Skip to main content
ACGL $110.89 +1.17%
ACGL logo
ACGL · Arch Capital Group Ltd.
Track ACGL — free
Market Cap
$36.10B
Shares
325.53M
Volume · Nov 16 2.08M Avg daily vol (3M) 2.87M
All webcasts

Earnings call · FY2026 Q1

Arch Capital Group Ltd. (ACGL) Q1 2026 Earnings Call Transcript

Concluded Apr 28, 2026 Audio replay Verified speakers
Apr 28, 2026 1:05:04 97 turns
Period
FY2026 Q1
Runtime
1:05:04
Sources
5 artifacts
Revenue $4.52B -3.3% YoY
Diluted EPS $2.88 +94.6% YoY
Net income $1.05B +82.4% YoY
Open full screen Slides 22 8-K 10-Q

Transcript & audio

Verified speakers 1:05:04 Audio
Operator

Good day, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the 1Q2026 Arch Capital Earnings Conference Call. At this time, all participants are in listen-only mode. Later, we will conduct a question-and-answer session, and instructions will follow at that time. As a reminder, this conference call is being recorded. Before the company gets started with its update, management wants to first remind everyone that certain statements in yesterday's press release and discussed on this call may constitute forward-looking statements under the federal securities laws. These statements are based upon management's current assessments and assumptions and are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties. Consequently, actual results may differ materially from those expressed or implied. For more information on the risks and other factors that may affect future performance, investors should review the periodic reports that are filed by the company with the SEC from time to time, including our annual report on Form 10-K for the 2025 fiscal year. Additionally, certain statements contained in the call that are not based on historical facts are forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. The company intends the forward-looking statements in the call to be subject to the safe harbor created thereby. Management also will make reference to certain non-GAAP measures of financial performance. The reconciliations to GAAP for each non-GAAP financial measure can be found in the company's current report on Form 8K furnished to the SEC yesterday, which contains the company's earnings press release and is available on the company's website at www.archgroup.com and on the SEC's website at www.sec.gov. I would now like to introduce your host for today's PERC conference, Mr. Nicholas Papadopoulou and Mr. Francois Morin. Sirs, you may begin.

Good morning and welcome to Archer's first quarter 2026 earnings call. We deliver the strong quarter reflecting both attractive underwriting margin and the disciplined execution of our underwriting and capital management strategies. After tax operating income for the quarter was $901 million, or $2.50 per share, producing an annualized net income return on average common equity of 17.8%. Today's market is clearly more competitive than in recent years. That said, rates and terms and conditions in aggregate still support strong returns. Capturing those returns requires the ability and willingness to actively manage the portfolio across and within lines of business. This is embedded in ARCH's operating principles and among our differentiating traits to dynamically add to areas where returns are attractive while declining those risks that no longer provide an adequate margin of safety. Regardless of where we are in the cycle, ARCH is committed to generating superior returns for our shareholders. I'll now provide updates across our reporting segments, beginning with insurance, which generated 66 million dollars of underwriting income in the first quarter. It compares favorably to the first quarter in 2025 that was impacted by the California wildfires. Overall, market conditions remain favorable. However, top-line growth in the segment was essentially flat in the quarter, reflecting our focus on profitability over volume as competitive pressures increase. Growth opportunities remain across most casualty-focused businesses, including excess and surplus line casualty, construction, alternative markets, as well as number of our London market businesses. Growth was offset by softening rates in a few areas, including large account and excess and surplus line property, as well as in some shorter lines in London. We also chose not to renew certain program business acquired in the middle market commercial transaction that did not align with our risk appetite or meet our profitability requirements. As we have discussed on prior calls, these non-renewals are expected to reduce net premium return by approximately $250 million throughout 2026. I also want to note a significant operational milestone achieved in our middle market commercial business. Earlier this month, our team successfully completed the data and system migration of the acquired businesses from valiance to our own systems. The ability to complete this effort in just 18 months speaks not only to the dedication of our teams, but also represents a strong use case for artificial intelligence in accelerating systems and platform transformations. With this significant step completed, the business can now pursue its objective of creating a scalable, best-in-class experience for clients and distribution partners. our insurance segment delivered an excellent 441 million dollars of underwriting income in the quarter a significant increase from the 167 million dollars in the first quarter of 2025 which was heavily impacted by the california wildfires right reductions and increased retentions by accidents contributed to a six percent decline in net premiums return versus the same quarter last year. Short-tail lines, including other property, property catastrophe and marine, were the primary driver of these declines. Strong industry results over the past few years have attracted significant new capacity from traditional markets and third-party capital, resulting in a broadly competitive environment. Its additional supply continues to put downward pressure on property catastrophe and short-term rates, while also moderating the push for needed rate increases in some casualty lines. However, underwriting performance remained excellent. Our focused and disciplined underwriting led to the reinsurance group's 76% combined ratio, marking the fourth straight quarter of sub-80% combined ratios. Consistent with our cycle management philosophy, our insurance team actively manages the portfolio mix by continuing to write new business that meets our risk-adjusted return targets and by reducing our share of business that falls below our minimum return thresholds. The mortgage segment delivered another strong quarter with $221 million of underwriting income to go along with $266 million of net premiums return. Mortgage originations picked up modestly in the first quarter, though affordability challenges tied to high mortgage rates and home prices continue to constrain demand. Credit quality across the mortgage insurance portfolio remains excellent, with delinquencies normalizing from seasonally higher levels in the fourth quarter of 2025. Competition remains discipline and we continue to pursue growth through innovation and new product introductions across our global footprint overall mortgage performance continues to exceed expectations and provide shareholders with a differentiated and diversifying source of earnings and support long-term value creation turning to investments which contributed $4 billion and $8 million, or $1.13 of net investment income per share in the quarter. The decline in net investment income from the fourth quarter of 2025 was driven in part by lower cash yields, lower qualified refundable tax credit benefits, and seasonal compensation payouts. Our nearly $48 billion investment portfolio provides a material contribution to earnings and book value growth, effectively raising our quarterly earnings flow. In the first quarter, we repurchased $783 million worth of harsh common stock, while still increasing book value per share by 1.7%. Our first priority remains to deploy capital into our business. When organic opportunities do not meet our return threshold, we view repurchasing our shares as an attractive use of excess capital, reflecting our conviction into the intrinsic value of the franchise. The board's recent $3 billion increase to our share repurchase authorization underscores its approach to capital allocation. To conclude, Arch delivered another strong quarter by staying true to our principles of discipline cycle management and by leveraging the strengths of the ARCH brand and our diversified platform. In today's market, underwriting discipline powered by insight from our investment in data and analytics, rewarding our underwriter for profit and volume, and put-on capital management continues to differentiate ARCH and drive long-term value for our investors. ARCH's 25-year record of strong return and compounding book value at double-digit rates is a direct result of hard work and discipline. That is ARCH. That is our DNA. And that is why we believe we will continue to deliver best-in-class results across market cycle and into the future. I will now turn the call over to Francois, who will talk through the financials in more details.

Thank you, Nicholas. And good morning to all. Last night, we reported our first quarter results with after-tax operating income of $2.50 per share and an annualized operating income return on average common equity of 15.4%. Book value per share grew by 1.7% in the quarter. Our three business segments once again delivered excellent underlying results with an overall ex-cat accident-year combined ratio of 82.3%, up 130 basis points from the same quarter last year, and consistent with the more competitive environment we are facing. I will provide more color on trends in each of our segments shortly. Our underwriting income included $200 million of favorable prior your development on a pre-tax basis in the first quarter or five points on the overall combined ratio recognized favorable development across all three of our segments and in many of our lines of business but mainly in short tail lines in our P&C segments and in mortgage due to strong cure activity of note this quarter we commuted a large transaction which increased the level of of favorable prior development in our reinsurance segment by approximately 25% in the quarter. Current year catastrophe losses were 174 million, net of reinsurance and reinstatement premiums, and were mainly the result of winter storms in the U.S. and the Iran conflict. All in, these losses were slightly lower than our seasonally adjusted expectations for natural catastrophes. The insurance segment's gross premiums written grew 2%, while net premiums written declined 1.4% year over year. As Nicholas explained, the non-renewal of certain program business acquired as part of the MCE transaction impacted our top line this quarter. In addition, net premiums written were also impacted by a shift in business mix toward lines with lower net-to-gross retention ratios. The XCAT accident year loss ratio improved by 70 basis points to 56.7% compared to the same quarter one year ago. The acquisition expense ratio for the current accident year increased by 160 basis points as the benefit we observed in the first quarter of 2025 from the write-off of deferred acquisition costs from the MCE acquired business rolled off. We would expect the most recent acquisition expense ratio to be more representative of long-term expectations. Our operating expense ratio was higher this quarter as we incurred additional expenses related to the transition of our middle market business to arch systems. We would expect our operating expense ratio to revert back to a level closer to historical levels during the second half of the year. The reinsurance segment had an excellent quarter, $441 million in pre-tax underwriting income. Overall, gross premiums written were down by 2.3%, while net premiums written were down by 6% from the same quarter one year ago. Net premiums written were up in specialty, partly due to timing differences and the recognition of certain treaty renewals that impacted our financials in the first quarter of 2025. Over one-third of the decrease in net premiums written in property catastrophe was attributable to a lower level of reinstatement premiums compared to a year ago, which were impacted by the California wildfires. Overall, our ex-catastrophe accident-year combined ratio of 78.1 percent is comparable to last year's result for the same quarter. Our mortgage segment produced another very strong quarter with underwriting income of $221 million. Net premiums earned were down by approximately $6 million from last quarter, mostly driven by lower levels of cancellation premiums in our CRT business. Of note this quarter, new insurance written at USMI reflects a large non-GSC transaction of $2.2 billion in NIW. Absent this transaction, which increased our NIW by 15%, we would expect our market share of the PMI market to remain relatively unchanged from the prior quarter. The delinquency rate for our USMI business decreased by- decreased to 2.06%, consistent with our expectations and seasonal trends. On the investment front, we earned a combined $568 million from net investment income and income from funds accounted using the equity method, or $1.57 per share pre-tax, slightly down from the $1.60 per share we earned last quarter. Cash flow from operations remained positive at $1.2 billion for the quarter. Our portfolio remains of very high quality with a short duration and in line with our asset allocation targets. Income from operating affiliates was $36 million for the quarter, up from $17 million from the same quarter one year ago, which was impacted by the California wildfires. As a reminder, this quarter's result reflects our lower ownership stake in summer's re since the start of the year. Our effective tax rate on pre-tax operating income was 14.8%, reflecting the mix of income by tax jurisdiction. It was slightly below the 16% to 18% previously-guided range, mostly due to a 1.7% benefit from discrete items. As of January 1, our peak zone natural catastrophe probable maximum loss from a single event one- and 250-year return level on a net basis, remained flat at $1.9 billion and now stands at 8.2% of tangible shareholders' equity. On the capital management front, we repurchased $783 million of our shares in the future, or 8.3 million shares. We have repurchased an additional $311 million dollars in shares so far this quarter through last night. Our balance sheet remains in excellent health with strong capitalization and low leverage. With these introductory comments, we are now prepared to take your question.

Operator

Thank you. If you would like to ask a question, please signal by pressing star one on your telephone keypad. If you are using a speakerphone, please make sure your mute function is turned off to allow your signal to reach our equipment. Again, press star one to ask a question and we'll pause for just a moment to allow everyone an opportunity to signal for questions. Our first question comes from Elise Greenspan from Wells Fargo. Please. Go ahead.

Elise Greenspan Analyst — Wells Fargo

Hi, thanks. Good morning. My first question is on, you know, property cat on the reinsurance side. We're just hoping to get, you know, some of your expectations for the mid-year renewals. And then, you know, if you expect, you know, declines in the book, you know, to continue, Would you expect, you know, your cat load to, you know, come down after the mid-years?

Yes, good morning. Yeah, so we don't, you know, as we always say, we don't have a crystal ball, but, you know, for the sixth one, I think we really expect the market to remain competitive and to adjust our underwriting stand based on the, you know, the actual rate decrease that we will see at that time. So we don't really have a forecast there. On the overall, you know, trend of the catastrophic portfolio, I think we have huge, huge headwinds, you know, because of the, you know, double-digit rate decrease. and we you know we really as i said it in prior call we we really monitor the the property cat through a length of 50 separate zones so i think some if i go back two years ago they were all green so now we have a bunch of them that are still green i think florida is still green but and but we have a bunch of them that are yellow and some of them that have turned red so i think it, you know, depending of the, where the business renew and our perception of the attractiveness of that zone, we, our underwriting team, we make, we make the decision, so.

Elise Greenspan Analyst — Wells Fargo

Okay, thanks. And then on the casualty side, you know, you guys were mentioning still some good opportunities, I think, on both the insurance and the reinsurance side. Can you just talk through within casualty where you're currently, you know, seeing the best growth opportunities?

Yes, I think, you know, we're still optimistic on the casualty, and we think that the pain has not gone through yet, as you may have seen. You know, I think we're still seeing some little development from the year 2016 and 17, But the most recent years, 21, 22, 23, 24, we've seen additional adverse development. And so that should, in our view, continue to sustain price increases above trend. So in terms of our risk appetite on the insurance and the insurance, I think it hasn't changed. I think we like the specialty casualty, you know, the excess and surplus line casualty, you know, primary position on the large account. So that's where we play. We stay away from, you know, the commercial auto and also, you know, the larger account excess towers, which we think are still very challenging, despite some of the rate increases that we've seen.

Operator

Our next question comes from David Motimaden from Evercore ISI. Please go ahead.

David Motimaden Analyst — Evercore ISI

Hey, thanks. Good morning. I was hoping maybe just to get an update on the insurance book, where we stand just on rate versus trend in both the US and internationally.

Yes, yes. Good morning. So, you know, starting with the U.S. I think on the U.S., I think we are broadly getting right at trend. And I think so, as I mentioned earlier, we are getting right above trend on the casualty lines of business. And we are getting, you know, as detractor on the trend is really the short-tail property lines of business where, you know, we've seen a rapid rate decrease. But when you sum it up for North America, I think we're seeing rate slightly below trend. If you go to international, I think we have more short-tail lines on the international book of business. So we're seeing some rate pressure on the short-tail lines. So overall, a low one-digit rate decrease of overtrend overall. But, you know, we started there with pretty high margins. So we feel very good about the business there.

David Motimaden Analyst — Evercore ISI

Got it. Thanks. And then I believe you mentioned just in reinsurance some of the supply there. you know, and good returns and short tail lines trickling into casualty re. Just wondering, does that change sort of how you're thinking about the growth opportunity there as an offset to the headwinds on the property side?

So on the casualty, on the reinsurance side, I think we're mainly talking about quota shares. I think that, you know, as I mentioned earlier, I think we like the fundamental of the specialty casualty business. the difficulty there it's really the ceiling commission i think you know based on the past experience of the casualty market ceiling commission should have gone down but we get you know we get excess supply i think there's a lot of uh of our competitors you know wanting to get on that business or increase share on that business so that that that allows for the ceiling commission to stay flat and on the best account to continue to grow up. So the sidecars, you know, the latest flavor of the day with the casualty sidecar is just going to add to that dynamic.

Operator

Our next question comes from Tracy Van Gigi from Wolf Research. Please, go ahead.

Tracy Van Gigi Analyst — Wolf Research, LLC

Thank you. Good morning. One of the largest primary insurers had said on their earnings calls some pretty pessimistic views of property pricing, particularly shared and layered in North America and in London. And the culprit is cheaper forms of capital coming in from MGA's reinsurers and alternative capital. So from your vantage point, is this a real structural shift in the market? And how does that influence your underwriting appetite?

For us, it's more business as usual so the the the advantage that we have is that we we are not retail large account players we don't we don't play in that space so that has been that has gone up that has got coming rapidly going down so we we don't play in that space we we play in the excess and surplus line uh property business and and so that space is getting competitive and you know we we we are taking a very careful approach to that line of business right now.

Tracy Van Gigi Analyst — Wolf Research, LLC

Excellent. And there was also a recent settlement development early in the second quarter around Francis Scott Bridge collapse. Are you currently sizing the industry loss, and has that pushed your loss estimate upward?

So in that particular case, I think we were holding much more conservative loss estimates than the market, so no real change for us.

Operator

Our next question comes from Mike Zabrensky from BMO. Please go ahead.

Mike Zarensky Analyst — BMO

Hey, thanks. Good morning. In the insurance segment, the underlying loss ratio, you know, continues to show some healthy improvement. Is that, if you can kind of talk about some of the drivers, I believe, right, some of the non-renewals on some programs is, I think, helping that. But if you can kind of talk around any dynamics, we should consider. Thanks.

Yeah, the, good morning, Mike. This quarter in particular was, you know, we benefited from a relatively benign, you know, amount of activity in the traditional losses in London in particular. So our international segment or, you know, book did very well this quarter. So that explains most of the favorable or reduction in the kind of XCAT loss ratio compared to a year ago. You know, again, as a reminder, we encourage you all to look at trailing 12-month kind of rolling numbers to kind of get a view on performance of the book. and the impact of the MCD non-renewals is yet to be seen, right? I think it's, you know, as the business earns out, it's, you know, it will show up in the numbers, but at this time, we don't think it'll be material. I think it's still a relatively small part of the book. You think of an $8 billion insurance segment book of business, the impact of non-renewing some of these programs will be somewhat, you know, immaterial or limited. So hopefully that explains that really the quarter was all about kind of really good performance out of London.

Mike Zarensky Analyst — BMO

Got it. And Francois, my follow up, I think you mentioned on the catastrophe side that this quarter's losses were, I think you said a bit lower than quote unquote normal. And you also added a bit on the Iran conflict. Maybe you can kind of just elaborate on the Iran conflict, how you how you guys are thinking about that. Is it all IBNR?

Are there real losses or thank you? yeah i mean there's nothing paid but it's certainly uh there are some real losses uh you know specialty book out of london like terror political violence i mean those are the some of the lines that are exposed will be exposed it's ongoing uh so we took a first stab at it this quarter based on what had happened and call it in the month of uh in the month of march but uh You know, we will expect, we do expect more losses to come through in the second quarter. And, you know, we'll keep reporting on it. But it's, yeah, it's ongoing. And the point in my comments was really to, you know, communicate that we have been able to absorb those losses in the first quarter as part of our overall cat load, even though technically, you know, the cat load is only on the natural catastrophe side. So it's a man-made, we call that, you know, man-made cap, but we still report it as part of our cap losses to the straight, and that's kind of included in the overall number.

Operator

Our next question comes from Andrew Kilgerman from TV Cowan. Please go ahead.

Andrew Kilgerman Analyst — TV Cowan

Hi, and good morning. So I know you've gotten a lot of questions about property, and just to kind of gauge a sense of where we are in the cycle, which you are very good at, I'm wondering if you could share, and again, this is blunt, where are you seeing risk-adjusted returns in property catastrophe reinsurance? reinsurance. And I know there are, you know, different layers and risk on lines, et cetera, but like if you had to gauge a risk adjusted return range, what are we seeing today? And maybe the same question with the E&S property that you've been writing.

And so the way you have to understand is that, as I explained, we, Property Cat, you know, we we manage very dynamically based on the actual underlying profitability we see in 50 zones. So, you know, we said earlier, you know, that, you know, two or three years ago, we were in the 30s. I think the business we have on the book today is still in our mind very attractive because, again, we're not writing some of the business that, you know, we think has fallen below the the threshold for us to write the business. So I think the business, it's a different mix than it was, you know, probably three years ago. The mix has shifted, but the business that we have today remains attractive on our book. So, and, you know, we are still in the high teens, I think.

Andrew Kilgerman Analyst — TV Cowan

I see. I see. But it sounds like...

And on the ENS... Go ahead.

Andrew Kilgerman Analyst — TV Cowan

Just following up on that, Nicholas, it sounds like that there is business out there that Arch Capital won't write that is well below your upper team's return threshold. Is that fair?

That's fair.

Andrew Kilgerman Analyst — TV Cowan

Okay.

Operator

Our next question comes from KB Montessori from Deutsche Bank. Please go ahead.

KV Montessori Analyst — Deutsche Bank

Thank you. First question is on share repurchases. It was nice to see a little uptick. I think this quarter was 87% of your operating income versus roughly 70% of each of the past two quarters. Now my question is, if the current pricing trends continue, you don't really need any capital to grow, and you're starting from a pretty healthy capital position.

So without any obvious targeted targets, is there any reason why you couldn't pay out 100 percent of income potentially even more given that you're releasing capital when you don't when you're shrinking um i guess i don't want to sound greedy but like i'm wondering what held you back from doing more this quarter i mean it's nothing i mean nothing's stopping us um you know we we don't set targets and how much we're going to buy back so we we go at it we look at what's in front of us we look at you know what you know both in terms of the stock price and also liquidity in the stock which is still very liquid so that means so far hasn't been a problem uh but you know in terms of like could we buy back 100 of our income for the year we could i mean we we but that's not how we think about it it's more i'd say an outcome uh if you know things work out in a certain way in terms of kind of, again, the stock price and the volume, et cetera. So, you know, you saw the reauthorization by the board. I think hopefully that gives you a little bit of, you know, some direction in terms of how we think about the opportunity there and how much, you know, how much capital we think we can buy back or are looking to buy back. But, you know, whether it happens this quarter or next quarter or next year, I think that's, you know, nothing set in stone. So we'll react to what's in front of us, but to answer your question, there's really no structural limitations beyond, again, the regulations around buying back stock that we have to deal with.

KV Montessori Analyst — Deutsche Bank

That's great to hear. Thank you. My second question, just want to pivot to cyber insurance, and maybe if you can help us separate the cyclical versus structural pieces for us. So I guess the first question, where are we in the underwriting clock today for cyber? And then structurally, like given the recent developments in AI and the potential for cyber attacks to become more frequent and more destructive, does that change your view of tail risk, aggregation risk, or even the long-term insurability of the product?

Yes, I think in terms of the ingrate clock, I would think cyber is probably around 3 p.m. I think so, you know, it's still okay, but it's, you know, it's getting to that point. So in terms of the recent AI, you know, tropic mythos, we see it as a real current threat, but we don't really see it's changing the cyber product. I think we see the cyber product as more of a, the cyber market as more of an arm race between attacker and defender, and certainly METOS is accelerating that trend, but, you know, METOS can help, you know, the attacker, but, you know, the defender can also, you know, reinforce in defense, you know, using the same model. So we think it's really an acceleration of the speed at which, you know, maybe cyber attacks can be conducted. And to your point, it's also an acceleration of the scale. So I would think because the scale would be larger, I would think we see it more as an increased systemic risk. So we are taking a very careful approach to that and, you know, in our RDS scenarios.

Operator

So our next question comes from Josh Shanker from Bank of America. Please go ahead.

Yeah, you know, I know you don't give guidance, certainly on margins, but it's an interesting time. Obviously, property declines in prices are well noted. Broadly speaking, at Arch and other companies, loss ratios are generally in the same sort of range they were a year ago, but growth is about zero. I guess maybe it's another clock question, but you sort of give an outlook to internally for the next year. Do you expect Arches and the industry's loss ratios to begin to deteriorate from here? Or do you think the current levels are supportable?

I don't know about the industry, to be honest. it's hard to uh it's hard to predict because uh as far as we are concerned you know we we are confident in our ability to to manage a cycle that's what we do so i think we uh i think you know that's the first line of defense if things you know fall below our threshold we uh we reduce and uh and we we are confident in our ability to continue to find uh you know attractive opportunities to be able to expand. And I think we have, you know, certainly the property market is coming down. So, you know, everybody can see that, but we still think we have a good opportunity on the casualty side. So, overall, I think we, again, as I said, you know, based on our own mix of business, we think that we see rates just below trend. So that would support a thesis that margins are sustainable, at least for the near future.

And then in terms of SME, the commercial business, the mid-core acquisition was in part to be less cyclical. Are you seeing fruits of that play out in 2026 that you're able to capture some incremental share in less cyclical SME business?

So again, we just, as I mentioned in my remark, we just finished the cutover. So the main focus for us has been to roll over the portfolio and to create an entirely workbench with which we can underwrite the business on arch paper. So those have been the primary goals. So now that this is done, it opens abilities to try to enhance the value proposition of that business and build scale. So I think we, I would doubt, you know, I think it's more of a 2027 game, you know, than it is a 2026, because after you do the cutover, you have to stabilize, then we have to start to, you know, we're focusing on building new tools to really help on the riders with better selection, you know, triage and so on that will make them, you know, more productive.

Operator

Our next question comes from Rob Cox with Goldman Sachs.

Rob Cox Analyst — Goldman Sachs

Please go ahead. Hey, good morning. Just a question on premium leverage. So on the one hand, the business is shifting away from property and property cat, which should allow for an increase to premium leverage. But in the past, we've noticed it's been hard to right-size leverage in a softening market like this due to the lack of growth opportunities. So I guess the question is, you know, do you foresee premium leverage would continue to fall like this as we get further into the soft market? And how does that impact your view on the future ROEs?

Well, certainly we're managing the equity side of the leverage. So if we can't grow, we can't deploy the capital in the business, as we've been doing like the last few quarters, we'll be returning more of the capital to the shareholders. So that's certainly a tool we have that we have been using, we'll keep using. And make sure that, you know, our ROEs remain attractive. So I say for sure, like if the mix goes more long tail than short tail, it helps on the leverage. And again, the equity part of it is something we're watching carefully.

Rob Cox Analyst — Goldman Sachs

Thanks. That's helpful. And then just to follow up on terms and conditions, just curious if any negotiations on terms and conditions started to change in the quarter. and, you know, like which terms you think could start to get further negotiated as we move deeper into the soft market?

So which lines of business are you talking about? Property CAT?

Rob Cox Analyst — Goldman Sachs

Yeah, particularly property CAT reinsurance.

So we've talked to our team and, you know, we're seeing a bit more, But, you know, it remains a very small portion of, you know, some of the aggregates, a bit more aggregates, a bit more top and drops, which, but, you know, it's at the margin so far. So, but, you know, as the market gets more competitive, we'd expect more of those structure that are much more difficult to price to come back to the market.

Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from Brian Tunis. with Cantor. Please go ahead.

Brian Tunis Analyst — Cantor

Hey, thanks. Good afternoon. So the company is obviously a much larger company today than it was seven years ago, both from a premium side, but also from an OPEX side. And I imagine a lot of that increase in OPEX is in support of hard market growth. So my question is, no longer being in a hard market, to what extent are you looking at managing the OPEX side of things as a potential source of boosting margins?

I think the answer is yes. That's something that's in our mind. I think the loss ratio part is probably more important as the market gets softer.

Brian Tunis Analyst — Cantor

But yes, I think, especially in the insurance group i mean the expense side is important and we we we actually uh paying attention to it okay and then just a follow-up for francois um underlying loss ratio and the mortgage insurance segment look a little elevated nothing really stood out to me maybe a little bit higher reserve for default i'm sure if that's seasonal but you know how how should we interpret um Yeah, that loss ratio result this quarter in their mind.

Yeah, definitely some of it is a result of the change or the growth in the average mortgage that goes into NOD. So if you think of the loans that are currently going in NOD this quarter are more, you know, post-COVID effectively, right? And that's when, you know, mortgage loans were up in size. So as you look at the, you know, frequency assumptions have not changed, you know, they've been flat for us the last couple of years, I want to say. But, you know, the math behind the reserve levels is such that, you know, we apply the frequency with a severity per loan and the severity, you know, has you know remains stable but it's it's the average size of the loan that's hitting the uh the loss ratio so i think it's you know it's it's a little bit kind of like uh an evolving kind of thing within the the loss ratios i think it's for mortgage it's gone up a little bit but still very much within what we would expect it to be our next question comes from alex scott with barclays please go ahead hey thanks for digging it um i guess i wanted to follow up on the excess capital

Alex Scott Analyst — Barclays

and you know less about just asking how much you buy back but i you know thinking more broadly i mean you don't you don't have the business that you can really lean into growth in right now like you have in sort of most environments in the past but one of your three businesses has been attractive to really leg into. So, you know, does it create any need to sort of look at, you know, potentially diversifying transaction and then, you know, is legging into an artificial intelligence investment and doing it that way to try to achieve growth, something that you think is achievable? Just trying to understand how you're thinking about the different ways you get invested.

Yeah, I mean, I'll take the first part. I mean, certainly, you know, the businesses are all doing well. I mean, yes, I mean, you're right. I think the growth opportunities in all three of our segments are somewhat limited. We're, you know, we're working hard trying to find new opportunities internationally and, you know, et cetera, like in mortgage and insurance for sure. But, you know, at this point, it's harder to see how the market will support, you know, massive or outsized growth in any of our segments. And it's so, yeah, I mean, the share buybacks, again, like as we generate, we keep generating meaningful earnings. I think, you know, that we don't want to accumulate excess capital beyond what we think is prudent. So we're certainly looking to return it or do something with it. M&A is, you know, we look at a lot of things, but, you know, we want, you know, for us to do something, given our scale, we truly think it has to be something that is additive. We're not interested in doing deals just for the sake of doing deals. It has to make us better. It has to make us more competitive, increase our presence or our scale in a market, et cetera. So we're very selective there, but we're trying to think outside the box, too. I mean, if there's things that we don't do currently that can make us better, we'll explore those. In terms of AI, I mean, it's certainly something that is coming at us really quickly, really fast. We're trying to think of ways where we can kind of, again, automate things, and we're doing some of that. But I think it's still very early innings, very early days of that. So I think that will evolve, and we'll see where it goes.

Yeah, and we've been investing in AI for the last 10 years, both in mortgage and PNC. So we've deployed a bunch of AI and machine learning models, but it's changing really fast. And I think the industry in our struggle is really to really show results while at the same time, you know, working on our data strategy and and and our integration of our system to really uh support you know ai at scale and for you know really figure out what ai would look like three years from now because it's changing so quickly you know if you look at the anthropic models you know they open huge huge opportunities to do certain things but what's next so i think you really have to take and it's a lot of investment at the same time you're trying to create productivity

Alex Scott Analyst — Barclays

and the insight for your underwriters to be able to compete so I think it's all helpful thanks and as a follow up I wanted to see if you could talk a little bit about exposure to private credit I know I think in the past you've talked about the alternatives portfolio allocation of private credit so I have a rough idea of that but wanted to see if you could tell us about, you know, anything that would be sort of considered private credit within the fixed maturity part of the book.

Yeah, we have some, but limited, right? So we have it both in our, again, public markets and private markets. The general thinking, you know, that the strategy with our investment guys has been to go more on the high quality loan, so kind of low loan to value and kind of very good collateral supporting the investments. So, yes, it's something we're watching like everybody else, but at this point, there's no red flags, nothing that really is rising to a level where we have to take action. Got it.

Operator

You're welcome. Our next question comes from Matthew Helmerman with Citi. please go ahead.

Speaker 7

Hey, good morning, everybody. I just wanted to follow up on your call related to using AI in the technology rollover of MidCorp, and just curious how that experience has been different than past. I recognize that you're not a significant acquirer, so the universe of past might be smaller, but just thought that was provocative comments.

Yes. So I think the way it really helped us and speed up the process is to write some of the codes. I think, you know, we really didn't do enough there, but when we did, it was really helpful. And the big help was on the testing.

A lot of the testing was done by AI, and that really accelerated the time to market so those are the two the two aspects and that that we uh when we talk to the teams they they they really highlight as uh you know the impact on ai on this uh on the shift on this uh cut over because again right now just quickly i mean again it it was a build out of a brand new effectively platform infrastructure right so it's it's It's unusual in that sense that we bought the business, but without the systems, we had to create this infrastructure, this platform, brand new, that we ourselves at Arts did not So that's where I think, to Nicholas's point, the AI capabilities really came through and helped speed up the process.

Speaker 7

That's helpful.

I just want to make sure I understand the use of the word testing correctly. is that should i should i think about that as auditing outcome outputs of yeah it's running scenario to make sure yeah yeah so it's so it's running scenarios to make sure that every time you create who created a new platform to uh good point francois to for context and so every time you create a new software you have a lot of testing that uh you know to to make sure that the software is doing what it's supposed to do, and a lot of it today can be done through AI, as opposed to individuals going in and asking the underwriter to test, the guys that collect the cash to test, that, you know, what the owners get to the right places, and so on.

Operator

Our next question comes from Meyer Shields with KBW. Please go ahead.

Meyer Shields Analyst — KBW

Great. Thanks so much. Francois, starting question for you. I guess I expected operating expense and reinsurance to go down because you should have more Bermuda tax credits. And I guess I didn't see that. I was hoping you could talk us through the moving parts.

Down relative to last year or last quarter? Last year. Prefer up from last quarter. Yeah, they're certainly up from last quarter. From last year, I mean, yes, there's some, no question that there's, you know, some QRTCs this quarter in reinsurance. I mean, what's, you know, what explains the increase is more investments in staffing and billing out further the insurance, the reinsurance group. So I think there's, well, I know that there's been kind of hiring around, like, you know, technology and improving systems. So that's certainly a big part of it. And then a little bit of noise around some of our structured deals that we wrote a year ago. I mean, they were actually beneficial to the expense ratio, the OPEX ratio a year ago. So if you adjust for that, you know, that explains a little bit of the difference as well. But nothing, I'd say nothing, I'd say structural that we, you know, was a surprise to us. Okay, that's very helpful.

Meyer Shields Analyst — KBW

And then shifting gears, there are some reports of, you know, very significant rate increases for product lines exposed to the Iran conflict. And I was wondering whether Arch is trying to write more of that business or being more cautious because of the risk.

So we do that, as I would be with our London office, where we write some political violence and war on land. So we've been cautious, but the red side spikes up. So we actually wrote a little bit more business, but in a very cautious way.

Operator

Our next question comes from Roland Mayer from RBC Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

Roland Mayer Analyst — RBC Capital Markets

Hi, good morning. I just wanted to ask on your PML disclosure, because I found it curious, do you think that the catastrophe models are fully capturing the improved loss environment in Florida from AOB benefit reform?

The PML that we report?

Roland Mayer Analyst — RBC Capital Markets

Yeah. I'm just curious on when you model the CAT losses out in the state, if it's fully capturing how the personal line side of the business has seen significant reports in the loss environment.

It's been reflected. I think we historically, you know, we have, you know, as we do our modeling, we have loads for certain features of those specific to the Florida market that, you know, with the reforms, I think, have changed. So we changed how we, you know, how we model those things on fraud and, you know, additional expenses around kind of claim handling, et cetera. So that's all captured right now. So, yes, our thinking has changed, and, you know, what we report to you is how we see the business, how we expect the environment to respond, given what we know about the latest reforms.

Roland Mayer Analyst — RBC Capital Markets

All right. That's perfect. Thank you so much.

Operator

Yep. Our next question comes from Brian Meredith with UBS. Please go ahead.

Brian Meredith Analyst — UBS

Yeah, thanks for fitting me in. Back on the PMLs, I noticed your PMLs did not decline. kind of stayed the same at 4-1 versus your 1-1 disclosure, but you're declining, you know, property cut and everything. Can you help us reconcile kind of what's going on with the PMLs relative to what you're doing with property reinsurance and insurance?

Yeah, I think, right, Brian, it's the 4-1 number, so not a ton. Again, think of it, it's the peak zone. So I would expect changes at 7-1 next quarter. There's not a ton of activity for us necessarily at the 4-1 renewal that impacts our peak zone. So that would be the answer being Florida, Tri-State, Tri-County in particular. We'll see what 6-1 and 7-1 does for us, but that's where I would expect maybe a more meaningful change.

Brian Meredith Analyst — UBS

Gotcha.

But, I mean, even if I look at what happened between September and 1-1, it still was up despite the reduction in business you had at one one renewals right so so is it like is it simply we're just looking at changes in rate are you dropping exposure as well well at one one i mean we we held on to most of the business we actually grew a little so yes you know we gave up some rate but we still found that that business met our you know was still attractive in terms of returns so dollars of pml didn't really change a whole lot there's always you know you lose one account you replace it with another so it might on on the margin change the pml's a little bit but you're right i mean the rates went down so we gave up some some returns weren't as good as they had been a year before but that's yeah again looking ahead six one seven one don't know how the how it's all going to shake out but you know that's when you made one and there could be some more significant changes in the pml's depending on kind of what we were doing as we said earlier we put florida was green so i think for us you know we getting the return we not gonna let go the renewals and we're gonna try at the margin to to to write more so i think that was not a zone where we decided to come back great thanks appreciate it you're welcome

Operator

Our next question comes from Pablo Saison with J.P. Morgan. Please go ahead.

Pablo Saison Analyst — J.P. Morgan

Hey, thanks for squeezing me in.

Andrew Kilgerman Analyst — TV Cowan

This will be a quick one.

Pablo Saison Analyst — J.P. Morgan

Nicholas, I just want to follow up on your comments regarding casualty sidecars. Do you think this is a blip, or is there a risk of casualty refacing the same structural hesitance that property can experience with alternative capital is exacerbating the soft market cycles there?

I couldn't hear you. Which line of business?

Pablo Saison Analyst — J.P. Morgan

Just the casualty sidecars, and do you think that ultimately it will have the same effect that alternative capital had on property cats?

I mean, it's hard to tell. You know, the thing we know is that it's not helping. I think the thing that may, you know, the thing that may mitigate that is the security risk. You know, I think that the people that have used those sidecars, they usually use it because because they want to write the business, but they don't like it. You know, I haven't seen people, you know, that are in the market like Arch, you know, using those tools yet. So I think it's for the buyer and for the broker, I mean, they have a decision to make because those claims are going to get paid, you know, five, six years, seven years from now. And will the vehicle and the sedan, which are usually not the best way to sedan, be there to pay the claim? So I think that that may be a mitigation factor compared to property cats where the loss is imminent and we know the capital loads are high. So I think that that.

Pablo Saison Analyst — J.P. Morgan

Thank you.

That would be the difference.

Operator

Our next question comes from Yaron Kinnar with Missoula. Please go ahead.

Speaker 13

Thank you. Good morning. I just want to circle back to the man-made Iran-related losses.

Can you break them out for us for insurance and reinsurance and then maybe what the associate premiums are as well, earned premiums? well we don't we don't break out any we report everything as part of cats but you know again the the the you know it's part of the it's priced right so when we write some of these perils or these lines of business again political violence terror etc which in this case are generating cat losses to us again just in terms of how we report them to you um you know there's it's part of the pricing but it's not really captured in the call it our cat load per se that we

report to you yeah I think to give you an idea I think when we talk to our teams we think the political violence wrong on loss is about 3 billion and we think that it's about you know the the premium that you collect for those lines of business so they give you I mean it's not a precise information but that's that's the sense that we we have two billion maybe two billion and that's across both reinsurance and insurance no so the loss for the market today i think is estimated at three billion we estimate it's an estimate the premium for those lines of business that have been impacted to be around two

Speaker 13

billion because i guess what i'm trying to get at here is when i look at the kind of the underlying loss ratio here it now doesn't capture some losses but we still have the premiums associated with that book and the attritional so i i like as we think forward i want to make sure that we're using the right of base for for the underlying loss ratio yeah good point and maybe i mean we can do that offline with you if you if that's okay i mean i think we can kind of walk you through what the, yeah. That'll be perfect. And then my other question was in the insurance book, I saw that the other liability claims made line grew quite nicely in the quarter. Can you talk about what drove that?

Yeah, it's really the transaction liability. I think we write transaction liability both in North America and in our London office. And it's really driven by higher pricing in that line of business, as well as the M&A activity that has picked up in the last couple of quarters.

Operator

I'm not showing any further questions. Would you like to proceed with any further remarks?

Yes, I want to thank you all to participate to our call and feel good about the business as it is, challenged with the market condition for sure. But I think as we said, we we think we are equipped and our teams are equipped and ready to to compete in the in that market environment and generate uh you know decent return for for our shareholders so thank you ladies and gentlemen thank you for participating in today's conference this concludes the program you may all disconnect

Analyst Q&A · 15 questions
Full-screen source Call document