On August 28, 2024, a day after a short seller's report, Super Micro Computer (SMCI $26.87 -0.46%) said it would not file its annual report on time. The stock fell 19.0% that day, on more than three times the previous day's volume. Two days later the company filed the notice itself, a short SEC form, and left one box on it empty: the one that says the report will follow within 15 days. A board committee was reviewing its internal controls.
It took 179 days. In between, Nasdaq sent a letter saying the company was out of compliance, and Ernst & Young resigned as its auditor. The 10-K arrived on February 25, 2025, with two late quarterly reports.
Super Micro is the case people remember, and it isn't the typical one. We read 2,168 late 10-K notices filed from 2020 to 2025 by 1,042 companies and followed each one to its annual report. Two in three companies filed by the extended deadline, and many of them used every day of it: 608 of the 1,464 that made it filed on the last day allowed. Super Micro left the 15-day box empty, cited a board review, and waited six months. Each of those is a sign the notice is not routine, and each is easy to check.
The data behind this piece
Explore the primary data Equibles carries for SMCI:
The form, in one paragraph
A company that will miss its 10-K deadline files Form 12b-25, known on EDGAR as an NT 10-K, no later than one business day after the due date. It has three parts that matter. Part II is a single box: tick it, and the company says the report will be filed within 15 calendar days of the due date. If it is, the report counts as filed on time. Part III is a free-text explanation of why the report is late. Part IV asks whether the results will show a significant change from the year before, and if the answer is yes, the company has to say what the change is. Below, we go through the form one part at a time and show what each part told us about how late the 10-K actually came.
At a glance
| What we measured | Result |
|---|---|
| Late 10-K notices, 2020 to 2025 | 2,168, from 1,042 companies |
| Ticked the box promising the 10-K within 15 days | 93.5% |
| Filed the 10-K by the extended deadline | 67.5% |
| Of those, filed on the last day allowed | 608 of 1,464 |
| Missed the extended deadline but filed later | 30.5%, a median 44 days after the notice |
| Gave none of the reasons we track, or only that the audit isn't finished | 78.5% |
| Stock move around the notice, exchange-listed companies | -2.0% against the Russell 2000 |
Part II: the 15-day box
Almost everyone ticks it. 93.5% of notices say the 10-K will follow within 15 days, so the box on its own tells you little: 69.1% of the companies that ticked it filed by the extended deadline.
The rare empty box is the warning. Only 72 notices left it empty, Super Micro's among them, and 25.0% of those companies made the deadline. Their median 10-K came 55 days after the notice, and three of the 58 filed through 2024 never filed it at all.
The companies that keep the promise tend to keep it at the last minute. This is when the 10-K arrived, counted from each company's extended deadline:
In notices filed through 2024, 475 of the 1,181 on-time 10-Ks came on the deadline day itself, more than in any whole week before it. The extension works less like a cushion and more like a new due date.
Part III: the reason
Most notices don't say much. 59.4% give none of the reasons we track, and most of those say only that the financial statements need more time. Another 19.1% add only that the audit isn't finished. The rest name something specific, and some of those reasons matter:
| Reason given in Part III | Notices | Filed by the extended deadline | Median days from notice to 10-K |
|---|---|---|---|
| None of the reasons below | 1,287 | 68.5% | 15 |
| The audit isn't finished | 531 | 64.2% | 15 |
| Internal controls (assessment, material weakness) | 154 | 76.6% | 14 |
| An acquisition or merger | 95 | 70.5% | 15 |
| COVID-19 | 83 | 66.3% | 15 |
| A restatement | 64 | 56.2% | 17 |
| A change of auditor | 40 | 60.0% | 15 |
| An investigation or board review | 25 | 40.0% | 27 |
| An impairment | 25 | 72.0% | 15 |
| Income taxes | 22 | 72.7% | 11.5 |
One notice can cite several reasons, so the rows overlap. An investigation or a board committee is the reason that most clearly means a long wait: fewer than half of those companies made the deadline, and the median 10-K came almost four weeks after the notice. Restatements come next.
Internal-control work sounds alarming but mostly isn't. Those notices come almost entirely from exchange-listed companies, whose auditors also have to sign off on their internal controls, and three in four filed on time.
Part IV: will the numbers change?
The last question asks whether the results will show a significant change from the year before. 27.4% of notices answered yes, and they were no more likely to be late: 69.7% filed by the deadline, against 67.9% of those that said no.
A yes is supposed to come with an explanation, "both narratively and quantitatively". 322 of the 595 yes answers put a dollar figure on the change, often revenue or net loss for the year. 48 attached no explanation we could find. When a company does attach numbers, they are often the first look at the year's results outside a press release, days or weeks before the 10-K.
Exchange-listed or not
Exchange-listed companies filed 48.6% of the notices, and they were more likely to make the deadline: 74.7% did, against 62.5% of companies traded over the counter (notices filed through 2024). Listed companies were also more likely to give a specific reason, 48.9% against 32.8%.
For a listed company, missing the extended deadline usually brings a letter from the exchange. 168 of the 271 notices from listed companies that missed it were followed within 45 days by an 8-K under Item 3.01, the item for exchange notices, against 89 of the 782 that made it. Some of those letters are for other rules, such as a low share price. We looked at those letters separately: what happened to Nasdaq companies after a $1 warning, and what followed deficiency notices released on a Friday evening. On Nasdaq, the letter gives the company 60 calendar days to file or to submit a plan to regain compliance, as Super Micro's did.
The letter is rarely the end of the listing. Within a year of the notice, about 8% of listed companies had a Form 25 filed to remove a listing whether they made the deadline or not, and that form also covers mergers and moves between exchanges.
What the stock did
For exchange-listed companies, the notice costs a little and arrives in the middle of a bigger fall.
- Before. Over the roughly six months before the notice, the median stock trailed the Russell 2000 by 20.3%.
- Around the notice. From three trading days before the notice to the day after it, the median stock fell 2.0% against the index, and 63% fell. The same stocks over a five-day window a quarter earlier: -0.2%.
- After. Over the 60 trading days from the notice, the median stock trailed the index by 10.0%. That sounds like a penalty, but the same stocks trailed it by 15.1% in the 60 trading days that ended about three months before the notice. The fall doesn't start with the notice, and it doesn't speed up after it.
The window matters. Counting only the notice day and the day after gives a median of -1.0%, half the five-day number, because many companies announce the delay before they file the form. Super Micro's notice-day move was close to zero; the 19.0% drop had come two days earlier.
The market also seems to sort the notices, at least partly. The companies that went on to miss the extended deadline fell more around the notice than those that made it:
The 40 notices from listed companies that left the 15-day box empty were followed by a median fall of 4.0%. That fits what Eli Bartov and Yaniv Konchitchki found in an earlier sample: investors don't take the company's account of the delay at face value.
How to read one
Every late notice is on the company's filings page on Equibles, next to its 8-Ks (Super Micro's are at /stocks/smci/documents). When one appears, five things are worth a minute:
- The Part II box. Ticked is normal. Empty means the company isn't promising 15 days.
- The reason. "Additional time" is the default. An investigation, a board committee, a restatement or an auditor change is not.
- The 8-Ks just before it. A delay announced by press release a day or two earlier is where the stock usually moves.
- Part IV. A yes with numbers attached is an early look at the year's results.
- The deadline. It is 15 calendar days after the 10-K's due date, moved past weekends and holidays. Most companies that make it file on the last day, so a 10-K a week early is a good sign, and one still missing the day after is not.
How we built this
- Notices. Every NT 10-K in our filings archive filed from January 2020 to December 2025 by a company we track, 2,242 in all. EDGAR full-text search finds 5,156 NT 10-K filings in those years, so this is about 43% of them, weighted toward companies that still file today. We dropped 57 blank-check companies, 7 notices that covered only the proxy section of a 10-K, 8 filed after the 10-K they refer to, and 2 repeat notices for the same fiscal year, leaving 2,168.
- Deadlines. A 10-K is due 60, 75 or 90 days after the fiscal year ends, depending on the company's size. We took the first of those due dates that the notice wasn't already past by more than a business day, added 15 days, and moved both dates past weekends and federal holidays, as SEC rules do. For 98 notices filed after every possible due date, about half of them in 2020 under the SEC's COVID-19 relief, we counted 15 days from the notice.
- The 10-K. The first 10-K filed for the same fiscal year, matched on its period of report. For 44 notices, EDGAR's period of report is the notice's own filing date or close to it, so for those we read the period from the form itself. "Not filed" is counted only for notices filed through 2024, so every company had at least 22 months.
- Boxes. Filing agents draw a ticked box in at least ten ways (☒, ☑, ⌧, þ, ý, √, ✓, [X], a plain x and a symbol-font character) and an empty one in seven. We read Part II for 96.8% of notices and Part IV for 95.2%; where a form draws a separate box for each statement, only the box at the 15-day promise counts; the rest show no box we could read.
- Reasons. Patterns on the Part III text, one notice can have several. In a random hand check of 25 notices against the final patterns, 23 had every reason right; in the other two we caught one reason and missed a second (a tax issue, a staffing shortage).
- Listed or OTC. A company counts as exchange-listed if EDGAR shows it on Nasdaq, NYSE, NYSE American or Cboe, or a Form 25 was later filed to delist it. In a random check of 20 against the cover of each company's previous 10-K, all 20 matched.
- Stock moves. Daily closing prices adjusted for splits and dividends, measured against the iShares Russell 2000 ETF (IWM), for listed companies only. The notice window covers the five trading days from three days before the notice to the day after it, because many companies announce the delay a day or two before filing the form. Each window is compared with the same stocks' returns over a window of the same length about a quarter earlier.
- Exchange letters. An 8-K under Item 3.01 (notice of delisting or failure to satisfy a listing rule) within 45 days of the notice.
Limitations
- Coverage. We see about 43% of all NT 10-K filings, and our archive favors companies still filing today, so companies that went dark after a late notice are probably undercounted. Only 1.6% of the notices filed through 2024 never led to a 10-K, and that share is a floor: it rises from 0.8% for 2020 notices to 2.7% for 2024 ones, the pattern you'd expect if companies that went dark years ago had dropped out of the archive.
- The deadline is our estimate. We infer each company's filer status from when it filed the notice. A few notices fit two deadlines, and an evening filing that EDGAR dates the next day can look one day late.
- Reasons are self-reported. Part III says what the company chose to say. A notice that cites "additional time" can still be hiding a restatement.
- Stock moves are for small companies. Most notices come from small and micro-cap companies, and a benchmark doesn't fit every one of them. The comparison windows help, but the 60-day numbers are noisy.
Conclusion
A late 10-K notice is usually a small company buying two weeks and using all of them. Two in three file by the extended deadline, and the form's checkbox promise is ticked so often that it means little until it's left empty. The form does carry information, though: an empty box, an investigation or a board review, or a yes with numbers each says more than the notice's existence. For listed companies the notice itself costs about 2%, while the bigger decline was already under way months before.
To check a notice with an assistant, connect Equibles to ChatGPT or Claude through our MCP server and ask, for example: "Did Super Micro tick the 15-day box on its August 2024 late 10-K notice, and what reason did it give?" It reads the form and answers with a link to the filing.
Sources
- SEC Rule 12b-25, Notification of inability to timely file all or any required portion of a Form 10-K, 10-Q or other report: 17 CFR 240.12b-25.
- Super Micro Computer filings: the 8-K of August 28, 2024 announcing the delay (accession 0001375365-24-000030), the NT 10-K of August 30, 2024 (0001375365-24-000031), the Nasdaq notice 8-K of September 20, 2024 (0001375365-24-000033), the auditor-change 8-K of October 30, 2024 (0001375365-24-000036) and the 10-K of February 25, 2025 (0001375365-25-000004).
- Bloomberg, "Super Micro Falls as Hindenburg Takes Aim With Short Report," August 27, 2024, and "Super Micro Slides on 10-K Delay Following Hindenburg Report," August 28, 2024.
- Bartov, Eli, and Yaniv Konchitchki. "SEC Filings, Regulatory Deadlines, and Capital Market Consequences." Accounting Horizons 31, no. 4 (2017): 109-131.