Skip to main content
ACGL $110.89 +1.17%
ACGL logo
ACGL · Arch Capital Group Ltd.
Track ACGL — free
Market Cap
$36.10B
Shares
325.53M
Volume · Nov 16 2.08M Avg daily vol (3M) 2.87M
All webcasts

Earnings call · FY2025 Q4

Arch Capital Group Ltd. (ACGL) Q4 2025 Earnings Call Transcript

Concluded Feb 10, 2026 Audio replay Verified speakers
Feb 10, 2026 59:16 79 turns
Period
FY2025 Q4
Runtime
59:16
Sources
5 artifacts
Revenue · derived Q4 $4.93B +8.5% YoY
Net income · derived Q4 $1.24B +32.4% YoY
Open full screen Slides 13 8-K 10-K

Transcript & audio

Verified speakers 59:16 Audio
Speaker 5

Good day, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to 4Q2024-25 Arch Capital Earnings Conference Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. Later, we will conduct a question-and-answer session, and instructions will follow at that time. As a reminder, this conference call is being recorded. Before the company gets started with its update, management wants to first remind everyone that certain statements in yesterday's press release and discussed on this call may constitute forward-looking statements under the federal securities laws. These statements are based upon management's current assessments and assumptions and are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties. Consequently, actual results may differ materially from those expressed or implied. For more information on the risks and other factors that may affect future performance, investors should review periodic reports that are filed by the company with the SEC from time to time, including our annual report on Form 10 for the 2024 fiscal year. Additionally, certain statements contained in the call that are not based on historical facts are forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Letication Reform Act of 1995. The company intends forward-looking statements in the call to be subject to safe harbor created thereby. Management also will make reference to certain non-GAAP measures of financial performance. The reconciliations to GAAP for each non-GAAP financial measure can be found in the company's current report on Form 8K, furnished to the SEC yesterday, which contains the company's earnings press release and is available on the company's website at www.archgroup.com and on the SCC website at www.scc.gov. I would now like to turn the call over. I will now introduce your hosts for today's conference, Mr. Nicolas Appadapolo and Mr. François Morin. Sirs, you may begin.

Good morning, and welcome to our fourth quarter earnings call. We concluded another exceptional year by generating $1.1 billion of after-tax operating income in the fourth quarter, up 26% from the same period in 2024. Our quarterly consolidated combined ratio of 80.6% reflects excellent underwriting results across the group. For the full year, we produced $3.7 billion of after-tax operating income, a new high, resulting in after-tax operating earnings per share of $9.84, and a 17.1% annualized operating return on average common equity for 2025. Continued strong operating cash flows and capital generation enabled the repurchase of $1.9 billion of ARCH common stock in 2025. We strongly believe our stock is a good long-term investment, and share buybacks represent an efficient way to return excess capital to our shareholders over time. Since our inception, Arches' commitment to maximize long-term shareholder value has been unwavering. In 2025, book value per share, a preferred measure of value creation, increased by 22.6%. Since our start in 2001, book value per share has gone at a compound annual growth rate in excess of 15%, placing us at the top of our peer group. We remain confident in our ability to deliver strong returns throughout the underwriting cycle and to build on the legacy of discipline, execution, and consistent results. We head into 2026 with measured optimism. We are starting from a position of strengths, but recognize that competition is increasing in several lines of business. In an evolving market, the arch playbook, which has served us well over the years, is a differentiator that remains as valid and effective as ever. Our playbook is anchored by an underwriting culture defined by deep expertise and disciplined risk selection. Combined with a diversified business model, a proven record of best-in-class cycle management, and the strengths of the art brand, we are well positioned to consistently deliver superior results for our shareholders. I will now provide updates on our reporting segments. I'll begin with our insurance group, which delivered $119 million of underwriting income in the fourth quarter. Underwriting performance was solid, with an underlying ex-cat combined ratio of 90.8% in the quarter, similar to the fourth quarter last year gross premium return increased two percent from the fourth quarter of 2024. in north america we continue to grow in specialty casualty lines including alternative market construction and ens casualty as for our international units we increased ridings through our Bermuda platform and in continental Europe. I will note that we experienced a year-over-year decline in net premium return, which Francois will explain in his remarks. Across the insurance platform, our underwriters pivoted towards lines of business offering the most attractive margins, and we grew premium volume in more than half of our business units, indicating a healthier underlying market that industry headlines would suggest. In North America, the rate environment is largely keeping pace with lost cost trends, while pricing in our international business units is tracking slightly below lost trends. Within East geography, consistent with our cycle management approach, we will adjust our business mix in response to changing market condition and pricing dynamics. Our insurance platform has expanded significantly over the last several years, providing more opportunities to capitalize on attractive margins in many areas. Going forward, our underwriters will continue to pursue growth in those areas where risk-adjusted returns exceed or meet our long-term objectives. Moving to reinsurance, which delivered a record $1.6 billion of underwriting income for the year. The fourth quarter combined ratio, XCAT, and prior year development was 74.9%, consistent with the prior year quarter and reflective of continued underlying market profitability. Gross premium returns were flat versus the fourth quarter of 2024, despite the non-renewal of a large structure of transaction. Net premium return declined primarily due to a change in the timing of certain retrocession purchases. On January 1, proper ticket and more generally short-term excess of loss renewals were highly competitive with rates down 10 to 20%. Ceiling commission increased in proportional reinsurance as supply continued to our best demand despite these headwinds our underwriting teams performed well by leveraging the strengths of our platform to source a handful of new opportunities these opportunities will reduce the negative top line impact from the right pressure the mortgage segment produced one billion dollars of underwriting income for the year our fourth consecutive year exceeding the one billion threshold. In our USMI business, new insurance return remained modest, and insurance in force was stable. The underlying credit quality of the portfolio is excellent, as illustrated by favorable cure rates on delinquent mortgages, which draw favorable reserve development in the quarter. While lower mortgage rates are beginning to support increased origination activity, the current market is still constrained. The team remains focused on underwriting discipline, expense management, and perfecting its data and analytical platforms to further optimize the business. Finally, investment generated $434 million of net investment income in the quarter, while equity method investment added another $155 million to net income. We continue to look to the investment portfolio, where assets surpassed $47 billion at URAN to provide a stable recurring earnings stream that enhances the group's overall returns. As we move past 2 p.m. on the PNC underwriting clock, it is increasingly important to focus on business that generates adequate risk-adjusted returns. For almost 25 years, ART has perfected its cycle management capabilities by adhering to some foundational principles. One, leveraging a diversified specialty platform to maximize flexibility and reduce volatility. Two, embracing a business owner mindset anchored on delivering a differentiated customer experience. Three, using data and analytics to sharpen insights and enhance risk selection. And last but not least, ensuring alignment with investors by rewarding underwriters for profitability, not volume, and incentivizing our executives to grow book value per share above all else. The stage of the underwriting cycle will test our underwriting discipline and acumen. Hard markets are exciting for many reasons, but successfully managing the cycle is equally, if not more, rewarding, as the decisions made today will shape future returns. With our experience, focus, proven track record, and capital strength, we believe Arch is ready for the task and well positioned to outperform the sector. This year marks Arch's 25th anniversary. Having been here since 2001, I firmly believe that Arches' culture, driven by our dedicated people, is a foundation of our success. So, before I turn the call over to Francois, I want to thank Team Arches for another outstanding year and for positioning the company for continued success in the years ahead. Francois.

Thank you, Nicholas, and good morning to all. Last night, we reported our fourth quarter results with after-tax operating income of $2.98 per share and an annualized net income return on average common equity of 21.2%. Book value per share grew by 4.5% in the quarter. Our three business segments once again delivered excellent underlying results with an overall ex-cap accident-year combined ratio of 79.5%, down 100 basis points from last quarter. Our underwriting income included $118 million of favorable prior development on a pre-tax basis in the fourth quarter, or 2.8 points on the overall combined ratio. we recognize favorable development across all three of our segments and in many of our lines of business the most significant improvements were once again seen in short tail lines in our PNC segments and in mortgage due to strong cure activity current year catastrophe losses were 164 million dollars net of reinsurance and reinstatement premiums lower than our seasonally adjusted expectations, but higher than last quarter, mostly as a result of U.S. severe convective storms, Hurricane Melissa, and a series of global events. The insurance segment's gross premiums written grew 2.3%, while net premiums written declined 4% year over year. The decrease in net premiums written was due, in part, to the timing of seeded written premium accruals related to the MC acquisition in the prior year quarter, and changes in business mix resulting from different levels of net-to-gross retention ratios. The X-CAT accident-year loss ratio improved by 80 basis points to 57.5% compared to the same quarter one year ago. The acquisition expense ratio for the current accident year increased by 150 basis points as the benefit we observed in the fourth quarter of 2024 from the write-off of deferred acquisition costs for the MC Acquired Business rolled off. The reinsurance segment had another stellar quarter in terms of pre-tax underwriting income at $458 million. Overall, gross premiums written were flat and net premiums written were down approximately 5.2% from the same quarter one year ago. Our net premium volume was up in casualty in property other than property catastrophe, but was down in specialty due to the impact of the non-renewal of a large transaction, as Nicholas mentioned, and in property catastrophe due to changes in the timing of certain retrocession purchases. We finished 2025 with an 80.8% combined ratio for the year, certainly an excellent result and the lowest since 2016. Once again, our mortgage segment delivered another very strong quarter with underwriting income of $250 million. Net premiums earned were down approximately $11 million from last quarter, mostly across our CRT and Australian businesses. That said, with fourth quarter new insurance written at USMI at its highest level for the year and persistency remaining high at 81.8%, USMI insurance and force was relatively flat. The current accident year combined ratio remained low at 34%, considering the increase in new notices of default due to seasonality. The delinquency rate for our USMI business increased to 2.17% in line with our expectations. On the investment front, we earned a combined $589 million from net investment income and income from funds accounted using the equity method, or $1.60 per share pre-tax. Strong positive cash flow from operations, $6.2 billion for the year, helped us further increase the size of our investable assets, which now stands at $47.4 billion. Our portfolio remains of very high quality, with a short duration, and remains in line with our asset allocation targets. Income from operating affiliates was strong at $61 million, due especially to a very good quarter at summer's rate. As you have heard, the Bermuda government enacted in December the Tax Credits Act 2025 designed to incentivize tangible on-island economic activity. At the heart of the Act are Qualified Refundable Tax Credits, or QRTCs, which are available to us given our operational presence in Bermuda. This quarter, we recognized the full year effect of the 2025 QRTCs, significantly impacting our financial results, primarily through the expense ratio for our reinsurance segment and the corporate expenses line. Of note, included in these numbers are some one-time benefits which we would not expect to recur in future years. Going forward, our view is that the impact of the QRTC should be most visible in two places. One, for the reinsurance segment, we would expect our operating expense ratio to benefit, resulting in a full year 2026 operating expense ratio between 3.9% and 4.5%. And two, our corporate expenses should also be reduced from their run rate levels and be approximately between 80 and 90 million dollars in 2026. The QRTCs will also benefit other expense line items, including the insurance and mortgage segment expense ratios and net investment income, but to a much lesser extent. As a reminder, our pattern of corporate expenses it is typically skewed towards the first quarter of the year due to the impact of equity compensation grants. For the 2025 year, our effective tax rate on pre-tax operating income was 14.9%, reflecting the mix of income by tax jurisdiction. It was slightly below the 16 to 18% previously guided range mostly due to a 1.4 percent benefit from discrete items as we look ahead to 2026 we would expect our annualized effective tax rate to return to the 16 to 18 percent range for the full year as of january 1 our peak zone natural cap probable maximum loss for a single event one in 250-year return period on a net-level basis remained flat at $1.9 billion and now stands at 8.2% of tangible shareholders' equity. For 2026, our current estimate of the full-year catastrophe losses stands within a range of 7% to 8% of overall net earned premium, similar to the estimate we disclosed last year. On the capital management front, we repurchased $798 million of our shares in the fourth quarter. For the year, we repurchased $1.9 billion or 21.2 million shares, representing 5.6% of the outstanding common shares at the start of the year. we have repurchased an additional 349 million dollars in shares so far this year through last night we close 2025 with a balance sheet and excellent help with strong capitalization and low leverage giving us plenty of optionality as we continue to work to put to work the capital our shareholders have entrusted in us with these introductory comments we are now prepared to take

Speaker 5

your question thank you if you would like to ask a question please signal by pressing star one on your telephone keypad if you're using your speakerphone please make sure your mute function is turned off to allow your signal to reach our equipment again please press star one to ask a question and we'll pause for just a moment to allow everyone an opportunity to signal for questions Our first question comes from Elise Griesman at Wells Fargo. Please go ahead.

Elise Griesman Analyst — Wells Fargo

Hi, thanks. Good morning. I wanted to start with the comments that you guys made on Property Cat. I think you said that there were some, you know, opportunities at 1-1, right, that, you know, sort of to offset the impact of the price declines.

Can you just expand, I guess, on the opportunities that you saw and just how you expect, I guess, growth in in property cat re um during 2026 so good morning i mean um i think the opportunities we we refer to in our comments i mean are not in property cat i think they they come from other geographies and mostly in the in specialty lines um okay and then um my my second question was just on capital.

Elise Griesman Analyst — Wells Fargo

You guys, it sounds like there was a, you know, the level of and the pace of buyback, Francois, based on your comments, picked up to start the year. I know you guys, right, typically buybacks, right, it depends upon capital as well as the stock price. But how should we think about the level trending from here, right, $350 million, right, in a little bit over a month, right, is a pretty big level?

Yeah, I think, I mean, sure, buybacks are, I think are certainly, as we said, like a good way to return capital. I don't think, I mean, we don't set a target. It's not like we're saying we're going to return X dollars by the end of the year. But, you know, the market, you know, depending on stock price and what we see in our ability to deploy capital in the business, we'll be active for sure. I mean, the pace will vary. It's not necessarily, I'd say, a binary event, whether we buy or we don't buy. It's, you know, We buy different levels during different times during the year, but I think it's no question that given the market environment we're in, I think you should expect us to be pretty active on the sure buybacks throughout the year.

Elise Griesman Analyst — Wells Fargo

And then one last one on the MCE side, can you just remind us of the expectations for the re-underwriting in terms of the premium impact? And from a seasonality perspective, is that more weighted to one quarter of the year versus another? Or should we think about that being an even impact during the four quarters of 26?

Yeah, I mean, part B, no question that the business is pretty well distributed throughout the year. There's not much seasonality in it. You know, the re-underwriting question, we touched on it in prior quarters. There's definitely some business that came with the acquisition primarily in the form of programs that we identified that were going to be non-renewed. We've done that work that will start to really impact our top line in 2026. And, you know, we hopefully, you know, depending on market conditions can offset some of that reduction by growth in the truly the middle market business that we have on the books. But, again, very much a function of market conditions. but that's the current thinking on that.

Elise Griesman Analyst — Wells Fargo

Thank you.

Speaker 12

You're welcome.

Speaker 5

Next question will be from Tracy Benjigi at Wolf Research. Please go ahead.

Tracy Benjigi Analyst — Wolfe Research

Good morning. On the 10% to 20% rate decreases at 1-1, based on prior conversations I had with Arch, I understand you don't like cap business below a 16% ROE. So in terms of sensitivities, I understood going into renewal, You thought that, let's say, if you got a 10% rate reduction, you could still land a 20% ROE, maybe 15% will get you between 16% to 20%. Now, the 10% to 20% is a wide band. So, how does this all shake out on an ROE perspective for PropCat business?

So, overall, I think we still like the CAD business we wrote at 1.1. I think we, as you said, some areas have been more competitive than others. We've seen Europe, you know, being very competitive. I think in the U.S., you know, probably less so compared to Europe. And I think we just adjust, you know, our ridings to the target profitability that is set by regions. So overall, I think we were able to, you know, retain most of our annuals. You know, we got some very favorable signing from our broker because of the, you know, the service we provide and the longstanding relationship we have with, you know, many of our selling companies. So I think we still like the business. I think if rates were to continue to go down, you know, in the mid-teens, you know, we will have to, on a case-by-case basis, you know, realize where it makes sense and where it doesn't.

Tracy Benjigi Analyst — Wolfe Research

Okay. And any early thoughts on mid-year reinsurance renewal pricing relative to what you're seeing in January?

Our thought is more about the market in general. I think the competition we are seeing is really a reflection of the excellent results we've all benefited from, you know, in the last three years. And, you know, the fact that we had only one major cat, which was the California wildfires. So I think we, you know, absent of any other major cat, I would expect, you know, the supplies to continue to be there. So I think people should pay attention to the risk-adjusted return, you know, going forward, because it will be a big element of how we underwrite the business.

Tracy Benjigi Analyst — Wolfe Research

Okay, thank you.

Speaker 5

Thank you. Next question will be from KV Montessori at Twitch Bank. Please go ahead.

Speaker 3

Morning. Given yesterday's move in the market, I was going to ask you about the risk of disruption to a business model from AI and whether you're more likely to be a net beneficiary from AI, do I improve deficiencies and smarter risk selection, rather than at risk of disruption, which I suspect is probably more limited to some distribution platforms or maybe to care if on the right lines are more commoditized. I'd love to hear your thoughts on this topic.

Yes, I think I agree with your premise. I think we think of AI as more of an opportunity for efficiency rather than a threat. But ultimately, the beneficiary of AI will be the consumers, as most of the savings and efficiency will be passed on to the insured. But yes, I think the advantage of being in the specialty market is it's complex, and I think it will – I'm not saying it's impossible, but it will take time for models to learn to replicate the behavior of the underwriters. So I think what we're seeing is, you know, personal lines or SME may be happening there faster than in the space that we're playing.

Speaker 3

Okay. And my follow-up question is a follow-up on capital return. I guess in theory, if there is no growth in 2026, and I hope you guys see growth, But if there is no growth, you could distribute close to 100% of the capital you generate. Is that something you would consider? If not, what's the highest ratio you'd consider in the no growth and no M&A scenario?

You're right. I mean, if we're not growing, which, again, we don't know if we will or not, but, you know, depends on the market. But absolutely, if the market, you know, we're not growing, you know, their capital need should remain relatively flat, and every dollar of, you know, income that we generate technically could be, you know, creating more excess capital. What's our, you know, do we have a, you know, do we have a set of targets? No, we don't, but we are, you know, if the market, you know, points us in a certain direction and the opportunity is there to buy back, you know, more than you would, you know, you saw us buy back last year, for example, we're happy to do that. It's very much a function of market conditions, and, you know, that's something we evaluate, you know, on a daily basis.

Speaker 3

Thank you. You're welcome.

Speaker 5

Next question will be from Mike Zaremsky at BMO. Please go ahead.

Mike Zaremski Analyst — BMO

Hey, thanks. Good morning. I guess first question on the reinsurance segment specifically. I guess a lot goes into the loss ratio, of course, for the segment. If we're looking at the underlying loss ratio trend, it's nudging a bit higher into the low 50s. I guess thinking about 26, to the extent the reinsurance market plays out the way you're thinking in terms of just some additional downwards grade pressure, should we continue to nudge that loss ratio trend line higher?

Yeah, I think the reinsurance side, I think margin is definitely under pressure. So I think you're right. And it comes from the pricing on the excess of loss. And also, you know, on the expense side, you know, we're seeing also a ceiling commission, you know, going up. Okay. But we still like the business. I think it's, you know, we have a big diversified platform. We write the business in many geographies. So I think we believe that we can find ways to continue to track attractive market. But, yes, the margin, I mean, they were very high, but the margins are definitely under pressure.

Mike Zaremski Analyst — BMO

Okay, great. And I'm going to ask another capital management question just because, you know, you all, as you point out, are good cycle managers. You're one of the few that's able or maybe willing to shrink in times that you're making a bet that the market isn't as conducive for growth. So on capital management, are there any items that would, you know, other than, you know, we can see the shrinkage and top-line growth that could free up more capital than we can kind of see at a high level, like the mortgage segment? Is that releasing, you know, a material amount of regulatory capital that we should potentially take into account?

On that question, Mike, I don't think so. I mean, I think we touched, well, we certainly have touched on it in the past. I think the overall capital position, you know, the fact that, yes, maybe there's some capital that is trapped in the MI companies hasn't really been a factor. I think we've been able to distribute through dividends, like, meaningful amounts of capital from our MI company to, you know, to buyback stock, to return to shareholders, et cetera. So, I don't think that should be any, you know, it shouldn't be materially different going forward. The one thing that is a capital consumer is the investment portfolio. That's one thing that we have some, I think, ability to influence capital requirements depending on how much capital or assets we deploy in riskier assets, such as equities and or private investments. But other than that, I think, and we can also play certainly on the reinsurance side, whether we buy more or less reinsurance like that impacts our net retained premium. But, you know, at this point, I wouldn't expect, like, drastic changes in how we think about excess capital or how we think about returning capital. It's pretty much, you know, I'd say 26 should be, you know, at a high level, a continuation of what we saw on 25.

Mike Zaremski Analyst — BMO

Great. Great. And just sneaking one quick one in, Nicholas, you said the North America rate environment largely keeping pace with trend, but international probably slightly below. I thought that was a bit of a provocative statement, since I think the assumption is that the data we're seeing is that lawsuit inflation continues to be an issue in the U.S. So any context, additional color you want to put on kind of why you feel better about U.S. versus international things?

Yes, I think that's, you know, the remarks that I made is really based on our own portfolio for the lines of business we write. And remember, the band in North America is more about, you know, long tail. We're more of a casualty rider. And in casualty, we've seen, you know, rates about above trend. So that drives, and certainly in the shorter lines, we've seen, you know, rates coming down. So I think, you know, that's – but when you take the entire portfolio and then we see one upsetting the other at this stage in the market.

Mike Zaremski Analyst — BMO

Thank you.

Speaker 5

Next question will be from Andrew Anderson at Jefferies. Please go ahead.

Andrew Anderson Analyst — Jefferies

Hey, good morning. Could you share about a bit what the conditions are in the casualty reinsurance market there? Are you still seeing right ahead of lost cost?

So on the casualty side, you know, generally on the primary, before we talk about the insurance market, I think on the primary side, we feel that rates are still, you know, we're still getting more rate than trend. You know, it seems that it's decelerating a little bit of what we saw in the last quarter, but I personally believe that there's still pain. You know, I think we still will see some unfavorable developments in the market for the old years and the, you know, the prior to 2022. So I'm optimistic that the rates could continue to at least meet trend for the foreseeable future. So that's the background. When we look specifically at the reinsurance, I think we've seen there's a lot of supply, a lot of willingness for the reinsurer to ride the business. And I think the thing that has been new is, you know, maybe based on what I said earlier, the ability or the willingness of seeding companies to retain more of the business, which has added, you know, supply is constant and the demand is stable to down. So that is another layer of competition there.

Andrew Anderson Analyst — Jefferies

Thanks. And that demand comment on staples to down, was that just on casualty? Or perhaps you could update us on how you're thinking about property demand into mid-year?

The one I talked about is with casualty. I think on property, we've seen on the reinsurance side, and especially on the CAD accessible side, we've seen retention being stable. Only a few Ceden decided to add sublayers to their program. So I think that – and on the other property, yeah, we're seeing companies based on, again, as I said earlier, the excellent results of the last three years, willing now to take on more of the business. So that's a factor there too. Thank you.

Speaker 5

Next question will be from David Motemaden at Evercore. Please go ahead.

David Motemaden Analyst — Evercore

Hey, thanks. I just had a question, you know, encouraging to see the level of buyback continue in the first quarter. But, you know, I'm just sort of wondering how you guys would frame how we should be thinking about the current excess capital position that you guys have before we start thinking about, you know, running through the puts and takes on growth and different sources and uses um would be great to to get a get an update on that front yeah i mean listen we the excess capital is a uh you know it's a it's a number that changes you know is not static right and you know but no question that you know given the level of results and returns we've generated the last few years we we did end up accumulating some excess capital uh you know our number one

mission we've said before is to put the capital to work in the business where we think it makes sense where we can generate adequate returns. You know, after that, yes, we absolutely are committed to returning the capital to the shareholders, but, you know, we want to do what's right for the shareholders. And sometimes it may just mean that, you know, for a given, you know, some period of time, we do hold on to the capital for a bit longer. The money is, you know, has been, it's been said before on our calls, it's in our pockets. It's not burning anything. It's just sitting there. It's maybe not the most optimal way, right? But it's still, it's not really destroying value in a meaningful way. So we're all about what doing is right for the shareholder. And, you know, if in an environment, again, if we don't grow materially going forward, or at least for the short term, you know, you could certainly think that, you know, you should think of the level of earnings we're going to generate to be, you know additive to our excess capital position and that's you know gives us more opportunity to return more capital to shareholders great thanks um and then maybe just following up uh on uh on the casualty reinsurance side um you know you've seen decent growth there it's offset um some of the the pressure uh on on the property side as you guys have managed the cycle um i'm interested

David Motemaden Analyst — Evercore

uh nicholas you had talked about um i guess i hire seeds on proportional reinsurance you know i was assuming that is for property um but given you know your answer to the you know one of the previous questions it sounds like you know is or i guess i'm wondering are you seeing higher seeds on on casualty read just given the supply demand um changes and you know do you still view casualty really is a growth opportunity in 26 that can help offset some of the pressure on the property side.

Just to answer your first question, I think it's marginal on the casualty, and it works both ways, like underperforming accounts, you see ceiling commission going down a bit, should be more, but, and, you know, excellent account that everybody is looking for, you may see marginal increase, but really, I should have clarified earlier, not the big factor, it's mostly the big swing has been on other property. And to answer your second questions on appetite in the space, I think backing the right seeding company, people like a little bit arch, have real good understanding of the business and can navigate their way in ultimately a pretty favorable, in some pockets, primary casualty market. We think it's something we would like to do more of. It's hard to do based on what I explained earlier, but again, our brand in the reinsurance side is good, and we have a huge trading relationship with our seeding companies. So we can, you know, we can find ways to, we certainly first call when, you know, new programs are set up or, you know, some reinsurers, you know, decided to be moved out of the program or reduce. I think we have a shot at growing going forward, I think.

David Motemaden Analyst — Evercore

Awesome. Thank you. You're welcome.

Speaker 12

Next question will be from Yaron Kinnar. please go ahead thank you good morning Francois I want to go back to your comment regarding looking to potentially retain more premiums in 26 can you elaborate on that just given the seating commission rates that are increasing and the supply demand imbalance I think pointing to more of a buyer's market is it that the margin on new casualty and specialty business in insurance is so much better that it's still more economic to keep it than to see that lower pricing?

Yeah, I mean, that's part of the equation, right? I mean, just like, you know, we have the advantage of having both insurance and reinsurance in our platform, so we see both ways. But, you know, as a buyer of reinsurance, we're no different than some of the seeding companies that buy from Archery. And, you know, Nicholas touched on it. It's like, well, yeah, sure. I mean, I can get, you know, maybe a slightly higher-seeding commission, and that's part of the economics of the transaction. But, you know, given the rate increases we've seen on the primary side the last couple of years that have compounded, and certainly maybe not across the board, but in sub-segments of our book, you know, primary insurers like the business, like the pricing a lot as it is today. So you have to, you know, compare the two. Am I better off retaining a bit more or do I just kind of lock in my profit effectively and just kind of go for the same commission? So I think it's, you know, as you can imagine, we have multiple reinsurance programs that we evaluate throughout the year. It's not, you know, every one of them is looked at individually depending on market conditions and what we see, you know, what the opportunities are. But I wouldn't say that we're necessarily planning to buy more or buy less at this point, but it could happen. And again, that's something that will evolve throughout the year.

Yeah. And I think the other way you can retain more is by switching the structure of your reinsurance, which is to go from a quarter share reinsurance to an excessive loss. And traditionally, not what the reinsurers like to offer, but based on the competition, the marketplace of those structures have been more common. So I think that's something we look at as well. And, again, we lack the casualty, you know, in most of our markets. So it's true also, you know, outside the U.S., I think, both on the insurance and reinsurance. We have a decent-sized portfolio outside the U.S. Just wanted to make sure we mentioned that.

Speaker 12

Yeah, that makes sense. And I appreciate the thought on the restructuring of reinsurance programs. I hadn't thought about that as much. My second question, one that's been asked on prior calls as well, can you give us an update as we look into 2026, how you rank the appetite and attractiveness of new business between the three segments in terms of capital deployment?

Yeah, I mean, no question that, you know, reinsurance has been, you know, the last couple of years, definitely, you know, a very attractive market for us. And we've deployed meaningfully. You saw our growth and you saw what we, you know, how we performed in that market. As the market comes down, it's, I think it's less, you know, ahead of the others, I would say. So, you know, if I had to rank them today, I'd say, yeah, reinsurance to me is still ahead, but, you know, the gap has narrowed. It's come down. Reinsurance is doing still very well, very attractive. But, you know, I think the gap between reinsurance and insurance is not as significant as it was a year ago. And mortgage, you know, we haven't had a question yet on mortgage. I mean, maybe it's a good thing. We love it, right? I mean, it's a great business. It's steady. It's been a great source of earnings for us. You know, again, we've laughed about it, we've talked about prior calls, like, which one of you three kids do you like the most or not like as much as the others? We love them all, right? We love all three of our segments, but certainly, you know, I think that the fact that the reinsurance market is compressing a little bit, I think, just brings all three segments a bit closer to each other.

Speaker 12

Thank you very much.

You're welcome.

Speaker 5

Next question will be from Matthew Heimerman at Citi. Please go ahead.

Matthew Heimerman Analyst — Citi

Hey, good morning. A couple of questions. One was just, with respect to the MCE re-underwriting, you've been asked about the consequences of that. I'd be curious about the margin consequences of that.

Well, I mean, you'd like to think that, you know, the business that we're shedding is the worst performing business. So absent, you know, absent any other event, you would think that our margins should improve. But that doesn't factor in kind of – that comment has, you know, obviously has been true, but the market in front of us, you know, may be different than what we had assumed. So on the one hand, no question that the non-renewals will improve our margins, but maybe depending on where the market – what the pricing looks like, It's still a very good market. Middle market business has been, I think, in a good place. I think rates have been holding up and have been improving, so that's been good. But what's margins going forward? It's hard to comment on that.

Yeah, and I think some of the programs we've shared are actually cat-exposed. So the upfront result may have looked okay, but we think it's a bad allocation of capital and we can get better return by deploying that capacity elsewhere. So I think especially on the insurance side. So I think those are the decisions we've made. I mean, some of them are, you know, running hard, but a few of them that we decided to shed were more, you know, cost of capital, you know, opportunity being better elsewhere. And I feel, you know, but again, to answer your question overall, I think we're still, you know, thinking that the business could run in, you know, one day in the low 90s, so.

Matthew Heimerman Analyst — Citi

Appreciate that. I guess another question I had was, given the QRTTs, any opportunistic investments you're thinking about making in tech or ops or accelerating existing investments?

Not as a direct result. I'd say we will make and have made investments, you know, over time based on, you know, what we're trying to accomplish and, you know, trying to streamline operations, trying to be more efficient and whether it's, you know, improving some systems, et cetera. So I think that's, you know, that's nothing is different in that respect. You know, the fact that, you know, certainly reinforces, you know, the value for sure for us. And it's been there throughout the value of having a presence in Bermuda. And I think, you know, we want to, we are committed and remain committed to the island. So that's, you know, reaffirms that.

But in terms of like making, I'd say, direct investments as a result of the QRTCs, I don't think it's the case. it's more you know based on need and based on what we were trying to accomplish and i think it's uh it's really an offset to the the high cost of doing business in bermuda so i think that's smart from the the bermuda government standpoint to make their jurisdiction more attractive to companies like arch yeah yeah that's totally fair and then i just normally wouldn't ask a third but But your comment on the demand quotient potentially changing for casual reinsurance just made

Matthew Heimerman Analyst — Citi

me curious whether or not you are seeing any real changes to subject premium basis in any of your reinsurance treaties at this point that's informing that, or is that unrelated?

So in terms of what can you can you provide a...

Matthew Heimerman Analyst — Citi

I'm curious, maybe a different way to ask it is, over the course of this year, it feels like there have been some companies that have had to adjust down their premium assumptions for their reinsurance book based on, you know, updated information from CEDENTS on the underlying subject premium basis. I'm just curious whether or not you're seeing any noticeable signal or information there that's worth calling out and whether or not your demand comment we should read as risk in two subject premium bases next year.

So what you described, I think it's true on the other property, you know, companies that wanted to go aggressively into the excess and surplus property side or energy, you know, have had to, you know, revise to the downside, their projections. I think on casualty, what I was referencing is more sedent, retaining more, but I think the underlying business is still growing. So I find that would not be the reason.

Yeah, but to add to that, I think, Matt, just to be clear, we do – I mean, that's something we look at every quarter. So we have been very active internally, certainly in 2025, and that will remain, making sure that, you know, yes, we get premium projections from the underwriters, from the scenes, and we obviously superimpose some of our own views based on where we think the business may end up. so we certainly don't want to be in a position where we we have to make a massive uh downward kind of adjustment because we we overshot the mark so i think we've been very careful and making sure that we remain on top of it throughout the year as we you know readjust our our premium projections based on market conditions okay thank you for that color appreciate it have a great day Yep.

Speaker 5

Next question will be from Meyershield at KBW. Please go ahead.

Meyershield Analyst — KBW

Great. Thank you so much. Two quick, you mentioned there were a couple of expense items in the quarter besides the tax credit. So don't you tell us where?

Yeah, I mean, the line broke down, so I apologize. I just, I don't know if it's our side or it's Meyers, it's the caller's side.

Meyershield Analyst — KBW

No, it's probably me. You mentioned that there were a couple of favorable expense items beyond the Bermuda tax credits, and I was hoping you could tell us where those showed up in terms of modeling for next year.

Well, I think I touched on, I mean, the Bermuda tax credits, I think the intent of the comment was that Bermuda tax credits, you know, at the core is very much a function of, like, how much presence we have in Bermuda and the direct, you know, payroll-related kind of expenses. So, yes, we have expenses in Bermuda in all three of our segments and also in, you know, our investment team. So, that is reflected as an investment expense and the corporate line. So, again, where it's noticeable, as I said, is in the reinsurance segment and in corporate. In the other places, there are, I mean, we're talking like single millions of dollars. I mean, it's not going to be noticeable to the outside world. So in terms of modeling, I would say, yes, there's some benefits, but it's so, I mean, it could be buried, it will be buried as part of the overall expense base of either the insurance or the mortgage segment, for example. So that's why it's just hard for us to kind of isolate it.

Meyershield Analyst — KBW

No, no, I appreciate that. You were very clear, actually. What I'm trying to get a handle on is the favorable expense items besides the tax credits? Because you said that there were a couple and just didn't know where they were.

I mean, there's nothing else really to point out. Those are, I mean, sorry for the confusion, but the idea was, you know, was just that. So there's nothing else to point out that was favorable in terms of expenses that were, again, that we should, you know, highlight or identify.

Meyershield Analyst — KBW

Okay, fair enough. And then final question. Does the fact that we're finally seeing the non-renewed program business actually hit the income statement, is that going to have an observable impact on the acquisition expense ratio in insurance?

I would say no. I would say no. I mean, again, we're talking, again, $200 million, $300 million of written premium that we're shedding on a written premium base of $8 billion. And you do the math from there. I would not factor in any meaningful improvement in the acquisition ratio for the insurance segment. Okay.

Meyershield Analyst — KBW

Very helpful. Thank you.

You're welcome.

Speaker 5

Next question will be from Roland Mayer at RBC Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

Roland Mayer Analyst — RBC Capital Markets

Good morning. Can you give an update on the carrying value of the deferred tax asset when we expect to hear some clarification on the ability to recognize it?

Yeah, I mean, that's been right. So we wrapped up the first year and we set up an asset in the 23 that we started amortizing in 25. So the billion two is now roughly came down by about $100 million in 25. And we are going to keep amortizing that in 26. and depending on where the law goes in Bermuda, maybe that asset goes away. We just don't know. I mean, it's not our decision. It's obviously, we follow the Bermuda law, but, you know, there's been talk that, you know, this, you know, depending on, you know, negotiations or kind of what the Bermuda government ends up doing, that this asset could be, you know, could no longer be an asset to us at the either, you know, late, you know, fourth quarter, 26, or maybe early part of 27.

Roland Mayer Analyst — RBC Capital Markets

Okay, perfect. And then I just wanted to ask on your view of M&A in this environment. I know there's been a couple of deals announced in the past month or so. And with how your sort of debt to cap is stacking up, you're kind of naturally deleveraging over time and just anything on leverage or M&A.

Yes, on M&A, I think our position doesn't change. So we We like strategic assets or anything that can really improve our platform or add lines of business or help us, you know, move forward into something we were planning to do and buy versus build. I think we look at everything else, but, you know, at this stage, especially in terms of where the market is, I think efficiencies, it would have to be an amazing deal for us to really pursue it, you know, and I'm not saying it's impossible, but, you know, I think it's unlikely. great thank you for the answers you're welcome thank you i am not showing any further questions so i would like to turn the conference over to mr nicholas papadapolo for closing remarks yes thank you everyone for spending an hour with us you know again another pretty damn good performance you know in 2025 and again thanking all the employees for their hard work they did to get us there and I think we're pretty much ready to go for 2026 and we'll talk to you next quarter. Thank you.

Speaker 5

Thank you, sir. Ladies and gentlemen, this does indeed conclude your conference call for today. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect your line.

Analyst Q&A · 8 questions
Full-screen source Call document