Earnings Call Transcript - HLNE Q2 2023

Operator, Operator

Good morning. My name is Dennis, and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Hamilton Lane Second Quarter Fiscal 2023 Earnings Conference Call. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. A supplemental slide presentation to accompany the prepared remarks can be found on the company’s website. After the speakers' remarks, there will be a question-and-answer session. Thank you. At this time, I would like to turn the call over to John Oh, Investor Relations Manager. Mr. Oh, you may begin your conference.

John Oh, Investor Relations Manager

Thank you, Dennis. Welcome to Hamilton Lane's Q2 fiscal 2023 earnings call. Today, I will be joined by Mario Giannini, CEO; Erik Hirsch, Vice Chairman; Brian Gildea, Managing Director, Investments; and Atul Varma, CFO. Before we discuss the quarter’s results, we want to remind you that we will be making forward-looking statements based on our current expectations for the business. These statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that may cause the actual results to differ materially. For a discussion of these risks, please review the risk factors included in Hamilton Lane fiscal 2022 10-K and subsequent reports we filed with the SEC. We will also be referring to non-GAAP measures that we view as important in assessing the performance of our business. Reconciliation of those non-GAAP measures to GAAP can be found in the earnings presentation materials made available on the Shareholders section of the Hamilton Lane website. Our detailed financial results will be made available on our 10-Q is filed. Please note that nothing on this call represents an offer to sell or a solicitation to purchase interest in any of Hamilton Lane’s products. A portion of our presentation will mention an offering of new share classes of our private assets fund that is subject to your registration statement filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The registration statement is not yet effective. We may not sell the securities until the registration statement is effective. Beginning with the financial highlights, year-to-date, our management and advisory fee revenue grew by 19%, while our fee-related earnings grew by 10% versus the prior year period. This translated into year-to-date GAAP EPS of $1.88 based on $68.4 million of GAAP net income and non-GAAP EPS of $1.95 based on $104.7 million of adjusted net income. We have also declared a dividend of $0.40 per share this quarter, which keeps us on track with a 14% increase over last fiscal year, equating to the targeted $1.60 per share for fiscal year 2023. With that, I’ll now turn the call over to Mario.

Mario Giannini, CEO

Thanks, John, and good morning, everyone. I’ll start with some commentary on the current state of the private markets and provide context on how we are navigating this environment and where we are deploying resources. The macro backdrop has remained the same throughout much of 2022. Inflation is high, and interest rates continue to rise. The results have weakened the public equity market. The public side is being disproportionately impacted by large technology growth companies. That market weighting is simply not the reality for the private markets and is certainly not the reality for the Hamilton Lane portfolios. While not impacted in the same magnitude, the picture is directionally similar, and we don’t believe this is likely to change in the near term. Central banks around the world have signaled that in order to fight rising inflation, rates will need to go higher, and the reality is economic growth is slowing. What does this mean for private markets? Public market volatility is a mixed bag for us. On a positive note, it increases attractive investment opportunities and creates return uncertainty for investors, which causes them to pivot towards the private markets for higher returns. On the negative side, capital bases are shrinking around the globe as wealth is being eroded. Market uncertainty can also cause paralysis or delay for some investors as they opt to wait to see how things sort out. At a portfolio level, the story is also mixed. Consumer spending in certain areas remains strong as those manufacturing, distribution, along with other sectors. Technology valuations are down based on public market comparables, but rising rates are generally aiding credit portfolios. Overall, unrealized markets are down but nowhere in line with what we are seeing in the public sector. Exits, however, are slowing, as is new deal doing. Over our 30-plus year history, we’ve experienced multiple cycles. We rely on those past experiences and stay focused on the fact that private markets are a long-term asset class. Our investment teams remain active, though cautious. We continue to lean in with clients to make sure they remain comfortable and confident. And on the fundraising front, we are expanding sales resources and leveraging strategic partnerships to make sure our story is being broadly told. We continue to invest in all facets of our business and expand our global footprint with new offices and strategic areas throughout Europe, such as Milan, Stockholm, and Zurich. We brought in key senior people to bolster our local presence, which helps with our distribution capabilities, client service, and proximity to investment opportunities. We take comfort from our scale, brand, and culture, and are determined to maintain our growth story. A key piece of that continued growth story centers around our people. In an effort to both retain key talent and to maintain alignment with shareholders across a broader employee base, we have instituted a new equity program. What does it mean to employees across levels and departments who are playing an important role in driving the company forward for years to come? Importantly, no awards were given to the three largest inside Hamilton Lane shareholders. In order for the recipients to receive value from new awards, they need to remain with the company over a multi-year time period, and the stock has to cross certain thresholds over the next seven years. Those three stock performance tiers are $150 per share, $190 per share, and a final one struck at $230 per share. We have set the bar high for ourselves with the final price threshold representing an 80% compounded annual growth rate from the grant date price. We believe these thresholds keep us focused on our commitment to growth and driving value for our shareholders. The financial impact of the award this quarter was minimal, and going forward will be approximately $3 million per year for the next five years. Let me now turn to the results for the quarter. Total asset footprint, which we define as the sum of our AUM, assets under management, and AUA, assets under advisement, stood at approximately $824 billion and represents a 2% increase to our footprint year-over-year, continuing our long-term growth trend. AUM growth year-over-year was over $11 billion or 12% across both our specialized funds and customized separate accounts. As for our AUM, similar to that of our AUM, growth is across client type and geographic region and came in at over $7 billion or 1%. With that, I will turn it over to Brian to cover fee earning AUM fund flows.

Brian Gildea, Managing Director, Investments

Thank you, Mario, and good morning, everyone. Moving on to our fee earning AUM, at quarter end, total fee earning AUM stood at $52.7 billion and grew $8.1 billion or 18% relative to the prior year, stemming from positive fund flows across both our specialized funds and our customized separate accounts. Taken separately, $4.9 billion of net fee earning AUM came from our customized separate accounts and over the same time period $3.1 billion came from our specialized funds. Additionally, our blended fee rate across both customized separate accounts and specialized funds remains healthy. Moving to customized separate account flows. Fee earning AUM from our customized separate accounts stood at $32.3 billion, growing 18% over the past 12 months. We continue to see growth coming across type, size, and geographic location of the clients. Over the last 12 months, more than 80% of the gross inflows in the customized separate accounts came from our existing client base, which continues to be a steady source of growth for our separate account business. As for our specialized funds, growth here continues to be strong. Fee earning AUM from our specialized funds stood at $20.4 billion at quarter end. Over the past 12 months, we achieved positive net inflows of $3.1 billion, representing growth of 18% relative to the prior year period. This growth stemmed from additional closes for funds in market, robust investment activity, and the continued growth of our Evergreen platform. I’ll provide a quick recap of some of the fundraising activity in our specialized funds and where those stand today. During our last call, we highlighted a number of closings that occurred. Those closings came from our current six secondaries fund, fifth direct equity fund, and seventh installment of our direct credit series. For our current secondaries fund in market, we held the first close of the fund in April of 2022. Then subsequently held another close in July and anticipate an additional close before year-end. The fund currently stands at nearly $1.1 billion of LP commitments based on the two closes and will be in market into the fourth quarter of calendar 2023. Secondaries strategies continue to benefit from strong demand from investors who continue to seek exposure to this segment of the private markets. We believe our dominant position as one of the largest allocators of capital, along with our global investment platform and solid track record will continue to benefit us as we progress with this current fundraise. We are certainly pleased with the early success so far and look forward to providing you updates in the future. Moving on to our direct equity fund, we’re in the final stretch of raising our fifth fund and to date have raised over $2 billion in LP commitments. This amount includes our most recent close on October 28th, that totaled over $160 million of LP commitments. At this level, we have surpassed the total amount raised for our prior vintage. Originally, we had until October of 2022 to finish raising this fund, but due to a small number of investors who are still wrapping up their processes, we’ve received approval to extend out the final closing. We expect to hold the final close for the fund in the coming months. Before I move on, I’d like to take a moment and acknowledge an award that our direct equity platform has recently won. Hamilton Lane Co-Investment Fund IV, the fourth vintage in our direct equity family of funds, came out on top in the category of Best Performance over $1.5 billion co-investment at the Equity Wires U.S. Award Ceremony. We are proud to have won this award as it highlights our commitment to delivering results for our investors. Let’s turn now to our annual direct credit series. During the quarter, we announced the final close for our seventh installment with over $940 million of investor commitments. And similar to our direct equity fund, this seventh installment marks the largest fund ever in this series. Interest in this sector remains strong and we remain well positioned. As for this series, as many of you know, we are constantly raising and deploying capital here, and we’ve already begun work on raising our eighth installment. With that, I will turn the call over to Erik.

Erik Hirsch, Vice Chairman

Thank you, Brian. I’ll start with a quick update regarding some recent developments around the 361 Capital acquisition we closed on in April of 2021. For quick background, when we embarked on the launch of the U.S. sleeve of our Evergreen product, we identified 361 Capital as a great partner to help us build out our distribution capabilities within the fragmented RIA channel. After we closed on the acquisition, the goal for the 361 team was to sell and grow Hamilton Lane’s U.S. Evergreen product, which they have done and continue to do successfully. The acquisition of 361 included two existing long-short products, which while not core to our strategy, were generating revenue to cover the full cost of the 361 team. Now, having successfully transitioned the team to be solely focused on Hamilton Lane’s retail products, we’ve entered into a transaction agreement whereby management of the two funds is expected to be transferred to a third-party. On August 19th, we, along with Allspring Global Investments, announced that the respective boards of those two funds have approved the proposed transaction whereby the 361 funds will merge into new entities managed by Allspring. Allspring is the current sub-advisor to both funds. The transaction is still subject to certain closing conditions, including approval of funds shareholders, but we expect that the deal will close sometime before the end of 2022. We remain very focused on growing our presence across the retail channel and are continuing to add additional resources. We are also focused on broadening out our product offering within the channel. Our newest addition to our Evergreen platform is Hamilton Lane’s Strategic Credit Opportunities Fund, or simply, SCOPE. This fund will invest in private credit transactions with a focus on current cash yield and capital preservation. The credit space is growing, offering increasingly interesting opportunities and is an area where we bring deep, strong, and tenured experience. While it’s still early days with SCOPE, initial flows have begun, and we look forward to providing you with more updates in the coming quarters. I’ll wrap up this section with commentary on our existing Evergreen funds and the continued expansion of our retail distribution channels. On our last call, we provided insight around what we’re experiencing with regards to capital flows against the continued uncertain economic macro backdrop and summer seasonality. In short, while we have not been immune from some of the short-term impacts of the markets and have seen fund flows slow, we have experienced net positive inflows in all but one month year-to-date. And despite the market downturn, we are averaging over $80 million of monthly net inflow for 2022. Given that continued success, our Evergreen platform stands at approximately $2.8 billion. Our growth here has been fueled by a combination of factors, including increasing the number of internal sales resources, expanding distribution channels, and leveraging technology partners. In addition to our strategic partnerships with iCapital, CASE, and TIFIN, we’ve also been an early adopter of blockchain technology and tokenization, as seen by our partnership in Asia with ADDX. We’ve now expanded our efforts on both those fronts by bringing on two new partners to bolster our success and help us grow in the U.S. On October 5th, we announced a partnership with leading digital assets security firm, Securitize, where we will work with them to provide qualified U.S. investors with tokenized access to three Hamilton Lane funds: direct equity, credit, and secondaries. Subsequently, on October 26th, we announced a partnership with blockchain-focused fintech firm Figure to launch the first-ever private markets focused blockchain native share classes of a Registered Investment Fund. The partnership will provide investors access via the blockchain to the U.S. version of our Evergreen platform. We see tokenization and blockchain technology as important steps towards making this asset class easier and more efficient to access. We are proud of our market leading early adopter status, and we are excited to be partnering with Securitize and Figure, both firms which we believe to be at the forefront of their domains. Let’s now move on to our strategic investment portfolio, and I’ll start with two new investments that we closed on in the quarter. On August 23rd, we joined FINTOP Capital, a firm with whom we’ve worked closely in the past, and invested in Hazeltree, which is a leading technology platform focused on delivering treasury and liquidity management solutions to alternative asset management firms. Hazeltree’s platform provides critical cash management and treasury oversight solutions that allow investment managers to increase the speed and reliability of their treasury operations and gain greater security over the entire cash management processing cycle. We have been users of the Hazeltree technology for a number of years prior to making this investment, and now I look forward to being both client and shareholder. Next up is our investment in StashAway. Headquartered in Singapore, StashAway is a data-driven digital wealth management platform through which retail and accredited investors across Asia can access a variety of financial planning and portfolio management tools. StashAway aims to help individual investors build wealth for their future financial security, and they’ve identified private markets as a key avenue towards achieving this goal. We share in the vision of providing expanded access to the private markets for the non-institutional channel and are proud to have invested in and now begin partnering with StashAway to provide their clients with seamless access to private market opportunities. Let me end here with some additional positive news. Recall that several years ago we partnered with then IHS Markit to create a data solutions business called Private Market Connect or PMC. At the creation, Hamilton Lane contributed both startup capital as well as personnel. The partnership between us and IHS Markit resulted in PMC quickly becoming one of the leaders in the private markets data solution space, with Hamilton Lane serving as one of the company’s largest clients. With the acquisition of IHS Markit now completed by S&P, we, PMC, and S&P agreed that the next best step for PMC would be a full integration into S&P’s Global Market Intelligence division. So on August 29th, S&P announced that they have acquired our 50% ownership stake in the PMC joint venture. For Hamilton Lane, the exit, along with dividends paid out along the way, generated over a 20 times multiple on our initial investment. But more importantly, given we remain a key customer, we believe this transaction best positions PMC to continue delivering best-in-class service at an attractive economic level. And with that, I’ll now turn the call over to Atul to cover the financials.

Atul Varma, CFO

Thank you, Erik, and good morning, everyone. Year-to-date, we achieved strong growth in our business with management advisory fees up 19% versus the prior year period. Our specialized funds revenue increased by $21.1 million or 30% compared to the prior year, driven primarily by a $1.2 billion increase in fee earning AUM in our Evergreen platform, approximately $450 million raised in our latest secondaries fund in the quarter, and approximately $1.8 billion raised to September from our latest direct equity fund. Retro fees for the year were approximately $1.2 million, stemming primarily from our direct equity fund versus a minimal amount in the prior year period. As a reminder, investors that come into later closes during the fundraise pay retroactive fees getting back to the fund's first close. We expect to generate additional retro fees as we hold subsequent closes for both our remaining direct equity fund as well as our latest secondaries fund. Moving on to customized separate accounts, revenue increased $8.2 million or 17% compared to the prior year period, due to reabsorption from existing clients, the addition of several new accounts, and continued investment activity. Revenue from our advisory, reporting, and other offerings decreased by $0.4 million compared to the prior year period, primarily due to a decrease in revenue from our distribution management business, partially offset by an increase in funding reimbursement revenue. Lastly, the final component of our revenue is incentive fees. Incentive fees year-to-date totaled $110.1 million. As we touched on last quarter, the relative increase in incentive fees compared to the prior quarters is due primarily to the fact that a number of specialized funds entered into the GP catch-up portion of their respective fund waterfalls. You typically find GP catch-up in connection with European-style waterfalls, which is the most conservative method related to earning carried interest and represents the method the vast majority of carry-eligible funds employed. While this method does delay the receipt of carried interest, it is more favorable to the client and avoids any clawback risk and thus represents stability for our shareholders. During the GP catch-up period, you typically see an outsized amount of value that flows through GP, whichever we experienced again this quarter. Let me now turn to some additional detail on our unrealized carry balance. The balance is down 1% from the prior year period, even as we recognized $138.3 million of incentive fees during the last 12 months. The unrealized carry balance now stands at just under $1 billion. Moving to expenses, total expenses increased $63.5 million compared with the prior year period. Total compensation and benefits increased by $52.5 million, driven primarily by compensation associated with the increased amount of incentive fees in the period. G&A expenses for the period increased by $10.9 million, which included increases in travel and conference calls that were limited during COVID. In addition, we saw increases in fund expenses and third-party commissions, which are tied to the strong fundraising and revenue growth we saw in the period. Year-to-date, our fee-related earnings were up 10% relative to the prior year period as a result of the management fee growth discussed earlier. I’ll wrap up here with some commentary on our balance sheet. Our largest asset continues to be our investments alongside our clients in our customized separate accounts and specialized funds. Over the long term, we view these investments as an important component of our continued growth and we will continue to invest in our balance sheet capital alongside our clients. In regard to our liabilities, we continue to be modestly levered. And with that, we thank you for joining the call and I’m happy to open it up for questions.

Operator, Operator

Your first question is from Ken Worthington with JPMorgan. Please go ahead.

Ken Worthington, Analyst

Hi. Good morning. Thanks for taking the questions. So, first, I’d love to dig deeper into tokenization and the use of blockchain technology to improve access to the products. So maybe, first, can you talk a little bit more about how tokenization improves distribution and access to the products? Is there a savings element in terms of the back and/or mid-office to pursuing this sort of tokenization and listing? And then, lastly, to what extent do you retain either greater control over the client or the client data from a relationship when you utilize sort of the blockchain technology, I know there’s little fishing in there, but you could comment?

Erik Hirsch, Vice Chairman

Thanks, Ken. It’s Erik. I will dive in there. There’s a lot. So let me do my best. I think the way we look at this is, to-date our asset class has operated in a very traditional environment, lots of documentation, lots of manual processes, lots of lawyers. I think as you look forward, there are a number of companies, especially the ones that we’ve recently partnered with, that are focused on trying to use different kinds of technology to make access easier. So if you think about a world where to-date every investor needs to go through a KYC process for every individual investment, because there’s no tie between in a world where you have a centralized digital wallet that’s housed on chain and you’re offering fun products via tokens; in that world, you can streamline a lot of the legal processes, and yes, that would bring cost savings. But, I think more importantly, you start to enter into a point-and-click environment where simply making acquisitions and investments in our industry begins to look much more similar to what you experience today in the public markets, where we can all pull out our phone, as we’re walking down the sidewalk and buy a stock. I think this is really just reflecting that there’s a move afoot with some very sophisticated technology, with some very interesting firms that are trying to drive more towards that. And so, no different than the evolution you saw in the public markets where things got easier, access became more broad, and frankly, costs came down for your interface costs. We expect the same thing over time here to be the case, as this all begins to mature and take hold.

Ken Worthington, Analyst

Okay. And control of data and the customer, anything there, or is that far-fetched?

Erik Hirsch, Vice Chairman

It's different. You're dealing with digital securities and digital tokens, so your customer base primarily consists of the entities that hold the wallets. However, that's a very small part of our overall business at this point, and it hasn't had any significant positive or negative impact.

Ken Worthington, Analyst

Okay. And then follow up on the Evergreen side. I think you said in prepared remarks that inflows this year, in all but one month of the year, was the one month of outflows in September. If it was September, do you see September as sort of a one-off or is it sort of near-term inflection point, given the macro environment that we’re seeing?

Erik Hirsch, Vice Chairman

I believe it was.

Mario Giannini, CEO

I believe it was August or September. I need to verify that. We see it as a one-time event and not something that has recurred in terms of outflows. Therefore, we do not consider it indicative of our performance since then.

Ken Worthington, Analyst

Awesome. Thank you very much.

Operator, Operator

Your next question is from the line of Adam Beatty with UBS. Please go ahead.

Adam Beatty, Analyst

Thank you and good morning. Just, first of all, a quick follow-up on a bit of the blockchain discussion and maybe I know the answer from the tone of Erik’s remarks so far. But just wondering about product suitability for that kind of environment. Do you see this as something where all private markets products and vehicles would eventually migrate to that, or are there certain products or vehicles that you would think even long-term would just stay in kind of a more conventional environment? Thank you.

Erik Hirsch, Vice Chairman

Sure, Adam. It’s Erik, I’ll take that. I mean, let’s leave aside the registration and legalities and what type of investor you’re going to, because there’s different rules across all the different geographies. And you can see even in the firms that we’re doing business with today, they’re all kind of taking a slightly different approach. But if you just take a more macro perspective, accessing private market investments funds is easier in this tokenized-blockchain world, and easier also means less friction points, which also means less cost and expenses for the customer. So our belief is that over time, and there’s no way of knowing what time means today, will this transition be two years, 20 years, or 200 years. But our view is that it’s all appropriately suited for it, how that migration occurs, how quickly it occurs is sort of to be determined. I think you can see clearly, strategically what we’re doing, which is, we’ve identified a variety of partners who we think are bringing an interesting value-add perspective with very interesting technology, and we’re aligning with a variety of them. Because it’s not clear today which piece is going to ultimately resonate in the market, and I suspect, just like in the public markets, there’s no single platform today that you utilize to access the public markets, there are lots of market leading platforms, and I suspect over time, that will be true here as well.

Adam Beatty, Analyst

Make sense. Thank you, Erik. And then just shifting over to the credit opportunities product, just wanted to get a little bit more detail around the underlying kind of strategies that you’re targeting with that. Is it something that’s fairly opportunistic, more of a core, core plus orientation? And also kind of maybe some background about what drove those decisions as to how and where to focus the fund, was it opportunities that you’re seeing from your in-house research or more around client demand or some mix of that? Thank you.

Brian Gildea, Managing Director, Investments

Sure. This is Brian. I’ll take that one. So across our private credit, we’re broadly investing in the private credit strategy. So think small- to mid-sized companies cash flow positive in a segment of the market that has moved away from bank financing. And that provides a little bit better return; it’s generally a floating-rate return, part of the market, and very attractive risk and reward characteristics compared to the public credit markets.

Adam Beatty, Analyst

Excellent. Any concerns around the potential credit cycle that we might be heading into?

Brian Gildea, Managing Director, Investments

Oh! I think as an investor, of course, we’re always very much focused on where we are in the market, as we’re shaping the investments that we’re making. We’ve been doing that for a number of years leading into this market, recognizing that we were late cycle. So high quality is, of course, the focus. And the underlying credit statistics have remained strong across portfolios. But, of course, we’re mindful of the environment that we’re in.

Adam Beatty, Analyst

Excellent. Thank you, Brian. Appreciate it.

Operator, Operator

Your next question comes from a line of Finian O’Shea with Wells Fargo Securities. Please go ahead.

Finian O’Shea, Analyst

Hi. Good morning. Thank you. A follow-on on the SCOPE product. Given its more recurring income-oriented nature, will that seek to be marketed more broadly to the retail market versus the other Evergreen funds?

Brian Gildea, Managing Director, Investments

Yeah. This is Brian. I will take that one. I think now we’re envisioning a similar audience. So we’re currently marketing our other Evergreen funds. So we’ve seen that there’s strong demand in the credit space from that investor type. This portfolio will have slightly different characteristics than the equity-oriented portfolios that we have today. But we think that many of the same attributes will really resonate with that market.

Operator, Operator

Your next question is from the line of Chris Kotowski with Oppenheimer. Please go ahead.

Chris Kotowski, Analyst

I have a modeling question. Many of us have been calculating your incentive fees as a percentage of the carried interest receivable. Typically, in this environment, you would expect that to be lower since the markets are down and it would lead to a slower harvesting phase. However, if you are in the catch-up phase for most of these funds, there might be an uneven increase. I’m curious if you could provide any guidance on how many quarters you are in this catch-up phase and what percentage of your carry receivable comes from those catch-up payments. Any insights would help us align our numbers more accurately.

Erik Hirsch, Vice Chairman

Yeah. Sure. It’s Erik. This will be a very unsatisfactory answer. I think when you’re using a European waterfall, it’s very difficult to model as we’ve seen. So we’ve been public now for over five years. I would say if you take a look at the quarterly history, despite everyone being intelligent and working hard to try to get all this right, we have been either light or heavy, but rarely have we been right on mark. I think the European waterfall is kind of akin to you spend years sort of pushing the boulder up the hill, and when you finally get to the top, it begins to kind of quickly roll down the other side. And so here, that’s what we’ve been doing. We’ve been pushing the boulder for a long time. We’ve continued to have liquidity. We’ve continued to have good performance. We’ve continued to have well-diversified portfolios. We finally got the boulder to the top of the hill, and now it’s beginning to sort of turn and run. The catch-up obviously doesn’t last forever. It lasts until we’re caught up. So I think our takeaway would simply be that because of good performance, we’ve gotten a variety of our flagship specialized funds to the point where they’re in the catch-up. You’ve seen that very clearly this quarter. You saw that last quarter. That won’t last forever. Again, eventually, we will be caught up. But the other takeaway I would leave you with is that despite a challenging market environment, I think reflecting on the size and diversity of these portfolios, we continue to have exit activity, which is obviously what’s driving the fact that we’re able to get the dollars and the catch-up. That only comes because you actually have exits. So all of that’s happening. What can I tell you for the quarter is coming? We’re going to still be working through the catch-up with some of these products. We continue to still see exit activity, although, as I noted, it’s certainly lower and slower than what we’ve seen in a more normalized market environment. But predicting beyond that, I would say, I’ll be as accurate as anyone else, which is to say not very accurate.

Chris Kotowski, Analyst

Okay. All right, Erik. Thank you. That’s it for me.

Operator, Operator

Your next question comes from a line of Alex Blostein with Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead.

Unidentified Analyst, Analyst

Hey, guys. This is Michael on for Alex. Just a quick one for me. On PEE allocation, maybe you can help us think about how things are changing in real time. 2022 was slow, but maybe is there a risk that 2023 new commitments to PEE will be worse, and any color you have around there would be helpful? Thanks.

Mario Giannini, CEO

Michael, it’s Mario. Hard to predict on 2023. I think you’re right on 2022. It’s been slower. Because of two factors, really the denominator effect everyone is talking about. LPs don’t have as much capital. And by the way, performance has been great. It’s been their best performing asset class, the private markets. So that NAV has continued to be pretty steady. But the other factor is there’s just no rush to do anything. There’s a lot of product in the market, no rush, and so everything has slowed down. I would expect 2023 will also be a difficult market. Will it be as challenging as what we’re experiencing 2022? Now, I don’t know. All that will depend on the public markets on where inflation and interest rates are going, and everyone has different points of view. But I would expect 2023 we will continue to see LPs with less capital than they’d like to invest and a lot of product coming into market. So it will still be a tough environment for some part of 2023.

Unidentified Analyst, Analyst

Great. Thanks so much.

Operator, Operator

This concludes the Q&A portion of today’s call. I will now turn the call back to Erik for any closing remarks.

Erik Hirsch, Vice Chairman

Great. Again, we always appreciate the time and the interest, and we wish you well. Thanks again.

Operator, Operator

This does conclude the Hamilton Lane second quarter fiscal 2023 earnings conference call. Thank you all for participating. You may now disconnect.