471
(1)
Included
 
in
 
Other
 
revenue
 
for
 
Australian
 
Operation
 
is
 
the
 
amortization
 
of
 
Stanwell
 
non-market
 
coal
 
supply
agreement liability recognized
 
on acquisition
 
of Curragh. See
 
further discussion in
 
Note 17
 
“Contract Obligations”.
Further explanation to tables above:
The following is a description of the principal activities
 
by reportable segments.
•
 
The Company primarily offers two types of products to its
 
customers: metallurgical coal and thermal coal
of
 
varying
 
qualities.
 
The
 
Company’s
 
metallurgical
 
coal
 
is
 
classified
 
as
 
hard
 
coking
 
coal,
 
further
distinguished by its volatility (defined as high, mid, or low),
 
and pulverized coal injection.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
130
•
 
The Australian Operations reportable segment
 
includes the Curragh mine. The
 
Australian Operations is
a separate
 
reportable segment
 
due to
 
having separate
 
management, location,
 
assets, and
 
operations.
 
Curragh
 
mine,
 
included
 
in
 
the
 
Australian
 
Operations,
 
is
 
located
 
in
 
central
 
Queensland,
 
Australia
 
and
produces a wide variety of metallurgical coal.
•
 
The United States reportable segment includes the Buchanan, Logan and Greenbrier coal
 
mine facilities
in Virginia and West Virginia,
 
United States. It produces high, mid and low volatility
 
hard coking coal.
4. Assets Held for Sale
During the fourth
 
quarter of
 
2020, the Company
 
committed to
 
a plan to
 
sell the Greenbrier
 
mining asset, or
 
the
Greenbrier asset, and determined that all of
 
the criteria to classify assets and liabilities as
 
held for sale were met.
The Greenbrier asset is part
 
of the Company’s U.S. segment, located
 
in the State of
 
Virginia in the United States.
The Greenbrier asset does not form part
 
of the Company’s core business
 
strategy and has been idle since April
1, 2020.
The
 
Company
 
remains
 
committed
 
to
 
a
 
plan
 
to
 
sell
 
the
 
Greenbrier
 
asset,
 
however,
 
on
 
March
 
31,
 
2023,
 
the
Company concluded that
 
the timing
 
of the
 
sale within the
 
next twelve months
 
is uncertain. As
 
such, the
 
Greenbrier
mining asset
 
has been
 
classified
 
as held
 
and
 
used since
 
March
 
31, 2023,
 
as it
 
does not
 
meet
 
the criteria
 
for
classification as held for sale.
 
The assets and liabilities
 
of the Greenbrier asset
 
met the criteria for
 
classification as held for
 
sale as of December
31, 2022,
 
therefore
 
the Consolidated
 
Balance Sheet
 
continues to
 
reflect these
 
asset
 
and liabilities
 
as held
 
for
sale as of that date.
 
5.
 
Other, net
Other, net consists of the following:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Year Ended December 31,
 
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
2021
Other foreign exchange gains (losses)
(1)
$
2,899
$
32,259
$
(7,049)
Other income
2,865
1,536
862
Total
 
Other, net
$
5,764
$
33,795
$
(6,187)
(1)
 
Other foreign
 
exchange gains
 
(losses) primarily
 
relates to
 
gains and
 
losses recognized
 
on the
 
translation of
short-term
 
inter-entity
 
balances
 
between
 
certain
 
entities
 
within
 
the
 
Group
 
that
 
are
 
denominated
 
in
 
currencies
other than their respective functional currencies.
6.
 
Capital Structure
(a)
 
Stockholders’ Equity
Authorized capital stock
The Company’s Certificate of Incorporation, as amended, authorize the Company to
 
issue
1,100,000,000
 
shares
of $
0.01
 
par value capital stock consisting of
1,000,000,000
 
shares of common stock and
100,000,000
 
shares of
preferred stock.
Common Stock / CDIs
The following table summarizes Common Stock activity
 
during the periods presented below:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Year Ended December 31,
 
2023
2022
2021
Shares outstanding at the beginning of the year
167,645,373
167,645,373
138,387,890
Shares issued during the year
-
-
29,257,483
Shares outstanding at the end of the year
167,645,373
167,645,373
167,645,373
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
131
A portion of the
 
Company’s common
 
stock is publicly
 
traded on the ASX
 
under the ticker
 
“CRN,” in the
 
form of
CHESS Depositary Interests (“CDIs).
 
CDIs are units of beneficial ownership
 
in shares of common stock
 
held by
CHESS Depositary Nominees Pty Limited (“CDN”), a wholly-owned subsidiary of ASX
 
Limited, the company that
operates the ASX.
As each CDI represents one tenth of a share,
 
holders of CDIs will be entitled to
one
 
vote for every
10
 
CDIs they
hold. CDI
 
holders
 
are to
 
receive
 
entitlements
 
which attach
 
to underlying
 
shares
 
such as
 
participation
 
in rights
issues, bonus issues, capital reductions and liquidation preferences.
The CDIs entitle
 
holders to dividends,
 
if any, and other rights
 
economically equivalent to
 
shares of common
 
stock,
including the right
 
to attend stockholders’
 
meetings. CDN, as
 
the stockholder of
 
record, will vote
 
the underlying
shares in accordance with the directions of the CDI holders
 
.
 
As of December 31,
 
2023,
831,392,221
 
CDIs (representing beneficial
 
interest in
83,139,233
 
shares of common
stock) were owned by investors in the form of CDIs publicly
 
traded on the ASX.
Coronado Group LLC
As
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
Coronado
 
Group
 
LLC,
 
the
 
Company’s
 
controlling
 
stockholder,
 
beneficially
 
owns
845,061,399
 
CDIs (representing a beneficial interest
 
in
84,506,140
 
shares of common stock) representing
50.4
%
of
 
the
 
total
1,676,453,730
 
CDIs
 
(representing
 
a
 
beneficial
 
interest
 
in
167,645,373
 
shares
 
of
 
common
 
stock)
outstanding.
 
Refer to Note 21 “Stock-Based Compensation” for
 
options to purchase common stock issued
 
and outstanding as
of December 31, 2023 and 2022.
Preferred Stock
Coronado Group
 
LLC holds
 
one share
 
of preferred
 
stock
 
Series A.
 
The holder
 
of Series
 
A Preferred
 
Stock
 
is
permitted
 
to
 
nominate
 
and
 
elect
 
members
 
of
 
the
 
Company’s
 
Board
 
of
 
Directors
 
in
 
relation
 
to
 
the
 
level
 
of
 
the
holder’s
 
aggregate
 
beneficial
 
ownership
 
of
 
shares
 
of
 
the
 
Company’s
 
common
 
stock.
 
The
 
Series
 
A
 
Preferred
Share
 
is
 
not
 
entitled
 
to
 
dividends
 
and
 
is
 
non
 
transferable.
 
The
 
Series
 
A
 
Preferred
 
Share
 
has
 
a
 
liquidation
preference of $
1.00
.
(b)
 
Dividends
The dividend
 
policy
 
and
 
the
 
payment
 
of future
 
cash
 
dividends
 
are subject
 
to
 
the
 
discretion
 
of the
 
Company’s
Board of Directors.
During the year ended December 31, 2023, the Company
 
declared:
•
 
Dividends of $
8.4
 
million, or $
0.005
 
per CDI ($
0.05
 
per share of common stock),
 
on February 21, 2023;
and
•
 
Dividends of $
8.4
 
million, or $
0.005
 
per CDI ($
0.05
 
per share of common stock), on August 7, 2023.
 
The Company paid a
 
total of $
16.7
 
million to stockholders and CDI
 
holders on the ASX, net
 
of $
0.1
 
million foreign
exchange gain on
 
payment to certain
 
CDI holders that
 
elected to be
 
paid in Australian
 
dollars,
 
in relation to
 
the
above declared dividends.
 
During the year ended December 31, 2022, the Company
 
declared:
•
 
Dividends of $
150.9
 
million, or $
0.09
 
per CDI ($
0.90
 
per share of common stock), on February 24, 2022;
•
 
Dividends of $
200.1
 
million, or $
0.119
 
per CDI ($
1.19
 
per share of common stock), on May 9, 2022;
 
•
 
Dividends of $
125.7
 
million, or $
0.075
 
per CDI ($
0.75
 
per share of
 
common stock),
 
on August 8,
 
2022;
and
•
 
Dividends of $
225.0
 
million, or $
0.134
 
per CDI ($
1.34
 
per share of common stock), on
 
October 30, 2022.
The
 
Company
 
paid
 
a
 
total
 
of
 
$
700.2
 
million
 
to
 
stockholders
 
and
 
CDI
 
holders
 
on
 
the
 
ASX,
 
net
 
of
 
$
1.4
 
million
foreign exchange gain on payment to certain CDI
 
holders that elected to be paid in Australian dollars,
 
in relation
to the above declared dividends.
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
132
During the year ended December 31, 2021, the Company did
no
t declare or pay dividends.
(c)
 
Earnings per Share
Basic earnings per
 
share of common
 
stock is computed
 
by dividing net
 
income attributable
 
to the Company
 
for
the period,
 
by the
 
weighted-average
 
number of
 
shares
 
of common
 
stock outstanding
 
during the
 
same period.
Diluted earnings per share of common stock is computed
 
by dividing net income attributable to the Company
 
by
the weighted-average number
 
of shares
 
of common
 
stock outstanding adjusted
 
to give
 
effect to potentially
 
dilutive
securities. During periods in which the Company incurs
 
a net loss, diluted weighted average shares outstanding
are equal to basic weighted average shares outstanding
 
because the effect of all equity awards is anti-dilutive.
Basic and diluted earnings per share was calculated as
 
follows (in thousands, except per share data):
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Year Ended December 31,
(US$ thousands, except per share data)
2023
2022
2021
Numerator:
Net income
$
156,065
$
771,703
$
189,423
Less:
 
Net loss attributable to non-controlling interest
—
—
(2)
Net income attributable to Company stockholders
$
156,065
$
771,703
$
189,425
Denominator (in thousands):
Weighted-average shares of common stock outstanding
167,645
167,645
156,710
Effects of dilutive shares
421
201
132
Weighted average diluted shares of common stock
 
outstanding
168,066
167,846
156,842
Earnings Per Share (US$):
Basic
0.93
4.60
1.21
Dilutive
0.93
4.60
1.21
7. Trade Receivables, net
The Company
 
extends trade
 
credit to
 
its customers
 
in the
 
ordinary course
 
of business.
 
Trade
 
receivables are
recorded initially at fair value and subsequently at amortized
 
cost, less any ECL.
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
Trade receivables
$
264,218
$
414,490
Provision for discounting and credit losses (Note 8)
(267)
(4,511)
Trade receivables, net
$
263,951
$
409,979
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
133
8. Provision for Discounting and Credit Losses
The following
 
table provides
 
the reconciliation
 
of the
 
allowance for
 
credit losses
 
that is
 
deducted from
 
financial
assets to present the net amount expected to be collected:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
(US$ thousands)
Trade
receivables
Other
Assets
Total
As at January 1, 2021
$
734
$
522
$
1,256
Change in estimates during the current period
3,777
44
3,821
As of December 31, 2022
4,511
566
5,077
Change in estimates during the current period
(4,244)
28
(4,216)
As of December 31, 2023
$
267
$
594
$
861
9. Inventories
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
Raw coal
$
55,998
$
50,604
Saleable coal
81,314
45,913
Total
 
coal inventories
137,312
96,517
Supplies inventory
54,967
61,501
Total
 
inventories
$
192,279
$
158,018
Coal inventories measured at its net realizable value were
 
$
2.4
 
million and $
5.0
 
million at December 31, 2023
and 2022, respectively,
 
and primarily relates to coal designated for deliveries under
 
the Stanwell below market
coal supply agreement. See further discussion in Note
 
17 “Contract Obligations”.
10.
 
Other Assets
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
Other current assets:
 
Prepayments
$
34,175
$
26,831
 
Long service leave receivable
8,438
7,884
 
Tax
 
credits receivable
3,265
4,183
 
Deposits to acquire mining equipment
18,935
—
 
Short term deposits
21,906
—
 
Other
16,890
21,290
Total
 
other current assets
$
103,609
$
60,188
Other non-current assets:
 
Favorable mineral leases
$
3,310
$
3,448
 
Deferred debt issue costs
2,672
2,463
 
Long service leave receivable
1,485
585
 
Tax
 
credits receivable
4,004
7,269
 
Deposits to acquire long lead mining equipment
8,185
18,126
 
Other
—
1,694
Total
 
other non-current assets
$
19,656
$
33,585
The Company
 
has other assets
 
which includes prepayments,
 
favorable mineral leases,
 
deferred debt issue
 
costs,
long service leave receivable
 
,
 
equipment deposits, short
 
term deposits and coalfield
 
employment enhancement
tax credit receivable.
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
134
Long service leave for
 
eligible coal mine workers
 
at the Company’s
 
Australian Operations is
 
paid when leave is
taken, with a subsequent
 
reimbursement received from
 
the Coal Mining Industry
 
(Long Service Leave Funding)
Corporation
 
in
 
Queensland,
 
Australia.
 
The
 
reimbursement
 
entitlement
 
is
 
recognized
 
as
 
a
 
receivable
 
and
 
is
measured as
 
the present
 
value of
 
expected future
 
reimbursements to
 
be received
 
for the
 
corresponding leave
liability recognized.
 
The Company
 
recognized tax
 
credits receivable
 
relating to
 
the Virginia
 
coalfield employment
 
enhancement tax
credit for
 
coal sales
 
from the
 
Company’s
 
mining properties
 
in the
 
State of
 
West
 
Virginia in
 
the U.S.
 
during the
2018
 
to
 
2021
 
income
 
years.
 
Where
 
the
 
credits
 
exceed
 
the
 
Company’s
 
state
 
tax
 
liability
 
for
 
the
 
tax
 
year,
 
the
excess is redeemable by the
 
Tax
 
Commissioner on behalf of
 
the Commonwealth of Virginia
 
for
85
% of the face
value
 
within
 
90
 
days
 
after
 
filing
 
the
 
return.
 
The
 
tax
 
credits
 
allowed
 
can
 
be
 
claimed
 
in
 
the
 
third
 
taxable
 
year
following the taxable year in which the credit was earned and
 
allowed.
Deposits to acquire long lead mining equipment are advance
 
payments made for future mining equipment.
 
Short term deposits
 
are term deposits
 
held with financial
 
institutions with
 
maturity greater
 
than ninety
 
days and
less than twelve months and that do not meet the cash
 
and cash equivalents criteria.
The favorable mineral leases were recognized on acquisition of certain U.S. assets
 
that are amortized based on
the
 
coal
 
tonnage
 
removed
 
from
 
the
 
lease
 
property
 
relative
 
to
 
the
 
total
 
estimated
 
acquired
 
reserves
 
on
 
that
property.
 
The deferred debt issue costs as of December 31, 2023 and
 
December 31, 2022, are unamortized costs relating
to the
 
establishment of
 
the senior
 
secured asset-based
 
revolving credit facilities
 
(refer to
 
Note 16
 
“Interest Bearing
Liabilities” for
 
further description
 
of these
 
facilities). The
 
deferred issue
 
costs are
 
amortized over
 
the life
 
of the
facility on a straight-line basis
 
and included in “Interest expense, net”
 
in the Company’s Consolidated Statements
of Operations and Comprehensive Income
.
11.
 
Property, Plant and
 
Equipment
The following
 
table indicates
 
the carrying
 
amount of
 
each of
 
the major
 
classes of
 
the Company’s
 
consolidated
depreciable assets:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
 
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
Land
$
28,282
$
27,711
Buildings and improvements
102,642
91,336
Plant, machinery, mining
 
equipment and transportation vehicles
1,189,088
1,012,844
Mineral rights and reserves
389,868
373,309
Office and computer equipment
9,771
9,488
Mine development
579,717
565,106
Asset retirement obligation asset
88,384
87,877
Construction in progress
143,041
82,713
Total
 
cost of property,
 
plant and equipment
2,530,793
2,250,384
Less accumulated depreciation, depletion and amortization
1,024,356
860,836
Property, plant and
 
equipment, net
$
1,506,437
$
1,389,548
The amount of depreciation and amortization expense
 
for property, plant
 
and equipment for the years ended
December 31, 2023, 2022 and 2021 was $
152.4
 
million, $
155.8
 
million and $
166.2
 
million, respectively.
12.
 
Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets
(a)
 
Goodwill
In connection with the
 
Buchanan acquisition on
 
March 31, 2016, the Company
 
recorded goodwill in the
 
amount
of $
28.0
 
million. The
 
Company performed
 
a qualitative
 
assessment to
 
determine if
 
impairment was
 
required at
December 31, 2023 and 2022. Based upon the Company’s qualitative assessment,
 
it is more likely than not that
the fair value
 
of the reporting
 
unit is greater
 
than its carrying amount
 
at December 31, 2023 and
 
2022. As a
 
result,
no
 
impairment was required, and
 
the balance of
 
goodwill at both
 
December 31, 2023 and 2022
was $
28.0
 
million.
The Company has not noted any indicators of impairment since
 
the acquisition date.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
135
(b)
 
Acquired Intangible Assets
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31, 2023
(US$ thousands)
Weighted
average
amortization
period (years)
Gross
carrying
amount
Accumulated
amortization
Net carrying
amount
Intangible assets:
Amortizing intangible assets:
Mining permits - Logan
15
$
1,642
$
1,068
$
574
Mining permits - Buchanan
28
3,501
967
2,534
Total
 
intangible assets
$
5,143
$
2,035
$
3,108
December 31, 2022
(US$ thousands)
Weighted
average
amortization
period (years)
Gross
carrying
amount
Accumulated
amortization
Net carrying
amount
Intangible assets:
Amortizing intangible assets:
Mining permits - Logan
15
$
1,642
$
990
$
652
Mining permits - Buchanan
28
3,501
842
2,659
Total
 
intangible assets
$
5,143
$
1,832
$
3,311
Amortization expense is charged using the
 
straight-line method over the useful
 
lives of the respective intangible
asset.
 
The
 
aggregate
 
amount
 
of
 
amortization
 
expense
 
for
 
amortizing
 
intangible
 
assets
 
for
 
the
 
years
 
ended
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
2022
 
and
 
2021,
 
were
$
0.2
 
million,
 
$
0.2
 
million
 
and
 
$
0.2
 
million,
 
respectively.
 
Estimated
amortization expense for each of the next five years is
 
$
0.2
 
million.
13.
 
Accrued Expenses and Other Current Liabilities
Accrued expenses and other current liabilities consist of the
 
following:
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
Wages and employee benefits
$
42,348
$
38,687
Taxes
 
other than income taxes
6,728
5,988
Accrued royalties
45,770
117,131
Accrued freight costs
47,549
44,496
Accrued mining fees
89,622
103,492
Acquisition related accruals
53,700
11,669
Other liabilities
26,988
22,228
 
Total
 
accrued expenses and other current liabilities
$
312,705
$
343,691
Acquisition
 
related
 
accruals
 
is
 
an
 
accrual
 
for
 
the
 
remaining
 
estimated
 
stamp
 
duty
 
payable
 
on
 
the
 
Curragh
acquisition of $
53.7
 
million (A$
79.0
 
million). Refer to Note 26 “Contingencies” for further
 
details.
14. Leases
During the year ended December 31,
 
2023, the Company entered into a
 
number of agreements to lease
 
mining
equipment.
 
Based
 
on
 
the
 
Company’s
 
assessment
 
of
 
terms
 
within
 
these
 
agreements,
 
the
 
Company
 
classified
these leases as
 
operating leases. On
 
mobilization of th
 
ese leased mining
 
equipment, the Company
 
recognized
right-of-use assets and operating lease liabilities of $
72.5
 
million.
 
Information related to Company’s right-of use assets
 
and related lease liabilities are as follows:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
136
 
 
 
 
 
 
Year ended December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
Operating lease costs
$
17,013
$
8,088
Cash paid for operating lease liabilities
14,597
8,244
Finance lease costs:
Amortization of right of use assets
133
304
Interest on lease liabilities
11
20
Total
 
finance lease costs
$
144
$
324
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
Operating leases:
Right of use asset – operating leases, net
$
80,899
$
17,385
Finance leases:
Property and equipment
371
371
Accumulated depreciation
(309)
(186)
Property and equipment, net
62
185
Current operating lease obligations
22,811
7,593
Non-current operating lease obligations
61,692
15,505
Total
 
Operating lease liabilities
84,503
23,098
Current finance lease obligations
68
127
Non-current finance lease obligations
—
68
Total
 
Finance lease liabilities
68
195
Current lease obligations
22,879
7,720
Non-current lease obligations
61,692
15,573
Total
 
lease obligations
$
84,571
$
23,293
 
 
 
 
December 31,
2023
2022
Weighted Average Remaining
 
Lease Term (Years)
Weighted average remaining lease term – finance
 
leases
0.5
1.5
Weighted average remaining lease term – operating
 
leases
3.7
4.1
Weighted Average Discount
 
Rate
Weighted discount rate – finance lease
7.6%
7.6%
Weighted discount rate – operating lease
9.0%
8.9%
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
137
The Company’s leases have remaining lease terms of
1 year
 
to
5 years
, some of which include
 
options to extend
the terms
 
where the
 
Company deems
 
it is
 
reasonably certain
 
the options
 
will be
 
exercised. Maturities
 
of lease
liabilities as at December 31, 2023, are as follows:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
(US$ thousands)
Operating
Lease
Finance
Lease
Year ending
 
December 31,
2024
$
29,148
$
70
2025
28,361
—
2026
20,628
—
2027
12,235
—
Thereafter
8,787
—
Total
 
lease payments
99,159
70
Less imputed interest
(14,656)
(2)
Total
 
lease liability
$
84,503
$
68
15.
 
Asset Retirement Obligations
Reclamation of
 
areas disturbed
 
by mining
 
operations
 
must be
 
performed
 
by the
 
Company in
 
accordance
 
with
approved
 
reclamation
 
plans
 
and
 
in
 
compliance
 
with
 
state
 
and
 
federal
 
laws
 
in
 
the
 
states
 
of
 
West
 
Virginia
 
and
Virginia
 
in
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
and
 
Queensland
 
in
 
Australia.
 
For
 
areas
 
disturbed,
 
reclamation
 
is
 
performed
progressively,
 
however,
 
a
 
significant
 
amount
 
of
 
the
 
reclamation
 
will
 
take
 
place
 
in
 
the
 
future
 
when
 
operations
cease. There were
no
 
assets that were
 
legally restricted for
 
purposes of settling asset
 
retirement obligations as
of December 31,
 
2023 and 2022.
 
In addition, state
 
agencies monitor
 
compliance with the
 
mine plans, including
reclamation.
The Company records the fair value
 
of its asset retirement obligations using the present
 
value of projected future
cash flows, with
 
an equivalent amount
 
recorded in the
 
related long lived
 
asset or a
 
change to the
 
Consolidated
Statements of Operations
 
if the related
 
permit is closed.
 
An accretion cost,
 
representing the
 
increase over time
in the present value of
 
the liability, is recorded each period and the capitalized cost is
 
depreciated over the useful
life of the related asset. As reclamation work is performed or liabilities
 
otherwise settled, the recorded amount of
the liability is reduced.
Changes in
 
the asset
 
retirement obligations
 
for the
 
years ended
 
December 31,
 
2023 and
 
December 31,
 
2022
were as follows:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
(US$ thousands)
December 31,
2023
December 31,
2022
Total
 
asset retirement obligations at beginning of the year
$
138,490
$
120,277
ARO liability additions - new disturbances
9,923
1,835
Accretion
11,252
9,066
Reclamation performed in the year
(5,334)
(3,270)
Reclass of asset held for sale
(1)
11,115
—
Gain on settlement of ARO
—
(53)
Change in estimate recorded to operations
(3,151)
(2)
Change in estimate recorded to assets
682
15,381
Foreign currency translation adjustment
952
(4,744)
Total
 
Asset retirement obligations at end of the year
163,929
138,490
Total
 
Asset retirement obligations at December 31
(15,321)
(10,646)
Asset retirement obligation, excluding current portion
$
148,608
$
127,844
(1)
 
Refer to Note 4 “Assets Held for Sale”
 
for further information.
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
138
16. Interest Bearing Liabilities
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The following is a summary of interest-bearing liabilities
 
at December 31, 2023:
 
(US$ thousands)
December 31,
2023
December 31,
2022
Weighted Average
Interest Rate at
December 31, 2023
Final
Maturity
10.75
% Senior Secured Notes
$
242,326
$
242,326
12.14
%
(2)
2026
New ABL Facility
—
—
2026
Discount and debt issuance costs
(1)
(6,983)
(9,373)
Total
 
interest bearing liabilities
$
235,343
$
232,953
(1)
Relates to discount
 
and debt
 
issuance costs
 
on the establishment
 
of the Notes.
 
Deferred debt
 
issuance costs
 
incurred on
 
the establishment
of the New ABL Facility has been included
 
within "Other non-current assets" on the Consolidated
 
Balance Sheets.
(2)
 
Represents the effective interest rate.
Senior Secured Notes
On May 12, 2021,
 
the Company entered
 
into an indenture, or
 
the Indenture, among
 
Coronado Finance Pty Ltd,
an Australian proprietary company,
 
as the issuer or the Australian Borrower, the Company,
 
as parent guarantor,
the other
 
guarantors
 
party
 
thereto
 
and
 
Wilmington
 
Trust,
 
National
 
Association,
 
as trustee,
 
and
 
as priority
 
lien
collateral trustee, relating to the issuance of
10.750
% Senior Secured Notes due 2026, or the Notes.
Interest on
 
the Notes
 
is payable
 
semi-annually in
 
arrears on
 
May 15
 
and November
 
15 of
 
each year
 
to record
holders of the Notes on the immediately preceding May
 
1 and November 1, as applicable. The Notes mature
 
on
May 15, 2026
 
and are senior secured obligations of the Company.
The Notes are guaranteed
 
on a senior secured
 
basis by the Company
 
and its wholly-owned
 
subsidiaries (other
than
 
the
 
Issuer)
 
(subject
 
to
 
certain
 
exceptions
 
and
 
permitted
 
liens)
 
and
 
secured
 
by
 
(i)
 
a
 
first-priority
 
lien
 
on
substantially all of the Company’s assets and the assets of the other
 
Guarantors (other than accounts receivable
and other rights to payment,
 
inventory,
 
intercompany indebtedness, certain
 
general intangibles and commercial
tort claims, commodities accounts, deposit accounts, securities accounts and other related assets and proceeds
and products of each of the foregoing, or, collectively, the New ABL Collateral), or the Notes Collateral, and (ii) a
second-priority lien on the New ABL Collateral,
 
which is junior to a first-priority lien, for
 
the benefit of the lenders
under
 
the
 
Company’s
 
senior
 
secured
 
asset-based
 
revolving
 
credit
 
agreement
 
in
 
an
 
initial
 
aggregate
 
principal
amount of $
150.0
 
million, or the New ABL Facility.
The terms
 
of the
 
Notes are
 
governed
 
by the
 
Indenture.
 
The Indenture
 
contains
 
customary covenants
 
for high
yield bonds, including,
 
but not limited
 
to, limitations on
 
investments, liens, indebtedness,
 
asset sales, transactions
with affiliates and
 
restricted payments, including
 
payment of dividends
 
on capital
 
stock. As of
 
December 31, 2023,
the Company was in compliance with all applicable covenants
 
under the Indenture.
Under the terms of the
 
Indenture, upon the occurrence of a “Change
 
of Control” (as defined in the
 
Indenture), the
issuer
 
is
 
required
 
to
 
make
 
an
 
offer,
 
or
 
a
 
Change
 
of
 
Control
 
Offer,
 
to
 
repurchase
 
the
 
Notes
 
at
101
%
 
of
 
the
aggregate principal
 
amount thereof,
 
plus accrued
 
and unpaid
 
interest, if
 
any,
 
to, but
 
excluding, the
 
repurchase
date. Alternatively,
 
if the
 
issuer elects
 
to redeem
 
all of
 
the Notes,
 
during the
 
12-month period
 
commencing
 
on
May 15 of
 
the years set
 
forth below at
 
the redemption
 
prices (expressed in
 
percentages of principal
 
amount on
the redemption date) set forth below, plus accrued and unpaid interest to,
 
but not including, the redemption date,
the issuer is not required to make a Change of Control
 
Offer:
Period
Redemption price
2024
104.03%
2025 and thereafter
100.00%
New Asset Based Revolving Credit Facility
 
On May
 
8, 2023,
 
the Company, Coronado Coal
 
Corporation, a Delaware
 
corporation and wholly
 
owned subsidiary
of the Company,
 
Coronado Finance Pty
 
Ltd, an Australian
 
proprietary company
 
and a wholly
 
owned subsidiary
of the Company,
 
or an Australian
 
Borrower, Coronado
 
Curragh Pty Ltd,
 
an Australian proprietary
 
company and
wholly
 
owned
 
subsidiary
 
of
 
the
 
Company,
 
or
 
an
 
Australian
 
Borrower
 
and,
 
together
 
with
 
the
 
other
 
Australian
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
139
Borrower, the Borrowers,
 
and the other guarantors party
 
thereto, collectively with the Company,
 
the Guarantors
and, together
 
with the
 
Borrowers, the
 
Loan Parties,
 
entered into
 
a senior
 
secured asset-based
 
revolving credit
agreement in
 
an initial
 
aggregate amount
 
of $
150.0
 
million, or
 
the New
 
ABL Facility,
 
with Global
 
Loan Agency
Services Australia
 
Pty Ltd,
 
as the
 
Administrative Agent,
 
Global Loan
 
Agency Services
 
Australia Nominees
 
Pty
Ltd, as the
 
Collateral Agent,
 
the Hongkong and
 
Shanghai Banking Corporation
 
Limited, Sydney
 
Branch, as the
Lender, and DBS Bank
 
Limited, Australia Branch,
 
as the
 
Lender and, together
 
with the other
 
Lender, the Lenders.
On August 3, 2023, the Company
 
satisfied all conditions precedent
 
under the New ABL Facility,
 
at which time it
became effective and replaced the predecessor
 
ABL Facility.
 
The New
 
ABL Facility
 
matures in
 
August 2026
 
and provides
 
for up
 
to $
150.0
 
million in
 
borrowings, including
 
a
$
100.0
 
million sublimit for the issuance
 
of letters of credit and $
70.0
 
million sublimit as a revolving
 
credit facility.
Availability under the New
 
ABL Facility is
 
limited to an
 
eligible borrowing base, determined
 
by applying customary
advance rates to eligible accounts receivable and inventory.
Borrowings under
 
the New
 
ABL Facility
 
bear interest
 
at a
 
rate per
 
annum equal
 
to an
 
applicable rate
 
of
2.80
%
plus BBSY,
 
for loans denominated in A$, or SOFR, for loans denominated
 
in US$, at the Borrower’s election.
 
The New
 
ABL Facility
 
is guaranteed
 
by the
 
Guarantors.
 
Amounts outstanding
 
under the
 
New ABL
 
Facility are
secured by
 
(i) first
 
priority lien
 
in the
 
accounts receivable
 
and other
 
rights to
 
payment, inventory,
 
intercompany
indebtedness, certain general
 
intangibles and commercial
 
tort claims, commodities accounts,
 
deposit accounts,
securities accounts
 
and other
 
related assets
 
and proceeds
 
and products
 
of each
 
of the
 
foregoing, collectively,
the New ABL Collateral, (ii)
 
a second-priority lien on substantially
 
all of the Company’s
 
assets and the assets
 
of
the guarantors, other than the New ABL
 
Collateral, and (iii) solely in the case of
 
the obligations of the Australian
Borrower, a featherweight
 
floating security interest over certain
 
assets of the Australian Borrower,
 
in each case,
subject to certain customary exceptions.
 
The New
 
ABL Facility
 
contains customary representations
 
and warranties
 
and affirmative and
 
negative covenants
including, among
 
others, a
 
covenant regarding
 
the maintenance
 
of leverage
 
ratio to
 
be less
 
than
3.00
 
times, a
covenant regarding maintenance of interest coverage ratio to be more than
3.00
 
times, covenants relating to the
payment of dividends, or purchase or redemption of, with respect to any Equity Interests of Holdings or
 
any of its
Subsidiaries,
 
covenants
 
relating
 
to
 
financial
 
reporting,
 
covenants
 
relating
 
to
 
the
 
incurrence
 
of
 
liens
 
or
encumbrances, covenants relating to the incurrence or prepayment of certain debt, compliance with laws, use of
proceeds, maintenance of properties, maintenance of insurance, payment obligations, financial accommodation,
mergers and
 
sales of all
 
or substantially all
 
of the Borrowers
 
and Guarantors’, collectively
 
the Loan Parties,
 
assets
and limitations on changes in the nature of the Loan Parties’
 
business.
Subject
 
to
 
customary
 
grace
 
periods
 
and
 
notice
 
requirements,
 
the
 
New
 
ABL
 
Facility
 
also
 
contains
 
customary
events of default.
Under the terms of New ABL Facility,
 
a Review Event (as defined in the New ABL Facility) is triggered if, among
other matters, a “change of control” (as defined in the
 
New ABL Facility) occurs.
 
Following the
 
occurrence of
 
a Review
 
Event, the
 
Borrowers must
 
promptly meet
 
and consult
 
in good
 
faith with
the Administrative Agent and the Lenders to agree a
 
strategy to address the relevant Review Event including but
not limited to a restructure of the terms of the New ABL Facility to the satisfaction of the Lenders.
 
If at the end of
a period
 
of
20
 
business days
 
after the
 
occurrence
 
of the
 
Review Event,
 
the Lenders
 
are not
 
satisfied
 
with the
result of their discussion or meeting with the Borrowers or do not
 
wish to continue to provide their commitments,
the Lenders may declare all amounts owing
 
under the ABL Facility immediately due and payable,
 
terminate such
Lenders’
 
commitments
 
to
 
make
 
loans
 
under
 
the
 
ABL
 
Facility,
 
require
 
the
 
Borrowers
 
to
 
cash
 
collateralize
 
any
letter of credit obligations and/or exercise any and all remedies
 
and other rights under the New ABL Facility.
To establish
 
the New ABL Facility, the Company incurred debt issuance costs of $
3.4
 
million. The Company has
elected an accounting
 
policy to present debt
 
issuance costs incurred
 
before the debt liability
 
is recognized (e.g.
before the debt
 
proceeds are received)
 
as an asset
 
which will be
 
amortized ratably
 
over the term
 
of the facility.
The costs
 
will not
 
be subsequently
 
reclassified as
 
a direct
 
deduction of
 
the liability.
 
The carrying
 
value of
 
debt
issuance costs, recorded
 
as “Other non-current
 
assets” in the
 
Consolidated Balance
 
Sheet was
 
$
2.7
 
million as
at December 31, 2023.
As
 
at
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
the
 
letter
 
of
 
credit
 
sublimit
 
had
 
been
 
partially
 
used
 
to
 
issue
 
$
21.9
 
million
 
of
 
bank
guarantees on
 
behalf of
 
the Company
 
and
no
 
amounts were
 
drawn under
 
the revolving
 
credit sublimit
 
of New
ABL Facility. As at December 31, 2023, the Company was in compliance with all applicable covenants under the
New ABL Facility.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
140
Predecessor ABL Facility
 
On
 
August
 
3,
 
2023,
 
the
 
New
 
ABL
 
Facility
 
replaced
 
the
 
predecessor
 
ABL
 
Facility.
 
As
 
a
 
result
 
of
 
the
 
early
termination of the predecessor ABL Facility, the Company recorded a loss on
 
debt extinguishment of $
1.4
 
million
in the
 
Consolidated Statement of
 
Operations and Comprehensive
 
Income for the
 
year ended December
 
31, 2023.
17. Contract Obligations
In
 
connection
 
with
 
the
 
acquisition
 
of
 
the
 
Logan
 
assets,
 
the
 
Company
 
assumed
 
certain
 
non-market
 
contracts
related to various
 
coal leases.
 
The non-market
 
coal leases
 
require royalty
 
payments based on
 
a percentage
 
of
the
 
realization
 
from
 
the
 
sale
 
of
 
the
 
respective
 
coal
 
under
 
lease.
 
On
 
acquisition,
 
the
 
Company
 
recorded
$
27.3
 
million related to the non-market
 
portion of the coal leases
 
and is amortizing it ratably
 
over the respective
estimated coal reserves as they are mined and sold.
In
 
connection
 
with
 
the
 
acquisition
 
of
 
Curragh,
 
the
 
Company
 
assumed
 
the
 
Stanwell
 
below
 
market
 
coal
 
supply
agreement
 
(CSA)
 
with
 
a
 
fixed
 
pricing
 
component
 
that
 
was
 
effectively
 
below
 
the
 
market
 
price
 
at
 
the
 
date
 
of
acquisition. As a
 
result, on acquisition,
 
the Company recorded
 
a liability
 
of $
307.0
 
million (A$
400.0
 
million) related
to the
 
unfavorable pricing
 
of the
 
Stanwell CSA
 
and is
 
amortizing it
 
ratably based
 
on the
 
tons sold
 
through the
contract. The
 
amortization of
 
this liability
 
for the
 
years
 
ended December
 
31, 2023,
 
2022 and
 
2021 were
 
$
32.8
million,
 
$
36.2
 
million
 
and
 
$
33.7
 
million,
 
respectively,
 
and
 
recorded
 
as
 
“Other
 
revenues”
 
in
 
the
 
Consolidated
Statements of Operations and Comprehensive Income.
The following is a summary of the contract obligations
 
as of December 31, 2023:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
(US$ thousands)
Short-term
Long-term
Total
Coal leases contract liability
$
843
$
19,476
$
20,319
Stanwell below market coal supply agreement
39,879
41,716
81,595
$
40,722
$
61,192
$
101,914
The following is a summary of the contract obligations
 
as of December 31, 2022:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
(US$ thousands)
Short-term
Long-term
Total
Coal leases contract liability
$
843
$
19,720
$
20,563
Stanwell below market coal supply agreement
39,500
74,805
114,305
$
40,343
$
94,525
$
134,868
18.
 
Deferred Consideration Liability
On August 14, 2018, the
 
Company completed the purchase of
 
the Stanwell Reserved Area,
 
or the SRA, adjacent
to
 
the
 
current
 
Curragh
 
mining
 
tenements.
 
This
 
area
 
was
 
acquired
 
on
 
a
 
deferred
 
consideration
 
basis
 
and
 
on
acquisition
 
the
 
Company
 
recognized
 
a
 
“Mineral
 
rights
 
and
 
reserves”
 
asset
 
and
 
a
 
corresponding
 
deferred
consideration liability of $
155.2
 
million (A$
210.0
 
million), calculated using the contractual pre-tax discount rate of
13
% representing
 
fair
 
value
 
of
 
the
 
arrangement
 
at
 
the
 
date
 
of
 
acquisition.
 
The
 
deferred
 
consideration
 
liability
reflects passage of
 
time changes by
 
way of an annual
 
accretion at the
 
contractual pre-tax discount
 
rate of
13
%
and will
 
be settled
 
as a
 
discount to
 
the price
 
of thermal
 
coal supplied
 
to Stanwell
 
over the
 
term of
 
a new
 
coal
supply agreement
 
which is
 
expected to
 
commence
 
in 2027.
 
The accretion
 
of deferred
 
consideration
 
liability is
recognized
 
within
 
“Interest
 
expense,
 
net”
 
in
 
the
 
Consolidated
 
Statements
 
of
 
Operations
 
and
 
Comprehensive
Income. The Right-to-mine-asset are amortized over the
 
coal reserves mined from the SRA.
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
Stanwell Reserved Area deferred consideration
$
277,442
$
243,191
$
277,442
$
243,191
19.
 
Workers’ Compensation and Pneumoconiosis (“Black
 
Lung”) Obligations
In
 
the
 
United
 
States,
 
coal
 
mine
 
operations
 
may
 
lead
 
to
 
traumatic
 
workers
 
compensation
 
claims,
 
as
 
well
 
as
workers’ compensation occupational disease claims
 
for black lung disease. Injured workers generally
 
file claims
for traumatic injury under
 
the governing state workers
 
compensation legislation. Workers
 
may file claims due
 
to
black
 
lung
 
under
 
the
 
governing
 
state
 
workers
 
compensation
 
legislation
 
or
 
under
 
a
 
series
 
of
 
federal
 
laws
 
that
include the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, as amended, the Black Lung Benefits Act of 1973,
and
 
the
 
Black
 
Lung
 
Benefits
 
Reform
 
Act
 
of
 
1977.
 
The
 
Company
 
provides
 
for
 
both
 
traumatic
 
workers
compensation claims and occupational disease claims
 
through an insurance policy.
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
141
The Company obtained workers
 
compensation insurance for work
 
related injuries, including black
 
lung, through
a third-party
 
commercial
 
insurance company.
 
The insurance
 
policy covers
 
claims
 
that exceed
 
$
0.5
 
million
 
per
occurrence for all years, or aggregate claims in excess of $
29.1
million, $
22.7
 
million and $
22.0
 
million for policy
years ending May 2024,
 
May 2023 and May
 
2022. Per the contractual
 
agreements, the Company
 
was required
to provide a collateral
 
security of $
63.4
 
million for policy
 
years 2017 through 2024,
 
ending May 31, 2024,
 
which
is accomplished through providing a combination of letters of credit and cash collateral in an escrow account.
As
of December 31,
 
2023, the Company
 
has provided $
16.8
 
million of letters
 
of credit, $
28.4
 
million of cash
 
collateral
and surety bonds of $
15.2
 
million totaling $
60.4
 
million. The remaining collateral
 
was provided in January 2024,
as required.
For the
 
years ended
 
December 31, 2023,
 
2022 and
 
2021, the
 
audited Consolidated
 
Statements of
 
Operations
and
 
Comprehensive
 
Income
 
included
 
Company
 
incurred
 
claims,
 
premium
 
expenses
 
and
 
administrative
 
fees
related to
 
worker’s
 
compensation
 
benefits
 
of
 
$
16.3
 
million,
 
$
12.2
 
million
 
and
 
$
12.2
 
million,
 
respectively.
 
As of
December 31, 2023 and 2022, the estimated workers’ compensation
 
liability was $
37.6
 
million and $
30.1
 
million,
respectively, representing claims incurred but not paid based on
 
the estimate of the
 
outstanding claims under the
coverage
 
limits
 
and
 
the
 
actuarially
 
determined
 
retained
 
liability
 
under
 
the
 
aggregate
 
claim
 
amount.
 
As
 
of
December
 
31,
 
2023
 
and
 
2022,
 
$
32.6
 
million
 
and
 
$
27.1
 
million,
 
respectively,
 
are
 
recorded
 
within
 
“Other
 
non-
current liabilities” in the Consolidated Balance Sheets.
 
The current portion of the Company’s estimated
 
workers’
compensation liabilities are
 
recorded within “Accrued
 
expenses and other
 
current liabilities” in the
 
Consolidated
Balance Sheets.
20.
 
Employee Benefit Plans
The
 
Company
 
has
 
a
 
401(k)-defined
 
contribution
 
plan
 
in
 
which
 
all
 
U.S.
 
full
 
time
 
employees
 
are
 
eligible
 
to
participate
 
upon
 
their
 
date
 
of
 
hire.
 
Employees
 
generally
 
may
 
contribute
 
up
 
to
100
%
 
of
 
their
 
qualifying
compensation
 
subject
 
to
 
statutory
 
limitations.
 
The
 
Company
 
matches
 
up
 
to
100
%
 
up
 
to
 
the
 
first
4
%
 
of
 
the
participant’s annual compensation
 
for all employees except
 
for those employed at Buchanan.
 
For employees at
Buchanan,
 
the
 
Company
 
matches
 
up
 
to
100
%
 
of
 
the
 
first
6
%
 
of
 
the
 
participant’s
 
annual
 
compensation.
 
The
Company’s contributions
 
immediately vest.
 
Total Company contributions for the
 
years ended December
 
31, 2023,
2022 and 2021 amounted to $
5.5
 
million, $
3.9
 
million and $
3.3
 
million, respectively.
In the United States, the Company is self-insured for
 
employee health care claims up to the lesser of $
0.2
 
million
per
 
covered
 
person
 
or
 
an
 
aggregate
 
amount
 
depending
 
on
 
the
 
various
 
coverages
 
provided
 
to
 
employees
throughout the plan year
 
for all employees. The
 
Company has purchased coverage from
 
a commercial insurance
carrier to provide for any claims
 
in excess of these amounts. At
 
December 31, 2023 and 2022, the Company had
provided
 
accruals
 
of
 
$
2.3
 
million
 
and
 
$
1.9
 
million,
 
respectively,
 
for
 
claims
 
incurred
 
but
 
not
 
paid
 
based
 
on
management’s estimate
 
of the Company’s
 
self-insured liability.
 
For the years
 
ended December
 
31, 2023, 2022
and 2021, the Company incurred claims,
 
premium expenses and administrative fees
 
related to this plan totaling
$
35.0
 
million, $
29.8
 
million and $
25.8
 
million, respectively.
21.
 
Stock-Based Compensation
Total
 
stock-based
 
compensation
 
expense
 
was
 
$
2.9
 
million,
 
$
2.7
 
million
 
and
 
$
0.5
 
million
 
for
 
the
 
years
 
ended
December 31,
 
2023,
 
2022
 
and
 
2021,
 
respectively,
 
and
 
was
 
included
 
as a
 
component
 
of
 
selling,
 
general,
 
and
administrative expenses in the Company’s Consolidated Statements of Operations and Comprehensive Income.
The stock-based compensation expense includes
 
compensation expense recognized in full
 
at the grant date for
employees that meet certain retirement eligibility criteria
 
per the 2018 Plan (as defined below).
As
 
of
 
December 31,
 
2023,
 
the
 
Company
 
had
 
$
5.4
 
million
 
of
 
total
 
unrecognized
 
compensation
 
cost
 
related
 
to
nonvested stock-based
 
compensation awards
 
granted under
 
the plans.
 
This cost
 
is expected to
 
be recognized
over
2.25
 
years,
 
with
 
a
 
weighted-average
 
period
 
of
1.76
 
years,
 
as
 
stock-based
 
compensation
 
expense.
 
This
expected cost does not include the impact of any future stock-based
 
compensation awards.
a) 2018 Equity Incentive Plan
In
 
connection
 
with
 
the
 
completion
 
of
 
the
 
Company’s
 
initial
 
public
 
offering
 
of
 
common
 
stock,
 
the
 
Company
implemented
 
the
 
Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources Inc.
 
2018
 
Equity
 
Incentive
 
Plan,
 
or
 
the
 
2018
 
Plan,
 
which
 
is
designed
 
to
 
align
 
compensation
 
for
 
certain
 
key
 
executives
 
with
 
the
 
performance
 
of
 
the
 
Company.
 
Since
 
its
approval, there have been no updates to the 2018 Plan
 
or issuance of a new plan.
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
142
The 2018
 
Plan provides
 
for the
 
grant of
 
awards
 
including stock
 
options, or
 
Options;
 
stock appreciation
 
rights;
restricted stock
 
units, or
 
RSUs; and
 
restricted stock,
 
valued in
 
whole or
 
in part
 
with reference
 
to shares
 
of the
Company’s CDIs or common stock, as well as performance-based awards, including performance stock
 
units, or
PSUs, denominated in CDIs or shares
 
of common stock. Each award
 
is entitled to receive one
 
CDI with
ten
 
CDIs
representing one share of common stock.
The Company
 
measures the cost
 
of all stock-based
 
compensation, including
 
stock options,
 
at fair value
 
on the
grant date
 
and recognizes
 
such costs
 
within “Selling,
 
general and
 
administrative expense”
 
in the
 
Consolidated
Statements of
 
Operations and Comprehensive
 
Income. The
 
Company recognizes compensation
 
expense related
to Options, PSUs and RSUs
 
that cliff vest using
 
the straight-line method during
 
the requisite service period.
 
For
stock-based
 
awards
 
where
 
vesting
 
is
 
dependent
 
upon
 
achieving
 
certain
 
operating
 
performance
 
goals,
 
the
Company
 
estimates
 
the
 
likelihood
 
of
 
achieving
 
the
 
performance
 
goals
 
during
 
the
 
performance
 
period.
 
The
Company accounts
 
for forfeitures as and when they occur.
All awards require the grantee
 
to be employed by the
 
Company at the vesting date except
 
for grantees who meet
certain retirement criteria under the 2018 Plan.
The following awards were outstanding under the 2018
 
as of December 31, 2023:
 
 
 
 
 
Grant year
Vesting date
Performance period
PSUs
RSUs
2023
31/03/2026
01/01/2023 - 31/12/2025
4,823,269
—
 
2023
01/01/2024
not applicable
—
 
43,650
2023
01/07/2024
not applicable
—
 
88,760
2022
01/01/2024
not applicable
—
 
359,291
2022
01/07/2024
not applicable
—
 
243,192
2022
31/03/2026
01/01/2022 - 31/12/2024
6,899,512
—
 
2021
31/03/2025
01/01/2021 - 31/12/2023
4,901,843
—
 
2020
31/03/2024
01/01/2020 - 31/12/2022
1,367,829
—
 
The Options
 
and PSUs granted
 
that will
 
vest are
 
subject to the
 
achievement of goals
 
over the
 
performance period.
These goals are relative total shareholder return, or TSR, and scorecard performance metrics, or the Scorecard.
TSR is determined based on the Company’s percentile ranking of TSR over the performance period relative to a
predefined peer group of similar companies.
Performance metrics applicable to the Options and
 
PSUs granted as summarized below:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Grant year
Relative TSR
Scorecard
TSR
Safety
TSR
Cashflow
2023
33.3%
33.3%
-
33.3%
2022, 2021 and 2020
33.3%
22.2%
22.2%
22.2%
Awards subject to
 
TSR vest based
 
on service
 
and market conditions.
 
The fair
 
value of
 
relative TSR was
 
estimated
on the grant date using a Monte Carlo simulation model.
 
Awards subject to Scorecard vest based on service and performance conditions. The fair value of the Scorecard
was
 
estimated
 
on
 
the
 
grant
 
date
 
fair
 
value
 
of
 
the
 
Company’s
 
common
 
stock
 
adjusted
 
for
 
dividends
 
foregone
during the performance period.
 
Stock Option Awards
The Company’s
 
2018 stock
 
option awards were
 
granted on the
 
date of the
 
IPO with an
 
exercise price
 
of $
2.84
per CDI (A$
4.00
 
per CDI) which was equal to the Company’s IPO
 
Price.
The Company’s Stock Option activity is summarized
 
below:
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
143
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Stock Option Plan Activity
2023
2022
2021
Opening at the beginning of the year
181,687
1,015,006
1,083,101
Forfeited
—
(833,319)
(68,095)
Vested
(181,687)
—
—
Outstanding at the end of the year
—
181,687
1,015,006
Exercisable at the end of the year
181,687
—
—
2023
2022
2021
Weighted-average remaining contractual term (in
years)
—
0.25
1.25
The weighted
 
average
 
grant
 
date
 
fair
 
value
 
of all
 
Option
 
Awards
 
granted
 
was
 
$
0.27
.
 
On August
 
5,
 
2019, the
Board of Directors declared and approved return of
 
capital of $
0.298
 
(A$
0.440
) per CDI. In accordance with ASX
listing rule clause 7.22.3 the exercise price of option
 
awards granted under 2018 plan were reduced by the same
amount as the return of capital to $
2.44
 
(A$
3.56
).
181,687
 
stock option awards vested during the year remained
exercisable as at December 31, 2023.
Performance Stock Unit Awards
Activity of the Company’s
 
PSUs that are ultimately
 
payable in the Company’s
 
CDIs or the equivalent
 
number of
shares of common stock granted under the 2018 Plan
 
is summarized below:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Performance Stock Units Plan Activity
2023
2022
2021
Nonvested at the beginning of the year
14,858,921
8,501,869
4,002,783
Granted
4,872,122
7,471,100
5,998,212
Forfeited
(1,451,677)
(1,114,048)
(1,499,126)
Vested and settled
(286,913)
—
—
Nonvested and outstanding at the end of the year
17,992,453
14,858,921
8,501,869
2023
2022
2021
Weighted-average grant date fair value (per CDI)
$
0.58
$
0.53
$
0.43
Weighted-average remaining term (in years)
1.82
2.54
2.79
The weighted average grant date fair value of all PSU
 
Awards granted in 2023 was $
0.74
 
(A$
1.11
).
The assumptions used to determine the PSUs fair value
 
on each grant date were as follow:
 
 
 
 
2023 Grant
2022 Grant
2021 Grant
2020 Grant
Time to maturity (in years) (i)
2.98
3.99
3.85
3.49
Dividend yield (ii)
7.8%
16.3%
3.0%
1.6%
Expected volatility (iii)
60.0%
60.0%
60.0%
60.0%
Risk-free interest rate (iv)
2.98%
2.66%
0.35%
0.18%
(i)
 
Time to maturity represents the period
 
that the Company’s stock-based
 
awards will vest. All awards cliff
vest at the end of the requisite service period.
(ii)
 
Dividend yield is the expected average yield of dividends
 
expected over the vesting period.
(iii)
 
The
 
volatility
 
was
 
estimated
 
using
 
comparable
 
public
 
company’s
 
volatility
 
and
 
the
 
Company’s
 
own
volatility for similar terms.
(iv)
 
Risk-free interest
 
rate is based
 
on an interpolated
 
Australian Government
 
Bond Rate
 
at the time
 
of the
grant for periods corresponding with the expected term
 
of the PSUs.
The above
 
inputs were
 
consistent to
 
determine the
 
fair value
 
of the
 
market and
 
performance conditions
 
of the
PSUs awards.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
144
Restricted Stock Units
RSUs issued to certain employees are only subject
 
to service conditions and vest at various intervals
 
during the
service period.
 
The fair
 
value of
 
the award
 
was determined
 
using the
 
market price
 
of the
 
Company’s Common
Stock at the date of grant and compensation expense
 
is recorded over the requisite service period.
 
Activity of the Company’s
 
RSUs that are ultimately
 
payable in the Company’s
 
CDIs or the equivalent
 
number of
shares of common stock granted under the 2018 Plan
 
is summarized below:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Restricted Stock Units Plan Activity
2023
2022
Nonvested at the beginning of the year
1,144,034
—
Granted
144,506
1,144,034
Forfeited
(46,593)
—
Vested and settled
(507,054)
—
Nonvested and outstanding at end of the year
734,893
1,144,034
2023
2022
Weighted-average grant date fair value (per CDI)
$
1.26
$
1.22
Weighted-average remaining term (in years)
0.23
0.70
Change in Control
Under the
 
Company’s
 
2018
 
Equity
 
Incentive
 
Plan,
 
the
 
change
 
of control
 
provisions
 
may
 
also
 
be
 
triggered
 
on
completion
 
of
 
the
 
SGI
 
Transaction,
 
however
 
the
 
Compensation
 
and
 
Nominating
 
Committee
 
of
 
the
 
Board
 
of
Directors, at its
 
sole discretion, will determine
 
how the outstanding awards
 
under the plan
 
will be dealt
 
with, which
may include acceleration of vesting condition and related compensation
 
costs.
22.
 
Income Taxes
Income from continuing operations before income
 
taxes for the years presented
 
below consisted of the following:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
2021
U.S.
$
334,373
$
609,617
$
226,463
Non-U.S.
(210,559)
393,660
16,062
Total
$
123,814
$
1,003,277
$
242,525
Total
income tax expense (benefit) for the periods presented
 
below consisted of the following:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
2021
Current:
U.S. federal
$
(6,303)
$
90,933
$
30,075
Non-U.S.
(2,715)
75,270
(4,443)
State
(1,895)
25,347
3,480
Total
 
current
(10,913)
191,550
29,112
Deferred:
U.S. federal
28,943
406
13,486
Non-U.S.
(45,976)
35,425
6,658
State
(4,305)
4,193
3,846
Total
 
deferred
(21,338)
40,024
23,990
Total
 
income tax (benefit) expense
$
(32,251)
$
231,574
$
53,102
 
 
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
145
The following is a reconciliation of the expected statutory federal income tax expense (benefit) to the Company’s
income tax (benefit) expense for the periods presented below:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
2021
Current:
Expected income tax expense at U.S. federal statutory rate
$
26,001
$
210,690
$
50,931
Percentage depletion
(17,871)
(41,047)
—
FDII deduction
(7,796)
—
—
Permanent differences
2,176
(2,262)
296
Prior period tax return adjustments and amendments
(46,060)
596
(4,259)
Uncertain tax positions
21,243
—
—
Australian branch impact on U.S. taxes
(14,552)
42,049
(1,699)
State income taxes, net of federal benefit
4,608
21,548
7,833
Total
 
income tax (benefit) expense
$
(32,251)
$
231,574
$
53,102
Effective tax rate
(
26.0
%)
23.1%
21.9%
The
 
prior
 
period
 
tax
 
return
 
adjustment
 
relates
 
predominantly
 
to
 
a
 
Foreign
 
Derived
 
Intangible
 
Income
 
(“FDII”)
deduction
 
in
 
the
 
U.S.
 
which
 
the
 
Company
 
has
 
chosen
 
to
 
deduct
 
after
 
undertaking
 
a
 
study
 
to
 
confirm
 
the
Company’s eligibility.
 
Deferred income taxes
 
reflect the net
 
tax effects of
 
temporary differences between the
 
carrying amounts of
 
assets
and liabilities
 
for financial
 
reporting purposes
 
and the
 
amount used
 
for income
 
tax purposes
 
using the
 
enacted
tax rates and laws currently
 
in effect. Significant components
 
of the Company’s deferred
 
income tax assets and
liabilities as of December 31, 2023 and 2022 were as follows:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$ thousands)
2023
2022
Deferred income tax assets:
Accruals and provisions
$
44,373
$
36,409
Contract obligations
108,672
119,505
Lease obligations
35,312
—
Asset retirement obligation
55,322
49,078
Goodwill
6,653
6,590
Tax
 
losses
59,964
6,886
Interest limitation carried forward
1,766
14,408
Other
19,574
31,747
Gross deferred income tax assets
331,636
264,623
Valuation allowance
(1)
(33,894)
(34,667)
Total
 
deferred income tax assets, net of valuation allowance
297,742
229,956
Deferred income tax liabilities:
Property, plant, equipment
 
and mine development, principally due to
differences in depreciation, depletion and asset
 
impairments
(297,915)
(300,968)
Warehouse stock
(12,824)
(13,980)
Right of use asset
(34,021)
—
U.S. liability on foreign deferred taxes
(19,075)
—
Other
(6,822)
(10,679)
Total
 
deferred income tax liabilities
(370,657)
(325,627)
Net deferred income tax liability
$
(72,915)
$
(95,671)
(1)
 
As of
 
December 31,
 
2023, the
 
Company recorded
 
a valuation
 
allowance against
 
a deferred
 
tax asset
 
of an
equal amount which relates
 
predominantly to tax losses
 
and land and goodwill.
 
A company,
 
which is not part
 
of
the Australian tax consolidated group,
 
had tax losses carried forward
 
of $
10.9
 
million (tax effected) for
 
which an
equal valuation allowance has been recognized. Due to the capital character of
 
land and goodwill and the lack of
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
146
expected capital gains, the Group is not expected to realize
 
the benefit of this deferred tax asset.
The Australian tax consolidated group has tax
 
losses of $
48.7
 
million carried forward at December 31, 2023.
 
The
tax losses of
 
$
27.0
 
million (tax effected) at
 
December 31, 2021, carried
 
forward at the
 
Australian Operations were
fully utilized in 2022.
 
The U.S. House
 
of Representatives
 
approved a
 
$740 billion budget
 
reconciliation package
 
that includes
 
a new
minimum tax on certain large corporations, an excise tax on stock buybacks, a significant increase in funding for
the Internal Revenue Service, incentives to promote climate change mitigation and clean energy,
 
and provisions
to promote health
 
care affordability.
 
The Inflation Reduction
 
Act includes a
 
book-minimum tax (AMT)
 
similar to
that originally proposed in the House-approved
 
Build Back Better legislation that would
 
impose a 15% minimum
tax on “adjusted
 
financial statement income” of
 
applicable corporations over the
 
“corporate AMT foreign tax
 
credit
for the taxable
 
year.”
 
Under the bill,
 
an applicable corporation’s
 
minimum tax would
 
be equal to
 
the amount by
which
 
the
 
tentative
 
minimum
 
tax
 
exceeds
 
the
 
sum
 
of
 
the
 
corporation’s
 
regular
 
tax
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
and
 
the
corporation’s base erosion and anti-abuse tax liability under section 59A. This provision was effective for taxable
years beginning after December 31, 2022 and did not
 
have any impact to the Company.
 
Unrecognized Tax
 
Benefits
The
 
Company
 
provides
 
for
 
uncertain
 
tax
 
positions,
 
and
 
the
 
related
 
interest
 
and
 
penalties,
 
based
 
upon
management’s assessment of whether a tax benefit is
 
more likely than not to be sustained upon examination by
tax authorities.
 
To
 
the extent
 
that the
 
anticipated
 
tax outcome
 
of these
 
uncertain
 
tax positions
 
changes,
 
such
changes in estimate will impact the income tax
 
provision in the period in which such determination is made.
 
The
Company recognizes accrued interest and penalties related to uncertain tax
 
positions as a component of income
tax expense.
During the
 
year ended
 
December 31,
 
2023, the
 
Company identified
 
unrecognized tax
 
benefits of
 
$
20.8
 
million
that, if recognized,
 
would affect the
 
effective tax rate.
 
The Company did
no
t identify or
 
record any uncertain
 
tax
positions during the years ended December 31, 2022 and 2021.
 
 
 
 
 
December 31,
(US$)
2023
At beginning of the year
$
—
Additions based on tax positions related to current year
6,388,281
Additions for tax positions of prior years
14,395,565
At end of the year
20,783,846
The Company
 
recorded
no
 
amounts related
 
to interest
 
and penalties
 
on uncertain
 
tax positions
 
for 2023, 2022
and 2021 as these were not material.
 
The Company is subject to taxation in
 
the United States and Australia. As of December 31, 2023,
 
tax years 2018
to 2022 are open to review
 
from taxation authorities in the United States. In
 
Australia, tax years 2019 to 2022 are
open to review and the Australian Taxation
 
Office is presently conducting a review
 
of these years.
23.
 
Fair Value Measurement
Fair Value of Financial Instruments
The fair
 
value of
 
a financial
 
instrument is
 
the amount
 
that will
 
be received
 
to sell
 
an asset
 
or paid
 
to transfer
 
a
liability in
 
an orderly transaction
 
between market participants
 
at the
 
measurement date. The
 
fair values
 
of financial
instruments involve uncertainty and cannot be determined with
 
precision.
The Company utilizes valuation
 
techniques that maximize
 
the use of observable inputs
 
and minimize the use of
unobservable
 
inputs
 
to
 
the
 
extent
 
possible.
 
The
 
Company
 
determines
 
fair
 
value
 
based
 
on
 
assumptions
 
that
market participants would
 
use in pricing
 
an asset or
 
liability in the
 
market. When considering
 
market participant
assumptions in fair
 
value measurements, the
 
following fair value
 
hierarchy distinguishes between observable
 
and
unobservable inputs, which are categorized in one of the following
 
levels:
Level
 
1
 
Inputs:
 
Unadjusted
 
quoted
 
prices
 
in
 
active
 
markets
 
for
 
identical
 
assets
 
or
 
liabilities
 
accessible
 
to
 
the
reporting entity at the measurement date.
 
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
147
Level 2 Inputs: Other than
 
quoted prices that are observable
 
for the asset or
 
liability, either
 
directly or indirectly,
for substantially the full term of the asset or liability.
Level
 
3
 
Inputs:
 
Unobservable
 
inputs
 
for
 
the
 
asset
 
or
 
liability
 
used
 
to
 
measure
 
fair
 
value
 
to
 
the
 
extent
 
that
observable inputs
 
are not
 
available, thereby
 
allowing for
 
situations in
 
which there
 
is little, if
 
any,
 
market activity
for the asset or liability at measurement date.
Financial Instruments Measured on a Recurring Basis
As of December
 
31, 2023
 
and 2022,
 
there were
no
 
financial instruments
 
required to
 
be measured
 
at fair
 
value
on a recurring basis.
 
Other Financial Instruments
The following methods
 
and assumptions
 
are used to
 
estimate the fair
 
value of other
 
financial instruments
 
as of
December 31, 2023 and 2022:
•
 
Cash
 
and
 
cash
 
equivalents,
 
accounts
 
receivable,
 
short-term
 
deposits,
 
accounts
 
payable,
 
accrued
expenses,
 
lease
 
liabilities
 
and
 
other
 
current
 
financial
 
liabilities:
 
The
 
carrying
 
amounts
 
reported
 
in
 
the
Consolidated Balance Sheets approximate fair value due to the
 
short maturity of these instruments.
•
 
Restricted deposits,
 
lease liabilities,
 
interest bearing
 
liabilities and
 
other financial
 
liabilities: The
 
fair values
approximate the carrying amounts
 
reported in the Consolidated Balance Sheets.
•
 
Interest bearing liabilities: The
 
Company’s outstanding interest-bearing liabilities are carried at
 
amortized
cost. As of December 31,
 
2023, there were
no
 
amounts drawn under the
 
revolving credit sublimit of
 
the
New ABL
 
Facility. The estimated fair
 
value of
 
the Notes as
 
of December
 
31, 2023
 
is approximately $
251.4
million based upon quoted market prices in a market that
 
is not considered active (Level 2).
24.
 
Accumulated Other Comprehensive Losses
The Company’s Accumulated
 
Other Comprehensive Losses
 
consists of foreign currency
 
translation adjustment
from subsidiaries not using the U.S. dollar as their functional currency.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
(US$ thousands)
Foreign
currency
translation
adjustments
Balance at December 31, 2021
$
(44,228)
Net current-period other comprehensive income (loss):
Loss in other comprehensive income before reclassifications
(19,610)
Loss on long-term intra-entity foreign currency transactions
(27,585)
Total
 
net current-period other comprehensive loss
(47,195)
Balance at December 31, 2022
(91,423)
Net current-period other comprehensive income (loss):
Gain in other comprehensive income before reclassifications
(2,367)
Gain on long-term intra-entity foreign currency transactions
3,863
Total
 
net current-period other comprehensive losses
1,496
Balance at December 31, 2023
$
(89,927)
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
148
25. Commitments
(a)
 
Mineral Leases
The
 
Company
 
leases
 
mineral
 
interests
 
and
 
surface
 
rights
 
from
 
land
 
owners
 
under
 
various
 
terms
 
and
 
royalty
rates. The future minimum royalties under these leases
 
are as follows:
 
 
 
 
 
(US$ thousands)
Amount
Year ending
 
December 31,
2024
$
5,795
2025
5,423
2026
5,280
2027
5,241
2028
5,174
Thereafter
26,162
Total
$
53,075
Mineral leases are not in scope of ASC 842 and continue to
 
be accounted for under the guidance in ASC 932,
Extractive Activities – Mining.
(b)
Other commitments
As of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
purchase
 
commitments
 
for
 
capital
 
expenditures
 
were
 
$
20.9
 
million,
 
all
 
of
 
which
 
is
obligated within the next 12 months.
In Australia, the
 
Company has generally
 
secured the ability
 
to transport coal
 
through rail contracts
 
and coal export
terminal contracts that are primarily funded
 
through take-or-pay arrangements with terms ranging up to
12 years
.
 
In the U.S., the Company typically
 
negotiates its rail and coal terminal
 
on an annual basis.
 
As of December 31,
2023, these Australian
 
and U.S. commitments
 
under take-or-pay
 
arrangements totaled
 
$
788.4
 
million, of which
approximately $
94.7
 
million is obligated
 
within the next
 
year,
 
$
187.3
 
million within
 
1-3 years, $
189.3
 
million 3-5
years and $
317.1
 
million thereafter.
26. Contingencies
Surety bond, letters of credit and bank guarantees
In the
 
normal course
 
of business,
 
the Company
 
is a
 
party to
 
certain guarantees
 
and financial
 
instruments with
off-balance sheet risk, such as bank
 
guarantees, letters of credit and performance
 
or surety bonds.
No
 
liabilities
related to these arrangements are reflected in the Company’s Consolidated Balance Sheets.
 
Management does
not expect any material losses to result from these guarantees
 
or off-balance sheet financial instruments.
For
 
the
 
U.S.
 
Operations
 
in
 
order
 
to
 
provide
 
the
 
required
 
financial
 
assurance
 
for
 
post
 
mining
 
reclamation,
 
the
Company generally uses
 
surety bonds. The
 
Company uses surety
 
bonds and bank
 
letters of credit
 
to collateralize
certain
 
other
 
obligations
 
including
 
contractual
 
obligations
 
under
 
workers’
 
compensation
 
insurances.
 
As
 
of
December 31,
 
2023, the
 
Company had
 
outstanding surety
 
bonds of
 
$
44.0
 
million and
 
letters of
 
credit of
 
$
16.8
million issued from available bank guarantees under the
 
New ABL Facility.
 
For the Australian
 
Operations as at
 
December 31, 2023, the
 
Company had bank
 
guarantees outstanding of $
24.4
million,
 
including
 
$
5.1
 
million
 
issued
 
from
 
the
 
New
 
ABL
 
Facility,
 
primarily
 
in
 
respect
 
of
 
certain
 
rail
 
and
 
port
arrangements of the Company.
 
As at December 31, 2023, the Company, in aggregate, had total outstanding bank guarantees provided of $
41.2
million to secure obligations and commitments, including $
21.9
 
million issued from the New ABL Facility.
 
Future regulatory changes relating to the above obligations could result in
 
increased obligations, additional costs
or additional collateral requirements.
Restricted deposits – cash collateral
As required
 
by certain
 
agreements,
 
the Company
 
had cash
 
collateral
 
in the
 
form of
 
deposits in
 
the amount
 
of
$
68.7
 
million and $
89.1
 
million as of December 31,
 
2023 and 2022, respectively, to provide back-to-back support
for bank guarantees, financial
 
payments, other performance obligations, various
 
other operating agreements and
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
149
contractual obligations
 
under workers
 
compensation insurance.
 
These deposits
 
are restricted
 
and classified
 
as
long-term assets in the Consolidated Balance Sheets.
In accordance
 
with the
 
terms of
 
the New
 
ABL Facility,
 
the Company
 
may be
 
required to
 
cash collateralize
 
the
New ABL Facility to
 
the extent of outstanding letters of
 
credit after the expiration or
 
termination date of such letter
of credit.
 
As of
 
December 31,
 
2023,
no
 
such letter
 
of credit
 
was outstanding
 
after the
 
expiration or
 
termination
date and
no
 
cash collateral was required.
Stamp duty on Curragh acquisition
On September 27, 2022, the Company received from
 
the Queensland Revenue Office, or QRO,
 
an assessment
of the stamp duty
 
payable on its
 
acquisition of the Curragh
 
mine in March
 
2018. The QRO assessed
 
the stamp
duty on this acquisition at an amount of $
56.2
 
million (A$
82.2
 
million) plus unpaid tax interest. On November 23,
2022, the Company filed an objection to the assessment
 
.
 
On January 9, 2024, the Company’s objection
 
to the assessed stamp duty was disallowed by the
 
QRO.
The Company,
 
based on legal
 
and valuation advice
 
obtained, continues to
 
maintain its position and
 
the estimated
stamp duty payable of $
29.4
 
million (A$
43.0
 
million) on the Curragh
 
acquisition. In October 2022,
 
the Company
made a partial payment prior to filing the filing of the objection of stamp duty, reducing the Company’s
 
estimated
accrual to $
11.8
 
million (A$
17.3
 
million).
As per the Taxation
 
Administration Act (Queensland)
 
2001, the Company
 
can only appeal
 
or apply for a
 
review
of QRO’s
 
decision if
 
it has
 
paid the
 
total assessed
 
stamp duty
 
of $
56.2
 
million (A$
82.2
 
million) plus
 
unpaid tax
interest of $
14.5
 
million (A$
21.2
 
million). Such appeal must be lodged by March 11,
 
2024.
 
The Company
 
disputes the
 
additional amount
 
assessed of
 
stamp duty
 
and unpaid
 
tax interest
 
and is
 
currently
considering its options to either appeal the decision to the Supreme Court of
 
Queensland or apply for a review of
QRO’s decision by the Queensland Civil and Administrative
 
Tribunal.
 
Given that
 
the Company
 
is unable
 
to avoid
 
the payment,
 
and the
 
recovery of
 
such amount
 
through litigation
 
is
uncertain,
 
the
 
additional
 
accrual
 
of
 
$
41.3
 
million
 
has
 
been
 
recognized
 
within
 
“Accrued
 
Expenses
 
and
 
Other
Current Liabilities”
 
in the
 
Consolidated Balance
 
Sheet as
 
at December
 
31, 2023,
 
and a
 
corresponding amount
recognized
 
under
 
“Selling,
 
general
 
and
 
administrative”
 
expense
 
in
 
the
 
Company’s
 
Consolidated
 
Statement
 
of
Operations and
 
Comprehensive Income.
 
The total
 
accrual of
 
$
53.7
 
million (A$
79.0
 
million) as
 
at 31
 
December
2023
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
Company’s
 
estimate
 
of
 
the
 
outstanding
 
stamp
 
duty
 
payable,
 
the
 
additional
 
accrual
recognized, less partial payments to date of $
17.6
 
million (A$
25.7
 
million).
 
From time to time, the
 
Company becomes a
 
party to other legal
 
proceedings in the
 
ordinary course of
 
business
in Australia, the U.S. and other countries where the Company does business.
 
Based on current information, the
Company believes that such other pending
 
or threatened proceedings are likely to
 
be resolved without a material
adverse
 
effect
 
on
 
its
 
financial
 
condition,
 
results
 
of
 
operations
 
or
 
cash
 
flows.
 
In
 
management’s
 
opinion,
 
the
Company is not currently
 
involved in any legal
 
proceedings, which individually
 
or in the aggregate
 
could have a
material effect on the financial condition, results of
 
operations and/or liquidity of the Company.
27. Related
‑
Party Transactions
Xcoal
On
 
May
 
27,
 
2021,
 
Xcoal
 
ceased
 
to
 
be
 
a
 
related
 
party
 
after
 
Xcoal’s
 
founder,
 
chief
 
executive
 
officer
 
and
 
chief
marketing officer,
 
Mr. Ernie Thrasher,
 
retired as a non-executive director of the Company.
 
“Coal
 
revenues
 
from
 
related
 
parties”
 
of
 
$
97.3
 
million
 
in
 
the
 
Consolidated
 
Statement
 
of
 
Operations
 
and
Comprehensive Income for the period up to May 27, 2021, represent
 
revenues from Xcoal while it was a related
party.
 
Revenues
 
from
 
coal
 
sales
 
to
 
Xcoal
 
after
 
May
 
27,
 
2021
 
are
 
included
 
within
 
“Coal
 
revenues”
 
in
 
the
Consolidated Statement of Operations and Comprehensive Income.
 
The Energy & Mineral Group
On
 
May
 
12,
 
2021,
 
affiliates
 
of
 
The
 
Energy
 
&
 
Minerals
 
Group,
 
or
 
EMG,
 
which
 
is
 
the
 
Company’s
 
controlling
stockholder
 
through
 
its
 
ownership
 
of
 
Coronado
 
Group
 
LLC,
 
participated
 
in
 
the
 
Notes Offering
 
and
 
purchased
$
65.0
 
million aggregate principal amount of Notes at the closing of the Notes Offering. Following
 
the redemption
of Notes to date, the principal amount of Notes held by EMG reduced to
 
$
52.0
 
million as at December 31, 2023.
At December
 
31, 2023
 
and 2022,
 
interest payable
 
to affiliates
 
of EMG
 
on the
 
Notes was
 
$
0.7
 
million and
 
$
0.7
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
150
million, respectively, and was recorded within
 
“Accrued expenses and other
 
current liabilities” in
 
the Consolidated
Balance
 
Sheets.
 
Interest
 
expense
 
to
 
affiliates
 
of
 
EMG
 
was
 
$
5.6
 
million
 
and
 
$
7.1
 
million
 
for
 
the
 
years
 
ended
December
 
31,
 
2023
 
and
 
2022,
 
respectively,
 
and
 
recorded
 
in
 
“Interest
 
expense,
 
net”
 
in
 
the
 
Consolidated
Statement of Operations and Comprehensive Income.
SGI Transaction
 
On September 25, 2023, Energy &
 
Minerals Group, the Company’s controlling stockholder through its ownership
of Coronado Group
 
LLC, including through
 
certain of its
 
affiliates and managed
 
funds (the Sellers),
 
advised the
Company
 
that
 
it
 
had
 
entered
 
into
 
a
 
membership
 
interest
 
purchase
 
agreement,
 
or
 
MIPA,
 
with
 
Sev.en
 
Global
Investments
 
a.s.,
 
or
 
SGI.
 
A
 
copy
 
of
 
the
 
MIPA
 
has
 
not
 
been
 
made
 
available
 
to
 
the
 
Company
 
or
 
the
 
Special
Committee
 
referred
 
to
 
below
 
as
 
of
 
the
 
date
 
of
 
this
 
Annual
 
Report
 
on
 
Form
 
10-K.
 
However,
 
the
 
Company
understands that, pursuant
 
to the terms of
 
the MIPA,
 
the Sellers agreed to
 
sell all of their
 
interests in Coronado
Group LLC to
 
a wholly-owned
 
subsidiary of
 
SGI. We
 
refer to the
 
proposed transaction
 
as the SGI
 
Transaction.
The
 
Company
 
also
 
understands
 
that,
 
under
 
the
 
MIPA,
 
the
 
SGI
 
Transaction
 
is
 
subject
 
to
 
customary
 
closing
conditions including regulatory approvals in the U.S. and Australia.
The Board of
 
Directors has appointed
 
a special committee
 
of independent
 
directors, or the
 
Special Committee,
to, among other things, assess
 
the impact and consequences of the
 
SGI Transaction on the
 
Company and take
such actions as the Special Committee deems appropriate
 
in connection with the SGI Transaction.
The Energy and
 
Minerals Group
 
has reported that
 
following the
 
closing of
 
the SGI Transaction,
 
SGI will
 
be the
direct or indirect
 
owner of Coronado
 
Group LLC. As
 
of the date
 
of this Annual
 
Report on Form
 
10-K, Coronado
Group LLC
 
is currently
 
the direct
 
owner of
845,061,399
 
CDIs (representing
 
a beneficial
 
interest in
84,506,140
shares
 
of common
 
stock,
 
or
50.4
% of
 
the Company’s
 
outstanding
 
total common
 
stock)
 
and the
one
 
Series
 
A
Share.
Based on information that the Company is currently aware of,
 
on completion of the SGI Transaction, a change of
control as defined under the terms of Notes and New
 
ABL Facility may occur. Refer to Note 16. “Interest Bearing
Liabilities” for further information.
Under the
 
Company’s
 
2018
 
Equity
 
Incentive
 
Plan,
 
the
 
change
 
of control
 
provisions
 
may
 
also
 
be
 
triggered
 
on
completion
 
of
 
the
 
SGI
 
Transaction,
 
however
 
the
 
Compensation
 
and
 
Nominating
 
Committee
 
of
 
the
 
Board
 
of
Directors, at its
 
sole discretion, will determine
 
how the outstanding awards
 
under the plan
 
will be dealt
 
with, which
may include acceleration of the vesting conditions.
In
 
addition,
 
certain
 
contract
 
counterparties,
 
including
 
Stanwell,
 
customers,
 
suppliers
 
and
 
third-party
 
providers
may assert
 
contractual rights, such
 
as consent or
 
termination rights that
 
may be triggered
 
by the
 
change of control
resulting from the consummation of the SGI Transaction.
For a number of
 
customers and supplier agreements, including
 
contractor agreements, the completion of
 
the SGI
Transaction
 
may
 
trigger
 
a
 
financial
 
or
 
suitability
 
assessment
 
by
 
the
 
counterparty,
 
which
 
may
 
entitle
 
the
counterparty
 
to
 
terminate
 
the
 
agreement,
 
request
 
further
 
security
 
or
 
seek
 
amendments
 
to
 
the
 
terms
 
of
 
the
agreement.
Coronado Group LLC
Under
 
the
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC
 
agreement
 
(as
 
amended,
 
effective
 
October 23,
 
2018),
2,900
 
management
incentive units were designated and authorized for issuance
 
to certain members of management to motivate and
retain senior management.
 
The plan is designated
 
to allow key members
 
of management to share
 
in the profits
of the Company
 
after certain
 
returns are
 
achieved by
 
the equity
 
investors. The
 
incentive units
 
constitute “profit
interests” for the benefit of senior management in consideration
 
of services rendered and to be rendered.
 
Coronado Coal LLC and Coronado II
 
LLC merged to form Coronado Group
 
LLC in July 2015. Coronado IV
 
LLC
was
 
merged
 
into
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC,
 
the
 
Company’s
 
controlling
 
stockholder,
 
on
 
June 30,
 
2016.
 
Under
 
the
updated formation
 
agreement dated
 
June 30, 2016,
 
the
2,500
 
designated and authorized
 
units under the
 
initial
formation of
 
Coronado Group LLC
 
were replaced
 
by these
 
new units.
 
At December
 
31, 2023
 
and 2022,
2,900
management incentive units were outstanding.
The incentive units are comprised of three
 
tiers, which entitle the holders to receive
 
distributions from Coronado
Group LLC subordinate
 
to the
 
distributions to
 
be received
 
by Members.
 
As of
 
December 31, 2023
 
and 2022,
 
a
portion of the authorized
 
units have been allocated
 
to various members of the
 
Company’s management including
Mr. Garold Spindler,
 
our former CEO and current Executive Chair, who is also member of Coronado Group LLC.
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
151
Stockholder’s Agreement and Registration Rights
 
and Sell-Down Agreement
As
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC
 
has
 
beneficial
 
ownership
 
in
 
the
 
aggregate
 
of
50.4
%
 
of
 
the
Company’s
 
Shares.
 
On
 
September 24,
 
2018,
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC
 
and
 
the
 
Company
 
entered
 
into
 
a
Stockholder’s Agreement
 
and a
 
Registration Rights
 
and Sell-Down
 
Agreement
 
which governs
 
the relationship
between Coronado
 
Group LLC
 
and the
 
Company
 
while the
 
EMG Group
 
beneficially owns
 
in the
 
aggregate
 
at
least
50
%
 
of
 
our
 
outstanding
 
shares
 
of
 
common
 
stock
 
(including
 
shares
 
of
 
common
 
stock
 
underlying
 
CDIs),
including certain governance matters relating to the Company. Under this Agreement, Coronado Group LLC has
the ability to
 
require the Company
 
to register its
 
shares under the
 
U.S. Securities Exchange
 
Act of 1934
 
and to
provide assistance to Coronado Group LLC in selling
 
some or all of its shares (including in the form of CDIs).
The Stockholder’s Agreement provides for the following:
•
 
Consent rights: Coronado
 
Group LLC (or its
 
successors or permitted
 
assigns) will have
 
certain consent
rights, whereby pre-agreed actions
 
require approval by Coronado
 
Group LLC prior to these
 
actions being
undertaken;
•
 
Provision
 
of
 
information
 
to
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC:
 
There
 
will
 
be
 
ongoing
 
information
 
sharing
arrangements
 
relating
 
to
 
the
 
provision
 
of
 
financial
 
and
 
other
 
information
 
by
 
the
 
Company
 
and
 
its
subsidiaries to Coronado Group LLC group entities and cooperation and assistance between the parties
in connection with any financing (or refinancing) undertaken
 
by the Company;
•
 
Pro rata issuances: While Coronado Group LLC Group entities beneficially own in the
 
aggregate at least
10
% of
 
the outstanding
 
Shares, unless
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC
 
(or
 
its successors
 
or permitted
 
assigns)
agrees
 
otherwise,
 
issuances
 
of
 
equity
 
securities
 
must
 
have
 
been
 
offered
 
to
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC
 
in
respect of
 
its pro
 
rata shares
 
and any
 
equity securities
 
to be
 
allocated by
 
the Company
 
under a
 
share
incentive plan will be sourced by purchasing them in the market
 
rather than by issuing them; and
•
 
Board rights:
 
Certain rights
 
regarding the
 
board including
 
the right,
 
but not
 
the obligation,
 
to designate
the Directors
 
to be
 
included in the
 
membership of
 
any board committee,
 
except to the
 
extent that
 
such
membership would violate applicable securities
 
laws or stock exchange or stock market rules.
Relationship Deed
On September 24, 2018, the Company and Coronado Group LLC entered into a Relationship Deed under which
the Company provides
 
a number of indemnities
 
in favor of Coronado
 
Group LLC, including in
 
relation to certain
ASX initial public
 
offering, or
 
Australian IPO, -related
 
matters and also
 
certain guarantees
 
that have in
 
the past
been provided or
 
arranged by Coronado
 
Group LLC and
 
its affiliates
 
in support of
 
Company obligations.
 
Under
the
 
Relationship
 
Deed,
 
Coronado
 
Group LLC
 
also
 
agrees
 
to
 
indemnify
 
the
 
Company
 
in
 
relation
 
to
 
certain
Australian IPO-related matters and reimburse certain costs.
28. Material Transactions
Curragh Housing Transaction
On May 8, 2023, the Company entered into an
 
agreement, the Curragh Housing Agreement, for accommodation
services
 
and
 
to
 
sell
 
and
 
leaseback
 
housing
 
and
 
accommodation
 
assets
 
included
 
in
 
property,
 
plant
 
and
equipment.
 
The
 
transaction
 
did
 
not
 
satisfy
 
the
 
sale
 
criteria
 
under
 
ASC
 
606
 
–
Revenues
 
from
 
Contracts
 
with
Customers
 
and
 
was
 
deemed
 
a
 
financing
 
arrangement.
 
As
 
a
 
result,
 
the
 
Company
 
continues
 
to
 
recognize
 
the
underlying property,
 
plant and equipment on its Consolidated
 
Balance Sheet. Upon completion, the proceeds
 
of
$
23.7
 
million (A$
34.6
 
million) received from the transaction will
 
be recorded as “Other Financial Liabilities”
 
on the
Company’s Consolidated
 
Balance Sheet.
 
The term
 
of the
 
financing arrangement
 
is
ten years
 
with an
 
effective
interest rate of
12.8
%.
 
In connection
 
with this
 
transaction, the Company
 
will borrow an
 
additional amount of
 
$
27.6
 
million (A$
40.4
 
million)
which will
 
be recorded
 
in “Interest
 
Bearing Liabilities”
 
on completion
 
date. The
 
term of
 
the arrangement
 
is
ten
years
 
with an effective interest rate of
12.8
%.
The Curragh Housing Agreement is subject to conditions
 
precedent not satisfied as at December 31, 2023.
 
In line
 
with the
 
Company’s
 
capital management
 
strategy,
 
the above
 
transactions provide
 
additional liquidity.
 
In
addition, the accommodation
 
services component of the
 
Curragh Housing Agreement
 
is anticipated to enhance
the level of service for our employees at our Curragh
 
mine.
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED
 
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
(Continued)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
152
29.
 
Subsequent Events
Ordinary dividends
On
 
February
 
19,
 
2024,
 
the
 
Company’s
 
Board
 
of
 
Directors
 
declared
 
a
 
bi-annual
 
fully
 
franked
 
fixed
 
ordinary
dividend of $
8.4
 
million, or
0.5
 
cents per CDI. The
 
Company is not required
 
to make an offer
 
to purchase Notes
for this dividend due to the available and unaccepted portion of the offer
 
to purchase the Notes previously made
in connection with special dividends declared on October
 
30, 2022.
The dividend will have
 
a record date of
March 12, 2024
, Australia time, and
 
be payable on
April 4, 2024
, Australia
time. CDIs
 
will be
 
quoted
 
“ex”
 
dividend on
 
March
 
11,
 
2024, Australia
 
time. The
 
total ordinary
 
dividend will
 
be
funded from available cash.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
153
REPORT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC
 
ACCOUNTING FIRM
To
the Shareholders and the Board of Directors of Coronado
 
Global Resources Inc.
Opinion on the Financial Statements
We
 
have
 
audited
 
the
 
accompanying
 
consolidated
 
balance
 
sheets
 
of
 
Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
(the
Company)
 
as
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023
 
and
 
2022,
 
the
 
related
 
consolidated
 
statements
 
of
 
operations
 
and
comprehensive
 
income,
 
stockholders’
 
equity
 
and
 
cash
 
flows
 
for
 
each
 
of
 
the
 
three
 
years
 
in
 
the
 
period
 
ended
December 31, 2023, and the related notes (collectively referred to as the “consolidated financial statements”). In
our opinion, the consolidated financial
 
statements present fairly,
 
in all material respects, the
 
financial position of
the Company at December 31, 2023 and
 
2022, and the results of its
 
operations and its cash flows for
 
each of the
three
 
years
 
in
 
the
 
period
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
in
 
conformity
 
with
 
U.S.
 
generally
 
accepted
 
accounting
principles.
We
 
also
 
have
 
audited,
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
the
 
standards
 
of the
 
Public
 
Company
 
Accounting
 
Oversight
 
Board
(United States)
 
(PCAOB), the
 
Company's internal control
 
over financial
 
reporting as
 
of December
 
31, 2023,
 
based
on
 
criteria
 
established
 
in
 
Internal
 
Control-Integrated
 
Framework
 
issued
 
by
 
the
 
Committee
 
of
 
Sponsoring
Organizations of the
 
Treadway Commission (2013 framework)
 
and our
 
report dated
 
February 20,
 
2024 expressed
an unqualified opinion thereon.
Basis for Opinion
These financial statements are the responsibility of the Company's
 
management. Our responsibility is to express
an opinion
 
on the
 
Company’s financial statements
 
based on
 
our audits.
 
We are a
 
public accounting firm
 
registered
with the PCAOB
 
and are
 
required to
 
be independent
 
with respect to
 
the Company
 
in accordance
 
with the
 
U.S.
federal securities laws and the applicable rules and regulations of the
 
Securities and Exchange Commission and
the PCAOB.
We conducted our audits in accordance with the standards of the PCAOB. Those standards require that we plan
and perform the audit to
 
obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial
 
statements are free of material
misstatement, whether
 
due to
 
error or
 
fraud. Our
 
audits included
 
performing procedures
 
to assess
 
the risks
 
of
material misstatement of the financial statements, whether due to error or fraud, and performing procedures that
respond to
 
those risks.
 
Such procedures
 
included examining,
 
on a
 
test basis,
 
evidence regarding
 
the amounts
and disclosures
 
in the
 
financial statements.
 
Our audits
 
also included
 
evaluating the
 
accounting principles
 
used
and significant
 
estimates made
 
by management,
 
as well
 
as evaluating
 
the overall
 
presentation
 
of the
 
financial
statements. We believe that our audits provide a reasonable
 
basis for our opinion.
Critical Audit Matter
The critical
 
audit
 
matter communicated
 
below is
 
a matter
 
arising
 
from
 
the current
 
period
 
audit
 
of the
 
financial
statements that was communicated
 
or required to be communicated
 
to the audit committee and that:
 
(1) relates
to accounts
 
or disclosures that
 
are material
 
to the
 
financial statements and
 
(2) involved our
 
especially challenging,
subjective, or
 
complex judgments.
 
The communication
 
of the critical
 
audit matter
 
does not alter
 
in any way
 
our
opinion on the consolidated financial
 
statements, taken as a whole,
 
and we are not, by
 
communicating the critical
audit matter below,
 
providing a separate opinion
 
on the critical audit matter
 
or on the accounts or
 
disclosures to
which it relates.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
154
Stamp Duty assessment on the acquisition of the
 
Curragh mine
Description
 
of
 
the
matter
As
 
described
 
in
 
Note
 
26
Contingencies
 
to
 
the
 
consolidated
 
financial
 
statements,
 
on
September 27, 2022, the Company received
 
an assessment from the Queensland Revenue
Office (“QRO”) for
 
the stamp
 
duty payable on
 
the Company’s acquisition
 
of the
 
Curragh mine
in March 2018. The
 
QRO assessed the stamp duty
 
on this acquisition at
 
an amount of $56.2
million plus unpaid tax interest, which the Company disputes.
On November 23, 2022, the Company filed
 
an objection to the stamp duty assessment.
 
On
January
 
9,
 
2024,
 
the
 
QRO
 
disallowed
 
the
 
Company’s
 
objection.
 
The
 
Company
 
is
considering its options to either appeal the decision to the Supreme Court of
 
Queensland or
apply
 
for
 
a
 
review
 
of
 
the
 
QRO’s
 
decision
 
by
 
the
 
Queensland
 
Civil
 
and
 
Administrative
Tribunal.
Under the
 
relevant
 
legislation,
 
the
 
Company
 
can only
 
appeal or
 
apply
 
for a
 
review
 
of the
QRO’s decision, if the full amount of the assessed stamp duty
 
(including interest) is paid by
March 11, 2024.
While the Company disputes the amount
 
of assessed stamp duty and interest
 
assessed by
the QRO,
 
it has
 
recorded an
 
additional accrual
 
and expense
 
of $41.3
 
million reflecting
 
the
additional payment the Company is required
 
to make, which may not be recovered
 
through
litigation.
Auditing the
 
accrual for
 
the stamp
 
duty payable
 
involved complex
 
auditor judgment,
 
given
the
 
materiality
 
of
 
the
 
assessment
 
made
 
by
 
the
 
QRO,
 
the
 
unique
 
nature
 
of
 
the
 
property
acquired
 
and
 
the
 
resulting
 
difficulty
 
in
 
assessing
 
the
 
Company’s
 
judgments
 
around
 
the
interpretation
 
and
 
application
 
of
 
the
 
law
 
to
 
this
 
matter,
 
including
 
the
 
QRO’s
 
decision
 
to
disallow the Company’s objection.
How
 
we
addressed
 
the
matter in our audit
We
 
obtained
 
an
 
understanding,
 
evaluated
 
the
 
design
 
and
 
tested
 
the
 
operation
 
of
management’s controls related to the Company’s process for the recognition, measurement
and disclosure of the stamp duty payable,
 
including the Company’s interpretation of tax law.
 
Our
 
audit
 
procedures
 
included,
 
among
 
others,
 
understanding
 
external
 
legal
 
counsel
opinions obtained by
 
management to support
 
their interpretation and
 
application of the
 
law
in this matter. We also
 
discussed external legal counsel’s opinion
 
with external legal counsel
directly.
We involved our tax professionals to help us evaluate management’s judgments around the
interpretation and application of the law to this matter.
 
We also evaluated the disclosures made in the consolidated financial statements in relation
to this matter.
/s/
Ernst & Young
We have served as the Company’s auditor
 
since 2020.
Brisbane, Australia
 
February 20, 2024
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
155
ITEM 9.
 
CHANGES IN AND DISAGREEMENTS WITH ACCOUNTANTS ON ACCOUNTING AND FINANCIAL
DISCLOSURE.
None.
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
156
ITEM 9A.
 
CONTROLS AND PROCEDURES
Disclosure Controls and Procedures
We are
 
subject to
 
the periodic
 
reporting requirements
 
of the
 
Exchange Act.
 
We have
 
designed our
 
disclosure
controls and procedures
 
to provide reasonable
 
assurance that information we
 
disclose in reports
 
we file or
 
submit
under the Exchange
 
Act is recorded,
 
processed, summarized,
 
and reported within
 
the time periods
 
specified in
the
 
rules
 
and
 
forms
 
of
 
the
 
SEC.
 
Disclosure
 
controls
 
and
 
procedures
 
are
 
controls
 
and
 
procedures
 
that
 
are
designed
 
to
 
ensure
 
that
 
information
 
required
 
to
 
be
 
disclosed
 
in
 
our
 
reports
 
filed
 
under
 
the
 
Exchange
 
Act
 
is
recorded, processed, summarized
 
and reported, within the
 
time periods specified
 
in the SEC’s rules
 
and forms.
Disclosure controls and procedures
 
include, without limitation,
 
controls and procedures
 
designed to ensure that
information required
 
to be
 
disclosed by
 
our company
 
in the
 
reports that
 
it files
 
or submits
 
under the
 
Exchange
Act is
 
accumulated and communicated
 
to our
 
management, including its
 
principal executive
 
and principal
 
financial
officers,
 
or
 
persons
 
performing
 
similar
 
functions,
 
as
 
appropriate
 
to
 
allow
 
timely
 
decisions
 
regarding
 
required
disclosure.
 
The Company, under the supervision and with the participation of its management, including the Chief Executive
Officer
 
and
 
the
 
Group
 
Chief
 
Financial
 
Officer,
 
evaluated
 
the
 
effectiveness
 
of
 
the
 
design
 
and
 
operation
 
of
 
the
Company’s
 
disclosure controls
 
and procedures
 
(as defined
 
in Rules
 
13a-15(e) under
 
the Exchange
 
Act) as
 
of
the end of
 
the period covered
 
by this report,
 
and concluded
 
that such disclosure
 
controls and
 
procedures were
effective to provide reasonable assurance that the
 
desired control objectives were achieved.
 
Changes to Internal Control over Financial Reporting
There have been
 
no changes in
 
our internal control
 
over financial reporting
 
or in
 
other factors that
 
occurred during
our
 
last
 
fiscal
 
quarter
 
that
 
have
 
materially
 
affected,
 
or
 
are
 
reasonably
 
likely
 
to
 
materially
 
affect,
 
our
 
internal
controls over financial reporting.
 
Management’s Report on Internal Control
 
Over Financial Reporting
Our management
 
is responsible
 
for establishing and
 
maintaining adequate internal
 
control over
 
financial reporting
as
 
defined
 
in
 
Rules
 
13a-15(f)
 
under
 
the
 
Exchange
 
Act.
 
Internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
 
reporting
 
is
 
a
 
process
designed to
 
provide reasonable
 
assurance regarding
 
the reliability
 
of financial
 
reporting and
 
the preparation
 
of
the Company’s
 
consolidated financial
 
statements for
 
external purposes
 
in accordance
 
with generally
 
accepted
accounting principles.
 
Internal control over financial reporting includes those
 
policies and procedures that (i) pertain
 
to the maintenance
of records that,
 
in reasonable detail,
 
accurately and fairly
 
reflect the transactions
 
and dispositions of
 
the assets
of the
 
Company;
 
(ii) provide
 
reasonable
 
assurance
 
that
 
transactions
 
are recorded
 
as
 
necessary
 
to permit
 
the
preparation of the
 
consolidated financial statements in
 
accordance with generally
 
accepted accounting principles,
and
 
that
 
receipts
 
and
 
expenditures
 
of
 
the
 
Company
 
are
 
being
 
made
 
only
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
appropriate
authorizations of management
 
and directors of
 
the Company;
 
and (iii) provide
 
reasonable assurance
 
regarding
prevention or timely detection of unauthorized acquisition, use or disposition of the Company’s
 
assets that could
have a material effect on the consolidated financial
 
statements.
 
Because
 
of
 
its
 
inherent
 
limitations,
 
internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
 
reporting
 
may
 
not
 
prevent
 
or
 
detect
misstatements. Also,
 
projections of
 
any evaluation
 
of effectiveness
 
to future
 
periods are
 
subject to
 
the risk
 
that
controls may
 
become inadequate
 
because of
 
changes in
 
conditions, or
 
that the
 
degree of
 
compliance with
 
the
policies or procedures may deteriorate.
 
Management
 
conducted
 
an
 
assessment
 
of
 
the
 
Company’s
 
internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
 
reporting
 
as
 
of
December 31, 2023, using the framework specified in
Internal Control – Integrated Framework (2013)
, published
by
 
the
 
Committee
 
of
 
Sponsoring
 
Organizations
 
of
 
the
 
Treadway
 
Commission
 
(COSO).
 
Based
 
on
 
this
assessment, management
 
concluded that
 
the Company’s
 
internal control
 
over financial
 
reporting was
 
effective
as of December 31, 2023.
 
Our
 
Independent
 
Registered
 
Public
 
Accounting
 
Firm,
 
Ernst
 
&
 
Young,
 
has
 
audited
 
our
 
internal
 
control
 
over
financial reporting, as stated in their unqualified opinion
 
report included herein.
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
157
REPORT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC
 
ACCOUNTING FIRM
To
 
the Shareholders and the Board of Directors of Coronado
 
Global Resources Inc.
 
Opinion on Internal Control Over Financial Reporting
We have audited Coronado Global Resources
 
Inc.’s internal control over financial
 
reporting as of December 31,
2023,
 
based
 
on
 
criteria
 
established
 
in
 
Internal
 
Control—Integrated
 
Framework
 
issued
 
by
 
the
 
Committee
 
of
Sponsoring Organizations
 
of the
 
Treadway
 
Commission (2013
 
framework) (the
 
COSO criteria).
 
In our
 
opinion,
Coronado Global
 
Resources
 
Inc. (the
 
Company)
 
maintained,
 
in
 
all material
 
respects,
 
effective
 
internal control
over financial reporting as of December 31, 2023, based on the
 
COSO criteria.
We
 
also
 
have
 
audited,
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
the
 
standards
 
of the
 
Public
 
Company
 
Accounting
 
Oversight
 
Board
(United States) (PCAOB), the consolidated balance sheets of the Company as of December 31, 2023 and 2022,
the
 
related
 
consolidated
 
statements
 
of
 
operations
 
and
 
comprehensive
 
income,
 
stockholders’
 
equity
 
and
 
cash
flows for each
 
of the three
 
years in the
 
period ended
 
December 31, 2023,
 
and the related
 
notes and our
 
report
dated February 20, 2024 expressed an unqualified opinion
 
thereon.
Basis for Opinion
The Company’s management is responsible for maintaining effective internal control over financial reporting and
for its assessment
 
of the effectiveness
 
of internal control
 
over financial reporting
 
included in the
 
accompanying
Management’s Report
 
on Internal
 
Control Over
 
Financial Reporting.
 
Our responsibility
 
is to express
 
an opinion
on the
 
Company’s internal
 
control over
 
financial reporting
 
based on
 
our audit.
 
We are
 
a public
 
accounting firm
registered with the PCAOB and are required to be independent with respect
 
to the Company in accordance with
the
 
U.S.
 
federal
 
securities
 
laws
 
and
 
the
 
applicable
 
rules
 
and
 
regulations
 
of
 
the
 
Securities
 
and
 
Exchange
Commission and the PCAOB.
We conducted our audit
 
in accordance with the standards
 
of the PCAOB. Those standards
 
require that we plan
and
 
perform
 
the
 
audit
 
to
 
obtain
 
reasonable
 
assurance
 
about
 
whether
 
effective
 
internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
reporting was maintained in all material respects.
Our audit included obtaining an understanding
 
of internal control over financial reporting,
 
assessing the risk that
a
 
material
 
weakness
 
exists,
 
testing
 
and
 
evaluating
 
the
 
design
 
and
 
operating
 
effectiveness
 
of
 
internal
 
control
based
 
on
 
the
 
assessed
 
risk,
 
and
 
performing
 
such
 
other
 
procedures
 
as
 
we
 
considered
 
necessary
 
in
 
the
circumstances. We believe that our audit provides a reasonable
 
basis for our opinion.
Definition and Limitations of Internal Control Over
 
Financial Reporting
A
 
company’s
 
internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
 
reporting
 
is
 
a
 
process
 
designed
 
to
 
provide
 
reasonable
 
assurance
regarding the reliability of financial reporting
 
and the preparation of financial statements
 
for external purposes in
accordance with generally
 
accepted accounting principles.
 
A company’s internal
 
control over financial
 
reporting
includes those policies
 
and procedures that (1)
 
pertain to the maintenance
 
of records that, in
 
reasonable detail,
accurately and
 
fairly reflect
 
the transactions and
 
dispositions of the
 
assets of
 
the company;
 
(2) provide reasonable
assurance
 
that
 
transactions
 
are
 
recorded
 
as
 
necessary
 
to
 
permit
 
preparation
 
of
 
financial
 
statements
 
in
accordance with
 
generally accepted
 
accounting principles,
 
and that
 
receipts and
 
expenditures of
 
the company
are being
 
made only
 
in accordance
 
with authorizations
 
of management
 
and directors
 
of the
 
company; and
 
(3)
provide
 
reasonable
 
assurance
 
regarding
 
prevention
 
or
 
timely
 
detection
 
of
 
unauthorized
 
acquisition,
 
use,
 
or
disposition of the company’s assets that could
 
have a material effect on the financial statements.
Because
 
of
 
its
 
inherent
 
limitations,
 
internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
 
reporting
 
may
 
not
 
prevent
 
or
 
detect
misstatements. Also,
 
projections of
 
any evaluation
 
of effectiveness
 
to future
 
periods are
 
subject to
 
the risk
 
that
controls may
 
become inadequate
 
because of
 
changes in
 
conditions, or
 
that the
 
degree of
 
compliance with
 
the
policies or procedures may deteriorate.
/s/ Ernst & Young
Brisbane, Australia
February 20, 2024
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
158
ITEM 9B.
 
OTHER INFORMATION
During
 
the quarter
 
ended
 
December
 
31, 2023,
 
no
 
director
 
or officer
 
(as
 
defined
 
in Rule
 
16a-1(f)
 
promulgated
under the Exchange
 
Act) of the
 
Company
adopted
 
or
terminated
 
a “Rule
 
10b5-1 trading arrangement”
 
or “
non
-
Rule
10b5-1
 
trading arrangement” (as each term is defined in Item
 
408 of Regulation S-K).
 
ITEM 9C.
 
DISCLOSURE REGARDING FOREIGN JURISDICTIONS
 
THAT PREVENT
 
INSPECTIONS
None.
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
159
PART III
ITEM 10.
 
DIRECTORS, EXECUTIVE OFFICERS AND
 
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE.
The information required to
 
be furnished by
 
this Item will be
 
set forth in
 
our definitive proxy statement
 
for the 2024
Annual General
 
Meeting of
 
Stockholders, or
 
the Proxy
 
Statement, under
 
the headings
 
“Executive Officers
 
and
Corporate
 
Governance”
 
and
 
“Delinquent
 
Section
 
16(a)
 
Reports”,
 
and
 
is
 
incorporated
 
herein by
 
reference
 
and
made a part hereof from the Proxy Statement.
 
ITEM 11.
 
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION.
The information required
 
to be furnished
 
by this Item
 
will be set forth
 
in the Proxy Statement
 
under the heading
“Executive
 
Compensation”
 
and
 
is
 
incorporated
 
herein
 
by
 
reference
 
and
 
made
 
a
 
part
 
hereof
 
from
 
the
 
Proxy
Statement.
 
ITEM
 
12.
 
SECURITY
 
OWNERSHIP
 
OF
 
CERTAIN
 
BENEFICIAL
 
OWNERS
 
AND
 
MANAGEMENT
 
AND
RELATED STOCKHOLDER
 
MATTERS.
The
 
information
 
required
 
to
 
be
 
furnished
 
by
 
this
 
Item
 
will
 
be
 
set
 
forth
 
in
 
the
 
Proxy
 
Statement
 
under
 
the
heading “Security
 
Ownership
 
of
 
Certain
 
Beneficial
 
Owners
 
and
 
Management”
 
and
 
is
 
incorporated
 
herein
 
by
reference and made a part hereof from the Proxy Statement.
 
ITEM 13.
 
CERTAIN RELATIONSHIPS AND RELATED
 
TRANSACTIONS, AND DIRECTOR INDEPENDENCE.
The information required to be furnished by this Item will be set forth in
 
the Proxy Statement under the headings
“Certain
 
Relationships
 
and
 
Related
 
Transactions”
 
and
 
“Executive
 
Officers
 
and
 
Corporate
 
Governance”
 
and
 
is
incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof from
 
the Proxy Statement.
 
ITEM 14. PRINCIPAL
 
ACCOUNTING FEES AND SERVICES.
The information required
 
to be furnished
 
by this Item
 
will be set forth
 
in the Proxy Statement
 
under the heading
“Ratification of Appointment of
 
Ernst & Young as the Company’s Independent Registered Public
 
Accounting Firm
for the Fiscal Year
 
Ending December 31, 2024” and is
 
incorporated herein by reference and made a
 
part hereof
from the Proxy Statement.
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
160
ITEM 15.
 
EXHIBITS, FINANCIAL STATEMENT
 
SCHEDULES
(a)
 
The following documents are filed as part of this
 
Annual Report:
1.
 
Financial Statements.
 
See index to
 
Financial Statements
 
and Supplementary
 
Data on page
 
114
 
of this
Annual Report on Form 10-K.
 
2.
 
Financial Statements Schedules. Schedules are omitted because
 
they are not required or applicable, or
the required information is included in the Financial Statements
 
or related notes thereto.
3.
 
Exhibits. The exhibits filed with or incorporated by reference as part of this Annual Report on Form
 
10-K
are set forth in the Exhibit Index.
 
(b)
 
The documents listed in
 
the Exhibit Index of
 
this Annual Report on
 
Form 10-K are incorporated
 
by reference
or are filed with this Annual Report on Form 10-K, in
 
each case as indicated therein.
 
The following documents are filed as exhibits hereto:
Exhibit No.
Description of Document
2.1*
3.1
3.2
4.1
 
(filed
 
as
 
Exhibit
 
4.1
 
to
 
the
 
Company’s
 
Registration
Statement
 
on
 
Form
 
10
 
(File
 
No.
 
000-56044)
 
filed
 
on
 
April
 
29,
 
2019
 
and
 
incorporated
herein by reference)
4.2
4.3
4.4
4.5
10.1
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
161
Exhibit No.
Description of Document
10.2†‡
10.3
10.4‡
10.5‡
10.6
10.7
10.8>‡
10.9>
10.10>‡
10.
11
>‡
10.12>
10.13>‡
10.14>‡
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
162
Exhibit No.
Description of Document
10.15>
10.16>
10.17>
10.18>
10.19>
10.20>
10.21>
10.22>
10.23‡
10.24‡
10.25‡
10.26
10.27
10.28
10.29†‡
21.1
23.1
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
163
Exhibit No.
Description of Document
23.2
23.3
23.4
23.5
31.1
31.2
32.1
95.1
96.1
96.2
96.3
96.4
101
The following materials from the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the period
ended December
 
31,
 
2023,
 
formatted
 
in
 
iXBRL
 
(Inline
 
Extensible
 
Business
 
Reporting
Language): (i) Consolidated Balance
 
Sheets, (ii) Consolidated
 
Statements of Operations
and Consolidated Statements of
 
Comprehensive Income, (iii)
 
Consolidated Statements
of Stockholders’ Equity/Members’ Capital, (iv) Consolidated
 
Statements of Cash Flows,
(v) related notes to these financial statements and (vi)
 
document and entity information
104
Cover Page
 
Interactive Data
 
File (the cover
 
page XBRL
 
tags are embedded
 
within the
Inline XBRL document)
 
____________________
*
 
Portions of this
 
exhibit have been omitted
 
pursuant to Item 601(b)(2)(ii)
 
of Regulation S-K,
 
which portions
will be furnished to the Securities and Exchange Commission
 
upon request.
†
 
Certain schedules and exhibits to this
 
agreement have been omitted pursuant to Item
 
601(a)(5) and Item
601(a)(6)
 
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K.
 
A
 
copy
 
of
 
any
 
omitted
 
schedule
 
and/or
 
exhibit
 
will
 
be
 
furnished
 
to
 
the
Securities and Exchange Commission upon request.
 
‡
 
Portions
 
of
 
this
 
exhibit
 
have
 
been
 
omitted
 
pursuant
 
to
 
Item
 
601(b)(10)(iv)
 
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K,
 
which
portions will be furnished to the Securities and Exchange Commission
 
upon request.
 
>
 
Management contract, compensatory plan or arrangement
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
164
ITEM 16.
 
FORM 10-K SUMMARY
None.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. Form 10-K December 31,
 
2023
 
165
SIGNATURES
Pursuant to the
 
requirements of
 
Section 13
 
or 15(d) of
 
the Securities
 
Exchange Act
 
of 1934, the
 
registrant has
duly caused this report to be signed on its behalf by the undersigned,
 
thereunto duly authorized.
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
(Registrant)
By:
/s/ Douglas Thompson
Douglas Thompson
Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer (as
 
duly
authorized officer and as principal executive officer
 
of
the registrant)
Date: February 20,
 
2024
Pursuant to the requirements
 
of the Securities Exchange
 
Act of 1934, this
 
report has been
 
signed below by
 
the
following persons, on behalf of the registrant and in the
 
capacities and on the dates indicated.
Name
Title
Date
/s/ Douglas Thompson
Managing
 
Director
 
and
 
Chief
 
Executive
Officer (Principal Executive Officer)
February 20, 2024
Douglas Thompson
/s/ Gerhard Ziems
Group
 
Chief
 
Financial
 
Officer
 
(Principal
Financial Officer and Principal Accounting
Officer)
February 20, 2024
Gerhard Ziems
/s/ Garold Spindler
Director
February 20, 2024
Garold Spindler
/s/ William Koeck
Director
February 20, 2024
William Koeck
/s/ Philip Christensen
Director
February 20, 2024
Philip Christensen
/s/ Greg Pritchard
Director
February 20, 2024
Greg Pritchard
/s/ Laura Tyson
Director
February 20, 2024
Laura Tyson
/s/ Aimee R. Allen
Director
February 20, 2024
Aimee R. Allen
/s/ Jan C. Wilson
Director
February 20, 2024
Jan C. Wilson
 
 
 
EXHIBIT 21.1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
subsidiaries
 
as of December 31, 2023
Name
Coronado’s Effective Ownership
Place of Incorporation
Buchanan Minerals, LLC
 
100%
Delaware
Buchanan Mining Company LLC
 
100%
Delaware
Coronado Australia Holdings Pty Ltd
100%
Australia
Coronado Coal Corporation
100%
Delaware
Coronado Coal II LLC
100%
Delaware
Coronado Coal LLC
100%
Delaware
Coronado Curragh LLC
 
100%
Delaware
Coronado Curragh Pty Ltd
 
100%
Australia
Coronado Finance Pty Ltd
100%
Australia
Coronado II LLC
100%
Delaware
Coronado IV LLC
 
100%
Delaware
Coronado VA, LLC
100%
Delaware
Curragh Coal Sales Co Pty Ltd
100%
Australia
Curragh Queensland Mining Pty Ltd
100%
Australia
Metallurgical Mineral Holdings Pty Ltd
100%
Australia
Greenbrier Minerals, LLC
 
100%
Delaware
Greenbrier Smokeless Coal Mining, LLC
100%
Delaware
JEP Mining LLC
 
100%
Delaware
Matoaka Land Company,
 
LLC
 
100%
Delaware
Midland Trail Resources, LLC
 
100%
West Virginia
Powhatan Mid-Vol Coal
 
Sales, LLC
 
100%
Delaware
Mon Valley Minerals
 
LLC
100%
Delaware
Company B Virginia LLC
100%
Virginia
 
 
EXHIBIT 23.1
CONSENT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC
 
ACCOUNTING FIRM
We consent to the incorporation by reference in
 
the following Registration Statements (including all amendments
thereto):
1.
 
Registration Statement (Form S-3 No. 333-239730) of
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.;
 
2.
 
Registration Statement
 
(Form S-8
 
No. 333-236597)
 
pertaining to
 
the Coronado
 
Global Resources
 
Inc.
2018 Equity Incentive Plan and the Coronado Global Resources Inc. 2018 Non-Executive Director Plan;
3.
 
Registration Statement
 
(Form S-8
 
No. 333-249566)
 
pertaining to
 
the Coronado
 
Global Resources
 
Inc.
2018 Equity Incentive Plan; and
4.
 
Registration Statement
 
(Form S-8
 
No. 333-275748)
 
pertaining to
 
the Coronado
 
Global Resources
 
Inc.
Employee Stock Purchase Plan.
 
of our reports dated February 20, 2024 with respect to the consolidated financial statements of Coronado Global
Resources, Inc. and the effectiveness of internal control
 
over financial reporting of Coronado Global Resources,
Inc. included
 
in this
 
Annual Report
 
(Form 10-K) of
 
Coronado Global Resources,
 
Inc. for
 
the year
 
ended December
31, 2023.
 
 
/s/ Ernst & Young
Brisbane, Australia
February 20, 2024
ex232p1i0
 
 
Resology Pty Ltd
 
5 Tristania Court,
Ormiston 4160
ACN # 622 794 834
ABN # 41622794834
 
CONSENT OF BARRY LAY
I, Barry
 
Lay, BSc Geology (Hons);
 
MAusIMM, Managing Director
 
of Resology Pty
 
Ltd prepared Sections
1.3, 1.4, 1.6, 5.2, 6, 7,
 
8, 9, 10, 11,
 
21, 22, 23, 24, 25
 
and 26 of the Technical
 
Report Summary titled “
Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
(“Coronado”)
 
Statement
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
and
 
Reserves
 
for
 
the
Curragh Mine
 
Complex
 
in
 
Accordance
 
with
 
the
 
JORC
 
Code and
 
United
 
States
 
SEC Regulation
 
S-K
1300 as
 
of December
 
31,
 
2023
 
Bowen
 
Basin Queensland,
 
Australia
”, dated
 
February
 
15,
 
2024 (the
“Technical
 
Report Summary”).
With respect to the portions
 
of the Technical
 
Report Summary that I
 
prepared, I hereby consent
 
to the
filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission
 
of the Technical
 
Report Summary as an exhibit to
the
 
Annual
 
Report
 
on
 
Form
 
10-K
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023
 
(the
 
“Annual
 
Report”)
 
of
Coronado Global
 
Resources Inc. (the
 
“Company”) and
 
to the
 
incorporation by reference
 
of the
 
Technical
Report Summary in the Company’s
 
Registration Statements on Form S-3 (No.
 
333-239730) and Form
S-8 (Nos. 333- 236597,
 
333-249566 and 333-275748) (the “Registration Statements”).
I hereby
 
further
 
consent
 
to
 
the
 
inclusion
 
or
 
incorporation
 
by reference
 
in
 
the
 
Annual
 
Report
 
and
 
the
Registration Statements
 
of references
 
to my
 
name (including
 
status as
 
an expert
 
or qualified
 
person
(as
 
defined
 
in
 
Item
 
1300
 
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K))
 
and
 
the
 
information
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
portions
 
of
 
the
Technical Report Summary that I
 
prepared, including any
 
quotation therefrom or
 
summarization thereof.
Date: February 15, 2024
/s/ Barry Lay
 
Name: Barry Lay
Managing Director
ex233p1i0
 
 
Coronado Curragh Pty Ltd
ABN 90 009 362 565
Level 33, Central Plaza One, 345 Queen Street
GPO Box 51, Brisbane QLD 4000
T:
 
+61 7 3031 7777 |
F:
 
+61 7 3229 7402
 
Private Mail Bag, Blackwater QLD 4717
T:
 
+61 7 4986 9211 |
F:
 
+61 7 4986 9361
www.coronadoglobal.com
 
CONSENT OF DANIEL MILLERS
I, Daniel
 
Millers, B.
 
Eng.; MAusIMM(CP),
 
Superintendent Long
 
Term
 
Planning of
 
Coronado Curragh
 
Pty Ltd,
 
a
wholly owned subsidiary
 
of Coronado
 
Global Resources
 
Inc. (the “Company”),
 
prepared Sections
 
1.1, 1.2, 1.5,
1.7 through
 
to 1.10,
 
2 through
 
to 5,
 
12.1, 13.1 and
 
14 through
 
to 26 and
 
reviewed all other
 
sections of the
 
technical
report
 
summary
 
titled
 
“Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
(
 
“Coronado”)
 
Statement
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
and
Reserves for the Curragh Mine Complex in Accordance with the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation
S-K
 
1300
 
as
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023
 
Bowen
 
Basin
 
Queensland,
 
Australia
,”
 
dated
 
February
 
15,
 
2024
 
(the
“Technical
 
Report Summary”).
With respect to the portions of the Technical
 
Report Summary that I prepared, I hereby
 
consent to the filing with
the
 
Securities
 
and
 
Exchange
 
Commission
 
of
 
the
 
Technical
 
Report
 
Summary
 
as
 
an
 
exhibit
 
to
 
the
 
Company’s
Annual
 
Report
 
on
 
Form
 
10-K
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
 
December
 
31,
 
2023
 
(the
 
“Annual
 
Report”)
 
and
 
to
 
the
incorporation by reference of the Technical Report Summary in the Company’s Registration Statements on
 
Form
S-3
 
(No.
 
333-239730)
 
and
 
Form
 
S-8
 
(Nos.
 
333-
 
236597,
 
333-249566
 
and
 
333-275748)
 
(the
 
“Registration
Statements”).
I hereby further consent to the inclusion
 
or incorporation by reference in the
 
Annual Report and the Registration
Statements of references to my name (including status as an expert or qualified person (as defined in Item 1300
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K))
 
and
 
the
 
information
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
portions
 
of
 
the
 
Technical
 
Report
 
Summary
 
that
 
I
prepared, including any quotation therefrom or summarization thereof
 
.
February 15, 2024
/s/ Daniel Millers
 
Name: Daniel Millers
ex234p1i1 ex234p1i0
 
 
 
Talisman Technical
ABN 97 652 676 849
Suite 2, Level 8, 10 Eagle Street, Brisbane
 
4000
t. 07 3112 7230
e. jjoubert@talismantechnical.com.au
w. talismantechnical.com.au
CONSENT OF CHRIS WILKINSON
I, Chris Wilkinson, Bsc (Mining); MAusIMM(CP), Director of Mining Consultancy Services
 
(Australia) Pty Ltd, the
advisory entity
 
of Talisman
 
Technical
 
Pty Ltd,
 
prepared
 
Sections
 
12.2,
 
13.2,
 
21, 22,
 
23,
 
24, 25
 
and
 
26 of
 
the
Technical
 
Report Summary
 
titled “
Coronado Global Resources
 
Inc. (“Coronado”) Statement
 
of Coal Resources
and
 
Reserves
 
for
 
the
 
Curragh
 
Mine
 
Complex
 
in
 
Accordance
 
with
 
the
 
JORC
 
Code
 
and
 
United
 
States
 
SEC
Regulation S-K 1300
 
as of December
 
31, 2023 Bowen
 
Basin Queensland,
 
Australia
”, dated February
 
15, 2024
(the “Technical
 
Report Summary”).
With respect to the portions of the Technical
 
Report Summary that I prepared, I hereby
 
consent to the filing with
the Securities and Exchange
 
Commission of the Technical
 
Report Summary as
 
an exhibit to the Annual
 
Report
on Form 10-K for the year
 
ended December 31, 2023 (the
 
“Annual Report”) of Coronado
 
Global Resources Inc.
(the
 
“Company”)
 
and
 
to
 
the
 
incorporation
 
by
 
reference
 
of
 
the
 
Technical
 
Report
 
Summary
 
in
 
the
 
Company’s
Registration Statements on Form S-3 (No. 333-239730) and Form S-8 (Nos. 333-236597, 333-249566 and
 
333-
275748) (the “Registration Statements”).
I hereby further consent to the inclusion
 
or incorporation by reference in the
 
Annual Report and the Registration
Statements of references to my name (including status as an expert or qualified person (as defined in Item 1300
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K))
 
and
 
the
 
information
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
portions
 
of
 
the
 
Technical
 
Report
 
Summary
 
that
 
I
prepared, including any quotation therefrom or summarization
 
thereof.
Date: February 15, 2024
/s/ Chris Wilkinson
 
Name: Chris Wilkinson
Director
Mining Consultancy Services (Australia) Pty Ltd a subsidiary
 
of Talisman
 
Technical
 
Pty Ltd
ex235p1i0
 
582 Industrial Park Road, Bluefield, VA 24605-9364
 
■
Phone 276.322.5467
www.mma1.com
 
■
 
info@gmail.com
 
ENERGY & MINERAL RESOURCES
 
■
 
HYDROGEOLOGY & GEOLOGY
 
■
 
GEOPHYSICAL LOGGING SERVICES
CARBON MANAGEMENT
 
■
 
EXPERT WITNESS TESTIMONY
 
■
 
MINING ENGINEERING
 
■
 
PETROLEUM ENGINEERING
CONSENT OF MARSHALL MILLER & ASSOCIATES,
 
INC.
Marshall Miller
 
& Associates,
 
Inc. (
MM&A
), a third-party
 
firm comprising
 
mining experts,
 
prepared the
technical report summaries
 
identified below, each dated
 
February 16, 2024,
 
relating to estimates
 
of coal
resources and reserves of Coronado Global Resources Inc. (the “Company”) as of December 31,
 
2023
(the
 
“Technical
 
Report
 
Summaries”).
 
Specifically,
 
MM&A
 
prepared
 
the
 
following
 
Technical
 
Report
Summaries:
1.
 
Technical
 
Report
 
Summary
 
entitled
“Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
Statement
 
of
 
Coal
Resources and
 
Reserves for
 
the Buchanan
 
Mine Complex
 
in Accordance
 
with the JORC
 
Code
and United States SEC
 
Regulation S-K 1300 as
 
of December 31,
 
2023 Central Appalachian Coal
Basin Virginia, USA”
;
2.
 
Technical
 
Report
 
Summary
 
entitled
“Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
Statement
 
of
 
Coal
Resources
 
and
 
Reserves
 
for
 
the
 
Logan County
 
Complex
 
in
 
Accordance
 
with
 
the
 
JORC
 
Code
and United States SEC
 
Regulation S-K 1300 as
 
of December 31,
 
2023 Central Appalachian Coal
Basin West Virginia, USA”
; and
3.
 
Technical
 
Report
 
Summary
 
entitled
“Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
Statement
 
of
 
Coal
Resources and
 
Reserves for
 
the Mon
 
Valley
 
Complex Upper
 
Freeport Holdings
 
in Accordance
with
 
the
 
JORC
 
Code
 
and
 
United
 
States
 
SEC
 
Regulation
 
S-K
 
1300
 
as
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin Pennsylvania, USA.”
MM&A hereby
 
consents
 
to the
 
filing with
 
the
 
Securities
 
and Exchange
 
Commission
 
of the
 
Technical
Report
 
Summaries
 
as
 
exhibits
 
to
 
the
 
Company’s
 
Annual
 
Report
 
on
 
Form
 
10-K
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
ended
December 31, 2023 (the
 
“Annual Report”) and to
 
the incorporation by reference of
 
the Technical Report
Summaries in
 
the Company’s
 
Registration Statements
 
on Form
 
S-3 (No.
 
333-239730) and
 
Form S-8
(Nos. 333- 236597, 333-249566 and 333-275748)
 
(the “Registration Statements”).
MM&A hereby further consents to the inclusion or incorporation
 
by reference in the Annual Report and
the Registration Statements of
 
references to the MM&A
 
name (including status as
 
an expert or qualified
person (as
 
defined
 
in Item
 
1300 of
 
Regulation
 
S-K))
 
and the
 
information
 
derived
 
from the
 
Technical
Report Summaries, including any quotation therefrom or summarization
 
thereof.
Date:
 
February 16, 2024
 
/s/ Justin S. Douthat
Name:
 
Justin S. Douthat
Title:
 
Executive Vice President
 
(MM&A Representative)
 
 
 
EXHIBIT 31.1
CERTIFICATION
I, Douglas Thompson,
 
certify that:
1. I have reviewed this Annual Report on Form 10-K
 
of Coronado Global Resources Inc.;
2. Based on my
 
knowledge, this report
 
does not contain
 
any untrue statement
 
of a material fact
 
or omit to state
a
 
material
 
fact
 
necessary
 
to
 
make
 
the
 
statements
 
made,
 
in
 
light
 
of
 
the
 
circumstances
 
under
 
which
 
such
statements were made, not misleading with respect to the period
 
covered by this report;
3. Based on my knowledge, the financial statements, and other financial information included in this report, fairly
present in
 
all material
 
respects the
 
financial condition,
 
results of
 
operations and
 
cash flows
 
of the
 
registrant as
of, and for, the periods presented
 
in this report;
4. The
 
registrant’s other certifying
 
officer and I
 
are responsible
 
for establishing and
 
maintaining disclosure
 
controls
and procedures (as
 
defined in Exchange
 
Act Rules 13a-15(e) and
 
15d-15(e)) and internal
 
control over financial
reporting (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(f)
 
and 15d-15(f) for the registrant and have:
(a) Designed
 
such
 
disclosure
 
controls
 
and
 
procedures,
 
or
 
caused
 
such
 
disclosure
 
controls
 
and
procedures
 
to
 
be
 
designed
 
under
 
our
 
supervision,
 
to
 
ensure
 
that
 
material
 
information
 
relating
 
to
 
the
registrant, including
 
its consolidated
 
subsidiaries, is
 
made known
 
to us
 
by others
 
within those
 
entities,
particularly during the period in which this report is being prepared;
(b) Designed such internal control over financial reporting,
 
or caused such internal control over financial
reporting to be designed under our
 
supervision, to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability
of financial reporting
 
and the preparation
 
of financial statements
 
for external purposes in
 
accordance with
generally accepted accounting principles;
(c) Evaluated the
 
effectiveness of
 
the registrant’s
 
disclosure controls
 
and procedures
 
and presented
 
in
this report our
 
conclusions about
 
the effectiveness
 
of the disclosure
 
controls and
 
procedures, as of
 
the
end of the period covered by this report based on such
 
evaluation; and
(d) Disclosed
 
in
 
this
 
report
 
any
 
change
 
in
 
the
 
registrant’s
 
internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
 
reporting
 
that
occurred during the
 
registrant’s most recent fiscal
 
quarter (the registrant’s fourth
 
fiscal quarter in
 
the case
of an
 
Annual Report)
 
that has
 
materially affected or
 
is reasonably
 
likely to
 
materially affect, the
 
registrant’s
internal control over financial reporting; and
5. The registrant’s
 
other certifying
 
officer and I
 
have disclosed,
 
based on
 
our most
 
recent evaluation
 
of internal
control over
 
financial reporting,
 
to the
 
registrant’s
 
auditors and
 
the audit
 
committee of
 
the registrant’s
 
board of
directors (or persons performing the equivalent functions):
(a) All significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in
 
the design or operation of internal
 
control over
financial
 
reporting
 
which
 
are
 
reasonably
 
likely
 
to
 
adversely
 
affect
 
the
 
registrant’s
 
ability
 
to
 
record,
process, summarize and report financial information; and
(b) Any
 
fraud,
 
whether
 
or
 
not
 
material,
 
that
 
involves
 
management
 
or
 
other
 
employees
 
who
 
have
 
a
significant role in the registrant’s internal control over financial
 
reporting.
Date: February 20,
 
2024
/s/ Douglas Thompson
Douglas Thompson
Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer
 
 
 
EXHIBIT 31.2
CERTIFICATION
I, Gerhard Ziems, certify that:
1. I have reviewed this Annual Report on Form 10-K
 
of Coronado Global Resources Inc.;
2. Based on my
 
knowledge, this report
 
does not contain
 
any untrue statement
 
of a material fact
 
or omit to state
a
 
material
 
fact
 
necessary
 
to
 
make
 
the
 
statements
 
made,
 
in
 
light
 
of
 
the
 
circumstances
 
under
 
which
 
such
statements were made, not misleading with respect to the period
 
covered by this report;
3. Based on my knowledge, the financial statements, and other financial information included in this report, fairly
present in
 
all material
 
respects the
 
financial condition,
 
results of
 
operations and
 
cash flows
 
of the
 
registrant as
of, and for, the periods presented
 
in this report;
4. The
 
registrant’s other certifying
 
officer and I
 
are responsible
 
for establishing and
 
maintaining disclosure
 
controls
and procedures (as
 
defined in Exchange
 
Act Rules 13a-15(e) and
 
15d-15(e)) and internal
 
control over financial
reporting (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(f)
 
and 15d-15(f) for the registrant and have:
(a) designed
 
such
 
disclosure
 
controls
 
and
 
procedures,
 
or
 
caused
 
such
 
disclosure
 
controls
 
and
procedures
 
to
 
be
 
designed
 
under
 
our
 
supervision,
 
to
 
ensure
 
that
 
material
 
information
 
relating
 
to
 
the
registrant, including
 
its consolidated
 
subsidiaries, is
 
made known
 
to us
 
by others
 
within those
 
entities,
particularly during the period in which this report is being prepared;
(b) Designed such internal control over financial reporting,
 
or caused such internal control over financial
reporting to be designed under our
 
supervision, to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability
of financial reporting
 
and the preparation
 
of financial statements
 
for external purposes in
 
accordance with
generally accepted accounting principles;
(c) Evaluated the
 
effectiveness of
 
the registrant’s
 
disclosure controls
 
and procedures
 
and presented
 
in
this report our
 
conclusions about
 
the effectiveness
 
of the disclosure
 
controls and
 
procedures, as of
 
the
end of the period covered by this report based on such
 
evaluation; and
(d) Disclosed
 
in
 
this
 
report
 
any
 
change
 
in
 
the
 
registrant’s
 
internal
 
control
 
over
 
financial
 
reporting
 
that
occurred during the
 
registrant’s most recent fiscal
 
quarter (the registrant’s fourth
 
fiscal quarter in
 
the case
of an
 
Annual Report)
 
that has
 
materially affected or
 
is reasonably
 
likely to
 
materially affect, the
 
registrant’s
internal control over financial reporting; and
 
5. The registrant’s
 
other certifying
 
officer and I
 
have disclosed,
 
based on
 
our most
 
recent evaluation
 
of internal
control over
 
financial reporting,
 
to the
 
registrant’s
 
auditors and
 
the audit
 
committee of
 
the registrant’s
 
board of
directors (or persons performing the equivalent functions):
(a) All significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in
 
the design or operation of internal
 
control over
financial
 
reporting
 
which
 
are
 
reasonably
 
likely
 
to
 
adversely
 
affect
 
the
 
registrant’s
 
ability
 
to
 
record,
process, summarize and report financial information; and
(b) Any
 
fraud,
 
whether
 
or
 
not
 
material,
 
that
 
involves
 
management
 
or
 
other
 
employees
 
who
 
have
 
a
significant role in the registrant’s internal control over financial
 
reporting.
Date: February 20,
 
2024
/s/ Gerhard Ziems
Gerhard Ziems
Group Chief Financial Officer
 
 
 
 
EXHIBIT 32.1
CERTIFICATIONS
 
PURSUANT TO
18 U.S.C. SECTION 1350,
AS ADOPTED PURSUANT TO
SECTION 906 OF THE SARBANES-OXLEY ACT OF
 
2002
In connection with the Annual Report of Coronado Global
 
Resources Inc. (the “Company”) on Form 10-K
 
for the
year ended December 31,
 
2023, as filed with the
 
Securities and Exchange Commission
 
on the date hereof
 
(the
“Annual Report”), each of the undersigned officers of the company certifies, pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section 1350,
as adopted pursuant to Section 906 of the Sarbanes-Oxley
 
Act of 2002, that, to such officer’s knowledge:
1.
The
 
Annual
 
Report
 
fully
 
complies
 
with
 
the
 
requirements
 
of
 
Section 13(a) or
 
15(d) of
 
the
 
Securities
Exchange Act of 1934; and
2.
The information
 
contained
 
in the
 
Annual
 
Report fairly
 
presents,
 
in all
 
material respects,
 
the financial
condition and results of operations of
 
the Company as of the
 
dates and for the periods
 
expressed in the
Annual Report.
/s/ Douglas Thompson
Douglas Thompson
Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer
/s/ Gerhard Ziems
Gerhard Ziems
Group Chief Financial Officer
Date: February 20,
 
2024
The foregoing certification is being furnished
 
solely pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section
 
1350 and is not being filed as
part of the Annual Report or as a separate disclosure
 
document.
A signed
 
original of
 
this written
 
statement required
 
by Section 906
 
has been
 
provided to
 
the Company
 
and will
be retained by the Company and furnished to the Securities
 
and Exchange Commission or its staff on request.
 
 
EXHIBIT 95.1
Mine Safety Disclosures
Safety is the cornerstone of our Company’s values and is the number one priority for all employees at Coronado
Global
 
Resources.
 
Our
 
mining
 
operation
 
at
 
Curragh,
 
located
 
in
 
Australia,
 
is
 
subject
 
to
 
regulation
 
by
 
the
Queensland Department of Natural Resources, Mine and Energy,
 
or DNRME, under the Coal Mining Safety and
Health Act
 
1999 (Qld).
 
The operation
 
of our
 
mines located
 
in the
 
United States
 
is subject
 
to regulation
 
by the
Mine Safety and Health Administration,
 
or MSHA, under the Federal Mine
 
Safety and Health Act of 1977, or
 
the
Mine Act. MSHA
 
inspects these mines on
 
a regular basis
 
and issues various
 
citations and orders when
 
it believes
a violation has
 
occurred under the
 
Mine Act. We
 
present information below
 
regarding certain mining
 
safety and
health
 
citations
 
that
 
MSHA
 
has
 
issued
 
with
 
respect
 
to
 
our
 
mining
 
operations.
 
In
 
evaluating
 
this
 
information,
consideration should
 
be given
 
to factors
 
such as:
 
(i) the
 
number of
 
citations and
 
orders will
 
vary depending
 
on
the size of the
 
mine; (ii) the number of
 
citations issued will vary from inspector
 
to inspector and mine to
 
mine; and
(iii) citations and
 
orders can be
 
contested and
 
appealed and, in
 
that process, are
 
often reduced
 
in severity and
amount, and are sometimes dismissed. Since MSHA is a branch of the U.S. Department of Labor, its jurisdiction
only applies to our operations in
 
the United States.
 
As such, the mine safety disclosures
 
included herein do not
contain information related to our Australian mines.
Under the Dodd-Frank Act, each
 
operator of a coal
 
or other mine is
 
required to include certain mine
 
safety results
within its
 
periodic reports
 
filed with
 
the Securities
 
and Exchange
 
Commission, or
 
the SEC.
 
As required
 
by the
reporting
 
requirements
 
included
 
in
 
§1503(a)
 
of
 
the
 
Dodd-Frank
 
Act and
 
Item
 
104
 
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K
 
(17
 
CFR
229.104), we present the following
 
items regarding certain mining safety
 
and health matters, for the
 
year ended
December 31, 2023, for each
 
of our U.S. mine
 
locations that are covered
 
under the scope of the
 
Dodd-Frank Act.
The table that
 
follows reflects
 
citations and orders
 
issued to
 
us by MSHA
 
during the year
 
ended December
 
31,
2023.
 
The
 
table
 
only
 
includes
 
those
 
U.S.
 
mines
 
that
 
were
 
issued
 
orders
 
or
 
citations
 
during
 
this
 
period,
 
and
commensurate
 
with
 
SEC
 
regulations,
 
does
 
not
 
reflect
 
orders
 
or
 
citations
 
issued
 
to
 
independent
 
contractors
working at our mines.
 
The proposed assessments
 
for the year ended
 
December 31, 2023, were
 
retrieved from
the MSHA Data Retrieval System, or MSHA DRS, as
 
of January 2, 2024.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
(E)
(F)
(G)
MSHA Mine
ID No.
Mine Name (1)(2)(3)
Section
104
S&S
Citations
Section
104(b)
Orders
Section 104(d)
Citations and
Orders
Section 110(b)(2)
Violations
Section
107(a)
Orders
Total Dollar Value of
MSHA Assessments
Proposed
($ in thousands)
Total Number of
Mining Related
Fatalities
4404856
Buchanan Mine #1
(4) (5)
92
—
—
—
1
$ 224.0
—
4609125
Mountaineer Pocahontas No. 1 Prep Plant
—
—
—
—
—
0.1
—
4602140
Saunders Prep Plant
8
—
—
—
—
16.2
—
4609217
Powellton #1 Mine
3
—
—
—
—
11.1
—
4609319
Lower War Eagle
(6)
37
1
3
—
—
182.8
—
4609563
Eagle No. 1 Mine
(7)
29
—
—
—
—
56.1
—
4609583
North Fork Winifrede Deep Mine
(8)
15
—
—
—
—
26.2
—
4609101
Toney
 
Fork Surface Mine
2
—
—
—
—
1.3
—
4609514
Muddy Bridge
(9)
31
—
—
—
—
110.7
—
4604315
Elk Lick Tipple
1
—
—
—
—
1.5
—
4609560
North Fork Surface Mine
—
—
—
—
—
0.3
—
4609172
Mountaineer Pocahontas No.1
—
—
—
—
—
0.6
—
4609564
Elklick Surface Mine
(10)
13
1
1
—
—
24.3
—
Total:
231
2
4
—
—
$ 655.2
—
(1)
 
The definition of “mine” under Section
 
3 of the Mine Act
 
includes the mine, as well
 
as other items used in,
 
or to be used in,
 
or resulting from, the work
 
of extracting
coal, such as land, structures, facilities, equipment, machines, tools
 
and coal preparation facilities. Also, there are instances where
 
the mine name per the MSHA
system differs from the mine name utilized by us.
(2)
 
Idle facilities are
 
not included in
 
the table above
 
unless they received
 
a citation, order
 
or assessment by
 
MSHA during the
 
current quarterly reporting
 
period or
are subject to pending legal actions.
(3)
 
During the year
 
ended December 31,
 
2023, none of
 
the Company’s
 
mines have received
 
written notice from
 
MSHA of a pattern
 
of violations or
 
the potential to
have such a pattern of violations
 
of mandatory health or safety
 
standards that are of such
 
nature as could have significantly
 
and substantially contributed to
 
the
cause and effect of coal or other mine health or safety
 
standards under section 104(e) of the Mine Act.
(4)
 
The 107(a) order was vacated.
(5)
 
One of the S&S citations were modified to non S&S at a Part
 
100 conference, another was vacated.
(6)
 
Two of the S&S’s
 
are 104(d)(1) Citations, which are also listed in Column
 
C.
(7)
 
Four of the S&S citations were modified to non S&S as
 
part of a settlement in dockets, WEVA
 
2023-0247, WEVA
 
2023-0413, and WEVA
 
2023-0454.
(8)
 
One of the S&S citations issued at North Fork Winifrede Deep
 
Mine was vacated by the inspector the day after
 
it was issued, and one was modified to non S&S
as a result of a settlement in WEVA
 
2023-0455.
(9)
 
Three of the S&S citation were modified to non S&S as
 
part of the settlement in dockets, WEVA
 
2023-0246 and WEVA
 
2023-0301.
(10) One of the S&S’s is a 104(d)(1) Citation,
 
which is also listed in column C.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
References used in the table above are as follows:
A. The total number of violations
 
of mandatory health or safety standards that could
 
significantly and substantially contribute to the cause and
 
effect of a coal or other
mine safety or health hazard under section 104 of the
 
Mine Act (30 U.S.C. 814) for which the operator received
 
a citation from MSHA.
B. The total number of orders issued under section
 
104(b) of the Mine Act (30 U.S.C. 814(b)).
C. The total number of citations and orders
 
for unwarrantable failure of the mine operator
 
to comply with mandatory health or safety
 
standards under section 104(d)
of the Mine Act (30 U.S.C. 814(d)).
D. The total number of flagrant violations under section
 
110(b)(2) of the Mine
 
Act.
E. The total number of imminent danger orders issued
 
under section 107(a) of the Mine Act (30 U.S.C. 817(a)).
F.
The total dollar value of proposed assessments from
 
MSHA under the Mine Act (30 U.S.C. 801 et seq.).
G. The total number of mining-related fatalities.
The table below presents legal actions pending before the Federal Mine Safety
 
and Health Review Commission, or FMSHRC, for each of
 
the Company’s U.S. mines as
of December 31, 2023, together with the number of legal
 
actions initiated and the number of legal actions resolved
 
during the year ended December 31, 2023.
Legal Actions Pending as of Last Day
 
of the Year (December 31, 2023) (1)
MSHA
Mine ID
No.
Mine Name
Contests of
Citations
and Orders
(Subpart B)
Contests of
Proposed
Penalties
(Subpart C)
Complaints for
Compensation
(Subpart D)
Complaints of
Discharge,
Discrimination
or Interference
(Subpart E)
Applications of
Temporary Relief
(Subpart F)
Appeals of Judges’
Decisions or
Orders
(Subpart H)
Legal Actions
Initiated
During the Year
Legal Actions
Resolved
During the
Year
4404856
Buchanan Mine #1
—
4
—
—
—
—
12
9
4609563
Eagle No. 1 Mine
—
1
—
—
—
1
7
10
4609514
Muddy Bridge
—
3
—
—
—
1
9
10
4609319
Lower War Eagle
—
2
—
—
—
—
10
9
4609217
Powellton #1 Mine
—
1
—
—
—
—
2
3
4609583
North Fork Winifrede Mine
—
—
—
—
—
—
3
3
4609564
Elklick Surface Mine
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
1
2
4602140
Saunders Prep Plant
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
1
Total:
—
11
—
—
—
2
44
47
(1)
 
The legal
 
actions
 
pending
 
shown
 
in the
 
table
 
above
 
have been
 
categorized
 
by
 
type of
 
proceeding
 
with
 
reference
 
to
 
the
 
procedural
 
rules established
 
by the
FMSHRC under 29 CFR Part 2700. Reference to the
 
applicable Subparts under this Rule are listed in the columns
 
above.
(2)
 
Secretary of Labor’s appeals of Administrative Law Judge’s orders
 
denying motion for settlement approval in WEVA
 
2021-0294 and WEVA
 
2022-0403.
ex961p1i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc. (“Coronado”) Statement of Coal
Resources and Reserves for the Curragh Mine Complex in Accordance
with the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300
 
as of
December 31st 2023
Bowen Basin
Queensland, Australia
February 2024
 
ex961p1i0
 
SIGNATURE PAGE
Effective Date of Report:
December 31st, 2023
Qualified Person(s) Preparers:
 
/s/ Barry Lay______________________
Name: Barry Lay
Managing Director of Resology Pty Ltd (Prepared Sections: 1.3, 1.4, 1.6, 5.2,
 
6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11
 
,
 
21,
22, 23, 24, 25, 26)
_/s/ Daniel Millers___________________
Name: Daniel Millers
Superintendent Long Term Planning – Coronado Curragh Pty Ltd (Prepared Sections: 1.1, 1.2, 1.5,
1.7, 1.8, 1.9, 1.10, 2, 3, 4, 5, 12.1, 13.1, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20,
 
21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26)
_/s/ Chris Wilkinson __________________
Name: Chris Wilkinson
Director Mining Consultancy Services (Australia) Pty Ltd – Talisman Technical
 
Pty Ltd
 
(Prepared Sections: 12.2, 13.2,
 
21, 22, 23, 24, 25,
 
26)
 
Signature Date:
February 15th, 2024
 
Page 1 of 118
Table
 
Of Contents
 
Page 2 of 118
 
Page 4 of 118
LIST OF FIGURES
 
Page 5 of 118
 
 
Page 6 of 118
LIST OF TABLES
 
 
 
Page 7 of 118
1
 
Executive Summary
1.1
 
Property Description
This
 
report
 
provides
 
a
 
statement
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
and
 
Coal
 
Reserves
 
estimates
 
for
 
Curragh
 
mine
(sometimes referred to herein as Curragh or the Property) in Central Queensland, Australia, as defined under
Subpart
 
1300
 
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K
 
(Regulation
 
S-K
 
1300)
 
promulgated
 
by
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
Securities
 
and
Exchange
 
Commission
 
(SEC)
 
and
 
the
 
Australasian
 
Code
 
for
 
Reporting
 
of
 
Exploration
 
Results,
 
Mineral
Resources
 
and
 
Ore
 
Reserves
 
(JORC
 
Code
 
2012).
 
This
 
report
 
was
 
also
 
prepared
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
the
Australasian Code for Public Reporting of Technical
 
Assessments and Valuations of Mineral Assets (VALMIN
Code 2015).
Coal Resources
 
and Coal
 
Reserves estimates
 
are herein
 
reported and
 
rounded to
 
millions of
 
metric tonnes
(Mt).
 
Curragh is located
 
approximately 200 kilometres
 
by road west
 
of Rockhampton and
 
approximately 14 km north
of the
 
town
 
of
 
Blackwater
 
(refer
 
to
 
Figure
 
3-1)
 
within
 
the
 
Central
 
Highlands
 
Regional
 
Council,
 
Queensland
Australia. The coordinates of the mine are 688,561 East,
 
7,400,933 North in the AMG66 grid system.
The
 
Property
 
is
 
comprised
 
of
 
approximately
 
25,586
 
total
 
hectares
 
of
 
approved
 
Mining
 
Leases
 
and
 
Mineral
Development
 
Licences.
 
Underlying
 
these
 
Resource
 
Authorities
 
are
 
various
 
forms
 
of
 
cadastral
 
land
 
with
different ownership
 
arrangements as
 
detailed in section
 
3.2. Coronado is
 
able to access
 
all the land
 
through
either direct ownership or signed agreements.
1.2
 
Ownership
Curragh commenced
 
operations in
 
1983 and
 
was formerly
 
controlled by
 
a consortium
 
of companies.
 
These
companies were bought out by Arco Australia who later
 
sold the Property to Wesfarmers. Coronado acquired
the Property from Wesfarmers in 2018. Further details
 
on ownership are presented in Sections 3.2 to 3.4
1.3
 
Geology and Mineralization
The Curragh mine
 
extracts
 
seams in the
 
Rangal Coal
 
Measures including
 
the Cancer,
 
Aries, Castor,
 
Pollux,
Orion
 
and
 
Pisces
 
seams.
 
These
 
coals
 
are
 
suitable
 
for
 
beneficiation
 
to
 
metallurgical
 
and
 
thermal
 
products.
Some seams
 
are suitable
 
to bypass
 
direct to
 
product.
 
Further details
 
on the
 
geology of
 
the operations
 
are
provided in Section 6.
1.4
 
Exploration Status
The Property
 
has been
 
extensively explored, largely
 
by drilling
 
open chip holes
 
as well
 
as core
 
holes, downhole
geophysics is
 
used extensively.
 
The majority
 
of the
 
data was
 
acquired or
 
generated by
 
previous owners
 
of
the Property. These sources comprise the primary data used in the evaluation of the coal Resources and coal
Reserves on the Property.
 
Ongoing exploration
 
has been
 
carried out
 
by Coronado
 
since acquiring
 
the Curragh
 
mine.
 
The exploration
data acquired by Coronado has been consistent with past drilling activities. Recent exploration has included a
focus on underground exploration including the acquisition of 2D and 3D seismic data. Further details on past
exploration efforts are discussed in Section 7.
1.5
 
Operations and Development
Curragh operates the open cut using a conventional open cut strip
 
mining technique using draglines
 
and truck
and excavator
 
methods
 
typical
 
throughout
 
the
 
Bowen Basin.
 
Curragh
 
operates
 
4 large
 
electric draglines,
 
1
large
 
electric
 
rope
 
shovel
 
and
 
fleets
 
of
 
diesel
 
hydraulic
 
excavators
 
in
 
the
 
open
 
cut.
 
The
 
mine’s
 
annual
production capacity
 
of approximately
 
185 Mbcm
 
of total
 
movement means
 
it can
 
be ranked
 
as a
 
large open
cut coal operation when compared to producers in
 
Australia and internationally. The open cut operation mines
around 13.5Mt Run of Mine (ROM) coal per annum, producing
 
around 11Mtpa
 
of product coal.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 8 of 118
The
 
Curragh
 
mine
 
includes
 
a
 
development
 
underground
 
project
 
at
 
Curragh
 
North
 
currently
 
in
 
operational
readiness phase and planned to
 
commence production in 2025.
 
The selected underground mining
 
method is
Bord and Pillar Mining using
 
the Place Change operating
 
methodology.
 
The Life of Mine (LOM)
 
underground
plan utilises up to
 
four continuous miners
 
over two separate
 
mining levels, entering
 
the target seams
 
directly
from a final
 
open cut highwall.
 
The target seams
 
to be mined
 
using underground
 
methods are the
 
Mammoth
and Mackenzie seams at Curragh North. The Mammoth seam corresponds to the
 
coalesced Aries and Castor
seams in
 
the open
 
cut, and
 
the Mackenzie seam
 
corresponds to the
 
coalesced Pollux, Orion
 
and Pisces seams
in the open cut.
 
The underground
 
project will
 
add a
 
ROM production
 
profile on
 
top of
 
the existing
 
open cut
 
mine, at
 
around
3Mtpa ROM coal.
 
This takes
 
the total ROM
 
coal feed to
 
the Coal Handling
 
and Preparation Plant
 
(CHPP) to
nameplate
 
capacity
 
of
 
around
 
16.5Mtpa
 
for
 
the
 
total
 
Curragh
 
mining
 
complex,
 
maximising
 
the
 
production
potential with the existing installed
 
processing infrastructure on site. The
 
product coal profile is targeted to
 
be
around 13.5Mtpa from the
 
combined open cut and
 
underground operations, decreasing
 
over the LOM as
 
the
yield from the open cut coal reduces
 
over the LOM plan. The mine produces
 
coal that is suitable for the export
metallurgical and thermal coal markets, as well as a long term
 
domestic thermal coal supply contract.
 
There are two coal preparation plants at Curragh, CPP1 and CPP2. CPP1 has a nameplate capacity
 
of 1,100
raw tonnes
 
per hour
 
(tph).
 
CPP2 has
 
a nameplate
 
capacity
 
of 1,200
 
tph but
 
is capable
 
of 1,350
 
tph when
processing selected
 
feed types.
 
Processes are
 
typical of
 
those used
 
in the
 
coal industry
 
and are
 
in use
 
at
adjacent
 
coal
 
processing
 
plants.
 
Further
 
details
 
on
 
coal
 
processing
 
and
 
infrastructure
 
are
 
discussed
 
in
Sections 14 and 15 respectively.
1.6
 
Mineral Resource
Mineral
 
Resources,
 
representing
 
in-situ
 
coal
 
form
 
a
 
portion
 
of
 
which
 
Reserves
 
are
 
derived,
 
are
 
presented
below.
 
The Coal Resource
 
estimate, summarized
 
in Table
 
1.1, was
 
prepared as
 
of December 31,
 
2023, for
the Curragh Mine. Further details on the Coal Resource
 
estimate is presented in Section 11
 
.
Table 1.1: Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2023
Area
Measure
d (Mt)
Indicate
d (Mt)
Meas +
Ind (Mt)
Inferred
(Mt)
Total
(Mt)
Ash %
VM
%
Sulphur
%
Opencut
Inclusive of Reserves
 
217
25
242
-
242
18.7
19.2
0.57
Exclusive of Reserves
 
167
81
247
54
302
22.9
19.1
0.59
Total Open-cut
383
106
489
54
543
21.0
19.1
0.58
Underground
Inclusive of Reserves
 
140
44
183
-
183
14.9
18.2
0.39
Exclusive of Reserves
 
41
62
103
106
209
18.6
18.1
0.39
Total
 
Underground
181
106
286
106
392
16.9
18.2
0.39
Total Resources
564
211
775
160
936
19.2
18.7
0.50
 
Notes
 
(i)
 
Total Coal Resources (936Mt) are reported inclusive of Reserves
(ii)
 
Coal Resource tonnes are reported on a 5.3%
 
in-situ Moisture basis
 
(iii)
 
Coal qualities are reported on an air-dried
 
basis
(iv)
 
Underground resources are those that are approximately >15:1 vertical strip ratio or those overlapping underground mining
reserves
(v)
 
The numbers have been rounded and the
 
totals may not add up.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 9 of 118
1.7
 
Mineral Reserve
The Coal
 
Reserve
 
estimate
 
summary
 
for Curragh
 
reported
 
in Table
 
1.2
 
has been
 
converted
 
from
 
the
 
Coal
Resource estimate. The Marketable Coal Reserve
 
estimate in Table
 
1.3 represents beneficiated or otherwise
enhanced coal product where modifications due to mining, dilution and processing have been considered and
is an estimate of the marketable product achievable from
 
the Coal Reserve.
 
The numbers
 
are based
 
on the
 
results and
 
findings of
 
the Qualified
 
Persons and
 
their application
 
of the
 
relevant
modifying factors to the
 
Coal Resource geological
 
model. The basis for
 
the conversion of
 
Coal Resources to
Coal Reserves
 
including the
 
modifying
 
factors
 
used
 
is discussed
 
in section
 
12.
 
Inferred
 
Resources
 
are not
included in the Coal Reserve estimate.
Table 1.2: Coal Reserve Estimate Summary as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Curragh ROM Tonnes
Proven
Probable
Total
Quality (adb)
Mt
Mt
Mt
Ash (%)
TS (%)
VM (%)
Open Cut
227
22
249
31.3
0.5
16.0
Underground
30
11
41
17.0
0.3
16.4
Curragh Total
257
33
290
Table 1.3: Marketable Coal Reserve Estimate Summary as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves
 
(Wet Tonnes,
 
Washed or Direct Shipped, Mt)
Quality (adb)
Product Tonnes
By Reliability Category
Proven
Probable
Total
Ash%
Sulphur%
VM%
Open Cut
173
16
189
12.2
0.5
19.5
Underground
25
9
34
10.0
0.3
16.9
Curragh Total
198
25
223
 
Notes
a)
 
Coronado's ownership is 100% of the Curragh
 
Mine
b)
 
All tonnes are millions of metric tonnes (Mt).
 
c)
 
Open Cut ROM Coal Reserves have been stated
 
on a 7.5% Moisture basis. Underground ROM Coal Reserves
 
have been
stated on an 8.0% Moisture basis.
d)
 
Open Cut
 
Marketable Reserves
 
are stated
 
on a
 
product moisture
 
basis of
 
9.5%. Underground
 
Marketable Reserves
 
are
stated on a product moisture basis of 10%
e)
 
Coal qualities are reported on an air-dried
 
basis.
f)
 
Typical marketable coal products produced
 
range from low-ash,
 
hard coking coal
 
to mid-ash semi-hard
 
coking coal, a variety
of low-volatile Pulverised Coal Injection (PCI) products
 
ranging from low to high ash, and thermal
 
coal
g)
 
Totals may not sum due to rounding.
1.8
 
Capital and Operating Costs
Capital costs for the
 
Curragh mine are split into development
 
capital for new projects such as
 
the underground
project,
 
X
 
pit
 
and
 
Z
 
pit
 
developments,
 
and
 
Stay
 
in
 
Business
 
(SIB)
 
capital
 
as
 
a
 
requirement
 
to
 
support
 
the
ongoing operations
 
with new
 
infrastructure
 
and equipment
 
as the
 
current
 
installed and
 
operated
 
equipment
reaches its useful
 
operating life. A
 
summary of
 
the estimated
 
capital profile over
 
the LOM for
 
the Property
 
is
provided in Figure 1-1.
ex961p12i0 ex961p12i1
 
Page 10 of 118
Figure 1-1: CAPEX US$ million (nominal)
Mine operating costs include
 
fixed and variable costs
 
for both the open cut
 
and underground operations
 
both
onsite and offsite to Free on Board (FOB) loaded onto a ship at the port for export coal, or Free on Rail (FOR)
loaded onto
 
a train
 
for domestic
 
thermal
 
coal.
 
The open
 
cut costs
 
have been
 
benchmarked
 
off the
 
existing
open cut operation at Curragh.
 
The underground development project operating costs
 
have been supplied by
a third
 
party independently
 
with experience
 
estimating costs
 
for similar
 
underground
 
Bord and
 
Pillar mining
projects in the Rangal seams in the Bowen Basin.
 
All state
 
regulated and
 
third party
 
contracted royalties
 
payable based
 
on the
 
Curragh coal
 
production profile
are included in
 
the operating
 
costs, as well
 
as indirect business
 
costs backcharged to
 
the Curragh operation
such as a corporate support functions.
 
A summary of projected operating costs profile over the
 
LOM for the Property is provided in Figure 1-2.
Figure 1-2: Curragh Operating Cost Profile (nominal)
1.9
 
Economic Evaluation
The financial model
 
prepared for this
 
Technical
 
Report Summary (TRS)
 
was developed to
 
test the economic
viability
 
of the
 
Coal
 
Reserves.
 
The results
 
of this
 
financial
 
model are
 
not
 
intended
 
to represent
 
a bankable
feasibility
 
study,
 
required
 
for
 
financing
 
of
 
any
 
current
 
or
 
future
 
mining
 
operations
 
contemplated
 
for
 
the
Coronado
 
properties,
 
but
 
are
 
intended
 
to
 
establish
 
the
 
economic
 
viability
 
of
 
the
 
estimated
 
Coal
 
Reserves.
 
Cash flows are simulated on an annual basis based on
 
projected production from the Coal
 
Reserves.
 
The
 
project
 
cash
 
flows,
 
excluding
 
debt
 
service,
 
are
 
calculated
 
by
 
subtracting
 
direct
 
and
 
indirect
 
operating
expenses, tax payments and capital expenditures from
 
revenue.
 
Customer coal pricing have been estimated
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 11 of 118
based on
 
industry
 
specialists
 
forecasts
 
and appropriate
 
discounts
 
and
 
adjustments
 
applicable
 
to Curragh’s
products.
Economic outcomes include capital forecasts and government and
 
contracted royalty and rebate payments.
Table 1.4: LOM tonnage, Profit & Loss (P&L) before tax and EBITDA
LOM Clean
LOM
PandL
LOM
EBITDA
Tonnes
Pre-Tax PandL
Per Tonne
EBITDA
Per Tonne
Curragh
253Mt
4.7 billion
18
7.0 billion
28
Clean tonnes
 
produced in LOM
 
plan are
 
greater than
 
Marketable Coal Reserve
 
tonnes due
 
to mine
 
sequencing
required for open
 
pit mine design
 
and operating long
 
strike dragline pit
 
operations to achieve
 
the Marketable
Reserves.
 
Under
 
SEC
 
requirements
 
Inferred
 
Resources
 
cannot
 
be
 
converted
 
to
 
a
 
Coal
 
Reserve,
 
only
Measured and Indicated Resources may be converted
 
to a Coal Reserve.
In order
 
to allow
 
the mine
 
plan to
 
proceed however
 
Inferred Resources
 
must be
 
mined as
 
part of
 
the LOM
plan,
 
these
 
are
 
then
 
excluded
 
for
 
reporting
 
purposes
 
from
 
the
 
marketable
 
tonnes.
 
The
 
majority
 
of
 
Inferred
Resources are mined late in the mine schedule and
 
due to time value of money these
 
have minimal impact on
net present value NPV valuation.
As shown in Table 1.4 the Curragh Mine shows positive
 
EBITDA over the LOM.
 
Overall, Curragh’s operations
show positive LOM P&L and EBITDA of over $4 billion
 
and $7 billion respectively.
Curragh’s cash flow summary,
 
excluding debt service, is shown in section 19.
Consolidated cash flow
 
from operations is
 
positive over the
 
mine life with
 
the post-production
 
years showing
negative cash flows due to end-of-mine reclamation spending.
 
Cash flow after tax, but before debt service, generated
 
over the life of the project was discounted to NPV at
 
a
10.0%
 
discount
 
rate,
 
which
 
represents
 
the
 
risk
 
adjusted
 
return
 
demanded
 
by
 
a
 
hypothetical
 
investor
 
in
Curragh, also referred as the Weighted Average Costs of Capital (WACC). The assessment of an appropriate
discount
 
rate
 
is
 
a
 
matter
 
of
 
judgement
 
considering
 
market
 
pricing
 
information
 
and
 
the
 
characteristics,
circumstances and risks specific to the asset generating
 
the cash flows subject to discounting.
 
The NPV of
 
the project cash
 
flows is a
 
point in time
 
estimate of
 
potential economic
 
outcomes with scope
 
for
further projects
 
not exhausted.
 
The NPV
 
amounts to
 
approximately USD
 
1.1 billion as
 
a base
 
line only
 
with
outcomes
 
highly
 
dependent
 
upon
 
market
 
based
 
pricing,
 
exchange
 
rates,
 
and
 
various
 
other
 
factors.
 
The
financial model prepared for the TRS was developed to test the economic viability of
 
each coal resource area.
 
The NPV estimate
 
was made for purposes
 
of confirming the economics
 
for classification of Coal
 
Reserves and
not
 
for
 
purposes
 
of
 
valuing
 
Coronado
 
or
 
its
 
Curragh
 
assets.
 
Mine
 
plans
 
may
 
change
 
or
 
be
 
optimised
 
in
increase cashflow/NPV,
 
and actual results of
 
the operations may be
 
different.
 
In all cases, the
 
mine production
plan assumes the properties are under competent management.
1.10
 
Conclusion and Recommendations
Sufficient data has
 
been obtained through various exploration
 
and sampling programs and mining
 
operations
to
 
support
 
the
 
geological
 
interpretations
 
of
 
seam
 
structure
 
and
 
thickness
 
for
 
coal
 
horizons
 
situated
 
on
 
the
Curragh Property.
 
The exploration
 
data is
 
of sufficient
 
quantity and
 
reliability to
 
reasonably support
 
the Coal
Resource and Coal Reserve estimates in this TRS.
The geological
 
data and
 
LOM Plan
 
in this
 
report consider
 
mining plans,
 
revenue, operating
 
and capital
 
cost
assumptions that are sufficient to support the classification
 
of Coal Reserves provided herein.
 
 
 
Page 12 of 118
2
 
Introduction
2.1
 
Registrant and Terms of Reference
This report
 
was prepared
 
for the
 
sole use
 
of Coronado
 
Global Resources
 
Inc. (“Coronado”)
 
and its
 
affiliated
and subsidiary companies
 
and advisors. The
 
report provides a
 
statement of coal
 
Resources and coal
 
Reserves
for the Curragh mine, as defined under SEC Regulation S-K 1300 and the Australasian Code for Reporting of
Exploration Results, Mineral Resources
 
and Ore Reserves (JORC
 
Code 2012).
 
This report was
 
also prepared
in accordance
 
with the
 
Australasian Code
 
for Public
 
Reporting of
 
Technical
 
Assessments and
 
Valuations
 
of
Mineral
 
Assets
 
(VALMIN
 
Code
 
2015).
 
This
 
report
 
updates
 
the
 
technical
 
report
 
summary
 
titled,
 
"Coronado
Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
(“Coronado”)
 
Statement
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
and
 
Reserves
 
for
 
the
 
Curragh
 
Mine
Complex in Accordance
 
with the
 
JORC Code and
 
United States SEC
 
Regulation S-K 1300
 
as of
 
December 31,
2021 Bowen Basin Queensland, Australia February 202
 
2," dated February 21, 2022.
The
 
report
 
provides
 
a
 
statement
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
and
 
Coal
 
Reserves
 
for
 
the
 
Curragh
 
mine.
 
Exploration
results and Resource calculations were used as the basis
 
for the mine planning.
Coal Resources
 
and Coal
 
Reserves are
 
herein reported
 
in metric
 
units of
 
measurement and
 
are rounded
 
to
millions of metric tonnes (Mt). All currency is in USD.
2.2
 
Information Sources
This
 
TRS
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
information
 
provided
 
by
 
various
 
Curragh
 
employees
 
and
 
external
 
consultants
 
and
reviewed by Barry Lay (Qualified
 
Person Resource) and Daniel
 
Millers (Qualified Person Open
 
Cut Reserve)
and Chris
 
Wilkinson (Qualified
 
Person Underground
 
Reserve).
 
For the
 
evaluation,
 
the
 
following tasks
 
were
completed:
●
 
Process
 
the
 
information
 
supporting
 
the
 
estimation
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
and
 
Coal
 
Reserves
 
into
geological models;
 
●
 
Develop LOM plans and financial models;
●
 
Held discussions with Coronado company management; and
 
●
 
Prepare
 
and
 
issue
 
a
 
Technical
 
Report
 
Summary
 
providing
 
a
 
statement
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
and
Reserves which would include:
o
 
A description of the mine and facilities.
 
o
 
A description of the evaluation process.
o
 
An
 
estimation
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
and
 
Coal
 
Reserves
 
with
 
compliance
 
elements
 
as
 
stated
under the JORC Code and Regulation S-K 1300.
2.3
 
Personal Inspections
Daniel Millers is a full time employee of Coronado Global
 
Resources in the role of Superintendent Long Term
Planning. Daniel
 
has a thorough
 
understanding of
 
the Curragh
 
mine site
 
and has
 
made numerous
 
site visits
during his 3 years of employment with the organisation
 
.
Barry Lay
 
is an
 
external consultant operating
 
under his
 
own company
 
Resology Pty Ltd
 
and is
 
a former
 
Curragh
employee with years of site experience.
Chris Wilkinson is a Director of
 
Mining Consultancy Services Pty Ltd the Advisory entity
 
of Talisman Technical
Pty
 
Ltd,
 
an
 
independent
 
consultancy
 
company
 
who
 
has
 
been
 
engaged
 
by
 
Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources
throughout
 
the
 
Curragh
 
North
 
Underground
 
Project.
 
Mr
 
Wilkinson
 
visited
 
Curragh
 
Mine
 
and
 
the
 
planned
underground mine location in S-Pit area during 2023.
 
ex961p15i0
 
Page 13 of 118
3
 
Property Description
3.1
 
Location
The Curragh Project
 
is located approximately 200
 
kilometres by road west
 
of Rockhampton and approximately
14 km
 
north
 
of the
 
town
 
of
 
Blackwater
 
(refer
 
to
 
Figure
 
3-1)
 
within
 
the
 
Central
 
Highlands
 
Regional
 
Council,
Queensland
 
Australia.
 
The
 
coordinates
 
of
 
Curragh
 
are
 
688,561
 
East,
 
7,400,933
 
North
 
in
 
the
 
AMG66
coordinate system.
Figure 3-1: Location Map
 
 
Page 14 of 118
3.2
 
Titles, Claims or Leases
The Mineral Resources
 
Act 1989 (Qld) (MRA)
 
and the Mineral
 
and Energy Resources
 
(Common Provisions)
Act
 
2014
 
(Qld)
 
(MERCPA),
 
together,
 
provide
 
for
 
the
 
assessment,
 
development
 
and
 
utilization
 
of
 
mineral
resources in
 
Queensland to
 
the maximum
 
extent practicable,
 
consistent with
 
sound economic
 
and land
 
use
management.
 
The
 
MRA
 
vests
 
ownership
 
of
 
minerals,
 
with
 
limited
 
exceptions,
 
in
 
the
 
Crown
 
(i.e.,
 
the
 
state
government). A royalty is
 
payable to the
 
Crown for the
 
right to extract minerals.
 
The MRA also
 
creates different
tenures for
 
different mining
 
activities, such
 
as prospecting,
 
exploring and
 
mining. A
 
mining lease
 
(ML) is
 
the
most important
 
tenure, as
 
it permits
 
the extraction
 
of minerals
 
in conjunction
 
with other
 
required authorities.
The MRA imposes general conditions on an ML.
Coronado controls
 
the coal mining rights
 
at Curragh under
 
14 coal and
 
infrastructure ML’s
 
and three Mineral
Development
 
Licences,
 
granted
 
pursuant
 
to
 
the
 
MRA.
 
The
 
ML’s
 
and
 
MDL’s
 
at
 
Curragh
 
are
 
referred
 
to,
collectively, as the Tenements.
 
Renewal of certain Tenements
 
will be required during the mine life of Curragh
and
 
the
 
Queensland
 
government
 
can
 
vary
 
the
 
terms
 
and
 
conditions
 
on
 
renewal.
 
There
 
are
 
a
 
number
 
of
petroleum tenements which overlap with the Tenements.
 
The priority, consent and
 
coordination requirements
under the MRA,
 
MERCPA
 
and the Petroleum
 
and Gas
 
(Production and
 
Safety) Act
 
2004 (Qld)
 
(as relevant)
may
 
apply
 
with
 
respect
 
to
 
those
 
overlaps.
 
Extensive
 
statutory
 
protocols
 
govern
 
the
 
relationships
 
between
co-existing
 
mining
 
and
 
exploration
 
rights
 
and
 
these
 
protocols
 
are
 
largely
 
focused
 
on
 
encouraging
 
the
overlapping tenement
 
holders to negotiate
 
and formulate
 
arrangements that
 
enable the co-existence
 
of their
respective
 
interests.
 
To
 
date,
 
Coronado
 
has
 
negotiated
 
arrangements
 
in
 
place
 
with
 
all
 
of
 
the
 
overlapping
tenement holders and full access to all of its Tenements.
 
The respective Curragh
 
ML and MDL tenements
 
are shown in Figure
 
3-2. Detail on individual
 
tenements are
listed in Table 3.1 for the Mining Leases and Table 3.2 for the Mineral Development Leases. A land ownership
map is shown in Figure 3-3.
ex961p17i0
 
Page 15 of 118
Figure 3-2 - Mining Leases and Mineral Development Licenses
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 16 of 118
Table 3.1: Mining Leases
Mineral Lease
Permit Name
Expires
Hectares
Comments
ML 1878
Curragh
5/31/2024
4,455
 
ML 80112
Curragh B
9/30/2025
110
Infrastructure
ML 80086
Curragh East
10/31/2025
3,033
 
ML 1990
Curragh A
5/31/2033
172
 
ML 80010
Curragh Extended No.1
5/31/2033
24
Infrastructure
ML 80011
Curragh Extended No.2
5/31/2033
6
Infrastructure
ML 80012
Curragh Extended No.3
5/31/2033
43
Infrastructure
ML 80171
Curragh West
7/31/2040
954
 
ML 700008
Curragh Central Extended
11/30/2040
2,643
 
ML 700009
Curragh Extended
11/30/2040
797
 
ML 700006
Curragh South
6/30/2041
1,432
 
ML 700007
Curragh Central
6/30/2041
1,123
 
ML 80110
Curragh North
7/31/2044
4,860
 
ML 80123
Curragh North A
7/31/2044
5
 
TOTAL
 
19,658
 
Table 3.2: Mineral Development Licenses
License
Permit Name
Expires
Hectares
Comments
MDL 328
Curragh West No. 1
8/31/2026
381
 
MDL 329
Curragh West No. 2
8/31/2026
2,334
 
MDL 162
Mackenzie
2/29/2028
3,213
 
 
 
5,928
 
ex961p19i0
 
Page 17 of 118
Figure 3-3: Surface landownership details
 
Page 18 of 118
There are no outstanding disputes or
 
litigation. Only one tenement (ML
 
80123) required a native title process
for its grant. Curragh
 
undertook the Right to
 
Negotiate process with the then
 
Native Title Parties, the Gaangalu
Nation People,
 
and concluded
 
an ancillary
 
agreement
 
and a
 
section
 
31 Deed
 
to allow
 
the ML
 
to be
 
validly
granted in compliance with
 
the Commonwealth Native
 
Title Act 1993.There
 
are no material issues
 
relating to
native title for the Curragh operations.
Curragh negotiated a Cultural Heritage Management Plan (“CHMP”) for the
 
project in 2012. There have been
subsequent changes
 
to the
 
registration and
 
composition of
 
the Native
 
Title
 
claim for
 
the relevant
 
Aboriginal
Party. A new CHMP
 
has been prepared for the
 
extended Curragh operations, signed on December 19,
 
2017.
Cultural heritage is unlikely to pose any material issues
 
to the Curragh operations.
3.3
 
Mineral Rights
Property control and
 
mining rights
 
at Curragh
 
are entirely
 
expressed in
 
the MLs
 
and MDLs mentioned
 
in the
previous section of this document.
 
Overlapping petroleum tenure exists over the southern and
 
eastern extents
of the
 
Curragh tenements.
 
Under the Mineral
 
and Energy Resource
 
(Common Provisions) Act
 
2014 legislation
(‘MERCPA 2014”) this requires
 
annual information
 
exchanges including the
 
provision and maintenance
 
of Joint
Information Management Plans with the overlapping petroleum
 
tenement holder.
 
Coronado is compliant with
the legislation and there are no current restrictions to
 
coal mining.
3.4
 
Encumbrances
There are mortgages on the tenements.
3.5
 
Other Risks
Risk exists
 
in areas
 
of high
 
environmental significance;
 
these are
 
managed by
 
internal processes
 
as part
 
of
the normal day to day operations of the mine. Areas that have high environmental value that lie outside of the
approved disturbance footprints are not included within
 
the Coal Resource and Reserve estimates.
There are
 
no indications
 
that matters
 
associated with
 
surface rights,
 
mineral rights,
 
or other
 
encumbrances
would deny access to the resources and reserves captured
 
in the current estimates.
 
 
 
Page 19 of 118
4
 
Accessibility, Climate, Local Resources, Infrastructure and
Physiography
 
4.1
 
Topography,
 
Elevation and Vegetation
Curragh coal
 
mine is
 
characterized by
 
a general
 
gently rolling
 
topography,
 
which is
 
the predominant
 
feature
for the Bowen Basin. The principal drainage conduits
 
are the Mackenzie River and the Blackwater Creek
 
and
their tributaries, which represent the upper phase of the hydrologic regime. The mean altitude is between 140
and 150 metres above sea level.
Vegetation at Curragh consists primarily of grass land, with pastures and low intensity cattle grazing being the
primary
 
forms
 
of
 
non-mining
 
land
 
use;
 
the
 
secondary
 
land
 
use
 
is
 
crop
 
farming
 
over
 
dry
 
lands.
 
Most
 
of
 
the
original vegetation was
 
cleared for agricultural
 
exploitation with a relatively
 
small portion remaining
 
along the
two aforementioned waterways.
4.2
 
Access and Transport
Established sealed roads
 
connect the mine
 
to the towns
 
of Emerald to
 
the west and the
 
port at Gladstone
 
to
the east.
 
Curragh site owns
 
and runs a
 
rail loop, adjacent
 
to product stockpiles
 
with a conveyor
 
system that
feeds train
 
loadout bin.
 
Domestic coal
 
sales are
 
loaded onto
 
train wagons
 
for transportation
 
to the
 
Stanwell
coal fired
 
power station
 
for power
 
generation. While
 
export coal
 
is transported
 
by rail
 
on the
 
Blackwater line
approximately
 
290km
 
to
 
the
 
RG
 
Tanna
 
or
 
Wiggins
 
Island
 
Coal
 
Export
 
Terminal
 
(WICET)
 
port
 
facilities
 
at
Gladstone. No coal transportation takes place on waterways.
4.3
 
Availability of Infrastructure
The closest
 
population centre
 
with respect
 
to Curragh
 
is the
 
town of
 
Blackwater approximately
 
14 km
 
to the
south.
 
The major regional town of Emerald, located
 
75 km to the west, offers daily flights
 
to the State Capital
of Brisbane and is used extensively by Coronado personnel
 
travelling to and from site.
 
4.4
 
Climate and Length of Operating Season
The prevailing climate
 
at Curragh is
 
sub-tropical characterized
 
by warm to
 
hot and wet
 
summers and cool
 
to
mild, dry
 
winters. The highest
 
temperatures are observed
 
in January, reaching an
 
average of 34°
 
C; the
 
coldest
temperatures occur
 
in July
 
at an
 
average
 
of 7°C.
 
Annual rainfall
 
averages
 
635 mm,
 
with January
 
being the
wettest month with typical rainfalls of +90 mm.
 
July is the driest month with typical precipitation
 
averaging 19
mm.
 
 
 
Page 20 of 118
5
 
History
 
5.1
 
Previous Operation
The
 
coal
 
mine
 
at
 
Curragh
 
was
 
developed
 
in
 
1983
 
as
 
a
 
joint
 
venture
 
between
 
the
 
following
 
partners
 
with
respective participation in ownership:
Arco Australia Ltd
 
30%
 
Australian Consolidated Industries Ltd
30%
 
R. W. Miller and Co.
30%
 
Mitsui and Co. (Australia)
10%
 
Arco Australia
 
Ltd. bought
 
out the other
 
joint venturers
 
and in
 
2000 sold the
 
property to
 
Wesfarmers Ltd.
 
In
2014, Wesfarmers acquired
 
MDL 162 from Peabody
 
Budjero Pty Ltd.
 
Coronado acquired all
 
the Tenements
from
 
Wesfarmers
 
Ltd.
 
in
 
March
 
2018.
 
Since
 
the
 
project’s
 
inception,
 
additional
 
MLs
 
and
 
MDLs
 
were
incorporated into Curragh at different times.
 
5.2
 
Previous Exploration
Curragh has been the
 
subject of numerous phases of
 
exploratory drilling programs extending back to
 
the early
1960s. Currently there are some 15,000 boreholes available
 
for geological evaluation of the asset with around
9,000 directly within the
 
current mineral concession
 
borders.
 
The vast majority of
 
these boreholes are of
 
the
non-coring type
 
(open hole)
 
but with
 
a regular
 
spacing cored
 
holes used
 
for coal
 
quality evaluation.
 
Further
details on past exploration efforts are presented in Section 7. Various
 
drilling programmes were conducted by
the
 
Queensland
 
Department
 
of
 
Minerals
 
and
 
Energy
 
(previously
 
known
 
as
 
Mines
 
Department)
 
during
 
the
period 1966-76
 
over a
 
large area
 
between the
 
Capricorn Highway
 
and the
 
Mackenzie River.
 
The area
 
was
within the
 
Department of
 
Mines Reserved
 
Area 56D
 
(RA56D). From
 
1976 to
 
1978 detailed
 
drilling and
 
coal
analysis was carried out
 
by officers of the
 
Geological Survey of Queensland
 
on behalf of the
 
State Electricity
Commission of
 
Queensland (SECQ).
 
During this
 
time the SECQ
 
(SECQ’s interest
 
is now vested
 
in Stanwell
Corporation Limited
 
(Stanwell)
 
was granted
 
Authority to
 
Prospect (ATP)
 
217C. Extensive
 
exploration of
 
the
Curragh area within ATP
 
217C occurred between 1976 and 1978.
). The Curragh lease (ML1878)
 
was granted on 27
 
May 1982 and that part
 
of the area was relinquished
 
from
ATP 217.
 
In 1982
 
further
 
exploration
 
was
 
carried out
 
by Geological
 
Survey
 
of Queensland
 
on behalf
 
of
 
SECQ
 
in the
Curragh East area (now ML
 
80086). A subsequent exploration programme in 1993
 
was also undertaken in the
area
 
to
 
collect
 
additional
 
coal
 
quality
 
and
 
structural
 
data.
 
Four
 
hundred
 
holes
 
were
 
drilled,
 
comprising
 
320
open holes with geophysical logs and 80 partially cored
 
holes. ML80086 was granted on 19 October 2000.
In 1996 a large
 
exploration programme was undertaken at
 
the northern end of
 
MDL162 and this work provided
the basis
 
for the
 
Pisces
 
Project
 
feasibility
 
study (Curragh
 
North). In
 
2001 twenty
 
partially cored
 
holes
 
were
drilled in this
 
northern part
 
of MDL162 to
 
provide samples
 
for bench scale
 
coking coal testing.
 
Another large
drilling programme was
 
commenced in 2003
 
and the culmination
 
of all this
 
work saw ML80110 (Curragh North)
granted on 22nd July 2004.
 
Systematic
 
drilling
 
programs
 
(ongoing),
 
conducted
 
since
 
the
 
mine
 
was
 
commissioned,
 
have
 
resulted
 
in
thousands of holes being drilled in the Curragh Lease
 
area.
 
In the last few years exploration focus has included business as usual open-cut
 
drilling but also an increasing
focus on underground resource evaluation. The underground
 
exploration program has included seismic 2D
 
&
3D surveys and core drilling for gas, geotech,
 
coal quality and spontaneous combustion evaluation. Additional
exploration has included permeability and hydrological
 
assessment.
 
 
Page 21 of 118
6
 
Geological Setting, Mineralization and Deposit
 
6.1
 
Regional, Local and Property Geology
Curragh
 
is
 
situated
 
within
 
the
 
Permo-Triassic
 
aged
 
Bowen
 
Basin
 
in
 
Eastern
 
Australia,
 
which
 
covers
approximately
 
16 million
 
hectares.
 
Its
 
physiographic
 
make-up
 
consists
 
of
 
lowlands,
 
flood
 
plains
 
as
 
well
 
as
rugged plateaus and ridges. The main lithological units derive from continental and marine
 
sedimentation with
limited volcanic
 
and intrusive
 
rocks.
 
The principal
 
Resources
 
are primarily
 
large
 
coal fields
 
and secondarily
natural gas.
The geological setting of
 
the property itself consists of sediments
 
of the Rangal Coal
 
Measures and Burngrove
Formation, both of Permian age which outcrop on the property. These units underlie alluvial Quaternary cover
and
 
minor
 
areas
 
of
 
Tertiary
 
sediments.
 
Alluvial
 
sediments
 
typically
 
have
 
an
 
average
 
thickness
 
of
 
10
 
to
 
15
metres, with locations of up to 30 metres of sand, clay
 
and gravel in northern areas.
The Yarrabee
 
Tuff marker
 
coincides with the present lower
 
limit of Resource estimate.
 
Figure
 
6-1 shows the
typical stratigraphic
 
column that applies
 
to the
 
property. Five main coal
 
seams groups, primarily
 
of metallurgical
quality with some thermal quality coals, are mined at Curragh,
 
as listed below:
●
 
Cancer seam
●
 
Aries seam
●
 
Castor seam
●
 
Pollux seam
●
Mackenzie
and Pisces seams
The Burngrove Formation typically has thick interbedded coal and
 
tuff beds. This coal is typically high ash
 
and
is not included in either the Resources or Reserves.
The structural environment at
 
Curragh can be complex
 
with the observed
 
seam deformation the result
 
of thrust
faulting from
 
the northeast
 
with fault
 
throws
 
up to
 
30 m.
 
Structural thickening
 
can occur
 
where thrust
 
faults
cause affected seams
 
to be repeated,
 
but in
 
most cases the
 
duplicated seams are
 
not included in
 
the Resource
estimation, although such repeats of coal are often mined and included
 
in the Resource estimation if required.
Thrust faulting can also
 
result in barren areas,
 
where seams have been
 
faulted out. North-south and east-west
trending normal
 
faults also
 
occur but
 
are less common
 
than thrust faulting.
 
The structural
 
geology within
 
the
Resource adds some
 
complexity to
 
the project, as
 
such the mine
 
employs a strong
 
geotechnical program
 
to
manage geotechnical risks.
The
 
major
 
structure
 
that
 
limits
 
mining
 
at
 
Curragh
 
North
 
is
 
the
 
Jellinbah
 
Fault
 
which
 
trends
 
in
 
a
 
northwest,
southeast direction with throw of several hundred metres
 
and various splays of lesser throw (10 to 20m).
ex961p24i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 22 of 118
Figure 6-1: Blackwater Group Stratigraphic Sequence
6.2
 
Mineralization
The
 
generalized
 
stratigraphic
 
columnar
 
section
 
in
 
Figure
 
6-1
 
demonstrates
 
the
 
vertical
 
relationship
 
of
 
the
principal coal seams
 
and rock formations
 
at Curragh. The
 
property,
 
as in the
 
Bowen Basin as
 
a whole, does
not contain any signs of metamorphic activity; the prevailing lithology is sedimentary
 
rocks with a few igneous
intrusions. The depth of host rock weathering at Curragh is
 
on average in the order of 10 to 15 metres.
6.3
 
Coal Quality
Coal seams
 
at Curragh
 
are mainly
 
of the
 
low volatile
 
metallurgical grade
 
with a
 
secondary middling
 
thermal
product. Sulphur and phosphorus content is generally low. Insitu ash is in the
 
range of 20% thus necessitating
beneficiation to
 
meet market
 
requirements, which
 
in this
 
case is
 
accomplished
 
through a
 
coal handling
 
and
preparation plant. Metallurgical coal products range
 
from 7-10% product ash.
ex961p25i0
 
Page 23 of 118
6.4
 
Deposits
Figure 6-2
 
shows
 
a 3D
 
view of
 
the geometry
 
of the
 
coal horizons
 
at Curragh.
 
In portions
 
of the
 
property,
 
a
number of
 
these seams
 
merge to
 
form a
 
single
 
package, without
 
any interburden
 
strata. In
 
the central
 
and
some of the
 
northern part
 
of the property
 
the Aries
 
and Castor
 
seams coalesce
 
into one coal
 
stratum that
 
is
referred
 
to
 
locally
 
as
 
the
 
“Mammoth”
 
seam.
 
The
 
Mammoth
 
Seam
 
is
 
analogous
 
to
 
the
 
Leichardt
 
seam
commonly
 
found
 
in
 
mining
 
operations
 
further
 
north.
 
At
 
Curragh
 
North
 
the
 
Pollux,
 
Orion
 
and
 
Pisces
 
seams
coalesce into
 
one unit
 
which is
 
correctly referred
 
to as
 
the Mackenzie
 
seam, but
 
in some contexts
 
has been
referred to as the “Pisces” seam even though the
 
true Pisces seam is only one of the constituent
 
seams of the
Mackenzie assemblage.
 
The Mackenzie seam is analogous to the Vermont seam which is commonly found in
mining operations further north.
Figure 6-2: Trends in Seam Splitting and Coalescing from North to South
Figure highlights a North-South section from the current geological model through Curragh properties. Seams
of economic interest occur at depths ranging from 15m from surface down to as deep as 400m in the deepest
part of the property.
 
Interburden
 
host rock
 
typically
 
consists
 
of regular
 
intercalations
 
of siltstones
 
and mudstones,
 
with
 
layers
 
of
variable
 
thicknesses.
 
The
 
rock
 
and
 
coal
 
beds
 
dip
 
gently
 
to
 
East
 
direction
 
at
 
an
 
angle
 
of
 
approximately
 
3
degrees,
 
with
 
some
 
sections
 
displaying
 
dip
 
angles
 
as
 
high
 
as
 
10
 
degrees
 
in
 
association
 
with
 
structural
deformation.
In
 
general,
 
only
 
minor
 
instances
 
of
 
intrusive
 
material
 
have
 
been
 
intercepted
 
in
 
drill
 
holes
 
or
 
mined
 
during
production at the Curragh Mine.
Igneous activity is more prevalent at Curragh North although these are not a major impact on operations. The
intrusive
 
includes
 
rare
 
dykes
 
occurring
 
at
 
the
 
northern
 
end
 
of
 
Curragh
 
North
 
deposit.
 
There
 
was
 
a
 
larger
igneous intrusion
 
approximately
 
500 metres
 
long and
 
100 metres
 
wide that
 
impacted the
 
Resources
 
of the
Aries, Castor and Mackenzie seams.
 
Mining has proceeded past the area of impact of this intrusion.
ex961p26i0 ex961p26i1
 
Page 24 of 118
Curragh has been
 
subjected to
 
moderate localized
 
faulting more intense
 
in southern areas
 
that has resulted
in
 
vertical
 
slips
 
(displacements)
 
as
 
high
 
as
 
20
 
metres,
 
along
 
with
 
variations
 
in
 
seam
 
thickness.
 
Seam
duplication is
 
also common
 
as a
 
result of
 
the thrust
 
faulting but
 
in most
 
cases the
 
duplicated seams
 
are not
included in the Resource estimation, although such repeats
 
of coal are often mined.
 
The principal
 
geostructural
 
feature is
 
the Jellinbah
 
regional thrust
 
fault located
 
east of
 
the mine
 
outside the
Resource area.
 
The structural
 
geology within
 
the Resource
 
adds some
 
complexity
 
to the
 
project. The
 
mine
employs a strong geotechnical program to manage geotechnical
 
risks.
Figure 6-3: North South Section through Curragh
 
Tenements showing major seams
 
 
 
Page 25 of 118
7
 
Exploration
 
7.1
 
Nature and Extent of Exploration
The Curragh geological
 
drilling database contains over
 
19,000 holes drilled over
 
a long history of
 
exploration
and
 
development
 
in
 
the
 
Curragh
 
area.
 
Various
 
drilling
 
programmes
 
were
 
conducted
 
by
 
the
 
Queensland
Department of Minerals and Energy (previously known
 
as Mines Department) during the period 1966-76
 
over
a large area between
 
the Capricorn Highway
 
and the Mackenzie
 
River. The
 
area was within
 
the Department
of
 
Mines
 
RA56D.
 
From
 
1976
 
to
 
1978
 
detailed
 
drilling
 
and
 
coal
 
analysis
 
was
 
carried
 
out
 
by
 
officers
 
of
 
the
Geological Survey of Queensland on behalf of the SECQ. During this time the SECQ (SECQ’s interest is now
vested in Stanwell was granted
 
Authority to Prospect (ATP)
 
217C. Extensive exploration
 
of the Curragh area
within ATP 217C occurred
 
between 1976 and 1978.
In 1982
 
further
 
exploration
 
was
 
carried out
 
by Geological
 
Survey
 
of Queensland
 
on behalf
 
of
 
SECQ
 
in the
Curragh East area. The
 
Curragh lease (ML1878)
 
was granted on
 
27 May 1982 and that
 
part of the area
 
was
relinquished
 
from
 
ATP
 
217.
 
A
 
significant
 
exploration
 
programme
 
was
 
undertaken
 
in
 
1993
 
to
 
provide
 
coal
quality information and
 
additional structural data
 
for Curragh East.
 
Four hundred holes
 
were drilled, comprising
320 open holes with geophysical logs and 80 partially cored
 
holes.
 
In 1996 a
 
large exploration programme
 
was undertaken at
 
the northern end
 
of MDL162, and
 
this work provided
the basis
 
for the
 
Pisces
 
Project
 
feasibility
 
study (Curragh
 
North). In
 
2001 twenty
 
partially cored
 
holes
 
were
drilled in this
 
northern part
 
of MDL162 to
 
provide samples
 
for bench scale
 
coking coal testing.
 
Another large
drilling programme was
 
commenced in 2003
 
and the culmination
 
of all this
 
work saw ML80110 (Curragh North)
granted on 22nd July 2004.
 
Systematic
 
drilling
 
programs
 
(ongoing),
 
conducted
 
since
 
the
 
mine
 
was
 
commissioned,
 
have
 
resulted
 
in
thousands of holes being drilled in the Curragh Lease
 
area.
 
In the last
 
three years, several
 
strategic holes
 
have been
 
drilled on an
 
ongoing basis
 
to investigate
 
potential
for future
 
underground mining.
 
Geotech, gas,
 
coal quality
 
and spontaneous
 
combustion samples
 
have been
collected as part of this program.
Some
 
geophysical
 
techniques
 
including
 
seismic
 
and
 
aeromagnetics
 
have
 
supplemented
 
the
 
geological
understanding. This work is discussed in the next sections.
7.1.0
 
Non-Drilling Exploration
Geophysical techniques have
 
been used to
 
supplement the understanding
 
of the Curragh
 
Resource. This work
has been to guide overall understanding of intrusions,
 
seam continuity and sub-surface faults.
The mains surveys are shown in
 
Figure 7-1. The surveys that have been conducted are:
●
 
In September 2003, a low
 
level airborne geophysical survey was flown over
 
large parts of the Curragh
tenements to acquire magnetic and radiometric data (31.5km’s
 
of line at 100m spacing).
●
 
In 2019, 44km
 
of regional
 
Scale 2D seismic
 
acquired to provide
 
characterisation of
 
seam continuity,
seam splits and sub-surface structure.
●
 
In 2020,
 
18km of
 
closely spaced
 
2D lines
 
in ML
 
80110
 
were acquired
 
to characterise
 
structure and
seam continuity adjacent to Pit S and Pit U
●
 
In August 2023, 4.1km2 of 3D seismic
 
was acquired by Terrex Pty Ltd east of Curragh North open-cut
operations
●
 
In August
 
2023, 2
 
kms of
 
Vibroseis seismic
 
was acquired
 
by Terrex
 
Pty Ltd
 
south of
 
Curragh North
open-cut operations
●
 
In September
 
2023, 9.32km
 
of Mini-SOSIE
 
2D seismic
 
data was
 
acquired by
 
Velseis
 
Pty Ltd
 
to the
south of Curragh North operations
ex961p28i0
 
Page 26 of 118
Aero-magnetic data
 
has indicated
 
that Resources
 
are largely
 
intrusion free
 
except for
 
one large
 
“plug” body
which was picked up in aero-magnetics and has since
 
been mined out.
The 2D
 
and 3D
 
survey has
 
been very
 
successful to
 
understand larger
 
scale structures
 
that are
 
difficult and
expensive to define with drilling. The seismic
 
data indicated that Resources are
 
largely continuous with some
disruption due
 
to faulting.
 
The Phase
 
I seismic
 
survey was
 
successful in
 
locating the
 
Jellinbah fault,
 
a major
regional fault and to define seam splitting in areas of sparse
 
drilling.
The 3D survey was particularly successful in precisely defining
 
faults and split lines is an
area of underground mining interest.Figure 7-1: Geophysical
 
Surveys
7.1.1
 
Drilling Exploration
The Curragh deposit has a long history of exploration with over 19000 holes drilled in its properties (Figure 8).
Of these approximately
 
15,700 holes are
 
deemed suitable for
 
use in
 
the geological model.
 
The remainder have
been
 
excluded
 
due
 
to
 
not
 
meeting
 
strict
 
data
 
quality
 
requirements.
 
Table
 
7.1
 
shows
 
the
 
Curragh
 
Property
drilling statistics as used in the Curragh 2023 geological model.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 27 of 118
 
The excluded holes comprise three broad groups of holes:
●
 
Holes that were not geophysically logged
●
 
Drill and blast holes that were only partially logged
●
 
Top
 
of coal grade control drilling
Approximately 7,500 of the 15,700
 
holes lie in areas of
 
declared coal Resources with the
 
remainder in mined
out areas or areas of Burngrove
 
Formation only.
 
Most of these boreholes are non-coring
 
(open holes), with a
portion
 
as
 
cored
 
holes
 
for
 
coal
 
quality
 
and
 
washability,
 
geotechnical,
 
gas
 
or
 
fugitive
 
emissions
 
purposes.
Predominantly all holes are logged by downhole wireline
 
geophysical techniques.
 
Table 7.1: Drill hole Statistics
Hole Type
Metres
Number of Holes
Chip
 
1,119,859
 
 
12487
 
Core
264,544
 
3217
 
Total
 
1,334,404
 
 
15704
All drilling and sampling
 
are conducted in accordance
 
with the Curragh Geology
 
Planning system which
 
sets
out standards for acquiring exploration data. A subset
 
of these procedures is shown in Table
 
7.2.
Table 7.2: Selected Exploration and Data management procedures
Procedure Name
CPS PLN 2.0 Geology System Plan
CPS PRO 2.3 Exploration Planning
CPS PRO 2.4 Exploration Execution
CPS WI 2.51 Drill Site Management
CPS PRO 2.5 Exploration Data Collection
CPS WI 2.21 Establishing Exploration Requirements
CPS WI 2.22 Guide to Exploration Planning
CPS WI 2.23 Core Logging and Sampling
CPS WI 2.24 Minimum Borehole Logging Requirements
CPS WI 2.26 Sampling for Coal Quality Analysis
The procedures specify the processes of planning through
 
business stakeholder engagement through to final
acquisition,
 
validation
 
and
 
safe storage
 
of
 
geological
 
data
 
and
 
adhere
 
to
 
various
 
industry
 
standards
 
where
applicable.
All logging
 
and data
 
management is
 
conducted by
 
qualified geologists.
 
In recent
 
years all
 
geological data
 
is
captured in specialist logging software and imported into the Company’s geological database (Geobank) after
rigorous
 
data
 
validation.
 
The
 
database
 
is
 
maintained
 
by
 
company
 
IT
 
professionals
 
and
 
administered
 
by
company geological staff.
Drilling
 
comprises
 
short
 
term
 
operational
 
drilling
 
designed
 
to
 
reduce
 
geological
 
uncertainty
 
in
 
short-term
planning and long-term strategic drilling to allow for assessment
 
of future mining options.
The primary drilling
 
techniques are
 
chip drilling
 
(non-core) and
 
coring. Chip
 
holes provide
 
ground up (“chip”)
samples that
 
are returned
 
to surface
 
by air
 
or water
 
which provides lithology
 
information down the
 
hole normally
logged
 
at
 
1m
 
intervals.
 
Down
 
hole
 
geophysics
 
provides
 
detailed
 
lithology
 
and
 
coal
 
thickness
 
data
 
in
 
these
holes for subsequent modelling.
ex961p30i0
 
Page 28 of 118
Downhole
 
wireline
 
techniques
 
include
 
calliper
 
(borehole
 
diameter),
 
gamma,
 
density,
 
sonic
 
and
 
borehole
verticality. In
 
some cases optical or acoustic
 
televiewers are run to provide
 
more detailed bedding and defect
orientation data.
Core allows
 
for a
 
more detailed
 
understanding of
 
rock characteristics
 
including lithology
 
fabric, rock
 
defects,
hardness and provides physical
 
intact samples for subsequent
 
laboratory testing. Cored holes
 
of either 63 or
100mm
 
diameter
 
are
 
logged,
 
photographed
 
and
 
sampled
 
by
 
a
 
qualified
 
geologist
 
into
 
company
 
geological
database. Cored holes
 
maybe partially cored
 
or fully cored
 
dependent on the
 
purpose of the
 
hole and samples.
Chip samples
 
may be
 
collected
 
and tested
 
for coal
 
oxidation. Core
 
samples are
 
more common
 
and maybe
taken for several reasons:
●
 
Coal Quality and Washability samples
●
 
Dilution Samples
●
 
Geotechnical Samples
●
 
Gas and Fugitive Emissions Samples
●
 
Reactive Ground and Spontaneous Combustion Samples
Figure 7-2: Curragh Boreholes as of 31 August 2023 used
 
in Resource Estimate
ex961p31i0
 
Page 29 of 118
Large core holes (200mm) are generally drilled at the start of project evaluation
 
to provide detailed sizing and
coal quality and coke
 
characterisation data
 
and form a small
 
part of the Curragh
 
coal quality database.
 
More
frequent
 
are
 
cored
 
holes
 
of
 
either
 
63mm
 
or
 
100mm
 
diameter.
 
These
 
holes
 
are
 
logged,
 
photographed
 
and
sampled by a qualified
 
geologist. The sample test data
 
provides information on coal quality, geotechnical, gas,
reactive
 
ground
 
and
 
spontaneous
 
combustion
 
characteristics
 
in
 
addition
 
to
 
data
 
to
 
estimate
 
product
 
yield.
Figure 7-3 shows the sample locations by main sample type.
Figure 7-3: Sample Locations by PrimarySample Type
 
Page 30 of 118
7.1.2
 
Drilling, Sampling and Recovery Factors
A number of drilling, sampling and recovery factors can materially affect the accuracy and reliability of results.
These factors are routinely reviewed as part of validation
 
and estimation processes.
Drillhole spacing varies
 
across Curragh properties
 
from as low
 
as 20m to
 
as high as
 
1-2km. In years
 
prior to
mining,
 
infill drilling
 
occurs
 
with drill
 
hole spacing
 
decreased
 
to the
 
order
 
of 50-100m
 
for chip
 
holes.
 
Cored
sample drilling spacing prior to mining is generally less
 
than 400m.
Core Recovery - The diameter of exploration cores
 
is generally between 50mm and 100 mm, with a
 
few larger
diameter (200 mm) holes used to
 
obtain samples for simulated degradation, washing, combustion, and coking
practices.
 
A minimum core
 
recovery of 90%
 
is used as
 
a criteria for
 
acceptance or
 
rejection of a
 
sample for
subsequent
 
analysis.
 
If
 
a
 
sample
 
fails
 
those
 
criteria,
 
the
 
sample
 
is
 
re-drilled
 
or
 
rejected
 
from
 
subsequent
modelling.
Drillhole Collar Survey – All borehole locations
 
and elevations since the mid-1980’s have been
 
surveyed by a
registered mine
 
surveyor registered
 
under the
 
Surveyors Act
 
2003. Boreholes
 
are surveyed
 
in a
 
local mine
grid which is
 
within a close
 
approximation to Australian
 
Geodetic Datum (ADG84). Some
 
historical holes drilled
in
 
several
 
decades
 
ago
 
have
 
lower
 
confidence
 
on
 
survey
 
accuracy.
 
Where
 
there
 
is
 
doubt
 
these
 
holes
 
are
excluded or when included tend to lie in lower category
 
resource areas e.g. Inferred
Downhole Verticality
 
- Recent holes
 
in last 5-10
 
years have been
 
surveyed by downhole
 
verticality tools that
give the holes dip
 
and dip direction at
 
frequent intervals down
 
the hole. Holes prior
 
to this were not surveyed
with verticality tools and it is assumed that these holes are vertical. For Resource and reserve estimation, this
assumption is not material.
7.1.3
 
Drilling Results and Interpretation
Coronado properties have been drilled at suitable density and sufficient samples have been collected to allow
for construction of a
 
detailed geological model. In
 
areas of wider drillhole
 
spacing, the uncertainty of this
 
model
increases. This uncertainty is
 
captured in Resource confidence
 
polygons in the Resource
 
estimation process
and
 
reported
 
accordingly
 
as
 
Measured,
 
Indicated
 
or
 
Inferred
 
Resources.
 
Only
 
Measured
 
or
 
Indicated
resources are considered for conversion into mineral reserves.
Figure 7-2
 
shows
 
all boreholes
 
used in
 
the 2023
 
Resource
 
model and
 
Resource
 
estimate. The
 
holes have
been used to
 
generate a
 
geological model,
 
through which
 
a geological
 
section is
 
presented in
 
Figure. Holes
in
 
Burngrove
 
Formation
 
in
 
south-western
 
Mineral
 
Development
 
Leases
 
are
 
not
 
shown
 
as
 
the
 
coal
 
in
 
the
Burngrove Formation is not included in the Resources or
 
Reserves.
Curragh has
 
extensive drilling.
 
The results
 
over the
 
years have
 
shown that
 
the seams
 
are generally
 
shallow
dip (less
 
than 5°),
 
however in
 
fault and
 
deformation zones,
 
steep dips
 
occur locally.
 
Seam deformation
 
has
resulted principally
 
from thrust
 
faulting from
 
the north-east
 
resulting in
 
seam displacements
 
up to
 
20 metres
vertically.
 
North-south
 
and
 
east-west
 
normal
 
faults
 
are
 
less
 
common
 
and
 
some
 
of
 
these
 
have
 
a
 
strike-slip
component.
Fault deformation has
 
resulted in seam thinning,
 
thickening and barren areas
 
which is more
 
prevalent in south.
The Jellinbah
 
fault occurs
 
on the
 
eastern side
 
of the
 
Curragh North
 
mining lease.
 
The fault
 
is a
 
thrust fault
upthrown on the eastern side by several hundred metres
 
.
 
This is a physical boundary to coal mining.
Coal quality sample data indicates that metallurgical
 
coal products (low-vol coking and
 
PCI) can be produced
from all seams. A
 
secondary thermal product
 
is also produced
 
after beneficiation. A
 
much smaller proportion
of seams in some areas are only
 
suitable for thermal coal. The metallurgical coal rank (impacts coke strength)
slowly decreases with increasing depth to the east.
 
Coal
 
quality
 
models
 
are
 
well
 
supported
 
by
 
historical
 
production
 
with
 
low
 
vol
 
coking,
 
PCI
 
and
 
thermal
 
coal
produced at Curragh for several decades.
 
Coal quality is not expected to materially
 
change in the life of mine
plan.
 
Page 31 of 118
7.2
 
Hydrology
Curragh Mine
 
is in
 
the Mackenzie
 
River sub-basin
 
of the
 
Fitzroy River
 
Basin. Mackenzie
 
River forms
 
at the
confluence
 
of
 
the
 
Nogoa
 
and
 
Comet
 
rivers
 
approximately
 
66
 
km
 
upstream
 
of
 
Curragh
 
Mine
 
and
 
joins
 
with
Dawson River to form Fitzroy River approximately 250
 
km downstream.
Rainfall is
 
relatively low,
 
with an
 
average of
 
635 mm
 
of annual
 
precipitation, and
 
consequently interruptions
seldom occur in the mining operations due to severe weather.
 
Most rain occurs in summer.
Water bearing units at Curragh Mine comprise:
 
●
 
sand
 
and
 
gravel
 
units
 
within
 
alluvial
 
sediments
 
of
 
Quaternary
 
and
 
Tertiary
 
age
 
and
 
the
Duaringa/Emerald Formation of Tertiary
 
age
 
●
 
cleated coal seams of the Rangal Coal Measures
 
●
fractured sediments
of the Burngrove Formation including coal seams and
 
sandstone units.
 
The aquitard units of low to very low permeability at Curragh
 
Mine comprise:
 
●
 
clay and silt layers within the Quaternary and Tertiary
 
alluvium
 
●
 
the weathered residual rock beneath the alluvium, which
 
is typically clay rich
 
●
 
the
 
Rewan
 
Formation
 
comprising
 
mudstones
 
and
 
lithic
 
sandstones
 
which
 
overlie
 
the
 
Rangal
 
Coa
Measures
 
●
 
interburden
 
layers
 
between
 
coal
 
seams
 
comprising
 
siltstones,
 
sandstones
 
and
 
mudstones,
 
which
have very low primary porosity
 
(typically void spacing in the
 
sandstones is cemented by clay providing
poor interconnection of void space).
 
Large north-west trending faults provide potential barriers
 
to groundwater flow.
Wetlands and swamps in the area are not believed
 
to be materially reliant on groundwater and are unlikely
 
to
be affected
 
by drawdown.
 
Current approved
 
Environmental Management
 
Plans ensures
 
any environmental
impacts are minimised.
The potential for acid mine drainage issues is low.
Curragh has a large network of hydro bores (Figure 7-4).
Curragh
 
has
 
a
 
groundwater
 
monitoring
 
procedure
 
as
 
part
 
of
 
its
 
Environmental
 
Management
 
System
 
to
characterize groundwater
 
systems and monitor
 
any potential impacts
 
on groundwater
 
over time and
 
to meet
its
 
obligations
 
under
 
Environmental
 
Authorities.
 
Monitoring
 
locations
 
are
 
installed
 
in
 
Alluvium,
 
Rangal
 
Coal
Measure
 
and
 
the
 
underlying
 
Burngrove
 
Formation
 
and
 
additionally
 
Observation
 
bores
 
adjacent
 
to
infrastructure such as dams and levees.
 
Compliance and Reference bores are
 
sampled bi-annually including the recording
 
of depth to water,
 
physical
chemical parameters as
 
well as the collection and
 
submission of a sample
 
to NATA
 
accredited laboratory for
analysis. Sampling
 
is undertaken
 
by a
 
suitably trained
 
and competent
 
person in
 
accordance with
 
Australian
Standard AS/NZS 5667.11:1998
 
– Water Quality Sampling.
Future underground mining requires a rigorous
 
understanding of groundwater systems. In
 
2023, a network of
monitoring bores and Vibrating Wire Piezometers (VWP) was installed in preparation for underground mining.
All bores
 
have dataloggers with
 
satellite telemetry. The new
 
boreholes are
 
tested monthly
 
for insitu
 
parameters,
and a standard suite of laboratory tests conducted by
 
NATA
 
accredited laboratory.
Detailed
 
hydrological
 
modelling
 
has
 
been
 
carried
 
out
 
in
 
order
 
to
 
obtain
 
approvals
 
from
 
the
 
environmental
authorities
 
for
 
existing
 
operations
 
and
 
new
 
modelling
 
is
 
being
 
undertaken
 
for
 
future
 
underground
 
mining
operations.
ex961p34i0
 
Page 32 of 118
Figure 7-4 Hydro Monitoring Sites
 
Page 33 of 118
7.3
 
Geotechnical Data
Geotechnical
 
data
 
is
 
collected
 
to
 
facilitate
 
geotechnical
 
assessments,
 
analysis
 
and
 
design,
 
with
 
the
 
aim
 
of
ensuring that the geotechnical risks encountered at Curragh
 
are appropriately understood and managed.
Geotechnical
 
ground
 
models
 
are
 
the
 
basis
 
on
 
which
 
geotechnical
 
assessments,
 
analysis
 
and
 
design
 
is
completed
 
and
 
need
 
to
 
be
 
informed
 
by
 
a
 
level
 
of
 
data
 
appropriate
 
to
 
the
 
design
 
phase.
 
The
 
geotechnical
ground
 
model
 
is
 
comprised
 
of
 
the:
 
Geological
 
Model,
 
Structural
 
Model,
 
Material
 
Properties
 
Model
 
and
Hydrogeological Model.
The development of geotechnical
 
ground models to support
 
mine planning is informed
 
by operational data (i.e.
geological mapping, survey
 
pick-ups, rock mass
 
defect logging etc.)
 
and exploration data
 
(i.e. drill hole
 
data,
down hole geophysical data, seismic surveys, piezometers
 
etc.).
The Curragh Safety Health Management System (Curragh
 
SHMS) provides instructions on how geotechnical
risks
 
at
 
Curragh
 
are
 
identified,
 
reported,
 
and
 
managed.
 
The
 
Curragh
 
Planning
 
System
 
(CPS)
 
is
 
used
 
in
conjunction with
 
the Curragh
 
SHMS and provisions
 
under the
 
relevant SHMS
 
documents, to
 
define the
 
data
requirements,
 
and
 
associated
 
data
 
management
 
systems,
 
necessary
 
to
 
inform
 
geotechnical
 
assessments,
analysis and design.
7.3.0
 
2022 to 2023 Geotechnical Logging and Material Testing
 
Curragh
 
has
 
undertaken
 
geotechnical
 
logging,
 
sampling
 
and
 
material
 
testing
 
of
 
select
 
boreholes
 
to
 
help
support the on-going development of the geotechnical
 
ground models.
 
7.3.1
 
2022 Geotechnical Borehole Locations
 
A total
 
of twenty-four
 
(24)
 
sites in
 
Curragh Main
 
and fourteen
 
(14) sites
 
in Curragh
 
North were
 
selected for
geotechnical
 
logging,
 
sampling
 
and
 
material
 
testing
 
in
 
2022
 
(refer
 
to
 
Table
 
7.5,
 
Table
 
7.6,
 
Figure
 
7-4
 
and
Figure 7-5).
 
These sites are comprised of geotechnically logged and sampled
 
HQ sized diamond core boreholes.
 
7.3.2
 
2023 Geotechnical Borehole Locations
A total
 
of eighteen
 
(18) sites
 
in Curragh
 
Main and
 
twenty-four (24)
 
sites in
 
Curragh North
 
(including four
 
(4)
boreholes within MDL162) were selected
 
for geotechnical logging, sampling and
 
material testing in 2023
 
(refer
to Table
 
7.7 ,Table
 
7.8, Figure 7-4 and Figure 7-5).
 
These sites comprised of HQ sized diamond core geotechnically
 
logged and sampled boreholes.
 
Four (4)
 
of these
 
boreholes were
 
selected for
 
further diagnostic
 
fracture injection
 
tests (DFIT)
 
and drill
 
stem
tests (DST) across the Mammoth and Mackenzie coal seams and within the Mackenzie Interburden as part of
the Curragh Gas Project.
 
7.3.3
 
Geotechnical Borehole Logging, Sampling and Material
 
Testing
Geotechnical logging was
 
undertaken using the
 
Australian coal industry
 
standard – ACARP
 
Project CoalLog
v3.1 and in line with Australia Standards for Geotechnical
 
Site Investigations (AS 1726 2017).
 
Geotechnical samples were collected and recorded by
 
trained and competent geologists, in line with Curragh
processes and work instructions
 
for the appropriate selection,
 
storage, handling and transport of
 
samples.
 
The
selection
 
of
 
samples
 
for
 
testing
 
and
 
determination
 
of
 
associated
 
testing
 
parameters
 
was
 
undertaken
 
by
appropriately qualified geotechnical engineers.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 34 of 118
7.3.4
 
On-Site Geotechnical Testing
7.3.4.1
 
Point Load Testing
Point
 
Load
 
Testing
 
(PLT)
 
on
 
selected
 
HQ
 
core
 
were
 
conducted
 
on-site
 
by
 
suitably
 
trained
 
and
 
competent
geologists. PLT
 
was completed
 
using a
 
calibrated PLT
 
Model 6510
 
from HMA
 
Geotechnical and
 
in line
 
with
AS 4133.4.1-2007.
7.3.4.2
 
Immersion Testing
Immersion testing
 
on selected
 
HQ core
 
was conducted
 
on-site by
 
suitably trained
 
and competent
 
geologists
in line with CPS.
7.3.4.3
 
Geotechnical Laboratory Testing
Geotechnical
 
laboratory
 
testing
 
was
 
undertaken
 
by
 
National
 
Association
 
of
 
Testing
 
Authorities
 
(NATA
accredited laboratories
 
in line
 
with Australian
 
Standards (AS)
 
and/or International
 
Standards (ASTM)
 
(Table
7.4).
 
A summary of the geotechnical laboratory testing completed is
 
provided in Table
 
7.4.
 
Table 7.4 Geotechnical Laboratory Testing: Australian Standards (AS) International
Standards (ASTM) and No. of Completed Tests 2022-23
Test
Standard
No. of Completed Test
Uniaxial Compressive Strength
 
Rock Moisture Content
AS 4133.4.2.2
AS 4133.1.1.1
298
Uniaxial Compressive Strength & Deformation
Test
 
Rock Moisture Content
AS 4133.4.3.2
AS 4133.1.1.1
204
Direct Shear Test
ASTM D5607
59
Strength of Rock Material in Triaxial
Compression
ASTM D7012
7
Slake Durability Index Test
AS 4133.3.4
177
Indirect Tensile
 
Strength
 
ASTM D3967
185
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 35 of 118
Hole ID
Completio
n Year
Lease
Easting
Northing
RL
Survey
Accuracy
Total
Depth (m)
Drilling
Completion
Date
Samples Sent to External
Laboratory for
Geotechnical Testing
Core
Photographs
Downhole
Geophysics
Acoustic Scanner
(ATV)
In Field Point Load Data
Collected
In Field Immersion
Tests
DFIT &
DST
Testing
18458C
2022
ML1878
690390.51
7396253.52
165.01
Surveyed
102.00
31/07/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18459C
2022
ML1878
689591.47
7396454.12
168.04
Surveyed
42.00
4/08/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
18464C
2022
ML1878
689932.82
7396107.03
169.08
Surveyed
89.89
22/08/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18435C
2022
ML80110
692614.98
7416655.02
138.16
Surveyed
114.07
9/04/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18436C
2022
ML80110
692469.32
7416310.65
133.82
Surveyed
99.05
11/04/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18437C
2022
ML80110
692719.34
7416450.32
130.98
Surveyed
120.00
12/04/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18438C
2022
ML80110
692565.23
7416469.16
135.41
Surveyed
101.90
15/04/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18439C
2022
ML80110
692622.33
7416186.45
129.56
Surveyed
114.20
16/04/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18440C
2022
ML80110
692761.08
7416738.6
138.65
Surveyed
132.19
18/04/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18441C
2022
ML80110
692747.29
7418700.75
113.59
Surveyed
162.42
1/05/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18442C
2022
ML80110
692779.65
7418921.44
129.75
Surveyed
120.00
4/05/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18443C
2022
ML80110
692774.31
7418582.18
112.65
Surveyed
162.28
17/05/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18444C
2022
ML80110
692793.91
7418478.63
113.96
Surveyed
162.30
27/05/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18445C
2022
ML80110
692730.09
7418791.05
112.58
Surveyed
162.08
29/05/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18446C
2022
ML80110
692610.78
7418442.73
51.63
Surveyed
78.17
6/06/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18447C
2022
ML80110
692631.67
7418307.46
54.18
Surveyed
78.05
8/06/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18448C
2022
ML80110
692898.38
7418635.84
134.42
Surveyed
132.19
11/06/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18449C
2022
ML80110
692875.79
7418775.21
133.62
Surveyed
132.58
12/06/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18450C
2022
ML80110
692790.76
7418284.21
98.72
Surveyed
138.08
21/06/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18479C
2022
ML80110
694200.22
7416070.65
139.53
Surveyed
324.54
26/09/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
18481C
2022
ML80110
693370.39
7420976.07
124.62
Surveyed
300.89
8/10/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
18482C
2022
ML80110
692470.73
7424159.36
124.94
Surveyed
214.00
11/11/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18483C
2022
ML80110
692051.77
7415848.3
128.28
Surveyed
126.12
15/11/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
18484C
2022
ML80110
691788.64
7415674.19
126.39
Surveyed
120.03
29/11/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Table 7.5 2022 Curragh North Geotechnical Drilling
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 36 of 118
Hole ID
Completio
n Year
Lease
Easting
Northing
RL
Survey
Accuracy
Total
Depth (m)
Drilling
Completion
Date
Samples Sent to External
Laboratory for
Geotechnical Testing
Core
Photographs
Downhole
Geophysics
Acoustic Scanner
(ATV)
In Field Point Load Data
Collected
In Field Immersion
Tests
DFIT &
DST
Testing
18421C
2022
ML8008
6
693196
7400988.68
156.49
Surveyed
95.09
15/03/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18422C
2022
ML8008
6
693166.01
7400596.12
156.34
Surveyed
101.3
17/03/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18423C
2022
ML8008
6
694001.47
7400767.62
161.69
Surveyed
96
19/03/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18431C
2022
ML8008
6
693829.43
7401050.63
156
Surveyed
95
26/03/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18433C
2022
ML8008
6
693694.72
7400778.78
157.83
Surveyed
95
28/03/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18434C
2022
ML8008
6
693713.19
7400530.49
161.08
Surveyed
83
31/03/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18451C
2022
ML8008
6
693498.69
7400103.62
160.74
Surveyed
101
15/07/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18452C
2022
ML8008
6
693718.94
7400326.65
161.76
Surveyed
95
17/07/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18453C
2022
ML8008
6
693458.79
7400402.16
159.13
Surveyed
95
19/07/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18454C
2022
ML8008
6
693825.21
7400208.22
165.43
Surveyed
95
23/07/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18455C
2022
ML8008
6
694044.15
7400087.91
166.04
Surveyed
95
26/07/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18456C
2022
ML8008
6
694283.77
7400116.8
167.57
Surveyed
108.07
28/07/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18460C
2022
ML8008
6
694640.9
7401615.1
158.82
Surveyed
134.42
13/08/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18461C
2022
ML8008
6
694546.33
7399913.2
169.83
Surveyed
120.42
14/08/2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
Table 7.6 2022 Curragh Main Geotechnical Drilling
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 37 of 118
Hole
ID
Completion
Year
Lease
Easting
Northing
RL
Survey
Accuracy
Total
Depth (m)
Drilling
Completion
Date
Samples Sent to External
Laboratory for
Geotechnical Testing
Core
Photographs
Downhole
Geophysics
Acoustic Scanner
(ATV)
In Field Point Load Data
Collected
In Field Immersion
Tests
DFIT &
DST
Testing
18491
C
2023
ML8011
0
692356.34
7414854.51
128.08
Surveyed
182
25/02/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
18492
C
2023
ML8011
0
692752.55
7415224.32
127.55
Surveyed
174.07
4/03/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
18493
C
2023
ML8011
0
693709.67
7416081.23
140.82
Surveyed
300.07
8/03/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
18494
C
2023
ML8011
0
693205.41
7414989.29
125.42
Surveyed
228.04
19/03/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
18532
C
2023
ML8011
0
693906.13
7418104.2
175.09
Surveyed
366.09
11/05/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
18533
C
2023
ML8011
0
693473.03
7418626.8
155.24
Surveyed
300.06
20/05/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
18536
C
2023
ML8011
0
692944.55
7418117.61
133.62
Surveyed
222.45
20/05/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
18537
C
2023
ML8011
0
692800.84
7419347
130.29
Surveyed
228
4/06/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
18538
C
2023
ML8011
0
693338.4
7415532.98
129.64
Surveyed
252.46
10/06/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
18542
C
2023
ML8011
0
692858.85
7420123.11
127.31
Surveyed
252
18/06/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
18546
C
2023
ML8011
0
693446.66
7418113.15
161.87
Surveyed
289.9
11/07/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
18573
C
2023
ML8011
0
691999.8
7415584.79
123.2
Surveyed
57.2
22/09/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18587
C
2023
ML8011
0
691843.27
7420307.70
8
126.97
Surveyed
180.28
1/11/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
20808
C
2023
ML8011
0
692913.66
7415971.49
132.56
Surveyed
201.53
28/03/2023
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
22058
C
2023
ML8011
0
692836.76
7414697.05
126.59
Surveyed
204.48
27/03/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
22059
C
2023
ML8011
0
693173.49
7416270.35
134.96
Surveyed
258.28
18/04/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
22062
C
2023
ML8011
0
692361.79
7415473.77
127.72
Surveyed
174.18
25/04/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
22063
C
2023
ML8011
0
693304.56
7419168.77
143.87
Surveyed
282.09
8/03/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
22089
2023
ML8011
0
693214.83
7419556.88
139.66
Surveyed
284.00
20/06/2023
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
22101
C
2023
ML8011
0
692447.22
7423352.68
166.11
Surveyed
329.9
26/08/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
22102
C
2023
MDL162
694532.01
7417576.79
143.84
Surveyed
348.36
16/09/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
22103
C
2023
MDL162
694864.6
7416659.39
144.42
Surveyed
402.08
25/09/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
22104
C
2023
MDL162
694681.51
7415806.01
144.08
Surveyed
375.25
5/10/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
22105
C
2023
MDL162
694729.23
2
7414860.30
9
130.00
Surveyed
345.42
17/10/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
22100
C
2023
ML7000
08
691864.2
7413476.33
128.11
Surveyed
54.23
24/08/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Table 7.7 2023 Curragh North Geotechnical Drilling
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 38 of 118
Hole
ID
Completion
Year
Lease
Easting
Northing
RL
Survey
Accuracy
Total
Depth (m)
Drilling
Completion
Date
Samples Sent to External
Laboratory for
Geotechnical Testing
Core
Photographs
Downhole
Geophysics
Acoustic Scanner
(ATV)
In Field Point Load Data
Collected
In Field Immersion
Tests
DFIT &
DST
Testing
18485
C
2023
ML8008
6
695027.24
7403034.28
152.99
Surveyed
144.24
26/01/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
18486
C
2023
ML8008
6
693975.49
7401275.99
159.46
Surveyed
96
30/01/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18487
C
2023
ML8008
6
693807.37
7399914.9
163.01
Surveyed
108.04
11/02/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18488
C
2023
ML8008
6
693956.08
7399572.65
163.94
Surveyed
79
15/02/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
18489
C
2023
ML8008
6
695229.39
7401176.59
156.74
Surveyed
126
17/02/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
18490
C
2023
ML8008
6
694299.11
7399473.99
166.3
Surveyed
83.3
20/02/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
18504
C
2023
ML8008
6
694569.07
7400317.27
168.55
Surveyed
102
4/04/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18510
C
2023
ML8008
6
694770.5
7399550.52
172.43
Surveyed
138
14/04/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18524
C
2023
ML8008
6
693834.83
7399742.35
162.31
Surveyed
101.98
27/04/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18541
C
2023
ML8008
6
694178.53
7401765.46
165.73
Surveyed
108
16/06/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
18543
C
2023
ML8008
6
694252.83
7399857.19
167.91
Surveyed
96
22/06/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18544
C
2023
ML8008
6
694161.57
7399475.41
166.84
Surveyed
126.18
26/06/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18551
C
2023
ML8008
6
694672.81
7399322.73
176.23
Surveyed
150.01
23/07/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18552
C
2023
ML8008
6
694397.71
7399093.68
177.81
Surveyed
162
30/07/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18554
C
2023
ML8008
6
694377.74
7399298.84
176.66
Surveyed
143.8
3/08/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18555
C
2023
ML8008
6
694907.44
7399849.69
172.6
Surveyed
150
10/08/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18560
C
2023
ML8008
6
694348.4
7400297.28
167.85
Surveyed
114
19/08/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18561
C
2023
ML8008
6
694583.49
7400531.59
167.64
Surveyed
132.07
22/08/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
18562
C
2023
ML8008
6
694724.28
7402251.06
152.6
Surveyed
156
25/08/2023
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
Table 7.8 2023 Curragh Main Geotechnical Drilling
ex961p41i0
 
Page 39 of 118
Figure 7-4 Curragh Main Sample Sites
ex961p42i0
 
Page 40 of 118
Figure 7-5 Curragh North Sample Sites
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 41 of 118
8
 
Sample Preparation, Analysis and Security
 
8.1
 
Prior to Sending to the Lab and Lab Procedures
Handling of
 
coal and
 
rock samples
 
at Curragh
 
follows standard
 
procedures used
 
in the
 
coal mining
 
industry
with
 
regard
 
to
 
preparation,
 
analysis
 
and
 
security.
 
Likewise,
 
laboratory
 
tests
 
are
 
performed
 
according
 
to
standards
 
utilized
 
internationally.
 
In
 
this
 
instance,
 
Curragh’s
 
standards
 
are
 
based
 
upon
 
the
 
Australian
Standards which are stated as applicable for this analysis.
Curragh
 
has
 
used
 
an
 
independent
 
laboratory
 
ALS
 
Coal
 
(formerly
 
ACIRL)
 
since
 
1983,
 
now
 
located
 
at
 
478
Freeman
 
Rd,
 
Richlands
 
QLD
 
4077
 
for
 
all
 
exploration
 
coal
 
quality
 
determinations.
 
ALS
 
is
 
regularly
benchmarked against ISO 17025. by reputable organisations
 
such as NATA.
The coal laboratory performs a specific workflow of
 
testing that is compatible for testing of
 
coking, thermal and
PCI
 
coals.
 
The
 
testing
 
comprises
 
sample
 
pre-treatment,
 
raw
 
coal
 
quality
 
analysis,
 
washability
 
and
 
product
composite testing
 
which is
 
suitable for
 
full beneficiation
 
and market
 
product characterization.
 
This testing
 
is
conducted
 
under
 
Australian
 
and
 
international
 
standards
 
samples
 
including
 
but
 
not
 
limited to
 
those
 
listed
 
in
Table
 
8.1.
Table 8.1: Analytical Test
 
Standards Numbers – Coal Quality
Analytical Test
Standard No
Ash
AS1038.3
Ash Fusibility
AS1038.15
Carbon
AS1038.15
Crucible Swelling Number
AS1038.12.1
Dilatometer
AS1038.12.3
Fixed Carbon
AS1038.3
Float/Sink Analysis
AS4156.1
Gieseler
AS1038.12.4.1
Hydrogen
AS1038.6.4
Moisture (residual)
AS1038.3
Moisture Holding Capacity
AS1038.17
Nitrogen
AS1038.6.4
Oxygen
AS1038.16
Phosphorus
BS1016.14
Relative Density
AS1038.21.1.1
Size Analysis
AS3881
Gross Calorific Value
AS1038.5
Total
 
Moisture
AS1038.1
Total
 
Sulfur
AS1038.6.3.3
Volatile Matter
AS1038.3
Ash Analysis
AS1038.14.3
Proximate Analysis
AS 1038
Geotechnical
 
testing
 
is
 
conducted
 
under
 
Australian
 
and
 
international
 
standards
 
samples
 
including
 
but
 
not
limited to those listed in
 
Table 8.2. Geotechnical testing in last five years has been completed by Trilab Pty
 
Ltd
at
 
362
 
Bilset
 
Rd
 
Geebung
 
Qld
 
4034
 
or
 
Strata
 
Testing
 
Services
 
Pty
 
Ltd
 
at
 
Unit
 
2,
 
77
 
Jardine
 
Street
 
Fairy
Meadow, N.S.W 2519 Australia
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 42 of 118
Table 8.2: Analytical Test
 
Standards Numbers – Geotechnical
Analytical Test
Standard No
Geotechnical Site Investigations
AS 1726 2017
Uniaxial Compressive Strength
AS 4133.4.2.2
Uniaxial Compressive Strength &
Deformation Test
AS 4133.4.3.2
Direct Shear Test
ASTM D5607
Strength Of Rock Material In Triaxial
Compression
ASTM D7012
Slake Durability Index Test
AS 4133.3.4
Rock Moisture Content
AS 4133.1.1.1
Atterberg Limits Test
AS 1289 2.1.1, 3.2.1, 3.3.1,
3.4.1
It is
 
the opinion of
 
the Qualified Person
 
that samples are
 
collected, dispatched, prepared,
 
analysed and verified
adequately for subsequent Resource and Reserve evaluation
 
and estimation.
9
 
Data Verification
 
9.1
 
Limitations of Verification
In a small percentage
 
of drillholes, downhole geophysical
 
records have been
 
lost or not stored
 
securely over
the
 
mine
 
life.
 
In
 
these
 
instances,
 
hole
 
logs
 
are
 
reviewed
 
for
 
detailed
 
logging
 
as
 
would
 
be
 
the
 
practice
 
if
geophysical
 
logs
 
were
 
available
 
and
 
corrected
 
by
 
a
 
geologist.
 
As
 
addition
 
checks,
 
seam
 
thicknesses
 
are
compared to surrounding data for consistency and excluded
 
if in doubt.
Some
 
of
 
the
 
historical
 
drilling
 
in
 
deeper
 
parts
 
of
 
MDL162
 
was
 
not
 
able
 
to
 
be
 
fully
 
validated
 
due
 
to
 
lack
 
of
original survey records
 
and geologists written logs.
 
Greater uncertainty is
 
placed on this
 
drilling data. However,
seismic data indicates
 
the presence of
 
strong reflectors
 
that are aligned
 
with boreholes
 
records. Where data
is considered less reliable, the coal resources are classified
 
as lower confidence resources i.e. Inferred.
 
9.2
 
Procedures of Qualified Person
 
The Qualified Person
 
has a long
 
history of working with
 
Coronado geological data and
 
production of geological
models and
 
Resource estimates.
 
The data
 
verification process
 
follows a
 
detailed process
 
for confirming
 
the
accuracy of data upon which subsequent Resource and
 
reserve estimation is based. This process includes:
●
 
Collar survey checks relative to topographic surfaces
●
 
Checking downhole geophysics against interpreted coal thickness
●
 
Correlation seam sequence checks within boreholes
●
 
Correlation checks from hole to hole through sectioning
 
geological database
●
 
Checking seam thickness, mid-burden and structure plots
●
 
Validating mined
 
out polygons against LIDAR surfaces
●
 
Reconciliation of variance of model iterations
●
 
Reconciliation of variance of Resource estimate iterations
 
9.3
 
Opinion of Qualified Person
In the opinion
 
of the Qualified
 
Person Mr
 
Barry Lay,
 
there has
 
been sufficient
 
data obtained
 
through various
exploration and
 
sampling programs
 
and mining
 
operations to
 
support the
 
geological interpretations
 
of seam
structure and thickness
 
for coal horizons
 
situated on the
 
Curragh property.
 
The data seem
 
to be of
 
sufficient
quantity and reliability to reasonably support the Coal Resource
 
and Coal Reserve estimates in this TRS.
 
 
 
Page 43 of 118
10
 
Mineral Processing and Metallurgical Testing
 
10.1
 
Testing Procedures and Sample Representatives
Laboratory testing procedures begin with a routine to ensure that each sample
 
is representative of typical run-
of-mine feed
 
and Coal
 
Prep Plant
 
(CPP) feed
 
involving
 
a process
 
including drop
 
shattering, dry
 
sizing, wet
tumbling and wet screening of coal samples.
These pre-treated samples are analysed
 
using a washability testing procedure
 
which estimates the yield and
ash at various density
 
cut points. This information
 
is subsequently used in
 
plant simulator (developed by A
 
and
B
 
Mylec
 
Pty
 
Ltd
 
(A&B
 
Mylec))
 
to
 
estimate
 
yield
 
and
 
product
 
quality
 
after
 
applying
 
plant
 
and
 
equipment
efficiency factors.
Test
 
samples are collected as sufficient density
 
to adequately represent the Resource at the level
 
of reported
Resource and reserve classification. The testing provides sufficient information to
 
determine the coal type (ie.
Coking, PCI
 
or Thermal).
 
There has
 
historically been
 
a good correlation
 
between laboratory
 
test results
 
and
train or shipping results.
10.2
 
Laboratory Details
Curragh has used an independent laboratory
 
now trading as ALS Coal
 
(“ALS”) since 1983, now located
 
at 478
Freeman Rd, Richlands QLD 4077 for all exploration coal
 
quality determinations.
 
ALS is accredited by NATA
NATA
 
assesses
 
that
 
ALS
 
has
 
appropriately
 
trained
 
people,
 
systems
 
and
 
controls.
 
A
 
NATA
 
assessed
 
coal
quality laboratory is certified against ISO/IEC 17025:2017.
Testing
 
is conducted against appropriate Australian
 
and international standards. The most
 
common standard
numbers are as per Table
 
8.1.
10.3
 
Assumptions and Prediction
Resource recovery estimates are based
 
on inputs of extensive
 
coal quality borehole testing
 
which provide run-
of-mine feed sizing, yield and expected product quality.
Expected processing product
 
yields are estimated
 
using coal borecore
 
information and coal
 
loss and dilution
assumptions
 
validated
 
through
 
mine
 
reconciliations.
 
A
 
process
 
simulator
 
developed
 
by
 
A&B
 
Mylec
 
applies
loss, dilution,
 
and plant
 
efficiency factors to
 
derive final
 
yield and quality
 
information at each
 
borehole datapoint.
This data
 
is then
 
modelled in
 
Vulcan software
 
for import
 
to mine
 
scheduling tools.
 
There are
 
no deleterious
elements that have not already been factored in reserves estimates and modelling that would have significant
impact on economic extraction.
 
10.4
 
Opinion of Qualified Person
 
Sufficient
 
metallurgical
 
testing
 
data
 
has
 
been obtained
 
through
 
various
 
exploration
 
and
 
sampling
 
programs
and mining operations to reasonably support the Coal Resource
 
and Coal Reserve estimates in this TRS.
 
 
 
Page 44 of 118
11
 
Mineral Resource Estimates
 
11.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
Coal Resources were estimated as of December 31, 2023.
Resology Pty Ltd independently created two geological models – one at the end of March 2023 and a second
model (sub-set) in August 2023 which
 
included more recent drilling in
 
underground mining areas.
 
Each model
was constructed
 
in MAPTEK
 
Vulcan
 
modelling software.
 
Both models
 
have been
 
used for
 
the estimation
 
of
Coal Resources and Reserve estimates as discussed in
 
the TRS.
The modelling process follows extensive validation of drillhole data. The model included drillholes available in
the company geological database at end
 
of March 2023 for the larger model
 
and August 2023 for the smaller
model.
The March 2023 geological model comprises a 50m grid cell model encompassing all of Curragh’s tenements
and seams within
 
the Rangal Coal
 
Measures only. Seams in the
 
Burngrove Formation have
 
not been modelled
or estimated.
 
The August
 
model comprised
 
a 10m
 
grid cell
 
encompassing the
 
underground potential
 
areas
down dip of the open-cut at Curragh North.
The geological model
 
s
 
include multiple
 
model types
 
including seam
 
roof and floor,
 
base of quaternary,
 
base
of weathering,
 
raw quality,
 
coking and
 
thermal quality
 
and simulated
 
yield and
 
product quality.
 
At Resource
classification
 
stage,
 
thickness
 
and
 
ash
 
cut-offs
 
were
 
applied.
 
Resource
 
classification
 
methodology
 
and
assumptions are discussed under section 11.4.
 
Coal Resource
 
were calculated
 
from a
 
series of
 
seam area
 
polygons (split
 
by resource
 
confidence) against
insitu geological models.
 
The density grid
 
was derived from
 
a seam ash
 
vs relative density
 
regression equation
with an
 
adjustment for
 
estimated insitu
 
moisture (5.3%).
 
MAPTEK RSVUTE
 
software was
 
used to
 
calculate
the resource tonnes for each seam and each resource
 
confidence category.
 
Mining surveyed face positions as
 
of September 30, 2023, were used
 
as a starting point of the
 
estimate, with
three
 
months
 
of
 
mining
 
depletion
 
(Sep
 
23–
 
Dec
 
23)
 
applied
 
to
 
give
 
coal
 
final
 
Resource
 
estimate
 
at
December 31, 2023.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 45 of 118
11.2
 
Qualified Person’s Resource Estimate
Based on the
 
assumptions and methodology described, a
 
Coal Resource estimate, summarized in
 
Table 11.1,
was prepared as of December 31, 2023, for property controlled
 
by Coronado.
 
Table 11.1:
 
Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2023
Area
Measu
red
(Mt)
Indicated
(Mt)
Meas +
Ind
Inferre
d (Mt)
Total
(Mt)
Ash %
VM %
Sulphur
%
Opencut
Inclusive of
Reserves
 
217
25
242
-
242
18.7
19.2
0.57
Exclusive of
Reserves
 
167
81
247
54
302
22.9
19.1
0.59
Total Opencut
383
106
489
54
543
21.0
19.1
0.58
Underground
Inclusive of
Reserves
 
140
44
183
-
183
14.9
18.2
0.39
Exclusive of
Reserves
 
41
62
103
106
209
18.6
18.1
0.39
Total
 
Underground
181
106
286
106
392
16.9
18.2
0.39
Total Resources
564
211
775
160
936
19.2
18.7
0.50
Notes
(i)
 
Total Coal Resources (936Mt) are reported inclusive of Reserves
(ii)
 
Coal Resource tonnes are reported on a 5.3%
 
in-situ Moisture basis
 
(iii)
 
Coal qualities are reported on an air-dried
 
basis
(iv)
 
Underground resources are those that are approximately
 
>15:1 vertical strip ratio or those overlapping
 
underground mining
 
Resources are reported into two subsets:
●
 
Inclusive of
 
Reserves
 
– Those
 
Coal Resources
 
that occur
 
within the
 
defined boundaries
 
LOM Plan
Reserves
Inclusive
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
are
 
calculated
 
from
 
cut-offs
 
described
 
in
 
section
 
11.3
 
and
 
resource
confidence polygonl
 
to determine Measured and Indicated resources.
 
These same coal resources are
the basis for Reserves
Reserves
 
have
 
been
 
assessed
 
for
 
economic
 
viability
 
in
 
the
 
Reserves
 
estimation
 
process
 
using
Modifying Factors and cut-off parameters as discussed
 
in section 12 of this TRS
●
 
Exclusive of Reserves – Those Coal
 
Resources that occur outside the defined
 
boundaries of the LOM
Plan Reserves
Exclusive
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
are
 
calculated
 
from
 
cut-offs
 
described
 
in
 
section
 
11.3
 
and
 
resource
confidence polygon to determine Measured and Indicated and
 
Inferred Resources
The Inclusive and Exclusive Coal Resources are also split
 
into open-cut and underground categories.
The total coal
 
Resources within
 
the project
 
concession boundaries
 
are approximately
 
936
 
million tonnes,
 
as
determined at
 
an effective
 
year end.
 
Compared
 
to established
 
criteria,
 
this quantity
 
of Resources
 
classifies
Curragh as a large coal mining proposition.
 
11.3
 
Cut-off thickness and insitu ash
Open cut Resources
 
have been estimated
 
where thickness is greater
 
than 0.3 metres
 
and raw insitu
 
ash below
50% (air-dried basis).
 
 
Page 46 of 118
Underground Resources
 
have been
 
estimated where
 
the insitu
 
coal thickness
 
is greater
 
than 1.8m.
 
No ash
cut-off has been applied as all reported seams
 
have low insitu ash (<~20% air-dried).
 
Underground Resources are
 
those that
 
can potentially be
 
accessed from final
 
open-cut highwall using
 
a variety
of techniques including but not limited to board and pillar
 
mining techniques and highwall mining.
 
Underground resources have been
 
defined as those that
 
are part of underground
 
reserves or in areas where
no reserves are declared, where the vertical overburden to
 
tonnes of insitu coal ratio is greater than 15:1
Deeper potential
 
mineralization that
 
is poorly
 
defined through
 
exploration or
 
not easily
 
accessible from
 
final
open-cut highwalls has been excluded from the Resource
 
Estimate.
 
11.4
 
Resources Exclusive of Reserves
 
Curragh
 
tenements
 
contain
 
Resources
 
exclusive
 
of
 
Reserves
 
which
 
have
 
not
 
been
 
included
 
in
 
the
 
current
mine plan (Table
 
11.1). Reasons
 
that may preclude elevation
 
for Resources to Reserves
 
include, but are not
limited to:
 
●
 
Insufficient
 
data
 
and/or
 
incomplete
 
technical
 
studies
 
to
 
justify
 
the
 
conversion
 
of
 
coal
 
Resources
 
to
Reserves
 
●
 
Open
 
cut
 
Resources
 
that
 
may
 
not
 
justify
 
conversion
 
to
 
Reserves
 
with
 
current
 
mining
 
costs
 
and/or
short-term product price assumptions
 
Considering the
 
long-life of
 
Curragh assets,
 
changing technologies
 
and varying
 
market conditions
 
over time
provide options to revise Reserves periodically.
 
11.5
 
Initial Economic Assessment
 
Opencut
An initial economic assessment has been completed to determine whether there are
 
reasonable prospects for
economic extraction of open-cut resources
 
outside of reserves. There are
 
247Mt of Coal Resources estimated
as
 
potentially
 
suitable
 
for
 
open
 
cut
 
mining
 
pending
 
future
 
suitable
 
feasibility
 
analysis
 
and
 
study.
 
The
assessment
 
assumes
 
that
 
any
 
future
 
mining
 
of
 
these
 
resources
 
would
 
occur
 
after
 
the
 
depletion
 
of
 
current
LOMP
 
reserves
 
(>20
 
years).
 
It
 
is assumed
 
that
 
demand
 
for
 
metallurgical
 
product
 
will
 
continue
 
beyond
 
this
timeframe.
The
 
assessment
 
is
 
preliminary
 
in
 
nature
 
and
 
contains
 
inferred
 
mineral
 
resources
 
that
 
are
 
considered
 
too
speculative geologically
 
to have modifying
 
factors applied to
 
them that would
 
enable them to
 
be categorized
as mineral reserves, and there is no certainty that this
 
economic assessment will be realized.
The cut-off
 
grades used
 
in
 
the assessment
 
correspond
 
to those
 
in section
 
11.3.
 
The cut-off
 
grade is
 
within
range of normal current open-cut Operations. The total resource average Insitu ash grade is much lower than
the cut-off
 
grade.
 
The portion
 
of resource
 
that approach
 
cut-off
 
grade is
 
only a
 
small proportion
 
of the
 
total
resource.
The analysis has included mining costs, processing costs, transport, marketing,
 
sustaining capital and royalty
costs. A long term realized product price of $US133/t was assumed based at an average total product yield of
75% calculated from LOMP average
 
product mix and yield. Resources
 
exclusive or reserves are
 
expected to
yield a similar product mix and yield to the LOMP plan.
The initial economic analysis indicates that a
 
break-even strip ratio of 17.3 is appropriate
 
for Curragh open-cut
operations as per Figure 14. The opencut Coal Resource estimates in this TRS
 
have been calculated
 
using a
lesser strip ratio cut-off ratio of approximately15:1.
 
ex961p49i0
 
Page 47 of 118
Various assumption and
 
limitation of this analysis include:
o
 
Costs based on the 2023 Life-of-Mine Plan (LOMP)
o
 
The
 
product
 
ratio
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
average
 
yearly
 
product
 
ratio
 
from
 
the
 
2023
 
LOMP
 
and
approximate 40% coking, 30% PCI and 30% thermal.
o
 
An US exchange rate of $0.73
o
 
Cutoff thickness of 0.3m of mineable coal and
 
50% insitu ash
o
 
All thermal
 
tonnes are
 
sold
 
at export
 
thermal (higher
 
prices) after
 
the cessation
 
of lower
 
priced
domestic thermal contracts due to finish in 2037
o
 
No capital costs have been applied in evaluating resources outside of reserves due to
 
no detailed
studies available at time of publication
o
 
As high-wall
 
mining
 
has been
 
used at
 
Curragh in
 
the
 
past, it
 
is assumed
 
that some
 
of the
 
coal
resources outside of reserves will be available at end of pit
 
life albeit at a low recovery
Risk with converting the resources to reserves include:
o
 
Acquiring the regulatory approvals to mine through Blackwater
 
Creek
o
 
Acquiring the regulatory approval and capital required to divert
 
Blackwater Creek
o
 
High capital costs that render conversion of resources to reserves
 
un-economic
o
 
Unfavorable margins due to increasing costs and/or declining
 
product prices
Figure 14 Breakeven analysis vs strip ratio.
Underground
An initial economic assessment has been completed to determine whether there are
 
reasonable prospects for
economic
 
extraction
 
of
 
underground
 
resources
 
outside
 
of
 
underground
 
reserves.
 
There
 
are
 
209Mt
 
of
 
Coal
Resources estimated as potentially suitable for
 
underground mining. The assessment is
 
preliminary in nature
and contains
 
inferred
 
mineral
 
resources
 
that are
 
considered
 
too speculative
 
geologically
 
to have
 
modifying
factors applied to
 
them that would enable
 
them to be categorized
 
as mineral reserves, and
 
there is no
 
certainty
that this economic assessment will be realized.
To
 
determine
 
whether
 
there
 
are
 
reasonable
 
prospects
 
for
 
economic
 
extraction
 
of
 
these
 
underground
resources,
 
mining
 
cost
 
and
 
capital
 
cost
 
data
 
was
 
extracted
 
from
 
a
 
financial
 
model
 
used
 
in
 
definition
 
of
Underground
 
Reserves
 
defined
 
in
 
section
 
12.2
 
and
 
merged
 
with
 
the
 
actual
 
cost
 
data
 
for
 
downstream
ex961p50i0
 
Page 48 of 118
processing costs,
 
transport, marketing
 
and royalties
 
on the
 
same basis
 
as the
 
previous opencut
 
analysis as
used in the 2023 LOMP Plan. The analysis demonstrates
 
a positive net margin as per Figure 11
 
-1.
Underground resources are only
 
those that could be
 
accessed from end
 
of open-cut life
 
highwalls or resources
as extension to declared underground reserves.
Figure 11-1 – Underground cost per tonne vs average realized price per product tonne
Various assumption and
 
limitation of this analysis include:
o
 
Underground bord and pillar mining method
o
 
Cut-off thickness of 1.8m
o
 
Mining and capital costs derived from December 2023
 
cost model provided by Talisman
 
Pty Ltd
o
 
Other costs based on the 2023 LOMP
o
 
Assumed PCI product @74% yield and secondary PCI
 
yield @11% yield
o
 
Assumed average product price US$140/tonne
o
 
An US exchange rate of $0.73
Risks with converting the resources to reserves include:
●
 
As geological knowledge
 
of seam structure
 
and deformation is
 
somewhat limited towards the
 
Jellinbah
Fault, there is risk that geological complexity may preclude
 
any coal extraction adjacent to the fault
●
 
Significant portion
 
of the underground
 
resources are in
 
the inferred category
 
and contain considerable
risk associated with confirming acceptable continuity,
 
coal quality and product yield
●
 
High capital costs that render conversion of resources to reserves
 
un-economic
●
 
Unfavorable margins due to increasing costs and/or declining
 
product prices
●
 
Acquiring the appropriate regulatory approval for underground
 
mining
●
 
Some resources lie
 
within Mineral Development Licence
 
162 and would
 
require successful conversion
to a Mining Lease
11.6
 
Resource Classification and Estimate Uncertainty
 
Resource Classifications have been based on a borehole
 
geostatistical study conducted in 2020:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 49 of 118
Curragh Drillhole Spacing Analysis Project; Resology
 
Pty Ltd; October 2020
The
 
project
 
involved
 
exploratory
 
data
 
analysis
 
(“EDA”)
 
of
 
seam
 
thickness
 
and
 
quality
 
information
 
to
 
define
seam domains. Each seam domain was then assessed using
 
drillhole spacing analysis (“DHSA”) to calculate
the global estimation precision (“error”)
 
for each major seam. A
 
10-year mining rate was then
 
used to calculate
error at different drillhole spacings for use in Resource
 
classification process.
 
The
 
critical
 
Resource
 
variables
 
analyzed
 
were
 
seam
 
thickness
 
and
 
insitu
 
ash.
 
These
 
were
 
chosen
 
for
 
the
Resource estimate classification
 
as these parameters are
 
the main drivers of economics.
 
Ash exhibits a very
good
 
correlation
 
to
 
density
 
and
 
hence
 
density
 
was
 
not
 
analyzed
 
separately.
 
Ash
 
also
 
exhibits
 
a
 
good
correlation
 
to total
 
product
 
yield, a
 
proxy for
 
product tonnes.
 
Other
 
quality
 
parameters
 
are well
 
with
 
market
acceptability and not reviewed separately.
 
As all seam exhibit
 
different variability for thickness and
 
ash in different domains, a
 
variety of drillhole spacings
have
 
been
 
applied.
 
In
 
summary,
 
the
 
following
 
drillhole
 
spacing
 
ranges
 
(Table
 
11.2)
 
have
 
been
 
applied
 
for
thickness and ash to define reported Resource categories. The value chosen
 
will depend on which seam, and
which
 
domain
 
is being
 
estimated.
 
The
 
drillhole
 
spacings
 
for a
 
given
 
category
 
tend
 
to be
 
higher
 
at Curragh
North due to lower seam variability compared to coal seams
 
further south.
Table 11.2:
 
Ranges of drillhole spacing used to define coal Resource
 
categories (metres)
Measured
Indicated
Inferred
Thickness
 
500-1000m
 
800-2400m
 
2000-4000m
 
Ash
 
800-1000m
 
1400-1800m
 
3500m
 
 
For reported
 
categories
 
the following
 
precision
 
levels apply
 
(Table
 
11.3).
 
Resources
 
reported as
 
Measured
would be expected to be within +/- 10% on if mined over
 
a 10-year mining timeframe.
 
Table 11.3:
 
Resource Estimate Global Precision
Category
Global Estimation Precision
Measured
+/- 10%
Indicated
+/- 10%-20%
Inferred
+/- 20%-50%
11.7
 
Qualified Person ’s Opinion
 
It
 
is
 
the
 
Qualified
 
Person’s
 
opinion
 
that
 
the
 
Resource
 
estimate
 
is
 
an
 
accurate
 
and
 
fair
 
representation
 
of
 
Curragh’s
 
coal
 
Resource
 
and
 
that
 
all
 
issues
 
relating
 
to
 
relevant
 
technical
 
and
 
economic
 
factors
 
likely
 
to
influence
 
the
 
prospect
 
of
 
economic
 
extraction
 
can
 
be
 
resolved
 
by further
 
work
 
and/or
 
improvement
 
in
 
cost
base over time
 
with innovation and
 
improving mining technology
 
over a long
 
mine life.
 
Sufficient exploration
data is
 
supported by
 
a longstanding
 
history of
 
successful coal
 
production at
 
Curragh, further
 
increasing the
confidence of the Resource estimates.
 
11.8
 
Qualified Person ’s Credentials
 
Mr.
 
Barry
 
Lay,
 
BSc
 
Geology
 
(Hons);
 
MAusIMM;
 
possesses
 
the
 
necessary
 
credentials
 
as
 
a
 
member
 
of
 
the
AusIMM to serve as a Qualified Person for this TRS.
 
 
 
 
Page 50 of 118
12
 
Mineral Reserve Estimates
12.1
 
Open Cut
12.1.0
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
A
Coal Reserve is the economically mineable part of
 
a Measured and/or Indicated Coal Resource. It
 
includes
diluting materials and allowances
 
for losses, which may
 
occur when the material is
 
mined or extracted and is
defined
 
by
 
studies
 
as
 
appropriate
 
that
 
include
 
application
 
of
 
Modifying
 
Factors.
 
These
 
include,
 
but
 
are
 
not
restricted
 
to,
 
mining,
 
processing,
 
metallurgical,
 
infrastructure,
 
economic,
 
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
social
 
and
 
governmental
 
factors.
 
Such
 
studies
 
demonstrate
 
that,
 
at
 
the
 
time
 
of
 
reporting,
 
extraction
 
could
reasonably
 
be
 
justified.
 
Coal
 
Reserves
 
are
 
sub-divided,
 
in
 
order
 
of
 
decreasing
 
geological
 
confidence,
 
into
Proven and Probable classifications.
Proven Coal Reserves are the economically mineable
 
part of a Measured Coal Resource, adjusted
 
for diluting
materials and
 
allowances for
 
losses when
 
the material
 
is mined.
 
It is
 
based on
 
appropriate assessment
 
and
studies
 
in
 
consideration
 
of
 
and
 
adjusted
 
for
 
reasonably
 
assumed
 
modifying
 
factors.
 
These
 
assessments
demonstrate that extraction could be reasonably justified at
 
the time of reporting.
 
Probable
 
Coal
 
Reserves
 
are
 
the
 
economically
 
mineable
 
part
 
of
 
an
 
Indicated
 
Coal
 
Resource,
 
and
 
in
 
some
circumstances a Measured Coal Resource, adjusted for diluting materials and allowances for losses
 
when the
material
 
is
 
mined.
 
It
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
appropriate
 
assessment
 
and
 
studies
 
in
 
consideration
 
of
 
and
 
adjusted
 
for
reasonably assumed modifying factors.
 
These assessments demonstrate that extraction could be reasonably
justified at the time of reporting.
 
The Life
 
of Mine
 
plan pit
 
limits for
 
the Curragh
 
Open Cut
 
were defined
 
using a
 
combination of
 
methods. An
initial first
 
pass unconstrained pit
 
optimisation was undertaken
 
on the
 
geological Resource model
 
using Deswik
pseudoflow.
 
This uses
 
a block
 
model of
 
the resource
 
with the
 
Lerchs-Grossman
 
algorithm to
 
determine the
optimised pit
 
shell limits
 
for the
 
available Resource.
 
Modifying factors
 
were then
 
applied including
 
approved
Mining
 
Lease
 
and
 
Environmental
 
constraints
 
as
 
hard
 
limits
 
to
 
the
 
open
 
cut
 
mine
 
extents,
 
including
 
flood
protection
 
levee
 
banks
 
and
 
environmental
 
offset
 
and
 
protected
 
conservation
 
areas.
 
Installed
 
critical
infrastructure such
 
as the
 
Curragh Noth
 
Overland Conveyor
 
were also
 
taken into
 
consideration for
 
limits on
the open cut mine extents.
 
A
 
mine
 
design
 
was
 
developed
 
using
 
a
 
pitwall
 
batter
 
angle
 
and
 
benching
 
configuration
 
consistent
 
with
 
the
existing open cut operation mine
 
design and used to cut
 
a full mining reserve set
 
of waste and coal solids for
margin ranking
 
and
 
scheduling.
 
Mining
 
reserves
 
were cut
 
to beyond
 
the
 
initial
 
Deswik
 
pit optimiser
 
pitshell
extents where other constraints were not limiting the mining reserve. This was a
 
more detailed margin ranking
process could be undertaken in a scheduling package
 
to define the economic cut-off point of the open
 
cut.
 
The mining
 
reserve
 
solids
 
were imported
 
into the
 
mine
 
scheduling
 
software
 
package
 
SPRY
 
and
 
converted
from Insitu to ROM reserves using a number of mining
 
modifying factor assumptions as summarised in Table
12.1.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 51 of 118
Table 12.1 – Insitu to ROM Coal Modifying Factors
Insitu to ROM Coal Modifying Factors
Unit
Value
Roof Loss
cm
15.0
Roof Dilution
cm
7.5
Floor Loss
cm
0.0
Floor Dilution
cm
15.0
Minimum Coal Mining Thickness
m
0.5
Minimum Waste Mining Thickness
m
0.5
Insitu Raw Ash (adb) cutoff
%
45
 
ROM mining loss factor
%
2.0
Dilution density
t/bcm
2.4
Dilution Raw Ash (adb)
%
90
A
 
detailed
 
margin
 
ranking
 
process
 
was
 
undertaken
 
on
 
the
 
ROM
 
reserve
 
set
 
in
 
SPRY
 
using
 
Long
 
Term
benchmark
 
revenue
 
pricing
 
assumptions
 
and
 
product
 
realisation
 
percentages
 
from
 
benchmark.
 
These
assumptions were Coronado’s internal view
 
of the long-term market as at October 2023. An
 
average realised
price of USD 131/t has been
 
adopted in this margin ranking
 
analysis The average realised
 
price is a result of
the
 
benchmark
 
price
 
forecast
 
assumption
 
for
 
the
 
Premium
 
Low
 
Volatile
 
Hard
 
Coking
 
Coal
 
combined
 
with
appropriate
 
quality
 
discounts
 
and
 
other
 
price
 
adjustments
 
relevant
 
to
 
Curragh’s
 
product
 
mix.
 
This
 
was
 
the
economic cut-off price used to determine the economic
 
limits of open cut mining in the Curragh Reserve.
 
Costs applied to the margin rank included unit rate actual
 
Curragh mine site costs on a 3-year historical rolling
average of actuals.
 
The product coal
 
yield estimation was
 
derived from an
 
A&B Mylec washability
 
simulation
model gridset
 
that was
 
reserved with
 
the mining
 
solids on
 
each coal
 
ply level
 
for each
 
mining reserve
 
solid.
The margin
 
ranking process
 
for the
 
Curragh LOM
 
plan was
 
undertaken in
 
SPRY and
 
the output
 
determined
the
 
economic
 
cut-off
 
point
 
of
 
the
 
open
 
cut
 
mine
 
plan
 
where
 
other
 
hard
 
constraints
 
like
 
Mining
 
Leases
 
or
Environmental constraints weren’t limiting the mining
 
extents.
 
It should be noted that the open cut mine design in some
 
pits has taken some slightly margin negative blocks
in
 
order
 
to
 
maintain
 
the
 
operational
 
strike
 
length
 
for
 
efficient
 
dragline
 
waste
 
mining
 
operations.
 
These
 
loss
making blocks are offset with
 
positive margin mining blocks within
 
the strip, and a
 
strip by strip margin analysis
shows the strips overall in the mine plan are margin positive. The pits where this is occurring is T pit, L pit and
Z pit in particular.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 52 of 118
12.1.1
 
Open Cut Reserves Estimate
The Open Cut (ROM) Coal Reserve estimate for Curragh reported in Table 12.2 has been converted from the
Coal Resource estimate.
 
The Open Cut
 
Marketable Coal Reserve estimate
 
represents beneficiated or otherwise enhanced
 
coal product
where modifications
 
due to
 
mining, dilution
 
and processing
 
have been
 
considered and
 
is an
 
estimate of
 
the
marketable product achievable from the ROM Coal Reserve.
 
This is shown in Table
 
12.3.
The numbers
 
are based
 
on the
 
results and
 
findings of
 
the Qualified
 
Persons and
 
their application
 
of the
 
relevant
modifying factors to the
 
Coal Resource geological
 
model. The basis for
 
the conversion of
 
Coal Resources to
Coal Reserves
 
presented considers only
 
the Measured and
 
Indicated Coal Resources
 
are converted
 
to Proven
and Probable Coal Reserves respectively.
Table 12.2: Open Cut ROM Coal Reserve Summary as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Curragh
Proven
Probable
Total
Coal Quality of Reserve inclusive of loss and dilution
(adb)
Mt
Mt
Mt
Ash (%)
TS (%)
VM (%)
ROM tonnes
227
22
249
31.3
0.5
16.0
Table 12.3: Open Cut Marketable Coal Reserve Summary as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves
 
(Wet Tonnes, Washed
 
or Direct Shipped, Mt)
Quality (adb)
Curragh
By Reliability Category
Proven
Probable
Total
Ash%
Sulphur%
VM%
Product
tonnes
173
16
189
12.2
0.5
19.5
Notes:
a)
 
Coronado’s ownership is 100% of the Curragh Mine
b)
 
All tonnes are millions of metric tonnes (Mt).
c)
 
ROM Coal Reserves have been stated on a 7.5%
 
Moisture basis.
d)
 
Marketable Reserves
 
are stated
 
on a
 
9.5% moisture
 
basis, including
 
a combination
 
of surface
 
moisture and
 
inherent moisture.
e)
 
Coal qualities are reported on an air-dried
 
basis.
f)
 
Totals may not sum due to rounding.
12.1.2
 
Qualified Person’s Opinion
Mr. Daniel Millers BE (Mining) MAusIMM(CP) possesses the required experience
 
in open cut coal mining and
reserve estimation and credentials
 
as a member
 
of the AusIMM
 
to act as
 
a Qualified Person for
 
Coal Reserves
estimation in this TRS.
Determination
 
of
 
Marketable
 
Reserves
 
has
 
relied
 
on
 
Product
 
Coal
 
Quality
 
grids
 
and
 
washability
 
yield
simulation data
 
at defined
 
CHPP cut
 
points provided
 
by Coronado
 
which are
 
then reserved
 
and imported
 
to
the
 
scheduling
 
model
 
to
 
calculate
 
marketable
 
reserve
 
tonnes
 
and
 
coal
 
quality.
 
The
 
product
 
qualities
 
and
washability yield
 
simulation grids
 
are based
 
on modelling
 
completed by
 
AB Mylec.
 
The models
 
and outputs
appear
 
consistent
 
with
 
historical
 
production
 
results.
 
The
 
washability
 
simulation
 
and
 
coal
 
quality
 
grids
 
are
showing a
 
deterioration in
 
yield and
 
quality in
 
the Z
 
and X
 
pit opencut
 
development mining
 
areas. This
 
has
been factored
 
into the
 
mine plan,
 
however there
 
has been
 
no production
 
data to
 
reconcile against
 
in these
new greenfield development pit areas.
 
It is the opinion of Mr. Daniel Millers that this TRS accurately reflects
 
the Open Cut Coal Reserve estimate for
Curragh as defined by
 
the JORC Code and
 
SEC Regulation S-K 1300. Sufficient
 
exploration data is supported
by a long history
 
of 40 years successful open
 
cut coal production at Curragh, further
 
increasing the confidence
of the
 
Coal Reserve estimate.
 
The application of
 
modifying factors is
 
supported by a
 
combination of laboratory-
based data and practical historical mining knowledge from
 
the Curragh operation.
 
Page 53 of 118
12.2
 
Underground
12.2.0
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
The author
 
adopted
 
reasonable
 
assumptions
 
when
 
applying
 
the appropriate
 
modifying
 
factors to
 
Curragh’s
Resources
 
to
 
derive
 
reserve
 
estimates.
 
Such
 
modifying
 
factors
 
include
 
mining,
 
metallurgical,
 
economic,
marketing, legal, environmental, social and governmental
 
factors.
 
Proven Coal Reserves are the economically mineable part of a measured coal Resource, adjusted for diluting
materials and allowances
 
for losses when
 
the material is
 
mined.
 
It is based
 
on appropriate assessment
 
and
studies
 
in
 
consideration
 
of
 
and
 
adjusted
 
for
 
reasonably
 
assumed
 
modifying
 
factors.
 
These
 
assessments
demonstrate that extraction could be reasonably justified at
 
the time of reporting.
 
Probable
 
Coal
 
Reserves
 
are
 
the
 
economically
 
mineable
 
part
 
of
 
an
 
indicated
 
coal
 
Resource,
 
and
 
in
 
some
circumstances a measured coal Resource, adjusted for diluting materials and allowances for losses when the
material
 
is mined.
 
It
 
is based
 
on
 
appropriate
 
assessment
 
and
 
studies
 
in
 
consideration
 
of
 
and
 
adjusted
 
for
reasonably assumed modifying factors.
 
These assessments demonstrate that extraction could be reasonably
justified at the time of reporting.
 
Upon completion
 
of delineation
 
and calculation
 
of coal
 
Resources, a
 
Pre-Feasibility
 
Study of
 
Curragh North
area
 
for
 
both
 
target
 
seams
 
(Mammoth
 
Seam
 
and
 
Mackenzie
 
Seam)
 
and
 
subsequently
 
a
 
more
 
detailed
Operational Readiness Study (Feasibility Study
 
level of accuracy)
 
of the Southern Area
 
in the Mammoth Seam
was undertaken.
 
The Mine plan was
 
generated based on the forecast
 
mine plan and permit
 
plan using current
property control limits, modifications to geologic mapping, or
 
other factors determined during the
 
evaluation.
The planned Mammoth Seam working section is for a minimum primary extraction of 2.5m and a maximum of
3.5m in combination
 
with secondary
 
floor coal
 
extraction of
 
up to 2m
 
resulting in
 
a maximum total
 
extraction
height of 5.5m. Additional
 
secondary extraction from
 
Bell Outs to a
 
maximum height of 5.5m
 
is also planned.
Where the seam height
 
exceeds 5.5m coal will
 
be left in the
 
floor. The
 
planned out of seam
 
dilution is 50mm
in the roof and 50mm in the floor when mining to the floor
 
of the seam
The
 
planned
 
Mackenzie
 
Seam
 
working
 
section
 
is
 
for
 
a
 
minimum
 
primary
 
extraction
 
height
 
of
 
3m
 
and
 
a
maximum of 3.5m in combination with secondary floor coal
 
extraction of up to 2m resulting in a
 
maximum total
extraction height of 5.5m. Additional secondary extraction from Bell Outs to a maximum height of 5.5m is also
planned. The working section
 
in Mackenzie Seam
 
will leave a minimum
 
of 0.5m of coal
 
in the floor and
 
0.8m
of coal in the roof due to geotechnical requirements. Consequently,
 
there is zero out of seam stone dilution in
the normal Mackenzie Seam working section.
Plant recovery is a function of in-seam recovery
 
and plant efficiency factor.
 
ROM and product data outputs
 
from the LOM plan
 
sequencing were processed
 
into reports and summarized
on an
 
annual basis
 
for processing
 
into the
 
economic model.
 
Product tonnes
 
are reported
 
at 10
 
percent moisture
and represent the Marketable product from the Property.
 
Pricing data as provided by Coronado
 
marketing team is based on
 
internationally recognised forecasting and
the view
 
of Coronado
 
Pricing Committee
 
as of October
 
2023. The average
 
FOB coal
 
price per
 
tonne for the
Underground Mine LOM was approximately
 
US$ 143 /
 
tonne. The breakeven cost
 
per FOB product tonne
 
over
the LOM (FOB Product
 
tonnes / (total cash
 
cost + total capital
 
cost)) was approximately US$
 
89 / tonne. The
minimum
 
annual
 
average
 
income
 
per
 
FOM
 
product
 
tonne
 
for
 
the
 
underground
 
mine
 
was
 
estimated
 
to
 
be
US$134 / tonne. Based on the stated coal price and cost assumptions the minable reserves are economically
extractable and
 
a Cut
 
Off
 
Grade has
 
not been
 
applied.
 
Practical limits
 
of mining
 
height and
 
depth of
 
cover
(DOC) have been applied.
The coal Resource mapping and estimation process, described in the report, was used as a basis for the coal
reserve
 
estimate.
 
Proven
 
and
 
probable
 
coal
 
Reserves
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
coal
 
Resource
considering
 
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
technical
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue,
 
and
 
cost),
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
 
socio-economic,
 
and
 
regulatory
 
factors
 
and
 
are
 
presented
 
on
 
a
 
moist,
 
Page 54 of 118
recoverable
 
basis.
 
Modifying
 
factors
 
have
 
been
 
applied
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
current
 
understanding
 
of
 
geological,
geotechnical and gas impacts on the planned mining method and
 
extraction.
Points of observation
 
include exploration drill
 
holes, degas holes,
 
and mine measurements
 
which have been
fully
 
vetted
 
and
 
processed
 
into
 
a
 
geologic
 
model.
 
The
 
geologic
 
model
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
seam
 
depositional
modelling, the interrelationship of overlying and underlying strata on
 
seam mineability, seam thickness trends,
the impact
 
of seam
 
structure (i.e.,
 
faulting), intra-seam
 
characteristics, etc.
 
Once the
 
geological model
 
was
completed, a
 
statistical analysis,
 
described in
 
Section 11.1.1
 
was conducted
 
and up
 
to a
 
1 kilometre
 
radius
from a valid point of observation was selected to define
 
Measured Resources.
 
Likewise,
 
the
 
distance
 
between
 
1
 
and
 
2
 
of a
 
kilometre
 
radius
 
was
 
selected
 
to
 
define
 
Indicated
 
Resources.
 
Indicated
 
Resources
 
may
 
convert
 
to
 
Probable
 
Reserves.
 
No
 
Inferred
 
coal
 
was
 
included
 
in
 
the
 
Reserve
estimation
The Measured,
 
Indicated and
 
Inferred Reso
 
urce classifications
 
overlayed on
 
the
 
current mine
 
layout at
 
the
time of
 
this study
 
in
 
the
 
Mammoth
 
Seam
 
and
 
Mackenzie
 
Seam
 
are
 
shown
 
in
 
Figure
 
12-1
 
and
 
Figure
 
12-2
respectively. No reserves
 
have been reported in the adjoining MDL162 tenement.
ex961p57i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 55 of 118
Figure 12-1. S-K 1300 Resource Classifications Relative
 
to Mammoth Seam Mine Plan
ex961p58i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 56 of 118
Figure 12-2. S-K 1300 Resource Classifications Relative
 
to Mackenzie Seam Mine Plan
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 57 of 118
12.2.1
 
Underground Reserves Estimate
Reserve tonnage
 
estimates
 
provided herein
 
report coal
 
Reserves
 
derived from
 
the in-situ
 
Resource tonnes
presented in
 
Table
 
12.4, and
 
not in
 
addition to
 
coal Resources.
 
Proven and
 
Probable coal
 
Reserves
 
were
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
coal
 
Resource
 
considering
 
relevant
 
mining,
 
processing,
 
infrastructure,
 
economic
(including
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue,
 
and
 
cost),
 
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
 
socio-economic
 
and
regulatory factors.
 
The Mineral
 
Reserve estimates
 
for Curragh
 
have been
 
determined and
 
are presented
 
in
Table
 
12.4 and Table
 
12.5. The numbers
 
are based on
 
the results and
 
findings of the
 
Qualified Persons and
their
 
application
 
of
 
the
 
relevant
 
modifying
 
factors
 
to
 
the
 
aforementioned
 
Resource
 
model.
 
The
 
Reserves
presented consider
 
only the
 
Measured and
 
Indicated Resources
 
that have
 
subsequently
 
been converted
 
to
Proven and Probable Reserves. The numbers exclude
 
tonnes from MDL162.
The LOM ROM
 
tonnes reported in
 
the Curragh North
 
Underground PFS (completed in
 
the first quarter
 
of 2023)
was approximately 40.4
 
Mt. Following updating
 
of the geological
 
model based on
 
additional exploration data
the Updated
 
LOM Plan
 
reported 57Mt
 
of which
 
50.4 Mt
 
ROM was
 
within Measured
 
and Indicated
 
Resource
classification and excluding inferred
 
resources and MDL 162.
 
At the time
 
of completion of
 
this reserve estimate
the results of a
 
3D Seismic Study were in
 
progress and incomplete.
 
Conservative modifying factors have been
applied for possible impacts of geological structures yet to be defined and impacts on mining recovery. Based
on potentially positive outcomes of further geological exploration (including Seismic Studies)
 
that are currently
in progress and
 
planned in
 
the future it
 
is probable that
 
the modifying factors
 
could be reviewed
 
.
 
Currently a
conservative value of 41 Mt
 
ROM of the 50 Mt ROM
 
of the current planned LOM
 
production within Measured
and
 
Indicated
 
resource
 
categories
 
and
 
excluding
 
MDL162,
 
have
 
been
 
reported
 
as
 
Proven
 
and
 
Probable
Reserves respectively.
 
This is approximately 84% of the potential LOM
 
ROM tonnes.
Table 12.4: Underground ROM Coal Reserve Summary as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Curragh North
Underground
Proven
Probable
Total
Coal Quality of Reserve inclusive of loss and dilution
(adb)
Mt
Mt
Mt
Ash (%)
TS (%)
VM (%)
ROM tonnes
30
11
41
17.0
0.3
16.4
Table 12.5: Underground Marketable Coal Reserve Summary as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves
 
(Wet Tonnes, Washed
 
or Direct Shipped, Mt)
Quality (adb)
Curragh
North
Undergroun
d
By Reliability Category
Proven
Probable
Total
Ash%
Sulphur%
VM%
Total
25
9
34
10.0
0.3
16.9
Notes:
a)
 
Coronado’s ownership is 100% of the Curragh Mine
b)
 
All tonnes are millions of metric tonnes (Mt).
c)
 
ROM Coal Reserves have been stated on a 8%
 
Moisture basis.
d)
 
Marketable Reserves
 
are stated
 
on a
 
10% moisture basis,
 
including a
 
combination of
 
surface moisture
 
and inherent
 
moisture.
e)
 
Coal qualities are reported on an air-dried
 
basis.
f)
 
Totals may not sum due to rounding.
g)
 
Curragh produce
 
a range
 
of Coking,
 
PCI and
 
Thermal Coal
 
products from
 
the underground
 
target seams.
 
The combined
yield for Primary and Secondary Product Coal modelled over
 
the LOM was approximately 87%
12.2.2
 
Qualified Person’s Opinion
Mr.
 
Christopher
 
Wilkinson
 
Bsc
 
(Mining)
 
MAusIMM(CP)
 
possesses
 
the
 
required
 
experience
 
in
 
underground
coal mining and reserve estimation
 
and credentials as a member
 
of the AusIMM to act as
 
a Qualified Person
for Coal Reserves estimation in this TRS.
It is the opinion of
 
Mr. Christopher Wilkinson that this TRS accurately reflects the Underground Coal Reserves
estimate as
 
defined by the
 
JORC Code and
 
SEC Regulation S-K
 
1300.
 
Sufficient exploration data
 
is supported
by a
 
longstanding history
 
of successful
 
coal production
 
at Curragh,
 
further increasing
 
the confidence
 
of the
reserve estimates.
 
The application
 
of modifying
 
factors are supported
 
by a combination
 
of laboratory-based
 
Page 58 of 118
data,
 
practical
 
historical
 
mining
 
knowledge
 
from
 
Curragh
 
and
 
relevant
 
experience
 
from
 
other
 
mines
 
in
 
the
region extracting
 
the target
 
seams using
 
the same
 
underground mining
 
methods.
 
Appropriate modifying factors
have
 
been
 
applied
 
in
 
determination
 
of
 
ROM
 
and
 
Marketable
 
Reserves
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
currently
 
available
exploration data and analysis.
Determination of
 
Marketable Reserves
 
has relied
 
on Product
 
Coal Quality
 
grids and
 
yields at
 
defined CHPP
cut
 
points
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
which
 
are
 
then
 
used
 
in
 
the
 
Deswik
 
LOM
 
scheduling
 
model
 
to
 
generate
marketable reserve
 
tonnes and
 
coal quality
 
The product
 
qualities and
 
yield grids
 
are based
 
on modelling
 
by
AB Mylec. The models and outputs
 
have not been validated by Mr Wilkinson
 
or Mining Consultancy Services
Pty Ltd / Talisman
 
Technical
 
Pty Ltd.
 
 
 
Page 59 of 118
13
 
Mining Methods
 
13.1
 
Open Cut Mining
Coal
 
mine
 
development
 
at
 
Curragh
 
is
 
accomplished
 
by
 
surface
 
strip
 
mining
 
methods
 
and
 
has
 
been
 
so
historically since the
 
mine commenced in
 
1983. The mine’s
 
annual production capacity
 
of around 200
 
Mbcm
of total movement means it can be ranked as a large open cut coal operation when compared to producers in
Australia and
 
internationally.
 
The open
 
cut operation
 
mines around
 
13.5Mt Run
 
of Mine
 
(ROM) coal
 
per annum,
producing around
 
11Mtpa of product coal
 
for both
 
international metallurgical markets,
 
thermal coal
 
for domestic
and international markets.
 
Curragh operates 4 large electric draglines, 1 large electric
 
rope shovel and a fleet of smaller diesel hydraulic
excavators.
 
This
 
is
 
typical
 
of
 
large
 
open
 
cut
 
coal
 
mines
 
in
 
the
 
Bowen
 
Basin
 
in
 
Central
 
Queensland.
 
The
Curragh Life of Mine
 
(LOM) plan continues
 
the use of dragline
 
strip mining, with
 
truck and shovel/excavators
moving the prestrip waste ahead of the
 
dragline fleet. Hydraulic excavators mine
 
the ROM coal and transport
it to the ROM stockpile for feed to the processing plant
 
for beneficiation.
 
13.1.0
 
Geotech and Hydrology
The
 
management
 
of
 
geotechnical
 
hazards
 
at
 
the
 
Curragh
 
Mine
 
is
 
managed
 
in
 
the
 
site
 
Safety
 
and
 
Health
Management System (SHMS) with a Principal Hazard Management Plan (PHMP). The Curragh Geotechnical
Hazard Control System Structure consists of 4 primary
 
elements:
●
 
Prevention and Implementation;
●
 
Monitoring;
●
 
Contingency; and,
●
 
Audit.
The validity
 
of the
 
mine design and
 
geotechnical hazard management
 
is achieved by
 
ensuring data of
 
sufficient
quantity and
 
quality for
 
the geotechnical
 
model is
 
available to
 
support the
 
design process.
 
Safe design
 
and
mine planning
 
processes are
 
applied throughout the
 
life of
 
mine. The
 
design is
 
prepared, reviewed,
 
and revised
by competent persons throughout the life of mine.
The coal seams at Curragh
 
generally dip to the east
 
at less than 5°, however
 
in fault and deformation zones,
steep dips occur
 
locally.
 
On the western
 
side of Curragh
 
East the seams
 
dip to the
 
west due to
 
the complex
dome and basin structures resulting from deformation.
Seam
 
deformation
 
has
 
resulted
 
principally
 
from
 
thrust
 
faulting
 
from
 
the
 
north-east
 
resulting
 
in
 
seam
displacements up to 20 metres
 
vertically. North-south and east-west normal faults are less common and
 
some
of these have a strike-slip component. Fault deformation has resulted in seam thinning, thickening and barren
areas within the mine plan.
The Jellinbah
 
fault occurs
 
on the
 
eastern side
 
of the
 
Curragh North
 
mining lease.
 
The fault
 
is a
 
thrust fault
upthrown on the eastern side by approximately 300 metres.
The
 
Curragh
 
Planning
 
System
 
(CPS)
 
consists
 
of
 
a
 
collective
 
of
 
mine
 
planning
 
systems
 
developed
 
and
maintained to ensure mine design and scheduling are consistently
 
applied.
 
The CPS describes, through each Process,
 
the steps to be
 
taken and relevant Work Instructions to be
 
utilised.
Refer to Appendix
 
B: Curragh
 
Planning System (CPS)
 
Documents for
 
a full list
 
of documents
 
used to inform
various stages of mine planning, design, monitoring,
 
and auditing.
 
Page 60 of 118
Geotechnical ground models are
 
the basis on
 
which slope stability analysis
 
and slope design
 
is completed and
need to
 
be informed
 
by a
 
level of
 
data appropriate
 
to the
 
design phase.
 
The Geotechnical
 
ground model
 
is
comprised of the following components:
●
 
Geological Model;
●
 
Structural Model;
●
 
Material Properties; and
●
 
Hydrogeological Model.
Geotechnical
 
slope
 
stability
 
analysis
 
aims
 
to
 
predictively
 
assess
 
slope
 
performance
 
based
 
on
 
developed
geotechnical
 
ground
 
models
 
and
 
understood
 
slope
 
failure
 
mechanisms
 
associated
 
with
 
the
 
observed
 
and
interpreted geological, geotechnical, and hydrogeological conditions.
There are various geotechnical slope stability analysis
 
methods available:
●
 
Kinematic slope stability analyses;
●
 
Limit equilibrium slope stability analysis;
●
 
Numerical slope stability analyses (e.g., finite element etc);
 
and,
●
 
Empirical methods.
Geotechnical
 
hazard
 
zoning
 
provides
 
an
 
indication
 
of
 
the
 
likelihood
 
of
 
failure
 
for
 
various
 
failure
 
scales
 
and
forms, and for a defined pit wall design option, to assist mine planning in determining if the risks presented by
the design are acceptable.
Geotechnical hazard zoning considers the following:
●
 
Geotechnical Models:
●
 
Geological Model;
●
 
Structural Model;
●
 
Material Strength Parameters; and
●
 
Hydrogeological Model.
●
 
Geotechnical Domains;
●
 
Past Pit wall Performance;
●
 
Proposed Pit wall Geometry; and,
●
 
Geotechnical Analysis.
Geotechnical
 
Hazard
 
Mapping
 
can
 
be
 
undertaken
 
at
 
a
 
conceptual
 
level
 
or
 
at
 
a
 
detailed
 
design
 
level.
 
The
Geotechnical Hazard
 
Mapping Plans
 
present the
 
projection design,
 
assessed level
 
of geological
 
uncertainty
and potential pit
 
wall failure
 
mechanism types
 
that have been
 
identified together
 
with an assessed
 
likelihood
of failure.
Seismic hazard assessments are completed, where required, for
 
geotechnical infrastructure during the design
and assessment phase with reference to Geoscience
 
Australia monitoring (maps, likelihood etc.).
Typical Highwall and lowall mine design profiles for the Curragh North active mining area are shown in Figure
13-1 and Figure 13-2
 
respectively.
 
The Draglines
 
will typically take
 
the lower Pisces
 
seam interburden which
as typically cast blasted into the adjacent mined out pit
 
void.
 
ex961p63i0 ex961p63i1
 
Page 61 of 118
Figure 13-1 - Curragh North typical Highwall design profile
Figure 13-2 - Curragh North typical Lowall design profile
Typical Highwall and
 
lowall mine design profiles for the
 
Curragh Main active mining area are
 
shown in Figure
13-3 and Figure 13-4 respectively.
 
The Draglines will typically take the lower two passes of Castor and Pollux
seam interburdens at Curragh Main.
ex961p64i0 ex961p64i1
 
Page 62 of 118
Figure 13-3 - Curragh Main typical Highwall design profile
Figure 13-4 - Curragh Main typical Lowall design profile
Groundwater impacts are greatest
 
at Curragh North, in particular
 
in the Northern pits of
 
S pit North, T pit
 
and
U pits where perched aquifers
 
exist in the upper alluvial sands.
 
This is managed by designing
 
wider benches
on the
 
base of
 
freedig horizon to
 
allow for a
 
trafficable roadway on
 
the bench as
 
well as
 
a drainage and
 
ponding
area on the highwall side of the bench for groundwater to pond and accumulate before being pumped out and
handled
 
with
 
the
 
site
 
surface
 
water
 
management
 
network.
 
Other
 
areas
 
of
 
the
 
mine
 
are
 
not
 
dramatically
impacted by groundwater presence. The coal seams are
 
the principal aquifers in the Rangal Coal Measures.
 
 
Page 63 of 118
Groundwater management at the
 
operation is achieved through
 
a network of
 
in-pit and highwall pump
 
systems
that move
 
both ground
 
water and
 
captured surface
 
water from
 
rainfall into
 
sacrificial pit
 
storages and/or
 
into
surface water
 
storages. Captured
 
mine affected
 
water onsite
 
is recycled
 
and used
 
for dust
 
suppression
 
via
water cart fill
 
points, or transferred
 
via the site
 
network back to
 
the CHPP for
 
use as processing
 
water in the
processing
 
plant.
 
Some
 
monitored
 
releases
 
of
 
water
 
to
 
the
 
receiving
 
environment
 
occur
 
when
 
regulated
conditions are met to remove water from the Curragh
 
site inventory.
 
Mine management at Curragh monitors groundwater inflows and
 
maintains comprehensive site water balance
models.
13.1.1
 
Open Cut LOM Plan
The Curragh
 
open cut
 
Life of
 
Mine (LOM)
 
plan essentially
 
is a continuation
 
of the
 
existing mining
 
method at
the site over the remaining economic Coal Reserves. The mine is
 
currently operating in the Curragh Main and
Curragh
 
North
 
operational
 
areas,
 
with
 
two
 
new
 
development
 
areas
 
(X
 
and
 
Z
 
pits)
 
to
 
be
 
built
 
and
 
mined
throughout
 
the
 
LOM
 
plan.
 
The
 
primary
 
waste
 
production
 
fleet
 
is
 
four
 
large
 
electric
 
draglines
 
that
 
currently
operate two
 
at Curragh
 
Main and
 
two at
 
Curragh North.
 
These
 
draglines
 
are supported
 
by
 
fleets
 
of diesel
hydraulic
 
excavators
 
at
 
Curragh
 
Main,
 
and
 
at
 
Curragh
 
North
 
an
 
electric
 
shovel
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
diesel
 
hydraulic
excavators.
 
Coal mining
 
is
 
undertaken
 
with
 
diesel
 
hydraulic
 
excavators
 
at
 
both
 
Curragh
 
Main and
 
Curragh
North.
The mining
 
operations utilise
 
cast blasting
 
methods where
 
applicable in
 
the dragline
 
waste passes
 
to move
some waste into final position from blasting practices. Bulk dozer push
 
is utilised to a minor extent at Curragh
for both dragline
 
bench prep and
 
coal uncovery using
 
Cast/Doze/Excavate (CDX)
 
methods in some
 
areas to
boost coal uncovery.
 
The Curragh
 
North
 
open cut
 
LOM
 
plan aligns
 
with
 
the underground
 
LOM
 
plan.
 
The final
 
open cut
 
highwall
position has
 
been used
 
to define
 
the underground LOM
 
plan. The
 
Open Cut LOM
 
plan is limited
 
in the
 
Southern
half of the mine
 
by the installed Overland
 
Conveyor (OLC). This
 
ROM coal transport system
 
transports ROM
coal from the Open
 
Cut and planned Underground
 
project from Curragh
 
North to the processing
 
plant facility
at Curragh Main.
 
For the purposes of the Open Cut LOM plan, the assumption was to leave this infrastructure
in place and mine
 
up to it with a
 
100m pit crest offset
 
for Geotechnical stability
 
risk control. The underground
project will mine Coal Reserves
 
under and to the East
 
of this infrastructure. This
 
OLC pit constraint exists
 
for
S Pit North,
 
S Pit and S Pit South.
The T Pit and
 
U Pit Open Cut
 
reserves are planned to be
 
mined down dip to
 
an economic break-even position,
where the underground project will continue with the extraction of ROM coal beyond this open cut break-even
point. The period progress plot of the Curragh North
 
open cut project can be seen in Figure 13-5.
 
ex961p66i0
 
Page 64 of 118
Figure 13-5 – Curragh North Period Progress Plot
The Curragh
 
Main mine
 
plan is
 
the continuation
 
of the
 
existing mining
 
pits within
 
the historic
 
mining area
 
of
the
 
Curragh
 
Main
 
project
 
area.
 
The
 
currently
 
active
 
mining
 
areas
 
that
 
the
 
draglines
 
are
 
active
 
in
 
will
 
be
exhausted with
 
the next
 
5 years. A
 
new development boxcut
 
is required
 
to open
 
L pit
 
which will
 
be a
 
investment
 
to bring online within the 3-5 years in the plan
 
to ensure dragline strike continuity. Critical to the open cut LOM
plan is the
 
re-entry to
 
D pit in
 
the North
 
of Curragh Main.
 
D Pit will
 
require dewatering
 
to EN pit
 
void when
 
it
becomes available as a
 
final void in 2025.
 
The establishment of
 
the L pit boxcut
 
and re-entry to D
 
Pit are the
critical factors in delaying the
 
development
 
of Z and X pits to late in the 2020’s.
 
This will ensure continuity of
dragline operations at Curragh
 
Main and maintaining the lowest
 
unit rate cost of production
 
from the Curragh
Main pits.
 
G pit is currently full of stored mine affected water and requires pumping to another
 
mine void/storage prior to
re-entry to
 
the remaining
 
reserves in
 
G pit.
 
J pit
 
is a truck
 
and excavator
 
and dozer
 
push pit
 
at the southern
end of
 
Curragh Main
 
and is
 
continued to
 
be worked
 
with these
 
mining methods
 
through the
 
LOM plan.
 
The
period progress plot of the Curragh Main open cut project
 
can be seen in Figure 13-6.
 
ex961p67i0
 
Page 65 of 118
Figure 13-6 - Curragh Main Period Progress Plot
X pit is a new development pit area that exists midway between the Curragh Main and Curragh North existing
mining areas at the
 
Curragh Mine. The
 
X Pit economic
 
reserve exists over
 
several different mining
 
pit areas,
with
 
differing
 
optimal
 
target
 
pit
 
floor
 
horizons
 
depending
 
on
 
seam
 
thickness,
 
depth
 
and
 
interburden
thicknesses. Surface development infrastructure is required
 
to unlock the X Pit reserve for mining including a
significant
 
creek
 
diversion
 
of
 
Minnie
 
Creek,
 
flood
 
protection
 
levees,
 
ROM
 
infrastructure
 
and
 
MIA
 
facilities,
surface water and mine affected
 
water handling infrastructure,
 
haulroads,
 
dragline walk road, conveyor cross
over
 
bridge
 
and
 
66kv
 
high
 
voltage
 
electrical
 
infrastructure
 
to
 
support
 
dragline
 
operations.
 
The
 
existing
Overland
 
Conveyor
 
(OLC)
 
installation
 
exists
 
through
 
the
 
centre
 
of
 
the
 
X
 
Pit
 
reserve.
 
The
 
coal
 
under
 
this
infrastructure produces an attractive cash margin and has been included as a coal reserve on the basis that it
will be mined
 
after the completion of
 
Curragh North open cut
 
and underground operations have
 
completed and
the existing OLC is decommissioned – essentially as the final
 
portion of the mines’ life.
 
The Eastern extent of
 
the X Pit deposit
 
is bounded by an
 
environmental biodiversity
 
offset conservation limit.
Other areas of the X Pit deposit are
 
cutoff with economic margi
 
n
 
limits where the modelled coal
 
seams break
even on an all-in cost basis margin rank.
 
X
 
pit
 
contains
 
an
 
‘early
 
entry’
 
option
 
by
 
way
 
of
 
the
 
Southern
 
two
 
mining
 
pit
 
areas
 
are
 
shallow
 
truck
 
and
excavator and bulk
 
dozer push areas that
 
can be accessed
 
with minimal surface
 
infrastructure investment to
unlock and could be
 
used by the
 
business as alternative
 
mining areas to
 
boost ROM coal
 
production prior to
what is scheduled
 
in the LOM
 
plan. The period
 
progress plot of the
 
X Pit open
 
cut project can
 
be seen in
 
Figure
13-7.
ex961p68i0
 
Page 66 of 118
Figure 13-7 - X Pit Period Progress Plot
Z Pit is
 
a second new development
 
area that exists to
 
the South-West of the existing
 
Curragh Main operational
area. This is a shallow, long strike length deposit ideal
 
for dragline operations. The coal seams however have
thinned in Z
 
pit compared
 
to Curragh
 
Main, and
 
in the
 
South of Z
 
pit the coal
 
seams down
 
dip split
 
into plys
with interburdens less
 
than 10m in
 
thickness and
 
are unsuitable
 
for dragline operations
 
.
 
The impact this
 
has
is Z
 
pit produces
 
the lowest
 
cash margin
 
of the
 
four main
 
mining areas
 
at Curragh
 
and has
 
been prioritised
within the LOM plan to optimise project cashflow.
 
Surface development infrastructure is required to be invested
 
in by the business to unlock
 
the Z Pit reserve for
mining including a creek diversion of Bonnie Doon Creek, flood protection
 
levee, ROM infrastructure and MIA
facilities, surface water and mine
 
affected water handling infrastructure,
 
haulroads, dragline walk road,
 
public
road upgrades and 66kv high voltage electrical infrastructure
 
to support dragline operations.
 
Most of
 
the Z
 
Pit mining
 
blocks
 
start on
 
the modelled
 
base of
 
weathering cropline
 
of the
 
Pollux seam
 
in the
Western side of the deposit. The North-Western edge of the Z pit deposit is limited by the Bonnie Doon Creek
diversion
 
on
 
the
 
existing
 
Mining
 
Lease.
 
The
 
Eastern
 
downdip
 
extent
 
of
 
the
 
Z
 
Pit
 
deposit
 
is
 
bounded
 
by
economic margin cut-off limits
 
where the modelled coal seams break
 
even on an all-in cost basis.
 
The period
progress plot of the Z Pit open cut project can be seen
 
in Figure 13-8.
ex961p69i0
 
Page 67 of 118
Figure 13-8 - Z Pit Period Progress Plot
The primary
 
production
 
fleet at
 
Curragh revolves
 
around both
 
maintaining sufficient
 
prestripping capacity
 
in
advance of the dragline waste stripping fleet and supporting
 
open cut coal targets. The dragline fleet consists
of two 8200 draglines, an 8750 and an 8750 Supermax dragline making for a total fleet of four machines. The
prestripping
 
fleet
 
consists
 
of
 
a
 
BE495
 
electric
 
rope
 
shovel,
 
and
 
three
 
classes
 
of
 
diesel
 
hydraulic
 
backhoe
excavators
 
– 800t,
 
600t
 
and
 
350t class
 
excavators.
 
There is
 
currently
 
budgeted
 
13 x
 
prestripping and
 
coal
mining
 
fleets
 
being
 
operated
 
at
 
Curragh
 
in
 
addition
 
to
 
the
 
four
 
electric
 
draglines.
 
This
 
prestripping
 
fleet
 
is
planned to increase to 15 fleets in the LOM plan to match the strip ratio requirements of the deposit,
 
and then
reduce later in the
 
LOM plan when capital
 
development is undertaken
 
in the new pit
 
development areas of
 
X
and Z pits. The primary excavator fleet is planned
 
to increase the number of 800t
 
class machines from two to
four in the LOM plan, with
 
an additional 800t excavator
 
replacing the retired BE495 electric
 
shovel at the end
of its
 
productive life in
 
2032. The
 
LOM plan
 
primary production
 
fleet scheduled is
 
shown in
 
Figure 13-9
 
inclusive
of the dragline fleet. The LOM
 
plan for the Curragh Open Cut
 
is 21 years and is completed
 
production in 2045.
 
ex961p70i0 ex961p70i1
 
Page 68 of 118
Figure 13-9 - Curragh Open Cut LOM Production Fleets
The LOM plan Run of Mine coal
 
production profile from the Open Cut is
 
shown in Figure 13-10. The mine plan
is
 
to
 
uncover
 
and
 
mine
 
around
 
13.6
 
Mtpa
 
ROM
 
coal
 
from
 
the
 
Open
 
Cut.
 
This
 
production
 
profile
 
can
 
be
maintained through
 
until 2040
 
when the
 
Curragh North
 
open cut
 
reserves
 
then
 
become exhausted
 
and the
mine production profile reduces as Open
 
Cut mining reserves are completed
 
and the remaining mining areas
of Curragh Main, X and Z pits are completed.
 
Figure 13-10 - Curragh Open Cut LOM ROM t Mined
Figure 13-
11
shows the
 
Open Cut
 
LOM waste
 
production
 
profile by
 
equipment
 
type and
 
the planned
 
ROM
strip ratio over the
 
LOM. The ROM strip
 
ratio reduces later
 
in the mine life
 
when X and Z
 
pits are developed.
The yield for these new pits however reduces and product
 
strip ratio increases.
ex961p71i0 ex961p71i1
 
Page 69 of 118
Figure 13-11 - Curragh Open Cut LOM Waste Handled by Equipment Type
The LOM ROM coal production profile by source pit is
 
shown in Figure 13-12.
Figure 13-12 - Curragh Open Cut ROM t Mined by Pit
The planned
 
product coal
 
production profile
 
from the
 
Curragh Open
 
Cut mine
 
plan is shown
 
in Figure
 
13-13
plotted
 
against
 
the
 
Run
 
of
 
Mine
 
coal
 
production
 
profile.
 
The
 
declining
 
product
 
yield
 
can
 
be
 
seen
 
with
 
the
reducing product coal over the LOM plan.
 
ex961p72i0 ex961p72i1
 
Page 70 of 118
Figure 13-13 - Curragh Open Cut ROM t Mined and Product Coal
The forecasted
 
Open Cut
 
product coal
 
by product
 
type can
 
be seen
 
in Figure
 
13-14, with
 
the declining
 
total
yield over time on the secondary chart axis.
Figure 13-14 - Curragh Open Cut Product Coal by Type
13.2
 
Underground Mining
The feasibility
 
of underground
 
mining of
 
the Curragh
 
North mine
 
east of
 
the planned
 
location of
 
the current
planned Open Cut
 
mine LOM has
 
been undertaken between
 
2020 and 2023
 
comprising a Pre
 
Feasibility Study
ex961p73i1
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex961p73i8
 
Page 71 of 118
BELLOUTS
PRODUCTION FACES
CONVEYOR
DCB
INTAKE AIRWAYS
RETURN AIRWAYS
MINING DIRECTION
completed
 
in
 
Q1
 
2023
 
and
 
a
 
subsequent
 
more
 
detailed
 
Operational
 
Readiness
 
Study
 
(Feasibility
 
Level
 
of
Study) on the South Area in the Mammoth Seam.
The selected mining method is Bord and Pillar Mining using the
 
Place Change operating methodology. Due to
the variation in
 
seam thickness Bord and
 
Pillar mining would be
 
undertaken using
 
Primary extraction of panels
with roadway widths of
 
6.5m reducing to 6m where
 
the overburden thickness (Depth of
 
Cover: DOC) or mining
conditions require. Primary
 
extraction height
 
would vary
 
between 2.5m
 
minimum to
 
3.5m maximum.
 
Secondary
extraction of
 
Floor Coal
 
over the
 
same panel
 
layout created
 
by Primary
 
Mining would
 
be undertaken
 
with a
minimum floor
 
coal extraction of
 
1m and
 
a maximum extraction
 
thickness of 2m
 
and a
 
maximum total
 
combined
(Primary plus Secondary
 
Extraction) extraction
 
height of 5.5m.
 
The secondary
 
extraction width would
 
be 1m
less
 
than
 
the
 
Primary
 
Extraction
 
roadway
 
width
 
(eg.
 
5.5m
 
Secondary
 
Extraction
 
width
 
in
 
a
 
6.5m
 
primary
extraction roadway).
 
Secondary Extraction would also comprise mining of
 
“Bell Outs” around the perimeter of
the production panels mined from stubs
 
(blind entry roadways) mined into the inter
 
panel pillar. The Bell Outs
would
 
be
 
mined
 
to
 
a
 
maximum
 
height
 
of
 
5.5m
 
(where
 
seam
 
thickness
 
allows)
 
or
 
the
 
combined
 
extraction
thickness of Primary and Secondary Extraction mining. The proposed mining method is
 
well proven at several
mines in the Region who extract the same target coal seams from underground mines. This method has been
proven to
 
not create
 
any sig
 
nificant surface
 
subsidence
 
and
 
impact on
 
overlying
 
aquifers. The
 
method
 
has
been shown to be safe, productive
 
and economicaly viable using readily
 
available equipment technology and
people skills.
A
 
typical
 
extraction
 
panel
 
would
 
comprise
 
of
 
5-7
 
roadways
 
with
 
pillars
 
designed
 
to
 
comply
 
with
 
industry
standard
 
pillar
 
design
 
methodologies
 
(UNSW
 
Pillar
 
Design
 
Method)
 
with
 
Bell
 
Out
 
extraction
 
around
 
the
perimiter of
 
the panel,
 
as shown
 
in Figure
 
13-15. Secondary
 
Coal Floor
 
extraction may
 
also occur
 
in panels
through out the mine in addition to the Bell Out Extraction, an
 
example of the secondary floor workings can be
found in Figure 13-16.
 
Figure 13-15. Typical Bord and Pillar Production Panel with Primary and Secondary
Extraction.
Note: No. of roadway and heading within Bord and
 
Pillar Panels vary across the Mine.
ex961p74i0
 
Page 72 of 118
Figure 13-16. Example of Secondary Floor Coal Workings
The Curragh North Underground
 
mine would commence
 
with 1 Bord and
 
Pillar Continuous Miner Production
Unit to
 
mine the
 
pit bottom
 
area and
 
scale up
 
to 4
 
Production Units
 
at full
 
production. Each
 
Production Unit
would utilise
 
a single
 
place change
 
continuous miner
 
with 3 shuttle
 
cars discharging
 
to a
 
Feeder Breaker.
 
A
single Mobile
 
Bolter would
 
install roof
 
and rib
 
support.
 
LHD vehicles
 
would be
 
used to
 
undertake floor
 
clean
up and materials supply and ancillary work.
All
 
the
 
Production
 
Units
 
would
 
be
 
able
 
to
 
undertake
 
Primary
 
and
 
Secondary
 
Extraction
 
and
 
mining
 
Mains
Development Panels as required by the LOM Schedule and
 
Plan.
13.2.0
 
Productivity
 
The
 
mine
 
has
 
been
 
planned
 
to
 
operate
 
on
 
a
 
similar
 
shift
 
roster
 
and
 
production
 
methodology
 
to
 
other
underground bord and pillar
 
mines in Central QLD with an
 
even time 7 day on, 7
 
day off roster for production
and
 
maintenance
 
crews
 
and
 
management
 
and
 
technical
 
staff
 
on
 
a
 
separate
 
roster.
 
The
 
planned
 
average
underground mine labour complement of approximately
 
320 people is consistent with similar mines.
 
The average
 
budgeted operating
 
time (Production
 
hours) per
 
week is
 
approximately 84
 
hrs per
 
week which
includes panel extension / retraction
 
time for primary and secondary
 
mining. This equates to an
 
overall system
utilisation
 
of
 
50%
 
and
 
has
 
been
 
benchmarked
 
against
 
other
 
similar
 
Bord
 
and
 
Pillar
 
mining
 
operations
 
in
Queensland who target and achieve similar utilisation.
Production Rates
 
have been
 
determined based
 
on first
 
principles analysis
 
of the following
 
parameters using
proven and calibrated simulation models which are benchmarked
 
to relevant operating bord and pillar mines:
●
 
Extraction height
●
 
Roadway width
●
 
Pillar size
●
 
Plunge depth
●
 
Equipment specifications
●
 
Roadway support requirements and pattens. With the support requirements defined at the PFS stage
production is not indicated to be constrained by normal
 
support requirements.
The scheduled average annual Production Rates
 
vary over the Mammoth Seam
 
LOM between 177 ROM tph
to 245 ROM tph with
 
an average of approximately
 
213 tph. The scheduled
 
average annual Production Rates
ex961p75i0
 
Page 73 of 118
vary over the Mackenzie Seam
 
LOM between 100 ROM tph
 
to 220 ROM tph with
 
an average of approximately
171 tph. Average annual ROM production per Continuous Miner Unit varies between 0.6Mt ROM
 
per CM per
year to 1.0Mt ROM
 
per CM per year and
 
a LOM average of
 
approximately 0.75Mt ROM
 
per CM per year. This
has been
 
benchmarked against
 
comparable bord
 
and pillar
 
mines in
 
Queensland mining
 
similar coal
 
seams
and using similar equipment. The average annual production rates
 
per continuous miner unit over the LOM is
shown in Figure 13-17.
Figure 13-17. Average Annual Production Rate by CM Unit over LOM
13.2.1
 
Underground Geotech and Hydrology
Geotechnical analysis
 
has been undertaken
 
based on the
 
available information at
 
the time of
 
the PFS by
 
Mr
Chris Hanson of
 
Prime Global Pty
 
Ltd for MCS
 
and subsequently
 
up to the
 
time of this
 
study by Mr.
 
Andrew
Seccombe of Blackrock Mining Solutions Pty Ltd.
 
Ongoing exploration, sampling and laboratory testing is also
ongoing. Both Geotechnical Consultants are appropriately
 
qualified and experienced.
Mine
 
design
 
analysis
 
of
 
the
 
following
 
aspects
 
of
 
the
 
proposed
 
underground
 
mine
 
design
 
have
 
been
considered:
●
 
Target
 
seam coal, roof, floor and overburden characteristics
●
 
Minimum thickness of un-weathered overburden (minimum
 
Rock Head)
●
 
Roadway widths
●
 
Pillar dimensions and design (Factor of
 
Safety using UNWS standard pillar design methods
 
and tools)
and width to height ratio.
●
 
Principle stress magnitude and direction as generally understood
 
at the time of this report.
●
 
Coal cleat and strata jointing as generally understood at the
 
time of this report.
●
 
Roof and rib
 
support requirements and plunge depth
 
as generally understood at
 
the time of
 
this report.
●
 
Pillar stability and subsidence impacts as generally understood
 
at the time of this report.
●
 
Highwall stabilisation requirements in the vicinity of proposed underground mine access, as generally
understood at the time of this report.
The
 
currently
 
planned
 
Bord
 
and
 
Pillar
 
Primary
 
and
 
Secondary
 
mining
 
method
 
has
 
been
 
applied
 
at
 
similar
mines in
 
the same
 
coal
 
measures
 
in Queensland
 
with
 
proven geotechnical
 
and hydrogeological
 
outcomes.
Using this
 
mining method
 
and design
 
principles has
 
been shown
 
to have
 
negligible surface
 
subsidence and
impact
 
on
 
overlying
 
aquifers
 
and
 
bodies
 
of
 
surface
 
water.
 
The
 
selected
 
mining
 
method
 
has
 
successfully
undermined a regional river without significant ground
 
water impacts due to mining.
Curragh
 
mine
 
has an
 
extensive
 
water
 
monitoring
 
system
 
and
 
history
 
which
 
is no
 
w
 
being
 
supplemented
 
by
additional borehole test
 
data over the
 
planned underground
 
mining area. Data
 
from these sampling
 
points is
being used by Hansen Environmental Consulting to support
 
the EA amendment for underground mining.
 
Page 74 of 118
13.2.2
 
Underground LOM Plan
The planned Curragh North Underground
 
Mine will initially extract the
 
Mammoth Seam and subsequently
 
the
underlying Mackenzie
 
seam. Production
 
would commence
 
in the
 
South Area
 
from the
 
southern end
 
of S-Pit
as this area has the
 
lowest DOC and is preferable from a productivity, recovery and gas drainage perspective.
 
Figure 13
 
-18 shows
 
the
 
DOC
 
to the
 
Mammoth
 
Seam
 
which ranges
 
from approximately
 
50m
 
to 28
 
0m.
 
The
interburden
 
to
 
the
 
underlying
 
Mackenzie
 
Seam
 
varies
 
between
 
approximately
 
50m
 
and
 
70m.
 
Figure
 
13-19
shows
 
the
 
DOC
 
to
 
the
 
Mackenzie
 
Seam
 
roof
 
and
 
varies
 
between
 
approximately
 
50m
 
to
 
350m.
 
The
 
DOC
includes
 
the
 
Open
 
Cut
 
waste
 
Dumps
 
of
 
between
 
50m
 
to
 
60m
 
height
 
which
 
overly
 
the
 
underground
 
mining
areas. The natural DOC of the Mammoth Seam is comparable
 
with other bord and pillar mines in QLD.
ex961p77i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 75 of 118
Figure 13-18.
 
Mammoth Seam Depth of Cover (DOC) (m)
ex961p78i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 76 of 118
Figure 13-19. Mackenzie Seam Depth of Cover (DOC) (m)
ex961p79i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 77 of 118
The thickness
 
of the
 
Mammoth Seam
 
varies from
 
approximately 2.5m
 
to 7m
 
over the
 
proposed LOM
 
layout
as illustrated in Figure 13-20 with a minimum 2.5m extraction
 
height cut off.
Figure 13-20. Mammoth Seam thickness (m)
ex961p80i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 78 of 118
The thickness of the Mackenzie Seam varies from
 
approximately 4m to 9m over the proposed LOM
 
layout as
illustrated in Figure 13-21 with a minimum 3m extraction
 
height (4.3m seam thickness).
Figure 13-21. Mackenzie Seam thickness (m)
ex961p81i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 79 of 118
The gas content
 
of the Mammoth
 
Seam is shown inFigure
 
13-22 and varies
 
from approximately 0
 
to 11
 
m3/t
and Mackenzie
 
Seams are
 
shown in
 
Figure 13-23,
 
which varies
 
from approximately
 
5m3/t to
 
13.5m3/t.
 
Gas
content and permeability have been determined by bore hole core sample testing and modeled by recognized
industry experts Novus Energy and Geogas. A Gas analysis and management
 
study on the initial South Area
of Mammoth Seam has been undertaken by Mr.
 
Miles Brown (Drive Mining).
Figure 13-22. Mammoth Seam Gas Content (m3/t)
ex961p82i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 80 of 118
Figure 13-23. Mackenzie Seam Gas Content (m3/t)
ex961p83i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 81 of 118
Permeability
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
seams
 
has
 
been
 
tested
 
and
 
mapped
 
in
 
order
 
to
 
model
 
the
 
requirements
 
for
 
gas
management
 
over
 
the
 
resource.
 
Where
 
the
 
gas
 
content
 
is
 
similar
 
to
 
or
 
greater
 
than
 
the
 
Gas
 
Outburst
Threshold,
 
gas drainage will
 
be required to
 
reduce the
 
gas content to
 
suitable levels
 
for safe and
 
productive
mining operations. Surface to In Seam (SIS) test gas
 
wells will be implemented and the results used to design
appropriate gas drainage strategies for the underground mine.
 
Drive Mining have completed an initial UIS and
SIS gas
 
drainage Plan
 
for the
 
Mammoth Seam
 
South Area.
 
The
 
results from
 
gas drainage
 
in this
 
area can
then be used as inputs to extend gas drainage layouts
 
and designs over the LOM.
Mine access
 
is via
 
4 portal
 
entries from
 
the southern
 
end of
 
S-Pit and
 
the surface
 
infrastructure and
 
access
would be as illustrated in
 
Figure 13-24. ROM coal
 
from the South Area underground
 
mine will be transported
by truck from the portal to
 
the Curragh North ROM stock pill area where
 
it is loaded onto the existing. overland
conveyor and delivered to the CHPP.
 
The underground MIA facilities would be located adjacent to the current
S-Pit Open Cut
 
MIA and Workshop and
 
men and material
 
access to the
 
underground mine would
 
be via mobile
vehicles.
 
The
 
mine
 
access
 
methodology
 
and
 
surface
 
infrastructure
 
arrangement
 
is
 
consistent
 
with
 
other
underground bord and pillar mines operating from existing
 
Open Cut mines in QLD.
Figure 13-24. Surface infrastructure for the Mammoth Seam
 
South Area Mine Access from
S-Pit
The mine
 
has been
 
planned with
 
three mining
 
areas: South,
 
Central and
 
North. Production
 
transitions from
South to Central
 
and then North
 
Areas as reserves
 
deplete and geographical expansion
 
is required to
 
maintain
the required LOM production.
The electrical
 
power requirements for
 
the Underground Mine
 
have been
 
determined.
 
Studies have
 
shown there
is adequate
 
power on
 
site
 
for establishing
 
the
 
underground
 
mine and
 
commencing
 
the first
 
two continuous
miner Units, however
 
upgrades to
 
the site infrastructure
 
for full underground
 
production with four
 
continuous
miner units is required.
A load
 
study is
 
being undertaken
 
for Curragh
 
site to
 
determine the
 
required upgrades
 
for the
 
Open Cut
 
and
Underground LOM.
 
Once completed,
 
the required power line and infrastructure
 
upgrades must be completed
before full underground production to sustain safe and
 
effective underground operations.
ex961p84i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 82 of 118
Figure 13-25. Curragh North Underground Mine – Mammoth Seam
 
LOM Layout
ex961p85i0
 
 
 
 
 
Page 83 of 118
Figure 13-26. Curragh North Underground Mine – Mackenzie Seam
 
LOM Layout
ex961p86i0
 
Page 84 of 118
The mine
 
will commence
 
in the
 
South Area
 
of Mammoth
 
Seam in
 
planned to commence
 
in December
 
2024
and then introduce additional continuous
 
miner units, with full production
 
using 4 units by 2026. Production
 
is
planned
 
to
 
commence
 
in
 
the
 
Mackenzie
 
Seam
 
in
 
2034
 
and
 
the
 
expected
 
LOM
 
of
 
approximately
 
20
 
years.
Figure 13-27 &
 
Figure 13-28
 
shows the Period
 
Plot of production
 
in the Mammoth
 
Seam by year
 
and Figure
13-29 shows
 
the Period
 
Plot
 
for production
 
in
 
Mackenzie
 
Seam
 
by year.
 
The ROM
 
Production
 
by Year
 
for
each seam
 
over the
 
LOM is
 
shown graph
 
form in
 
Figure 13-30.
 
The annual
 
ROM Production
 
by continuous
miner unit over the LOM is shown in Figure 13-31.
Figure 13-27. LOM Production Period Plot for
Mammoth
 
Seam South
ex961p87i0
 
Page 85 of 118
Figure 13-28. LOM Production Period Plot for Mammoth
 
Seam Central & North
ex961p88i0
 
Page 86 of 118
Figure 13-29. LOM Production Period Plot for Mackenzie Seam
ex961p89i0 ex961p89i1
 
Page 87 of 118
Figure 13-30. LOM ROM Production per year by seam mined graph.
Figure 13-31. LOM ROM Production per year by CM Production
 
Unit graph
Curragh
 
Mine
 
currently
 
produces
 
a
 
range
 
of
 
Met
 
Coal
 
(Coking
 
Coals),
 
PCI
 
and
 
Thermal
 
Coal
 
from
 
the
Mammoth and Mackenzie seams depending on market conditions and requirements to optimize recovery and
income. The product yield
 
from the underground for
 
both target seams has
 
been determined based on
 
existing
washing models and data at Specific Gravity Cut Points
 
of 1.34 SG for a Primary Product consistent with
 
Met
Coal and
 
a Secondary
 
Product at
 
a Cut
 
Point of
 
1.7 SG.
 
Alternative Cut
 
Points and
 
blending strategies
 
with
Open Cut coal from Curragh have been considered and would
 
generate different products and yields.
The LOM Marketable
 
coal based
 
on a
 
Primary Product
 
at a 1.34SG
 
cut point and
 
a Secondary
 
Product at
 
a
1.7SG cut point and the combined Yield
 
% is shown by year over the LOM in Figure 13-32.
ex961p90i0
 
Page 88 of 118
Figure 13-32. LOM Marketable tonnes by Primary and Secondary
 
Product per year graph
 
 
 
Page 89 of 118
14
 
Process and recovery methods
 
14.1
 
Description
Curragh has
 
two coal
 
preparation plants
 
CPP1 and
 
CPP2. CPP1
 
is the
 
oldest of
 
the two
 
processing plants
and has a documented nameplate capacity
 
of 1100 t/h (as received). The CPP processes the
 
32mm x 0.7 mm
fractions through
 
a 2-stage
 
dense medium
 
cyclone (“DMC”)
 
circuit operating
 
in a
 
low density
 
/ high
 
density
configuration
 
to
 
produce
 
a
 
low
 
ash
 
primary
 
and
 
a
 
high
 
ash
 
secondary
 
product
 
respectively.
 
The
 
primary
cyclone underflow has
 
the functionality to
 
bypass the secondary
 
DMC circuit and
 
report directly as
 
a secondary
product.
The minus 0.7 mm fraction is
 
directed to a Jameson cell flotation
 
circuit for processing. The concentrate
 
from
the flotation
 
circuit is
 
pre-thickened via
 
classifying cyclones
 
before reporting
 
to horizontal
 
belt vacuum
 
filters
and
 
screen
 
bowls
 
for
 
further
 
dewatering
 
prior
 
to
 
being
 
conveyed
 
to
 
the
 
primary
 
product
 
conveyor.
 
The
classifying
 
cyclone
 
overflow
 
is
 
directed
 
to
 
a
 
coal
 
thickener,
 
where
 
the
 
thickened
 
product
 
material
 
is
 
then
combined with the horizontal belt vacuum filter feed.
 
These
 
processing
 
methods
 
are
 
typical
 
of
 
what
 
is
 
used
 
at
 
other
 
coal
 
mines
 
throughout
 
the
 
Bowen
 
Basin
 
in
Central Queensland, the technology is tried and proven.
CPP 2 has a
 
documented nameplate capacity of 1200
 
t/h (as received) with
 
a capability of up
 
to 1350 t/h when
processing selected feed types.
CPP2 largely mirrors CPP 1 with the following exceptions.
●
 
Raw coal screens have been installed as an option to separate the plant feed material into a plus and
minus
 
12
 
mm
 
size
 
fraction.
 
This
 
functionality
 
directs
 
the
 
higher
 
ash,
 
coarse
 
fraction
 
directly
 
to
 
the
secondary dense medium circuit reducing the circuit loading
 
of the primary circuit.
●
 
A spirals circuit has
 
been included in
 
the plant to reprocess
 
the flotation tailings
 
stream. The product
stream from
 
the spirals
 
circuit is
 
directed to
 
a splitter
 
box which
 
allows the
 
recovered product
 
to be
diverted to either the primary
 
product or secondary product streams via
 
the screen-bowls or fine coal
centrifuges respectively.
 
 
ex961p92i0
 
Page 90 of 118
Figure 14-1: Aerial view of the CHPP facilities and associated infrastructure
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 91 of 118
14.1.0
 
Raw Coal Handling
The
 
22
 
km
 
overland
 
conveyor
 
from
 
Curragh
 
North
 
is
 
an
 
integral
 
component
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
transportation
 
and
logistics system at
 
the Curragh operation.
 
The two ROM
 
systems are important
 
features of the
 
mine operations
to ensure blending of the ROM coals for
 
the CPPs. A series of conveyors, a ROM crushed
 
stockpile and small
ROM bins allows flexibility in the operations of the two
 
CPPs.
14.1.1
 
Product Handling
Product
 
coal
 
is
 
stockpiled
 
on
 
to
 
either
 
the
 
primary
 
or
 
secondary
 
product
 
stockpiles.
 
Two
 
stockpiles
 
of
approximately
 
190,000
 
tonnes
 
each
 
are
 
available
 
for
 
metallurgical
 
and
 
thermal
 
coal
 
products.
 
Multiple
stockpiles of differing quality
 
can be built on the
 
overall stockpile footprint and
 
reclaimed discretely by means
of the
 
4400 t/h
 
bucket wheel
 
reclaim system.
 
The two
 
installed product
 
stackers have
 
the capability
 
to slew
180
 
degrees
 
and
 
stack
 
to
 
an
 
emergency
 
stockpile
 
area.
 
The
 
emergency
 
stockpile
 
area
 
is
 
not
 
able
 
to
 
be
recovered directly but is transferred by truck and loader operation to the
 
main stockpiling area to be reclaimed
by the bucket wheel reclaim system.
14.1.2
 
Train Loadout
The processed coal is loaded onto trains via a single dedicated bucket
 
wheel reclaimer which loads two 580 t
capacity bins,
 
designed to
 
load both
 
thermal and
 
metallurgical coal.
 
In an
 
emergency,
 
there is a
 
dozer push
loading
 
system
 
in
 
place
 
should
 
there
 
an
 
electrical
 
outage
 
at
 
the
 
mine
 
site,
 
which
 
reduces
 
the
 
risk
 
of
 
train
loading system.
14.1.3
 
Reject and Tailings
Coarse reject is conveyed from each CPP to a common
 
reject bin for collection by mine trucks and deposited
in the allocated
 
reject dump, as
 
capping material
 
for the tailings
 
dam or as
 
part of the
 
rehabilitation process.
Flotation
 
tailings
 
material
 
is
 
passed
 
through
 
thickening
 
cyclones
 
with
 
the
 
underflow
 
directed
 
to
 
a
 
fine
 
coal
dewatering
 
screen
 
for
 
dewatering.
 
The
 
screen
 
overflow
 
is
 
combined
 
with
 
the
 
coarse
 
reject
 
material
 
and
conveyed to
 
the reject
 
bin. The
 
remaining flotation
 
tailings material
 
from either
 
CPP is
 
directed to
 
dedicated
tailings thickeners
 
with the
 
underflow pumped
 
to the
 
tails storage
 
facility (TSF).
 
The LOM TSF
 
is currently
 
a
project in progress assessing
 
the use of the
 
void at Pit B.
 
Water recovered
 
from the in-pit
 
TSF is included as
part of the site water balance model and is reused within the site to offset the volume of purchased raw water.
14.1.4
 
Operating performance
The two
 
processing plants
 
have a
 
nominal nameplate
 
throughput capacity
 
of 2300
 
t/h on
 
a combined
 
basis,
with
 
a
 
surge
 
capacity
 
on
 
selected
 
coal
 
feeds
 
to
 
2350t/h.
 
Applying
 
the
 
nominal
 
throughput
 
capacity
 
with
 
a
planned 7400 operating
 
hours per annum
 
the capacity
 
of the CHPP’s
 
at Curragh
 
would be as
 
seen in Table
14.1. This is consistent with the LOM plan annual production
 
rates planned from the combined Open Cut and
Underground mining complex at Curragh.
Table 14.1: CHPP Capacity
CHPP
Nameplate
Feed (t/hr)
Operating
Hours (per
year)
Feed Capacity
(Mtpa)
Forecast
Yield (%)
Total Product
Capacity(Mtpa)
1
1,100
7,400
8.1
79
6.4
2
1,200
7,400
8.9
79
7.0
TOTAL
2,300
7,400
16.5
79
13.4
Historical operating performance
 
indicates that the
 
combined facilities
 
have achieved a
 
maximum processed
throughput of 15.2 Mtpa ROM
 
feed in recent years and would
 
require further increases in
 
utilised hours to be
achieved to exceed
 
this value. The
 
ability to bypass
 
selected raw feed
 
material directly
 
as a thermal
 
product
is considered an accepted site practice
 
and where quality shortfalls are
 
realised can be blended with washed
thermal product to achieve the required product specification
 
and the required annual product volumes.
 
 
 
Page 92 of 118
15
 
Infrastructure
 
Curragh
 
owns
 
and
 
operates
 
the
 
necessary
 
coal
 
load-out
 
system
 
for
 
dispatches
 
via
 
rail
 
line
 
to
 
the
 
port
 
at
Gladstone or the
 
Stanwell Power Plant.
 
Moreover,
 
the mine has
 
maintenance facilities
 
for the fleet
 
of mining
equipment as well as office buildings for the mine
 
staff and personnel.
 
15.1.0
 
Water
Curragh obtains its water requirement from two main
 
sources:
Pursuant to
 
a supply
 
agreement with
 
SunWater
 
Ltd (“SunWater”)
 
from the
 
Bedford Weir
 
and Fairburn
 
Dam.
Curragh
 
is
 
permitted
 
to
 
draw
 
up
 
to
 
708
 
M
 
gallons
 
per
 
year
 
through
 
a
 
take
 
or
 
pay
 
offtake
 
agreement
 
with
SunWater.
 
Mine
 
water
 
recycling
 
can
 
significantly
 
reduce
 
the
 
need
 
for
 
importing
 
purchased
 
water
 
into
 
the
stored mine water inventory.
 
Pollution control dams and old pit voids capture rainfall and mine affected water from pit dewatering activities.
15.1.1
 
Power
Curragh has a dedicated
 
66kv power supply
 
to support the
 
mining operations with
 
a capacity of up
 
to 57MW
sourced from the main
 
grid power.
 
The substation is
 
located on the southwest
 
corner of the lease
 
and both
66kv and
 
22kv distribution
 
networks to
 
supply
 
the draglines,
 
shovel and
 
CHPP’s.
 
Part of
 
the site
 
electrical
system was upgraded in 2015 at the time of upgrading
 
the ROM crushing station.
The electrical
 
power requirements for
 
the Underground Mine
 
have been
 
determined. Studies have
 
shown there
is adequate
 
power on
 
site
 
for establishing
 
the
 
underground
 
mine and
 
commencing
 
the first
 
two continuous
miner Units, however
 
upgrades to
 
the site infrastructure
 
for full underground
 
production with four
 
continuous
miner units is required.
A load
 
study is
 
being undertaken
 
for Curragh
 
site to
 
determine the
 
required upgrades
 
for the
 
Open Cut
 
and
Underground
 
LOM.
 
Once
 
completed,
 
the
 
required
 
66kv
 
power
 
line
 
and
 
infrastructure
 
upgrades
 
must
 
be
completed before full underground production to sustain safe
 
and effective underground operations
15.1.2
 
Roads
Curragh
 
has
 
a
 
network
 
of
 
haul
 
roads
 
and
 
ramps
 
connecting
 
the
 
various
 
working
 
areas
 
of
 
the
 
operation.
 
Established
 
national
 
highways
 
such
 
as
 
Route
 
A4
 
(Capricorn
 
Highway)
 
connect
 
nearby
 
regional
 
towns
 
of
Blackwater
 
and
 
Emerald
 
to
 
the
 
regional
 
city
 
of
 
Rockhampton
 
to
 
the
 
East.
 
Site
 
access
 
from
 
the
 
Capricorn
Highway is via sealed road to the Curragh Mine Industrial Area
 
main carpark.
15.1.3
 
Rail
Curragh
 
is
 
linked
 
to
 
the
 
main
 
Blackwater
 
rail
 
link
 
to
 
the
 
Port
 
of Gladstone’s
 
RG
 
Tanna
 
Coal
 
Terminal
 
(RG
Tanna)
 
and Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal
 
(WICET) coal terminals by dedicated rail balloon loop with a
Marketable Coal
 
capacity of
 
14 million tonnes
 
per year.
 
Train
 
capacity averages
 
8,500 tonnes
 
at a
 
loading
capacity of 4,400 t/h with an average 28 trains loaded
 
every week (with a maximum capacity of 36 trains).
Curragh is located
 
290 km from
 
the Port of
 
Gladstone.
 
Under an existing
 
agreement, CCPL
 
has the right
 
to
rail up to 11.0 Mtpa, plus surge
 
of rail capacity on the
 
Blackwater system.
 
This network is operated by Aurizon
and links Central Queensland mines from the Bowen
 
Basin to two export terminals at the Port of Gladstone
 
–
RG Tanna
 
and WICET,
 
under two long term rail haulage agreements with Aurizon.
Domestically, Curragh’s steam coal is railed 160 km to the Stanwell Power Station
 
near Rockhampton.
 
Under
the Stanwell Coal Supply Agreement, Stanwell is responsible for the transport of the steam coal from Curragh
to the power station and pays for the railing costs.
ex961p95i0
 
Page 93 of 118
15.1.4
 
Port
Curragh’s export coal is
 
shipped either from RG
 
Tanna or WICET terminals at Gladstone.
 
The coal is
 
blended
at the port to meet market requirements.
There are agreements in place for approximately 8.6
 
million tonnes per year in exports from RG Tanna
 
and a
take
 
or pay
 
agreement
 
with
 
WICET
 
for
 
1.5 million
 
tonnes
 
per year.
 
There
 
is
 
sufficient
 
capacity
 
to
 
increase
these capacities as required.
Figure 15-1: Curragh Preparation Plant Infrastructure
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 94 of 118
16
 
Market studies
 
16.1
 
Market Description
Coronado maintains a specialist
 
corporate marketing team
 
that focusses on
 
direct sales of Curragh
 
products
to steel mills in
 
all major international
 
markets.
 
Curragh coals are widely
 
technically tested and
 
approved for
use
 
in
 
coke
 
making
 
blends,
 
with
 
product
 
positioning
 
optimised
 
over
 
many
 
years
 
(40
 
years)
 
in
 
the
market.
 
Curragh
 
coals
 
are
 
widely known
 
for their
 
low
 
ash, low
 
to mid
 
volatile
 
matter,
 
low
 
Sulphur
 
and
 
low
Phosphorous content. Curragh
 
Metallurgical Coal products
 
are also
 
known for their
 
consistent delivered quality
which supports a consistent offtake across
 
a diversified market base.
Table 16.1: Coal Quality for Washed Products
Seam
Primary
 
Yield (%)
Secondary
Yield (%)
CSN
Primary
Comments
Cancer
~30 @ 9% Ash
30
7 - 8
~0.5m thick.
 
Typically,
 
a Coking Coal blend
Aries
~50 @ 9% Ash
20 - 30
6 - 7
Aries Lower
 
has better
 
Coking Coal
 
properties
and
 
higher
 
CSN
 
than
 
Aries
 
Upper,
 
also
 
has
fluidity
 
50-100
 
ddpm.
 
Aries
 
Upper
 
typically
produces a high-ash blend PCI.
Castor Lower
45 - 50 @ 8% Ash
30 - 35
7 - 8
A
 
high
 
quality
 
coking
 
coal
 
seam
 
with
 
strong
swelling
 
and
 
plastics
 
and
 
an
 
important
 
coking
coal
 
blend component.
 
Good middlings
 
blend
product for steam coal.
Pollux
~45 @ 7% Ash
30 - 35
6.5 - 7.5
A
 
low
 
ash
 
Coking
 
coal
 
blend
 
coal,
 
Pollux
 
has
low plastic properties. The
 
middlings product is
a key high Ash PCI blend component.
Pisces Working
Section
UWS:
 
~80 @ 9%
Ash, mainly PCI
-
<3
Split
 
into
 
upper
 
working
 
section
 
(UWS)
 
and
lower
 
working
 
section
 
(LWS).
 
The
 
UWS
products a
 
low ash
 
PCI product
 
for PCI
 
blend.
The
 
LWS
 
middlings
 
typically produces
 
a
 
high-
ash (12%) PCI.
LWS:
 
~45 @ 7.5%
Ash
30 - 35
6.5 - 7.5
 
ex961p97i0
 
Page 95 of 118
16.2
 
Price Forecasts
In selecting forward
 
prices for Curragh’s
 
products, Coronado has
 
had regard to
 
price index forward
 
curve as
well
 
as
 
prices
 
forecasts
 
prepared
 
by
 
several
 
brokers
 
and
 
coal
 
industry
 
analysts.
 
For
 
the
 
purpose
 
of
 
this
analysis, Coronado has
 
adopted price benchmark
 
forecasts from a reputable
 
coal market research
 
company
as base
 
case. The
 
projected index
 
price benchmark
 
was then
 
adjusted to
 
reflected realised prices
 
for Curragh’s
products taking into account historical price relativities,
 
recent price negotiations and the product mix strategy
expected to be pursued over the mine life.
 
Domestic thermal sales tonnes are sold to Stanwell based on the Stanwell Coal Supply Agreement described
in 16.3
Average realised product coal price projections
 
over the LOM for Curragh are set out in Table
 
16.2.
 
Table 16.2: Coal Pricing (Real US$/t sold)
16.3
 
Contract Requirements
Material contracts considered in the economic evaluation
 
of Curragh include:
Stanwell
Coronado
 
are
 
party
 
to
 
contractual
 
arrangements
 
with
 
Stanwell,
 
including
 
a
 
Coal
 
Supply
 
Agreement,
 
or
 
the
CSA, and the Curragh Mine New Coal Supply Deed, dated August
 
14, 2018, or the Supply Deed.
Under
 
the
 
CSA,
 
Coronado
 
deliver
 
thermal
 
coal
 
from
 
Curragh
 
to
 
Stanwell
 
at
 
an
 
agreed
 
price
 
and
 
quantity.
Stanwell may
 
vary the
 
quantity of
 
thermal coal
 
purchased each
 
year so
 
the total
 
quantity to
 
be delivered
 
to
Stanwell each year cannot be precisely
 
forecast. The coal that Coronado
 
supplies to Stanwell constitutes the
majority of the thermal coal production from Curragh. The cost of supplying coal to Stanwell has been greater
than the contracted price paid by Stanwell during the year
 
ended December 31, 2023 and for prior years.
 
Under the CSA,
 
Coronado also share
 
part of the
 
revenue earned from
 
export Met coal
 
sales (from particular
Tenements
 
(as defined below)) with Stanwell through
 
various rebates. The most material rebate is
 
the export
price rebate, which is linked to the realized export coal price
 
for a defined Met coal product, as follows:
●
 
For
 
the first
 
7.0 MMtpa
 
of export
 
coal sales:
 
when
 
the
 
12month trailing,
 
weighted
 
average realized
export coal
 
price of
 
Reference
 
coal
 
exceeds
 
the
 
Tier 1
 
Rebate
 
Coal Floor
 
Price,
 
Coronado
 
pays
 
a
rebate of
 
25% of
 
the difference
 
between
 
the realized
 
export coal
 
price
 
and the
 
Tier 1
 
Rebate
 
Coal
Floor Price.
●
 
For export coal sales above 7.0 MMtpa: when the 12month trailing, weighted
 
average realized export
coal price of Reference
 
coal exceeds the Tier
 
2 Rebate Coal Floor
 
Price, Coronado pays
 
a rebate of
10% of the difference between the realized
 
export coal price and the Tier 2 Rebate
 
Coal Floor Price.
 
Page 96 of 118
The CSA also provides for:
●
a
tonnage rebate
 
to Stanwell
 
per Mt
 
on the
 
first 7.0
 
MMtpa of
 
export coal
 
sales
 
and on
 
export coal
sales above 7.0 MMtpa; and
●
 
a rebate on run-of-mine, or ROM, coal mined in the Curragh “Pit U
 
East Area.”
The total Stanwell
 
rebate for
 
the year ended
 
December 31, 2023,
 
was $136.5 million
 
and has been
 
included
in
 
the
 
Consolidated
 
Statements
 
of
 
Operations
 
and
 
Comprehensive
 
Income
 
included
 
elsewhere
 
in
 
the
Coronado Annual Report on Form 10-K.
The Supply Deed
 
grants Coronado the
 
right to mine
 
the coal reserves
 
in the Stanwell
 
Reserved Area, or
 
the
SRA. In exchange, Coronado agrees
 
to certain amendments to the CSA and to enter into a New Coal Supply
Agreement, or
 
the NCSA
 
upon the
 
expiration of
 
the CSA
 
(which is
 
expected to
 
occur in
 
2027).
 
On July 12,
2019, Coronado entered into the NCSA with Stanwell.
 
The following are the key terms under the NCSA:
●
 
Coronado’s supply obligation will commence
 
on the earliest of:
-
 
the day after final delivery date under the NCSA;
-
 
the date ate of termination of the CSA, if it does so prior
 
to final delivery date; and
-
 
January 1, 2029;
 
●
 
The
 
term
 
of
 
the
 
NCSA
 
is
 
expected
 
to
 
be
 
10
 
years,
 
and
 
Coronado
 
will
 
supply
 
to
 
Stanwell
 
2 million
‘Tonnes
 
Equivalent’ of
 
thermal coal per
 
annum (based
 
on a nominal
 
gross calorific
 
value of 25.6GJ)
at
 
a
 
fixed
 
contract
 
price
 
that
 
varies
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
agreed
 
formulae,
 
inclusive
 
of
 
all
 
statutory
charges and royalties in respect of coal sold and delivered
 
under the NCSA;
●
 
The export rebates which were payable under the CSA are not
 
payable during the term of NCSA;
The supply
 
term, the
 
contract
 
tonnage and
 
the contract
 
price under
 
the NCSA
 
are subject
 
to adjustment
 
in
accordance
 
with
 
a
 
financial
 
model
 
agreed
 
between
 
Stanwell
 
and
 
Coronado.
 
In
 
summary,
 
Coronado
 
have
agreed that the total value of
 
the discount received by Stanwell on
 
coal supplied to it under the
 
NCSA should
(by the expiry date of
 
the NCSA) be equal to
 
the net present value of
 
$155.2 million (A$210.0 million) as at the
date of the Supply Deed, using a
 
contractual pre-tax discount rate of
 
13% per annum.
 
The net present value
of the deferred
 
consideration was
 
$277.4million as
 
of December 31,
 
2023. On
 
January 18, 2021,
 
the Option
Coal Supply Agreement, or the OCSA, contemplated
 
by clause 5 of the NCSA was entered into,
 
in respect of
the supply of certain additional coal to Stanwell during the
 
term of the NCSA.
Logistics
Curragh typically sells
 
export coal
 
FOB, with
 
the customer paying
 
for transportation from
 
the outbound
 
shipping
port. The majority of Curragh’s export Met coal is railed approximately 300 kilometers to the Port
 
of Gladstone
for export via two
 
main port terminals,
 
RG Tanna
 
Coal Terminal,
 
or RGTCT,
 
and Wiggins Island
 
Coal Export
Terminal,
 
or WICET.
 
Curragh also has capacity available to stockpile
 
coal at the Port of Gladstone. For sales
of thermal coal to Stanwell, Stanwell is responsible for
 
the transport of coal to the Stanwell Power Station.
 
Rail Services
Curragh is linked to the Blackwater rail line of the Central Queensland Coal
 
Network, or CQCN, an integrated
coal haulage rail system
 
owned and operated by
 
Aurizon Network Pty Ltd.,
 
or Aurizon Network.
 
Curragh has
secured annual rail
 
haulage capacity of
 
up to 12.0
 
MMtpa (plus surge
 
capacity) under long-term
 
rail haulage
agreements with
 
Aurizon Operations
 
Limited, or
 
Aurizon Operations, and
 
Pacific National
 
Holdings Pty
 
Limited,
or Pacific National.
 
The RGTCT Coal
 
Transport Services Agreement with Aurizon
 
Operations is for
 
8.5 MMtpa of
 
haulage capacity
to
 
RGTCT.
 
Curragh
 
pays
 
a
 
minimum
 
monthly
 
charge
 
(components
 
of
 
which
 
are
 
payable
 
on
 
a
 
take-or-pay
basis),
 
which
 
is
 
calculated
 
with
 
reference
 
to
 
the
 
below-rail
 
access
 
charges,
 
haulage/freight
 
charges,
 
a
 
Page 97 of 118
minimum
 
annual
 
tonnage
 
charge
 
and
 
other
 
charges.
 
The
 
RGTCT
 
Coal
 
Transport
 
Services
 
Agreement
terminates on June 30, 2030.
 
The Coal Transport Services Agreement with Pacific National is for
 
1.0 MMtpa of haulage capacity to
 
RGTCT.
Curragh pays a minimum monthly charge (components of which are payable on a take-or-pay basis), which is
calculated
 
with
 
reference
 
to
 
the
 
below-rail
 
access
 
charges,
 
haulage/freight
 
charges,
 
a
 
minimum
 
annual
tonnage charge and other
 
charges. The Coal Transport
 
Services Agreement with Pacific
 
National terminates
on July 31, 2029.
 
The Wiggins
 
Island Rail
 
Project, or
 
WIRP,
 
Transport
 
Services Agreement
 
with Aurizon
 
Operations is
 
for 2.0
MMtpa of
 
capacity to
 
WICET.
 
This contract
 
is effectively
 
100% take-or-pay
 
(for a
 
portion of
 
the rail
 
haulage
and all capacity access charges). This agreement expires
 
on June 30, 2030.
Port Services
Curragh exports coal through
 
two terminals at the
 
Port of Gladstone, RGTCT
 
and WICET. At RGTCT,
 
Curragh
and Gladstone
 
Port Corporation
 
Limited, or
 
GPC,
 
are
 
parties to
 
a coal
 
handling
 
agreement that
 
expires
 
on
June 30,
 
2030.
 
The
 
agreement
 
may
 
be
 
renewed
 
at
 
our
 
request
 
and,
 
subject
 
to
 
certain
 
conditions, GPC
 
is
required to
 
agree to
 
the extension
 
if there
 
is capacity
 
at RGTCT
 
to allow
 
the extension.
 
Coronado currently
have the right to export between 7.7 MMtpa and 8.7 MMtpa at Coronado’s nomination on a take-or-pay basis.
Coronado have a
 
minority interest in
 
WICET Holdings Pty Ltd, whose
 
wholly-owned subsidiary, Wiggins Island
Coal Export Terminal
 
Pty Ltd, or WICET Pty Ltd, owns WICET.
 
Other coal producers who export coal through
WICET also hold
 
shares in
 
WICET Holdings
 
Pty Ltd. In addition,
 
Coronado and
 
the other coal
 
producers (or
shippers) have take-or-pay agreements with WICET Pty Ltd and
 
pay a terminal handling charge to
 
export coal
through WICET,
 
which is calculated by reference to WICET’s annual operating costs, as well as finance costs
associated
 
with
 
WICET
 
Pty Ltd’s
 
external
 
debt
 
facilities.
 
Coronado’s
 
take-or-pay
 
agreement
 
with
 
WICET
Pty Ltd,
 
or
 
the
 
WICET
 
Take
 
-or-Pay
 
Agreement,
 
provides
 
Curragh
 
with
 
export
 
capacity
 
of
 
1.5
 
MMtpa.
 
The
WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement is an “evergreen” agreement, with rolling ten-year terms. If we inform WICET
Pty Ltd that we do not wish to continue to roll the term
 
of the WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement, the term would
be set at nine
 
years and the terminal handling charge payable
 
by us would be increased so
 
that our proportion
of WICET Pty Ltd’s debt is amortized to nil
 
by the end of that nine-year term.
Under
 
the
 
WICET
 
Take
 
-or-Pay
 
Agreement,
 
Coronado
 
are
 
obligated
 
to
 
pay
 
for
 
that
 
capacity
 
via
 
terminal
handling charges, whether utilized or not.
 
The terminal handling charge payable by Coronado
 
can be adjusted
by WICET Pty Ltd if our share of WICET Pty Ltd’s operational and finance costs increases, including because
of increased
 
operational costs
 
or because
 
another shipper
 
defaults and
 
has its
 
capacity reduced
 
to nil.
 
The
terminal handling charge
 
is subject to a
 
financing cap set out in
 
the terminal handling charge methodology and
has already
 
been reached
 
and is
 
in force.
 
If another
 
shipper defaults
 
under its
 
take-or-pay agreement,
 
each
remaining shipper is effectively proportionately liable to pay that
 
defaulting shipper’s share of WICET Pty Ltd’s
costs going forward, in the form of increased terminal handling
 
charges.
If
 
Coronado
 
default
 
under
 
the
 
WICET
 
Take
 
-or-Pay
 
Agreement,
 
Coronado
 
would
 
be
 
obligated
 
to
 
pay
 
a
termination
 
payment
 
to
 
WICET
 
Pty Ltd.
 
The
 
termination
 
payment
 
effectively
 
represents
 
our
 
proportion
 
of
WICET
 
Pty Ltd’s
 
total
 
debt
 
outstanding,
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
proportion
 
of
 
our
 
contracted
 
tonnage
 
to
 
the
 
total
contracted
 
tonnage
 
of shippers
 
at WICET
 
at the
 
time
 
the payment
 
is triggered.
 
Shippers
 
can also
 
become
liable to
 
pay the
 
termination payment
 
where there
 
is a
 
permanent cessation
 
of operations
 
at WICET.
 
Since
WICET began
 
shipping export tonnages
 
in April
 
2015, four
 
WICET Holdings
 
Pty Ltd shareholders have
 
entered
into
 
administration
 
and
 
Take
 
-or-Pay
 
Agreements
 
subsequently
 
terminated,
 
resulting
 
in
 
the
 
aggregate
contracted tonnage of shippers decreasing from 27 MMtpa
 
to 15.5 MMtpa.
Under the WICET Take
 
-or-Pay Agreement, Coronado is required to
 
provide security (which is provided in the
form of a
 
bank guarantee). The amount
 
of the security must
 
cover Coronado’s estimated liabilities as
 
a shipper
under
 
the
 
WICET
 
Take
 
-or-Pay
 
Agreement
 
for
 
the
 
following
 
twelve-month
 
period.
 
If
 
Coronado
 
is
 
in
 
default
under the WICET Take-or-Pay Agreement and are subject to a termination payment, WICET Pty Ltd
 
can draw
on the security and apply it to amounts owing by Coronado
 
.
 
 
Page 98 of 118
Thiess Mining Services Contract
Thiess Pty
 
Ltd has
 
provided mining
 
services to
 
Curragh at
 
Curragh North
 
since 2004
 
and currently
 
operate
five excavator fleets.
 
The current contract expires
 
at the end
 
of December 2025.
 
The mining services contract
includes overburden removal and haulage, mining, equipment
 
maintenance and pit dewatering.
 
Golding Mining Services Contract
Golding Contractors Pty
 
Ltd has
 
provided mining services
 
to Curragh at
 
Curragh Main since
 
2014 and
 
currently
operate six excavator fleets.
 
The current contract expires at the end of December 2026.
 
The mining services
contract includes overburden removal and haulage, mining
 
and equipment maintenance.
 
 
 
 
Page 99 of 118
17
 
Environmental studies, permitting, and plans, negotiations,
or agreements with local individuals or groups
 
17.1
 
Results of Studies
Prior to securing the existing relevant
 
Queensland and Commonwealth approvals
 
for Curragh, the necessary
environmental
 
and
 
cultural
 
heritage
 
studies
 
have
 
been
 
completed.
 
Additional
 
environmental
 
studies
 
are
progressing to support relevant approval requirements
 
for future underground mining.
Besides mining,
 
the area
 
affected
 
by the
 
Curragh project
 
is used
 
essentially
 
for low
 
intensity
 
cattle grazing
plus some
 
amount of
 
dryland cropping.
 
Most of
 
the land
 
within the
 
area is
 
currently disturbed
 
as a
 
result of
historical
 
grazing
 
and
 
mining
 
activities.
 
The
 
property
 
has
 
been
 
the
 
subject
 
of
 
extensive
 
activities
 
prior
 
to
Curragh.
Curragh
 
has
 
complied
 
with
 
environmental
 
and
 
heritage
 
requirements
 
under
 
relevant
 
Queensland
 
and
Commonwealth legislation
 
and adheres to
 
standard practices
 
for environmental
 
management set
 
for all coal
mines
 
in
 
central
 
Queensland,
 
including
 
mitigation
 
of
 
impacts
 
on
 
cultural
 
heritage.
 
There
 
have
 
been
 
some
adverse incidents, however, the main ones being spills of diesel fuel (87,000 litres in 2016 and 25,000 litres in
2017), as
 
well occasions
 
of minor
 
uncontrolled or
 
non-compliant
 
water releases.
 
Corrective measures
 
have
remediated these incidents where required.
 
Remediation of the main diesel spills is ongoing.
17.2
 
Requirements and Plans for Waste Disposal
General and
 
Hazardous (Regulated)
 
solid waste
 
at Curragh
 
is the
 
object of
 
a mandatory
 
management plan
under the environmental
 
license. General
 
waste is
 
disposed at
 
an approved
 
landfill site
 
at Curragh,
 
while all
regulated waste is
 
transported and treated offsite in
 
an environmentally appropriate manner and
 
in compliance
with
 
the
 
Queensland
 
regulations.
 
The
 
mine
 
infrastructure
 
includes
 
two
 
Sewage
 
Treatment
 
Plants
 
(STP)
subject
 
to conditions
 
in the
 
environmental
 
license
 
and
 
with the
 
necessary
 
site procedures
 
in
 
place.
 
These
STPs process effluents from all office and
 
camp/accommodation facilities.
 
Industrial
 
waste
 
(tailings)
 
from
 
the
 
CHPP
 
is
 
disposed
 
of
 
in
 
regulated
 
structures.
 
There
 
are
 
three
 
TSF’s
 
at
Curragh, two in-pit and one conventional above ground
 
TSF.
 
The above ground TSF is the original, complete
and
 
non-operational
 
facility.
 
In-pit
 
TSF
 
is
 
the
 
process
 
of
 
backfilling
 
abandoned
 
pits,
 
this
 
is
 
currently
 
the
preferred method by
 
the regulator.
 
Pit A TSF
 
has limited remaining
 
capacity and
 
is non-operational
 
while Pit
B TSF is
 
an active facility
 
with storage
 
capacity of
 
significant volume
 
remaining
 
and thus
 
provides long-term
security for tailings storage.
 
These locations are shown in Figure 17-1.
 
All regulated structures are subject to
ongoing inspection by
 
Curragh and annual
 
inspections by an
 
independent Registered
 
Professional Engineer
of Queensland (RPEQ).
 
ex961p102i0
 
Page 100 of 118
Figure 17-1: Mine Waste Disposal Areas
17.3
 
Permit Requirements and Status
All applicable environmental licenses and permits under
 
both the Queensland and Commonwealth legislation
have
 
been
 
secured
 
and
 
are
 
in
 
place
 
for
 
approved
 
open-cut
 
operations.
 
Work
 
is
 
in
 
progress
 
to
 
meet
 
the
approved open-cut pre-mining requirements for ML’s
 
700006, 700007, 700008, and 700009.
 
An amendment
 
to the
 
state-based Queensland
 
Environmental Authority
 
is required
 
for underground
 
mining.
Preparation
 
for
 
an
 
Environmental
 
Authority
 
amendment
 
application
 
lodgement
 
is
 
progressing.
 
No
Commonwealth based approvals
 
are expected. There
 
are no perceived
 
issues expected to
 
prevent securing
any future permits.
 
Page 101 of 118
17.4
 
Local Plans, Negotiations or Agreements
Curragh has five environmental management areas that are requirements
 
of conditions of approval under the
two
 
separate
 
referrals
 
under
 
the
 
Commonwealth
 
EPBC
 
Act
 
1999
 
Under
 
Commonwealth
 
requirements,
Curragh
 
has
 
also
 
provided
 
a
 
biodiversity
 
offset
 
at
 
Mt.
 
Flora,
 
near
 
Nebo
 
in
 
Central
 
Queensland.
 
Further
biodiversity
 
offsets
 
are
 
required
 
under
 
obligations
 
related
 
to
 
the
 
Commonwealth
 
and
 
State
 
approvals
 
for
ML700007 and ML700008 and are in progress.
Curragh negotiated a CHMP in 2012.
 
This plan was subsequently repealed and replaced by the 2017 CHMP
with the
 
statutory Aboriginal
 
parties for
 
the area
 
to allow
 
access for
 
mining activities.
 
A Services
 
Agreement
signed in December 2017 details the fee schedule for services such as cultural heritage survey and mitigation
prior to mining
 
and exploration
 
activities by Curragh.
 
These agreements
 
comply with
 
the legislation
 
and are
within industry standards.
 
All cultural heritage sites are protected and subject to
 
mitigation, however there are
currently no identified sites of significant cultural heritage
 
value.
 
With reference to
 
native title, the
 
Queensland Government
 
coordinates the
 
application process
 
for Resource
authorities and advises on
 
land that may
 
be subject to native
 
title.
 
To date none of the Curragh Mining
 
Leases,
other than ML80123, require
 
native title processes
 
for its grant.
 
However, most
 
areas in central Queensland
are subject to
 
an undetermined
 
Native Title
 
Claim and
 
the determination
 
of native
 
title may affect
 
existing or
future mining activities at Curragh.
17.5
 
Mine closure plans and associated costs
Queensland
 
legislation
 
requires
 
that
 
all
 
mining
 
activities
 
approved
 
through
 
a
 
site-specific
 
environmental
authority develop a Progressive Rehabilitation
 
and Closure Plan (PRCP).
 
The main purposes of
 
the PRCP are
to plan
 
for how and
 
where mining activities
 
will be
 
carried out in
 
a way
 
that maximises progressive
 
rehabilitation
and to detail the condition to which the land must be rehabilitated
 
prior to relinquishment.
 
The
 
Curragh
 
Project
 
PRCP
 
has
 
been
 
developed
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
the
 
legislative
 
requirements
 
and
 
was
submitted
 
by
 
Coronado
 
Curragh
 
on
 
21
 
October
 
2022
 
to
 
the
 
administering
 
authority,
 
the
 
Department
 
of
Environment
 
and
 
Science
 
(DES)
 
for
 
assessment.
 
DES
 
reviewed
 
and
 
subsequently
 
issued
 
a
 
Request
 
for
Information Notice
 
(RFI). Coronado
 
Curragh submitted
 
a response
 
addressing the
 
RFI on
 
the 20
 
November
2023. DES has
 
extended the
 
period for deciding
 
the application
 
to 2 February
 
2024.
 
The PRCP will
 
include
post-mining
 
land
 
uses,
 
rehabilitation
 
methodologies,
 
community
 
consultation
 
requirements,
 
supporting
technical studies and
 
a schedule
 
outlining when rehabilitation
 
will occur.
 
The Curragh
 
Project is approved
 
to
have residual voids in the post-mining landform.
 
Estimated
 
costs
 
for mine
 
closure,
 
including removal
 
of
 
infrastructure,
 
contaminated
 
land
 
investigations
 
and
remediation, reshaping
 
and rehabilitation
 
works, monitoring
 
and maintenance
 
and a
 
10% contingency,
 
have
been undertaken using
 
a government estimated
 
rehabilitation cost calculator.
 
This cost was updated
 
in 2022
and
 
as
 
required
 
by
 
legislation;
 
an
 
appropriate
 
financial
 
provision
 
contribution
 
has
 
been
 
lodged
 
with
 
the
Queensland State Government. Curragh has recognised a
 
provision for Asset Retirement Obligation (ARO) of
$70.2million based on disturbances to date as disclosed in Coronado’s Form 10K for the fiscal year ending
 
31
December 2023.
17.6
 
Commitment to local hiring
Curragh
 
has
 
a
 
long
 
association
 
with
 
the
 
Blackwater
 
community.
 
Since
 
the
 
mine
 
opened
 
in
 
1983,
 
many
employees and their families have lived in Blackwater, and through this connection Curragh has been a major
supporter of the Blackwater community.
Curragh’s community
 
engagement includes
 
providing support
 
across community
 
organisations, health
 
care,
education,
 
sport,
 
culture,
 
indigenous
 
communities
 
and
 
local
 
tourism.
 
Curragh
 
is
 
proud
 
to
 
support
 
the
development of a strong, healthy and vibrant Blackwater
 
community.
Respecting
 
and
 
preserving
 
Indigenous
 
cultural
 
heritage
 
is
 
important
 
to
 
Curragh.
 
Curragh
 
holds
 
regular
 
co-
ordination meetings with representatives
 
of the local
 
Indigenous communities and educates its
 
employees and
contractors on the importance and significance of Aboriginal heritage
 
and culture.
 
Page 102 of 118
Coronado has long standing
 
relationships with the communities
 
surrounding Curragh. Many
 
of the Coronado
employees
 
live
 
near
 
Curragh
 
and
 
benefit
 
from
 
Coronado’s
 
social
 
partnerships
 
and
 
investments.
 
As
 
at
 
31
October 2023, Curragh employed over 485 permanent employees. The majority of permanent employees are
based in nearby Blackwater regional township with
 
other staff located in the Brisbane office. Additionally, circa
3500 contractor employees regularly supplement the permanent
 
workforce.
17.7
 
Qualified Person ’s Opinion
It
 
is
 
the
 
Qualified
 
Person’s
 
opinion
 
(Daniel
 
Millers)
 
that
 
the
 
approach
 
taken
 
to
 
manage
 
environmental
compliance,
 
community impacts and
 
permitting is sufficient
 
to not raise any
 
concerns with the
 
open cut LOM
plan and Coal
 
Reserve estimate in this
 
TRS. There are some
 
secondary approvals required as
 
outlined in 17.3
above,
 
that
 
will
 
need
 
to
 
be
 
in
 
place
 
before
 
overburden
 
waste
 
stripping
 
commences
 
in
 
the
 
X
 
and
 
Z
 
pit
development areas. This is currently planned in this LOM
 
plan for 2030 and 2031 respectively.
 
It is the Qualified Person’s opinion (Chris Wilkinson) that
 
appropriate approvals for underground mining will be
obtained based on the feedback provided by Coronado.
 
The planned workings
 
of the Southern
 
area of the underground
 
project in the Mammoth
 
Seam extend under
the environmental offset area within ML 80123. A
 
major amendment will be made
 
to current Environmental
Authority
 
(EPML00643713)
 
for
 
the
 
inclusion
 
of
 
underground
 
mining
 
activities.
 
This
 
major
 
amendment
 
is
supported
 
by
 
an
 
Environmental
 
Assessment
 
Report
 
(EAR)
 
which
 
will
 
be
 
submitted
 
to
 
the
 
Department
 
of
Environment and Science (DES) in early 2024. It is anticipated that the approval of
 
the major EA amendment
to support project commencement will be achieved in December 2024.
 
 
ex961p105i0
 
Page 103 of 118
18
 
Capital and Operating Costs
18.1
 
Capital Cost Estimate
The production
 
sequence
 
selected
 
for a
 
property
 
must
 
consider the
 
proximity
 
of
 
each reserve
 
area
 
to coal
preparation
 
plants,
 
and
 
railroad
 
loading
 
points,
 
along
 
with
 
suitability
 
of
 
production
 
equipment
 
to
 
coal
 
seam
conditions.
 
Existing
 
in-place
 
infrastructure
 
was
 
evaluated,
 
and
 
any
 
future
 
needs
 
were
 
planned
 
to
 
a
 
level
suitable for economic
 
reserves production including assessment
 
of sustaining and
 
development capex to
 
allow
entry into new open pit mining areas.
A summary of the estimated capital costs
 
for the Property is provided in Figure 18-1 below.
 
Figure 18-1: CAPEX US$ million (nominal)
Exploration,
 
development
 
and
 
expansion
 
capital
 
expenditure
 
for
 
the
 
period
 
between
 
2024
 
and
 
2026
 
are
associated
 
primarily
 
with
 
the
 
underground
 
project
 
(c.
 
US$
 
105 million)
 
and
 
planned
 
boxcut
 
development
 
(c
US$ 31million).
 
From 2028
 
to 2032,
 
exploration, development
 
and expansion
 
capex are
 
associated with
 
the
developments of X and Z pits in the open cut mine
 
plan (c. US$ 319 million).
The
 
development
 
and
 
expansion
 
capital
 
cost
 
estimates
 
for
 
both
 
the
 
open
 
cut
 
and
 
underground
 
mines
 
at
Curragh are
 
currently completed
 
to a
 
Pre-Feasibility
 
Study level
 
at +/-25%
 
level of
 
accuracy.
 
The proposed
startup location for the
 
underground mine in the
 
Mammoth seam has a
 
more detailed capital development
 
cost
estimate undertaken at a Feasibility level of study with
 
an accuracy level of +/-15%.
 
18.2
 
Operating Cost Estimate
Curragh’s costs
 
estimates are
 
based on
 
expected operational
 
productivity and
 
associated fixed
 
and variable
costs
 
which have
 
been projected having
 
regard to
 
a number
 
of factors
 
including existing and
 
estimated contract
rates for
 
both upstream
 
and downstream
 
costs, forecast
 
exchange rate,
 
impact of
 
inflation on
 
costs, among
other macroeconomic conditions impacting the business.
 
Unit rates by activities are assessed in detail for site
budget preparations
 
and long
 
term averages
 
adjusted for
 
inflation are applied
 
to future
 
periods for
 
the life of
mine.
 
Operating
 
costs
 
include
 
calculation
 
of
 
Queensland
 
state
 
royalties
 
applied
 
to
 
sales
 
revenue
 
and
calculated within mandated tiers as well as contractual rebates
 
paid to Stanwell as per the CSA.
 
The operating
 
costs for
 
the open
 
cut mine
 
are at
 
a high
 
level of
 
accuracy supported
 
by supply
 
contracts for
material goods and
 
services including offsite
 
logistics and existing
 
mining costs
 
from the open cut
 
operation.
The forecasted LOM
 
open cut costs
 
have been benchmarked
 
against actuals and
 
budget costs for
 
the open
cut operation to
 
ensure validity in
 
this LOM financial
 
model. The level
 
of accuracy
 
for the open
 
cut operating
costs would
 
be described
 
as detailed
 
budget level
 
costs for
 
2024 and
 
2025 years
 
at +/-
 
10%. For
 
2026 and
beyond the LOM open cut operating costs are at a Feasibility
 
Study level detail at +/- 15% level of accuracy.
 
 
ex961p12i1
 
Page 104 of 118
The underground LOM operating costs
 
are project level cost estimates
 
as there is no existing operating
 
mine
at
 
Curragh
 
to
 
benchmark
 
or
 
reconcile
 
against.
 
The
 
Curragh
 
underground
 
operating
 
costs
 
are
 
at
 
a
 
Pre-
Feasibility Study level of accuracy of +/-25%.
 
A summary of nominal operating costs is provided in Figure
 
18-2.
Figure 18-2 : Curragh Operating Cost Profile (nominal)
19
 
Economic Analysis
19.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methods
The
 
Mine
 
plan,
 
productivity
 
expectations
 
and
 
cost
 
estimates
 
generally
 
reflect
 
historical
 
performance
 
by
Coronado and efforts
 
have been made
 
to adjust plans
 
and costs to
 
reflect future conditions
 
and comply with
contractual obligations.
The financial model, prepared for
 
this TRS, was developed to
 
test the economic viability of
 
the Coal Reserve
estimate. The results of
 
this financial model are not
 
intended to represent a
 
bankable feasibility study, required
for financing of any current or future mining operations, but are intended to prove the economic viability of the
estimated Coal Reserves.
 
On
 
an
 
unlevered
 
basis,
 
the
 
NPV
 
of
 
the
 
project
 
cash
 
flows
 
after
 
taxes
 
was
 
estimated
 
for
 
the
 
purpose
 
of
classifying Coal Reserves. The project cash flows, excluding debt service, are calculated by subtracting direct
and indirect operating
 
expenses and
 
capital expenditures
 
from revenue.
 
Revenue is derived
 
from long term
forward price
 
estimates
 
observed
 
at December
 
2023.
 
Both upstream
 
and downstream
 
costs are
 
calculated
based on
 
site knowledge
 
of costs
 
profiles and
 
contractor
 
obligations. Net
 
cash flows
 
incorporate
 
applicable
state and federal taxes plus progressive reclamation obligations to the end of mine closure. All cash flows are
denominated in nominal USD incorporating inflation of 2.5%
 
in FY24 and 2.0% thereafter.
All figures
 
are reported in
 
USD millions unless
 
otherwise stated and
 
volume related data
 
is reported on
 
a metric
tonne basis. The net present value of the projected cash flows have been calculated adopting a 10% post-tax
discount rate.
The projection model also includes
 
notional income tax calculations at
 
the Curragh level adopting a
 
federal tax
rate of
 
30%. To
 
the extent
 
the mine
 
generates net
 
operating losses
 
for tax
 
purposes, the
 
losses are
 
carried
over to offset
 
future taxable income. The
 
terms “cash flows”
 
and “project cash flows”
 
used in this report
 
refer
to after tax, unlevered cash flows.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 105 of 118
19.2
 
Results
 
A base
 
case NPV
 
of US$1.1 billion
 
is based
 
on life
 
of mine
 
average exchange
 
rate of
 
0.69 which
 
has been
assessed
 
having
 
regard
 
to
 
exchange
 
rate
 
forward
 
curves,
 
economic
 
specialists
 
forecasts
 
and
 
broker
consensus as at 31 December 2023.
Annual cash flows based
 
throughout mine life
 
to final reclamation
 
and make good
 
on assumptions applied
 
is
provided in Figure 19-1.
Figure 19-1: Project Post Tax Net Cash Flow Summary (Millions)
US$ million
(nominal)
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
2031
2032
2033
Rest of
LOM
EBITDA
113
76
133
224
310
364
314
334
318
347
4,509
Payable income tax
(5)
0
(7)
(43)
(63)
(78)
(59)
(63)
(57)
(73)
(1,010)
Change in working capital
5
55
(29)
15
(17)
7
(1)
(6)
2
(5)
(120)
Capex
(105)
(99)
(92)
(64)
(115)
(123)
(153)
(151)
(148)
(80)
(921)
Rehabilitation costs
(9)
(5)
(4)
(4)
(5)
(4)
(5)
(9)
(8)
(9)
(389)
Free cash flow
(2)
27
1
128
110
166
96
106
106
179
2,070
 
The results
 
of this
 
financial model
 
are not
 
intended to
 
represent a
 
bankable feasibility study, as
 
may be
 
required
for financing of any current
 
or future mining operations
 
contemplated but are intended
 
to prove the economic
viability of the estimated Coal Reserves.
Cash flows are sufficient to support identified economic
 
reserves.
19.3
 
Sensitivity
Sensitivity of the
 
NPV results
 
to changes in
 
the key drivers
 
is presented in
 
Table
 
19.1.
 
The sensitivity study
shows the
 
NPV at
 
the 10%
 
discount rate
 
when Base
 
Case sales
 
prices and
 
exchange rates
 
increased and
decreased in increments of 5%.
Table 19.1: Sensitivity of NPV (USD billions)
Price/FX
-5%FX
Base
+5% FX
+5% Price
$1.8
$1.5
$1.2
Base
$1.4
$1.1
$0.8
-5% Price
$0.9
$0.6
$0.3
 
 
 
Page 106 of 118
20
 
Adjacent properties
 
20.1
 
Information Used
No Proprietary information associated with neighbouring properties
 
was used as part of this study.
 
 
 
Page 107 of 118
21
 
Other relevant data and information
 
This document applies solely to the Curragh mining operations and no
 
other relevant data or information were
contemplated in its findings.
 
 
 
 
Page 108 of 118
22
 
Interpretation and conclusions
 
22.1
 
Conclusion
Upon
 
completion
 
of
 
these
 
studies
 
and
 
analyses
 
of
 
the
 
Curragh
 
project,
 
the
 
authors
 
have
 
reached
 
the
conclusion
 
that
 
the
 
Coal
 
Resource
 
and
 
Reserve
 
estimates
 
and
 
related
 
findings
 
presented
 
in
 
this
 
TRS
 
are
reasonably accurate
 
and representative
 
of the property
 
conditions. The
 
data has
 
been interpreted
 
according
to industry standards,
 
geostatistics was used
 
to estimate resource
 
tonnes and qualities
 
away from drill
 
holes
according to the
 
level of
 
confidence as drill
 
hole spacing outlined
 
in this
 
report.
 
Reserve estimates were
 
derived
from the defined
 
Coal Resource considering
 
relevant mining,
 
processing, infrastructure,
 
economic (including
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue,
 
and
 
cost),
 
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
 
socio-economic
 
and
 
regulatory
modifying factors.
22.2
 
Significant Risk Factors
The purpose of the characterization of the project risk components is to inform the project stakeholders of key
aspects of the
 
Curragh project
 
that can be
 
impacted by
 
events whose consequences
 
can affect the
 
success
of the
 
venture.
 
The significance of
 
an impacted aspect
 
of the operation
 
is directly related
 
to both the
 
probability
of occurrence and the severity of the
 
consequences.
 
Risk can be ranked numerically, derived from the values
assigned to probability and consequence ranging from
 
very low risk to very high risk.
 
The
 
probability
 
and
 
consequence
 
parameters
 
are
 
subjective
 
estimates
 
made
 
by
 
the
 
Qualified
 
Persons’
authoring this report.
 
Consequence estimates are
 
assigned numerical values from
 
1 to 5 for which the
 
value
1
 
represents
 
the
 
highest
 
consequence,
 
and
 
the
 
value
 
5
 
represents
 
the
 
lowest.
 
Probability
 
estimates
 
are
assigned
 
alphabetical
 
values
 
from
 
A
 
to
 
E
 
with
 
A
 
representing
 
the
 
highest
 
probability
 
of
 
occurrence
 
and
 
E
representing the
 
lowest probability.
 
The combination
 
of Consequence
 
and Probability
 
rankings are
 
used to
assign the Risk Level classified from Very
 
High to Low risk.
 
22.2.0
 
Governing Assumptions
The listing
 
of the
 
aspects is
 
not presumed
 
to be
 
exhaustive.
 
Instead that
 
listing is
 
presented based
 
on the
experiences of the contributors to the TRS.
 
The probability
 
and
 
consequence
 
ratings
 
are
 
subjectively
 
assigned,
 
and
 
it
 
is
 
assumed
 
that
 
this
 
subjectivity
reasonably reflects the condition of the active and projected
 
mine operations.
The Control Measures shown in
 
the matrices presented in this
 
chapter are not exhaustive.
 
They represent a
condensed collection of
 
activities that the
 
author of the
 
risk assessment section
 
has observed to
 
be effective
in coal mining scenarios.
 
Mitigation
 
Measures
 
listed
 
for
 
each
 
risk
 
factor
 
of
 
the
 
operation
 
are
 
not
 
exhaustive.
 
The
 
measures
 
listed,
however, have been observed
 
by the author to be effective.
 
The financial values
 
used in ranking
 
the consequences
 
are generally accepted
 
quantities for the
 
coal mining
industry.
22.2.1
 
Limitations
The risk assessment in
 
this report is subject to
 
the limitations of the information
 
currently collected, tested, and
interpreted at the time of the writing of the report.
22.2.2
 
Development of the Risk Matrix
Risks have
 
been identified
 
for the
 
technical, operational,
 
and administrative
 
subjects addressed
 
in the
 
TRS.
 
The risk
 
matrix and
 
risk assessment process
 
are modelled according
 
to the Coronado
 
group Risk Management
Policy.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 109 of 118
22.2.2.1
 
Consequence and Probability Level Tables
The
 
Likelihood
 
Table
 
22.1
 
was
 
sourced
 
from
 
the
 
Coronado
 
Group
 
Risk
 
Management
 
Policy
 
dated
 
16th
February 2023.
 
Table 22.1:
 
Likelihood/Probability Level Table
Cat.
Likelihood
Description
A
Almost Certain
May occur more than once in a year
B
Likely
May occur over a one to two-year period
C
Possible
May occur within a five-year period
D
Unlikely
May occur within a 10-year period
E
Rare
May occur within a 30-year time period
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 110 of 118
The Consequence Level Table
 
22.2 was sourced from the Coronado Group Risk
 
Management Policy dated 16th February 2023.
 
Table 22.2; Consequence Level Table
#
FL Category
Safety
Environment
Reputation
Production
Financial
5
Catastrophic
 
Multiple fatalities.
 
Unplanned permanent
environmental impact over
extensive area.
 
Permanent loss of
ecosystem or extinction of
species.
 
Serious and long-term
damage to corporate
reputation through the loss
of trust and respect across
all stakeholder groups and
the general public.
 
Lost production by more
than 2 million tonnes.
 
Breach of bank covenants.
 
Unable to make payment to
employees in accordance
with agreed terms.
 
Reduces revenue or
increases cost by more
than US$ 200 million.
 
4
Major
 
Single fatality and/ or
 
Severe irreversible disability
or impairment (>30% of
body) to one or more
persons.
 
Severe impact (>20 years)
on ecosystem or
Threatened Species.
 
Serious and long-term
damage to corporate
reputation through the loss
of trust and respect of one
or more key stakeholder
groups and the general
public.
 
Lost production of 1 to
2 million tonnes.
 
Unable to pay contractors in
accordance with agreed
terms
 
Reduces revenue or
increases cost by between
US$ 100 million to US$
200 million
 
3
Moderate
Severe irreversible disability
or impairment (<30% of
body) to one or more
persons.
 
Serious or extensive impact
(<20 years) on ecosystem
or Threatened Species.
 
Short-term corporate
reputation damage through
the loss of trust and respect
limited to one or more key
stakeholder group.
 
Lost production of 0.5 to
1 million tonnes.
 
Reduces revenue or
increases cost by between
US$ 50 million to US$
100 million
 
2
Minor
Lost time injury/ies.
 
Major impact (<5 years) on
ecosystem or Threatened
Species
 
Short-term corporate
reputation damage through
the loss of trust and respect
limited to one key
stakeholder group.
 
Lost production of 0.1 to
0.5 million tonnes.
 
Reduces revenue or
increases cost by between
US$ 5 million to US$
50 million
 
1
Insignificant
Medical treatment case(s).
 
Minor impact (< 3 months)
to non-threatened species
or their habitat
 
Small impact on corporate
reputation through some
loss of trust and respect –
minor and isolated
expression of concern.
 
Lost production of less than
0.1 million tonnes.
 
Reduces revenue or
increases cost by less than
US$ 5 million.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page
111
of 118
22.2.2.2
 
Composite Risk Matrix and Color-Code Convention
The risk matrix in Table
 
22.3 is sourced from the Curragh site Safety
 
and Health Management System
(SHMS) Workplace
 
Risk Assessment
 
and Controls
 
(WRAC) template
 
form. This
 
5x5 matrix
 
uses the
consequence and
 
likelihood values
 
to identify
 
and colour
 
code risk
 
categories from
 
a Low
 
(green) to
Very High (red) Risk Rating.
 
Table 22.3:
 
Risk Matrix
CONSEQUENCE
Loss Type
1
 
-
Insignificant
2 - Minor
3 - Moderate
4 - Major
5
 
-
Catastrophic
Likelihood
Risk Rating
A
- Almost
Certain
Medium
High
High
Very High
Very High
B - Likely
Medium
Medium
High
High
Very High
C - Possible
Low
Medium
High
High
High
D - Unlikely
Low
Low
Medium
High
High
E - Rare
Low
Low
Medium
Medium
High
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 112 of 118
22.2.2.3
 
Risk Assessment
Table 22.4:
 
Risk Assessment
IDENTIFICATION
C
L
Risk
Ratin
g
RISK
TREATMENT
Discipline
Risk Factors
 
Consequence
s
Risk
 
treatment
strategy
Mining
Equipment
productivity
assumptions
unrealistic or
cannot be
achieved
Production
schedule
unachievable
and increased
cost/t driving
down project
valuation.
Reserve loss
from this.
3
C
H
Reconciling
planned
productivities in
LOM plan against
historical actuals
from the
operation.
Significant
flood event
overtopping 1
in 100yr levees
on site –
inundation of
underground
operations
Loss of
production for
duration
required to
dewater
operation
5
E
M
Site inclement
weather TARP’s
and site SHMS
Unplanned
inrush of water
from
underground
mining under
Blackwater
Creek
Loss of
production for
duration
required to
dewater
operation
5
D
H
Exploration and
fault delineation
drilling and
modelling and
inclusion in UG
mine plan
Lower than
predicted
permeability
causing
ineffective gas
drainage in
underground
operations
 
Loss of
Reserves as
cannot be
mined safely or
economically
Potential gas
outburst
 
4
C
H
Exploration and
testing – gas
drainage
requirements
Operational
systems – Permit
to Mine etc
Spontaneous
combustion in
underground
work areas
Loss of
production
while
inertisation
takes place to
stabilise spon
com
4
D
M
Coal samples
tested and contain
low propensity for
spon com.
 
good ventilation
and management
practices
combined with gas
monitoring and
Inertisation
infrastructure.
Unplanned fall
of ground in
underground
operations
 
Potential safety
hazard and
suspension of
operations.
Potential loss
of reserves if
areas cannot
be mined
safely.
4
C
H
Geotechincal
design based on
exploration
samples.
Operational SHMS
and principal
hazard TARPS.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0
 
 
ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0
 
Page 113 of 118
Significant
unplanned
geotechnical
failure on
highwall
impacting flood
protection
levees.
 
Loss of
production
potentially
safety hazard
5
E
H
Geotechincal
design based on
exploration
samples.
Operational SHMS
and principal
hazard TARPS.
Significant
safety incident
Loss of license
to operate
 
5
E
H
Continue to
adhere to the
SHMS and
operational
discipline
Uncertain soft
floor conditions
encountered in
UG mining
Loss of
Reserves
leaving coal in
floor
 
3
D
M
Geotechnical core
investigation for
floor conditions
(slake durability
etc) include in UG
mine planning.
Control of mine
water.
Unexpectedly
high frictional
ignition
propensity of
roof, floor or
partings
material in UG
operation
Health and
safety risk in
operations
4
D
H
Gas control in
operations –
ventilation etc
when mining in
areas which may
exhibit this
harzard
Geology/Geotechnica
l
Unexpected
geological
complexity in
underground
Higher
operational
costs of mining.
Loss of reserve
3
B
H
 
JORC
Reserve allows for
up to 15%
geological risk in
Reserve estimate
 
Plan mine
orientation to
consider faulting.
 
Plan mine
orientation to
consider joints.
 
Continue
geotech drilling
and modelling.
 
UIS drilling
ahead of mining.
Unexpected
geological
complexity in
open cut
Planned
reserve not
recovered
2
C
M
 
Plan mine
orientation to
consider faulting.
 
Plan mine
orientation to
consider joints.
 
Continue
geotech drilling
and modelling.
 
In-fill
drilling ahead of
mining.
Incorporation of
highwall structural
mapping into the
short-term
geological model.
 
 
ex961p115i0
 
ex961p115i0
 
ex961p115i0
 
 
ex961p116i1 ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0
 
ex961p115i0
 
ex961p115i0
 
ex961p115i0
 
 
ex961p115i0
 
 
ex961p115i0
 
Page 114 of 118
Product yields
or coal quality
data
significantly
lower than
estimated
 
Lower revenue
than planned
affecting
project
valuation
 
3
C
H
 
Coal
quality core drilling
and washability
simulation ahead
of mining.
Unexpected
igneous
intrusions
 
Loss of
Reserve
3
D
M
 
Geological
exploration
including seismic
studies, UIS and
SIS drilling ahead
of mining in UG
 
Unexpected
seam splitting
Loss of
Reserve
Increased ROM
dilution
 
Reduced
operational
productivity
2
C
M
 
Exploratio
n drilling and
seismic
investigations
Excessive
stress,
magnitude and
direction
Reduced
roadway widths
in UG,
increased
ground support
requirements
Reduced
productivity and
loss of Reserve
3
D
M
 
Insitu
stress testing
investigations
 
Core
breakout analysis
 
Pillar and
roof monitoring
Geological
uncertainty in
UG below
existing out of
pit waste
dumps
 
Loss of
Reserve
Unexpected
geotechnical
conditions
4
D
H
 
UIS and
spoil drilling
exploration
Infrastructure
Failure of
CHPP
structures due
to age of
infrastructure
Increased
operating costs
and potential
for production
loss in
unplanned
downtime
4
D
H
 
Continue
to maintain the
structural
maintenance
programme
CHPP yield
below planned
recoveries
Loss of
production
revenue due to
failure to
achieve
forecast
production
recoveries
3
C
H
 
Ongoing
monitoring of plant
operations to
improve
recoveries
Insufficient HV
power available
for UG
development
project at
Curragh
Production
delays due to
insufficient
supply
available to full
planned UG
production fleet
3
C
H
 
Load study
in progress in
2024 to determine
requirements .
Upgrades
undertaken in time
for underground
production build
up.
Environmental
Environmental
Authority
amendment for
UG operation
not approved in
time to meet
planned
production
profile
Production
delays
4
E
M
 
CCPL
working with
regulatory bodies
through the EA
amendment
process
 
ex961p115i0
 
ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0
 
ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0
 
 
ex961p115i0 ex961p117i1
 
 
 
 
ex961p115i0 ex961p115i0
 
Page 115 of 118
 
Non
subsidence mining
method planned in
UG mine plan
Environmental
complaints
from sensitive
receptors for
new open cut
development
areas (Z pits)
 
Loss of reserve
if
Environmental
Authority
conditions
cannot be met
(noise/dust etc)
4
D
H
 
Curragh
Expansion Project
EIS
 
 
Stakehold
er management of
external
stakeholders
Restriction to
exploration
activities in
biodiversity
offset areas
 
Increased
geological
uncertainty to
UG mine plan
in these areas
causing
potential loss of
Reserves
3
C
H
 
Stakehold
er relationships
with regulator
 
UIS drilling
ahead of mining.
Economics
Price forecast
reducing
significantly or
foreign
exchange rate
fluctuation
impacting
revenue
negatively
 
Reserve
reduction and
potential
business asset
value write
down
5
C
H
 
Review
mining method
and cost
assumptions in
financial model
 
Review
capex
assumptions
 
Underestimate
d capital costs
for operation
Lower return on
investment
3
D
M
Review capital
plan and re-
engineer to suit
business
requirements
Underestimate
d operating
costs for
operation
Lower return on
investment
 
4
D
H
 
Reconcilin
g planned
operating costs in
LOM plan against
historical actuals
from the
operation.
 
Undergrou
nd costs
calculated from
first principles and
benchmarked
against industry
 
 
 
Page 116 of 118
23
 
Recommendations
 
Coronado
 
is
 
continuing
 
to
 
work
 
both
 
internally
 
and
 
with
 
outside
 
assistance
 
to
 
further
 
define
 
their
resource base and to optimize the open cut LOM plan.
 
The current primary focus
 
for exploration for the
 
underground mine is concentrated in
 
the southern area
where production is planned
 
to commence. Various
 
techniques including 2D and
 
3D Seismic surveys,
exploration bore holes
 
and both Surface
 
to In
 
Seam (SIS) and
 
Underground in Seam
 
(UIS) gas drainage
bore holes will provide additional definition of
 
the resource and mining predicted mining conditions. The
results obtained
 
and experience
 
gained will
 
then be
 
used to
 
derive appropriate
 
exploration programs
for the
 
remaining areas
 
of the
 
underground. Exploration
 
techniques and
 
strategies appropriate
 
to the
requirements of
 
the planned
 
mining method
 
and LOM
 
plan will
 
need to
 
be considered
 
where surface
access is limited due to open cut waste dumps and restricted
 
access areas.
A major amendment will
 
be made to
 
current Environmental Authority (EPML00643713) for the
 
inclusion
of underground mining
 
activities. This major
 
amendment is supported
 
by an Environmental
 
Assessment
Report (EAR)
 
which will
 
be submitted
 
to the
 
Department of
 
Environment and
 
Science (DES)
 
in early
2024. It is anticipated that the approval of the major EA amendment to support project commencement
will be achieved in December 2024.
 
 
 
 
Page 117 of 118
24
 
References
 
Publicly available information from various State and Federal
 
agencies was used where relevant.
25
 
Reliance on information provided by the registrant
Portions
 
of
 
this
 
report
 
has
 
been
 
prepared
 
by
 
Qualified
 
Persons
 
for
 
Coronado.
 
The
 
information,
conclusions, opinions, and estimates contained herein
 
are based on:
●
 
Information available to Qualified Persons at the time of preparation
 
of this report,
●
 
Assumptions, conditions, and qualifications as set forth in
 
this report, and
●
 
Data, reports, and other information supplied by Coronado
 
and other third-party sources.
For the
 
purpose of
 
this report,
 
the Qualified
 
Person for
 
Resources has
 
relied on
 
information provided
by Coronado and other third-party sources,
 
specifically for Sections 7.2 & 7.3 & 10 & 11.5
 
.
 
For the purpose of
 
this report, the Qualified
 
Persons for Reserves
 
have relied on information
 
provided
by Coronado and other third-party sources, specifically
 
for Sections 12 and 13.
The
 
Qualified
 
Persons
 
for
 
Reserves
 
have
 
relied
 
on
 
information
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
for
 
property
control,
 
marketing,
 
material
 
contracts,
 
environmental
 
studies,
 
permitting,
 
infrastructure,
 
product
washability yield simulation data and macro-economic
 
assumptions as stated in:
●
 
Section 1 – Executive Summary
●
 
Section 3.2 – Titles, Claims or Leases
●
 
Section 15 – Infrastructure
●
 
Section 16 – Market Studies
●
 
Section 17 – Environmental Studies and Permitting
●
 
Section 18 – Capital and Operating Costs
●
 
Section 19 – Economic Analysis
As
 
the
 
mine
 
has
 
been
 
in
 
operation
 
for
 
forty
 
years,
 
Coronado
 
has
 
considerable
 
experience
 
in
 
those
areas.
 
The
 
Qualified
 
Persons
 
have
 
relied
 
on
 
Coronado
 
for
 
guidance
 
on
 
applicable
 
taxes,
 
royalties,
government interests,
 
revenue assumptions,
 
projected capital
 
costs and
 
operating cost
 
data from
 
the
mine in the Executive Summary and Sections
 
18 and 19.
 
The Qualified Persons have taken all appropriate steps, in their professional opinion, to ensure
 
that the
above information from Coronado or its third-party sources
 
is sound.
Except for the purposes
 
legislated under applicable securities
 
laws, any use of
 
this report by any
 
third
party is at that party’s sole risk.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Page 118 of 118
26
 
Glossary of Abbreviations and Definitions
 
Abbreviation
Definition
AUD
Australian Dollar
AUD:USD
Australian Dollar to US Dollar currency conversion rate
CHPP
Coal Handling and Processing Plant
CM
Continuous Miner
DOC
Depth of Cover
EBITDA
Earnings Before Interest Tax
 
Depreciation & Amortization
FS
Feasibility Study
Kt
Kilo tonnes; Units in thousands
LHD
Load haul dump
LOM
Life Of Mine
m3/t
Cubic meters per tonne
Mbcm
Million bank cubic meters
MIA
Mine Industrial Area
MDL
Mineral Development Licence
Metallurgical Coal
Coal used in the steel making process
ML
Mining Lease
MMt
Million Metric Tonne
Mt
Million Tonnes
NPV
Net present value
P&L
Profit and loss
PCI
Pulverised Coal Injection
PFS
Pre Feasibility Study
Prdt
Product Tonne
QLD
Queensland
ROM
Run Of Mine, Coal mined
t
Metric tonnes
tph
Tonnes
 
per hour
UNSW
University of New South Wales
USD
US Dollar
WACC
Weighted average cost of capital as a percentage
 
ex962p1i0
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
i
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
February 2024
 
Prepared for:
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
100 Bill Baker Way
 
Beckley, West
 
Virginia 25801
Prepared by:
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
582 Industrial Park Road
Bluefield, Virginia
 
24605
www.mma1.com
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
Statement of Use and Preparation
This Technical
 
Report Summary (
TRS
) was prepared by
Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc. (
MM&A
)
for
 
the
 
sole
 
use
 
of
Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
(
Coronado
)
and
 
its
 
affiliated
 
and
 
subsidiary
companies and advisors.
 
Copies or
 
references to information in this
 
report may not
 
be used
 
without
the written permission of Coronado.
This report provides a
 
statement of coal resources and
 
coal reserves for Coronado, as
 
defined under
the
Australasian Code
 
for Reporting
 
of Exploration Results,
 
Mineral Resources
 
and Ore Reserves
(
JORC Code
) as well as under Subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K (Regulation S-K 1300) promulgated by
the
United States
 
Securities and
 
Exchange Commission
 
(
SEC
)
.
 
Subject to
 
the comments
 
below,
 
this
report
 
was
 
also
 
prepared
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
the
Australasian
 
Code
 
for
 
Public
 
Reporting
 
of
Technical
 
Assessments and Valuations of Mineral Assets
(
VALMIN Code
).
 
The statement
 
is based
 
on information
 
provided
 
by Coronado
 
and reviewed
 
by
Qualified Persons
(
QPs
) who are full-time employees of MM&A.
As noted above, this report is a “Public Report” for the purposes of the VALMIN Code.
 
However,
 
in
accordance with paragraph 12.1 of the VALMIN Code, it is noted that this report is not a “Valuation
of
 
Mineral
 
Assets”
 
and
 
it
 
also
 
does
 
not
 
comply
 
with
 
the
 
following
 
requirements
 
that
 
apply
 
to
“Technical Assessments” (as defined in the VALMIN
 
Code):
This report does
 
not include a determination
 
of the status
 
of tenure (as
 
required by paragraph
7.2 of the VALMIN
 
Code) on the basis that tenure was
 
separately reviewed by
 
Coronado’s
 
legal
advisors.
This
 
report
 
does
 
not
 
include
 
separate
 
commentary
 
on
 
the
 
reasonableness
 
and
 
quality
 
of
 
the
Resources and Reserves estimates
 
and the basis on which they have been reported (as required
 
by
paragraph
 
7.3
 
of
 
the
 
VALMIN
 
Code).
 
MM&A
 
did
 
not
 
consider
 
that
 
this
 
was
 
appropriate
 
in
circumstances
 
where MM&A
 
was engaged
 
for
 
the specific
 
purpose of
 
preparing
 
those estimates.
 
However,
 
MM&A
 
notes
 
that,
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
its
 
usual
 
practice,
 
a
 
separate
 
team
 
of
 
MM&A
employees undertook a peer review of this report and confirmed that both
 
the process followed by
the
 
authors
 
of
 
this
 
report
 
and
 
the
 
estimates
 
prepared
 
were
 
reasonable
 
and
 
comply
 
with
 
the
requirements of the JORC Code.
 
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
The information in this TRS
 
related to coal resources and reserves is
 
based on, and fairly
 
represents,
information compiled by the QPs.
 
At the time of
 
reporting, MM&A’s QPs have sufficient experience
relevant
 
to the
 
style of
 
mineralization
 
and type
 
of deposit
 
under consideration
 
and to
 
the activity
they are undertaking to qualify as a QP as defined by Regulation S-K 1300 and the JORC Code.
 
Each
QP consents
 
to the
 
inclusion in
 
this report
 
of the
 
matters
 
based on
 
their information
 
in the
 
form
and context in which it appears.
Marshall
 
Miller
 
&
 
Associates,
 
Inc.
 
(
MM&A
)
 
hereby
 
consents
 
to
 
the
 
use
 
of
 
the
 
information
contained in this report
 
dated December 31, 2023, relating
 
to estimates of
 
coal resources and coal
reserves controlled by Coronado.
 
Qualified Person:
/s/ Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc.
Date:
February 16, 2024
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
i
Table
 
of Contents
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
ii
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
iii
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
iv
Figures (in Report)
Tables
 
(in Report)
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
v
Appendices
A
 
.....................................................................................................................MM&A
Qualifications
B
 
.................................................................................................................................................
Map
C
 
...........................................................................................................................Glossary of
Terms
D
 
.................................................Initial Economic Assessment for Resources Exclusive
 
of
Reserves
E
 
...................................................................................................................................JORC
Table 1
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
1
 
Executive Summary
1.1
 
Property Description
Coronado Global Resources
 
Inc. (
Coronado
)
authorized
Marshall Miller &
 
Associates, Inc. (
MM&A
)
to prepare this
 
Technical Report Summary (
TRS
) of
 
its controlled coal
 
resources and reserves
 
located
at the
Buchanan Division
 
(
Buchanan
)
 
in Buchanan
 
and Tazewell
 
Counties, Virginia
 
(the
Property
).
This TRS updates the
 
TRS titled, "Coronado Global Resources
 
Inc. Statement of Coal Resources
 
and
Reserves for the Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with the JORC Code and United States SEC
Regulation S-K 1300 as
 
of December 31,
 
2022 Central Appalachian Coal
 
Basin Virginia, USA February
2023," dated
 
February 15,
 
2023, due
 
to material
 
differences
 
in the
 
key financial
 
modifying factors
including
 
mining
 
plans,
 
coal
 
sales
 
price
 
assumptions,
 
operating
 
costs
 
and
 
capital
 
costs
 
from
December 31, 2022 to
 
December 31, 2023.
 
Mining plans are
 
discussed in
Section 13
 
of the TRS, coal
sales price
 
assumptions are
 
discussed in
 
Sections 12
 
and 16
 
of the
 
TRS, while
 
operating
 
costs and
capital costs are discussed in
Sections 18 and
 
19
 
of the TRS.
 
This report provides a
 
statement of coal
resources and coal reserves for Coronado, as defined under the
Australasian Code for Reporting of
Exploration
 
Results,
 
Mineral
 
Resources
 
and
 
Ore
 
Reserves
(
JORC
 
Code
)
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
under
 
Subpart
1300
 
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K
 
(Regulation
 
S-K
 
1300)
 
promulgated
 
by
 
the
United
 
States
 
Securities
 
and
Exchange
 
Commission (
SEC
)
.
 
This report
 
was also
 
prepared
 
in accordance
 
with the
Australasian
Code
 
for
 
Public
 
Reporting
 
of
 
Technical
 
Assessments
 
and
 
Valuations
 
of
 
Mineral
 
Assets
(
VALMIN
Code
).
Coal
 
resources
 
and
 
coal
 
reserves
 
are
 
herein
 
reported
 
in
 
metric
 
units
 
of
 
measurement
 
and
 
are
rounded to millions of metric tonnes (
Mt
).
 
The
 
Buchanan
 
No.
 
1
 
Mine
 
Complex
 
is
 
located
 
in
 
Buchanan
 
County
 
in
 
southwest
 
Virginia.
 
The
Property is 24
 
kilometers northwest of
 
the town of
 
Richlands, Virginia and
 
65.9 kilometers southeast
of
 
Pikeville,
 
Kentucky.
 
The
 
nearest
 
major
 
population
 
centers
 
are
 
Lexington,
 
Kentucky
 
(290
kilometers
 
northwest)
 
and
 
Roanoke,
 
Virginia
 
(153
 
kilometers
 
northeast)
 
(see
Figure
 
1-1
).
 
The
Property
 
is
 
composed
 
of
 
approximately
 
33,578
 
total
 
hectares,
 
of
 
which
 
25,853
 
are
 
leased
 
or
subleased from private landholders under approximately 150 individual coal lease tracts, and 7,725
hectares are
 
owned by Coronado.
 
Subject to Coronado’s
 
exercising
 
its renewal
 
rights thereunder,
all the
 
leases expire
 
upon exhaustion
 
of the
 
relevant
 
coal reserves,
 
which is
 
expected
 
to occur
 
in
2042.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0 ex962p10i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
Figure 1-1:
 
Coronado Buchanan Mine Complex Property Index Map
1.2
 
Ownership
The
 
Property
 
was
 
formerly
 
controlled
 
by
Consolidation
 
Coal
 
Company
 
(
CONSOL
)
.
 
Mine
development
 
was
 
started
 
by CONSOL
 
in 1983
 
and longwall
 
production began
 
in 1987.
 
Coronado
acquired the Buchanan Mine from CONSOL in March 2016.
1.3
 
Geology
Operations
 
at
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
Mine
 
Complex
 
extract
 
the
 
Pocahontas
 
No.
 
3
 
coal
 
bed
 
by
 
longwall
mining methods.
 
Strata of economic interest for
 
this TRS are of the Pennsylvanian-age Pocahontas
Formation and the subject Pocahontas No. 3 seam
 
is the principal coal seam
 
of that formation.
 
Due
to the
 
high value
 
of this low-volatile
 
coking coal,
 
it has been
 
extensively mined
 
in the region.
 
The
seam is situated below drainage throughout the Property and is accessed by existing
 
mine shafts.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
1.4
 
Exploration Status
The
 
Property
 
has been
 
extensively
 
explored,
 
largely
 
by
 
drilling
 
using
 
continuous
 
coring
 
methods,
rotary
 
drilling
 
but
 
also
 
by
 
obtaining
 
coal
 
measurements
 
at
 
mine
 
exposures,
 
ongoing
 
drilling
associated with degas activities, and by
 
downhole geophysical methods.
 
Exploration activities from
the surface and underground
 
have continued to the
 
present time (2023), however,
 
the majority of
the data
 
was acquired
 
or generated
 
by previous
 
owners of
 
the Property.
 
These sources
 
comprise
the primary
 
data
 
used in
 
the evaluation
 
of the
 
coal
 
resources
 
and coal
 
reserves
 
on the
 
Property.
 
MM&A examined
 
the data
 
available for
 
the evaluation
 
and incorporated
 
all pertinent
 
information
into this TRS.
 
Where data appeared to be anomalous or
 
not representative, that data was excluded
from the digital databases and subsequent processing by MM&A.
 
Ongoing
 
exploration
 
(core
 
drilling,
 
bore
 
scoping
 
of
 
roof
 
strata,
 
and
 
channel
 
sampling)
 
has
 
been
carried
 
out
 
by
 
Coronado
 
since
 
acquiring
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
Mine.
 
The
 
exploration
 
data
 
acquired
 
by
Coronado has been consistent with past drilling and sampling activities.
1.5
 
Operations and Development
Due
 
to
 
its
 
coal
 
reserve
 
and
 
seam
 
characteristics,
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
No.
 
1
 
Mine
 
operates
 
using
 
the
longwall method.
 
The model was therefore generated with longwall-mining constraints in mind for
Buchanan’s
 
underground
 
resources.
 
The
 
mine produces
 
coal
 
that
 
is
 
suitable
 
for
 
the
 
low-volatile
metallurgical coal markets.
The Buchanan
 
No. 1
 
Mine in
 
Buchanan County,
 
Virginia, is
 
the only
 
active longwall
 
mine currently
being operated by Coronado.
Coronado currently
 
operates a
 
coal preparation
 
plant at
 
Buchanan.
 
The Buchanan Plant
 
operates
at a feed rate of approximately 1,270 raw
 
tonnes per hour (
tph)
.
 
Processes are typical of
 
those used
in the coal industry and are in use at adjacent coal processing plants.
1.6
 
Mineral Resource
Mineral
 
resources,
 
representing
 
in-situ
 
coal
 
from
 
a
 
portion
 
of
 
which
 
reserves
 
are
 
derived,
 
are
presented below.
 
A coal resource estimate, summarized
 
in
Table 1-1
, was prepared as
 
of December
31, 2023, for property controlled by Coronado.
Table 1-1:
 
Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2023
 
Coal Resource (Dry Tonnes, In Situ, Mt)
Resource Quality (Dry)
Area
Measured
Indicated
Inferred
Total
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Inclusive of Reserves
158.9
9.2
0.0
168.1
16
0.8
18
Exclusive of Reserves
30.7
4.3
0.0
34.9
Total 12/31/2023
189.6
13.4
0.0
203.0
 
Note:
 
Resource tonnes are inclusive of reserve tonnes since they include the in-situ tonnes from which recoverable coal reserves are derived.
Note 2:
 
Coal resources are reported on a dry basis.
 
Surface moisture and inherent moisture are excluded.
Note 3: The Property contains 34.9 Mt of dry, in-place measured and indicated coal resources exclusive of reserves as of December 31, 2023.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
4
1.7
 
Mineral Reserve
Reserve tonnage
 
estimates provided
 
herein report
 
coal reserves
 
derived from
 
the in-situ resource
tons
 
presented
 
in
Table
 
1-1
,
 
and
 
not
 
in
 
addition
 
to
 
coal
 
resources.
 
Proven
 
and
 
probable
 
coal
reserves
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
coal
 
resource
 
considering
 
relevant
 
mining,
 
processing,
infrastructure,
 
economic
 
(including
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue,
 
and
 
cost),
 
marketing,
 
legal,
environmental, socioeconomic and regulatory factors.
 
The Resource estimate has been used as
 
the
basis for this Reserve
 
calculation, which utilizes a reasonable
 
preliminary feasibility study,
 
a life-of-
mine (
LOM
) mine plan and practical recovery factors.
 
Production modeling was completed with an
effective start date of
 
October 1,
 
2023.
 
Additions and
 
depletion have
 
been used
 
to bring
 
the Reserve
estimate forward to
 
December 31, 2023.
Factors
 
that
 
would
 
typically
 
preclude
 
conversion
 
of
 
a
 
coal
 
resource
 
to
 
coal
 
reserve,
 
include
 
the
following:
 
inferred
 
resource
 
classification;
 
absence
 
of
 
coal
 
quality;
 
poor
 
mine
 
recovery;
 
lack
 
of
access; geological
 
encumbrances
 
associated
 
with
 
overlying
 
and underlying
 
strata;
 
seam thinning;
structural
 
complication;
 
and
 
insufficient
 
exploration
 
have
 
all
 
been
 
considered.
 
Reserve
consideration
 
excludes
 
those
 
portions
 
of
 
the
 
resource
 
area
 
which
 
exhibit
 
the
 
aforementioned-
geological and operational encumbrances.
 
Coal reserves are
 
presented on
 
a run-of-mine
 
(
ROM
) basis in
Table
 
1-2
.
 
Proven and
 
probable coal
reserves
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
in-situ
 
coal
 
resource
 
considering
 
relevant
 
processing,
economic
 
(including
 
technical
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue,
 
and
 
cost),
 
marketing,
 
legal,
environmental,
 
socioeconomic, and regulatory
 
factors.
 
The proven
 
and probable
 
coal reserves
 
on
the Property are summarized below in
Table 1-3
.
Table 1-2:
 
Coal Summary (ROM (Moist))
 
as of December 31, 2023
 
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Mt, Moist ROM)
Quality (Dry)
 
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area /
Mine
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Subleased
Ash
Sulfur
Vol
Buchanan
145.9
8.5
154.4
0.0
154.4
20.2
125.8
8.4
44
0.7
12
Table 1-3:
 
Coal Reserves Summary (Marketable Sales Basis) as of December 31, 2023
 
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet Ton
 
nes, Washed or Direct Shipped, Mt)
Quality (Dry Basis)
 
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area / Mine
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Subleased
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Buchanan Mine Complex
87.1
5.0
92.1
0.0
92.1
13.6
73.8
4.8
6
0.7
20
 
Note: Marketable reserve tonnes are reported on a moist basis, including a combination of surface and inherent moisture.
 
The combination of
surface and inherent moisture is modeled at 6-percent.
 
Actual product moisture is dependent upon multiple geological factors, operational
factors, and product contract specifications and can exceed 8-percent.
 
As such, the modeled moisture values provide a level of conservatism
for reserve reporting.
In
 
summary,
 
Coronado
 
controls
 
a
 
total
 
of
 
92.1
 
Mt
 
(moist
 
basis)
 
of
 
marketable
 
coal
 
reserves,
 
at
Buchanan,
 
as
 
of
 
December
 
31,
 
2023.
 
Of
 
that
 
total,
 
95
 
percent
 
are
 
proven,
 
and
 
5
 
percent
 
are
probable.
 
There are 13.6 Mt of owned
 
coal reserves and 73.8 Mt
 
of leased coal reserves and
 
4.8 Mt
of subleased reserves.
 
All the Buchanan reserves are considered suitable for the metallurgical
 
coal
market, and all of the Buchanan reserves are assigned.
 
 
ex962p2i0 ex962p13i2 ex962p13i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
5
1.8
 
Capital Summary
Coronado
 
provided
 
MM&A
 
with
 
an
 
inventory
 
of
 
operating
 
equipment
 
available
 
at
 
Buchanan.
 
MM&A’s
 
capital
 
schedules assume
 
that
 
major
 
equipment
 
rebuilds
 
occur over
 
the
 
course
 
of each
machine’s
 
remaining
 
assumed
 
operating
 
life.
 
Replacement
 
equipment
 
was
 
scheduled
 
based
 
on
MM&A’s
 
experience and
 
knowledge of
 
mining equipment
 
and industry
 
standards
 
with respect
 
to
the useful life of such equipment.
 
A summary of the estimated capital for the Property
 
is provided
in
Figure 1-2
 
below.
Figure 1-2:
 
CAPEX
1.9
 
Operating Costs
Coronado
 
provided
 
historical
 
and
 
preliminary
 
5-year
 
projections
 
of operating
 
costs
 
for
 
Buchanan
for MM&A’s
 
review.
 
MM&A used the historical and/or budget cost information
 
as a reference and
developed personnel
 
schedules for the mine
 
and support facilities.
 
Hourly labor rates
 
and salaries
were
 
based upon
 
information
 
contained
 
in Coronado’s
 
financial summaries.
 
Fringe-benefit
 
costs
were developed for vacation and holidays,
 
federal and state unemployment insurance,
 
retirement,
workers’ compensation and
 
pneumoconiosis, casualty and life insurance,
 
healthcare, and bonuses.
 
A cost factor
 
for mine supplies
 
was developed that
 
relates expenditures
 
to mine advance
 
rates for
roof-control
 
costs
 
and
 
other
 
mine-supply
 
costs
 
at
 
underground
 
mines.
 
Other
 
factors
 
were
developed for maintenance and repair costs, rentals, mine power, outside services and other direct
mining costs.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0 ex962p14i2 ex962p14i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
6
Operating
 
costs
 
factors
 
were
 
also
 
developed
 
for
 
the
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plant
 
processing,
 
refuse
handling, coal loading, property taxes,
 
and insurance and bonding.
 
Appropriate royalty
 
rates were
assigned for production from leased coal lands, and sales taxes were
 
calculated for state severance
taxes, the federal
 
black lung excise tax, and federal
 
and state reclamation fees.
A summary of the projected operating costs for the Property
 
is provided in
Figure 1-3
.
Figure 1-3:
 
OPEX
1.10
 
Economic Evaluation
The pre-feasibility financial
 
model prepared for
 
this TRS
 
was developed to
 
test the
 
economic viability
of
 
the
 
coal
 
resource
 
area.
 
The
 
results
 
of
 
this
 
financial
 
model
 
are
 
not
 
intended
 
to
 
represent
 
a
bankable
 
feasibility
 
study,
 
required
 
for
 
financing
 
of
 
any
 
current
 
or
 
future
 
mining
 
operations
contemplated
 
for the Coronado
 
properties, but are
 
intended to establish
 
the economic viability
 
of
the estimated coal reserves.
 
Cash flows are simulated on an annual basis in
 
year-end 2023 nominal
dollars
 
assuming
 
a
 
2%
 
inflation
 
rate
 
based
 
on
 
projected
 
production
 
from
 
the
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
The
discounted cash flow analysis presented herein
 
is based on an effective date of January 1, 2024.
 
On an un-levered basis, the net
 
present value (
NPV
) of the project cash flow
 
after taxes represents
the Enterprise
 
Value of
 
the project.
 
The project cash
 
flow,
 
excluding debt
 
service, is calculated
 
by
subtracting direct
 
and indirect
 
operating expenses
 
and capital
 
expenditures from
 
revenue.
 
Direct
costs
 
include
 
labor,
 
operating
 
supplies,
 
maintenance
 
and
 
repairs,
 
facilities
 
costs
 
for
 
materials
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
7
handling,
 
coal
 
preparation,
 
refuse
 
disposal,
 
coal
 
loading,
 
reclamation
 
and
 
general
 
and
administrative costs.
 
Indirect costs include statutory and legally agreed
 
upon fees related to direct
extraction
 
of
 
the
 
mineral.
 
The
 
indirect
 
costs
 
are
 
the
 
federal
 
black
 
lung
 
tax,
 
federal
 
and
 
state
reclamation taxes, property
 
taxes, coal production royalties,
 
and income taxes.
 
Table
 
1-4
 
shows LOM tonnage, profit
 
& loss (
P&L
), and earnings before income tax,
 
depreciation &
amortization (
EBITDA
) for Buchanan.
Table 1-4:
 
Life-of-Mine Tonnage,
 
P&L before Tax,
 
and EBITDA
 
LOM
LOM
P&L
LOM
EBITDA
 
Tonnes
Pre-Tax P&L
Per Tonne
EBITDA
Per Tonne
Buchanan
92,135
$5,590,394
$60.68
$7,386,829
$80.17
As
 
shown
 
in
Table
 
1-4,
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
Mine
 
shows
 
positive
 
EBITDA
 
over
 
the
 
LOM.
 
Overall,
 
the
Coronado consolidated operations show positive LOM P&L and
 
LOM EBITDA of $5.6 billion and
 
$7.4
billion, respectively.
 
Coronado’s
 
consolidated Buchanan
 
cash flow
 
summary in nominal
 
dollars assuming
 
a 2%
 
inflation
rate, excluding debt
 
service, is shown in
Table 1-5
 
below.
Table 1-5:
 
Project Cash Flow Summary (000)
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
Total
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
Production & Sales tonnes
92,136
3,738
4,186
4,249
4,980
5,210
Total Revenue
$15,924,429
$643,698
$586,802
$585,176
$703,140
$753,693
EBITDA
$7,386,829
$207,113
$163,862
$184,715
$277,497
$315,709
Net Income
$4,381,299
$113,324
$64,939
$71,959
$135,601
$156,242
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$6,095,981
$136,440
$157,841
$166,973
$228,295
$268,684
Purchases of Property, Plant, and
 
Equipment
$(1,360,951)
$(135,370)
$(149,944)
$(113,912)
$(94,118)
$(83,209)
Net Cash Flow
$4,735,031
$1,070
$7,897
$53,061
$134,177
$185,475
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2029
2030
2031
2032
2033
2034
Production & Sales tonnes
5,728
5,545
5,782
5,882
5,936
5,268
Total Revenue
$924,020
$912,413
$970,382
$1,007,050
$1,036,474
$938,266
EBITDA
$459,985
$437,470
$477,050
$500,805
$518,098
$430,129
Net Income
$263,089
$241,288
$280,342
$310,395
$330,940
$268,398
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$360,606
$373,729
$392,820
$411,198
$422,794
$372,147
Purchases of Property, Plant, and
 
Equipment
$(70,177)
$(49,244)
$(72,844)
$(58,404)
$(48,601)
$(65,801)
Net Cash Flow
$290,429
$324,486
$319,977
$352,794
$374,193
$306,346
 
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
8
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
2040
Production & Sales tonnes
5,590
5,378
4,984
5,236
5,589
4,183
Total Revenue
$1,015,529
$996,590
$942,014
$1,009,435
$1,099,026
$839,126
EBITDA
$493,255
$471,648
$463,185
$557,984
$630,017
$392,781
Net Income
$319,755
$303,536
$295,288
$366,694
$422,733
$244,806
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$393,113
$391,050
$382,466
$436,349
$494,321
$365,966
Purchases of Property, Plant, and
 
Equipment
$(54,932)
$(67,914)
$(63,646)
$(75,866)
$(42,226)
$(35,019)
Net Cash Flow
$338,181
$323,135
$318,820
$360,483
$452,095
$330,947
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
2046
Production & Sales tonnes
3,390
1,285
-
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$693,501
$268,094
$-
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$336,112
$69,413
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Income
$203,036
$(341)
$(6,037)
$(2,443)
$(1,255)
$(649)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$290,379
$132,563
$(48,316)
$(16,427)
$(8,378)
$(4,273)
Purchases of Property, Plant, and
 
Equipment
$(49,148)
$(30,577)
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$241,231
$101,986
$(48,316)
$(16,427)
$(8,378)
$(4,273)
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2047
2048
2049
2050
2051
2052
Production & Sales tonnes
-
-
-
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Income
$(341)
$(0)
$(0)
$(0)
$(0)
$(0)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$(4,358)
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Purchases of Property, Plant, and
 
Equipment
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$(4,358)
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Consolidated cash flows are driven
 
by annual sales
 
tonnage, which at steady-state level ranges from
a peak of 5.9 million
 
tonnes in 2033 to
 
a low of 1.2 million tonnes
 
in 2042.
 
Projected consolidated
revenue ranges from $585.2 million to $1.099 billion at a steady state.
 
Revenue totals $15.9 billion
for the project’s life.
Consolidated cash flow from operations is positive throughout the projected operating period, with
the
 
exception
 
of post
 
-production
 
years,
 
due to
 
end-of-mine
 
reclamation
 
spending.
 
Consolidated
cash flow from operations
 
peaks at $494.3 million in
 
2039 and totals $6.1 billion over
 
the project’s
life.
 
Capital expenditures total $576.6 million through 2028 and $1.4 billion over the project’s
 
life.
 
1.10.1
 
Discounted Cash Flow Analysis
Cash flow after
 
tax, but before
 
debt service, generated
 
over the life
 
of the project
 
was discounted
to NPV
 
at a 10.0%
 
discount rate,
 
which represents
 
Coronado’s
 
estimate of
 
the nominal dollar,
 
risk
adjusted
 
weighted
 
average
 
cost
 
of
 
capital
 
(
WACC
)
 
for
 
likely
 
market
 
participants
 
if
 
the
 
subject
reserves were offered for sale.
 
On an un-levered basis,
 
the NPV of
 
the project cash
 
flows represents
the Enterprise Value of
 
the project and
 
amounts to
 
$1.804 billion.
 
The pre-feasibility financial
 
model
prepared for the
 
TRS was developed to test
 
the economic viability of each coal
 
resource area.
 
The
NPV
 
estimate
 
was
 
made
 
for
 
the
 
purpose
 
of
 
confirming
 
the
 
economics
 
for
 
classification
 
of
 
coal
reserves
 
and not
 
for
 
purposes of
 
valuing
 
Coronado
 
or its
 
Buchanan assets.
 
Mine plans
 
were
 
not
optimized,
 
and
 
actual
 
results
 
of
 
the
 
operations
 
may
 
be
 
different,
 
but
 
in
 
all
 
cases,
 
the
 
mine
production plan assumes the properties are under competent management.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
ex962p17i2 ex962p17i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
9
1.10.2
 
Sensitivity Analysis
Sensitivity
 
of the
 
NPV
 
results
 
to
 
changes
 
in
 
the
 
key
 
drivers
 
is presented
 
in the
 
chart below.
 
The
sensitivity study shows
 
the NPV at
 
the 10.0% discount rate
 
when Base Case sales
 
prices, operating
costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased in increments
 
of 5% within a +/- 15% range.
Figure 1-4:
 
Sensitivity of NPV
As shown, NPV is quite sensitive to changes in sales price and operating cost estimates, and slightly
sensitive to changes in capital cost estimates.
1.11
 
Permitting
Coronado
 
has
 
obtained
 
all
 
mining
 
and
 
discharge
 
permits
 
to
 
operate
 
its
 
mine
 
and
 
processing,
loadout,
 
or
 
related
 
support
 
facilities.
 
MM&A
 
is
 
unaware
 
of
 
any
 
obvious
 
or
 
current
 
Coronado
permitting issues that
 
are expected to prevent
 
the issuance of
 
future permits.
 
Buchanan, along
 
with
all coal
 
producers,
 
is subject to
 
a level
 
of uncertainty
 
regarding
 
future clean
 
water permits
 
due to
United States Environmental Protection Agency
(
EPA
)
 
and
United States Fish and Wildlife (
USFW
)
involvement with state
 
programs.
1.12
 
Conclusion and Recommendations
Sufficient data have been obtained through various exploration and sampling programs and mining
operations
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
geological
 
interpretations
 
of
 
seam
 
structure
 
and
 
thickness
 
for
 
coal
horizons situated
 
on the Property.
 
The data are
 
of sufficient
 
quantity and reliability
 
to reasonably
support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates in this TRS.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
10
The
 
geological
 
data
 
and
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
study,
 
which
 
consider
 
mining
 
plans,
 
revenue,
 
and
operating
 
and
 
capital
 
cost
 
estimates
 
are
 
sufficient
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
classification
 
of
 
coal
 
reserves
provided herein.
This geologic
 
evaluation conducted
 
in conjunction
 
with the
 
preliminary feasibility
 
study concludes
that
 
the
 
92.1
 
Mt
 
of
 
marketable
 
underground
 
coal
 
reserves
 
identified
 
on
 
the
 
Property
 
are
economically
 
mineable
 
under
 
reasonable
 
expectations
 
of
 
market
 
prices
 
for
 
metallurgical
 
coal
products, estimated operation costs,
 
and capital expenditures.
2
 
Introduction
2.1
 
Registrant and Terms
 
of Reference
This report
 
was prepared
 
for
 
the sole
 
use of
Coronado Global
 
Resources
 
Inc. (
Coronado
)
and
 
its
affiliated and subsidiary companies and
 
advisors.
 
This TRS updates the
 
TRS titled, "Coronado Global
Resources
 
Inc.
 
Statement
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
and
 
Reserves
 
for
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
Mine
 
Complex
 
in
Accordance with the
 
JORC Code and
 
United States SEC Regulation
 
S-K 1300
 
as of December
 
31, 2022
Central
 
Appalachian
 
Coal
 
Basin
 
Virginia,
 
USA
 
February
 
2023,"
 
dated
 
February
 
15,
 
2023,
 
due
 
to
material
 
differences
 
in the
 
key
 
financial modifying
 
factors
 
including mining
 
plans, coal
 
sales price
assumptions,
 
operating
 
costs
 
and
 
capital
 
costs
 
from
 
December
 
31,
 
2022
 
to
 
December
 
31,
 
2023.
 
Mining plans
 
are discussed
 
in
Section 13
 
of the
 
TRS, coal
 
sales price
 
assumptions are
 
discussed in
Sections 12
 
and 16
 
of the TRS,
 
while operating
 
costs and
 
capital costs
 
are discussed in
Sections 18
and
 
19
 
of
 
the
 
TRS.
 
This
 
report
 
provides
 
a
 
statement
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
coal
 
reserves
 
for
Coronado,
 
as defined
 
under the
Australasian Code
 
for Reporting
 
of Exploration
 
Results, Mineral
Resources
 
and
 
Ore
 
Reserves
(
JORC
 
Code
)
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
under
 
Subpart
 
1300
 
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K
(Regulation
 
S-K
 
1300)
 
promulgated
 
by
 
the
United
 
States
 
Securities
 
and
 
Exchange
 
Commission
(
SEC
)
.
 
This report was also
 
prepared in accordance with the
Australasian Code for Public
 
Reporting
of Technical
 
Assessments and Valuations of Mineral Assets
(
VALMIN Code
).
This
 
report
 
provides
 
a
 
statement
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
coal
 
reserves
 
for
 
Coronado
 
at
 
Buchanan.
 
Exploration results and Resource
 
calculations were used as the basis for the mine planning and the
preliminary feasibility study completed to determine
 
the extent and viability of the reserve.
Coal
 
resources
 
and
 
coal
 
reserves
 
are
 
herein
 
reported
 
in
 
metric
 
units
 
of
 
measurement
 
and
 
are
rounded to millions of metric tonnes (
Mt
).
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
11
2.2
 
Information Sources
This TRS
 
is based on
 
information provided
 
by Coronado
 
and reviewed
 
by MM&A.
 
Sources of data
and information are listed below in
Table 2-1
:
Table
 
2-1:
 
Information Provided to MM&A by Coronado
Category
Information Provided by Coronado
Report
Section
Geological
Geologic data including digital databases
 
and original source data including geologist logs,
driller’s logs, geophysical
 
logs
9.1
Coal Quality
Database of coal quality information
 
supplemented with original source laboratory
 
sheets
where available
10.1
Mining
Historical productivities and manpower
 
from operating and future
 
Coronado mines
13.2, 13.4
Coal
Preparation
Flow sheet and other information representing
 
current and future methods of coal
processing
 
14.1
Waste
Disposal
Engineering data and estimates representing
 
remaining capacities for coarse
 
and fine coal
waste disposal
17.2
Costs
Historical and budgetary operating
 
cost information used to derive
 
cost drivers for reserve
financial modeling
18.2
Economic
WACC and inflation rate
 
used in discounted cash flow analysis
19.1, 19.2,
19.3
Note: While the sources
 
of data listed
 
in Table
 
2-1 are not
 
exhaustive, they represent
 
a significant portion
 
of information which
 
supports this TRS.
 
MM&A
 
reviewed
 
the
 
provided
 
data
 
and
 
found
 
it
 
to
 
be
 
reasonable
 
prior
 
to
 
incorporating
 
it
 
into
 
the
 
TRS.
 
The
 
TRS
 
contains
 
“forward-looking
information” including
 
forecasts
 
of productivity
 
and annual
 
coal production,
 
operating and
 
capital cost
 
estimates, coal
 
sales price
 
forecasts,
 
the
assumption that
 
Coronado
 
will
 
continue
 
to
 
acquire
 
necessary permits,
 
and
 
other assumptions.
 
The
 
TRS
 
statements
 
and
 
conclusions
 
are
 
not
 
a
guarantee of future performance and undue reliance should not be placed on them.
 
The ability of Coronado to recover the estimated coal reserves
is dependent on multiple factors beyond the
 
control of MM&A including, but not
 
limited to geologic factors, mining conditions, regulatory approvals,
and changes in regulations.
 
In all cases, the plans assume the Property is under competent management.
Coronado engaged MM&A to conduct a coal resource and reserve evaluation
 
of the Coronado coal
properties as of
 
September 30, 2023.
 
Additions and
 
depletion have been
 
used to
 
bring the
 
Resource
and Reserve estimates
 
forward to December
 
31, 2023, the effective date
 
of this TRS for Buchanan.
 
For the evaluation, the following tasks were
 
to be completed:
 
>
Conduct site visits of the mines and mine infrastructure facilities;
 
>
Process the information supporting
 
the estimation of
 
coal resources and
 
reserves into geological
models;
 
>
Develop life-of-reserve mine
 
(
LOM
) plans and financial models;
>
Hold discussions with Coronado company management; and
 
>
Prepare
 
and
 
issue
 
a
 
TRS
 
providing
 
a
 
statement
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
which
 
would
include:
-
A description of the mine and facilities.
 
-
A description of the evaluation process.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
12
-
An estimation of coal resources and reserves with compliance elements as stated under the
JORC Code and the SEC Regulation S-K 1300.
2.3
 
Personal Inspections
MM&A is very familiar with Buchanan,
 
having provided a variety of services
 
in recent years, and the
QPs involved in this TRS have
 
conducted multiple site visits.
3
 
Property Description
3.1
 
Location
The Buchanan Mine Complex is located in Buchanan County in southwestern Virginia (see
Figure 1-
1
above) approximately
 
16 kilometers
 
southeast of
 
Grundy,
 
which is
 
the county
 
seat of
 
Buchanan
County.
 
Surface facilities for the shaft mine are located along
 
Garden Creek and a Norfolk Southern
(NS) rail line about 6.4 kilometers south-southeast of Oakwood, Virginia.
The Property
 
is located
 
within portions
 
of the
 
following ten
 
(10)
United States
 
Geological Survey
(
USGS
)
 
7.5-Minute Quadrangles:
 
>
Amonate
>
Big A Mountain
>
Bradshaw
>
Honaker
>
Keen Mountain
 
>
Jewell Ridge
>
Prater
>
Richlands
>
Vansant
>
War
 
Current
 
mining projections
 
fall within
 
the Bradshaw,
 
Keen Mountain
 
,
 
Jewell Ridge,
 
and Patterson
Quadrangles.
 
The
 
coordinate
 
system
 
and
 
datum
 
used
 
for
 
the
 
model
 
of Buchanan
 
No. 1
 
and
 
the
subsequent maps were produced in the Virginia State
 
Plane South system, NAD 83.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
13
3.2
 
Titles, Claims or Leases
The Buchanan coal reserves are located in Buchanan and Tazewell
 
Counties, Virginia.
 
The Property
is composed of approximately
 
33,578 total hectares, of which 25,853
 
are leased or subleased from
private
 
landholders under
 
approximately
 
150 individual
 
coal lease
 
tracts,
 
and 7,725
 
hectares
 
are
owned by Coronado.
 
Subject to Coronado’s
 
exercising its renewal
 
rights thereunder,
 
all the leases
expire upon exhaustion of the relevant
 
coal reserves, which is expected to occur in 2042.
 
MM&A has
 
not carried
 
out a
 
separate
 
title verification
 
for
 
the coal
 
property
 
and has
 
not verified
leases,
 
deeds,
 
surveys,
 
or other
 
property
 
control
 
instruments
 
pertinent
 
to
 
the
 
subject resources.
 
Tenure was separately reviewed by Coronado’s legal advisors.
 
Coronado has
 
represented to MM&A
that
 
it controls
 
the mining
 
rights to
 
the reserves
 
as shown
 
on its
 
property maps,
 
and MM&A
 
has
accepted these as being a
 
true and accurate depiction of
 
the mineral rights controlled by Coronado.
 
The TRS assumes the Property is developed under responsible and experienced management.
3.3
 
Mineral Rights
Coronado supplied property control maps to MM&A related to properties for which mineral and/or
surface
 
property
 
are
 
controlled
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
While
 
MM&A
 
accepted
 
these
 
representations
 
as
being
 
true
 
and
 
accurate,
 
MM&A
 
has
 
no
 
knowledge
 
of
 
past
 
property
 
boundary
 
disputes
 
or
 
other
concerns, through
 
past knowledge
 
of the
 
Property,
 
that would
 
signal concern
 
over future
 
mining
operations or development potential.
Property control
 
in Appalachia
 
can be
 
intricate.
 
Coal mining
 
properties are
 
typically composed
 
of
numerous property
 
tracts which
 
are owned
 
and/or leased
 
from both
 
land-holding companies
 
and
private
 
individuals
 
or
 
companies.
 
It
 
is
 
common
 
to
 
encounter
 
severed
 
ownership,
 
with
 
different
entities
 
or individuals
 
controlling
 
the
 
surface
 
and mineral
 
rights.
 
Mineral
 
control
 
in the
 
region
 
is
typically characterized by leases or ownership of larger tracts of land,
 
with surface control generally
comprised of smaller tracts, particularly in developed areas.
Legal mining rights may reflect a combination of fee or
 
mineral ownership and fee or mineral leases
of coal lands through various surface and mineral lease agreements.
 
There is also a relatively small
amount
 
of area
 
where the
 
coal
 
is partially
 
owned and/or
 
partially leased
 
on a
 
limited number
 
of
individual tracts.
 
Control
 
of
 
the
 
surface
 
property
 
is
 
necessary
 
to
 
conduct
 
surface
 
mining
 
but
 
is
 
not
 
necessary
 
to
conduct
 
underground
 
mining.
 
Given that
 
the Buchanan
 
Mine has
 
been active
 
dating back
 
to the
1980s, Coronado,
 
and its predecessors,
 
have a
 
successful history of
 
obtaining any
 
necessary rights
and the associated permits to mine.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
14
3.4
 
Encumbrances
No Title Encumbrances are known.
 
By assignment, MM&A did not complete an independent query
related to Title Encumbrances.
 
3.5
 
Other Risks
There is always risk
 
involved in property control.
 
Coronado and its predecessor, CONSOL, have both
had their legal teams examine the deeds and title
 
control in order to minimize the risk.
 
Historically,
property control has not posed any challenges relate
 
d
 
to Buchanan’s operations.
 
4
 
Accessibility,
 
Climate, Local Resources,
Infrastructure and Physiography
4.1
 
Topography,
 
Elevation, and Vegetation
The
 
topography
 
of
 
the
 
area
 
surrounding
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
Mine
 
Complex
 
is
 
typical
 
of
 
the
 
Central
Appalachian Plateau being rugged and deeply dissected by V-shaped
 
river valleys flanked by steep-
sided
 
upland
 
regions.
 
Surface
 
elevations
 
near
 
the
 
mine
 
complex
 
range
 
from
 
approximately
 
823
meters above sea level
 
in upland regions
 
to approximately 579 meters at
 
stream level.
 
The Property
is moderately vegetated, with a mixture of hardwood and conifer forest in the temperate broadleaf
category.
 
The Property
 
is not
 
situated near
 
any major
 
urban centers,
 
and the
 
surrounding area
 
is
considered rural.
4.2
 
Access and Transport
General
 
access to
 
the Buchanan
 
No. 1
 
Mine property
 
is via
 
a well-developed
 
network of
 
primary,
secondary,
 
and unimproved roads.
 
Highway 460 is the primary highway
 
connecting Pike County in
Eastern
 
Kentucky
 
to
 
Buchanan
 
and
 
Tazewell
 
Counties
 
in
 
Southwestern
 
Virginia.
 
Numerous
secondary
 
and
 
unimproved
 
roads
 
provide
 
direct
 
access
 
to
 
the
 
Property,
 
some
 
being
 
state-
 
and
town-maintained.
 
These roads
 
typically stay
 
open throughout
 
the year.
 
A
Norfolk Southern
 
(
NS
)
rail line that is located
 
approximately 6.44 kilometers
 
south-southeast of Oakwood, Virginia serves
as the primary means
 
of transport for
 
produced coal.
 
NS transports coal
 
from the Buchanan Mine
Complex
 
either
 
to
 
domestic
 
customers
 
or
 
to
 
the
 
Pier
 
6
 
export
 
terminal
 
at
 
Norfolk,
 
Virginia
 
for
overseas
 
shipment.
 
A
 
small
 
portion
 
of
 
production
 
is
 
transported
 
via
 
truck
 
haul.
 
An
 
extensive
network
 
of
 
service
 
roads
 
to
 
gob
 
gas
 
and
 
coalbed
 
methane
 
(
CBM
)
 
production
 
wells
 
exist
 
on
 
the
subject property.
 
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
15
4.3
 
Proximity to Population Centers
The
 
Buchanan
 
No.
 
1
 
Mine
 
property
 
lies
 
near
 
the
 
town
 
of
 
Grundy
 
in
 
Buchanan
 
County,
 
Virginia
approximately
 
290 kilometers
 
southeast of
 
Lexington,
 
Kentucky
 
and 153
 
kilometers
 
southwest
 
of
Roanoke, Virginia.
 
As of 2023, Buchanan County has an estimated population of 19,233 residents.
 
4.4
 
Climate and Length of Operating Season
The
 
climate
 
of
 
the
 
region
 
is
 
classified
 
as
 
humid
 
sub-tropical
 
with
 
four
 
distinct
 
seasons:
 
warm
summers,
 
cold
 
winters,
 
and
 
moderate
 
fall
 
and
 
spring
 
seasons.
 
Precipitation
 
in
 
the
 
region
 
is
consistent throughout the year with the most
 
rain falling in spring and the
 
early months of summer.
 
Average
 
yearly rainfall
 
is 112.62 centimeters.
 
Summer months typically begin
 
in late May
 
and end
in early September and range in average temperature
 
from 49 to 84 degrees Fahrenheit (or 9.44 to
28.89 degrees
 
Celsius).
 
Winters
 
typically begin
 
in mid
 
to late
 
November and
 
run until
 
mid to
 
late
March
 
with
 
average
 
temperatures
 
ranging
 
from
 
26
 
to
 
56
 
degrees
 
Fahrenheit
 
(or
 
-3.33
 
to
 
13.33
degrees Celsius).
 
Precipitation in the winter typically
 
comes in the form of snowfall or as
 
a wintery
mix
 
(sleet
 
and
 
snow)
 
with
 
severe
 
snowfall
 
events
 
occurring
 
occasionally.
 
Seasonal
 
variations
 
in
climate
 
typically
 
do
 
not
 
affect
 
underground
 
mining
 
in
 
Virginia.
 
However,
 
weather
 
events
 
could
potentially
 
negatively
 
impact
 
efficiency
 
of
 
surface
 
and
 
preparation
 
plant
 
operations
 
on
 
a
 
very
limited basis and lasting less than a few days.
4.5
 
Infrastructure
The
 
Buchanan No.
 
1 Mine
 
Complex
 
has
 
sources
 
of water,
 
power,
 
personnel,
 
and
 
supplies readily
available
 
for use.
 
Personnel
 
have historically
 
been sourced
 
from the
 
surrounding communities
 
in
Buchanan, Tazewell,
 
McDowell, and Pike
 
counties, and have
 
proven to
 
be adequate in
 
numbers to
operate the mine.
 
As mining
 
is common
 
in the
 
surrounding areas, the
 
workforce is generally familiar
with
 
mining practices,
 
and
 
many
 
are
 
experienced
 
miners.
 
Water
 
is sourced
 
locally from
 
streams
that
 
flow
 
over
 
Coronado-owned
 
property.
 
The
 
mine
 
also
 
utilizes
 
ground
 
water
 
from
 
an
 
old,
abandoned mine.
 
Electricity
 
is
 
sourced
 
from
American
 
Electric
 
Power
 
(
AEP
)
.
 
The
 
service
 
industry
 
in
 
the
 
areas
surrounding the
 
mine complex
 
has historically provided
 
supplies, equipment
 
repairs and fabrication,
etc.
 
The
 
Coronado-owned
 
Buchanan
 
Preparation
 
Plant
 
services
 
the
 
mine
 
via
 
a
 
skip
 
hoist
 
and
conveyor
 
belt system
 
which transports
 
extracted coal
 
from an
 
underground bunker
 
to the surface
facility.
 
The NS rail line serves as the main means of transport from the mine.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
16
5
 
History
5.1
 
Previous Operation
The
 
Property
 
was
 
formerly
 
controlled
 
by
Consolidation
 
Coal
 
Company
 
(
CONSOL
)
.
 
Mine
development
 
was
 
started
 
by CONSOL
 
in 1983
 
and longwall
 
production began
 
in 1987.
 
Coronado
acquired the Buchanan Mine from CONSOL in March 2016.
The most
 
productive mining of
 
any period
 
since 1987
 
has occurred since
 
the acquisition
 
of Buchanan
Mine by Coronado.
 
Production history
 
has been approximately
 
3.5 Mt in
 
2016 (in only
 
a 9-month
period), 4.9
 
Mt in
 
2017, 4.7
 
Mt in
 
2018, 4.5
 
Mt in
 
2019, 3.4
 
Mt in
 
2020, 4.4
 
Mt in
 
2021, 3.9
 
Mt in
2022,
 
and 3.6 Mt in 2023.
5.2
 
Previous Exploration
The Property has
 
been extensively
 
explored by subsurface
 
drilling efforts carried
 
out by numerous
entities,
 
many
 
of
 
which
 
were
 
completed
 
prior
 
to
 
acquisition
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
The
 
majority
 
of
 
the
drilling was accomplished using vertical continuous (diamond) coring or air rotary methods.
Drill records
 
indicate that
 
independent contract
 
drilling operators
 
have
 
typically been
 
engaged
 
to
carry out drilling on the Property.
 
Geophysical logging on those
 
properties acquired from
 
CONSOL
was
 
often
 
performed
 
by
 
both
 
CONSOL’s
 
in-house
 
logging
 
services
 
and
 
outside
 
logging
 
firms.
 
MM&A,
 
via
 
its
 
Geophysical
 
Logging
 
Systems
 
subsidiary,
 
has
 
subsequently
 
logged
 
a
 
significant
number of
 
the past
 
exploration holes and
 
degas wells, and
 
currently logs most
 
of the
 
recently-drilled
holes.
6
 
Geological Setting, Mineralization and Deposit
6.1
 
Regional, Local and Property Geology
The
 
Property
 
lies in
 
the Central
 
Appalachian Coal
 
basin
 
in the
 
Appalachian Plateau
 
physiographic
province.
 
The coal deposits in the eastern
 
US are the oldest and
 
most extensively developed
 
coal deposits in
the country.
 
The coal deposits
 
on the Property
 
are Carboniferous in age,
 
being of the
 
Pennsylvanian
system.
 
Overall, these Carboniferous
 
coals contain two-fifths
 
of the US’s
 
bituminous coal deposits
and extend
 
over 1,448
 
kilometers from
 
northern Alabama to
 
Pennsylvania
 
and are
 
part of what
 
is
known broadly as the
Appalachian Basin
.
 
The Appalachian Basin is more than 402 kilometers wide
and, in some
 
portions,
 
contains over
 
60 coal seams
 
of varying economic
 
significance; the Property
is located within the Central Appalachian Basin.
As shown on
Figure 1-1
 
above, the southern edge of the Property
 
is structurally bounded by
 
major
faulting
 
associated
 
with
 
the
 
Boissevain
 
Thrust
 
Fault,
 
located
 
approximately
 
4.0
 
kilometers
 
from
mine projections
 
at the south
 
end of the
 
mine. (North of
 
the fault
 
is the coal-bearing
 
Appalachian
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
17
Plateau region; south of the fault is the Valley and Ridge imbricate thrust region.) Moreover, a well-
defined,
 
northwest-southeast
 
trending
 
strike-slip
 
feature,
 
Keen
 
Mountain
 
Fault,
 
is
 
located
approximately 1.0 kilometer from
 
mine projections at the southwestern edge of the mine.
 
Furthermore, the
 
southwest-northeast trending axis
 
of the
 
Dry Fork
 
Anticline skirts
 
mine projections
located
 
at the
 
south end
 
of the
 
mine.
 
Otherwise, regional
 
structure
 
is typically
 
characterized
 
by
gently dipping strata to the northwest
 
at less than one percent.
Seams of economic significance
 
typically range between
 
0.30 meters and 1.83 meters
 
in thickness,
with relatively
 
little structural
 
deformation.
 
Seams of
 
the Pocahontas
 
Formation have
 
historically
been
 
mined;
 
and
 
the
 
Pocahontas
 
No.
 
3
 
seam
 
currently
 
being
 
mined
 
at
 
Buchanan
 
Mine
 
is
 
the
principal
 
mineable
 
seam
 
within
 
the
 
formation.
 
Coal
 
from
 
the
 
region
 
has
 
historically
 
been
 
sold
primarily in metallurgical markets.
6.2
 
Mineralization
The generalized stratigraphic columnar section in
Figure 6-1
 
demonstrates the vertical relationships
of the principal coal seams and rock formations on the Property.
 
 
ex962p2i0 ex962p26i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
18
Figure 6-1:
 
Buchanan Stratigraphic Column
Note: not to scale
6.3
 
Deposits
The
 
coal
 
produced
 
at
 
Buchanan No.
 
1
 
is typically
 
Low
 
Volatile
 
(<23%
 
volatile
 
matter)
 
bituminous
coal.
 
Due
 
to
 
the
 
value
 
of
 
the
 
Pocahontas
 
No.
 
3
 
(
P3
)
 
as
 
a
 
low-volatile
 
coking
 
coal,
 
it
 
has
 
been
extensively
 
mined
 
in
 
the
 
region.
 
The
 
P3
 
seam
 
consists
 
of
 
multiple
 
benches
 
that
 
split
 
and
 
merge
across the Property,
 
including in descending stratigraphic order (refer
 
to
Figure 6-2
below):
 
>
P31, uppermost bench(es),
 
represented in purple; locally
 
splits into two
 
benches in the
 
northeast
areas of the property,
 
with the uppermost bench referred to as P30.5.
 
>
P32, represented in orange.
>
P33, represented in blue.
 
 
ex962p2i0 ex962p27i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
19
>
345, lowermost bench, represented
 
in green;
 
may split locally into
 
2 benches referred
 
to as P34
and P35.
The
 
P3
 
seam
 
is
 
situated
 
entirely
 
below
 
drainage
 
throughout
 
the
 
Property
 
and
 
is
 
accessible
 
by
existing mine shafts.
 
Floor and roof strata vary throughout the
 
mine area with floor
 
strata including
fireclay,
 
claystone, shale,
 
sandy shale, and
 
sandstone, but primarily
 
fireclay and
 
shale.
 
Roof strata
varies throughout as well but primarily is composed of sandstone, sandy shale, and shale.
As
 
illustrated
 
on
Figure
 
6-2
,
 
sandstone
 
paleochannels
 
are
 
common
 
within
 
the
 
Pocahontas
Formation,
 
occurring
 
above
 
and
 
below
 
the
 
P3,
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
within
 
non-coal
 
partings
 
(identified
 
as
Intervals
 
0,
 
I,
 
II,
 
and
 
III
 
between
 
the
 
main
 
benches)
 
that
 
separate
 
the
 
seam
 
into
 
its
 
component
benches.
 
In some areas adjacent to the Property,
 
the P3 has been entirely eroded and replaced by
multi-storied sandstone channels.
Figure 6-2: Schematic Cross-Section of the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam and Enclosing Strata
The
 
mineable
 
benches
 
within
 
the
 
P3
 
horizon
 
generally
 
consist
 
of
 
three
 
principal
 
mining
configurations
 
determined
 
by
 
variable
 
seam
 
splitting
 
characteristics
 
present
 
across
 
the
 
Property
(refer to
Figure 6-2
 
above):
 
1.
Full Seam
; typically,
 
four benches (P31,
 
P32, P33, and 345)
 
are included within
 
the mineable
section.
 
>
This
 
configuration
 
is present
 
within
 
the
 
remaining
 
North
 
/
 
Northwest
 
resource
 
areas,
 
as
well as the northern portion of the South resource area.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
20
>
Due to the seam
 
splitting and the localized
 
presence of sandstone
 
paleochannel scouring,
the Full-seam bench (P3) thickness ranges from 0.00 to 3.44 meters with an average
 
of:
A.
1.45 meters in the North.
B.
1.51 meters in the West.
C.
2.16 meters in the South.
2.
P31, P32, and
 
P33 Benches
; occurs where
 
the underlying 345
 
bench extends
 
more than two
feet below the P33 bench and is no longer included within the mineable section.
 
>
This configuration
 
is present on
 
the South side of
 
the Property,
 
and south of the
 
two-foot
split line between the P33 and 345 benches.
 
>
Longwall mining within this geologic configuration is anticipated to commence for the first
time in Buchanan Mine’s history during early 2024.
>
Locally,
 
the P32 and
 
P33 benches likewise
 
splits, resulting
 
in higher than
 
average
 
in-seam
reject.
>
The P31, P32,
 
P33 bench thickness
 
ranges from 0.25 to 2.78
 
meters with an average of 1.53
meters.
3.
P32, P33, and
 
345 Benches
; the overlying
 
P31 bench extends
 
more than
 
two feet
 
above the
P32 (or
 
has been
 
scoured out
 
by sandstone
 
paleochannels) and
 
is no
 
longer included
 
within
the mineable section.
 
>
This configuration is present on the East
 
side of the Property.
 
>
Due
 
to
 
the
 
localized
 
presence
 
of
 
sandstone
 
scouring, the
 
P32,
 
P33,
 
345 bench
 
thickness
ranges from 0.00 to 2.71 meters with an
 
average of 1.50 meters.
 
7
 
Exploration
7.1
 
Nature and Extent of Exploration
Extensive exploration in the form of subsurface drill efforts has been carried out on the Property by
numerous entities,
 
much of which
 
was completed
 
prior to
 
the acquisition by
 
Coronado.
 
Diamond
core, rotary,
 
and CBM drilling are the three primary types
 
of exploration on the Property.
 
Data for
correlation
 
and mining
 
conditions
 
are
 
derived
 
from
 
core
 
descriptions
 
and geophysical
 
logging (e-
logging).
 
Coal quality analyses were also employed during the core exploration
 
process.
 
A total of 15,725 core, rotary, channel samples, mine measurements, and CBM
 
wells that penetrate
the
 
Pocahontas
 
No.
 
3
 
seam
 
are
 
found
 
within
 
Coronado’s
 
property-wide
 
lithologic
 
database.
(Locations
 
of drill holes are shown on the map included in
Appendix B
.)
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
21
Of the 15,725 data points, approximately
 
11,720 are located within or immediately adjacent to
 
the
current
 
mine
 
/
 
resource
 
areas;
 
consisting
 
of
 
1,945
 
(17%)
 
drill
 
holes;
 
and
 
9,775
 
(83%)
 
in-mine
measurements.
 
The concentration of
 
exploration varies slightly
 
across the
 
Property, with the proposed
 
underground
mining
 
areas
 
having
 
the
 
highest
 
concentration
 
of
 
drill
 
holes.
 
Drilling
 
on the
 
Property
 
is
 
typically
sufficient
 
for
 
delineation
 
of
 
potential
 
underground
 
mineable
 
benches.
 
Core
 
logging
 
is
 
typically
conducted by professional
 
geologists in cases
 
where roof and
 
floor strata
 
are of particular
 
interest
and in
 
cases where
 
greater
 
resolution and
 
geologic detail
 
are needed.
 
Unlike
 
recent
 
information
provided by experienced geologists, much of the earlier drill
 
hole data consists of simplified driller’s
logs, which
 
often lack
 
specific details
 
regarding geotechnical conditions and
 
specific geology, making
seam
 
correlations
 
and
 
floor
 
and
 
roof
 
conditions
 
difficult
 
to
 
determine.
 
Geophysical
 
logging
techniques,
 
by
 
contrast,
 
document
 
some
 
details
 
useful
 
for
 
geologic
 
interpretation
 
and
 
mining
conditions,
 
but do not provide detailed lithologic information.
 
Given
 
the
 
variability
 
of
 
geologic
 
conditions
 
and
 
data-gathering
 
methods,
 
definitive
 
mapping
 
of
future
 
mining
 
conditions
 
has
 
limitations,
 
but
 
projections
 
and
 
assumptions
 
can
 
be
 
made
 
with
 
a
reasonable degree
 
of certainty.
 
After the
 
integrity of
 
the database
 
was established,
 
stratigraphic
columnar sections were
 
generated
 
using cross-sectional analysis
 
to establish
 
or confirm coal
 
seam
correlations (refer to
Figures
 
6-1
and
 
6-2
above).
Due
 
to
 
the
 
extended
 
history
 
of
 
exploration
 
by
 
various
 
parties
 
on
 
the
 
Property,
 
a
 
wide
 
variety
 
of
survey techniques
 
exist for
 
documentation of
 
data point
 
locations.
 
Many of
 
the older exploration
drill holes appear to have been located by survey and more recently completed drill holes are often
located by
 
high-resolution Global
 
Positioning System
 
(
GPS
) units.
 
However,
 
some holes appear
 
to
have
 
been
 
approximately
 
located
 
using USGS
 
topography
 
maps
 
or
 
other methods
 
which
 
are
 
less
accurate.
 
Therefore, discretion
 
had to be used regarding
 
the accuracy for the
 
location and ground
surface
 
elevation
 
of
 
some
 
of
 
these
 
older
 
drill
 
holes.
 
In
 
instances
 
where
 
a
 
drill
 
hole
 
location
 
(or
associated coal
 
seam elevations)
 
appeared to
 
be inconsistent
 
with the
 
overall
 
structural trend
 
(or
surface
 
topography
 
for
 
surface-mineable
 
areas),
 
the
 
data
 
point
 
was
 
not
 
honored
 
for
 
geological
modeling.
 
Others with apparently minor variances were adjusted and then used by MM&A.
 
Surveying of the underground and surface mined areas has been performed by the mine operators
and/or
 
their
 
consulting
 
surveyors.
 
By
 
assignment,
 
MM&A
 
did
 
not
 
verify
 
the
 
accuracy
 
or
completeness of supplied
 
mine maps but
 
accepted this information as
 
being the
 
work of responsible
engineers and surveyors.
7.2
 
Non-Drilling Procedures and Parameters
To
 
supplement
 
the
 
core
 
hole
 
quality
 
database,
 
samples
 
have
 
been
 
collected
 
from
 
underground
channel samples, mine stockpiles, and/or truck / train shipments.
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
22
7.3
 
Drilling Procedures
Core
 
drilling
 
methods
 
typically
 
utilize
 
NX-size
 
(5.4
 
centimeters)
 
or
 
similar-sized
 
core
 
cylinders
 
to
recover core
 
samples, which can be
 
used to delineate
 
geologic characteristics,
 
and for coal
 
quality
testing
 
and geotechnical
 
logging.
 
For the
 
core holes,
 
the geophysical
 
logs are
 
especially useful
 
in
verifying the core recovery
 
of both the coal samples
 
(for assurance that
 
a sample is representative
of the
 
full seam)
 
and of
 
the roof and
 
floor rock
 
samples (for evaluating
 
ground control characteristics
of deep mineable coal seams).
 
In addition to core holes,
 
rotary-drilled holes also exist on much
 
of the Property.
 
Data for the rotary
drilled holes
 
are mainly derived
 
from downhole
 
geophysical
 
logs, which are
 
used to
 
interpret coal
and rock
 
thickness and
 
depth since
 
logging of the
 
drill cuttings
 
is not
 
reliable.
 
From time
 
to time,
geological
 
staff
 
at
 
MM&A
 
have
 
been
 
engaged
 
by
 
Coronado
 
to
 
interpret
 
geophysical
 
logs
 
within
specific areas of interest, the results of which have been added to the Coronado geologic database.
Moreover,
 
MM&A field geologists have conducted gas content (desorption) testing of core samples
as part of an
 
ongoing effort to assess levels of coalbed
 
methane gas (
CBM
) present within the seam.
Additionally, there is an
 
ongoing active surface
 
drilling program for
 
degassing the mined
 
seam ahead
of mining.
 
The degas holes
 
are typically logged geophysically, and the resulting
 
interpreted data are
incorporated into
 
the geological model.
 
Exploratory drilling generally
 
requires drilling to depths of
over 305 meters to penetrate
 
the target coal seam at Buchanan.
A wide
 
variety of
 
core
 
logging techniques
 
exist
 
for the
 
Property.
 
For many
 
of the
 
core holes,
 
the
primary data source
 
is a
 
generalized lithology description
 
by the driller, which
 
may be supplemented
by
 
a
 
more
 
detailed
 
core
 
log
 
completed
 
by
 
a
 
geologist.
 
These logs
 
were
 
provided
 
to
 
MM&A as
 
a
geological database.
 
MM&A geologists were not
 
involved in the production
 
of original core logs
 
but
did perform a basic check of information within the provided database.
 
Where geophysical logs for
such holes are available,
 
they were used by MM&A
 
geologists to verify the coal
 
thickness and core
recovery of seams.
 
7.4
 
Hydrology
Buchanan is an
 
active mine with
 
no hydrologic concerns or
 
material issues experienced
 
in its history.
 
Future
 
mining
 
is projected
 
to
 
occur
 
in areas
 
exhibiting
 
similar hydrogeological
 
conditions
 
as
 
past
mining, including
 
stream undermining,
 
undermining of
 
aquifers,
 
and mining
 
through hydraulically
fractured (frac’d)
 
coalbed methane wells.
 
Based upon the successful history
 
of the operation
 
with
regards to
 
hydrogeological
 
conditions, MM&A assumes
 
that the operation
 
will not be
 
hindered by
such issues in the future.
7.5
 
Geotechnical Data
Mining
 
plans
 
for
 
potential
 
underground
 
mines
 
were
 
developed
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
modified
 
by
MM&A to
 
fit current
 
property constraints.
 
Pillar stability
 
was tested
 
by MM&A
 
using the
Analysis
of
 
Coal
 
Pillar
 
Stability
 
(ACPS)
and
Analysis
 
of
 
Longwall
 
Pillar
 
Stability
 
(ALPS)
 
programs
 
that
 
were
developed by the
National Institute for Occupational Safety and
 
Health (
NIOSH
)
.
 
MM&A reviewed
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
23
the results
 
from the ACPS
 
and ALPS analysis
 
and considered them
 
in the development
 
of the LOM
plan.
8
 
Sample Preparation, Analyses and Security
8.1
 
Prior to Sending to the Lab
Most
 
of the
 
coal
 
samples have
 
been obtained
 
from
 
the Property
 
by subsurface
 
exploration
 
using
core drilling
 
techniques.
 
The protocol
 
for preparing
 
and testing
 
the samples
 
has varied
 
over time
and is
 
not well
 
documented for the
 
older holes
 
drilled on
 
the Property.
 
Typical core-drilling sampling
methods for
 
coal in
 
the United
 
States
 
involves
 
drilling through
 
the seam,
 
removing the
 
core from
the
 
barrel,
 
describing the
 
lithology,
 
wrapping
 
the
 
sample in
 
a
 
sealed
 
plastic
 
sleeve
 
and
 
placing it
lengthwise into
 
a covered core
 
box, and carefully
 
marking hole ID and depth
 
intervals on each box
and
 
lid, allowing
 
the
 
core
 
to
 
be delivered
 
to
 
a
 
laboratory
 
in correct
 
stratigraphic
 
order,
 
and with
original
 
moisture
 
content.
 
This
 
process
 
has
 
been
 
the
 
norm
 
for
 
both
 
historical
 
and
 
ongoing
exploration activities at the Property.
This
 
work
 
is
 
typically
 
performed
 
by
 
the
 
supervising
 
driller,
 
geologist,
 
or
 
company
 
personnel.
 
Samples
 
are
 
most
 
often
 
delivered
 
to
 
the
 
company
 
by
 
the
 
driller
 
after
 
each
 
shift
 
or
 
acquired
 
by
company personnel
 
or representatives.
 
Most of the
 
coal core
 
samples were
 
obtained by previous
or current
 
operators
 
on the
 
Property.
 
MM&A did
 
not participate
 
in the
 
collection, sampling,
 
and
analysis of the core samples.
 
However,
 
it is reasonable to assume, given the consistency
 
of quality
from previous operators, that these samples
 
were generally collected and processed
 
under industry
best practices.
 
This assumption is based on MM&A’s
 
familiarity with the operating companies
 
and
the companies used to perform the analyses.
8.2
 
Lab Procedures
Coal-quality testing
 
has been
 
performed over
 
many years
 
by operating
 
companies using
 
different
laboratories and testing regimens.
 
Some of the
 
samples have raw analyses and
 
washabilities on the
full seam (with coal and rock parting layers co-mingled) and are mainly useful for characterizing the
coal quality for projected production from underground
 
mining.
 
Other samples have coal and rock
analyzed
 
separately,
 
the results
 
of which
 
can
 
be utilized
 
to
 
forecast
 
underground
 
mining quality.
 
Care
 
has
 
been
 
taken
 
to
 
use
 
only
 
those
 
analyses
 
that
 
are
 
representative
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
quality
parameters for the appropriate
 
mining type for each sample.
 
Unlike many Appalachian properties,
Buchanan has interest
 
in a single deep-mineable seam,
 
the Pocahontas
 
No. 3 seam; therefore,
 
the
analyses have been conducted following a consistent
 
protocol.
Standard procedure upon receipt of core
 
samples by the testing laboratory is to: 1) log the depth
and thickness of the sample; then 2) perform testing as specified by a representative
 
of the
operating company.
 
Samples
 
are
 
analyzed
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
procedures
 
defined
 
under
ASTM
 
International
 
(
ASTM
)
standards including, but not limited to (not all analytical tests identified in the list below have been
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
24
run on
 
each sample):
 
washability (ASTM
 
D4371); ash (ASTM
 
D3174); sulfur (ASTM
 
D4239); Btu/lb.
(ASTM D5865); volatile matter (ASTM D3175); Free Swell Index
 
(
FSI
) (ASTM D720).
 
While not confirmed
 
by MM&A, it
 
is assumed
 
that best practices
 
and ASTM (or
 
equivalent standards
at the time
 
of testing) were utilized in
 
laboratory quality testing. Since
 
1958 (the earliest coal
 
quality
information available), the Property has been controlled by various mining
 
companies utilizing their
own
 
corporate
 
laboratories
 
including:
Island
 
Creek
 
Coal
 
Company
(Keen
 
Mountain,
 
Virginia),
Pocahontas Fuel Company
(Pocahontas, Virginia), and
Consol
(Library,
 
Pennsylvania).
 
Since
 
1977
 
to
 
the
 
present,
 
additional
 
laboratories
not
 
affiliated
 
with
 
coal
 
companies
 
who
 
have
provided analytical data for the Property include:
>
Dickinson Laboratories, Inc.
 
(El Paso, Texas)
 
– no longer in operation.
>
Geochemical
 
Testing
 
(Somerset,
 
Pennsylvania)
 
–
 
accredited
 
by
 
the
National
 
Environmental
Laboratory Accreditation Program
 
(
NELAP
).
>
SGS
 
North
 
America
 
(Sophia,
 
West
 
Virginia)
 
–
 
a
 
leading
 
accredited
 
body
 
and
 
a
Nationally
Recognized Test
 
Laboratory
 
(
NRTL
); currently analyzing samples for Coronado.
Additional accredited coal testing laboratories are utilized for other less frequent analyses on
 
an as-
needed basis.
9
 
Data Verification
9.1
 
Procedures of Qualified Person
MM&A reviewed the digital geologic
 
database supplied by Coronado.
 
The database consists of
 
data
records, which
 
include drill hole
 
information for
 
holes that
 
lie within and
 
adjacent to
 
the Property
and records
 
for numerous
 
supplemental coal
 
seam thickness measurements.
 
Upon completion of
the database
 
verification,
 
copies of
 
each entry
 
were
 
printed,
 
and cross
 
referenced
 
to the
 
original
document for
 
verification.
 
Once the initial
 
integrity of the
 
database was
 
established, stratigraphic
columnar sections were
 
generated using
 
cross-sectional analysis to
 
establish or confirm
 
coal-seam
correlations.
 
Geophysical
 
logs
 
were
 
used
 
wherever
 
available
 
to
 
assist
 
in
 
confirming
 
the
 
seam
correlation and to verify proper seam thickness measurements and recovery
 
of coal samples.
 
After establishing and/or verifying proper seam correlation, seam data-control maps and geological
cross-sections were generated
 
and again used to verify seam correlations and data
 
integrity.
 
Once
the database was fully vetted, seam thickness, base-of-seam elevation, roof and
 
floor lithology, and
overburden maps were independently generated
 
for use in the mine planning process.
9.2
 
Limitations
As with any exploration program, localized anomalies
 
cannot always be discovered.
 
The greater the
density of
 
the samples
 
taken,
 
the less
 
the risk.
 
Once an
 
area is
 
identified as
 
being of
 
interest
 
for
inclusion
 
in
 
the
 
mine
 
plan,
 
additional
 
samples
 
are
 
taken
 
to
 
help
 
reduce
 
the
 
risk
 
in
 
those
 
specific
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
25
areas.
 
In general, provision is made in the mine planning portion of the study to allow for localized
anomalies that are typically
 
classed more as
 
a nuisance than
 
a hinderance.
 
Longwall production has
been de-rated in thinner coal zones.
9.3
 
Opinion of Qualified Person
Sufficient data have been obtained through various exploration and sampling programs and mining
operations
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
geological
 
interpretations
 
of
 
seam
 
structure
 
and
 
thickness
 
for
 
coal
horizons situated
 
on the Property.
 
The data are
 
of sufficient
 
quantity and reliability
 
to reasonably
support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates in this TRS.
10
 
Mineral Processing and Metallurgical Testing
10.1
 
Testing
 
Procedures
Separate
 
tabulations
 
have
 
been
 
compiled
 
for
 
basic
 
chemical
 
analyses
 
(both
 
raw
 
and
 
washed
quality),
 
petrographic
 
data,
 
rheological
 
data
 
and
 
chlorine,
 
ash,
 
ultimate
 
and
 
sulfur
 
analysis.
 
The
latter two data types
 
are not as prevalent and have
 
been supplemented by samples collected from
mine stockpiles and either truck- or train-shipment samples.
Available
 
coal-quality data
 
were
 
tabulated
 
by resource
 
area in
 
a Microsoft®
 
EXCEL
 
workbook and
the details of that work are maintained on file at the offices of Coronado and MM&A.
 
These tables
also
 
provide
 
basic
 
statistical
 
analyses
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
quality
 
data
 
sets,
 
including
 
average
 
value;
maximum
 
and
 
minimum
 
values;
 
and
 
the
 
number
 
of
 
samples
 
available
 
to
 
represent
 
each
 
quality
parameter
 
of
 
the
 
seam.
 
Coal
 
samples
 
that
 
were
 
deemed
 
by
 
MM&A
 
geologists
 
to
 
be
unrepresentative
 
were
 
not
 
used
 
for
 
statistical
 
analysis
 
of
 
coal
 
quality,
 
as
 
documented
 
in
 
the
tabulations.
 
A
 
representative
 
group
 
of
 
drill
 
hole
 
samples
 
from
 
the
 
Property
 
were
 
then
 
checked
against the original drill laboratory reports to verify accuracy
 
and correctness.
The amount and areal extent of coal sampling
 
for geological data is generally sufficient to represent
the quality characteristics of
 
the coal horizons
 
and allow for
 
proper market placement of
 
the subject
coal seams.
 
For some portions
 
of the
 
Property, considerable laboratory data are available from core
samples and channel samples
 
that are representative of the full
 
extent of the resource area; and
 
for
others
 
there
 
are
 
more
 
limited
 
data
 
to
 
represent
 
the
 
resource
 
area.
 
For
 
example,
 
in
 
the
 
active
operations with considerable previous mining, there may be limited
 
quality data within some of the
remaining
 
resource
 
areas;
 
however,
 
in those
 
cases
 
the
 
core
 
sampling
 
data
 
can
 
be supplemented
with operational data from
 
mining and shipped
 
quality samples representative
 
of the resource area.
10.2
 
Relationship of Tests
 
to the Whole
The extensive
 
sampling and
 
testing procedures
 
typically followed
 
in the
 
coal
 
industry result
 
in an
excellent correlation between samples and marketable products.
 
Shipped analyses of
 
the coal from
Buchanan mine were reviewed
 
to verify that the coal quality
 
and characteristics were
 
as expected.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
26
Table 10-1
 
below compares the similarity of quality from core samples and coal shipments for: Ash,
Sulfur,
 
BTU, and Volatile Matter.
Table 10-1:
 
Comparison of Core with Shipped Coal Quality
Ash %
Sulfur %
Btu
Volatile Matter %
Core Samples (1.60 Float)
5.18
0.65
14,967
16.76
Coal Shipments (4thQ 2021- 3rdQ 2023)
5.79
0.71
14,847
17.13
 
Note: All values are on a dry basis.
Buchanan
 
has
 
a
 
long
 
history
 
of
 
saleable
 
production
 
in
 
the
 
low-volatile
 
metallurgical
 
markets,
confirming
 
exploration
 
results.
 
Degradation
 
of
 
coking
 
coal
 
characteristics
 
over
 
time
 
is
 
not
anticipated to be an issue.
10.3
 
Lab Information
As
 
noted
 
previously,
 
samples
 
are
 
analyzed
 
at
 
area
 
Laboratories
 
that
 
operate
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
procedures defined under ASTM standards including, but not limited to the following (Note:
 
not all
analytical tests identified in this list have been run on each sample.):
>
ASTM D 4371
 
– Test
 
Method for Determining Washability Characteristics
 
of Coal
>
ASTM D 3174
 
– Method for Ash in the Analysis Sample of Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D
 
4239
 
– Test
 
Methods for
 
Sulphur in
 
the Analysis
 
Sample of
 
Coal and
 
Coke
 
Using High-
Temperature
 
Tube Furnace Combustion Methods
>
ASTM D 5865
 
– Test
 
Method for Gross Calorific Value
 
of Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 3175
 
– Test
 
Method for Volatile Matter
 
in the Analysis Sample of Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 3176
– Standard Practice for Ultimate Analysis of Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 3178
- Test
 
Method for Carbon and Hydrogen in Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 3179
- Test
 
Method for Nitrogen in Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 720
 
– Test
 
Method for Free-Swelling Index (
FSI
) of Coal
>
ASTM
 
D
 
5515
-
 
Test
 
Method
 
for
 
Determination
 
of
 
the
 
Swelling
 
Properties
 
of
 
Bituminous
 
Coal
Using a Dilatometer (Arnu)
>
ASTM D 2639
 
– Test
 
Method for Plastic Properties of Coal (Gieseler)
>
ASTM D 3683
– Trace Elements
 
in Coal and Coke Ash by the Atomic Absorption Method
>
ASTM D 1857
– Standard Test
 
Method for Fusibility of Coal and Coke Ash
>
ASTM
 
D
 
2798
–
 
Microscopical
 
Determination
 
of
 
the
 
Reflectance
 
of
 
Vitrinite
 
in
 
a
 
Polished
Specimen of Coal
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
27
Ultimate analysis is a process typically used which gives the composition of coal in terms of carbon,
hydrogen,
 
nitrogen,
 
oxygen,
 
ash,
 
and
 
sulfur
 
without
 
regard
 
to
 
origin.
 
The
 
sum
 
of
 
the
 
carbon,
hydrogen, nitrogen, sulfur,
 
and ash are subtracted from 100 percent to
 
calculate oxygen percent.
Heating value or calorific value is a measure of the heat produced from a
 
unit weight of coal.
 
In the
United States, it is commonly
 
expressed in British thermal
 
units per pound
 
(
Btu/lb.
).
 
Other units are
kilocalories
 
per
 
kilogram
 
(
Kcal/kg
)
 
and
 
kilojoules
 
per
 
gram
 
(
KJ/g
).
 
Heating
 
value
 
is
 
generally
determined by burning a weighed coal sample, in oxygen, in a calorimeter.
As noted
 
previously,
 
since 1958
 
(the earliest
 
coal quality
 
information
 
available),
 
the Property
 
has
been controlled
 
by various
 
mining companies
 
utilizing their
 
own corporate
 
laboratories
 
including:
Island
 
Creek
 
Coal
 
Company
(Keen
 
Mountain,
 
Virginia),
Pocahontas
 
Fuel
 
Company
(Pocahontas,
Virginia), and
Consol
(Library, Pennsylvania).
 
Since
 
1977
 
to
 
the
 
present,
 
additional
 
laboratories
not
 
affiliated
 
with
 
coal
 
companies
 
who
 
have
provided analytical data for the Property include:
>
Dickinson Laboratories, Inc.
 
(El Paso, Texas)
 
– no longer in operation.
>
Geochemical Testing
 
(Somerset, Pennsylvania) – accredited
 
by the
NELAP
.
>
SGS North America
 
(Sophia, West Virginia) – a leading accredited body and a
NRTL
; currently
analyzing samples for Coronado.
Additional accredited coal testing laboratories
 
are utilized for other less frequent analyses on an
as-needed basis
10.4
 
Relevant Results
No critical factors have been found
 
that would adversely affect the recovery
 
of the Reserve.
 
11
 
Mineral Resource Estimates
MM&A independently created a geologic model to define the coal resources at Buchanan.
 
Coal
resources were estimated
 
as of December 31, 2023.
11.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
Geological
 
data
 
were
 
imported
 
into
 
Carlson
 
Mining
®
 
(formerly
 
SurvCADD
®
)
 
geological
 
modelling
software
 
in
 
the
 
form
 
of Microsoft
®
 
Excel
 
files
 
incorporating
 
drill
 
hole
 
collars,
 
seam
 
and
 
thickness
picks, bottom
 
seam elevations
 
and raw
 
and washed
 
coal quality.
 
These data
 
files were
 
validated
prior to importing into the software.
 
Once imported, a geologic model was created, reviewed,
 
and
verified with a key element being a gridded model of coal seam thickness.
 
Resource
 
tonnes
 
were
 
estimated
 
by
 
using
 
the
 
seam
 
thickness
 
grid
 
based
 
on
 
each
 
valid
 
point
 
of
observation and
 
by defining
 
resource confidence
 
arcs around
 
the points
 
of observation.
 
Points of
observation for
 
Measured and
 
Indicated confidence
 
arcs were
 
defined for
 
all valid
 
drill holes
 
that
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
28
intersected
 
the seam
 
using standards
 
deemed acceptable
 
by MM&A
 
based on
 
a detailed
 
geologic
evaluation and a statistical analysis
 
of all drill holes within the projected reserve areas as described
in
Section 11.1.1
.
 
The geological
 
evaluation incorporated
 
an analysis
 
of seam
 
thickness related
 
to
depositional environments, adjacent roof and floor lithologies, and structural influences.
After validating coal seam data and establishing correlations, the thickness and elevation for seams
of
 
economic
 
interest
 
were
 
used
 
to
 
generate
 
a
 
geologic
 
model.
 
Due
 
to
 
the
 
relative
 
structural
simplicity
 
of
 
the
 
deposits
 
and
 
the
 
reasonable
 
continuity
 
of
 
the
 
tabular
 
coal
 
beds,
 
the
 
principal
geological
 
interpretation
 
necessary
 
to
 
define
 
the
 
geometry
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
deposits
 
is
 
the
 
proper
modeling
 
of
 
their
 
thickness
 
and
 
elevation.
 
Both
 
coal
 
thickness
 
and
 
quality
 
data
 
are
 
deemed
 
by
MM&A to be reasonably sufficient within the resource areas.
 
Therefore, there is a reasonable level
of confidence in the geologic
 
interpretations required for coal resource determination based on the
available data and the techniques applied to the data.
Table 11-1
 
below provides the geological mapping and
 
coal tonnage estimation criteria used for the
coal resource
 
and reserve
 
evaluation.
 
These cut-off
 
parameters
 
have
 
been developed
 
by MM&A
based
 
on
 
its
 
experience
 
with
 
the
 
Coronado
 
property
 
and
 
are
 
typical
 
of
 
mining
 
operations
 
in
 
the
Central
 
Appalachian
 
coal
 
basin.
 
This
 
experience
 
includes
 
technical
 
and
 
economic
 
evaluations
 
of
numerous
 
properties
 
in the
 
region
 
for
 
the
 
purposes of
 
determining
 
the
 
economic
 
viability of
 
the
subject coal reserves.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
29
Table
 
11-1:
 
General Reserve and Resource Criteria
Item
Parameters
Technical Notes & Exceptions*
•
 
General Criteria
 
 
Reserve
 
Classification
Reserve and Resource
Reliability Categories
Reserve (Proven and Probable)
Resource (Measured, Indicated,
 
and Inferred)
Distances between points of observation are standard
USGS (in meters), respectively, for measured and
indicated and inferred.
Effective Date of Resource Estimate
December 31, 2023
Coal resources were updated for depletion based on
information from Coronado.
 
Effective date for coal
resources is as of December 31, 2023.
Effective Date of Reserve Estimate
December 31, 2023
Coal reserves were updated for depletion based on
information from Coronado.
 
Effective date for coal
reserves is as of December 31, 2023.
Seam Density
Variable, dependent upon seam characteristics
(based on available drill hole quality).
 
In the
absence of laboratory data, estimated by (1)
assuming specific gravity of 1.30 for coal and 2.25
to 2.5 for rock parting, or (2) 1280 kg/m
3
 
to 1324
kg/m
3
 
for a "clean" seam
•
 
Underground-Mineable Criteria
Map Thickness
Total seam thickness
Minimum Seam Thickness
1.2 meters (locally <1.2 m for limited areas
integral to the mine plan)
Minimum Mining Thickness
1.83 meters
Minimum In-Seam Wash Recovery
40 percent
 
Wash Recovery Applied to Coal
Reserves
Based on average yield for drill holes within
reserve area, or in the absence of laboratory
washability data, based on estimated visual
recovery using specific gravities noted above and
95 percent yield on "clean" coal
Out-of-Seam Dilution Thickness for
Run-of-Mine Tonnes Applied to Coal
Reserves
0.05 meters
2243 kg/m³ density used for dilution tonnage estimate
Mine Barrier
61-meter distance from abandoned mines and
sealed or pillared areas.
Adjustments Applied to Coal Reserves
6 percent moisture increase; 5 percent
preparation plant inefficiency
Note: The 6-percent moisture adjustment is
conservative;
 
actual shipped quality from 4thQ of 2021
through 3rdQ of 2023 averaged 8.31 percent (ranging
from 7.95 to 8.62 percent on a quarterly basis).
Note:
 
Exceptions for
 
application of
 
these criteria
 
to resource
 
and reserve
 
estimation are
 
made as
 
warranted
 
and demonstrated
 
by either
 
actual
mining experience or detailed data that allows for empirical evaluation of mining
 
conditions.
 
Final classification of coal reserve is made based
 
on the
pre-feasibility evaluation.
11.1.1
 
Geostatistical Analysis for Classification
MM&A completed a
 
geostatistical analysis on drill
 
holes within
 
the reserve boundaries
 
to determine
the applicability of the common United States classification system for measured and indicated and
inferred coal resources.
 
Historically,
 
the United States has assumed that coal within 0.4 kilometers
of a point of observation represents a measured resource whereas coal between 0.4 kilometer
 
and
1.2
 
kilometers
 
from
 
a
 
point
 
of
 
observation
 
is
 
classified
 
as
 
indicated.
 
Inferred
 
resources
 
are
commonly
 
assumed
 
to
 
be
 
located
 
between
 
1.2
 
kilometers
 
and
 
4.8
 
kilometers
 
from
 
a
 
point
 
of
observation.
 
Per
 
SEC
 
and
 
JORC
 
regulations,
 
only
 
measured
 
and
 
indicated
 
resources
 
may
 
be
considered for reserve classification, respectively
 
as proven and probable reserves.
MM&A
 
performed
 
a
 
geostatistical
 
analysis
 
of
 
the
 
Buchanan data
 
set
 
using the
 
Drill
 
Hole
 
Spacing
Analysis
 
(
DHSA
)
 
method.
 
This
 
method
 
attempts
 
to
 
quantify
 
the
 
uncertainty
 
of
 
applying
 
a
measurement
 
from
 
a
 
central
 
location
 
to
 
increasingly
 
larger
 
square
 
blocks
 
and
 
provides
 
 
ex962p2i0 ex962p38i2 ex962p38i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
30
recommendations
 
for determining
 
the distances
 
between drill
 
holes for
 
measured, indicated,
 
and
inferred resources.
To
 
perform DHSA the data
 
set was processed to remove
 
any erroneous data points,
 
clustered data
points, as
 
well as
 
directional trends.
 
This was
 
achieved through
 
the use
 
of histograms,
 
as seen
 
in
Figure 11-1
, color-coded scatter
 
plots showing the geospatial positioning of
 
the borings,
Figure 11-
2
, and trend analysis.
Figure 11-1:
 
Histogram of the Total
 
Seam
Thickness for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam
Present in the Buchanan Mine Complex
Figure 11-2:
 
Scatter plot of the Total
 
Seam
Thickness for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam
Present in the Buchanan Mine Complex
Following the completion of
 
data processing, a variogram
 
of the data set was
 
created,
Figure 11-3
.
 
The
 
variogram
 
plots average
 
square difference
 
against
 
the separation
 
distance
 
between
 
the data
pairs.
 
The
 
separation
 
distance
 
is broken
 
up into
 
separate
 
bins defined
 
by a
 
uniform
 
lag distance
(e.g., for
 
a lag
 
distance of
 
152 meters
 
the bins
 
would be
 
0 –
 
152 meters,
 
153 –
 
305 meters,
 
etc.).
 
Each pair of data points that are less than one lag distance apart are reported in the first bin.
 
If the
data
 
pair
 
is
 
further
 
apart
 
than
 
one
 
lag
 
distance
 
but
 
less
 
than
 
two
 
lag
 
distances
 
apart,
 
then
 
the
variance is reported in the second bin.
 
The numerical average for differences
 
reported for each bin
is then plotted on the variogram.
 
Care was taken to
 
define the lag distance in such a way
 
as to not
overestimate any nugget effect
 
present in the data set.
 
Lastly, modeled equations, often spherical,
gaussian, or
 
exponential, are
 
applied to
 
the variogram
 
in order
 
to represent
 
the data
 
set across
 
a
continuous spectrum.
 
 
ex962p2i0 ex962p39i2 ex962p39i1
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
31
Figure 11-3: Variogram of
 
the Total
 
Seam Thickness for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam
 
Present in the Buchanan Mine Complex
The estimation
 
variance is
 
then calculated
 
using information
 
from the
 
modeled variogram
 
as well
as
 
charts
 
published
 
by
 
Journel
 
and
 
Huijbregts
 
(1978).
 
This
 
value
 
estimates
 
the
 
variance
 
from
applying
 
a
 
single
 
central
 
measurement
 
to
 
increasingly
 
larger
 
square
 
blocks.
 
Care
 
was
 
taken
 
to
ensure any nugget effect present was added back
 
into the data.
 
This process was repeated for each
test block size.
The final step of the process is to calculate the global estimation variance.
 
In this step, the number
of square blocks that would fit inside the selected study area is determined for
 
each block size that
was
 
investigated
 
in the
 
previous
 
step.
 
The estimation
 
variance
 
is then
 
divided by
 
the number
 
of
blocks that
 
would fit
 
inside the
 
study area
 
for
 
each test
 
block size.
 
Following this
 
determination,
the data is then transformed back to represent
 
the relative error in the 95th-percentile range.
Figure 11-4
shows the
 
results of
 
the DHSA
 
performed on
 
the Pocahontas
 
No. 3
 
seam data
 
for the
Buchanan Mine.
 
DHSA provides hole to hole
 
spacing values; these distances need to
 
be converted
to radius
 
from a
 
central point
 
in order
 
to compare
 
to the
 
historical
 
standards.
 
A summary
 
of the
radius
 
data
 
is shown
 
in
Table
 
11-2
.
 
DHSA
 
prescribes
 
that
 
measured,
 
indicated,
 
and inferred
 
drill
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex962p40i2 ex962p40i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
32
hole spacing be
 
determined at
 
the 10-percent,
 
20-percent, and
 
50-percent levels
 
of relative
 
error,
respectively.
Figure 11-4: Result of DHSA for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam Present in the Buchanan Mine
Complex
Table 11-2:
 
DHSA Results Summary for Radius from a Central Point
Model:
Measured Radial Distance
(10% Relative Error)
Indicated Radial Distance
(20% Relative Error)
Inferred Radial Distance
(50% Relative Error)
(km)
(km)
(km)
Gaussian:
0.71
1.10
2.76
Spherical:
0.71
1.08
2.67
Exponential:
0.67
1.08
3.08
Comparing
 
the
 
results
 
of
 
the
 
DHSA
 
to
 
the
 
historical
 
standards,
 
it
 
is
 
evident
 
that
 
the
 
historical
standards
 
are
 
more
 
conservative
 
than
 
even
 
the
 
most
 
conservative
 
DHSA
 
model
 
with
 
regards
 
to
determining
 
measured
 
resources.
 
The
 
Exponential
 
model
 
recommends
 
using
 
a
 
radius
 
of
 
0.67
kilometers for measured resources compared to the
 
historical value of 0.4
 
kilometers.
 
With respect
to indicated resources,
 
the DHSA falls in
 
line closely with the historical
 
standards.
 
The Exponential
and
 
Spherical
 
models
 
recommend
 
using
 
a
 
radius
 
of
 
1.08
 
kilometers,
 
while
 
the
 
Gaussian
 
model
recommends a
 
radius of
 
1.10 kilometers.
 
These values line
 
up closely with
 
the historical
 
radius of
1.2
 
kilometers.
 
These
 
results
 
have
 
led
 
the
 
QPs
 
to
 
report
 
the
 
data
 
following
 
the
 
historical
classification standards, rather
 
than use the results of the DHSA.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
33
11.2
 
Qualified Person’s
 
Estimates
Mineral
 
resources,
 
representing
 
in-situ
 
coal
 
from
 
a
 
portion
 
of
 
which
 
reserves
 
are
 
derived,
 
are
presented below.
 
Based on the work described and detailed modelling of the areas
 
considering all
the parameters
 
defined, a
 
coal resource
 
estimate,
 
summarized
 
in
Table
 
11-3
, was
 
prepared
 
as of
December 31, 2023, for property controlled by Coronado.
Table 11-3:
 
Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2023
 
Coal Resource (Dry Tonnes, In Situ, Mt)
Resource Quality (Dry)
Area
Measured
Indicated
Inferred
Total
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Inclusive of Reserves
158.9
9.2
0.0
168.1
16
0.8
18
Exclusive of Reserves
30.7
4.3
0.0
34.9
Total 12/31/2023
189.6
13.4
0.0
203.0
 
Note:
 
Resource tonnes are inclusive of reserve tonnes since they include the in-situ tonnes from which recoverable coal reserves are derived.
Note 2:
 
Coal resources are reported on a dry basis.
 
Surface moisture and inherent moisture are excluded.
Note 3: The Property contains 34.9
 
Mt of dry, in-place measured and indicated coal resources exclusive of reserves as of December 31, 2023.
11.3
 
Resources Exclusive of Reserves
The Property contains multiple resource blocks which
 
were not deemed to
 
exhibit reserve potential
at the time of the
 
study.
 
These resources, formally identified as resources exclusive of reserves, are
located in the Pocahontas
 
No. 3 coal seam.
 
Reasons which may preclude elevation
 
of resources to
reserves include, but are not limited to:
1.
 
Insufficient density of drilling and/or coal quality data available
 
at the time of this evaluation.
2.
 
Unfavorable
 
economics at
 
the PFS
 
level, yet
 
economics could
 
become attractive
 
in the
 
future
under different market
 
conditions.
 
3.
 
Exclusion
 
from LOM
 
planning by
 
mining operator
 
due to
 
remaining resource
 
blocks which
 
are
relatively
 
small,
 
isolated
 
blocks
 
and
 
not
 
currently
 
attractive
 
from
 
an
 
operational
 
perspective.
 
Multiple resource blocks in the active Buchanan Mine have not been considered as reserve due
to relatively small size and isolation.
11.3.1
 
Initial Economic Assessment
MM&A completed an initial economic assessment to
 
determine the potential economic viability of
resources exclusive of reserves.
 
Unlike the economic analysis presented in
Section 19
 
developed to
test
 
reserves,
 
the initial
 
economic
 
assessment
 
below is
 
presented
 
on a
 
real basis
 
in 2023
 
dollars.
 
MM&A
 
applied
 
relevant
 
technical
 
factors
 
to
 
estimate
 
potential
 
saleable
 
tonnes
 
without
 
the
resource blocks, should
 
the resources be
 
extracted via deep,
 
continuous mining methods
 
(given that
their irregular and isolated nature
may
 
preclude longwall mining).
 
MM&A
 
developed
 
cash
 
cost
 
profiles
 
for
 
the
 
resource
 
blocks,
 
including
 
direct
 
cash
 
costs
 
(labor,
supplies,
 
roof
 
control,
 
maintenance
 
and
 
repair,
 
power,
 
and
 
other);
 
washing,
 
trucking,
 
materials
handling, general
 
and administrative,
 
and environmental
 
costs;
 
and indirect
 
cash
 
costs
 
(royalties,
production
 
taxes,
 
property tax,
 
insurance).
 
Costs were
 
developed based
 
off
 
relevant
 
cost
 
drivers
(per-meter,
 
per-raw-tonne,
 
per-clean-tonne).
 
Additionally,
 
MM&A
 
estimated
 
capital
 
costs
 
to
extract
 
resources.
 
Capital
 
costs
 
associated
 
with
 
mine
 
development
 
were
 
amortized
 
across
 
the
resource’s
 
potential saleable tonnages.
 
Additional non-cash items (depreciation of equipment and
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex962p42i2 ex962p42i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
34
depletion) and cash
 
costs were compared to
 
an assumed sale
 
price of
 
$143 per
 
tonne (FOB loadout),
representing the long-term average
 
price forecast for Buchanan supplied by Coronado.
 
The results
of the analysis are shown
 
below and demonstrate potential profitability on a fully
 
loaded cost basis.
 
Detailed summaries are shown in
Appendix D
.
 
Table
 
11-4:
 
Results of Initial Economic Assessment
Seam
Direct Cash
Transportation,
Washing, Enviro,
G&A
Indirect
Non-Cash
Total Cost
Fully Loaded
P&L
P3
 
$61.76
 
 
$16.84
 
 
$9.39
 
 
$19.29
 
 
$107.28
 
 
$36.03
 
Figure 11-5:
 
Results of Initial Economic Assessment
11.4
 
Qualified Person’s
 
Opinion
While there is
 
some level of stratigraphically
 
controlled seam-thickness
 
variability,
 
the Pocahontas
No.
 
3
 
coal
 
seam
 
at
 
Buchanan
 
demonstrates
 
reasonable
 
thickness
 
consistency
 
according
 
to
 
the
classification system of
measured
 
(0 – 0.4 kilometer),
indicated
 
(0.4 to 1.2
 
kilometers), and
inferred
(1.2
 
to
 
4.8
 
kilometers).
 
MM&A
 
geologists
 
and
 
engineers
 
modeled
 
the
 
deposit
 
and
 
delineated
mineable
 
regions
 
to
 
reflect
 
the
 
nature
 
of
 
each
 
seam
 
and
 
the
 
practicality
 
of
 
mining
 
constraints.
 
Based on MM&A’s
 
geostatistical analysis, it would be possible to
 
extend the measured arcs slightly
beyond historically accepted practices due to consistent
 
geological settings.
 
These results have led
the
 
QPs
 
to
 
report
 
the
 
data
 
following
 
the
 
historical
 
classification
 
standards,
 
rather
 
than
 
use
 
the
results of the DHSA.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
35
Based on the data
 
review,
 
the attendant work
 
done to verify the data
 
integrity and the creation
 
of
an
 
independent
 
geologic model,
 
the
 
QPs
 
believe
 
this
 
is a
 
fair
 
and
 
accurate
 
representation
 
of the
Buchanan coal resources.
 
Moreover,
 
the QPs opine that
 
additional exploration, mine
 
planning and
financial
 
analysis
 
could
 
result
 
in
 
conversion
 
of
 
additional
 
resources
 
to
 
reserves
 
in
 
the
 
future;
however,
 
there is no guarantee
 
that such will be the case
 
until such time as that additional
 
work is
completed.
12
 
Mineral Reserve Estimates
12.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
Coal Reserves are classified as
proven
 
or
probable
 
considering “modifying factors” including mining,
metallurgical, economic, marketing, legal,
 
environmental, social, and governmental
 
factors.
 
>
Proven Coal Reserves
 
are the economically mineable part
 
of a measured coal resource, adjusted
for
 
diluting
 
materials
 
and
 
allowances
 
for
 
losses
 
when
 
the
 
material
 
is
 
mined.
 
It
 
is
 
based
 
on
appropriate
 
assessment
 
and
 
studies
 
in
 
consideration
 
of
 
and
 
adjusted
 
for
 
reasonably
 
assumed
modifying factors.
 
These assessments demonstrate that extraction could be reasonably justified
at the time of reporting.
 
>
Probable Coal Reserves
 
are the economically mineable part
 
of an indicated coal resource, and in
some
 
circumstances
 
a measured
 
coal
 
resource,
 
adjusted
 
for
 
diluting
 
materials
 
and allowances
for
 
losses
 
when
 
the
 
material
 
is
 
mined.
 
It
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
appropriate
 
assessment
 
and
 
studies
 
in
consideration
 
of
 
and
 
adjusted
 
for
 
reasonably
 
assumed
 
modifying
 
factors.
 
These
 
assessments
demonstrate that extraction
 
could be reasonably justified at the time of reporting.
 
Upon completion of delineation
 
and calculation of coal
 
resources, MM&A generated a LOM plan
 
for
Buchanan.
 
The footprint
 
of the
 
reserve area
 
is shown
 
on the
 
map in
Appendix B
.
 
The Mine
 
plan
was
 
generated
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
forecast
 
mine
 
plan
 
and
 
permit
 
plan
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
with
modifications by
 
MM&A where
 
necessary due
 
to current
 
property control
 
limits, modifications
 
to
geologic mapping, or other factors determined during the evaluation.
Carlson
 
Mining
 
software
 
was
 
used
 
to
 
generate
 
the
 
LOM
 
plan
 
for
 
Buchanan.
 
The
 
mine
 
plan
 
was
sequenced based on productivity schedules provided by
 
Coronado.
 
MM&A judged the productivity
estimates and plans to be reasonable based on experience and current industry practice.
At the Buchanan No. 1
 
Mine, a minimum mining
 
height of 1.83 meters was used
 
due to the longwall
mining
 
method
 
being
 
employed.
 
For
 
coal
 
seams
 
thinner
 
than
 
the
 
assigned
 
mining
 
height,
 
the
difference
 
between
 
the
 
coal
 
seam
 
height
 
and
 
assigned
 
mining
 
height
 
consists
 
of
 
out-of-seam
dilution (
OSD
).
 
Mine recovery
 
generally varies
 
between 40
 
and 60
 
percent for
 
continuous mining
panels,
 
and 100
 
percent
 
for
 
longwall.
 
Plant
 
recovery
 
is a
 
function
 
of in-seam
 
recovery,
 
OSD and
plant efficiency factor, which is set at 95 percent.
 
Typical entry width is 5.49 meters to 6.10 meters.
Raw,
 
ROM
 
production
 
data
 
outputs
 
from
 
LOM
 
plan
 
sequencing
 
were
 
processed
 
into
 
Microsoft
®
EXCEL spreadsheets
 
and summarized
 
on an
 
annual basis
 
for processing
 
into the
 
economic model.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
36
Average seam densities were
 
estimated to determine raw
 
coal tonnes produced
 
from the LOM
 
plan.
 
Average mine recovery
 
and wash recovery factors were
 
applied to determine coal reserve tonnes.
 
Coal reserve
 
tonnes in
 
this evaluation
 
are reported
 
at a
 
6.0-percent moisture
 
basis and
 
represent
the saleable product from the Property.
Pricing
 
data
 
as
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
is
 
described
 
in
Section
 
16.2
.
 
The
 
pricing
 
data
 
assumes
 
a
weighted
 
average
 
domestic
 
and
 
international
 
FOB-mine
 
price
 
of
 
approximately
 
$172
 
per
 
metric
tonne for calendar
 
year 2024.
 
The weighted average price
 
decreases to approximately $138
 
to $145
per metric
 
tonne through
 
year 2028
 
and averages
 
approximately
 
$173 per
 
metric tonne
 
over the
LOM.
The coal resource
 
mapping and estimation
 
process described in
 
this report was
 
used as a basis
 
for
the coal reserve
 
estimate.
 
Proven and
 
probable coal
 
reserves were
 
derived from
 
the defined coal
resource
 
considering
 
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
technical
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
revenue, and cost), marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors and are
presented on a moist, recoverable
 
basis.
As is
 
customary in
 
the US,
 
the categories
 
for proven
 
and probable
 
coal reserves
 
are based
 
on the
distances
 
from
 
valid
 
points
 
of
 
measurement
 
as
 
determined
 
by
 
the
 
QPs
 
for
 
the
 
area
 
under
consideration.
 
For this
 
evaluation, measured
 
resource, which
 
may convert
 
to a
 
proven reserve,
 
is
based on a 0.4-kilometer radius from a valid point of observation.
Points
 
of observation
 
include exploration
 
drill holes,
 
degas holes,
 
and mine
 
measurements which
have been fully vetted
 
and processed into a
 
geologic model.
 
The geologic model is based on seam
depositional modeling, the
 
interrelationship of overlying and
 
underlying strata on seam mineability,
seam thickness trends,
 
the impact of seam
 
structure (i.e., faulting),
 
intra-seam characteristics,
 
etc.
 
Once
 
the
 
geologic
 
model
 
was
 
completed,
 
a
 
statistical
 
analysis,
 
described
 
in
Section
 
11.1.1
 
was
conducted
 
and
 
a
 
0.4-kilometer
 
radius
 
from
 
a
 
valid
 
point
 
of
 
observation
 
was
 
selected
 
to
 
define
Measured Resources.
 
Likewise,
 
the distance
 
between 0.4
 
and 1.2 of
 
a kilometer
 
radius was
 
selected to
 
define Indicated
Resources.
 
Indicated Resources may convert
 
to Probable Reserves.
 
There
 
are
 
no
 
Inferred
 
Resources
 
(greater
 
than
 
a
 
1.2-kilometer
 
radius
 
from
 
a
 
valid
 
point
 
of
observation) at Buchanan.
12.2
 
Qualified Person’s
 
Estimates
Reserve tonnage
 
estimates provided
 
herein report
 
coal reserves
 
derived from
 
the in-situ resource
tonnes presented in
Table 11-3
, and not in addition to coal resources.
 
Coal reserves are presented
on a
 
ROM basis
 
in
Table
 
12-1
.
 
Proven
 
and probable
 
coal reserves
 
were derived
 
from the
 
defined
coal
 
resource
 
considering
 
relevant
 
mining,
 
processing,
 
infrastructure,
 
economic
 
(including
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue,
 
and
 
cost),
 
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
 
socioeconomic
 
and
regulatory factors.
 
The coal reserves,
 
as shown in
Table
 
12-2
, are based
 
on a technical
 
evaluation
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
37
of the geology and a preliminary feasibility study of the coal deposits.
 
The extent to which the coal
reserves
 
may
 
be
 
affected
 
by
 
any
 
known
 
environmental,
 
permitting,
 
legal,
 
title,
 
socioeconomic,
marketing, political, or other relevant
 
issues has been reviewed rigorously.
 
Similarly,
 
the extent to
which
 
the
 
estimates
 
of
 
coal
 
reserves
 
may
 
be
 
materially
 
affected
 
by
 
mining,
 
metallurgical,
infrastructure and other relevant
 
factors has also been considered.
 
Table 12-1:
 
Coal ROM (Moist) Summary as of December 31, 2023
 
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Mt, Moist ROM)
Quality (Dry)
 
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area /
Mine
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Subleased
Ash
Sulfur
Vol
Buchanan
145.9
8.5
154.4
0.0
154.4
20.2
125.8
8.4
43
0.7
12
Table 12-2:
 
Coal Reserves Summary (Marketable Sales Basis) as of December 31, 2023
 
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet Ton
 
nes, Washed or Direct Shipped, Mt)
Quality (Dry Basis)
 
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area / Mine
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Subleased
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Buchanan Mine Complex
87.1
5.0
92.1
0.0
92.1
13.6
73.8
4.8
6
0.7
20
Note: Marketable
 
reserve tonnes
 
are reported
 
on a
 
moist basis,
 
including a
 
combination of
 
surface and
 
inherent moisture.
 
The
combination of surface and inherent moisture is
 
modeled 6-percent.
 
Actual product moisture is dependent upon
 
multiple geological
factors, operational
 
factors, and
 
product contract
specifications and can
 
exceed 8-percent.
 
As such, the
 
modeled moisture values
 
provide a
level of conservatism for reserve reporting.
As shown below,
 
coal shipments during 2023 (primarily from the northern portion of the Property)
exhibit a year-to-date
 
average quality comparable
 
to quality projected
 
from core samples (refer
 
to
Table 12-2
 
above).
 
>
Moisture content: 8.5%
>
Ash content: 5.9% (db)
>
Sulfur content: 0.7% (db)
>
VM content: 17% (db)
The
 
results
 
of
 
this
 
TRS
 
define
 
an
 
estimated
 
92.1
 
Mt
 
of
 
proven
 
and
 
probable
 
marketable
 
coal
reserves.
 
Of that
 
total, 95
 
percent are
 
proven, and
 
5 percent
 
are probable.
 
There are
 
13.6 Mt
 
of
owned coal reserves and 73.8 Mt
 
of leased coal and 4.8
 
Mt of subleased reserves.
 
All the Buchanan
reserves are considered suitable for the metallurgical
 
coal market, and all are assigned.
12.3
 
Qualified Person’s
 
Opinion
The
 
estimate
 
of coal
 
reserves was
 
determined
 
in accordance
 
with the
 
JORC
 
Code along
 
with SEC
Regulation S-K 1300.
The
 
LOM
 
mining
 
plan
 
for
 
Buchanan
 
was
 
prepared
 
to
 
the
 
level
 
of
 
preliminary
 
feasibility.
 
Mine
projections
 
were
 
prepared
 
with
 
a
 
timing
 
schedule
 
to
 
match
 
production
 
with
 
coal
 
seam
characteristics.
 
Production timing
 
was carried
 
out from
 
current locations
 
to depletion
 
of the
 
coal
reserve
 
area.
 
Coal reserve
 
estimates
 
could be
 
materially
 
affected
 
by the
 
risk factors
 
described in
Section 22.2
.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
38
Based on the preliminary feasibility study and the attendant economic review,
 
the QPs believe this
is a fair and accurate calculation of the Buchanan coal reserves.
13
 
Mining Methods
13.1
 
Geotech and Hydrology
Mining
 
plans
 
for
 
potential
 
underground
 
mines
 
were
 
developed
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
MM&A.
 
Pillar
stability
 
was
 
tested
 
by
 
MM&A
 
using
 
the
Analysis
 
of
 
Coal
 
Pillar
 
Stability
 
(ACPS)
 
and
Analysis
 
of
Longwall
 
Pillar
 
Stability
(
ALPS
)
 
programs
 
that
 
were
 
developed
 
by
 
the
National
 
Institute
 
for
Occupational
 
Safety
 
and
 
Health
 
(
NIOSH
)
.
 
MM&A
 
reviewed
 
the
 
results
 
from
 
the
 
ACPS
 
and
 
ALPS
analysis and considered them in the development of the LOM plan.
Hydrology has not been an issue
 
of concern at Buchanan.
 
Based on numerous site visits
 
to both the
surface and
 
underground portions
 
of the
 
Property by
 
the QPs,
 
it has
 
been determined
 
that this
 
is
not
 
a
 
significant
 
concern.
 
Mining
 
of
 
future
 
reserves
 
is
 
projected
 
to
 
occur
 
in
 
areas
 
which
 
exhibit
similar hydrogeological characteristics
 
as those formerly mined areas.
13.2
 
Production Rates
The
 
Buchanan
 
mine
 
has
 
historically
 
included
 
six
 
continuous
 
mining
 
sections
 
and
 
one
 
longwall
section.
 
This
 
report
 
includes
 
the
 
expansion
 
program
 
that
 
is expected
 
to
 
increase
 
the
 
number of
continuous
 
miner sections
 
to eight
 
by calendar
 
year
 
2029 and
 
add a
 
second longwall
 
mining unit
during
 
the first
 
quarter
 
of
 
2025.
 
Operations
 
at
 
Buchanan
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
its predecessor
 
have
been
 
ongoing
 
for
 
many
 
years.
 
The
 
mine
 
plan
 
and
 
productivity
 
expectations
 
reflect
 
historical
performance and efforts have
 
been made to adjust the plan to reflect
 
future conditions.
 
MM&A is
confident that the mine plan is reasonably representative to provide an accurate estimation
 
of coal
reserves.
 
Mine development and operation have not been optimized
 
within the TRS.
Longwall production
 
is scheduled
 
for
 
approximately
 
295 to
 
312 days
 
each year,
 
which represents
production on Monday
 
through Saturday with
 
allowances for holidays
 
and longwall
 
moves.
 
On each
day,
 
the
 
continuous
 
mining
 
sections
 
and
 
longwall
 
produce
 
coal
 
on
 
three
 
shifts.
 
The
 
sections
 
are
configured
 
as
 
regular
 
sections
 
with
 
one
 
continuous
 
miner
 
available
 
for
 
production
 
on
 
each
section.
 
Productivity is
 
planned at
 
the rate
 
of 18.8
 
meters
 
to 20.7
 
meters
 
of advance
 
per shift
 
of
operation for
 
the continuous
 
miner sections, and
 
4.42 meters
 
to 7.32
 
meters per
 
shift of longwall
retreat.
 
A second longwall is scheduled to begin production in the first quarter of 2025.
Carlson Mining software was used
 
by MM&A to generate mine plans
 
for the underground mineable
coal seam.
 
Coronado recently revised the Buchanan
 
mine plan with an independent headgate and
tailgate
 
for
 
longwall
 
panels
 
in
 
the
 
South,
 
West,
 
Northeast
 
and
 
Northern-most
 
districts.
 
Such
 
a
change was made to allow
 
for an effective panel width of 982
 
feet, as opposed to an effective width
of 688 feet
 
used previously.
 
The active area
 
in the North
 
is still based on an
 
effective panel width
of
 
approximately
 
688
 
feet.
 
MM&A
 
incorporated
 
this
 
mine
 
plan
 
revision
 
into
 
the
 
layout
 
and
subsequent reserve estimates contained herein.
 
Mine plans were sequenced
 
based on productivity
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
39
schedules provided by Coronado, which were based on historically achieved productivity levels.
 
All
production
 
forecasting
 
ties
 
assumed
 
production
 
rates
 
to
 
geological
 
models
 
as
 
constructed
 
by
MM&A’s
 
team of geologists and mining engineers.
As shown in
Table
 
13-1
, the areas planned for underground
 
production continue until
 
2042.
 
Clean
coal production varies directly with coal thickness.
Table 13-1:
 
Summary of Production by Year (Tonnes
 
x 1,000)
Mine Name
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
2031
Buchanan
3,738
4,186
4,249
4,980
5,210
5,728
5,545
5,781
 
Mine Name
2032
2033
2034
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
Buchanan
5,882
5,935
5,268
5,590
5,378
4,984
5,236
5,589
 
Mine Name
2040
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
2046
2047
Buchanan
4,183
3,390
1,285
0
0
0
0
0
13.3
 
Mining Related Requirements
Although the continuous miner
 
sections are significantly more
 
expensive to operate
 
on a cost-per-
tonne basis,
 
they are
 
necessary to open
 
up areas
 
of the mine
 
for the
 
longwall.
 
At the
 
time of this
study, Buchanan had 6 operating continuous miner stations that were used to develop main
 
entries
and gate
 
roads in
 
preparation
 
for the
 
longwall.
 
As the mine
 
develops, this
 
number will
 
be able to
be reduced.
An additional
 
requirement at
 
Buchanan is the
 
drilling of degas
 
holes prior to
 
mining.
 
This process
was initially developed
 
as a
 
safety measure to extract
 
methane from the
 
coal seam
 
prior to
 
exposure
to the workforce.
 
As such, it has been very effective.
More
 
recently,
 
the
 
methane
 
extracted
 
has
 
been
 
able
 
to
 
be
 
processed
 
and
 
sold.
 
However,
degasifying of the coal seam will continue as a safety measure regardless.
13.4
 
Required Equipment and Personnel
The Buchanan
 
Mine is
 
currently Coronado’s only longwall
 
operation.
 
The longwall
 
shearing machine
is used for extraction
 
of coal at the production face.
 
A chain conveyor is used
 
to remove coal from
the
 
longwall
 
face
 
for
 
discharge
 
onto
 
the
 
conveyor
 
belt
 
which
 
then
 
ultimately
 
delivers
 
it
 
to
 
an
underground storage
 
bunker.
 
Development for the longwall
 
is conducted by the extraction
 
of coal
from
 
the
 
production
 
faces
 
using
 
continuous
 
miners
 
and
 
haulage
 
using
 
shuttle
 
cars
 
to
 
a
 
feeder-
breaker located at the tail
 
of the section conveyor belt.
 
The feeder-breaker crushes large pieces of
coal and rock
 
and regulates
 
coal feed
 
onto the mine
 
conveyor.
 
Roof-bolting machines are
 
used to
support the
 
roof on
 
the developm
 
ent
 
sections of
 
the
 
longwall mines.
 
Roof-bolting
 
machines are
used to
 
install
 
roof bolts,
 
and battery
 
scoops are
 
available
 
to clean
 
the mine
 
entries and
 
assist in
delivery of mine supplies to
 
work areas.
 
Other supplemental equipment such as
 
personnel carriers,
supply vehicles, etc., are also used daily.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
40
Mine
 
conveyors
 
typically
 
range
 
in
 
width
 
up to
 
1.83
 
meters.
 
Multiple
 
belt
 
flights
 
are
 
arranged
 
in
series to
 
deliver raw
 
coal to
 
the underground
 
storage.
 
Along the
 
main and
 
sub-main entries
 
and
panels, a
 
travel
 
way is
 
provided for
 
personnel and
 
materials by
 
rubber-tired equipment
 
or on rail.
 
The Buchanan No. 1 Mine
 
utilizes a skip hoist in order to transport ROM coal from the
 
underground
storage
 
bunker
 
to
 
the
 
surface
 
where
 
the
 
coal
 
may
 
be
 
sampled,
 
crushed
 
and
 
washed
 
in
 
the
preparation plant and stockpiled to
 
await shipment.
 
Surface
 
ventilation
 
fans
 
are
 
installed
 
as
 
needed
 
to
 
provide
 
a
 
sufficient
 
volume
 
of
 
air
 
to
 
ventilate
production sections, coal
 
haulage and transport
 
entries, battery charging stations, and
 
transformers
in accordance with approved plans.
 
High-voltage cables deliver power throughout the mine where
transformers reduce voltage for specific equipment
 
requirements.
 
The Mine
 
Improvement and New
Emergency Response Act of 2006
 
(
MINER Act
) requires that carbon monoxide detection systems be
installed
 
along
 
mine
 
conveyor
 
belts
 
and
 
that
 
electronic
 
two-way
 
tracking
 
and
 
communications
systems
 
be
 
installed
 
throughout
 
underground
 
mines.
 
Water
 
is
 
required
 
to
 
control
 
dust
 
at
production sections and along conveyor
 
belts, and to cool electric motors.
 
Water is available
 
from
nearby sources and is distributed within
 
the mine by pipelines
 
as required.
 
A total of 636 salary
 
and
hourly employees are assigned to the mine in 2024, and a total of 717 salary and hourly employees
are
 
assigned
 
to
 
the
 
mine
 
beginning
 
in
 
2029
 
when
 
2
 
longwall
 
sections
 
and
 
8
 
continuous
 
miner
sections
 
are
 
projected
 
to
 
be
 
in
 
operation.
 
The
 
aforementioned
 
staffing
 
levels
 
only
 
represent
employees
 
assigned
 
to
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
Mine.
 
Labor
 
associated
 
with
 
coal
 
processing,
 
water
treatment, as well as general & administrative activities are modeled on
 
a cost-per-ton basis for the
economic analysis in
Section 19
.
 
14
 
Processing and Recovery Methods
14.1
 
Description or Flowsheet
Coronado currently
 
operates a
 
coal preparation
 
plant at
 
Buchanan.
 
The Buchanan Plant
 
operates
at
 
a feed
 
rate
 
of approximately
 
1,270 raw
 
tonnes per
 
hour (
tph
).
 
Coarse
 
material
 
is washed
 
in a
heavy medium vessel, the intermediate-size material is washed in heavy medium cyclones and fine
material is
 
washed using
 
froth flotation.
 
These processes
 
are supported
 
by the
 
requisite screens,
centrifuges, vacuum filters, sumps, pumps, and distribution systems.
 
Processes and equipment are
typical of those
 
used in
 
the coal industry
 
and are in
 
use in
 
nearly all plants
 
in the
 
Central Appalachian
Basin.
 
14.2
 
Requirements for Energy,
 
Water,
 
Material and Personnel
Personnel have historically been sourced from
 
the surrounding communities
 
in Buchanan, Tazewell,
McDowell, and Pike Counties, and have proven to be adequate in numbers to operate the mine.
 
As
mining
 
is
 
common
 
in
 
the
 
surrounding
 
areas,
 
the
 
workforce
 
is
 
generally
 
familiar
 
with
 
mining
practices, and many are experienced miners.
The
 
Buchanan No.
 
1 Mine
 
Complex
 
has
 
sources
 
of water,
 
power,
 
personnel,
 
and
 
supplies readily
available for use.
 
Water is sourced locally from a nearby abandoned underground mine.
 
Electricity
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
ex962p49i2 ex962p49i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
41
is sourced from
 
AEP.
 
The service
 
industry in
 
the areas surrounding
 
the mine
 
complex has historically
provided supplies, equipment repairs and fabrication, etc.
15
 
Infrastructure
The Coronado-owned
 
Buchanan Preparation
 
Plant services the
 
mine via a
 
skip hoist
 
and conveyor
belt
 
system
 
which
 
transports
 
extracted
 
coal
 
from
 
an
 
underground
 
bunker
 
to
 
the
 
surface
 
facility.
 
The NS rail line serves as the main means of transport from the mine.
As an active operation, the necessary support
 
infrastructure for Buchanan is in place.
 
In addition to
the
 
plant
 
and
 
loadout,
 
there
 
are
 
also
 
portal
 
facilities,
 
including
 
personnel
 
access
 
to
 
the
 
mine,
ventilation fans and a coal hoisting skip shaft.
 
A map of the existing facilities in
Figure 15-1
.
Figure 15-1:
 
Buchanan Surface Facilities
16
 
Market Studies
16.1
 
Market Description
The quality
 
characteristics for
 
the subject
 
coal resources
 
and coal
 
reserves have
 
been reviewed
 
in
detail
 
by MM&A.
 
The drill
 
hole data
 
were
 
utilized to
 
develop
 
average
 
coal quality
 
characteristics
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
42
for
 
the mining
 
site.
 
These average
 
coal
 
quality characteristics
 
were
 
then utilized
 
as the
 
basis for
determining the various markets into which the saleable coal will likely
 
be placed.
 
The projected quality specifications for the Buchanan products are as shown in
Table 16-1
.
Table 16-1:
 
Quality Specifications by Product
 
Buchanan
 
HCC
PCI
Moisture (%)
7.50
7.50
Ash (%)
5.50
6.00
Sulfur (%)
0.75
0.85
Volatile Matter (%)
18.00
18.00
Btu/lb.
N/A
14,926
Fluidity (ddpm)
130
N/A
MMR (%)
1.69
N/A
CSR
40
N/A
FSI
8.5
N/A
Note:
 
All Specs are dry basis except Moisture and Thermal
All the mine production
 
serves the metallurgical
 
markets.
 
Metallurgical coal
 
is marketed
 
as a low-
volatile (typically less than 23 percent volatile matter
 
content) product.
16.2
 
Price Forecasts
Coronado provided
 
MM&A with
 
price forecasts
 
for the
 
Buchanan operation
 
in terms
 
of real
 
2024
(January) real dollars.
1
 
MM&A applied a 2% annual inflation rate
 
to the Coronado price forecast
 
in
order
 
to
 
estimate
 
revenues
 
in
 
nominal
 
dollars.
 
Customer
 
coal
 
pricing
 
is
 
derived
 
from
 
market
observed forward estimates based on global
 
economic supply and
 
demand analysis which is
 
applied
to
 
mine
 
plan
 
sales
 
volumes
 
and
 
product
 
mix
 
and
 
is
 
supplemented
 
with
 
Coronado’s
 
in-house
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
 
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
 
charges.
 
Concurrent
 
with
 
the
 
active
 
operation,
 
Buchanan’s
 
production
 
is
 
assumed
 
to
 
enter
 
domestic
 
and
international
 
low volatile
 
coking coal
 
markets.
 
Pricing provided
 
by Coronado
 
assumes applicable
quality adjustments.
 
Pricing was provided through calendar year 2042.
 
Coal price forecasts for the Buchanan products were
 
provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US nominal dollars per metric tonne.
 
16.3
 
Contract Requirements
Some contracts are
 
necessary for successful marketing
 
of the coal.
 
For Buchanan, since all mining,
preparation and marketing is done in-house, the remaining
 
contracts required are:
>
Transportation
 
–
 
The
 
Mine
 
contracts
 
with
 
NS
 
to
 
transport
 
the
 
coal
 
to
 
either
 
the
 
domestic
customers or to the Pier 6 export terminal for
 
overseas shipment.
1
 
The Coronado pricing forecast
 
was provided to MM&A in real 2024 (January) dollars
 
based on Coronado’s
 
internal
budget sales pricing for the first
 
5 years of the forecast.
 
Beyond the first 5 years,
 
Coronado’s forecast
 
is based on
sales price information from AME Group
 
adjusted for transportation
 
costs to an FOB Mine basis.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
43
>
Handling
 
–
 
Contracts
 
for
 
loading
 
vessels
 
for
 
export
 
sales
 
are
 
necessary.
 
These
 
are
 
typically
handled by annual negotiations based on projected shipments.
>
Sales
– Sales
 
contracts
 
are a
 
mix of
 
spot and
 
contract
 
sales.
 
With the
 
volatility
 
of the
 
market,
long-term contracts are not typically written.
17
 
Environmental Studies, Permitting
 
and Plans,
Negotiations or Agreements with Local Individuals
 
17.1
 
Results of Studies
MM&A completed
 
a Limited Phase
 
I Environmental
 
Site Assessment (
ESA
) on the
 
Property in April
2016 on behalf
 
of Coronado.
 
Coronado reports not having
 
conducted such a study
 
since the MM&A
study.
 
The
 
ESA
 
completed
 
by
 
MM&A
 
included
 
a
 
site
 
inspection,
 
review
 
of
 
historical
 
records,
 
a
database
 
search
 
of
 
state
 
and
 
federal
 
regulatory
 
records
 
and
 
interviews
 
to
 
identify
 
potential
recognized
 
environmental
 
conditions
 
(
RECs
) that
 
may
 
create
 
environmental
 
liability
 
for
 
the
 
sites.
 
MM&A concluded that no long-term liabilities existed at the time of the ESA.
Based on the former ESA completed by MM&A, it is the
 
QPs’ opinion that Buchanan generally has a
record
 
consistent
 
with
 
industry
 
standards
 
regarding
 
compliance
 
with
 
applicable
 
mining,
 
water
quality,
 
and
 
environmental
 
laws.
 
Estimated
 
costs
 
for
 
mine
 
closure,
 
including
 
water
 
quality
monitoring during site reclamation, are included in the financial models.
17.2
 
Requirements and Plans for Waste
 
Disposal
Based on
 
a study
 
commissioned by
 
Coronado in
 
June 2020,
 
the current
 
Buchanan refuse
 
disposal
site adjacent
 
to the
 
preparation
 
plant has
 
a capacity
 
of 29
 
million cubic
 
meters
 
(
CM
) as
 
currently
designed;
 
with
 
an
 
additional
 
lift
 
(No.
 
11),
 
the
 
capacity
 
is 37
 
million
 
CM.
 
Projected
 
requirements
within
 
the
 
MM&A
 
financial
 
model
 
are
 
28.0
 
million
 
CM.
 
Permitting
 
for
 
such
 
an
 
expansion
 
is
anticipated to be achievable.
17.3
 
Permit Requirements and Status
All
 
mining
 
operations
 
are
 
subject
 
to
 
federal
 
and
 
state
 
laws
 
and
 
must
 
obtain
 
permits
 
to
 
operate
mines, coal preparation and related facilities,
 
haul roads, and other incidental surface disturbances
necessary for
 
mining to
 
occur.
 
Permits
 
generally
 
require
 
that
 
the
 
permittee
 
post
 
a
 
performance
bond in
 
an amount
 
established by the
 
regulatory program to provide
 
assurance that any
 
disturbance
or liability
 
created during
 
mining operations
 
is properly
 
restored
 
to an
 
approved post-mining
 
land
use and
 
that all
 
regulations and
 
requirements
 
of the
 
permits are
 
fully satisfied
 
before
 
the bond
 
is
returned
 
to
 
the
 
permittee.
 
Significant
 
penalties
 
exist
 
for
 
any
 
permittee
 
who
 
fails
 
to
 
meet
 
the
obligations
 
of
 
the
 
permits
 
including
 
cessation
 
of
 
mining
 
operations,
 
which
 
can
 
lead
 
to
 
potential
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
44
forfeiture
 
of the
 
bond.
 
Any company,
 
and its
 
directors,
 
owners and
 
officers, which
 
are subject
 
to
bond forfeiture can be denied future permits under the program.
2
New permits
 
or permit
 
revisions will occasionally
 
be necessary
 
to facilitate the
 
expansion or
 
addition
of new
 
mining areas
 
on the
 
properties, such
 
as amendments
 
to existing
 
permits and
 
new permits
for mining
 
of reserve
 
areas.
 
Exploration permits
 
are also
 
required.
 
Property under
 
lease includes
provisions
 
for
 
exploration
 
among
 
the
 
terms
 
of
 
the
 
lease.
 
New
 
or
 
modified
 
mining
 
permits
 
are
subject
 
to
 
a
 
public
 
advertisement
 
process
 
and
 
comment
 
period,
 
and
 
the
 
public
 
is
 
provided
 
an
opportunity
 
to
 
raise
 
objections
 
to
 
any
 
proposed
 
mining
 
operation.
 
MM&A
 
is
 
not
 
aware
 
of
 
any
specific
 
prohibition
 
of
 
mining
 
on
 
the
 
subject
 
property
 
and
 
given
 
sufficient
 
time
 
and
 
planning,
Coronado should
 
be able
 
to secure
 
new permits
 
to maintain
 
its planned mining
 
operations within
the context of current regulations.
 
Necessary permits are in
 
place to support current production on
the Property,
 
but future permits
 
are required
 
to maintain
 
and expand production.
 
Portions of the
Property
 
are
 
located
 
near
 
local
 
communities.
 
Regulations
 
prohibit
 
mining
 
activities
 
within
 
91.44
meters
 
of a
 
residential dwelling,
 
school, church,
 
or similar
 
structure unless
 
written consent
 
is first
obtained
 
from
 
the
 
owner
 
of
 
the
 
structure.
 
Where
 
required,
 
such
 
consents
 
have
 
been
 
obtained
where mining is proposed beyond the regulatory limits.
Coronado
 
has
 
obtained
 
all
 
mining
 
and
 
discharge
 
permits
 
to
 
operate
 
its
 
mines
 
and
 
processing,
loadout,
 
or
 
related
 
facilities.
 
MM&A
 
is
 
unaware
 
of
 
any
 
obvious
 
or
 
current
 
Coronado
 
permitting
issues that
 
are expected
 
to prevent
 
the issuance
 
of future
 
permits.
 
Buchanan, along
 
with all
 
coal
producers,
 
is subject
 
to a
 
level of
 
uncertainty regarding
 
future clean
 
water
 
permits due
 
to
United
States
 
Environmental
 
Protection
 
Agency
(
EPA
)
and
United
 
States
 
Fish
 
and
 
Wildlife
 
(
USFW
)
involvement with state
 
programs.
The active Mining permit currently held by Buchanan is shown in
Table 17-1.
Table 17-1:
 
Buchanan Mining Permit
Type
Permit ID
Permit Name
$ Bond
Current
Status
Issued Date
Expiration
Date
1
Hectares
NPDES No.
Coal Underground
1402152
Buchanan No. 1
Mine
$2,478,000
Active
03/08/1983
03/08/2023
334.00
VA0082152
1.
 
Permit renewal is currently under agency review. The existing permit will continue after the current expiration date
 
until the renewal is
approved.
 
17.4
 
Local Plans, Negotiations or Agreements
MM&A found no indication of agreements beyond the scope of federal
 
or state regulations.
17.5
 
Mine Closure Plans
Applicable
 
regulations
 
require
 
that
 
mines
 
be
 
properly
 
closed,
 
and
 
reclamation
 
commenced
immediately
 
upon
 
abandonment.
 
In
 
general,
 
site
 
reclamation
 
includes
 
removal
 
of
 
structures,
backfilling, regrading, and revegetation of disturbed areas.
 
Sediment control is required during the
establishment of vegetation, and
 
bond release generally requires
 
a minimum
 
five-year period of
 
site
2
 
Monitored under the Applicant Violator
 
System (AVS) by
 
the Federal Office of Surface Mining
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
45
maintenance, water sampling, and
 
sediment control following
 
mine completion.
 
This requirement
is
 
reduced
 
to
 
two
 
years
 
for
 
certain
 
operations
 
involving
 
re-mining.
 
Reclamation
 
of underground
mines includes
 
closure and
 
sealing of
 
mine openings
 
such as
 
portals and
 
shafts in
 
addition to
 
the
items listed above.
 
Estimated
 
costs
 
for
 
mine closure,
 
including water
 
quality monitoring
 
during site
 
reclamation,
 
are
included in the financial
 
model.
 
As with all
 
mining companies, an accretion
 
calculation is performed
annually
 
so the
 
necessary Asset
 
Retirement
 
Obligations
 
(
ARO
) can
 
be shown
 
as
 
a Liability
 
on the
balance sheet.
17.6
 
Qualified Person’s
 
Opinion
The Buchanan Mine is an operating facility; all necessary permits for
 
current production have been
obtained.
 
The QPs know
 
of no reason
 
that any
 
permits revisions
 
that may be
 
required cannot
 
be
obtained.
 
Estimated expenditures for site
 
closure and reclamation are included in the financial model for this
site.
18
 
Capital and Operating Costs
18.1
 
Capital Cost Estimate
The production sequence selected for
 
a property must consider the proximity
 
of each reserve area
to
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plants,
 
river
 
docks
 
and
 
railroad
 
loading
 
points,
 
along
 
with
 
suitability
 
of
production equipment to coal seam conditions.
 
The in-place infrastructure was evaluated, and any
future needs were planned to a level suitable for a Preliminary Feasibility Study and included in the
Capital Forecast.
Coronado
 
provided
 
MM&A
 
with
 
an
 
inventory
 
of
 
operating
 
equipment
 
available
 
at
 
Buchanan.
 
MM&A’s
 
capital
 
schedules assume
 
that
 
major
 
equipment
 
rebuilds
 
occur over
 
the
 
course
 
of each
machine’s
 
remaining
 
assumed
 
operating
 
life.
 
Replacement
 
equipment
 
was
 
scheduled
 
based
 
on
MM&A’s
 
experience and
 
knowledge of
 
mining equipment
 
and industry
 
standards
 
with respect
 
to
the useful life of such equipment.
 
 
ex962p2i0 ex962p54i2 ex962p13i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
46
A summary of the estimated capital for the Property is provided
 
in
Figure 18-2
 
below.
 
Figure 18-1:
 
CAPEX
18.2
 
Operating Cost Estimate
Coronado provided historical and a preliminary five-year
 
projection of operating costs for MM&A’s
review.
 
MM&A used the historical and/or budget cost information
 
as a reference and developed a
personnel
 
schedule
 
for
 
the
 
mine.
 
Hourly
 
labor
 
rates
 
and
 
salaries
 
were
 
based
 
upon
 
information
contained in Coronado’s financial summaries.
 
Fringe-benefit costs were developed
 
for vacation and
holidays,
 
federal
 
and
 
state
 
unemployment
 
insurance,
 
retirement,
 
workers’
 
compensation
 
and
pneumoconiosis,
 
casualty
 
and
 
life
 
insurance,
 
healthcare,
 
and
 
bonuses.
 
A
 
cost
 
factor
 
for
 
mine
supplies was developed that
 
relates expenditures to
 
mine advance rates
 
for roof-control
 
costs and
other
 
mine-supply
 
costs
 
experienced
 
at
 
underground
 
mines.
 
Other
 
factors
 
were
 
developed
 
for
maintenance and repair costs, rentals, mine power,
 
outside services and other direct mining costs.
 
Other
 
cost
 
factors
 
were
 
developed
 
for
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plant
 
processing,
 
refuse
 
handling,
 
coal
loading, property
 
taxes,
 
and insurance
 
and bonding.
 
Appropriate
 
royalty
 
rates
 
were
 
assigned for
production
 
from leased
 
coal lands,
 
and sales
 
taxes
 
were
 
calculated
 
for
 
state
 
severance
 
taxes,
 
the
federal black lung excise tax,
 
and federal and state reclamation
 
fees.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
47
Mandated Sales Related Costs such as Black Lung Excise are
 
summarized in
 
Table 18-1.
Table 18-1:
 
Estimated Coal Production Taxes
 
and Sales Costs
Description of Tax or Sales Cost
Basis of Assessment
Cost
Federal Black Lung Excise Tax - Underground
Per Tonne
$1.21
Federal Reclamation Fees – Underground
Per Tonne
$0.13
Virginia Reclamation Tax – Underground
Per Tonne
$0.05
Virginia Severance Tax
2%
Royalties – Underground
Percentage of Revenue
4.2%
Notes:
 
1.
 
Federal black lung excise tax is paid only on coal sold domestically.
 
MM&A assumed 18% of total coal sales to be domestic in the
economic analysis discussed below.
 
A summary of the projected Operating Costs is in
Table 18-2
.
Table 18-2:
 
Buchanan Mine Operating Costs
 
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
Remaining
 
Total
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
2031
LOM Average
ROM Production Tonnes
162.0
7.5
8.6
9.2
10.9
10.9
9.4
8.8
9.2
6.2
Yield
56.88%
49.81%
48.47%
45.96%
45.83%
47.77%
61.00%
63.22%
62.62%
60.30%
Saleable Production Tonnes
92.1
3.7
4.2
4.2
5.0
5.2
5.7
5.5
5.8
3.8
 
Thermal Tonnes
9.2
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.5
0.5
0.6
0.6
0.6
0.4
Domestic & Non-Asia Export Met Tonnes
31.5
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.7
1.8
2.0
1.9
2.0
1.3
Export Met Tonnes
51.4
2.1
2.3
2.4
2.8
2.9
3.2
3.1
3.2
2.1
 
Total Saleable Tonnes
92.1
3.7
4.2
4.2
5.0
5.2
5.7
5.5
5.8
3.8
 
Cash Costs per Tonne:
Mining Costs
$68.92
$74.56
$73.04
$72.54
$64.35
$62.90
$60.61
$65.10
$64.31
$70.75
Processing and Transport
$9.92
$27.52
$15.54
$10.68
$9.75
$9.46
$7.60
$7.50
$7.70
$8.98
Sales Related Costs
$11.09
$10.77
$9.72
$8.27
$8.98
$9.37
$10.42
$10.62
$10.82
$11.99
G&A
$2.71
$3.96
$2.74
$2.75
$2.40
$2.35
$2.39
$2.44
$2.49
$2.77
 
Total Cash Costs
$92.65
$116.81
$101.04
$94.24
$85.47
$84.07
$81.02
$85.65
$85.33
$94.49
19
 
Economic Analysis
19.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methods
A pre-feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for the Buchanan operations.
 
MM&A prepared
mine projections
 
and production
 
timing forecasts
 
based on
 
coal seam
 
characteristics.
 
Production
timing
 
was
 
carried
 
out
 
from
 
2024
 
to
 
depletion
 
(exhaustion)
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
reserve
 
areas,
 
which
 
is
projected for the year 2042.
 
All costs and prices are based on
 
year-end 2023 nominal United States
dollars.
The Mine
 
plan, productivity
 
expectations and cost
 
estimates generally reflect
 
historical performance
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
efforts
 
have
 
been
 
made
 
to
 
adjust
 
plans
 
and
 
costs
 
to
 
reflect
 
future
 
conditions.
 
MM&A is confident
 
that the mine
 
plan and
 
financial model
 
are reasonably representative to provide
an accurate estimation of coal reserves.
Capital
 
schedules were
 
developed by
 
MM&A for
 
mine development,
 
infrastructure,
 
and on-going
capital
 
requirements
 
for
 
the
 
life
 
of the
 
mine.
 
Staffing
 
levels
 
were
 
prepared,
 
and operating
 
costs
estimated
 
by
 
MM&A.
 
MM&A
 
utilized
 
historical
 
cost
 
data
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
its
 
own
knowledge and experience to estimate direct and indirect operating
 
costs.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
48
The
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
financial
 
model,
 
prepared
 
for
 
this
 
TRS,
 
was
 
developed
 
to
 
test
 
the
economic viability of
 
the coal reserve
 
area.
 
The results of
 
this financial model
 
are not intended
 
to
represent
 
a
 
bankable
 
feasibility
 
study,
 
required
 
for
 
financing
 
of
 
any
 
current
 
or
 
future
 
mining
operations,
 
but
 
are
 
intended
 
to
 
prove
 
the
 
economic
 
viability
 
of the
 
estimated
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
All
costs and prices are based on year-end 2023 nominal United
 
States dollars assuming a 2% inflation
rate.
On an unlevered basis, the NPV of the project cash flows after taxes was
 
estimated for the purpose
of
 
classifying
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
The
 
project
 
cash
 
flows,
 
excluding
 
debt
 
service,
 
are
 
calculated
 
by
subtracting direct
 
and indirect
 
operating expenses
 
and capital
 
expenditures from
 
revenue.
 
Direct
costs include labor, drilling and
 
blasting, operating supplies,
 
maintenance and repairs,
 
facilities costs
for
 
materials
 
handling,
 
coal
 
preparation,
 
refuse
 
disposal,
 
coal
 
loading,
 
sampling
 
and
 
analysis
services,
 
reclamation
 
and
 
general
 
and
 
administrative
 
costs.
 
Indirect
 
costs
 
include
 
statutory
 
and
legally
 
agreed
 
upon
 
fees
 
related
 
to
 
direct
 
extraction
 
of
 
the
 
mineral.
 
The
 
indirect
 
costs
 
are
 
the
federal black lung tax, federal and
 
state reclamation taxes, property taxes, local transportation prior
to delivery at rail or barge loading sites, coal production royalties, sales
 
and use taxes, income taxes
and state severance taxes.
 
Coronado’s historical costs provided a useful reference for MM&A’s cost
estimates.
Sales revenue is based on
 
the metallurgical coal price information provided to MM&A
 
by Coronado.
Projected
 
debt
 
service
 
is
 
excluded
 
from
 
the
 
P&L
 
and
 
cash
 
flow
 
model
 
in
 
order
 
to
 
determine
Enterprise Value.
The financial model expresses coal sales prices, operating costs, and capital expenditures in current
day
 
dollars
 
without
 
adjustment
 
for
 
inflation.
 
Capital
 
expenditures
 
and
 
reclamation
 
costs
 
are
included based
 
on engineering
 
estimates for
 
each mine
 
by year.
 
The Coronado
 
division’s
 
existing
allocations of administrative costs are
 
continued in the future projections.
Coronado will pay royalties for the various current and projected operations.
 
The royalty rates vary
by mining
 
method and
 
location.
 
The royalty
 
rates
 
for
 
Buchanan are
 
estimated
 
to be
 
4.2% of
 
the
sales revenue.
The
 
projection
 
model
 
also
 
includes
 
consolidated
 
income
 
tax
 
calculations
 
at
 
the
 
Coronado
 
level,
incorporating statutory
 
depletion calculations, as well
 
as state income
 
taxes, and a
 
federal tax rate
of
 
21%.
 
To
 
the
 
extent
 
the
 
mine
 
generates
 
net
 
operating
 
losses
 
for
 
tax
 
purposes,
 
the
 
losses
 
are
carried over to offset future taxable
 
income.
 
The terms “cash flows” and “project cash flows” used
in this report refer to after tax
 
cash flows.
Consolidated cash flows are driven
 
by annual sales
 
tonnage, which at steady-state level ranges from
a peak of 5.9 million
 
tonnes in 2033 to
 
a low of 1.2 million tonnes
 
in 2042.
 
Projected consolidated
revenue ranges from $585.2 million to $1.099 billion at a steady state.
 
Revenue totals $15.9 billion
for the project’s life.
 
 
ex962p2i0 ex962p57i2 ex962p57i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
49
Consolidated cash flow from operations is positive throughout the projected operating period, with
the
 
exception
 
of post
 
-production
 
years,
 
due to
 
end-of-mine
 
reclamation
 
spending.
 
Consolidated
cash flow from operations
 
peaks at $494.3 million in
 
2039 and totals $6.1 billion over
 
the project’s
life.
 
Capital expenditures total $576.6 million through 2028 and $1.4 billion over the project’s
 
life.
 
Coal price
 
forecasts
 
for
 
coal products
 
were prepared
 
by Coronado
 
for
 
its active
 
operations.
 
Such
prices
 
were
 
used
 
for
 
the
 
revenue
 
input
 
into
 
the
 
financial
 
model.
 
Sales
 
variable
 
costs
 
such
 
as
production royalties and severance
 
taxes were based upon the revenue
 
input.
19.2
 
Results
The
 
pre-feasibility
 
financial
 
model,
 
prepared
 
by
 
MM&A
 
for
 
this
 
TRS,
 
was
 
developed
 
to
 
test
 
the
economic viability of
 
each coal resource
 
area.
 
The results of
 
this financial model
 
are not intended
to represent
 
a bankable feasibility
 
study,
 
as may be
 
required for
 
financing of any
 
current or future
mining operations contemplated but are intended
 
to prove the economic viability of the estimated
coal reserves.
 
Optimization of the LOM plan was outside the scope of the engagement.
Figure 19-1
 
shows the annual variance of cash costs per ton.
 
Table 19-1
 
shows LOM tonnage, P&L,
and EBITDA for Buchanan.
Figure 19-1:
 
Cash Costs per Tonne
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
50
As shown above, the Buchanan Mine’s average
 
cash cost ranges between approximately
 
$81 and
$117 per tonne for most of the operating period.
Table 19-1:
 
Life-of-Mine Tonnage,
 
P&L before Tax,
 
and EBITDA
 
LOM
LOM
P&L
LOM
EBITDA
 
Tonnes
Pre-Tax P&L
Per Tonne
EBITDA
Per Tonne
Buchanan
92,135
$5,590,394
$60.68
$7,386,829
$80.17
As
 
shown
 
in
Table
 
19-1,
 
the
 
Buchanan
 
Mine
 
shows
 
positive
 
EBITDA
 
over
 
the
 
LOM.
 
Overall,
Coronado’s
 
consolidated
 
operations
 
show positive
 
LOM
 
P&L
 
and
 
EBITDA
 
of
 
$5.6
 
billion
 
and
 
$7.4
billion,
 
respectively.
 
A summary of
 
the key
 
financial performance metrics
 
projected through
 
2031
is provided below in
Table 19-2
.
Table 19-2:
 
Summary of Buchanan Key Financial Performance Metrics (2024-2031)
 
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
YE 12/31
Remaining
 
Total
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
2031
LOM Average
ROM Production Tonnes
 
162.0
 
 
7.5
 
 
8.6
 
 
9.2
 
 
10.9
 
 
10.9
 
 
9.4
 
 
8.8
 
 
9.2
 
 
6.2
 
Yield
56.88%
49.81%
48.47%
45.96%
45.83%
47.77%
61.00%
63.22%
62.62%
60.30%
Saleable Production Tonnes
 
92.1
 
 
3.7
 
 
4.2
 
 
4.2
 
 
5.0
 
 
5.2
 
 
5.7
 
 
5.5
 
 
5.8
 
 
3.8
 
 
Thermal Tonnes
 
9.2
 
 
0.4
 
 
0.4
 
 
0.4
 
 
0.5
 
 
0.5
 
 
0.6
 
 
0.6
 
 
0.6
 
 
0.4
 
Domestic & Non-Asia Export Met Tonnes
 
31.5
 
 
1.3
 
 
1.4
 
 
1.5
 
 
1.7
 
 
1.8
 
 
2.0
 
 
1.9
 
 
2.0
 
 
1.3
 
Export Met Tonnes
 
51.4
 
 
2.1
 
 
2.3
 
 
2.4
 
 
2.8
 
 
2.9
 
 
3.2
 
 
3.1
 
 
3.2
 
 
2.1
 
 
Total Saleable Tonnes
 
92.1
 
 
3.7
 
 
4.2
 
 
4.2
 
 
5.0
 
 
5.2
 
 
5.7
 
 
5.5
 
 
5.8
 
 
3.8
 
 
Cash Costs per Tonne:
Mining Costs
 
$68.92
 
 
$74.56
 
 
$73.04
 
 
$72.54
 
 
$64.35
 
 
$62.90
 
 
$60.61
 
 
$65.10
 
 
$64.31
 
 
$70.75
 
Processing and Transport
 
$9.92
 
 
$27.52
 
 
$15.54
 
 
$10.68
 
 
$9.75
 
 
$9.46
 
 
$7.60
 
 
$7.50
 
 
$7.70
 
 
$8.98
 
Sales Related Costs
 
$11.09
 
 
$10.77
 
 
$9.72
 
 
$8.27
 
 
$8.98
 
 
$9.37
 
 
$10.42
 
 
$10.62
 
 
$10.82
 
 
$11.99
 
G&A
 
$2.71
 
 
$3.96
 
 
$2.74
 
 
$2.75
 
 
$2.40
 
 
$2.35
 
 
$2.39
 
 
$2.44
 
 
$2.49
 
 
$2.77
 
 
Total Cash Costs
 
$92.65
 
 
$116.81
 
 
$101.04
 
 
$94.24
 
 
$85.47
 
 
$84.07
 
 
$81.02
 
 
$85.65
 
 
$85.33
 
 
$94.49
 
 
EBITDA per Tonne
 
$80.17
 
 
$55.41
 
 
$39.15
 
 
$43.47
 
 
$55.72
 
 
$60.60
 
 
$80.31
 
 
$78.90
 
 
$82.51
 
 
$92.25
 
 
Expansion CapEx ($M)
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
Maintenance CapEx ($M)
 
$1,361.0
 
 
$135.4
 
 
$149.9
 
 
$113.9
 
 
$94.1
 
 
$83.2
 
 
$70.2
 
 
$49.2
 
 
$72.8
 
 
$42.3
 
 
Total CapEx
 
$1,361.0
 
 
$135.4
 
 
$149.9
 
 
$113.9
 
 
$94.1
 
 
$83.2
 
 
$70.2
 
 
$49.2
 
 
$72.8
 
 
$42.3
 
After Tax
 
Cash Flows
 
were
 
developed in
 
order to
 
calculate
 
the NPV
 
for
 
this Property.
 
The NPV
 
is
estimated
 
to be
 
$1.804 billion
 
at a
 
discount rate
 
of 10.0%.
 
A summary
 
of the
 
Buchanan after-tax
cash flow is shown in
Table 19-3
.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
51
Table
 
19-3:
 
Project Cash Flow Summary (000)
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
Total
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
Production & Sales tonnes
92,136
3,738
4,186
4,249
4,980
5,210
Total Revenue
$15,924,429
$643,698
$586,802
$585,176
$703,140
$753,693
EBITDA
$7,386,829
$207,113
$163,862
$184,715
$277,497
$315,709
Net Income
$4,381,299
$113,324
$64,939
$71,959
$135,601
$156,242
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$6,095,981
$136,440
$157,841
$166,973
$228,295
$268,684
Purchases of Property,
 
Plant, and Equipment
$(1,360,951)
$(135,370)
$(149,944)
$(113,912)
$(94,118)
$(83,209)
Net Cash Flow
$4,735,031
$1,070
$7,897
$53,061
$134,177
$185,475
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2029
2030
2031
2032
2033
2034
Production & Sales tonnes
5,728
5,545
5,782
5,882
5,936
5,268
Total Revenue
$924,020
$912,413
$970,382
$1,007,050
$1,036,474
$938,266
EBITDA
$459,985
$437,470
$477,050
$500,805
$518,098
$430,129
Net Income
$263,089
$241,288
$280,342
$310,395
$330,940
$268,398
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$360,606
$373,729
$392,820
$411,198
$422,794
$372,147
Purchases of Property,
 
Plant, and Equipment
$(70,177)
$(49,244)
$(72,844)
$(58,404)
$(48,601)
$(65,801)
Net Cash Flow
$290,429
$324,486
$319,977
$352,794
$374,193
$306,346
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
2040
Production & Sales tonnes
5,590
5,378
4,984
5,236
5,589
4,183
Total Revenue
$1,015,529
$996,590
$942,014
$1,009,435
$1,099,026
$839,126
EBITDA
$493,255
$471,648
$463,185
$557,984
$630,017
$392,781
Net Income
$319,755
$303,536
$295,288
$366,694
$422,733
$244,806
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$393,113
$391,050
$382,466
$436,349
$494,321
$365,966
Purchases of Property,
 
Plant, and Equipment
$(54,932)
$(67,914)
$(63,646)
$(75,866)
$(42,226)
$(35,019)
Net Cash Flow
$338,181
$323,135
$318,820
$360,483
$452,095
$330,947
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
2046
Production & Sales tonnes
3,390
1,285
-
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$693,501
$268,094
$-
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$336,112
$69,413
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Income
$203,036
$(341)
$(6,037)
$(2,443)
$(1,255)
$(649)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$290,379
$132,563
$(48,316)
$(16,427)
$(8,378)
$(4,273)
Purchases of Property,
 
Plant, and Equipment
$(49,148)
$(30,577)
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$241,231
$101,986
$(48,316)
$(16,427)
$(8,378)
$(4,273)
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2047
2048
2049
2050
2051
2052
Production & Sales tonnes
-
-
-
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Income
$(341)
$(0)
$(0)
$(0)
$(0)
$(0)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$(4,358)
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Purchases of Property,
 
Plant, and Equipment
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$(4,358)
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
ex962p60i2 ex962p17i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
52
19.3
 
Sensitivity
Sensitivity
 
of the
 
NPV
 
results
 
to
 
changes
 
in
 
the
 
key
 
drivers
 
is presented
 
in the
 
chart below.
 
The
sensitivity study shows
 
the NPV at
 
the 10.0% discount rate
 
when Base Case sales
 
prices, operating
costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased
 
in increments of 5% within a +/- 15% range.
Figure 19-2:
 
Sensitivity of NPV
As shown, NPV is quite sensitive to changes in sales price and operating cost estimates, and slightly
sensitive to changes in capital cost estimates.
20
 
Adjacent Properties
20.1
 
Information Used
No proprietary information associated with neighboring properties was
 
used as part of this study.
21
 
Other Relevant Data
 
and Information
MM&A performed
 
a previous
 
audit of
 
all the
 
properties
 
in year
 
2017 for
 
Coronado
 
based on
 
SEC
Industry
 
Guide 7
 
standards.
 
In addition,
 
MM&A completed
 
a Limited
 
Phase I
 
Environmental
 
Site
Assessment
 
(
ESA
)
 
on
 
the
 
Property
 
in
 
2016
 
on
 
behalf
 
of
 
Coronado.
 
MM&A
 
has
 
subsequently
conducted Joint Ore Reserve Committee (
JORC
) compliant resource and reserve assessments of the
Buchanan assets as of: (1) December 31, 2017, (2) December 31, 2020, (3)
 
December 31, 2021, and
(4) December 31, 2022.
 
By assignment, the JORC assessment included
 
a preliminary feasibility level
study of the subject coal
 
reserves, encompassing detailed
 
mine planning and cost analysis
 
through
depletion
 
of Buchanan’s
 
JORC-compliant
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
MM&A utilized
 
these former
 
preliminary
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
53
feasibility
 
studies
 
as the
 
basis of
 
an updated
 
study
 
which meets
 
those standards
 
set forth
 
by the
JORC Code and SEC in Regulation S-K 1300.
22
 
Interpretation and
 
Conclusions
22.1
 
Conclusion
Sufficient data have been obtained through various exploration and sampling programs and mining
operations
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
geological
 
interpretations
 
of
 
seam
 
structure
 
and
 
thickness
 
for
 
coal
horizons situated
 
on the Property.
 
The data are
 
of sufficient
 
quantity and reliability
 
to reasonably
support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates in this TRS.
The
 
geological
 
data
 
and
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
study,
 
which
 
consider
 
mining
 
plans,
 
revenue,
 
and
operating
 
and
 
capital
 
cost
 
estimates
 
are
 
sufficient
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
classification
 
of
 
coal
 
reserves
provided herein.
This geologic evaluation conducted in conjunction with the preliminary feasibility study is sufficient
to conclude
 
that the
 
92.1 Mt
 
of marketable
 
underground coal
 
reserves identified
 
on the
 
Property
are
 
economically
 
mineable under
 
reasonable
 
expectations
 
of market
 
prices for
 
metallurgical
 
coal
products, estimated operation costs,
 
and capital expenditures.
22.2
 
Risk Factors
Risks have
 
been identified
 
for
 
operational,
 
technical and
 
administrative
 
subjects addressed
 
in the
Pre-Feasibility
 
Study.
 
A risk
 
matrix has
 
been constructed
 
to present
 
the risk
 
levels for
 
all the
 
risk
factors identified and quantified in
 
the risk assessment process.
 
The risk matrix and
 
risk assessment
process are modelled
 
according to the Australian
 
and New Zealand Standard
 
on Risk Management
(AS/NZS 4360).
 
The
 
purpose
 
of
 
the
 
characterization
 
of
 
the
 
project
 
risk
 
components
 
is
 
to
 
inform
 
the
 
project
stakeholders
 
of
 
key
 
aspects
 
of
 
the
 
Coronado
 
projects
 
that
 
can
 
be
 
impacted
 
by
 
events
 
whose
consequences can affect
 
the success of the venture.
 
The significance of an impacted
 
aspect of the
operation
 
is
 
directly
 
related
 
to
 
both
 
the
 
probability
 
of
 
occurrence
 
and
 
the
 
severity
 
of
 
the
consequences.
 
The initial risk for
 
a risk factor
 
is herein defined
 
as the risk level
 
after the potential
impact
 
of
 
the
 
risk
 
factor
 
is
 
addressed
 
by
 
competent
 
and
 
prudent
 
management
 
utilizing
 
control
measures readily available.
 
Residual risk for a risk factor is herein defined as the risk
 
level following
application
 
of
 
special
 
mitigation
 
measures
 
if
 
management
 
determines
 
that
 
the
 
initial
 
risk
 
level
 
is
unacceptable.
 
Initial risk and residual risk can be quantified numerically,
 
derived by the product of
values assigned to probability and consequence ranging from very low risk to very high risk.
 
The probability and consequence
 
parameters are subjective numerical estimates made
 
by practiced
mine engineers and
 
managers.
 
Both are
 
assigned values
 
from 1 to
 
5 for which
 
the value
 
1 represents
the
 
lowest
 
probability
 
and least
 
consequence,
 
and the
 
value
 
5 represents
 
the highest
 
probability
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
54
and greatest
 
consequence.
 
The products, which define
 
the Risk Level,
 
are classified from
 
very low
to very high.
 
Risk Level Table
 
(R = P x C)
Risk Level I (R)
Very Low (1 to 2)
Low (3 to 5)
Moderate (6 to 11)
High (12 to 19)
Very High (20 to 25)
Risk aspects
 
identified and
 
evaluated
 
during this
 
assignment total
 
12.
 
No residual
 
risks are
 
rated
Very High.
 
One (1) residual risk is rated High.
 
Seven (7) of the risk aspects could be associated with
Moderate residual risk.
 
Four (4) of the risk aspects were attributed Low or Very
 
Low residual risks.
 
22.2.1
 
Governing Assumptions
The listing of the aspects is
 
not presumed to be exhaustive.
 
Instead that listing is
 
presented based
on the experiences of the contributors to the TRS.
 
1.
 
The probability and consequence ratings are subjectively assigned, and it is assumed that this
subjectivity reasonably reflects the condition of the active and projected mine operations.
2.
 
The
 
Control
 
Measures
 
shown
 
in
 
the
 
matrices
 
presented
 
in this
 
chapter
 
are
 
not
 
exhaustive.
 
They
 
represent
 
a
 
condensed
 
collection
 
of
 
activities
 
that
 
the
 
author
 
of
 
the
 
risk
 
assessment
section has observed to be effective in coal mining scenarios.
 
3.
 
Mitigation
 
Measures
 
listed
 
for
 
each
 
risk
 
factor
 
of
 
the
 
operation
 
are
 
not
 
exhaustive.
 
The
measures listed, however,
 
have been observed by the author to be effective.
 
4.
 
The monetary values used in
 
ranking the consequences are generally
 
-accepted quantities for
the coal mining industry.
22.2.2
 
Limitations
The risk assessment proposed in
 
this report is subject to
 
the limitations of the information currently
collected, tested, and interpreted
 
at the time of the writing of this report.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
55
22.2.3
 
Methodology
The
 
numerical
 
quantities
 
(i.e.,
 
risk
 
levels)
 
attributable
 
to
 
either
 
“initial”
 
or
 
“residual”
 
risks
 
are
derived
 
by the
 
product
 
of values
 
assigned to
 
probability
 
and consequence
 
ranging
 
from
 
very low
risk to very high risk.
R = P x C
Where:
R = Risk Level
P = Probability of Occurrence
C = Consequence of Occurrence
The Probability (P) and
 
Consequence (C) parameters recited in the
 
formula are subjective numerical
estimates
 
made
 
by
 
practiced
 
mine
 
engineers
 
and
 
managers.
 
Both
 
P
 
and
 
C
 
are
 
assigned
 
integer
values
 
ranging
 
from
 
1
 
to
 
5
 
for
 
which
 
the
 
value
 
1
 
represents
 
the
 
lowest
 
probability
 
and
 
least
consequence,
 
and the
 
value 5
 
represents
 
the highest
 
probability
 
and greatest
 
consequence.
 
The
products (R = P x C) which define the Risk Level, are
 
thereafter classified from very low to very high.
Risk Level Table
Risk Ievel (R)
Very Low (1 to 2)
Low (3 to 5)
Moderate (6 to 11)
High (12 to 19)
Very High (20 to 25)
Very
 
high
 
initial
 
risks
 
are
 
considered
 
to
 
be
 
unacceptable
 
and
 
require
 
corrective
 
action
 
well
 
in
advance of project
 
development.
 
In short,
 
measures must be
 
applied to reduce
 
very high initial
 
risks
to a tolerable level.
 
As
 
shown
 
and
 
discussed
 
above,
 
after
 
taking
 
into
 
account
 
the
 
operational,
 
technical,
 
and
administrative actions that have been
 
applied or
 
are available for action
 
when required, the
 
residual
risk can be determined.
 
The residual risk provides
 
a basis for the
 
management team to determine
if the residual risk
 
level is acceptable or tolerable.
 
If the risk level
 
is determined to be unacceptable,
further actions should be considered to reduce the residual risk to acceptable or tolerable
 
levels to
provide justification for continuation
 
of the proposed operation.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
56
22.2.4
 
Development of the Risk Matrix
Risks have
 
been identified for
 
the technical,
 
operational, and
 
administrative
 
subjects addressed
 
in
the TRS.
 
The risk matrix and risk assessment process
 
are modelled according to the Australian
 
and
New Zealand Standard on Risk Management (AS/NZS 4360).
 
22.2.4.1
 
Probability Level Table
Table 22-1:
 
Probability Level Table
Category
Probability Level (P)
1
Remote
Not likely to occur except
 
in exceptional circumstances.
<10%
2
Unlikely
Not likely to occur; small in degree.
10 - 30%
3
Possible
Capable of occurring.
30 - 60%
4
Likely
High chance of occurring in most circumsta
 
nces.
60 - 90%
5
Almost Certain
Event is expected under
 
most circumstances; impossible to
 
avoid.
>90%
The lowest rated probability of occurrence is assigned the value of 1 and described as remote, with
a likelihood
 
of occurrence
 
of less
 
than ten
 
percent.
 
Increasing values
 
are assigned
 
to each
 
higher
probability
 
of occurrence,
 
culminating
 
with the
 
value
 
of 5
 
assigned to
 
incidents considered
 
to
 
be
almost certain to occur.
22.2.4.2
 
Consequence Level Table
Table 22-2
 
lists the consequence levels.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
57
Table 22-2:
 
Consequence Level Table
Correlation of Events in Key Elements of the Project Program
 
to Event Severity Category
Category
Severity of
the Event
Financial Impact
of the Event
Unplanned
Loss of
Production
(Impact on
Commercial
Operations)
Events Impacting
on the
Environment
Events Affecting the Program's
Social and Community
Relations
Resultant Regulatory /
Sovereign Risk
Events Affecting Occupational Health &
Safety
1
Insignificant
< USD $0.5
million
≤ 12 hours
Insignificant loss of
habitat; no
irreversible effects
on water,
 
soil and
the environment.
Occasional nuisance impact on
travel.
-
 
Event recurrence avoided by corrective
action through established procedures
(Engineering, guarding, training).
2
Minor
USD $0.5 million
to $2.0 million
≤ 1 day
No significant
change to species
populations; short-
term reversible
perturbation to
ecosystem
function.
Persistent nuisance impact on
travel.
 
Transient adverse
media coverage.
-
 
First aid – lost time.
 
Event recurrence
avoided by corrective action through
established procedures.
3
Moderate
USD $2.0 million
to $10.0 million
≤ 1 week
Appreciable change
to species
population;
medium-term (≤10
years) detriment to
ecosystem
function.
Measurable impact on travel
and water/air quality.
 
Significant adverse media
coverage / transient public
outrage.
Uncertainty securing or
retaining essential
approval / license.
Medical Treatment –
permanent
incapacitation.
 
Avoiding event
recurrence requires modification to
established corrective action
procedures
.
Change to regulations
(tax; bonds; standards).
4
Major
USD $10.0
million to $50.0
million
1 to 2 weeks
Change to species
population
threatening
viability; long-term
(>10 years)
detriment to
ecosystem
function.
Long-term, serious impact on
travel and use of water
resources; degradation of air
quality; sustained and effective
public opposition.
Suspension / long-delay
in securing essential
approval / license.
Fatality.
 
Avoiding event recurrence
requires modification to established
corrective action procedures and staff
retraining.
Change to laws (tax;
bonds; standards).
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
58
Correlation of Events in Key Elements of the Project Program
 
to Event Severity Category
Category
Severity of
the Event
Financial Impact
of the Event
Unplanned
Loss of
Production
(Impact on
Commercial
Operations)
Events Impacting
on the
Environment
Events Affecting the Program's
Social and Community
Relations
Resultant Regulatory /
Sovereign Risk
Events Affecting Occupational Health &
Safety
5
Critical
>USD $50.0
million
>1 month
Species extinction;
irreversible damage
to ecosystem
function.
Loss of social license.
Withdraw / failure to
secure essential
approval / license.
Multiple fatalities.
 
Avoiding event
recurrence requires major overhaul of
policies and procedures.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
59
The
 
lowest
 
rated
 
consequence
 
is
 
assigned
 
the
 
value
 
of
 
1
 
and
 
is
 
described
 
as
 
an
 
Insignificant
Consequence,
 
parameters
 
of
 
which
 
include
 
non-reportable
 
safety
 
incidents
 
with
 
zero
 
days
 
lost
accidents, no environmental damage,
 
loss of production or systems for less than
 
12 hours and cost
of
 
less
 
than
 
USD
 
$0.5
 
million.
 
Increasing
 
values
 
are
 
assigned
 
to
 
each
 
higher
 
consequence,
culminating with the value of
 
5 assigned to critical consequences, the
 
parameters of which include
multiple-fatality
 
accidents,
 
major
 
environmental
 
damage,
 
and
 
loss
 
of
 
production
 
or
 
systems
 
for
longer than one month and cost of greater than USD $50.0 million.
Composite Risk Matrix R = P x C and Color-Code Convention
The risk level, defined as the
 
product of probability of occurrence and consequence, ranges in
 
value
from
 
1 (lowest
 
possible risk)
 
to
 
25 (maximum
 
risk level).
 
The
 
values
 
are color-coded
 
to facilitate
identification of the highest risk aspects.
Table 22-3:
 
Risk Matrix
P x C = R
Consequence (C)
Insignificant
Minor
Moderate
Major
Critical
1
2
3
4
5
Probability Level
(P)
Remote
1
1
2
3
4
5
Unlikely
2
2
4
6
8
10
Possible
3
3
6
9
12
15
Likely
4
4
8
12
16
20
Almost
Certain
5
5
10
15
20
25
22.2.5
 
Categorization of Risk Levels and Color Code Convention
Very
 
high
 
risks
 
are
 
considered
 
to
 
be
 
unacceptable
 
and
 
require
 
corrective
 
action.
 
Risk
 
reduction
measures must be applied to reduce very high risks to a tolerable level.
22.2.6
 
Description of the Coal Property
The Buchanan Mine Complex is located in Buchanan and
 
Tazewell
 
Counties, Virginia and operates a
longwall section with supporting continuous mining
 
sections.
 
Operations are projected to continue
in the present mode until reserves are depleted in 2042.
22.2.7
 
Summary of Residual Risk Ratings
Each
 
risk factor
 
is numbered,
 
and
 
a
 
risk level
 
for
 
each
 
is determined
 
by
 
multiplying
 
the
 
assigned
probability by
 
the assigned
 
consequence.
 
The risk
 
levels are
 
plotted
 
on a
 
risk matrix
 
to provide
 
a
composite
 
view
 
of
 
the
 
Coronado
 
risk
 
profile.
 
The
 
average
 
risk
 
level
 
is
 
7.1,
 
which
 
is
 
defined
 
as
Moderate.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
60
Table 22-4:
 
Risk Assessment Matrix
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Consequence
Critical
>$50 MM
8,9
 
 
 
 
 
Major
$10-50MM
 
2
 
6
 
 
Moderate
$2-10 MM
11
1,4
3
 
 
 
Minor
$0.5-$2 MM
 
 
12
5
7
 
Low
<$0.5 MM
 
 
10
 
 
 
 
<10%
10-30%
30-60%
60-90%
>90%
 
Remote
Unlikely
Possible
Likely
Almost
Certain
22.2.8
 
Risk Factors
A
 
high-level
 
approach
 
is
 
utilized
 
to
 
characterize
 
risk
 
factors
 
that
 
are
 
generally
 
similar
 
across
 
a
number of
 
the active
 
and proposed
 
mining operations.
 
Risk factors
 
that
 
are
 
unique to
 
a specific
operation or are particularly noteworthy are
 
addressed individually.
22.2.8.1
 
Geological and Coal Resource
Coal
 
mining
 
is
 
accompanied
 
by
 
risk
 
that,
 
despite
 
exploration
 
efforts,
 
mining
 
areas
 
will
 
be
encountered
 
where geological
 
conditions render
 
extraction
 
of the
 
resource to
 
be uneconomic,
 
or
that coal quality characteristics disqualify the product for sale into
 
target markets.
Offsetting
 
the
 
geological
 
and
 
coal
 
resource
 
risks
 
are
 
the
 
massive
 
size
 
of
 
the
 
controlled
 
property
which allows large
 
areas to be
 
mined in
 
the preferred mine areas
 
sufficiently away from areas
 
where
coal
 
quality
 
and
 
mineability
 
may
 
be
 
less
 
favorable.
 
This
 
flexibility,
 
combined
 
with
 
the
 
extensive
work done to define the reserve, reduces the
 
risk at Buchanan below that of
 
other mine properties.
Table 22-5:
 
Geological and Coal Resource Risk Assessment (Risks 1 and 2)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Recoverable coal
tonnes recognized to
be significantly less
than previously
estimated.
Reserve base is adequate to
serve market commitments
and respond to opportunities
for many years.
 
Local
adverse conditions may
increase frequency and cost
of production unit
relocations.
Previous and ongoing
exploration and extensive
regional mining history
provide a high level of
confidence of coal seam
correlation, continuity of
the coal seams, and coal
resource tonnes.
3
4
12
Optimize mine plan to
increase resource
recovery; develop
mine plan to provide
readily available
alternate mining
locations to sustain
expected production
level.
2
3
6
Coal quality locally
proves to be lower
than initially projected.
If uncontrolled, production
and sale of coal that is out of
specification can result in
rejection of deliveries,
cancellation of coal sales
agreements and damage to
reputation.
Exploration and vast
experience and history in
local coal seams provide
confidence in coal quality;
limited excursions can be
managed with careful
product segregation and
blending.
2
5
10
Develop mine plan to
provide readily
available alternate
mining locations to
sustain expected
production level;
modify coal sales
agreements to reflect
coal quality.
2
4
8
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
61
22.2.8.2
 
Environmental
MM&A completed
 
a Limited Phase
 
I Environmental
 
Site Assessment
 
(
ESA
) on the
 
Property in April
2016 on behalf
 
of Coronado.
 
MM&A concluded that
 
no long-term liabilities
 
existed at
 
the time of
this ESA.
Water
 
quality and
 
other permit
 
requirements
 
are subject
 
to modification
 
and such
 
changes could
have a
 
material impact on
 
the capability of
 
the operator
 
to meet modified
 
standards or
 
to receive
new permits and modifications
 
to existing permits.
 
Permit protests
 
may result in delays
 
or denials
to permit applications.
Environmental standards and permit requirements have evolved significantly over the
 
past 50 years
and
 
to
 
date,
 
mining
 
operators
 
and
 
regulatory
 
bodies
 
have
 
been
 
able
 
to
 
adapt
 
successfully
 
to
evolving environmental requirements.
Table 22-6:
 
Environmental (Risks 3 and 4)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Environmental
performance standards
are modified in the
future.
Delays in receiving new
permits and modifications to
existing permits; cost of
testing and treatment of water
and soils
Work with regulatory
agencies to understand and
influence final standards;
implement testing, treatment
and other actions to comply
with new standards.
3
4
12
Modify mining and
reclamation plans to improve
compliance with new
standards while reducing
cost of compliance.
3
3
9
New permits and permit
modifications are
increasingly delayed or
denied.
Interruption of production and
delayed implementation of
replacement production from
new mining areas.
Comply quickly with testing,
treatment and other actions
required; continue excellent
compliance performance
within existing permits.
2
4
8
Establish and maintain close
and constructive working
relationships with regulatory
agencies, local communities
and community action
groups.
 
Prepare and submit
permits well in advance of
needs.
 
2
3
6
22.2.8.3
 
Regulatory Requirements
Federal
 
and
 
state
 
health
 
and
 
safety
 
regulatory
 
agencies
 
occasionally
 
amend
 
mine
 
laws
 
and
regulations.
 
The impact is
 
industry-wide.
 
Mining operators and regulatory agencies have been
 
able
to adapt successfully to evolving health and safety requirements.
Table
 
22-7:
 
Regulatory Requirements (Risk 5)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Federal and state mine
safety and health
regulatory agencies
amend mine laws and
regulations.
Cost of training, materials,
supplies and equipment;
modification of mine
examination and production
procedures; modification of
mining plans.
Participate in hearings and
workshops when possible to
facilitate understanding and
implementation; work
cooperatively with agencies
and employees to facilitate
implementation of new laws
and regulations.
4
3
12
Familiarity and
experience with new
laws and regulations
results in reduced
impact to operations
and productivity and
improved supplies
and equipment
options.
4
2
8
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
62
22.2.8.4
 
Market and Transportation
Most of the current and future production is expected to be directed to domestic and international
metallurgical markets.
 
Historically the metallurgical markets
 
have been cyclical and highly volatile.
 
Table
 
22-8:
 
Market and Transportation
 
(Risk 6)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Volatile coal prices
drop precipitously.
Loss of revenue adversely
affects profitability; reduced
cash flow may disrupt capital
expenditures plan.
Cost control measures
implemented; capital
spending deferred.
4
5
20
High-cost
operations closed,
and employees
temporarily
furloughed.
4
4
16
Occasional delay or interruption of rail,
 
river and terminals service may be expected.
 
The operator
can
 
possibly
 
minimize
 
the
 
impact
 
of
 
delays
 
by
 
being
 
a
 
preferred
 
customer
 
by
 
fulfilling
 
shipment
obligations promptly and maintaining close working relationships.
Table
 
22-9:
 
Market and Transportation
 
(Risk 7)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Rail or river transport is
delayed; storage and
shipping access at river
and ocean terminals is
not available.
Fulfillment of coal sales
agreements delayed; limited
coal storage at mines may
increase cost of rehandling;
production may be
temporarily idled.
Provide adequate storage
capacity at mines;
coordinate continuously
with railroad and shipping
companies to respond
quickly and effectively to
changing circumstances.
5
3
15
Provide back-up
storage facility
along with
personnel,
equipment and
rehandle plan to
sustain production
and fulfill sales
obligations timely.
5
2
10
22.2.8.5
 
Mining Plan
Occupational health and
 
safety risks are inherent
 
in mining
 
operations.
 
Comprehensive training and
retraining
 
programs,
 
internal
 
safety
 
audits
 
and
 
examinations,
 
regular
 
mine
 
inspections,
 
safety
meetings, along
 
with support
 
of trained
 
fire brigades
 
and mine-rescue
 
teams are
 
among activities
that
 
greatly
 
reduce
 
accident
 
risks.
 
Employee
 
health-monitoring
 
programs
 
coupled with
 
dust
 
and
noise monitoring and abatement reduce health risks to miners.
 
As underground mines are developed and
 
extended, observation of geological, hydrogeological and
geotechnical
 
conditions
 
leads
 
to
 
modification
 
of mine
 
plans
 
and
 
procedures
 
to
 
enable
 
safe
 
work
within the mine environments.
Highlighted
 
below
 
are
 
selected
 
examples
 
of
 
safety
 
and
 
external
 
factors
 
relevant
 
to
 
Coronado
operations.
22.2.8.5.1
 
Methane Management
Coalbed methane is
 
present in coal
 
operations below
 
drainage.
 
Often the methane
 
concentration
in shallow coal seams is at such low levels that it can be readily managed with frequent testing
 
and
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
63
monitoring,
 
vigilance,
 
and
 
routine
 
mine
 
ventilation.
 
Very
 
high
 
methane
 
concentrations
 
may
 
be
present at greater depths, as
 
experienced in the
 
Pocahontas No. 3 seam
 
at Buchanan Mine
 
Complex
in Virginia.
 
High methane
 
concentrations
 
may require
 
degasification
 
of the
 
coal seam
 
via surface
and/or underground
 
methods to
 
assure safe
 
mining.
 
The Buchanan
 
Mine has
 
operated
 
safely for
many years in one of the most intense methane environments
 
in the United States through careful
management of coal seam degasification, gob degasification
 
and mine-ventilation procedures.
Table 22-10:
 
Methane Management (Risk 8)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Methane hazard is
present in mines
operating below
drainage.
Injury or loss of life; possible
ignition of gas and mine
explosion; potential loss of
mine and equipment
temporarily or permanently;
additional mine fan, mine
power, ventilation, monitoring
and examination
requirements.
Low to moderate levels
can be managed with
frequent examinations,
testing and monitoring
within the mine ventilation
system.
 
Excellent rock
dust maintenance
minimizes explosion
propagation risk should an
ignition occur.
1
5
5
Very high-level
methane
concentrations may
require coal seam
degasification and
gob degasification if
longwall or pillar
extraction methods
are employed.
1
5
5
22.2.8.5.2
 
Mine Fires
Mine
 
fires,
 
once
 
common
 
at
 
mine operations,
 
are
 
rare
 
today.
 
Most
 
active
 
coal
 
miners
 
have
 
not
encountered a mine
 
fire.
 
Vastly improved mine power and
 
equipment electrical systems, along
 
with
safe
 
mine
 
practices,
 
reduce
 
mine
 
fire
 
risks.
 
Crew
 
training
 
and
 
fire
 
brigade
 
support
 
and
 
training
improve response for containment and
 
control if a
 
fire occurs.
 
Spontaneous combustion within coal
mines, which is the source of most fires that occur today,
 
is not expected to occur at Buchanan.
 
Table 22-11:
 
Mine Fires (Risk 9)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Mine fire at underground
or surface mine
operation.
Injury or loss of life;
potential loss of mine
temporarily or
permanently; damage to
equipment and mine
infrastructure.
Inspection and
maintenance of mine
power, equipment and
mine infrastructure; good
housekeeping; frequent
examination of conveyor
belt entries; prompt
removal of accumulations
of combustible materials.
1
5
5
If spontaneous
combustion conditions
are present, enhanced
monitoring and
examination
procedures will be
implemented; mine
design will incorporate
features to facilitate
isolation, containment
and extinguishment of
spontaneous
combustion locations.
1
5
5
22.2.8.5.3
 
Availability of Supplies and Equipment
The industry
 
has periodically
 
experienced
 
difficulty receiving
 
timely delivery
 
of mine
 
supplies and
equipment.
 
Availability
 
issues
 
often
 
accompanied
 
boom
 
periods
 
for
 
coal
 
demand.
 
Any
 
future
delivery
 
of
 
supplies
 
and
 
equipment
 
delays
 
are
 
expected
 
to
 
be
 
temporary
 
with
 
limited
 
impact
 
on
production.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
64
Table 22-12:
 
Availability of Supplies and Equipment (Risk 10)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Disruption of availability
for supplies and
equipment.
Temporary interruption of
production.
Force majeure provision
in coal sales agreements
to limit liability for delayed
or lost sales.
3
2
6
Work closely with
customers to
assure delayed
coal delivery rather
than cancelled
sales; monitor
external conditions
and increase
inventory of critical
supplies;
accelerate delivery
of equipment when
possible.
3
1
3
22.2.8.5.4
 
Labor
Work stoppage due
 
to labor
 
protests are considered
 
unlikely and are
 
accompanied by
 
limited impact
should
 
it occur.
 
Excellent
 
employee
 
relations
 
and
 
communications
 
limit the
 
exposure
 
to
 
outside
protesters.
 
Loss of supervisors and skilled employees to retirement is inevitable; the impact can be
lessened with succession planning and training and mentorship of new employees.
Table
 
22-13:
 
Labor – Work Stoppage (Risk 11)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Work stoppage due to
strikes, slowdowns or
secondary boycott
activity.
Loss of production and coal
sales; damaged customer
and employee relations;
reputation loss.
Maintain excellent
employee relations and
communications; maintain
frequent customer
communications.
1
3
3
Develop plan for
employee
communications
and legal support to
minimize impact of
secondary boycott
activities.
1
3
3
Table 22-14:
 
Labor – Retirement (Risk 12)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Retirement of
supervisors and skilled
employees.
Loss of leadership and critical
skills to sustain high levels of
safety, maintenance and
productivity.
Monitor demographics
closely and maintain
communications with
employees who are
approaching retirement
age; maintain employee
selection and training
programs.
3
3
9
Maintain selection
of candidates and
implementation of
in-house or third-
party training for
electricians and
mechanics; develop
employee
mentoring program.
3
2
6
23
 
Recommendations
Coronado is
 
continuing to
 
work both
 
internally and
 
with outside
 
assistance to
 
further define
 
their
resource base and to optimize the LOM plan.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
65
24
 
References
Publicly available information from various
 
state and federal agencies
 
was used where relevant.
25
 
Reliance on Information Provided by the Registrant
A summary of
 
the information provided by Coronado relied upon
 
by MM&A for the purposes
 
of this
TRS is provided in
Table 25-1
.
Table 25-1:
 
Information from Registrant
 
Relied Upon by MM&A
 
Category
Information Provided by Coronado
Report Section
Marketing
Long-term price forecast used
 
in financial projections
16.2
 
Legal
Mineral control and surface
 
control rights as shown on maps
3.2, 3.3
Environmental
Permit and bonding information
17.3
ex962p74i0
 
 
Appendix
A
MM&A QUALIFICATIONS
ex962p75i0
 
 
 
ex962p74i0
 
 
Appendix
B
MAP
ex962p77i0
 
 
ex962p78i0
 
 
Appendix
C
 
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
1
Glossary of Abbreviations and Definitions
Abbreviation
Definition
ACPS
Analysis of Coal Pillar Stability
ASTM
ASTM International
AVS
Applicant Violator System
Btu/lb.
British Thermal Unit per pound
Carlson
Carlson Mining – formerly SurvCADD
®
 
– a prevalent software package used for
modeling in the Appalachian region
CBM
Coalbed Methane
CFR
Code of Federal Regulations
Coronado
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
CSR
Coke strength after
 
reaction
CSX
CSX Corporation, a rail-based freight transportation
 
company
Demonstrated
reserves
Demonstrated reserves are the sum of proven
 
and probable reserves.
EBITDA
Earnings before Interest,
 
Taxes,
 
Depreciation, and Amortization
 
EOM
End-of-mine reclamation
EPA
United States Environmental
 
Protection Agency
 
ESA
Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment
Feasibility Study
“…comprehensive technical and economic study of the selected development
option for a mineral project, which includes detailed assessments of all
applicable modifying factors together with any other relevant
 
operational
factors, and detailed financial analysis that
 
are necessary to demonstrate, at
the time of reporting, that extraction is economically viable.
 
According to the
proposed definition, the results of the study may serve as the basis for a final
decision by a proponent or financial institution to proceed with, or finance,
the development of the project. Thus, a feasibility study is more
comprehensive, with a higher degree of accuracy,
 
and yielding results with a
higher level of confidence, than a pre-feasibility study.”
 
HCC
Hard coking coal
In situ
Its natural position; said specific of a rock, soil, or fossil when in the situation
in which was originally formed or deposited
Indicated
Resources
Indicated resources are those lying between 0.4-kilometer
 
and 1.2-kilometer
radius from such an observation point and reported herein as in-situ mineral
resources.
Inferred Resources
Inferred resources lie more than a
 
1.2-kilometer radius from a valid point of
measurement but less than 4.8 kilometers from one and reported
 
herein as
in-situ mineral resources.
JORC Code
Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration
 
Results, Mineral Resources and
Ore Reserves
lb. SO
2
 
/ mm Btu
Pounds per sulfur dioxide per million British thermal units
LOM
Life-of-mine
M&R
Maintenance and repair
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
2
Abbreviation
Definition
Measured
Resources
Measured resources are those lying within 0.4-kilometer radius
 
from a valid
point of measurement and reported herein as in-situ mineral resources.
MINER Act
Mine Improvement and New Emergency Response Act of 2006
 
Mineral Reserve
“…the economically mineable part of a Measured and/or Indicated Mineral
Resource.
 
It includes dilution materials and allowances for losses, which occur
when the material is mined or extracted and is defined by studies at
Preliminary Feasibility or Feasibility level as appropriate that include
Modifying Factors.
 
Such studies demonstrate that, at the time of reporting,
extraction of the mineral reserve is economically viable under reasonable
investment and marketing assumptions.”
 
Mineral Resource
“…a concentration or occurrence of solid material of economic interest
 
or on
the Earth’s crust
 
in such form, grade or quality that there are reasonable
prospects for eventual economic extraction.
 
The location, quantity,
 
grade,
continuity and other geological characteristics and continuity of a Mineral
Resource are known, estimated or interpreted
 
from specific geological
evidence and knowledge, including sampling.”
 
MM&A
Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc.
Modifying Factors
“…considerations used to convert Mineral
 
Resources to Mineral Reserves.
These include, but are not restricted to, mining, processing, metallurgical,
infrastructure, economic, marketing,
 
legal, environmental compliance, plans,
negotiations, or agreements with local individuals or groups and
governmental factors.”
MRMR
Mineral Resources to Mineral Reserves
MSHA
United States Department of Labor Mine Safety and Health Administration
Mt
Million metric tonnes
NELAP
National Environmental Laboratory
 
Accreditation Program
NIOSH
National Institute for Occupational Safety
 
and Health
NRTL
Nationally Recognized Test
 
Laboratory
NS
Norfolk Southern Corporation, a rail-based freight transportation
 
company
O&M
Operating and maintenance
 
OSD
Out-of-seam dilution
P&L
Profit and loss before tax
 
PCI
Pulverized coal injection
P.E.
Professional Engineer
Preliminary
Feasibility Study
“…as a comprehensive study of a range of options for the technical and
economic viability of a mineral project that has advanced to a stage
 
where a
qualified person has determined (in the case of underground mining) a
preferred mining method, or in the case of surface mining) a pit configuration,
and in all cases has determined an effective method of mineral processing
 
and
an effective plan to sell the product. The study’s
 
financial analysis must have
the level of detail necessary to demonstrate, at the time of reporting, that
extraction is economically viable. In addition, as noted in the proposed
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
3
Abbreviation
Definition
definition of a pre-feasibility study,
 
while a pre-feasibility study is less
comprehensive and results in a lower confidence level than a feasibility
 
study,
a pre-
 
feasibility study is more comprehensive and results
 
in a higher
confidence level than an initial assessment.”
 
Property(ies)
Bituminous coal deposits located in Buchanan and Tazewell
 
Counties, Virginia.
 
QP
Qualified Person
Qualified Person
“…a person who is a mineral industry professional with at
 
least five years of
relevant experience in the type of mineralization and type of deposit under
consideration and in the specific type of activity that person is undertaking on
behalf of the registrant. In addition, the proposed definition requires
 
a
qualified person to be an
eligible member or licensee in good standing of a
recognized professional
 
organization at the
time the technical report is prepared.”
RECs
Recognized Environmental
 
Conditions
Resource Database
The Resource Database is established by the collection, validation,
 
recording,
storing and processing of data and forms the foundation
 
necessary for the
estimation of Mineral Resource and Mineral
 
Reserve.
 
A quality assurance and quality control program is essential
 
and must be
established to govern the collection of all data.
 
In reporting, a Mineral
Resource must meet the minimum requirement of “reasonable
 
prospects for
economic extraction”.
 
This will require the concurrent collection and storage
of preliminary economic, mining, metallurgical, environmental,
 
legal and
social data and other information for use in the estimation
 
of MRMR.
 
The Resource Database will include both “primary” (observation and
measurement) and “interpreted” data.
 
It is recommended that data be stored
digitally,
 
using a documented, standard format and a reliable storage
 
medium
that allows for easy and complete
 
retrieval of the data.
ROM
Run-of-mine
S-K 1300
United States Securities and Exchange Commission Regulation
 
S-K 1300
Modernization of Property Disclosures
SEC
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
SMCRA
Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977 is the primary federal
 
law
that regulates the environmental
 
effects of coal mining in the United States.
tph
tonnes per hour
 
TRS
Technical
 
Report Summary
USA
United States of America
USFW
United States Fish and Wildlife
USGS
United States Geologic Survey
 
VALMIN Code
Australasian Code for Public Reporting of Technical
 
Assessments and
Valuations of Mineral
 
Assets
ex962p78i0
 
 
Appendix
D
INITIAL ECONOMIC ASSESSMENT FOR RESOURCES EXCLUSIVE
 
OF RESERVES
ex962p83i0
 
 
ex962p78i0
 
 
Appendix
E
JORC TABLE 1
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
1
Section 1 Sampling Techniques and Data
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Sampling techniques
>
Nature and quality of sampling (e.g. cut channels, random chips, or specific specialised
industry standard measurement tools appropriate to the minerals under investigation, such
as downhole gamma sondes, or handheld XRF instruments, etc.). These examples should not
be taken as limiting the broad meaning of sampling.
>
Include reference to measures taken to ensure sample representivity and the appropriate
calibration of any measurement tools or systems used.
>
Aspects of the determination of mineralisation that are Material to the Public Report. In
cases where ‘industry standard’ work has been done this would be relatively simple (e.g.
‘reverse circulation drilling was used to obtain 1 m samples from which 3 kg was pulverised
to produce a 30 g charge for fire assay’). In other cases, more explanation may be required,
such as where there is coarse gold that has inherent sampling problems. Unusual
commodities or mineralisation types (e.g. submarine nodules) may warrant disclosure of
detailed information.
>
Most of the coal samples have been obtained from the Properties by subsurface exploration using
core drilling techniques.
 
The protocol for preparing and testing the samples has varied over time
and is not well documented for the older holes drilled on the Properties.
>
Typical USA core drilling sampling technique is for the coal core sample, once recovered from the
core barrel, to be described then wrapped in a sealed plastic sleeve and placed into a covered core
box, which is the length of the sample so that the core can be delivered to a laboratory in
relatively intact condition and with original moisture content.
>
It is reasonable to assume, given the sophistication level of the previous operators, that these
samples were generally collected and processed under industry best-practices.
 
This assumption is
based on MM&A’s familiarity with the operating companies and the companies used to perform
the analysis.
 
>
Some of the drill holes were air rotary bored and no coal core samples were collected.
 
Seam
thickness for rotary-drilled bore holes is verified by calibrated downhole gamma-density logs.
 
>
Coal samples that were deemed by MM&A geologists to be unrepresentative were not used for
statistical analysis of coal quality, as documented in the tabulations. A representative group of drill
hole samples from the Properties were then checked against the original drill laboratory reports to
verify accuracy and correctness.
 
Drilling techniques
>
Drill type (e.g. core, reverse circulation, open-hole hammer, rotary air blast, auger,
 
Bangka,
sonic, etc.) and details (e.g. core diameter, triple or standard tube, depth of diamond tails,
face-sampling bit or other type, whether core is oriented and if so, by what method, etc.).
>
The Properties have been extensively explored by subsurface drilling efforts carried out by
numerous entities, most of which were completed prior to acquisition by Coronado.
 
The majority
of the drilling was accomplished using vertical continuous (diamond) coring or air rotary methods.
>
Core drilling methods utilize NX-size (5.4 centimeter) or similar-sized core cylinders to recover core
samples, which can be used to delineate geologic characteristics, and for coal quality testing and
geotechnical logging.
 
>
Data for the rotary drilled holes is mainly derived from downhole geophysical logs, which are used
to interpret coal and rock thickness and depth since logging of the drill cuttings is not reliable.
>
Geophysical logging was performed on many of the holes, either by Geological Logging Systems (a
division of MM&A), other geophysical logging contractors, and on those properties acquired from
CONSOL geophysical logging was often performed by CONSOL’s in-house logging services.
Drill sample recovery
>
Method of recording and assessing core and chip sample recoveries and results assessed.
>
Measures taken to maximise sample recovery and ensure representative nature of the
samples.
>
Whether a relationship exists between sample recovery and grade and whether sample bias
may have occurred due to preferential loss/gain of fine/coarse material.
>
Where available, core recovery thickness of coal samples was reconciled with the thickness
interpreted from geophysical logs.
>
Core recovery of the older coal samples lacking geophysical logs is sometimes not well-
documented: however, when the laboratory results for such holes had anomalous values, the data
was disqualified and not used.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
2
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Logging
>
Whether core and chip samples have been geologically and geotechnically logged to a level
of detail to support appropriate Mineral Resource estimation, mining studies and
metallurgical studies.
>
Whether logging is qualitative or quantitative in nature. Core (or costean, channel, etc.)
photography.
>
The total length and percentage of the relevant intersections logged.
>
A wide variety of core-logging techniques exist for the properties.
 
For many of the core holes, the
primary data source is a generalized lithology description by the driller, in some cases
supplemented by a more detailed core log completed by a geologist.
 
>
The logging of core thickness and depth is quantitative.
 
With the exception of the coal seams,
logging of rock strata type is more subjective and best considered as qualitative.
Sub-sampling
techniques and sample
preparation
>
If core, whether cut or sawn and whether quarter, half or all core taken.
>
If non-core, whether riffled, tube sampled, rotary split, etc. and whether sampled wet or dry.
>
For all sample types, the nature, quality and appropriateness of the sample preparation
technique.
>
Quality control procedures adopted for all sub-sampling stages to maximise representivity of
samples.
>
Measures taken to ensure that the sampling is representative of the in situ material
collected, including for instance results for field duplicate/second-half sampling.
>
Whether sample sizes are appropriate to the grain size of the material being sampled.
>
Typical US practice in the Appalachian Basin is that core samples for deep mineable core samples
are not sawn or subsampled (since seams are not of great thickness and the entire seam is mined
and co-mingled). The entire coal interval drilled is generally analyzed.
>
Oftentimes, core for surface-mineable coal seams are bench sampled separately by the various
coal and rock layers (plies).
>
MM&A has exercised diligence to use only those analyses that are representative of the coal
quality parameters for the appropriate mining type for each sample.
Quality of assay data
and laboratory tests
>
The nature, quality and appropriateness of the assaying and laboratory procedures used and
whether the technique is considered partial or total.
>
For geophysical tools, spectrometers, handheld XRF instruments, etc., the parameters used
in determining the analysis including instrument make and model, reading times,
calibrations factors applied and their derivation, etc.
>
Nature of quality control procedures adopted (e.g. standards, blanks, duplicates, external
laboratory checks) and whether acceptable levels of accuracy (i.e. lack of bias) and precision
have been established.
>
Sample analysis was typically carried out by accredited US laboratories.
 
>
Standard procedure upon receipt of core samples by the testing laboratory is to log the depth and
thickness of the sample, then perform testing as specified by a representative of the operating
company.
 
Each sample is then analyzed in accordance with procedures defined under
ASTM
International (
ASTM
)
 
standards including, but not limited to; washability (ASTM D4371); ash
(ASTM D3174); sulfur (ASTM D4239); Btu/lb. (ASTM D5865); volatile matter (ASTM D3175); Free
Swell Index (
FSI
) (ASTM D720).
>
Geophysical tools are calibrated by the logging company and where possible, validated using a
calibration hole.
Verification of
sampling and assaying
>
The verification of significant intersections by either independent or alternative company
personnel.
>
The use of twinned holes.
>
Documentation of primary data, data entry procedures, data verification, data storage
(physical and electronic) protocols.
>
Discuss any adjustment to assay data.
>
All coal intersection data used to generate the geologic model has been cross referenced with the
lithological and geophysical logs by MM&A.
>
Laboratory quality was adjusted from dry basis to reflect the anticipated marketable product
moisture.
>
Coal quality results were verified by spot-check with laboratory analysis sheets by MM&A before
inclusion into the geologic model and use in the resource estimate.
Location of data points
>
Accuracy and quality of surveys used to locate drill holes (collar and down-hole surveys),
trenches, mine workings and other locations used in Mineral Resource estimation.
>
Specification of the grid system used.
>
Quality and adequacy of topographic control.
>
Due to the long history of exploration by various parties on the Properties, a wide variety of survey
techniques exist for documentation of data point locations.
 
Many of the older exploration drill
holes appear to have been located by ground survey; more recently completed drill holes are
often located by high-resolution Global Positioning System (
GPS
) units.
>
Grid systems used are typically the State Plane Coordinate System pertinent to each property.
 
>
Topography is based on either the USGS topographic 7.5-minute quadrangle maps or on recent
aerial photogrammetry as necessary (subject to availability).
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
3
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Data spacing and
distribution
>
Data spacing for reporting of Exploration Results.
>
Whether the data spacing and distribution is sufficient to establish the degree of geological
and grade continuity appropriate for the Mineral Resource and Ore Reserve estimation
procedure(s) and classifications applied.
>
Whether sample compositing has been applied.
>
Spacing and distribution of data point information may vary from seam to seam within each
mining area.
 
The areas estimated for coal resource and coal reserve tonnes have been limited so
that the data spacing and distribution is sufficient to establish the degree of geological continuity
appropriate for the estimation and classification of the coal tonnes.
>
MM&A performed a geostatistical analysis using the Drill Hole Spacing Analysis (
DHSA
) method.
 
This method attempts to quantify the uncertainty of applying a measurement from a central
location to increasingly larger square blocks and provides recommendations for determining the
distances between drill holes for measured, indicated, and inferred resources.
 
>
All of the coal resource tonnes are in the measured, indicated, and inferred categories, and all of
the coal reserve tonnes are in the proved and probable categories in accordance with the JORC
Code and SEC standards.
 
Orientation of data in
relation to geological
structure
>
Whether the orientation of sampling achieves unbiased sampling of possible structures and
the extent to which this is known, considering the deposit type.
>
If the relationship between the drilling orientation and the orientation of key mineralised
structures is considered to have introduced a sampling bias, this should be assessed and
reported if material.
>
Drill holes have been vertically drilled.
 
No downhole deviation logs have been collected and it is
therefore not known if the drill holes have deviated away from vertical.
 
Based on the relatively
shallow seam depths, any deviation is expected to be insignificant and immaterial to the geologic
characterization of the Property.
>
The dip of the coal seams is relatively minor, generally 1-2 degrees, and not a material issue for
representation of seam thickness or quality.
Sample security
The measures taken to ensure sample security.
>
Sample handling procedures employed by explorationists follow typical US protocol and should be
adequate to ensure sample security.
Audits or reviews
The results of any audits or reviews of sampling techniques and data.
>
MM&A has reviewed all available geological information for the Properties in developing the
geologic model.
 
Only that data deemed suitable has been used for the purpose of generating the
resource and reserve estimates.
Section 2 Reporting of Exploration Results
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Mineral tenement and
land tenure status
>
Type, reference name/number,
 
location and ownership including agreements or material
issues with third parties such as joint ventures, partnerships, overriding royalties, native title
interests, historical sites, wilderness or national park and environmental settings.
>
The security of the tenure held at the time of reporting along with any known impediments
to obtaining a license to operate in the area.
>
The Coronado coal resources are located within the United States
 
of America in the states of
Virginia; West Virginia; and Pennsylvania.
 
Control of these Properties is governed by multiple
agreements.
>
MM&A has not carried out separate title verification for the coal properties and has not verified
leases, deeds, surveys or other property control instruments pertinent to the subject resources.
 
>
Coronado has represented to MM&A that it controls the mining rights to the coal deposits as
shown on its property maps, and MM&A has accepted these as being a true and accurate
depiction of the mineral rights controlled by Coronado.
 
The TRS assumes the properties are
developed under responsible and experienced management.
>
There are no known legal or environmental encumbrances that would impede development of the
subject coal reserves.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
4
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Exploration done by
other parties
>
Acknowledgment and appraisal of exploration by other parties.
>
The Properties have been extensively explored by subsurface drilling efforts carried out by
numerous entities, most of which were completed prior to acquisition by Coronado.
>
This exploration work was generally performed to prevailing US best practice standards and
deemed adequate for the purposes of this TRS.
 
Geology
>
Deposit type, geological setting and style of mineralisation.
>
The Coronado coal resources are located within the Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins.
>
The coal deposits are Carboniferous in age, being of the Pennsylvanian system with. sedimentary,
stratigraphic deposition.
>
Seam of economic significance typically range between 0.3 meters and 1.8 meters in thickness,
with relatively little structural deformation.
>
Regional structure is typically characterized by gently dipping strata to the northwest at less than
one percent.
Drill hole Information
>
A summary of all information material to the understanding of the exploration results
including a tabulation of the following information for all Material drill holes:
●
easting and northing of the drill hole collar
●
elevation or RL (Reduced Level – elevation above sea level in metres) of the drill hole collar
●
dip and azimuth of the hole
●
down hole length and interception depth
●
hole length.
>
If the exclusion of this information is justified on the basis that the information is not
Material and this exclusion does not detract from the understanding of the report, the
Competent Person should clearly explain why this is the case.
>
MM&A reviewed and entered all pertinent data into a digital geologic database for each Coronado
property.
 
The database consists of thousands of data records, which include drill hole and
supplemental coal seam thickness measurements from outcrop and mine exposures.
 
>
All drill holes in the database are provided with a collar elevation and the State Plane Coordinate
System easting and northing coordinate.
>
After MM&A confirmed proper coal seam thickness and correlation, the seam data was modelled
and compiled into coal resource maps.
>
The maps are provided in the TRS show drill hole locations; however, a tabulation of the individual
data records is not practical to include.
Data aggregation
methods
>
In reporting Exploration Results, weighting averaging techniques, maximum and/or
minimum grade truncations (e.g. cutting of high grades) and cut-off grades are usually
Material and should be stated.
>
Where aggregate intercepts incorporate short lengths of high grade results and longer
lengths of low grade results, the procedure used for such aggregation should be stated and
some typical examples of such aggregations should be shown in detail.
>
The assumptions used for any reporting of metal equivalent values should be clearly stated.
>
If a coal seam has been bench sampled he individual analyses for the coal plies would be weight-
averaged to represent the total of recoverable coal to be included in the quality model.
>
Coal quality summary results have been documented in the TRS.
 
Average coal quality on a per-
seam basis is used to represent the coal resources within a given mining area.
>
Average coal quality for each Coronado complex is provided in Tables 1-1, 1-2 and 1-3 of this TRS.
 
>
No other data aggregations methods are used.
Relationship between
mineralisation widths
and intercept lengths
>
These relationships are particularly important in the reporting of Exploration Results.
>
If the geometry of the mineralisation with respect to the drill hole angle is known, its nature
should be reported.
>
If it is not known and only the down hole lengths are reported, there should be a clear
statement to this effect (e.g. ‘down hole length, true width not known’).
>
Coal thickness values from all coal intersections and down hole geophysical logs are considered to
be vertical thicknesses.
 
Seam dip of approximately 2.0 to 3.0 degrees has little effect on the
vertical thickness of the seam.
Diagrams
>
Appropriate maps and sections (with scales) and tabulations of intercepts should be included
for any significant discovery being reported These should include, but not be limited to a
plan view of drill hole collar locations and appropriate sectional views.
>
Diagrams and maps showing the coal seam intercepts are presented in the TRS.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
5
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Balanced reporting
>
Where comprehensive reporting of all Exploration Results is not practicable, representative
reporting of both low and high grades and/or widths should be practiced to avoid misleading
reporting of Exploration Results.
>
All of the available, qualified exploration data has been included within the tabulations, maps, and
diagrams for this TRS.
>
Both coal thickness and quality data are deemed by MM&A to be reasonably sufficient within the
resource areas. Therefore, there is a reasonable level of confidence in the geologic interpretations
required for coal resource determination based on the available data and the techniques applied
to the data.
Other substantive
exploration data
>
Other exploration data, if meaningful and material, should be reported including (but not
limited to): geological observations; geophysical survey results; geochemical survey results;
bulk samples – size and method of treatment; metallurgical test results; bulk density,
groundwater, geotechnical and rock characteristics; potential deleterious or contaminating
substances.
>
Informational material available from the U.S. Geological Survey and the respective State Surveys
was used to assist in the Resource estimate.
 
Further work
>
The nature and scale of planned further work (e.g. tests for lateral extensions or depth
extensions or large-scale step-out drilling).
>
Diagrams clearly highlighting the areas of possible extensions, including the main geological
interpretations and future drilling areas, provided this information is not commercially
sensitive.
>
Further work is expected to include additional exploration, geotechnical testing, coal quality
analyses, and coal property acquisition.
 
Section 3 Estimation and Reporting of Mineral Resources
(Criteria listed in the preceding section also apply to this section.)
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Database
 
integrity
>
Measures taken to ensure that data has not been corrupted by,
 
for example, transcription or
keying errors, between its initial collection and its
 
use for Mineral Resource estimation
purposes.
>
Data validation procedures used.
>
MM&A confirmed coal seam thickness and correlations in databases used for coal deposit modelling.
 
Representative records were spot-checked for data entry validation.
 
>
Geophysical logs were used wherever available to assist in confirming the seam correlation and to
verify proper seam thickness measurements and recovery of coal samples.
Site
visits
>
Comment on
 
any site
 
visits undertaken
 
by the
 
Competent Person and the outcome of those
visits.
>
If no
 
site visits
 
have been
 
undertaken indicate
 
why this
 
is the case.
>
MM&A is very familiar with the Properties and has conducted multiple site visits and evaluations of
the Property and adjoining properties throughout the years.
>
A site visit to Mon Valley was conducted as recently as December 2023, although there are no
facilities or surface expression of the coal reserves on the Property.
 
Planned surface areas for mine
facilities were viewed.
Geological interpretation
>
Confidence in (or conversely,
 
the uncertainty
 
of) the geological interpretation of the mineral
deposit.
>
Nature of the data used and of any assumptions
 
made.
>
The effect,
 
if any,
 
of alternative
 
interpretations on
 
Mineral Resource estimation.
>
The use of geology in guiding
 
and controlling
 
Mineral Resource estimation.
>
The factors affecting continuity both of grade and geology.
>
Due to the relative structural simplicity of the deposits and the reasonable continuity of the tabular
coal beds, the principal geological interpretation necessary to define the geometry of the coal
deposits is the proper modeling of their thickness and elevation.
 
>
Both coal thickness and quality data are deemed by MM&A to be reasonable within the resource
areas.
 
>
Therefore, there is a reasonable level of confidence in the geologic interpretations required for coal
resource determination based on the available data and the techniques applied to the data.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
6
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Dimensions
>
The extent and variability of the Mineral Resource expressed as length (along strike or
otherwise), plan width, and depth below surface to the upper and lower limits of the Mineral
Resource.
>
The subject coal resource areas mostly exist in discreet, individual deposits of highly variable
dimensions, shapes and depth below the ground surface.
>
Such factors are best depicted in the maps contained in the TRS.
>
Details of the parameters are cited within the TRS and included in the table of Cut-off Parameters
listed in Section 11.1 of the TRS.
 
Estimation
and
modelling techniques
>
The nature and appropriateness
 
of the estimation technique(s) applied and key assumptions,
including treatment of extreme grade values, domaining, interpolation parameters and
maximum distance of extrapolation from data points. If
 
a computer assisted estimation
method was chosen include a description of computer software and parameters used.
>
The availability of check estimates, previous estimates and/or mine production records
 
and
whether the Mineral Resource estimate
 
takes
 
appropriate account
 
of such
 
data.
>
The assumptions made regarding
 
recovery of by-products.
>
Estimation of deleterious elements or other non-grade variables of economic
 
significance (e.g.
sulphur for acid mine drainage characterisation).
>
In the case of
 
block model interpolation, the
 
block size in relation to
 
the average sample
spacing and the search employed.
>
Any assumptions behind modelling of
 
selective mining units.
>
Any assumptions about correlation
 
between variables.
>
Description of how the
 
geological interpretation was
 
used to control the resource estimates.
>
Discussion of basis for using or not
 
using grade cutting or capping.
>
The process of validation,
 
the checking process used, the comparison of
 
model data to drill
hole data, and use of reconciliation data if available.
>
Geological data was imported into Carlson Mining
®
 
(formerly SurvCADD
®
) geological modelling
software in the form of Microsoft
®
 
Excel files incorporating, drill hole collars, seam and thickness
picks, bottom seam elevations and raw and washed coal quality. These data files were validated prior
to importing into the software.
>
Once imported, a geologic model was created.
>
The geological model was verified and reviewed.
 
>
Resources were estimated by defining seam thickness at each point of observation and by defining
resource confidence arcs around the points of observation.
>
Points of observation for Measured and Indicated confidence arcs were defined for all drill holes that
intersected the seam.
 
>
As prescribed by the common United States classification system the following distances from points
of observation were used to define the corresponding Resource category arcs:
-
Inferred Resources – greater than 3,960 feet (1.2 kilometers) but less than 15,840 feet (4.8
kilometers)
-
Indicated Resources – 3,960 feet (1.2 kilometers)
-
Measured Resources – 1,320 feet (0.4 kilometers)
>
The use of the standards commonly used in the United States are appropriate and customary for this
resource jurisdiction and deposition type.
>
MM&A performed a geostatistical analysis test of the Coronado data sets using the Drill Hole Spacing
Analysis (
DHSA
) method to justify coal resource confidence levels.
>
Based on MM&A’s analysis, it would be possible to extend the measured, indicated and inferred arcs
slightly beyond historically accepted practices due to consistent geological settings. The QP’s have
elected not to extend arc distances, introducing a level of conservatism in the coal classification.
Moisture
>
Whether the tonnages are estimated on a dry basis or with natural moisture, and the method
of determination of the moisture content.
>
Coal resource tonnes are presented on a dry, in-situ basis.
>
Reserve tonnes are presented on a moist basis at anticipated product moisture ranging from 4.0 to
6.0 percent. Moisture content based on historic analyses of shipped coal from the region.
Cut-off Parameters
>
The basis of the adopted cut-off grade(s) or quality parameters applied.
>
The cut-off parameters were tailored for each of the Coronado properties to be in accordance with
mining/ processing capabilities and market conditions prevalent at each operation.
>
Examples include minimum recoverable coal thickness, acceptable ash content and wash recovery,
and manageable overburden to coal ratio for surface mineable coal.
>
Details of the parameters are cited within the TRS and included in the table of Cut-off Parameters
listed in Section 11.1 of this TRS.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
7
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
These cut-off parameters have been developed by MM&A based on its experience with the Coronado
properties and other mining operations of the Central and Northern Appalachian coal basin.
 
This
experience includes technical and economic evaluations of numerous properties in the region for the
purposes of determining the economic viability of the subject coal reserves.
Mining factors or
assumptions
>
Assumptions made regarding possible mining methods, minimum mining dimensions and
internal (or, if applicable, external) mining dilution. It is always necessary as part of the process
of determining reasonable prospects for eventual economic extraction to consider potential
mining methods, but the assumptions made regarding mining methods and parameters when
estimating Mineral Resources may not always be rigorous. Where this is the case, this should
be reported with an explanation of the basis of the mining assumptions made.
>
Mining factors such as dilution, mining and washing recovery are variable and have been applied at
the coal deposits at each operation based on site-specific characteristics.
>
Details of the factors are cited within the TRS.
>
Factors that would typically preclude conversion of a coal resource to coal reserve include the
following: inferred resource classification; absence of coal quality; poor mine recovery; lack of access;
insufficient exploration; or uncontrolled surface property for areas of proposed for surface mining.
 
>
While such factors were used to preclude the conversion of a very limited number of coal resources
to coal reserves in this report, the extensive history of mining on the Properties would suggest that
there are reasonable prospects for eventual economic extractions of all coal resources under
favorable market conditions.
Metallurgical factors
 
or
assumptions
>
The basis for assumptions or predictions regarding metallurgical amenability. It is always
necessary as part of the process of determining reasonable prospects for eventual economic
extraction to consider potential metallurgical methods, but the assumptions regarding
metallurgical treatment processes and parameters made when reporting Mineral Resources
may not always be rigorous. Where this is the case, this should be reported with an explanation
of the basis of the metallurgical assumptions made.
>
The products mined from coal resources controlled by Coronado can be sold into high-, mid-, and
low-volatile metallurgical coal markets because of their inherent quality characteristics.
 
>
Run-of-mine production is washed at the coal preparation plants as needed for quality control.
 
>
Coronado may blend production from multiple sources to manage ash and sulfur content along with
the rheological and petrographic characteristics of the shipped products.
 
Environmental factors
 
or
assumptions
>
Assumptions made regarding possible waste and process residue disposal options. It is always
necessary as part of the process of determining reasonable prospects for eventual economic
extraction to consider the potential environmental impacts of the mining and processing
operation.
 
While at this stage the determination of potential environmental impacts,
particularly for a greenfields project, may not always be well advanced, the status of early
consideration of these potential environmental impacts should be reported. Where these
aspects have not been considered this should be reported with an explanation of the
environmental assumptions made.
>
A study completed on behalf of Coronado for Mon Valley has identified a Preferred Site for refuse
disposal at Pangburn with capacity of 22.6 million cubic meters.
 
Estimated requirements for
Pangburn and Shaner combined is 29.7 million tonnes or approximately 13.2 million cubic meters.
 
Permitting for such a facility is anticipated to be achievable.
>
MM&A completed a Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) on the Buchanan property
in April 2016, and on the Logan County and Greenbrier Properties in May 2017 on behalf of
Coronado.
 
Coronado reports not having conducted such a study since the MM&A studies.
 
>
The ESAs completed by MM&A included a site inspection, review of historical records, a database
search of State and Federal regulatory records and interviews to identify potential recognized
environmental conditions (RECs) that may create environmental liability for the sites.
 
>
MM&A identified one REC at Greenbrier associated with stained soil and gravel near a fueling and
maintenance area.
 
Coronado reported to MM&A that satisfactory clean-up efforts were completed
at Greenbrier.
 
>
Based on these former ESAs completed by MM&A, it is MM&A’s opinion that Coronado has a
generally typical coal industry record of compliance with applicable mining, water quality, and
environmental laws.
 
Estimated costs for mine closure, including water quality monitoring during site
reclamation, are included in the TRS financial models.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
8
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Bulk density
>
Whether assumed or determined. If assumed, the basis for the assumptions. If determined, the
method used, whether wet or dry, the frequency of the measurements, the nature, size and
representativeness of the samples.
>
The bulk density for bulk material must have been measured by methods that adequately
account for void spaces (vugs, porosity, etc), moisture and differences between rock and
alteration zones within the deposit.
>
Discuss assumptions for bulk density estimates used in the evaluation process of the different
materials.
>
Laboratory derived seam densities measured in specific gravity were used where available.
 
As
needed, this data was supplemented by estimated seam density values based on the relative
proportion of coal and non-coal material within the seam (typically at 1.30 and 2.25 specific gravity,
respectively).
>
Average seam density was determined for each coal deposit and used to convert coal volumes into
coal tonnage estimates.
Classification
>
The basis for the classification of the Mineral Resources into varying confidence categories.
>
Whether appropriate account has been taken of all relevant factors (i.e. relative confidence in
tonnage/grade estimations, reliability of input data, confidence in continuity of geology and
metal values, quality, quantity and distribution of the data).
>
Whether the result appropriately reflects the Competent
>
Person’s view of the deposit.
>
The Resource has been classified based on suitable distances from points of observations prescribed
in the common United States classification system.
>
The use of the United States standards is appropriate and customary for this resource jurisdiction and
deposition type.
>
MM&A performed a geostatistical analysis test of the Coronado data sets using the Drill Hole Spacing
Analysis (
DHSA
) method.
>
Based on MM&A’s analysis, it would be possible to extend the measured, indicated and inferred arcs
slightly beyond historically accepted practices due to consistent geological settings. The QP’s have
elected not to extend arc distances, introducing a level of conservatism in the coal classification.
>
All relevant factors have been accounted for and reflect the Competent Person’s
 
view of the deposit.
Audits or reviews
>
The results of any audits or reviews of Mineral Resource estimates.
>
MM&A completed prepared a statement of coal resources and reserves for the Properties in
accordance with the JORC Code as of December 31, 2017.
 
MM&A also subsequently updated the
estimate of resources and reserves for depletion as of December 31, 2018, December 31, 2019,
December 31, 2020, December 31, 2021,
 
and December 31, 2022.
>
MM&A performed a previous audit of the Properties in year 2017 for Coronado based on U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Industry Guide 7 and USGS Circular 891 standards.
 
>
Earlier audits were performed by various independent consultants for predecessors-in-title to
Coronado and at various levels of detail depending on the clients concerns and the allotted time for
completion.
 
Previous audits and reviews defined the primary coal resource areas and estimated the
recoverable tonnes for each seam based on the expected mining methods.
 
>
Additionally, MM&A has performed proprietary evaluations for predecessors-in-title to Coronado,
which encompass portions of the Properties included in this TRS.
Discussion of relative
accuracy/ confidence
>
Where appropriate a statement of the relative accuracy and confidence level in the Mineral
Resource estimate using an approach or procedure deemed appropriate by the Competent
Person. For example, the application of statistical or geostatistical procedures to quantify the
relative accuracy of the resource within stated confidence limits, or, if such an approach is not
deemed appropriate, a qualitative discussion of the factors that could affect the relative
accuracy and confidence of the estimate.
>
The statement should specify whether it relates to global or local estimates, and, if local, state
the relevant tonnages, which should be relevant to technical and economic evaluation.
Documentation should include assumptions made and the procedures used.
>
The relative accuracy of and confidence in the coal tonnage and quality estimates provided herein are
judged to be in conformance with current industry best-practices.
 
>
The representation of average coal quality characteristics should be understood to represent a
reasonably representative sampling that is generally indicative of coal quality and does not represent
a statistically rigorous approach to coal quality modeling.
>
Resource estimation has been completed using standard coal estimation methods which are deemed
appropriate for this deposit.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
9
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
These statements of relative accuracy and confidence of the estimate should be compared with
production data, where available.
Section 4 Estimation and Reporting of Ore Reserves
(Criteria listed in the preceding section also apply to this section.)
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Mineral Resource
estimate for conversion
to Ore Reserves
 
>
Description of the Mineral Resource estimate used as a basis for the conversion to an Ore
Reserve.
>
The coal resource estimate was prepared as part of the report Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves in Accordance with JORC Code and United States SEC
Standards as of December 31, 2023 – Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins – Virginia,
West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA – February 2024 prepared by MM&A.
>
The resource estimation criteria were developed by MM&A based on the capabilities of the
mining equipment used within the production model and on industry-accepted standards to
assure that the basic geologic characteristics of the coal resources are in reasonable conformity
with those to be mined and marketed by Coronado.
>
Clear statement as to whether the Mineral Resources are reported additional to, or
inclusive of, the Ore Reserves.
>
Coal resources generally are reported inclusive of the coal reserves.
 
In some cases, resources are
reported in addition to coal reserves.
 
Tables 1-1 and 11-3 of the TRS clearly identify resources
“inclusive of mine plan” from which coal reserves were estimated along with those resources
“exclusive of mine plan” from which no reserves were estimated.
 
Site visits
 
>
Comment on any site visits undertaken by the Competent Person and the outcome of those
visits.
>
MM&A is very familiar with the Properties and has conducted multiple site visits and reserve
evaluations throughout the years.
>
A site visit
 
was conducted to Mon Valley as recently as December 2023 to assess proposed
surface mine facilities areas.
 
Currently there are no mine facilities or surface expression of the
coal reserve on the Property.
Study status
 
>
The type and level of study undertaken to enable Mineral Resources to be converted to Ore
Reserves.
>
A preliminary feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for active and proposed mines.
 
>
The Code requires that a study to at least Pre-Feasibility Study level has been undertaken to
convert Mineral Resources to Ore Reserves. Such studies will have been carried out and will
have determined a mine plan that is technically achievable and economically viable, and
that material Modifying Factors have been considered.
>
This geologic evaluation conducted in accordance with JORC and SEC standards and in
conjunction with the preliminary feasibility study is sufficient to conclude that the surface,
highwall miner and underground coal reserves identified on the Properties are economically
mineable under reasonable expectations of market prices for thermal and metallurgical coal
products, estimated operation costs, and capital expenditures.
>
The pre-feasibility financial models, prepared by MM&A for this TRS, was developed to test the
economic viability of each coal resource area.
>
Proved and probable coal reserve were derived from the defined in-situ coal resource considering
relevant processing, economic (including independent estimates of capital, revenue and cost,
marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors).
Cut-off parameters
>
The basis of the adopted cut-off grade(s) or quality parameters applied.
>
The cut-off parameters were tailored for each of the Coronado properties to be in accordance
with mining/ processing capabilities and market conditions prevalent at each operation.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
10
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
Examples include minimum recoverable coal thickness, acceptable ash content and wash
recovery, and manageable overburden to coal ratio for surface mineable coal.
>
Details of the parameters are cited within the TRS and included in the table of Cut-off Parameters
listed in Section 11.1 of this TRS.
>
These cut-off parameters have been developed by MM&A based on its experience with the
Coronado properties and are typical of mining operations in the Central and Northern
Appalachian coal basin.
 
This experience includes technical and economic evaluations of
numerous properties in the region for the purposes of determining the economic viability of the
subject coal reserves.
Mining factors or
assumptions
 
>
The method and assumptions used as reported in the Pre-Feasibility or Feasibility Study to
convert the Mineral Resource to an Ore Reserve (i.e. either by application of appropriate
factors by optimisation or by preliminary or detailed design).
>
After validating coal seam data and establishing correlations, the thickness and elevation for
seams of economic interest were used to generate a geologic model.
>
A pre-feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for active and proposed mines.
 
MM&A
prepared mine projections and production timing forecasts based on coal seam characteristics.
 
Production timing was carried out from 2024 to depletion (exhaustion) of the coal reserve areas.
>
The choice, nature and appropriateness of the selected mining method(s) and other mining
parameters including associated design issues such as pre-strip, access, etc.
>
The room-and-pillar mining method was selected to model the underground mining resources,
utilizing continuous miners for coal extraction, shuttle cars for production section haulage and
roof bolters for roof control, with the exception that the Buchanan Mine also uses longwall
shearers, armored face conveyors, and hydraulic self-advancing roof support.
 
The resource areas
located above drainage are relatively small and often have irregular boundaries.
The Buchanan
Mine in Buchanan County, Virginia is the only active longwall mine currently being operated by
Coronado.
>
The Coronado underground mining resource areas which are located above-drainage require an
access road and mine access development along the outcrop, whereas below-drainage mines are
accessed via shaft or slope based on other proposed surface infrastructure locations and/or
surface property control.
 
>
The surface mining method selected utilizes highly productive hydraulic shovels, front-end
loaders, large tractors and rock trucks for overburden removal.
 
The mobile equipment spreads
adapt readily to winding coal outcrops for contour surface mining and are effective for point-
removal and area mining applications.
>
Application of highwall and auger mining units is an effective method to recover coal resources
not suitable for underground mining and under excessive cover for surface mining.
>
The assumptions made regarding geotechnical parameters (e.g. pit slopes, stope sizes, etc.),
grade control and pre-production drilling.
>
Mining plans for potential underground mines were developed by MM&A.
 
Pillar stability was
tested by MM&A using the
Analysis of Coal Pillar Stability (ACPS
) program that was developed by
the
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (
NIOSH
)
.
 
>
Coronado must obtain approved mining plans from
United States Department of Labor Mine
Safety and Health Administration (
MSHA
)
that define safety parameters for the highwalls
developed during contour and area mining.
 
MM&A’s planning model does not require input of
specific highwall design parameters, but provides for timing of mining within mine plan polygons
that is representative of the operation performance attained at Central Appalachia surface mines.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
11
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
Highwall and auger mining is conducted under highwalls designed and constructed to meet MSHA
permit requirements.
 
To better assure highwall stability and safety
 
during highwall coal
extraction, MSHA requires that coal fenders, or stumps, be left in place between successive cuts.
Periodic barrier pillars must be left in place as an additional safeguard.
 
MM&A has adjusted the
expected mining recovery for highwall and auger mining resources to reflect highwall stability and
safety requirements.
>
The major assumptions made and Mineral Resource model used for pit and stope
optimisation (if appropriate).
>
Underground Mining Resources:
 
For metallurgical resources, minimum coal seam thickness
extends down to between 0.6 and 1.2 meters and a minimum overburden (depth of cover) of
30.5 meters.
 
A 61-meter horizontal distance is maintained from abandoned mines and sealed or
pillared areas, and a 30-meter horizontal distance is maintained from planned highwall miner
panels.
 
Mine recovery is reduced when a rider coal seam is present within a 1.5- to 3.0-meter
interval above the coal seam.
 
No mining is projected when the interval between overlying and
underlying reserves is less than 12 meters.
>
Surface Mining Resources:
 
For classification as a surface-mineable resource, a seam must be at
least 0.3 meters in thickness as a stand-alone (principal) seam and 0.15 meters in thickness when
less than 0.8 meters from a principal seam.
 
The maximum cumulative area mining strip ratio is
generally 20:1 for thermal coal and 30:1 for metallurgical coal.
 
Some areas were assessed for
their economic viability at higher ratios, and were included as reserves if deemed economic.
 
For
contour surface mining, a minimum of 38-meter bench is provided to support HWM.
>
HWM and Auger Mining Resources: HWM cut depth (penetration) is established at a maximum of
244 meters.
 
The minimum mineable coal thickness is limited at 0.6 meters. For coal seams less
than 0.8 meters thick, roof and/or floor characteristics must allow OSD cutting to maintain a 0.8-
meter minimum cutting height.
Auger mining cut depth is established at an average of 91 meters.
 
The minimum mineable coal thickness is limited at 0.5 meters.
>
The mining dilution factors used.
>
Underground Mining Reserves:
 
The planning model assigns minimum mining heights of 1.4 to 1.8
meters for mains and panel development.
 
At the Buchanan Mine, a minimum mining height of
1.8 meters was used due to the longwall mining method being employed.
 
For coal seams thinner
than the assigned mining height, the difference between the coal seam height and assigned
mining height consists of OSD.
 
In all cases a minimum of 0.05 meters of OSD was assumed, with
the exception of the Mon Valley mines, where a minimum 0.15 meters of OSD was assumed due
to weaker floor strata.
>
Surface Mining Reserves:
 
Area mining is generally limited to a cumulative overburden ratio of
30:1 and a 15:1 ratio for contour mining.
 
Exceptions were considered for mining of metallurgical
grade coal where deemed economical.
 
It is assumed that careful cleaning of exposed coal pits will
result in minimal OSD.
>
HWM and Auger Mining Reserves:
 
The mining plan assumes that the HWM cutting height is a
minimum of 76 to 99 centimeters for clearance purposes.
 
When the coal seam is less than 76 to
99 centimeters thick, OSD is assumed and included in the ROM product.
Because the auger has
very limited OSD cutting ability, it is assumed that an appropriate auger diameter will be chosen
based on the coal seam thickness and that OSD will be minimal.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
12
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
The mining recovery factors used.
>
Underground Mining Reserves:
 
Mine recovery generally varies between 40 and 60 percent for
continuous mining panels, and 100 percent for longwall.
>
Surface Mining Reserves:
 
Mining recovery is 90 percent for virgin areas.
 
Mining recovery is
reduced where second mining is projected in previously underground and auger mined areas.
>
HWM and Auger Mining Reserves:
 
A mine recovery of 40 percent has been applied for HWM.
A
mine recovery of 35 percent has been applied for auger mining.
>
Any minimum mining widths used.
>
Underground Mining Reserves:
 
Typical entry width is 5.8 to 6.1 meters.
>
The manner in which Inferred Mineral Resources are utilised in mining studies and the
sensitivity of the outcome to their inclusion.
>
Proved and probable coal reserve were derived from the defined in-situ coal resource considering
relevant processing, economic (including independent estimates of capital, revenue and cost,
marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors).
>
Mine plan LOM tonnage includes inferred coal and those areas that do not meet the minimum
coal thickness requirement for classification as reserve.
 
Inferred coal represents approximately
0.6% of the LOM production for Mon Valley and 0.000001% of the total LOM production for
Logan.
 
None of this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
>
The infrastructure requirements of the selected mining methods.
>
Underground Mining Resources:
 
The continuous mining method provides for the extraction of
coal from the production faces using continuous miners (and longwall shearing machine at
Buchanan) and haulage using shuttle cars or battery haulers to a feeder-breaker located at the tail
of the section conveyor belt.
 
The feeder-breaker crushes large pieces of coal and rock and
regulates coal feed onto the mine conveyor.
 
A chain conveyor is used to remove coal from the
longwall face at the Buchanan Mine for placement onto the conveyor belt which is ultimately
delivered to an underground storage bunker.
 
Roof-bolting machines are used to install roof bolts,
and battery scoops are available to clean the mine entries and assist in delivery of mine supplies
to work areas.
 
Surface ventilation fans are installed as needed to provide a sufficient volume of
air to ventilate production sections, coal haulage and transport entries, battery charging stations,
and transformers in accordance with approved plans.
>
Coronado currently operates three coal preparation plants, one each at the Buchanan, Logan
County and Greenbrier Divisions.
 
The Buchanan Plant operates at a feed rate of approximately
907 raw tonnes per hour (
tph
), whereas the Saunders Plant (Logan County Division) has a nominal
feed rate of 816 tph, and the Mountaineer Plant (Greenbrier Division) operates at 544 tph.
MM&A has included capital estimates for construction of additional coal preparation plants at the
Russell County and Mon Valley Complex for
 
the purposes of this TRS.
 
>
Surface Mining Resources: The surface mining mobile equipment spreads advance the contour
and area mining pits while systematically reclaiming the trailing side of pits where coal has been
removed.
 
The coal haul roads are extended and maintained as the pits advance.
 
Support
facilities are maintained nearby but away from the active mining, and include storage areas for
blasting agents, fuel and lubricants, and mine supplies along with maintenance facilities and
offices.
 
Most of the surface mine production is transported to a loading point for crushing,
blending and direct-shipment to customers.
 
>
HWM and Auger Resources: The HWM equipment advances along with the contour mining pits.
 
The rate of advance of the contour mining is governed by the advancement rate of the HWM.
 
A
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
13
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
diesel-powered generator trails the highwall miner and powers the continuous mining unit.
 
Other support facilities are provided along with the contour mining support facilities.
 
HWM
production is all transported by truck to the coal preparation plant for washing.
Metallurgical factors or
assumptions
 
>
The metallurgical process proposed and the appropriateness of that process to the style of
mineralisation.
>
Coarse material is washed in a heavy medium vessel.
 
Intermediate-size material is washed in
heavy medium cyclones.
 
Fine material is washed using conventional froth flotation cells.
>
Whether the metallurgical process is well-tested technology or novel in nature.
>
Processes are typical of those used in the coal industry and are in use at adjacent coal processing
plants.
>
The nature, amount and representativeness of metallurgical test work undertaken, the
nature of the metallurgical domaining applied and the corresponding metallurgical recovery
factors applied.
>
The quality characteristics for the subject coal resources and coal reserves have been reviewed in
detail by MM&A.
 
The drill hole data was utilized to develop average coal quality characteristics
mining site.
 
These average coal quality characteristics were then utilized as the basis for
determining the various markets into which the saleable coal will likely be placed.
>
Any assumptions or allowances made for deleterious elements.
>
No significant effects on product quality are anticipated from dilution material; float product
quality was used to model final product quality.
>
The existence of any bulk sample or pilot scale test work and the degree to which such
samples are considered representative of the orebody as a whole
>
No bulk sample or pilot scale work has been completed.
>
For minerals that are defined by a specification, has the ore reserve estimation been based
on the appropriate mineralogy to meet specifications?
>
Notwithstanding the complexity of the coal quality data set, the seams of the central and
northern Appalachian coalfields have a long history of providing both high-Btu thermal coals and
high-, mid- and low-volatile coking coals with favorable metallurgical
 
properties.
Environmental
 
>
The status of studies of potential environmental impacts of the mining and processing
operation. Details of waste rock characterisation and the consideration of potential sites,
status of design options considered and, where applicable, the status of approvals for
process residue storage and waste dumps should be reported.
>
A study completed on behalf of Coronado has identified a Preferred Site for refuse disposal at
Pangburn with capacity of 22.6 million cubic meters.
 
Estimated requirements for Pangburn and
Shaner combined is 29.7 million tonnes or approximately 13.2 million cubic meters.
 
Permitting
for such a facility is anticipated to be achievable
.
>
MM&A completed a Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (
ESA
) on the Buchanan
property in April 2016, and on the Logan County and Greenbrier Properties in May 2017 on behalf
of Coronado.
>
MM&A identified one REC at Greenbrier associated with stained soil and gravel near a fueling and
maintenance area.
 
Coronado reported to MM&A that satisfactory clean-up efforts were
completed at Greenbrier.
>
Based on these former ESAs completed by MM&A, it is MM&A’s opinion that Coronado has a
generally typical coal industry record of compliance with applicable mining, water quality, and
environmental laws.
 
Estimated costs for mine closure, including water quality monitoring during
site reclamation, are included in the TRS financial models.
Infrastructure
 
>
The existence of appropriate infrastructure: availability of land for plant development,
power, water,
 
transportation (particularly for bulk commodities), labour, accommodation;
or the ease with which the infrastructure can be provided or accessed.
>
Coronado currently operates one surface mine (Toney Fork Mine at the Logan Mine Complex);
Coronado also controls the idle Midland Surface Mine at the Greenbrier Mine Complex.
 
>
Coronado operates five underground mines as follows:
 
Buchanan Mine at the Buchanan Mine
Complex; Winifrede, Eagle No. 1, Muddy Bridge and Lower War Eagle Mines in the Logan Mine
Complex; the Mountaineer #1 Mine at the Greenbrier Mine Complex is currently idle.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
14
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
All ROM production is currently planned for either truck transportation from the mines to the
processing or shipping facilities, or in some cases there is either a current or planned mine mouth
preparation plant and barge/rail loading facility.
 
>
There is a network of public highways that provide serviceable coal haul routes and private,
internal roads on the Properties would be developed as may be needed.
 
Rail service to the
Properties is most readily provided by NS and CSX
with connections to both domestic consumers
and international trans-shipment points.
 
NS track is located across the Monongahela River from
the proposed Pangburn Hollow load-out facility.
 
Coal would be shipped to customers via barge
and rail and sold as both metallurgical and thermal products.
 
Costs
 
>
The derivation of, or assumptions made, regarding projected capital costs in the study.
>
The methodology used to estimate operating costs.
>
Coronado provided historical and 5-year budget operating costs for its active mines for MM&A’s
review.
 
MM&A used the historical and/or budget cost information as a reference and developed
personnel schedules for each mine.
 
Hourly labor rates and salaries were based upon information
contained in Coronado’s financial summaries.
 
Fringe benefit costs were developed for vacation
and holidays, federal and state unemployment insurance, retirement, workers’ compensation and
pneumoconiosis, casualty and life insurance, healthcare and bonuses.
 
A cost factor for mine
supplies was developed that relates expenditures to mine advance rates for roof control costs and
other mine supply costs at underground mines.
 
Other factors were developed for maintenance
and repair costs, rentals, mine power, outside services and other direct mining costs.
>
Surface mine direct operating costs were developed as a function of overburden ratio for repair
and maintenance supplies, diesel fuel, explosives and blasting, and miscellaneous supplies and
services.
 
Operating costs for highwall mines are based on costs per ROM tonne estimates.
 
Other
cost factors were developed for coal preparation plant processing, refuse handling, coal loading,
trucking, property taxes, and insurance and bonding.
 
Appropriate royalty rates were assigned for
production from leased coal lands and sales taxes were calculated for state severance taxes, the
federal black lung excise tax, and federal and state reclamation fees.
>
Capital schedules were developed by MM&A for mine development, infrastructure, and on-going
capital requirements for the life of each projected mine.
>
Staffing levels were prepared and operating costs estimated by MM&A for each projected mine.
 
MM&A utilized historical cost data provided by Coronado and its own knowledge and experience
to estimate direct and indirect operating costs.
 
>
Allowances made for the content of deleterious elements.
>
No allowances have been made for deleterious elements; no impact to quality from deleterious
elements is anticipated.
>
The derivation of assumptions made of metal or commodity price(s), for the principal
minerals and co- products.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand
analysis which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with
Coronado’s in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges
and port charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for
various coal markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation
factor in order to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
>
Derivation of transportation charges.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
15
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
analysis which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with
Coronado’s in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges
and port charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for
various coal markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation
factor in order to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
>
The basis for forecasting or source of treatment and refining charges, penalties for failure to
meet specification, etc.
>
MM&A utilized historical cost data provided by Coronado and its own knowledge and experience
to estimate direct and indirect operating costs.
 
All ROM production is currently planned for
either truck transportation from the mines to the processing or shipping facilities, or in some
cases there is either a current or planned mine mouth preparation plant and barge/rail loading
facility.
>
The allowances made for royalties payable, both Government and private.
>
Appropriate royalty rates were assigned for production from leased coal lands and sales taxes
were calculated for state severance taxes,
 
the federal black lung excise tax, and federal and state
reclamation fees.
Revenue factors
 
>
The derivation of, or assumptions made regarding revenue factors including head grade,
metal or commodity price(s) exchange rates, transportation and treatment charges,
penalties, net smelter returns, etc.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is derived
from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand analysis
which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with Coronado’s
in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges and port
charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation factor in order
to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
>
The Greenbrier property is not considered material to Coronado’s business or financial conditions,
and thus no update was completed for Greenbrier in 2024.
 
Resources exclusive of reserves, as
well as reserves, are based on assumed long-term average price as of December 31, 2022 provided
by Coronado, representing Coronado’s long-term average price forecast for
 
Greenbrier at that
time.
>
The derivation of assumptions made of metal or commodity price(s), for the principal
metals, minerals and co-products.
>
Coal sales prices as defined above.
 
All reported reserves are on a marketable basis.
Market assessment
 
>
The demand, supply and stock situation for the particular commodity, consumption trends
and factors likely to affect supply and demand into the future.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand
analysis which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with
Coronado’s in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges
and port charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for
various coal markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation
factor in order to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
>
A customer and competitor analysis along with the identification of likely market windows
for the product.
>
All of the mine production serves metallurgical and thermal markets.
 
The metallurgical coal is
marketed as high-volatile (typically 28 percent or greater volatile matter content); mid-volatile
(typically 23- to 27-percent volatile matter content) and low-volatile (typically less than 23
percent volatile matter content) products.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
16
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
Raw ROM production that requires washing is currently processed through Coronado owned and
operated coal preparation plants.
 
>
ROM coal that does not require further processing is delivered directly to the loading points for
sizing and delivery to customers.
 
Coronado has access to two rail-loading points serviced by the
Norfolk Southern Corporation (
NS
)
 
and two rail-loading points serviced by
CSX Corporation
(
CSX
)
.
>
Price and volume forecasts and the basis for these forecasts.
>
Carlson Mining
®
 
was used by MM&A to generate mine plans for underground-
 
and surface-
mineable coal seams.
 
Underground mine plans were sequenced based on productivity schedules
provided by Coronado, which were based on historically achieved productivity levels.
 
Surface
mine plans were generated under productivity assumptions (bank cubic yard per shift) as
provided by Coronado and reviewed by MM&A, again based heavily on productivity levels
achieved by Coronado.
 
All production forecasting ties assumed production rates to geological
models as constructed independently by MM&A’s team of geologists and mining engineers.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand
analysis which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with
Coronado’s in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges
and port charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for
various coal markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation
factor in order to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
Economic
 
>
The inputs to the economic analysis to produce the net present value (NPV) in the study,
the source and confidence of these economic inputs including estimated inflation, discount
rate, etc.
>
On an unlevered basis, the NPV of the project cash flows after taxes was estimated for the
purpose of classifying coal reserves.
 
The project cash flows, excluding debt service, are calculated
by subtracting direct and indirect operating expenses and capital expenditures from revenue.
 
Direct costs include labor, drilling and blasting, operating supplies, maintenance and repairs,
facilities costs for materials handling, coal preparation, refuse disposal, coal loading, sampling and
analysis services, reclamation and general and administrative costs.
 
Indirect costs include
statutory and legally agreed upon fees related to direct extraction of the mineral.
 
The indirect
costs are the Federal black lung tax, Federal and State reclamation taxes, property taxes,
 
local
transportation prior to delivery at rail or barge loading sites, coal production royalties, sales and
use taxes, income taxes and State severance taxes. Coronado’s
 
historical costs provided a useful
reference for MM&A’s
 
cost estimates.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand
analysis which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with
Coronado’s in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges
and port charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for
various coal markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation
factor in order to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
>
All costs and prices are based on year-end 2023 nominal United States dollars.
>
A pre-feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for active and proposed mines.
 
MM&A
prepared mine projections and production timing forecasts based on coal seam characteristics.
 
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
17
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Production timing was carried out from 2024 to depletion (exhaustion) of the coal reserve areas,
which is projected for the year 2101.
>
The all-mines average cash cost ranges between approximately $73 and $338 per tonne for most
of the operating period.
>
NPV ranges and sensitivity to variations in the significant assumptions and inputs.
>
An estimate of NPV at a base discount rate of 10.0% was included in Section 19 of the TRS.
>
NPV of the Buchanan, Russell, Mon Valley, Logan and Greenbrier Properties was estimated to be
$1.804 billion, $155.1 million, $563.4 million, $616.8 million and
 
$62.7 million, respectively. The
Grenbrier NPV is based on December 31, 2022 coal sales price information provided by Coronado
as described previously.
 
>
The sensitivity study shows the NPV at the 10.0% discount rate when Base Case sales prices,
operating costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased in increments of 5% within a +/-
15% range.
 
Social
 
>
The status of agreements with key stakeholders and matters leading to social license to
operate.
>
Portions of the properties are located near local communities.
 
Regulations prohibit mining
activities within 91 meters of a residential dwelling, school, church, or similar structure unless
written consent is first obtained from the owner of the structure.
 
Where required, such consents
have been obtained where mining is proposed beyond the regulatory limits.
Other
 
To the extent relevant, the impact of the following on the project and/or on the estimation and
classification of the Ore Reserves:
>
Any identified material naturally occurring risks.
>
No material naturally occurring risks have been identified.
>
The status of material legal agreements and marketing arrangements.
>
The Coronado coal resources are located in Buchanan, Russell and Tazewell Counties, Virginia;
Greenbrier, Logan, Boone, Wyoming and Greenbrier Counties, West Virginia; Allegheny,
Washington and Westmoreland Counties, Pennsylvania.
>
MM&A has not carried out separate title verification for the coal properties and has not verified
leases, deeds, surveys or other property control instruments pertinent to the subject resources.
>
Coronado has represented to MM&A that it controls the mining rights to the reserves as shown
on its property maps, and MM&A has accepted these as being a true and accurate depiction of
the mineral rights controlled by Coronado.
 
The TRS assumes the properties are developed under
responsible and experienced management.
>
The status of government agreements and approvals critical to the viability of the project,
such as mineral tenement status and government and statutory approvals. There must be
reasonable grounds to expect that all necessary Government approvals will be received
within the timeframes anticipated in the Pre-Feasibility or Feasibility study. Highlight and
discuss the materiality of any unresolved matter that is dependent on a third part on which
extraction of the reserve is contingent.
>
Coronado has obtained all mining and discharge permits to operate 19 underground mines, 15
surface mines, and 16 processing, loadout or related facilities.
 
MM&A is unaware of any obvious
or current Coronado permitting issues that are expected to prevent the issuance of future
permits.
 
Coronado, along with all Central and Northern Appalachian basin coal producers, is
subject to a level of uncertainty regarding future clean water permits due to
United States
Environmental Protection Agency
(
EPA
)
 
involvement with state programs.
Classification
 
>
The basis for the classification of the Ore Reserves into varying confidence categories.
Whether the result appropriately reflects the Competent Person’s view of the deposit. The
>
Measured and indicated resources have been converted to proved and probable reserves,
respectively.
>
None of the probable coal reserves have been derived from measured resources.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
18
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
proportion of Probable Ore Reserves that have been derived from Measured Mineral
Resources (if any).
>
In a limited number of cases where there was only very limited data available to demonstrate the
metallurgical suitability of a given coal deposit, that deposit was classified as a probable reserve
instead of a proved reserve.
>
The results of this TRS define an estimated total initial ROM recoverable ore (coal) reserve
estimate of 548 million tonnes for Coronado as follows:
a)
 
Buchanan =
 
154 Mt
b)
 
Logan
 
=
 
135 Mt
c)
 
Greenbrier=
 
12 Mt
d)
 
Russell =
 
50 Mt
e)
 
Mon Valley =
 
197 Mt
 
>
Coronado controls a total of 333 Mt (moist basis) of marketable coal reserves for Coronado as of
December 31, 2023 (total may not add due to rounding).
 
Of that total, 74 percent are proved,
and 26 percent are probable.
 
Total reserves by complex are as follows:
a)
 
Buchanan =
 
92 Mt
b)
 
Logan
 
=
 
71 Mt
c)
 
Greenbrier=
 
7 Mt
d)
 
Russell =
 
30 Mt
e)
 
Mon Valley =
 
134 Mt
 
Audits or reviews
 
>
The results of any audits or reviews of Ore Reserve estimates.
>
MM&A completed prepared a statement of coal resources and reserves for the Properties in
accordance with the JORC Code as of December 31, 2017.
 
MM&A also subsequently updated the
estimate of resources and reserves for depletion as of December 31, 2018, December 31, 2019,
December 31, 2020, December 31, 2021,
 
and December 31, 2022.
>
MM&A performed a previous audit of the Properties in year 2017 for Coronado based on
U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission (
SEC
)
 
Industry Guide 7 standards.
 
Earlier audits were
performed by various independent consultants for predecessors-in-title to Coronado and at
various levels of detail depending on the clients concerns and the allotted time for completion.
 
Previous audits and reviews defined the primary coal resource areas and estimated the
recoverable tonnes for each seam based on the expected mining methods.
>
Additionally, MM&A has performed proprietary evaluations for predecessors-in-title to Coronado,
which encompass portions of the Properties included in this TRS.
Discussion of relative
accuracy/ confidence
 
>
Where appropriate a statement of the relative accuracy and confidence level in the Ore
Reserve estimate using an approach or procedure deemed appropriate by the Competent
Person. For example, the application of statistical or geostatistical procedures to quantify
the relative accuracy of the reserve within stated confidence limits, or, if such an approach
is not deemed appropriate, a qualitative discussion of the factors which could affect the
relative accuracy and confidence of the estimate.
>
Operations on the Properties by Coronado and its predecessors have been on-going for many
years.
 
>
MM&A is confident that the mine plans and financial models are reasonably representative to
provide an accurate estimation of coal reserves.
>
Mine development and operation have not been optimized within the TRS.
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
19
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
The statement should specify whether it relates to global or local estimates, and, if local,
state the relevant tonnages, which should be relevant to technical and economic
evaluation. Documentation should include assumptions made and the procedures used.
>
Proved and probable coal reserve were derived from the defined in-situ coal resource considering
relevant processing, economic (including independent estimates of capital, revenue and cost),
marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors on a global scale as
current local data reflects the global assumptions.
>
Accuracy and confidence discussions should extend to specific discussions of any applied
Modifying Factors that may have a material impact on Ore Reserve viability, or for which
there are remaining areas of uncertainty at the current study stage.
The major risk factors for the active Coronado mines and future resource development are summarized
below:
>
Mine Accidents
>
Highwall Failure.
 
Highwall failures are likely to result in a temporary mine closure and should not
have a material impact on the mine sustainability.
 
The risk is considered to be probable.
 
>
Adverse Geological Conditions.
 
Adverse geological conditions include such conditions as faults
and sandstone washouts.
 
The risk is considered to be probable.
 
The impact is expected to be
temporary with little material impact on mine sustainability.
>
Environmental Risk.
 
Numerous federal and state permits are required to operate coal mines and
mine surface facilities. Permitting rules are complex and may change over time, making
compliance difficult or impossible.
>
Water Quality.
 
Permit requirements to fulfill Clean Water Act obligations are subject to
modification.
 
The probability of water quality changes having a material impact on mine
operations is possible.
 
As a contemporary example, the selenium discharge issue that affects
western Canadian and Central Appalachian Basin operators has only recently emerged as a
concern and its ultimate impact has not been determined.
>
New Permits.
 
Permit protests by environmental groups and individuals can contribute to permit
delays or denial and increase the cost of permitting and delay development.
 
Surface mining
activities, coal refuse disposal and construction of access roads in mountainous terrain often
require storage of material in valley fills.
 
Authority to dispose of fill material into waters of the
United States must be granted by the
United States Army Corps of Engineers (
COE
)
.
 
COE permits
are increasingly difficult to obtain.
>
Regulatory Requirements.
 
Adverse impact from regulatory changes is considered to be probable.
 
The impact will likely affect the broader industry and is not expected to result in mine closure.
>
Market Risk.
 
Metallurgical and thermal coal markets ultimately depend upon the global steel and
thermal coal demand and are considered to be volatile.
 
Currently, the US coal market has seen a
decline in demand for thermal coal due to thermal plant closures, as a result of new air and water
pollution regulations, and competition from other commodities used for power generation such
as natural gas.
 
This has resulted in an overall decline in CAPP coal production.
 
Continued
regulatory changes and declining demand could result in material changes in domestic and global
coal markets.
 
The impact cannot be predicted at this time; however, while MM&A expects the
coal reserve within this TRS to remain economically viable throughout the life of the projected
mines, the LOM financial model is very sensitive to changes in coal sales price and therefore
market risk is not insignificant.
>
Labor Risk.
 
Work stoppage due to organized labor protests is considered to be unlikely and not
likely to lead to permanent mine closure.
 
The mines are likely to suffer the loss of key supervisors
 
 
ex962p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
I
NC
.
20
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
and skilled employees due to retirement as the workforce ages.
 
The problem is industry-wide
and the impact is expected to be temporary and have no sustained impact on coal production.
>
Availability of Equipment and Supplies.
 
Risk of equipment and supply availability is likely to be
temporary and should not have a sustained adverse impact on the production of coal.
>
Transportation Delay.
 
Interruption of coal transport services by river or rail is considered to be
probable but unlikely to have a sustained impact on coal production.
>
It is recognised that this may not be possible or appropriate in all circumstances. These
statements of relative accuracy and confidence of the estimate should be compared with
production data, where available.
>
Mine plans, productivity expectations and cost estimates generally reflect historical performance
and efforts have been made to adjust plans and costs to reflect future conditions.
ex963p1i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
February 2024
Prepared for:
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
100 Bill Baker Way
 
Beckley, West
 
Virginia 25801
Prepared by:
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
582 Industrial Park Road
Bluefield, Virginia
 
24605
www.mma1.com
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
Statement of Use and Preparation
This
 
Technical
 
Report
 
Summary
 
(
TRS
)
 
was
 
prepared
 
by
Marshall
 
Miller
 
&
 
Associates,
 
Inc.
(
MM&A
)
 
for the sole
 
use of
Coronado Global Resources
 
Inc. (
Coronado
)
and its affiliated
 
and
subsidiary companies and advisors.
 
Copies or references to information
 
in this report may not
be used without the written permission of Coronado.
This report provides
 
a statement
 
of coal resources
 
and coal reserves
 
for Coronado,
 
as defined
under the
Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore
Reserves
(
JORC Code
) as
 
well as
 
under Subpart
 
1300 of
 
Regulation
 
S-K (Regulation
 
S-K 1300)
promulgated
 
by
the
United
 
States
 
Securities
 
and
 
Exchange
 
Commission
 
(
SEC
)
.
 
Subject
 
to
 
the
comments below,
 
this report was
 
also prepared in
 
accordance with the
Australasian Code for
Public Reporting of Technical
 
Assessments and Valuations of Mineral Assets
(
VALMIN Code
).
 
The
 
statement
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
information
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
reviewed
 
by
Qualified
Persons
 
(
QPs
) who are full-time employees of MM&A.
As noted above,
 
this report is
 
a “Public
 
Report” for
 
the purposes
 
of the
 
VALMIN Code.
 
However,
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
paragraph
 
12.1
 
of
 
the
 
VALMIN
 
Code,
 
it
 
is
 
noted
 
that
 
this
 
report
 
is
 
not
 
a
“Valuation of Mineral Assets
”,
and it also
 
does not comply
 
with the following
 
requirements that
apply to “Technical Assessments” (as defined in the VALMIN
 
Code):
This report does not include a determination of the status
 
of tenure (as required by paragraph
7.2 of the VALMIN Code) on the basis that tenure was separately reviewed by Coronado’s
 
legal
advisors.
This report
 
does not
 
include separate
 
commentary on
 
the reasonableness
 
and quality
 
of the
Resources and Reserves estimates and
 
the basis on
 
which they have
 
been reported (as
 
required
by paragraph
 
7.3 of
 
the VALMIN
 
Code).
 
MM&A did
 
not consider
 
that this
 
was appropriate
 
in
circumstances
 
where
 
MM&A
 
was
 
engaged
 
for
 
the
 
specific
 
purpose
 
of
 
preparing
 
those
estimates.
 
However,
 
MM&A notes that, in accordance with its usual practice, a separate team
of
 
MM&A
 
employees
 
undertook
 
a
 
peer
 
review
 
of
 
this
 
report
 
and
 
confirmed
 
that
 
both
 
the
process followed by the
 
authors of this
 
report and the
 
estimates prepared were reasonable and
comply with the requirements of the JORC Code.
 
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
The
 
information
 
in
 
this
 
TRS
 
related
 
to
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
is
 
based
 
on,
 
and
 
fairly
represents,
 
information
 
compiled
 
by
 
the
 
QPs.
 
At
 
the
 
time
 
of
 
reporting,
 
MM&A’s
 
QPs
 
have
sufficient
 
experience
 
relevant
 
to
 
the
 
style
 
of
 
mineralization
 
and
 
type
 
of
 
deposit
 
under
consideration
 
and
 
to
 
the
 
activity
 
they
 
are
 
undertaking
 
to
 
qualify
 
as
 
a
 
QP
 
as
 
defined
 
by
Regulation S-K 1300 and the JORC Code.
 
Each QP consents to the inclusion in this report of the
matters based on their information
 
in the form and context in which it appears.
Marshall
 
Miller
 
&
 
Associates,
 
Inc.
 
(
MM&A
)
 
hereby
 
consents
 
to
 
the
 
use
 
of
 
the
 
information
contained in this
 
report dated December 31,
 
2023, relating to
 
estimates of coal
 
resources and
coal reserves controlled by Coronado.
 
Qualified
Person:
/s/ Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc.
Date:
February 16, 2024
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
i
Table
 
of Contents
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
ii
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
iii
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
iv
Figures (in Report)
Tables
 
(in Report)
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
v
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
vi
Appendices
A...............................................................................................................................MM&A
Qualifications
B.........................................................................................................................................................M
aps
C.....................................................................................................................................Glossary of
Terms
D..........................................................Initial Economic Assessment for Resources
 
Exclusive of
Reserves
E.............................................................................................................................................JORC
Table 1
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
1
Executive Summary
1.1
 
Property Description
Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
(
Coronado
)
authorized
 
Marshall
 
Miller
 
&
 
Associates,
 
Inc.
(
MM&A
)
 
to prepare
 
this Technical
 
Report Summary (TRS)
 
of its controlled
 
coal resources
 
and
reserves located at
 
the
Logan County
 
Complex (
Logan
)
 
in Boone,
 
Logan and
 
Wyoming Counties,
West Virginia
 
(the
Property
).
 
This TRS updates the TRS titled,
 
"
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement
 
of Coal
 
Resources
 
and Reserves
 
for the
 
Logan County
 
Complex
 
in Accordance
 
with
the
 
JORC
 
Code
 
and
 
United
 
States
 
SEC
 
Regulation
 
S-K
 
1300
 
as
 
of
 
December 31,
 
2022
 
Central
Appalachian Coal
 
Basin West
 
Virginia, USA
 
February 2023
,"
 
dated
 
February 15,
 
2023,
 
due to
material
 
differences
 
in
 
the
 
key
 
financial
 
modifying
 
factors
 
including
 
coal
 
sales
 
price
assumptions, operating costs and capital costs
 
from December 31, 2022
 
to December 31, 2023.
 
Coal sales
 
price assumptions
 
are discussed
 
in
 
Sections 12
 
and 16
 
of the
 
TRS, while
 
operating
costs and capital
 
costs are discussed
 
in
Sections 18
 
and 19
 
of the TRS.
 
A portion
 
of the resources
defined in the February 2023 TRS
 
were converted
 
to reserves as discussed in
Section 11
of the
current TRS.
 
The report provides a
 
statement of coal resources and
 
coal reserves for Coronado,
as
 
defined
 
under
 
the
Australasian
 
Code
 
for
 
Reporting
 
of
 
Exploration
 
Results,
 
Mineral
Resources
 
and
 
Ore
 
Reserves
(
JORC
 
Code
)
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
under
 
Subpart
 
1300
 
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K
(Regulation S-K 1300) promulgated
 
by the
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
(
SEC
)
.
 
This
 
report
 
was
 
also
 
prepared
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
the
Australasian
 
Code
 
for
 
Public
Reporting of Technical
 
Assessments and Valuations of Mineral Assets
(
VALMIN Code
).
Coal resources
 
and coal reserves
 
are herein
 
reported in
 
metric units of
 
measurement and
 
are
rounded to millions of metric tonnes (
Mt
).
Surface facilities for
 
the operations are
 
located along Buffalo
 
Creek and a
CSX Corporation (
CSX
)
rail
 
line
 
about
 
21
 
kilometers
 
north-northeast
 
of
 
Man,
 
West
 
Virginia
 
(see
Figure
 
1-1
).
 
The
Property
 
is
 
composed
 
of
 
13,183
 
total
 
hectares,
 
13,114
 
of
 
which
 
are
 
leased
 
from
 
private
landholders under approximately 15
 
individual leases,
 
and 69
 
hectares are owned
 
by Coronado.
 
Subject to Coronado exercising its renewal rights thereunder, a majority of the leases, covering
a majority of the Logan reserves, expire upon exhaustion of the
 
relevant coal reserves, which is
expected to occur in 2057.
 
One lease expires in 2032; however,
 
Coronado is projected to have
previously exhausted the reserves covered
 
thereby.
 
 
ex963p2i0 ex963p11i2 ex963p11i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
Figure 1-1:
 
Coronado Logan Property Location Map
1.2
 
Ownership
The Logan properties started mining in 1945 by
Lorado Mining Company
.
 
The properties
were
sold to
Buffalo Mining Company
 
in 1964 and then
 
to
Pittston Coal Company (
Pittston
)
 
in 1971.
 
Pittston operated the properties until the
 
early 1990’s when it idled
 
the mine complex
 
and then
in
 
2004
 
sold
 
them
 
to
Addington
 
Resources
.
 
Production
 
resumed
 
in
 
2005.
 
Imagin
 
Natural
Resources
 
acquired the
 
properties in
 
2007 and then
 
sold them to
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
 
(
Cliffs
)
in 2011, which in turn sold the properties to Coronado in 2014.
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
1.3
 
Geology
The coal-bearing
 
formation of
 
interest
 
at Logan
 
is primarily
 
the Kanawha
 
Formation of
 
Lower
Pennsylvanian
 
System, which
 
comprises a major
 
portion of the
 
exposed ridges.
 
The Kanawha
Formation
 
is
 
a
 
coal
 
bearing
 
sequence
 
of
 
sandstones,
 
siltstones,
 
shales,
 
and
 
mudstones
 
with
minor occurrences of siderite, limestone and flint clay.
 
Coronado
mines
 
several
 
coal
 
horizons
 
within
 
the
 
Kanawha
 
formation.
 
The
 
horizons
 
are
 
as
follows:
 
Buffalo
 
Creek,
 
Upper
 
Clarion
 
Rider,
 
Clarion,
 
Lower
 
Clarion,
 
Upper
 
Stockton,
 
Lower
Stockton, Upper Coalburg, Lower Coalburg,
 
Lower Dorothy, Upper Winifrede, Lower Winifrede,
Chilton-A, Chilton, Upper Cedar
 
Grove, Middle Cedar Grove,
 
Lower Cedar Grove,
 
2 Gas, Upper
Powellton,
 
Lower
 
Powellton,
 
Eagle,
 
and
 
Lower
 
War
 
Eagle.
 
Operations
 
at
 
the
 
Logan
 
Mine
Complex extract multiple coal seams by both underground and surface
 
mining methods.
1.4
 
Exploration Status
The Property has been extensively explored, largely by drilling with continuous coring methods
and
 
rotary
 
drilling,
 
often
 
supported
 
by
 
downhole
 
geophysical
 
methods.
 
In
 
addition
 
to
exploration
 
means,
 
coal
 
measurements
 
from
 
mine
 
exposures
 
have
 
supplemented
 
the
database.
 
The
 
majority
 
of
 
the
 
data
 
was
 
acquired
 
or
 
generated
 
by
 
previous
 
owners
 
of
 
the
Property.
 
These sources comprise
 
the primary data
 
used in the
 
evaluation of the
 
coal resources
and coal reserves on the Property.
 
MM&A examined the data available
 
for the evaluation and
incorporated
 
all
 
pertinent
 
information
 
into
 
this
 
TRS.
 
Where
 
data
 
was
 
anomalous
 
or
 
not
representative,
 
that
 
data
 
was
 
not
 
honored
 
within
 
the
 
digital
 
databases
 
and
 
for
 
subsequent
processing by MM&A.
 
Ongoing
 
exploration
 
has
 
been
 
carried
 
out
 
by
 
Coronado
 
since
 
acquiring
 
the
 
Logan
 
Complex.
 
Exploration data acquired from Coronado
 
has been consistent with past drilling activities.
 
1.5
 
Operations and Development
As of December 31, 2023, underground mine
 
operations were active at Lower War Eagle, Eagle
No. 1 and Muddy Bridge
 
Mines with three, three
 
and two active mining
 
sections, respectively,
using the room-and-pillar method.
 
The North Fork Winifrede Mine was fully depleted in 2023.
 
The Powellton
 
No. 1
 
Mine was
 
in process
 
of being
 
rehabilitated
 
and had
 
minimal production
during the fourth quarter of 2023, with
 
plans to initiate full production with one
 
mining section
in the
 
first
 
quarter
 
of 2024.
 
Annual deep
 
mine production
 
peaks
 
at approximately
 
2.6 Mt
 
in
2033.
 
Two
 
active
 
surface
 
mines,
 
Toney
 
Fork
 
and
 
Elklick
 
(Buffalo
 
Creek
 
South),
 
were
 
also
operating.
 
Surface
 
production
 
is
 
projected
 
to
 
peak
 
at
 
0.7
 
Mt
 
in
 
2028.
 
Highwall
 
miner
production
 
is
 
also
 
projected
 
to
 
resume
 
in
 
2024
 
with
 
a
 
peak
 
in
 
2047
 
at
 
0.54
 
Mt.
 
Overall
production will continue until 2057 with peak production occurring in 2033 at 3.5 Mt.
The Logan
 
County Complex
 
includes the
 
Saunders Preparation
 
Plant in
 
addition to
 
the mines.
 
The
 
plant
 
site
 
includes
 
raw
 
coal
 
storage,
 
clean
 
coal
 
storage,
 
a
 
railroad
 
loadout,
 
and
 
refuse
disposal area.
 
The plant has a feed rate capacity of 1,088 raw
 
tonnes per hour.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
4
1.6
 
Mineral Resource
Mineral resources,
 
representing in-situ
 
coal from
 
a portion of
 
which reserves
 
are derived,
 
are
presented
 
below.
 
A
 
coal
 
resource
 
estimate,
 
summarized
 
in
Table
 
1-1
,
 
was
 
prepared
 
as
 
of
December 31, 2023, for property controlled by Coronado.
Table 1-1:
 
Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Coal Resource (Dry Tonnes, In Situ, MT)
Resource Quality (Dry)
Area
Measured
Indicated
Inferred
Total
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Inclusive of Reserves
133.9
35.8
0.0
169.7
17
1.0
31
Exclusive of Reserves
39.2
35.9
3.4
78.5
Total 12/31/2023
173.1
71.7
3.4
248.3
Note:
 
Resource tonnes are inclusive
 
of reserve tonnes
 
since they include
 
the in-situ tonnes
 
from which recoverable coal
 
reserves are derived.
Note 2:
 
Coal resources are reported on a dry basis.
 
Surface moisture and inherent moisture are excluded.
Note 3: The Property has 75.1 Mt of dry, in-place measured and indicated resource tonnes exclusive of reserves as of December 31, 2023.
1.7
 
Mineral Reserve
Reserve
 
tonnage
 
estimates
 
provided
 
herein
 
report
 
coal
 
reserves
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
in-situ
resource
 
tons
 
presented
 
in
Table
 
1-1
,
 
and
 
not
 
in
 
addition
 
to
 
coal
 
resources.
 
Proven
 
and
probable
 
coal
 
reserves
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
coal
 
resource
 
considering
 
relevant
mining, processing,
 
infrastructure, economic (including estimates
 
of capital, revenue, and
 
cost),
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
 
socio-economic
 
and
 
regulatory
 
factors.
 
The
 
Resource
estimate
 
has
 
been
 
used as
 
the
 
basis for
 
this Reserve
 
calculation,
 
which utilizes
 
a
 
reasonable
Preliminary
 
Feasibility
 
Study,
 
a
 
Life-of
 
Mine
 
(
LOM
)
 
Mine
 
Plan
 
and
 
practical
 
recovery
 
factors.
 
Production modeling was completed with an effective start date of October 1, 2023.
 
Additions
and depletion have been used to bring the Reserve estimate forward
 
to December 31, 2023.
Factors
 
that
 
would
 
typically
 
preclude
 
conversion
 
of
 
a
 
coal
 
resource
 
to
 
coal
 
reserve,
 
which
include
 
the
 
following:
 
inferred
 
resource
 
classification;
 
absence
 
of
 
coal
 
quality;
 
poor
 
mine
recovery;
 
lack
 
of
 
access;
 
geological
 
encumbrances
 
associated
 
with
 
overlying
 
and
 
underlying
strata;
 
seam
 
thinning;
 
structural
 
complication;
 
and
 
insufficient
 
exploration,
 
have
 
all
 
been
considered.
 
Reserve consideration excludes
 
those portions of the resource area
 
which exhibit
the aforementioned geological and operational encumbrances.
 
Coal reserves are presented on
a run-of-mine (
ROM
) basis in
Table 1-2.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
5
Table
 
1-2:
 
Coal Summary (ROM Basis (Moist)) as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Mt, Moist ROM)
Quality (Dry)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area / Mine
Proved
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Ash
Sulfur
Vol
Logan Mine Complex
104.1
30.5
134.6
37.0
97.6
0.0
134.6
49
0.9
19
Proven
 
and
 
probable
 
coal
 
reserve
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
in-situ
 
coal
 
resource
considering
 
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
technical
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue
and cost), marketing, legal,
 
environmental, socio-economic, and regulatory factors.
 
The proven
and probable coal reserves on the Property are summarized below in
Table 1-3.
Table 1-3:
 
Coal Reserves Summary (Marketable Sales Basis) as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet Ton
 
nes, Washed or Direct Shipped, MT)
Quality (Dry Basis)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Property
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Logan County Complex
54.9
15.7
70.6
32.2
38.4
0.0
70.6
8
0.9
35
Note: Marketable
 
reserve tonnes
 
are reported
 
on a
 
moist basis,
 
including a
 
combination of
 
surface and
 
inherent moisture.
 
The combination
 
of
surface and inherent moisture is
 
modeled between 4.5 and
 
6-percent, depending upon mining
 
method.
 
Actual product moisture is dependent
upon multiple geological
 
factors, operational
 
factors, and
 
product contract
 
specifications and can
 
exceed 8-percent.
 
As such, the
 
modeled
moisture values provide a level of conservatism for reserve reporting.
In summary,
 
Coronado controls
 
a total of
 
70.6 Mt (moist basis)
 
of marketable
 
coal reserves at
Logan
 
as
 
of
 
December 31,
 
2023.
 
Of
 
that
 
total,
 
78
 
percent
 
are
 
proven,
 
and
 
22
 
percent
 
are
probable.
 
All
 
70.6 Mt
 
are
 
leased
 
coal
 
reserves
 
and
 
are
 
assigned.
 
Approximately
 
62.2
 
Mt
 
of
reserves are considered
 
suitable for the
 
metallurgical coal market
 
and 8.4 Mt are
 
projected to
be sold into the thermal coal market.
 
1.8
 
Capital Summary
Coronado
 
provided
 
MM&A
 
with
 
an
 
inventory
 
of
 
operating
 
equipment
 
available
 
at
 
Logan.
 
MM&A’s capital schedules assume
 
that major
 
equipment rebuilds occur
 
over the
 
course of
 
each
machine’s
 
remaining
 
assumed operating
 
life.
 
Replacement
 
equipment was
 
scheduled
 
based
on
 
MM&A’s
 
experience
 
and
 
knowledge
 
of
 
mining
 
equipment
 
and
 
industry
 
standards
 
with
respect
 
to
 
the
 
useful
 
life
 
of
 
such
 
equipment.
 
A
 
summary
 
of
 
the
 
estimated
 
capital
 
for
 
the
Property is provided in
Figure 1-2
 
below.
 
 
ex963p2i0 ex963p15i2 ex963p15i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
6
Figure 1-2:
 
CAPEX
1.9
 
Operating Costs
Coronado provided historical and preliminary
 
5-year projections of operating
 
costs for its active
mines
 
for
 
MM&A’s
 
review.
 
MM&A
 
used
 
the
 
historical
 
and/or
 
budget
 
cost
 
information
 
as
 
a
reference
 
and developed
 
personnel schedules
 
for each
 
mine.
 
Hourly labor
 
rates
 
and salaries
were
 
based
 
upon
 
information
 
contained
 
in
 
Coronado’s
 
financial
 
summaries.
 
Fringe
 
benefit
costs
 
were
 
developed for
 
vacation
 
and holidays,
 
federal
 
and state
 
unemployment insurance,
retirement,
 
workers’
 
compensation
 
and
 
pneumoconiosis,
 
casualty
 
and
 
life
 
insurance,
healthcare and bonuses.
For
 
the
 
underground
 
operations,
 
a
 
cost
 
factor
 
for
 
mine
 
supplies
 
was
 
developed
 
that
 
relates
expenditures
 
to
 
mine
 
advance
 
rates
 
for
 
roof
 
control
 
costs
 
and
 
other
 
mine
 
supply
 
costs
 
at
underground mines.
 
Other factors were
 
developed for maintenance
 
and repair costs,
 
rentals,
mine power,
 
outside services and other direct mining costs.
 
Surface mine direct operating costs
 
were developed as a
 
function of overburden ratio
 
for repair
and maintenance supplies, diesel fuel, explosives and blasting, and miscellaneous supplies and
services.
Operating costs for highwall mines are based
 
on costs per ROM tonne estimates.
Operating costs
 
factors were
 
also developed
 
for the
 
coal preparation
 
plant processing,
 
refuse
handling, coal loading, property taxes, and insurance and bonding.
 
 
ex963p2i0 ex963p16i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
7
Appropriate royalty
 
rates were
 
assigned for production
 
from leased coal
 
lands and sales taxes
were
 
calculated
 
for
 
state
 
severance
 
taxes,
 
the
 
federal
 
black
 
lung excise
 
tax,
 
and
 
federal
 
and
state reclamation fees.
A summary of the projected operating costs for the Property
 
is provided in
Figure 1-3
.
Figure 1-3:
 
OPEX
1.10
 
Economic Evaluation
The pre-feasibility
 
financial model
 
prepared for
 
this TRS
 
was developed
 
to test
 
the economic
viability
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
resource
 
area.
 
The
 
results
 
of
 
this
 
financial
 
model
 
are
 
not
 
intended
 
to
represent
 
a bankable
 
feasibility
 
study,
 
required
 
for
 
financing of
 
any
 
current
 
or future
 
mining
operations
 
contemplated
 
for
 
the
 
Coronado
 
properties,
 
but
 
are
 
intended
 
to
 
establish
 
the
economic viability of the estimated coal reserves.
 
Cash flows are simulated on an annual basis
in year-end
 
2023 nominal dollars
 
assuming a 2%
 
inflation rate
 
based on projected
 
production
from
 
the
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
The
 
discounted
 
cash
 
flow
 
analysis
 
presented
 
herein
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
an
effective date of January 1, 2024.
 
On
 
an
 
un-levered
 
basis,
 
the
 
net
 
present
 
value
 
(
NPV
)
 
of
 
the
 
project
 
cash
 
flow
 
after
 
taxes
represents the
 
Enterprise Value
 
of the project.
 
The project
 
cash flow,
 
excluding debt
 
service,
is
 
calculated
 
by
 
subtracting
 
direct
 
and
 
indirect
 
operating
 
expenses
 
and
 
capital
 
expenditures
from revenue.
 
Direct costs include
 
labor, operating supplies, maintenance and
 
repairs, facilities
cost
 
for
 
materials
 
handling,
 
coal
 
preparation,
 
refuse
 
disposal,
 
coal
 
loading,
 
reclamation
 
and
general and administrative costs.
 
Indirect costs include statutory and legally agreed upon fees
related
 
to direct
 
extraction
 
of the
 
mineral.
 
The indirect
 
costs
 
are the
 
Federal
 
black lung
 
tax,
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
8
Federal
 
and
 
State
 
reclamation
 
taxes,
 
property
 
taxes,
 
coal
 
production
 
royalties,
 
and
 
income
taxes.
 
Table 1-4
 
shows LOM
 
tonnage, profit &
 
loss (
P&L
), and
 
earnings before income
 
tax, depreciation
& amortization (
EBITDA
) for Logan.
Table 1-4:
 
Life-of-Mine Tonnage,
 
P&L before Tax,
 
and EBITDA ($000)
LOM
LOM
P&L
LOM
EBITDA
Tonnes
*
Pre-Tax P&L
Per Tonne
EBITDA
Per Tonne
Deep Mines
 
 
 
 
 
Camp Br Chilton
1,607
$61,067
$38.00
$92,000
$57.24
Ramaco N2G
1,519
$38,659
$25.45
$84,549
$55.66
Eagle No. 1 (Toney Fork)
10,962
$177,450
$16.19
$344,402
$31.42
Elk Lick Chilton
3,809
$184,040
$48.32
$250,250
$65.70
Lower Powellton
5,095
$216,991
$42.59
$328,684
$64.51
Lower War Eagle
5,731
$230,836
$40.28
$336,103
$58.65
Powellton No. 1
3,474
$37,743
$10.86
$142,820
$41.11
Muddy Br No.2 Gas
2,713
$43,531
$16.05
$83,882
$30.92
Upper Winifrede
1,438
$89,318
$62.11
$113,233
$78.74
Lower Winifrede
2,091
$83,351
$39.86
$118,042
$56.45
Winifrede (Chilton Rider)
**
-
$(1,302)
$-
$(1,302)
$-
Consolidated Deep Mines
38,439
$1,161,684
$30.22
$1,892,665
$49.24
 
Surface Mines
Toney Fork Surf
6,313
$184,154
$29.17
$367,638
$58.23
Buffalo Cr South Area
7,673
$125,604
$16.37
$279,578
$36.44
Sugar Camp Area 1
4,912
$(11,563)
$(2.35)
$149,696
$30.47
Surface Mines Consolidated
18,899
$298,195
$15.78
$796,912
$42.17
 
HWM Operations
Toney Fork HWM
4,919
$468,937
$95.33
$488,239
$99.25
Buffalo Cr South HWM
7,004
$624,409
$89.15
$648,796
$92.63
Sugar Camp HWM
1,328
$117,241
$88.27
$128,692
$96.90
HWM Consolidated
13,251
$1,210,588
$91.36
$1,265,728
$95.52
 
Grand Total
70,589
$2,670,467
$37.83
$3,955,305
$56.03
* The Financial model includes 0.001 million tonnes of inferred
 
coal production.
 
Inferred coal represents 0.000001%
 
of
the total production, and none of this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
** The Winifrede (Chilton Rider) was depleted in the 4th quarter of 2023.
As shown in
Table
 
1-4,
 
the Logan operations show
 
positive EBITDA over the LOM.
 
Overall, the
Coronado consolidated operations show positive LOM P&L and LOM EBITDA of $2.7 billion and
$4.0 billion,
 
respectively.
 
Coronado’s
 
consolidated Logan
 
cash flow summary in
 
nominal dollars assuming a
 
2% inflation
rate, excluding debt
 
service, is shown in
Table 1-5
 
below.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
9
Table 1-5:
 
Project Cash Flow Summary ($000)
*
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
Total
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
Production & Sales tonnes
70,589
2,543
2,696
2,702
2,526
2,399
Total Revenue
$12,974,983
$373,206
$396,734
$393,101
$373,074
$362,422
EBITDA
$3,955,305
$77,551
$87,738
$84,030
$62,398
$58,012
Net Income
$2,228,588
$26,894
$36,861
$31,587
$14,764
$12,933
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$3,424,770
$51,951
$77,858
$77,752
$62,427
$53,137
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(1,170,916)
$(50,053)
$(33,920)
$(40,038)
$(22,171)
$(21,683)
Net Cash Flow
$2,253,854
$1,897
$43,938
$37,714
$40,256
$31,454
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2029
2030
2031
2032
2033
2034
Production & Sales tonnes
2,850
3,138
3,064
3,243
3,562
3,025
Total Revenue
$458,804
$514,757
$513,368
$553,202
$619,064
$522,816
EBITDA
$139,605
$158,273
$150,615
$185,698
$215,324
$154,820
Net Income
$79,578
$89,148
$85,572
$111,984
$132,364
$84,624
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$106,155
$135,115
$135,231
$153,748
$177,944
$149,613
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(76,046)
$(58,438)
$(33,904)
$(37,120)
$(64,965)
$(78,661)
Net Cash Flow
$30,109
$76,677
$101,328
$116,628
$112,979
$70,953
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
2040
Production & Sales tonnes
2,996
3,323
3,481
3,308
2,953
2,659
Total Revenue
$527,811
$597,215
$638,225
$618,446
$562,910
$517,016
EBITDA
$133,825
$186,994
$205,149
$190,958
$163,745
$150,046
Net Income
$67,184
$112,148
$121,122
$101,624
$83,396
$79,543
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$124,743
$156,490
$174,943
$171,838
$153,628
$138,325
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(74,607)
$(44,478)
$(63,118)
$(74,744)
$(52,178)
$(35,077)
Net Cash Flow
$50,136
$112,012
$111,825
$97,094
$101,449
$103,248
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
2046
Production & Sales tonnes
2,061
1,821
2,124
1,504
1,147
1,149
Total Revenue
$403,182
$362,533
$432,405
$310,415
$239,824
$245,029
EBITDA
$132,897
$113,992
$163,646
$115,279
$82,962
$84,911
Net Income
$80,858
$69,151
$103,893
$67,062
$56,130
$56,391
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$121,947
$105,404
$131,578
$111,482
$78,873
$73,990
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(18,189)
$(33,880)
$(32,406)
$(16,899)
$(22,623)
$(17,389)
Net Cash Flow
$103,758
$71,523
$99,172
$94,583
$56,250
$56,601
 
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
10
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2047
2048
2049
2050
2051
2052
Production & Sales tonnes
1,152
1,151
1,147
1,145
1,150
1,151
Total Revenue
$250,477
$255,353
$259,457
$264,205
$270,675
$276,402
EBITDA
$86,985
$88,741
$90,123
$91,953
$94,720
$96,464
Net Income
$57,379
$57,306
$56,385
$55,409
$56,916
$58,687
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$75,029
$76,216
$77,221
$78,584
$80,464
$81,827
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(13,999)
$(16,432)
$(20,924)
$(24,880)
$(17,227)
$(16,997)
Net Cash Flow
$61,029
$59,784
$56,296
$53,704
$63,237
$64,830
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2053
2054
2055
2056
2057
2058
Production & Sales tonnes
1,149
1,016
809
437
11
-
Total Revenue
$281,461
$254,502
$207,028
$116,946
$2,919
$-
EBITDA
$98,676
$83,364
$68,788
$54,740
$2,282
$-
Net Income
$59,804
$46,844
$35,921
$45,217
$(3,918)
$(1,177)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$83,397
$75,074
$63,550
$31,102
$(5,848)
$(7,880)
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(19,175)
$(21,624)
$(8,199)
$(5,725)
$(3,148)
$-
Net Cash Flow
$64,222
$53,450
$55,351
$25,378
$(8,996)
$(7,880)
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2059
2060
2061
2062
2063
2064
Production & Sales tonnes
-
-
-
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Income
$(607)
$(317)
$(70)
$(0)
$(0)
$(0)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$(4,019)
$(3,221)
$(895)
$-
$-
$-
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$(4,019)
$(3,221)
$(895)
$-
$-
$-
* The
 
Financial model includes
 
0.001 million tonnes of
 
inferred coal
 
production.
 
Inferred coal
 
represents 0.000001%
 
of the total
 
production, and
none of this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
Consolidated cash flows are driven by annual sales tonnage, which at steady-state
 
level ranges
from
 
a
 
peak
 
of
 
3.6 million
 
tonnes
 
in
 
2033
 
to
 
a
 
low
 
of
 
0.4 million
 
tonnes
 
in
 
2056.
 
Projected
consolidated revenue
 
ranges from $116.9 million to
 
$638.2 million at a steady state.
 
Revenue
totals $13.0 billion for the project’s
 
life.
Consolidated cash flow from operations is positive throughout the projected operating
 
period,
with
 
the
 
exception
 
of
 
post-production
 
years,
 
due
 
to
 
end-of-mine
 
reclamation
 
spending.
 
Consolidated cash flow
 
from operations
 
peaks at $177.9 million
 
in 2033 and totals
 
$3.4 billion
over the
 
project’s life.
 
Capital expenditures
 
total $167.9 million
 
from 2024
 
through 2028
 
and
$1.2 billion over the project’s life.
 
1.10.1
 
Discounted Cash Flow Analysis
Cash
 
flow
 
after
 
tax,
 
but
 
before
 
debt
 
service,
 
generated
 
over
 
the
 
life
 
of
 
the
 
project
 
was
discounted
 
to
 
NPV
 
at
 
a
 
10.0%
 
discount
 
rate,
 
which
 
represents
 
Coronado’s
 
estimate
 
of
 
the
nominal
 
dollar,
 
risk
 
adjusted
 
weighted
 
average
 
cost
 
of
 
capital
 
(
WACC
)
 
for
 
likely
 
market
participants if
 
the subject
 
reserves were
 
offered
 
for sale.
 
On an
 
un-levered basis,
 
the NPV
 
of
the
 
project
 
cash
 
flows
 
represents
 
the
 
Enterprise
 
Value
 
of
 
the
 
project
 
and
 
amounts
 
to
$616.8 million.
 
The pre-feasibility financial
 
model prepared for
 
the TRS was developed
 
to test
the economic viability of each
 
coal resource area.
 
The NPV estimate was made for the purpose
of confirming the
 
economics for
 
classification of coal
 
reserves and not
 
for purposes of
 
valuing
Coronado
 
or
 
its
 
Logan
 
assets.
 
Mine
 
plans
 
were
 
not
 
optimized,
 
and
 
actual
 
results
 
of
 
the
operations may be different,
 
but in all cases, the mine production plan assumes the properties
are under competent management.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
ex963p20i2 ex963p20i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
11
1.10.2
 
Sensitivity Analysis
Sensitivity of the NPV results to changes in the key drivers is presented in the chart
 
below.
 
The
sensitivity
 
study
 
shows
 
the
 
NPV
 
at
 
the
 
10.0%
 
discount
 
rate
 
when
 
Base
 
Case
 
sales
 
prices,
operating costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased in increments of 5% within a +/-
15% range.
Figure 1-4:
 
Sensitivity of NPV
As
 
shown,
 
NPV
 
is quite
 
sensitive
 
to
 
changes
 
in sales
 
price and
 
operating
 
cost
 
estimates,
 
and
slightly sensitive to changes in capital cost estimates.
1.11
 
Permitting
Coronado
 
has
 
obtained
 
all
 
mining
 
and
 
discharge
 
permits
 
to
 
operate
 
its
 
active
 
mines
 
and
processing, loadout or
 
related support facilities.
 
MM&A is unaware
 
of any obvious
 
or current
Coronado permitting issues that
 
are expected to prevent the
 
issuance of
 
future permits.
 
Logan,
along with
 
all coal
 
producers, is
 
subject to
 
a level
 
of uncertainty
 
regarding
 
future clean
 
water
permits due to
United States
 
Environmental
 
Protection Agency
(
EPA
)
 
and
United States
 
Fish
and Wildlife (
USFW
)
 
involvement with state progr
 
ams.
1.12
 
Conclusion and Recommendations
Sufficient
 
data
 
has
 
been
 
obtained
 
through
 
various
 
exploration
 
and
 
sampling
 
programs
 
and
mining operations to support the
 
geological interpretations of seam structure and
 
thickness for
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
12
coal horizons
 
situated on
 
the Logan
 
Property.
 
The data
 
is of sufficient
 
quantity and
 
reliability
to reasonably support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates
 
in this TRS.
The geological data
 
and preliminary
 
feasibility study, which consider mining
 
plans, revenue, and
operating and capital cost estimates
 
are sufficient to support the classification of coal reserves
provided herein.
This
 
geologic
 
evaluation
 
conducted
 
in
 
conjunction
 
with
 
the
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
study
concludes
 
that
 
the
 
70.6
 
Mt
 
of
 
marketable
 
coal
 
reserves
 
identified
 
on
 
the
 
Property
 
are
economically mineable
 
under reasonable
 
expectations
 
of market
 
prices for
 
metallurgical
 
coal
products, estimated operation costs,
 
and capital expenditures.
2
Introduction
2.1
 
Registrant and Terms
 
of Reference
This report
 
was prepared
 
for the
 
sole use of
Coronado Global
 
Resources Inc.
 
(
Coronado
)
and
its affiliated and subsidiary
 
companies and advisors.
 
This TRS updates
 
the TRS titled,
 
"
Coronado
Global Resources Inc. Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the Logan County Complex
in
 
Accordance
 
with
 
the
 
JORC
 
Code
 
and
 
United
 
States
 
SEC
 
Regulation
 
S-K
 
1300
 
as
 
of
December 31, 2022
 
Central Appalachian Coal
 
Basin West
 
Virginia, USA
 
February 2023
," dated
February 15, 2023, due
 
to material
 
differences
 
in the key
 
financial modifying factors
 
including
coal
 
sales
 
price
 
assumptions,
 
operating
 
costs
 
and
 
capital
 
costs
 
from
 
December 31,
 
2022
 
to
December 31, 2023.
 
Coal sales
 
price assumptions
 
are discussed
 
in
 
Sections 12
 
and 16
 
of the
TRS, while operating costs and capital costs are discussed in
Sections 18 and 19
 
of the TRS.
 
The
report provides a statement of coal
 
resources and coal reserves
 
for Coronado, as defined under
the
Australasian
 
Code
 
for
 
Reporting
 
of
 
Exploration
 
Results,
 
Mineral
 
Resources
 
and
 
Ore
Reserves
(
JORC Code
) as
 
well as
 
under Subpart
 
1300 of
 
Regulation
 
S-K (Regulation
 
S-K 1300)
promulgated by the
United States Securities and Exchange Commission (
SEC
)
.
 
This report was
also
 
prepared
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
the
Australasian
 
Code
 
for
 
Public
 
Reporting
 
of
 
Technical
Assessments and Valuations of Mineral Assets
(
VALMIN Code
).
The
 
report
 
provides
 
a
 
statement
 
of coal
 
resources
 
and
 
coal
 
reserves
 
for
 
Coronado
 
at
 
Logan.
 
Exploration results and Resource calculations were used as the basis for the mine planning and
the preliminary feasibility study completed to
 
determine the extent and viability
 
of the reserve.
Coal resources
 
and coal reserves
 
are herein
 
reported in
 
metric units of
 
measurement and
 
are
rounded to millions of metric tonnes (
Mt
).
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
13
2.2
 
Information Sources
This TRS
 
is based
 
on information
 
provided
 
by Coronado
 
and reviewed
 
by MM&A.
 
Sources
 
of
data and information are listed below in
Table 2-1
:
Table 2-1:
 
Information Provided to MM&A by Coronado
Category
Information Provided by Coronado
Report Section
Geological
Geologic data including digital databases
 
and original source data including
geologist logs, driller’s logs, geophysical
 
logs
9.1
Coal Quality
Database of coal quality information
 
supplemented with original source
laboratory sheets where available
10.1
Mining
Historical productivities and manpower
 
from operating and future
 
Coronado
mines
13.2, 13.4
Coal
Preparation
Flow sheet and other information representing
 
current and future methods
of coal processing
 
14.1
Waste
Disposal
Engineering data and estimates representing
 
remaining capacities for coarse
and fine coal waste disposal
17.2
Costs
Historical and budgetary operating
 
cost information used to derive
 
cost
drivers for reserve financial modeling
18.2
Economic
WACC and inflation rate
 
used in discounted cash flow analysis
19.1, 19.2, 19.3
Note: While the sources
 
of data listed
 
in Table
 
2-1 are not
 
exhaustive, they represent
 
a significant portion
 
of information which
 
supports this TRS.
 
MM&A
 
reviewed
 
the
 
provided
 
data
 
and
 
found
 
it
 
to
 
be
 
reasonable
 
prior
 
to
 
incorporating
 
it
 
into
 
the
 
TRS.
 
The
 
TRS
 
contains
 
“forward-looking
information” including
 
forecasts
 
of productivity
 
and annual
 
coal production,
 
operating and
 
capital cost
 
estimates, coal
 
sales price
 
forecasts,
 
the
assumption that
 
Coronado
 
will
 
continue
 
to
 
acquire
 
necessary permits,
 
and
 
other assumptions.
 
The
 
TRS
 
statements
 
and
 
conclusions
 
are
 
not
 
a
guarantee of future performance and undue reliance should not be placed on them.
 
The ability of Coronado to recover the estimated coal reserves
is dependent on multiple factors beyond the
 
control of MM&A including, but not
 
limited to geologic factors, mining conditions, regulatory approvals,
and changes in regulations.
 
In all cases, the plans assume the Property is under competent management.
Coronado engaged MM&A to
 
conduct a coal resource and reserve
 
evaluation of the Coronado
coal properties
 
as of September 30,
 
2023. In the process,
 
additions (mine data)
 
and depletion
(mine) have been used
 
to bring the Resource
 
and Reserve estimates
 
forward to December
 
31,
2023, the effective
 
date of this
 
TRS for
 
Logan.
 
For the evaluation,
 
the following
 
tasks were
 
to
be completed:
 
>
Conduct site visits of the mines and mine infrastructure facilities;
 
>
Process
 
the
 
information
 
supporting
 
the
 
estimation
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
into
geological models;
 
>
Develop life-of-reserve mine
 
(
LOM
) plans and financial models;
>
Hold discussions with Coronado company management; and
 
>
Prepare and
 
issue a TRS providing
 
a statement
 
of coal resources
 
and reserves which
 
would
include:
-
A description of the mines and facilities.
 
-
A description of the evaluation process.
-
An estimation of
 
coal resources
 
and reserves with compliance
 
elements as stated
 
under
the JORC Code and the SEC Regulation S-K 1300.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
ex963p23i2 ex963p23i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
14
2.3
 
Personal Inspections
MM&A is very
 
familiar with Logan, having provided a
 
variety of services
 
in recent years and one
of the QP’s involved in this TRS has conducted
 
multiple site visits.
3
Property Description
3.1
 
Location
The Logan County
 
Complex is located
 
in Logan, Boone,
 
and Wyoming Counties
 
in southern
 
West
Virginia.
 
The Property
 
encompasses the
 
towns of
 
Lorado and
 
Pardee
 
in the
 
northern portion
and
 
Lacoma
 
and
 
Cyclone
 
in
 
the
 
southern
 
portion
 
(approximately
 
6
 
kilometers
 
between
 
the
northern
 
and
 
southern towns).
 
The
 
nearest
 
major population
 
centers
 
are
 
Huntington,
 
West
Virginia
 
(145
 
kilometers
 
northwest)
 
and
 
Charleston,
 
West
 
Virginia
 
(129
 
kilometers
 
north-
northeast).
Figure 3-1:
 
Logan Property Location
The Logan
 
property is
 
composed of
 
13,183 total
 
leased and
 
owned hectares
 
and is
 
located in
Logan, Boone, and Wyoming
 
Counties.
 
The Property is located on
 
the following
United States
Geological
 
Survey
(
USGS
) Quadrangles:
 
Lorado,
 
Mallory,
 
Amherstdale,
 
and
 
Oceana.
 
Current
mining
 
projections
 
fall
 
within
 
portions
 
of
 
all
 
four
 
quadrangles.
 
The
 
coordinate
 
system
 
and
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
15
datum
 
used
 
for
 
the
 
model
 
of
 
the
 
Logan
 
County
 
Complex
 
and
 
the
 
subsequent
 
maps
 
were
produced in the West Virginia State
 
Plane South system, NAD 27.
3.2
 
Titles, Claims or Leases
The
 
Property
 
is composed
 
of
 
13,183 total
 
hectares,
 
13,114
 
of which
 
are leased
 
from
 
private
landholders under approximately 15
 
individual leases,
 
and 69
 
hectares are owned
 
by Coronado.
The latest Coronado lease of
 
45 hectares was obtained in
 
2022.
 
Subject to Coronado exercising
its
 
renewal
 
rights
 
thereunder,
 
a
 
majority
 
of
 
the
 
leases,
 
covering
 
a
 
majority
 
of
 
the
 
Logan
reserves,
 
expire
 
upon exhaustion
 
of the
 
relevant
 
coal reserves,
 
which is
 
expected
 
to occur
 
in
2057.
 
One lease expires in
 
2032; however, Coronado is projected to have previously exhausted
the reserves
 
covered thereby.
 
MM&A has
 
not carried
 
out a
 
separate title
 
verification for
 
the
coal
 
properties
 
and
 
has
 
not
 
verified
 
leases,
 
deeds,
 
surveys,
 
or
 
other
 
property
 
control
instruments pertinent
 
to the
 
subject resources.
 
Property tenure
 
was separately
 
reviewed
 
by
Coronado’s
 
legal
 
advisors.
 
Coronado
 
has
 
represented
 
to
 
MM&A
 
that
 
it
 
controls
 
the
 
mining
rights to the reserves
 
as shown on its property maps,
 
and MM&A has accepted these
 
as being
a true and
 
accurate depiction
 
of the mineral
 
rights controlled
 
by Coronado.
 
The TRS assumes
the properties are developed under responsible and experienced management.
3.3
 
Mineral Rights
Coronado
 
supplied property
 
control
 
maps
 
to
 
MM&A related
 
to properties
 
for
 
which mineral
and/or
 
surface
 
property
 
are
 
controlled
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
While
 
MM&A
 
accepted
 
these
representations
 
as
 
being
 
true
 
and
 
accurate,
 
MM&A
 
has
 
no
 
knowledge
 
of
 
past
 
property
boundary
 
disputes
 
or
 
other
 
concerns,
 
through
 
past
 
knowledge
 
of
 
the
 
Property,
 
that
 
would
signal concern over future mining operations or development potential.
Property control in Appalachia can be intricate.
 
Coal mining properties are typically composed
of numerous property tracts
 
which are owned
 
and/or leased from
 
both land
 
holding companies
and
 
private
 
individuals
 
or
 
companies.
 
It
 
is
 
common
 
to
 
encounter
 
severed
 
ownership,
 
with
different
 
entities or
 
individuals controlling
 
the surface
 
and mineral
 
rights.
 
Mineral
 
control
 
in
the region is typically characterized by leases or ownership of larger tracts of land,
 
with surface
control generally comprised of smaller tracts, particularly
 
in developed areas.
Legal
 
mining
 
rights
 
may
 
reflect
 
a
 
combination
 
of
 
in
 
fee
 
or
 
mineral
 
ownership
 
and
 
in
 
fee
 
or
mineral
 
leases of
 
coal lands
 
through
 
various surface
 
and mineral
 
lease agreements.
 
There is
also a relatively small amount of area where the coal is partially-owned
 
and/or partially leased
on a limited number of individual tracts.
 
Control of
 
the surface property
 
is necessary to
 
conduct surface mining
 
but is not necessary
 
to
conduct underground mining.
Upon
 
acquisition
 
of
 
mineral
 
control
 
for
 
desired
 
coal
 
seams
 
of
 
surface-mineable
 
economic
interest,
 
it
 
is
 
typical
 
practice
 
in
 
the
 
region
 
for
 
operators
 
to
 
delay
 
the
 
acquisition
 
of
 
surface
control
 
for
 
purposes
 
of
 
surface
 
mining
 
and
 
other
 
surface
 
development
 
until
 
plans
 
are
established for
 
near-future
 
development.
 
Therefore,
 
it is
 
common for
 
an operator
 
to control
mineral
 
for
 
proposed
 
areas
 
of
 
mining
 
for
 
which
 
they
 
have
 
not
 
established
 
the
 
legal
 
right
 
to
surface mine due to
 
the lack of surface
 
control.
 
Acquisition of these rights
 
is typically delayed
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
16
in order
 
to limit
 
cost and
 
royalty
 
payments
 
for
 
areas not
 
under consideration
 
for near-future
development.
 
Coronado’s
 
executive
 
management
 
team
 
has
 
a
 
history
 
of
 
surface
 
mining
 
in
Central Appalachia and has conveyed to MM&A that it has been successful in acquiring surface
rights where needed for past operations.
3.4
 
Encumbrances
No Title Encumbrances are known.
 
By assignment, MM&A did not complete a query
 
related to
Title Encumbrances.
 
3.5
 
Other Risks
There
 
is
 
always
 
risk
 
involved
 
in
 
property
 
control.
 
As
 
is
 
common
 
practice,
 
Coronado,
 
and
 
its
predecessors,
 
have
 
had
 
their
 
legal
 
teams
 
examine
 
the
 
deeds
 
and
 
title
 
control
 
in
 
order
 
to
minimize the risk.
 
Historically, property control has not
 
posed any significant
 
challenges related
to Logan’s
 
operations.
 
4
Accessibility, Climate, Local Resources,
Infrastructure and Physiography
4.1
 
Topography,
 
Elevation, and Vegetation
Topography
 
of
 
the
 
area
 
surrounding
 
the
 
Logan
 
County
 
Complex
 
is
 
typical
 
of
 
the
 
Central
Appalachian Plateau, being
 
rugged and
 
deeply dissected
 
by v-shaped river
 
valleys, and generally
flanked
 
by steeply
 
sided upland
 
regions, with
 
occasional gentle
 
slopes in
 
select areas
 
such as
river valleys.
 
The drainage system in the region tends to be mostly dendritic in
 
nature.
 
Surface
elevations
 
near
 
the
 
mine
 
complex
 
range
 
from
 
approximately
 
823
 
meters
 
above
 
sea
 
level
 
in
upland regions
 
to roughly
 
338 meters
 
at stream
 
level.
 
The Property
 
is moderately
 
to heavily
vegetated, with oak-hickory forests
 
as the dominant forest type and northern hardwood forest
being
 
less
 
prominent.
 
The
 
Property
 
is
 
not
 
situated
 
near
 
any
 
major
 
urban
 
centers,
 
and
 
the
surrounding area is rural.
4.2
 
Access and Transport
Access
 
to
 
the
 
Logan
 
Mine
 
property
 
consists
 
of
 
primary,
 
secondary,
 
and
 
unimproved
 
roads,
forming a well-developed
 
transportation network.
 
Highway 119 is
 
the primary highway in
 
the
area
 
running
 
southwest
 
to
 
northeast
 
from
 
the
 
Kentucky-West
 
Virginia
 
line
 
through
 
Mingo,
Logan, and
 
Boone Counties.
 
Secondary roads
 
Route 16
 
and Route
 
10 provide
 
the most direct
access
 
through
 
the
 
Property
 
running
 
east-west
 
across
 
the
 
leased
 
area.
 
Numerous
 
other
secondary and unimproved roads
 
provide direct access
 
to the mine
 
property, some being state-
and
 
county-maintained.
 
These
 
roads
 
typically
 
stay
 
open
 
throughout
 
the
 
year.
 
Additionally,
private access roads to existing mines
 
provide transport corridors, and more such
 
roads may be
developed
 
as needed.
 
The
 
Coronado-owned
 
Saunders
 
Preparation
 
Plant services
 
the mines.
 
The ROM coal is delivered from the
 
Lower War Eagle Mine via overland conveyor, all remaining
production is or will be delivered to the plant site by truck.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
17
4.3
 
Proximity to Population Centers
The Logan property lies near the town
 
of Lorado in Logan County, West Virginia, approximately
145 kilometers southeast of Huntington,
 
West Virginia and 129 kilometers
 
south-southwest of
Charleston, West Virginia.
 
As of 2021, Logan County had a
 
population of approximately 31,900
residents, Boone County had 21,300 residents, and Wyoming
 
County had 21,000 residents.
 
4.4
 
Climate and Length of Operating Season
The
 
region’s
 
climate
 
is
 
classified
 
as
 
humid,
 
sub-tropical
 
with
 
four
 
distinct
 
seasons:
 
warm
summers, cold winters, and
 
moderate fall and spring
 
seasons.
 
Precipitation in the
 
region occurs
throughout
 
the
 
year
 
with
 
the
 
most
 
rain
 
falling
 
in
 
spring
 
and
 
the
 
early
 
months
 
of
 
summer.
 
Average
 
yearly rainfall
 
is 67.69
 
centimeters.
 
Summer months
 
typically begin
 
in late
 
May and
end in
 
early September and
 
range
 
in average
 
temperature
 
from 53
 
to 84
 
degrees Fahrenheit
(or 11.6 to 28.9 degrees Celsius).
 
Winters typically begin in mid to late November and run until
mid to
 
late March with
 
average
 
temperatures
 
ranging from
 
26 to
 
57 degrees
 
Fahrenheit
 
(or -
3.3 to 13.9 degrees Celsius).
 
Precipitation in the winter typically comes in the form of snowfall
or
 
as
 
a
 
wintery
 
mix
 
(sleet
 
and
 
snow)
 
with
 
severe
 
snowfall
 
events
 
occurring
 
occasionally.
 
Seasonal
 
variations
 
in
 
climate
 
typically
 
do
 
not
 
affect
 
underground
 
mining
 
in
 
West
 
Virginia.
 
However,
 
weather
 
events
 
could
 
potentially
 
incumber
 
surface
 
mining
 
and
 
preparation
 
plant
operations on a very limited basis, typically lasting less than a few days.
4.5
 
Infrastructure
The Logan Mine
 
Complex has sources
 
of water, power,
 
personnel, and supplies
 
readily available
for use.
 
Personnel have historically been sourced from the surrounding communities in Logan,
Boone, Wyoming, and Mingo counties, and have proven to be adequate in numbers to operate
past
 
and
 
current
 
mines.
 
As
 
mining
 
is
 
common
 
in
 
the
 
surrounding
 
areas,
 
the
 
workforce
 
is
generally familiar with mining practices and is comprised of
 
a strong talent pool of experienced
miners.
 
Water
 
is
 
sourced
 
locally
 
from
 
Buffalo
 
Creek
 
Public
 
Service
 
District
 
and
 
electricity
 
is
sourced from
American Electric Power (
AEP
)
.
 
The service industry
 
in the areas
 
surrounding the
mine complex
 
has historically
 
provided
 
supplies, equipment
 
repairs
 
and fabrication,
 
etc.
 
The
Coronado-owned Saunders Preparation
 
plant services the mines and operates
 
at a rate
 
of 952
tph.
 
The
 
Coronado-owned
 
Elk Lick
 
Loadout
 
serves as
 
the primary
 
means of
 
shipment
 
and
 
is
connected to a CSX rail line,
 
which either serves the
 
domestic market directly, or transports the
coal to the Pier 9 and Dominion terminals at Norfolk, Virginia for overseas
 
shipment.
5
History
5.1
 
Previous Operation
The Logan
 
County properties
 
were
 
started
 
in 1945
 
by
Lorado Mining
 
Company
, were
 
sold to
Buffalo
 
Mining
 
Company
 
in
 
1964
 
and
 
then
 
to
Pittston
 
Coal
 
Company
 
(
Pittston
)
 
in
 
1971.
 
Pittston
 
operated
 
the
 
properties
 
until
 
the
 
early
 
1990’s.
 
After
 
being
 
idle
 
for
 
a
 
period,
 
the
properties were then
 
sold to
Addington Resources
 
in 2004.
 
Imagin Natural Resources
 
acquired
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
18
the
 
properties
 
in
 
2007,
 
and
 
subsequently
 
sold
 
them
 
to
 
Cliffs
 
in
 
2011,
 
which
 
in
 
turn
 
sold
 
the
properties to Coronado in 2014.
Coronado
 
produced
 
approximately
 
1.8 Mt
 
in 2016,
 
2.6 Mt
 
in 2017,
 
2.6 Mt
 
in 2018,
 
2.7 Mt
 
in
2019, 1.6 Mt in 2020, 1.9 Mt in 2021, 2.1 Mt in 2022, and 2.5 Mt in 2023.
5.2
 
Previous Exploration
The
 
Properties
 
have
 
been
 
extensively
 
explored
 
by
 
subsurface
 
drilling
 
efforts
 
carried
 
out
 
by
numerous entities, most of which were completed prior to acquisition by Coronado.
Drill records indicate that independent
 
contract drilling operators
 
have typically been engaged
to carry out drilling on the Properties.
 
Geophysical logging was typically performed by outside
logging firms.
 
MM&A, via its Geophysical Logging Systems
 
subsidiary,
 
has in the past logged a
significant number
 
of exploration
 
holes and
 
gas wells,
 
and currently
 
logs most
 
of the recently
drilled holes.
6
Geological Setting, Mineralization and Deposit
6.1
 
Regional, Local and Property Geology
The
 
Property
 
lies
 
in
 
the
 
Central
 
Appalachian
 
Coal
 
basin
 
in
 
the
 
Appalachian
 
Plateau
physiographic province.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0 ex963p28i2 ex963p28i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
19
Figure 6-1:
 
Coal Basins & Logan Property Location
Coal deposits in the eastern USA are the oldest and most
 
extensively developed in the country.
 
The
 
coal
 
deposits
 
on
 
the
 
Properties
 
are
 
Carboniferous
 
in
 
age,
 
being
 
of
 
the
 
Pennsylvanian
system.
 
Overall,
 
these
 
Carboniferous
 
coals
 
contain
 
two-fifths
 
of
 
the
 
USA’s
 
bituminous
 
coal
deposits
 
and
 
extend
 
over
 
1,448
 
kilometers
 
from
 
northern
 
Alabama
 
to
 
Pennsylvania
 
and
 
are
part
 
of
 
what
 
is
 
known
 
as
 
the
Appalachian
 
Basin
.
 
The
 
Appalachian
 
Basin
 
is
 
more
 
than
 
402
kilometers
 
wide
 
and,
 
in
 
some
 
portions,
 
contains
 
over
 
60
 
coal
 
seams
 
of
 
varying
 
economic
significance.
Within the Central Appalachian Basin, seams of economic significance typically range
 
between
0.3 meters
 
and 1.8
 
meters in
 
thickness, with
 
relatively
 
little structural
 
deformation.
 
Regional
structure
 
is typically
 
characterized
 
by gently
 
dipping strata
 
to the
 
northwest
 
at less
 
than one
percent.
The
 
coal-bearing
 
formations
 
of
 
interest
 
at
 
Logan
 
is
 
of
 
the
 
lower
 
section
 
of
 
the
 
Kanawha
Formation, which comprise a major portion of
 
the exposed ridges.
 
The coal-bearing Formation
includes
 
sedimentary sequences
 
of sandstones,
 
siltstones, shales,
 
and mudstones
 
with minor
occurrences of siderite, limestone and flint clay.
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
20
Coronado
mines several coal seams
 
within the Kanawha formation.
 
The seams are as follows:
Buffalo
 
Creek,
 
Upper
 
Clarion
 
Rider,
 
Clarion,
 
Lower
 
Clarion,
 
Upper
 
Stockton,
 
Lower
 
Stockton,
Lower Coalburg, Lower
 
Dorothy,
 
Upper Winifrede, Lower Winifrede,
 
Chilton-A, Chilton, Upper
Cedar
 
Grove,
 
Middle
 
Cedar
 
Grove,
 
Lower
 
Cedar
 
Grove,
 
No.
 
2
 
Gas,
 
Upper
 
Powellton,
 
Lower
Powellton, Eagle, and Lower War
 
Eagle seams demonstrate mining potential on this property.
Logan in
 
2023 had two
 
active surface
 
mines and four
 
active underground
 
mines.
 
The Elk Lick
(Buffalo
 
Creek South)
 
and Toney
 
Fork mines
 
are surface
 
mines, while
 
the Eagle
 
No. 1,
 
Muddy
Bridge and Lower War Eagle are underground mines.
 
The North Fork Winifrede Mine was fully
depleted
 
in
 
2023.
 
The
 
Powellton
 
No.
 
1
 
Mine
 
was
 
in
 
process
 
of
 
being
 
rehabilitated
 
and
 
had
minimal production
 
during the fourth
 
quarter 2023, with
 
plans to initiate
 
full production
 
with
one
 
mining
 
section
 
in
 
the
 
first
 
quarter
 
of
 
2024.
 
The
 
active
 
Toney
 
Fork
 
surface
 
mine
 
has
historically
 
mined
 
multiple
 
seams
 
including
 
the
 
Upper
 
Winifrede,
 
Lower
 
Winifrede,
 
Upper
Clarion Rider,
 
Upper Clarion, Lower Clarion, Lower Coalburg, Upper
 
Coalburg, Upper Stockton,
Lower Stockton, Chilton-A, and Lower Dorothy Seams.
 
Future surface mine reserve production
at Logan
 
is anticipated
 
to focus
 
on those
 
seams having
 
the best
 
opportunity for
 
sale into
 
the
metallurgical coal
 
markets, namely the Lower
 
Coalburg seam and below.
 
The Powellton
 
No. 1
Mine is projected to extract
 
the Lower and Upper Powellton
 
jointly in some areas, while other
areas are projected to extract only the Lower Powellton
 
due to seam splitting.
 
The Eagle No. 1
and Muddy
 
Bridge Mines
 
are projected
 
to extract
 
the No.
 
2 Gas
 
seam.
 
The Lower
 
War
 
Eagle
mine is projected to extract the Lower War
 
Eagle seam.
 
6.2
 
Mineralization
The
 
generalized
 
stratigraphic
 
columnar
 
section
 
in
Figure
 
6-1
 
demonstrates
 
the
 
vertical
relationship of the principal coal seams and rock formations on the Property.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
ex963p30i2 ex963p30i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
21
Figure 6-2:
 
Logan Stratigraphic Column
(not to scale)
6.3
 
Deposits
The
 
coal
 
produced
 
at
 
Logan
 
Mine
 
complex
 
is
 
typically
 
high-volatile
 
(typically
 
28
 
percent
 
or
greater
 
volatile matter
 
content) bituminous
 
coal.
 
Seam quality
 
varies with
 
distance from
 
the
cropline,
 
so
 
some
 
seams
 
will
 
be
 
shipped
 
into
 
both
 
the
 
thermal
 
and
 
metallurgical
 
markets
depending
 
on
 
mining
 
method
 
and
 
ultimate
 
quality.
 
Saleable
 
product
 
from
 
the
 
surface
operations is projected
 
to be sold primarily into the
 
metallurgical coal market;
 
however,
 
some
production
 
is
 
planned
 
to
 
be
 
sold
 
into
 
the
 
thermal
 
coal
 
market
 
due
 
to
 
quality
 
limitations.
 
Underground coal is sold almost exclusively
 
in the metallurgical markets.
7
Exploration
7.1
 
Nature and Extent of Exploration
The
 
Properties
 
have
 
been
 
extensively
 
explored
 
by
 
subsurface
 
drilling
 
efforts
 
carried
 
out
 
by
numerous entities, most of which were completed prior to acquisition by Coronado.
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
22
Diamond core,
 
rotary,
 
and gas
 
well drilling
 
are the
 
three primary
 
types of
 
exploration
 
on the
Property.
 
Drill hole collar elevations and
 
total depths vary by hole
 
due to the hilly
 
terrain of the
Property.
 
Data
 
for
 
correlation
 
and
 
mining
 
conditions
 
are
 
derived
 
from
 
core
 
descriptions
 
and
geophysical
 
logging
 
(e-logging).
 
Coal
 
quality
 
analyses
 
were
 
also
 
employed
 
during
 
the
 
core
exploration
 
process.
 
A total
 
of 1,133
 
core and
 
rotary
 
holes have
 
been drilled
 
for
 
exploration
purposes on and around the leased property.
In 2023, Coronado completed one exploration
 
hole, along the Toney
 
Fork drainage and for the
Lower War Eagle Mine reserve area,
 
which has been incorporated herein.
 
Drill records indicate that independent
 
contract drilling operators
 
have typically been engaged
to carry
 
out drilling
 
on the
 
Property.
 
Geophysical
 
logging was
 
typically performed
 
by outside
logging firms.
 
MM&A, via its Geophysical
 
Logging Systems subsidiary,
 
has logged a
 
significant
number
 
of
 
the
 
past
 
exploration
 
holes
 
and
 
gas
 
wells,
 
and
 
currently
 
logs
 
most
 
of
 
the
 
recently
drilled holes.
The location of the drilling is shown on the maps included in
Appendix B
.
The concentration of exploration
 
varies slightly across the Property.
 
Drilling on the Property is
typically
 
sufficient
 
for
 
delineation
 
of
 
potential
 
surface,
 
highwall
 
miner,
 
and
 
deep
 
mineable
benches.
 
Core logging
 
is performed
 
by professional
 
geologists
 
in cases
 
where
 
roof and
 
floor
strata
 
are of
 
particular interest
 
and in
 
cases where
 
greater
 
resolution and
 
geologic detail
 
are
needed.
 
Even
 
so,
 
most of
 
the drill
 
hole data
 
comes from
 
more simplified
 
driller’s logs,
 
which
often
 
lack
 
specific
 
details
 
regarding
 
geotechnical
 
conditions
 
and
 
specific
 
geology,
 
making
correlations and floor and roof conditions more difficult to determine.
 
Geophysical logging (e-
logging)
 
techniques,
 
by contrast,
 
document
 
specific details
 
useful
 
for
 
geologic
 
interpretation
and mining conditions.
 
Given the variability
 
of data-gathering
 
methods,
definitive
 
mapping of
future mining
 
conditions may
 
not be
 
possible, but
 
projections and
 
assumptions can
 
be made
within a
reasonable
 
degree of certainty.
 
A significant effort was put into verifying the integrity
of
 
the
 
database
 
records.
 
Once
 
the
 
data
 
was
 
verified,
 
stratigraphic
 
columnar
 
sections
 
were
generated using cross-sectional analysis to establish
 
or confirm coal seam correlations.
A typical cross-section is shown in
Figure 7-1
.
 
 
ex963p2i0 ex963p32i2 ex963p32i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
23
Figure 7-1:
 
Logan Cross-Section
Due
 
to
 
the
 
long
 
history
 
of
 
exploration
 
by
 
various
 
parties
 
on
 
the
 
Property,
 
a
 
wide
 
variety
 
of
survey
 
techniques
 
exist
 
for
 
documentation
 
of
 
data
 
point
 
locations.
 
Many
 
of
 
the
 
older
exploration drill holes
 
appear to
 
have been located by
 
survey and
 
more recently-completed drill
holes
 
are
 
often
 
located
 
by
 
high-resolution
 
Global
 
Positioning
 
System
 
(
GPS
)
 
units.
 
However,
some holes appear to have been approximately
 
located using USGS topography
 
maps or other
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
24
methods
 
which are
 
less accurate
 
.
 
Therefore,
 
discretion
 
by MM&A
 
had to
 
be used
 
regarding
the accuracy
 
for the
 
location and
 
ground surface
 
elevation
 
of some
 
of these
 
older drill
 
holes.
 
In
 
instances
 
where
 
a
 
drill
 
hole
 
location
 
(or
 
associated
 
coal
 
seam
 
elevations)
 
appeared
 
to
 
be
inconsistent
 
with
 
the
 
overall
 
structural
 
trend
 
(or
 
surface
 
topography
 
for
 
surface-mineable
areas), the data point was not honored for geological modeling.
 
Others with apparently minor
variances were logically adjusted and then used by MM&A.
 
Surveying
 
of
 
the
 
underground
 
and
 
surface
 
mined
 
areas
 
has
 
been
 
performed
 
by
 
the
 
mine
operators and/or their consulting surveyors.
 
By assignment, MM&A did
 
not verify the
 
accuracy
or completeness of the supplied mine maps but accepted
 
this information as being the work of
responsible engineers and surveyors, as required by both State
 
and Federal Law.
MM&A
 
compiled
 
comprehensive
 
topographic
 
map files
 
by
 
selecting
 
the
 
best
 
available
 
aerial
mapping for
 
each area,
 
surface mine
 
resources and
 
reserves in
 
particular,
 
and filled
 
any gaps
with digital USGS topographic mapping.
7.2
 
Non-Drilling Procedures and Parameters
Some analyses,
 
specifically ultimate
 
ash and sulfur
 
types are
 
not as prevalent
 
as others
 
in the
testing
 
done
 
on
 
samples
 
recovered
 
by
 
drilling.
 
To
 
supplement
 
the
 
information
 
database,
samples have been collected from mine stockpiles and either truck or tra
 
in shipment samples.
7.3
 
Drilling Procedures
Core drilling methods utilize NX-size (5.4 centimeters) or similar-sized
 
core cylinders to recover
core
 
samples,
 
which
 
can
 
be
 
used
 
to
 
delineate
 
geologic
 
characteristics,
 
and
 
for
 
coal
 
quality
testing and geotechnical logging.
 
For the core holes, the geophysical
 
logs are especially useful
in
 
verifying
 
the
 
core
 
recovery
 
of
 
both
 
the
 
coal
 
samples
 
(for
 
assurance
 
that
 
sample
 
is
representative
 
of the full seam)
 
and of the roof
 
and floor rock
 
samples (for evaluating
 
ground
control
 
characteristics
 
of
 
deep
 
mineable
 
coal
 
seams).
 
In
 
addition
 
to
 
the
 
core
 
holes,
 
rotary
drilled
 
holes also
 
exist
 
on most
 
of the
 
Properties.
 
Data
 
for
 
the
 
rotary
 
drilled
 
holes is
 
mainly
derived from
 
downhole geophysical
 
logs, which
 
are used
 
to interpret
 
coal and
 
rock thickness
and depth since logging of the drill cuttings is not reliable.
A wide variety of core
 
-logging techniques exist for the
 
properties.
 
For many of the core
 
holes,
the
 
primary
 
data
 
source
 
is
 
a
 
generalized
 
lithology
 
description
 
by
 
the
 
driller,
 
typically
supplemented
 
by a
 
more detailed
 
core
 
log completed
 
by a
 
geologist.
 
The Logan
 
drilling logs
were provided to MM&A as a geological database.
 
MM&A geologists were not involved in the
production
 
of
 
original
 
core
 
logs
 
but
 
did
 
perform
 
a
 
basic
 
check
 
of
 
information
 
within
 
the
provided
 
database.
 
Where
 
geophysical
 
logs
 
for
 
such
 
holes
 
are
 
available,
 
they
 
were
 
used
 
by
MM&A geologists to verify the coal thickness and core recovery of each
 
seam.
 
7.4
 
Mine Data
Mine
 
data
 
from
 
underground
 
mines
 
was
 
supplied
 
to
 
supplement
 
the
 
exploration
 
drillhole
records,
 
by seam.
 
In-seam mine
 
data was
 
provided from
 
Coronado through
 
Microsoft® Excel
files or from coal
 
section measurements recorded within maps
 
of several mines.
 
The mine data
was
 
processed
 
for
 
seam
 
thickness
 
and
 
coal
 
thickness,
 
by
 
seam
 
and
 
then
 
appended
 
to
 
the
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
25
Carlson model
 
database for
 
seam model
 
updates.
 
Seam thickness
 
data
 
excluded
 
roof and
 
or
floor strata records
 
above and below the measured
 
seam.
 
In 2023, active underground
 
mines
that
 
included
 
supplemental
 
mine
 
data
 
included
 
Muddy
 
Bridge
 
and
 
Eagle
 
No.
 
1
 
Mine
 
in
 
the
Lower No. 2 Gas (Eagle) seam and the Lower War Eagle mine.
 
In-mine seam
 
measurements were taken
 
by mine
 
survey workers with
 
a tape
 
measure to record
coal
 
and parting(s)
 
thicknesses and
 
data
 
locations.
 
Subsequently,
 
the thickness
 
and
 
location
records
 
were transferred
 
into digital
 
format
 
and AutoCAD
 
maps.
 
Seam section
 
data of
 
these
records were then used with drill hole seam data to update geologic models.
 
Anomalous seam
thickness data,
 
of which there were only a few,
 
were not honored for the update.
 
Coal quality
samples were
 
not collected
 
by surveyors
 
with seam thickness
 
measurements.
 
The spacing
 
of
the in-mine measurements is tighter than
 
that of the drill hole data.
 
In general, the mine data
fit thickness trends
 
of the surrounding
 
drill holes and
 
emphasized existing
 
thickness trends
 
as
seen from surrounding
 
drill hole data.
 
In a few
 
places the in-mine data
 
showed local thinning
or thickening thickness trends of limited extent.
In-Mine seam measurement counts by seam are as follows:
 
>
Lower Winifrede seam includes 51 in-mine data locations taken from the adjacent, inactive
deep mine.
>
Lower
 
War
 
Eagle
 
seam
 
includes
 
551
 
in-mine
 
data
 
locations,
 
mainly
 
located
 
beside
 
remaining
mineable sections of the active deep mine.
>
Lower No. 2 Gas seam includes 1,974 in-mine data locations.
 
Of the 1,974 mine data locations,
478 are from the Muddy Bridge deep
 
mine and 1,496 are from the
 
Eagle No. 1 Mine.
 
The Lower
No. 2 Gas update displays a seam
 
thickness differential between the thicker Muddy Bridge mine
area and the thinner Eagle No. 1 Mine which is represented with the mine data.
7.5
 
Hydrology
Hydrologic
 
testing
 
and forecasting
 
are necessary
 
parts of
 
the permitting
 
process
 
and as
 
such
are routinely considered in the mine planning process.
Logan
 
has
 
a
 
lengthy
 
history
 
of
 
operation
 
and
 
five
 
currently
 
active
 
mines
 
with
 
no
 
significant
hydrologic concerns or material issues experienced in its history.
 
Future mining is projected to
occur
 
in
 
areas
 
exhibiting
 
similar
 
hydrogeological
 
conditions
 
as
 
past
 
mining,
 
including
 
stream
undermining and undermining of aquifers.
 
Based upon the successful history of the operation
with
 
regards
 
to
 
hydrogeological
 
features,
 
MM&A
 
assumes
 
that
 
the
 
operation
 
will
 
not
 
be
hindered by such issues in the future.
7.6
 
Geotechnical Data
Mining plans
 
for potential
 
underground mines
 
were developed
 
by Coronado
 
and modified by
MM&A
 
to
 
fit
 
current
 
property
 
constraints.
 
Pillar
 
stability
 
was
 
tested
 
by
 
MM&A
 
using
 
the
Analysis of Coal
 
Pillar Stability (ACPS)
 
program that was developed by the
National Institute for
Occupational Safety and Health (
NIOSH
)
.
 
MM&A reviewed the results from the ACPS analysis
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
26
and
 
considered
 
it
 
in
 
the
 
development
 
of
 
the
 
LOM
 
plan.
 
Coal
 
and
 
rock
 
strengths
 
from
 
core
testing are used to verify the empirical assumptions integral
 
to ACPS.
8
Sample Preparation, Analyses and Security
8.1
 
Prior to Sending to the Lab
Most
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
samples
 
have
 
been
 
obtained
 
from
 
the
 
Property
 
by
 
subsurface
 
exploration
using core
 
drilling techniques.
 
The protocol
 
for preparing
 
and testing
 
the samples
 
has varied
over time and
 
is not well documented
 
for the older
 
holes drilled on the
 
Property.
 
Following a
process, typical USA
 
core drilling
 
sampling technique
 
is for
 
the coal
 
core sample,
 
once recovered
from the core barrel, to be described then wrapped in a sealed plastic sleeve and placed into
 
a
wooden core box, which is the length of the sample and covered with a lid so that the core can
be delivered
 
to a laboratory
 
in relatively
 
intact condition
 
and with inherent
 
moisture content.
 
Each core
 
sample box
 
is identified
 
with the
 
seam, hole
 
identification number
 
and the
 
sample
interval depth scribed on
 
the sample box lid.
 
This process has
 
been the norm
 
for both historical
and ongoing exploration activities at Logan.
This
 
work
 
is
 
typically
 
performed
 
by
 
the
 
supervising
 
driller,
 
geologist
 
or
 
company
 
personnel.
 
Samples are most often delivered
 
to the company by the
 
driller after each shift or acquired
 
by
company
 
personnel
 
or
 
representatives.
 
Most
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
core
 
samples
 
were
 
obtained
 
by
previous
 
or
 
current
 
operators
 
on
 
the
 
Property.
 
MM&A
 
did
 
not
 
participate
 
in
 
the
 
sample
collection
 
and
 
analysis
 
of
 
the
 
core
 
samples.
 
However,
 
it
 
is
 
reasonable
 
to
 
assume,
 
given
 
the
sophistication level of the previous operators, that these samples were generally collected
 
and
processed under industry best-practices.
 
This assumption is based on MM&A’s familiarity with
the operating companies and the companies used to perform the analysis.
8.2
 
Lab Procedures
Coal quality testing has been performed
 
over a large number of years
 
by operating companies
using different laboratories
 
and testing regimens.
 
Some of the samples have raw analyses and
washabilities
 
of
 
the
 
full
 
seam
 
(with
 
coal
 
and
 
rock
 
parting
 
layers
 
co-mingled)
 
and
 
are
 
mainly
useful
 
for
 
characterizing
 
the
 
coal
 
quality
 
for
 
projected
 
production
 
from
 
underground
 
and
highwall mine
 
operations.
 
Other samples
 
have coal
 
and rock
 
analyzed separately,
 
the results
of which can be manipulated to forecast either surface or underground
 
mine quality.
 
Care has
been taken
 
to use
 
only those
 
analyses that
 
are representative
 
of the
 
coal quality
 
parameters
for the appropriate mining type for each sample.
Standard procedure
 
upon receipt of
 
core samples by the
 
testing laboratory
 
is to log the
 
depth
and
 
thickness
 
of
 
the
 
sample,
 
then
 
perform
 
testing
 
as
 
specified
 
by
 
a
 
representative
 
of
 
the
operating
 
company.
 
Each
 
sample
 
is
 
then
 
analyzed
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
procedures
 
defined
under
ASTM International
 
(
ASTM
)
 
standards including,
 
but not
 
limited to;
 
washability (ASTM
D4371); ash (ASTM D3174); sulfur
 
(ASTM D4239); Btu/lb. (ASTM D5865); volatile
 
matter (ASTM
D3175); Free Swell Index (
FSI
) (ASTM D720).
Since 1957 (the earliest
 
coal quality information available), the Property has
 
been controlled by
various mining companies
 
utilizing their own corporate
 
laboratories including:
Buffalo Mining
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
27
Company
(Lorado,
 
West Virginia),
Pittston Coal Group
(Lyburn, West
 
Virginia), and
Clinchfield
Coal Company
(Clinchfield, Virginia).
 
Since 1985 to the present, additional laboratories
not
 
affiliated with coal companies who have
provided analytical data for the Property include:
>
Mineral
 
Labs,
 
Inc.
(Salyersville,
 
Kentucky)
accredited
 
by
 
the
Perry
 
Johnson
 
Laboratory
Accreditation, Inc.
(
PJLA
).
 
>
Standard
 
Laboratories,
 
Inc
(South
 
Charleston,
 
West
 
Virginia)
accredited
 
by
 
the
ANSI
National Accreditation Board (
ANAB
).
>
Standard Laboratories, Inc
(Whitesburg, Kentucky)
accredited by the ANAB.
>
Commercial
 
Testing
 
&
 
Engineering
 
Company
 
(Charleston,
 
West
 
Virginia)
 
–
 
no
 
longer
 
in
operation.
>
Gallagher Coal Research Center
(Crab Orchard, West
 
Virginia) – no longer in operation.
>
Standard Laboratories, Inc.
(Scott Depot, West Virginia) – accredited
 
by the ANAB
.
>
SGS
 
North
 
America
(Sophia,
 
West
 
Virginia)
 
–
 
a
 
leading
 
accredited
 
body
 
and
 
a
Nationally
Recognized Test
 
Laboratory
 
(
NRTL
); currently utilized by Coronado for sample analysis.
9
Data Verification
9.1
 
Procedures of Qualified Person
MM&A reviewed the digital geologic database supplied by Coronado.
 
The database consists of
data records,
 
which include drill
 
hole information
 
for holes that
 
lie within and
 
adjacent to the
Property
 
and
 
records
 
for
 
numerous
 
supplemental
 
coal
 
seam
 
thickness
 
measurements.
 
For
supplemental
 
record
 
verification,
 
copies of
 
each entry
 
were
 
printed,
 
and cross
 
referenced
 
to
the
 
original
 
document
 
for
 
verification.
 
Once
 
the
 
initial
 
integrity
 
of
 
the
 
database
 
was
established,
 
stratigraphic
 
columnar
 
sections were
 
generated
 
using cross
 
-sectional analysis
 
to
establish or confirm coal seam correlations.
 
Geophysical logs were used wherever available to
assist
 
in confirming
 
the seam
 
correlation
 
and to
 
verify proper
 
seam thickness
 
measurements
and recovery of intercepted
 
coal sections and collected samples.
 
After
 
establishing
 
and/or
 
verifying
 
proper
 
seam
 
correlation,
 
seam
 
data
 
control
 
maps
 
and
geological cross-sections
 
were generated
 
and again used
 
to verify
 
seam correlations
 
and data
integrity.
 
Once the database was
 
fully vetted, seam thickness,
 
base of seam
 
elevation, roof and
floor
 
lithology,
 
and
 
overburden
 
maps
 
were
 
independently
 
generated
 
for
 
use
 
in
 
the
 
mine
planning process.
9.2
 
Limitations
As with any exploration program, localized anomalies
 
cannot always be discovered.
 
Ideally, the
greater the
 
density of the
 
samples taken,
 
the less the
 
risk.
 
Once an area
 
is identified as being
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
28
of interest
 
for inclusion
 
in the mine
 
plan, additional samples
 
are taken
 
to help reduce
 
the risk
in those specific areas.
 
In general, provision is made in the
 
mine planning portion of the study
to allow for localized anomalies
 
that are typically classed
 
more as a
 
nuisance than a
 
hinderance.
9.3
 
Opinion of Qualified Person
Sufficient
 
data
 
has
 
been
 
obtained
 
through
 
various
 
exploration
 
and
 
sampling
 
programs
 
and
mining operations to support the
 
geological interpretations of seam structure and
 
thickness for
coal
 
horizons
 
situated
 
on
 
the
 
Property.
 
The
 
data
 
is
 
of
 
sufficient
 
quantity
 
and
 
reliability
 
to
reasonably support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates
 
in this TRS.
10
Mineral Processing and Metallurgical Testing
10.1
 
Testing
 
Procedures
Separate
 
tabulations
 
have
 
been
 
compiled for
 
basic chemical
 
analyses
 
(both raw
 
and washed
quality),
 
petrographic
 
data,
 
rheological
 
data
 
and
 
chlorine,
 
ash,
 
ultimate
 
and
 
sulfur
 
analysis.
 
Some
 
of
 
the
 
data
 
categories
 
from
 
the
 
analyses
 
are
 
not
 
as
 
prevalent
 
and
 
have
 
been
supplemented
 
by
 
samples collected
 
from
 
mine stockpiles
 
and
 
either truck
 
or
 
train
 
shipment
samples.
Available
 
coal quality
 
data
 
were
 
tabulated
 
by resource
 
area in
 
a Microsoft®
 
EXCEL
 
workbook
and the
 
details of
 
that work are
 
maintained on
 
file at
 
the offices
 
of Coronado
 
and MM&A.
 
These
tables
 
also
 
provide
 
basic
 
statistical
 
analyses
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
quality
 
attributes,
 
including
 
average
value; maximum and minimum values; and the sample count (number of samples)
 
available to
represent
 
each
 
quality
 
parameter
 
of
 
the
 
seam.
 
Coal
 
samples
 
that
 
were
 
deemed
 
by
 
MM&A
geologists
 
to
 
be
 
unrepresentative
 
were
 
not
 
used
 
for
 
statistical
 
analysis
 
of
 
coal
 
quality,
 
as
documented
 
in
 
the
 
tabulations.
 
A
 
representative
 
group
 
of
 
drill
 
hole
 
samples
 
from
 
the
Properties were then checked against the
 
original drill laboratory reports
 
to verify accuracy and
correctness.
The
 
amount
 
and
 
areal
 
extent
 
of
 
coal
 
sampling
 
for
 
geological
 
data
 
is
 
generally
 
sufficient
 
to
represent
 
the
 
quality
 
characteristics
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
horizons
 
and
 
allow
 
for
 
proper
 
market
placement
 
of the
 
subject coal
 
seams.
 
For
 
some of
 
the
 
coal
 
deposits,
 
there
 
are
 
considerable
laboratory
 
data
 
from
 
core
 
samples
 
that
 
are
 
representative
 
of the
 
full
 
extent
 
of the
 
resource
area; and for others there
 
are more limited data to represent
 
the resource area.
 
For example,
in the
 
active operations
 
with considerable
 
previous mining,
 
there may
 
be limited
 
quality data
within some of
 
the remaining resource
 
areas; however,
 
in those cases
 
the core
 
sampling data
can
 
be
 
supplemented
 
with
 
operational
 
data
 
from
 
mining
 
and
 
shipped
 
quality
 
samples
representative of the resource
 
area.
10.2
 
Relationship of Tests
 
to the Whole
The extensive
 
sampling and testing
 
procedures typically
 
followed in
 
the coal industry
 
result in
an
 
excellent
 
correlation
 
between
 
samples and
 
marketable
 
product.
 
Shipped
 
analyses
 
of the
coal
 
from
 
Logan
 
were
 
reviewed
 
to
 
verify
 
that
 
the
 
coal
 
quality
 
and
 
characteristics
 
were
 
as
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
29
expected.
 
The
 
Logan
 
properties
 
have
 
a
 
long
 
history
 
of
 
saleable
 
production,
 
under
 
various
owners, in the high-volatile metallurgical
 
and thermal markets, confirming exploration results.
10.3
 
Lab Information
Each
 
sample
 
is
 
analyzed
 
at
 
area
 
Laboratories
 
that
 
operate
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
procedures
defined
 
under
 
ASTM
 
standards
 
including,
 
but
 
not
 
limited
 
to
 
the
 
following
 
(Note:
 
not
 
all
analytical tests identified in this list have been run on each sample):
 
>
ASTM D 4371
 
– Test
 
Method for Determining Washability Characteristics
 
of Coal
>
ASTM D 3174
 
– Method for Ash in the Analysis Sample of Coal and Coke
>
ASTM
 
D
 
4239
 
–
 
Test
 
Methods
 
for
 
Sulphur
 
in
 
the
 
Analysis
 
Sample
 
of
 
Coal
 
and
 
Coke
 
Using
High-Temperature
 
Tube Furnace Combustion Methods
>
ASTM D 5865
 
– Test
 
Method for Gross Calorific Value
 
of Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 3175
 
– Test
 
Method for Volatile Matter
 
in the Analysis Sample of Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 3176
– Standard Practice for Ultimate Analysis of Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 3178
– Test
 
Method for Carbon and Hydrogen in Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 3179
– Test
 
Method for Nitrogen in Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 720
 
– Test
 
Method for Free-Swelling Index (
FSI
) of Coal
>
ASTM
 
D
 
5515
–
 
Test
 
Method
 
for
 
Determination
 
of
 
the
 
Swelling
 
Properties
 
of
 
Bituminous
Coal Using a Dilatometer (Arnu)
>
ASTM D 2639
 
– Test
 
Method for Plastic Properties of Coal (Gieseler)
>
ASTM D 3683
– Trace Elements
 
in Coal and Coke Ash by the Atomic Absorption Method
>
ASTM D 1857
– Standard Test
 
Method for Fusibility of Coal and Coke Ash
>
ASTM
 
D
 
2798
–
 
Microscopical
 
Determination
 
of
 
the
 
Reflectance
 
of
 
Vitrinite
 
in
 
a
 
Polished
Specimen of Coal
Ultimate
 
analysis
 
is
 
a
 
process
 
typically
 
used
 
which
 
gives
 
the
 
composition
 
of
 
coal
 
in
 
terms
 
of
carbon, hydrogen,
 
nitrogen, oxygen,
 
ash, and sulfur
 
without regard
 
to origin.
 
The sum
 
of the
carbon,
 
hydrogen,
 
nitrogen,
 
sulfur,
 
and
 
ash
 
are
 
subtracted
 
from
 
100
 
percent
 
to
 
calculate
oxygen percent.
Heating value
 
or calorific
 
value is
 
a measure
 
of the
 
heat produced
 
from a
 
unit weight
 
of coal.
 
In
 
the
 
United
 
States,
 
it
 
is
 
commonly
 
expressed
 
in
 
British
 
thermal
 
units
 
per
 
pound
 
(
Btu/lb.
).
 
Other units are kilocalories
 
per kilogram (
Kcal/kg
) and kilojoules
 
per gram (
KJ/g
).
 
Heating value
is generally determined by burning a weighed coal sample, in oxygen,
 
in a calorimeter.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
30
As noted
 
previously,
 
since 1957
 
(the earliest
 
coal quality
 
information
 
available), the
 
Property
has
 
been
 
controlled
 
by
 
various
 
mining
 
companies
 
utilizing
 
their
 
own
 
corporate
 
laboratories
including:
Buffalo Mining Company
(Lorado,
 
West Virginia),
Pittston Coal Group
(Lyburn, West
Virginia), and
Clinchfield Coal Company
(Clinchfield, Virginia).
 
Since 1985 to the present, additional laboratories
not
 
affiliated with coal companies who have
provided analytical data for the Property include:
>
Mineral Labs, Inc. (Salyersville,
 
Kentucky)
accredited by the PJLA
 
.
 
>
Standard Laboratories, Inc.
(South Charleston, West Virginia)
accredited by the ANAB
.
>
Standard Laboratories, Inc.
(Whitesburg, Kentucky)
accredited by the ANAB.
 
>
Commercial
 
Testing
 
&
 
Engineering
 
Company
 
(Charleston,
 
West
 
Virginia)
 
–
 
no
 
longer
 
in
operation.
>
Gallagher Coal Research Center (Crab Orchard,
 
West Virginia) – no longer in operation.
>
Standard Laboratories, Inc. (Scott Depot, West
 
Virginia) – accredited by the ANAB.
>
SGS North America (Sophia,
 
West Virginia) – a leading
 
accredited body and a
 
NRTL; currently
utilized by Coronado for sample analysis.
 
10.4
 
Relevant Results
No critical factors have been found
 
that would adversely affect the recovery
 
of the Reserve.
 
11
Mineral Resource Estimates
MM&A
 
independently
 
created
 
geologic
 
models
 
to
 
define
 
the
 
coal
 
resources
 
of
 
Logan.
 
Coal
resources were estimated
 
as of December 31, 2023.
11.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
Geological
 
data
 
was
 
imported
 
into
 
Carlson
 
Mining
®
 
software
 
for
 
geological
 
modelling
 
and
resource
 
estimates.
 
The imported
 
data,
 
formatted
 
in Microsoft
®
 
Excel
 
files, incorporat
 
es drill
hole collar elevations, seam and thickness
 
picks, bottom seam elevations and
 
raw and washed
coal
 
quality.
 
These
 
data
 
files
 
were
 
validated
 
prior
 
to
 
importing
 
into
 
the
 
software.
 
Once
imported,
 
a
 
geologic
 
model
 
was
 
created,
 
reviewed,
 
and
 
verified
 
with
 
a
 
key
 
element
 
being
 
a
gridded
 
model
 
of
 
coal
 
seam
 
thickness.
 
Resource
 
tonnes
 
were
 
estimated
 
by
 
using
 
the
 
seam
thickness
 
grid based
 
on each
 
valid
 
point
 
of observation
 
and
 
by defining
 
resource
 
confidence
arcs
 
around
 
the
 
points
 
of
 
observation.
 
Points
 
of
 
observation
 
for
 
Measured
 
and
 
Indicated
confidence arcs were
 
defined for all valid
 
drill holes that intersected
 
the seam using standards
deemed acceptable by MM&A based on
 
a detailed geologic evaluation and a statistical analysis
of all
 
drill holes
 
within the
 
projected reserve areas
 
as described
 
in
Section 11.1.1
.
 
The geological
evaluation
 
incorporated
 
an
 
analysis
 
of seam
 
thickness related
 
to
 
depositional
 
environments,
adjacent roof and floor lithologies, and structural influences.
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
31
After
 
establishing
 
seam correlations,
 
validated
 
coal
 
seam data
 
,
 
including seam
 
thickness and
elevation for seams of economic interest,
 
were used to generate a geologic model.
 
Due to the
relative
 
structural
 
simplicity of
 
the deposits
 
and the
 
reasonable continuity
 
of the
 
tabular coal
beds, the
 
principal geological
 
interpretation
 
necessary to
 
define the
 
lateral
 
extent
 
of the
 
coal
deposits
 
is
 
the
 
proper
 
modeling
 
of
 
seam
 
thickness
 
and
 
elevation.
 
Both
 
coal
 
thickness
 
and
quality
 
data
 
are
 
deemed
 
by
 
MM&A
 
to
 
be
 
reasonably
 
sufficient
 
within
 
the
 
resource
 
areas.
 
Therefore, there is a reasonable level of confidence in the geologic interpretations required for
coal
 
resource
 
determination
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
available
 
data
 
and
 
the
 
techniques
 
applied
 
to
 
the
data.
Table
 
11-1
 
below provides
 
the geological
 
mapping and
 
coal tonnage
 
estimation
 
criteria
 
used
for the
 
coal resource
 
and reserve evaluation
 
.
 
These cut-off
 
parameters
 
have been
 
developed
by
 
MM&A
 
based
 
on
 
its
 
experience
 
with
 
the
 
Coronado
 
properties
 
and
 
are
 
typical
 
of
 
mining
operations
 
in
 
the
 
Central
 
Appalachian
 
coal
 
basin.
 
This
 
experience
 
includes
 
technical
 
and
economic
 
evaluations
 
of numerous
 
properties
 
in the
 
region
 
for
 
the
 
purposes of
 
determining
the economic viability of the subject coal reserves.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
32
Table 11-1:
 
General Reserve & Resource Criteria
Item
Parameters
Technical Notes & Exceptions*
•
 
General Criteria
 
 
Reserve Classification
Reserve and Resource
Coal resources as reported are inclusive of coal reserves.
Reliability Categories
Reserve (Proven and Probable)
Resource (Measured, Indicated & Inferred)
To better reflect geological conditions of the coal
deposits, distance between points of observation is
standard USGS (in meters), respectively, for measured
and indicated and inferred.
Effective Date of Resource Estimate
December 31, 2023
Coal resources were updated for depletion and non-
material resource additions based on information from
Coronado.
 
Effective date for coal resources is as of
December 31, 2023.
Effective Date of Reserve Estimate
December 31, 2023
Coal reserves were updated for depletion and non-
material reserve additions based on information from
Coronado.
 
Effective date for coal reserves is as of
December 31, 2023.
Seam Density
Variable, dependent upon seam characteristics
(based on available drill hole quality).
 
In the
absence of laboratory data, estimated by (1)
assuming specific gravity of 1.30 for coal and 2.25
to 2.5 for rock parting, or (2) 1280 kg/m
3
to 1324
kg/m
3
 
for a “clean”
 
seam)
•
 
Underground-Mineable Criteria
Map Thickness
Total seam thickness
Minimum Seam Thickness
0.76 meters (thermal coal); 0.68 meters
(metallurgical coal)
 
Minimum Mining Thickness
1.4 to 1.8 meters
Minimum Total Coal Thickness
0.76 meters (thermal coal); 0.68 meters
(metallurgical coal)
 
Minimum In-Seam Wash Recovery
50 percent; 40 percent where coal is belted
directly to preparation plant
Wash Recovery Applied to Coal
Reserves
Based on average yield for drill holes within
reserve area, or in the absence of laboratory
washability data, based on estimated visual
recovery using specific gravities noted above and
95 percent yield on “clean” coal
Out-of-Seam Dilution Thickness for
Run-of-Mine Tonnes Applied to Coal
Reserves
0.05 meters minimum
2243 kg/m³ density used for dilution tonnage estimate
Mine Barrier
60.96-meter distance from abandoned mines and
sealed or pillared areas; 30.4-meter distance from
planned highwall miner panels
Minimum Reserve Tonnage
226,796 recoverable tonnes for individual area
(logical mining unit)
Minimum Overburden Depth
30.48 meters
Minimum Interval to Rider Coal
Considered on a case-by-case basis, depending on
interval lithology, etc.
<1.5 meters are resource
Minimum Interval to Overlying or
Underlying Reserves
Considered on a case-by-case basis, depending on
interval lithology, extent and type of extraction,
etc.
Typically, 12.19 meters
Minimum Interval to Overlying or
Underlying Mined Areas
Considered on a case-by-case basis, depending on
interval lithology, extent and type of extraction,
etc.
Adjustments Applied to Coal Reserves
6 percent moisture increase; 5 percent loss for
preparation plant inefficiency
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
33
Item
Parameters
Technical Notes & Exceptions*
Surface Mineable Criteria
Topographic Map Source
Reserves estimated based on aerial topography,
where available, and best available aerial
topography for other areas.
 
Pre-law highwalls
also based on aerial topography, where available
Map Thickness
Total mineable seam thickness (excluding removal
partings)
Mine Recovery Applied to Coal
Reserves
90 percent; 25 percent for previously
underground mined areas.
 
Wash Recovery
Not Applicable for most reserves estimated on a
direct-ship basis.
 
Where surface mineable coal is
projected to be washed, based on average yield
for drill holes within reserve area, or in the
absence of laboratory washability data, based on
estimated visual recovery using specific gravities
noted above and 95 percent yield on “clean”
 
coal
Minimum Thickness
0.3 meter for principal seam (principal seam is any
that is >0.76 meters from another mineable coal
bench)
0.15 meters for a split of a principal seam (split is
within 0.76 meters of another mineable coal
bench)
Minimum thickness of recoverable
coal within single seam
CTR/Area/HWM areas
0.6 meters
Minimum HWM Cutting Height
0.8 meters
Removable Rock Parting Thickness
0.07 meters
Maximum Cumulative Area Mining
Strip Ratio
30:1 – Area
15:1 – CTR
Exceptions considered for metallurgical grade coal
products if deemed economical
Design Bench Width for
Contour/HWM Areas
38.1 meters (Contour reserves estimated in
conjunction with potential HWM reserves)
Adjustments Applied to Marketable
Coal Reserves
4.5 percent moisture increase
Out-of-Seam Dilution Thickness
Applied to Coal Reserves
NA
2% adjustment (addition) made to product coal quality
ash to account for dilution
 
Surface Property Control
Reserves considered where surface is controlled;
tonnage not estimated or classified as resource
where surface is uncontrolled.
Highwall Miner Reserves
Penetration Depth
91.4 – 243.8 meters
Seam Density & Wash Recovery
Similar to underground-mineable reserves
Mine Recovery Applied to Coal
Reserves
40 percent
 
Minimum Coal Thickness
0.6 meter
Minimum Mining Height
0.9 meter
Adjustments Applied to Marketable
Coal Reserves
6 percent moisture increase and 5 percent loss for
preparation plant inefficiency
Out-of-Seam Dilution Thickness
Applied to Coal Reserves
0.9 meter less seam height
2242 to 2402 kg/m
3
 
density used for dilution tonnage
estimate
Note:
 
Exceptions for application of
 
these criteria to
 
resource and reserve estimation
 
are made as
 
warranted and demonstrated by either
 
actual
mining experience or detailed data that allows for empirical evaluation of mining conditions.
 
Final classification of coal reserve is made based
on the pre-feasibility evaluation.
11.1.1
 
Geostatistical Analysis
MM&A
 
completed
 
a
 
geostatistical
 
analysis
 
on
 
drill
 
holes
 
within
 
the
 
reserve
 
boundaries
 
to
determine
 
the
 
applicability
 
of
 
the
 
common
 
United
 
States
 
classification
 
system
 
for
 
measured
and indicated and inferred coal
 
resources.
 
Historically, the United States has assumed that
 
coal
within 0.4-kilometer
 
of a
 
point
 
of observation
 
represents
 
a measured
 
resource
 
whereas
 
coal
between 0.4 kilometer and
 
1.2 kilometer from a point
 
of observation is classified as
 
indicated.
 
Inferred
 
resources
 
are
 
commonly
 
assumed
 
to
 
be
 
located
 
between
 
1.2
 
kilometers
 
and
 
4.8
kilometers
 
from
 
a
 
point
 
of
 
observation.
 
Per
 
SEC
 
and
 
JORC
 
regulations,
 
only
 
measured
 
and
 
 
ex963p2i0 ex963p43i2 ex963p43i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
34
indicated
 
resources
 
may
 
be
 
considered
 
for
 
reserve
 
classification,
 
respectively
 
as
 
proven
 
and
probable reserves.
MM&A performed a
 
geostatistical analysis test of
 
the Logan
 
data set using
 
the Drill
 
Hole Spacing
Analysis
 
(
DHSA
)
 
method.
 
This
 
method
 
attempts
 
to
 
quantify
 
the
 
uncertainty
 
of
 
applying
 
a
measurement
 
from
 
a
 
central
 
location
 
to
 
increasingly
 
larger
 
square
 
blocks
 
and
 
provides
recommendations
 
for determining
 
the distances
 
between drill
 
holes for
 
measured, indicated,
and inferred resources.
To
 
perform DHSA
 
the data set
 
was processed to
 
remove any
 
erroneous data
 
points, clustered
data points, as well as directional
 
trends.
 
This was achieved through the use
 
of histograms, as
seen in
Figure 11-1
, color coded scatter plots showing
 
the geospatial positioning of
 
the borings,
Figure 11-2
, and trend analysis.
Figure 11-1:
 
Histogram of the Total Seam Thickness for the No. 2
Gas Seam Present in the Logan Complex
Figure 11-2:
 
Scatter plot of the Total Seam Thickness for the No. 2 Gas
Seam Present in the Logan Complex
Following the
 
completion of
 
data processing,
 
a variogram
 
of the
 
data set
 
was created,
Figure
11-3
.
 
The variogram plots average
 
square difference against
 
the separation distance
 
between
the data
 
pairs.
 
The separation
 
distance is
 
broken
 
up into
 
separate
 
bins defined
 
by a
 
uniform
lag distance (e.g., for a lag distance of 152 meters the bins would be 0 – 152 meters, 153 – 305
meters, etc.).
 
Each pair of data points that are less than one lag distance
 
apart are reported in
the first bin.
 
If the
 
data pair is
 
further apart
 
than one
 
lag distance
 
but less
 
than two
 
lag distances
apart, then the
 
variance is
 
reported in
 
the second bin.
 
The numerical average
 
for differences
reported
 
for
 
each
 
bin
 
is
 
then
 
plotted
 
on
 
the
 
variogram.
 
Care
 
was
 
taken
 
to
 
define
 
the
 
lag
distance in such a way as to not overestimate any nugget effect
 
present in the data set.
 
Lastly,
modeled equations,
 
often spherical,
 
gaussian, or
 
exponential, are
 
applied to
 
the variogram
 
in
order to represent the data set across
 
a continuous spectrum.
 
 
ex963p2i0 ex963p44i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
35
Figure 11-3: Variogram of the Total
 
Seam Thickness for the No. 2 Gas Seam
 
Present in the Logan Complex
The estimation
 
variance is
 
then calculated
 
using information
 
from the
 
modeled variogram
 
as
well
 
as charts
 
published by
 
Journel and
 
Huijbregts
 
(1978).
 
This value
 
estimates
 
the variance
from
 
applying
 
a
 
single
 
central
 
measurement
 
to
 
increasingly
 
larger
 
square
 
blocks.
 
Care
 
was
taken
 
to
 
ensure
 
any
 
nugget
 
effect
 
present
 
was
 
added
 
back
 
into
 
the
 
data.
 
This
 
process
 
was
repeated for each test block size.
The
 
final
 
step
 
of
 
the
 
process
 
is
 
to
 
calculate
 
the
 
global
 
estimation
 
variance.
 
In
 
this
 
step,
 
the
number of
 
square blocks
 
that would
 
fit inside
 
the selected
 
study area
 
is determined
 
for each
block size
 
that was
 
investigated
 
in the
 
previous step
 
.
 
The estimation
 
variance is
 
then divided
by the number of blocks that would fit inside the study area for each test block size.
 
Following
this determination, the
 
data is then
 
transformed back to represent the
 
relative error in
 
the 95
th
-
percentile range.
Figure 11-4
shows the results of the DHSA
 
performed on the No. 2 Gas
 
seam data for the Logan
Complex.
 
DHSA provides hole to hole spacing values,
 
these distances need to be converted
 
to
radius from
 
a central point
 
in order to compare
 
to the historical
 
standards.
 
A summary of the
radius data is
 
shown in
Table 11-2
.
 
DHSA prescribes measured,
 
indicated, and inferred drill
 
hole
spacings be determined at
 
the 10-percent, 20-percent,
 
and 50-percent levels
 
of relative error,
respectively.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex963p45i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
36
Figure 11-4: Result of DHSA for the No. 2 Gas Seam Present in the Logan Complex
Table 11-2:
 
DHSA Results Summary for Radius from a Central Point
Model:
Measured Radial Distance
(10% Relative Error)
Indicated Radial Distance
(20% Relative Error)
Inferred Radial Distance
(50% Relative Error)
(km)
(km)
(km)
Gaussian:
0.99
1.66
3.94
Spherical:
0.87
1.53
3.53
Exponential:
0.87
1.53
3.53
Comparing the
 
results of
 
the DHSA
 
to the
 
historical standards,
 
it is
 
evident that
 
the historical
standards are more conservative than even the most conservative DHSA model with regards to
determining measured
 
resources.
 
The Exponential
 
and Spherical
 
models recommend
 
using a
radius
 
of
 
0.87
 
kilometers
 
for
 
measured
 
resources
 
compared
 
to
 
the
 
historical
 
value
 
of
 
0.4
kilometers.
 
With
 
respect
 
to
 
indicated
 
resources,
 
the
 
Spherical
 
and
 
Exponential
 
models
recommend
 
using
 
a
 
radius
 
of
 
1.53
 
kilometers.
 
The
 
historical
 
radius
 
of
 
1.2
 
kilometers
 
is
therefore also more conservative
 
than the DHSA results for indicated
 
resources.
 
These results
have led the QPs to report the data following the
 
historical classification standards, rather than
use the results of the DHSA.
11.2
 
Qualified Person’s Estimates
Mineral resources representing
 
in-situ coal are estimated Inclusive
 
of Reserve and Exclusive of
Reserves.
 
Based on the work and methods
 
described above and detailed geologic modelling of
the
 
areas considering
 
all defined
 
parameters,
 
a coal
 
resource
 
estimate,
 
summarized
 
in
Table
11-3
, was prepared as of December 31, 2023, for property controlled
 
by Coronado.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
37
Table 11-3:
 
Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Coal Resource (Dry Tonnes, In Situ, MT)
Resource Quality (Dry)
Area
Measured
Indicated
Inferred
Total
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Inclusive of Reserves
133.9
35.8
0.0
169.7
17
1.0
31
Exclusive of Reserves
39.2
35.9
3.4
78.5
Total 12/31/2023
173.1
71.7
3.4
248.3
Note:
 
Resource tonnes are inclusive of
 
reserve tonnes since they include the
 
in-situ tonnes from which recoverable
 
coal reserves
are derived.
Note 2:
 
Coal resources are reported on a dry basis.
 
Surface moisture and inherent moisture are excluded.
Note 3: The Property has 75.1
 
Mt of dry, in-place measured and indicated
 
resource tonnes exclusive of reserves as of
 
December 31,
2023.
11.3
 
Resources Exclusive of Reserves
The
 
Property
 
contains
 
multiple
 
resource
 
blocks
 
which
 
were
 
not
 
deemed
 
to
 
exhibit
 
reserve
potential at the time of the study.
 
These underground-mineable resources, formally identified
as resources
 
exclusive
 
of reserves,
 
are from
 
the No.
 
2 Gas,
 
Lower Powellton,
 
Peerless,
 
Lower
Winifrede,
 
Middle
 
Cedar
 
Grove
 
and
 
Beckley
 
coal
 
seams.
 
A
 
portion
 
of
 
the
 
Lower
 
Winifrede
resources defined
 
in the February
 
2023 TRS were
 
converted to
 
reserves as part
 
of the current
2024 TRS by
 
virtue of a mine plan
 
and economic analysis
 
in
Section 19
.
 
There are also
 
surface
mineable
 
resources
 
exclusive
 
of
 
reserves
 
in
 
various
 
seams.
 
Reasons
 
which
 
may
 
preclude
elevation of resources to reserves include, but are not limited to:
1.
 
Unfavorable
 
economics
 
at
 
the
 
PFS
 
level,
 
yet
 
economics
 
could
 
become
 
attractive
 
in
 
the
future under different market
 
conditions.
 
2.
 
Exclusion from
 
LOM planning
 
by mining
 
operator due
 
to remaining
 
resource blocks
 
which
are
 
relatively
 
small,
 
isolated
 
blocks
 
and
 
not
 
currently
 
attractive
 
from
 
an
 
operational
perspective.
 
11.3.1
 
Initial Economic Assessment
MM&A
 
completed
 
an
 
initial
 
economic
 
assessment
 
to
 
determine
 
the
 
potential
 
economic
viability of resources
 
exclusive of
 
reserves.
 
Unlike the
 
economic analysis presented
 
in
Section
19
 
developed
 
to
 
test
 
reserves,
 
the
 
initial
 
economic assessment
 
below
 
is presented
 
on a
 
real
basis in 2023
 
dollars.
 
MM&A applied relevant
 
technical factors
 
to estimate
 
potential saleable
tonnes
 
without
 
the resource
 
blocks, should
 
the resources
 
be
 
extracted
 
via deep,
 
continuous
mining methods or
 
surface area methods.
 
MM&A developed cash
 
cost profiles for the
 
resource
blocks, including
 
direct cash costs
 
(labor, supplies, roof control, maintenance
 
and repair, power,
and
 
other);
 
washing,
 
trucking,
 
materials
 
handling,
 
general
 
and
 
administrative,
 
and
environmental
 
costs;
 
and
 
indirect
 
cash
 
costs
 
(royalties,
 
production
 
taxes,
 
property
 
tax,
insurance).
 
Costs were
 
developed based
 
off relevant
 
cost drivers
 
(per-meter,
 
per-bank
 
cubic
meter,
 
per-raw-tonne,
 
per-clean-tonne).
 
Additionally,
 
MM&A
 
estimated
 
capital
 
costs
 
to
extract resources.
 
Capital costs associated with mine development were
 
amortized across the
resource’s
 
potential saleable tonnages.
 
Additional non-cash items (depreciation of equipment
and depletion) and cash costs were compared to an assumed
 
sale price of $154 per
 
tonne (FOB
loadout)
 
for
 
underground-mineable
 
resources,
 
representing
 
the
 
long-term
 
average
 
price
forecast
 
for
 
HVB provided
 
by Coronado.
 
Surface
 
resources
 
were
 
assessed at
 
a sales
 
price of
$83
 
per
 
tonne
 
(FOB
 
loadout)
 
based
 
on
 
estimated
 
historical
 
pricing
 
for
 
Coronado’s
 
surface
operations.
 
The results of
 
the analysis are
 
shown below and
 
demonstrate potential profitability
on a fully loaded cost basis.
 
Detailed summaries are shown in
Appendix D
.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex963p47i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
38
Table 11-4:
 
Results of Initial Economic Assessment ($/tonne)
Mine
Resource
Block
Direct
Cash
Transportation,
Washing,
Enviro, G&A
Indirect
Non-Cash
Total Cost
Fully
Loaded
P&L
Toney Fork #2
N2G
$70.46
$17.34
$19.81
$17.53
$125.13
$29.19
Pardee
N2G
$77.59
$20.85
$19.81
$12.63
$130.88
$23.44
Sugar Camp
N2G
$97.33
$25.16
$19.81
$10.40
$152.70
$1.62
Lower Powellton Block A
LPOW
$74.99
$18.22
$19.81
$8.52
$121.54
$32.79
Lower Powellton Block B
LPOW
$78.47
$18.99
$19.81
$20.22
$137.49
$16.83
N2G Peerless
Peer
$100.47
$15.53
$19.81
$16.83
$152.64
$1.69
Beckley
Bec
$68.42
$16.72
$19.81
$17.09
$122.03
$32.29
Middle Cedar Grove
MCG
$72.41
$18.21
$19.81
$36.75
$147.18
$7.14
Lower Winifrede
LWIN
$38.58
$13.04
$19.81
$43.83
$115.25
$39.07
Powellton No. 1
UPOW
$63.63
$21.11
$19.81
$8.52
$113.07
$41.25
Thermal Area Mines (S)
S
$50.27
$6.34
$12.73
$8.52
$77.87
$4.81
Figure 11-5:
 
Results of Initial Economic Assessment
11.4
 
Resources Inclusive of Reserves
The
Inclusive
 
of
 
Reserves
 
in-place
 
resource
 
account
 
for
 
68-percent
 
of
 
the
 
total
 
248.3 million
estimated
 
in-situ
 
resource.
 
Recoverable
 
reserves
 
for
 
both
 
surface
 
and
 
underground
 
mine
methods
 
are
 
derived
 
from
 
the
Inclusive
 
of
 
Reserve
 
169.7 million
 
in-situ
 
resource.
 
Logan
reserves are discussed further in
Section 12
, Mineral Reserve Estimates below.
11.5
 
Qualified Person’s Opinion
While there is some level of stratigraphically controlled
 
seam-thickness variability due to seam
splitting,
 
sand
 
channels,
 
etc.,
 
the
 
coal
 
seams
 
on
 
the
 
mine
 
property
 
in
 
Logan
 
County
demonstrate
 
reasonable
 
thickness
 
consistency
 
according
 
to
 
the
 
classification
 
system
 
of
measured
 
(0
 
–
 
0.4
 
kilometer),
indicated
 
(0.4
 
to
 
1.2
 
kilometers),
 
and
inferred
 
(1.2
 
to
 
4.8
kilometers).
 
MM&A geologists
 
and engineers
 
modeled the
 
deposit and
 
delineated
 
mineable
regions to reflect the nature of each seam and the practicality of mining constraints.
 
Based on
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
39
MM&A’s
 
geostatistical
 
analysis,
 
it
 
would
 
be
 
possible
 
to
 
extend
 
the
 
measured,
 
indicated
 
and
inferred
 
arcs
 
slightly
 
beyond
 
historically
 
accepted
 
practices
 
due
 
to
 
consistent
 
geological
settings.
 
The
 
QP’s
 
have
 
again
 
elected
 
not
 
to
 
extend
 
arc
 
distances,
 
introducing
 
a
 
level
 
of
conservatism in measured and indicated coal classification.
Based on the
 
data review, the attendant work done to verify the data integrity and
 
the creation
of an independent geologic model, the
 
QPs believe
 
this is a fair and accurate representation of
the Logan coal resources.
 
Moreover,
 
the QPs opine that additional exploration, mine planning
and
 
financial
 
analysis
 
could
 
result
 
in
 
conversion
 
of
 
additional
 
resources
 
to
 
reserves
 
in
 
the
future;
 
however,
 
there
 
is
 
no
 
guarantee
 
that
 
such
 
will
 
be
 
the
 
case
 
until
 
such
 
time
 
as
 
that
additional work is completed.
12
Mineral Reserve Estimates
12.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
Coal
 
Reserves
 
are
 
classified
 
as
proven
 
or
probable
 
considering
 
“modifying
 
factors”
 
including
mining,
 
metallurgical,
 
economic,
 
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
 
social
 
and
 
governmental
factors.
>
Proven
 
Coal
 
Reserves
 
are
 
the
 
economically
 
mineable
 
part
 
of
 
a
 
measured
 
coal
 
resource,
adjusted
 
for diluting
 
materials and
 
allowances for
 
losses when
 
the material
 
is mined.
 
It is
based
 
on
 
appropriate
 
assessment
 
and
 
studies
 
in
 
consideration
 
of
 
and
 
adjusted
 
for
reasonably
 
assumed
 
modifying
 
factors.
 
These
 
assessments
 
demonstrate
 
that
 
extraction
could be reasonably justified at the time of reporting.
 
>
Probable Coal
 
Reserves
 
are the
 
economically mineable
 
part of
 
an indicated
 
coal resource,
and
 
in
 
some circumstances
 
a
 
measured
 
coal
 
resource,
 
adjusted
 
for
 
diluting
 
materials
 
and
allowances for losses when
 
the material is
 
mined.
 
It is based
 
on appropriate assessment and
studies in
 
consideration of
 
and adjusted
 
for reasonably
 
assumed modifying factors.
 
These
assessments
 
demonstrate
 
that
 
extraction
 
could
 
be
 
reasonably
 
justified
 
at
 
the
 
time
 
of
reporting.
 
Upon
 
completion
 
of
 
delineation
 
and
 
calculation
 
of
 
coal
 
resources,
 
MM&A
 
generated
 
a
 
LOM
plan for
 
Logan.
 
The footprint
 
of each
 
reserve area
 
is shown
 
on the
 
maps in
Appendix B
.
 
The
Mine
 
plan
 
was
 
generated
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
forecast
 
mine
 
plan
 
and
 
permit
 
plan
 
provided
 
by
Coronado with modifications
 
by MM&A
 
where necessary
 
due to current
 
property control limits,
modifications to geologic mapping, or other factors determined during the evaluation.
Carlson
 
Mining
 
software
 
was
 
used
 
to
 
generate
 
the
 
LOM
 
plan
 
for
 
Logan.
 
The
 
mine
 
plan
 
was
sequenced
 
based
 
on
 
productivity
 
schedules
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
MM&A
 
judged
 
the
productivity
 
estimates
 
and plans
 
to
 
be reasonable
 
based on
 
experience
 
and
 
current
 
industry
practice.
Raw, ROM production data outputs from LOM plan sequencing were processed into Microsoft
®
EXCEL
 
spreadsheets
 
and
 
summarized
 
on
 
an
 
annual
 
basis
 
for
 
processing
 
into
 
the
 
economic
model.
 
Average seam
 
densities were estimated
 
to determine raw
 
coal tonnes produced
 
from
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
40
the LOM
 
plan.
 
Average
 
mine recovery
 
and wash
 
recovery
 
factors
 
were applied
 
to determine
coal reserve tonnes.
 
Coal reserve tonnes in
 
this evaluation are reported at
 
a 4.5 percent to
 
6.0 percent moisture and
represent the saleable product from the Property.
 
Pricing data
 
as provided
 
by Coronado
 
is described
 
in
Section 16.2
.
 
The pricing
 
data
 
assumes
respective HVA,
 
HVB and thermal FOB-mine prices of approximately
 
$162, $144, and $120 per
metric tonne
 
for
 
calendar year
 
2024.
 
HVA,
 
HVB, and
 
thermal prices
 
respectively decrease
 
to
approximately $161, $143, and $114 per metric tonne through year 2026, and then increase
 
to
$308, $273, and $212 per metric tonne through year 2057.
The coal resource mapping and estimation process, described in this report was
 
used as a basis
for the coal
 
reserve estimate.
 
Proven and probable
 
coal reserves were
 
derived from
 
the defined
coal
 
resource
 
considering
 
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
technical
 
estimates
 
of
capital,
 
revenue,
 
and
 
cost),
 
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental,
 
socio-economic,
 
and
 
regulatory
factors and are presented
 
on a moist, recoverable basis.
As is
 
customary in
 
the US, the
 
categories for
 
proven and
 
probable coal
 
reserves are
 
based on
the distances
 
from valid
 
points of measurement
 
as determined by
 
the QPs for
 
the area
 
under
consideration.
 
For this evaluation, measured resource,
 
which may convert to a proven reserve,
is based on a 0.4-kilometer radius from a valid point of observation.
Points of observation include
 
exploration drill holes, gas wells,
 
and mine measurements which
have
 
been fully
 
vetted
 
and processed
 
into a
 
geologic model.
 
The geologic
 
model is
 
based on
seam depositional
 
modeling, the interrelationship
 
of overlying
 
and underlying
 
strata
 
on seam
mineability,
 
seam
 
thickness
 
trends,
 
the
 
impact
 
of
 
seam
 
structure
 
(i.e.,
 
faulting),
 
intra-seam
characteristics, etc.
 
Once the geologic model
 
was completed, a statistical analysis, described in
Section 11.1.1
 
was conducted and a 0.4-kilometer radius from a valid
 
point of observation was
selected to define Measured Resources.
 
Likewise,
 
the
 
distance
 
between
 
0.4
 
and
 
1.2
 
of
 
a
 
kilometer
 
radius
 
was
 
selected
 
to
 
define
Indicated Resources.
 
Indicated Resources may convert
 
to Probable Reserves.
 
Inferred Resources (greater than a 1.2-kilometer radius
 
from a valid point of observation) have
been excluded from Reserve consideration.
12.2
 
Mineral Reserves
Logan reserves
 
were derived
 
from multiple
 
coal seams
 
located on
 
the Property
 
and shown
 
in
Figure 7.1
.
 
Reserves are estimated
 
for both surface and
 
underground mine methods.
 
Surface
reserves were estimated for three designated
 
mine areas: Toney Fork, Buffalo Creek South,
 
and
Sugar
 
Camp.
 
Underground
 
reserves
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
six
 
seams
 
including
 
the
 
Upper
Winifrede,
 
Lower
 
Winifrede,
 
Chilton
 
(Williamson),
 
Upper
 
Powellton,
 
Lower
 
Powellton,
 
No.
 
2
Gas-Lower
 
(Eagle)
 
and Lower
 
War
 
Eagle.
 
The 70.6
 
Mt of
 
demonstrated
 
marketable
 
reserves
are sited in the discussion below.
 
Table
 
12-2
 
shows the demonstrated tonnage
 
by Proven and
Probable category.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
41
Individual seam maps are included in
Appendix B
 
herein.
 
12.2.1
 
Surface Reserves
Surface coal reserves
 
of the Property include
 
an estimated 32.2
 
Mt.
 
Each surface mine
 
area –
Tony
 
Fork, Buffalo Creek
 
South and Sugar
 
Camp – includes coal
 
reserves from multiple
 
seams.
 
Two
 
of
 
the
 
three
 
surface
 
reserve
 
areas,
 
Toney
 
Fork
 
and
 
Buffalo
 
Creek
 
South,
 
include
 
both
permitted
 
and
 
non-permitted
 
tonnages,
 
where
 
Sugar
 
Camp
 
tonnage
 
is
 
not
 
permitted.
 
The
Property has five surface mine permits for contour and
 
highwall mining.
 
Even so, in 2023 there
was minor surface mine
 
activity on just
 
two of the
 
five surface mine permits
 
at Toney Fork Mine
No. 3 and Elk Lick.
 
12.2.1.1
 
Toney
 
Fork Surface
Toney Fork surface area is located north of Buffalo
 
Creek on the
 
north side of
 
the Property.
 
The
Toney
 
Fork
 
drainage
 
bisects
 
much
 
of
 
the
 
area
 
which
 
includes
 
contour
 
and
 
highwall
 
miner
reserve from
 
six seams.
 
The Toney
 
Fork reserve
 
includes 11.2 Mt
 
of both permitted
 
and not-
permitted
 
status.
 
There
 
is one
 
active
 
permit
 
– Toney
 
Fork
 
Mine No
 
3
 
(S-5007-09).
 
In 2023,
minimal tons were mined from this permit during the fourth quarter.
 
Mine depletion from
 
surface and underground
 
mining, seam dependent, exists
 
in all seams of
the
 
Toney
 
Fork
 
reserve
 
which
 
include
 
the
 
Upper
 
Coalburg,
 
Lower
 
Coalburg,
 
Lower
 
Dorothy,
Chilton A, Upper Winifrede and Lower Winifrede seams.
 
12.2.1.2
 
Buffalo Creek South
Buffalo Creek South
 
(Elklick) surface area
 
includes an
 
estimated 14.7 Mt
 
from projected contour
and highwall
 
mines.
 
The reserve
 
total
 
includes both
 
permitted
 
and not-permitted
 
tonnages.
 
Permitted
 
tonnages
 
are
 
estimated
 
from
 
four
 
surface
 
mine
 
permits
 
–
 
North
 
Fork
 
Winifrede
Contour (S-5004-17), Middle Fork Surface (S-5004-22),
 
and two at Elk
 
Lick (S-5014-10 &
 
S-5008-
22).
 
In 2023, minimal tons were mined and only at Elk Lick.
 
The highwall
 
mineable tonnage
 
is estimated
 
for six
 
seams with
 
adequate seam
 
heights which
include
 
the Lower
 
Coalburg, Lower
 
Dorothy,
 
Chilton,
 
Chilton
 
A, Buffalo
 
Creek
 
and the
 
Upper
Winifrede.
 
Contour
 
mine tonnage
 
is derived
 
from
 
the highwall
 
mine seams,
 
along with
 
four
additional
 
seams
 
with
 
acceptable
 
seam
 
thickness.
 
They
 
include
 
the
 
Lower
 
Clarion,
 
Upper
Stockton, Lower Stockton and Upper Coalburg.
 
Mine depletion to various extents exists
 
in the
Buffalo Creek South seams.
12.2.1.3
 
Sugar Camp Surface
Sugar Camp surface area
 
is a ridge above
 
Sugar Camp Branch tributary
 
of Huff Creek.
 
The Sugar
Camp reserve includes 6.2 Mt
 
with a suitable surface mine
 
strip ratio.
 
Proposed surface mining
includes reserve from 12 seams beginning
 
with the Chilton A seam
 
down to the S80 seam,
 
each
with an
 
acceptable
 
seam height.
 
The seams
 
included are
 
Chilton A,
 
Upper Winifrede,
 
Lower
Winifrede, Chilton,
 
Upper Cedar
 
Grove, Middle
 
Cedar Grove,
 
Lower Cedar
 
Grove, S132
 
seam,
S120 seam, S110 seam, S84 seam and S80 seam.
 
No mine depletion exists in
 
the seams of the
reserve on the ridge.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
42
12.2.2
 
Underground Reserves
Underground coal reserves
 
of the
 
Property include an
 
estimated 38.4 Mt
 
derived from the
 
small
above-drainage deposits in the Upper Winifrede
 
and Lower Winifrede seams along with larger
seam
 
deposits
 
of
 
the
 
deeper
 
Chilton,
 
Upper
 
Powellton,
 
Lower
 
Powellton,
 
No.
 
2
 
Gas-Lower
(Eagle) and Lower War Eagle seams.
 
Active underground mines are operating in the No. 2 Gas-
Lower and the Lower War Eagle seams.
 
12.2.2.1
 
Upper Winifrede (No 8) Seam
The Upper
 
Winifrede seam
 
included two
 
underground
 
reserves in
 
2023, the
 
permitted
 
North
Fork Winifrede
 
Mine (U-5009-19)
 
and a
 
not-permitted
 
proposed Upper
 
Winifrede mine.
 
The
North Fork
 
Winifrede Mine
 
was fully
 
depleted in
 
2023.
 
The Proposed
 
Upper Winifrede
 
seam
deposit along
 
Sugar Camp
 
Branch was
 
evaluated
 
for
 
this report.
 
On the
 
Property,
 
the Upper
Winifrede seam has been extensively mined from both surface and underground
 
mining.
12.2.2.2
 
Lower Winifrede
The
 
Lower
 
Winifrede
 
seam
 
reserve
 
includes
 
an
 
estimated
 
2.1
 
Mt
 
from
 
one
 
proposed
 
mine
situated north of
 
the Toney
 
Fork drainage.
 
The average
 
seam height for
 
the two areas
 
is 1.37
meters
 
thick.
 
On
 
the
 
Property,
 
the
 
Lower
 
Winifrede
 
seam
 
has
 
been
 
mined,
 
mainly
 
by
underground mining, immediately east of the proposed underground
 
mine area.
12.2.2.3
 
Chilton (Williamson) Seam
The Chilton seam
 
reserve includes an
 
estimated 5.4
 
Mt from two
 
proposed mine areas:
 
Camp
Branch and Elk Lick.
 
The average seam height for the
 
two areas is 1.17
 
meters and 1.06 meters,
respectively.
 
On
 
the
 
Property,
 
the
 
Chilton
 
seam
 
has
 
been
 
extensively
 
mined,
 
mainly
 
by
underground mining.
12.2.2.4
 
Upper Powellton (Upper Alma)
The
 
Powellton
 
No.
 
1
 
Mine
 
permit
 
provides
 
access
 
to
 
the
 
remaining
 
3.5
 
Mt
 
of
 
the
 
Upper
Powellton
 
reserve.
 
The
 
seam
 
has
 
an
 
average
 
thickness
 
of
 
nearly
 
1.12
 
meters.
 
The
 
mine
 
is
bound by the property extent to the northeast and
 
thin coal from a seam split
 
to the west.
 
The
south end
 
of Mine
 
No. 1
 
is mined
 
out.
 
Elsewhere,
 
no prior
 
Upper Powellton
 
seam mining
 
is
noted on the Property.
12.2.2.5
 
Lower Powellton (Lower Alma)
The Lower
 
Powellton
 
seam reserve
 
includes an
 
estimated
 
5.1 Mt
 
from a
 
proposed mine
 
area
situated north of Toney Fork.
 
In the mapped resource area, the interval to the overlying Upper
Powellton
 
seam
 
is
 
in
 
a
 
range
 
of
 
5.1
 
to
 
7.2
 
meters.
 
Therefore,
 
only
 
resources
 
(exclusive
 
of
reserves) are
 
projected below
 
the Upper
 
Powellton
 
underground
 
mine where
 
the two
 
seams
overlap.
 
The
 
Lower
 
Powellton
 
seam has
 
an
 
average
 
reserve
 
thickness of
 
0.89
 
meters
 
and
 
is
bound by property control to
 
the north, by low
 
coal to the west
 
and south and
 
from overmining
in the Upper
 
Powellton
 
seam to the
 
east.
 
No prior Lower
 
Powellton
 
seam mining is
 
noted on
the Property.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
43
12.2.2.6
 
No. 2 Gas-Lower (Eagle)
The
 
No.
 
2
 
Gas-Lower
 
seam
 
reserve
 
includes
 
an
 
estimated
 
15.2
 
Mt.
 
The
 
demonstrated
 
total
includes both permitted and not permitted
 
tonnes.
 
Two active mines
 
access the reserve – the
Eagle No. 1 / Toney
 
Fork Mine (U-5013-11) from Toney
 
Fork Drainage and the Muddy Bridge
 
1
& 2 Mine (U-5034-96, U-5035
 
-96) from Muddy Bridge
 
Branch of Huff Creek.
 
Mine boundaries
of
 
the
 
two
 
mines
 
are
 
immediately
 
adjacent
 
to
 
one
 
another
 
and
 
mine
 
plans
 
maximize
 
the
mineable area.
 
The average seam height is 1.00 meter and 1.52 meters for the Eagle No. 1 and
Muddy Bridge mines, respectively.
 
On the Property,
 
the No. 2 Gas-Lower reserve
 
is limited by
low
 
coal
 
thickness
 
to
 
the
 
east
 
and
 
seam
 
outcrop
 
along
 
large
 
drainages
 
elsewhere.
 
Previous
underground mining of the seam is mapped immediately west of the Property.
 
12.2.2.7
 
Lower War Eagle
 
The Lower War Eagle seam
 
reserve includes an
 
estimated 5.7 Mt.
 
One underground Lower War
Eagle
 
mine
 
(U-4002-99B)
 
provides
 
seam
 
access
 
from
 
the
 
portal
 
located
 
along
 
Huff
 
Creek.
 
Mapped mine depletion is from within the existing
 
mine.
 
The Lower War Eagle
 
reserve extent
is limited to the north by low coal.
 
12.3
 
Qualified Person’s Estimates
Reserve
 
tonnage
 
estimates
 
provided
 
herein
 
report
 
coal
 
reserves
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
in-situ
resource
 
tonnes
 
presented
 
in
Table
 
11-3
, and
 
not in
 
addition to
 
coal
 
resources.
 
Proven
 
and
probable
 
coal
 
reserves
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
coal
 
resource
 
considering
 
relevant
mining, processing,
 
infrastructure, economic (including estimates
 
of capital, revenue, and
 
cost),
marketing, legal,
 
environmental, socio-economic
 
and regulatory factors.
 
The coal reserves, as
shown
 
in
Table
 
12-2
,
 
are
 
based
 
on
 
a
 
technical
 
evaluation
 
of
 
the
 
geology
 
and
 
a
 
preliminary
feasibility study of the coal deposits.
 
The extent to which the coal reserves may be affected by
any known environmental, permitting,
 
legal, title,
 
socio-economic, marketing, political,
 
or other
relevant
 
issues has
 
been reviewed
 
rigorously.
 
Similarly,
 
the extent
 
to which
 
the estimates
 
of
coal
 
reserves
 
may
 
be
 
materially
 
affected
 
by
 
mining,
 
metallurgical,
 
infrastructure
 
and
 
other
relevant
 
factors
 
has
 
also
 
been
 
considered.
 
Coal
 
reserves
 
are
 
presented
 
on
 
a
 
ROM
 
basis
 
in
Table
 
12-1.
Table 12-1:
 
Coal Summary (ROM Basis (Moist)) as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Mt, Moist ROM)
Quality (Dry)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area / Mine
Proved
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Ash
Sulfur
Vol
Logan Mine Complex
104.1
30.5
134.6
37.0
97.6
0.0
134.6
49
0.9
19
In the financial analysis some
 
of the projected mines were not economically
 
viable.
 
The tonnes
projected to be mined from these locations have
 
not been included in the Reserve Base.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
44
Table 12-2:
 
Coal Reserves Summary (Marketable Sales Basis) as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet Ton
 
nes, Washed or Direct Shipped, MT)
Quality (Dry Basis)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Property
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Logan County Complex
54.9
15.7
70.6
32.2
38.4
0.0
70.6
8
0.9
35
Note: Marketable reserve tonnes are
 
reported on a moist basis, including a
 
combination of surface and inherent moisture.
 
The combination
of
 
surface
 
and
 
inherent
 
moisture
 
is
 
modeled
 
between
 
4.5
 
and
 
6-percent,
 
depending
 
upon
 
mining
 
method.
 
Actual
 
product
 
moisture
 
is
dependent upon multiple geological factors, operational
 
factors, and product contract
 
specifications and can exceed 8-percent.
 
As such, the
modeled moisture values provide a level of conservatism for reserve reporting.
The
 
results of
 
this TRS
 
define an
 
estimated
 
70.6 Mt
 
of proven
 
and probable
 
marketable
 
coal
reserves.
 
Of that
 
total, 77
 
percent are
 
proven, and
 
23 percent
 
are probable.
 
All 70.6
 
Mt are
leased
 
coal
 
reserves
 
and
 
are
 
assigned.
 
Approximately
 
62.2
 
Mt
 
of
 
reserves
 
are
 
considered
suitable for the metallurgical
 
coal market and 8.4
 
Mt are projected to be
 
sold into the thermal
coal market.
12.4
 
Qualified Person’s Opinion
The
 
estimate
 
of coal
 
reserves
 
was
 
determined
 
in accordance
 
with the
 
JORC Code
 
along with
SEC Regulation S-K 1300.
The
 
LOM
 
mining
 
plan
 
for
 
Logan
 
was
 
prepared
 
to
 
the
 
level
 
of
 
preliminary
 
feasibility.
 
Mine
projections
 
were
 
prepared,
 
and
 
timing
 
scheduled
 
to
 
match
 
production
 
with
 
coal
 
seam
characteristics.
 
Production timing
 
was carried
 
out from
 
current locations
 
to depletion
 
of the
coal
 
reserve
 
area.
 
Coal
 
reserve
 
estimates
 
could
 
be
 
materially
 
affected
 
by
 
the
 
risk
 
factors
described in
Section 22.2
.
Based on the
 
Preliminary Feasibility Study and
 
the attendant Economic Review, the QPs believe
this is a fair and accurate calculation of the Logan coal reserves.
13
Mining Methods
Ten underground and three surface mining
 
areas were modeled
 
and tested economically.
 
Once
the
 
Resources
 
were
 
calculated,
 
mine
 
plans
 
were
 
created
 
to
 
project
 
operating
 
each
 
resource
area to
 
depletion, with
 
crews and
 
equipment scheduled
 
to move
 
to subsequent
 
mining areas
as
 
depletion
 
occurs.
 
Underground
 
mine
 
operations
 
are
 
projected
 
to
 
be
 
exhausted
 
in
 
2044,
surface mines deplete in 2055 and the highwall miners finish in 2057.
13.1
 
Geotech and Hydrology
Mining plans for potential underground mines
 
were developed by Coronado and MM&A.
 
Pillar
stability was tested by MM&A
 
using the
Analysis of Coal
 
Pillar Stability (ACPS)
 
program that was
developed
 
by
 
the
National
 
Institute
 
for
 
Occupational
 
Safety
 
and
 
Health
 
(
NIOSH
)
.
 
MM&A
reviewed the results from the
 
ACPS and ALPS
 
analysis and considered
 
them in the
 
development
of the LOM plan.
For the HWM operation, Mining cuts are approximately 2.9 meters
 
wide, and cuts are typically
laid out on approximately 5.03-meter centers.
 
A 2.1-meter to 2.4-meter solid
 
coal fender is left
in
 
place
 
between
 
cuts.
 
The
 
mining
 
plan
 
provides
 
that
 
larger
 
barrier
 
pillars
 
be
 
provided
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
45
periodically,
 
depending
 
on
 
overburden
 
depth
 
and
 
characteristics
 
and
 
the
 
immediate
 
roof
composition, typically after 15 to
 
20 cuts.
 
Although this plan,
 
with minor variations, is common
throughout Appalachia, specific rock and coal strength information is used to verify whether or
not this plan provided a sufficient factor of safety.
Hydrology
 
has not
 
been an
 
issue of
 
concern at
 
Logan.
 
Based on
 
numerous site
 
visits to
 
both
the surface and underground portions of the Property by the QPs, it has been determined that
this is not a significant concern.
 
Mining of future reserves
 
is projected to occur
 
in areas which
exhibit similar hydrogeological characteristics
 
as those formerly mined areas.
13.2
 
Production Rates
Operations at Logan by
 
Coronado and its
 
predecessors have been on-going
 
for many years.
 
The
mine plan
 
and productivity
 
expectations reflect
 
historical performance
 
and efforts
 
have been
made to adjust the plan to
 
reflect future conditions.
 
MM&A is confident that
 
the mine plan is
reasonably
 
representative
 
to
 
provide
 
an
 
accurate
 
estimation
 
of
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
Mine
development and operation have not been optimized
 
within the TRS.
Carlson
 
Mining
 
software
 
was
 
used
 
by
 
MM&A
 
to
 
generate
 
mine
 
plans
 
for
 
the
 
mineable
 
coal
seams.
 
Mine plans
 
were
 
sequenced based
 
on productivity
 
schedules provided
 
by Coronado,
which were
 
based on
 
historically achieved
 
productivity levels.
 
All production
 
forecasting
 
ties
assumed production rates
 
to geological models as
 
constructed by MM&A’s
 
team of geologists
and mining engineers.
The projected
 
underground mines
 
are set
 
up similarly to
 
the four
 
currently active
 
operations.
 
Each mine is
 
scheduled to operate one
 
to three production sections.
 
All sections are
 
configured
as full supersections with two
 
continuous miners per section.
 
In all cases, mines are
 
forecasted
to
 
produce
 
coal
 
two
 
or
 
three
 
shifts
 
each
 
day.
 
In
 
most
 
cases
 
the
 
third
 
shift
 
is
 
reserved
 
for
maintenance and belt and
 
power moves.
 
Production is scheduled Monday
 
through Friday each
week, and every other Saturday.
Three
 
surface
 
resource
 
areas were
 
modeled.
 
Mining operations
 
are projected
 
to utilize
 
area
mining
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
contour
 
mining
 
(
CTR
)
 
methods
 
with
 
an
 
emphasis
 
on
 
creating
 
highwall
 
for
highwall mining activity.
 
The
 
models assume
 
that the
 
operations
 
will
 
work two,
 
10-hour production
 
shifts, 5
 
days
 
per
week plus every other Saturday,
 
with sufficient staffing to float vacation
 
during the year.
 
Coals from the
 
surface operations are
 
hauled to
 
the loadout
 
for direct ship
 
or to the
 
preparation
plant for washing ultimately to be blended to shipment’s specifications.
 
Saleable product from
the surface
 
operations
 
is projected
 
to be
 
sold primary
 
into the
 
thermal coal
 
market
 
on a
 
raw
basis; however,
 
some production is planned to be washed for the metallurgical coal market.
 
The
 
three
 
areas
 
planned
 
for
 
highwall
 
mining
 
are
 
assumed
 
to
 
be
 
mined
 
by
 
a
 
contractor;
therefore,
 
the contractor
 
costs
 
included in
 
the financial
 
model assume
 
that the
 
contractor
 
is
responsible for staffing those operations
 
along with providing necessary equipment capital.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
46
Spoil for
 
final highwall
 
reclamation
 
is expected
 
to come
 
from
 
strategic
 
placement of
 
spoil on
pre-existing
 
benches
 
by
 
haul
 
trucks
 
such
 
that
 
they
 
are
 
within
 
the
 
push
 
distance
 
of
 
the
reclamation dozer.
 
13.3
 
Mining Related Requirements
13.3.1
 
Underground
A mine plan with sequenced mining projections was prepared for each logical mining unit.
 
For
each mine plan, the
 
appropriate number of
 
production units is selected
 
for the resource
 
area,
and a productivity level
 
assigned, expressed in
 
meters of advance
 
per unit-shift of production.
 
The
 
productivity
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
equipment
 
and
 
personnel
 
configuration,
 
mining
 
height
 
and
expected physical conditions.
At the underground mines, ventilation fans are installed to provide a sufficient volume of air to
ventilate production sections, coal
 
haulage and transport
 
entries, battery charging
 
stations, and
transformers
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
approved
 
plans.
 
High-voltage
 
cables
 
deliver
 
power
throughout the mine where transformers reduce voltage for specific equipment requirements.
 
The Mine
 
Improvement and
 
New Emergency
 
Response Act
 
of 2006
 
(
MINER Act
) requires
 
that
carbon monoxide detection systems be installed along mine conveyor belts and that electronic
two-way
 
tracking
 
and
 
communications
 
systems
 
be
 
installed
 
throughout
 
underground
 
mines.
 
Water is
 
required to control
 
dust at production
 
sections and along conveyor
 
belts, and to cool
electric motors.
 
Water
 
is available
 
from nearby sources
 
and is distributed
 
within the mine
 
by
pipelines as required.
 
13.3.2
 
Surface Mine
A mine plan with sequenced mining projections was prepared for each logical mining unit.
 
The
mobile
 
equipment
 
spreads
 
selected
 
are
 
representative
 
of
 
Coronado’s
 
equipment
 
fleets
 
and
deemed to be appropriate for the local mining conditions.
13.3.3
 
HWM
Contract
 
HWM units
 
are available
 
for assignment
 
to contour
 
surface mining
 
pits in
 
the Logan
County Division.
 
HWM substantially increases coal recovery from contour mining benches and
is ideally suited
 
for coal resource areas characterized by
 
thin coal seams
 
and irregular or
 
narrow
boundaries that
 
are
 
not well-suited
 
for
 
underground
 
mining.
 
The
 
contour
 
mining bench
 
will
extend
 
into
 
the
 
highwall
 
to
 
the
 
maximum
 
overburden
 
stripping
 
ratio
 
that
 
is
 
economically
feasible or the minimum bench requirement for operation
 
of the HWM unit.
 
13.4
 
Required Equipment and Personnel
13.4.1
 
Underground Mines
13.4.1.1
 
Powellton No. 1
The Powellton No. 1 Mine was
 
in the process of being rehabilitated
 
as of December 2023.
 
It is
scheduled to
 
resume full
 
production with
 
one continuous
 
mine section
 
in the
 
first
 
quarter of
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
47
2024.
 
The Upper Powellton seam is accessed via
 
a shallow slope and crop.
 
This mine produces
metallurgical coal from leased mineral.
Production is scheduled for approximately 242 days each
 
year, which represents production on
Monday through Friday.
 
On each day,
 
the production section is
 
scheduled to produce coal
 
on
two
 
shifts;
 
the
 
third
 
shift
 
is
 
reserved
 
for
 
maintenance
 
and
 
mine
 
conveyor
 
belt
 
and
 
power
moves.
 
The production section
 
is configured as
 
a full
 
super section
 
with two
 
continuous miners.
 
Productivity
 
is planned
 
at
 
an average
 
rate
 
of 67.3
 
meters
 
of advance
 
and retreat
 
per shift
 
of
operation.
 
A total of 59 employees are assigned to the mine.
Principal production equipment includes two continuous miners, two roof bolters, four
 
shuttle
cars,
 
and two
 
scoops.
 
Coal is
 
extracted
 
from
 
the production
 
face
 
with the
 
continuous miner
and hauled
 
to the
 
mine conveyor
 
in shuttle
 
cars.
 
At the
 
conveyor
 
belt, the
 
coal is
 
discharged
from the shuttle
 
cars onto a
 
feeder breaker for transfer onto the
 
conveyor.
 
The conveyors carry
the coal to the outside, where
 
it is transported via overland
 
conveyor to
 
the preparation plant
and load-out.
 
The Powellton
 
No. 1 Mine
 
was in the
 
process of being
 
rehabilitated as
 
of December 2023
 
and
all
 
necessary
 
infrastructure
 
and
 
utilities
 
remain
 
in
 
place.
 
All
 
necessary
 
permits
 
have
 
been
obtained.
 
Estimated expenditures for site closure and reclamation are included in the financial
model for
 
this site.
 
Expected annual
 
production averages
 
approximately
 
208,000 marketable
tonnes.
 
The mine is scheduled to terminate during 2040.
13.4.1.2
 
Lower War Eagle
The Lower War Eagle Mine is
 
active with three production
 
sections.
 
The Lower War Eagle seam
is accessed via an existing
 
slope.
 
This mine is a metallurgical
 
coal operation with all
 
remaining
production on leased mineral property.
Production is scheduled for approximately 242 days each
 
year, which represents production on
Monday through Friday.
 
On each day, three production sections are scheduled
 
to produce coal
on two
 
shifts; the
 
third shift
 
is reserved
 
for
 
maintenance
 
and mine
 
conveyor
 
belt and
 
power
moves.
 
The sections are configured as super sections with
 
two continuous miners available for
production.
 
Productivity is planned at the rate
 
of 75.6 meters of advance and retreat
 
per shift
of operation.
 
A total of 150 employees are assigned to the mine.
Principal production equipment includes two continuous miners, two roof bolters, four
 
shuttle
cars,
 
and two
 
scoops
 
for
 
each operating
 
section.
 
Coal is
 
extracted
 
from the
 
production
 
face
with the
 
continuous miner
 
and hauled
 
to the
 
mine conveyor
 
in shuttle
 
cars.
 
At the
 
conveyor
belt, the
 
coal
 
is discharged
 
from
 
the shuttle
 
cars
 
onto
 
a feeder
 
breaker
 
for
 
transfer
 
onto
 
the
conveyor.
 
The
 
conveyors
 
carry
 
the
 
coal
 
outside,
 
where
 
it
 
is
 
transported
 
to
 
the
 
preparation
plant and load-out via overland conveyor.
 
The Lower War
 
Eagle Mine is an operating
 
facility; all necessary infrastructure
 
and utilities are
in place.
 
All necessary
 
permits have
 
been obtained.
 
Estimated
 
expenditures
 
for
 
site closure
and reclamation
 
are included
 
in the financial
 
model for
 
this site.
 
Expected annual production
averages
 
approximately
 
617,000
 
marketable
 
tonnes.
 
The
 
mine
 
is
 
scheduled
 
to
 
terminate
during 2033.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
48
13.4.1.3
 
Eagle No. 1/Toney
 
Fork #1
The Eagle No. 1
 
(Toney Fork #1) Mine is an
 
active mine in
 
the Eagle (No. 2
 
Gas Lower) seam with
three
 
production
 
sections.
 
This
 
mine
 
is
 
a
 
metallurgical
 
coal
 
operation
 
on
 
leased
 
mineral
property and is accessed via drift entries from the outcrop.
Production is scheduled for approximately 242 days each
 
year, which represents production on
Monday through Friday.
 
On each day, three production sections are scheduled
 
to produce coal
on two
 
shifts; the
 
third shift
 
is reserved
 
for
 
maintenance
 
and mine
 
conveyor
 
belt and
 
power
moves.
 
All sections
 
are full
 
super sections
 
with two
 
continuous miners per
 
section.
 
Productivity
is planned at the rate of 73.5 meters of advance per shift (87.5 meters of retreat)
 
for the super
sections.
 
A total of 176 employees are assigned to the mine.
The
 
principal
 
production
 
equipment
 
per
 
section
 
includes
 
two
 
continuous
 
miners,
 
two
 
roof
bolters, four shuttle cars,
 
and two scoops.
 
Coal is extracted from the production face
 
with the
continuous miner
 
and hauled
 
to the
 
mine conveyor
 
in shuttle
 
cars.
 
At the
 
conveyor
 
belt, the
coal is
 
discharged onto
 
a feeder
 
breaker
 
for transfer
 
onto the
 
conveyor.
 
The conveyors
 
carry
the coal outside, where it is
 
stacked on the ground
 
to await truck transport
 
to the preparation
plant and load-out.
The
 
Eagle
 
No.
 
1
 
Mine
 
is
 
an
 
operating
 
facility;
 
all
 
necessary
 
infrastructure
 
and
 
utilities
 
are
 
in
place.
 
All necessary permits have been obtained; the underground footprint area expansion
 
is
pending
 
final
 
approval.
 
Estimated
 
expenditures
 
for
 
mine
 
closure
 
and
 
site
 
reclamation
 
are
included in the financial model.
Expected annual production averages approximately
 
684,000 marketable tonnes.
The mine is scheduled to terminate during 2040.
 
13.4.1.4
 
Muddy Bridge
The Muddy Bridge
 
Mine is an
 
active mine in
 
the Eagle (No.
 
2 Gas Lower)
 
seam.
 
This mine is a
metallurgical
 
coal operation
 
on leased
 
mineral property
 
and is
 
accessed via
 
drift entries
 
from
the outcrop.
Production is scheduled for approximately 242 days each
 
year, which represents production on
Monday through Friday.
 
On each day,
 
two production sections are
 
scheduled to produce coal
on two
 
shifts; the
 
third shift
 
is reserved
 
for
 
maintenance
 
and mine
 
conveyor
 
belt and
 
power
moves.
 
The sections are configured as
 
full super sections with
 
two continuous miners available
for production
 
on each section.
 
Productivity is planned
 
at the rate
 
of 72.3 meters
 
of advance
and retreat per shift of operation.
 
A total of 122 employees are assigned to the mine.
Principal production equipment includes two continuous miners, two roof bolters, four
 
shuttle
cars,
 
and two
 
scoops
 
for
 
each operating
 
section.
 
Coal is
 
extracted
 
from the
 
production
 
face
with the continuous
 
miner and hauled to
 
the mine conveyor
 
via shuttle cars.
 
At the conveyor
belt, the coal
 
is discharged from
 
the haulage units onto
 
a feeder breaker
 
for transfer
 
onto the
conveyor.
 
The conveyors
 
carry the
 
coal to
 
the outside,
 
where
 
it is
 
stacked
 
on the
 
ground to
await truck transport
 
to the Lower
 
War Eagle
 
mine for placement
 
onto the overland
 
conveyor
leading to the preparation plant and load-out.
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
49
The Muddy Bridge
 
Mine is an operating
 
facility; all necessary
 
infrastructure and
 
utilities are in
place.
 
All necessary permits have been obtained.
 
Coal mining permits are routinely obtained.
 
Estimated
 
expenditures
 
for
 
mine
 
closure
 
and
 
site
 
reclamation
 
are
 
included
 
in
 
the
 
financial
model.
Expected
 
annual
 
production
 
averages
 
approximately
 
691,000
 
marketable
 
tonnes
 
at
 
steady
state production levels.
The mine is scheduled to terminate during 2028.
13.4.1.5
 
Elklick Chilton
The proposed Elklick Chilton Mine is scheduled to begin production in 2028.
 
The Chilton seam
is
 
accessed
 
via
 
drift
 
entry.
 
The
 
seam
 
is
 
above
 
drainage.
 
This
 
mine
 
is
 
projected
 
to
 
be
 
a
metallurgical coal operation on leased mineral
 
property.
 
Production is scheduled for approximately 265 days each
 
year, which represents production on
Monday
 
through
 
Friday
 
plus
 
every
 
other
 
Saturday.
 
On
 
each
 
day,
 
one
 
production
 
section
 
is
scheduled to produce
 
coal on two
 
shifts; the third
 
shift is reserved
 
for maintenance
 
and mine
conveyor
 
belt
 
and
 
power
 
moves.
 
The
 
section
 
is
 
configured
 
as
 
a
 
full
 
super
 
section
 
with
 
two
continuous miners
 
available for
 
production on the section.
 
Productivity is planned at
 
the rate
of
 
73.2
 
meters
 
of
 
advance
 
(109.8
 
meters
 
of
 
retreat)
 
per
 
shift
 
of
 
operation.
 
A
 
total
 
of
 
59
employees are assigned to the mine.
Principal production equipment includes two continuous miners, two roof bolters, four
 
shuttle
cars,
 
and two
 
scoops.
 
Coal is
 
extracted
 
from
 
the production
 
face
 
with the
 
continuous miner
and hauled to the
 
mine conveyor
 
via shuttle cars.
 
At the conveyor
 
belt, the coal is
 
discharged
from the
 
haulage units
 
onto a
 
feeder
 
breaker
 
for transfer
 
onto the
 
conveyor.
 
The conveyors
carry
 
the
 
coal
 
outside,
 
where
 
it
 
is
 
stacked
 
on
 
the
 
ground
 
to
 
await
 
truck
 
transport
 
to
 
the
preparation plant and load-out.
 
The Elklick Chilton mine is a permitted mine with
 
surface infrastructure in place.
 
The proposed
mine
 
is
 
located
 
in
 
an
 
area
 
with
 
a
 
long
 
history
 
of
 
coal
 
mining,
 
with
 
numerous
 
permitted
operations
 
in close
 
proximity.
 
Estimated
 
expenditures
 
for
 
mine closure
 
and site
 
reclamation
are included in the financial model.
Expected
 
annual
 
production
 
averages
 
approximately
 
301,000
 
marketable
 
tonnes
 
at
 
steady
state production levels.
The mine is scheduled to begin production in 2028 and terminate during 2040.
13.4.1.6
 
Camp Branch Chilton
The Camp Branch Chilton Mine is proposed mine
 
in the Chilton seam which is
 
accessed via drift
entry
 
from
 
the
 
outcrop
 
and
 
is
 
scheduled
 
to
 
begin
 
production
 
in
 
2027.
 
This
 
mine
 
is
 
a
metallurgical coal operation on leased mineral
 
property.
Production is scheduled for approximately 265 days each
 
year, which represents production on
Monday
 
through
 
Friday
 
plus
 
every
 
other
 
Saturday.
 
On
 
each
 
day,
 
one
 
production
 
section
 
is
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
50
scheduled to produce
 
coal on two
 
shifts; the third
 
shift is reserved
 
for maintenance
 
and mine
conveyor
 
belt
 
and
 
power
 
moves.
 
The
 
section
 
is
 
configured
 
as
 
a
 
full
 
super
 
section
 
with
 
two
continuous miners
 
available for
 
production on the section.
 
Productivity is planned at
 
the rate
of
 
73.2
 
meters
 
of
 
advance
 
(109.8
 
meters
 
of
 
retreat)
 
per
 
shift
 
of
 
operation.
 
A
 
total
 
of
 
59
employees are assigned to the mine.
Principal production equipment includes two continuous miners, two roof bolters, four
 
shuttle
cars,
 
and two
 
scoops.
 
Coal is
 
extracted
 
from
 
the production
 
face
 
with the
 
continuous miner
and hauled to the
 
mine conveyor
 
via shuttle cars.
 
At the conveyor
 
belt, the coal is
 
discharged
from the
 
haulage units
 
onto a
 
feeder
 
breaker
 
for transfer
 
onto the
 
conveyor.
 
The conveyors
carry
 
the
 
coal
 
outside,
 
where
 
it
 
is
 
stacked
 
on
 
the
 
ground
 
to
 
await
 
truck
 
transport
 
to
 
the
preparation plant and load-out.
Due
 
to
 
the
 
projected
 
starting
 
date
 
for
 
the
 
Camp
 
Branch
 
Chilton
 
Mine,
 
no
 
detailed
 
design
 
of
infrastructure
 
or surface
 
facilities has
 
been completed
 
to date.
 
The proposed
 
mine is located
in the Appalachian Basin,
 
which has an
 
extensive history
 
(>100 years) of
 
coal mining.
 
There is
a sufficient population base
 
within commuting distance of
 
the proposed operation; no Camp or
Town
 
construction will be required.
 
Estimated mine access and utility capital expenditures are
included in the financial model for the mine.
The proposed
 
Camp Branch
 
Chilton Mine
 
has an
 
existing permit.
 
Estimated
 
expenditures for
mine closure and site reclamation are included in the financial model.
Expected
 
annual
 
production
 
averages
 
approximately
 
321,000
 
marketable
 
tonnes
 
at
 
steady
state production levels.
The mine is scheduled to begin production in 2027 and terminate during 2032.
13.4.1.7
 
Lower Winifrede
The Lower Winifrede Mine
 
is a proposed mine
 
in the Lower Winifrede
 
seam which is accessed
via drift
 
entry from
 
the outcrop
 
and is
 
scheduled to
 
begin production
 
in 2033.
 
This mine
 
is a
metallurgical coal operation on leased mineral
 
property.
Production is scheduled for approximately 242 days each
 
year, which represents production on
Monday through Friday.
 
On each day,
 
two production sections are
 
scheduled to produce coal
on two
 
shifts; the
 
third shift
 
is reserved
 
for
 
maintenance
 
and mine
 
conveyor
 
belt and
 
power
moves.
 
The sections are configured as
 
full super sections with
 
two continuous miners available
for production
 
on each section.
 
Productivity is planned
 
at the rate
 
of 64.0 meters
 
of advance
per shift of operation.
 
A total of 122 employees are assigned to the mine.
Principal production equipment includes two continuous miners, two roof bolters, four
 
shuttle
cars,
 
and
 
two
 
scoops
 
for
 
each
 
section.
 
Coal
 
is
 
extracted
 
from
 
the
 
production
 
face
 
with
 
the
continuous miner and
 
hauled to the mine
 
conveyor via
 
shuttle cars.
 
At the conveyor
 
belt, the
coal is discharged from the haulage units onto a feeder breaker for transfer onto the conveyor.
 
The conveyors carry the coal outside,
 
where it is stacked on
 
the ground to await truck
 
transport
to the preparation plant and load-out.
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
51
Due
 
to
 
the
 
projected
 
starting
 
date
 
for
 
the
 
Lower
 
Winifrede
 
Mine,
 
no
 
detailed
 
design
 
of
infrastructure
 
or surface
 
facilities has
 
been completed
 
to date.
 
The proposed
 
mine is located
in the Appalachian Basin,
 
which has an
 
extensive history
 
(>100 years) of
 
coal mining.
 
There is
a sufficient population base
 
within commuting distance of
 
the proposed operation; no Camp or
Town
 
construction will be required.
 
Estimated mine access and utility capital expenditures are
included in the financial model for the mine.
The mine is scheduled to begin production in 2033 and terminate during 2038.
13.4.1.8
 
Upper Winifrede
The
 
proposed
 
Upper
 
Winifrede
 
Mine
 
is
 
scheduled
 
to
 
begin
 
production
 
in
 
2036.
 
The
 
Upper
Winifrede seam is accessed via
 
a proposed drift along the
 
outcrop.
 
This mine is projected to be
a metallurgical coal operation on leased mineral property.
Production is scheduled for approximately 265 days each
 
year, which represents production on
Monday
 
through
 
Friday
 
plus
 
every
 
other
 
Saturday.
 
On
 
each
 
day,
 
one
 
production
 
section
 
is
scheduled to produce
 
coal on two
 
shifts; the third
 
shift is reserved
 
for maintenance
 
and mine
conveyor
 
belt
 
and
 
power
 
moves.
 
The
 
section
 
is
 
configured
 
as
 
a
 
full
 
super
 
section
 
with
 
two
continuous miners
 
available for
 
production on the section.
 
Productivity is planned at
 
the rate
of 73.2 meters
 
of advance per
 
shift of operation
 
.
 
A total
 
of 59 employees
 
are assigned to
 
the
mine.
Principal production equipment includes two continuous miners, two roof bolters, four
 
shuttle
cars,
 
and two
 
scoops.
 
Coal is
 
extracted
 
from
 
the production
 
face
 
with the
 
continuous miner
and hauled
 
to the
 
mine conveyor
 
in shuttle
 
cars.
 
At the
 
conveyor
 
belt, the
 
coal is
 
discharged
from the shuttle
 
cars onto a
 
feeder breaker for transfer onto the
 
conveyor.
 
The conveyors carry
the coal outside, where it is
 
stacked on the ground
 
to await truck transport
 
to the preparation
plant and load-out.
 
Due
 
to
 
the
 
projected
 
starting
 
date
 
for
 
the
 
Upper
 
Winifrede
 
Mine,
 
no
 
detailed
 
design
 
of
infrastructure
 
or surface
 
facilities has
 
been completed
 
to date.
 
The proposed
 
mine is located
in the Appalachian Basin,
 
which has an
 
extensive history
 
(>100 years) of
 
coal mining.
 
There is
a sufficient population base
 
within commuting distance of
 
the proposed operation; no Camp or
Town
 
construction will be required.
 
Estimated mine access and utility capital expenditures are
included in the financial model for the mine.
Due
 
to
 
the
 
projected
 
start-up
 
date
 
of
 
the
 
Upper
 
Winifrede
 
Mine,
 
no
 
permit
 
work
 
has
 
been
completed to date.
 
The proposed mine is located in an area with a long history of coal mining,
with
 
numerous
 
permitted
 
operations
 
in
 
close
 
proximity.
 
Coal
 
mining
 
permits
 
are
 
routinely
obtained.
 
Estimated
 
expenditures
 
for
 
mine closure
 
and
 
site
 
reclamation
 
are
 
included in
 
the
financial model for each mine or plant site.
Expected
 
annual
 
production
 
averages
 
approximately
 
464,000
 
marketable
 
tonnes
 
at
 
steady
state levels.
 
The mine is scheduled to begin production in 2036 and terminate during 2039.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
52
13.4.1.9
 
Lower Powellton
The
 
proposed
 
Lower
 
Powellton
 
Mine
 
is
 
scheduled
 
to
 
begin
 
production
 
in
 
2032.
 
The
 
Lower
Powellton
 
seam is
 
accessed via
 
a proposed
 
drift along
 
the outcrop.
 
This mine
 
is projected
 
to
be a metallurgical coal operation on leased mineral property.
Production is scheduled for approximately 265 days each
 
year, which represents production on
Monday through
 
Friday plus every
 
other Saturday.
 
On each day,
 
two production
 
sections are
scheduled to produce
 
coal on two
 
shifts; the third
 
shift is reserved
 
for maintenance
 
and mine
conveyor
 
belt
 
and
 
power
 
moves.
 
Both
 
sections
 
are
 
configured
 
as
 
a
 
super
 
section
 
with
 
two
continuous miners per section available for production.
 
Productivity is planned at 73.2 meters
of advance
 
per shift
 
(85.4 meters
 
of retreat
 
per shift).
 
A total
 
of 122
 
employees are
 
assigned
to the mine during steady state production.
Principal production equipment per
 
section includes two continuous
 
miners, two roof
 
bolters,
four
 
shuttle
 
cars,
 
and
 
one
 
scoop.
 
Coal
 
is
 
extracted
 
from
 
the
 
production
 
face
 
with
 
the
continuous miner
 
and hauled
 
to the
 
mine conveyor
 
in shuttle
 
cars.
 
At the
 
conveyor
 
belt, the
coal is discharged
 
from the
 
shuttle cars
 
onto a feeder
 
breaker for
 
transfer onto
 
the conveyor.
 
The conveyors carry the coal outside,
 
where it is stacked on
 
the ground to await truck
 
transport
to the preparation plant and load-out.
 
Due
 
to
 
the
 
projected
 
starting
 
date
 
for
 
the
 
Lower
 
Powellton
 
Mine,
 
no
 
detailed
 
design
 
of
infrastructure
 
or surface
 
facilities has
 
been completed
 
to date.
 
The proposed
 
mine is located
in the Appalachian Basin,
 
which has an
 
extensive history
 
(>100 years) of
 
coal mining.
 
There is
a sufficient population base
 
within commuting distance of
 
the proposed operation; no Camp or
Town
 
construction will be required.
 
Estimated mine access and utility capital expenditures are
included in the financial model for the mine.
Due
 
to
 
the
 
projected
 
start-up
 
date
 
of
 
the
 
Lower
 
Powellton
 
Mine,
 
no
 
permit
 
work
 
has
 
been
completed to date.
 
The proposed mine is located in an area with a long history of coal mining,
with
 
numerous
 
permitted
 
operations
 
in
 
close
 
proximity.
 
Coal
 
mining
 
permits
 
are
 
routinely
obtained.
 
Estimated
 
expenditures
 
for
 
mine closure
 
and
 
site
 
reclamation
 
are
 
included in
 
the
financial model for each mine or plant site.
Expected
 
annual
 
production
 
averages
 
approximately
 
501,000
 
marketable
 
tonnes
 
at
 
steady
state levels.
 
The mine is scheduled to begin production in 2032 and terminate during 2042.
13.4.2
 
Surface Mines and Highwall Miners
Three
 
surface
 
resource
 
areas were
 
modeled.
 
Mining operations
 
are projected
 
to utilize
 
area
mining
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
contour
 
mining
 
(
CTR
)
 
methods
 
with
 
an
 
emphasis
 
on
 
creating
 
highwall
 
for
highwall
 
mining
 
activity.
 
The
 
projected
 
operations
 
will
 
employ
 
a
 
recently
 
acquired
 
Komatsu
PC2000
 
hydraulic
 
backhoe
 
and
 
a
 
Caterpillar
 
993K
 
front-end
 
loader
 
capable
 
of
 
a
 
combined
production
 
rate
 
of
 
approximately
 
1,162
 
bank
 
cubic
 
meters
 
per
 
hour
 
(
bcm/hr
)
 
with
supplemental assistance of 6 dozers that can generate approximately an additional 700
 
bcm/hr
providing their
 
spoil placement
 
does not
 
interfere
 
with planned
 
highwall mining
 
activity.
 
The
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
53
front-end loader is
 
not expected to
 
contribute to production
 
until late 2024.
 
Dozer contribution
is expected to be limited to contours that have
 
lower benches available for placement of spoil.
 
To
 
encourage its usage, contour and highwall mining activity is generally expected to be mined
from
 
lower
 
to
 
upper
 
seams.
 
Larger
 
area
 
mining
 
boundaries
 
offer
 
greater
 
opportunities
 
for
dozers
 
to
 
contribute
 
to
 
production.
 
Since
 
the
 
majority
 
of
 
the
 
mining
 
boundaries
 
during
 
the
initial
 
budget
 
years
 
are
 
primarily
 
contours,
 
dozers
 
will
 
supplement
 
production
 
on
 
a
 
periodic
basis.
 
They,
 
however,
 
will
 
likely
 
also
 
be
 
used
 
to
 
help
 
feed
 
loading
 
machines
 
and
 
reclaim
highwalls
 
when
 
not
 
directly
 
contributing
 
to
 
production.
 
The
 
potential
 
production
 
level
 
of
combined machines is
 
not projected to be
 
achieved until 2025.
 
Sufficient reserves allow mining
to continue to the year 2055.
 
The
 
models assume
 
that the
 
operations
 
will
 
work two,
 
10-hour production
 
shifts, 5
 
days
 
per
week
 
plus
 
every
 
other
 
Saturday,
 
with
 
sufficient
 
staffing
 
to
 
float
 
vacation
 
during
 
the
 
year.
 
A
total of 86 employees are assumed for
 
the surface mines at full production.
 
It is assumed that
most of the spoil movement goes through a shovel or loader bucket and is eventually returned
to the pit for final reclamation.
 
The dozer’s primary responsibility is cutting the initial benches
for the drill and shaping the reclaimed contour highwall.
 
All highwall mining is assumed to
 
be performed by a contractor
 
.
 
The contractor is responsible
for staffing
 
those operations
 
along with providing
 
necessary equipment capital.
 
One highwall
miner will be used
 
until 2028 then
 
an additional highwall miner
 
will be introduced
 
in 2029.
 
In
2044,
 
a
 
third
 
highwall
 
miner
 
will
 
be
 
introduced
 
to
 
keep
 
the
 
miners
 
in
 
close
 
proximity
 
to
 
the
surface mining activity.
Spoil for
 
final highwall
 
reclamation
 
is expected
 
to come
 
from
 
strategic
 
placement of
 
spoil on
pre-existing
 
benches
 
by
 
haul
 
trucks
 
such
 
that
 
they
 
are
 
within
 
the
 
push
 
distance
 
of
 
the
reclamation dozer.
 
13.4.2.1
 
Toney
 
Fork
Toney
 
Fork surface
 
mining operations
 
are projected
 
to be
 
completed
 
in 2055,
 
with emphasis
placed
 
on
 
preparing
 
space
 
for
 
HWM
 
operations.
 
Expected
 
production
 
for
 
the
 
operations
averages approximately
 
234,000 marketable tonnes annually.
The Toney
 
Fork HWM
 
is projected
 
to be
 
completed
 
in 2056
 
and mines
 
an additional
 
176,000
marketable tonnes annually at steady
 
state levels.
13.4.2.2
 
Buffalo Creek South
The
 
Buffalo
 
Creek
 
South
 
surface
 
and/or
 
HWM
 
mining
 
operations
 
are
 
projected
 
to
 
operate
between
 
2024
 
and
 
2055,
 
with
 
emphasis
 
placed
 
on
 
preparing
 
space
 
for
 
HWM
 
operations.
 
Expected
 
surface
 
production
 
for
 
the
 
operations
 
totals
 
approximately
 
245,000
 
marketable
tonnes
 
annually at
 
steady state
 
levels.
 
The Buffalo
 
Creek HWM
 
mines an
 
additional 212,000
marketable tonnes annually at steady state
 
levels.
13.4.2.3
 
Sugar Camp
Sugar Camp surface mining operations are projected to
 
be mined from 2029
 
to 2055.
 
Expected
production for the operations averages
 
approximately 189,000 marketable
 
tonnes annually.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
54
The Sugar Camp HWM operates from 2029 to
 
2056 and mines an
 
additional 47,000 marketable
tonnes per year.
As shown in
Tables 13-1 through 13-3
, the areas planned for underground production continue
until 2044, whereas
 
surface and auger/HWM
 
production is projected
 
to finish in
 
2055 and
 
2057,
respectively.
 
Clean
 
coal
 
production
 
varies
 
directly
 
with
 
coal
 
thickness
 
in
 
the
 
case
 
of
 
the
underground mines, and overburden removal for
 
the surface mines.
Table 13-1:
 
Underground Summary of Production by Year (Tonnes
 
x 1,000)
Mine Name
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
2031
Camp Br Chilton
0
0
0
0
0
38
361
366
Ramaco N2G
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Eagle No. 1 (Toney
 
Fork)
665
682
647
669
619
774
679
556
Elk Lick Chilton
0
0
0
0
0
227
252
275
Lower Powellton
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Lower War Eagle
453
467
483
464
492
630
664
687
Powellton No. 1
151
171
165
165
158
230
232
231
Muddy Br No.2 Gas
636
575
581
518
403
0
0
0
Lower Winifrede
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Upper Winifrede
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Winifrede (Chilton Rider)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
 
Total
1,905
1,895
1,876
1,817
1,673
1,900
2,188
2,114
Mine Name
2032
2033
2034
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
Camp Br Chilton
324
283
235
0
0
0
0
0
Ramaco N2G
0
0
0
0
0
0
76
274
Eagle No. 1 (Toney
 
Fork)
773
713
674
611
645
636
676
580
Elk Lick Chilton
285
277
292
247
298
346
360
313
Lower Powellton
0
0
101
466
508
496
504
507
Lower War Eagle
678
711
0
0
0
0
0
0
Powellton No. 1
232
231
227
214
219
216
214
210
Muddy Br No.2 Gas
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Lower Winifrede
0
396
545
491
266
247
146
0
Upper Winifrede
0
0
0
0
412
567
361
98
Winifrede (Chilton Rider)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
 
Total
2,292
2,612
2,075
2,030
2,349
2,509
2,337
1,982
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
55
Mine Name
2040
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
2046
2047
Camp Br Chilton
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Ramaco N2G
291
265
268
271
74
0
0
0
Eagle No. 1 (Toney
 
Fork)
359
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Elk Lick Chilton
319
317
0
0
0
0
0
0
Lower Powellton
508
507
510
704
284
0
0
0
Lower War Eagle
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Powellton No. 1
209
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Muddy Br No.2 Gas
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Lower Winifrede
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Upper Winifrede
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Winifrede (Chilton Rider)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
 
Total
1,687
1,089
777
975
358
0
0
0
Table 13-2:
 
Surface Summary of Production by Year (Tonnes
 
x 1,000)
Mine Name
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
2031
Toney Fork Surf
0
0
0
0
0
233
233
233
Buffalo Cr South Area
470
593
625
591
725
174
174
174
Sugar Camp Area 1
0
0
0
0
0
188
188
188
 
Total
470
593
625
591
725
595
595
595
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2032
2033
2034
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
Toney Fork Surf
233
233
233
240
239
239
238
239
Buffalo Cr South Area
174
174
174
174
178
178
178
177
Sugar Camp Area 1
188
188
188
193
192
192
191
192
 
Total
595
595
595
607
609
609
607
608
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2040
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
2046
2047
Toney Fork Surf
239
239
239
239
238
239
239
240
Buffalo Cr South Area
178
178
178
178
178
177
178
178
Sugar Camp Area 1
192
192
192
192
191
192
192
193
 
Total
609
609
609
609
607
608
609
611
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2048
2049
2050
2051
2052
2053
2054
2055
Toney Fork Surf
239
238
238
240
239
239
164
208
Buffalo Cr South Area
178
178
177
177
178
178
178
73
Sugar Camp Area 1
192
191
191
193
192
192
134
7
 
Total
609
607
607
610
609
609
476
288
Table 13-3:
 
Highwall Summary of Production by Year (Tonnes
 
x 1,000)
Mine Name
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
2031
Toney Fork HWM
0
0
0
0
0
138
138
138
Buffalo Cr South HWM
168
208
201
119
0
179
179
179
Sugar Camp HWM
0
0
0
0
0
37
37
37
 
Total
168
208
201
119
0
355
355
355
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2032
2033
2034
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
Toney Fork HWM
138
138
138
142
142
142
141
142
Buffalo Cr South HWM
179
179
179
179
184
184
184
183
Sugar Camp HWM
37
37
37
37
38
38
38
38
 
Total
355
355
355
359
365
364
363
363
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
56
Mine Name
2040
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
2046
2047
Toney Fork HWM
142
142
213
213
212
213
213
214
Buffalo Cr South HWM
184
184
184
270
270
269
270
270
Sugar Camp HWM
38
38
38
57
57
57
57
57
 
Total
364
364
435
540
539
539
540
541
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2048
2049
2050
2051
2052
2053
2054
2055
Toney Fork HWM
213
212
212
214
213
213
213
193
Buffalo Cr South HWM
271
270
269
269
271
270
270
270
Sugar Camp HWM
58
57
57
57
58
57
57
57
 
Total
541
539
538
540
541
540
540
521
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2056
2057
2058
2059
2060
2061
2062
2063
Toney Fork HWM
138
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Buffalo Cr South HWM
247
11
0
0
0
0
0
0
Sugar Camp HWM
52
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
 
Total
437
11
0
0
0
0
0
0
14
Processing and Recovery Methods
14.1
 
Description or Flowsheet
The
 
Logan
 
County
 
Division includes
 
the
 
Saunders Preparation
 
Plant
 
in addition
 
to the
 
mines.
 
The
 
plant
 
site
 
includes
 
raw
 
coal
 
storage,
 
clean
 
coal
 
storage,
 
a
 
railroad
 
loadout,
 
and
 
refuse
disposal
 
area.
 
The
 
plant
 
has
 
a
 
feed
 
rate
 
capacity
 
of
 
1,088
 
raw
 
tonnes
 
per
 
hour.
 
Primary
separation
 
equipment
 
includes
 
a
 
heavy
 
media
 
vessel,
 
heavy
 
media
 
cyclones,
 
classifying
cyclones,
 
spirals,
 
flotation
 
cells,
 
and
 
column
 
flotation,
 
supported
 
by
 
the
 
requisite
 
screens,
centrifuges,
 
vacuum
 
filters,
 
sumps, pumps,
 
and distribution
 
systems.
 
Coarse
 
and fine
 
refuse
are disposed separately in an adjacent refuse area which incorporates
 
slurry cells.
Processes and equipment are typical of those used in the coal industry and are
 
in use in nearly
all plants in the Central Appalachian Basin.
 
14.2
 
Requirements for Energy,
 
Water,
 
Material and Personnel
Personnel have
 
historically been sourced
 
from the surrounding
 
communities in Logan,
 
Boone,
Wyoming,
 
and Mingo
 
counties, and
 
have
 
proven
 
to be
 
adequate
 
in numbers
 
to operate
 
past
and current
 
mines.
 
As mining is common
 
in the surrounding
 
areas, the workforce
 
is generally
familiar with mining practices and is comprised of a strong talent pool of experienced
 
miners.
Water
 
is sourced locally
 
from Buffalo
 
Creek Public Service District
 
and/or locally from
 
streams
via water
 
withdrawal permits,
 
and electricity is
 
sourced from
 
AEP.
 
The service industry
 
in the
areas surrounding the mine complex
 
has historically provided supplies, equipment
 
repairs and
fabrication, etc.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
57
15
Infrastructure
The
 
Coronado-owned
 
Saunders
 
Preparation
 
Plant
 
services
 
the
 
mines.
 
The
 
ROM
 
coal
 
is
delivered from the Lower War Eagle Mine via overland conveyor, all remaining production is or
will be delivered to the plant site by truck.
The CSX rail line serves as the main means of transport from the mine complex/loadout.
As an active operation, the necessary support infrastructure for
 
Logan is in place.
As new areas are developed, the infrastructure requirements will change.
 
These changes have
been considered in the LOM plans and financial model.
A
 
few
 
of
 
the
 
seams
 
lie
 
below
 
drainage;
 
however,
 
a
 
substantial
 
number
 
of
 
metallurgical
 
coal
seams are situated above drainage.
 
The underground mining resource areas which are located
above-drainage
 
require
 
an
 
access
 
road
 
and
 
mine
 
access
 
development
 
along
 
the
 
outcrop,
whereas
 
below-drainage
 
mines are
 
accessed based
 
on other
 
proposed
 
surface
 
infrastructure
locations
 
and/or
 
surface
 
property
 
control.
 
In
 
some
 
cases,
 
the
 
access
 
and
 
face-up
 
may
 
be
developed as part of surface mining activities.
 
A mine transformer and water
 
tank are located
at
 
the
 
face-up,
 
along with
 
the
 
mine fan,
 
stacker
 
conveyor,
 
supply
 
facilities,
 
shop,
 
office,
 
and
bath house.
The surface mining mobile equipment spreads advance the contour and area mining pits while
systematically
 
reclaiming the trailing
 
side of pits where
 
coal has been removed.
 
The coal haul
roads
 
are
 
extended
 
and
 
maintained
 
as
 
the
 
pits
 
advance.
 
Support
 
facilities
 
are
 
maintained
nearby but away from the active mining, and
 
include storage areas for blasting agents, fuel and
lubricants, and mine supplies along with maintenance facilities and offices.
The
 
HWM
 
equipment
 
advances
 
along
 
with
 
the
 
contour
 
mining
 
pits.
 
The
 
rate
 
of
 
advance
 
of
contour
 
mining
 
is
 
somewhat
 
constrained
 
by
 
the
 
advancement
 
rate
 
of
 
the
 
HWM.
 
A
 
diesel-
powered
 
generator
 
trails
 
the
 
highwall
 
miner
 
and powers
 
the
 
continuous
 
mining
 
unit.
 
Other
support facilities are provided along with the contour mining support facilities.
 
A map of the existing facilities in
Figure 15-1
 
shows the layout of the required infrastructure.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
ex963p67i2 ex963p67i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
58
Figure 15-1:
 
Logan Surface Facilities
16
Market Studies
16.1
 
Market Description
The quality characteristics for the subject coal resources and coal reserves have been reviewed
in
 
detail
 
by
 
MM&A.
 
The
 
drill
 
hole
 
data
 
was
 
utilized
 
to
 
develop
 
average
 
coal
 
quality
characteristics for the mining site.
 
These average coal quality characteristics were then utilized
as
 
the
 
basis
 
for
 
determining
 
the
 
various
 
markets
 
into
 
which
 
the
 
saleable
 
coal
 
will
 
likely
 
be
placed.
 
The projected quality specifications for the Logan products
 
are as shown in
Table 16-1
.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
59
Table 16-1:
 
Quality Specifications by Product
HVA
HVB
Thermal
(A/R)
Moisture (%)
7.50
8.00
7.50
Ash (%)
7.50
8.00
12.50
Sulfur (%)
0.90
0.95
1.00
Volatile Matter (%)
32.5
37.0
36.0
Btu/lb.
N/A
N/A
12,300
Fluidity (ddpm)
30,000
25,000
N/A
MMR (%)
1.04
0.93
N/A
CSR
62
58
N/A
FSI
8.00
8.00
N/A
Note:
 
All Specs are dry basis except Moisture and Thermal
The mine production serves both the high-volatile metallurgical and thermal markets.
16.2
 
Price Forecasts
Coronado
 
provided
 
MM&A
 
with
 
price
 
forecasts
 
for
 
the
 
various
 
coal
 
markets
 
supplied
 
by
 
its
active
 
and
 
future
 
operations
 
in
 
terms
 
of
 
2024
 
(January)
 
real
 
dollars.1
 
MM&A
 
applied
 
a
 
2%
annual inflation
 
rate
 
to the
 
Coronado price
 
forecast
 
in order
 
to estimate
 
revenues in
 
nominal
dollars.
 
Customer
 
coal pricing
 
is derived
 
from
 
market
 
observed
 
forward
 
estimates
 
based
 
on
global economic supply
 
and demand analysis
 
which is applied to
 
mine plan sales volumes
 
and
product
 
mix
 
and
 
is
 
supplemented
 
with
 
Coronado’s
 
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
transportation
 
charges, ocean
 
freight
 
charges and
 
port charges.
 
MM&A utilized
 
this data
 
for
price forecasting in financial modeling.
 
Concurrent with aforementioned-quality parameters in
the
 
preceding
 
section,
 
production
 
from
 
the
 
proposed
 
operations
 
is
 
assumed
 
to
 
be
 
primarily
sold in metallurgical markets with
 
limited thermal sales.
 
Pricing was provided through
 
calendar
year
 
2057.
 
The
 
pricing
 
data
 
assumes
 
respective
 
HVA,
 
HVB
 
and
 
thermal
 
FOB-mine
 
prices
 
of
approximately $162,
 
$144, and $120 per metric
 
tonne for calendar
 
year 2024.
 
HVA, HVB,
 
and
thermal prices respectively decrease
 
to approximately
 
$161, $143, and $114 per
 
metric tonne
through year
 
2026, and then increase
 
to $308, $273,
 
and $212 per metric
 
tonne through
 
year
2057.
 
16.3
 
Contract Requirements
Some contracts are necessary for successful marketing
 
of the coal.
 
For Logan, since all mining,
preparation and marketing is done in-house, the remaining
 
contracts required are:
1 The
 
Coronado pricing
 
forecast
 
was provided
 
to MM&A
 
in real
 
2024 (January)
 
dollars based
on Coronado’s internal budget sales pricing
 
for the first 5
 
years of the forecast.
 
Beyond the first
5 years, Coronado’s
 
forecast is based
 
on sales price information
 
from AME Group
 
adjusted for
transportation costs to an FOB Mine basis.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
60
>
Transportation
 
– The
 
Mine contracts
 
with the
 
CSX Railroad
 
to transport
 
the coal
 
to either
the
 
domestic
 
customers
 
or
 
to
 
the
 
Pier
 
9
 
and
 
Dominion
 
terminals
 
at
 
Norfolk,
 
Virginia
 
for
overseas shipment.
>
Sales
– Sales contracts are a
 
mix of spot
 
and contract sales.
 
With the volatility
 
of the market,
long-term contracts are not typically written.
17
Environmental Studies, Permitting and Plans,
Negotiations or Agreements with Local
Individuals
17.1
 
Results of Studies
MM&A
 
completed
 
a
 
Limited
 
Phase
 
I
 
Environmental
 
Site
 
Assessment
 
(
ESA
)
 
on
 
the
 
Logan
Property in May
 
2017 on behalf of
 
Coronado.
 
Coronado reports not
 
having conducted
 
such a
study
 
since
 
the
 
MM&A
 
studies.
 
The
 
ESA
 
completed
 
by
 
MM&A
 
included
 
a
 
site
 
inspection,
review
 
of
 
historical
 
records,
 
a
 
database
 
search
 
of
 
State
 
and
 
Federal
 
regulatory
 
records
 
and
interviews
 
to
 
identify
 
potential
 
recognized
 
environmental
 
conditions
 
(
RECs
)
 
that
 
may
 
create
environmental
 
liability for
 
the sites.
 
MM&A concluded
 
that no
 
long-term liabilities
 
existed at
the time of these ESAs.
Based
 
on
 
these
 
former
 
ESAs
 
completed
 
by
 
MM&A,
 
it
 
is
 
the
 
QPs’
 
opinion
 
that
 
Logan
 
has
 
a
generally typical coal
 
industry record of compliance
 
with applicable mining, water quality,
 
and
environmental
 
laws.
 
Estimated
 
costs
 
for
 
mine
 
closure,
 
including
 
water
 
quality
 
monitoring
during site reclamation, are included in the financial models.
17.2
 
Requirements and Plans for Waste
 
Disposal
The original design for
 
the North Fork Refuse Area
 
(
North Fork
) at the Logan Property projected
a
 
crest
 
to
 
elevation
 
686
 
meters.
 
The
 
present
 
elevation
 
of
 
the
 
deck
 
is
 
±685meters.
 
In
 
2018
MSHA approved an expansion
 
plan to raise the
 
cross-valley crest
 
to elevation 802
 
meters, and
from there converting to a sidehill fill.
 
This will allow for a total volume of 50 million CM which
would be
 
sufficient capacity
 
for
 
all the
 
refuse generated
 
by the
 
LOM plan
 
that underpins
 
the
current Logan County Division
 
reserves.
 
Further plans
 
for the North
 
Fork site call
 
for conversion
of the
 
fill to
 
a total
 
cross-valley
 
configuration,
 
predicated
 
on completion
 
of surface
 
mining on
the ridge between
 
North Fork
 
and Middle
 
Fork.
 
This has
 
the potential of
 
providing an additional
10 million CM of capacity.
17.3
 
Permit Requirements and Status
All mining operations are subject to federal and state
 
laws and must obtain permits to operate
mines,
 
coal
 
preparation
 
and
 
related
 
facilities,
 
haul
 
roads,
 
and
 
other
 
incidental
 
surface
disturbances necessary for mining
 
to occur.
 
Permits generally require
 
that the permittee
 
post
a performance bond in an amount established by the regulatory program to provide assurance
that
 
any
 
disturbance
 
or
 
liability
 
created
 
during
 
mining
 
operations
 
is
 
properly
 
restored
 
to
 
an
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
61
approved
 
post-mining
 
land
 
use and
 
that
 
all
 
regulations
 
and requirements
 
of
 
the permits
 
are
fully satisfied before
 
the bond is
 
returned to
 
the permittee.
 
Significant penalties exist
 
for any
permittee
 
who
 
fails
 
to
 
meet
 
the
 
obligations
 
of
 
the
 
permits
 
including
 
cessation
 
of
 
mining
operations, which can lead to potential forfeiture of the bond.
 
Any company,
 
and its directors,
owners and
 
officers, which
 
are subject to
 
bond forfeiture
 
can be denied
 
future permits under
the program.2
New
 
permits
 
or permit
 
revisions
 
will occasionally
 
be
 
necessary to
 
facilitate
 
the
 
expansion
 
or
addition of
 
new mining
 
areas on
 
the properties,
 
such as
 
amendments to
 
existing permits
 
and
new permits for
 
mining of
 
reserve areas.
 
Exploration permits also
 
are required.
 
Property under
lease includes
 
provisions for exploration among
 
the terms of
 
the lease.
 
New or modified
 
mining
permits are
 
subject to
 
a public
 
advertisement process
 
and comment
 
period, and
 
the public
 
is
provided an
 
opportunity to raise
 
objections to any
 
proposed mining
 
operation.
 
MM&A is not
aware
 
of any
 
specific prohibition
 
of mining
 
on the
 
subject property
 
and given
 
sufficient time
and planning, Coronado
 
should be able
 
to secure
 
new permits to
 
maintain its
 
planned mining
operations within the context of current regulations.
 
Necessary permits are in
 
place to support
current production on the
 
properties, but future permits are
 
required to maintain
 
and expand
production.
 
Portions
 
of
 
the
 
properties
 
are
 
located
 
near
 
local
 
communities.
 
Regulations
prohibit mining activities within 91.4 meters of a residential dwelling, school, church, or
 
similar
structure
 
unless
 
written
 
consent
 
is
 
first
 
obtained
 
from
 
the
 
owner
 
of
 
the
 
structure.
 
Where
required, such consents
 
have been obtained
 
where mining is
 
proposed beyond the
 
regulatory
limits.
Coronado has
 
obtained all
 
mining and discharge
 
permits to
 
operate its
 
mines and processing,
loadout or related facilities.
 
MM&A is unaware of any obvious or current Coronado permitting
issues that
 
are expected
 
to prevent
 
the issuance of
 
future permits.
 
Logan, along
 
with all
 
coal
producers,
 
is
 
subject
 
to
 
a
 
level
 
of
 
uncertainty
 
regarding
 
future
 
clean
 
water
 
permits
 
due
 
to
United
 
States
 
Environmental
 
Protection
 
Agency
(
EPA
)
and
United
 
States
 
Fish
 
and
 
Wildlife
(
USFW
)
 
involvement with state
 
programs.
The Mining permits currently held by Logan are shown in
Table 17-1.
2 Monitored under the
 
Applicant Violator System (AVS) by the Federal Office
 
of Surface Mining.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
62
Table 17-1:
 
Logan Mining Permits
Type
Permit ID
Permit Name
$ Bond
Current Status
Issued Date
Expiration Date
Hectares
NPDES
Other
O001984
 
North Fork Refuse
1
$1,033,200
 
Renewed
4/11/1984
4/11/2024
116.03
WV0095699
Other – Loadout Only
O009283
 
Elk Lick Dock
$33,000
 
Renewed
6/10/1983
6/10/2028
13.31
WV1023071
Other
O009883
 
Saunders Prep Plant
$223,200
 
Renewed
6/24/1983
6/24/2028
36.36
WV0095699
Other – Refuse Disposal
O012383
 
Middle Fork Refuse
1
$364,800
 
Renewed
9/27/1983
9/27/2028
46.13
WV0096156
Other – Loadout Only
O500513
 
Toney Fork Loadout
 
$32,000
 
Renewed
9/11/2014
9/11/2024
12.67
WV1028081
Other – Refuse Disposal
O501108
Elklick Branch Haulroad/Refuse
1
 
$15,000
 
Renewed
11/13/2008
11/13/2028
5.83
WV1029843
Coal Surface Mine
S500417
 
North Fork Winifrede Contour Mine
 
$78,000
 
Not Started
2/13/2018
2/13/2028
50.59
WV1028430
Coal Surface Mine
S500615
 
Toney Fork A-Ridge Surface Mine
 
$150,000
 
Phase 1 Released
2/24/2016
2/24/2026
15.8
WV1028278
Coal Surface Mine
S500709
 
Toney Fork Surface Mine No. 3
 
$2,625,000
 
Renewed
11/20/2013
11/20/2028
340.83
WV1019902
Coal Surface Mine
S501210
 
Toney Fork West Surface Mine
 
$1,660,000
 
Active Rec. Only
2/29/2012
12/7/2026
134.3
WV1024990
Coal Surface Mine
S501410
 
Elklick Surface Mine
 
$2,767,600
 
Renewed
8/16/2013
8/16/2028
328.42
WV1025015
Coal Surface Mine
S503395
 
TONEY FORK SURFACE #2
 
$5,605,000
 
Renewed
5/28/1998
5/22/2028
453.61
WV1016750
Coal Underground
U004485
 
Dingess Br. No. 1
$0
 
Inactive
6/12/1985
PHII Released
4.05
WV1008340
Coal Underground
U400299
 
Paynter Branch Mine No. 1
 
$73,000
 
Renewed
4/5/2002
4/5/2027
10.01
WV1018728
Coal Underground
U500109
 
Chilton Deep Mine No. 1
 
$30,800
 
Inactive
1/31/2011
1/31/2026
5.53
WV1019821
Coal Underground
U500789
WA #1 Mine
$0
 
Completely Released
 
7/31/1990
PHII Released
0
WV0096385
Coal Underground
U500919
North Fork Winifrede Deep Mine
$16,320
 
Active Rec. Only
3/3/2020
3/3/2025
3.58
WV1030990
Coal Underground
U501311
 
Eagle No. 1 Mine
 
$143,520
 
Renewed
5/20/2013
5/20/2028
20.68
WV1025139
Coal Underground
U502008
 
Dingess Br-Chilton Mine No. 2
 
$22,570
 
Phase 2 Released
10/10/2008
PHII Released
11.62
WV1029908
Coal Underground
U505392
 
ALMA NO. 1 MINE
 
$286,160
 
Renewed
3/3/1995
3/3/2025
39.43
WV1013408
Coal Underground
U506686
Camp Branch Deep Mine
$96,200
 
Rec., Chem. Water Treatment
1/26/1987
1/26/1997
26.24
WV0093122
Coal Surface Mine
S500615
 
Toney Fork A-Ridge Surface Mine
 
$80,000
 
Phase 1 Released
2/24/2016
2/24/2026
15.8
WV1028278
Coal Underground
U501015
 
CB Chilton #1 Mine
 
$10,600
 
Not Started
12/28/2016
12/28/2026
1.68
WV1028316
Coal Underground
U503496
Muddy Bridge Branch #1
$33,040
 
Renewed
8/4/1997
8/4/2027
5.46
WV1016954
Coal Underground
U503596
Muddy Bridge Branch #2
$65,520
 
Renewed
8/4/1997
8/4/2027
10.35
WV1016954
River Dock
810-8037
Big Sandy Dock
$222,200
 
Active
7/10/1986
7/10/2026
7.38
KYGE40032
Coal Surface Mine
S500422
Middle Fork Surface Mine
$571,200
 
Renewed
12/9/2022
12/9/2027
81.73
WV1031198
Coal Surface Mine
S500822
Elklick Contour Surface mine
$1,307,520
 
Not Started
2/27/2023
2/27/2028
182.45
WV1031228
Notes:
 
 
1.
 
Permits containing refuse placement.
 
2.
 
Does not include prospect permits.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
63
17.4
 
Local Plans, Negotiations or Agreements
MM&A found no indication of agreements beyond the scope of Federal
 
or State Regulations.
17.5
 
Mine Closure Plans
Applicable
 
regulations
 
require
 
that
 
mines
 
be
 
properly
 
closed,
 
and
 
reclamation
 
commenced
immediately upon
 
abandonment.
 
In general,
 
site reclamation
 
includes removal
 
of structures,
backfilling, regrading,
 
and revegetation
 
of disturbed areas.
 
For surface
 
mines, the majority
 
of
the expense
 
for
 
backfilling and
 
regrading
 
is completed
 
as part
 
of ongoing
 
mining operations,
with only
 
reclamation of
 
final pits
 
and HWM benches
 
required at
 
end-of-mine life.
 
Sediment
control is required during the establishment of vegetation, and bond release generally requires
a
 
minimum
 
five-year
 
period
 
of
 
site
 
maintenance,
 
water
 
sampling,
 
and
 
sediment
 
control
following
 
mine completion.
 
This requirement
 
is reduced
 
to two
 
years
 
for
 
certain
 
operations
involving re
 
-mining.
 
Reclamation of
 
underground mines
 
includes closure
 
and sealing
 
of mine
openings such as portals and shafts in addition to the items listed above.
 
Estimated
 
costs for
 
mine closure,
 
including water
 
quality monitoring
 
during site
 
reclamation,
are included in
 
the financial models.
 
As with all mining
 
companies, an accretion
 
calculation is
performed
 
annually so
 
the necessary
 
Asset Retirement
 
Obligations
 
(
ARO
) can
 
be
 
shown as
 
a
Liability on the Balance Sheet.
17.6
 
Qualified Person’s Opinion
The Logan
 
complex is
 
an operating
 
facility; all
 
necessary permits
 
for
 
current production
 
have
been obtained.
 
The QPs
 
know
 
of no
 
reason that
 
any permits
 
revisions that
 
may be
 
required
cannot be obtained.
 
Estimated expenditures for site closure and reclamation are
 
included in the financial model for
this site.
18
Capital and Operating Costs
18.1
 
Capital Cost Estimate
The production sequence
 
selected for a
 
property must consider
 
the proximity
 
of each reserve
area to coal preparation plants, river docks and railroad loading points, along with suitability of
production equipment to coal seam conditions.
 
The in-place infrastructure was evaluated, and
any
 
future
 
needs
 
were
 
planned
 
to
 
a
 
level
 
suitable
 
for
 
a
 
Preliminary
 
Feasibility
 
Study
 
and
included in the Capital Forecast.
Coronado
 
provided
 
MM&A
 
with
 
an
 
inventory
 
of
 
operating
 
equipment
 
available
 
at
 
Logan.
 
MM&A’s capital schedules assume
 
that major
 
equipment rebuilds occur
 
over the
 
course of
 
each
machine’s
 
remaining
 
assumed operating
 
life.
 
Replacement
 
equipment was
 
scheduled
 
based
on
 
MM&A’s
 
experience
 
and
 
knowledge
 
of
 
mining
 
equipment
 
and
 
industry
 
standards
 
with
respect to the useful life of such equipment.
 
As one mine is depleted, the equipment is moved
to its replacement.
 
 
ex963p2i0 ex963p15i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
64
A summary of the estimated capital for the Property is provided
 
in
Figure 18-1
 
below.
 
Figure 18-1:
 
CAPEX
18.2
 
Operating Cost Estimate
Coronado
 
provided
 
historical
 
and
 
a
 
preliminary
 
5-year
 
projection
 
of
 
operating
 
costs
 
for
MM&A’s review.
 
MM&A used the
 
historical and/or budget cost information as a
 
reference and
developed a personnel schedule for the mine.
 
Hourly labor rates and salaries
 
were based upon
information contained in Coronado’s financial summaries.
 
Fringe benefit costs
 
were developed
for
 
vacation
 
and
 
holidays,
 
federal
 
and
 
state
 
unemployment
 
insurance,
 
retirement,
 
workers’
compensation and
 
pneumoconiosis, casualty
 
and life
 
insurance, healthcare and
 
bonuses.
 
A cost
factor
 
for
 
mine
 
supplies
 
was
 
developed
 
that
 
relates
 
expenditures
 
to
 
mine
 
advance
 
rates
 
for
roof
 
control
 
costs
 
and
 
other
 
mine
 
supply
 
costs
 
experienced
 
at
 
underground
 
mines.
 
Other
factors were developed for maintenance
 
and repair costs,
 
rentals, mine power, outside services
and other direct mining costs.
 
Other cost factors
 
were developed for
 
coal preparation plant processing,
 
refuse handling, coal
loading, property
 
taxes,
 
and insurance
 
and bonding.
 
Appropriate royalty
 
rates were
 
assigned
for production from leased
 
coal lands and
 
sales taxes were calculated for state severance taxes,
the federal black lung excise tax,
 
and federal and state reclamation
 
fees.
Mandated Sales Related Costs such as Black Lung Excise are
 
summarized in
Table 18-1
.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
65
Table 18-1:
 
Estimated Coal Production Taxes
 
and Sales Costs
Description of Tax or Sales Cost
Basis of Assessment
Cost
Federal Black Lung Excise Tax
 
– Underground
Per Tonne
$1.21
Federal Black Lung Excise Tax
 
– Surface
Per Tonne
$0.61
Federal Black Lung Excise Tax
 
– Highwall Miner
Per Tonne
$0.61
Federal Reclamation Fees – Underground
Per Tonne
$0.13
Federal Reclamation Fees – Surface
Per Tonne
$0.31
Federal Reclamation Fees – Highwall Miner
Per Tonne
$0.31
West Virginia Reclamation Tax
 
– Underground
Per Tonne
$0.308
West Virginia Reclamation Tax
 
– Surface
Per Tonne
$0.308
West Virginia Reclamation Tax
 
– Highwall Miner
Per Tonne
$0.308
West Virginia Severance Tax
Percentage of Revenue
1 to 5%
Royalties – Underground
Percentage of Revenue
5 to 8.5%
Royalties – Surface
Percentage of Revenue
9%
Royalties – Highwall Miner
Percentage of Revenue
9%
Notes: 1. Federal
 
black lung excise
 
tax is
 
paid only on
 
coal sold domestically.
 
MM&A estimated a
 
weighted average
 
black
lung excise tax of $0.66 per tonne in the economic analysis below.
A summary of the projected Operating Costs is in
Table 18-2
.
Table 18-2:
 
Logan Operating Costs
Total
YE 12/31
2024
YE 12/31
2025
YE 12/31
2026
YE 12/31
2027
YE 12/31
2028
YE 12/31
2029
YE 12/31
2030
YE 12/31
2031
Remaining
LOM
Average
ROM Production
Tonnes
 
136.5
 
 
6.6
 
 
7.1
 
 
7.0
 
 
7.1
 
 
6.8
 
 
6.2
 
 
6.8
 
 
6.9
 
 
3.2
 
Yield
51.72%
38.35%
37.78%
38.86%
35.51%
35.18%
45.80%
46.02%
44.48%
59.43%
Saleable Production
Tonnes
 
70.6
 
 
2.5
 
 
2.7
 
 
2.7
 
 
2.5
 
 
2.4
 
 
2.9
 
 
3.1
 
 
3.1
 
 
1.9
 
Thermal Tonnes
 
4.69
 
 
0.14
 
 
0.18
 
 
0.19
 
 
0.18
 
 
0.22
 
 
0.14
 
 
0.14
 
 
0.14
 
 
0.13
 
Domestic Met Tonnes
 
65.90
 
 
2.40
 
 
2.52
 
 
2.51
 
 
2.35
 
 
2.18
 
 
2.71
 
 
3.00
 
 
2.92
 
 
1.74
 
Export Met Tonnes
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
Total Saleable Tonnes
 
70.59
 
 
2.54
 
 
2.70
 
 
2.70
 
 
2.53
 
 
2.40
 
 
2.85
 
 
3.14
 
 
3.06
 
 
1.9
 
Cash Costs per Tonne:
Mining Costs
 
$84.51
 
 
$77.01
 
 
$75.72
 
 
$76.41
 
 
$82.69
 
 
$85.48
 
 
$73.27
 
 
$73.73
 
 
$77.23
 
 
$87.70
 
Processing and
Transport
 
$19.71
 
 
$19.17
 
 
$19.99
 
 
$20.15
 
 
$22.12
 
 
$22.53
 
 
$18.41
 
 
$18.66
 
 
$19.66
 
 
$19.59
 
Sales Related Costs
 
$20.25
 
 
$16.61
 
 
$15.80
 
 
$14.76
 
 
$14.89
 
 
$15.59
 
 
$17.01
 
 
$17.89
 
 
$18.20
 
 
$21.97
 
G&A
 
$3.30
 
 
$3.49
 
 
$3.08
 
 
$3.08
 
 
$3.29
 
 
$3.31
 
 
$3.31
 
 
$3.31
 
 
$3.31
 
 
$3.31
 
 
Total Cash Costs
$127.78
 
 
$116.28
 
 
$114.60
 
 
$114.39
 
 
$122.99
 
 
$126.90
 
 
$111.99
 
 
$113.59
 
 
$118.40
 
 
$132.57
 
* The Financial model includes
 
0.001 million tonnes of inferred
 
coal production.
 
Inferred coal represents
 
0.000001% of the total
 
production,
and none of this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
19
Economic Analysis
19.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methods
A pre-feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for the Logan operations.
 
MM&A prepared
mine
 
projections
 
and
 
production
 
timing
 
forecasts
 
based
 
on
 
coal
 
seam
 
characteristics.
 
Production
 
timing
 
was
 
carried
 
out
 
from
 
2024
 
to
 
depletion
 
(exhaustion)
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
reserve
areas, which
 
is projected
 
for
 
the year
 
2057.
 
All costs
 
and prices
 
are based
 
on year-end
 
2023
nominal United States dollars.
The
 
Mine
 
plan,
 
productivity
 
expectations
 
and
 
cost
 
estimates
 
generally
 
reflect
 
historical
performance
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
efforts
 
have
 
been
 
made
 
to
 
adjust
 
plans
 
and
 
costs
 
to
 
reflect
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
66
future conditions.
 
MM&A is confident
 
that the
 
mine plan and
 
financial model are
 
reasonably
representative to provide
 
an accurate estimation of coal reserves.
Capital
 
schedules
 
were
 
developed
 
by
 
MM&A
 
for
 
mine
 
development,
 
infrastructure,
 
and
 
on-
going capital requirements for
 
the life of
 
the mine.
 
Staffing levels were prepared,
 
and operating
costs estimated
 
by MM&A.
 
MM&A utilized
 
historical cost
 
data provided
 
by Coronado
 
and its
own knowledge and experience to estimate direct and indirect operating
 
costs.
 
The
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
financial
 
model,
 
prepared
 
for
 
this
 
TRS,
 
was
 
developed
 
to
 
test
 
the
economic viability of the coal reserve area.
 
The results of this financial model are
 
not intended
to represent a bankable feasibility study,
 
required for financing of any current or future mining
operations, but are intended to prove the economic
 
viability of the estimated coal reserves.
 
All
costs
 
and
 
prices
 
are
 
based
 
on
 
year-end
 
2023
 
nominal
 
United
 
States
 
dollars
 
assuming
 
a
 
2%
inflation rate.
On
 
an
 
unlevered
 
basis,
 
the
 
NPV
 
of
 
the
 
project
 
cash
 
flows
 
after
 
taxes
 
was
 
estimated
 
for
 
the
purpose
 
of
 
classifying
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
The
 
project
 
cash
 
flows,
 
excluding
 
debt
 
service,
 
are
calculated by subtracting direct and indirect operating expenses and capital expenditures from
revenue.
 
Direct costs include labor,
 
drilling and blasting, operating supplies, maintenance
 
and
repairs,
 
facilities
 
costs
 
for
 
materials
 
handling, coal
 
preparation,
 
refuse
 
disposal,
 
coal
 
loading,
sampling and
 
analysis services,
 
reclamation and general and
 
administrative costs.
 
Indirect costs
include statutory and
 
legally agreed upon fees
 
related to direct
 
extraction of the mineral.
 
The
indirect
 
costs
 
are
 
the
 
Federal
 
black
 
lung
 
tax,
 
Federal
 
and
 
State
 
reclamation
 
taxes,
 
property
taxes,
 
local
 
transportation
 
prior
 
to
 
delivery
 
at
 
rail
 
or
 
barge
 
loading
 
sites,
 
coal
 
production
royalties,
 
sales and
 
use taxes,
 
income taxes
 
and State
 
severance taxes
 
.
 
Coronado’s
 
historical
costs provided a useful reference
 
for MM&A’s
 
cost estimates.
Sales
 
revenue
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
the
 
metallurgical
 
coal
 
price
 
information
 
provided
 
to
 
MM&A
 
by
Coronado.
Projected
 
debt
 
service is
 
excluded
 
from
 
the
 
P&L and
 
cash
 
flow
 
model
 
in order
 
to
 
determine
Enterprise Value.
The
 
financial
 
model
 
expresses
 
coal
 
sales
 
prices,
 
operating
 
costs,
 
and
 
capital
 
expenditures
 
in
current
 
day
 
dollars
 
without
 
adjustment
 
for
 
inflation.
 
Capital
 
expenditures
 
and
 
reclamation
costs
 
are
 
included
 
based
 
on
 
engineering
 
estimates
 
for
 
each
 
mine
 
by
 
year.
 
The
 
Coronado
division’s existing
 
allocations of administrative costs are
 
continued in the future projections.
Coronado will pay royalties for the various current and projected operations.
 
The royalty rates
vary by mining
 
method and location.
 
The royalty
 
rates for
 
Logan are
 
estimated to
 
be 5 to
 
9%
of the sales revenue.
The projection model also includes consolidated income tax calculations at the Coronado level,
incorporating statutory
 
depletion calculations, as
 
well as state
 
income taxes,
 
and a federal
 
tax
rate of 21%.
 
To the extent the mine generates net operating losses for tax purposes, the losses
are
 
carried
 
over
 
to
 
offset
 
future
 
taxable
 
income.
 
The
 
terms
 
“cash
 
flows”
 
and
 
“project
 
cash
flows” used in this report refer to after tax
 
cash flows.
 
 
ex963p2i0 ex963p76i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
67
Consolidated cash flows are driven by annual sales tonnage, which at steady-state
 
level ranges
from
 
a
 
peak
 
of
 
3.6 million
 
tonnes
 
in
 
2033
 
to
 
a
 
low
 
of
 
0.4 million
 
tonnes
 
in
 
2056.
 
Projected
consolidated revenue
 
ranges from $116.9 million to
 
$638.2 million at a steady state.
 
Revenue
totals $13.0 billion for the project’s
 
life.
Consolidated cash flow from operations is positive throughout the projected operating
 
period,
with
 
the
 
exception
 
of
 
post-production
 
years,
 
due
 
to
 
end-of-mine
 
reclamation
 
spending.
 
Consolidated cash flow
 
from operations
 
peaks at $177.9 million
 
in 2033 and totals
 
$3.4 billion
over the
 
project’s life.
 
Capital expenditures
 
total $167.9 million
 
from 2024
 
through 2028
 
and
$1.2 billion over the project’s life.
 
Coal price forecasts for
 
coal products were prepared by Coronado for
 
its proposed operations.
 
Such prices were used for the revenue input into the financial model.
 
Sales variable costs such
as production royalties and severance taxes
 
were based upon the revenue input.
19.2
 
Results
The pre-feasibility financial model, prepared
 
by MM&A for this TRS, was developed
 
to test the
economic
 
viability
 
of
 
each
 
coal
 
resource
 
area.
 
The
 
results
 
of
 
this
 
financial
 
model
 
are
 
not
intended
 
to
 
represent
 
a
 
bankable
 
feasibility
 
study,
 
as
 
may
 
be
 
required
 
for
 
financing
 
of
 
any
current
 
or
 
future
 
mining
 
operations
 
contemplated
 
but
 
are
 
intended
 
to
 
prove
 
the
 
economic
viability of
 
the estimated
 
coal reserves.
 
Optimization of
 
the LOM
 
plan was
 
outside the
 
scope
of the engagement.
Figure 19-1
 
shows the annual variance
 
of cash costs
 
per ton.
 
Table
 
19-1
 
shows LOM
 
tonnage,
P&L, and EBITDA for Logan.
Figure 19-1:
 
Cash Costs per Tonne
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
68
As shown above, Logan’s
 
average cash cost
 
ranges between approximately
 
$114 and $168 per
tonne for most of the operating period.
Table 19-1:
 
Life-of-Mine Tonnage,
 
P&L before Tax,
 
and EBITDA ($000)
LOM
LOM
P&L
LOM
EBITDA
Tonnes
*
Pre-Tax
 
P&L
Per Tonne
EBITDA
Per Tonne
Deep Mines
 
 
 
 
 
Camp Br Chilton
1,607
$61,067
$38.00
$92,000
$57.24
Ramaco N2G
1,519
$38,659
$25.45
$84,549
$55.66
Eagle No. 1 (Toney
 
Fork)
10,962
$177,450
$16.19
$344,402
$31.42
Elk Lick Chilton
3,809
$184,040
$48.32
$250,250
$65.70
Lower Powellton
5,095
$216,991
$42.59
$328,684
$64.51
Lower War Eagle
5,731
$230,836
$40.28
$336,103
$58.65
Powellton No. 1
3,474
$37,743
$10.86
$142,820
$41.11
Muddy Br No.2 Gas
2,713
$43,531
$16.05
$83,882
$30.92
Upper Winifrede
1,438
$89,318
$62.11
$113,233
$78.74
Lower Winifrede
2,091
$83,351
$39.86
$118,042
$56.45
Winifrede (Chilton Rider)
**
-
$(1,302)
$-
$(1,302)
$-
Consolidated Deep Mines
38,439
$1,161,684
$30.22
$1,892,665
$49.24
 
Surface Mines
Toney Fork Surf
6,313
$184,154
$29.17
$367,638
$58.23
Buffalo Cr South Area
7,673
$125,604
$16.37
$279,578
$36.44
Sugar Camp Area 1
4,912
$(11,563)
$(2.35)
$149,696
$30.47
Surface Mines Consolidated
18,899
$298,195
$15.78
$796,912
$42.17
 
LOM
LOM
P&L
LOM
EBITDA
Tonnes
Pre-Tax
 
P&L
Per Tonne
EBITDA
Per Tonne
HWM Operations
Toney Fork HWM
4,919
$468,937
$95.33
$488,239
$99.25
Buffalo Cr South HWM
7,004
$624,409
$89.15
$648,796
$92.63
Sugar Camp HWM
1,328
$117,241
$88.27
$128,692
$96.90
HWM Consolidated
13,251
$1,210,588
$91.36
$1,265,728
$95.52
 
Grand Total
70,589
$2,670,467
$37.83
$3,955,305
$56.03
*
 
The
 
Financial model
 
includes 0.001 million
 
tonnes of
 
inferred
 
coal
 
production.
 
Inferred
 
coal represents
0.000001% of the total production, and none of this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
** The Winifrede (Chilton Rider) was depleted in the 4th quarter of 2023.
As
 
shown
 
in
Table
 
19-1,
 
the
 
Logan
 
Complex
 
shows
 
positive
 
EBITDA
 
over
 
the
 
LOM.
 
Overall,
Coronado’s
 
consolidated
 
operations
 
show
 
positive
 
LOM
 
P&L
 
and
 
LOM
 
EBITDA
 
of
 
$2.7 billion
and $4.0 billion,
 
respectively.
 
A summary
 
of the
 
key
 
financial performance
 
metrics projected
through 2031 is provided below in
Table 19-2
.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
69
Table 19-2:
 
Summary of Logan Key Financial Performance Metrics (2024-2031)
Total
YE
12/31
2024
YE
12/31
2025
YE
12/31
2026
YE
12/31
2027
YE
12/31
2028
YE
12/31
2029
YE
12/31
2030
YE
12/31
2031
Remaining
LOM
Average
ROM Production Tonnes
136.5
6.6
7.1
7.0
7.1
6.8
6.2
6.8
6.9
3.2
Yield
51.72%
38.35%
37.78%
38.86%
35.51%
35.18%
45.80%
46.02%
44.48%
59.43%
Saleable Production Tonnes
70.6
2.5
2.7
2.7
2.5
2.4
2.9
3.1
3.1
1.9
Thermal Tonnes
4.69
0.14
0.18
0.19
0.18
0.22
0.14
0.14
0.14
0.13
Domestic Met Tonnes
65.90
2.40
2.52
2.51
2.35
2.18
2.71
3.00
2.92
1.74
Export Met Tonnes
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Total Saleable Tonnes
70.59
2.54
2.70
2.70
2.53
2.40
2.85
3.14
3.06
1.9
Cash Costs per Tonne:
Mining Costs
$84.51
$77.01
$75.72
$76.41
$82.69
$85.48
$73.27
$73.73
$77.23
$87.70
Processing and Transport
$19.71
$19.17
$19.99
$20.15
$22.12
$22.53
$18.41
$18.66
$19.66
$19.59
Sales Related Costs
$20.25
$16.61
$15.80
$14.76
$14.89
$15.59
$17.01
$17.89
$18.20
$21.97
G&A
$3.30
$3.49
$3.08
$3.08
$3.29
$3.31
$3.31
$3.31
$3.31
$3.31
Total Cash Costs
$127.78
$116.28
$114.60
$114.39
$122.99
$126.90
$111.99
$113.59
$118.40
$132.57
EBITDA per Tonne
$56.03
$30.50
$32.54
$31.10
$24.70
$24.18
$48.98
$50.43
$49.16
$64.46
Expansion CapEx ($M)
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Maintenance CapEx ($M)
$1,170.9
$50.1
$33.9
$40.0
$22.2
$21.7
$76.0
$58.4
$33.9
$32.1
Total CapEx
$1,170.9
$50.1
$33.9
$40.0
$22.2
$21.7
$76.0
$58.4
$33.9
$32.1
* The
 
Financial model includes
 
0.001 million tonnes of
 
inferred coal
 
production.
 
Inferred coal
 
represents 0.000001%
 
of the total
 
production, and
none of this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
After Tax
 
Cash Flows were developed in
 
order to calculate the NPV
 
for this Property.
 
The NPV
is estimated to be $616.8 million at
 
a discount rate of 10.0%.
 
A summary of
 
the Logan after-tax
cash flow is shown in
Table 19-3
.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
70
Table 19-3:
 
Project Cash Flow Summary ($000)
*
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
Total
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
Production & Sales tonnes
70,589
2,543
2,696
2,702
2,526
2,399
Total Revenue
$12,974,983
$373,206
$396,734
$393,101
$373,074
$362,422
EBITDA
$3,955,305
$77,551
$87,738
$84,030
$62,398
$58,012
Net Income
$2,228,588
$26,894
$36,861
$31,587
$14,764
$12,933
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$3,424,770
$51,951
$77,858
$77,752
$62,427
$53,137
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(1,170,916)
$(50,053)
$(33,920)
$(40,038)
$(22,171)
$(21,683)
Net Cash Flow
$2,253,854
$1,897
$43,938
$37,714
$40,256
$31,454
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2029
2030
2031
2032
2033
2034
Production & Sales tonnes
2,850
3,138
3,064
3,243
3,562
3,025
Total Revenue
$458,804
$514,757
$513,368
$553,202
$619,064
$522,816
EBITDA
$139,605
$158,273
$150,615
$185,698
$215,324
$154,820
Net Income
$79,578
$89,148
$85,572
$111,984
$132,364
$84,624
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$106,155
$135,115
$135,231
$153,748
$177,944
$149,613
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(76,046)
$(58,438)
$(33,904)
$(37,120)
$(64,965)
$(78,661)
Net Cash Flow
$30,109
$76,677
$101,328
$116,628
$112,979
$70,953
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
2040
Production & Sales tonnes
2,996
3,323
3,481
3,308
2,953
2,659
Total Revenue
$527,811
$597,215
$638,225
$618,446
$562,910
$517,016
EBITDA
$133,825
$186,994
$205,149
$190,958
$163,745
$150,046
Net Income
$67,184
$112,148
$121,122
$101,624
$83,396
$79,543
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$124,743
$156,490
$174,943
$171,838
$153,628
$138,325
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(74,607)
$(44,478)
$(63,118)
$(74,744)
$(52,178)
$(35,077)
Net Cash Flow
$50,136
$112,012
$111,825
$97,094
$101,449
$103,248
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
2046
Production & Sales tonnes
2,061
1,821
2,124
1,504
1,147
1,149
Total Revenue
$403,182
$362,533
$432,405
$310,415
$239,824
$245,029
EBITDA
$132,897
$113,992
$163,646
$115,279
$82,962
$84,911
Net Income
$80,858
$69,151
$103,893
$67,062
$56,130
$56,391
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$121,947
$105,404
$131,578
$111,482
$78,873
$73,990
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(18,189)
$(33,880)
$(32,406)
$(16,899)
$(22,623)
$(17,389)
Net Cash Flow
$103,758
$71,523
$99,172
$94,583
$56,250
$56,601
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2047
2048
2049
2050
2051
2052
Production & Sales tonnes
1,152
1,151
1,147
1,145
1,150
1,151
Total Revenue
$250,477
$255,353
$259,457
$264,205
$270,675
$276,402
EBITDA
$86,985
$88,741
$90,123
$91,953
$94,720
$96,464
Net Income
$57,379
$57,306
$56,385
$55,409
$56,916
$58,687
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$75,029
$76,216
$77,221
$78,584
$80,464
$81,827
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(13,999)
$(16,432)
$(20,924)
$(24,880)
$(17,227)
$(16,997)
Net Cash Flow
$61,029
$59,784
$56,296
$53,704
$63,237
$64,830
 
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex963p20i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
71
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2053
2054
2055
2056
2057
2058
Production & Sales tonnes
1,149
1,016
809
437
11
-
Total Revenue
$281,461
$254,502
$207,028
$116,946
$2,919
$-
EBITDA
$98,676
$83,364
$68,788
$54,740
$2,282
$-
Net Income
$59,804
$46,844
$35,921
$45,217
$(3,918)
$(1,177)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$83,397
$75,074
$63,550
$31,102
$(5,848)
$(7,880)
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(19,175)
$(21,624)
$(8,199)
$(5,725)
$(3,148)
$-
Net Cash Flow
$64,222
$53,450
$55,351
$25,378
$(8,996)
$(7,880)
 
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
 
2059
2060
2061
2062
2063
2064
Production & Sales tonnes
-
-
-
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Income
$(607)
$(317)
$(70)
$(0)
$(0)
$(0)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$(4,019)
$(3,221)
$(895)
$-
$-
$-
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$(4,019)
$(3,221)
$(895)
$-
$-
$-
* The
 
Financial model includes
 
0.001 million tonnes of
 
inferred coal
 
production.
 
Inferred coal
 
represents 0.000001%
 
of the total
 
production, and
none of this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
19.3
 
Sensitivity
Sensitivity of the NPV results to changes in the key drivers is presented in the chart
 
below.
 
The
sensitivity
 
study
 
shows
 
the
 
NPV
 
at
 
the
 
10.0%
 
discount
 
rate
 
when
 
Base
 
Case
 
sales
 
prices,
operating costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased in increments of 5% within a +/-
15% range.
Figure 19-2:
 
Sensitivity of NPV
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
72
As
 
shown,
 
NPV
 
is quite
 
sensitive
 
to
 
changes
 
in sales
 
price and
 
operating
 
cost
 
estimates,
 
and
slightly sensitive to changes in capital cost estimates.
20
Adjacent Properties
20.1
 
Information Used
No
 
Proprietary
 
information
 
associated
 
with
 
neighboring
 
properties
 
was
 
used
 
as
 
part
 
of
 
this
study.
21
Other Relevant Data and Information
MM&A performed
 
a previous
 
audit of
 
all the
 
Properties in
 
year 2017
 
for
 
Coronado
 
based on
SEC Industry Guide
 
7 standards.
 
In addition,
 
MM&A completed a
 
Limited Phase
 
I Environmental
Site Assessment (
ESA
) on
 
the Property in
 
2017 on
 
behalf of
 
Coronado.
 
MM&A has
 
subsequently
conducted
 
Joint Ore
 
Reserve Committee
 
(
JORC
) compliant
 
resource and
 
reserve
 
assessments
of
 
the
 
Logan
 
County
 
assets
 
as
 
of:
 
(1)
 
December 31,
 
2017,
 
(2)
 
December 31,
 
2020,
 
(3)
December 31, 2021, and
 
(4) December 31, 2022.
 
By assignment, the
 
JORC assessment included
a preliminary
 
feasibility
 
level study
 
of the
 
subject coal
 
reserves, encompassing
 
detailed mine
planning and cost analysis through depletion of Logan’s JORC-compliant
 
coal reserves.
 
MM&A
utilized
 
these
 
former
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
studies
 
as
 
the
 
basis
 
of
 
an
 
updated
 
study
 
which
meets those standards set forth by the SEC in Regulation
 
S-K 1300.
22
Interpretation and Conclusions
22.1
 
Conclusion
Sufficient
 
data
 
has
 
been
 
obtained
 
through
 
various
 
exploration
 
and
 
sampling
 
programs
 
and
mining operations to support the
 
geological interpretations of seam structure and
 
thickness for
coal
 
horizons
 
situated
 
on
 
the
 
Property.
 
The
 
data
 
is
 
of
 
sufficient
 
quantity
 
and
 
reliability
 
to
reasonably support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates in this TRS.
The geological data
 
and preliminary
 
feasibility study, which consider mining
 
plans, revenue, and
operating and capital cost estimates
 
are sufficient to support the classification of coal reserves
provided herein.
This
 
geologic
 
evaluation
 
conducted
 
in
 
conjunction
 
with
 
the
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
study
 
is
sufficient to
 
conclude that
 
the 70.6 Mt
 
of marketable
 
coal reserves
 
identified on the
 
Property
are
 
economically
 
mineable
 
under
 
reasonable
 
expectations
 
of
 
market
 
prices
 
for
 
metallurgical
coal products, estimated operation costs,
 
and capital expenditures.
22.2
 
Risk Factors
Risks have
 
been identified
 
for operational,
 
technical and
 
administrative
 
subjects addressed
 
in
the Pre
 
-Feasibility
 
Study.
 
A risk
 
matrix has
 
been constructed
 
to present
 
the risk
 
levels for
 
all
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
73
the risk
 
factors
 
identified and
 
quantified
 
in the
 
risk assessment
 
process.
 
The risk
 
matrix and
risk
 
assessment
 
process
 
are
 
modelled
 
to
 
that
 
presented
 
in
 
the
 
Australian
 
and
 
New
 
Zealand
Standard on Risk Management (AS/NZS 4360).
 
The
 
purpose
 
of
 
the
 
characterization
 
of
 
the
 
project
 
risk
 
components
 
is
 
to
 
inform
 
the
 
project
stakeholders
 
of key
 
aspects of
 
the Coronado
 
projects that
 
can be
 
impacted by
 
events
 
whose
consequences can affect the success of the venture.
 
The significance of an impacted aspect of
the operation
 
is directly
 
related
 
to both
 
the probability
 
of occurrence
 
and the
 
severity of
 
the
consequences.
 
The
 
initial
 
risk
 
for
 
a
 
risk
 
factor
 
is
 
herein
 
defined
 
as
 
the
 
risk
 
level
 
after
 
the
potential
 
impact
 
of
 
the
 
risk
 
factor
 
is
 
addressed
 
by
 
competent
 
and
 
prudent
 
management
utilizing control
 
measures readily
 
available.
 
Residual risk
 
for a
 
risk factor
 
is herein
 
defined as
the risk
 
level following
 
application of
 
special mitigation
 
measures if
 
management determines
that
 
the
 
initial
 
risk
 
level
 
is
 
unacceptable.
 
Initial
 
risk
 
and
 
residual
 
risk
 
can
 
be
 
quantified
numerically, derived by the product of values assigned to probability and consequence ranging
from very low risk to very high risk.
 
The
 
probability
 
and
 
consequence
 
parameters
 
are
 
subjective
 
numerical
 
estimates
 
made
 
by
practiced
 
mine engineers
 
and managers.
 
Both are
 
assigned values
 
from 1
 
to 5
 
for
 
which the
value
 
1 represents
 
the lowest
 
probability
 
and least
 
consequence, and
 
the value
 
5 represents
the highest
 
probability
 
and greatest
 
consequence.
 
The
 
products
 
which define
 
the Risk
 
Level
are classified from very low to very high.
 
Risk Level Table
 
(R = P x C)
Risk Level (R)
Very Low (1 to 2)
Low (3 to 5)
Moderate (6 to 11)
High (12 to 19)
Very High (20 to 25)
Risk aspects
 
identified and
 
evaluated during this
 
assignment total 13.
 
No residual
 
risks are
 
rated
Very High.
 
One (1) residual risk
 
is rated High.
 
Eight (8) of the risk
 
aspects could be associated
with
 
Moderate
 
residual
 
risk.
 
Four
 
(4)
 
of
 
the
 
risk
 
aspects
 
were
 
attributed
 
Low
 
or
 
Very
 
Low
residual risks.
 
22.2.1
 
Governing Assumptions
The listing
 
of the
 
aspects is
 
not presumed
 
to be
 
exhaustive.
 
Instead that
 
listing
 
is presented
based on the experiences of the contributors to the TRS.
 
1.
 
The probability and consequence ratings are subjectively assigned, and it is assumed that this
subjectivity reasonably reflects the condition of the active and projected mine operations.
2.
 
The
 
Control
 
Measures
 
shown
 
in
 
the
 
matrices
 
presented
 
in this
 
chapter
 
are
 
not
 
exhaustive.
 
They
 
represent
 
a
 
condensed
 
collection
 
of
 
activities
 
that
 
the
 
author
 
of
 
the
 
risk
 
assessment
section has observed to be effective in coal mining scenarios.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
74
3.
 
Mitigation
 
Measures
 
listed
 
for
 
each
 
risk
 
factor
 
of
 
the
 
operation
 
are
 
not
 
exhaustive.
 
The
measures listed, however,
 
have been observed by the author to be effective.
 
4.
 
The monetary values used in
 
ranking the consequences are generally
 
-accepted quantities for
the coal mining industry.
22.2.2
 
Limitations
The
 
risk
 
assessment
 
proposed
 
in
 
this
 
report
 
is
 
subject
 
to
 
the
 
limitations
 
of
 
the
 
information
currently collected, tested, and interpreted
 
at the time of the writing of the report.
22.2.3
 
Methodology
The numerical
 
quantities (i.e.,
 
risk levels)
 
attributable
 
to either
 
“initial” or
 
“residual” risks
 
are
derived
 
by the
 
product of
 
values
 
assigned to
 
probability
 
and consequence
 
ranging
 
from
 
very
low risk to very high risk.
R = P x C
Where:
R = Risk Level
P = Probability of Occurrence
C = Consequence of Occurrence
The
 
Probability
 
(P)
 
and
 
Consequence
 
(C)
 
parameters
 
recited
 
in
 
the
 
formula
 
are
 
subjective
numerical
 
estimates
 
made
 
by
 
practiced
 
mine
 
engineers
 
and
 
managers.
 
Both
 
P
 
and
 
C
 
are
assigned
 
integer
 
values
 
ranging
 
from
 
1
 
to
 
5
 
for
 
which
 
the
 
value
 
1
 
represents
 
the
 
lowest
probability
 
and
 
least
 
consequence,
 
and
 
the
 
value
 
5
 
represents
 
the
 
highest
 
probability
 
and
greatest
 
consequence.
 
The
 
products
 
(R
 
=
 
P
 
x
 
C)
 
which
 
define
 
the
 
Risk
 
Level,
 
are
 
thereafter
classified from very low to very high.
Risk Level Table
Risk Level (R)
Very Low (1 to 2)
Low (3 to 5)
Moderate (6 to 11)
High (12 to 19)
Very High (20 to 25)
Very
 
high initial
 
risks are
 
considered to
 
be unacceptable
 
and require
 
corrective action
 
well in
advance of project development.
 
In short, measures must
 
be applied to reduce
 
very high initial
risks to a tolerable level.
 
As
 
shown
 
and
 
discussed
 
above,
 
after
 
taking
 
into
 
account
 
the
 
operational,
 
technical,
 
and
administrative
 
actions
 
that
 
have
 
been
 
applied or
 
are
 
available
 
for
 
action when
 
required,
 
the
residual risk
 
can be
 
determined.
 
The residual
 
risk provides
 
a basis for
 
the management
 
team
to determine
 
if the residual
 
risk level is
 
acceptable or tolerable.
 
If the risk level
 
is determined
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
75
to
 
be
 
unacceptable,
 
further
 
actions
 
should
 
be
 
considered
 
to
 
reduce
 
the
 
residual
 
risk
 
to
acceptable
 
or
 
tolerable
 
levels
 
to
 
provide
 
justification
 
for
 
continuation
 
of
 
the
 
proposed
operation.
22.2.4
 
Development of the Risk Matrix
Risks have been identified
 
for the technical, operational, and
 
administrative subjects addressed
in the TRS.
 
The risk matrix and
 
risk assessment process
 
are modelled to
 
that presented
 
in the
Australian and New Zealand Standard on Risk Management (AS/NZS 4360).
 
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
76
22.2.4.1
 
Probability Level Table
Table 22-1:
 
Probability Level Table
Category
Probability Level (P)
1
Remote
Not likely to occur except
 
in exceptional circumstances.
<10%
2
Unlikely
Not likely to occur; small in degree.
10 - 30%
3
Possible
Capable of occuring.
30 - 60%
4
Likely
High chance of occurring in most circumsta
 
nces.
60 - 90%
5
Almost Certain
Event is expected under
 
most circumstances; impossible to
avoid.
>90%
The lowest rated
 
probability of occurrence is assigned the
 
value of 1 and described as remote,
with a likelihood of occurrence of less than ten percent.
 
Increasing values are assigned to each
higher
 
probability
 
of
 
occurrence,
 
culminating
 
with
 
the
 
value
 
of
 
5
 
assigned
 
to
 
incidents
considered to be almost certain to occur.
22.2.4.2
 
Consequence Level Table
Table 22-2
 
lists the consequence levels.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
77
Table 22-2:
 
Consequence Level Table
Correlation of Events in Key Elements of the Project Program
 
to Event Severity Category
Category
Severity of
the Event
Financial Impact
of the Event
Unplanned
Loss of
Production
(Impact on
Commercial
Operations)
Events Impacting
on the Environment
Events Affecting th’ Program's
Social and Community
Relations
Resultant Regulatory /
Sovereign Risk
Events Affecting Occupational Health &
Safety
1
Insignificant
< USD
$0.5 million
≤ 12 hours
Insignificant loss of
habitat; no
irreversible effects
on water,
 
soil and
the environment.
Occasional nuisance impact on
travel.
-
Event recurrence avoided by corrective
action through established procedures
(Engineering, guarding, training).
2
Minor
USD $0.5 million
to $2.0 million
≤ 1 day
No significant
change to species
populations; short-
term reversible
perturbation to
ecosystem function.
Persistent nuisance impact on
travel.
 
Transient adverse media
coverage.
-
First aid – lost time.
 
Event recurrence
avoided by corrective action through
established procedures.
3
Moderate
USD $2.0 million
to $10.0 million
≤ 1 week
Appreciable change
to species
population;
medium-term (≤10
years) detriment to
ecosystem function.
Measurable impact on travel
and water/air quality.
 
Significant adverse media
coverage / transient public
outrage.
Uncertainty securing or
retaining essential
approval / license.
Medical Treatment –
permanent
incapacitation.
 
Avoiding event
recurrence requires modification to
established corrective action procedures
.
Change to regulations
(tax; bonds; standards).
4
Major
USD
$10.0 million to
$50.0 million
1 to 2 weeks
Change to species
population
threatening
viability; long-term
(>10 years)
detriment to
ecosystem function.
Long-term, serious impact on
travel and use of water
resources; degradation of air
quality; sustained and effective
public opposition.
Suspension / long-delay
in securing essential
approval / license.
Fatality.
 
Avoiding event recurrence
requires modification to established
corrective action procedures and staff
retraining.
Change to laws (tax;
bonds; standards).
5
Critical
>USD
$50.0 million
>1 month
Species extinction;
irreversible damage
to ecosystem
function.
Loss of social license.
Withdraw / failure to
secure essential
approval / license.
Multiple fatalities.
 
Avoiding event
recurrence requires major overhaul of
policies and procedures.
 
 
ex963p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
78
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
The
 
lowest
 
rated
 
consequence
 
is assigned
 
the
 
value
 
of 1
 
and
 
is described
 
as
 
an
 
Insignificant
Consequence,
 
parameters of which include non-reportable safety incidents with zero
 
days lost
accidents, no environmental
 
damage, loss of production or systems
 
for less than 12 hours
 
and
cost of less than USD $0.5 million.
 
Increasing values are assigned to each higher consequence,
culminating
 
with
 
the
 
value
 
of
 
5
 
assigned
 
to
 
critical
 
consequences,
 
the
 
parameters
 
of
 
which
include
 
multiple-fatality
 
accidents,
 
major
 
environmental
 
damage,
 
and
 
loss
 
of
 
production
 
or
systems for longer than one
 
month and cost of greater than USD $50.0 million.
Composite Risk Matrix R = P x C and Color-Code Convention
The risk level,
 
defined as the product
 
of probability of occurrence
 
and consequence, ranges
 
in
value from
 
1 (lowest
 
possible risk)
 
to 25
 
(maximum risk
 
level).
 
The values
 
are color-coded
 
to
facilitate identification of the highest risk aspects.
Table 22-3:
 
Risk Matrix
P x C = R
Consequence (C)
Insignificant
Minor
Moderate
Major
Critical
1
2
3
4
5
Probability Level (P)
Remote
1
1
2
3
4
5
Unlikely
2
2
4
6
8
10
Possible
3
3
6
9
12
15
Likely
4
4
8
12
16
20
Almost
Certain
5
5
10
15
20
25
22.2.5
 
Categorization of Risk Levels and Color Code Convention
Very high risks are considered to be unacceptable
 
and require corrective action.
 
Risk reduction
measures must be applied to reduce very high risks to a tolerable level.
22.2.6
 
Description of the Coal Property
The
 
Logan
 
Mine
 
Complex
 
(
Logan
)
 
is
 
located
 
in
 
Logan,
 
Boone,
 
and
 
Wyoming
 
Counties,
 
West
Virginia
 
–is an
 
active operation
 
with four
 
underground
 
mines and
 
two
 
surface
 
mines.
 
Active
underground
 
operations
 
within
 
the
 
Logan
 
Mine
 
Complex
 
all
 
utilize
 
continuous
 
mining
production sections.
 
Large mining operations are conducted
 
at the Muddy Bridge, Eagle No. 1
Mine and Lower
 
War Eagle
 
Mine.
 
The North Fork
 
Winifrede Mine
 
was fully depleted
 
in 2023.
 
The Powellton
 
No. 1
 
Mine was
 
in process
 
of being
 
rehabilitated
 
and had
 
minimal production
during the fourth quarter 2023, with plans to initiate full production with
 
one mining section in
the first
 
quarter of 2024.
 
Other operations are
 
projected on relatively
 
small reserve blocks
 
to
be developed sequentially
 
to sustain production levels
 
as each
 
reserve is depleted.
 
The method
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
provides
 
continuity,
 
preserving
 
skilled
 
work
 
groups
 
and
 
enabling
 
effective
 
utilization
 
of
production equipment.
 
Mines located
 
above drainage
 
have access
 
via drift
 
entries.
 
A few
 
of
the coal seams are below drainage and are accessed with slopes and shafts or box cuts.
The
 
Logan
 
Mine
 
Complex
 
also
 
includes
 
two
 
active
 
surface
 
mines:
 
Toney
 
Fork
 
and
 
Elklick
(Buffalo Creek
 
South).
 
Both area
 
and contour
 
surface mining
 
are employed.
 
Highwall mining
is conducted by contract operators
 
.
 
The surface operations are relatively small and developed
sequentially to
 
sustain production
 
levels.
 
Similar to the
 
underground operations,
 
the method
provides
 
continuity
 
while
 
preserving
 
skilled
 
work
 
groups
 
and
 
enabling
 
effective
 
utilization
 
of
production
 
equipment.
 
The surface
 
mining methods
 
selected utilize
 
hydraulic
 
shovels, front-
end loaders, large tractors and rock
 
trucks for overburden removal.
22.2.7
 
Summary of Residual Risk Ratings
Each risk factor is numbered, and
 
a risk level for each
 
is determined by multiplying
 
the assigned
probability by the assigned consequence.
 
The risk levels are plotted on a risk matrix to provide
a composite view of the Coronado risk profile.
 
The average risk level is 7.7, which is defined as
Moderate.
Table 22-4:
 
Risk Assessment Matrix
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Consequence
Critical
>$50 MM
8, 9
 
Major
$10-50MM
6
 
Moderate
$2-10 MM
12
1, 2, 3, 4
 
Minor
$0.5-$2 MM
13
5, 10
7
 
Low
<$0.5 MM
11
 
 
<10%
10-30%
30-60%
60-90%
>90%
 
Remote
Unlikely
Possible
Likely
Almost
Certain
22.2.8
 
Risk Factors
A high-level
 
approach is
 
utilized to
 
characterize
 
risk factors
 
that are
 
generally similar
 
across a
number of the
 
active and proposed
 
mining operations.
 
Risk factors that are unique
 
to a specific
operation or are particularly noteworthy are
 
addressed individually.
22.2.8.1
 
Geological and Coal Resource
Coal
 
mining
 
is
 
accompanied
 
by
 
risk
 
that,
 
despite
 
exploration
 
efforts,
 
mining
 
areas
 
will
 
be
encountered where geological conditions render extraction
 
of the resource to be uneconomic,
or that coal quality characteristics disqualify the product for
 
sale into target markets.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
Offsetting the geological
 
and coal resource risk are
 
the massive size of the controlled
 
property
which
 
allows
 
large
 
areas
 
to
 
be
 
mined
 
sufficiently
 
away
 
from
 
areas
 
where
 
coal
 
quality
 
and
mineability
 
may
 
be
 
less
 
favorable.
 
In
 
addition,
 
several
 
mines
 
are
 
designed
 
to
 
operate
 
with
multiple
 
production
 
sections,
 
which
 
lessens
 
the
 
immediate
 
impact
 
when
 
one
 
section
encounters difficulties.
 
The large reserve areas
 
also provide a mitigation
 
strategy of developing
an additional
 
(spare) section
 
at each
 
mine, or
 
additional mines,
 
which can
 
be activated
 
when
adverse
 
conditions
 
are
 
encountered,
 
thereby
 
maintaining
 
consistent
 
production
 
and
 
quality.
 
The spare
 
section or
 
mines require
 
additional mine
 
extension cost
 
but increase
 
flexibility and
performance consistency.
The
 
larger
 
reserve
 
areas
 
will
 
be
 
developed
 
with
 
multiple
 
production
 
sections
 
and
 
the
 
small,
replacement production reserve
 
areas provide ready
 
access to
 
alternative locations if
 
geological
and coal resource characteristics require
 
abandonment of an active production area.
Table 22-5:
 
Geological and Coal Resource Risk Assessment (Risks 1 and 2)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Recoverable coal
tonnes recognized to
be significantly less
than previously
estimated.
Reserve base is adequate
to serve market
commitments and
respond to opportunities
for many years.
 
Local
adverse conditions may
increase frequency and
cost of production unit
relocations.
Previous and ongoing
exploration and
extensive regional
mining history provide
a high level of
confidence of coal
seam correlation,
continuity of the coal
seams, and coal
resource tonnes.
4
4
16
Optimize mine
plan to increase
resource
recovery;
develop mine
plan to provide
readily available
alternate mining
locations to
sustain expected
production level.
3
3
9
Coal quality locally
proves to be lower
than initially
projected.
If uncontrolled,
production and sale of
coal that is out of
specification can result in
rejection of deliveries,
cancellation of coal sales
agreements and damage
to reputation.
Exploration and vast
experience and history
in local coal seams
provide confidence in
coal quality; limited
excursions can be
managed with careful
product segregation
and blending.
3
5
15
Develop mine
plan to provide
readily available
alternate mining
locations to
sustain expected
production level;
modify coal sales
agreements to
reflect coal
quality.
3
3
9
22.2.8.2
 
Environmental
MM&A completed a Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (
ESA
) on the Logan County
Property in
 
May 2017
 
on behalf
 
of Coronado.
 
MM&A concluded
 
that no
 
long-term liabilities
existed at the time of this ESA.
Water
 
quality
 
and
 
other
 
permit
 
requirements
 
are
 
subject
 
to
 
modification
 
and
 
such
 
changes
could have
 
a material impact
 
on the capability
 
of the operator
 
to meet modified
 
standards or
to
 
receive
 
new permits
 
and
 
modifications
 
to
 
existing
 
permits.
 
Permit
 
protests
 
may
 
result
 
in
delays or denials to permit applications.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
4
Environmental
 
standards and permit
 
requirements have
 
evolved significantly
 
over the past
 
50
years and to-date, mining operators and
 
regulatory bodies have been
 
able to adapt
 
successfully
to evolving environmental requirements.
Table 22-6:
 
Environmental (Risks 3 and 4)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Environmental
performance
standards are
modified in the
future.
Delays in receiving new
permits and modifications
to existing permits; cost
of testing and treatment
of water and soils
Work with regulatory
agencies to understand
and influence final
standards; implement
testing, treatment and
other actions to
comply with new
standards.
3
4
12
Modify mining
and reclamation
plans to improve
compliance with
new standards
while reducing
cost of
compliance.
3
3
9
New permits and
permit modifications
are increasingly
delayed or denied.
Interruption of
production and delayed
implementation of
replacement production
from new mines.
Comply quickly with
testing, treatment and
other actions required;
continue excellent
compliance
performance within
existing permits.
3
4
12
Establish and
maintain close
and constructive
working
relationships
with regulatory
agencies, local
communities and
community
action groups.
3
3
9
22.2.8.3
 
Regulatory Requirements
Federal
 
and
 
state
 
health
 
and
 
safety
 
regulatory
 
agencies
 
occasionally
 
amend
 
mine
 
laws
 
and
regulations.
 
The impact is industry-wide.
 
Mining operators and regulatory agencies have been
able to adapt successfully to evolving health and safety requirements.
Table 22-7:
 
Regulatory Requirements (Risk 5)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Federal and state
mine safety and
health regulatory
agencies amend mine
laws and regulations.
Cost of training, materials,
supplies and equipment;
modification of mine
examination and
production procedures;
modification of mining
plans.
Participate in hearings
and workshops when
possible to facilitate
understanding and
implementation; work
cooperatively with
agencies and
employees to facilitate
implementation of new
laws and regulations.
4
3
12
Familiarity and
experience with
new laws and
regulations
results in
reduced impact
to operations and
productivity and
improved
supplies and
equipment
options.
4
2
8
22.2.8.4
 
Market and Transportation
Most
 
of
 
the
 
current
 
and
 
future
 
production
 
is
 
expected
 
to
 
be
 
directed
 
to
 
domestic
 
and
international
 
metallurgical
 
markets.
 
Historically
 
the metallurgical
 
markets
 
have
 
been cyclical
and
 
highly
 
volatile.
 
Thermal
 
coal
 
markets
 
are
 
also
 
cyclical
 
and
 
domestic
 
markets
 
have
 
been
adversely affected
 
by competition
 
from natural
 
gas and
 
subsidized renewable
 
energy sources
and regulation.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
5
Table 22-8:
 
Market and Transportation (Risk 6)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Volatile coal prices
drop precipitously.
Loss of revenue adversely
affects profitability;
reduced cash flow may
disrupt capital
expenditures plan.
Cost control measures
implemented; capital
spending deferred.
4
5
20
High-cost
operations
closed, and
employees
temporarily
furloughed.
4
4
16
Occasional
 
delay
 
or
 
interruption
 
of
 
rail,
 
river
 
and
 
terminals
 
service
 
may
 
be
 
expected.
 
The
operator can possibly minimize the impact of delays by being a preferred
 
customer by fulfilling
shipment obligations promptly and maintaining close working relationships.
Table 22-9:
 
Market and Transportation (Risk 7)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Rail or river transport is
delayed; storage and
shipping access at river
and ocean terminals is
not available.
Fulfillment of coal sales
agreements delayed;
limited coal storage at
mines may increase cost of
rehandling; production may
be temporarily idled.
Provide adequate
storage capacity at
mines; coordinate
continuously with
railroad and shipping
companies to respond
quickly and effectively to
changing circumstances.
5
3
15
Provide back-up
storage facility
along with
personnel,
equipment and
rehandle plan to
sustain production
and fulfill sales
obligations timely.
5
2
10
22.2.8.5
 
Mining Plan
Occupational health
 
and safety risks
 
are inherent in
 
mining operations.
 
Comprehensive training
and
 
retraining
 
programs,
 
internal
 
safety
 
audits
 
and
 
examinations,
 
regular
 
mine
 
inspections,
safety meetings, along with support of trained fire brigades and mine rescue teams are among
activities
 
that
 
greatly
 
reduce
 
accident
 
risks.
 
Employee
 
health
 
monitoring
 
programs
 
coupled
with dust and noise monitoring and abatement reduce health risks to miners.
 
As
 
underground
 
and
 
surface
 
mines
 
are
 
developed
 
and
 
extended,
 
observation
 
of
 
geological,
hydrogeological
 
and
 
geotechnical
 
conditions
 
leads
 
to
 
modification
 
of
 
mine
 
plans
 
and
procedures to enable safe work within the mine environments.
Highlighted below
 
are selected
 
examples
 
of safety
 
and external
 
factors
 
relevant
 
to Coronado
operations.
22.2.8.5.1
 
Methane Management
Coalbed
 
methane
 
is
 
present
 
in
 
coal
 
operations
 
below
 
drainage.
 
Often
 
the
 
methane
concentration
 
in shallow
 
coal seams
 
is at
 
such low
 
levels that
 
it can
 
be readily
 
managed with
frequent
 
testing
 
and monitoring,
 
vigilance and
 
routine
 
mine ventilation.
 
Very
 
high
 
methane
concentrations
 
may be
 
present at
 
greater depths.
 
High methane
 
concentrations
 
may require
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
6
degasification
 
of the
 
coal seam
 
to assure
 
safe
 
mining.
 
Due to
 
the
 
seams being
 
targeted
 
and
their depths, excessive methane is not expected to
 
be encountered at Logan.
Table 22-10:
 
Methane Management (Risk 8)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Methane hazard is
present in mines
operating below
drainage.
Injury or loss of life; possible
ignition of gas and mine
explosion; potential loss of
mine and equipment
temporarily or permanently;
additional mine fan, mine
power, ventilation,
monitoring and examination
requirements.
Low to moderate levels
can be managed with
frequent examinations,
testing and monitoring
within the mine
ventilation system.
 
Excellent rock dust
maintenance minimizes
explosion propagation
risk should an ignition
occur.
1
5
5
Very high-level
methane
concentrations
may require coal
seam
degasification and
gob degasification
if longwall or pillar
extraction
methods are
employed.
1
5
5
22.2.8.5.2
 
Mine Fires
Mine fires, once common at
 
mine operations, are rare today.
 
Most active coal miners have not
encountered a mine fire.
 
Vastly improved mine power and equipment
 
electrical systems, along
with
 
safe
 
mine
 
practices
 
reduce
 
mine
 
fire
 
risks.
 
Crew
 
training
 
and
 
fire
 
brigade
 
support
 
and
training
 
improve
 
response
 
for
 
containment
 
and
 
control
 
if
 
a
 
fire
 
occurs.
 
Spontaneous
combustion
 
within
 
coal
 
mines,
 
which
 
is
 
the
 
source
 
of
 
most
 
fires
 
that
 
occur
 
today,
 
is
 
not
expected to commonly
 
occur at
 
the Logan
 
property.
 
When spontaneous
 
combustion conditions
are present, monitoring systems are employed for early detection and mine plans are
 
designed
to facilitate isolation, containment
 
and rapid extinguishment.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
7
Table 22-11:
 
Mine Fires (Risk 9)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Mine fire at
underground or surface
mine operation.
Injury or loss of life;
potential loss of mine
temporarily or permanently;
damage to equipment and
mine infrastructure.
Inspection and
maintenance of mine
power, equipment and
mine infrastructure;
good housekeeping;
frequent examination of
conveyor belt entries;
prompt removal of
accumulations of
combustible materials.
1
5
5
If spontaneous
combustion
conditions are
present, enhanced
monitoring and
examination
procedures will be
implemented;
mine design will
incorporate
features to
facilitate isolation,
containment and
extinguishment of
 
spontaneous
combustion
locations.
1
5
5
22.2.8.5.3
 
Highwall Failure
Contour
 
surface
 
mining,
 
area
 
surface
 
mining
 
and
 
highwall
 
mining
 
all
 
expose
 
miners
 
and
production
 
equipment
 
to
 
the
 
risk
 
of
 
highwall
 
failure.
 
The
 
highwall
 
can
 
be
 
designed
 
to
incorporate safety
 
precautions to address geotechnical
 
and hydrogeological concerns.
 
Drilling
and
 
blasting
 
design
 
can
 
be
 
modified
 
to
 
fit
 
soil
 
and
 
strata
 
conditions
 
to
 
enhance
 
highwall
stability.
 
Foremen
 
and
 
crews
 
are
 
trained
 
to
 
examine
 
the
 
highwalls
 
frequently
 
to
 
observe
changes and
 
indications of failure
 
.
 
Highwall designs
 
incorporate
 
adequate web
 
thickness and
safety pillar width to assure highwall stability.
Table 22-12:
 
Highwall Failure (Risk 10)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Highwall failure occurs
at surface or highwall
mining operations.
Injury or loss of life;
catastrophic damage to
equipment; production
interruption.
Regular inspection for
change and signs of
failure; conservative
design of HWM web
thickness and safety
pillar width; conservative
wall slope and bench
width in design.
4
3
12
Optimize drilling
and blasting plan;
increase safety
factors for wall
slope and bench
width; install
instrumentation
and frequent
survey to detect
movement;
dewater to reduce
wall pressure.
4
2
8
22.2.8.5.4
 
Availability of Supplies and Equipment
The industry
 
has periodically
 
experienced
 
difficulty receiving
 
timely delivery
 
of mine
 
supplies
and
 
equipment.
 
Availability
 
issues
 
often
 
accompanied
 
boom
 
periods
 
for
 
coal
 
demand.
 
Any
future
 
delivery of
 
supplies and
 
equipment delays
 
are
 
expected
 
to
 
be temporary
 
with limited
impact on production.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
8
Table 22-13:
 
Availability of Supplies and Equipment (Risk 11)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Disruption of
availability for supplies
and equipment.
Temporary interruption of
production.
Force majeure provision
in coal sales agreements
to limit liability for
delayed or lost sales.
3
2
6
Work closely with
customers to
assure delayed
coal delivery
rather than
cancelled sales;
monitor external
conditions and
increase inventory
of critical supplies;
accelerate delivery
of equipment
when possible.
3
1
3
22.2.8.5.5
 
Labor
Work stoppage due to labor protests are considered to be unlikely and accompanied by limited
impact should
 
it occur.
 
Excellent
 
employee relations
 
and communications
 
limit the
 
exposure
to outside protesters.
 
Loss of supervisors and
 
skilled employees to retirement is inevitable;
 
the
impact can
 
be lessened with
 
succession planning
 
and training
 
and training
 
and mentorship
 
of
new employees.
Table 22-14:
 
Labor – Work Stoppage (Risk 12)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Work stoppage due to
strikes, slowdowns or
secondary boycott
activity.
Loss of production and coal
sales; damaged customer
and employee relations;
reputation loss.
Maintain excellent
employee relations and
communications;
maintain frequent
customer
communications.
2
3
6
Develop plan for
employee
communications
and legal support
to minimize
impact of
secondary boycott
activities.
1
3
3
Table 22-15:
 
Labor – Retirement (Risk 13)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Retirement of
supervisors and skilled
employees.
Loss of leadership and
critical skills to sustain
high levels of safety,
maintenance and
productivity.
Monitor demographics
closely and maintain
communications with
employees who are
approaching retirement
age; maintain employee
selection and training
programs.
3
3
9
Maintain selection of
candidates and
implementation of in-
house or third-party
training for electricians
and mechanics; develop
employee mentoring
program.
3
2
6
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Logan County Complex in Accordance with
 
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
 
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
West Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
9
23
Recommendations
Coronado
 
is continuing
 
to work
 
both internally
 
and with
 
outside assistance
 
to
 
further define
their Resource Base and to Optimize the LOM Plan.
24
References
Publicly
 
available
 
information
 
from
 
various
 
State
 
and
 
Federal
 
agencies
 
was
 
used
 
where
relevant.
25
Reliance on Information Provided by the
Registrant
A summary of
 
the information
 
provided by
 
Coronado relied
 
upon by MM&A
 
for the
 
purposes
of this TRS is provided in
Table 25-1
.
Table 25-1:
 
Information from Registrant Relied Upon by MM&A
Category
Information Provided by Coronado
Report
Section
Marketing
Long-term price forecast used
 
in financial projections
16.2
Legal
Mineral control and surface
 
control rights as shown on maps
3.2, 3.3
Environmental
Permit and bonding information
17.3
ex963p97i0
 
 
APPENDIX
A
MM&A QUALIFICATIONS
ex963p98i0
 
 
 
ex963p97i0
 
 
APPENDIX
B
 
MAPS
ex963p100i0
 
 
 
ex963p101i0
 
 
 
ex963p102i0
 
 
 
ex963p103i0
 
 
 
ex963p104i0
 
 
 
ex963p105i0
 
 
 
ex963p106i0
 
 
 
ex963p107i0
 
 
 
ex963p108i0
 
 
 
ex963p109i0
 
 
 
ex963p110i0
 
 
 
ex963p111i0
 
 
 
ex963p112i0
 
 
 
ex963p113i0
 
 
 
ex963p114i0
 
 
ex963p115i0
 
 
 
ex963p116i0
 
 
 
ex963p117i0
 
 
ex963p97i0
 
 
APPENDIX
C
 
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
Glossary of Abbreviations and Definitions
Abbreviation
Definition
ACPS
Analysis of Coal Pillar Stability
ANAB
ANSI National Accreditation Board
ASTM
ASTM International
AVS
Applicant Violator System
bcm
Bank cubic meters
bcm/hr
Bank cubic meters per hour
Btu/lb.
British Thermal Unit per pound
Carlson
Carlson Mining – formerly SurvCADD
®
 
– a prevalent software package used for
modeling in the Appalachian region
CFR
Code of Federal Regulations
Coronado
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
CSR
Coke strength after
 
reaction
CSX
CSX Corporation, a rail-based freight transportation
 
company
CTR
Contour mining
Demonstrated
reserves
Demonstrated reserves are the sum of proven
 
and probable reserves.
EBITDA
Earnings before Interest,
 
Taxes,
 
Depreciation, and Amortization
 
EOM
End-of-mine reclamation
EPA
United States Environmental
 
Protection Agency
 
ESA
Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment
Feasibility Study
“…comprehensive technical and economic study of the selected development
option for a mineral project, which includes detailed assessments of all applicable
modifying factors together with any other
 
relevant operational factors,
 
and detailed
financial analysis that are necessary to demonstrate, at the time of reporting, that
extraction is economically viable.
 
According to the proposed definition, the results
of the study may serve as the basis for a final decision by a proponent or financial
institution to proceed with, or finance, the development of the project.
 
Thus, a
feasibility study is more comprehensive, with a higher degree of accuracy,
 
and
yielding results with a higher level of confidence, than a pre-feasibility study.”
 
HWM
Highwall mining
In situ
Its natural position; said specific of a rock, soil, or fossil when in the situation in
which was originally formed or deposited
Indicated
Resources
Indicated resources are those lying between 0.4-kilometer
 
and 1.2-kilometer radius
from such an observation point and reported herein as in-situ mineral
 
resources.
Inferred
Resources
Inferred resources lie more than a 1.2-kilometer radius
 
from a valid point of
measurement but less than 4.8 kilometers from one, and reported herein
 
as in-situ
mineral resources.
JORC Code
Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration
 
Results, Mineral Resources and Ore
Reserves
lb. SO
2
 
/ mm Btu
Pounds per sulfur dioxide per million British thermal units
LOM
Life-of-mine
M&R
Maintenance and repair
Measured
Resources
Measured resources are those lying within 0.4-kilometer radius from
 
a valid point of
measurement and reported herein as in-situ mineral resources.
MINER Act
Mine Improvement and New Emergency Response Act of 2006
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
Abbreviation
Definition
Mineral Reserve
“…the economically mineable part of a Measured and/or Indicated Mineral
Resource.
 
It includes dilution materials and allowances for losses, which occur
when the material is mined or extracted and is defined by studies at Preliminary
Feasibility or Feasibility level as appropriate that include Modifying Factors.
 
Such
studies demonstrate that, at the time of reporting, extraction
 
of the mineral reserve
is economically viable under reasonable investment and marketing
 
assumptions
”.
 
Mineral Resource
“…a concentration or occurrence of solid material of economic interest
 
or on the
Earth’s crust
 
in such form, grade or quality that there are reasonable prospects for
eventual economic extraction.
 
The location, quantity,
 
grade, continuity and other
geological characteristics and continuity of a Mineral
 
Resource are known,
estimated or interpreted from
 
specific geological evidence and knowledge, including
sampling.”
 
MM&A
Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc.
Modifying Factors
“…considerations used to convert Mineral
 
Resources to Mineral Reserves.
 
These
include, but are not restricted to, mining, processing, metallurgical,
 
infrastructure,
economic, marketing, legal, environmental
 
compliance, plans, negotiations, or
agreements with local individuals or groups and governmental factors.”
MRMR
Mineral Resources to Mineral Reserves
MSHA
United States Department of Labor Mine Safety and Health Administration
Mt
Million metric tonnes
NIOSH
National Institute for Occupational Safety
 
and Health
NRTL
Nationally Recognized Test
 
Laboratory
NS
Norfolk Southern Corporation, a rail-based freight transportation
 
company
O&M
Operating and maintenance
 
OSD
Out-of-seam dilution
P&L
Profit and loss before tax
 
P.E.
Professional Engineer
PJLA
Perry Johnson Laboratory Accreditation, Inc.
Preliminary
Feasibility Study
“…as a comprehensive study of a range of options for the technical and economic
viability of a mineral project that has advanced to a stage where
 
a qualified person
has determined (in the case of underground mining) a preferred
 
mining method, or
in the case of surface mining) a pit configuration, and in all cases has determined an
effective method of mineral processing
 
and an effective plan to sell the product. The
study’s financial analysis must have
 
the level of detail necessary to demonstrate, at
the time of reporting, that extraction is economically viable. In addition, as noted in
the proposed definition of a pre-feasibility study,
 
while a pre-feasibility study is less
comprehensive and results in a lower confidence level than a feasibility
 
study, a pre
 
-
feasibility study is more comprehensive and results in a higher confidence level
 
than
an initial assessment.”
 
Property(ies)
Bituminous coal deposits located in Boone, Logan, and Wyoming Counties, West
Virginia.
 
QP
Qualified Person
Qualified Person
“…a person who is a mineral industry professional with at least
 
five years of relevant
experience in the type of mineralization and type of deposit under consideration
and in the specific type of activity that person is undertaking on behalf of the
registrant.
 
In addition, the proposed definition requires a qualified person to be an
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
Abbreviation
Definition
eligible member or licensee in good standing of a recognized professional
organization at the
time the technical report is prepared
”.
RECs
Recognized Environmental
 
Conditions
Resource
Database
The Resource Database is established by the collection, validation,
 
recording, storing
and processing of data and forms the foundation necessary for
 
the estimation of
Mineral Resource and Mineral Reserve.
 
A quality assurance and quality control program is essential
 
and must be established
to govern the collection of all data.
 
In reporting, a Mineral Resource must meet the
minimum requirement of “reasonable prospects for economic
 
extraction”.
 
This will
require the concurrent collection and storage
 
of preliminary economic, mining,
metallurgical, environmental,
 
legal and social data and other information for use
 
in
the estimation of MRMR.
 
The Resource Database will include both “primary” (observation and measurement)
and “interpreted” data.
 
It is recommended that data be stored digitally,
 
using a
documented, standard format
 
and a reliable storage medium that allows for
 
easy
and complete retrieval of the data.
ROM
Run-of-mine
S-K 1300
United States Securities and Exchange Commission Regulation
 
S-K 1300
Modernization of Property Disclosures
SEC
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
SMCRA
Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977 is the primary federal
 
law that
regulates the environmental
 
effects of coal mining in the United States.
Strip Ratio
Represented by bcm of overburden to recoverable
 
coal tonnes
 
tph
tonnes per hour
 
TRS
Technical
 
Report Summary
USA
United States of America
USFW
United States Fish and Wildlife
USGS
United States Geologic Survey
 
VALMIN Code
Australasian Code for Public Reporting of Technical
 
Assessments and Valuations of
Mineral Assets
ex963p97i0
 
 
APPENDIX
D
INITIAL ECONOMIC ASSESSMENT FOR RESOURCES EXCLUSIVE
OF RESERVES
ex963p123i0
 
 
 
ex963p124i0
 
 
ex963p125i0
 
 
 
ex963p97i0
 
 
 
APPENDIX
E
JORC TABLE 13
3
 
JORC
 
Table
 
1
 
is
 
included
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
JORC
 
Code
 
standards.
 
Note
 
that
 
all
 
Coronado
properties are covered by JORC Table
 
1 herein.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
Section 1 Sampling Techniques and Data
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Sampling
techniques
>
 
Nature
 
and
 
quality of
 
sampling
 
(e.g. cut
 
channels, random
 
chips, or
 
specific
specialised industry standard
 
measurement tools
 
appropriate to
 
the minerals
under
 
investigation,
 
such
 
as
 
downhole
 
gamma
 
sondes,
 
or
 
handheld
 
XRF
instruments, etc.).
 
These examples
 
should not
 
be taken
 
as limiting
 
the broad
meaning of sampling.
>
 
Include reference to
 
measures taken
 
to ensure sample
 
representivity and the
appropriate calibration of any measurement tools or systems used.
>
 
Aspects of the determination
 
of mineralisation that
 
are Material to
 
the Public
Report. In cases
 
where ‘industry standard’
 
work has been
 
done this would
 
be
relatively
 
simple
 
(e.g.
 
‘reverse
 
circulation
 
drilling
 
was
 
used
 
to
 
obtain
 
1
 
m
samples
 
from
 
which
 
3
 
kg
 
was
 
pulverised
 
to
 
produce
 
a
 
30
 
g
 
charge
 
for
 
fire
assay’). In other cases, more
 
explanation may be required, such as where there
is coarse
 
gold that
 
has inherent
 
sampling problems.
 
Unusual commodities
 
or
mineralisation
 
types
 
(e.g.
 
submarine
 
nodules)
 
may
 
warrant
 
disclosure
 
of
detailed information.
>
 
Most
 
of
 
the coal
 
samples have
 
been
 
obtained
 
from
 
the Properties
 
by
 
subsurface
exploration using core drilling
 
techniques.
 
The protocol for preparing and
 
testing the
samples has varied over time and is not well documented
 
for the older holes drilled
on the Properties.
>
 
Typical
 
USA
 
core
 
drilling
 
sampling
 
technique
 
is
 
for
 
the
 
coal
 
core
 
sample,
 
once
recovered
 
from the
 
core barrel,
 
to
 
be described
 
then wrapped
 
in a
 
sealed plastic
sleeve and placed into a covered core box,
 
which is the length of the sample so that
the
 
core
 
can
 
be
 
delivered
 
to
 
a
 
laboratory
 
in
 
relatively
 
intact
 
condition
 
and
 
with
original moisture content.
>
 
It is reasonable to
 
assume, given the sophistication
 
level of the previous
 
operators,
that
 
these
 
samples
 
were
 
generally
 
collected
 
and
 
processed
 
under
 
industry
 
best-
practices.
 
This
 
assumption
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
MM&A’s
 
familiarity
 
with
 
the
 
operating
companies and the companies used to perform the analysis.
 
>
 
Some of the
 
drill holes
 
were air rotary
 
bored and no
 
coal core samples
 
were collected.
 
Seam
 
thickness
 
for
 
rotary-drilled
 
bore
 
holes
 
is
 
verified
 
by
 
calibrated
 
downhole
gamma-density logs.
 
>
 
Coal samples that
 
were deemed by
 
MM&A geologists to
 
be unrepresentative were
not used for statistical
 
analysis of coal
 
quality, as
 
documented in the tabulations.
 
A
representative group
 
of drill
 
hole samples
 
from the
 
Properties were
 
then checked
against the original drill laboratory reports to verify accuracy and correctness.
 
Drilling
techniques
>
 
Drill type
 
(e.g. core,
 
reverse
 
circulation,
 
open-hole hammer,
 
rotary air
 
blast,
auger,
 
Bangka, sonic,
 
etc.) and
 
details (e.g.
 
core diameter,
 
triple or
 
standard
tube, depth of diamond
 
tails, face-sampling bit
 
or other type, whether
 
core is
oriented and if so, by what method, etc.).
>
 
The Properties have been extensively
 
explored by subsurface drilling efforts
 
carried
out
 
by
 
numerous
 
entities,
 
most
 
of
 
which
 
were
 
completed
 
prior to
 
acquisition
 
by
Coronado.
 
The majority of
 
the drilling was
 
accomplished using vertical
 
continuous
(diamond) coring or air rotary methods.
>
 
Core drilling methods utilize
 
NX-size (5.4
 
centimeter) or similar-sized
 
core cylinders
to recover core samples, which
 
can be used to delineate
 
geologic characteristics, and
for coal quality testing and geotechnical logging.
 
>
 
Data for
 
the rotary
 
drilled holes is
 
mainly derived from
 
downhole geophysical logs,
which are
 
used to
 
interpret coal
 
and rock
 
thickness and depth
 
since logging
 
of the
drill cuttings is not reliable.
>
 
Geophysical
 
logging
 
was
 
performed
 
on
 
many
 
of
 
the
 
holes,
 
either
 
by
 
Geological
Logging Systems (a division
 
of MM&A), other
 
geophysical logging contractors, and on
those properties acquired from
 
CONSOL geophysical logging was often
 
performed by
CONSOL’s
 
in-house logging services.
Drill sample
recovery
>
 
Method of recording and assessing
 
core and chip sample recoveries
 
and results
assessed.
>
 
Measures
 
taken
 
to
 
maximise
 
sample
 
recovery
 
and
 
ensure
 
representative
nature of the samples.
>
 
Whether a relationship
 
exists between sample recovery
 
and grade and
 
whether
sample
 
bias
 
may
 
have
 
occurred
 
due
 
to
 
preferential
 
loss/gain
 
of
 
fine/coarse
material.
>
 
Where available,
 
core recovery
 
thickness of
 
coal samples
 
was reconciled
 
with the
thickness interpreted from geophysical logs.
>
 
Core recovery
 
of the
 
older coal
 
samples lacking
 
geophysical logs
 
is sometimes
 
not
well-documented:
 
however,
 
when
 
the
 
laboratory
 
results
 
for
 
such
 
holes
 
had
anomalous values, the data was disqualified and not used.
 
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Logging
>
 
Whether
 
core
 
and
 
chip
 
samples
 
have
 
been
 
geologically
 
and
 
geotechnically
logged to a level of detail to support appropriate Mineral Resource estimation,
mining studies and metallurgical studies.
>
 
Whether
 
logging
 
is
 
qualitative
 
or
 
quantitative
 
in
 
nature.
 
Core
 
(or
 
costean,
channel, etc.) photography.
>
 
The total length and percentage of the relevant intersections logged.
>
 
A wide variety of
 
core-logging techniques exist
 
for the properties.
 
For many of
 
the
core
 
holes,
 
the
 
primary
 
data
 
source
 
is
 
a
 
generalized
 
lithology
 
description
 
by
 
the
driller,
 
in some
 
cases
 
supplemented
 
by
 
a
 
more
 
detailed
 
core
 
log
 
completed
 
by
 
a
geologist.
 
>
 
The logging of
 
core thickness and
 
depth is quantitative.
 
With the exception
 
of the
coal seams,
 
logging of
 
rock strata
 
type is
 
more subjective
 
and best
 
considered as
qualitative.
Sub-sampling
techniques
and sample
preparation
>
 
If core, whether cut or sawn and whether quarter, half or all core taken.
>
 
If
 
non-core,
 
whether
 
riffled,
 
tube
 
sampled,
 
rotary
 
split,
 
etc.
 
and
 
whether
sampled wet or dry.
>
 
For
 
all sample
 
types, the
 
nature,
 
quality and
 
appropriateness
 
of the
 
sample
preparation technique.
>
 
Quality control
 
procedures
 
adopted
 
for
 
all
 
sub-sampling
 
stages
 
to
 
maximise
representivity of samples.
>
 
Measures taken
 
to
 
ensure
 
that
 
the
 
sampling
 
is representative
 
of
 
the
 
in
 
situ
material collected, including for instance results for field duplicate/second-half
sampling.
>
 
Whether sample
 
sizes are
 
appropriate to
 
the grain
 
size of
 
the material
 
being
sampled.
>
 
Typical US practice in
 
the Appalachian Basin is that core
 
samples for deep mineable
core samples are
 
not sawn or
 
subsampled (since seams
 
are not of
 
great thickness and
the entire seam is mined and co-mingled).
 
The entire coal interval drilled is generally
analysized.
>
 
Oftentimes, core for
 
surface-mineable coal seams are
 
bench sampled separately by
the various coal and rock layers (plies).
>
 
MM&A has exercised diligence to use only those analyses that are representative
 
of
the coal quality parameters for the appropriate mining type for each sample.
Quality of
assay data and
laboratory
tests
>
 
The
 
nature,
 
quality
 
and
 
appropriateness
 
of
 
the
 
assaying
 
and
 
laboratory
procedures used and whether the technique is considered partial or total.
>
 
For
 
geophysical
 
tools,
 
spectrometers,
 
handheld
 
XRF
 
instruments,
 
etc.,
 
the
parameters
 
used in
 
determining the
 
analysis including
 
instrument make
 
and
model, reading times, calibrations factors applied and their derivation, etc.
>
 
Nature
 
of
 
quality
 
control
 
procedures
 
adopted
 
(e.g.
 
standards,
 
blanks,
duplicates,
 
external
 
laboratory
 
checks)
 
and
 
whether
 
acceptable
 
levels
 
of
accuracy (i.e. lack of bias) and precision have been established.
>
 
Sample analysis was typically carried out by accredited US laboratories.
 
>
 
Standard procedure upon receipt of
 
core samples by the testing
 
laboratory is to log
the
 
depth
 
and
 
thickness
 
of
 
the
 
sample,
 
then
 
perform
 
testing
 
as
 
specified
 
by
 
a
representative
 
of
 
the
 
operating
 
company.
 
Each
 
sample
 
is
 
then
 
analyzed
 
in
accordance with
 
procedures defined
 
under
ASTM
 
International (
ASTM
)
 
standards
including, but
 
not limited
 
to; washability
 
(ASTM D4371);
 
ash (ASTM
 
D3174); sulfur
(ASTM
 
D4239);
 
Btu/lb.
 
(ASTM
 
D5865);
 
volatile
 
matter
 
(ASTM
 
D3175);
 
Free
 
Swell
Index (
FSI
) (ASTM D720).
>
 
Geophysical
 
tools
 
are
 
calibrated
 
by
 
the
 
logging
 
company
 
and
 
where
 
possible,
validated using a calibration hole.
Verification of
sampling and
assaying
>
 
The verification of
 
significant intersections by either
 
independent or alternative
company personnel.
>
 
The use of twinned holes.
>
 
Documentation of primary data, data entry procedures,
 
data verification, data
storage (physical and electronic) protocols.
>
 
Discuss any adjustment to assay data.
>
 
All
 
coal
 
intersection
 
data
 
used
 
to
 
generate
 
the
 
geologic
 
model
 
has
 
been
 
cross
referenced with the lithological and geophysical logs by MM&A.
>
 
Laboratory quality was adjusted from dry basis to reflect the anticipated marketable
product moisture.
>
 
Coal quality
 
results were
 
verified by
 
spot-check with
 
laboratory analysis
 
sheets by
MM&A before inclusion into the geologic model and use in the resource estimate.
Location of
data points
>
 
Accuracy and quality of surveys used to locate drill holes (collar and down-hole
surveys), trenches, mine
 
workings and other
 
locations used in
 
Mineral Resource
estimation.
>
 
Specification of the grid system used.
>
 
Quality and adequacy of topographic control.
>
 
Due to
 
the long
 
history of
 
exploration by
 
various parties
 
on the
 
Properties, a
 
wide
variety of survey techniques exist
 
for documentation of data
 
point locations.
 
Many
of the older
 
exploration drill
 
holes appear
 
to have
 
been located
 
by ground
 
survey;
more
 
recently
 
completed
 
drill
 
holes
 
are
 
often
 
located
 
by
 
high-resolution
 
Global
Positioning System (
GPS
) units.
>
 
Grid systems used are typically the State Plane Coordinate System
 
pertinent to each
property.
 
>
 
Topography is based on either the
 
USGS topographic 7.5-minute quadrangle maps
 
or
on recent aerial photogrammetry as necessary (subject to availability).
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Data spacing
and
distribution
>
 
Data spacing for reporting of Exploration Results.
>
 
Whether the data spacing and distribution is
 
sufficient to establish the
 
degree
of geological
 
and grade
 
continuity appropriate
 
for the
 
Mineral Resource
 
and
Ore Reserve estimation procedure(s) and classifications applied.
>
 
Whether sample compositing has been applied.
>
 
Spacing
 
and
 
distribution
 
of
 
data
 
point
 
information
 
may
 
vary
 
from
 
seam
 
to
 
seam
within each
 
mining area.
 
The areas
 
estimated for
 
coal resource
 
and coal
 
reserve
tonnes have
 
been limited
 
so that
 
the data
 
spacing and
 
distribution is
 
sufficient to
establish
 
the
 
degree
 
of
 
geological
 
continuity
 
appropriate
 
for
 
the
 
estimation
 
and
classification of the coal tonnes.
 
>
 
MM&A
 
performed
 
a
 
geostatistical
 
analysis
 
using
 
the
 
Drill
 
Hole
 
Spacing
 
Analysis
(
DHSA
)
 
method.
 
This method
 
attempts
 
to
 
quantify the
 
uncertainty of
 
applying a
measurement
 
from
 
a
 
central
 
location
 
to
 
increasingly
 
larger
 
square
 
blocks
 
and
provides
 
recommendations
 
for
 
determining
 
the
 
distances
 
between
 
drill
 
holes
 
for
measured, indicated, and inferred resources.
>
 
All
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
resource
 
tonnes
 
are
 
in
 
the
 
measured,
 
indicated,
 
and
 
inferred
categories,
 
and
 
all
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
reserve
 
tonnes
 
are
 
in
 
the
 
proved
 
and
 
probable
categories in accordance with the JORC Code and SEC standards.
 
Orientation of
data in
relation to
geological
structure
>
 
Whether the
 
orientation of
 
sampling achieves
 
unbiased sampling
 
of possible
structures and the extent to which this is known, considering the deposit type.
>
 
If the relationship
 
between the drilling
 
orientation and the
 
orientation of
 
key
mineralised structures
 
is considered
 
to have
 
introduced a
 
sampling bias,
 
this
should be assessed and reported if material.
>
 
Drill
 
holes
 
have
 
been
 
vertically
 
drilled.
 
No
 
downhole
 
deviation
 
logs
 
have
 
been
collected and
 
it is
 
therefore
 
not known
 
if the
 
drill holes
 
have deviated
 
away
 
from
vertical.
 
Based on the relatively
 
shallow seam depths, any
 
deviation is expected
 
to
be insignificant and immaterial to the geologic characterization of the Property.
>
 
The dip of
 
the coal seams
 
is relatively minor, generally 1-2
 
degrees, and not
 
a material
issue for representation of seam thickness or quality.
Sample
security
The measures taken to ensure sample security.
>
 
Sample handling procedures employed by explorationists
 
follow typical US protocol
and should be adequate to ensure sample security.
Audits or
reviews
The results of any audits or reviews of sampling techniques and data.
>
 
MM&A
 
has
 
reviewed
 
all
 
available
 
geological
 
information
 
for
 
the
 
Properties
 
in
developing the geologic
 
model.
 
Only that data
 
deemed suitable has
 
been used for
the purpose of generating the resource and reserve estimates.
Section 2 Reporting of Exploration Results
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Mineral
tenement and
land tenure
status
>
 
Type, reference name/number,
 
location and ownership including agreements
or material issues with third parties such as joint ventures, partnerships,
overriding royalties, native title interests, historical sites, wilderness or
national park and environmental settings.
>
 
The security of the tenure held at the time of reporting along with any known
impediments to obtaining a licence to operate in the area.
>
 
The Coronado coal resources are located
 
within the United States
 
of America in the
states
 
of Virginia;
 
West
 
Virginia; and
 
Pennsylvania.
 
Control of
 
these Properties
 
is
governed by multiple agreements.
>
 
MM&A has not carried out separate title verification for the coal properties
 
and has
not verified leases,
 
deeds, surveys or
 
other property control
 
instruments pertinent
to the subject resources.
 
>
 
Coronado has
 
represented to
 
MM&A that
 
it controls
 
the mining
 
rights to
 
the coal
deposits as shown on its
 
property maps, and MM&A
 
has accepted these as being
 
a
true and accurate
 
depiction of the
 
mineral rights controlled
 
by Coronado.
 
The TRS
assumes
 
the
 
properties
 
are
 
developed
 
under
 
responsible
 
and
 
experienced
management.
>
 
There
 
are
 
no
 
known
 
legal
 
or
 
environmental
 
encumbrances
 
that
 
would
 
impede
development of the subject coal reserves.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
ex963p130i2 ex963p130i2 ex963p130i2 ex963p130i1 ex963p130i2
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
4
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Exploration
done by other
parties
>
 
Acknowledgment and appraisal of exploration by other parties.
>
 
The Properties have been extensively
 
explored by subsurface drilling efforts
 
carried
out
 
by
 
numerous
 
entities,
 
most
 
of
 
which
 
were
 
completed
 
prior to
 
acquisition
 
by
Coronado.
>
 
This
 
exploration
 
work
 
was
 
generally
 
performed
 
to
 
prevailing
 
US
 
best
 
practice
standards and deemed adequate for the purposes of this TRS.
 
Geology
>
 
Deposit type, geological setting and style of mineralisation.
>
 
The
 
Coronado
 
coal
 
resources
 
are
 
located
 
within
 
the
 
Northern
 
and
 
Central
Appalachian Coal Basins.
>
 
The coal deposits are Carboniferous in age, being of the Pennsylvanian system
 
with.
sedimentary, stratigraphic deposition.
>
 
Seam of economic significance typically range between 0.3 meters and 1.8 meters in
thickness, with relatively little structural deformation.
>
 
Regional structure is typically
 
characterized by gently dipping strata to the
 
northwest
at less than one percent.
Drill hole
Information
>
 
A summary of all information material to the understanding of the exploration
results including a tabulation of the following information for all Material drill
holes:
 
easting and northing of the drill hole collar
 
elevation or RL (Reduced Level – elevation above sea level in metres) of the
drill hole collar
 
dip and azimuth of the hole
 
down hole length and interception depth
 
hole length.
>
 
If the exclusion of this information is justified on the basis that the
information is not Material and this exclusion does not detract from the
understanding of the report, the Competent Person should clearly explain why
this is the case.
>
 
MM&A reviewed and entered
 
all pertinent data
 
into a digital
 
geologic database for
each Coronado property.
 
The database consists of thousands of data records, which
include drill hole
 
and supplemental coal seam
 
thickness measurements from outcrop
and mine exposures.
 
>
 
All drill holes in the
 
database are provided with a collar elevation and
 
the State Plane
Coordinate System easting and northing coordinate.
>
 
After MM&A confirmed proper
 
coal seam thickness and
 
correlation, the seam
 
data
was modelled and compiled into coal resource maps.
>
 
The maps are
 
provided in the
 
TRS and show
 
drill hole locations;
 
however, a tabulation
of the thousands of individual data records is not practical to include.
Data
aggregation
methods
>
 
In reporting Exploration Results, weighting averaging techniques, maximum
and/or minimum grade truncations (e.g. cutting of high grades) and cut-off
grades are usually Material and should be stated.
>
 
Where aggregate intercepts incorporate short lengths of high grade results
and longer lengths of low grade results, the procedure used for such
aggregation should be stated and some typical examples of such aggregations
should be shown in detail.
>
 
The assumptions used for any reporting of metal equivalent values should be
clearly stated.
>
 
If a
 
coal seam
 
has been
 
bench sampled,
 
the individual
 
analyses for
 
the coal
 
plies
would be weight-averaged
 
to represent the total of
 
recoverable coal to be
 
included
in the quality model.
>
 
Coal quality
 
summary results have
 
been documented in
 
the TRS.
 
Average coal quality
on a
 
per-seam basis
 
is used
 
to represent
 
the coal
 
resources within
 
a given
 
mining
area.
>
 
Average coal quality for each Coronado complex is provided in Tables 1-1, 1-2 and 1-
3 of this TRS.
 
>
 
No other data aggregations methods are used.
Relationship
between
mineralisation
widths and
intercept
lengths
>
 
These relationships are particularly important in the reporting of Exploration
Results.
>
 
If the geometry of the mineralisation with respect to the drill hole angle is
known, its nature should be reported.
>
 
If it is not known and only the down hole lengths are reported, there should
be a clear statement to this effect (e.g. ‘down hole length, true width not
known’).
>
 
Coal thickness values from all coal intersections and down
 
hole geophysical logs are
considered to be vertical thicknesses.
 
Seam dip of approximately 2.0 to 3.0 degrees
has little effect on the vertical thickness of the seam.
Diagrams
>
 
Appropriate maps and sections (with scales) and tabulations of intercepts
should be included for any significant discovery being reported These should
>
 
Diagrams and maps showing the coal seam intercepts are presented in the TRS.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
5
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
include, but not be limited to a plan view of drill hole collar locations and
appropriate sectional views.
Balanced
reporting
>
 
Where comprehensive reporting of all Exploration Results is not practicable,
representative reporting of both low and high grades and/or widths should be
practiced to avoid misleading reporting of Exploration Results.
>
 
All
 
of
 
the
 
available,
 
qualified
 
exploration
 
data
 
has
 
been
 
included
 
within
 
the
tabulations, maps, and diagrams for this TRS.
>
 
Both
 
coal
 
thickness
 
and
 
quality
 
data
 
are
 
deemed
 
by
 
MM&A
 
to
 
be
 
reasonably
sufficient
 
within
 
the
 
resource
 
areas.
 
Therefore,
 
there
 
is
 
a
 
reasonable
 
level
 
of
confidence in the geologic interpretations
 
required for coal resource
 
determination
based on the available data and the techniques applied to the data.
Other
substantive
exploration
data
>
 
Other exploration data, if meaningful and material, should be reported
including (but not limited to): geological observations; geophysical survey
results; geochemical survey results; bulk samples – size and method of
treatment; metallurgical test results; bulk density, groundwater,
 
geotechnical
and rock characteristics; potential deleterious or contaminating substances.
>
 
Informational material available from
 
the U.S. Geological Survey
 
and the respective
State Surveys was used to assist in the Resource estimate.
 
Further work
>
 
The nature and scale of planned further work (e.g. tests for lateral extensions
or depth extensions or large-scale step-out drilling).
>
 
Diagrams clearly highlighting the areas of possible extensions, including the
main geological interpretations and future drilling areas, provided this
information is not commercially sensitive.
>
 
Further work is expected to include
 
additional exploration, geotechnical testing, coal
quality analyses, and coal property acquisition.
 
Section 3 Estimation and Reporting of Mineral Resources
(Criteria listed in the preceding section also apply to this section.)
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Database integrity
>
 
Measures taken to ensure that data has not been corrupted by, for example,
transcription or keying errors, between its initial collection and its use for Mineral
Resource estimation purposes.
>
 
Data validation procedures used.
>
 
MM&A confirmed coal seam thickness and correlations
 
in databases used for coal
 
deposit
modelling.
 
Representative records were spot-checked for data entry validation.
 
>
 
Geophysical logs were used wherever available to assist in confirming the seam correlation
and to verify proper seam thickness measurements and recovery of coal samples.
Site
visits
>
 
Comment on any site visits undertaken by the Competent Person and the outcome
of those visits.
>
 
If no site visits have been undertaken indicate why this is the case.
>
 
MM&A
 
is
 
very
 
familiar
 
with
 
the
 
Properties
 
and
 
has
 
conducted
 
multiple
 
site
 
visits
 
and
evaluations of the Property and adjoining properties throughout the years.
>
 
A site visit to Mon Valley was conducted as recently as December 2023, although there are
no facilities
 
or surface
 
expression of
 
the coal
 
reserves on
 
the Property.
 
Planned surface
areas for mine facilities were viewed.
Geological
interpretation
>
 
Confidence in (or conversely, the uncertainty of) the geological interpretation of the
mineral deposit.
>
 
Nature of the data used and of any assumptions made.
>
 
The effect, if any, of alternative interpretations
 
on Mineral Resource estimation.
>
 
The use of geology in guiding and controlling Mineral Resource estimation.
>
 
The factors affecting continuity both of grade and geology.
>
 
Due to the relative structural simplicity
 
of the deposits and the
 
reasonable continuity of the
tabular coal beds, the principal geological interpretation necessary to define
 
the geometry
of the coal deposits is the proper modeling of their thickness and elevation.
 
>
 
Both coal
 
thickness and
 
quality data
 
are deemed
 
by MM&A
 
to be
 
reasonable within
 
the
resource areas.
 
>
 
Therefore, there is a reasonable level of confidence
 
in the geologic interpretations required
for coal resource determination based on the available
 
data and the techniques applied to
the data.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
6
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Dimensions
>
 
The extent and variability of the Mineral Resource expressed as length (along strike
or otherwise), plan width, and depth below surface to the upper and lower limits of
the Mineral Resource.
>
 
The subject coal
 
resource areas mostly
 
exist in discreet,
 
individual deposits
 
of highly variable
dimensions, shapes and depth below the ground surface.
>
 
Such factors are best depicted in the maps contained in the TRS.
>
 
Details
 
of
 
the
 
parameters
 
are
 
cited
 
within
 
the
 
TRS
 
and
 
included
 
in
 
the
 
table
 
of
 
Cut-off
Parameters listed in Section 11.1 of the TRS.
 
Estimation
and
modelling
techniques
>
 
The nature and appropriateness of the estimation technique(s) applied and key
assumptions, including treatment of extreme grade values, domaining, interpolation
parameters and maximum distance of extrapolation from data points. If a computer
assisted estimation method was chosen include a description of computer software
and parameters used.
>
 
The availability of check estimates, previous estimates and/or mine production
records and whether the Mineral Resource estimate takes appropriate account of
such data.
>
 
The assumptions made regarding recovery of by-products.
>
 
Estimation of deleterious elements or other non-grade variables of economic
significance (e.g. sulphur for acid mine drainage characterisation).
>
 
In the case of block model interpolation, the block size in relation to the average
sample spacing and the search employed.
>
 
Any assumptions behind modelling of selective mining units.
>
 
Any assumptions about correlation between variables.
>
 
Description of how the geological interpretation was used to control the resource
estimates.
>
 
Discussion of basis for using or not using grade cutting or capping.
>
 
The process of validation, the checking process used, the comparison of model data
to drill hole data, and use of reconciliation data if available.
>
 
Geological
 
data
 
was
 
imported
 
into
 
Carlson
 
Mining®
 
(formerly
 
SurvCADD®)
 
geological
modelling software
 
in the
 
form
 
of Microsoft®
 
Excel
 
files incorporating,
 
drill hole
 
collars,
seam and thickness picks, bottom seam elevations and raw and washed coal quality. These
data files were validated prior to importing into the software.
>
 
Once imported, a geologic model was created.
>
 
The geological model was verified and reviewed.
 
>
 
Resources were estimated by
 
defining seam thickness at each point of
 
observation and by
defining resource confidence arcs around the points of observation.
>
 
Points of observation for Measured and Indicated confidence arcs were
 
defined for all drill
holes that intersected the seam.
 
>
 
As prescribed
 
by the
 
common United
 
States classification
 
system
 
the following
 
distances
from points of observation were used to define the corresponding Resource category arcs:
-
 
Inferred Resources – greater than 3,960
 
feet (1.2 kilometers) but less
 
than 15,840 feet
(4.8 kilometers)
-
 
Indicated Resources – 3,960 feet (1.2 kilometers)
-
 
Measured Resources – 1,320 feet (0.4 kilometers)
>
 
The
 
use
 
of
 
the
 
standards
 
commonly
 
used
 
in
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
are
 
appropriate
 
and
customary for this resource jurisdiction and deposition type.
>
 
MM&A performed
 
a geostatistical
 
analysis test
 
of the
 
Coronado data
 
sets using
 
the Drill
Hole Spacing Analysis (DHSA) method to justify coal resource confidence levels.
>
 
Based on
 
MM&A’s
 
analysis, it
 
would be
 
possible to
 
extend the
 
measured, indicated
 
and
inferred
 
arcs
 
slightly
 
beyond
 
historically
 
accepted
 
practices
 
due
 
to
 
consistent
 
geological
settings.
 
The
 
QP’s
 
have
 
elected
 
not
 
to
 
extend
 
arc
 
distances,
 
introducing
 
a
 
level
 
of
conservatism in the coal classification.
Moisture
>
 
Whether the tonnages are estimated on a dry basis or with natural moisture, and the
method of determination of the moisture content.
>
 
Coal resource tonnes are presented on a dry, in-situ basis.
>
 
Reserve tonnes are
 
presented on a
 
moist basis
 
at anticipated product
 
moisture ranging from
4.0 to
 
6.0 percent.
 
Moisture content
 
based on historic
 
analyses of
 
shipped coal
 
from the
region.
Cut-off Parameters
>
 
The basis of the adopted cut-off grade(s) or quality parameters applied.
>
 
The
 
cut-off
 
parameters
 
were
 
tailored
 
for
 
each
 
of
 
the
 
Coronado
 
properties
 
to
 
be
 
in
accordance with
 
mining/ processing capabilities
 
and market
 
conditions prevalent
 
at each
operation.
>
 
Examples include
 
minimum recoverable
 
coal thickness,
 
acceptable ash
 
content and
 
wash
recovery, and manageable overburden to coal ratio for surface mineable coal.
>
 
Details
 
of
 
the
 
parameters
 
are
 
cited
 
within
 
the
 
TRS
 
and
 
included
 
in
 
the
 
table
 
of
 
Cut-off
Parameters listed in Section 11.1 of this TRS.
>
 
These cut-off parameters have been developed by MM&A based on its
 
experience with the
Coronado properties and other mining operations
 
of the Central and Northern Appalachian
coal
 
basin.
 
This
 
experience
 
includes
 
technical
 
and
 
economic
 
evaluations
 
of
 
numerous
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
7
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
properties
 
in
 
the
 
region
 
for
 
the
 
purposes
 
of
 
determining
 
the
 
economic
 
viability
 
of
 
the
subject coal reserves.
Mining factors or
assumptions
>
 
Assumptions made regarding possible mining methods, minimum mining dimensions
and internal (or, if applicable, external) mining dilution. It is always necessary as part
of the process of determining reasonable prospects for eventual economic extraction
to consider potential mining methods, but the assumptions made regarding mining
methods and parameters when estimating Mineral Resources may not always be
rigorous. Where this is the case, this should be reported with an explanation of the
basis of the mining assumptions made.
>
 
Mining factors
 
such as
 
dilution, mining
 
and washing
 
recovery are
 
variable and
 
have been
applied at the coal deposits at each operation based on site-specific characteristics.
>
 
Details of the factors are cited within the TRS.
>
 
Factors that would typically preclude
 
conversion of a coal
 
resource to coal reserve
 
include
the following: inferred resource classification; absence of coal quality; poor mine recovery;
lack
 
of
 
access;
 
insufficient
 
exploration;
 
or
 
uncontrolled
 
surface
 
property
 
for
 
areas
 
of
proposed for surface mining.
 
>
 
While such factors were
 
used to preclude the
 
conversion of a
 
very limited number of
 
coal
resources to coal reserves
 
in this report, the extensive
 
history of mining on the
 
Properties
would suggest that there are reasonable prospects for eventual economic extractions of all
coal resources under favorable market conditions.
Metallurgical factors
or assumptions
>
 
The basis for assumptions or predictions regarding metallurgical amenability. It is
always necessary as part of the process of determining reasonable prospects for
eventual economic extraction to consider potential metallurgical methods, but the
assumptions regarding metallurgical treatment processes and parameters made
when reporting Mineral Resources may not always be rigorous. Where this is the
case, this should be reported with an explanation of the basis of the metallurgical
assumptions made.
>
 
The products mined
 
from coal resources controlled
 
by Coronado can
 
be sold into
 
high-, mid-
,
 
and
 
low-volatile
 
metallurgical
 
coal
 
markets
 
because
 
of
 
their
 
inherent
 
quality
characteristics.
 
>
 
Run-of-mine
 
production is
 
washed
 
at
 
the
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plants
 
as
 
needed
 
for
 
quality
control.
 
>
 
Coronado may
 
blend production from
 
multiple sources to
 
manage ash and
 
sulfur content
along with the rheological and petrographic characteristics of the shipped products.
 
Environmental
factors or
assumptions
>
 
Assumptions made regarding possible waste and process residue disposal options. It
is always necessary as part of the process of determining reasonable prospects for
eventual economic extraction to consider the potential environmental impacts of the
mining and processing operation.
 
While at this stage the determination of potential
environmental impacts, particularly for a greenfields project, may not always be well
advanced, the status of early consideration of these potential environmental impacts
should be reported. Where these aspects have not been considered this should be
reported with an explanation of the environmental assumptions made.
>
 
A study completed on behalf of Coronado for Mon Valley has identified a Preferred Site for
refuse
 
disposal
 
at
 
Pangburn
 
with
 
capacity
 
of
 
22.6 million
 
cubic
 
meters.
 
Estimated
requirements for
 
Pangburn and
 
Shaner combined is
 
29.7 million tonnes or
 
approximately
13.2 million cubic meters.
 
Permitting for such a facility is anticipated to be achievable.
>
 
MM&A completed a Limited Phase I
 
Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) on the Buchanan
property in April 2016, and on the Logan County and Greenbrier Properties in May 2017 on
behalf of Coronado.
 
Coronado reports not having conducted such
 
a study since the MM&A
studies.
 
>
 
The ESAs
 
completed by
 
MM&A included
 
a site
 
inspection, review
 
of historical
 
records,
 
a
database search of State and
 
Federal regulatory records and interviews to
 
identify potential
recognized environmental conditions (RECs) that may create environmental liability for the
sites.
 
>
 
MM&A
 
identified one
 
REC
 
at
 
Greenbrier
 
associated
 
with
 
stained
 
soil
 
and
 
gravel
 
near
 
a
fueling and
 
maintenance area.
 
Coronado reported
 
to
 
MM&A
 
that satisfactory
 
clean-up
efforts were completed at Greenbrier.
 
>
 
Based on these former ESAs completed by
 
MM&A, it is MM&A’s opinion that Coronado has
a generally typical coal industry record of
 
compliance with applicable mining,
 
water quality,
and
 
environmental
 
laws.
 
Estimated
 
costs
 
for
 
mine
 
closure,
 
including
 
water
 
quality
monitoring during site reclamation, are included in the TRS financial models.
 
Bulk density
>
 
Whether assumed or determined. If assumed, the basis for the assumptions. If
determined, the method used, whether wet or dry, the frequency of the
measurements, the nature, size and representativeness of the samples.
>
 
Laboratory derived seam densities measured in specific gravity were used where available.
 
As needed, these data were supplemented by estimated seam density values based on the
relative proportion of coal and
 
non-coal material within the seam
 
(typically at 1.30 and 2.25
specific gravity, respectively).
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
8
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
The bulk density for bulk material must have been measured by methods that
adequately account for void spaces (vugs, porosity, etc), moisture and differences
between rock and alteration zones within the deposit.
>
 
Discuss assumptions for bulk density estimates used in the evaluation process of the
different materials.
>
 
Average
 
seam
 
density
 
was
 
determined
 
for
 
each
 
coal
 
deposit
 
and
 
used
 
to
 
convert
 
coal
volumes into coal tonnage estimates.
Classification
>
 
The basis for the classification of the Mineral Resources into varying confidence
categories.
>
 
Whether appropriate account has been taken of all relevant factors (i.e. relative
confidence in tonnage/grade estimations, reliability of input data, confidence in
continuity of geology and metal values, quality, quantity and distribution of the
data).
>
 
Whether the result appropriately reflects the Competent
>
 
Person’s view of the deposit.
>
 
The Resource has
 
been classified based
 
on suitable distances
 
from points
 
of observations
prescribed in the common United States classification system.
>
 
The
 
use
 
of
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
standards
 
is
 
appropriate
 
and
 
customary
 
for
 
this
 
resource
jurisdiction and deposition type.
>
 
MM&A performed
 
a geostatistical
 
analysis test
 
of the
 
Coronado data
 
sets using
 
the Drill
Hole Spacing Analysis (DHSA) method.
>
 
Based on
 
MM&A’s
 
analysis, it
 
would be
 
possible to
 
extend the
 
measured, indicated
 
and
inferred
 
arcs
 
slightly
 
beyond
 
historically
 
accepted
 
practices
 
due
 
to
 
consistent
 
geological
settings.
 
The
 
QP’s
 
have
 
elected
 
not
 
to
 
extend
 
arc
 
distances,
 
introducing
 
a
 
level
 
of
conservatism in the coal classification.
>
 
All relevant factors have been
 
accounted for and reflect
 
the Competent Person’s view of
 
the
deposit.
Audits or reviews
>
 
The results of any audits or reviews of Mineral Resource estimates.
>
 
MM&A completed prepared a statement
 
of coal resources and reserves for the
 
Properties
in accordance
 
with the
 
JORC Code
 
as
 
of December 31,
 
2017.
 
MM&A also
 
subsequently
updated the
 
estimate of
 
resources and
 
reserves for
 
depletion as
 
of December 31,
 
2018,
December 31, 2019, December 31, 2020,
 
December 31, 2021,
 
and December 31, 2022.
>
 
MM&A performed a previous
 
audit of the
 
Properties in year
 
2017 for Coronado
 
based on
U.S.
 
Securities and
 
Exchange
 
Commission (SEC)
 
Industry Guide
 
7
 
and
 
USGS
 
Circular 891
standards.
 
>
 
Earlier audits were performed by various independent consultants for predecessors-in-title
to
 
Coronado
 
and
 
at
 
various
 
levels
 
of
 
detail
 
depending
 
on
 
the
 
clients
 
concerns
 
and
 
the
allotted time for
 
completion.
 
Previous audits and
 
reviews defined the
 
primary coal resource
areas and estimated the
 
recoverable tonnes for
 
each seam based on
 
the expected mining
methods.
 
>
 
Additionally,
 
MM&A
 
has
 
performed
 
proprietary
 
evaluations
 
for
 
predecessors-in-title
 
to
Coronado, which encompass portions of the Properties included in this TRS.
Discussion of relative
accuracy/ confidence
>
 
Where appropriate a statement of the relative accuracy and confidence level in the
Mineral Resource estimate using an approach or procedure deemed appropriate by
the Competent Person. For example, the application of statistical or geostatistical
procedures to quantify the relative accuracy of the resource within stated
confidence limits, or, if such an approach is not deemed appropriate, a qualitative
discussion of the factors that could affect the relative accuracy and confidence of the
estimate.
>
 
The statement should specify whether it relates to global or local estimates, and, if
local, state the relevant tonnages, which should be relevant to technical and
economic evaluation. Documentation should include assumptions made and the
procedures used.
>
 
These statements of relative accuracy and confidence of the estimate should be
compared with production data, where available.
>
 
The relative accuracy of and confidence in the coal tonnage and quality estimates provided
herein are judged to be in conformance with current industry best-practices.
 
>
 
The
 
representation
 
of
 
average
 
coal
 
quality
 
characteristics
 
should
 
be
 
understood
 
to
represent a reasonably
 
representative sampling
 
that is generally
 
indicative of coal
 
quality
and does not represent a statistically rigorous approach to coal quality modeling.
>
 
Resource estimation
 
has been
 
completed using
 
standard coal
 
estimation methods
 
which
are deemed appropriate for this deposit.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
9
Section 4 Estimation and Reporting of Ore Reserves
(Criteria listed in the preceding section also apply to this section.)
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Mineral Resource
estimate for
conversion to Ore
Reserves
 
>
 
Description of the Mineral Resource estimate used as a basis for the conversion to an
Ore Reserve.
>
 
The coal resource estimate was prepared
 
as part of the report Coronado Global Resources
Inc. Statement of
 
Coal Resources and
 
Reserves in Accordance with
 
JORC Code and United
States SEC
 
Standards as
 
of December 31,
 
2023 –
 
Northern and
 
Central Appalachian
 
Coal
Basins – Virginia,
 
West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
– February 2024
 
prepared by MM&A.
>
 
The resource estimation criteria were developed by
 
MM&A based on the capabilities
 
of the
mining equipment used
 
within the production model
 
and on industry-accepted
 
standards
to
 
assure
 
that the
 
basic
 
geologic characteristics
 
of
 
the coal
 
resources
 
are
 
in reasonable
conformity with those to be mined and marketed by Coronado.
>
 
Clear statement as to whether the Mineral Resources are reported additional to, or
inclusive of, the Ore Reserves.
>
 
Coal
 
resources
 
generally
 
are
 
reported
 
inclusive
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
In
 
some
 
cases,
resources are reported in addition
 
to coal reserves.
 
Tables 1-1
 
and 11-3 of the TRS clearly
identify resources “inclusive of mine plan” from
 
which coal reserves were estimated along
with those resources “exclusive of mine plan” from which no reserves were estimated.
 
Site visits
 
>
 
Comment on any site visits undertaken by the Competent Person and the outcome
of those visits.
>
 
MM&A is very
 
familiar with
 
the Properties
 
and has conducted
 
multiple site visits
 
and reserve
evaluations throughout the years.
>
 
A site visit
 
was conducted to Mon Valley as recently as December 2023 to assess proposed
surface mine facilities areas.
 
Currently there are no mine facilities or surface expression of
the coal reserve on the Property.
Study status
 
>
 
The type and level of study undertaken to enable Mineral Resources to be converted
to Ore Reserves.
>
 
A preliminary feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for active and proposed mines.
 
>
 
The Code requires that a study to at least Pre-Feasibility Study level has been
undertaken to convert Mineral Resources to Ore Reserves. Such studies will have
been carried out and will have determined a mine plan that is technically achievable
and economically viable, and that material Modifying Factors have been considered.
>
 
This
 
geologic
 
evaluation
 
conducted
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
JORC
 
and
 
SEC
 
standards
 
and
 
in
conjunction with the preliminary feasibility study is sufficient to conclude that
 
the surface,
highwall miner and
 
underground coal reserves
 
identified on the
 
Properties are economically
mineable under
 
reasonable expectations of
 
market prices for thermal
 
and metallurgical coal
products, estimated operation costs, and capital expenditures.
>
 
The pre-feasibility financial models, prepared by MM&A for
 
this TRS, was developed to test
the economic viability of each coal resource area.
>
 
Proved
 
and
 
probable
 
coal
 
reserve
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
in-situ
 
coal
 
resource
considering
 
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
independent
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
revenue and cost, marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors).
Cut-off parameters
 
>
 
The basis of the adopted cut-off grade(s) or quality parameters applied.
>
 
The
 
cut-off
 
parameters
 
were
 
tailored
 
for
 
each
 
of
 
the
 
Coronado
 
properties
 
to
 
be
 
in
accordance with
 
mining/ processing capabilities
 
and market
 
conditions prevalent
 
at each
operation.
>
 
Examples include
 
minimum recoverable
 
coal thickness,
 
acceptable ash
 
content and
 
wash
recovery, and manageable overburden to coal ratio for surface mineable coal.
>
 
Details
 
of
 
the
 
parameters
 
are
 
cited
 
within
 
the
 
TRS
 
and
 
included
 
in
 
the
 
table
 
of
 
Cut-off
Parameters listed in Section 11.1 of this TRS.
>
 
These cut-off parameters have been developed by MM&A based on its
 
experience with the
Coronado
 
properties
 
and
 
are
 
typical
 
of
 
mining
 
operations
 
in
 
the
 
Central
 
and
 
Northern
Appalachian coal
 
basin.
 
This experience
 
includes technical
 
and economic
 
evaluations of
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
10
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
numerous properties in the
 
region for the
 
purposes of determining the
 
economic viability
of the subject coal reserves.
Mining factors or
assumptions
 
>
 
The method and assumptions used as reported in the Pre-Feasibility or Feasibility
Study to convert the Mineral Resource to an Ore Reserve (i.e. either by application of
appropriate factors by optimisation or by preliminary or detailed design).
>
 
After validating
 
coal seam
 
data and
 
establishing correlations,
 
the thickness
 
and elevation
for seams of economic interest were used to generate a geologic model.
>
 
A pre-feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for active and proposed mines.
 
MM&A
prepared
 
mine
 
projections
 
and
 
production
 
timing
 
forecasts
 
based
 
on
 
coal
 
seam
characteristics.
 
Production timing was carried
 
out from 2024
 
to depletion (exhaustion) of
the coal reserve areas.
>
 
The choice, nature and appropriateness of the selected mining method(s) and other
mining parameters including associated design issues such as pre-strip, access, etc.
>
 
The
 
room-and-pillar
 
mining
 
method
 
was
 
selected
 
to
 
model
 
the
 
underground
 
mining
resources, utilizing continuous
 
miners for coal
 
extraction, shuttle cars
 
for production section
haulage and roof bolters for
 
roof control, with the exception
 
that the Buchanan Mine also
uses longwall shearers, armored face conveyors, and hydraulic self-advancing roof support.
 
The resource
 
areas
 
located
 
above
 
drainage
 
are
 
relatively
 
small and
 
often
 
have
 
irregular
boundaries. The
 
Buchanan Mine
 
in Buchanan
 
County,
 
Virginia is
 
the only
 
active longwall
mine currently being operated by Coronado.
>
 
The
 
Coronado
 
underground
 
mining
 
resource
 
areas
 
which
 
are
 
located
 
above-drainage
require an
 
access road and
 
mine access development
 
along the outcrop,
 
whereas below-
drainage
 
mines
 
are
 
accessed
 
via
 
shaft
 
or
 
slope
 
based
 
on
 
other
 
proposed
 
surface
infrastructure locations and/or surface property control.
 
>
 
The surface mining method selected utilizes highly productive hydraulic
 
shovels, front-end
loaders,
 
large
 
tractors
 
and
 
rock
 
trucks
 
for
 
overburden
 
removal.
 
The
 
mobile equipment
spreads adapt readily to winding coal outcrops for
 
contour surface mining and are effective
for point-removal and area mining applications.
>
 
Application
 
of
 
highwall
 
and
 
auger
 
mining
 
units
 
is
 
an
 
effective
 
method
 
to
 
recover
 
coal
resources
 
not
 
suitable
 
for
 
underground
 
mining
 
and
 
under
 
excessive
 
cover
 
for
 
surface
mining.
>
 
The assumptions made regarding geotechnical parameters (e.g. pit slopes, stope
sizes, etc.), grade control and pre-production drilling.
>
 
Mining plans for
 
potential underground
 
mines were developed
 
by MM&A.
 
Pillar stability
was tested
 
by MM&A
 
using the
 
Analysis of
 
Coal Pillar
 
Stability (ACPS)
 
program
 
that was
developed by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH).
 
>
 
Coronado
 
must
 
obtain
 
approved
 
mining
 
plans
 
from
 
United
 
States
 
Department
 
of
 
Labor
Mine
 
Safety
 
and
 
Health
 
Administration
 
(MSHA)
 
that
 
define
 
safety
 
parameters
 
for
 
the
highwalls developed during
 
contour and
 
area mining.
 
MM&A’s
 
planning model does
 
not
require
 
input
 
of
 
specific
 
highwall
 
design
 
parameters,
 
but
 
provides
 
for
 
timing
 
of
 
mining
within mine plan polygons that is representative of
 
the operation performance attained at
Central Appalachia surface mines.
>
 
Highwall and auger mining is conducted under
 
highwalls designed and constructed to meet
MSHA permit requirements.
 
To better
 
assure highwall stability and safety
 
during highwall
coal
 
extraction,
 
MSHA
 
requires
 
that
 
coal
 
fenders,
 
or
 
stumps,
 
be
 
left
 
in
 
place
 
between
successive cuts.
 
Periodic
 
barrier pillars
 
must
 
be left
 
in place
 
as
 
an
 
additional safeguard.
 
MM&A has adjusted the
 
expected mining recovery for highwall and
 
auger mining resources
to reflect highwall stability and safety requirements.
>
 
The major assumptions made and Mineral Resource model used for pit and stope
optimisation (if appropriate).
>
 
Underground Mining Resources:
 
For metallurgical resources, minimum coal
 
seam thickness
extends down to between 0.6 and 1.2 meters and a minimum overburden (depth of cover)
of 30.5 meters.
 
A 61-meter horizontal
 
distance is maintained from
 
abandoned mines and
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
11
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
sealed or
 
pillared areas,
 
and a
 
30-meter horizontal
 
distance is
 
maintained from
 
planned
highwall miner panels.
 
Mine recovery is reduced when a rider coal
 
seam is present within
a 1.5- to 3.0-meter interval above the coal seam.
 
No mining is projected when the interval
between overlying and underlying reserves is less than 12 meters.
>
 
Surface Mining Resources:
 
For classification as a
 
surface-mineable resource, a seam
 
must
be at
 
least 0.3
 
meters
 
in thickness
 
as
 
a stand-alone
 
(principal) seam
 
and 0.15
 
meters
 
in
thickness when less than 0.8 meters from a principal seam.
 
The maximum cumulative area
mining strip ratio
 
is generally 20:1
 
for thermal coal
 
and 30:1 for
 
metallurgical coal.
 
Some
areas
 
were
 
assessed
 
for
 
their
 
economic
 
viability at
 
higher
 
ratios,
 
and
 
were
 
included
 
as
reserves if deemed economic.
 
For contour surface mining, a
 
minimum of 38-meter bench
is provided to support HWM.
>
 
HWM
 
and
 
Auger
 
Mining
 
Resources:
 
HWM
 
cut
 
depth
 
(penetration)
 
is
 
established
 
at
 
a
maximum of 244
 
meters.
 
The minimum mineable
 
coal thickness is
 
limited at
 
0.6 meters.
For coal seams less than 0.8 meters thick, roof and/or floor characteristics
 
must allow OSD
cutting
 
to
 
maintain
 
a
 
0.8-meter
 
minimum
 
cutting
 
height.
 
Auger
 
mining
 
cut
 
depth
 
is
established at an average of 91 meters.
 
The minimum mineable coal thickness is limited at
0.5 meters.
>
 
The mining dilution factors used.
>
 
Underground Mining Reserves:
 
The planning model assigns
 
minimum mining heights of 1.4
to 1.8 meters for mains and
 
panel development.
 
At the Buchanan Mine, a
 
minimum mining
height of 1.8 meters
 
was used due to
 
the longwall mining method
 
being employed.
 
For coal
seams
 
thinner
 
than
 
the
 
assigned
 
mining
 
height,
 
the
 
difference
 
between
 
the
 
coal
 
seam
height and assigned mining height consists of
 
OSD.
 
In all cases a minimum
 
of 0.05 meters
of OSD was assumed, with the exception of
 
the Mon Valley mines, where
 
a minimum 0.15
meters of OSD was assumed due to weaker floor strata.
>
 
Surface Mining Reserves:
 
Area mining is generally limited to a cumulative
 
overburden ratio
of 30:1
 
and
 
a
 
15:1
 
ratio
 
for
 
contour
 
mining.
 
Exceptions
 
were
 
considered
 
for
 
mining
 
of
metallurgical grade coal where deemed
 
economical.
 
It is assumed that careful cleaning
 
of
exposed coal pits will result in minimal OSD.
>
 
HWM and Auger Mining Reserves:
 
The mining plan assumes that the HWM cutting height
is a minimum of 76
 
to 99 centimeters
 
for clearance purposes.
 
When the coal seam
 
is less
than 76 to 99
 
centimeters thick, OSD assumed
 
and included in the ROM
 
product. Because
the
 
auger
 
has
 
very
 
limited
 
OSD
 
cutting
 
ability,
 
it
 
is
 
assumed
 
that
 
an
 
appropriate
 
auger
diameter will be chosen based on the coal seam thickness and that OSD will be minimal.
>
 
The mining recovery factors used.
>
 
Underground Mining Reserves:
 
Mine recovery generally varies between 40 and 60 percent
for continuous mining panels, and 100 percent for longwall.
>
 
Surface Mining Reserves:
 
Mining recovery is 90
 
percent for virgin
 
areas.
 
Mining recovery
is reduced where
 
second mining is
 
projected in previously
 
underground and auger
 
mined
areas.
>
 
HWM and
 
Auger Mining
 
Reserves:
 
A mine
 
recovery of
 
40 percent
 
has been
 
applied for
HWM. A mine recovery of 35 percent has been applied for auger mining.
>
 
Any minimum mining widths used.
>
 
Underground Mining Reserves:
 
Typical entry width is 5.8 to 6.1 meters.
>
 
The manner in which Inferred Mineral Resources are utilised in mining studies and
the sensitivity of the outcome to their inclusion.
>
 
Proved
 
and
 
probable
 
coal
 
reserve
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
in-situ
 
coal
 
resource
considering
 
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
independent
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
revenue and cost, marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors).
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
12
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
Mine
 
plan
 
LOM
 
tonnage
 
includes
 
inferred
 
coal
 
and
 
those
 
areas
 
that
 
do
 
not
 
meet
 
the
minimum coal thickness requirement for classification as reserve.
 
Inferred coal represents
approximately 0.6% of the LOM
 
production for Mon Valley and 0.000001% of
 
the total LOM
production for Logan.
 
None of this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
>
 
The infrastructure requirements of the selected mining methods.
>
 
Underground Mining Resources:
 
The continuous mining
 
method provides for
 
the extraction
of coal from the production faces using continuous miners (and longwall shearing machine
at Buchanan) and haulage using shuttle cars or battery haulers to a feeder-breaker
 
located
at the tail of the section conveyor belt.
 
The feeder-breaker crushes large pieces of coal and
rock and regulates coal feed
 
onto the mine conveyor.
 
A chain conveyor is used to
 
remove
coal from
 
the longwall
 
face at
 
the Buchanan
 
Mine for
 
placement onto
 
the conveyor
 
belt
which is ultimately
 
delivered to an underground storage bunker.
 
Roof-bolting machines are
used to
 
install roof
 
bolts, and
 
battery scoops
 
are available
 
to clean
 
the mine
 
entries and
assist in delivery of
 
mine supplies to
 
work areas.
 
Surface ventilation fans
 
are installed as
needed to provide a sufficient
 
volume of air to ventilate
 
production sections, coal haulage
and
 
transport
 
entries,
 
battery
 
charging
 
stations,
 
and
 
transformers
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
approved plans.
>
 
Coronado
 
currently
 
operates
 
three
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plants,
 
one
 
each
 
at
 
the
 
Buchanan,
Logan
 
County and
 
Greenbrier Divisions.
 
The Buchanan
 
Plant
 
operates
 
at a
 
feed
 
rate
 
of
approximately 907
 
raw tonnes per
 
hour (tph), whereas
 
the Saunders Plant
 
(Logan County
Division)
 
has
 
a
 
nominal
 
feed
 
rate
 
of
 
816
 
tph,
 
and
 
the
 
Mountaineer
 
Plant
 
(Greenbrier
Division) operates
 
at
 
544 tph.
 
MM&A has
 
included capital
 
estimates
 
for
 
construction of
additional coal
 
preparation plants
 
at the
 
Russell County
 
and Mon
 
Valley
 
Complex for
 
the
purposes of this TRS.
 
>
 
Surface
 
Mining
 
Resources:
 
The
 
surface
 
mining
 
mobile
 
equipment
 
spreads
 
advance
 
the
contour and area mining pits while systematically
 
reclaiming the trailing side of pits where
coal
 
has
 
been
 
removed.
 
The
 
coal
 
haul
 
roads
 
are
 
extended
 
and
 
maintained
 
as
 
the
 
pits
advance.
 
Support facilities
 
are maintained
 
nearby but
 
away from
 
the active
 
mining, and
include storage areas for blasting agents, fuel and lubricants, and mine supplies along with
maintenance facilities and offices.
 
Most of the surface mine production is transported to a
loading point for crushing, blending and direct-shipment to customers.
 
>
 
HWM and Auger Resources: The HWM equipment advances along with the contour mining
pits.
 
The rate of advance of the
 
contour mining is governed by the
 
advancement rate of the
HWM.
 
A diesel-powered
 
generator trails
 
the highwall
 
miner and
 
powers the
 
continuous
mining unit.
 
Other support facilities
 
are provided
 
along with the
 
contour mining
 
support
facilities.
 
HWM
 
production is
 
all
 
transported
 
by
 
truck to
 
the coal
 
preparation
 
plant
 
for
washing.
Metallurgical factors
or assumptions
 
>
 
The metallurgical process proposed and the appropriateness of that process to the
style of mineralisation.
>
 
Coarse material is washed in a heavy medium vessel.
 
Intermediate-size material is washed
in heavy medium cyclones.
 
Fine material is washed using conventional froth flotation cells.
>
 
Whether the metallurgical process is well-tested technology or novel in nature.
>
 
Processes are
 
typical of
 
those
 
used
 
in the
 
coal
 
industry and
 
are
 
in
 
use
 
at
 
adjacent coal
processing plants.
>
 
The nature, amount and representativeness of metallurgical test work undertaken,
the nature of the metallurgical domaining applied and the corresponding
metallurgical recovery factors applied.
>
 
The
 
quality
 
characteristics
 
for
 
the
 
subject
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
coal
 
reserves
 
have
 
been
reviewed in
 
detail by
 
MM&A.
 
The drill
 
hole data
 
were
 
utilized
 
to develop
 
average
 
coal
quality characteristics
 
mining
 
site.
 
These average
 
coal quality
 
characteristics
 
were
 
then
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
13
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
utilized as
 
the basis for
 
determining the
 
various markets
 
into which
 
the saleable coal
 
will
likely be placed.
>
 
Any assumptions or allowances made for deleterious elements.
>
 
No
 
significant
 
effects
 
on
 
product
 
quality
 
are
 
anticipated
 
from
 
dilution
 
material;
 
float
product quality was used to model final product quality.
>
 
The existence of any bulk sample or pilot scale test work and the degree to which
such samples are considered representative of the orebody as a whole
>
 
No bulk sample or pilot scale work has been completed.
>
 
For minerals that are defined by a specification, has the ore reserve estimation been
based on the appropriate mineralogy to meet specifications?
>
 
Notwithstanding the complexity
 
of the coal
 
quality data set,
 
the seams of
 
the central and
northern Appalachian
 
coalfields have a long
 
history of providing
 
both high-Btu thermal
 
coals
and high-, mid- and low-volatile coking coals with favorable metallurgical properties.
Environmental
 
>
 
The status of studies of potential environmental impacts of the mining and
processing operation. Details of waste rock characterisation and the consideration of
potential sites, status of design options considered and, where applicable, the status
of approvals for process residue storage and waste dumps should be reported.
>
 
A study completed on behalf of Coronado has identified a Preferred Site for refuse disposal
at
 
Pangburn
 
with
 
capacity
 
of
 
22.6 million
 
cubic
 
meters.
 
Estimated
 
requirements
 
for
Pangburn and Shaner combined is 29.7 million tonnes or approximately 13.2 million.
>
 
MM&A completed a Limited Phase I
 
Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) on the Buchanan
property in April 2016, and on the Logan County and Greenbrier Properties in May 2017 on
behalf of Coronado.
>
 
MM&A
 
identified one
 
REC
 
at
 
Greenbrier
 
associated
 
with
 
stained
 
soil
 
and
 
gravel
 
near
 
a
fueling and
 
maintenance area.
 
Coronado reported
 
to
 
MM&A
 
that satisfactory
 
clean-up
efforts were completed at Greenbrier.
>
 
Based on these former ESAs completed by
 
MM&A, it is MM&A’s opinion that Coronado has
a generally typical coal industry record of
 
compliance with applicable mining,
 
water quality,
and
 
environmental
 
laws.
 
Estimated
 
costs
 
for
 
mine
 
closure,
 
including
 
water
 
quality
monitoring during site reclamation, are included in the TRS financial models.
Infrastructure
 
>
 
The existence of appropriate infrastructure: availability of land for plant
development, power, water,
 
transportation (particularly for bulk commodities),
labour, accommodation; or the ease with which the infrastructure can be provided
or accessed.
>
 
Coronado
 
currently
 
operates
 
one
 
surface
 
mine
 
(Toney
 
Fork
 
Mine
 
at
 
the
 
Logan
 
Mine
Complex); Coronado
 
also controls
 
the idle
 
Midland Surface
 
Mine at
 
the Greenbrier
 
Mine
Complex.
 
>
 
Coronado operates
 
five underground
 
mines as
 
follows:
 
Buchanan Mine at
 
the Buchanan
Mine Complex;
 
Winifrede, Eagle
 
No. 1,
 
Muddy Bridge
 
and Lower
 
War Eagle
 
Mines in
 
the
Logan
 
Mine
 
Complex;
 
the
 
Mountaineer
 
#1
 
Mine
 
at
 
the
 
Greenbrier
 
Mine
 
Complex
 
is
currently idle.
>
 
All ROM production is currently
 
planned for either truck transportation
 
from the mines
 
to
the processing or
 
shipping facilities,
 
or in some
 
cases there is
 
either a current
 
or planned
mine mouth preparation plant and barge/rail loading facility.
 
>
 
There is a network of public
 
highways that provide serviceable coal haul routes and
 
private,
internal roads on the Properties would be developed as may be needed.
 
Rail service to the
Properties
 
is
 
most
 
readily
 
provided
 
by
 
NS
 
and
 
CSX
 
with
 
connections
 
to
 
both
 
domestic
consumers
 
and
 
international
 
trans-shipment
 
points.
 
NS
 
track
 
is
 
located
 
across
 
the
Monongahela River from
 
the proposed Pangburn
 
Hollow load-out facility.
 
Coal would be
shipped to
 
customers via barge
 
and rail and
 
sold as
 
both metallurgical and
 
thermal products.
 
Costs
 
>
 
The derivation of, or assumptions made, regarding projected capital costs in the
study.
>
 
The methodology used to estimate operating costs.
>
 
Coronado
 
provided
 
historical
 
and
 
5-year
 
budget
 
operating
 
costs
 
for
 
its
 
active mines
 
for
MM&A’s review.
 
MM&A used the historical and/or budget cost information as a reference
and developed
 
personnel schedules
 
for each
 
mine.
 
Hourly labor
 
rates and
 
salaries were
based upon information contained in Coronado’s financial summaries.
 
Fringe benefit costs
were
 
developed
 
for
 
vacation
 
and
 
holidays,
 
federal
 
and
 
state
 
unemployment
 
insurance,
retirement,
 
workers’
 
compensation
 
and
 
pneumoconiosis,
 
casualty
 
and
 
life
 
insurance,
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
14
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
healthcare
 
and
 
bonuses.
 
A
 
cost
 
factor
 
for
 
mine
 
supplies
 
was
 
developed
 
that
 
relates
expenditures to mine
 
advance rates
 
for roof
 
control costs
 
and other mine
 
supply costs at
underground
 
mines.
 
Other
 
factors
 
were
 
developed
 
for
 
maintenance
 
and
 
repair
 
costs,
rentals, mine power, outside services and other direct mining costs.
>
 
Surface mine direct
 
operating costs
 
were developed as
 
a function of
 
overburden ratio
 
for
repair and
 
maintenance supplies,
 
diesel fuel,
 
explosives and
 
blasting, and
 
miscellaneous
supplies and
 
services.
 
Operating costs for highwall
 
mines are based
 
on costs per
 
ROM tonne
estimates.
 
Other cost factors were developed for coal preparation plant processing, refuse
handling, coal loading,
 
trucking, property taxes,
 
and insurance and
 
bonding.
 
Appropriate
royalty
 
rates
 
were
 
assigned for
 
production from
 
leased coal
 
lands and
 
sales
 
taxes
 
were
calculated for state severance taxes, the federal black lung excise tax, and federal and state
reclamation fees.
>
 
Capital schedules were developed
 
by MM&A for mine development,
 
infrastructure, and on-
going capital requirements for the life of each projected mine.
>
 
Staffing levels were prepared
 
and operating costs estimated
 
by MM&A for each projected
mine.
 
MM&A utilized historical cost
 
data provided by Coronado
 
and its own
 
knowledge and
experience to estimate direct and indirect operating costs.
 
>
 
Allowances made for the content of deleterious elements.
>
 
No
 
allowances
 
have
 
been
 
made
 
for
 
deleterious
 
elements;
 
no
 
impact
 
to
 
quality
 
from
deleterious elements is anticipated.
>
 
The derivation of assumptions made of metal or commodity price(s), for the principal
minerals and co- products.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for
 
all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from
 
market
 
observed forward
 
estimates
 
based on
 
global economic
 
supply and
demand
 
analysis
 
which
 
is
 
applied
 
to
 
mine
 
plan
 
sales
 
volumes
 
and
 
product
 
mix
 
and
 
is
supplemented
 
with
 
Coronado’s
 
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
 
charges.
 
Coal
 
price
 
forecasts
 
for
 
the
 
various
products were
 
provided by
 
Coronado for
 
various coal
 
markets in
 
terms of
 
US real
 
dollars
per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a
 
2% inflation factor
 
in order
 
to estimate
 
the prices in
nominal dollars.
>
 
Derivation of transportation charges.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for
 
all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from
 
market
 
observed forward
 
estimates
 
based on
 
global economic
 
supply and
demand
 
analysis
 
which
 
is
 
applied
 
to
 
mine
 
plan
 
sales
 
volumes
 
and
 
product
 
mix
 
and
 
is
supplemented
 
with
 
Coronado’s
 
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
charges, ocean
 
freight charges and
 
port charges Coal
 
price forecasts for the
 
various products
were provided by Coronado for
 
various coal markets in
 
terms of US real dollars
 
per metric
tonne.
 
MM&A
 
applied a
 
2%
 
inflation
 
factor
 
in
 
order
 
to
 
estimate
 
the
 
prices
 
in nominal
dollars.
>
 
The basis for forecasting or source of treatment and refining charges, penalties for
failure to meet specification, etc.
>
 
MM&A
 
utilized
 
historical
 
cost
 
data
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
its
 
own
 
knowledge
 
and
experience to estimate direct and indirect operating costs.
 
All ROM production is currently
planned
 
for
 
either
 
truck
 
transportation
 
from
 
the
 
mines
 
to
 
the
 
processing
 
or
 
shipping
facilities, or in
 
some cases there
 
is either a
 
current or planned
 
mine mouth preparation
 
plant
and barge/rail loading facility.
>
 
The allowances made for royalties payable, both Government and private.
>
 
Appropriate royalty
 
rates
 
were assigned
 
for production
 
from leased
 
coal lands
 
and sales
taxes
 
were
 
calculated
 
for
 
state
 
severance
 
taxes,
 
the
 
federal
 
black
 
lung
 
excise
 
tax,
 
and
federal and state reclamation fees.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
15
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Revenue factors
 
>
 
The derivation of, or assumptions made regarding revenue factors including head
grade, metal or commodity price(s) exchange rates, transportation and treatment
charges, penalties, net smelter returns, etc.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for
 
all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from
 
market
 
observed forward
 
estimates
 
based on
 
global economic
 
supply and
demand
 
analysis
 
which
 
is
 
applied
 
to
 
mine
 
plan
 
sales
 
volumes
 
and
 
product
 
mix
 
and
 
is
supplemented
 
with
 
Coronado’s
 
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
 
charges.
 
Coal
 
price
 
forecasts
 
for
 
the
 
various
products were
 
provided by
 
Coronado for
 
various coal
 
markets in
 
terms of
 
US real
 
dollars
per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a
 
2% inflation factor
 
in order
 
to estimate
 
the prices in
nominal dollars.
>
 
The
 
Greenbrier
 
property
 
is
 
not
 
considered
 
material
 
to
 
Coronado’s
 
business
 
or
 
financial
conditions, and thus no update was completed for Greenbrier in 2024. Resources exclusive
of
 
reserves,
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
reserves,
 
are
 
based
 
on
 
assumed
 
long-term
 
average
 
price
 
as
 
of
December 31,
 
2022
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado,
 
representing
 
Coronado’s
 
long-term
 
average
price forecast for Greenbrier at that time.
>
 
The derivation of assumptions made of metal or commodity price(s), for the principal
metals, minerals and co-products.
>
 
Coal sales prices as defined above.
 
All reported reserves are on a marketable basis.
Market assessment
 
>
 
The demand, supply and stock situation for the particular commodity, consumption
trends and factors likely to affect supply and demand into the future.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for
 
all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from
 
market
 
observed forward
 
estimates
 
based on
 
global economic
 
supply and
demand
 
analysis
 
which
 
is
 
applied
 
to
 
mine
 
plan
 
sales
 
volumes
 
and
 
product
 
mix
 
and
 
is
supplemented
 
with
 
Coronado’s
 
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
 
charges.
 
Coal
 
price
 
forecasts
 
for
 
the
 
various
products were
 
provided by
 
Coronado for
 
various coal
 
markets in
 
terms of
 
US real
 
dollars
per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a
 
2% inflation factor
 
in order
 
to estimate
 
the prices in
nominal dollars.
>
 
A customer and competitor analysis along with the identification of likely market
windows for the product.
>
 
All of the
 
mine production serves
 
metallurgical and thermal markets.
 
The metallurgical coal
is marketed
 
as high-volatile (typically
 
28 percent or
 
greater volatile matter
 
content); mid-
volatile (typically 23- to
 
27-percent volatile matter content)
 
and low-volatile (typically
 
less
than 23 percent volatile matter content) products.
>
 
Raw
 
ROM
 
production
 
that
 
requires
 
washing
 
is
 
currently
 
processed
 
through
 
Coronado
owned and operated coal preparation plants.
 
>
 
ROM coal that does
 
not require further processing is
 
delivered directly to the loading
 
points
for sizing and
 
delivery to
 
customers.
 
Coronado has access
 
to two rail-loading
 
points serviced
by
 
the
 
Norfolk
 
Southern
 
Corporation
 
(NS)
 
and
 
two
 
rail-loading
 
points
 
serviced
 
by
 
CSX
Corporation (CSX).
>
 
Price and volume forecasts and the basis for these forecasts.
>
 
Carlson Mining ®
 
was used by MM&A
 
to generate mine plans
 
for underground-
 
and surface-
mineable
 
coal
 
seams.
 
Underground
 
mine
 
plans
 
were
 
sequenced
 
based
 
on
 
productivity
schedules provided
 
by Coronado,
 
which were
 
based on
 
historically achieved
 
productivity
levels.
 
Surface mine plans
 
were generated under productivity
 
assumptions (bank cubic
 
yard
per
 
shift)
 
as
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
reviewed
 
by
 
MM&A,
 
again
 
based
 
heavily
 
on
productivity
 
levels
 
achieved
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
All
 
production
 
forecasting
 
ties
 
assumed
production rates
 
to geological
 
models as
 
constructed independently by
 
MM&A’s
 
team of
geologists and mining engineers.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for
 
all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from
 
market
 
observed forward
 
estimates
 
based on
 
global economic
 
supply and
demand
 
analysis
 
which
 
is
 
applied
 
to
 
mine
 
plan
 
sales
 
volumes
 
and
 
product
 
mix
 
and
 
is
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
16
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
supplemented
 
with
 
Coronado’s
 
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
 
charges.
 
Coal
 
price
 
forecasts
 
for
 
the
 
various
products were
 
provided by
 
Coronado for
 
various coal
 
markets in
 
terms of
 
US real
 
dollars
per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a
 
2% inflation factor
 
in order
 
to estimate
 
the prices in
nominal dollars.
Economic
 
>
 
The inputs to the economic analysis to produce the net present value (NPV) in the
study, the source and confidence of these economic inputs including estimated
inflation, discount rate, etc.
>
 
On an unlevered basis, the NPV of the project cash flows after
 
taxes was estimated for
 
the
purpose of
 
classifying coal
 
reserves.
 
The project
 
cash flows,
 
excluding
 
debt service,
 
are
calculated by
 
subtracting direct
 
and indirect
 
operating expenses
 
and capital
 
expenditures
from
 
revenue.
 
Direct
 
costs
 
include
 
labor,
 
drilling
 
and
 
blasting,
 
operating
 
supplies,
maintenance and
 
repairs,
 
facilities costs
 
for
 
materials
 
handling, coal
 
preparation,
 
refuse
disposal,
 
coal
 
loading,
 
sampling
 
and
 
analysis
 
services,
 
reclamation
 
and
 
general
 
and
administrative costs.
 
Indirect costs include statutory
 
and legally agreed upon
 
fees related
to direct extraction of the
 
mineral.
 
The indirect costs are the
 
Federal black lung tax, Federal
and State reclamation taxes, property
 
taxes, local transportation prior to
 
delivery at rail or
barge loading sites, coal
 
production royalties, sales
 
and use taxes,
 
income taxes and
 
State
severance taxes.
 
Coronado’s historical
 
costs provided a
 
useful reference
 
for MM&A’s
 
cost
estimates.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for
 
all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is
derived from
 
market
 
observed forward
 
estimates
 
based on
 
global economic
 
supply and
demand
 
analysis
 
which
 
is
 
applied
 
to
 
mine
 
plan
 
sales
 
volumes
 
and
 
product
 
mix
 
and
 
is
supplemented
 
with
 
Coronado’s
 
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
 
charges.
 
Coal
 
price
 
forecasts
 
for
 
the
 
various
products were
 
provided by
 
Coronado for
 
various coal
 
markets in
 
terms of
 
US real
 
dollars
per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a
 
2% inflation factor
 
in order
 
to estimate
 
the prices in
nominal dollars.
>
 
All costs and prices are based on year-end 2023 nominal United States dollars.
>
 
A pre-feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for active and proposed mines.
 
MM&A
prepared
 
mine
 
projections
 
and
 
production
 
timing
 
forecasts
 
based
 
on
 
coal
 
seam
characteristics.
 
Production timing was carried
 
out from 2024
 
to depletion (exhaustion) of
the coal reserve areas, which is projected for the year 2101.
>
 
The all-mines average cash cost ranges between approximately $73 and $338 per
 
tonne for
most of the operating period.
>
 
NPV ranges and sensitivity to variations in the significant assumptions and inputs.
>
 
An estimate of NPV at a base discount rate of 10.0% was included in Section 19 of the TRS.
>
 
NPV of the Buchanan, Russell, Mon Valley, Logan and Greenbrier Properties was estimated
to
 
be
 
$1.804 billion,
 
$155.1 million,
 
$563.4 million,
 
$616.8 million
 
and
 
$62.7 million,
respectively.
 
The
 
Greenbrier
 
NPV
 
is
 
based
 
on
 
December 31,
 
2022
 
coal
 
sales
 
price
information provided by Coronado as described previously.
>
 
The sensitivity study
 
shows the NPV at
 
the 10.0% discount rate when
 
Base Case sales prices,
operating costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased
 
in increments of 5% within a
+/- 15% range.
 
Social
 
>
 
The status of agreements with key stakeholders and matters leading to social license
to operate.
>
 
Portions of the properties are located near local communities.
 
Regulations prohibit mining
activities within
 
91
 
meters
 
of
 
a
 
residential
 
dwelling,
 
school,
 
church,
 
or
 
similar structure
unless written consent is first
 
obtained from the owner of
 
the structure.
 
Where required,
such consents have been obtained where mining is proposed beyond the regulatory limits.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
17
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Other
 
To the extent relevant, the impact of the following on the project and/or on the
estimation and classification of the Ore Reserves:
>
 
Any identified material naturally occurring risks.
>
 
No material naturally occurring risks have been identified.
>
 
The status of material legal agreements and marketing arrangements.
>
 
The
 
Coronado
 
coal
 
resources
 
are
 
located
 
in
 
Buchanan,
 
Russell
 
and
 
Tazewell
 
Counties,
Virginia;
 
Greenbrier,
 
Logan,
 
Boone,
 
Wyoming
 
and
 
Greenbrier
 
Counties,
 
West
 
Virginia;
Allegheny, Washington and Westmoreland Counties, Pennsylvania.
>
 
MM&A has
 
not carried
 
out separate
 
title verification
 
for the
 
coal properties
 
and has
 
not
verified
 
leases,
 
deeds,
 
surveys
 
or
 
other
 
property
 
control
 
instruments
 
pertinent
 
to
 
the
subject resources.
>
 
Coronado has
 
represented to
 
MM&A that
 
it controls
 
the mining
 
rights to
 
the reserves as
shown on its property
 
maps, and MM&A has
 
accepted these as being a
 
true and accurate
depiction of the
 
mineral rights controlled by Coronado.
 
The TRS assumes the
 
properties are
developed under responsible and experienced management.
>
 
The status of government agreements and approvals critical to the viability of the
project, such as mineral tenement status and government and statutory approvals.
There must be reasonable grounds to expect that all necessary Government
approvals will be received within the timeframes anticipated in the Pre-Feasibility or
Feasibility study. Highlight and discuss the materiality of any unresolved matter that
is dependent on a third part on which extraction of the reserve is contingent.
>
 
Coronado has obtained all mining
 
and discharge permits to operate 19 underground
 
mines,
15 surface mines, and 16 processing,
 
loadout or related facilities.
 
MM&A is unaware of any
obvious or current Coronado permitting issues
 
that are expected to prevent the issuance
 
of
future
 
permits.
 
Coronado,
 
along
 
with
 
all
 
Central
 
and
 
Northern
 
Appalachian
 
basin
 
coal
producers, is subject to
 
a level of uncertainty
 
regarding future clean water
 
permits due to
United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
 
involvement with state programs.
Classification
 
>
 
The basis for the classification of the Ore Reserves into varying confidence
categories. Whether the result appropriately reflects the Competent Person’s view
of the deposit. The proportion of Probable Ore Reserves that have been derived
from Measured Mineral Resources (if any).
>
 
Measured and indicated resources have
 
been converted to proved
 
and probable reserves,
respectively.
>
 
None of the probable coal reserves have been derived from measured resources.
>
 
In
 
a
 
limited
 
number
 
of
 
cases
 
where
 
there
 
was
 
only
 
very
 
limited
 
data
 
available
 
to
demonstrate the metallurgical suitability of a given coal deposit, that deposit was classified
as a probable reserve instead of a proved reserve.
>
 
The results of this TRS define an estimated
 
total initial ROM recoverable ore
 
(coal) reserve
estimate of 548 million tonnes for Coronado as follows:
a)
 
Buchanan =
 
154 Mt
b)
 
Logan
 
=
 
135 Mt
c)
 
Greenbrier=
 
12 Mt
d)
 
Russell
 
=
 
50 Mt
e)
 
Mon Valley =
 
197 Mt
 
>
 
Coronado controls a total of 333 Mt (moist basis) of
 
marketable coal reserves for Coronado
as of December 31, 2023 (total may not add
 
due to rounding).
 
Of that total, 74 percent are
proved, and 26 percent are probable.
 
Total reserves by complex are as follows:
a)
 
Buchanan
 
=
 
92 Mt
b)
 
Logan
 
=
 
71 Mt
c)
 
Greenbrier =
 
7 Mt
d)
 
Russell
 
=
 
30 Mt
e)
 
Mon Valley =
 
134 Mt
 
Audits or reviews
 
>
 
The results of any audits or reviews of Ore Reserve estimates.
>
 
MM&A completed prepared a statement
 
of coal resources and reserves for the
 
Properties
in accordance
 
with the
 
JORC Code
 
as
 
of December 31,
 
2017.
 
MM&A also
 
subsequently
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
18
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
updated the
 
estimate of
 
resources and
 
reserves for
 
depletion as
 
of December 31,
 
2018,
December 31, 2019, December 31, 2020,
 
December 31, 2021,
 
and December 31, 2022.
>
 
MM&A performed a previous
 
audit of the
 
Properties in year
 
2017 for Coronado
 
based on
U.S. Securities and Exchange
 
Commission (SEC) Industry Guide
 
7 standards.
 
Earlier audits
were performed by various independent consultants
 
for predecessors-in-title to Coronado
and at various levels
 
of detail depending
 
on the clients concerns
 
and the allotted
 
time for
completion.
 
Previous
 
audits
 
and
 
reviews
 
defined
 
the
 
primary
 
coal
 
resource
 
areas
 
and
estimated the recoverable tonnes for each seam based on the expected mining methods.
>
 
Additionally,
 
MM&A
 
has
 
performed
 
proprietary
 
evaluations
 
for
 
predecessors-in-title
 
to
Coronado, which encompass portions of the Properties included in this TRS.
Discussion of relative
accuracy/ confidence
 
>
 
Where appropriate a statement of the relative accuracy and confidence level in the
Ore Reserve estimate using an approach or procedure deemed appropriate by the
Competent Person. For example, the application of statistical or geostatistical
procedures to quantify the relative accuracy of the reserve within stated confidence
limits, or, if such an approach is not deemed appropriate, a qualitative discussion of
the factors which could affect the relative accuracy and confidence of the estimate.
>
 
Operations on
 
the Properties
 
by Coronado
 
and its
 
predecessors
 
have
 
been on-going
 
for
many years.
 
>
 
MM&A is confident that the mine
 
plans and financial models
 
are reasonably representative
to provide an accurate estimation of coal reserves.
>
 
Mine development and operation have not been optimized within the TRS.
>
 
The statement should specify whether it relates to global or local estimates, and, if
local, state the relevant tonnages, which should be relevant to technical and
economic evaluation. Documentation should include assumptions made and the
procedures used.
>
 
Proved
 
and
 
probable
 
coal
 
reserve
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
in-situ
 
coal
 
resource
considering
 
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
independent
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
revenue and cost), marketing, legal, environmental,
 
socioeconomic, and regulatory factors
on a global scale as current local data reflects the global assumptions.
>
 
Accuracy and confidence discussions should extend to specific discussions of any
applied Modifying Factors that may have a material impact on Ore Reserve viability,
or for which there are remaining areas of uncertainty at the current study stage.
The
 
major
 
risk
 
factors
 
for
 
the
 
active
 
Coronado
 
mines
 
and
 
future
 
resource
 
development
 
are
summarized below:
>
 
Mine Accidents
>
 
Highwall
 
Failure.
 
Highwall
 
failures
 
are
 
likely
 
to
 
result
 
in
 
a
 
temporary
 
mine
 
closure
 
and
should not have a material
 
impact on the mine sustainability.
 
The risk is considered to
 
be
probable.
 
>
 
Adverse Geological
 
Conditions.
 
Adverse geological
 
conditions include
 
such conditions
 
as
faults
 
and
 
sandstone
 
washouts.
 
The
 
risk
 
is
 
considered
 
to
 
be
 
probable.
 
The
 
impact
 
is
expected to be temporary with little material impact on mine sustainability.
>
 
Environmental Risk.
 
Numerous federal and
 
state permits are
 
required to operate coal
 
mines
and mine surface facilities. Permitting rules
 
are complex and may change over
 
time, making
compliance difficult or impossible.
>
 
Water
 
Quality.
 
Permit requirements
 
to fulfill
 
Clean Water
 
Act obligations
 
are subject
 
to
modification.
 
The probability of
 
water quality
 
changes having
 
a material
 
impact on mine
operations
 
is
 
possible.
 
As
 
a
 
contemporary
 
example,
 
the
 
selenium
 
discharge
 
issue
 
that
affects
 
western
 
Canadian
 
and
 
Central
 
Appalachian
 
Basin
 
operators
 
has
 
only
 
recently
emerged as a concern and its ultimate impact has not been determined.
>
 
New Permits.
 
Permit protests
 
by environmental
 
groups and individuals
 
can contribute to
permit delays or denial
 
and increase the cost
 
of permitting and delay
 
development.
 
Surface
mining
 
activities, coal
 
refuse
 
disposal
 
and
 
construction
 
of
 
access
 
roads
 
in
 
mountainous
terrain often require storage
 
of material in valley
 
fills.
 
Authority to dispose of fill
 
material
into
 
waters
 
of
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
must
 
be
 
granted
 
by
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
Army
 
Corps
 
of
Engineers (COE).
 
COE permits are increasingly difficult to obtain.
 
 
ex963p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2023
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix E:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
19
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
Regulatory
 
Requirements.
 
Adverse
 
impact
 
from
 
regulatory changes
 
is considered
 
to
 
be
probable.
 
The impact will likely affect the broader industry and is not expected to result in
mine closure.
>
 
Market Risk.
 
Metallurgical and
 
thermal coal
 
markets ultimately
 
depend upon
 
the global
steel and
 
thermal coal
 
demand and
 
are considered
 
to be
 
volatile.
 
Currently,
 
the US
 
coal
market has
 
seen a decline in
 
demand for thermal
 
coal due to
 
thermal plant closures,
 
as a
result of new air and water pollution regulations, and competition
 
from other commodities
used for
 
power generation
 
such as
 
natural gas.
 
This has
 
resulted in
 
an overall
 
decline in
CAPP coal production.
 
Continued regulatory changes and declining demand could result in
material changes in domestic and
 
global coal markets.
 
The impact cannot be predicted
 
at
this
 
time;
 
however,
 
while
 
MM&A
 
expects
 
the
 
coal
 
reserve
 
within
 
this
 
TRS
 
to
 
remain
economically viable throughout the life of the projected mines, the LOM
 
financial model is
very sensitive to changes in coal sales price and therefore market risk is not insignificant.
>
 
Labor Risk.
 
Work stoppage due to organized labor protests is considered to be unlikely and
not likely to lead to permanent mine
 
closure.
 
The mines are likely to suffer
 
the loss of key
supervisors and skilled employees
 
due to retirement as the workforce ages.
 
The problem is
industry-wide and the
 
impact is expected to be
 
temporary and have no sustained impact
 
on
coal production.
>
 
Availability of Equipment and Supplies.
 
Risk of equipment and supply availability
 
is likely to
be temporary and should not have a sustained adverse impact on the production of coal.
>
 
Transportation Delay.
 
Interruption of coal transport services
 
by river or rail is considered
 
to
be probable but unlikely to have a sustained impact on coal production.
>
 
It is recognised that this may not be possible or appropriate in all circumstances.
These statements of relative accuracy and confidence of the estimate should be
compared with production data, where available.
>
 
Mine
 
plans,
 
productivity
 
expectations
 
and
 
cost
 
estimates
 
generally
 
reflect
 
historical
performance
 
and
 
efforts
 
have
 
been
 
made
 
to
 
adjust
 
plans
 
and
 
costs
 
to
 
reflect
 
future
conditions.
ex964p1i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
 
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
 
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
 
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania,
 
USA
February 2024
Prepared for:
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
100 Bill Baker Way
Beckley, West
 
Virginia 25801
Prepared by:
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
582 Industrial Park Road
Bluefield, Virginia
 
24605
www.mma1.com
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
Statement of Use and Preparation
This Technical
 
Report Summary (TRS) was prepared by
Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc. (MM&A)
for
 
the
 
sole
 
use
 
of
Coronado
 
Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
(Coronado)
 
and
 
its
 
affiliated
 
and
 
subsidiary
companies and advisors.
 
Copies or
 
references to information in this
 
report may not
 
be used
 
without
the written permission of Coronado.
This report provides a
 
statement of coal resources and
 
coal reserves for Coronado, as
 
defined under
the
Australasian Code
 
for Reporting
 
of Exploration Results,
 
Mineral Resources
 
and Ore Reserves
(JORC Code)
 
as well as under Subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K (Regulation S-K 1300) promulgated by
the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
 
Subject to the comments below,
 
this
report
 
was
 
also
 
prepared
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
the
Australasian
 
Code
 
for
 
Public
 
Reporting
 
of
Technical
 
Assessments and Valuations of Mineral Assets (VALMIN
 
Code).
 
The statement is based on
 
information provided by Coronado and reviewed by
 
Qualified Persons
(QPs) who are full-time employees of MM&A.
As noted above, this report is a “Public Report” for the purposes of the VALMIN Code.
 
However,
 
in
accordance with paragraph 12.1 of the VALMIN Code, it is noted that this report is not a “Valuation
of
 
Mineral
 
Assets
”,
and
 
it
 
also
 
does
 
not
 
comply
 
with
 
the
 
following
 
requirements
 
that
 
apply
 
to
“Technical Assessments” (as defined in the VALMIN
 
Code):
This report does
 
not include a determination
 
of the status
 
of tenure (as
 
required by paragraph
 
7.2
of the VALMIN Code)
 
on the
 
basis that tenure
 
was separately reviewed by
 
Coronado’s legal advisors.
This
 
report
 
does
 
not
 
include
 
separate
 
commentary
 
on
 
the
 
reasonableness
 
and
 
quality
 
of
 
the
Resources and Reserves estimates
 
and the basis on which they have been reported (as required
 
by
paragraph
 
7.3
 
of
 
the
 
VALMIN
 
Code).
 
MM&A
 
did
 
not
 
consider
 
that
 
this
 
was
 
appropriate
 
in
circumstances
 
where MM&A
 
was engaged
 
for
 
the specific
 
purpose of
 
preparing
 
those estimates.
 
However,
 
MM&A
 
notes
 
that,
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
its
 
usual
 
practice,
 
a
 
separate
 
team
 
of
 
MM&A
employees undertook a peer review of this report and confirmed that both
 
the process followed by
the
 
authors
 
of
 
this
 
report
 
and
 
the
 
estimates
 
prepared
 
were
 
reasonable
 
and
 
comply
 
with
 
the
requirements of the JORC Code.
 
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
The information in this TRS
 
related to coal resources and reserves is
 
based on, and fairly
 
represents,
information compiled by the QPs.
 
At the time of
 
reporting, MM&A’s QPs have sufficient experience
relevant
 
to the
 
style of
 
mineralization
 
and type
 
of deposit
 
under consideration
 
and to
 
the activity
they are undertaking to qualify as a QP as defined by Regulation S-K 1300 and the JORC Code.
 
Each
QP consents
 
to the
 
inclusion in
 
this report
 
of the
 
matters
 
based on
 
their information
 
in the
 
form
and context in which it appears.
Marshall
 
Miller
 
&
 
Associates,
 
Inc.
 
(MM&A)
 
hereby
 
consents
 
to
 
the
 
use
 
of
 
the
 
information
contained in this report
 
dated December 31, 2023, relating
 
to estimates of
 
coal resources and coal
reserves controlled by Coronado.
Qualified Person:
/s/ Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc.
Date:
February 16, 2024
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
i
Table
 
of Contents
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
ii
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
iii
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
iv
Figures (in Report)
Tables
 
(in Report)
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
v
Appendices
A...............................................................................................................................MM&A
Qualifications
B.........................................................................................................................................................M
aps
C.....................................................................................................................................Glossary
 
of
Terms
D.............................................................................................................................................JORC
Table 1
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
1
 
Executive Summary
1.1
 
Property Description
Coronado Global Resources
 
Inc. (Coronado)
 
authorized
Marshall Miller &
 
Associates, Inc. (MM&A)
to prepare this Technical Report Summary (TRS) of its
 
controlled coal resources and reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex in southwestern
 
Pennsylvania (Mon Valley
 
or the Property).
 
This TRS updates
the TRS titled,
 
“Coronado Global Resources
 
Inc. Statement
 
of Coal Resources
 
and Reserves for
 
the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings in Accordance with the JORC Code and United States
SEC Regulation
 
S-K 1300
 
as of
 
December 31, 2022
 
Northern Appalachian
 
Coal Basin
 
Pennsylvania,
USA
 
February
 
2023”
 
dated
 
February 15,
 
2023,
 
due
 
to
 
material
 
differences
 
in
 
the
 
key
 
financial
modifying
 
factors
 
including
 
coal
 
sales
 
price
 
assumptions,
 
operating
 
costs
 
and
 
capital
 
costs
 
from
December 31, 2022 to
 
December 31, 2023.
 
Coal sales price assumptions
 
are discussed in
 
Sections
12 and 16 of the TRS, while operating costs and capital
 
costs are discussed in Sections 18 and 19 of
the
 
TRS.
 
The
 
report
 
provides
 
a
 
statement
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
coal
 
reserves
 
for
 
Coronado,
 
as
defined under
the Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration
 
Results, Mineral Resources and
Ore Reserves
 
(JORC Code)
 
as well
 
as under
 
Subpart 1300
 
of Regulation
 
S-K (Regulation
 
S-K 1300)
promulgated by the
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
 
(SEC).
 
This report was also
prepared in accordance with the
Australasian Code for Public Reporting of Technical
 
Assessments
and Valuations of Mineral Assets (VALMIN
 
Code).
The Mon
 
Valley
 
property is
 
comprised of
 
three separate
 
reserve holdings,
 
namely,
 
the Pangburn,
Shaner
 
and
 
Fallowfield
 
proposed
 
underground
 
mines
 
in
 
the
 
Upper
 
Freeport
 
seam.
 
All
 
three
respective
 
reserve
 
areas
 
are
 
greenfield
 
sites
 
and
 
are
 
undeveloped.
 
The
 
three
 
mines
 
have
 
been
projected
 
to
 
operate
 
independently,
 
with
 
production
 
initially
 
beginning
 
at
 
Pangburn.
 
Shaner
 
is
projected
 
to
 
come
 
online
 
as
 
replacement
 
production
 
for
 
Pangburn,
 
and
 
Fallowfield
 
represents
expanded Mon Valley
 
production after Pangburn
 
is in full production.
 
In addition to the individual
mine/plant sites,
 
a barge
 
loading dock on
 
the Monongahela
 
River adjacent to
 
the Pangburn
 
site is
proposed and will
 
be used to
 
ship clean coal
 
for all three
 
mines.
 
Each mine site
 
will include a
 
coal
preparation plant and all necessary surface facilities.
Coal
 
resources
 
and
 
coal
 
reserves
 
are
 
herein
 
reported
 
in
 
metric
 
units
 
of
 
measurement
 
and
 
are
rounded to millions of metric tonnes (Mt).
 
The Mon
 
Valley
 
properties are
 
located approximately
 
16 kilometers
 
to 32
 
kilometers southeast
 
of
Pittsburgh,
 
Pennsylvania
 
(see
Figure 1-1
).
 
The property
 
is composed
 
of 41,615
 
total
 
hectares,
 
of
which 1,339 are leased from private landholders under two leases, and 40,276 hectares
 
are owned
by
 
Coronado.
 
Subject to
 
Coronado’s
 
exercising
 
its
 
renewal
 
rights thereunder,
 
both
 
of the
 
leases
expire
 
upon exhaustion of the relevant coal reserves, which is expected
 
to occur in 2101.
 
 
ex964p2i0 ex964p10i1
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
Figure 1-1:
 
Mon Valley Complex Property Location Map
1.2
 
Ownership
Mineral rights for the Property were formerly controlled by Consolidation Coal
 
Company (CONSOL).
 
Coronado acquired the Mon Valley
 
properties from CONSOL in March 2016.
1.3
 
Geology
There are currently no active operations in
 
the Mon Valley complex.
 
Strata of economic interest for
this TRS are of the Pennsylvanian-age Allegheny Formation, and the subject
 
Upper Freeport seam is
the
 
principal
 
coal
 
seam
 
of
 
interest
 
for
 
Coronado.
 
The
 
Upper
 
Freeport
 
seam
 
has
 
been
 
mined
extensively in the region.
 
The seam is situated below drainage throughout the Property and will be
accessed by constructed mine shafts and slopes.
1.4
 
Exploration Status
The
 
Property
 
has
 
been
 
explored
 
extensively,
 
largely
 
by
 
drilling
 
using
 
continuous
 
coring
 
method,
rotary
 
drilling, and
 
by downhole
 
geophysical
 
methods.
 
The majority
 
of the
 
data
 
was
 
acquired
 
or
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
generated
 
by previous
 
owners of
 
the Property.
 
These sources
 
comprise the
 
primary data
 
used in
the evaluation of the coal resources
 
and coal reserves on the Property.
 
MM&A examined the data
available
 
for the
 
evaluation
 
and incorporated
 
all pertinent
 
information
 
into this
 
TRS.
 
Where data
appeared
 
to be
 
anomalous or
 
not representative,
 
that information
 
was excluded
 
from the
 
digital
databases and subsequent processing by MM&A.
 
Ongoing exploration has been carried out by Coronado since acquiring the Mon Valley
 
properties.
 
1.5
 
Operations and Development
Coronado
 
currently has
 
no active
 
operations
 
in the
 
Mon Valley
 
complex.
 
The mines
 
will produce
coal that is suitable for the high-volatile metallurgical
 
coal markets.
The
 
preliminary
 
design
 
for
 
the
 
Pangburn
 
mine
 
surface
 
facilities
 
was
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
The
facilities
 
include
 
offices,
 
warehouses,
 
shops,
 
a
 
bathhouse
 
for
 
personnel,
 
a
 
preparation
 
plant
 
to
process run-of-mine (ROM) coal, a refuse area with a designed capacity of
 
approximately 35 million
refuse
 
tonnes,
 
raw
 
coal
 
storage
 
at
 
the
 
plant
 
totaling
 
approximately
 
100,000
 
tonnes,
 
clean
 
coal
storage
 
at the
 
plant site
 
of approximately
 
54,000 tonnes,
 
and three
 
clean coal
 
stockpiles adjacent
to the
 
dock loading facility
 
on the Monongahela
 
River.
 
The three
 
river stockpiles
 
have a
 
designed
capacity of
 
approximately
 
266,000 tonnes.
 
Processes are
 
expected
 
to be
 
typical of
 
those used
 
at
operating
 
coal-processing plants
 
and the
 
coal industry
 
in general.
 
The river
 
dock is
 
anticipated
 
to
also
 
support
 
production
 
from
 
the
 
planned
 
Fallowfield
 
and
 
Shaner
 
operations.
 
Room-and-pillar
mining will be employed at these properties.
1.6
 
Mineral Resource
Mineral
 
resources,
 
representing
 
in-situ
 
coal
 
from
 
a
 
portion
 
of
 
which
 
reserves
 
are
 
derived,
 
are
presented
 
below.
 
A
 
coal
 
resource
 
estimate,
 
summarized
 
in
 
Table
 
1-1,
 
was
 
prepared
 
as
 
of
December 31, 2023, for property controlled by Coronado.
Table 1-1:
 
Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2023
 
Coal Resource (Dry Tonnes, In Situ, Mt)
Resource Quality (Dry)
Area
Measured
Indicated
Inferred
Total
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Inclusive of Reserves
291.0
213.5
9.3
513.8
31
1.4
26
Exclusive of Reserve
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Total 12/31/2023
291.0
213.5
9.3
513.8
Note:
 
Resource tonnes are inclusive of reserve tonnes since they include the in-situ tonnes from which recoverable coal reserves are derived.
Note 2:
 
Coal resources are reported on a dry basis.
 
Surface moisture and inherent moisture are excluded.
Note 3: The Mon Valley properties do not have any resource tonnes exclusive of reserves as of December 31, 2023.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
4
1.7
 
Mineral Reserve
Reserve tonnage
 
estimates provided
 
herein report
 
coal reserves
 
derived from
 
the in-situ resource
tonnes
 
presented
 
in
 
Table
 
1-1,
 
and
 
not
 
in
 
addition
 
to
 
coal
 
resources.
 
Proven
 
and
 
probable
 
coal
reserves
 
were
 
derived
 
from
 
the
 
defined
 
coal
 
resource
 
considering
 
relevant
 
mining,
 
processing,
infrastructure,
 
economic
 
(including
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue,
 
and
 
cost),
 
marketing,
 
legal,
environmental, socioeconomic and regulatory factors.
 
The Resource estimate has been used as
 
the
basis for this Reserve calculation, which utilizes
 
a reasonable Preliminary Feasibility Study,
 
a Life-of
Mine (LOM) Mine Plan and practical recovery factors.
 
Production modeling was completed with an
effective start date
 
of May 1, 2033.
 
Factors
 
that
 
would
 
typically
 
preclude
 
conversion
 
of
 
a
 
coal
 
resource
 
to
 
coal
 
reserve
 
include
 
the
following:
 
inferred
 
resource
 
classification;
 
absence
 
of
 
coal
 
quality;
 
poor
 
mine
 
recovery;
 
lack
 
of
access; geological
 
encumbrances
 
associated
 
with
 
overlying
 
and underlying
 
strata;
 
seam thinning;
structural
 
complication;
 
and
 
insufficient
 
exploration
 
have
 
all
 
been
 
considered.
 
Reserve
consideration
 
excludes
 
those
 
portions
 
of
 
the
 
resource
 
area
 
which
 
exhibit
 
the
 
aforementioned
geological and operational encumbrances.
 
Table 1-2:
 
Coal Summary (ROM Basis (Moist)) as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Mt, Moist ROM)
Quality (Dry)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area / Mine
Proved
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Ash
Sulfur
Vol
Mon Valley
113.9
83.2
197.1
0.0
197.1
195.7
1.4
37
1.4
23
Coal reserves are presented
 
on a ROM basis in
 
Table
 
1-2.
 
Proven and probable
 
coal reserves were
derived from the defined in-situ coal resource considering relevant processing, economic (including
technical estimates of capital,
 
revenue, and cost), marketing, legal,
 
environmental, socioeconomic,
and
 
regulatory
 
factors.
 
The
 
proven
 
and
 
probable
 
coal
 
reserves
 
on the
 
Property
 
are
 
summarized
below in Table 1-3.
Table 1-3:
 
Coal Reserves Summary (Marketable Sales Basis) as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
 
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet Ton
 
nes, Washed or Direct Shipped, Mt)
Quality (Dry Basis)
 
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Property
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Mon Valley
77.8
56.6
134.4
0.0
134.4
133.4
1.0
8
1.4
35
Note: Marketable
 
reserve tonnes
 
are reported
 
on a
 
moist basis,
 
including a
 
combination of
 
surface and
 
inherent moisture.
 
The combination
 
of
surface and inherent moisture
 
is modeled at 6-percent.
 
Actual product moisture is
 
dependent upon multiple geological factors,
 
operational
factors, and product contract specifications and can exceed 8-percent.
 
As such, the modeled moisture values provide a level of conservatism
for reserve reporting.
 
Life-of-mine sulfur for Pangburn is an estimated 1.21%; however, overall Mon Valley
 
Complex reserve average is 1.36%
sulfur.
In summary, Coronado controls a total of 134.4
 
Mt (moist basis) of
 
marketable coal reserves at Mon
Valley,
 
as of December 31, 2023.
 
Of that total, 58 percent are
 
proven, and 42 percent are probable.
 
There are 133.4 Mt
 
of owned coal reserves
 
and 1.0 Mt
 
of leased coal reserves.
 
All of the
 
Mon Valley
reserves are
 
considered suitable
 
for the
 
metallurgical coal
 
market.
 
All of the
 
Mon Valley
 
reserves
are unassigned.
 
 
ex964p2i0 ex964p13i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
5
1.8
 
Capital Summary
The
 
MM&A
 
financial
 
model
 
includes
 
provisions
 
for
 
operating
 
equipment
 
at
 
the
 
proposed
 
Mon
Valley operations.
 
MM&A’s capital schedules assume that major
 
equipment rebuilds occur
 
over the
course
 
of
 
each
 
machine’s
 
remaining
 
assumed
 
operating
 
life.
 
Replacement
 
equipment
 
was
scheduled
 
based
 
on
 
MM&A’s
 
experience
 
and
 
knowledge
 
of
 
mining
 
equipment
 
and
 
industry
standards with respect to the useful life of
 
such equipment.
 
A summary of
 
the estimated capital for
the Property is provided in
Figure 1-2 below
.
Figure 1-2:
 
CAPEX
1.9
 
Operating Costs
MM&A used the Coronado historical and/or budget cost information
 
for comparable operations as
a reference
 
and developed
 
personnel
 
schedules for
 
the mine
 
and support
 
facilities.
 
Hourly labor
rates
 
and
 
salaries
 
were
 
based
 
upon
 
information
 
contained
 
in
 
Coronado’s
 
financial
 
summaries.
 
Fringe
 
benefit
 
costs
 
were
 
developed
 
for
 
vacation
 
and
 
holidays,
 
federal
 
and
 
state
 
unemployment
insurance,
 
retirement,
 
workers’
 
compensation
 
and
 
pneumoconiosis,
 
casualty
 
and
 
life
 
insurance,
healthcare, and bonuses.
 
A cost factor
 
for mine supplies
 
was developed that
 
relates expenditures
to
 
mine advance
 
rates
 
for
 
roof
 
control
 
costs
 
and other
 
mine supply
 
costs
 
at underground
 
mines.
 
Other
 
factors
 
were
 
developed
 
for
 
maintenance
 
and
 
repair
 
costs,
 
rentals,
 
mine
 
power,
 
outside
services and other direct mining costs.
 
Operating-cost
 
factors
 
were
 
also
 
developed
 
for
 
the
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plant
 
processing,
 
refuse
handling, coal loading, property taxes,
 
and insurance and bonding.
 
Appropriate royalty
 
rates were
assigned for production from leased coal lands and sales taxes were calculated for the federal black
lung excise tax, and federal
 
reclamation fees.
A summary of the projected operating costs for the Property
 
is provided in
Figure 1-3
.
 
 
ex964p2i0 ex964p14i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
6
Figure 1-3:
 
OPEX
1.10
 
Economic Evaluation
The pre-feasibility financial
 
model prepared for
 
this TRS
 
was developed to
 
test the
 
economic viability
of
 
each
 
coal
 
resource
 
area.
 
The
 
results
 
of
 
this
 
financial
 
model
 
are
 
not
 
intended
 
to
 
represent
 
a
bankable
 
feasibility
 
study,
 
required
 
for
 
financing
 
of
 
any
 
current
 
or
 
future
 
mining
 
operations
contemplated
 
for the Coronado
 
properties, but are
 
intended to establish
 
the economic viability
 
of
the estimated coal reserves.
 
Cash flows are simulated on an annual basis in
 
year-end 2023 nominal
dollars
 
assuming
 
a
 
2%
 
inflation
 
rate
 
based
 
on
 
projected
 
production
 
from
 
the
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
The
discounted cash flow analysis presented herein
 
is based on an effective date of January 1, 2024.
 
On an un-levered basis, the net
 
present value (NPV) of the project
 
cash flow after taxes
 
represents
the Enterprise
 
Value of
 
the project.
 
The project cash
 
flow,
 
excluding debt
 
service, is calculated
 
by
subtracting direct
 
and indirect
 
operating expenses
 
and capital
 
expenditures from
 
revenue.
 
Direct
costs
 
include
 
labor,
 
operating
 
supplies,
 
maintenance
 
and
 
repairs,
 
facilities
 
costs
 
for
 
materials
handling,
 
coal
 
preparation,
 
refuse
 
disposal,
 
coal
 
loading,
 
reclamation
 
and
 
general
 
and
administrative costs.
 
Indirect costs include statutory and legally agreed
 
upon fees related to direct
extraction
 
of
 
the
 
mineral.
 
The
 
indirect
 
costs
 
are
 
the
 
Federal
 
black
 
lung
 
tax,
 
Federal
 
reclamation
taxes, property taxes,
 
coal production royalties, and income taxes.
Table
 
1-4
 
shows LOM tonnage, profit
 
& loss (P&L), and earnings before income
 
tax, depreciation &
amortization
(EBITDA)
 
for each proposed Coronado mine at Mon Valley
 
.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
7
Table 1-4:
 
Life-of-Mine Tonnage,
 
P&L before Tax,
 
and EBITDA ($000)
LOM
LOM
P&L
LOM
EBITDA
Tonnes*
Pre-Tax P&L
Per Tonne
EBITDA
Per Tonne
Pangburn
 
14,376
 
 
$1,375,780
 
 
$95.70
 
 
$1,987,175
 
 
$138.23
 
Fallowfield
 
72,640
 
 
$18,671,106
 
 
$257.04
 
 
$21,133,469
 
 
$290.93
 
Shaner
 
48,294
 
 
$7,602,034
 
 
$157.41
 
 
$8,739,568
 
 
$180.97
 
Consolidated PA Deep Mines
 
135,309
 
 
$27,648,920
 
 
$204.34
 
 
$31,860,212
 
 
$235.46
 
Note:
 
*Financial model includes 0.9 million tonnes of inferred coal production.
 
Inferred coal represents 0.6% of the total production, and none of
this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
As
 
shown
 
in
Table
 
1-4
,
 
all
 
of
 
the
 
mines
 
analyzed
 
show
 
positive
 
EBITDA
 
over
 
the
 
LOM.
 
Overall,
Coronado’s
 
consolidated operations
 
show positive
 
LOM P&L
 
and LOM
 
EBITDA of
 
$27.6 billion and
$31.9 billion, respectively.
Coronado’s consolidated
 
Mon Valley cash flow summary in nominal dollars assuming a 2% inflation
rate, excluding debt
 
service, is shown in
Table 1-5
 
below.
Table 1-5:
 
Project Cash Flow Summary (000)*
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
Total
2028
2029
2030
2031
2032
Production & Sales tonnes
135,311
-
-
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$53,543,217
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$22,878,217
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
Net Income
$11,796,769
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$15,418,952
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(328)
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(3,886,154)
$-
$(5,556)
$(32,461)
$(38,382)
$(230,691)
Net Cash Flow
$11,532,798
$(388)
$(5,944)
$(32,849)
$(38,770)
$(231,019)
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2033
2034
2035
2036
2037
2038
Production & Sales tonnes
399
1,810
1,875
1,958
2,029
2,030
Total Revenue
$78,296
$362,106
$382,594
$407,547
$430,792
$439,609
EBITDA
$46,091
$230,681
$245,301
$265,119
$283,202
$289,071
Net Income
$(34,286)
$140,882
$121,310
$131,898
$147,171
$160,015
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$37,454
$188,509
$200,525
$213,069
$227,279
$239,643
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(220,159)
$(5,973)
$(1,492)
$(23,825)
$(21,154)
$(220,098)
Net Cash Flow
$(182,704)
$182,535
$199,033
$189,243
$206,125
$19,544
 
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
8
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2039
2040
2041
2042
2043
2044
Production & Sales tonnes
2,062
1,960
1,762
2,366
1,804
1,724
Total Revenue
$455,388
$441,481
$405,009
$554,640
$431,343
$420,513
EBITDA
$299,233
$282,680
$246,717
$355,857
$259,717
$249,422
Net Income
$148,359
$159,358
$124,218
$201,201
$155,408
$140,412
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$252,685
$239,821
$209,856
$264,281
$200,448
$197,055
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(198,968)
$(17,709)
$(15,403)
$(21,709)
$(9,653)
$(15,904)
Net Cash Flow
$53,717
$222,112
$194,453
$242,571
$190,795
$181,152
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2045
2046
2047
2048
2049
2050
Production & Sales tonnes
1,717
1,641
1,719
1,657
1,582
1,704
Total Revenue
$427,051
$416,456
$444,946
$437,356
$426,059
$468,115
EBITDA
$252,966
$242,678
$263,719
$255,907
$244,963
$276,975
Net Income
$154,860
$163,403
$176,959
$170,156
$161,907
$181,850
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$201,354
$194,705
$200,387
$200,909
$193,250
$210,580
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(105,936)
$(32,944)
$(3,311)
$(5,576)
$(21,182)
$(43,937)
Net Cash Flow
$95,418
$161,760
$197,075
$195,333
$172,067
$166,643
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2051
2052
2053
2054
2055
2056
Production & Sales tonnes
1,656
1,732
1,702
1,596
1,642
1,750
Total Revenue
$463,895
$494,756
$495,913
$474,451
$497,980
$541,261
EBITDA
$271,431
$294,451
$293,461
$274,133
$291,105
$323,591
Net Income
$177,355
$206,754
$205,313
$186,501
$196,906
$224,271
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$214,333
$224,264
$225,466
$215,317
$222,950
$245,045
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(26,060)
$(4,135)
$(20,511)
$(39,988)
$(30,028)
$(36,861)
Net Cash Flow
$188,273
$220,129
$204,955
$175,329
$192,922
$208,184
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2057
2058
2059
2060
2061
2062
Production & Sales tonnes
1,751
2,609
3,582
3,732
3,839
3,762
Total Revenue
$552,393
$839,589
$1,175,652
$1,249,528
$1,310,820
$1,310,433
EBITDA
$330,405
$494,167
$701,904
$754,323
$798,832
$793,460
Net Income
$249,858
$295,564
$442,235
$473,877
$508,672
$492,348
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$270,454
$378,130
$521,997
$586,273
$620,328
$627,936
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(538,808)
$(89,843)
$(36,104)
$(44,278)
$(21,847)
$(132,543)
Net Cash Flow
$(268,354)
$288,286
$485,893
$541,995
$598,481
$495,393
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2063
2064
2065
2066
2067
2068
Production & Sales tonnes
3,494
3,390
3,460
3,398
2,967
2,826
Total Revenue
$1,241,303
$1,228,573
$1,278,870
$1,280,972
$1,141,063
$1,108,535
EBITDA
$732,113
$720,210
$757,835
$754,462
$680,158
$663,742
Net Income
$446,588
$500,822
$521,333
$515,526
$450,699
$434,909
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$595,943
$568,873
$577,763
$583,053
$543,306
$522,205
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(60,459)
$(26,978)
$(66,446)
$(58,982)
$(120,137)
$(56,340)
Net Cash Flow
$535,484
$541,895
$511,317
$524,071
$423,169
$465,865
 
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
9
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2069
2070
2071
2072
2073
2074
Production & Sales tonnes
2,472
2,318
2,178
1,496
2,041
1,993
Total Revenue
$988,943
$946,112
$906,727
$635,345
$883,982
$880,465
EBITDA
$594,651
$554,448
$531,931
$346,940
$538,047
$535,996
Net Income
$384,720
$356,548
$335,438
$231,328
$359,458
$366,134
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$480,465
$443,994
$423,083
$260,436
$368,430
$408,513
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(118,056)
$(37,796)
$(41,704)
$(27,793)
$(47,154)
$(29,787)
Net Cash Flow
$362,409
$406,198
$381,378
$232,643
$321,276
$378,726
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2075
2076
2077
2078
2079
2080
Production & Sales tonnes
1,822
2,098
2,055
2,107
1,883
2,129
Total Revenue
$820,772
$874,560
$874,031
$913,861
$833,007
$960,656
EBITDA
$488,892
$527,243
$524,666
$555,561
$491,518
$587,784
Net Income
$332,175
$373,438
$366,231
$382,757
$335,406
$410,847
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$382,976
$392,261
$399,542
$415,100
$383,380
$424,802
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(3,295)
$(3,360)
$(41,878)
$(73,655)
$(15,800)
$(6,365)
Net Cash Flow
$379,682
$388,901
$357,664
$341,445
$367,580
$418,437
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2081
2082
2083
2084
2085
2086
Production & Sales tonnes
1,937
1,723
2,242
1,568
2,285
1,637
Total Revenue
$891,498
$809,214
$1,073,587
$766,070
$1,138,488
$832,210
EBITDA
$531,568
$460,863
$663,473
$428,042
$708,813
$464,168
Net Income
$368,045
$304,770
$448,699
$277,710
$492,938
$308,597
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$409,096
$358,874
$460,364
$364,186
$480,016
$392,806
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(25,353)
$(73,457)
$(43,005)
$(12,687)
$(19,996)
$(33,624)
Net Cash Flow
$383,743
$285,417
$417,359
$351,499
$460,019
$359,182
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2087
2088
2089
2090
2091
2092
Production & Sales tonnes
1,982
1,477
1,857
1,616
1,993
1,305
Total Revenue
$1,027,701
$781,052
$1,001,339
$888,873
$1,118,529
$747,144
EBITDA
$612,327
$424,413
$581,701
$495,500
$667,329
$373,435
Net Income
$412,609
$267,442
$390,044
$326,813
$454,337
$232,648
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$432,632
$353,475
$408,375
$388,300
$469,549
$335,144
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(41,648)
$(60,042)
$(27,048)
$(31,038)
$(4,523)
$(40,242)
Net Cash Flow
$390,984
$293,433
$381,327
$357,262
$465,027
$294,902
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2093
2094
2095
2096
2097
2098
Production & Sales tonnes
1,637
1,612
1,747
1,355
1,731
1,752
Total Revenue
$955,700
$959,852
$1,060,820
$839,478
$1,093,737
$1,129,433
EBITDA
$536,078
$531,972
$608,559
$412,363
$623,984
$652,244
Net Income
$344,367
$335,321
$398,419
$255,237
$407,178
$415,344
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$374,267
$401,019
$443,538
$347,072
$431,542
$484,871
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(85,557)
$(75,058)
$(4,895)
$(4,993)
$(48,993)
$(79,742)
Net Cash Flow
$288,710
$325,960
$438,643
$342,078
$382,550
$405,129
 
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
10
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2099
2100
2101
2102
2103
2104
Production & Sales tonnes
1,407
896
393
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$925,181
$600,980
$268,578
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$493,808
$312,584
$135,457
$-
$-
$-
Net Income
$335,906
$195,168
$94,312
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$310,205
$239,384
$(26,022)
$-
$-
$-
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(17,075)
$(5,405)
$(2,757)
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$293,130
$233,979
$(28,778)
$-
$-
$-
Financial model includes 0.9 million tonnes of inferred coal production.
 
Inferred coal represents 0.6% of the total production, and none of this
coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
Consolidated cash flows are driven by annual sales
 
tonnage, which grows from 0.4 million tonnes in
2033
 
to
 
a
 
peak
 
of
 
3.8 million
 
tonnes
 
in
 
2061.
 
Between
 
years
 
2062
 
and
 
2091,
 
sales
 
range
 
from
1.5 million to 2.7 million tonnes and between years 2092-2101, sales range from 0.4 million tonnes
to 1.3 million
 
tonnes.
 
Projected consolidated
 
revenue grows
 
from $78.3 million
 
in 2033 to
 
a peak
of $1.3 billion in 2061.
 
Revenue totals $53.5 billion for the project’s
 
life.
Consolidated cash flow from operations is positive throughout the projected operating period, with
the
 
exception
 
of post
 
-production
 
years,
 
due to
 
end-of-mine
 
reclamation
 
spending.
 
Consolidated
cash flow from operations peaks at $627.9 million in 2062
 
and totals $15.4 billion over the project’s
life.
 
Capital
 
expenditures
 
total
 
$527.3 million during
 
the
 
first
 
five
 
years
 
and
 
$3.9 billion over
 
the
project’s life.
 
1.10.1
 
Discounted Cash Flow Analysis
Cash flow after
 
tax, but before
 
debt service, generated
 
over the life
 
of the project
 
was discounted
to NPV
 
at a 10.0%
 
discount rate,
 
which represents
 
Coronado’s
 
estimate of
 
the nominal dollar,
 
risk
adjusted
 
weighted
 
average
 
cost
 
of
 
capital
 
(WACC)
 
for
 
likely
 
market
 
participants
 
if
 
the
 
subject
reserves were offered for sale.
 
On an un-levered basis,
 
the NPV of
 
the project cash
 
flows represents
the
 
Enterprise
 
Value
 
of
 
the
 
project
 
and
 
amounts
 
to
 
$563.4 million.
 
The
 
pre-feasibility
 
financial
model prepared for the
 
TRS was developed to
 
test the economic
 
viability of
 
each coal resource area.
 
The
 
NPV
 
estimate
 
was
 
made
 
for
 
purposes
 
of
 
confirming
 
the
 
economics
 
for
 
classification
 
of
 
coal
reserves and
 
not for
 
purposes of valuing
 
Coronado or
 
its Mon Valley
 
assets.
 
Mine plans were
 
not
optimized,
 
and
 
actual
 
results
 
of
 
the
 
operations
 
may
 
be
 
different,
 
but
 
in
 
all
 
cases,
 
the
 
mine
production plan assumes the properties are under competent management.
1.10.2
 
Sensitivity Analysis
Sensitivity
 
of the
 
NPV
 
results
 
to
 
changes
 
in
 
the
 
key
 
drivers
 
is presented
 
in the
 
chart below.
 
The
sensitivity study shows
 
the NPV at
 
the 10.0% discount rate
 
when Base Case sales
 
prices, operating
costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased in increments
 
of 5% within a +/- 15% range.
 
 
ex964p2i0 ex964p19i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
11
Figure 1-4:
 
Sensitivity of NPV
As shown, NPV is quite sensitive to changes in sales price and operating cost estimates, and slightly
sensitive to changes in capital cost estimates.
1.11
 
Permitting
Due
 
to
 
the
 
projected
 
start-up
 
date
 
of
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
mines,
 
initial-stage
 
permit
 
work
 
has
 
been
completed
 
to date;
 
however,
 
no permit
 
applications have
 
been submitted
 
to the
 
state
 
or federal
regulatory agencies.
 
The proposed mines are
 
located in an area with
 
a long history of coal mining,
with
 
numerous
 
permitted
 
operations
 
in
 
close
 
proximity.
 
Coal
 
mining
 
permits
 
are
 
routinely
obtained; a
 
2 to
 
3-year lead
 
time is
 
recommended.
 
Estimated
 
expenditures for
 
mine closure
 
and
site reclamation are included in the financial model for each mine or plant site.
 
MM&A is unaware
of any obvious or
 
current Coronado permitting
 
issues that are expected
 
to prevent the
 
issuance of
future permits.
 
All coal producers are subject to a level of uncertainty regarding future clean water
permits
 
due
 
to
 
United
 
States
 
Environmental
 
Protection
 
Agency
 
(EPA)
 
and
 
United
 
States
 
Fish
 
and
Wildlife (USFW) involvement with state
 
programs.
1.12
 
Conclusion and Recommendations
Sufficient
 
data
 
has
 
been
 
obtained
 
through
 
various
 
exploration,
 
sampling
 
programs,
 
and
 
mining
operations
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
geological
 
interpretations
 
of
 
seam
 
structure
 
and
 
thickness
 
for
 
coal
horizons situated
 
on the Property.
 
The data are
 
of sufficient
 
quantity and reliability
 
to reasonably
support the coal-resource and coal-reserve estimates
 
in this TRS.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
12
The
 
geological
 
data
 
and
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
study,
 
which
 
consider
 
mining
 
plans,
 
revenue,
 
and
operating-
 
and
 
capital-cost
 
estimates
 
are
 
sufficient
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
classification
 
of
 
coal
 
reserves
provided herein.
This geologic
 
evaluation conducted
 
in conjunction
 
with the
 
preliminary feasibility
 
study concludes
that
 
the
 
134.4
 
Mt
 
of
 
marketable
 
underground
 
coal
 
reserves
 
identified
 
on
 
the
 
Property
 
are
economically
 
mineable
 
under
 
reasonable
 
expectations
 
of
 
market
 
prices
 
for
 
metallurgical
 
coal
products, estimated operation costs,
 
and capital expenditures.
2
 
Introduction
2.1
 
Registrant and Terms
 
of Reference
This report
 
was
 
prepared
 
for
 
the
 
sole use
 
of
Coronado Global
 
Resources
 
Inc.
 
(Coronado)
 
and its
affiliated and subsidiary companies and
 
advisors.
 
This TRS updates the
 
TRS titled, “Coronado Global
Resources
 
Inc.
 
Statement
 
of
 
Coal
 
Resources
 
and
 
Reserves
 
for
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
Complex
 
Upper
Freeport Holdings in Accordance with the JORC Code and United States
 
SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as
of December 31,
 
2022 Northern
 
Appalachian Coal
 
Basin Pennsylvania,
 
USA February
 
2023” dated
February 15, 2023, due to
 
material differences
 
in the key
 
financial modifying factors
 
including coal
sales price assumptions,
 
operating costs and capital
 
costs from December 31,
 
2022 to December 31,
2023.
 
Coal sales price assumptions are discussed in Sections 12 and 16 of the TRS,
 
while operating
costs
 
and
 
capital
 
costs
 
are
 
discussed
 
in
 
Sections
 
18
 
and
 
19
 
of
 
the
 
TRS.
 
The
 
report
 
provides
 
a
statement of coal
 
resources and coal
 
reserves for Coronado,
 
as defined
 
under the
Australasian Code
for Reporting
 
of Exploration Results,
 
Mineral Resources and
 
Ore Reserves (JORC
 
Code)
 
as well
 
as
under
 
Subpart
 
1300
 
of
 
Regulation
 
S-K
 
(Regulation
 
S-K
 
1300)
 
promulgated
 
by
 
the
United
 
States
Securities and Exchange
 
Commission (SEC)
.
 
This report was
 
also prepared in accordance
 
with the
Australasian Code for Public
 
Reporting of Technical Assessments and Valuations of Mineral
 
Assets
(VALMIN Code).
The Mon
 
Valley
 
property is
 
comprised of
 
three separate
 
reserve holdings,
 
namely,
 
the Pangburn,
Shaner and Fallowfield proposed underground mines in the Upper Freeport seam.
The report provides
 
a statement
 
of coal resources
 
and coal reserves for
 
Coronado at the Property.
 
Exploration results and Resource
 
calculations were used as the basis for the mine planning and the
preliminary feasibility study completed to determine
 
the extent and viability of the reserve.
Coal
 
resources
 
and
 
coal
 
reserves
 
are
 
herein
 
reported
 
in
 
metric
 
units
 
of
 
measurement
 
and
 
are
rounded to millions of metric tonnes (Mt).
2.2
 
Information Sources
This TRS
 
is based on
 
information provided
 
by Coronado
 
and reviewed
 
by MM&A.
 
Sources of data
and information are listed below in
Table 2-1
:
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
13
Table 2-1:
 
Information Provided to MM&A by Coronado
Category
Information Provided by Coronado
Report Section
Geological
Geologic
 
data
 
including
 
digital
 
databases
 
and
 
original
 
source
 
data
 
including
geologist logs, driller’s logs, geophysical
 
logs
9.1
Coal Quality
Database of coal quality
 
information supplemented
 
with original source laboratory
sheets where available
10.1
Mining
Historical productivities and manpower from
 
operating and future Coronado
 
mines
13.2, 13.4
Coal
Preparation
Flow sheet and other information
 
representing current
 
and future methods of
 
coal
processing
 
14.1
Waste
Disposal
Engineering
 
data
 
and
 
estimates
 
representing
 
remaining
 
capacities
 
for
 
coarse
 
and
fine coal waste disposal
17.2
Costs
Historical and
 
budgetary operating
 
cost information
 
used to derive
 
cost drivers
 
for
reserve financial modeling
18.2
Economic
WACC and inflation rate
 
used in discounted cash flow analysis
19.1, 19.2,
19.3
Note: While the sources of
 
data listed in
 
Table 2-1
 
are not exhaustive, they
 
represent a significant portion of
 
information which supports this
TRS.
 
MM&A reviewed the
 
provided data and found
 
it to be reasonable
 
prior to incorporating it
 
into the TRS.
 
The TRS contains “forward-looking
information” including forecasts of productivity and annual coal production,
 
operating and capital cost estimates, coal sales price forecasts, the
assumption that Coronado will continue to
 
acquire necessary permits, and other assumptions.
 
The TRS statements
 
and conclusions are not a
guarantee of
 
future performance
 
and undue
 
reliance should
 
not be placed
 
on them.
 
The ability of
 
Coronado to
 
recover the
 
estimated coal
reserves
 
is
 
dependent on
 
multiple factors
 
beyond
 
the
 
control
 
of
 
MM&A
 
including, but
 
not
 
limited
 
to
 
geologic
 
factors,
 
mining
 
conditions,
regulatory approvals, and changes in regulations.
 
In all cases, the plans assume the Property is under competent management.
Coronado engaged MM&A to conduct a coal resource and reserve evaluation
 
of the Coronado coal
properties
 
as
 
of
 
December 31,
 
2023,
 
the
 
effective
 
date
 
of
 
this
 
TRS
 
for
 
Mon
 
Valley.
 
For
 
the
evaluation, the following tasks were
 
to be completed:
 
>
 
Conduct a site visit to the projected resource/reserve area;
>
 
Process
 
the
 
information
 
supporting
 
the
 
estimation
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
into
geological models;
 
>
 
Develop life-of-reserve mine
 
(LOM) plans and financial models;
>
 
Hold discussions with Coronado company management; and
 
>
 
Prepare and
 
issue a TRS providing
 
a statement
 
of coal resources
 
and reserves which
 
would
include:
-
 
A description of the mines and facilities.
 
-
 
A description of the evaluation process.
-
 
An estimation of coal resources and reserves with compliance elements as stated under the
JORC Code and the SEC Regulation S-K 1300.
2.3
 
Personal Inspections
MM&A is very familiar
 
with the Mon Valley
 
properties, having provided
 
a variety of geological
 
and
engineering
 
evaluations
 
of
 
the
 
subject
 
property
 
and
 
neighboring
 
properties
 
in
 
recent
 
years.
 
No
facilities
 
are
 
constructed
 
on
 
the
 
properties.
 
A
 
site
 
inspection
 
of
 
proposed
 
and
 
potential
 
surface
facility areas was last conducted in December 2023.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
14
3
 
Property Description
3.1
 
Location
The Mon Valley
 
Complex will include the
 
Pangburn, Shaner,
 
and Fallowfield underground
 
mines in
the Upper Freeport coal
 
seam.
 
The properties are located approximately 22.5 kilometers southeast
of Pittsburgh.
 
The property
 
is located
 
in Allegheny,
 
Washington,
 
and Westmoreland
 
Counties, Pennsylvania
 
(see
Figure 1-1 above
).
 
Mining operations here
 
have not yet
 
been initiated.
 
The Property is located
 
on
portions
 
of
 
eight
United
 
States
 
Geological
 
Survey
 
(USGS)
 
quadrangles:
 
Irwin;
 
Glassport;
Monongahela;
 
Donora;
 
Smithton;
 
California;
 
Ellsworth;
 
and
 
Hackett.
 
The
 
coordinate
 
system
 
and
datum
 
used
 
for
 
the
 
model
 
of
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
and
 
the
 
subsequent
 
maps
 
were
 
produced
 
in
 
the
Pennsylvania State
 
Plane South system, NAD 27.
3.2
 
Titles, Claims or Leases
The
 
property
 
is
 
composed
 
of
 
41,615
 
total
 
hectares,
 
of
 
which
 
1,339
 
are
 
leased
 
from
 
private
landholders under two leases, and 40,276 hectares are owned by Coronado.
 
Subject to Coronado’s
exercising
 
its renewal rights thereunder,
 
both of the leases expire
 
upon exhaustion of the
 
relevant
coal
 
reserves,
 
which
 
is
 
expected
 
to
 
occur
 
in
 
2101.
 
MM&A
 
has
 
not
 
carried
 
out
 
a
 
separate
 
title
verification
 
for
 
the coal
 
properties
 
and has
 
not verified
 
leases, deeds,
 
surveys, or
 
other property-
control
 
instruments
 
pertinent
 
to
 
the
 
subject
 
resources.
 
Tenure
 
was
 
separately
 
reviewed
 
by
Coronado’s
 
legal advisors.
 
Coronado has
 
represented
 
to MM&A
 
that it
 
controls the
 
mining rights
to the reserves as shown on
 
its property maps, and MM&A has accepted
 
these as being a true and
accurate
 
depiction of
 
the mineral
 
rights controlled
 
by Coronado.
 
The TRS
 
assumes the
 
properties
are developed under responsible and experienced management.
 
3.3
 
Mineral Rights
Coronado supplied property control maps to MM&A related to properties for which mineral and/or
surface
 
property
 
are
 
controlled
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
While
 
MM&A
 
accepted
 
these
 
representations
 
as
being
 
true
 
and
 
accurate,
 
MM&A
 
has
 
no
 
knowledge
 
of
 
past
 
property
 
boundary
 
disputes
 
or
 
other
concerns, through
 
past knowledge
 
of the
 
Property,
 
that would
 
signal concern
 
over future
 
mining
operations or development potential.
Property control
 
in Appalachia can
 
be intricate.
 
Coal-mining properties
 
are typically
 
composed of
numerous property
 
tracts which
 
are owned
 
and/or leased
 
from both
 
land-holding companies
 
and
private
 
individuals
 
or
 
companies.
 
It
 
is
 
common
 
to
 
encounter
 
severed
 
ownership,
 
with
 
different
entities
 
or individuals
 
controlling
 
the
 
surface
 
and mineral
 
rights.
 
Mineral
 
control
 
in the
 
region
 
is
typically characterized by leases or ownership of larger tracts of land,
 
with surface control generally
comprised of smaller tracts, particularly in developed areas.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
15
Legal mining rights may reflect a combination of fee or
 
mineral ownership and fee or mineral leases
of coal lands through various surface and mineral lease agreements.
 
Control
 
of
 
the
 
surface
 
property
 
is
 
necessary
 
to
 
conduct
 
surface
 
mining
 
but
 
is
 
not
 
necessary
 
to
conduct underground mining.
 
Given that the vicinity of the Mon Valley properties has an extensive
history
 
of
 
coal
 
mining,
 
Coronado
 
and
 
its
 
predecessors
 
have
 
a
 
successful
 
history
 
of
 
obtaining
 
any
necessary rights and the associated permits to mine.
3.4
 
Encumbrances
No Title Encumbrances are known.
 
By assignment, MM&A did
 
not complete a query
 
related to Title
Encumbrances.
 
3.5
 
Other Risks
There is always risk
 
involved in property control.
 
Coronado and its predecessor, CONSOL, have both
had their legal teams examine the deeds and title control in order to
 
minimize the risk.
 
4
 
Accessibility,
 
Climate, Local Resources,
Infrastructure and Physiography
4.1
 
Topography,
 
Elevation and Vegetation
Topography
 
of the
 
area surrounding
 
the proposed
 
Mon Valley
 
complex is
 
typical of
 
the Northern
Appalachian
 
Plateau
 
consisting
 
of
 
broad
 
river
 
valleys
 
and
 
rolling
 
hills,
 
with
 
some
 
upland
 
regions.
 
Surface
 
elevations
 
near
 
the
 
Property
 
range
 
from
 
approximately
 
396
 
meters
 
above
 
sea
 
level
 
in
upland regions to approximately 220 meters at stream level.
 
The property is moderately vegetated
by primarily oak
 
hardwood forests, but the
 
majority of
 
the land
 
is developed
 
for farm and
 
residential
use.
 
The
 
property
 
is
 
situated
 
near
 
the
 
major
 
urban
 
center
 
of
 
Pittsburgh,
 
PA
 
and
 
is
 
considered
suburban.
 
4.2
 
Access and Transport
There
 
is
 
general
 
access
 
to
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
property
 
via
 
a
 
well-developed
 
network
 
of
 
primary,
secondary,
 
and
 
unimproved
 
roads.
 
The
 
Monongahela
 
and
 
Youghiogheny
 
Rivers
 
traverse
 
the
Property from
 
south to north.
 
There are
 
numerous four
 
-lane limited-access
 
roads situated
 
within
or adjacent to the Property as well as a network of improved two-lane state and county roads.
 
U.S.
Interstate
 
70
 
and
 
Pennsylvania
 
Route
 
51
 
traverse
 
the
 
Fallowfield
 
and
 
Pangburn
 
properties,
respectively.
 
Numerous
 
secondary
 
and
 
unimproved
 
roads
 
provide
 
direct
 
access
 
to
 
the
 
mine
property,
 
some being state-
 
and town-maintained.
 
These roads typically stay open throughout the
year.
 
There
 
are
 
numerous
 
transportation/logistical
 
options
 
for
 
shipping
 
product.
 
The
 
primary
means
 
of
 
transport
 
for
 
produced
 
coal
 
would
 
be
 
by
 
barge
 
on
 
the
 
Monongahela
 
River/Ohio
 
River
system.
 
Additionally, a CS
X Corporation (CSX)
 
rail line located along the banks of the
 
Monongahela
River would provide another option for the shipment of coal.
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
16
4.3
 
Proximity to Population Centers
 
The
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
property
 
lies
 
near
 
the
 
communities
 
of
 
Bentleyville,
 
Lockview,
 
Monongahela,
Elizabeth,
 
Sutersville,
 
and
 
Irwin,
 
Pennsylvania
 
approximately
 
16
 
kilometers
 
to
 
32
 
kilometers
southeast
 
of
 
Pittsburgh,
 
and
 
16
 
kilometers
 
to
 
32
 
kilometers
 
from
 
Washington
 
and
 
McKeesport,
Pennsylvania.
 
As
 
of
 
2021
 
Pittsburgh
 
had
 
a
 
population
 
of
 
approximately
 
300,400
 
residents;
McKeesport, 17,500; and Washington, 13,200.
 
4.4
 
Climate and Length of Operating Season
The climate of
 
the region
 
is classified
 
as warm-summer
 
humid continental with
 
four distinct seasons:
 
warm summers,
 
cold winters,
 
and moderate
 
fall and
 
spring seasons.
 
Precipitation in
 
the region
 
is
consistent throughout the year with the most
 
rain falling in spring and the
 
early months of summer.
 
Average
 
yearly rainfall
 
is 95.1 centimeters.
 
Summer months typically begin
 
in late May
 
and end in
early September
 
and range
 
in average
 
temperature
 
from 51
 
to 84
 
degrees Fahrenheit
 
(or 10.6
 
to
28.9
 
degrees
 
Celsius).
 
Winters
 
typically
 
begin
 
in
 
mid to
 
late
 
November and
 
run until
 
mid
 
to
 
late
March with average temperatures
 
ranging from 22 to 50 degrees Fahrenheit
 
(or -5.6 to 10 degrees
Celsius).
 
Precipitation in the winter
 
typically comes in
 
the form of snowfall
 
or as a
 
wintery mix (sleet
and
 
snow)
 
with
 
severe
 
snowfall
 
events
 
occurring
 
occasionally.
 
Seasonal
 
variations
 
in
 
climate
typically
 
do
 
not
 
affect
 
underground
 
mining
 
in
 
Pennsylvania.
 
However,
 
weather
 
events
 
could
potentially
 
negatively
 
impact
 
efficiency
 
of
 
surface
 
and
 
preparation
 
plant
 
operations
 
on
 
a
 
very
limited basis, typically lasting less than a few days.
4.5
 
Infrastructure
The Mon Valley property has sources
 
of water,
 
power,
 
personnel, and supplies readily available for
use.
 
Personnel
 
have
 
historically
 
been
 
sourced
 
from
 
the
 
surrounding
 
communities
 
in
 
Allegheny,
Washington, and
 
Westmoreland Counties, and have
 
proven to be adequate
 
in numbers to operate
the mines.
 
As mining is common in the surrounding
 
areas, the workforce
 
is generally familiar
 
with
mining practices, and
 
many are experienced
 
miners.
 
Water is
 
expected to be
 
sourced locally from
nearby public
 
water sources or
 
rivers.
 
Electricity is
 
anticipated to be
 
sourced from
West Penn Power
(
West Penn
)
 
or
Duquesne Light (
Duquesne Light
)
.
 
The service industry
 
in the areas
 
surrounding the
proposed mine
 
complex has historically
 
provided supplies, equipment
 
repairs and
 
fabrication, etc.
 
Barge
 
transport
 
on
 
the
 
Monongahela
 
River/Ohio
 
River
 
system
 
will
 
serve
 
as
 
the
 
main
 
means
 
of
product
 
transport
 
from
 
the
 
mine,
 
and
 
currently
 
serve
 
as
 
a
 
means
 
of
 
coal
 
transportation
 
for
neighboring Pittsburgh seam operations.
 
Rail access is provided by a CSX rail line.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
17
5
 
History
5.1
 
Previous Operation
The
 
property
 
was
 
formerly
 
controlled
 
by
Consolidation
 
Coal
 
Company
 
(CONSOL)
.
 
Historic
underground
 
operations
 
were
 
active
 
in
 
the
 
area
 
in
 
the
 
early
 
1900’s
 
and
 
contour
 
surface
 
mining
operations
 
were
 
performed
 
in
 
the
 
1950
 
to
 
1960
 
era.
 
Coronado
 
acquired
 
the
 
properties
 
from
CONSOL in March 2016.
5.2
 
Previous Exploration
The
 
properties
 
have
 
been
 
extensively
 
explored
 
by
 
subsurface
 
drilling
 
efforts
 
carried
 
out
 
by
numerous entities,
 
most of which
 
were completed
 
prior to acquisition
 
by Coronado.
 
The majority
of the drilling was accomplished
 
using vertical continuous (diamond) coring and air
 
rotary methods.
Drill records
 
indicate that
 
independent contract
 
drilling operators
 
have been
 
engaged periodically
to carry out
 
exploration drilling on
 
the properties.
 
Geophysical logging on
 
those properties acquired
from CONSOL was often performed by
 
both CONSOL’s in-house logging services and outside logging
firms.
 
6
 
Geological Setting, Mineralization and Deposit
6.1
 
Regional, Local and Property Geology
The property lies in the Northern Appalachian
 
Coal basin in the Appalachian Plateau
 
physiographic
province.
 
The coal deposits in the eastern USA are the oldest and most extensively
 
developed coal
deposits in the country.
 
The coal deposits on the properties
 
are Carboniferous in age,
 
being of the
Pennsylvanian
 
system.
 
Overall,
 
these
 
Carboniferous
 
coals
 
contain
 
roughly
 
two-fifths
 
of
 
the
bituminous
 
coal
 
deposits
 
in
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
and
 
extend
 
over
 
1,448
 
kilometers
 
from
 
northern
Alabama to Pennsylvania and are part of what is known as the Appalachian Basin.
 
The Appalachian
Basin
 
is
 
more
 
than
 
402
 
kilometers
 
wide
 
and,
 
in
 
some
 
portions,
 
contains
 
over
 
60
 
coal
 
seams
 
of
varying economic significance.
Seams of economic significance typically range between 0.3 meters to 2.4 meters in thickness, with
relatively
 
little
 
structural
 
deformation.
 
Regional
 
structure
 
is
 
typically
 
characterized
 
by
 
gently
dipping strata to the northwest at less than one percent.
 
Local anticline and syncline structures are
present on the property with seam dips up to 5 percent.
Seams of the Allegheny Formation have historically been mined in the Pennsylvania region with the
Upper
 
Freeport
 
seam being
 
one of
 
the principal
 
seams in
 
the formation.
 
Coal from
 
the area
 
has
historically sold in thermal and metallurgical markets.
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
18
Future
 
operations
 
at the
 
Mon Valley
 
properties will
 
extract
 
the Upper
 
Freeport coal
 
seam, which
covers large areas of Pennsylvania, Ohio, Maryland, and West Virginia.
 
The Upper Freeport seam is
situated
 
at
 
the
 
top
 
of
 
the
 
Allegheny
 
Group
 
of
 
the
 
middle
 
Pennsylvanian
 
period
 
(307-315 million
years ago).
 
The top of the Upper Freeport
 
seam is commonly used as the marker
 
between the top
of
 
the
 
Allegheny
 
Formation
 
and
 
the
 
overlying
 
Upper
 
Pennsylvanian
 
Conemaugh
 
Group.
 
The
Allegheny Formation is made up of laminated cyclothemic sequences of coal, shale, limestone, and
clay.
 
The
 
Upper
 
Freeport
 
seam
 
lies
 
generally
 
around
 
183
 
meters
 
below
 
the
 
Pittsburgh
 
seam.
 
Deposits associated with the Upper Freeport are often irregular and dislocated deposits (formed in
domed peat swamps commonly referred
 
to as “peat islands”).
 
The
 
primary
 
structural
 
controls
 
on
 
the
 
Upper
 
Freeport
 
coal
 
basin
 
are
 
localized
 
syn-depositional
anticlines
 
and
 
synclines
 
that
 
directly
 
influence
 
the
 
accumulation
 
of
 
peat
 
bogs.
 
These
 
structures
create
 
gently
 
folded
 
and
 
rolling
 
coal
 
strata.
 
The
 
axis
 
of
 
the
 
Waynesburg
 
and
 
Port
 
Royal
 
(Irwin)
synclines pass through the center and eastern portions of the properties with a trend and incline to
the Northeast.
 
The Amity, Murrysville, and Belle Vernon
 
anticlines (listed from west to east) reside
to the
 
center and western
 
portions of the
 
properties.
 
These anticlines
 
often coincide
 
with thicker
coal seams where peat accumulated
 
in domes along the anticlinal crest.
 
It is understood that local
anticlines
 
represent
 
the upthrown
 
side of
 
syn-depositionally
 
active
 
deep
 
faults.
 
Inversely,
 
fluvial
channel sediments were deposited on the structural downthrown
 
side within synclines.
 
Within the Pangburn,
 
Shaner,
 
and Fallowfield mine-plan
 
areas, the Upper
 
Freeport is typically
 
183
meters to
 
335 meters below
 
the ground surface.
 
Mine access is therefore
 
to be provided
 
by shaft
and slope development.
 
The planned Pangburn shaft depth is
 
approximately 195 meters
 
in depth.
 
The
 
shaft
 
depths
 
at
 
the
 
projected
 
locations
 
for
 
the
 
Shaner
 
and
 
Fallowfield
 
shafts
 
range
 
from
approximately 232 meters to
 
268 meters.
 
6.2
 
Mineralization
The coal to be produced at The Mon Valley
 
Complex is typically high volatile (>31% volatile matter)
bituminous coal.
 
The generalized stratigraphic
 
columnar section in
Figure 6-1
 
demonstrates the vertical
 
relationship
of the principal coal seams and rock formations on the Property.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p27i2
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p27i2
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p27i2
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p27i2
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p27i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p27i0 ex964p27i0
 
 
ex964p27i0 ex964p27i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p27i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p27i0 ex964p27i0
 
ex964p27i0 ex964p27i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p27i0 ex964p27i3
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
19
RM
Redstone
 
Limestone
RML
Lower Redstone Limestone
PSU
Pittsburgh SS Upper Bench
PR
Pittsburgh
 
Rider Coal
PSL
Pittsburgh SS Lower Bench
RCZ
Pittsburgh Roof Coal Zone
DS
Drawslate
PG
Pittsburgh Coal Main Bench
PGS
Pittsburgh Coal Expected
 
Horizon (Surface)
AM
Ames Marine Zone
AMS
Ames Marine Zone
 
Expected
 
Horizon (Surface)
HR
Harlem Coal
BK2
Upper Bakerstown Coal
WRM
Woods
 
Run Marine Zone
BK1
Lower Bakerstown Coal
PC
Pine Creek Marine Zone
BCM
Brush Creek Marine Zone
BC
Brush Creek Coal
BCS
Brush Creek Coal Expected
 
Horizon (Surface)
MHU
Upper Mahoning
 
Sandstone
MA
Mahoning
 
Coal
MH
Lower Mahoning
 
Sandstone
UFR
Upper Freeport Rider Coal
UF
Upper Freeport
 
Coal
UFS
Upper Freeport
 
Coal Expected Horizon
 
(Surface)
UFL
Upper Freeport Leader Coal
LUF
Upper Freeport Limestone
BUT
Butler
 
Sandstone
LFR
Lower Freeport Rider Coal
LF
Lower Freeport
 
Coal
LFL
Lower Freeport Leader Coal
LLF
Lower Freeport Limestone
FSS
Freeport Sandstone
REQUIRED
 
UNIT
Age
Group
Formation
Member
Code
Pennsylvanian
Monongahela
Pittsburgh
Lower
Major Units
Mahoning
Pennsylvanian
Conemaugh
Glenshaw
Ames
Saltsburg
Woods
 
Run
Pine Creek
Brush Creek
Pennsylvanian
Allegheny
Freeport
Figure 6-1:
 
Stratigraphic Column
(not to scale)
6.3
 
Deposits
Historic
 
underground
 
mining
 
has
 
occurred
 
in
 
the
 
overlying
 
Pittsburgh
 
Seam
 
on
 
this
 
property.
 
Contour
 
surface
 
mining
 
on
 
the
 
Pittsburgh
 
and
 
Redstone
 
outcrop
 
has
 
occurred
 
within
 
the
 
areas
projected
 
for
 
the coal
 
refuse
 
disposal area,
 
the slope
 
portal
 
area and
 
the preparation
 
plant
 
area.
 
The three
 
proposed mines
 
(Pangburn, Shaner,
 
and Fallowfield)
 
are all
 
projected to
 
be deep mines
in the Upper
 
Freeport seam.
 
Mining is projected
 
in areas where
 
the total seam
 
thickness exceeds
1.2 meters.
 
Areas of
 
sandstone washout
 
and seam thinning
 
have been
 
excluded from
 
projections
by MM&A personnel.
 
Additional exploration could identify additional geologically
 
limiting features,
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
20
which could alter the proposed mine plan.
 
The Upper Freeport seam in the projected areas ranges
from 0.7 meters to 3.1 meters thick and averages
 
1.95 meters thick.
7
 
Exploration
7.1
 
Nature and Extent of Exploration
Extensive exploration in the form of subsurface drill efforts has been carried out on the Property by
numerous
 
entities,
 
most
 
of
 
which
 
efforts
 
were
 
completed
 
prior
 
to
 
the
 
acquisition
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
Diamond
 
core
 
and
 
rotary
 
drilling
 
are
 
the
 
primary types
 
of exploration
 
on the
 
Property.
 
Data
 
for
correlation
 
and mining
 
conditions
 
are
 
derived
 
from
 
core
 
descriptions
 
and geophysical
 
logging (e-
logging).
 
Coal quality analyses were also
 
employed during the core exploration
 
process.
 
A total of
approximately 750 core and rotary
 
holes have been drilled for exploration.
The location of the drilling is shown on the maps included in Appendix B.
The
 
concentration
 
of
 
exploration
 
varies
 
slightly
 
across
 
the
 
Property.
 
Drilling
 
on
 
the
 
Property
 
is
typically
 
sufficient
 
for
 
delineation
 
of
 
potential
 
underground
 
mineable
 
benches.
 
Core
 
logging
 
is
carried out by professional
 
geologists in cases where
 
roof and floor strata
 
are of particular interest
and in cases
 
where greater resolution and
 
geologic detail are
 
needed.
 
Generally speaking, however,
most drill
 
hole data
 
come from
 
simplified driller’s
 
logs, which
 
often lack
 
specific details
 
regarding
geotechnical
 
conditions
 
and
 
specific
 
geology,
 
making
 
correlations
 
and
 
floor
 
and
 
roof
 
conditions
difficult to
 
determine.
 
Geophysical logging
 
(e-logging) techniques,
 
by contrast,
 
document specific
details
 
useful
 
for
 
geologic
 
interpretation
 
and
 
mining
 
conditions.
 
Given
 
the
 
variability
 
of
 
data-
gathering
 
methods,
 
definitive
 
mapping
 
of
 
future
 
mining
 
conditions
 
may
 
not
 
be
 
possible,
 
but
projections and assumptions can be made within a reasonable degree of certainty.
A significant effort
 
was put into
 
verifying the integrity
 
of the database.
 
Once this was established,
stratigraphic
 
columnar
 
sections
 
were
 
generated
 
using
 
cross-sectional
 
analysis
 
to
 
establish
 
or
confirm coal seam correlations.
 
A typical cross-section is shown in
Figure 7-1.
 
 
ex964p2i0 ex964p29i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
21
Figure 7-1:
 
Mon Valley Cross-Section
Due to
 
the long history
 
of exploration
 
by various
 
parties on the
 
Property,
 
a wide
 
variety of
 
survey
techniques exist for
 
documentation of data
 
point locations.
 
Many of
 
the older
 
exploration drill holes
appear to
 
have been
 
located by
 
survey and
 
more recently-completed
 
drill holes
 
are often
 
located
by high-resolution Global
 
Positioning System (GPS)
 
units.
 
However, some holes appear
 
to have been
approximately
 
located
 
using
 
USGS
 
topography
 
maps
 
or
 
other
 
methods
 
which
 
are
 
less
 
accurate.
 
Therefore,
 
discretion
 
had
 
to
 
be
 
used
 
regarding
 
the
 
accuracy
 
for
 
the
 
location
 
and
 
ground
 
surface
elevation of
 
some of these
 
older drill holes.
 
In instances
 
where a drill
 
hole location
 
(or associated
coal
 
seam
 
elevations)
 
appeared
 
to
 
be
 
inconsistent
 
with
 
the
 
overall
 
structural
 
trend
 
(or
 
surface
topography
 
for surface
 
-mineable areas),
 
the data
 
point was
 
not honored
 
for
 
geological modeling.
 
Others with apparently minor variances were adjusted
 
and then used by MM&A.
 
Surveying of the underground and surface mined areas has been performed by the mine operators
and/or
 
their
 
consulting
 
surveyors.
 
By
 
assignment,
 
MM&A
 
did
 
not
 
verify
 
the
 
accuracy
 
or
completeness of supplied
 
mine maps but
 
accepted this information as
 
being the
 
work of responsible
engineers and surveyors.
MM&A
 
compiled
 
comprehensive
 
topographic
 
map
 
files
 
by
 
selecting
 
the
 
best
 
available
 
aerial
mapping for each area and filling any gaps with digital USGS topographic
 
mapping.
7.2
 
Non-Drilling Procedures and Parameters
All pertinent data used to characterize the coal
 
resources and coal reserves have been acquired via
exploration-based drilling methods.
 
The region has historically produced and sold Upper Freeport-
based coal
 
into metallurgical
 
and thermal
 
markets, enhancing
 
the confidence
 
of the
 
marketability
and quality of the resource.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
22
7.3
 
Drilling Procedures
Core drilling methods
 
utilize NX-size (~5.4 centimeter) or similar-sized core cylinders
 
to recover core
samples, which
 
can
 
be used
 
to
 
delineate
 
geologic characteristics,
 
for
 
coal-quality
 
testing,
 
and for
geotechnical
 
logging.
 
With core
 
holes, geophysical
 
logs are
 
especially useful
 
in verifying
 
the core
recovery of both the coal samples (for assurance that the sample is representative of the full seam)
and
 
of
 
the
 
roof
 
and
 
floor
 
rock
 
samples
 
(for
 
evaluating
 
ground
 
control
 
characteristics
 
of
 
deep
mineable coal
 
seams).
 
In addition
 
to the
 
core holes,
 
rotary-drilled holes
 
also exist
 
on most
 
of the
Property.
 
Data
 
for
 
the
 
rotary-drilled
 
holes
 
are
 
mainly
 
derived
 
from
 
downhole
 
geophysical
 
logs,
which are
 
used to
 
interpret coal
 
and rock thickness
 
and depth,
 
since logging of
 
the drill cuttings
 
is
unreliable.
 
Exploratory drilling generally requires drilling to depths of
 
over 152 meters to penetrate
the target coal seam at Mon Valley
 
.
A wide variety
 
of core-logging techniques
 
exist for
 
the properties.
 
For many of
 
the core holes, the
primary data
 
source is a
 
generalized
 
lithology description by
 
the driller,
 
typically supplemented
 
by
a more detailed
 
core log completed
 
by a geologist.
 
These drilling logs were
 
provided to MM&A
 
as
a geological database.
 
MM&A geologists were
 
not involved
 
in the production
 
of original core
 
logs
but did perform a
 
basic check of information within
 
the provided database.
 
Where geophysical logs
for such holes were available,
 
they were used by MM&A geologists to
 
verify the coal thickness and
core recovery of seams.
 
7.4
 
Hydrology
Based on
 
historical successful
 
production of
 
Upper Freeport,
 
and stratigraphically
 
proximal
 
seams
in the
 
region, the Mon
 
Valley Complex is not
 
expected to have hydrologic concerns
 
of material issue.
 
Future
 
mining
 
is projected
 
to
 
occur
 
in areas
 
exhibiting
 
similar hydrogeological
 
conditions
 
as
 
past
mining,
 
including
 
stream
 
undermining
 
and
 
undermining
 
of
 
aquifers.
 
Based
 
upon
 
the
 
successful
history of
 
mining in the
 
region with
 
regards to
 
hydrogeological
 
features, MM&A
 
assumes that
 
the
operations will not be hindered by such issues.
The Pittsburgh seam has
 
been mined extensively above
 
the Upper Freeport seam on
 
the Property.
 
The
 
interval
 
(approximately
 
183
 
meters)
 
between
 
the
 
seams
 
is
 
anticipated
 
to
 
be
 
adequate
 
to
minimize inflow of water to the planned operations
 
from the overlying Pittsburgh works.
7.5
 
Geotechnical Data
Mining
 
plans
 
for
 
potential
 
underground
 
mines
 
were
 
developed
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
modified
 
by
MM&A to
 
fit current
 
property constraints.
 
Pillar stability
 
was tested
 
by MM&A
 
using the Analysis
of
 
Coal
 
Pillar
 
Stability
 
(ACPS)
 
program
 
that
 
was
 
developed
 
by
 
the
National
 
Institute
 
for
Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH).
 
MM&A reviewed the results from the ACPS analysis and
considered them in the development of the LOM plan.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
23
8
 
Sample Preparation, Analyses and Security
8.1
 
Prior to Sending to the Lab
Most
 
of the
 
coal
 
samples have
 
been obtained
 
from
 
the Property
 
by subsurface
 
exploration
 
using
core drilling
 
techniques.
 
The protocol
 
for preparing
 
and testing
 
the samples
 
has varied
 
over time
and is
 
not well
 
documented for the
 
older holes
 
drilled on
 
the Property.
 
Typical core-drilling sampling
methods for
 
coal in
 
the United
 
States
 
involves
 
drilling through
 
the seam,
 
removing the
 
core from
the
 
barrel,
 
describing the
 
lithology,
 
wrapping
 
the
 
sample in
 
a
 
sealed
 
plastic
 
sleeve
 
and
 
placing it
lengthwise into
 
a covered core
 
box, and carefully
 
marking hole ID and depth
 
intervals on each box
and
 
lid, allowing
 
the
 
core
 
to
 
be delivered
 
to
 
a
 
laboratory
 
in correct
 
stratigraphic
 
order,
 
and with
original
 
moisture
 
content.
 
This
 
process
 
has
 
been
 
the
 
norm
 
for
 
both
 
historical
 
and
 
ongoing
exploration activities at the Property.
This
 
work
 
is
 
typically
 
performed
 
by
 
the
 
supervising
 
driller,
 
geologist,
 
or
 
company
 
personnel.
 
Samples
 
are
 
most
 
often
 
delivered
 
to
 
the
 
company
 
by
 
the
 
driller
 
after
 
each
 
shift
 
or
 
acquired
 
by
company personnel
 
or representatives.
 
Most of the
 
coal core
 
samples were
 
obtained by previous
or
 
current
 
operators
 
on the
 
Property.
 
MM&A did
 
not participate
 
in the
 
collection,
 
sampling and
analysis of the core samples.
 
However,
 
it is reasonable to assume, given the consistency
 
of quality
from previous operators, that these samples
 
were generally collected and processed
 
under industry
best practices.
 
This assumption is based on MM&A’s
 
familiarity with the operating companies
 
and
the companies used to perform the analyses.
 
8.2
 
Lab Procedures
Coal quality
 
testing has
 
been performed
 
over many
 
years
 
by operating
 
companies using
 
different
laboratories and testing regimens.
 
Some of the
 
samples have raw analyses and
 
washabilities on the
full seam (with coal and rock parting layers co-mingled) and are mainly useful for characterizing the
coal quality for projected production from underground
 
mining.
 
Other samples have coal and rock
analyzed
 
separately,
 
the
 
results
 
of
 
which
 
can
 
be
 
manipulated
 
to
 
forecast
 
either
 
surface
 
or
underground mining quality.
 
Care has been
 
taken to use only
 
those analyses
 
that are representative
of
 
the
 
coal
 
quality
 
parameters
 
for
 
the
 
appropriate
 
mining
 
type
 
for
 
each
 
sample.
 
Unlike
 
many
Appalachian
 
properties,
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
only
 
has
 
interest
 
in
 
one
 
deep
 
seam;
 
therefore,
 
the
 
analyses
have likely been completed following
 
a consistent protocol.
Standard procedure
 
upon receipt of
 
core samples by the
 
testing laboratory
 
is to log the
 
depth and
thickness
 
of
 
the
 
sample,
 
then
 
perform
 
testing
 
as
 
specified
 
by
 
a
 
representative
 
of
 
the
 
operating
company.
 
Each
 
sample
 
is
 
then
 
analyzed
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
procedures
 
defined
 
under
ASTM
International (
ASTM
)
 
standards including, but not
 
limited to; washability (ASTM D4371);
 
ash (ASTM
D3174);
 
sulfur
 
(ASTM
 
D4239);
 
Btu/lb.
 
(ASTM
 
D5865);
 
volatile
 
matter
 
(ASTM
 
D3175);
 
Free
 
Swell
Index (FSI) (ASTM D720).
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
24
While not confirmed
 
by MM&A, it
 
is assumed
 
that best practices
 
and ASTM (or
 
equivalent standards
at the time
 
of testing) were
 
utilized in laboratory quality
 
testing.
 
Since 1970
 
(the earliest coal
 
quality
information
 
available),
 
the
 
Property
 
has
 
been
 
controlled
 
primarily by
 
CONSOL
 
utilizing
 
their
 
own
corporate
 
laboratories
 
including:
CONSOL Research
 
Laboratory
 
in Library,
 
PA,
CONSOL’s
 
Mathies
Mine Laboratory
 
at Mathies
 
Mine in
 
southwest Pennsylvania
 
and
Dickinson Laboratories,
 
Inc.
 
(El
Paso, Texas).
 
Both CONSOL’s Research Laboratory and the
 
Mathies Mine
 
lab have since
 
been closed.
 
Since
 
1977
 
to
 
the
 
present,
 
additional
 
laboratories
 
not
 
affiliated
 
with
 
coal
 
companies
 
who
 
have
provided analytical data for the Property include:
>
Geochemical Testing
 
(Somerset, Pennsylvania)
 
– accredited by
 
the National Environmental
Laboratory Accreditation Program
 
(NELAP).
>
SGS
 
North
 
America
 
(Sophia,
 
West
 
Virginia)
 
–
 
a
 
leading
 
accredited
 
body
 
and
 
a
Nationally
Recognized Test
 
Laboratory (
NRTL
)
; currently analyzing samples for Coronado.
9
 
Data Verification
9.1
 
Procedures of Qualified Person
MM&A reviewed the digital geologic
 
database supplied by Coronado.
 
The database consists of
 
data
records, which
 
include drill hole
 
information for
 
holes that
 
lie within and
 
adjacent to
 
the Property
and records
 
for numerous
 
supplemental coal
 
seam thickness measurements.
 
Upon completion of
the database
 
verification,
 
copies of
 
each entry
 
were
 
printed,
 
and cross
 
referenced
 
to the
 
original
document for
 
verification.
 
Once the initial
 
integrity of the
 
database was
 
established, stratigraphic
columnar sections were
 
generated using
 
cross-sectional analysis to
 
establish or confirm
 
coal-seam
correlations.
 
Geophysical
 
logs
 
were
 
used
 
wherever
 
available
 
to
 
assist
 
in
 
confirming
 
the
 
seam
correlation and to verify proper seam thickness measurements and recovery
 
of coal samples.
 
After establishing and/or verifying proper seam correlation, seam data control maps and geological
cross-sections were generated
 
and again used to verify seam correlations and data
 
integrity.
 
Once
the database was fully vetted, seam thickness, base-of-seam elevation, roof and
 
floor lithology, and
overburden maps were independently generated
 
for use in the mine planning process.
9.2
 
Limitations
As with any exploration program, localized anomalies
 
cannot always be discovered.
 
The greater the
density of
 
the samples
 
taken,
 
the less
 
the risk.
 
Once an
 
area is
 
identified as
 
being of
 
interest
 
for
inclusion
 
in
 
the
 
mine
 
plan,
 
additional
 
samples
 
are
 
taken
 
to
 
help
 
reduce
 
the
 
risk
 
in
 
those
 
specific
areas.
 
In general, provision is made in the mine planning portion of the study to allow for localized
anomalies that are typically classed more as a nuisance than a hinderance.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
25
9.3
 
Opinion of Qualified Person
Sufficient data
 
has been obtained
 
through various
 
exploration and
 
sampling programs
 
and mining
operations
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
geological
 
interpretations
 
of
 
seam
 
structure
 
and
 
thickness
 
for
 
coal
horizons
 
situated
 
on the
 
Property.
 
The data
 
is of
 
sufficient
 
quantity
 
and reliability
 
to
 
reasonably
support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates in this TRS.
10
 
Mineral Processing and Metallurgical Testing
10.1
 
Testing
 
Procedures
Separate
 
tabulations
 
have
 
been
 
compiled
 
for
 
basic
 
chemical
 
analyses
 
(both
 
raw
 
and
 
washed
quality), petrographic data, rheological data
 
and chlorine, ash, ultimate and sulfur analysis.
 
Available
 
coal quality
 
data
 
were
 
tabulated
 
by resource
 
area in
 
a Microsoft®
 
EXCEL
 
workbook and
the details of that work are maintained on file at the offices of Coronado and MM&A.
 
These tables
also
 
provide
 
basic
 
statistical
 
analyses
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
quality
 
data
 
sets,
 
including
 
average
 
value;
maximum
 
and
 
minimum
 
values;
 
and
 
the
 
number
 
of
 
samples
 
available
 
to
 
represent
 
each
 
quality
parameter
 
of
 
the
 
seam.
 
Coal
 
samples
 
that
 
were
 
deemed
 
by
 
MM&A
 
geologists
 
to
 
be
unrepresentative
 
were
 
not
 
used
 
for
 
statistical
 
analysis
 
of
 
coal
 
quality,
 
as
 
documented
 
in
 
the
tabulations.
 
A
 
representative
 
group
 
of
 
drill
 
hole
 
samples
 
from
 
the
 
Property
 
were
 
then
 
checked
against the original drill laboratory reports to verify accuracy
 
and correctness.
The amount and areal extent of coal sampling
 
for geological data is generally sufficient to represent
the quality characteristics of
 
the coal horizons
 
and allow for
 
proper market placement of
 
the subject
coal seams.
 
For some of
 
the coal deposits
 
there are considerable laboratory data
 
from core samples
that
 
are representative
 
of full
 
extent
 
of the
 
resource
 
area;
 
and for
 
others
 
there are
 
more
 
limited
data
 
to
 
represent
 
the
 
resource
 
area.
 
For
 
example,
 
in
 
the
 
active
 
operations
 
with
 
considerable
previous
 
mining, there
 
may
 
be limited
 
quality data
 
within some
 
of the
 
remaining resource
 
areas;
however,
 
in those
 
cases the
 
core sampling
 
data can
 
be supplemented
 
with operational
 
data from
mining and shipped quality samples representative of the resource area.
10.2
 
Relationship of Tests
 
to the Whole
The extensive
 
sampling and
 
testing procedures
 
typically followed
 
in the
 
coal
 
industry result
 
in an
excellent
 
correlation
 
between
 
samples and
 
marketable
 
product.
 
The Upper
 
Freeport
 
seam has
 
a
long
 
history
 
of
 
saleable
 
production
 
in
 
the
 
high-volatile
 
metallurgical
 
and
 
thermal
 
markets,
consistent
 
with
 
exploration
 
results.
 
Degradation
 
of
 
coking
 
coal
 
characteristics
 
over
 
time
 
is
 
not
anticipated to be an issue.
10.3
 
Lab Information
Each sample
 
is analyzed
 
at area
 
Laboratories
 
that operate
 
in accordance
 
with procedures
 
defined
under ASTM standards including, but not limited to; washability (ASTM D4371); ash (ASTM D3174);
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
26
sulfur (ASTM
 
D4239); Btu/lb.
 
(ASTM D5865);
 
volatile matter
 
(ASTM D3175);
 
Free Swell
 
Index (FSI)
(ASTM D720).
While not confirmed
 
by MM&A, it
 
is assumed
 
that best practices
 
and ASTM (or
 
equivalent standards
at the time
 
of testing) were
 
utilized in laboratory quality
 
testing.
 
Since 1970
 
(the earliest coal
 
quality
information
 
available),
 
the
 
Property
 
has
 
been
 
controlled
 
primarily by
 
CONSOL
 
utilizing
 
their
 
own
corporate
 
laboratories
 
including:
 
CONSOL
 
Research
 
Laboratory
 
in
 
Library,
 
PA,
 
CONSOL’s
 
Mathies
Mine
 
Laboratory
 
at
 
Mathies
 
Mine
 
in
 
southwest
 
Pennsylvania
 
and Dickinson
 
Laboratories,
 
Inc. (El
Paso, Texas).
 
Both CONSOL’s Research Laboratory and the
 
Mathies mine
 
lab have since
 
been closed.
 
Since
 
1977
 
to
 
the
 
present,
 
additional
 
laboratories
 
not
 
affiliated
 
with
 
coal
 
companies
 
who
 
have
provided analytical data for the Property include:
>
 
Geochemical Testing
 
(Somerset, Pennsylvania) – accredited
 
by the NELAP.
>
 
SGS North America (Sophia,
 
West Virginia) – a leading
 
accredited body and a
 
NRTL; currently
analyzing samples for Coronado.
10.4
 
Relevant Results
No critical factors have been found
 
that would adversely affect the recovery
 
of the Reserve.
11
 
Mineral Resource Estimates
MM&A independently created
 
a geologic model to define
 
the coal resources at
 
the Property.
 
Coal
resources were estimated
 
as of December 31, 2023.
11.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
Geological
 
data
 
was
 
imported
 
into
 
Carlson
 
Mining®
 
(formerly
 
SurvCADD®)
 
geological
 
modelling
software
 
in the
 
form
 
of Microsoft®
 
Excel
 
files incorporating
 
drill hole
 
collars,
 
seam and
 
thickness
picks, bottom
 
seam elevations
 
and raw
 
and washed
 
coal quality.
 
These data
 
files were
 
validated
prior to importing into the software.
 
Once imported, a geologic model was created, reviewed, and
verified with
 
a key
 
element being
 
a gridded model
 
of coal
 
seam thickness.
 
Resource tonnes
 
were
estimated by using the
 
seam thickness grid
 
based on each
 
valid point of observation
 
and by defining
resource confidence arcs around the
 
points of observation.
 
Points of observation for Measured
 
and
Indicated
 
confidence
 
arcs
 
were
 
defined
 
for
 
all
 
valid
 
drill
 
holes
 
that
 
intersected
 
the
 
seam
 
using
standards
 
deemed acceptable
 
by MM&A
 
based on
 
a detailed
 
geologic evaluation
 
and a
 
statistical
analysis
 
of
 
all
 
drill
 
holes
 
within
 
the
 
projected
 
reserve
 
areas
 
as
 
described
 
in
Section
 
11.1.1
.
 
The
geological
 
evaluation
 
incorporated
 
an
 
analysis
 
of
 
seam
 
thickness
 
related
 
to
 
depositional
environments, adjacent roof and floor lithologies, and structural influences.
After validating coal seam data and establishing correlations, the thickness and elevation for seams
of
 
economic
 
interest
 
were
 
used
 
to
 
generate
 
a
 
geologic
 
model.
 
Due
 
to
 
the
 
relative
 
structural
simplicity
 
of
 
the
 
deposits
 
and
 
the
 
reasonable
 
continuity
 
of
 
the
 
tabular
 
coal
 
beds,
 
the
 
principal
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
27
geological
 
interpretation
 
necessary
 
to
 
define
 
the
 
geometry
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
deposits
 
is
 
the
 
proper
modeling
 
of
 
their
 
thickness
 
and
 
elevation.
 
Both
 
coal
 
thickness
 
and
 
quality
 
data
 
are
 
deemed
 
by
MM&A to be reasonably sufficient within the resource areas.
 
Therefore, there is a reasonable level
of confidence in the geologic
 
interpretations required for coal resource determination based on the
available data and the techniques applied to the data.
Table 11-1
 
below provides the geological mapping and
 
coal tonnage estimation criteria used for the
coal resource
 
and reserve
 
evaluation.
 
These cut-off
 
parameters
 
have
 
been developed
 
by MM&A
based on
 
its experience
 
with the
 
Coronado properties
 
and are
 
typical of
 
mining operations
 
in the
Northern Appalachian Coal
 
Basin.
 
This experience includes
 
technical and economic
 
evaluations of
numerous
 
properties
 
in the
 
region
 
for
 
the
 
purposes of
 
determining
 
the
 
economic
 
viability of
 
the
subject coal reserves.
Table 11-1:
 
General Reserve and Resource Criteria
Item
Parameters
Technical Notes & Exceptions*
•
 
General Criteria
 
 
Reserve Classification
Reserve and Resource
Reliability Categories
Reserve (Proven and Probable)
To better reflect geological conditions of the coal
deposits, distance between points of observation are
standard USGS (in meters), respectively, for measured
and indicated and inferred.
Effective Date of Resource
Estimate
December 31, 2023
Effective Date of Reserve Estimate
December 31, 2023
Seam Density
Variable, dependent upon seam characteristics (based
on available drill hole quality).
 
In the absence of
laboratory data, estimated by (1) assuming specific
gravity of 1.30 for coal and 2.25 to 2.5 for rock
parting, or (2) 1280 kg/m3 to 1324 kg/m3 for a
"clean" seam)
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
28
Item
Parameters
Technical Notes & Exceptions*
•
 
Underground-Mineable Criteria
Map Thickness
Total seam thickness
Minimum Seam Thickness
1.2 meters (locally <1.2 m for limited areas integral
to the mine plan)
Pangburn was mapped at 0.92-meter cutoff in
conjunction with Coronado mine plan.
Minimum Mining Thickness
1.4 meters
Minimum In-Seam Wash
Recovery
40 percent
 
Wash Recovery Applied to Coal
Reserves
Based on average yield for drill holes within
reserve area, or in the absence of laboratory
washability data, based on estimated visual
recovery using specific gravities noted above and
95 percent yield on "clean" coal
Out-of-Seam Dilution Thickness
for Run-of-Mine Tonnes Applied
to Coal Reserves
0.05 meters minimum
2243 kg/m³ density used for dilution tonnage
estimate
Mine Barrier
61-meter distance from abandoned mines and
sealed or pillared areas.
Adjustments Applied to Coal
Reserves
6 percent moisture increase; 5 percent
preparation plant inefficiency
Note:
 
Exceptions for application of these criteria
 
to resource and reserve estimation are made
 
as warranted and demonstrated by either actual
mining experience or detailed data that allows for empirical evaluation
 
of mining conditions.
 
Final classification of coal reserve is made based
on the pre-feasibility evaluation.
11.1.1
 
Geostatistical Analysis
MM&A completed a
 
geostatistical analysis on drill
 
holes within
 
the reserve boundaries
 
to determine
the applicability of the common United States classification system for measured and indicated and
inferred coal resources.
 
Historically,
 
the United States has assumed that coal within 0.4-kilometers
of a point of
 
observation represents a measured resource whereas coal
 
between 0.4 kilometers and
1.2
 
kilometers
 
from
 
a
 
point
 
of
 
observation
 
is
 
classified
 
as
 
indicated.
 
Inferred
 
resources
 
are
commonly
 
assumed
 
to
 
be
 
located
 
between
 
1.2
 
kilometers
 
and
 
4.8
 
kilometers
 
from
 
a
 
point
 
of
observation.
 
Per
 
SEC
 
and
 
JORC
 
regulations,
 
only
 
measured
 
and
 
indicated
 
resources
 
may
 
be
considered for reserve classification, respectively
 
as proven and probable reserves.
MM&A
 
performed
 
a
 
geostatistical
 
analysis
 
test
 
of
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
data
 
set
 
using
 
the
 
Drill
 
Hole
Spacing Analysis
 
(DHSA) method.
 
This method
 
attempts to
 
quantify the
 
uncertainty of
 
applying a
measurement
 
from
 
a
 
central
 
location
 
to
 
increasingly
 
larger
 
square
 
blocks
 
and
 
provides
recommendations
 
for determining
 
the distances
 
between drill
 
holes for
 
measured, indicated,
 
and
inferred resources.
To
 
perform DHSA the data
 
set was processed to remove
 
any erroneous data points,
 
clustered data
points, as
 
well as
 
directional trends.
 
This was
 
achieved through
 
the use
 
of histograms,
 
as seen
 
in
Figure 11-1, color
 
coded scatter plots
 
showing the geospatial positioning of
 
the borings, Figure 11-
2, and trend analysis.
 
 
ex964p2i0 ex964p37i2 ex964p37i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
29
Figure
 
11-1:
 
Histogram
 
of
 
the
 
Total
 
Seam
 
Thickness
 
for
 
the
 
Upper
Freeport Seam Present in the Mon Valley Complex
Figure 11-2:
 
Scatter plot
 
of the
 
Total
 
Seam Thickness
 
for the
 
Upper
Freeport Seam Present in the Mon Valley Complex
Following the completion of
 
data processing, a variogram
 
of the data set was
 
created,
Figure 11-3
.
 
The
 
variogram
 
plots average
 
square difference
 
against
 
the separation
 
distance
 
between
 
the data
pairs.
 
The
 
separation
 
distance
 
is broken
 
up
 
into
 
separate
 
bins defined
 
by a
 
uniform
 
lag distance
(e.g., for
 
a lag
 
distance of
 
152 meters
 
the bins
 
would be
 
0 –
 
152 meters,
 
153 –
 
305 meters,
 
etc.).
 
Each pair of data points that are less than one lag distance apart are reported in the first bin.
 
If the
data
 
pair
 
is
 
further
 
apart
 
than
 
one
 
lag
 
distance
 
but
 
less
 
than
 
two
 
lag
 
distances
 
apart,
 
then
 
the
variance is reported in the second bin.
 
The numerical average for differences
 
reported for each bin
is then plotted on the variogram.
 
Care was taken to
 
define the lag distance in such a way
 
as to not
overestimate any nugget effect
 
present in the data set.
 
Lastly, modeled equations, often spherical,
gaussian, or
 
exponential, are
 
applied to
 
the variogram
 
in order
 
to represent
 
the data
 
set across
 
a
continuous spectrum.
 
 
ex964p2i0 ex964p38i1
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
30
Figure 11-3:
 
Variogram of the Total
 
Seam Thickness for the Upper Freeport Seam
 
Present in the Mon Valley Complex
The estimation
 
variance is
 
then calculated
 
using information
 
from the
 
modeled variogram
 
as well
as
 
charts
 
published
 
by
 
Journel
 
and
 
Huijbregts
 
(1978).
 
This
 
value
 
estimates
 
the
 
variance
 
from
applying
 
a
 
single
 
central
 
measurement
 
to
 
increasingly
 
larger
 
square
 
blocks.
 
Care
 
was
 
taken
 
to
ensure any nugget effect present was added back
 
into the data.
 
This process was repeated for each
test block size.
The final step of the process is to calculate the global estimation variance.
 
In this step,
 
the number
of square blocks that would fit inside the selected study area is determined
 
for each block size that
was
 
investigated
 
in the
 
previous
 
step.
 
The estimation
 
variance
 
is then
 
divided by
 
the number
 
of
blocks that
 
would fit
 
inside the
 
study area
 
for
 
each test
 
block size
 
.
 
Following this
 
determination,
the data is then transformed back to represent
 
the relative error in the 95th-percentile range.
Figure 11-4
 
shows the results
 
of the
 
DHSA performed on
 
the Upper Freeport
 
data for the
 
Mon Valley
Complex.
 
DHSA provides hole
 
to hole
 
spacing values,
 
these distances need
 
to be converted
 
to radius
from a central point in order to
 
compare to the historical standards
 
.
 
A summary of the radius data
is shown
 
in Table
 
11-2.
 
DHSA prescribes
 
measured, indicated,
 
and inferred
 
drill hole
 
spacings be
determined at the 10-percent, 20-percent, and 50-percent
 
levels of relative error,
 
respectively.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p39i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
31
Figure 11-4:
 
Result of DHSA for the Upper Freeport Seam Present in the Mon Valley Complex
Table 11-2:
 
DHSA Results Summary for Radius from a Central Point
Model:
Measured Radial Distance
(10% Relative Error)
Indicated Radial Distance
(20% Relative Error)
Inferred Radial Distance
(50% Relative Error)
(km)
(km)
(km)
Gaussian:
0.72
1.42
3.53
Spherical:
0.72
1.42
3.53
Exponential:
0.75
1.43
3.49
Comparing
 
the
 
results
 
of
 
the
 
DHSA
 
to
 
the
 
historical
 
standards,
 
it
 
is
 
evident
 
that
 
the
 
historical
standards
 
are
 
more
 
conservative
 
than
 
even
 
the
 
most
 
conservative
 
DHSA
 
model
 
with
 
regards
 
to
determining measured resources.
 
The Gaussian and Spherical
 
models recommend using a
 
radius of
0.72 kilometers
 
for
 
measured resources
 
compared to
 
the historical
 
value of
 
0.4 kilometers.
 
With
respect
 
to
 
indicated
 
resources
 
the
 
DHSA
 
falls
 
in
 
line
 
closely
 
with
 
the
 
historical
 
standards.
 
The
Exponential model recommends using a radius of 1.43
 
kilometers, while the Spherical and Gaussian
models recommend a radius of 1.42
 
kilometers, respectively.
 
These values line up closely with the
historical radius
 
of 1.2 kilometers.
 
These results have
 
led the QPs
 
to report the
 
data following
 
the
historical classification standards, rather
 
than use the results of the DHSA.
11.2
 
Qualified Person’s Estimates
Mineral
 
resources,
 
representing
 
in-situ
 
coal
 
from
 
a
 
portion
 
of
 
which
 
reserves
 
are
 
derived,
 
are
presented below.
 
Based on the work described and detailed modelling of the areas
 
considering all
the parameters
 
defined, a
 
coal resource
 
estimate,
 
summarized
 
in
Table
 
11-3
, was
 
prepared
 
as of
December 31, 2023, for property controlled by Coronado.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
32
Table 11-3:
 
Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2023
Coal Resource (Dry Tonnes, In Situ, Mt)
Resource Quality (Dry)
Area
Measured
Indicated
Inferred
Total
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Inclusive of Reserve
291.0
213.5
9.3
513.8
31
1.4
26
Exclusive of Reserve
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Total 12/31/2023
291.0
213.5
9.3
513.8
Note:
 
Resource tonnes are inclusive of reserve tonnes since they include the in-situ tonnes from which recoverable coal reserves are derived.
Note 2:
 
Coal resources are reported on a dry basis.
 
Surface moisture and inherent moisture are excluded.
Note 3: The Mon Valley properties do not have any resource tonnes exclusive of reserves as of December 31, 2023.
11.3
 
Qualified Person’s Opinion
While
 
there
 
is
 
some
 
level
 
of
 
stratigraphically
 
controlled
 
seam-thickness
 
variability
 
due
 
to
 
sand
channels,
 
etc.,
 
the
 
Upper
 
Freeport
 
coal
 
seam
 
on
 
the
 
mine
 
property
 
at
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
demonstrate
reasonable thickness consistency
 
according to
 
the classification system
 
of
measured
 
(0 kilometers
– 0.4
 
kilometers),
indicated
 
(0.4 kilometers
 
to 1.2
 
kilometers),
 
and
inferred
 
(1.2 kilometers
 
to 4.8
kilometers).
 
MM&A geologists and
 
engineers modeled
 
the deposit
 
and delineated
 
mineable regions
to
 
reflect
 
the nature
 
of each
 
seam and
 
the practicality
 
of mining
 
constraints.
 
Based on
 
MM&A’s
geostatistical
 
analysis,
 
it
 
would
 
be
 
possible
 
to
 
extend
 
the
 
measured,
 
indicated
 
and
 
inferred
 
arcs
slightly beyond
 
historically accepted
 
practices due to
 
consistent geological
 
settings.
 
The QPs have
again
 
elected
 
not
 
to
 
extend
 
arc
 
distances,
 
introducing
 
a
 
level
 
of
 
conservatism
 
in
 
measured
 
and
indicated coal classification.
Based on the data
 
review,
 
the attendant work
 
done to verify the data
 
integrity and the creation
 
of
an
 
independent
 
geologic model,
 
the
 
QPs
 
believe
 
this
 
is a
 
fair
 
and
 
accurate
 
representation
 
of the
Mon Valley coal resources.
12
 
Mineral Reserve Estimates
12.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
Coal Reserves are classified
 
as proven or probable
 
considering “modifying factors” including mining,
metallurgical, economic, marketing, legal,
 
environmental, social, and governmental
 
factors.
>
Proven
 
Coal
 
Reserves
 
are
 
the
 
economically
 
mineable
 
part
 
of
 
a
 
measured
 
coal
 
resource,
adjusted
 
for diluting
 
materials and
 
allowances for
 
losses when
 
the material
 
is mined.
 
It is
based
 
on
 
appropriate
 
assessment
 
and
 
studies
 
in
 
consideration
 
of
 
and
 
adjusted
 
for
reasonably
 
assumed
 
modifying
 
factors.
 
These
 
assessments
 
demonstrate
 
that
 
extraction
could be reasonably justified at the time of reporting.
 
>
Probable Coal
 
Reserves
 
are the
 
economically mineable
 
part of
 
an indicated
 
coal resource,
and
 
in
 
some circumstances
 
a
 
measured
 
coal
 
resource,
 
adjusted
 
for
 
diluting
 
materials
 
and
allowances for losses when
 
the material is
 
mined.
 
It is based
 
on appropriate assessment and
studies in
 
consideration of
 
and adjusted
 
for reasonably
 
assumed modifying factors.
 
These
assessments
 
demonstrate
 
that
 
extraction
 
could
 
be
 
reasonably
 
justified
 
at
 
the
 
time
 
of
reporting.
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
33
Upon completion of delineation
 
and calculation of coal
 
resources, MM&A generated a LOM plan
 
for
each of the projected
 
mines within the Mon Valley
 
Complex.
 
The footprint of
 
each reserve area
 
is
shown on the maps
 
in Appendix B.
 
The mine plans
 
were generated based on the forecast mine plan
and
 
permit
 
plan
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
with
 
modifications
 
by
 
MM&A
 
where
 
necessary
 
due
 
to
current
 
property
 
control
 
limits,
 
modifications
 
to
 
geologic
 
mapping,
 
or
 
other
 
factors
 
determined
during the evaluation.
Carlson Mining
 
software was
 
used to
 
generate
 
the LOM
 
plan for
 
Mon Valley.
 
The mine
 
plan was
sequenced
 
based
 
on
 
productivity
 
schedules
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
MM&A
 
determined
 
the
productivity
 
estimates
 
and
 
plans
 
to
 
be
 
reasonable
 
based
 
on
 
experience
 
and
 
current
 
industry
practice.
At
 
the Mon
 
Valley
 
mines, a
 
minimum mining
 
height
 
of 1.4
 
meters
 
was
 
generally
 
used due
 
to the
continuous mining method
 
being employed;
 
however, Pangburn was mapped at
 
a 0.92-meter cutoff
in
 
conjunction
 
with
 
the
 
Coronado
 
mine
 
plan.
 
For
 
coal
 
seams
 
thinner
 
than
 
the
 
assigned
 
mining
height, the difference between the coal seam height and assigned mining height consists of out-of-
seam
 
dilution
 
(OSD).
 
Mine
 
recovery
 
generally
 
varies
 
between
 
40
 
percent
 
and
 
55
 
percent
 
for
continuous mining panels.
 
Plant recovery is
 
a function
 
of in-seam
 
recovery, OSD and plant efficiency
factor,
 
which is set at 95 percent.
 
Typical entry width is 5.8 meters.
Raw,
 
ROM
 
production
 
data
 
outputs
 
from
 
LOM
 
plan
 
sequencing
 
were
 
processed
 
into
 
Microsoft®
EXCEL spreadsheets
 
and summarized
 
on an
 
annual basis
 
for processing
 
into the
 
economic model.
 
Average seam densities were
 
estimated to determine raw
 
coal tonnes produced
 
from the LOM
 
plan.
 
Average mine recovery
 
and wash recovery factors were
 
applied to determine coal reserve tonnes.
 
Coal
 
reserve
 
tonnes
 
in
 
this
 
evaluation
 
are
 
reported
 
at
 
a
 
6.0
 
percent
 
moisture
 
and
 
represent
 
the
saleable product from the Property.
 
Pricing
 
data
 
as
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
is
 
described
 
in
 
Section
 
16.2.
 
The
 
pricing
 
data
 
assumes
 
a
blended HVB
 
domestic and
 
export FOB-mine
 
nominal price
 
of $164
 
per metric
 
tonne for
 
calendar
year
 
2029.
 
HVB
 
domestic
 
and
 
export
 
prices
 
respectively
 
are
 
increased
 
by
 
2%
 
annual
 
inflation
thereafter.
The coal resource mapping and estimation process, described in the report, was
 
used as a basis for
the coal reserve
 
estimate.
 
Proven and
 
probable coal
 
reserves were
 
derived from
 
the defined coal
resource
 
considering
 
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
technical
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
revenue, and cost), marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors and are
presented on a moist, recoverable
 
basis.
As is customary
 
in the USA, the categories
 
for proven
 
and probable coal reserves
 
are based on the
distances
 
from
 
valid
 
points
 
of
 
measurement
 
as
 
determined
 
by
 
the
 
QPs
 
for
 
the
 
area
 
under
consideration.
 
For this
 
evaluation, measured
 
resource, which
 
may convert
 
to a
 
proven reserve,
 
is
based on a 0.4-kilometer radius from a valid point of observation.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
34
Points
 
of observation
 
include exploration
 
drill holes,
 
degas holes,
 
and mine
 
measurements which
have been fully vetted
 
and processed into a
 
geologic model.
 
The geologic model is based on seam
depositional modeling, the
 
interrelationship of overlying and
 
underlying strata on seam mineability,
seam thickness trends,
 
the impact of seam
 
structure (i.e., faulting),
 
intra-seam characteristics,
 
etc.
 
Once
 
the
 
geologic
 
model
 
was
 
completed,
 
a
 
statistical
 
analysis,
 
described
 
in
 
Section
 
11.1.1
 
was
conducted
 
and
 
a
 
0.4-kilometer
 
radius
 
from
 
a
 
valid
 
point
 
of
 
observation
 
was
 
selected
 
to
 
define
Measured Resources.
 
Likewise,
 
the distance
 
between 0.4
 
and 1.2 of
 
a kilometer
 
radius was
 
selected to
 
define Indicated
Resources.
 
Indicated Resources may convert
 
to Probable Reserves
 
Inferred Resources (greater
 
than a 1.2-kilometer radius from a valid point of observation) are to be
excluded from Reserve consideration.
12.2
 
Qualified Person’s Estimates
Reserve tonnage
 
estimates provided
 
herein report
 
coal reserves
 
derived from
 
the in-situ resource
tons presented in
Table 11-3
, and not in addition to coal resources.
 
Coal reserves are presented on
a ROM basis in
Table
 
12-1
.
 
Proven and probable
 
coal reserves were
 
derived from the defined
 
coal
resource considering
 
relevant mining,
 
processing, infrastructure,
 
economic (including estimates
 
of
capital, revenue, and cost), marketing,
 
legal, environmental, socioeconomic and regulatory
 
factors.
 
The coal reserves, as shown in
Table 12-2
, are based on a technical evaluation of the geology and a
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
study
 
of
 
the
 
coal
 
deposits.
 
The
 
extent
 
to
 
which
 
the
 
coal
 
reserves
 
may
 
be
affected
 
by any
 
known environmental,
 
permitting, legal,
 
title, socioeconomic,
 
marketing, political,
or other relevant issues has been reviewed
 
rigorously.
 
Similarly, the extent
 
to which the estimates
of
 
coal
 
reserves
 
may
 
be
 
materially
 
affected
 
by
 
mining,
 
metallurgical,
 
infrastructure
 
and
 
other
relevant factors
 
has also been considered.
Table 12-1:
 
Coal Summary (ROM Basis (Moist)) as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Mt, Moist ROM)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Quality (Dry)
Area / Mine
Proved
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Ash
Sulfur
Vol
Mon Valley
113.9
83.2
197.1
0.0
197.1
195.7
1.4
37
1.4
23
Table 12-2:
 
Coal Reserves Summary (Marketable Sales Basis) as of December 31, 2023 (Mt)
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet Ton
 
nes, Washed or Direct Shipped, Mt)
Quality (Dry Basis)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Property
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Mon Valley
77.8
56.6
134.4
0.0
134.4
133.4
1.0
8
1.4
35
 
Note: Marketable reserve tonnes are reported on a moist
 
basis, including a combination of
 
surface and inherent moisture.
 
The combination of
surface and inherent
 
moisture is
 
modeled at 6-percent.
 
Actual product
 
moisture is dependent
 
upon multiple geological
 
factors, operational
factors, and product contract
 
specifications and can exceed
 
8-percent.
 
As such, the modeled moisture
 
values provide a level
 
of conservatism
for reserve reporting.
The
 
results
 
of
 
this
 
TRS
 
define
 
an
 
estimated
 
134.4
 
Mt
 
of
 
proven
 
and
 
probable
 
marketable
 
coal
reserves.
 
Of that total, 58 percent are proven, and 42 percent are probable.
 
There are 133.4 Mt of
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
35
owned
 
coal
 
reserves
 
and
 
1.0
 
Mt
 
of
 
leased
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
All
 
of
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
reserves
 
are
considered
 
to
 
be
 
suitable
 
for
 
the
 
metallurgical
 
coal
 
market.
 
All
 
of
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
reserves
 
are
unassigned.
12.3
 
Qualified Person’s Opinion
The
 
estimate
 
of coal
 
reserves was
 
determined
 
in accordance
 
with the
 
JORC
 
Code along
 
with SEC
Regulation S-K 1300.
The LOM
 
mining plans
 
for Mon
 
Valley
 
were prepared
 
to the
 
level of
 
preliminary feasibility.
 
Mine
projections
 
were
 
prepared,
 
and
 
timing
 
scheduled
 
to
 
match
 
production
 
with
 
coal
 
seam
characteristics.
 
Production timing
 
was carried
 
out from
 
current locations
 
to depletion
 
of the
 
coal
reserve
 
area.
 
Coal reserve
 
estimates
 
could be
 
materially
 
affected
 
by the
 
risk factors
 
described in
Section 22.2.
Based on the Preliminary Feasibility Study
 
and the attendant Economic Review, the QPs believe this
is a fair and accurate calculation of the Mon Valley
 
coal reserves.
13
 
Mining Methods
Three separate underground mine areas were modeled and tested economically
 
for the Mon Valley
Complex.
 
Once the Resources were calculated,
 
mine plans were created to
 
project operating each
resource
 
area to
 
depletion, with
 
crews
 
and equipment
 
scheduled to
 
move
 
to
 
subsequent
 
mining
areas as depletion occurs.
 
Underground mine operations are projected to
 
be exhausted in 2101.
13.1
 
Geotech and Hydrology
Mining
 
plans
 
for
 
potential
 
underground
 
mines
 
were
 
developed
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
MM&A.
 
Pillar
stability
 
was
 
tested
 
by
 
MM&A
 
using the
 
Analysis
 
of
 
Coal
 
Pillar
 
Stability
 
(ACPS)
 
program
 
that
 
was
developed by the
National Institute for Occupational Safety and
 
Health (
NIOSH
)
.
 
MM&A reviewed
the results from the ACPS analysis and considered them in the development of the LOM plan.
Hydrology is not
 
expected to be
 
an issue of concern at
 
Mon Valley.
 
Extensive mining has occurred
in the Pittsburgh seam,
 
183 meters above the Upper
 
Freeport horizon.
 
The Upper Freeport coal
 
has
been mined
 
in the
 
region—based on
 
successful historical
 
mining in
 
comparable
 
geologic settings,
material impacts related to hydrology
 
are not anticipated to be of concern.
13.2
 
Production Rates
The Mon Valley Complex is not
 
yet active, with three
 
distinct mines and preparation plants
 
planned.
 
The
 
mine
 
plan
 
and
 
productivity
 
expectations
 
reflect
 
historical
 
performance
 
of
 
similar
 
operations
and efforts have been made to adjust the
 
plan to reflect future conditions.
 
MM&A is confident that
the mine plan
 
is reasonably representative to provide
 
an accurate estimation of
 
coal reserves.
 
Mine
development and operation has not been optimized within the TRS.
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
36
Production
 
is
 
scheduled
 
for
 
approximately
 
273
 
days
 
each
 
year,
 
which
 
represents
 
production
 
on
Monday through
 
Friday plus
 
every other
 
Saturday with
 
allowances for
 
holidays.
 
On each day,
 
the
continuous mining sections
 
are scheduled to
 
produce coal on
 
two shifts; the third
 
shift is reserved
for
 
maintenance
 
and
 
mine
 
conveyor
 
belt
 
and
 
power
 
moves.
 
The
 
sections
 
are
 
configured
 
as
 
full
super sections with
 
two continuous
 
miners per
 
section.
 
Productivity is
 
planned at
 
the rate
 
of 272
meters of advance per shift for the super sections.
Carlson Mining software was used
 
by MM&A to generate mine plans
 
for the underground mineable
coal
 
seam.
 
Mine
 
plans
 
were
 
sequenced
 
based
 
on
 
productivity
 
schedules
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado,
which
 
were
 
based
 
on
 
historically
 
achieved
 
productivity
 
levels.
 
All
 
production
 
forecasting
 
ties
assumed production rates
 
to geological models as
 
constructed by MM&A’s
 
team of geologists
 
and
mining engineers.
As shown in
Table
 
13-1
, the areas
 
planned for
 
underground mines
 
produce coal
 
until 2101.
 
Clean
coal production varies directly with coal thickness.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
37
Table 13-1:
 
Production Summary by Mine by Year (Tonnes
 
x 1,000)
Mine Name
2032
2033
2034
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
Pangburn
0
399
1,810
1,875
1,958
2,029
2,030
1,695
Fallowfield
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shaner
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
367
 
Total
0
399
1,810
1,875
1,958
2,029
2,030
2,062
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2040
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
2046
2047
Pangburn
1,339
637
603
0
0
0
0
0
Fallowfield
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shaner
620
1,125
1,763
1,804
1,724
1,717
1,641
1,719
 
Total
1,960
1,762
2,366
1,804
1,724
1,717
1,641
1,719
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2048
2049
2050
2051
2052
2053
2054
2055
Pangburn
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Fallowfield
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shaner
1,657
1,582
1,704
1,656
1,732
1,702
1,596
1,642
 
Total
1,657
1,582
1,704
1,656
1,732
1,702
1,596
1,642
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2056
2057
2058
2059
2060
2061
2062
2063
Pangburn
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Fallowfield
0
0
859
1,786
2,010
1,999
1,987
1,820
Shaner
1,750
1,751
1,750
1,796
1,723
1,839
1,775
1,674
 
Total
1,750
1,751
2,609
3,582
3,732
3,839
3,762
3,494
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2064
2065
2066
2067
2068
2069
2070
2071
Pangburn
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Fallowfield
1,657
1,855
1,893
1,900
1,869
1,862
1,707
1,783
Shaner
1,733
1,605
1,504
1,067
957
610
612
395
 
Total
3,390
3,460
3,398
2,967
2,826
2,472
2,318
2,178
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2072
2073
2074
2075
2076
2077
2078
2079
Pangburn
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Fallowfield
1,496
2,041
1,993
1,822
1,903
1,864
1,911
1,708
Shaner
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
 
Total
1,496
2,041
1,993
1,822
1,903
1,864
1,911
1,708
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2080
2081
2082
2083
2084
2085
2086
2087
Pangburn
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Fallowfield
1,931
1,757
1,563
2,034
1,423
2,073
1,485
1,798
Shaner
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
 
Total
1,931
1,757
1,563
2,034
1,423
2,073
1,485
1,798
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2088
2089
2090
2091
2092
2093
2094
2095
Pangburn
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Fallowfield
1,340
1,684
1,466
1,808
1,184
1,485
1,462
1,584
Shaner
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
 
Total
1,340
1,684
1,466
1,808
1,184
1,485
1,462
1,584
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mine Name
2096
2097
2098
2099
2100
2101
2102
2103
Pangburn
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Fallowfield
1,229
1,570
1,590
1,277
813
356
0
0
Shaner
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
 
Total
1,229
1,570
1,590
1,277
813
356
0
0
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
38
13.3
 
Mining Related Requirements
A mine plan with
 
sequenced mining projections was prepared for each logical
 
mining unit.
 
For each
mine
 
plan,
 
the
 
appropriate
 
number
 
of
 
production
 
units
 
is
 
selected
 
for
 
the
 
resource
 
area,
 
and
 
a
productivity
 
level
 
assigned,
 
expressed
 
in
 
meters
 
of
 
advance
 
per
 
unit-shift
 
of
 
production.
 
The
productivity is
 
based on
 
the equipment
 
and personnel
 
configuration,
 
mining height
 
and expected
physical conditions.
13.4
 
Required Equipment and Personnel
Production
 
from
 
the proposed
 
Mon Valley
 
Complex
 
mines will
 
be conducted
 
using the
 
room
 
and
pillar method,
 
utilizing continuous miners
 
and haulage
 
using shuttle cars
 
to a
 
feeder-breaker located
at the
 
tail of
 
the section
 
conveyor
 
belt.
 
The feeder-breaker
 
crushes large
 
pieces of
 
coal and
 
rock
and regulates coal feed onto the mine conveyor.
 
Roof-bolting machines will be used to support
 
the
roof
 
on the
 
continuous miner
 
sections.
 
Roof-bolting
 
machines are
 
used to
 
install
 
roof
 
bolts,
 
and
battery scoops are available to clean the
 
mine entries and assist
 
in delivery of mine
 
supplies to work
areas.
 
Other
 
supplemental
 
equipment,
 
such
 
as
 
personnel
 
carriers,
 
supply
 
vehicles,
 
etc.,
 
are
 
also
planned to be used daily.
Mine conveyors typically range in width
 
up to 1.5
 
meters.
 
Multiple belt flights
 
are arranged in series
to deliver raw coal to the underground storage.
 
Along the main and sub-main entries and panels, a
travel way
 
will be provided
 
for personnel
 
and materials by
 
rubber-tired equipment
 
or on rail.
 
The
Mon
 
Valley
 
mines
 
will
 
use
 
conveyors
 
to
 
transport
 
ROM
 
coal
 
from
 
the
 
underground
 
production
sections to the surface
 
where the coal may
 
be sampled, crushed, washed in
 
the preparation plant,
and stockpiled to await shipment.
 
Surface ventilation
 
fans are planned
 
to be installed
 
as needed to provide
 
a sufficient volume
 
of air
to ventilate
 
production sections, coal haulage
 
and transport entries, battery
 
charging stations, and
transformers in accordance with approved
 
plans.
 
High-voltage cables will deliver
 
power throughout
the
 
mine
 
where
 
transformers
 
reduce
 
voltage
 
for
 
specific
 
equipment
 
requirements.
 
The
 
Mine
Improvement
 
and
 
New
 
Emergency
 
Response
 
Act
 
of
 
2006
 
(MINER
 
Act)
 
requires
 
that
 
carbon
monoxide
 
detection
 
systems
 
be install
 
ed along
 
mine
 
conveyor
 
belts
 
and that
 
electronic
 
two-way
tracking
 
and
 
communications
 
systems
 
be
 
installed
 
throughout
 
underground
 
mines.
 
Water
 
is
required
 
to
 
control
 
dust
 
at
 
production
 
sections
 
and
 
along
 
conveyor
 
belts,
 
and
 
to
 
cool
 
electric
motors.
 
Water
 
is available
 
from nearby
 
sources and
 
is distributed
 
within the mine
 
by pipelines as
required.
13.4.1
 
Mine:
 
Pangburn
The Pangburn mine is proposed to start in
 
2033 with three continuous mining sections.
 
The Upper
Freeport
 
seam
 
will
 
be
 
accessed
 
via
 
decline
 
slope
 
and
 
vertical
 
shaft.
 
This
 
mine
 
will
 
produce
metallurgical coal from leased and owned mineral.
Production
 
is
 
scheduled
 
for
 
approximately
 
273
 
days
 
each
 
year,
 
which
 
represents
 
production
 
on
Monday
 
through
 
Friday
 
and
 
every
 
other
 
Saturday.
 
On
 
each
 
day,
 
three
 
production
 
sections
 
are
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
39
scheduled
 
to
 
produce
 
coal
 
on
 
two
 
shifts;
 
the
 
third
 
shift
 
is
 
reserved
 
for
 
maintenance
 
and
 
mine
conveyor belt and
 
power moves.
 
Each section
 
is configured as
 
full supersection
 
with two
 
continuous
miners available
 
for production.
 
Productivity is
 
planned at
 
the rate
 
of 272
 
meters of
 
advance per
shift for the super sections.
 
A total of 203 employees are assigned to the mine.
Principal production equipment on
 
each section includes two continuous
 
miners, two roof
 
bolters,
four
 
shuttle cars,
 
and two
 
scoops.
 
Coal is
 
planned to
 
be extracted
 
from the
 
production face
 
with
the continuous
 
miner and
 
hauled to
 
the mine
 
conveyor
 
in shuttle
 
cars.
 
At
 
the conveyor
 
belt, the
coal will be discharged
 
from the shuttle
 
cars onto a
 
feeder breaker
 
for transfer
 
onto the conveyor.
 
The
 
conveyors
 
will
 
carry
 
the
 
coal
 
outside,
 
where
 
it
 
is
 
planned
 
to
 
be
 
transported
 
via
 
overland
conveyor
 
to
 
the
 
proposed
 
Pangburn
 
preparation
 
plant
 
and
 
barge
 
load-out
 
on
 
the
 
Monongahela
River.
 
Rail access is expected to be provided by a CSX rail line.
The proposed Pangburn mine will be located approximately 1.6 kilometers south of the community
of Elizabeth,
 
Pennsylvania.
 
Main paved
 
roads exist
 
both east
 
and west
 
of the
 
site.
 
The proposed
dock, located on the western boundary of the
 
proposed Pangburn permit area, is currently used for
bulk material transshipment.
 
The area has hosted
 
both industrial and residential
 
development for
an
 
extensive
 
time
 
period.
 
No
 
extraordinary
 
measures
 
or
 
expenses
 
will
 
be
 
required
 
to
 
establish
infrastructure or utilities at the Pangburn site.
 
The
 
preliminary
 
design
 
for
 
the
 
Pangburn
 
mine
 
surface
 
facilities
 
was
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
The
facilities include offices, warehouses,
 
shops, and a bathhouse for personnel;
 
a preparation plant to
process ROM coal;
 
a refuse area
 
with a
 
designed capacity of
 
approximately 35 million refuse tonnes;
raw coal storage at the plant totaling
 
approximated 100,000 tonnes, clean coal storage
 
at the plant
site of
 
approximately
 
54,000 tonnes,
 
and three
 
clean coal
 
stockpiles adjacent
 
to the
 
dock loading
facility
 
on
 
the
 
Monongahela
 
River.
 
The
 
three
 
river
 
stockpiles
 
have
 
a
 
designed
 
capacity
 
of
approximately 266,000 tonnes.
A
 
study
 
completed
 
and
 
approved
 
through
 
the
 
Pennsylvania
 
Department
 
of
 
Environmental
Protection
 
on
 
behalf
 
of
 
Coronado
 
has
 
identified
 
a
 
Preferred
 
Site
 
for
 
refuse
 
disposal
 
at
 
Pangburn
with
 
capacity
 
of
 
22.6 million
 
cubic
 
meters.
 
MM&A’s
 
estimated
 
requirements
 
for
 
Pangburn
 
and
Shaner combined is 29.7 million tonnes or approximately 13.2 million cubic meters.
The preliminary design layout of the Pangburn facilities is shown
Figure 13-1.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
ex964p48i1
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
40
Figure 13-1:
 
Proposed Pangburn Plant and Mine Site Infrastructure
13.4.2
 
Mine: Shaner
The
 
Shaner
 
mine
 
is
 
a
 
proposed
 
mine
 
in
 
the
 
Upper
 
Freeport
 
seam
 
and
 
is
 
scheduled
 
to
 
begin
production in 2039 as the Pangburn reserve is depleted.
 
This mine is a metallurgical coal operation
on leased and owned mineral property.
Production
 
is
 
scheduled
 
for
 
approximately
 
273
 
days
 
each
 
year,
 
which
 
represents
 
production
 
on
Monday
 
through
 
Friday
 
and
 
every
 
other
 
Saturday.
 
On
 
each
 
day,
 
three
 
production
 
sections
 
are
scheduled
 
to
 
produce
 
coal
 
on
 
two
 
shifts;
 
the
 
third
 
shift
 
is
 
reserved
 
for
 
maintenance
 
and
 
mine
conveyor
 
belt
 
and
 
power
 
moves.
 
All
 
three
 
sections
 
are
 
full
 
super
 
sections
 
with
 
two
 
continuous
miners per
 
section.
 
Productivity is
 
planned at
 
the rate
 
of 272
 
meters of
 
advance per
 
shift for
 
the
super sections.
 
A total of 203 employees are assigned to the mine.
Principal production equipment per section includes two continuous miners,
 
two roof bolters, four
shuttle
 
cars,
 
and two
 
scoops.
 
Coal is
 
planned to
 
be extracted
 
from
 
the production
 
face
 
with the
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
41
continuous miner
 
and hauled to
 
the mine conveyor
 
in shuttle
 
cars.
 
At the
 
conveyor belt,
 
the coal
will be
 
discharged onto
 
a feeder
 
breaker
 
for transfer
 
onto the
 
conveyor.
 
The conveyors
 
will carry
the coal to the outside and to the proposed preparation
 
plant and load-out.
The Shaner
 
mine will
 
be located approximately 1.6
 
kilometers north of
 
the community
 
of Sutersville,
Pennsylvania,
 
between
 
the
 
Youghiogheny
 
and
 
Monongahela
 
Rivers.
 
Numerous
 
improved
 
roads
traverse the Property.
 
An additional shaft
 
and slope will
 
be required to access
 
Upper Freeport seam
reserves
 
west of
 
the Monongahela
 
River,
 
accessed across
 
the 1st
 
Street bridge
 
and Douglass
 
Run
Road.
 
The
 
immediate
 
vicinity
 
of
 
the
 
proposed
 
Shaner
 
surface
 
facilities
 
is
 
well
 
developed;
 
no
extraordinary
 
measures
 
or
 
expenses
 
will be
 
required
 
to
 
establish
 
infrastructure
 
or utilities
 
at
 
the
Fallowfield
 
site.
 
Due
 
to
 
the
 
projected
 
starting
 
date
 
for
 
the
 
Shaner
 
mine,
 
no
 
detailed
 
design
 
of
infrastructure or
 
surface facilities has
 
been completed to date.
 
The proposed mines are
 
located in
the
 
Appalachian
 
Basin,
 
which
 
has
 
an
 
extensive
 
history
 
(>100
 
years)
 
of
 
coal
 
mining.
 
There
 
is
 
a
sufficient population base
 
within commuting
 
distance of
 
the proposed
 
operations; no Camp
 
or Town
construction
 
will
 
be
 
required.
 
Mine
 
opening
 
capital
 
expenditures
 
are
 
included
 
in
 
the
 
MM&A
financial model.
Due to the projected start-up
 
date of the Shaner
 
mine, no permit work
 
has been completed to date.
 
The proposed mine
 
is located in
 
an area with
 
a long
 
history of coal
 
mining, with
 
numerous permitted
operations in close proximity.
 
Coal mining permits are routinely obtained in this region; a 2-year to
3-year
 
lead time
 
is recommended.
 
Estimated
 
expenditures for
 
mine closure
 
and site
 
reclamation
are included in the financial model for each mine or plant site.
Infrastructure for Shaner will resemble that
 
shown in Figure 13-1 for Pangburn.
13.4.3
 
Mine: Fallowfield
The
 
Fallowfield
 
mine
 
is
 
proposed
 
to
 
start
 
in
 
2058
 
with
 
three
 
production
 
sections.
 
The
 
Upper
Freeport
 
seam
 
will
 
be
 
accessed
 
via
 
a
 
decline
 
slope
 
and
 
vertical
 
shaft.
 
This
 
mine
 
will
 
be
 
a
metallurgical coal operation on leased and owned mineral
 
property.
Production
 
is
 
scheduled
 
for
 
approximately
 
273
 
days
 
each
 
year,
 
which
 
represents
 
production
 
on
Monday
 
through
 
Friday
 
and
 
every
 
other
 
Saturday.
 
On
 
each
 
day,
 
three
 
production
 
sections
 
are
scheduled
 
to
 
produce
 
coal
 
on
 
two
 
shifts;
 
the
 
third
 
shift
 
is
 
reserved
 
for
 
maintenance
 
and
 
mine
conveyor belt and power
 
moves.
 
The sections are
 
configured as super sections
 
with two continuous
miners available
 
for production.
 
Productivity is
 
planned at
 
the rate
 
of 272
 
meters of
 
advance per
shift of operation.
 
A total of 203 employees are assigned to the mine.
Principal production equipment includes
 
two continuous miners, two roof bolters, four shuttle
 
cars,
and
 
two
 
scoops.
 
Coal
 
is
 
planned
 
to
 
be
 
extracted
 
from
 
the
 
production
 
face
 
with
 
the
 
continuous
miner
 
and
 
hauled
 
to
 
the
 
mine
 
conveyor
 
in
 
shuttle
 
cars.
 
At
 
the
 
conveyor
 
belt,
 
the
 
coal
 
will
 
be
discharged
 
from
 
the
 
shuttle
 
cars
 
onto
 
a
 
feeder
 
breaker
 
for
 
transfer
 
onto
 
the
 
conveyor.
 
The
conveyors
 
will
 
carry
 
the
 
coal
 
outside,
 
where
 
it
 
is
 
transported
 
to
 
the
 
proposed
 
Fallowfield
preparation plant and truck load-out via overland conveyor.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
42
The
 
Fallowfield
 
property
 
boundary
 
is
 
traversed
 
by
 
the
 
four-lane
 
limited-access
 
Mon-Fayette
Expressway in addition
 
to numerous improved
 
roads.
 
Previous mining and
 
coal preparation facilities
have
 
existed
 
in
 
the
 
immediate
 
vicinity
 
of
 
the
 
proposed
 
Fallowfield
 
surface
 
facilities.
 
No
extraordinary
 
measures
 
or
 
expenses
 
will be
 
required
 
to
 
establish
 
infrastructure
 
or utilities
 
at
 
the
Fallowfield site.
 
Due to the
 
projected starting
 
date for
 
the Fallowfield
 
mine, no detailed
 
design of
infrastructure or
 
surface facilities has
 
been completed to date.
 
The proposed mines are
 
located in
the Appalachian
 
Basin, which
 
has an
 
extensive history (greater than
 
100 years) of
 
coal mining.
 
There
is a sufficient population
 
base within commuting distance
 
of the proposed operations;
 
no Camp or
Town
 
construction will be required.
 
Mine opening capital expenditures are
 
included in the MM&A
financial model.
Due to the projected
 
start-up date of
 
the Fallowfield mine, no permit
 
work has been completed
 
to
date.
 
The proposed
 
mine is
 
located
 
in an
 
area with
 
a long
 
history of
 
coal mining,
 
with numerous
permitted
 
operations
 
in
 
close
 
proximity.
 
Coal
 
mining
 
permits
 
are
 
routinely
 
obtained;
 
a
 
two-
 
to
three-year
 
lead
 
time
 
is
 
recommended.
 
Estimated
 
expenditures
 
for
 
mine
 
closure
 
and
 
site
reclamation are included in the financial model for each mine or plant site.
Infrastructure for Fallowfield
 
will resemble that shown in Figure 13-1 for Pangburn.
14
 
Processing and Recovery Methods
14.1
 
Description or Flowsheet
Due
 
to
 
the
 
projected
 
starting
 
date
 
for
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
Complex,
 
only
 
preliminary
 
design
 
of
preparation
 
plant
 
or
 
associated
 
material
 
handling
 
facilities
 
has
 
been
 
initiated
 
to
 
date.
 
Coal
processing
 
is
 
a
 
well
 
understood
 
science—it
 
is
 
anticipated
 
that
 
typical
 
coal
 
sizing,
 
cleaning
 
and
dewatering
 
equipment
 
will
 
be
 
utilized
 
for
 
processing
 
of
 
run-of-mine
 
coal
 
at
 
Pangburn,
 
including
combinations of
 
vibratory screens,
 
classifying cyclones, heavy
 
media baths, heavy
 
media cyclones,
spirals,
 
froth
 
flotation,
 
and
 
drain-and-rinse
 
screens,
 
screen-bowl
 
centrifuges,
 
among
 
others.
 
No
novel technologies will be required to process run-of-mine
 
material.
 
14.2
 
Requirements for Energy,
 
Water,
 
Material and Personnel
The Mon Valley property has sources
 
of water,
 
power,
 
personnel, and supplies readily available for
use.
 
Personnel
 
have
 
historically
 
been
 
sourced
 
from
 
the
 
surrounding
 
communities
 
in
 
Allegheny,
Washington, and
 
Westmoreland Counties, and have
 
proven to be adequate
 
in numbers to operate
the mines.
 
As mining is common in the surrounding
 
areas, the workforce
 
is generally familiar
 
with
mining practices, and
 
many are experienced
 
miners.
 
Water is
 
expected to be
 
sourced locally from
nearby public
 
water
 
sources or
 
rivers.
 
Electricity is
 
anticipated
 
to be
 
sourced from
 
West
 
Penn or
Duquesne
 
Light.
 
The
 
service
 
industry
 
in
 
the
 
areas
 
surrounding
 
the
 
proposed
 
mine
 
complex
 
has
historically
 
provided
 
supplies,
 
equipment
 
repairs
 
and
 
fabrication,
 
etc.
 
Barge
 
transport
 
on
 
the
Monongahela River/Ohio River
 
system will
 
serve as the main means
 
of product transport from
 
the
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
43
mine,
 
and
 
currently
 
serve
 
as
 
a
 
means
 
of
 
coal
 
transportation
 
for
 
neighboring
 
Pittsburgh
 
seam
operations.
15
 
Infrastructure
Due
 
to
 
the
 
projected
 
starting
 
date
 
for
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
mines,
 
only
 
conceptual
 
design
 
of
infrastructure and surface facilities has been completed
 
to date.
 
The proposed Pangburn mine will be located approximately 1.6 kilometers south of the community
of Elizabeth, PA.
 
Main paved roads exist both
 
east and west of
 
the site.
 
The proposed dock, located
on the western boundary of the proposed Pangburn permit area, is currently used for bulk material
transhipment.
 
The area
 
has hosted
 
both industrial
 
and residential
 
development
 
for
 
an extensive
time period.
 
No extraordinary measures or expenses will be
 
required to establish infrastructure
 
or
utilities at the Pangburn site.
 
The Shaner
 
mine will
 
be located approximately 1.6
 
kilometers north of
 
the community
 
of Sutersville,
PA,
 
between the Youghiogheny
 
and Monongahela Rivers.
 
Numerous improved
 
roads traverse
 
the
Property.
 
An additional
 
shaft and
 
slope will
 
be required
 
to access
 
Upper Freeport
 
seam reserves
west of the Monongahela River,
 
accessed across the 1st Street bridge and Douglass Run Road.
 
The
immediate
 
vicinity
 
of
 
the
 
proposed
 
Shaner
 
surface
 
facilities
 
is
 
well
 
developed;
 
no
 
extraordinary
measures or expenses will be required to establish
 
infrastructure or utilities at the Shaner site.
The
 
Fallowfield
 
property
 
boundary
 
is
 
traversed
 
by
 
the
 
4-lane
 
limited-access
 
Mon-Fayette
Expressway in addition
 
to numerous improved
 
roads.
 
Previous mining and
 
coal preparation facilities
have
 
existed
 
in
 
the
 
immediate
 
vicinity
 
of
 
the
 
proposed
 
Fallowfield
 
surface
 
facilities.
 
No
extraordinary
 
measures
 
or
 
expenses
 
will be
 
required
 
to
 
establish
 
infrastructure
 
or utilities
 
at
 
the
Fallowfield site.
 
Due to the
 
projected starting
 
date for
 
the Fallowfield
 
mine, no detailed
 
design of
infrastructure or surface facil
 
ities has been completed to date.
 
A CSX
 
rail line
 
and loadout on
 
the Monongahela
 
River as
 
well as
 
barge transportation
 
on the
 
river
are expected to serve as the primary means of transport for produced coal.
 
16
 
Market Studies
16.1
 
Market Description
The quality
 
characteristics for
 
the subject
 
coal resources
 
and coal
 
reserves have
 
been reviewed
 
in
detail
 
by MM&A.
 
The drill
 
hole data
 
were
 
utilized to
 
develop
 
average
 
coal quality
 
characteristics
for
 
the mining
 
site.
 
These average
 
coal
 
quality characteristics
 
were
 
then utilized
 
as the
 
basis for
determining the various markets into which the saleable coal will likely
 
be placed.
 
The projected quality specifications for the Mon Valley
 
products are as shown in
Table 16-1.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
44
Table 16-1:
 
Quality Specifications by Product
HVB
Moisture (%)
7.50
Ash (%)
7.50
Sulfur (%)
1.2
Volatile Matter (%)
35
Btu/lb.
N/A
Fluidity (ddpm)
26,000
MMR (%)
0.98
CSR
55
FSI
7.50
Note:
 
All Specs are dry basis except
 
Moisture.
 
Life-of-mine sulfur for Pangburn
 
is an estimated 1.21%; however,
 
overall Mon Valley
 
Complex
reserve average is 1.36% sulfur.
All of the mine production is projected to serve the metallurgical markets.
 
The metallurgical coal is
marketed
 
as a
 
high-volatile (typically
 
greater
 
than 31
 
percent
 
volatile matter
 
content) product
 
on
both the domestic and export markets.
16.2
 
Price Forecasts
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts
 
for its proposed Mon Valley
 
operations in terms of
year-end 2024
 
(January) real
 
dollars.1
 
MM&A applied
 
a 2% annual
 
inflation rate
 
to the
 
Coronado
price forecast
 
in order
 
to estimate
 
revenues
 
in nominal
 
dollars.
 
Customer
 
coal
 
pricing is
 
derived
from
 
market
 
observed
 
forward
 
estimates
 
based on
 
global economic
 
supply and
 
demand
 
analysis
which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with Coronado’s
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
 
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
charges.
 
MM&A
 
extrapolated
 
the
 
provided
 
data
 
for
 
the
 
greenfield
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
operations.
 
Concurrent with aforementioned quality parameters
 
in the preceding section, production from the
proposed operations
 
is assumed to
 
be sold in
 
high volatile
 
domestic and export
 
coal markets
 
with
respective
 
percentages
 
of
 
66
 
percent
 
and
 
34
 
percent.
 
The
 
pricing
 
data
 
assumes
 
a
 
blended
 
HVB
domestic and export FOB-mine nominal
 
price of $164
 
per metric tonne
 
for calendar year 2029.
 
HVB
domestic and export prices respectively are increased by 2% annual inflation thereafter.
16.3
 
Contract Requirements
Some contracts are necessary for successful marketing of the
 
coal.
 
For Mon Valley, since all mining,
preparation
 
and marketing
 
is expected
 
to be done
 
in-house, the remaining
 
contracts
 
required will
be:
>
Transportation
 
– The Mine is expected
 
to contract with
 
barge transportation
 
companies or
with
 
CSX
 
Railroad
 
to
 
transport
 
the
 
coal
 
to
 
either
 
of
 
the
 
domestic
 
customers
 
ports
 
for
overseas shipments.
>
Handling
 
–
 
Contracts
 
for
 
loading
 
vessels
 
for
 
export
 
sales
 
will
 
be
 
necessary.
 
These
 
are
expected to be handled by annual negotiations based on projected shipments.
1 The Coronado pricing forecast was provided to
 
MM&A in real 2024 (January) dollars based on
sales price information from AME Group adjusted for
 
transportation costs to an FOB Mine basis.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
45
>
Sales
 
– Sales
 
contracts are expected to
 
be a
 
mix of
 
spot and
 
contract sales.
 
With the
 
volatility
of the market, long-term contracts are
 
not expected to be written.
17
 
Environmental Studies, Permitting
 
and Plans,
Negotiations or Agreements with Local Individuals
 
17.1
 
Results of Studies
MM&A
 
is not
 
aware
 
of any
 
Phase
 
I Environmental
 
Site
 
Assessment
 
(ESA)
 
completed
 
on the
 
Mon
Valley property on behalf
 
of Coronado.
 
Coronado reports not
 
having conducted such
 
a study.
 
Based
on our experience
 
with Coronado,
 
it is the
 
QPs’ opinion that
 
Coronado has a
 
generally typical
 
coal
industry
 
record
 
of
 
compliance
 
with
 
applicable
 
mining,
 
water
 
quality,
 
and
 
environmental
 
laws.
 
Estimated
 
costs
 
for
 
mine closure,
 
including water
 
quality monitoring
 
during site
 
reclamation,
 
are
included in the financial models.
17.2
 
Requirements and Plans for Waste
 
Disposal
A
 
study
 
completed
 
on
 
behalf
 
of
 
Coronado
 
has
 
identified
 
a
 
Preferred
 
Site
 
for
 
refuse
 
disposal
 
at
Pangburn
 
with
 
capacity
 
of
 
22.6 million
 
cubic
 
meters.
 
Estimated
 
requirements
 
for
 
Pangburn
 
and
Shaner combined is 29.7 million tonnes or approximately
 
13.2 million cubic meters.
 
Permitting for
such a facility is anticipated to be achievable.
17.3
 
Permit Requirements and Status
All
 
mining
 
operations
 
are
 
subject
 
to
 
federal
 
and
 
state
 
laws
 
and
 
must
 
obtain
 
permits
 
to
 
operate
mines, coal preparation and related facilities,
 
haul roads, and other incidental surface disturbances
necessary for
 
mining to
 
occur.
 
Permits
 
generally
 
require
 
that
 
the
 
permittee
 
post
 
a
 
performance
bond in
 
an amount
 
established by the
 
regulatory program to provide
 
assurance that any
 
disturbance
or liability
 
created during
 
mining operations
 
is properly
 
restored
 
to an
 
approved post-mining
 
land
use and
 
that all
 
regulations and
 
requirements
 
of the
 
permits are
 
fully satisfied
 
before
 
the bond
 
is
returned
 
to
 
the
 
permittee.
 
Significant
 
penalties
 
exist
 
for
 
any
 
permittee
 
who
 
fails
 
to
 
meet
 
the
obligations
 
of
 
the
 
permits
 
including
 
cessation
 
of
 
mining
 
operations,
 
which
 
can
 
lead
 
to
 
potential
forfeiture
 
of the bond.
 
Any company,
 
and its directors,
 
owners, and
 
officers, which
 
are subject to
bond forfeiture can be denied future permits under the program.
 
2
The refuse disposal
 
area will receive
 
combined coarse refuse
 
from the proposed
 
preparation plant
by conveyor belts.
 
The fine material will be
 
processed by filter press technology where the
 
majority
of the water is removed.
 
The filter cake material will be placed on the refuse conveyor
 
for disposal
with the coarse portion of the refuse material.
2 Monitored under the Applicant Violator System
 
(AVS) by the Federal
 
Office of Surface Mining.
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
46
New permits
 
or permit
 
revisions will occasionally
 
be necessary
 
to facilitate the
 
expansion or
 
addition
of new
 
mining areas
 
on the
 
properties, such
 
as amendments
 
to existing
 
permits and
 
new permits
for mining
 
of reserve
 
areas.
 
Exploration permits
 
are also
 
required.
 
Property under
 
lease includes
provisions
 
for
 
exploration
 
among
 
the
 
terms
 
of
 
the
 
lease.
 
New
 
or
 
modified
 
mining
 
permits
 
are
subject
 
to
 
a
 
public
 
advertisement
 
process
 
and
 
comment
 
period,
 
and
 
the
 
public
 
is
 
provided
 
an
opportunity
 
to
 
raise
 
objections
 
to
 
any
 
proposed
 
mining
 
operation.
 
MM&A
 
is
 
not
 
aware
 
of
 
any
specific
 
prohibition
 
of
 
mining
 
on
 
the
 
subject
 
property
 
and
 
given
 
sufficient
 
time
 
and
 
planning,
Coronado should
 
be able
 
to secure
 
new permits
 
to maintain
 
its planned mining
 
operations within
the context
 
of current
 
regulations.
 
Portions of
 
the properties are
 
located near
 
local communities.
 
Regulations prohibit
 
mining activities within 91
 
meters of a
 
residential dwelling, school,
 
church, or
similar structure
 
unless written
 
consent is
 
first obtained
 
from the
 
owner of
 
the structure.
 
Where
required, such consents
 
have been obtained
 
where mining is
 
proposed beyond the
 
regulatory limits.
MM&A
 
is
 
unaware
 
of
 
any
 
obvious
 
or
 
current
 
Coronado
 
permitting
 
issues
 
that
 
are
 
expected
 
to
prevent the issuance of future
 
permits.
 
Coronado, along with all
 
coal producers, is subject to
 
a level
of uncertainty regarding future clean
 
water permits due to
United States Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) and United States
 
Fish and Wildlife (
USFW
)
 
involvement with state programs.
 
17.4
 
Local Plans, Negotiations or Agreements
MM&A found
 
no indication
 
of requirements
 
for agreements
 
beyond the
 
scope of Federal
 
or State
Regulations.
MM&A identified
 
local zoning
 
requirements from Forward
 
Township in Allegheny County
 
for surface
areas of
 
the proposed
 
Pangburn mine.
 
Additionally,
 
local floodplain
 
permits and building
 
permits
will be required.
17.5
 
Mine Closure Plans
Applicable
 
regulations
 
require
 
that
 
mines
 
be
 
properly
 
closed,
 
and
 
reclamation
 
commenced
immediately
 
upon
 
abandonment.
 
In
 
general,
 
site
 
reclamation
 
includes
 
removal
 
of
 
structures,
backfilling, regrading, and revegetation of disturbed areas.
 
Sediment control is required during the
establishment of vegetation, and
 
bond release generally requires
 
a minimum
 
five-year period of
 
site
maintenance, water sampling, and
 
sediment control following
 
mine completion.
 
This requirement
is
 
reduced
 
to
 
two
 
years
 
for
 
certain
 
operations
 
involving
 
re-mining.
 
Reclamation
 
of underground
mines includes
 
closure and
 
sealing of
 
mine openings
 
such as
 
portals and
 
shafts in
 
addition to
 
the
items listed above.
 
Estimated
 
costs
 
for
 
mine closure,
 
including water
 
quality monitoring
 
during site
 
reclamation,
 
are
included in the financial
 
model.
 
As with all
 
mining companies, an accretion
 
calculation is performed
annually
 
so the
 
necessary Asset
 
Retirement
 
Obligations
 
(ARO)
 
can
 
be shown
 
as
 
a Liability
 
on the
Balance Sheet.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
ex964p13i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
47
17.6
 
Qualified Person’s Opinion
The QPs know
 
of no reason that any permits that may be required cannot be obtained.
 
Estimated expenditures for site
 
closure and
 
reclamation are included
 
in the
 
financial model
 
for these
sites.
18
 
Capital and Operating Costs
18.1
 
Capital Cost Estimate
The production sequence selected for
 
a property must consider the proximity
 
of each reserve area
to
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plants,
 
river
 
docks
 
and
 
railroad
 
loading
 
points,
 
along
 
with
 
suitability
 
of
production equipment to coal seam conditions.
 
The in-place infrastructure was evaluated, and any
future needs were planned to a level suitable for a Preliminary Feasibility Study and included in the
Capital Forecast.
MM&A
 
developed
 
capital
 
spending
 
estimates
 
for
 
the
 
proposed
 
operations
 
in
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
Complex.
 
MM&A’s
 
capital schedules assume that major equipment rebuilds occur over the course
of each
 
machine’s remaining assumed operating
 
life.
 
Replacement equipment was
 
scheduled based
on MM&A’s
 
experience and
 
knowledge of
 
mining equipment
 
and industry
 
standards
 
with respect
to the useful life of such equipment.
 
A summary of the estimated capital for the Property is provided
 
in
Figure 18-1
 
below.
 
Figure 18-1:
 
CAPEX
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
48
18.2
 
Operating Cost Estimate
Coronado
 
provided
 
a
 
historical
 
summary
 
of
 
operating
 
costs
 
for
 
similar
 
operations
 
for
 
MM&A’s
review.
 
MM&A used the historical and/or budget cost information
 
as a reference and developed a
personnel
 
schedule
 
for
 
the
 
mine.
 
Hourly
 
labor
 
rates
 
and
 
salaries
 
were
 
based
 
upon
 
information
contained in Coronado’s financial summaries.
 
Fringe benefit costs were developed
 
for vacation and
holidays,
 
federal
 
and
 
state
 
unemployment
 
insurance,
 
retirement,
 
workers’
 
compensation
 
and
pneumoconiosis,
 
casualty
 
and
 
life
 
insurance,
 
healthcare,
 
and
 
bonuses.
 
A
 
cost
 
factor
 
for
 
mine
supplies was developed that
 
relates expenditures
 
to mine advance rates
 
for roof
 
control costs
 
and
other
 
mine
 
supply
 
costs
 
experienced
 
at
 
underground
 
mines.
 
Other
 
factors
 
were
 
developed
 
for
maintenance and repair costs, rentals, mine power,
 
outside services and other direct mining costs.
 
Other
 
cost
 
factors
 
were
 
developed
 
for
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plant
 
processing,
 
refuse
 
handling,
 
coal
loading, property
 
taxes,
 
and insurance
 
and bonding.
 
Appropriate
 
royalty
 
rates
 
were
 
assigned for
production from leased coal lands and sales
 
taxes were calculated
 
for federal black
 
lung excise tax,
and
 
federal
 
reclamation
 
fees.
 
There
 
are
 
currently
 
no
 
state
 
coal
 
severance
 
or
 
reclamation
 
taxes
required in Pennsylvania.
Mandated Sales Related Costs such as Black Lung Excise are
 
summarized in
Table 18-1
.
Table 18-1:
 
Estimated Coal Production Taxes
 
and Sales Costs
Description of Tax or Sales Cost
Basis of Assessment
Cost
Federal Black Lung Excise Tax - Underground
Per Tonne
$1.21
 
Federal Reclamation Fees – Underground
Per Tonne
$0.13
 
Royalties – Underground
Percentage of Revenue
7%
Note:
 
1.
 
Federal black lung excise tax
 
is paid only on
 
coal sold domestically.
 
MM&A assumed 67% of
 
total coal sales
 
to be domestic in
 
the economic
analysis discussed below.
A summary of the projected Operating Costs is in
Table 18-2
.
Table 18-2:
 
Mon Valley Operating Costs
YE
12/31
2024
YE
12/31
2025
YE
12/31
2026
YE
12/31
2027
YE
12/31
2028
YE
12/31
2029
YE
12/31
2030
YE
12/31
2031
Remaining
Total
LOM
Average
ROM Production Tonnes
 
198.7
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
2.9
 
Yield
68.10%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
68.10%
Saleable Production Tonnes*
 
135.311
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
2.0
 
 
Thermal Tonnes
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
Domestic Met Tonnes
 
89.3
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
1.3
 
Export Met Tonnes
 
46.0
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
0.7
 
 
Total Saleable Tonnes
 
135.3
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
-
 
 
2.0
 
 
Cash Costs per Tonne:
Mining Costs
 
$112.93
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$112.90
 
Processing and Transport
 
$42.60
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$42.60
 
Sales Related Costs
 
$1.97
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$1.97
 
G&A
 
$5.32
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$5.32
 
 
Total Cash Costs
 
$162.81
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$-
 
 
$162.79
 
Financial model includes 0.9 million tonnes of inferred coal production.
 
Inferred coal represents 0.6% of the total production, and none of this
coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
49
19
 
Economic Analysis
19.1
 
Assumptions, Parameters and Methods
A pre-feasibility LOM plan
 
was prepared by
 
MM&A for
 
the proposed Mon
 
Valley operations.
 
MM&A
prepared
 
mine
 
projections
 
and
 
production
 
timing
 
forecasts
 
based
 
on
 
coal
 
seam
 
characteristics.
 
Production
 
timing was
 
carried out
 
from
 
2033 to
 
depletion (exhaustion)
 
of the
 
coal reserve
 
areas,
which
 
is
 
projected
 
for
 
the
 
year
 
2101.
 
All
 
costs
 
and
 
prices
 
are
 
based
 
on
 
year-end
 
2023
 
nominal
United States dollars.
The Mine
 
plan, productivity
 
expectations and cost
 
estimates generally reflect
 
historical performance
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
efforts
 
have
 
been
 
made
 
to
 
adjust
 
plans
 
and
 
costs
 
to
 
reflect
 
future
 
conditions.
 
MM&A is confident
 
that the mine
 
plan and
 
financial model
 
are reasonably representative to provide
an accurate estimation of coal reserves.
Capital
 
schedules were
 
developed by
 
MM&A for
 
mine development,
 
infrastructure,
 
and on-going
capital
 
requirements
 
for
 
the
 
life
 
of the
 
mine.
 
Staffing
 
levels
 
were
 
prepared,
 
and operating
 
costs
estimated
 
by
 
MM&A.
 
MM&A
 
utilized
 
historical
 
cost
 
data
 
provided
 
by
 
Coronado
 
and
 
its
 
own
knowledge and experience to estimate direct and indirect operating
 
costs.
 
The
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
financial
 
model,
 
prepared
 
for
 
this
 
TRS,
 
was
 
developed
 
to
 
test
 
the
economic viability of
 
the coal reserve
 
area.
 
The results of
 
this financial model
 
are not intended
 
to
represent
 
a
 
bankable
 
feasibility
 
study,
 
required
 
for
 
financing
 
of
 
any
 
current
 
or
 
future
 
mining
operations,
 
but
 
are
 
intended
 
to
 
prove
 
the
 
economic
 
viability
 
of the
 
estimated
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
All
costs and prices are based on year-end 2023 nominal United
 
States dollars assuming a 2% inflation
rate.
On an unlevered basis, the NPV of the project cash flows after taxes was
 
estimated for the purpose
of
 
classifying
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
The
 
project
 
cash
 
flows,
 
excluding
 
debt
 
service,
 
are
 
calculated
 
by
subtracting direct
 
and indirect
 
operating expenses
 
and capital
 
expenditures from
 
revenue.
 
Direct
costs include labor, drilling and
 
blasting, operating supplies,
 
maintenance and repairs,
 
facilities costs
for
 
materials
 
handling,
 
coal
 
preparation,
 
refuse
 
disposal,
 
coal
 
loading,
 
sampling
 
and
 
analysis
services,
 
reclamation
 
and
 
general
 
and
 
administrative
 
costs.
 
Indirect
 
costs
 
include
 
statutory
 
and
legally
 
agreed
 
upon
 
fees
 
related
 
to
 
direct
 
extraction
 
of
 
the
 
mineral.
 
The
 
indirect
 
costs
 
are
 
the
Federal
 
black
 
lung
 
tax,
 
Federal
 
reclamation
 
taxes,
 
property
 
taxes,
 
local
 
transportation
 
prior
 
to
delivery
 
at
 
rail
 
or
 
barge
 
loading
 
sites,
 
coal
 
production
 
royalties,
 
sales
 
and
 
use
 
taxes,
 
and
 
income
taxes.
 
Coronado’s historical
 
costs provided a useful reference
 
for MM&A’s
 
cost estimates.
Sales revenue is based on
 
the metallurgical coal price information provided to MM&A
 
by Coronado.
Projected
 
debt
 
service
 
is
 
excluded
 
from
 
the
 
P&L
 
and
 
cash
 
flow
 
model
 
in
 
order
 
to
 
determine
Enterprise Value.
 
 
ex964p2i0
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
50
The financial model expresses coal sales prices, operating costs, and capital expenditures in current
day
 
dollars
 
without
 
adjustment
 
for
 
inflation.
 
Capital
 
expenditures
 
and
 
reclamation
 
costs
 
are
included based
 
on engineering
 
estimates for
 
each mine
 
by year.
 
The Coronado
 
division’s
 
existing
allocations of administrative costs are
 
continued in the future projections.
Coronado will pay royalties for the various current and projected operations.
 
The royalty rates vary
by
 
mining method
 
and location.
 
The
 
royalty
 
rates
 
for
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
are estimated
 
to be
 
7% of
 
the
sales revenue.
The
 
projection
 
model
 
also
 
includes
 
consolidated
 
income
 
tax
 
calculations
 
at
 
the
 
Coronado
 
level,
incorporating statutory
 
depletion calculations, as well
 
as state income
 
taxes, and a
 
federal tax rate
of
 
21%.
 
To
 
the
 
extent
 
the
 
mine
 
generates
 
net
 
operating
 
losses
 
for
 
tax
 
purposes,
 
the
 
losses
 
are
carried over to offset future taxable
 
income.
 
The terms “cash flows” and “project cash flows” used
in this report refer to after tax
 
cash flows.
Consolidated cash flows are driven by annual sales
 
tonnage, which grows from 0.4 million tonnes in
2033
 
to
 
a
 
peak
 
of
 
3.8 million
 
tonnes
 
in
 
2061.
 
Between
 
years
 
2062
 
and
 
2091,
 
sales
 
range
 
from
1.5 million to 2.7 million tonnes and between years 2092-2101, sales range from 0.4 million tonnes
to 1.3 million
 
tonnes.
 
Projected consolidated
 
revenue grows
 
from $78.3 million
 
in 2033 to
 
a peak
of $1.3 billion in 2061.
 
Revenue totals $53.5 billion for the project’s
 
life.
Consolidated cash flow from operations is positive throughout the projected operating period, with
the
 
exception
 
of post
 
-production
 
years,
 
due to
 
end-of-mine
 
reclamation
 
spending.
 
Consolidated
cash flow from operations peaks at $627.9 million in 2062
 
and totals $15.4 billion over the project’s
life.
 
Capital
 
expenditures
 
total
 
$527.3 million during
 
the
 
first
 
five
 
years
 
and
 
$3.9 billion over
 
the
project’s life.
 
Coal
 
price
 
forecasts
 
for
 
coal
 
products
 
were
 
prepared
 
by
 
Coronado
 
for
 
its
 
active
 
operations
 
and
modified
 
appropriately
 
by
 
MM&A
 
for
 
its
 
greenfield
 
operations.
 
Such
 
prices
 
were
 
used
 
for
 
the
revenue input into the
 
financial model.
 
Sales variable costs such
 
as production royalties were based
upon the revenue input.
19.2
 
Results
The
 
pre-feasibility
 
financial
 
model,
 
prepared
 
by
 
MM&A
 
for
 
this
 
TRS,
 
was
 
developed
 
to
 
test
 
the
economic viability of
 
each coal resource
 
area.
 
The results of
 
this financial model
 
are not intended
to represent
 
a bankable feasibility
 
study,
 
as may be
 
required for
 
financing of any
 
current or future
mining operations contemplated but are intended
 
to prove the economic viability of the estimated
coal reserves.
 
Optimization of the LOM plan was outside the scope of the engagement.
Figure 19-1
 
shows the annual variance of cash costs per ton.
 
Table 19-1
 
shows LOM tonnage, P&L,
and EBITDA for each proposed Coronado mines in Mon Valley
 
.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p59i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
51
Figure 19-1:
 
Cash Costs per Tonne
As
 
shown
 
above,
 
the
 
mines’ average
 
cash
 
cost
 
ranges
 
between
 
approximately
 
$73
 
and
 
$338
 
per
tonne for most of the operating period.
Table 19-1:
 
Life-of-Mine Tonnage,
 
P&L before Tax,
 
and EBITDA ($000)
LOM
LOM
P&L
LOM
EBITDA
Tonnes*
Pre-Tax P&L
Per Tonne
EBITDA
Per Tonne
Pangburn
 
14,376
 
 
$1,375,780
 
 
$95.70
 
 
$1,987,175
 
 
$138.23
 
Fallowfield
 
72,640
 
 
$18,671,106
 
 
$257.04
 
 
$21,133,469
 
 
$290.93
 
Shaner
 
48,294
 
 
$7,602,034
 
 
$157.41
 
 
$8,739,568
 
 
$180.97
 
Consolidated PA Deep Mines
 
135,309
 
 
$27,648,920
 
 
$204.34
 
 
$31,860,212
 
 
$235.46
 
Note:
 
*Financial model includes 0.9 million
 
tonnes of inferred coal production.
 
Inferred coal represents 0.6% of the total production,
 
and none
of this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
As
 
shown
 
in
Table
 
19-1
,
 
the
 
mines
 
show
 
positive
 
EBITDA
 
over
 
the
 
LOM.
 
Overall,
 
Coronado’s
consolidated operations show positive LOM P&L and LOM EBITDA of $27.6 billion and $31.9 billion,
respectively.
 
A summary of
 
the key
 
financial performance
 
metrics projected
 
for years
 
is provided
below in
Table 19-2.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
52
Table 19-2:
 
Summary of Mon Valley Key Financial Performance Metrics (2024-2031)
YE
12/31
2024
YE
12/31
2025
YE
12/31
2026
YE
12/31
2027
YE
12/31
2028
YE
12/31
2029
YE
12/31
2030
YE
12/31
2031
Remaining
 
Total
LOM
Average
ROM Production Tonnes
198.7
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
2.9
Yield
68.10%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
68.10%
Saleable Production Tonnes*
135.311
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
2.0
 
Thermal Tonnes
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Domestic Met Tonnes
89.3
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
1.3
Export Met Tonnes
46.0
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
0.7
 
Total Saleable Tonnes
135.3
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
2.0
 
Cash Costs per Tonne:
Mining Costs
$112.93
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$112.90
Processing and Transport
$42.60
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$42.60
Sales Related Costs
$1.97
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$1.97
G&A
$5.32
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$5.32
 
Total Cash Costs
$162.81
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$162.79
 
EBITDA per Tonne
$232.89
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$232.92
 
Expansion CapEx ($M)
$38.02
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$5.56
$32.46
$-
$-
Maintenance CapEx ($M)
$3,848.14
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$38.38
$54.43
 
Total CapEx
$3,886.15
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$5.56
$32.46
$38.38
$54.43
Financial model includes 0.9 million tonnes of inferred coal production.
 
Inferred coal represents 0.6% of the total production, and none of this
coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
After-Tax
 
Cash Flows
 
were developed
 
in order
 
to calculate
 
the NPV
 
for
 
this Property.
 
The NPV
 
is
estimated to be $563.4 million at a discount
 
rate of 10.0%.
 
A summary of the Mon Valley after
 
-tax
cash flow is shown in
Table 19-3
.
Table 19-3:
 
Project Cash Flow Summary (000)*
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
Total
2028
2029
2030
2031
2032
Production & Sales tonnes
135,311
-
-
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$53,543,217
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$22,878,217
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
Net Income
$11,796,769
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$15,418,952
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(388)
$(328)
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(3,886,154)
$-
$(5,556)
$(32,461)
$(38,382)
$(230,691)
Net Cash Flow
$11,532,798
$(388)
$(5,944)
$(32,849)
$(38,770)
$(231,019)
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2033
2034
2035
2036
2037
2038
Production & Sales tonnes
399
1,810
1,875
1,958
2,029
2,030
Total Revenue
$78,296
$362,106
$382,594
$407,547
$430,792
$439,609
EBITDA
$46,091
$230,681
$245,301
$265,119
$283,202
$289,071
Net Income
$(34,286)
$140,882
$121,310
$131,898
$147,171
$160,015
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$37,454
$188,509
$200,525
$213,069
$227,279
$239,643
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(220,159)
$(5,973)
$(1,492)
$(23,825)
$(21,154)
$(220,098)
Net Cash Flow
$(182,704)
$182,535
$199,033
$189,243
$206,125
$19,544
 
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
53
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2039
2040
2041
2042
2043
2044
Production & Sales tonnes
2,062
1,960
1,762
2,366
1,804
1,724
Total Revenue
$455,388
$441,481
$405,009
$554,640
$431,343
$420,513
EBITDA
$299,233
$282,680
$246,717
$355,857
$259,717
$249,422
Net Income
$148,359
$159,358
$124,218
$201,201
$155,408
$140,412
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$252,685
$239,821
$209,856
$264,281
$200,448
$197,055
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(198,968)
$(17,709)
$(15,403)
$(21,709)
$(9,653)
$(15,904)
Net Cash Flow
$53,717
$222,112
$194,453
$242,571
$190,795
$181,152
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2045
2046
2047
2048
2049
2050
Production & Sales tonnes
1,717
1,641
1,719
1,657
1,582
1,704
Total Revenue
$427,051
$416,456
$444,946
$437,356
$426,059
$468,115
EBITDA
$252,966
$242,678
$263,719
$255,907
$244,963
$276,975
Net Income
$154,860
$163,403
$176,959
$170,156
$161,907
$181,850
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$201,354
$194,705
$200,387
$200,909
$193,250
$210,580
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(105,936)
$(32,944)
$(3,311)
$(5,576)
$(21,182)
$(43,937)
Net Cash Flow
$95,418
$161,760
$197,075
$195,333
$172,067
$166,643
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2051
2052
2053
2054
2055
2056
Production & Sales tonnes
1,656
1,732
1,702
1,596
1,642
1,750
Total Revenue
$463,895
$494,756
$495,913
$474,451
$497,980
$541,261
EBITDA
$271,431
$294,451
$293,461
$274,133
$291,105
$323,591
Net Income
$177,355
$206,754
$205,313
$186,501
$196,906
$224,271
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$214,333
$224,264
$225,466
$215,317
$222,950
$245,045
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(26,060)
$(4,135)
$(20,511)
$(39,988)
$(30,028)
$(36,861)
Net Cash Flow
$188,273
$220,129
$204,955
$175,329
$192,922
$208,184
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2057
2058
2059
2060
2061
2062
Production & Sales tonnes
1,751
2,609
3,582
3,732
3,839
3,762
Total Revenue
$552,393
$839,589
$1,175,652
$1,249,528
$1,310,820
$1,310,433
EBITDA
$330,405
$494,167
$701,904
$754,323
$798,832
$793,460
Net Income
$249,858
$295,564
$442,235
$473,877
$508,672
$492,348
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$270,454
$378,130
$521,997
$586,273
$620,328
$627,936
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(538,808)
$(89,843)
$(36,104)
$(44,278)
$(21,847)
$(132,543)
Net Cash Flow
$(268,354)
$288,286
$485,893
$541,995
$598,481
$495,393
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2063
2064
2065
2066
2067
2068
Production & Sales tonnes
3,494
3,390
3,460
3,398
2,967
2,826
Total Revenue
$1,241,303
$1,228,573
$1,278,870
$1,280,972
$1,141,063
$1,108,535
EBITDA
$732,113
$720,210
$757,835
$754,462
$680,158
$663,742
Net Income
$446,588
$500,822
$521,333
$515,526
$450,699
$434,909
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$595,943
$568,873
$577,763
$583,053
$543,306
$522,205
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(60,459)
$(26,978)
$(66,446)
$(58,982)
$(120,137)
$(56,340)
Net Cash Flow
$535,484
$541,895
$511,317
$524,071
$423,169
$465,865
 
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
54
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2069
2070
2071
2072
2073
2074
Production & Sales tonnes
2,472
2,318
2,178
1,496
2,041
1,993
Total Revenue
$988,943
$946,112
$906,727
$635,345
$883,982
$880,465
EBITDA
$594,651
$554,448
$531,931
$346,940
$538,047
$535,996
Net Income
$384,720
$356,548
$335,438
$231,328
$359,458
$366,134
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$480,465
$443,994
$423,083
$260,436
$368,430
$408,513
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(118,056)
$(37,796)
$(41,704)
$(27,793)
$(47,154)
$(29,787)
Net Cash Flow
$362,409
$406,198
$381,378
$232,643
$321,276
$378,726
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2075
2076
2077
2078
2079
2080
Production & Sales tonnes
1,822
2,098
2,055
2,107
1,883
2,129
Total Revenue
$820,772
$874,560
$874,031
$913,861
$833,007
$960,656
EBITDA
$488,892
$527,243
$524,666
$555,561
$491,518
$587,784
Net Income
$332,175
$373,438
$366,231
$382,757
$335,406
$410,847
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$382,976
$392,261
$399,542
$415,100
$383,380
$424,802
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(3,295)
$(3,360)
$(41,878)
$(73,655)
$(15,800)
$(6,365)
Net Cash Flow
$379,682
$388,901
$357,664
$341,445
$367,580
$418,437
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2081
2082
2083
2084
2085
2086
Production & Sales tonnes
1,937
1,723
2,242
1,568
2,285
1,637
Total Revenue
$891,498
$809,214
$1,073,587
$766,070
$1,138,488
$832,210
EBITDA
$531,568
$460,863
$663,473
$428,042
$708,813
$464,168
Net Income
$368,045
$304,770
$448,699
$277,710
$492,938
$308,597
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$409,096
$358,874
$460,364
$364,186
$480,016
$392,806
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(25,353)
$(73,457)
$(43,005)
$(12,687)
$(19,996)
$(33,624)
Net Cash Flow
$383,743
$285,417
$417,359
$351,499
$460,019
$359,182
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2087
2088
2089
2090
2091
2092
Production & Sales tonnes
1,982
1,477
1,857
1,616
1,993
1,305
Total Revenue
$1,027,701
$781,052
$1,001,339
$888,873
$1,118,529
$747,144
EBITDA
$612,327
$424,413
$581,701
$495,500
$667,329
$373,435
Net Income
$412,609
$267,442
$390,044
$326,813
$454,337
$232,648
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$432,632
$353,475
$408,375
$388,300
$469,549
$335,144
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(41,648)
$(60,042)
$(27,048)
$(31,038)
$(4,523)
$(40,242)
Net Cash Flow
$390,984
$293,433
$381,327
$357,262
$465,027
$294,902
 
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2093
2094
2095
2096
2097
2098
Production & Sales tonnes
1,637
1,612
1,747
1,355
1,731
1,752
Total Revenue
$955,700
$959,852
$1,060,820
$839,478
$1,093,737
$1,129,433
EBITDA
$536,078
$531,972
$608,559
$412,363
$623,984
$652,244
Net Income
$344,367
$335,321
$398,419
$255,237
$407,178
$415,344
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$374,267
$401,019
$443,538
$347,072
$431,542
$484,871
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(85,557)
$(75,058)
$(4,895)
$(4,993)
$(48,993)
$(79,742)
Net Cash Flow
$288,710
$325,960
$438,643
$342,078
$382,550
$405,129
 
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ex964p19i1
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
55
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2099
2100
2101
2102
2103
2104
Production & Sales tonnes
1,407
896
393
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$925,181
$600,980
$268,578
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$493,808
$312,584
$135,457
$-
$-
$-
Net Income
$335,906
$195,168
$94,312
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$310,205
$239,384
$(26,022)
$-
$-
$-
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(17,075)
$(5,405)
$(2,757)
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$293,130
$233,979
$(28,778)
$-
$-
$-
Financial model includes 0.9 million tonnes of inferred coal production.
 
Inferred coal represents 0.6% of the total production, and none of this
coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
19.3
 
Sensitivity
Sensitivity
 
of the
 
NPV
 
results
 
to
 
changes
 
in
 
the
 
key
 
drivers
 
is presented
 
in
 
the
 
chart below.
 
The
sensitivity study shows
 
the NPV at
 
the 10.0% discount rate
 
when Base Case sales
 
prices, operating
costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased in increments
 
of 5% within a +/- 15% range.
Figure 19-2:
 
Sensitivity of NPV
As shown, NPV is quite sensitive to changes in sales price and operating cost estimates, and slightly
sensitive to changes in capital cost estimates.
20
 
Adjacent Properties
20.1
 
Information Used
No Proprietary information associated with neighboring properties was
 
used as part of this study.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
56
21
 
Other Relevant Data
 
and Information
MM&A
 
performed
 
a
 
previous
 
audit of
 
the
 
Property
 
in
 
2017 for
 
Coronado
 
based
 
on
 
SEC
 
Industry
Guide
 
7
 
standards.
 
MM&A
 
has
 
subsequently
 
conducted
 
Joint
 
Ore
 
Reserve
 
Committee
 
(JORC)
compliant resource and reserve
 
assessments of the
 
Mon Valley assets as
 
of:
 
(1) December 31,
 
2017,
(2)
 
December 31,
 
2020,
 
(3)
 
December 31,
 
2021,
 
and
 
(4)
 
December 31,
 
2022.
 
By
 
assignment,
 
the
JORC
 
assessment
 
included
 
a
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
level
 
study
 
of
 
the
 
subject
 
coal
 
reserves,
encompassing
 
detailed
 
mine
 
planning
 
and
 
cost
 
analysis
 
through
 
depletion
 
of
 
Mon
 
Valley’s
 
JORC-
compliant coal reserves.
 
MM&A utilized these former preliminary feasibility studies as the basis of
an updated study which meets those standards set forth by the JORC Code and SEC in Regulation S-
K 1300.
22
 
Interpretation and
 
Conclusions
22.1
 
Conclusion
Sufficient data
 
has been obtained
 
through various
 
exploration and
 
sampling programs
 
and mining
operations
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
geological
 
interpretations
 
of
 
seam
 
structure
 
and
 
thickness
 
for
 
coal
horizons
 
situated
 
on the
 
Property.
 
The data
 
is of
 
sufficient
 
quantity
 
and reliability
 
to
 
reasonably
support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates in this TRS.
The
 
geological
 
data
 
and
 
preliminary
 
feasibility
 
study,
 
which
 
consider
 
mining
 
plans,
 
revenue,
 
and
operating
 
and
 
capital
 
cost
 
estimates
 
are
 
sufficient
 
to
 
support
 
the
 
classification
 
of
 
coal
 
reserves
provided herein.
This geologic evaluation conducted in conjunction with the preliminary feasibility study is sufficient
to conclude that the 134.4
 
Mt of marketable underground
 
coal reserves identified on the Property
are
 
economically
 
mineable under
 
reasonable
 
expectations
 
of market
 
prices for
 
metallurgical
 
coal
products, estimated operation costs,
 
and capital expenditures.
22.2
 
Risk Factors
Risks have
 
been identified
 
for
 
operational,
 
technical and
 
administrative
 
subjects addressed
 
in the
Pre-Feasibility
 
Study.
 
A risk
 
matrix has
 
been constructed
 
to present
 
the risk
 
levels for
 
all the
 
risk
factors identified and quantified in
 
the risk assessment process.
 
The risk matrix and
 
risk assessment
process
 
are
 
modeled
 
to
 
that
 
presented
 
in
 
the
 
Australian
 
and
 
New
 
Zealand
 
Standard
 
on
 
Risk
Management (AS/NZS 4360).
 
The
 
purpose
 
of
 
the
 
characterization
 
of
 
the
 
project
 
risk
 
components
 
is
 
to
 
inform
 
the
 
project
stakeholders
 
of
 
key
 
aspects
 
of
 
the
 
Coronado
 
projects
 
that
 
can
 
be
 
impacted
 
by
 
events
 
whose
consequences can affect
 
the success of the venture.
 
The significance of an impacted
 
aspect of the
operation
 
is
 
directly
 
related
 
to
 
both
 
the
 
probability
 
of
 
occurrence
 
and
 
the
 
severity
 
of
 
the
consequences.
 
The initial risk for
 
a risk factor
 
is herein defined
 
as the risk level
 
after the potential
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
57
impact
 
of
 
the
 
risk
 
factor
 
is
 
addressed
 
by
 
competent
 
and
 
prudent
 
management
 
utilizing
 
control
measures readily available.
 
Residual risk for a risk factor is herein defined as the risk
 
level following
application
 
of
 
special
 
mitigation
 
measures
 
if
 
management
 
determines
 
that
 
the
 
initial
 
risk
 
level
 
is
unacceptable.
 
Initial risk and residual risk can be quantified numerically,
 
derived by the product of
values assigned to probability and consequence ranging from very low risk to very high risk.
 
The probability and consequence
 
parameters are subjective numerical estimates made
 
by practiced
mine engineers and
 
managers.
 
Both are
 
assigned values
 
from 1 to
 
5 for which
 
the value
 
1 represents
the
 
lowest
 
probability
 
and least
 
consequence,
 
and the
 
value
 
5 represents
 
the highest
 
probability
and greatest
 
consequence.
 
The products, which define
 
the Risk Level,
 
are classified from
 
very low
to very high.
 
Risk Level Table
 
(R = P x C)
Risk Level (R)
Very Low (1 to 2)
Low (3 to 5)
Moderate (6 to 11)
High (12 to 19)
Very High (20 to 25)
Risk aspects
 
identified and
 
evaluated
 
during this
 
assignment total
 
13.
 
No residual
 
risks are
 
rated
Very High.
 
Four (4) residual risks are rated High.
 
Six (6) of the risk aspects could be associated with
Moderate residual risk.
 
Three (3) of the risk aspects
 
were attributed Low or Very Low residual risks.
 
22.2.1
 
Governing Assumptions
The listing of the aspects is
 
not presumed to be exhaustive.
 
Instead that listing is
 
presented based
on the experiences of the contributors to the TRS.
 
1.
 
The probability and consequence ratings are subjectively assigned, and it is assumed that this
subjectivity reasonably reflects the condition of the active and projected mine operations.
2.
 
The
 
Control
 
Measures
 
shown
 
in
 
the
 
matrices
 
presented
 
in this
 
chapter
 
are
 
not
 
exhaustive.
 
They
 
represent
 
a
 
condensed
 
collection
 
of
 
activities
 
that
 
the
 
author
 
of
 
the
 
risk
 
assessment
section has observed to be effective in coal mining scenarios.
 
3.
 
Mitigation
 
Measures
 
listed
 
for
 
each
 
risk
 
factor
 
of
 
the
 
operation
 
are
 
not
 
exhaustive.
 
The
measures listed, however,
 
have been observed by the author to be effective.
 
4.
 
The monetary values used in
 
ranking the consequences are generally
 
-accepted quantities for
the coal mining industry.
22.2.2
 
Limitations
The risk assessment proposed in
 
this report is subject to
 
the limitations of the information currently
collected, tested, and interpreted
 
at the time of the writing of the report.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
58
22.2.3
 
Methodology
The
 
numerical
 
quantities
 
(i.e.,
 
risk
 
levels)
 
attributable
 
to
 
either
 
“initial”
 
or
 
“residual”
 
risks
 
are
derived
 
by the
 
product
 
of values
 
assigned to
 
probability
 
and consequence
 
ranging
 
from
 
very low
risk to very high risk.
R = P x C
Where:
R = Risk Level
P = Probability of Occurrence
C = Consequence of Occurrence
The Probability (P) and
 
Consequence (C) parameters recited in the
 
formula are subjective numerical
estimates
 
made
 
by
 
practiced
 
mine
 
engineers
 
and
 
managers.
 
Both
 
P
 
and
 
C
 
are
 
assigned
 
integer
values
 
ranging
 
from
 
1
 
to
 
5
 
for
 
which
 
the
 
value
 
1
 
represents
 
the
 
lowest
 
probability
 
and
 
least
consequence,
 
and the
 
value 5
 
represents
 
the highest
 
probability
 
and greatest
 
consequence.
 
The
products (R = P x C) which define the Risk Level, are
 
thereafter classified from very low to very high.
Risk Level Table
Risk Level (R)
Very Low (1 to 2)
Low (3 to 5)
Moderate (6 to 11)
High (12 to 19)
Very High (20 to 25)
Very
 
high
 
initial
 
risks
 
are
 
considered
 
to
 
be
 
unacceptable
 
and
 
require
 
corrective
 
action
 
well
 
in
advance of project
 
development.
 
In short,
 
measures must be
 
applied to reduce
 
very high initial
 
risks
to a tolerable level.
 
As
 
shown
 
and
 
discussed
 
above,
 
after
 
taking
 
into
 
account
 
the
 
operational,
 
technical,
 
and
administrative actions that have been
 
applied or
 
are available for action
 
when required, the
 
residual
risk can be determined.
 
The residual risk provides
 
a basis for the
 
management team to determine
if the residual risk
 
level is acceptable or tolerable.
 
If the risk level
 
is determined to be unacceptable,
further actions should be considered to reduce the residual risk to acceptable or tolerable
 
levels to
provide justification for continuation
 
of the proposed operation.
22.2.4
 
Development of the Risk Matrix
Risks have
 
been identified for
 
the technical,
 
operational, and
 
administrative
 
subjects addressed
 
in
the
 
TRS.
 
The
 
risk
 
matrix
 
and
 
risk
 
assessment
 
process
 
are
 
modeled
 
to
 
that
 
presented
 
in
 
the
Australian and New Zealand Standard on Risk Management (AS/NZS 4360).
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
59
22.2.4.1
 
Probability Level Table
Table 22-1:
 
Probability Level Table
Category
Probability Level (P)
1
Remote
Not likely to occur except in exceptional circumstances.
<10%
2
Unlikely
Not likely to occur; small in degree.
10 - 30%
3
Possible
Capable of occurring.
30 - 60%
4
Likely
High chance of occurring in most circumstances.
60 - 90%
5
Almost Certain
Event is expected under most circumstances; impossible to avoid.
>90%
The lowest rated probability of occurrence is assigned the value of 1 and described as remote, with
a likelihood
 
of occurrence
 
of less
 
than ten
 
percent.
 
Increasing values
 
are assigned
 
to each
 
higher
probability
 
of occurrence,
 
culminating
 
with the
 
value
 
of 5
 
assigned to
 
incidents considered
 
to
 
be
almost certain to occur.
22.2.4.2
 
Consequence Level Table
Table 22-2
 
lists the consequence levels.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
60
Table 22-2:
 
Consequence Level Table
Correlation of Events in Key Elements of the Project Program
 
to Event Severity Category
Category
Severity of
the Event
Financial Impact
of the Event
Unplanned
Loss of
Production
(Impact on
Commercial
Operations)
Events Impacting
on the Environment
Events Affecting the Program's
Social and Community
Relations
Resultant Regulatory /
Sovereign Risk
Events Affecting Occupational Health &
Safety
1
Insignificant
< USD
$0.5 million
≤ 12 hours
Insignificant loss of
habitat; no
irreversible effects
on water,
 
soil and
the environment.
Occasional nuisance impact on
travel.
-
Event recurrence avoided by corrective
action through established procedures
(Engineering, guarding, training).
2
Minor
USD $0.5 million
to $2.0 million
≤ 1 day
No significant
change to species
populations; short-
term reversible
perturbation to
ecosystem function.
Persistent nuisance impact on
travel.
 
Transient adverse media
coverage.
-
First aid – lost time.
 
Event recurrence
avoided by corrective action through
established procedures.
3
Moderate
USD $2.0 million
to $10.0 million
≤ 1 week
Appreciable change
to species
population;
medium-term (≤10
years) detriment to
ecosystem function.
Measurable impact on travel
and water/air quality.
 
Significant adverse media
coverage / transient public
outrage.
Uncertainty securing or
retaining essential
approval / license.
Medical Treatment – permanent
incapacitation.
 
Avoiding event
recurrence requires modification to
established corrective action procedures.
Change to regulations
(tax; bonds; standards).
4
Major
USD
$10.0 million to
$50.0 million
1 to 2 weeks
Change to species
population
threatening
viability; long-term
(>10 years)
detriment to
ecosystem function.
Long-term, serious impact on
travel and use of water
resources; degradation of air
quality; sustained and effective
public opposition.
Suspension / long-delay
in securing essential
approval / license.
Fatality.
 
Avoiding event recurrence
requires modification to established
corrective action procedures and staff
retraining.
Change to laws (tax;
bonds; standards).
5
Critical
>USD
$50.0 million
>1 month
Species extinction;
irreversible damage
to ecosystem
function.
Loss of social license.
Withdraw / failure to
secure essential
approval / license.
Multiple fatalities.
 
Avoiding event
recurrence requires major overhaul of
policies and procedures.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
61
The
 
lowest
 
rated
 
consequence
 
is
 
assigned
 
the
 
value
 
of
 
1
 
and
 
is
 
described
 
as
 
an
 
Insignificant
Consequence,
 
parameters
 
of
 
which
 
include
 
non-reportable
 
safety
 
incidents
 
with
 
zero
 
days
 
lost
accidents, no environmental damage,
 
loss of production or systems for less than
 
12 hours and cost
of
 
less
 
than
 
USD
 
$0.5 million.
 
Increasing
 
values
 
are
 
assigned
 
to
 
each
 
higher
 
consequence,
culminating with the value of
 
5 assigned to critical consequences, the
 
parameters of which include
multiple-fatality
 
accidents,
 
major
 
environmental
 
damage,
 
and
 
loss
 
of
 
production
 
or
 
systems
 
for
longer than one month and cost of greater than USD $50.0 million.
Composite Risk Matrix R = P x C and Color-Code Convention
The risk level, defined as the
 
product of probability of occurrence and consequence, ranges in
 
value
from
 
1 (lowest
 
possible risk)
 
to
 
25 (maximum
 
risk level).
 
The
 
values
 
are color-coded
 
to facilitate
identification of the highest risk aspects.
Table 22-3:
 
Risk Matrix
P x C = R
Consequence (C)
Insignificant
Minor
Moderate
Major
Critical
1
2
3
4
5
Probability Level (P)
Remote
1
1
2
3
4
5
Unlikely
2
2
4
6
8
10
Possible
3
3
6
9
12
15
Likely
4
4
8
12
16
20
Almost
Certain
5
5
10
15
20
25
22.2.5
 
Categorization of Risk Levels and Color Code Convention
Very
 
high
 
risks
 
are
 
considered
 
to
 
be
 
unacceptable
 
and
 
require
 
corrective
 
action.
 
Risk
 
reduction
measures must be applied to reduce very high risks to a tolerable level.
22.2.6
 
Description of the Coal Property
The Mon Valley Reserve (including Pangburn, Shaner and Fallowfield Areas) is located
 
in Allegheny,
Washington,
 
and Westmoreland
 
Counties, Pennsylvania.
 
Mon Valley
 
underground operations
 
are
projected
 
to
 
commence
 
in
 
2033
 
at
 
the
 
Mon
 
Valley
 
Complex
 
in
 
the
 
large
 
Upper
 
Freeport
 
seam
reserve area.
 
Three mines are planned,
 
and each will
 
utilize continuous mining methods.
 
The initial
operation is designated as the Pangburn Mine;
 
subsequently, the Shaner Mine is projected for 2039
and followed
 
by the
 
Fallowfield Mine
 
in 2058.
 
The operations
 
are projected
 
to utilize
 
continuous
mining production
 
sections.
 
The method
 
provides
 
continuity,
 
preserving skilled
 
work groups
 
and
enabling effective utilization of production equipment.
 
The Upper Freeport seam
 
is below drainage
and therefore all mines will be accessed with slopes and shafts.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
62
22.2.7
 
Summary of Residual Risk Ratings
Each
 
risk factor
 
is numbered,
 
and
 
a
 
risk level
 
for
 
each
 
is determined
 
by
 
multiplying
 
the
 
assigned
probability by
 
the assigned
 
consequence.
 
The risk
 
levels are
 
plotted
 
on a
 
risk matrix
 
to provide
 
a
composite
 
view
 
of
 
the
 
Coronado
 
risk
 
profile.
 
The
 
average
 
risk
 
level
 
is
 
8.4,
 
which
 
is
 
defined
 
as
Moderate.
Table 22-4:
 
Risk Assessment Matrix
Consequence
Critical
>$50 MM
9, 10
Major
$10-50MM
4
1, 2, 3
6
Moderate
$2-10 MM
12
Minor
$0.5-$2 MM
7, 13
5
8
Low
<$0.5 MM
11
<10%
10-30%
30-60%
60-90%
>90%
Remote
Unlikely
Possible
Likely
Almost
Certain
22.2.8
 
Risk Factors
A
 
high-level
 
approach
 
is
 
utilized
 
to
 
characterize
 
risk
 
factors
 
that
 
are
 
generally
 
similar
 
across
 
a
number of
 
the active
 
and proposed
 
mining operations.
 
Risk factors
 
that
 
are
 
unique to
 
a specific
operation or are particularly noteworthy are
 
addressed individually.
22.2.8.1
 
Geological and Coal Resource
Coal
 
mining
 
is
 
accompanied
 
by
 
risk
 
that,
 
despite
 
exploration
 
efforts,
 
mining
 
areas
 
will
 
be
encountered
 
where geological
 
conditions render
 
extraction
 
of the
 
resource to
 
be uneconomic,
 
or
that coal quality characteristics disqualify the product for sale into
 
target markets.
To
 
illustrate these points, the Upper Freeport coal seam deposits at Mon Valley are examined.
 
The
coal
 
is
 
deposited
 
in
 
large,
 
elliptical
 
pods.
 
During
 
deposition,
 
the
 
raised
 
peat
 
deposits
 
were
surrounded
 
by
 
areas
 
void
 
of
 
peat
 
and
 
deposited
 
instead
 
with
 
dirt,
 
clay,
 
and
 
stream
 
channels.
 
Consequently,
 
the perimeter
 
of the
 
peat,
 
and consequent
 
coal
 
deposits may
 
contain
 
significantly
higher concentration of ash
 
and sulfur, and reduced product yield.
 
The perimeter deposits
 
may also
be
 
affected
 
by
 
immediate
 
roof
 
and
 
floor
 
conditions
 
that
 
adversely
 
affect
 
mining
 
cost
 
and
productivity.
 
Meandering sandstone
 
channels may
 
reduce coal
 
seam thickness by
 
scouring action
at the top of the coal seam and support the migration of sulfur to the Upper Freeport seam.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
63
Offsetting the geological and
 
coal resource risk
 
are the massive
 
size of the
 
controlled property which
allows
 
large
 
areas
 
to
 
be
 
mined
 
in
 
the
 
three
 
designated
 
mine
 
areas
 
sufficiently
 
away
 
from
 
areas
where coal quality
 
and mineability
 
are less
 
favorable.
 
In addition,
 
the mines
 
are designed to
 
operate
with
 
multiple
 
production
 
sections,
 
which
 
lessens
 
the
 
immediate
 
impact
 
when
 
one
 
section
encounters difficulties.
 
The large reserve areas also
 
provide a mitigation strategy
 
of developing an
additional
 
(spare)
 
section
 
at
 
each
 
mine
 
which
 
can
 
be
 
activated
 
when
 
adverse
 
conditions
 
are
encountered,
 
thereby
 
maintaining
 
consistent
 
production
 
and quality.
 
The
 
spare
 
section requires
additional mine extension cost but increases flexibility and performance consistency.
Table 22-5:
 
Geological and Coal Resource Risk Assessment (Risks 1 and 2)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Recoverable coal tonnes
recognized to be
significantly less than
previously estimated.
Reserve base is adequate to
serve market commitments
and respond to opportunities
for many years.
 
Local
adverse conditions may
increase frequency and cost of
production unit relocations.
Previous and ongoing
exploration and extensive
regional mining history
provide a high level of
confidence of coal seam
correlation, continuity of the
coal seams, and coal
resource tonnes.
4
4
16
Optimize mine plan
to increase resource
recovery; develop
mine plan to provide
readily available
alternate mining
locations to sustain
expected production
level.
3
4
12
Coal quality locally
proves to be lower than
initially projected.
If uncontrolled, production and
sale of coal that is out of
specification can result in
rejection of deliveries,
cancellation of coal sales
agreements and damage to
reputation.
Exploration and vast
experience and history in
local coal seams provide
confidence in coal quality;
limited excursions can be
managed with careful
product segregation and
blending.
3
5
15
Develop mine plan
to provide readily
available alternate
mining locations to
sustain expected
production level;
modify coal sales
agreements to
reflect coal quality.
3
4
12
22.2.8.2
 
Environmental
Water
 
quality and
 
other permit
 
requirements
 
are subject
 
to modification
 
and such
 
changes could
have a
 
material impact on
 
the capability of
 
the operator
 
to meet modified
 
standards or
 
to receive
new permits and modifications
 
to existing permits.
 
Permit protests
 
may result in delays
 
or denials
to permit applications.
Environmental standards and permit requirements have evolved significantly over the
 
past 50 years
and
 
to-date,
 
mining
 
operators
 
and
 
regulatory
 
bodies
 
have
 
been
 
able
 
to
 
adapt
 
successfully
 
to
evolving environmental requirements.
The Residual
 
Risk has is
 
projected to
 
be slightly higher
 
for the
 
PA
 
reserves due to
 
the proximity
 
of
the rivers and the residual environmental
 
complaints, in the vicinity, left
 
from mining in the past.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
64
Table 22-6:
 
Environmental (Risks 3 and 4)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Environmental
performance standards
are modified in the future.
Delays in receiving new
permits and modifications to
existing permits; cost of testing
and treatment of water and
soils
Work with regulatory
agencies to understand and
influence final standards;
implement testing,
treatment and other actions
to comply with new
standards.
3
4
12
Modify mining and
reclamation plans to
improve compliance
with new standards
while reducing cost
of compliance.
3
4
12
New permits and permit
modifications are
increasingly delayed or
denied.
Interruption of production and
delayed implementation of
replacement production from
new mines.
Comply quickly with testing,
treatment and other actions
required; continue excellent
compliance performance
within existing permits.
2
4
8
Establish and
maintain close and
constructive working
relationships with
regulatory agencies,
local communities
and community
action groups.
2
4
8
22.2.8.3
 
Regulatory Requirements
Federal
 
and
 
state
 
health
 
and
 
safety
 
regulatory
 
agencies
 
occasionally
 
amend
 
mine
 
laws
 
and
regulations.
 
The impact is
 
industry-wide.
 
Mining operators and regulatory agencies have been
 
able
to adapt successfully to evolving health and safety requirements.
Table 22-7:
 
Regulatory Requirements (Risk 5)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Federal and state mine
safety and health
regulatory agencies
amend mine laws and
regulations.
Cost of training, materials,
supplies and equipment;
modification of mine
examination and production
procedures; modification of
mining plans.
Participate in hearings and
workshops when possible to
facilitate understanding and
implementation; work
cooperatively with agencies
and employees to facilitate
implementation of new laws
and regulations.
4
3
12
Familiarity and
experience with new
laws and regulations
results in reduced
impact to operations
and productivity and
improved supplies
and equipment
options.
4
2
8
22.2.8.4
 
Market and Transportation
Most of the current and future production is expected to be directed to domestic and international
metallurgical markets.
 
Historically the metallurgical markets
 
have been cyclical and highly volatile.
 
The Mon Valley business plan assumes that 75 percent of production can be sold into the favorably
priced
 
metallurgical
 
market.
 
The mining
 
plan must
 
minimize
 
exposure
 
to the
 
perimeter reserves
where quality may not be suitable for the market plan and be flexible to manage exposure
 
to areas
where coal quality fails to meet metallurgical
 
standards.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
65
Table 22-8:
 
Market and Transportation (Risks 6 and 7)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Volatile
 
coal prices
 
drop
precipitously.
Loss
 
of
 
revenue
 
adversely
affects
 
profitability;
 
reduced
cash
 
flow
 
may
 
disrupt
 
capital
expenditures plan.
Cost
 
control
 
measures
implemented;
 
capital
spending deferred.
4
5
20
High-cost
 
operations
closed,
 
and
employees
temporarily
furloughed.
4
4
16
Coal
 
quality
 
at
 
Mon
Valley
 
Upper
 
Freeport
mines is not adequate to
support
 
100
 
percent
metallurgical sales.
Reduced
 
revenue
 
from
 
a
percentage
 
of
 
thermal
 
sales
jeopardizes
 
financial
performance and expectations.
Lower preparation plant
gravities for ash and sulfur
reduction; segregate lower
quality coal when possible
and manage shipped
quality by blending.
3
5
15
Adjust
 
mine
 
plan
 
to
keep
 
minimize
exposure
 
to
perimeter
 
coal
 
and
sandstone
 
channels;
provide spare section
to sustain production
and quality when low
quality
 
areas
 
are
encountered.
3
2
6
Occasional delay or interruption of rail,
 
river and terminals service may be expected.
 
The operator
can
 
possibly
 
minimize
 
the
 
impact
 
of
 
delays
 
by
 
being
 
a
 
preferred
 
customer
 
by
 
fulfilling
 
shipment
obligations promptly and maintaining close working relationships.
Table 22-9:
 
Market and Transportation (Risk 8)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Rail or river transport is
delayed; storage and
shipping access at river
and ocean terminals is not
available.
Fulfillment of coal sales
agreements delayed; limited
coal storage at mines may
increase cost of rehandling;
production may be temporarily
idled.
Provide adequate storage
capacity at mines;
coordinate continuously with
railroad and shipping
companies to respond
quickly and effectively to
changing circumstances.
5
3
15
Provide back-up
storage facility along
with personnel,
equipment and
rehandle plan to
sustain production
and fulfill sales
obligations timely.
5
2
10
22.2.8.5
 
Mining Plan
Occupational health and
 
safety risks are inherent
 
in mining
 
operations.
 
Comprehensive training and
retraining
 
programs,
 
internal
 
safety
 
audits
 
and
 
examinations,
 
regular
 
mine
 
inspections,
 
safety
meetings, along
 
with support
 
of trained
 
fire brigades
 
and mine
 
rescue teams
 
are among
 
activities
that
 
greatly
 
reduce
 
accident
 
risks.
 
Employee
 
health monitoring
 
programs
 
coupled
 
with dust
 
and
noise monitoring and abatement reduce health risks to miners.
 
As underground mines are developed and
 
extended, observation of geological, hydrogeological and
geotechnical
 
conditions
 
leads
 
to
 
modification
 
of mine
 
plans
 
and
 
procedures
 
to
 
enable
 
safe
 
work
within the mine environments.
Highlighted
 
below
 
are
 
selected
 
examples
 
of
 
safety
 
and
 
external
 
factors
 
relevant
 
to
 
Coronado
operations.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
66
22.2.8.5.1
 
Methane Management
Coalbed methane is
 
present in coal
 
operations below
 
drainage.
 
Often the methane
 
concentration
is at such low levels that it can be readily managed with frequent testing and monitoring, vigilance,
and routine mine ventilation.
 
Very high methane concentrations may be present at greater depths.
 
High methane concentrations may require
 
degasification of the coal seam to assure safe mining.
 
Table 22-10:
 
Methane Management (Risk 9)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Methane hazard is present
in mines operating below
drainage.
Injury or loss of life; possible
ignition of gas and mine
explosion; potential loss of
mine and equipment
temporarily or permanently;
additional mine fan, mine
power, ventilation, monitoring
and examination requirements.
Low to moderate levels can
be managed with frequent
examinations, testing and
monitoring within the mine
ventilation system.
 
Excellent rock dust
maintenance minimizes
explosion propagation risk
should an ignition occur.
1
5
5
Very high-level
methane
concentrations may
require coal seam
degasification and
gob degasification if
longwall or pillar
extraction methods
are employed.
1
5
5
22.2.8.5.2
 
Mine Fires
Mine
 
fires,
 
once
 
common
 
at
 
mine operations,
 
are
 
rare
 
today.
 
Most
 
active
 
coal
 
miners
 
have
 
not
encountered a mine
 
fire.
 
Vastly improved mine power and
 
equipment electrical systems, along
 
with
safe
 
mine
 
practices
 
reduce
 
mine
 
fire
 
risks.
 
Crew
 
training
 
and
 
fire
 
brigade
 
support
 
and
 
training
improve response for containment and
 
control if a
 
fire occurs.
 
Spontaneous combustion within coal
mines, which is the source of most fires that occur today, is not expected to commonly occur at the
Coronado
 
property.
 
When
 
spontaneous
 
combustion
 
conditions
 
are
 
present,
 
monitoring
 
systems
are employed
 
for early
 
detection and
 
mine plans
 
are designed
 
to facilitate
 
isolation, containment
and rapid extinguishment.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
67
Table 22-11:
 
Mine Fires (Risk 10)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Mine fire at underground
or surface mine operation.
Injury or loss of life; potential
loss of mine temporarily or
permanently; damage to
equipment and mine
infrastructure.
Inspection and maintenance
of mine power, equipment
and mine infrastructure;
good housekeeping;
frequent examination of
conveyor belt entries;
prompt removal of
accumulations of
combustible materials.
1
5
5
If spontaneous
combustion
conditions are
present, enhanced
monitoring and
examination
procedures will be
implemented; mine
design will
incorporate features
to facilitate isolation,
containment and
extinguishment of
spontaneous
combustion
locations.
1
5
5
22.2.8.5.3
 
Availability of Supplies and Equipment
The industry
 
has periodically
 
experienced
 
difficulty receiving
 
timely delivery
 
of mine
 
supplies and
equipment.
 
Availability
 
issues
 
often
 
accompanied
 
boom
 
periods
 
for
 
coal
 
demand.
 
Any
 
future
delivery
 
of
 
supplies
 
and
 
equipment
 
delays
 
are
 
expected
 
to
 
be
 
temporary
 
with
 
limited
 
impact
 
on
production.
Table 22-12:
 
Availability of Supplies and Equipment (Risk 11)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Disruption of availability
for supplies and
equipment.
Temporary interruption of
production.
Force majeure provision in
coal sales agreements to
limit liability for delayed or
lost sales.
3
2
6
Work closely with
customers to assure
delayed coal
delivery rather than
cancelled sales;
monitor external
conditions and
increase inventory
of critical supplies;
accelerate delivery
of equipment when
possible.
3
1
3
22.2.8.5.4
 
Labor
Work
 
stoppage
 
due
 
to
 
labor
 
protests
 
are
 
considered
 
to
 
be
 
unlikely
 
and
 
accompanied
 
by
 
limited
impact
 
should
 
it
 
occur.
 
Excellent
 
employee
 
relations
 
and
 
communications
 
limit
 
the
 
exposure
 
to
outside protesters.
 
Loss of supervisors
 
and skilled
 
employees to retirement is inevitable;
 
the impact
can be lessened with succession planning, training, and mentorship of new employees.
These will
 
be new
 
mines in
 
an historically
 
United Mine
 
Workers
 
of America
 
(UMWA)
 
represented
area.
 
Newer mines
 
in the area
 
are not represented
 
so the precedent
 
has been set.
 
However,
 
the
Residual risk is shown as slightly elevated over some other Coronado properties.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Mon Valley Complex Upper Freeport Holdings
in Accordance with the JORC Code and
United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2023
Northern Appalachian Coal Basin
Pennsylvania, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
68
Table 22-13:
 
Labor – Work Stoppage (Risk 12)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Work stoppage due to
strikes, slowdowns or
secondary boycott
activity.
Loss of production and coal
sales; damaged customer and
employee relations; reputation
loss.
Maintain excellent
employee relations and
communications; maintain
frequent customer
communications.
2
3
6
Develop plan for
employee
communications and
legal support to
minimize impact of
secondary boycott
activities.
2
3
6
Table 22-14:
 
Labor – Retirement (Risk 13)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Retirement of supervisors
and skilled employees.
Loss of leadership and critical
skills to sustain high levels of
safety, maintenance and
productivity.
Monitor demographics
closely and maintain
communications with
employees who are
approaching retirement
age; maintain employee
selection and training
programs.
3
3
9
Maintain selection of
candidates and
implementation of in-
house or third-party
training for
electricians and
mechanics; develop
employee mentoring
program.
3
2
6
23
 
Recommendations
Coronado is
 
continuing to
 
work both
 
internally and
 
with outside
 
assistance to
 
further define
 
their
Resource Base and to Optimize the LOM Plan.
24
 
References
Publicly available information from various
 
State and Federal agencies was used where
 
relevant.
25
 
Reliance on Information Provided by the Registrant
A summary of
 
the information provided by Coronado relied upon
 
by MM&A for the purposes
 
of this
TRS is provided in
Table 25-1
.
Table 25-1:
 
Information from Registrant Relied Upon by MM&A
Category
Information Provided by Coronado
Report
Section
Marketing
Long-term price forecast used
 
in financial projections
16.2
Legal
Mineral control and surface
 
control rights as shown on maps
3.2, 3.3
Environmental
Permit and bonding information
17.3
ex964p77i0
 
 
APPENDIX
A
 
MM&A QUALIFICATION
ex964p78i0
 
 
 
ex964p77i0
 
 
APPENDIX
B
 
MAPS
ex964p80i0
 
 
ex964p81i0
 
 
 
ex964p82i0
 
 
ex964p77i0
 
 
APPENDIX
C
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
Glossary of Abbreviations and Definitions
Abbreviation
Definition
ACPS
Analysis of Coal Pillar Stability
ASTM
ASTM International
AVS
Applicant Violator System
Btu/lb.
British Thermal Unit per pound
Carlson
Carlson
 
Mining
 
–
 
formerly
 
SurvCADD®
 
–
 
a
 
prevalent
 
software
 
package
 
used
 
for
modeling in the Appalachian region
CFR
Code of Federal Regulations
Coronado
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
CSR
Coke strength after
 
reaction
 
CSX
CSX Corporation, a rail-based freight transportation
 
company
Demonstrated
reserves
Demonstrated reserves are the sum of proven
 
and probable reserves.
EBITDA
Earnings before Interest,
 
Taxes,
 
Depreciation, and Amortization
 
EOM
End-of-mine reclamation
EPA
United States Environmental
 
Protection Agency
 
ESA
Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment
Feasibility Study
“…comprehensive
 
technical
 
and
 
economic
 
study
 
of
 
the
 
selected
 
development
option for
 
a mineral
 
project,
 
which includes
 
detailed
 
assessments
 
of all
 
applicable
modifying factors together with any other relevant operational factors, and detailed
financial analysis
 
that are
 
necessary to
 
demonstrate,
 
at the
 
time of
 
reporting, that
extraction is
 
economically viable.
 
According to the
 
proposed definition, the
 
results
of the
 
study may
 
serve as
 
the basis
 
for
 
a final
 
decision by
 
a proponent
 
or financial
institution
 
to
 
proceed
 
with,
 
or
 
finance,
 
the
 
development
 
of
 
the
 
project.
 
Thus,
 
a
feasibility
 
study
 
is
 
more
 
comprehensive,
 
with
 
a
 
higher
 
degree
 
of
 
accuracy,
 
and
yielding results with a higher level of confidence, than a pre-feasibility study.”
 
HWM
Highwall mining
In situ
Its natural position;
 
said specific
 
of a
 
rock, soil,
 
or fossil when
 
in the
 
situation in
 
which
was originally formed or deposited
Indicated
Resources
Indicated resources are those lying between 0.4-kilometer
 
and 1.2-kilometer radius
from such an observation point and reported herein as in-situ mineral
 
resources.
Inferred Resources
Inferred
 
resources
 
lie
 
more
 
than
 
a
 
1.2-kilometer
 
radius
 
from
 
a
 
valid
 
point
 
of
measurement but
 
less than 4.8
 
kilometers from
 
one and
 
reported herein
 
as in-situ
mineral resources.
JORC Code
Australasian
 
Code for
 
Reporting of
 
Exploration Results,
 
Mineral Resources
 
and Ore
Reserves
lb. SO2 / mm Btu
Pounds per sulfur dioxide per million British thermal units
LOM
Life-of-mine
M&R
Maintenance and repair
Measured
Resources
Measured resources are those lying within 0.4-kilometer radius
 
from a valid point of
measurement and reported herein as in-situ mineral resources.
MINER Act
Mine Improvement and New Emergency Response Act of 2006
 
Mineral Reserve
“…the
 
economically
 
mineable
 
part
 
of
 
a
 
Measured
 
and/or
 
Indicated
 
Mineral
Resource.
 
It includes
 
dilution materials and
 
allowances for losses,
 
which occur when
the material is mined
 
or extracted and is defined
 
by studies at Preliminary
 
Feasibility
or
 
Feasibility
 
level
 
as
 
appropriate
 
that
 
include
 
Modifying
 
Factors.
 
Such
 
studies
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
Abbreviation
Definition
demonstrate
 
that,
 
at
 
the
 
time
 
of
 
reporting,
 
extraction
 
of
 
the
 
mineral
 
reserve
 
is
economically viable under reasonable investment and marketing
 
assumptions.”
 
Mineral Resource
“…a
 
concentration
 
or
 
occurrence
 
of
 
solid
 
material
 
of
 
economic
 
interest
 
or
 
on
 
the
Earth’s
 
crust in such
 
form, grade
 
or quality that
 
there are
 
reasonable prospects
 
for
eventual
 
economic extraction.
 
The location,
 
quantity,
 
grade,
 
continuity and
 
other
geological
 
characteristics
 
and
 
continuity
 
of
 
a
 
Mineral
 
Resource
 
are
 
known,
estimated or interpreted from specific
 
geological evidence and
 
knowledge, including
sampling.”
 
MM&A
Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc.
Modifying Factors
“…considerations
 
used
 
to
 
convert
 
Mineral
 
Resources
 
to
 
Mineral
 
Reserves.
 
These
include, but
 
are not
 
restricted
 
to,
 
mining, processing,
 
metallurgical,
 
infrastructure,
economic,
 
marketing,
 
legal,
 
environmental
 
compliance,
 
plans,
 
negotiations,
 
or
agreements with local individuals or groups and governmental factors.”
MRMR
Mineral Resources to Mineral Reserves
MSHA
United States Department of Labor Mine Safety and Health Administration
Mt
Million metric tonnes
NELAP
National Environmental Laboratory
 
Accreditation Program
NIOSH
National Institute for Occupational Safety
 
and Health
NRTL
Nationally Recognized Test
 
Laboratory
NS
Norfolk Southern Corporation, a rail-based freight transportation
 
company
O&M
Operating and maintenance
 
OSD
Out-of-seam dilution
P&L
Profit and loss before tax
 
P.E.
Professional Engineer
Preliminary
Feasibility Study
“…as a
 
comprehensive
 
study of
 
a range
 
of options
 
for
 
the technical
 
and economic
viability of a mineral
 
project that has
 
advanced to a
 
stage where
 
a qualified person
has determined (in the case of underground mining) a preferred
 
mining method, or
in the case of surface mining) a pit configuration, and in all cases has determined an
effective method of mineral
 
processing and an
 
effective plan to sell
 
the product.
 
The
study’s financial analysis must
 
have the level of detail
 
necessary to demonstrate,
 
at
the time of reporting, that extraction is economically viable.
 
In addition, as noted in
the proposed definition of a pre-feasibility
 
study, while
 
a pre-feasibility study is less
comprehensive and results in a lower
 
confidence level than a
 
feasibility study, a pre-
feasibility study is more comprehensive and results
 
in a higher confidence level
 
than
an initial assessment.”
 
Property(ies)
Bituminous coal
 
deposits located
 
in southwestern
 
Pennsylvania.
 
The Pennsylvania
properties
 
include
 
the
 
combined
 
Pangburg,
 
Shaner,
 
and
 
Fallowfield
 
underground
mines in the Upper Freeport seam.
 
QP
Qualified Person
Qualified Person
“…a person who is a
 
mineral industry professional with at least five years of
 
relevant
experience in the
 
type of
 
mineralization and type
 
of deposit
 
under consideration and
in the specific type of activity that person is undertaking on behalf of the registrant.
 
In
 
addition,
 
the
 
proposed
 
definition
 
requires
 
a
 
qualified
 
person
 
to
 
be
 
an
 
eligible
member
 
or licensee
 
in good
 
standing
 
of a
 
recognized
 
professional
 
organization
 
at
the
time the technical report is prepared.”
RECs
Recognized Environmental
 
Conditions
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
Abbreviation
Definition
Resource Database
The Resource Database is
 
established by the
 
collection, validation, recording, storing
and
 
processing
 
of
 
data
 
and
 
forms
 
the
 
foundation
 
necessary
 
for
 
the
 
estimation
 
of
Mineral Resource and Mineral Reserve.
 
A quality assurance and
 
quality control program is essential and
 
must be established
to govern the collection of all data.
 
In reporting, a Mineral Resource must meet the
minimum requirement of
 
“reasonable prospects for
 
economic extraction”.
 
This will
require
 
the
 
concurrent
 
collection
 
and
 
storage
 
of
 
preliminary
 
economic,
 
mining,
metallurgical, environmental,
 
legal and social data
 
and other information for
 
use in
the estimation of MRMR.
 
The Resource Database will include both “primary”
 
(observation and measurement)
and
 
“interpreted”
 
data.
 
It
 
is
 
recommended
 
that
 
data
 
be
 
stored
 
digitally,
 
using
 
a
documented,
 
standard
 
format
 
and
 
a reliable
 
storage
 
medium that
 
allows
 
for
 
easy
and complete retrieval of the data.
ROM
Run-of-mine
S-K 1300
United
 
States
 
Securities
 
and
 
Exchange
 
Commission
 
Regulation
 
S-K
 
1300
Modernization of Property Disclosures
SEC
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
SMCRA
Surface Mining Control
 
and Reclamation Act of 1977
 
is the primary federal law that
regulates the environmental
 
effects of coal mining in the United States.
Strip Ratio
Represented by bcm of overburden to recoverable
 
coal tonnes
 
tph
tonnes per hour
 
TRS
Technical
 
Report Summary
USA
United States of America
USFW
United States Fish and Wildlife
USGS
United States Geologic Survey
 
VALMIN Code
Australasian
 
Code for
 
Public Reporting
 
of Technical
 
Assessments and
 
Valuations
 
of
Mineral Assets
ex964p77i0
 
 
APPENDIX
D
 
JORC TABLE 13
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
Section 1 Sampling Techniques and Data
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Sampling techniques
>
 
Nature
 
and
 
quality
 
of
 
sampling
 
(e.g.
 
cut
 
channels,
 
random
 
chips,
 
or
 
specific
 
specialised
industry standard measurement
 
tools appropriate to
 
the minerals under
 
investigation, such
as downhole gamma sondes, or handheld XRF instruments, etc.). These examples should not
be taken as limiting the broad meaning of sampling.
>
 
Include reference
 
to
 
measures taken
 
to ensure
 
sample representivity
 
and
 
the appropriate
calibration of any measurement tools or systems used.
>
 
Aspects of the determination
 
of mineralisation that are Material to
 
the Public Report. In
 
cases
where ‘industry standard’
 
work has been
 
done this would
 
be relatively simple
 
(e.g. ‘reverse
circulation drilling was used
 
to obtain 1 m samples
 
from which 3 kg was
 
pulverised to produce
a 30 g charge for
 
fire assay’). In
 
other cases, more explanation
 
may be required, such as
 
where
there
 
is
 
coarse
 
gold
 
that
 
has
 
inherent
 
sampling
 
problems.
 
Unusual
 
commodities
 
or
mineralisation types (e.g.
 
submarine nodules)
 
may warrant disclosure of
 
detailed information.
>
 
Most of the coal samples have
 
been obtained from the Properties by
 
subsurface exploration using
core drilling techniques.
 
The protocol for
 
preparing and testing
 
the samples has
 
varied over time
and is not well documented for the older holes drilled on the Properties.
>
 
Typical USA
 
core drilling sampling technique
 
is for the
 
coal core sample,
 
once recovered from
 
the
core barrel, to be described then wrapped in a sealed plastic sleeve and placed into a covered core
box, which is the length of the sample so that the core can be delivered to a laboratory in relatively
intact condition and with original moisture content.
>
 
It
 
is
 
reasonable
 
to
 
assume,
 
given
 
the
 
sophistication
 
level
 
of
 
the
 
previous
 
operators,
 
that
 
these
samples were generally collected and
 
processed under industry best-practices.
 
This assumption is
based on MM&A’s familiarity with the
 
operating companies and the
 
companies used to perform the
analysis.
 
>
 
Some
 
of
 
the
 
drill
 
holes
 
were
 
air
 
rotary
 
bored
 
and
 
no
 
coal
 
core
 
samples
 
were
 
collected.
 
Seam
thickness for rotary-drilled bore holes is verified by calibrated downhole gamma-density logs.
 
>
 
Coal samples
 
that were
 
deemed by
 
MM&A geologists
 
to be
 
unrepresentative
 
were not
 
used for
statistical analysis of coal quality, as documented in the tabulations.
 
A representative group of drill
hole samples from the Properties were then checked against the original drill laboratory reports to
verify accuracy and correctness.
 
Drilling techniques
>
 
Drill type (e.g.
 
core, reverse
 
circulation, open-hole
 
hammer,
 
rotary air
 
blast, auger,
 
Bangka,
sonic, etc.)
 
and details
 
(e.g. core
 
diameter,
 
triple or
 
standard tube,
 
depth of
 
diamond tails,
face-sampling bit or other type, whether core is oriented and if so, by what method, etc.).
>
 
The
 
Properties
 
have
 
been
 
extensively
 
explored
 
by
 
subsurface
 
drilling
 
efforts
 
carried
 
out
 
by
numerous entities, most of which
 
were completed prior to
 
acquisition by Coronado.
 
The majority
of the drilling was accomplished using vertical continuous (diamond) coring or air rotary methods.
>
 
Core drilling methods utilize NX-size (5.4 centimeter) or similar-sized core cylinders to
 
recover core
samples, which can
 
be used to
 
delineate geologic
 
characteristics, and
 
for coal
 
quality testing
 
and
geotechnical logging.
 
>
 
Data for the rotary drilled
 
holes is mainly derived from downhole geophysical
 
logs, which are used
to interpret coal and rock thickness and depth since logging of the drill cuttings is not reliable.
>
 
Geophysical logging was performed on
 
many of the holes, either
 
by Geological Logging Systems
 
(a
division of MM&A), other
 
geophysical logging contractors,
 
and on those properties
 
acquired from
CONSOL geophysical logging was often performed by CONSOL’s in-house logging services.
Drill sample recovery
>
 
Method of recording and assessing core and chip sample recoveries and results assessed.
>
 
Measures
 
taken
 
to
 
maximise
 
sample
 
recovery
 
and
 
ensure
 
representative
 
nature
 
of
 
the
samples.
>
 
Whether a relationship exists
 
between sample recovery and grade
 
and whether sample bias
may have occurred due to preferential loss/gain of fine/coarse material.
>
 
Where
 
available,
 
core
 
recovery
 
thickness
 
of
 
coal
 
samples
 
was
 
reconciled
 
with
 
the
 
thickness
interpreted from geophysical logs.
>
 
Core recovery of
 
the older coal
 
samples lacking geophysical
 
logs is sometimes
 
not well-documented:
however,
 
when
 
the
 
laboratory
 
results
 
for
 
such
 
holes
 
had
 
anomalous
 
values,
 
the
 
data
 
was
disqualified and not used.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Logging
>
 
Whether core and chip samples
 
have been geologically and geotechnically logged
 
to a level of
detail to support appropriate
 
Mineral Resource estimation,
 
mining studies and metallurgical
studies.
>
 
Whether
 
logging
 
is
 
qualitative
 
or
 
quantitative
 
in
 
nature.
 
Core
 
(or
 
costean,
 
channel,
 
etc.)
photography.
>
 
The total length and percentage of the relevant intersections logged.
>
 
A wide variety of core-logging
 
techniques exist for the properties.
 
For many of the core
 
holes, the
primary data source
 
is a generalized lithology
 
description by the
 
driller, in some cases supplemented
by a more detailed core log completed by a geologist.
 
>
 
The logging
 
of core
 
thickness and
 
depth is
 
quantitative.
 
With the
 
exception
 
of
 
the coal
 
seams,
logging of rock strata type is more subjective and best considered as qualitative.
Sub-sampling
techniques and sample
preparation
>
 
If core, whether cut or sawn and whether quarter, half or all core taken.
>
 
If non-core, whether riffled, tube sampled, rotary split, etc. and whether sampled wet or dry.
>
 
For
 
all
 
sample
 
types,
 
the
 
nature,
 
quality
 
and
 
appropriateness
 
of
 
the
 
sample
 
preparation
technique.
>
 
Quality control procedures adopted for all sub-sampling stages
 
to maximise representivity of
samples.
>
 
Measures taken to ensure that the
 
sampling is representative of the in
 
situ material collected,
including for instance results for field duplicate/second-half sampling.
>
 
Whether sample sizes are appropriate to the grain size of the material being sampled.
>
 
Typical US
 
practice in the
 
Appalachian Basin is
 
that core samples
 
for deep mineable
 
core samples
are not sawn or
 
subsampled (since seams are
 
not of great thickness
 
and the entire
 
seam is mined
and co-mingled).
 
The entire coal interval drilled is generally analyzed.
>
 
Oftentimes, core for surface-mineable coal seams are
 
bench sampled separately by the
 
various coal
and rock layers (plies).
>
 
MM&A has exercised diligence to use
 
only those analyses that are
 
representative of the coal quality
parameters for the appropriate mining type for each sample.
Quality of assay data
and laboratory tests
>
 
The nature, quality and appropriateness of the assaying and laboratory
 
procedures used and
whether the technique is considered partial or total.
>
 
For geophysical tools, spectrometers, handheld XRF instruments,
 
etc., the parameters used in
determining the
 
analysis including
 
instrument make
 
and model,
 
reading times,
 
calibrations
factors applied and their derivation, etc.
>
 
Nature
 
of
 
quality
 
control
 
procedures
 
adopted
 
(e.g.
 
standards,
 
blanks,
 
duplicates,
 
external
laboratory checks) and whether acceptable levels
 
of accuracy (i.e. lack of
 
bias) and precision
have been established.
>
 
Sample analysis was typically carried out by accredited US laboratories.
 
>
 
Standard procedure upon receipt of
 
core samples by the testing laboratory
 
is to log the depth and
thickness of
 
the sample,
 
then perform
 
testing
 
as
 
specified by
 
a
 
representative
 
of
 
the operating
company.
 
Each
 
sample
 
is
 
then
 
analyzed
 
in
 
accordance
 
with
 
procedures
 
defined
 
under
 
ASTM
International (ASTM) standards including, but not limited to; washability (ASTM D4371); ash (ASTM
D3174); sulfur
 
(ASTM D4239); Btu/lb.
 
(ASTM D5865); volatile
 
matter (ASTM D3175);
 
Free Swell Index
(FSI) (ASTM D720).
>
 
Geophysical
 
tools
 
are
 
calibrated
 
by
 
the
 
logging
 
company
 
and
 
where
 
possible, validated
 
using
 
a
calibration hole.
Verification of
sampling and assaying
>
 
The
 
verification
 
of
 
significant
 
intersections
 
by
 
either
 
independent
 
or
 
alternative
 
company
personnel.
>
 
The use of twinned holes.
>
 
Documentation
 
of
 
primary
 
data,
 
data
 
entry
 
procedures,
 
data
 
verification,
 
data
 
storage
(physical and electronic) protocols.
>
 
Discuss any adjustment to assay data.
>
 
All coal intersection data
 
used to generate
 
the geologic model has been
 
cross referenced with
 
the
lithological and geophysical logs by MM&A.
>
 
Laboratory
 
quality
 
was
 
adjusted
 
from
 
dry
 
basis
 
to
 
reflect
 
the
 
anticipated
 
marketable
 
product
moisture.
>
 
Coal quality results
 
were verified
 
by spot-check
 
with laboratory
 
analysis sheets
 
by MM&A
 
before
inclusion into the geologic model and use in the resource estimate.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Location of data points
>
 
Accuracy
 
and
 
quality
 
of
 
surveys
 
used
 
to
 
locate
 
drill
 
holes
 
(collar
 
and
 
down-hole
 
surveys),
trenches, mine workings and other locations used in Mineral Resource estimation.
>
 
Specification of the grid system used.
>
 
Quality and adequacy of topographic control.
>
 
Due to the long history of exploration by various parties on the Properties, a wide variety of survey
techniques exist for
 
documentation of data
 
point locations.
 
Many of the
 
older exploration drill
 
holes
appear to
 
have been located
 
by ground survey;
 
more recently completed
 
drill holes
 
are often located
by high-resolution Global Positioning System (GPS) units.
>
 
Grid systems used are typically the State Plane Coordinate System pertinent to each property.
 
>
 
Topography
 
is based
 
on either
 
the USGS
 
topographic 7.5-minute
 
quadrangle
 
maps or
 
on recent
aerial photogrammetry as necessary (subject to availability).
Data spacing and
distribution
>
 
Data spacing for reporting of Exploration Results.
>
 
Whether the data
 
spacing and distribution
 
is sufficient to
 
establish the degree
 
of geological
and
 
grade
 
continuity
 
appropriate
 
for
 
the
 
Mineral
 
Resource
 
and
 
Ore
 
Reserve
 
estimation
procedure(s) and classifications applied.
>
 
Whether sample compositing has been applied.
>
 
Spacing and distribution of data point information may vary from seam to seam within each mining
area.
 
The areas estimated for coal resource and
 
coal reserve tonnes have been limited so that the
data spacing
 
and distribution
 
is sufficient to
 
establish the degree
 
of geological
 
continuity appropriate
for the estimation and classification of the coal tonnes.
 
>
 
MM&A performed a
 
geostatistical analysis using
 
the Drill Hole
 
Spacing Analysis
 
(DHSA) method.
 
This
method attempts to quantify the uncertainty of applying a measurement from a central location to
increasingly
 
larger
 
square
 
blocks
 
and
 
provides
 
recommendations
 
for
 
determining
 
the
 
distances
between drill holes for measured, indicated, and inferred resources.
>
 
All of the
 
coal resource
 
tonnes are
 
in the measured,
 
indicated, and
 
inferred categories,
 
and all of
the coal reserve
 
tonnes are in
 
the proved and
 
probable categories in accordance
 
with the JORC
 
Code
and SEC standards.
 
Orientation of data in
relation to geological
structure
>
 
Whether the orientation
 
of sampling achieves
 
unbiased sampling of
 
possible structures and
the extent to which this is known, considering the deposit type.
>
 
If
 
the relationship
 
between
 
the drilling
 
orientation and
 
the
 
orientation
 
of
 
key
 
mineralised
structures
 
is
 
considered
 
to
 
have
 
introduced
 
a
 
sampling
 
bias,
 
this
 
should
 
be
 
assessed
 
and
reported if material.
>
 
Drill holes have
 
been vertically
 
drilled.
 
No downhole deviation
 
logs have
 
been collected and
 
it is
therefore not
 
known if
 
the drill
 
holes have
 
deviated away
 
from vertical.
 
Based on
 
the relatively
shallow seam depths,
 
any deviation is
 
expected to be
 
insignificant and immaterial
 
to the geologic
characterization of the Property.
>
 
The dip
 
of the
 
coal seams
 
is relatively
 
minor,
 
generally 1-2
 
degrees and
 
not a
 
material issue
 
for
representation of seam thickness or quality.
Sample security
The measures taken to ensure sample security.
>
 
Sample handling procedures employed by explorationists
 
follow typical US protocol and
 
should be
adequate to ensure sample security.
Audits or reviews
The results of any audits or reviews of sampling techniques and data.
>
 
MM&A
 
has
 
reviewed
 
all
 
available
 
geological
 
information
 
for
 
the
 
Properties
 
in
 
developing
 
the
geologic model.
 
Only that data deemed
 
suitable has been used for
 
the purpose of generating
 
the
resource and reserve estimates.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
4
Section 2 Reporting of Exploration Results
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Mineral tenement and
land tenure status
>
 
Type,
 
reference
 
name/number,
 
location
 
and
 
ownership
 
including
 
agreements
 
or
 
material
issues with third parties such as joint ventures, partnerships,
 
overriding royalties, native title
interests, historical sites, wilderness or national park and environmental settings.
>
 
The security of the
 
tenure held at the time
 
of reporting along with
 
any known impediments to
obtaining a license to operate in the area.
>
 
The
 
Coronado
 
coal
 
resources
 
are
 
located
 
within
 
the
 
United
 
States
 
of
 
America
 
in
 
the
 
states
 
of
Virginia;
 
West
 
Virginia;
 
and
 
Pennsylvania.
 
Control
 
of
 
these
 
Properties
 
is
 
governed
 
by
 
multiple
agreements.
>
 
MM&A has
 
not carried
 
out separate
 
title verification
 
for the
 
coal properties
 
and has
 
not verified
leases, deeds, surveys or other property control instruments pertinent to the subject resources.
 
>
 
Coronado has represented to MM&A
 
that it controls the mining
 
rights to the coal
 
deposits as shown
on its property maps, and MM&A has accepted these as being a true and accurate depiction of the
mineral
 
rights
 
controlled
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
The
 
TRS
 
assumes
 
the
 
properties
 
are
 
developed
 
under
responsible and experienced management.
>
 
There are no known legal or environmental encumbrances that
 
would impede development of the
subject coal reserves.
Exploration done by
other parties
>
 
Acknowledgment and appraisal of exploration by other parties.
>
 
The
 
Properties
 
have
 
been
 
extensively
 
explored
 
by
 
subsurface
 
drilling
 
efforts
 
carried
 
out
 
by
numerous entities, most of which were completed prior to acquisition by Coronado.
>
 
This exploration work
 
was generally performed to
 
prevailing US best practice
 
standards and deemed
adequate for the purposes of this TRS.
 
Geology
>
 
Deposit type, geological setting and style of mineralisation.
>
 
The Coronado coal resources are located within the Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basin.
>
 
The coal
 
deposits are Carboniferous
 
in age,
 
being of the
 
Pennsylvanian system
 
with sedimentary,
stratigraphic deposition.
>
 
Seam of
 
economic significance
 
typically ranges
 
between 0.3
 
meters and
 
1.8 meters
 
in thickness,
with relatively little structural deformation.
>
 
Regional structure is
 
typically characterized
 
by gently dipping
 
strata to
 
the northwest at
 
less than
one percent.
Drill hole Information
>
 
A
 
summary
 
of
 
all
 
information
 
material
 
to
 
the
 
understanding
 
of
 
the
 
exploration
 
results
including a tabulation of the following information for all Material drill holes:
•
 
easting and northing of the drill hole collar
•
 
elevation or
 
RL (Reduced
 
Level –
 
elevation above
 
sea level
 
in metres)
 
of the
 
drill hole
collar
•
 
dip and azimuth of the hole
•
 
down hole length and interception depth
•
 
hole length.
>
 
If the exclusion of this information is
 
justified on the basis that
 
the information is not Material
and this
 
exclusion
 
does not
 
detract
 
from the
 
understanding
 
of the
 
report, the
 
Competent
Person should clearly explain why this is the case.
>
 
MM&A reviewed and entered all pertinent data into a
 
digital geologic database for each Coronado
property.
 
The
 
database
 
consists
 
of
 
thousands
 
of
 
data
 
records,
 
which
 
include
 
drill
 
hole
 
and
supplemental coal seam thickness measurements from outcrop and mine exposures.
 
>
 
All drill holes
 
in the database
 
are provided with
 
a collar elevation
 
and the State
 
Plane Coordinate
System easting and northing coordinate.
>
 
After MM&A confirmed
 
proper coal seam
 
thickness and correlation, the
 
seam data was
 
modelled
and compiled into coal resource maps.
>
 
The maps are provided in the TRS show drill hole locations;
 
however, a
 
tabulation of the individual
data records is not practical to include.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
5
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Data aggregation
methods
>
 
In reporting Exploration Results, weighting averaging techniques, maximum and/or minimum
grade
 
truncations (e.g.
 
cutting of
 
high
 
grades) and
 
cut-off
 
grades
 
are usually
 
Material and
should be stated.
>
 
Where aggregate intercepts incorporate short
 
lengths of high grade
 
results and longer lengths
of low
 
grade
 
results, the
 
procedure used
 
for such
 
aggregation
 
should be
 
stated
 
and some
typical examples of such aggregations should be shown in detail.
>
 
The assumptions used for any reporting of metal equivalent values should be clearly stated.
>
 
If a coal seam has been
 
bench sampled,
 
the individual analyses for the coal plies
 
would be weight-
averaged to represent the total of recoverable coal to be included in the quality model.
>
 
Coal quality summary
 
results have been documented
 
in the TRS.
 
Average coal quality on
 
a per-seam
basis is used to represent the coal resources within a given mining area.
>
 
Average coal quality for each Coronado complex is provided in Tables 1-1, 1-2 and 1-3 of this TRS.
 
>
 
No other data aggregations methods are used.
Relationship between
mineralisation widths
and intercept lengths
>
 
These relationships are particularly important in the reporting of Exploration Results.
>
 
If the geometry of the mineralisation
 
with respect to the drill hole angle
 
is known, its nature
should be reported.
>
 
If
 
it
 
is
 
not
 
known
 
and
 
only
 
the
 
down
 
hole
 
lengths
 
are
 
reported,
 
there
 
should
 
be
 
a
 
clear
statement to this effect (e.g. ‘down hole length, true width not known’).
>
 
Coal thickness values from all coal
 
intersections and down hole geophysical
 
logs are considered to
be vertical thicknesses.
 
Seam dip of approximately 2.0 to
 
3.0 degrees has little effect on the
 
vertical
thickness of the seam.
Diagrams
>
 
Appropriate maps and sections (with scales) and tabulations of intercepts should be included
for any significant discovery being reported These should include,
 
but not be limited to a plan
view of drill hole collar locations and appropriate sectional views.
>
 
Diagrams and maps showing the coal seam intercepts are presented in the TRS.
Balanced reporting
>
 
Where comprehensive
 
reporting of
 
all Exploration
 
Results is
 
not practicable,
 
representative
reporting of both low and high grades and/or widths should be practiced to avoid misleading
reporting of Exploration Results.
>
 
All of the available, qualified exploration data
 
has been included within the tabulations, maps, and
diagrams for this TRS.
>
 
Both coal thickness and
 
quality data are
 
deemed by MM&A to
 
be reasonably sufficient within
 
the
resource areas.
 
Therefore, there is a reasonable level of confidence in the geologic interpretations
required for coal resource determination based on the
 
available data and the techniques applied to
the data.
Other substantive
exploration data
>
 
Other exploration
 
data,
 
if meaningful
 
and
 
material,
 
should be
 
reported
 
including (but
 
not
limited to):
 
geological observations;
 
geophysical survey
 
results; geochemical
 
survey results;
bulk
 
samples
 
–
 
size
 
and
 
method
 
of
 
treatment;
 
metallurgical
 
test
 
results;
 
bulk
 
density,
groundwater,
 
geotechnical and
 
rock
 
characteristics; potential
 
deleterious or
 
contaminating
substances.
>
 
Informational material available
 
from the U.S.
 
Geological Survey and
 
the respective State
 
Surveys
was used to assist in the Resource estimate.
 
Further work
>
 
The
 
nature
 
and
 
scale
 
of
 
planned
 
further
 
work
 
(e.g.
 
tests
 
for
 
lateral
 
extensions
 
or
 
depth
extensions or large-scale step-out drilling).
>
 
Diagrams clearly highlighting
 
the areas of
 
possible extensions, including
 
the main geological
interpretations
 
and
 
future
 
drilling
 
areas,
 
provided
 
this
 
information
 
is
 
not
 
commercially
sensitive.
>
 
Further
 
work
 
is
 
expected
 
to
 
include
 
additional
 
exploration,
 
geotechnical
 
testing,
 
coal
 
quality
analyses, and coal property acquisition.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
6
Section 3 Estimation and Reporting of Mineral Resources
(Criteria listed in the preceding section also apply to this section.)
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Database integrity
>
 
Measures taken to ensure that data has not been corrupted
 
by, for example, transcription or
keying
 
errors,
 
between
 
its
 
initial
 
collection
 
and
 
its
 
use
 
for
 
Mineral
 
Resource
 
estimation
purposes.
>
 
Data validation procedures used.
>
 
MM&A confirmed coal
 
seam thickness
 
and correlations in
 
databases used for
 
coal deposit
 
modelling.
 
Representative records were spot-checked for data entry validation.
 
>
 
Geophysical logs were
 
used wherever available to
 
assist in confirming
 
the seam correlation and to
verify proper seam thickness measurements and recovery of coal samples.
Site visits
>
 
Comment on any site visits undertaken by the
 
Competent Person and the outcome of
 
those
visits.
>
 
If no site visits have been undertaken indicate why this is the case.
>
 
MM&A is very familiar with the Properties and has conducted multiple site visits and evaluations of
the Property and adjoining properties throughout the years.
 
>
 
A
 
site visit
 
to
 
Mon Valley
 
was
 
conducted
 
as
 
recently
 
as
 
December 2023,
 
although there
 
are
 
no
facilities or surface expression of the coal reserves on the Property.
 
Planned surface areas for mine
facilities were viewed.
Geological
interpretation
>
 
Confidence in (or conversely, the uncertainty of) the geological interpretation of the mineral
deposit.
>
 
Nature of the data used and of any assumptions made.
>
 
The effect, if any, of alternative interpretations
 
on Mineral Resource estimation.
>
 
The use of geology in guiding and controlling Mineral Resource estimation.
>
 
The factors affecting continuity both of grade and geology.
>
 
Due to the relative structural simplicity of the deposits and the reasonable continuity of the tabular
coal
 
beds,
 
the
 
principal
 
geological
 
interpretation
 
necessary
 
to
 
define
 
the
 
geometry
 
of
 
the
 
coal
deposits is the proper modeling of their thickness and elevation.
 
>
 
Both coal thickness
 
and quality data
 
are deemed by
 
MM&A to
 
be reasonable within
 
the resource
areas.
 
>
 
Therefore, there is a reasonable level of confidence in the geologic interpretations required for coal
resource determination based on the available data and the techniques applied to the data.
Dimensions
>
 
The
 
extent
 
and
 
variability
 
of
 
the
 
Mineral
 
Resource
 
expressed
 
as
 
length
 
(along
 
strike
 
or
otherwise), plan width, and
 
depth below surface to the
 
upper and lower limits of
 
the Mineral
Resource.
>
 
The
 
subject
 
coal
 
resource
 
areas
 
mostly
 
exist
 
in
 
discreet,
 
individual
 
deposits
 
of
 
highly
 
variable
dimensions, shapes, and depth below the ground surface.
>
 
Such factors are best depicted in the maps contained in the TRS.
>
 
Details of the parameters
 
are cited within
 
the TRS and
 
included in the table
 
of Cut-off Parameters
listed in Section 11.1 of the TRS.
 
Estimation and
modelling techniques
>
 
The nature and appropriateness
 
of the estimation technique(s)
 
applied and key assumptions,
including
 
treatment
 
of
 
extreme
 
grade
 
values,
 
domaining,
 
interpolation
 
parameters
 
and
maximum
 
distance
 
of
 
extrapolation
 
from
 
data
 
points.
 
If
 
a
 
computer
 
assisted
 
estimation
method was chosen include a description of computer software and parameters used.
>
 
The availability of check estimates,
 
previous estimates and/or mine
 
production records and
whether the Mineral Resource estimate takes appropriate account of such data.
>
 
The assumptions made regarding recovery of by-products.
>
 
Estimation of
 
deleterious
 
elements or
 
other non-grade
 
variables of
 
economic significance
(e.g. sulphur for acid mine drainage characterisation).
>
 
In the
 
case of
 
block model
 
interpolation, the
 
block size
 
in relation
 
to the
 
average
 
sample
spacing and the search employed.
>
 
Geological
 
data
 
was
 
imported
 
into
 
Carlson
 
Mining®
 
(formerly
 
SurvCADD®)
 
geological
 
modelling
software in
 
the form
 
of Microsoft®
 
Excel files
 
incorporating, drill
 
hole collars,
 
seam and
 
thickness
picks, bottom
 
seam elevations
 
and raw
 
and washed
 
coal quality.
 
These data
 
files were
 
validated
prior to importing into the software.
>
 
Once imported, a geologic model was created.
>
 
The geological model was verified and reviewed.
 
>
 
Resources were estimated by
 
defining seam thickness at each point of observation and
 
by defining
resource confidence arcs around the points of observation.
>
 
Points of observation
 
for Measured and Indicated
 
confidence arcs were defined
 
for all drill
 
holes that
intersected the seam.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
7
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
Any assumptions behind modelling of selective mining units.
>
 
Any assumptions about correlation between variables.
>
 
Description of how the geological interpretation was used to control the resource estimates.
>
 
Discussion of basis for using or not using grade cutting or capping.
>
 
The process of validation,
 
the checking process used,
 
the comparison of model
 
data to drill
hole data, and use of reconciliation data if available.
>
 
As prescribed by
 
the common United
 
States classification system the
 
following distances from points
of observation were used to define the corresponding Resource category arcs:
-
 
Inferred Resources
 
– greater
 
than 3,960
 
feet (1.2
 
kilometers) but
 
less than
 
15,840 feet
 
(4.8
kilometers)
-
 
Indicated Resources – 3,960 feet (1.2 kilometers)
-
 
Measured Resources – 1,320 feet (0.4 kilometers)
>
 
The use of the
 
standards commonly used in
 
the United States are
 
appropriate and customary for this
resource jurisdiction and deposition type.
>
 
MM&A performed a
 
geostatistical analysis test of
 
the Coronado data
 
sets using the
 
Drill Hole Spacing
Analysis (DHSA) method to justify coal resource confidence levels.
>
 
Based on MM&A’s analysis, it
 
would be possible
 
to extend the measured,
 
indicated and inferred arcs
slightly beyond historically accepted practices due
 
to consistent geological settings.
 
The QP’s have
elected not to extend arc distances, introducing a level of conservatism in the coal classification.
Moisture
>
 
Whether the tonnages
 
are estimated on a dry
 
basis or with
 
natural moisture, and the
 
method
of determination of the moisture content.
>
 
Coal resource tonnes are presented on a dry, in-situ basis.
>
 
Reserve tonnes are presented on a moist basis at
 
anticipated product moisture ranging from 4.0 to
6.0 percent.
 
Moisture content based on historic analyses of shipped coal from the region.
Cut-off Parameters
>
 
The basis of the adopted cut-off grade(s) or quality parameters applied.
>
 
The cut-off parameters were tailored
 
for each of the Coronado properties to be in accordance with
mining/ processing capabilities and market conditions prevalent at each operation.
>
 
Examples include minimum recoverable coal thickness, acceptable ash
 
content and wash recovery,
and manageable overburden to coal ratio for surface mineable coal.
>
 
Details of the parameters
 
are cited within
 
the TRS and
 
included in the table
 
of Cut-off Parameters
listed in Section 11.1 of this TRS.
>
 
These
 
cut-off
 
parameters
 
have
 
been
 
developed
 
by
 
MM&A
 
based
 
on
 
its
 
experience
 
with
 
the
Coronado properties
 
and other
 
mining
 
operations of
 
the Central
 
and
 
Northern Appalachian
 
coal
basin.
 
This experience includes technical and
 
economic evaluations of numerous properties
 
in the
region for the purposes of determining the economic viability of the subject coal reserves.
Mining factors or
assumptions
>
 
Assumptions made
 
regarding
 
possible mining
 
methods, minimum
 
mining dimensions
 
and
internal
 
(or,
 
if
 
applicable,
 
external)
 
mining
 
dilution.
 
It
 
is
 
always
 
necessary
 
as
 
part
 
of
 
the
process of determining
 
reasonable prospects for
 
eventual economic
 
extraction to
 
consider
potential
 
mining
 
methods,
 
but
 
the
 
assumptions
 
made
 
regarding
 
mining
 
methods
 
and
parameters when
 
estimating Mineral
 
Resources may
 
not always
 
be rigorous.
 
Where this
 
is
the case, this should be reported with an explanation of the basis of the mining assumptions
made.
>
 
Mining factors such as dilution, mining and washing recovery are variable and have been applied at
the coal deposits at each operation based on site-specific characteristics.
>
 
Details of the factors are cited within the TRS.
>
 
Factors
 
that
 
would
 
typically
 
preclude
 
conversion
 
of
 
a
 
coal
 
resource
 
to
 
coal
 
reserve
 
include
 
the
following:
 
inferred
 
resource
 
classification;
 
absence
 
of
 
coal
 
quality;
 
poor
 
mine
 
recovery;
 
lack
 
of
access; insufficient exploration; or
 
uncontrolled surface property
 
for areas of
 
proposed for surface
mining.
 
>
 
While such factors were used to preclude the conversion of a very limited number of coal resources
to coal reserves in this report, the extensive history of mining on the Properties would suggest that
there
 
are
 
reasonable
 
prospects
 
for
 
eventual
 
economic
 
extractions
 
of
 
all
 
coal
 
resources
 
under
favorable market conditions.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
8
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Metallurgical factors or
assumptions
>
 
The
 
basis
 
for
 
assumptions or
 
predictions
 
regarding
 
metallurgical
 
amenability.
 
It
 
is
 
always
necessary as part of the process of determining reasonable prospects for eventual economic
extraction
 
to
 
consider
 
potential
 
metallurgical
 
methods,
 
but
 
the
 
assumptions
 
regarding
metallurgical treatment processes and parameters made when reporting Mineral Resources
may
 
not
 
always
 
be
 
rigorous.
 
Where
 
this
 
is
 
the
 
case,
 
this
 
should
 
be
 
reported
 
with
 
an
explanation of the basis of the metallurgical assumptions made.
>
 
The products mined
 
from coal resources
 
controlled by
 
Coronado can be
 
sold into high
 
-, mid-, and
low-volatile metallurgical coal markets because of their inherent quality characteristics.
 
>
 
Run-of-mine production is washed at the coal preparation plants as needed for quality control.
 
>
 
Coronado may blend production from
 
multiple sources to manage ash
 
and sulfur content along with
the rheological and petrographic characteristics of the shipped products.
 
Environmental factors
or assumptions
>
 
Assumptions made regarding
 
possible waste and
 
process residue disposal
 
options. It is
 
always
necessary as part of the process of determining reasonable prospects for eventual economic
extraction
 
to
 
consider the
 
potential
 
environmental
 
impacts of
 
the mining
 
and
 
processing
operation.
 
While
 
at
 
this
 
stage
 
the
 
determination
 
of
 
potential
 
environmental
 
impacts,
particularly for
 
a greenfields
 
project, may
 
not always
 
be well
 
advanced, the
 
status of
 
early
consideration of
 
these potential
 
environmental
 
impacts should
 
be reported.
 
Where these
aspects
 
have
 
not
 
been
 
considered
 
this
 
should
 
be
 
reported
 
with
 
an
 
explanation
 
of
 
the
environmental assumptions made.
>
 
A study completed on
 
behalf of Coronado for
 
Mon Valley has
 
identified a Preferred
 
Site for refuse
disposal
 
at
 
Pangburn
 
with
 
capacity
 
of
 
22.6 million
 
cubic
 
meters.
 
Estimated
 
requirements
 
for
Pangburn and Shaner
 
combined is 29.7 million tonnes
 
or approximately
 
13.2 million cubic meters.
 
Permitting for such a facility is anticipated to be achievable.
>
 
MM&A completed a
 
Limited Phase I
 
Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) on
 
the Buchanan property
in
 
April
 
2016,
 
and
 
on
 
the
 
Logan
 
County
 
and
 
Greenbrier
 
Properties
 
in
 
May
 
2017
 
on
 
behalf
 
of
Coronado.
 
Coronado reports not having conducted such a study since the MM&A studies.
 
>
 
The ESAs completed
 
by MM&A included
 
a site inspection,
 
review of historical
 
records, a
 
database
search
 
of
 
State
 
and
 
Federal
 
regulatory
 
records
 
and
 
interviews
 
to
 
identify
 
potential
 
recognized
environmental conditions (RECs) that may create environmental liability for the sites.
 
>
 
MM&A identified one REC
 
at Greenbrier associated with
 
stained soil and
 
gravel near a
 
fueling and
maintenance area.
 
Coronado reported to MM&A that satisfactory clean-up efforts were completed
at Greenbrier.
 
>
 
Based
 
on
 
these
 
former
 
ESAs
 
completed
 
by
 
MM&A,
 
it
 
is
 
MM&A’s
 
opinion
 
that
 
Coronado
 
has
 
a
generally
 
typical
 
coal
 
industry
 
record
 
of
 
compliance
 
with
 
applicable
 
mining,
 
water
 
quality,
 
and
environmental laws.
 
Estimated costs
 
for mine
 
closure, including
 
water quality
 
monitoring during
site reclamation, are included in the TRS financial models.
 
Bulk density
>
 
Whether assumed or determined. If assumed, the
 
basis for the assumptions. If determined,
the method used, whether wet or dry,
 
the frequency of the measurements, the nature, size
and representativeness of the samples.
>
 
The bulk
 
density for
 
bulk material
 
must have
 
been measured
 
by methods
 
that adequately
account for
 
void spaces
 
(vugs, porosity,
 
etc),
 
moisture
 
and
 
differences
 
between rock
 
and
alteration zones within the deposit.
>
 
Discuss assumptions
 
for bulk density
 
estimates used in
 
the evaluation process of
 
the different
materials.
>
 
Laboratory
 
derived
 
seam
 
densities
 
measured
 
in
 
specific
 
gravity
 
were
 
used
 
where
 
available.
 
As
needed, these
 
data
 
were
 
supplemented by
 
estimated seam
 
density values
 
based on
 
the relative
proportion of coal and non-coal material within the seam (typically at 1.30 and
 
2.25 specific gravity,
respectively).
>
 
Average seam density was determined for each coal deposit and used
 
to convert coal volumes into
coal tonnage estimates.
Classification
>
 
The basis for the classification of the Mineral Resources into varying confidence categories.
>
 
Whether appropriate account has been taken
 
of all relevant factors
 
(i.e. relative confidence
in tonnage/grade
 
estimations, reliability
 
of input
 
data, confidence
 
in continuity
 
of geology
and metal values, quality, quantity and distribution of the data).
>
 
Whether the result appropriately reflects the Competent
>
 
Person’s view of the deposit.
>
 
The Resource has been
 
classified based on suitable
 
distances from points of observations
 
prescribed
in the common United States classification system.
>
 
The use of
 
the United States
 
standards is
 
appropriate and customary
 
for this resource
 
jurisdiction
and deposition type.
>
 
MM&A performed a
 
geostatistical analysis test of
 
the Coronado data
 
sets using the
 
Drill Hole Spacing
Analysis (DHSA) method.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
9
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
Based on MM&A’s analysis, it
 
would be possible
 
to extend the measured,
 
indicated and inferred arcs
slightly beyond historically accepted practices due
 
to consistent geological settings.
 
The QP’s have
elected not to extend arc distances, introducing a level of conservatism in the coal classification.
>
 
All relevant factors have been
 
accounted for and reflect
 
the Competent Person’s view of
 
the deposit.
Audits or reviews
>
 
The results of any audits or reviews of Mineral Resource estimates.
>
 
MM&A
 
completed
 
prepared
 
a
 
statement
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
for
 
the
 
Properties
 
in
accordance with the
 
JORC Code as
 
of December 31, 2017.
 
MM&A also subsequently updated
 
the
estimate
 
of
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
for
 
depletion
 
as
 
of
 
December 31, 2018,
 
December 31, 2019,
December 31, 2020, December 31, 2021,
 
and December 31, 2022.
>
 
MM&A
 
performed
 
a
 
previous
 
audit
 
of
 
the
 
Properties
 
in
 
year
 
2017
 
for
 
Coronado
 
based
 
on
 
U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Industry Guide 7 and USGS Circular 891 standards.
 
>
 
Earlier
 
audits
 
were
 
performed
 
by
 
various
 
independent
 
consultants
 
for
 
predecessors-in-title
 
to
Coronado and at various levels of detail depending on the clients concerns and the allotted time
 
for
completion.
 
Previous audits and reviews defined
 
the primary coal resource areas
 
and estimated the
recoverable tonnes for each seam based on the expected mining methods.
 
>
 
Additionally, MM&A
 
has performed proprietary
 
evaluations for
 
predecessors-in-title to Coronado,
which encompass portions of the Properties included in this TRS.
Discussion of relative
accuracy/ confidence
>
 
Where appropriate a statement of
 
the relative accuracy and confidence level
 
in the Mineral
Resource estimate using
 
an approach or procedure
 
deemed appropriate by
 
the Competent
Person. For example, the application of
 
statistical or geostatistical procedures to quantify the
relative accuracy
 
of the resource
 
within stated
 
confidence limits, or,
 
if such an
 
approach is
not deemed appropriate, a qualitative discussion of the factors that could affect the
 
relative
accuracy and confidence of the estimate.
>
 
The statement should
 
specify whether it
 
relates to global
 
or local estimates,
 
and, if local,
 
state
the
 
relevant
 
tonnages,
 
which
 
should
 
be
 
relevant
 
to
 
technical
 
and
 
economic
 
evaluation.
Documentation should include assumptions made and the procedures used.
>
 
These statements of
 
relative accuracy
 
and confidence of
 
the estimate should
 
be compared
with production data, where available.
>
 
The relative accuracy of
 
and confidence in the
 
coal tonnage and
 
quality estimates provided herein
are judged to be in conformance with current industry best-practices.
 
>
 
The
 
representation
 
of
 
average
 
coal
 
quality
 
characteristics
 
should
 
be
 
understood
 
to
 
represent
 
a
reasonably representative sampling
 
that is generally
 
indicative of coal
 
quality and does
 
not represent
a statistically rigorous approach to coal quality modeling.
>
 
Resource
 
estimation
 
has
 
been
 
completed
 
using
 
standard
 
coal
 
estimation
 
methods
 
which
 
are
deemed appropriate for this deposit.
Section 4 Estimation and Reporting of Ore Reserve
(Criteria listed in the preceding section also apply to this section.)
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Mineral Resource
estimate for conversion
to Ore Reserves
 
>
 
Description of the
 
Mineral Resource
 
estimate used
 
as a
 
basis for
 
the conversion
 
to an
 
Ore
Reserve.
>
 
The coal
 
resource estimate
 
was prepared
 
as part
 
of the
 
report Coronado
 
Global Resources
 
Inc.
Statement of Coal
 
Resources and
 
Reserves in Accordance
 
with JORC Code
 
and United States
 
SEC
Standards as
 
of December 31,
 
2023 –
 
Northern and
 
Central Appalachian Coal
 
Basins –
 
Virginia, West
Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA – February 2024 prepared by MM&A.
>
 
The resource estimation criteria were developed by
 
MM&A based on the capabilities
 
of the mining
equipment used within the
 
production model and
 
on industry-accepted standards
 
to assure that
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
10
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
the basic geologic characteristics of the coal resources are
 
in reasonable conformity with those to
be mined and marketed by Coronado.
>
 
Clear statement as to whether the Mineral Resources are reported additional to, or inclusive
of, the Ore Reserves.
>
 
Coal resources generally are reported
 
inclusive of the coal reserves.
 
In some cases, resources are
reported in
 
addition to
 
coal reserves.
 
Tables
 
1-1 and
 
11-3 of
 
the TRS
 
clearly identify
 
resources
“inclusive
 
of
 
mine
 
plan”
 
from
 
which
 
coal
 
reserves
 
were
 
estimated
 
along
 
with
 
those
 
resources
“exclusive of mine plan” from which no reserves were estimated.
 
Site visits
 
>
 
Comment on any site visits undertaken by the
 
Competent Person and the outcome of
 
those
visits.
>
 
MM&A
 
is
 
very
 
familiar
 
with
 
the
 
Properties
 
and
 
has
 
conducted
 
multiple
 
site
 
visits
 
and
 
reserve
evaluations throughout the years.
>
 
A site visit
 
was conducted to Mon Valley as recently as December
 
2023 to assess proposed surface
mine facilities areas.
 
Currently there are no mine
 
facilities or surface expression of
 
the coal reserve
on the Property.
Study status
 
>
 
The type and level of study undertaken to enable Mineral
 
Resources to be converted to Ore
Reserves.
>
 
A preliminary feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for active and proposed mines.
 
>
 
The Code requires that a study to at least Pre-Feasibility Study
 
level has been undertaken to
convert Mineral Resources to Ore Reserves.
 
Such studies will have been carried out and will
have determined a mine plan that is
 
technically achievable and economically viable, and that
material Modifying Factors have been considered.
>
 
This geologic evaluation conducted in accordance with JORC and SEC standards and in conjunction
with the preliminary feasibility study is sufficient to conclude that the
 
surface, highwall miner and
underground
 
coal
 
reserves
 
identified
 
on
 
the
 
Properties
 
are
 
economically
 
mineable
 
under
reasonable expectations of
 
market prices
 
for thermal
 
and metallurgical
 
coal products, estimated
operation costs, and capital expenditures.
>
 
The pre-feasibility
 
financial models,
 
prepared by
 
MM&A for
 
this TRS,
 
was developed
 
to test
 
the
economic viability of each coal resource area.
>
 
Proved and probable coal reserve were derived from the defined in-situ coal
 
resource considering
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
independent
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue
 
and
 
cost,
marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors).
Cut-off parameters
 
>
 
The basis of the adopted cut-off grade(s) or quality parameters applied.
>
 
The cut-off parameters were tailored for each of the Coronado
 
properties to be in accordance with
mining/ processing capabilities and market conditions prevalent at each operation.
>
 
Examples include minimum recoverable coal thickness,
 
acceptable ash content and wash recovery,
and manageable overburden to coal ratio for surface mineable coal.
>
 
Details of the parameters are cited within
 
the TRS and included in the table of Cut-off
 
Parameters
listed in Section 11.1 of this TRS.
>
 
These
 
cut-off
 
parameters
 
have
 
been
 
developed
 
by
 
MM&A
 
based
 
on
 
its
 
experience
 
with
 
the
Coronado properties and are typical of mining
 
operations in the Central and Northern Appalachian
coal basin.
 
This experience includes technical
 
and economic evaluations of numerous
 
properties in
the region for the purposes of determining the economic viability of the subject coal reserves.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
11
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Mining factors or
assumptions
 
>
 
The method and
 
assumptions used as
 
reported in the
 
Pre-Feasibility or
 
Feasibility Study to
convert the
 
Mineral Resource
 
to an
 
Ore Reserve
 
(i.e. either
 
by application
 
of appropriate
factors by optimisation or by preliminary or detailed design).
>
 
After validating coal seam data
 
and establishing correlations, the
 
thickness and elevation for seams
of economic interest were used to generate a geologic model.
>
 
A
 
pre-feasibility
 
LOM
 
plan
 
was
 
prepared
 
by
 
MM&A
 
for
 
active
 
and
 
proposed
 
mines.
 
MM&A
prepared mine
 
projections and
 
production timing
 
forecasts
 
based on
 
coal seam
 
characteristics.
 
Production timing was carried out from 2024 to depletion (exhaustion) of the coal reserve areas.
>
 
The choice, nature and appropriateness
 
of the selected mining method(s) and
 
other mining
parameters including associated design issues such as pre-strip, access, etc.
>
 
The
 
room-and-pillar mining
 
method was
 
selected to
 
model the
 
underground
 
mining
 
resources,
utilizing continuous miners for coal
 
extraction, shuttle cars for production section haulage
 
and roof
bolters for
 
roof control,
 
with the exception
 
that the Buchanan
 
Mine also uses
 
longwall shearers,
armored face
 
conveyors,
 
and hydraulic
 
self-advancing roof
 
support.
 
The resource
 
areas located
above drainage
 
are relatively
 
small and
 
often have
 
irregular boundaries.
 
The Buchanan Mine
 
in
Buchanan County, Virginia is the only active longwall mine currently being operated by Coronado.
>
 
The Coronado
 
underground mining
 
resource areas
 
which are
 
located above-drainage
 
require an
access road and mine
 
access development along the
 
outcrop, whereas below-drainage mines
 
are
accessed via shaft
 
or slope based
 
on other proposed
 
surface infrastructure locations and/or
 
surface
property control.
 
>
 
The surface mining method
 
selected utilizes highly productive hydraulic shovels, front-end
 
loaders,
large
 
tractors
 
and
 
rock
 
trucks
 
for
 
overburden
 
removal.
 
The
 
mobile
 
equipment
 
spreads
 
adapt
readily to winding coal
 
outcrops for contour surface mining and
 
are effective for point-removal and
area mining applications.
>
 
Application of highwall and auger
 
mining units is an effective method
 
to recover coal resources not
suitable for underground mining and under excessive cover for surface mining.
>
 
The assumptions made regarding geotechnical parameters (e.g. pit slopes, stope sizes,
 
etc.),
grade control and pre-production drilling.
>
 
Mining
 
plans
 
for
 
potential
 
underground
 
mines
 
were
 
developed
 
by
 
MM&A.
 
Pillar
 
stability
 
was
tested by MM&A
 
using the Analysis of Coal
 
Pillar Stability (ACPS) program
 
that was developed by
the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH).
 
>
 
Coronado must obtain approved
 
mining plans from United
 
States Department of Labor
 
Mine Safety
and
 
Health
 
Administration
 
(MSHA)
 
that
 
define
 
safety
 
parameters
 
for
 
the
 
highwalls
 
developed
during
 
contour
 
and
 
area
 
mining.
 
MM&A’s
 
planning
 
model
 
does
 
not
 
require
 
input
 
of
 
specific
highwall design
 
parameters
 
but provides
 
for timing
 
of mining
 
within mine
 
plan polygons
 
that is
representative of the operation performance attained at Central Appalachia surface mines.
>
 
Highwall and auger mining is conducted under highwalls designed and constructed to meet MSHA
permit requirements.
 
To better assure highwall stability and safety during
 
highwall coal extraction,
MSHA requires
 
that coal
 
fenders,
 
or stumps,
 
be left
 
in place
 
between successive
 
cuts.
 
Periodic
barrier pillars must be left in
 
place as an additional safeguard.
 
MM&A has adjusted the expected
mining recovery
 
for highwall
 
and auger
 
mining resources
 
to reflect
 
highwall stability
 
and safety
requirements.
>
 
The
 
major
 
assumptions
 
made
 
and
 
Mineral
 
Resource
 
model
 
used
 
for
 
pit
 
and
 
stope
optimisation (if appropriate).
>
 
Underground
 
Mining
 
Resources:
 
For
 
metallurgical
 
resources,
 
minimum
 
coal
 
seam
 
thickness
extends down to between 0.6 and 1.2 meters and a minimum overburden (depth of cover) of 30.5
meters.
 
A 61-meter horizontal
 
distance is maintained
 
from abandoned mines
 
and sealed
 
or pillared
areas, and a 30-meter
 
horizontal distance is maintained from
 
planned highwall miner panels.
 
Mine
recovery is reduced when a rider coal seam
 
is present within a 1.5- to 3.0-meter interval above
 
the
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
12
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
coal seam.
 
No mining is projected when the interval between overlying and underlying reserves is
less than 12 meters.
>
 
Surface Mining
 
Resources:
 
For classification
 
as a
 
surface-mineable resource,
 
a seam
 
must be
 
at
least 0.3 meters in thickness
 
as a stand-alone (principal) seam
 
and 0.15 meters in thickness when
less than
 
0.8 meters
 
from a
 
principal seam.
 
The maximum
 
cumulative area
 
mining strip
 
ratio is
generally 20:1 for thermal coal and 30:1 for metallurgical coal.
 
Some areas were assessed for their
economic viability at higher
 
ratios and were included as reserves
 
if deemed economic.
 
For contour
surface mining, a minimum of 38-meter bench is provided to support HWM.
>
 
HWM and Auger Mining Resources: HWM cut depth (penetration) is established at
 
a maximum of
244 meters.
 
The minimum
 
mineable coal thickness
 
is limited
 
at 0.6
 
meters. For
 
coal seams
 
less
than 0.8 meters
 
thick, roof and/or floor
 
characteristics must allow
 
OSD cutting to
 
maintain a 0.8-
meter minimum cutting height.
 
Auger mining cut depth is established at an average of 91 meters.
 
The minimum mineable coal thickness is limited at 0.5 meters.
>
 
The mining dilution factors used.
>
 
Underground Mining Reserves:
 
The planning model assigns minimum mining heights of 1.4 to 1.8
meters for mains and panel development.
 
At the Buchanan Mine, a minimum mining height
 
of 1.8
meters was used due to the longwall mining
 
method being employed.
 
For coal seams thinner than
the assigned
 
mining
 
height,
 
the difference
 
between
 
the
 
coal
 
seam
 
height
 
and
 
assigned mining
height consists
 
of OSD.
 
In all
 
cases a
 
minimum of
 
0.05 meters
 
of OSD
 
was
 
assumed, with
 
the
exception of
 
the Mon
 
Valley
 
mines, where
 
a minimum
 
0.15 meters
 
of OSD
 
was assumed
 
due to
weaker floor strata.
>
 
Surface Mining Reserves:
 
Area mining is generally limited to
 
a cumulative overburden ratio of 30:1
and a 15:1 ratio for contour mining.
 
Exceptions were considered for mining of metallurgical grade
coal where deemed economical.
 
It is assumed that careful cleaning of exposed coal pits will result
in minimal OSD.
>
 
HWM and
 
Auger Mining
 
Reserves:
 
The mining
 
plan assumes
 
that the
 
HWM cutting
 
height is
 
a
minimum of 76 to
 
99 centimeters for
 
clearance purposes.
 
When the coal seam
 
is less than 76
 
to
99 centimeters
 
thick, OSD is
 
assumed and
 
included in the
 
ROM product.
 
Because the auger
 
has
very limited OSD
 
cutting ability,
 
it is assumed
 
that an appropriate
 
auger diameter will
 
be chosen
based on the coal seam thickness and that OSD will be minimal.
>
 
The mining recovery factors used.
>
 
Underground Mining
 
Reserves:
 
Mine recovery
 
generally
 
varies between
 
40 and
 
60 percent
 
for
continuous mining panels, and 100 percent for longwall.
>
 
Surface Mining
 
Reserves:
 
Mining recovery is
 
90 percent for
 
virgin areas.
 
Mining recovery is
 
reduced
where second mining is projected in previously underground and auger mined areas.
>
 
HWM and Auger Mining
 
Reserves:
 
A mine recovery of
 
40 percent has been
 
applied for HWM.
 
A
mine recovery of 35 percent has been applied for auger mining.
>
 
Any minimum mining widths used.
>
 
Underground Mining Reserves:
 
Typical entry width is 5.8 to 6.1 meters.
>
 
The
 
manner
 
in
 
which
 
Inferred
 
Mineral
 
Resources
 
are
 
utilised
 
in
 
mining
 
studies
 
and
 
the
sensitivity of the outcome to their inclusion.
>
 
Proved and probable coal reserve were derived from the defined in-situ coal
 
resource considering
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
independent
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue
 
and
 
cost,
marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors).
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
13
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
Mine plan LOM tonnage includes
 
inferred coal and those areas that
 
do not meet the minimum coal
thickness requirement for classification as reserve.
 
Inferred coal represents approximately 0.6% of
the LOM production for Mon Valley
 
and 0.000001% of the total LOM production for
 
Logan.
 
None
of this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
>
 
The infrastructure requirements of the selected mining methods.
>
 
Underground Mining Resources:
 
The continuous mining
 
method provides for the
 
extraction of coal
from the production faces
 
using continuous miners (and
 
longwall shearing machine at
 
Buchanan)
and haulage
 
using shuttle
 
cars
 
or battery
 
haulers
 
to a
 
feeder-breaker
 
located
 
at
 
the tail
 
of the
section conveyor belt.
 
The feeder-breaker crushes large pieces of coal and rock and regulates coal
feed onto the mine
 
conveyor.
 
A chain conveyor
 
is used to remove
 
coal from the
 
longwall face at
the
 
Buchanan
 
Mine
 
for
 
placement
 
onto
 
the
 
conveyor
 
belt
 
which
 
is
 
ultimately
 
delivered
 
to
 
an
underground storage
 
bunker.
 
Roof-bolting
 
machines are
 
used to
 
install
 
roof bolts,
 
and battery
scoops are available to clean the mine entries
 
and assist in delivery of mine supplies
 
to work areas.
 
Surface ventilation
 
fans are
 
installed as
 
needed to provide
 
a sufficient
 
volume of
 
air to
 
ventilate
production
 
sections,
 
coal
 
haulage
 
and
 
transport
 
entries,
 
battery
 
charging
 
stations,
 
and
transformers in accordance with approved plans.
>
 
Coronado
 
currently
 
operates
 
three
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plants,
 
one
 
each
 
at
 
the
 
Buchanan,
 
Logan
County and Greenbrier
 
Divisions.
 
The Buchanan Plant
 
operates at a feed rate of approximately 907
raw tonnes per hour (tph), whereas the Saunders
 
Plant (Logan County Division) has a nominal feed
rate of 816 tph, and the Mountaineer Plant (Greenbrier Division) operates at 544 tph.
 
MM&A has
included
 
capital
 
estimates
 
for
 
construction
 
of
 
additional
 
coal
 
preparation
 
plants
 
at
 
the
 
Russell
County and Mon Valley Complex for the purposes of this TRS.
 
>
 
Surface Mining Resources: The surface
 
mining mobile equipment spreads
 
advance the contour and
area
 
mining
 
pits
 
while
 
systematically
 
reclaiming
 
the
 
trailing
 
side
 
of
 
pits
 
where
 
coal
 
has
 
been
removed.
 
The coal haul roads are extended and maintained as the pits advance.
 
Support facilities
are maintained
 
nearby but
 
away
 
from the
 
active mining,
 
and include
 
storage
 
areas for
 
blasting
agents, fuel and lubricants, and mine supplies along with maintenance facilities and offices.
 
Most
of the surface mine production is transported to a
 
loading point for crushing, blending and direct-
shipment to customers.
 
>
 
HWM and
 
Auger Resources:
 
The HWM
 
equipment advances along
 
with the
 
contour mining
 
pits.
 
The rate of
 
advance of the contour
 
mining is governed by
 
the advancement rate
 
of the HWM.
 
A
diesel-powered generator trails the highwall miner and powers the continuous mining unit.
 
Other
support facilities are provided along
 
with the contour mining support facilities.
 
HWM production
is all transported by truck to the coal preparation plant for washing.
Metallurgical factors or
assumptions
 
>
 
The metallurgical process
 
proposed and the
 
appropriateness of that
 
process to
 
the style of
mineralisation.
>
 
Coarse material is
 
washed in a
 
heavy medium vessel.
 
Intermediate-size material is washed
 
in heavy
medium cyclones.
 
Fine material is washed using conventional froth flotation cells.
>
 
Whether the metallurgical process is well-tested technology or novel in nature.
>
 
Processes are typical of those
 
used in the coal industry
 
and are in use at
 
adjacent coal processing
plants.
>
 
The
 
nature,
 
amount
 
and
 
representativeness
 
of
 
metallurgical
 
test
 
work
 
undertaken,
 
the
nature of the metallurgical domaining applied and the corresponding metallurgical recovery
factors applied.
>
 
The quality characteristics for the subject
 
coal resources and coal reserves
 
have been reviewed in
detail by MM&A.
 
The drill hole data
 
were utilized to
 
develop average coal
 
quality characteristics
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
14
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
mining
 
site.
 
These
 
average
 
coal
 
quality
 
characteristics
 
were
 
then
 
utilized
 
as
 
the
 
basis
 
for
determining the various markets into which the saleable coal will likely be placed.
>
 
Any assumptions or allowances made for deleterious elements.
>
 
No significant effects
 
on product quality
 
are anticipated from
 
dilution material;
 
float product quality
was used to model final product quality.
>
 
The
 
existence
 
of
 
any
 
bulk
 
sample
 
or
 
pilot scale
 
test
 
work
 
and
 
the
 
degree
 
to
 
which
 
such
samples are considered representative of the orebody as a whole
>
 
No bulk sample or pilot scale work has been completed.
>
 
For minerals that
 
are defined by a
 
specification, has the ore
 
reserve estimation been based
on the appropriate mineralogy to meet specifications?
>
 
Notwithstanding the complexity of the coal quality
 
data set, the seams of the central and northern
Appalachian coalfields have a long history of providing both
 
high-Btu thermal coals and high-, mid-
and low-volatile coking coals with favorable metallurgical properties.
Environmental
 
>
 
The
 
status
 
of
 
studies
 
of
 
potential
 
environmental
 
impacts
 
of
 
the
 
mining
 
and
 
processing
operation. Details
 
of waste
 
rock
 
characterisation and
 
the consideration
 
of potential
 
sites,
status of design
 
options considered and,
 
where applicable, the
 
status of approvals for
 
process
residue storage and waste dumps should be reported.
>
 
A study
 
completed
 
on behalf
 
of Coronado
 
has identified
 
a Preferred
 
Site
 
for
 
refuse
 
disposal at
Pangburn with
 
capacity of
 
22.6 million cubic
 
meters.
 
Estimated requirements
 
for Pangburn
 
and
Shaner combined is 29.7 million tonnes or
 
approximately 13.2 million cubic meters.
 
Permitting for
such a facility is anticipated to be achievable.
 
>
 
MM&A
 
completed
 
a
 
Limited
 
Phase
 
I
 
Environmental
 
Site
 
Assessment
 
(ESA)
 
on
 
the
 
Buchanan
property in April 2016, and on the Logan County and Greenbrier Properties in May 2017 on behalf
of Coronado.
>
 
MM&A identified one REC at Greenbrier associated with stained soil and gravel near a fueling and
maintenance area.
 
Coronado reported to
 
MM&A that
 
satisfactory clean-up efforts were
 
completed
at Greenbrier.
>
 
Based on
 
these former
 
ESAs
 
completed
 
by
 
MM&A,
 
it is
 
MM&A’s
 
opinion that
 
Coronado
 
has
 
a
generally
 
typical
 
coal
 
industry
 
record
 
of
 
compliance with
 
applicable mining,
 
water
 
quality,
 
and
environmental laws.
 
Estimated costs for
 
mine closure, including
 
water quality monitoring
 
during
site reclamation, are included in the TRS financial models.
Infrastructure
 
>
 
The existence of
 
appropriate infrastructure: availability of
 
land for plant
 
development, power,
water,
 
transportation
 
(particularly for
 
bulk
 
commodities),
 
labour,
 
accommodation;
 
or the
ease with which the infrastructure can be provided or accessed.
>
 
Coronado currently
 
operates
 
one surface
 
mine (Toney
 
Fork Mine
 
at
 
the Logan
 
Mine Complex);
Coronado also controls the idle Midland Surface Mine at the Greenbrier Mine Complex.
 
>
 
Coronado operates
 
five underground
 
mines as
 
follows:
 
Buchanan Mine
 
at the
 
Buchanan Mine
Complex; Winifrede,
 
Eagle No.
 
1, Muddy
 
Bridge and
 
Lower War
 
Eagle Mines
 
in the
 
Logan Mine
Complex; the Mountaineer #1 Mine at the Greenbrier Mine Complex is currently
 
idle.
>
 
All
 
ROM
 
production
 
is currently
 
planned for
 
either
 
truck transportation
 
from
 
the mines
 
to
 
the
processing or shipping facilities, or in some cases there
 
is either a current or planned mine mouth
preparation plant and barge/rail loading facility.
 
>
 
There is a
 
network of public
 
highways that provide serviceable
 
coal haul routes and
 
private, internal
roads on the
 
Properties would be
 
developed as may
 
be needed.
 
Rail service to
 
the Properties is
most
 
readily
 
provided
 
by
 
NS
 
and
 
CSX
 
with
 
connections
 
to
 
both
 
domestic
 
consumers
 
and
international trans-shipment
 
points.
 
NS track
 
is located
 
across the
 
Monongahela River
 
from the
proposed Pangburn Hollow load-out
 
facility.
 
Coal would be shipped
 
to customers via barge and
 
rail
and sold as both metallurgical and thermal products.
 
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
15
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Costs
 
>
 
The derivation of, or assumptions made, regarding projected capital costs in the study.
>
 
The methodology used to estimate operating costs.
>
 
Coronado provided historical
 
and 5-year
 
budget operating
 
costs for
 
its active mines
 
for MM&A’s
review.
 
MM&A used the historical and/or
 
budget cost information as
 
a reference and developed
personnel schedules for each mine.
 
Hourly labor rates and salaries were
 
based upon information
contained in
 
Coronado’s
 
financial summaries.
 
Fringe benefit
 
costs were
 
developed for
 
vacation
and holidays, federal and state unemployment insurance, retirement,
 
workers’ compensation and
pneumoconiosis,
 
casualty
 
and
 
life
 
insurance,
 
healthcare
 
and
 
bonuses.
 
A
 
cost
 
factor
 
for
 
mine
supplies was developed that relates expenditures to mine advance rates for roof control costs and
other mine
 
supply costs
 
at underground
 
mines.
 
Other factors
 
were developed
 
for maintenance
and repair costs, rentals, mine power, outside services and other direct mining costs.
>
 
Surface mine
 
direct operating
 
costs were
 
developed as
 
a function of
 
overburden ratio
 
for repair
and
 
maintenance supplies,
 
diesel fuel,
 
explosives
 
and
 
blasting,
 
and
 
miscellaneous supplies
 
and
services.
 
Operating costs for highwall mines are
 
based on costs per ROM tonne estimates.
 
Other
cost factors
 
were developed
 
for coal
 
preparation plant
 
processing, refuse handling,
 
coal loading,
trucking, property taxes, and insurance and
 
bonding.
 
Appropriate royalty rates were
 
assigned for
production from leased
 
coal lands and
 
sales taxes
 
were calculated
 
for state
 
severance taxes,
 
the
federal black lung excise tax, and federal and state reclamation fees.
>
 
Capital schedules were developed
 
by MM&A for
 
mine development, infrastructure, and
 
on-going
capital requirements for the life of each projected mine.
>
 
Staffing levels
 
were prepared
 
and operating costs
 
estimated by
 
MM&A for
 
each projected mine.
 
MM&A utilized historical cost
 
data provided by
 
Coronado and its own
 
knowledge and experience
to estimate direct and indirect operating costs.
 
>
 
Allowances made for the content of deleterious elements.
>
 
No allowances
 
have been
 
made for
 
deleterious elements;
 
no impact
 
to quality
 
from deleterious
elements is anticipated.
>
 
The
 
derivation
 
of
 
assumptions
 
made
 
of
 
metal
 
or
 
commodity
 
price(s),
 
for
 
the
 
principal
minerals and co- products.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is derived
from market
 
observed forward estimates
 
based on global
 
economic supply and
 
demand analysis
which is applied to mine
 
plan sales volumes and product
 
mix and is supplemented with
 
Coronado’s
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
 
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation factor in order
to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
>
 
Derivation of transportation charges.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is derived
from market
 
observed forward estimates
 
based on global
 
economic supply and
 
demand analysis
which is applied to mine
 
plan sales volumes and product
 
mix and is supplemented with
 
Coronado’s
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
 
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation factor in order
to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
 
MM&A utilized this data for price forecasting in financial
modeling.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
16
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
The basis for forecasting or source of treatment and refining charges, penalties for failure
 
to
meet specification, etc.
>
 
MM&A utilized historical cost
 
data provided by
 
Coronado and its own
 
knowledge and experience
to estimate direct and indirect operating costs.
 
All ROM production is currently planned for either
truck transportation from the mines to the processing or shipping facilities, or in some cases there
is either a current or planned mine mouth preparation plant and barge/rail loading facility.
>
 
The allowances made for royalties payable, both Government and private.
>
 
Appropriate royalty rates were assigned for
 
production from leased coal
 
lands and sales taxes were
calculated
 
for
 
state
 
severance
 
taxes,
 
the
 
federal
 
black
 
lung
 
excise
 
tax,
 
and
 
federal
 
and
 
state
reclamation fees.
Revenue factors
 
>
 
The
 
derivation
 
of,
 
or
 
assumptions
 
made
 
regarding
 
revenue
 
factors
 
including
 
head
 
grade,
metal
 
or
 
commodity
 
price(s)
 
exchange
 
rates,
 
transportation
 
and
 
treatment
 
charges,
penalties, net smelter returns, etc.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is derived
from market
 
observed forward estimates
 
based on global
 
economic supply and
 
demand analysis
which is applied to mine
 
plan sales volumes and product
 
mix and is supplemented with
 
Coronado’s
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
 
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation factor in order
to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
 
MM&A utilized this data for price forecasting in financial
modeling.
>
 
The Greenbrier property is not considered material to Coronado’s business or financial conditions,
and thus no
 
update was completed for Greenbrier in
 
2024.
 
Resources exclusive of reserves, as
 
well
as reserves, are based on assumed
 
long-term average price
 
as of December 31, 2022 provided by
Coronado, representing Coronado’s long-term average
 
price forecast for Greenbrier at that time.
>
 
The derivation of assumptions
 
made of metal or
 
commodity price(s), for the principal
 
metals,
minerals and co-products.
>
 
Coal sales prices as defined above.
 
All reported reserves are on a marketable basis.
Market assessment
 
>
 
The demand, supply
 
and stock
 
situation for
 
the particular commodity,
 
consumption trends
and factors likely to affect supply and demand into the future.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is derived
from market
 
observed forward estimates
 
based on global
 
economic supply and
 
demand analysis
which is applied to mine
 
plan sales volumes and product
 
mix and is supplemented with
 
Coronado’s
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
 
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation factor in order
to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
 
MM&A utilized this data for price forecasting in financial
modeling.
>
 
A customer
 
and competitor analysis
 
along with the
 
identification of likely
 
market windows
for the product.
>
 
All of
 
the mine
 
production serves
 
metallurgical
 
and thermal
 
markets.
 
The
 
metallurgical
 
coal is
marketed
 
as
 
high-volatile
 
(typically
 
28
 
percent
 
or greater
 
volatile
 
matter
 
content);
 
mid-volatile
(typically 23- to 27-percent volatile matter content) and low-volatile (typically less than 23 percent
volatile matter content) products.
>
 
Raw ROM production that
 
requires washing is
 
currently processed through
 
Coronado owned and
operated coal preparation plants.
 
>
 
ROM coal
 
that does
 
not require
 
further processing
 
is delivered
 
directly to
 
the loading
 
points for
sizing and delivery
 
to customers.
 
Coronado has access
 
to two rail
 
-loading points serviced
 
by the
Norfolk Southern Corporation (NS) and two rail-loading points serviced by CSX Corporation (CSX).
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
17
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
Price and volume forecasts and the basis for these forecasts.
>
 
Carlson
 
Mining
 
®
 
was
 
used
 
by
 
MM&A
 
to
 
generate
 
mine
 
plans
 
for
 
underground-
 
and
 
surface-
mineable coal seams.
 
Underground mine plans were sequenced
 
based on productivity schedules
provided by Coronado, which
 
were based on historically
 
achieved productivity levels.
 
Surface mine
plans were
 
generated under
 
productivity assumptions (bank
 
cubic yard
 
per shift)
 
as provided
 
by
Coronado
 
and
 
reviewed
 
by
 
MM&A,
 
again
 
based
 
heavily
 
on
 
productivity
 
levels
 
achieved
 
by
Coronado.
 
All
 
production
 
forecasting
 
ties
 
assumed
 
production
 
rates
 
to
 
geological
 
models
 
as
constructed independently by MM&A’s team of geologists and mining engineers.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is derived
from market
 
observed forward estimates
 
based on global
 
economic supply and
 
demand analysis
which is applied to mine
 
plan sales volumes and product
 
mix and is supplemented with
 
Coronado’s
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
 
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation factor in order
to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
 
MM&A utilized this data for price forecasting in financial
modeling.
Economic
 
>
 
The inputs to the economic analysis to produce the net present value (NPV) in the study, the
source and confidence of these economic inputs
 
including estimated inflation, discount rate,
etc.
>
 
On an unlevered basis, the
 
NPV of the project cash flows
 
after taxes was estimated for the purpose
of
 
classifying
 
coal
 
reserves.
 
The
 
project
 
cash
 
flows,
 
excluding
 
debt
 
service,
 
are
 
calculated
 
by
subtracting direct and indirect operating
 
expenses and capital expenditures from
 
revenue.
 
Direct
costs
 
include
 
labor,
 
drilling and
 
blasting,
 
operating
 
supplies, maintenance
 
and
 
repairs,
 
facilities
costs for materials handling, coal preparation,
 
refuse disposal, coal loading, sampling and analysis
services, reclamation
 
and general
 
and administrative
 
costs.
 
Indirect costs
 
include statutory
 
and
legally agreed
 
upon fees
 
related
 
to
 
direct extraction
 
of the
 
mineral.
 
The indirect
 
costs are
 
the
Federal black
 
lung tax,
 
Federal and
 
State reclamation
 
taxes, property
 
taxes,
 
local transportation
prior to delivery at
 
rail or barge loading sites, coal
 
production royalties, sales and use
 
taxes, income
taxes
 
and
 
State
 
severance
 
taxes.
 
Coronado’s
 
historical
 
costs
 
provided
 
a
 
useful
 
reference
 
for
MM&A’s cost estimates.
>
 
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties.
 
Customer coal pricing is derived
from market
 
observed forward estimates
 
based on global
 
economic supply and
 
demand analysis
which is applied to mine
 
plan sales volumes and product
 
mix and is supplemented with
 
Coronado’s
in-house
 
knowledge
 
of
 
applicable
 
rail
 
transportation
 
charges,
 
ocean
 
freight
 
charges
 
and
 
port
charges.
 
Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US real dollars per metric tonne.
 
MM&A applied a 2% inflation factor in order
to estimate the prices in nominal dollars.
 
MM&A utilized this data for price forecasting in financial
modeling.
>
 
All costs and prices are based on year-end 2023 nominal United States dollars.
>
 
A
 
pre-feasibility
 
LOM
 
plan
 
was
 
prepared
 
by
 
MM&A
 
for
 
active
 
and
 
proposed
 
mines.
 
MM&A
prepared mine
 
projections and
 
production timing
 
forecasts
 
based on
 
coal seam
 
characteristics.
 
Production timing was
 
carried out from
 
2024 to depletion (exhaustion)
 
of the coal reserve
 
areas,
which is projected for the year 2101.
>
 
The all-mines average
 
cash cost ranges
 
between approximately $73
 
and $338 per tonne for
 
most
of the operating period.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
18
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
NPV ranges and sensitivity to variations in the significant assumptions and inputs.
>
 
An estimate of NPV at a base discount rate of 10.0% was included in Section 19 of the TRS.
>
 
NPV of the Buchanan,
 
Russell, Mon Valley,
 
Logan and Greenbrier
 
Properties was estimated
 
to be
$1.804 billion,
 
$155.1 million,
 
$563.4 million,
 
$616.8 million and
 
$62.7 million,
 
respectively.
 
The
Greenbrier NPV is based on December 31,
 
2022 coal sales price information provided by
 
Coronado
as described previously.
>
 
The
 
sensitivity
 
study
 
shows
 
the
 
NPV
 
at
 
the
 
10.0%
 
discount
 
rate
 
when
 
Base
 
Case
 
sales
 
prices,
operating costs, and capital
 
costs are increased and
 
decreased in increments of
 
5% within a +/-
 
15%
range.
 
Social
 
>
 
The
 
status
 
of
 
agreements
 
with
 
key
 
stakeholders
 
and
 
matters
 
leading
 
to
 
social
 
license
 
to
operate.
>
 
Portions
 
of
 
the
 
properties
 
are
 
located
 
near
 
local
 
communities.
 
Regulations
 
prohibit
 
mining
activities within
 
91
 
meters
 
of
 
a
 
residential
 
dwelling,
 
school,
 
church,
 
or
 
similar
 
structure
 
unless
written consent is first obtained from
 
the owner of the structure.
 
Where required, such consents
have been obtained where mining is proposed beyond the regulatory limits.
Other
 
To
 
the extent relevant,
 
the impact of
 
the following on
 
the project and/or
 
on the estimation
 
and
classification of the Ore Reserves:
>
 
Any identified material naturally occurring risks.
>
 
No material naturally occurring risks have been identified.
>
 
The status of material legal agreements and marketing arrangements.
>
 
The
 
Coronado
 
coal
 
resources
 
are
 
located
 
in
 
Buchanan, Russell
 
and
 
Tazewell
 
Counties, Virginia;
Greenbrier,
 
Logan,
 
Boone,
 
Wyoming
 
and
 
Greenbrier
 
Counties,
 
West
 
Virginia;
 
Allegheny,
Washington and Westmoreland Counties, Pennsylvania.
>
 
MM&A has not
 
carried out separate
 
title verification for
 
the coal properties
 
and has not
 
verified
leases, deeds, surveys or other property control instruments pertinent to the subject resources.
>
 
Coronado has represented to MM&A that it controls the mining
 
rights to the reserves as shown on
its property maps,
 
and MM&A has
 
accepted these as
 
being a
 
true and accurate
 
depiction of the
mineral
 
rights
 
controlled
 
by
 
Coronado.
 
The
 
TRS
 
assumes
 
the
 
properties
 
are
 
developed
 
under
responsible and experienced management.
>
 
The status
 
of government
 
agreements and
 
approvals critical
 
to the
 
viability of
 
the project,
such as
 
mineral tenement
 
status and
 
government and
 
statutory approvals.
 
There must
 
be
reasonable
 
grounds
 
to
 
expect
 
that
 
all
 
necessary
 
Government
 
approvals
 
will
 
be
 
received
within the
 
timeframes anticipated
 
in the
 
Pre-Feasibility
 
or Feasibility
 
study.
 
Highlight and
discuss the materiality of any unresolved
 
matter that is dependent on
 
a third part on which
extraction of the reserve is contingent.
>
 
Coronado has
 
obtained all
 
mining and
 
discharge permits
 
to operate
 
19 underground
 
mines, 15
surface mines, and 16 processing,
 
loadout or related facilities.
 
MM&A is unaware of any
 
obvious
or current Coronado permitting issues that
 
are expected to prevent the issuance of future permits.
 
Coronado, along
 
with all
 
Central and
 
Northern Appalachian basin
 
coal producers,
 
is subject
 
to a
level
 
of
 
uncertainty
 
regarding
 
future
 
clean
 
water
 
permits
 
due
 
to
 
United
 
States
 
Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) involvement with state programs.
Classification
 
>
 
The
 
basis
 
for
 
the
 
classification
 
of
 
the
 
Ore
 
Reserves
 
into
 
varying
 
confidence
 
categories.
Whether the result
 
appropriately reflects the
 
Competent Person’s
 
view of the
 
deposit. The
proportion
 
of
 
Probable
 
Ore
 
Reserves
 
that
 
have
 
been
 
derived
 
from
 
Measured
 
Mineral
Resources (if any).
>
 
Measured
 
and
 
indicated
 
resources
 
have
 
been
 
converted
 
to
 
proved
 
and
 
probable
 
reserves,
respectively.
>
 
None of the probable coal reserves have been derived from measured resources.
>
 
In a limited number of cases where there was
 
only very limited data available to
 
demonstrate the
metallurgical suitability
 
of a
 
given coal
 
deposit, that
 
deposit was
 
classified as
 
a probable
 
reserve
instead of a proved reserve.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
19
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
The results of
 
this TRS define an
 
estimated total initial ROM recoverable ore
 
(coal) reserve estimate
of 548 million tonnes for Coronado as follows:
a)
 
Buchanan =
 
154 Mt
b)
 
Logan
 
=
 
135 Mt
c)
 
Greenbrier=
 
12 Mt
d)
 
Russell =
 
50 Mt
e)
 
Mon Valley =
 
197 Mt
 
>
 
Coronado controls a
 
total of 333
 
Mt (moist basis) of
 
marketable coal reserves
 
for Coronado as
 
of
December 31, 2023 (total may not add due to rounding).
 
Of that total, 74 percent are proved, and
26 percent are probable.
 
Total reserves by complex are as follows:
a)
 
Buchanan =
 
92 Mt
b)
 
Logan
 
=
 
71 Mt
c)
 
Greenbrier=
 
7 Mt
d)
 
Russell =
 
30 Mt
e)
 
Mon Valley =
 
134 Mt
 
Audits or reviews
 
>
 
The results of any audits or reviews of Ore Reserve estimates.
>
 
MM&A
 
completed
 
prepared
 
a
 
statement
 
of
 
coal
 
resources
 
and
 
reserves
 
for
 
the
 
Properties
 
in
accordance with the JORC Code as of December 31, 2017.
 
MM&A also subsequently updated the
estimate of
 
resources and
 
reserves for
 
depletion as
 
of December 31,
 
2018, December 31,
 
2019,
December 31, 2020, December 31, 2021,
 
and December 31, 2022.
>
 
MM&A performed
 
a previous
 
audit
 
of the
 
Properties
 
in year
 
2017 for
 
Coronado
 
based on
 
U.S.
Securities
 
and
 
Exchange
 
Commission
 
(SEC)
 
Industry
 
Guide
 
7
 
standards.
 
Earlier
 
audits
 
were
performed by various
 
independent consultants for
 
predecessors-in-title to Coronado
 
and at various
levels of detail depending
 
on the clients concerns and
 
the allotted time for
 
completion.
 
Previous
audits and reviews defined the primary coal resource areas and estimated the recoverable tonnes
for each seam based on the expected mining methods.
>
 
Additionally, MM&A has performed proprietary evaluations for predecessors-in-title to Coronado,
which encompass portions of the Properties included in this TRS.
Discussion of relative
accuracy/ confidence
 
>
 
Where
 
appropriate
 
a
 
statement
 
of
 
the
 
relative
 
accuracy
 
and
 
confidence
 
level
 
in
 
the
 
Ore
Reserve estimate
 
using an
 
approach or
 
procedure deemed
 
appropriate by
 
the Competent
Person. For example, the application of
 
statistical or geostatistical procedures to quantify the
relative accuracy of the reserve within stated confidence limits, or, if such an approach is
 
not
deemed appropriate,
 
a qualitative
 
discussion of
 
the factors
 
which could
 
affect the
 
relative
accuracy and confidence of the estimate.
>
 
Operations on the
 
Properties by Coronado
 
and its predecessors
 
have been on-going for
 
many years.
 
>
 
MM&A
 
is confident
 
that the
 
mine
 
plans
 
and
 
financial models
 
are
 
reasonably
 
representative
 
to
provide an accurate estimation of coal reserves.
>
 
Mine development and operation have not been optimized within the TRS.
>
 
The statement should
 
specify whether it
 
relates to global
 
or local estimates,
 
and, if local,
 
state
the
 
relevant
 
tonnages,
 
which
 
should
 
be
 
relevant
 
to
 
technical
 
and
 
economic
 
evaluation.
Documentation should include assumptions made and the procedures used.
>
 
Proved and probable coal reserve were derived from the defined in-situ coal
 
resource considering
relevant
 
processing,
 
economic
 
(including
 
independent
 
estimates
 
of
 
capital,
 
revenue
 
and
 
cost),
marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and
 
regulatory factors on a global scale
 
as current
local data reflects the global assumptions.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
20
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
Accuracy
 
and
 
confidence
 
discussions should
 
extend
 
to
 
specific discussions
 
of any
 
applied
Modifying Factors
 
that may
 
have
 
a material
 
impact on
 
Ore Reserve
 
viability,
 
or for
 
which
there are remaining areas of uncertainty at the current study stage.
The major risk factors for the active Coronado mines and future resource development are summarized
below:
>
 
Mine Accidents
>
 
Highwall Failure.
 
Highwall failures are likely
 
to result in a temporary
 
mine closure and should not
have a material impact on the mine sustainability.
 
The risk is considered to be probable.
 
>
 
Adverse Geological Conditions.
 
Adverse geological conditions include such
 
conditions as faults and
sandstone
 
washouts.
 
The
 
risk
 
is
 
considered
 
to
 
be
 
probable.
 
The
 
impact
 
is
 
expected
 
to
 
be
temporary with little material impact on mine sustainability.
>
 
Environmental Risk.
 
Numerous federal and
 
state permits are
 
required to operate
 
coal mines and
mine surface facilities.
 
Permitting rules are
 
complex and may change
 
over time, making
 
compliance
difficult or impossible.
>
 
Water
 
Quality.
 
Permit
 
requirements
 
to
 
fulfill
 
Clean
 
Water
 
Act
 
obligations
 
are
 
subject
 
to
modification.
 
The probability of
 
water quality changes
 
having a material
 
impact on mine
 
operations
is
 
possible.
 
As
 
a
 
contemporary
 
example,
 
the
 
selenium
 
discharge
 
issue
 
that
 
affects
 
western
Canadian and Central Appalachian Basin operators has only recently emerged as a concern and its
ultimate impact has not been determined.
>
 
New Permits.
 
Permit protests by
 
environmental groups
 
and individuals can
 
contribute to permit
delays
 
or
 
denial
 
and
 
increase
 
the
 
cost
 
of
 
permitting
 
and
 
delay
 
development.
 
Surface
 
mining
activities,
 
coal
 
refuse
 
disposal
 
and
 
construction
 
of
 
access
 
roads
 
in
 
mountainous
 
terrain
 
often
require storage
 
of material
 
in valley
 
fills.
 
Authority to
 
dispose of
 
fill material
 
into waters
 
of the
United States must be granted
 
by the United States
 
Army Corps of Engineers (COE).
 
COE permits
are increasingly difficult to obtain.
>
 
Regulatory Requirements.
 
Adverse impact from regulatory changes
 
is considered to be probable.
 
The impact will likely affect the broader industry and is not expected to result in mine closure.
>
 
Market Risk.
 
Metallurgical and thermal coal markets ultimately depend
 
upon the global steel and
thermal coal demand and are considered
 
to be volatile.
 
Currently, the US
 
coal market has seen a
decline in demand for thermal coal due to thermal plant closures, as a result of new air and water
pollution regulations, and competition from other
 
commodities used for power generation such as
natural gas.
 
This has resulted in an overall decline in CAPP coal production.
 
Continued regulatory
changes
 
and
 
declining
 
demand
 
could
 
result
 
in
 
material
 
changes
 
in
 
domestic
 
and
 
global
 
coal
markets.
 
The impact
 
cannot be
 
predicted at
 
this time;
 
however,
 
while MM&A
 
expects the
 
coal
reserve within this TRS
 
to remain economically viable
 
throughout the life
 
of the projected mines,
the LOM financial model is very sensitive to
 
changes in coal sales price and therefore market risk is
not insignificant.
>
 
Labor Risk.
 
Work stoppage
 
due to
 
organized
 
labor protests
 
is considered
 
to be
 
unlikely and
 
not
likely to lead to permanent mine closure.
 
The mines are likely to suffer the loss of key
 
supervisors
and skilled employees due to retirement as the workforce ages.
 
The problem is industry-wide and
the impact is expected to be temporary and have no sustained impact on coal production.
>
 
Availability of
 
Equipment and
 
Supplies.
 
Risk of
 
equipment and
 
supply availability
 
is likely
 
to be
temporary and should not have a sustained adverse impact on the production of coal.
 
 
ex964p2i0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
 
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
 
Appendix D:
 
JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
21
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
 
Transportation
 
Delay.
 
Interruption of
 
coal transport
 
services by
 
river or
 
rail is
 
considered to
 
be
probable but unlikely to have a sustained impact on coal production.
>
 
It
 
is
 
recognised
 
that
 
this
 
may
 
not
 
be
 
possible
 
or
 
appropriate
 
in
 
all
 
circumstances.
 
These
statements of
 
relative
 
accuracy and
 
confidence of
 
the estimate
 
should be
 
compared with
production data, where available.
>
 
Mine plans, productivity expectations
 
and cost estimates
 
generally reflect
 
historical performance
and efforts have been made to adjust plans and costs to reflect future conditions.