Earnings Call Transcript
AUTOMATIC DATA PROCESSING INC (ADP)
Earnings Call Transcript - ADP Q3 2020
Operator, Operator
Good morning. My name is Shannon, and I will be your conference operator. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to ADP's Third Quarter Fiscal 2020 Earnings Call. I would like to inform you that this conference is being recorded. [Operator Instructions] Thank you, I will now turn the conference over to Mr. Danyal Hussain, Vice President, Investor Relations. Please go ahead.
Danyal Hussain, Vice President, Investor Relations
Thank you, Shannon. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining ADP's Third Quarter Fiscal 2020 Earnings Call and Webcast. Participating today are Carlos Rodriguez, our President and Chief Executive Officer; and Kathleen Winters, our Chief Financial Officer. Earlier this morning, we released our results for the third quarter of fiscal 2020. The earnings materials are available on the SEC's website and our Investor Relations website at investors.adp.com, where you will also find the investor presentation that accompanies today’s call as well as our quarterly history of revenue and pretax earnings by reportable segment. During our call today, we will reference non-GAAP financial measures, which we believe to be useful to investors and that exclude the impact of certain items. A description and the timing of these items, along with a reconciliation of non-GAAP measures to their most comparable GAAP measure, can be found in our earnings release. Today's call will also contain forward-looking statements that refer to future events and as such, involve some risk. We encourage you to review our filings with the SEC for additional information on factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from our current expectations. As always, please do not hesitate to reach out should you have any questions. And with that, let me now turn the call over to Carlos.
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
Thank you, Danny, and thank everyone for joining our call. Before we begin, I want to first say that our thoughts and prayers are with those who have been or know someone who has been impacted by COVID-19. Every day we hear about how much of a challenge it has been for employers and workers alike, including our own. I'd like to recognize our associates for rising to the challenge and delivering exceptional service to our clients despite the extraordinary circumstances they've had to face. To them, I want to say thank you. For our discussion today, we'll spend a little less time talking about the third quarter and more time on the current operating climate. And I'd like to offer a couple of upfront points. First is that ADP is not immune to the global pandemic's impact on the labor market, but while we may make tactical adjustments as we navigate through this crisis, we believe our long-term strategy is unaffected, and we remain optimistic about how we're positioned over the coming years, once the business environment and our clients return to more normal operations. The second point is that we will continue to serve our clients in the way we know best, by offering the tools, resources, and support they need to manage their business and workforce through all types of operating environments, including this challenging one. With that said, this morning we reported our third quarter fiscal 2020 results with revenue of $4 billion, up 6% reported and organic constant currency, and in line with our expectations. We expanded our adjusted EBIT margin by 60 basis points in the quarter, which was ahead of our expectations, even though it included an unplanned $50 million global associate assistance payment in response to COVID-19. And with the solid revenue and margin performance, we were pleased to deliver 8% adjusted diluted EPS growth, which was also slightly ahead of our expectations coming into the quarter. Turning now to the current situation, I'd like to take a few minutes to go deeper on how COVID-19 has affected our operations and what we've done to respond. As the situation evolved over the past couple of months, we focused first on the safety of our associates. In March, we took steps to quickly shift over 50,000 of our associates to work from home and now have approximately 98% of our workforce working remotely in a secure manner. In doing so, we leveraged our previous investments in business resiliency, and in addition, we ordered thousands of laptops, expanded remote access capacity, and provided at-home internet. For those critical personnel that needed to work onsite, we took steps to ensure their safety while they performed those essential onsite tasks. This was a huge undertaking by our global IT, security, legal, and HR organizations, and I'm extremely proud of their execution. We also worked with our critical third-party service providers to ensure they were positioned to continue to support us. In March, we also had our field sales force shift from in-person to a virtual sales model, and while that's not an ideal circumstance for some of our quota carriers, they're making the most of the situation. While we were executing on these business resiliency plans, we also worked nonstop to address our clients' needs to ensure uninterrupted service across our HCM solutions. We provide a mission-critical service and process payroll for one in six Americans and over 40 million workers around the world, and to offer immediate support we’ve provided a number of online resources including an employer preparedness toolkit and webinars attended by tens of thousands of clients. We also quickly made available for free the payroll costs and headcount reports necessary to apply for forgivable loans under the Paycheck Protection Program of the CARES Act, and these reports have been downloaded hundreds of thousands of times. Service is more important than ever in times like this. We saw call volumes increase significantly beginning in March and have nearly 2 million inbound requests across our service channels in a matter of weeks, with clients looking for help with a variety of issues including adding custom pay codes related to COVID-19, redirecting checks to different locations, and requesting new time tracking hardware that doesn't require physical contact. In many cases, they were simply seeking general guidance in understanding new legislation. To meet our clients' needs, we retrained and quickly redeployed hundreds of associates to where they were needed most. Our service and IT teams worked quickly to digest and translate new legislation from the many jurisdictions around the world into our global payroll, time and attendance, and other systems in a short period of time to allow our clients to comply with and benefit from these changes in legislation. As the environment for companies continues to evolve, whether due to legislative changes or operational realities, we at ADP are committed to supporting our clients to help them best navigate those changes. As we communicated in an open letter to U.S. policy leaders, ADP stands ready to facilitate current and future initiatives that provide support to our clients and their workers. In support of our local communities, ADP has made over $2 million in donations to relief efforts, including a dedicated relief fund for ADP associates that needed assistance as well as donations of medical supplies for hospitals and food banks. With all that said, the significant impact of COVID-19 is having on the broader economy, is in turn having an effect on our reported metrics in a much more abrupt fashion compared to previous macroeconomic slowdowns. You can see this in our Employer Services new business bookings metric. This quarter we reported a decrease of 9%, as we saw bookings decline significantly and rapidly in mid-March when we typically would have expected to close many deals for the quarter. These results were, of course, well below our expectations coming into the quarter, and while some of our businesses performed slightly better than others in March, the weakness was generally broad-based as the health crisis is affecting companies of all sizes and regions, including internationally. We believe the impact to bookings stems from two factors. First is the buying behavior of our clients and prospects. As with prior uncertain economic environments, our clients and prospects have become time and resource-constrained and are faced with reassessing their own operations to best ride out the impact of this health crisis. And although our products support mission-critical functions, making decisions about additional HCM services or making the decision to switch from another vendor to ADP can get put off to a later time. Even in circumstances where decisions have already been made, clients are understandably delaying implementation, which can also cause us to adjust down the bookings we record. The general change in behavior is common in recessionary periods, and we are certainly not surprised to see it this time. It's clearly happening in a more abrupt manner compared to what we've experienced in the past. Second, as I mentioned earlier, there have naturally been constraints that limited the activity of our salesforce. What we have been able to lean more heavily on is an inside sales strategy and virtual interactions by our field sales force. There has still been a reduction in our salesforce productivity. Our sales organization is experienced and resilient, and we will continue to work hard in the fourth quarter. Because of a variety of factors, which we believe will have an outside impact on the fourth quarter bookings, including the effectiveness of the Paycheck Protection Program in supporting small to mid-sized businesses and how quickly our clients can adapt to working in this new environment and resume more normal buying behavior, there is clearly a very wide range of outcomes. But to calibrate your expectations, we are guiding for a full year ES New Business Bookings, our ES New Business bookings to be down 20%, which implies our fourth quarter bookings will be down by more than 50%. With all that said, we remain confident in our product portfolio and optimistic about our ability to drive sustained growth in ES bookings in a sounder economic environment. I now like to spend a minute or two on some of the other macro-driven trends we've observed in our client base. Our pays per control metric, which represents employee growth for a broad subset of our client base, was solid through February but decelerated to a slight negative growth by the end of March, averaging 1.9% growth for the quarter. Early in April, we saw it deteriorate further to a double-digit negative decline, with the steepest decline among smaller businesses. For context, this level of pays per controlled decline is significantly worse than even the worst quarter in the financial crisis, underscoring that it's hard to compare this environment even against past recessions. While we hope that legislation aimed at preserving employment will drive a recovery in pays per control, we had not seen it through mid-April. On retention, we were actually pleased with our performance in the third quarter, with both third quarter and year-to-date retention performance better than our expectations and ahead of our previous annual guidance. We set an all-time third quarter retention record in our down market and mid-market businesses, as client satisfaction scores were at or near all-time highs and as the benefits of our technology and migration strategy over the past several years continue to bear fruit. But clearly, out-of-business losses are a concern for the fourth quarter and beyond. Although they have not yet meaningfully picked up by the end of March or even into April, early indicators of stress in our client base have shown up, and we expect deterioration in retention in May and June. Kathleen will share some of the assumptions for the fourth quarter when she goes through the outlook. I'd like to pivot now from the current macro environment and focus on our strategy and what we're doing to drive longer-term value for our clients. At ADP, we remain steadfast in our commitment to lead in the HCM industry with best-in-class technology and service. At our February Innovation Day, we shared an update with many of you about the innovation we are driving across our key strategic and next-gen solutions. The HCM industry is an exciting place with constant change, and we will continue to invest to position ourselves to meet the evolving needs of our clients over not just the coming years, but the coming decade. At Innovation Day, we've covered several topics, and I'd like to reframe a few of our key products against today's backdrop. With ADP RUN, we help small businesses manage their essential HR tasks from basic payroll to a full HCM suite. We highlighted our push to drive digital sales and onboarding capabilities, which is especially relevant in today's environment, and we also highlighted innovations in automating service and implementation, which relieves pressure on our service organization. We discussed Workforce Now and our public cloud-native version, which we are pairing with our next-gen payroll engine that utilizes a fully transparent policy-based model for improved implementation, maintenance, and self-service, as well as continuous payroll calculations for clients looking for on-demand pay options. We also talked about Wisely and the ease of use and the financial tools that make it an attractive way to get paid. Just this month, we made Wisely Direct available to our mid-market Workforce Now clients, which we believe will be beneficial to many workers in our base that still get paid by a paper check. And of course, we discussed our next-gen HCM, which we believe represents a big step ahead of current offerings in the market and for which we remain excited about scaling and selling more broadly. Before I turn it over to Kathleen, I'd like to take a moment to once again thank our associates. This health crisis and the resulting economic fallout haven't been easy on anyone, but our associates have really stepped up to ensure we continue to provide our clients with the support they need, and our clients and I appreciate it. Kathleen, I'll turn it over to you now.
Kathleen Winters, CFO
Thank you, Carlos, and good morning everyone. As Carlos mentioned, we were generally pleased with our execution in Q3 and our financial results were not significantly impacted by COVID-19, with the exception of New Business Bookings. We expect Q4, however, to be challenging on a few fronts. And I will cover this when I go through our guidance. This quarter’s revenue growth of 6% reported and organic constant currency was in line with our expectations. Our adjusted EBIT margin was up 60 basis points compared to the third quarter of fiscal 2019, even though it included a $50 million cost of a global associate assistance payment related to COVID-19, which we disclosed in an 8-K several weeks ago. Excluding this, our margin performance was even further ahead of our expectations and continued to benefit from a combination of cost savings related to our transformation initiatives and operating efficiencies, as well as lower than expected incentive compensation expenses. These benefits were partially offset by growth in PEO zero-margin benefits pass-through expenses and amortization expense, as well as certain other expenses related to COVID-19. Our adjusted effective tax rate increased 30 basis points to 23.8% compared to the third quarter of fiscal 2019, and adjusted diluted earnings per share increased 8% to $1.92 driven by revenue growth and margin expansion, as well as fewer shares outstanding compared to a year ago. Moving on to segment results. In our Employer Services Segment, revenues grew 3% reported and 4% organic constant currency, reflecting steady underlying performance with strong retention trends offset by continued FX pressure and a growing headwind from interest income. Interest income on client funds declined 5%, and the average yield on client funds declined 20 basis points to 2%, offsetting growth in average client funds balances of 4% to $31.3 billion. This growth in balances was driven by a combination of client growth, wage inflation, and growth in our pays per control in the quarter, partially offset by lower SUI collections and the closure of our Netherlands money movement operation earlier this year. Our Employer Services same-store pays per control metric in the U.S. was 1.9% for the third quarter and I’ll talk a bit more about the trends we’re seeing in a moment. Employer Services margins increased 100 basis points in the quarter, ahead of expectations, driven by many of the same factors I mentioned earlier when discussing our consolidated results. Our PEO segment revenues grew 11% for the quarter to $1.2 billion, and average worksite employees grew 7% to $595,000, ahead of our expectations and driven by strong year-to-date new business bookings. We were pleased with this reacceleration in our Worksite Employee growth in the third quarter and believe we would have been positioned for further acceleration exiting the year if not for COVID-19. Revenues excluding zero margin benefits pass-through grew 9% to $490 million and continue to include pressure from lower workers' compensation and SUI costs and related pricing. PEO margin expanded 10 basis points in the quarter in-line with our expectations. Let me now turn to our outlook for the remainder of the year. I'll start by discussing some of the specific macro-driven factors that affect our financial performance. I'll caveat by saying that we're clearly operating in an evolving and uncertain situation, and we're using data currently available to us to make reasonable assumptions on which we are basing our guidance. First, out-of-business losses. We expect our retention to be impacted by elevated out-of-business losses in Q4, and although the federal government is providing stimulus to help companies continue operating, we're seeing clear strain on our client base and have observed certain leading indicators such as companies going inactive and not running payroll, many of whom will restart their operations at some point, but some of whom we expect will not. Based on our experience with these leading indicators, we are building in an expectation for additional losses in our fourth quarter outlook, and as a result, we're lowering our full-year retention guidance to be down 30 basis points to 50 basis points despite running ahead of our expectations on a year-to-date basis. Next, pays per control. We exited March with negative pays per control growth, and in April it deteriorated to a double-digit decline. We were assuming a 2% to 2.5% pays per control decline for the full year, which implies a mid-teens decline for Q4. As a reminder of how this affects us, we have varied contracts throughout our businesses that blend base fees and per employee fees, and we also often utilize shared pricing and have certain annual revenues that are not as affected. As a result, with our current mix of business, the direct revenue impact we expect to see is about 25 basis points in ES revenue growth for every 1% change in PPC. Some of our businesses are more sensitive to pays per control than others, and so the precise impact that pays per control by business can drive the actual revenue impact higher or lower in any given period. This direct impact also doesn't include the impact from our volume-based businesses like recruiting or payment cards. Finally, on client funds balances, through the combination of a challenging sales environment and anticipated increase in out-of-business losses, a decline in pays per control, and potential decline in wages and hours worked, we expect to see pressure in our balances in the near term. Furthermore, the CARES Act has a provision that allows companies to defer the payment of the employer portion of payroll taxes, which represents less than 5% of our average client funds balance. But depending on the actual take rate of that provision, we could see further pressure on our balance growth. As a result of all these factors, we now expect 1% balance growth for the full year, which implies a low double-digit decline in the fourth quarter. To adjust the size of our client's fund investments to match expected changes in average client payroll and tax volumes, beginning in March, we halted all new reinvestment of maturity in our client long and extended portfolios. In April, we took the additional step of selling approximately $1.2 billion of previously purchased securities in the client long and extended portfolios. This decision to suspend new purchases means our Q4 interest income forecast reflects a slightly greater skew to overnight rates than previously forecasted. Both the suspension of new purchases and the completed sale of securities are contemplated in our guidance. To be clear, these decisions represent tactical adjustments and do not represent a change to our overall client funds strategy. Let's now turn to our revised outlook for the full year and start with the ES segments. We are lowering our guidance to 1% to 2% revenue growth versus our prior outlook of 4%, driven mainly by an expectation of lower pays per control, new business booking, client fund interest, and retention versus our prior outlook. Much of this lost revenue comes at high incremental margins, and as a result, and also due to additional costs related to COVID-19, we now expect our margin in the employer services segment to be down 25 to up 25 basis points. For our PEO, we saw good momentum up through the end of March, and as I mentioned earlier, we believe we were on track for continued acceleration exiting the year, but are now layering in our expectation for layoffs and furloughs and additional out-of-business losses. As a reminder, in our PEO segment, we earn revenues as a percent of the gross payroll we process, and as a result, we are more directly tied to changes in our client's headcount and hours worked compared to our employer services segment. As a result of these assumptions and our expectations for lower Q4 PEO sales, we are lowering our average worksite employee growth expectations to 3% to 5% from 7% to 8% previously. We are likewise lowering our revenue guidance and now expect 5% to 7% PEO revenue growth in fiscal 2020 and 3% to 5% growth in PEO revenues excluding zero margin benefits pass-through. As we also discussed throughout the year, we continue to expect lower workers' compensation and SUI costs and related pricing to pressure our total PEO revenue growth, though we could see those trends change in the coming years. For PEO margin, we now expect to be down 100 basis points to 125 basis points in fiscal 2020. As we noted in previous calls, this outlook continues to include pressure from a smaller favorable reserve adjustment that ADP Indemnity in fiscal 2020 compared to fiscal 2019, but we now expect about 75 basis points of pressure compared to our previous expectation of 50 basis points of pressure. So we still expect a slight benefit this year. With these changes to the segment, we now anticipate total revenue growth of about 3% in fiscal 2020 as compared to our previous outlook of 6%. This revenue outlook continues to assume slight FX unfavorability for fiscal 2020. As I mentioned, we anticipate our growth in average client funds balances to be about 1% compared to our previous outlook of 4%, and we expect the average yield earned on our client funds investments to be about 2.1% compared to our previous outlook of 2.2%. We expect interest income on client funds to be $540 million to $550 million and for interest income from our extended investment strategy to be $550 million to $560 million. We anticipate our adjusted EBIT margin to be down 25 to up 25 basis points, as the benefits from our workforce optimization and procurement transformation initiatives are now being offset by the impact of expected loss of revenue due to COVID-19 as well as incremental expenses related to COVID-19, including the $50 million in global associate assistance payments. We now anticipate our adjusted effective tax rate to be 22.9%. The rate includes this quarter's unplanned tax benefit from stock-based compensation related to stock option exercises. It does not include any further estimated tax benefits related to potential future stock option exercises. As a result of our lower revenue and margin outlook, we now expect adjusted diluted earnings per share to grow 4% to 7% in fiscal 2020. In light of this revised 2020 guidance and multiple headwinds created by the global pandemic and the uncertain and evolving situation, we are withdrawing the fiscal 2021 targets that we set out at our 2018 Investor Day as they are no longer appropriate to the current circumstances. However, we continue to believe in our long-term strategy and are well positioned to continue to invest to execute this strategy. Finally, before I conclude, I'd like to talk about the strength of ADP’s business model and balance sheet. We have a highly cash-generative business with low capital needs, and the HCM Solutions we provide give critical support to our clients' HR and management functions, especially at times like these. In addition to having a resilient product and business model, we also have a significant buffer between our free cash flow and our modest debt obligations, and our cash to spend enables us to absorb the impact of downturns and continue to prioritize investments aligned with our longer-term strategy as well as our commitments to shareholder-friendly actions. So although our revenue growth can clearly be impacted by challenging macroconditions, our recurring revenue model and high retention rate position us to continue with the type of investments we highlighted at our innovation day even when times are tough. We will, meanwhile, continue to manage our cost base prudently. We have instituted hiring containment and started to execute on our recession playbook with a pre-planned set of areas where we will see some of our expenses self-adjust, such as management and sales incentives, and we will eliminate or defer non-essential staff. We're working through an evolving and uncertain situation and are formulating our approach for next year, and we will, of course, provide you with our expectations and outlook for fiscal 2021 when we report our fourth quarter results. As always, expect us to be balanced in our approach. With that, I will pass it back to Carlos for some comments before we go to Q&A.
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
Thanks, Kathleen. Before we move on to the Q&A, I just wanted to share with you an excerpt of one of the many notes we received from our clients that captures how we want to define ourselves. This one said, 'We are a small business that has used ADP for quite a few years now. Every time we call, there has been a knowledgeable professional at ADP that immediately solves the problem and answers the question. We recently needed payroll data to apply for the COVID-19 payroll protection program. I immediately went to ADP's website to see how I should go about selecting and downloading the required payroll data. Imagine the relief when opening the screen there was a COVID-19 pop-up that proactively provided your clients with the payroll data needed; I was floored. This type of customer service is unheard of these days.' As this client suggests, the value of a true HCM partner becomes even more critical at times like these, and it continues to be our goal to exceed the expectations of our clients. And with that, I'll turn it over to the operator for Q&A.
Operator, Operator
[Operator Instructions] We'll take our first question from the line of Ramsey El-Assal with Barclays. Please go ahead.
Ramsey El-Assal, Analyst
Hi, thanks so much for taking my question. I hope you both are doing well. I wanted to ask about your visibility on the paycheck protection loan program in terms of can you see that it's having the desired impact on businesses in the country? Are you seeing terminated workers that are being brought back on book? And I guess just tying that back to your own performance or potential future performance, are you seeing the leading indicators of bankruptcy staved off a little bit in your book?
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
Great question. We're obviously keeping our eye on that. Unfortunately, what we have is really kind of limited anecdotal evidence that people are beginning to get money to be able to continue their payroll, they continue to pay people. As an example, a few days ago I was forwarded a letter that was sent to – an email that was sent to one of our associates from a client that was grateful for the help that we gave them in applying for the loan and they sent a screenshot of their bank account that had $10 the previous day and then now had $84,000, indicating that they have gotten their money from the SBA deposited into their commercial bank account. But I think, as you've heard, same as us in the press, the process has been, given the scale of the challenge, it's been a difficult process both for the SBA and I think for the banks. We've tried to do our part to help, and we're optimistic and hopeful that it will make a difference and that there will be rehiring and that it will at least in some respects stop the furloughing and the elimination of jobs going forward. But unfortunately, it's just a little too early for us to give you any kind of concrete evidence other than some anecdotal stories that money is making its way into the bank accounts of small businesses.
Ramsey El-Assal, Analyst
Okay. Yes, that's helpful. Thank you. And then just a follow-up. In terms of your overall product strategy in the context of this crisis, are there any adjustments you're having to make in terms of how you're thinking of new challenges like employees working from home, some of your major initiatives like Lifion? How’s the timeline, the market being impacted, how are you thinking about the product set sort of evolving from here on out?
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
I mean, clearly, we have to be nimble, and I think remain open to making further adjustments, but I think it's safe to say that if you go back over the course of decades, the concept of outsourcing and now what some people would call the SaaS models, which I think ADP was kind of one of the pioneers of, I think by definition lend themselves to these kinds of remote work environments, whether it's for the technology people, because we generally obviously host and maintain and update all of the systems for our clients. But also through the variety of portals we have for our clients and the employees of our clients. All of the information that anyone needs is available online through all the tools we have to access that information, whether it's for the payroll practitioners or for the employees of our clients. Including, when you think about the app that we have for the employees of our clients to be able to check whether they've gotten paid, they can check their hours; they can make changes to 401(k). There's really no need to move paper or for anyone to be in the office to do that kind of work. So clearly, there will be things that we will learn and we'll probably hear in the early innings of this kind of new talent and how it might affect our products. But I think in general, as an industry, it's not just for ADP, I think in general for us as an industry we're pretty well positioned for this kind of work environment.
Kathleen Winters, CFO
And I think if I could just add to that. I think you had asked about, I couldn't quite hear, but I think you had asked about Lifion and any updates to that and changes to our view on go-to-market. I would say over the longer term, while certainly this year looks like things have slowed down at least for a little bit, I'd say over the long-term, no change to how we're thinking about that. And we've got a handful of live clients. We're continuing to sell clients on and implement clients on Lifion, and we're encouraged about the long-term prospects there.
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
Yes. It's clear, like every time that we have, whether it's an economic downturn or now this is obviously a new challenge, there's always questions about, will this drive greater adoption? I think intellectually it makes sense that this would drive greater outsourcing and greater adoption of a SaaS, but it's kind of hard to make that statement kind of where we are today. But theoretically and intellectually, two or three years from now, there should be more demand and more people using SaaS solutions than there are today.
Ramsey El-Assal, Analyst
That makes a lot of sense. Thanks so much for taking my questions.
Operator, Operator
Thank you. Our next question comes from the line of Tien-Tsin Huang with JP Morgan. Your line is open.
Tien-Tsin Huang, Analyst
Hi, thanks so much. Appreciate the extent of disclosure here. Just on some of the follow-up to Ramsey's question, just on the sales performance side, you mentioned productivity challenges in addition to the demand factors. What would you think you'll get your productivity back on track and align your sales to where you see the puck going next in terms of demand as it evolved?
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
So we're trying to actually keep an eye on it week-to-week to get some sense of what levers there are still there. We clearly still have, our sales force is still selling and they're selling a lot of business, but at lower levels than we had expected and in lower levels compared to the previous year. So unfortunately, given the nature of the situation, it's kind of difficult to give you a kind of scientific or concrete answer. I think as we generate more information, I think probably for our guidance for the next fiscal year, we'll be able to – I know that's not helpful to you today, but it's really a very difficult thing to talk about. We have a lot of our sales force was already what we call an inside sales force and so we've proven that we can sell through insight selling, but we have some products that are what I would call high involvement decision sales. And it doesn't mean that those can't be done remotely. But it hasn't been the norm. So when you sell a very large complicated multinational solution, or frankly, even when you sell the PEO, historically there's been a relationship that's built there and a trust that gets built before that transaction gets consummated. So it clearly, these are new and different times. So I don't think everyone is going to sit and wait around for everything to go back to normal before making decisions. But I think it's safe to assume, I think common sense would tell us that it's safe to assume that there will be some level of hesitation and pullback in terms of decision making. Even though a good percentage of our salesforce is still outselling as they have before, although they're doing it virtually now.
Tien-Tsin Huang, Analyst
Yes, sure. So we'll check in with you on that again next quarter. So then my quick follow-up, both of you have talked about cost initiatives. You guys did much better than we thought on the margin side even with the $50 million, but you've also both hinted at a pipeline of more cost takeout, potentially pre-pandemic. So I'm curious, your willingness to pull incremental expense levers, maybe some chunkier stuff, is that available to you, and are you willing to do that at this stage?
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
So we did have a number of transformation initiatives underway. A lot of them were really around digital transformation efforts to kind of automate and improve the way our implementation or our services is delivered, which would create a better experience for our clients, the employees of our clients, frankly also for our associates that we thought would result in lower costs going forward. Yes, part of the challenge we have is, and again, every company may be different in terms of how they approach their level of support for their clients, but based on our model and the way we see ourselves playing a role, and frankly in society and with our clients, we've actually experienced quite an increase in volume and cost in the short-term. And so, as an example, as the government rolled out the payroll protection program, we saw 40% to 50% spikes in inquiries right through whether it's phone or chat or by email. And so we had to work people overtime. We had to work people on weekends, which we're very grateful that people were willing to do because you can imagine they've got lots of other concerns and distractions as this is all going on. And so we made a commitment that we're going to deliver to our clients through this and help them work through it, whether it's for themselves or for their employees. Unfortunately, I would say in the short-term, we actually have an increase in cost. Now, realistically that's not going to continue indefinitely. But every week that we said we think our call volumes and our workloads are going to go down, there's a new government program or a change in the government program, which by the way we think is great. I think the efforts by the Fed and by policymakers, I think to help clients and their employees, I think is the right thing to do and we're very supportive. But as an example, there was just, as you know, there was an approval of an additional amount for the payroll protection program, which generates additional volume for us. By the way, I think the banks are in the same – probably in the same situation in terms of how having to handle kind of increased volumes. And so we expect these levels to normalize and then to be in a position where we can reevaluate our cost structure, but again, given the timing of this call and where we are today, we really can't tell you that there has been a meaningful decline in our workloads. In fact, it's actually been an increase.
Tien-Tsin Huang, Analyst
Got it. I appreciate the work behind that. Kathleen, I just wanted to get your thoughts on the pipeline of efforts you've identified, how are you feeling about your ability to balance those investments against the macro uncertainties you just discussed?
Kathleen Winters, CFO
So, Tien-Tsin if I could just – let me just add a little bit more to that because I made some comments on our transformation efforts and transformation work even with the significant increase in service demand. So, even with this kind of very abrupt disruption and need to move our entire practically our entire workforce to work from home. We were able to do that almost seamlessly. I mean, that worked really well through the huge, huge efforts of many of the different parts of the organization, from our technology groups to our HR to legal. I mean, it was a huge effort, but it worked well and so we've been able to continue our normal processes, if you will around transformation work. There were certainly some projects that we have to look at and assess and say, okay, because of the big service demands we may need to slow down these. But our process in terms of tracking progress, continuing to execute, adjusting as necessary based on service demands, and importantly continuing to look at the pipeline of projects, that continues and I would just add one further comment that in particular in this environment, the ability to look at procurement and find procurement opportunities is potentially even greater today than it was, say three or four months ago.
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
I think if I can just one more comment, I think that the part of the challenge here is that we are – the nature of our company and our business and our Board is to not focus on one month or one quarter. I think when you look at what we're able to deliver just in this quarter in terms of margin improvement and what we've been able to do in the last couple of years, I think demonstrates very clearly our ability to take advantage of operating leverage and also to manage our costs very effectively. We've had a couple of years with a very modest, if any cost – true cost increases while revenues were growing at what for us is very healthy rates. So I think we've demonstrated what we can do, but unfortunately we've been handed a very abrupt change here in the environment and we're going to handle it first to take care of our associates, next take care of our clients. I think when we get through this transitory period, which we all know is transitory, now we don't know if it's transitory for a month or two or six months. But either way it's not multiple years and we want to make sure that we continue to invest in our business, take care of our people, and take care of our clients, so that when we come out of this, we come out of it as strong as we were before we went into it.
Tien-Tsin Huang, Analyst
Yes, very clear. Thank you.
Operator, Operator
And the next question comes from the line of Kevin McVeigh with Credit Suisse. Your line is open.
Kevin McVeigh, Analyst
Great. Thank you and thanks for the guidance and obviously the tough environment. Any thoughts on, one question we get a lot is how much of the layoffs are going to be furlough versus structural? So just any sense within kind of the pays per control, how much of that would be potentially furloughed workers versus structural? Maybe start there?
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
It's a great question. So we have, as you know, we operate in multiple countries and offer multiple segments; small business, midsize national accounts, but also in many countries and also multinational companies. The policies that companies have around how they treat employees is going to vary from company to company and generally also varies from segment to segment. But what we can tell you is that, the way we count pays per control is very straightforward. It's whether or not someone got paid during that period of time that we're counting. And so we would not probably be able to give you a firm number of how many people are furloughed versus how many people are laid off because we don't control necessarily that coding in the system. Clients can exercise some discretion about how they, I guess tagged some of their employees. But what we do know is that if somebody doesn't get paid, they don't get counted in pays per control. And if they do get paid, even if it's at a reduced wage, that does count, and so that creates a number of challenges obviously. Because you could have reduced wage levels, which then doesn't negatively impact pays per control but impacts the employees themselves. And may in some cases, impact our fees generally wouldn't other than in the PEO, but could impact our fees as well. So I would say that the best thing to do is to stick to – trying to use the pays per control metric as a way of building your models and using the guidance that we provided around 25 basis points of revenue growth, impact from each 1% change in pays per control. I think that gives you a very – we spent a lot of time pressure testing that assumption. I think Danny did a lot of work on it, and I think that's a pretty solid way for you to look at things. So when you hear guidance from us about pays per control and you use that metric for your model, I think that's a much cleaner and easier way than to try to separate how many are furloughs versus how many are layoffs.
Kevin McVeigh, Analyst
That's super helpful. And then I guess just a quick follow-up would be kind of coming out of this, obviously, in these types of events; you're really turn to in terms of the cavalry of the organization. Do you see any change competitively, particularly as obviously coming out of the last cycle much more service oriented as opposed to the shift to the cloud in this one, but from a competitive perspective, any changes where you look to even build on that attrition number, longer term in terms of improvement?
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
I think you do see some subtle differences in terms of company cultures and I think behavior. So as an example, one of the things that we have always tried to talk about is this willingness by us to really help our clients navigate through things, not just provide them the software solution. We actually took some responsibility for the outcomes of what they're trying to accomplish. The support we're providing around all these regulatory actions is an example of that. That doesn't mean that other competitors aren't doing similar things. But as an example, some competitors would be more along the lines of providing tools online and directing clients to third parties or directing them to resources where they could get help versus in our case, we actually take the work on and we help our clients get to where they need to go in order to get their retention credit, tax credit, in order to get their payroll protection loan, in order to calculate in a few weeks or at least in a couple of months people are going to be needing help with calculating how to get forgiveness on those loans. This is a complicated environment; by the way, employment in general is always complicated. But this is a very complicated environment, and having great tools and technology is incredibly important, and we're totally committed to that. But I think it's undeniable that you also need extra help in these situations to help with questions and to help you navigate through all the various regulatory hurdles. As an example, some of the legislation that was passed in the U.S., you have to really understand the interplay like, as an example, you can't take advantage of the deferral social security taxes and the payroll protection loans, but if you – you can take advantage of the social security deferrals up until you can get a loan, but then once it's forgiven, you can no longer defer your social security taxes. I mean those are things that are typically not well understood by our client base, and I think just directing them to a website or to a tool, we don't think is really the best way to help them.
Kevin McVeigh, Analyst
That's awesome. Thank you.
Operator, Operator
Our next question comes from the line of Bryan Bergin with Cowen. Your line is open.
Bryan Bergin, Analyst
Hi, good morning. Thank you. Hope your families are all well. I wanted to try on outlook here. Just understanding the material uncertainty, can you help us frame some initial fiscal 2021 guideposts in trying to think how we should be thinking about next year based on some of the implied 4Q run rates? So, any sense of visibility you have across the businesses or maybe thinking across client size would be helpful. Thanks.
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
First of all, thanks for asking about our families. I hope yours is well also. Unfortunately, I mean it's a very fair question and I can understand why you're looking for any additional color. It's – as you can imagine, we struggled with even providing kind of fourth quarter metrics, because two, three, four weeks ago, we had – or people had a certain view of how long the issue is going to continue and when things were going to open up again. And then it got more negative and now it feels like it's gotten more positive. So I think that it's very difficult for us to go really beyond the fourth quarter in this environment. We have to remain optimistic that things are going to improve, but I think that we all have to take advantage of the time we have to wait and see how things play out, whether it's with the clients or with GDP or with the economy, or with these government programs, so that we can make more informed decisions about what 2021 might look like. So I apologize for not being able to give you any additional color. But I think it would be a mistake to assume that the levels of activity that we've given you in the fourth quarter will continue into 2021, but it's also a mistake to assume that things are going to go back to normal at the beginning of 2021. And so we're going to keep an eye on the data and the information and do our best as we gather more information to give you a good view of what's going to happen in 2021 when we get there.
Kathleen Winters, CFO
Yes, maybe I could just add a few comments around the process and what we're doing in the data that we're looking at. Hence, while, as Carlos said, we can't really give you the view right now or the exact guidepost, at least if you'll understand and know the process we're going through, that might help a little bit. So, look, things are, as Carlos said, it's extremely fluid right now. We're spending a lot of time studying and watching developments every single day, and kind of looking at, I think about it in three steps if you will, in terms of first understanding what's happening from a pandemic standpoint and the epidemiology. Then understanding how that impacts the economy broadly around the world and then understanding how that impacts each of the business. So as we do that, obviously we're looking at numerous forecasts that I'm sure you all are looking at the same forecasts that are being put out. But we're really spending a lot of time in parsing through those and eliminating outliers and really utilizing the ones that we feel make the most sense and then applying that to, you know, as I said, the implications for our business units. And when you do that, as we've said, largely PPC is going to be an extremely significant driver for us. And then certainly the shape of the recovery from a new business booking standpoint will be critically important, so we're watching that as we see different regions and states kind of formulating and attempting the return to work.
Bryan Bergin, Analyst
Okay. I appreciate that. Wanted on retention, the comments on the assumptions in Q4, is the reduction wholly due to business closures? I'm curious if you're seeing any change in the competitive client loss.
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
Well, I think based on the comments we gave you about the third quarter and the year-to-date, I think we're doing pretty well competitively, because I think our retention was up. I mean we don't talk about quarterly retention, but why not like everything's out the window in this kind of environment. But I think we were over 50 basis points improvement in the third quarter, and through the year-to-date, I think we were well ahead of both the guidance, we had provided and our own internal expectations. So it's pretty clear that we were doing something right competitively. Our NPS scores are at record levels across most of our businesses. So again, the problem is this is not the time to brag and talk about the third quarter, but we really had incredible momentum coming into the third quarter on a number of fronts, but that's that, and we're onto figuring out how to deal with the future challenges, but I have no concerns about the solidity of our business on every front coming into the third quarter.
Bryan Bergin, Analyst
Thank you. Be well.
Operator, Operator
Our next question comes from the line of Kartik Mehta with Northcoast Research. Your line is open.
Kartik Mehta, Analyst
Hi, good morning, Carlos. I was wondering, based on the data you're seeing, and I realize this is so early in, but what kind of changes do you anticipate for the business, permanent changes or at least over the next 12 months to 18 months because of this current crisis?
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
Well, over the next 12 months to 18 months is probably the right focus because I mean, I think it'd be naive to think there aren't some things that are going to change permanently, but I'm not sure I have that kind of crystal ball to be precise about that. But for the next 12 months to 18 months, because of the focus we have on our associates, it's unlikely that we will be going back to business as usual here in the next few months. Now the good news is we've adapted to the current work environment. So, but I kind of concrete change in terms of the next 12 months, 18 months is we don't anticipate having 100% of our workforce back working in these one locations and some of these other places where we have large populations of associates. And so that's a change that we have to make sure that we stay on top of, that we support our people and lead them remotely and virtually and help them navigate through what's a very different way of working. Now obviously we plan on, as society kind of normalizes, we plan on coming along for the ride with us. So we do a lot of formulating plans as we speak, very preliminary plans around how do we slowly get back into some of our offices with limited number of personnel, but that's a change that we're definitely going to have to continue to live with for the next 12 months to 18 months. Now, what that means is that impacts our salesforce, and so the question is if the demand equation improves significantly and our salesforce is still working remotely, how can we make sure that they have the right tools and the right processes to continue to take advantage of the demand that's out there. Because we don't anticipate having large numbers of salespeople back in our offices. Our salespeople, by definition, many of them are inside sales, but many of them are out in face-to-face transactions, and that's not something that's going to normalize in the next 12 months to 18 months. Sadly, I’m sad to report that of the number of associates that we had impacted by COVID-19, we were disproportionately impacted in our salesforce. So as we go back to normalization, we're going to be exceptionally careful about protecting our salesforce as well.
Kartik Mehta, Analyst
And then just finally, Carlos, what do you think the recovery will look like? We've heard so much about a V, a U, an L; I'm just interested in your perspective of what you're anticipating from a recovery.
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
Well, I think the — again, we're looking at, we get information from all of the usual places like Morgan Stanley is obviously our banks so they've been very helpful in getting us their information, but we have access to information from a number of other sources. I don't want to say any of the names so I don't hurt anybody's feelings, but all the usual banks we get the information from them. We have information from Moody's, by the way we also work with the Fed. We work with Treasury. We have a lot of sources of information to give us some sense of kind of where things are headed. The challenges that I don't think anyone has really well — I don't think, I know that no one has ever been through this. So there really aren't any great models other than using inputs like PMIs or consumer confidence and other metrics that tend to be lagging indicators. And you have regression that gives you some sense of where the economy is headed. But, as I’ve seen myself in the last four to five weeks, you have to take any forecasts with a large grain of salt. So the best approach we think you can have right now is to remain flexible and agile about how you're planning and what you're planning for. If I were — if we had to make a bet today, we would say that it's not going to be a V-shaped recovery and it's probably not going to be a U or an L, but it's going to be some other kind of shape where we obviously already had the precipitous decline. We’ve already seen some signs of some stabilization. So we have metrics that we track like in our HR systems of our clients. For example, new job postings or number of screenings that are done like background checks, and some of those metrics have actually begun to stabilize. So I think we've had the abrupt drop. Now the question is the recovery. It feels like that recovery will be not a V, but not an L. The difference between V and L is a check mark. Like I think some people are out there quoting, by the way we have an economist on our board and he referred to as a Nike Swoosh, but that's probably a copyright or trademark violation, so I won't use the Nike Swoosh, but you get the idea of rough drop and hopefully a climb back up over some period of time. Hopefully that climb is over the course of three to six months and not over 12 to 18 months.
Kartik Mehta, Analyst
Thank you very much.
Operator, Operator
The next question comes from the line of David Grossman with Stifel. Your line is open.
David Grossman, Analyst
Alright, thank you. Good morning. Carlos, I think you've addressed this in a couple of previous questions, but based on how this may play out coming out of the crisis and you talked just a moment ago about some possible structural changes at least in the intermediate term being work from home or virtual sales. How do you feel the way you're positioned coming out of that versus where you were going into it and how do you view your ability to leverage that to your advantage? Is it structural or is it based on execution, I'm sure it's a combination of both, but if you could just give us a little more insight into how you're feeling about what you can do with this crisis to really enhance your position both competitively and operationally.
Carlos Rodriguez, CEO
Well, look, I think that some of this is philosophical. I think that like everyone else when we were entering this space I was scared like everyone else, not just personally for myself and my family, but also for the company and all of our associates and our clients that depend on us. And when you see the reaction and the ability of the organization to kind of get through it and not just get through it, but actually deliver a higher level of service and help with very complicated questions in a very complicated situation, which was changing in some cases on a daily basis with the regulatory landscape. I think it tells you something about the strength of the culture and the company. And so that gives me, again, this is all intellectual and philosophical, but I think it gives me great hope about how we emerge from this competitively. We already had incredibly strong momentum going into the third quarter, as you saw from retention we think we have a strong product lineup that was beginning to get traction. One of the things we didn't talk about when someone asked the question about our competitive situation, like we had really good growth in client counts, particularly in Workforce Now and specifically in our mid-market business. So the combination of positive momentum and coming into this and then the reaction and the strength of the organization through this gives me great optimism and hope that we're going to come out of this stronger than any of our competitors.
Kathleen Winters, CFO
Yes. Let me just add to that – Yes, I would just add to that; in addition to the great service that we've been able to provide to our clients throughout this, which theoretically ideally should sustain or drive even better retention going-forward, I would say the strength of our balance sheet and the ability to continue to invest aligned with what we laid out at our Innovation Day for investing in our strategic products and Workforce Now and RUN and our next-gen product, our ability to continue to do that throughout this should position us well.
David Grossman, Analyst
Okay, that's it for me. Thanks very much. And be well.
Operator, Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.